Hey I noticed your Upkeep is at 1.9M. I can leave full war gear and have ( 0 ) Upkeep...I figured this out not long ago. Go in alliance research and Max out every EFFICIENCY. Then when you're at 0 Upkeep you don't have to worry about having Tons food open and being forced to use it on training or building when it isn't an event. Cuz then u won't be getting rewards for it if not an event. So now you can save it with NO worries that it's open. For example after kill stage looting on Gold event. Say you loot 200m food....With 0 Upkeep it don't matter. Now it can just sit there.. THIS was HUGE for my alliance as we always have hundreds millions rss. Hope this helps people. :) 😀 Also with every efficiency done you don't have to switch to the gathering gear with Upkeep reduction or your hero...U can keep war gear and all war covenants on and still be st 0 😁
Thanks Abbas have a question though I'm a mid spender will this formation work for me do you think or is this tailored for players that have alot of money or gold to heal during raid event etc
So, any real difference between 35 SH and 39 SH is size of march. I will need calculator to work out percentages, but thanks! Finally good help about crit defense! I was beginning to lose hope...
Is it not worth excluding one type of troop to have millions of t2 infantry? I was thinking of having t11 and t10 and t2 inf, t11 and t10 cav and only t11 bowmen. This with brutus on wall makes them even more dangerous than with t10 bowmen, because 100% if the 20% of bowmen that are affected will have a higher attack against infantry since they are t11 The reason I excluded t10 bowmen and not t10 cavalry -> (since t10 cavalry have a chance to directly attack bowmen, and bowmen have a higher attack than cavalry, this makes them better than t10 bowman that have a chance to directly attack only cavalry, and with heroes on the march, brutus is better than goirlois, making Bowmen even more dangerous than cavalry) Let me know what you think.
hi brother, I am testing the t2 part on my alternative account. That account will have t12 all, t11 cav bow and t2 inf. I think you should include t10 bow and exclude t11 inf. t11 inf helps but I think in your case t10 bow will be much effective as compared to t11 inf. when I will test t11, i will test this pairing combination too
Why exactly t2? T1 and t3 are spearmen, which means they get hit after warriors are dead. Would they not be more beneficial to use? Lets say you have t12 warriors and t3 spearmen, your hospital and sanctum will fill with your t12s first. With t2 warriors, your high level troops will be lost instead, wont they?
@@heinzzzzlol because, and I don't know why, but when you get attacked and you have t2 infantry at base, you literally will not lose anything but t2, and you will continue to lose not a single other troop except for t2, until they run out, while still killing the attackers troops. No idea why it works, but it is insanely good. You could literally zero somone by having millions of t2 at base, they would keep attacking you until either they ran out of troops, or until you ran out of t2. And this only works for t2 infantry, no other tier works like this, so this might be an exploit, ion know.
Wanna see ur test on spearmen because from my testing they don't bring anything better, they are not useless but its better to have 150k t12 than 100k t12 and 50 t11 for example.
Having t11 inf is pointless, they gonna be attacked after all your t12 and other front line tiers die. So not only u wait with those t11 till your t12 die, but also have to invest some scrolls to boost em... Good luck ;) for c40 crit I would just go by t12/12&11/12&11 inf cav dis, with one slot under crit build for let's say ... T9 dis as it will boost your golem results ;) but wouldn't mind just fly with 5 types of troops ;)
@@BANSH33ee yeah thats what I was thinking as well, or you could go for t10 meat shield as well instead of t9 bow? to have ur t12 losses lower when someone attacks your castle, thoughts?
I thought about it a little. If your city is attacked, your t11 infantry will not fight at all, unless all of the t12 infantry of the city is already dead. But in such a case it is a disaster for you already, your hospital and sanctum overflow and it will take ages to get back your power. So in order to not reach that point, have more t12 infantry instead. As a sixth tier, pick t9 crossbowmen. They attack infantry, and work well with Brutus.
@@jeanefpraxiadis1128 how can i apply this early game say im at t6 and having fun while i grind up? can i just invest into alot of t2s to give me an edge? or am i being too simplistic?
Was debating t11 inf myself to protect my Bowman a little as t13 are hideous for my t12 Bowman but would mean hiding my t9 bow for a hit but only have a handful of them 🤔 so not bad. My t9 Bowman in small numbers in attacking are brutal against someone similar stats or bigger than I am, 7k can take out anywhere between 7-16k by themselves. Hard little workers and they rarely get killed
@@souldoubt3203 ah I cannot comment although he will be hitting with the new ns3 heros now as he should have them both at 5 stars minimum now, he hit me with Lancelot and dindrane leading the March before ns3 heros were released 5.3k/11k stats at the time 👀😳
@@maniacqueenie4578 That is scary, the new heroes change the game with how strong they will sit in council let alone how much of a pain they have been for me in arena so far :P
hey, thx for that video, is it still up to date (we all know KoA likes to change game mechanics)? also i wanted to ask what to do with siege? since i'd like to keep some for gathering, what would you say - highest tier, to add to defense, lowest or none at all?
Also I'm SH31. I have all 8500k stats. My other SH31 is 9600k inf and everything else 7500k stats. So I'm trying to do this Crit defense. On one of your videos it shows you have 0 seige and 0 traps leaving just the 6 tiers. But your other crit defense videos you have tons of siege and traps....Can I have siege and traps with only 6 troop types 2inf 2cav 2bow ?? Or does siege and traps count towards that??? It's confusing because I could have swore u posted video saying always train seige...soo keep siege and traps and be able to still have crit or get ride them and the traps????? Ok just saw u reply to someone on seige haha so what about traps???
What am going to do with siege is put them gathering our rein in farm .I can't get them killed off I tried 🤣🤣.it be great too have 6th march too am save them in march and send them away.
Hi, I am sure t11 or odd inf don't work in the way that people describe. I had tested them, but I will do one more proper testing with recording on. No, don't have 50-50% Like for me, I will have only 300k-500k t11, and millions of t12. You actually need very less amount of t11 or odd infantry
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 87 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "ก้องชัย vs โชคปรีชา"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YN6e7HVnekw/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey I noticed your Upkeep is at 1.9M. I can leave full war gear and have ( 0 ) Upkeep...I figured this out not long ago. Go in alliance research and Max out every EFFICIENCY. Then when you're at 0 Upkeep you don't have to worry about having Tons food open and being forced to use it on training or building when it isn't an event. Cuz then u won't be getting rewards for it if not an event. So now you can save it with NO worries that it's open. For example after kill stage looting on Gold event. Say you loot 200m food....With 0 Upkeep it don't matter. Now it can just sit there.. THIS was HUGE for my alliance as we always have hundreds millions rss. Hope this helps people. :) 😀 Also with every efficiency done you don't have to switch to the gathering gear with Upkeep reduction or your hero...U can keep war gear and all war covenants on and still be st 0 😁
Loved it buddy,carry on the good work
Thanks for all those amazing videos bro ❤❤❤
you are always welcome brother
Aftr mch waiting finally here it comes, thk q mch sir...
Thanks Abbas have a question though I'm a mid spender will this formation work for me do you think or is this tailored for players that have alot of money or gold to heal during raid event etc
The only thing I didn't see was about what percentage you should have of each
So, any real difference between 35 SH and 39 SH is size of march. I will need calculator to work out percentages, but thanks! Finally good help about crit defense! I was beginning to lose hope...
Is it not worth excluding one type of troop to have millions of t2 infantry? I was thinking of having t11 and t10 and t2 inf, t11 and t10 cav and only t11 bowmen. This with brutus on wall makes them even more dangerous than with t10 bowmen, because 100% if the 20% of bowmen that are affected will have a higher attack against infantry since they are t11
The reason I excluded t10 bowmen and not t10 cavalry -> (since t10 cavalry have a chance to directly attack bowmen, and bowmen have a higher attack than cavalry, this makes them better than t10 bowman that have a chance to directly attack only cavalry, and with heroes on the march, brutus is better than goirlois, making Bowmen even more dangerous than cavalry)
Let me know what you think.
hi brother,
I am testing the t2 part on my alternative account. That account will have t12 all, t11 cav bow and t2 inf.
I think you should include t10 bow and exclude t11 inf.
t11 inf helps but I think in your case t10 bow will be much effective as compared to t11 inf.
when I will test t11, i will test this pairing combination too
Why exactly t2? T1 and t3 are spearmen, which means they get hit after warriors are dead. Would they not be more beneficial to use? Lets say you have t12 warriors and t3 spearmen, your hospital and sanctum will fill with your t12s first. With t2 warriors, your high level troops will be lost instead, wont they?
@@heinzzzzlol because, and I don't know why, but when you get attacked and you have t2 infantry at base, you literally will not lose anything but t2, and you will continue to lose not a single other troop except for t2, until they run out, while still killing the attackers troops. No idea why it works, but it is insanely good. You could literally zero somone by having millions of t2 at base, they would keep attacking you until either they ran out of troops, or until you ran out of t2.
And this only works for t2 infantry, no other tier works like this, so this might be an exploit, ion know.
Thnx for this masterclass Evert time. Like colleg in university. Is there a precentige in how many bow, inf and cav?
Thanks for sharing this info! Ive still got a question. if you have 6 types of troops + siege. The siege will f*ck up the crit formation right?
Yes it would, which is why you need to either hide your siege or get rid of them
Great job, ty so much for formations on t10.no one has done any videos of t10. Should this be the same for attack or strictly defense?
Wanna see ur test on spearmen because from my testing they don't bring anything better, they are not useless but its better to have 150k t12 than 100k t12 and 50 t11 for example.
sure brother, I will test and post :)
I will also test this t9 bowmen theory.
We will see which one works better and use it
Having t11 inf is pointless, they gonna be attacked after all your t12 and other front line tiers die. So not only u wait with those t11 till your t12 die, but also have to invest some scrolls to boost em... Good luck ;) for c40 crit I would just go by t12/12&11/12&11 inf cav dis, with one slot under crit build for let's say ... T9 dis as it will boost your golem results ;) but wouldn't mind just fly with 5 types of troops ;)
@@BANSH33ee yeah thats what I was thinking as well, or you could go for t10 meat shield as well instead of t9 bow? to have ur t12 losses lower when someone attacks your castle, thoughts?
I thought about it a little. If your city is attacked, your t11 infantry will not fight at all, unless all of the t12 infantry of the city is already dead. But in such a case it is a disaster for you already, your hospital and sanctum overflow and it will take ages to get back your power. So in order to not reach that point, have more t12 infantry instead. As a sixth tier, pick t9 crossbowmen. They attack infantry, and work well with Brutus.
@@jeanefpraxiadis1128 how can i apply this early game say im at t6 and having fun while i grind up?
can i just invest into alot of t2s to give me an edge? or am i being too simplistic?
Very helpful!! But in my attacking March should I have it like you said for defense have spearman and warriors etc.
I have t11 and t12s bow inf and cav in my city
Is it good?
Was debating t11 inf myself to protect my Bowman a little as t13 are hideous for my t12 Bowman but would mean hiding my t9 bow for a hit but only have a handful of them 🤔 so not bad. My t9 Bowman in small numbers in attacking are brutal against someone similar stats or bigger than I am, 7k can take out anywhere between 7-16k by themselves. Hard little workers and they rarely get killed
Can show you a report where one of the top stat players in all koa hit me and t9 bow barely got touched
100% agree, however I will say Gorloris changes this slightly if he's on attack I have found the T9 bow get train wrecked by that fella :(
@@souldoubt3203 ah I cannot comment although he will be hitting with the new ns3 heros now as he should have them both at 5 stars minimum now, he hit me with Lancelot and dindrane leading the March before ns3 heros were released 5.3k/11k stats at the time 👀😳
@@maniacqueenie4578 That is scary, the new heroes change the game with how strong they will sit in council let alone how much of a pain they have been for me in arena so far :P
@@souldoubt3203 I'm dreading getting hit by him again, but part of me is curious to see how it goes👀 you know... For science 😂😇
Thank you master 👍👍👍
at 07:35 there is a mistake. T9 cavalry are light and tier 10 are heavy. So you should use both for a crit march.
please check again, t9 and t10 both are light cavalry
@@BestGamesHub yeah bro, sorry, you're right lol
10s and 9s for cavalry have the same effect
Hello I have sh 30 with 600k troups and march 217k please what is the best defense crit march for me
hey, thx for that video, is it still up to date (we all know KoA likes to change game mechanics)? also i wanted to ask what to do with siege? since i'd like to keep some for gathering, what would you say - highest tier, to add to defense, lowest or none at all?
Hail to the KOA Non-spender King Abbas
Thanks for the video. How about Siege? Is it count if the siege still in the city?
Sad im a 24sh and the crit in university unlock at 23lvl good vid
So i should upgrade all the other tiers?? What about golem and portal formation???
As sh30, for crit formation, do i have yo get rid of my t9 cavs for it to work or i can keep my t9 cavs?
Tell you now the only way it will be better to have t12/t11 inf in a march will be with madoc
i have t1, t2, t3 and t4, should I convert t1,t2 or should i leave them be
Also I'm SH31. I have all 8500k stats. My other SH31 is 9600k inf and everything else 7500k stats. So I'm trying to do this Crit defense. On one of your videos it shows you have 0 seige and 0 traps leaving just the 6 tiers. But your other crit defense videos you have tons of siege and traps....Can I have siege and traps with only 6 troop types 2inf 2cav 2bow ?? Or does siege and traps count towards that??? It's confusing because I could have swore u posted video saying always train seige...soo keep siege and traps and be able to still have crit or get ride them and the traps????? Ok just saw u reply to someone on seige haha so what about traps???
I thought t11 infantry made t12 weaker, is that true?
great, how muchs trops? 50%/50% infatery, cavalery, bowmen
Always more t12 inf, they die super fast in comparison to other troops 😅
Abbas can you gave me a troops formation for attack im sh44
So brother crit deff is like to have all t12 and all t11 ?
Yeah
I see you have a million siege those don't count as the crit defense formation, Do we need to dismiss them?
just kill them on kvk and get 300% buff
What am going to do with siege is put them gathering our rein in farm .I can't get them killed off I tried 🤣🤣.it be great too have 6th march too am save them in march and send them away.
Kill them in kvk
Are you really, really sure about that 11 infantry? How much t11 infantry and how much t12? 50-50?
Hi, I am sure t11 or odd inf don't work in the way that people describe.
I had tested them, but I will do one more proper testing with recording on.
No, don't have 50-50%
Like for me, I will have only 300k-500k t11, and millions of t12.
You actually need very less amount of t11 or odd infantry
Bro which country you are
and siege?
Get out of here with siege s h I t e. Only used for gathering on tiles or bringing plunder back from attacks on strong holds with 0 troop inside
😀😀😀