Part 2: th-cam.com/video/fUB6wXURR-I/w-d-xo.html I HAVE A SPECIAL MISSION FOR ALL OF YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Please SHARE this video when & where you can! It's SO helpful to the channel, and it gets the word out about this video to as many eyes and ears as possible! Share on Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, send to all your friends, and more! Be my fellowship and help me on my journey to getting this video seen by the world! THANK YOU SO MUCH, and cheers, dear viewers.
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is a truly once-in-a-lifetime (yes, once. I'm looking at you, Hobbit trilogy) event. So many things had to go right, so many little things could have gone wrong, but everything came together so perfectly. Even Tolkien himself felt that the Lord of the Rings was unadatable, and not only did Peter Jackson adapt it, but he created one of the greatest works of cinema ever
@@LordBaronsworth Keep wishing, never gonna happen! :-) Bingewatch them in a row, the Hobbit is so utterly disappointing even though it of course still does have some good moments here and there, although some of those good moments made little sense. It also ruins the continuity with LOTR.
Seriously. These movies are the hight of cinema mastery, and the hight of adaptation.. Both at the same time. I read the books directly before watching each movie for the first time and I was not disappointed. I've never ever had that happen when reading a book first, with anything else.... I mean in 9(12) my only criticism was a lack of Tom bombadil
Putting aside the difficulties in rewriting the script and the time constraints Jackson had when he took over the helm of the Hobbit films...The Hobbit as a novel has nowhere near the depth and gravitas of The Lord of the Rings. Jackson was working with a smaller supply of material, and lighter material at that. A child's novel was not going to match an adult's trilogy in emotional impact.
@@LordBaronsworth I feel sorry for those who hate The Hobbit. They only have 3 movies set in Middle-Earth that they get to enjoy. We on the other hand get 6!
The story of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit mean more to me than anyone could know. Middle Earth is like a rope that ever connects me to my childhood and has always been there ever since I was born, the music, the characters, the journey, it all calls to me. I grew up knowing it, my parents introduced it to us before I could even speak, and it calls me to the mountains where I would listen to The Hobbit audio book camping while I was young, it feels like it is connected to my soul. It is a symbol of my home, my Dad, and the longing for group of companions just like that, as you said. It connects me to the feeling of looking at vast mountain ranges, untouched, that feel like they belong to you because it's where you grew up. When I watched the movies for the first time in highschool, it became one of my all time favorite movie trilogy's. Then after, I re-read The Hobbit and finally read all The Lord of the Rings in about a month. I hope one day, I can give my children the same experience I had with the stories, and that when they read it, hear it, or see it, they learn love, companionship, and commitment to something bigger than yourself, that no matter how small they are or who they are, they can make a change. I hope when they look out into the forest, and up at the mountains, that is what they think of, and that it'll remind them of me the same way I am reminded of my Dad. To that I just say, Thank You J.R.R Tolkien.
Random Girl I know exactly how you feel. Every time I think of something wise Gandalf said, every time I hike the mossy, dirty, and green mountains of my home state, and more than anything, when I hear the song of the shire in my head, I feel that no matter where I am and no matter how dark the times may be that I am somehow home. Not a place in the waking world, nor in my dreams, but a beautiful little hobbit hole in the center of heart that opens it’s door only to the very old friends who take me back to middle earth, to my home.
In the book, Gimli said "Faithless is he who says farewell when the road darkens". After Boromir's death the fellowship could have easily been broken, yet each character/group continued on to the goal of destroying the one ring. That is loyalty to the beliefs and commitment the fellowship made to themselves and each other. They all continued to have faith in each other. As Arwen and Aragorn each said, "There is always hope". Hanon le, melon nin (thank you my friend), i am now a subscriber!!😚👌☺
Jennifer Baldini Thank you for sharing! This is such a good reference from the source material to back up the thesis of this video. It’s amazing how such incredible qualities from the original works are captured well by the filmmakers for the film adaptation; we can see the main themes from the film reflected in the book, and vice versa. Good to have you as a subscriber, Jennifer!
I was 18 when I watched the LotR trilogy for the first time. I was impressed but not invested at all. I had heard so many stories over the years of this epic, revolutionary piece of cinema and naturally, my mind created its own interpretation of what I had heard. So, of course, when I watched it, it wasn’t like my mind made it out to be. Fast forward two years (into the present), three watch-throughs later, having watched countless video essays and love letters to these films (and also having watched the Hobbit trilogy (oof… >_>)) and with each viewing, it got more and more amazing. These characters grew so much on me, although they are really just names and words in a script but brought to life by amazing performances! The music is beyond words. Just hearing the Shire theme is enough to make me tear up and send a chill down my spine. From intimate moments to epic, large-scale battles, the soundtrack is just so incredibly perfect and wonderful, I really can’t express it. This is a great video essay and you really captured a lot of what makes us love The Lord of the Rings so much. The ending though, so touching… Can't wait for your next part on this masterpiece!
Very similar to me. I was around 15 and watched the movies and understood they were great movies and enjoyed them but felt no investment in them. A year or 3 later it was as if something just clicked and I was watching the movies multiple times a year and learning everything I possibly could about them and the books and laughing and tearing up at scenes every time. I still watch them around once a year and return to Middle-earth in all its glory
I don't think it can be overstated how important the technical aspects of these movies are in supporting/enhancing the emotion conveyed in the story and characters. The music, the cinematography, the sound design and the editing in these movies is so good at communicating the emotional beats of what's going on. You almost don't even have to pay attention to what's being said in order to just "feel" the impact of what's happening. The filmmaking itself has such emotional weight to it. Howard Shore's amazing score combined with these amazingly beautiful and epic shots (beautiful and epic even when it's just a shot of an actor's face... even when what's going on in frame is disgusting like an Uruk-Hai being birthed, the shot still looks amazing) with perfectly timed editing and powerful sounds for everything... I don't think any movie combines these factors more perfectly than Fellowship of the Ring does. You can get lost in a world of feeling just purely from looking at and listening to these movies. As I have done... many times...
It's the greatest fantasy movie I've ever seen in my life. I can't describe my feelings about this movie. I just can feel it. 😢😢😢 Thanks a lot for making such a GOOD VIDEO.🙏🙏🙏
You know you love a story, and you know a story has done such a beautiful job when you watch a 2 second clip with two words, "For Frodo.", and it immediately sends shivers down your spine.
My dad introudced me to the world of Tolkien at a very young age. He read The Hobbit to me and we watched the LOTR 2d animated movie. I read The Hobbit myself a few years later at the age of 11 ish and tried reading the LOTR books but I wasn't ready yet. A year after the first movie came out my mom finally allowed me to watch it on VHS with my dad and I fell in love with it. I bought all the LOTR games for the PS2 and some for PC and have both the extended and theatrical version on DVD and I still play many of the games and read the books from time to time but I watch the extended edt of the movies every year. LOTR are one of the very few products of art and entertainment that make me cry:')
I grew up with LOTR. First my sister read me the Hobbit and then we watched the 1976 animated version. My sister had the boardgame. I often fell asleep while the animated version was playing and it seeped into my very blood. When the movies came out it was an extremely emotional thing for me because it felt like coming home. I watch the movies and read the books all throughout the year because LOTR is.. Home.
Did the same. Read all the books, saw that animated version. When I heard they were making a proper version and doing all 3 books. I couldn't wait for release date. The stunning cinema photography is what grabbed me and how faithful to the books they were. It wasn't cheesy or cutified like other movies of my childhood books
same ! my dad took me to the theater a the age of nine years old to see Lord of the Rings ... It has completely changed my life since then, I am now a huge fantasy fan and proud:) Thanks to my dad and Tolkien!
These films are the literal definition of cinematic masterpiece. I fisrt watched them when i was 14/15 just before the Hobbit films came out. I fell in love with them immediately. I watched the extended versions (which are the only versions I will accept) at least once a month (lol back when i still had free time) and read every Tolkien book I could get my hands on. These films affected me in a way i can only describe as life-changing. They are my favourite films of all time and cannot be replicated (I'm looking at you Amazon).
As a kid, I really disliked all the Arwen stuff in the middle of nowhere, but on my most recent watch, I really appreciated it, and totally bought her and Aragorn’s relationship in a way I never had before
This whole Arwen storyline gives Aragorn an actual arc, which he misses in the books or which is really underdeveloped in the books. I don't like Arwen as a character, but she gives Aragorn so much more depth to his character.
Splendid video and such creative ideas. As a fan of the series, I can say that I agree with most of your points except the part where you said the fellowship lacked the historical relationship. Most of the characters actually had a very close relationship with each other. Legolas and Aragorn for example, Aragorn was raised by the elves in Rivendell and Legolas was an acquaintance of Aragorn. And we can see how Legolas defends Aragorn verbally in the Council of Elrond. Also the four of the hobbits had known each other for a long time. Although some of them had known each other, I believe what you were trying to say was that the fellowship had some antagonising characters (Boromir-Aragorn, Gimli-Legolas). And actually this is what makes the fellowship so emotionally effective. As the audience, we witness how their relationship become so intimate with time and how they even feel willing to risk their lives for each other (Boromir's death for example). Finally, I would like to say that Gimli-Legolas friendship was so emotional for me. Especially this dialogue between Legolas and Gimli brought tears to my eyes: "Never thought I'd die fighting side by side with an Elf - What about side by side with a friend?"
Thank you for your comment and kindness! ... Yes, there are *certain* histories, but the Fellowship *as a whole* is a collection of strangers. I’m making that point collectively, not individually. In the film, we don’t see much evidence for Aragorn’s and Legolas’ prior relationship; this is briefly alluded to but not expounded upon. Therefore, it remains true that, at least to audience, the fellowship is a group of strangers (as I said in the video, also, the Hobbits and Gandalf don’t really fit the mold of being strangers to one another. I excluded them). Thanks again!!
Lord of the rings is my favorite fantasy and film trilogy of all time. I watched them as a kid around 2007 with my dad. They were game changing. The battle of helms deep and Minas tirith were mind blowing. Watching the extended versions in 2012 were yet again, mind blowing. Now in 2018 about 10 years later, I have read all of The books, played the games, and know all the lore. I have experienced this wonderful universe. As a kid I loved the action but now I appreciate the writing and story and THEMES. This story is the first and greatest fantasy and work of all time. Tolkien truly put important life lessons in his work and Jackson adapted it beautifully. Also the music is the best soundtrack ever.
I wasn't old enough to watch LotR in the theaters unfortunately. But i was old enough to see the Marvel Cinematic Universe unfold. The MCU is good but it does not come anywhere close to LotR. LotR is literally as close to perfection that you could get
Well it wasn't really the writers of the films that made us believe in their emotional impact, it was THE writer *J.R.R.* *Tolkien* The story and characters were already written.
I am lucky enough to say that i saw ALL 3 films at the cinemas when they came out. It was basically a family tradition at x mas. I was about 7 when the i saw the 1st one and even back then at that age i knew the movie was amazing and that the journey had only just begun. In my opinion lord of the rings is to movies what avatar is to television. Both masterpieces and actually share a lot of similarities. But thank you for this. Your videos make me love my favorite things even more than i thought possible :)
This theme of loyalty, of fellowship, resonates so much with me. It's an ideal, that to this day, is so essential to me. Loyalty to your friends is one of the highest virtues in my opinion. I guess that is why LotR is so very important and so emotional for me. It really does hold a special part in my heart.
Well said. As we keep putting principles and morals in jeopardy, making it a characteristic of modern day society, the movie holds more and more to me.
It should be noted that Aragorn and Legolas also have a relationship, as they have known each other for many years in the books, but it's not talked about at all in the movies. They have traveled together and I think they even hunted Golum together on orders from Gandalf.
And Aragorn and Gandalf have a relationship. And all 4 Hobbits have relationships with each other (Merry, Pippin, and Frodo are literally related to each other). And all 4 Hobbits have relationships with Gandalf, though Frodo has the best relationship with him. And given Faramir's knowledge of and experience with Gandalf, Boromir is probably familiar with him, as I'm sure each member of the Fellowship actually is.
I love your analysis of these films! I was thinking of the scene in Return of the King where Frodo wakes up and sees everyone in his room - and the audience is made to remember that Frodo, unlike us, hasn't known of any of their outcomes the entire time. It seems like the final reinforcement of fellowship you were talking about - after all that time, they were all still fighting for him (even Gandalf, who he thought was dead). Its such a beautiful scene. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on Sam and Frodo's friendship. It seems as if the series begins with them and ends with them. We watch as they endure so much together, making their final goodbye so heartbreaking!
Beautiful, poignant and in depth analysis of the greatest films ever made and indeed greatest source material. You had me in tears at the use of the soundtrack and the visuals and reinforced why these movies mean so much to people. You have deservedly earned yourself another sub. Can’t wait for the next two parts!
I know alot of the credit goes to Howard Shore's amazing music, Peter Jackson's directing and cinematography, and of course the actors and countless others who produced the original films you borrowed content from, but some of the credit also belongs to you, for making literally the first TH-cam video ever to bring me to tears of joy as you described all the ways in which the fellowship reaffirmed their commitments at the end. Brought back all the feels, and reminded me why The Lord of the Rings is my favorite film trilogy of all time.
@@khodexus4963 Is it? The video gives all the writing credit to the movie makers, and you're trying to give credit to this guy who had absolutely nothing to do with either the books or the movies. Give credit where it's due, don't kiss ass.
@@khodexus4963 Oh yeah? Let's see... you edited your comment, and you still make no mention of Tolkien and still give credit to this guy who had absolutely nothing to do with any of the books or movies. Yes, that is doing just that, you're absolutely right.
It's such a pure and heavy story. I don't remember a time that I didn't know what Lord of the Rings was, but I always wanted to hear or see it told again and again. As I grew up, I knew why. It's exactly what Sam's speech says.."those are the stories that stuck with you, even if you were too small to understand why". It shows what honor truly is, it shows us that even the heros had short comings, but they all chose to overcome them in the end. They all became servants to eachother & carried brotherly-love for one another..something we should all have and do. It will always be deeper and more important to so many people than most understand or believe.
Great essay. I'm sitting here going "Wow, yeah, he's right, that's exactly how it feels..." I kind of took it for granted at first, but the fact that this fellowship is so strong that it connects story threads that don't meet again for SO long... is kind of incredible. I remember reading the books for the first time and being super excited for the characters to meet again, I was looking forward to it so much that it filled me with excitement and joy for basically two entire books. And when they succeed in the end and everything is over, even though the evil is defeated, it it so gut wrenching to witness the end of the fellowship. All of them going their separate ways, some most likely to never meet again. Man, if I think about it too hard, I'm gonna cry again, and I already did that for a looong time after finishing the books... :'D
Awesome made video!! The edit is just crazy good. LOTR means a lot to me, watched it for the first time when I was 8 years old. I've been a big fan through out the years and I have so many memories related to these films. The movies takes every emotional cell you have in your body and makes it into music, life, storytelling... and the actors are just ON POINT in the best combination ever possible.
The LOTR films came out when I was in high school---one of the lowest points in my life. They were one of the only sources of joy and beauty I can remember from that time; they helped me through so much. I am really happy you are making this series.
Im so grateful of how i was raised. Raised in the enviroment of fantasy stories like LOTR, Harry Potter, Star Wars, Narnia, etc. From age 6 i believe. I am a huge nerd on fantasy stories, and love to write my own stories. Good music, and amazing stories gives you a wonderful childhood. Furthermore, i came to love history too, and have since watched amazing historical movies. I am very grateful, that i wasn’t raised as my friends, who barely knows what a movie is, and thinks that every fantasy movie is shit, without ever having seen it.
As a 12 year old watching these movies I was blown away by the scale of the spectacle, the enormous battles and giant armies of evil, epic speaches and the heroism on display, all grounded in the attention to detail during the production, making middle earth feel like a place that actually existed. I always liked the third movie the most. Now I can appreciate the quite moments as well and understand how they are an integral part to the beauty of these movies and this story in general. Howard Shore's score is perfect too, without him these movies wouldn't be what they are. 15 years later these movies are still my favorite pieces of cinema but for different reasons. Today The Fellowship of the Ring is my favorite movie between the three. We're so lucky to have these movies, it's a true miracle that they were made the way they are.
My heart is broken because there's only one part right now. I needs the other 2! I agree wholeheartedly. This series is and will probably forever be my favorite. As a writer I strive for my books to be a fraction as good as this series and if someone ever compares my books to these I could die happy
When I was younger I just thought Lord of the Rings was cool, but a couple months ago I marathoned them over a weekend and I actually got choked up at the end, for the first time after like 12 watches. I was amazed at how deep it actually is if you really invest in it
I just wanted to say... thank you. I was in need for smart and deep analysis of movies. This channel is amazing! And about this particular video...well I'm just going to admit that you made my share a tear or two. I love LOTR for years, i watched movies countless times. You captured and put into the words what I felt, what many of us felt on scene between Sam and Frodo. I cry on that scene every single time and the reason why i exactly as you said it..because we are longing for a commitment like that, for someone who will keep our back no matter what. This is so true... Thank you so much for this video. Wish you all the best.
The LOTR has been my favorite movie experience for many many years. I watch the entire series (directors extended cut) twice a year. I've seen all the special features and watched the films with commentary by both directors and actors. I LOVE LOTR! You have perfectly captures what was only a "thought and a shadow" in my own mind. Excellent video, I am now a subscriber and look forward to the rest of the series!
Based on one of the most read and loved books of all time. Which touches on a vast amount of important ageless topics relevant to individuals and humanity at large. And a generally well done adaptation of the books by the movie. Combined with one of the most fantastic and moving musical scores of all time by Howard Shore. And there you have it, you have a winning formula. Rare to have a character driven plot, with an emphasis on character development and relationships these days to be honest.
It just struck me that at the end of Fellowship Frodo pulls Sam up from the water and saves him, through his love and commitment for him, and in Return of the King at the end of all things Sam pulls Frodo up as he hangs above Mount Doom. Through water, through fire. Beautiful parallels.
I got introduced to this series as a child with the Lego LOTR, then I watched the trilogy, and after that I started getting more and more involved to the LOTR. Then I became a great fan. Time has passed but I'm still, and i will always be a fan of this series (including the Hobbit).
Your assessment is nothing short of brilliant, and I can truly relate to your feelings as well. The emotional heft of this movie and the Trilogy as a whole is palpable, and has no peer in cinematic history for bringing out the full gamut of emotions in me. Joy, laughter, dread, sadness, and ultimately exultation (among many other feeligs!) are present and on full display when I watch these three films! No other movie has managed to move me so completely and thoroughly as this Trilogy. I also have the added bonus of sharing these feelings about the film with my Daughter who loves and appreciates them as much I as do, so sharing that Love of the Trilogy enhances the bond that she and I already share. I look forward to (hopefully!) more of your assessments covering The Two Towers and The Return of the King as well. Great job!
Almost cried watching this. No trilogy has ever impacted my life the way lord of the rings has and does. Not a day goes by where I am not thinking of the movie or books in some way.
As someone who's been reading Tolkien avidly since 1974, I find it quite fascinating how invested in the story people are who first saw the films without prior reading of the books. If you haven't read all the Tales from Arda yet, you've an entire universe into which to fall!
Man I know what you are talking about. I have seen the movies like a billion times. Whenever I finish them I always feel a hole in my heart. Thanks for telling me why.
I got chills at 13:00....how did you know? D': You're absolutely right. I wasn't expecting you to hit the nail on the head so accurately for that rhetorical question. Dude.
Establishment and commitment, audience trust. Challenges along the way. Splitting of the group, is all in vain? Reinforcement of commitment. Even when the road ahead looks terrifying, we need someone who won't abandon us. That's essential. Makes sense. Love the video.
2:23 got me. not the words but the music. this theme is so awesome so emotional so memoriable i think that the music in lotr is the reason for the emotions you feel during the movies.
3:33 to 3:41 Just, wow. The building of their relationship is done so well throughout the story that until you see the stark contrast between the two moments you don't realize just how much has changed.
Real fellowship is defined by the decision to stay in the face of hardship and waning emotion. No relationship of any sort will have power to lift you up and make you better unless both parties are committed to each other on a level above emotion. Real love is a decision. Great video.
Man I just binged watched your avatar vids and now this. The audo is clear, the edditing is spot on and the topics taken up are expanded upon with razor focus. I cannot comprehend why this channel does not have more subs. But any ways you have one more. Great work
OMG! Such a good video! I just realized something, the genius behind Tolkiens story: By gathering a group of strangers to commit to a cause bigger than them, but at the same time have the item they all are committing to be the one thing that is constantly trying to tear them apart you have a constant narrative and emotional conflict in the story at any time, no matter what happens. It's the "I am not going to give up"-feeling both the book and the movies gives the audience that makes you emotionally invested in the movie. Your video is so on point, and somehow I never realized it is that one simple thing that makes the lord of the ring so good. Like two parents getting an unwanted child, but they decide to fully commit to raising it despite not loving each other, nor the child, but still takes all their energy and effort to commit towards this cause. That's what's noble, loveable and heartfelt. That is also what's wrong with so many blockbusters today, they're missing the one simple commitment and promise the main characters should make in the start of the story. Not a single Lord of the rings character has an important plot or emotional relevant dramatic backstory, they just all happen to be in this situation and now have to fully commit to the cause, or they'll die. And we get to know these characters through their actions, and actions of loyalty. Not through their tragic origins, but through their relationship with each other. You don't really need to explain anything, all u need is characters who commit to the cause.
The Lord of the Rings movies are my favorite movies of all time, and I am often wary of watching analysis videos about them. You did them justice. Thank you.
the only movie trilogy that touches me for it's characters not it's special effects or sheer beauty. I believe in this commitment, weight of cinema for these movies.
I've just been getting into this trilogy seriously for the first time in years. Such a coincidence that all these quality LotR videos are coming out. Good reminder that a modern blockbuster can still have quality writing. So many people dont understand why I hated Starwars Episode 8, lots of people dont see the laziness in writing plaguing Hollywood.
Loved this a lot. I think you captured in words what I felt when i watched this, roughly at the same time and age that you did. Nice production value too.
Thank You so much for revealing why I cried at that part when Sam went into the water for staying with Frodo. I have never realised that I wanted to have a friend like him. This is a very important thing in life and so few could tell they have just one. Great analisys!
elrond- "no oath, nor bond is laid to go further than you will" that line further states that any one of these people really don't have to stick around and just goes to show how much their connection grows from being total strangers(well at least some of them) to willingly laying down their lives for the others for the greater good despite not being bound by anything but their own choices to stay.
being raised on lord of the rings, i have never found films that have made me feel so much nuance every time. i have an overwhelmingly strong feeling of nostalgia every time someone even brings it up
Wow I loved this. So spot on. I love this series, but never quite dug in like have fleshing out just what exactly it is these movie do. Great video. Looking forward to parts 2 and 3.
I watched this with tear building up :'( I have watched the trilogy at least 10 times but i still watch it time to time. Masterpiece !! Im going to watch it to my kids in the future.
Thank you for putting into words the feelings LOTR gives. Its the fellowship between characters. The commitments they make and the fact they stick to them in spite of what lay ahead. I think that near universally appeals to people. Everyone wants that sort of connection whether it's someone who would go to the ends of the earth for you or someone you care so deeply for that you would go to the ends of the earth for them.
![Exclusive! น้องลิกก้า&น้องโรร่า มาแล้ว!! [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.48 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UmlpJhRekyY/mqdefault.jpg)
Part 2: th-cam.com/video/fUB6wXURR-I/w-d-xo.html
I HAVE A SPECIAL MISSION FOR ALL OF YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Please SHARE this video when & where you can! It's SO helpful to the channel, and it gets the word out about this video to as many eyes and ears as possible!
Share on Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, send to all your friends, and more!
Be my fellowship and help me on my journey to getting this video seen by the world!
THANK YOU SO MUCH, and cheers, dear viewers.
Guys please do so, this channel is one of the rarest which has so much effort in it. Let's help it grow as much as we can.
Amazing sound selection and design for this video. Bringing them feels
You're pronouncing the world "just" wrong. You say jest. The second letter is a long U. Say it with me. JUh--ST.
Done. This is the first time I've come across this channel but I'm captivated. Subbed 👍🏼
@@GerryBolger Thank you so much!
The Lord of the Rings trilogy is a truly once-in-a-lifetime (yes, once. I'm looking at you, Hobbit trilogy) event. So many things had to go right, so many little things could have gone wrong, but everything came together so perfectly. Even Tolkien himself felt that the Lord of the Rings was unadatable, and not only did Peter Jackson adapt it, but he created one of the greatest works of cinema ever
I wish people would stop hating on the hobbit.
@@LordBaronsworth Keep wishing, never gonna happen! :-)
Bingewatch them in a row, the Hobbit is so utterly disappointing even though it of course still does have some good moments here and there, although some of those good moments made little sense.
It also ruins the continuity with LOTR.
Seriously. These movies are the hight of cinema mastery, and the hight of adaptation.. Both at the same time.
I read the books directly before watching each movie for the first time and I was not disappointed. I've never ever had that happen when reading a book first, with anything else....
I mean in 9(12) my only criticism was a lack of Tom bombadil
Putting aside the difficulties in rewriting the script and the time constraints Jackson had when he took over the helm of the Hobbit films...The Hobbit as a novel has nowhere near the depth and gravitas of The Lord of the Rings. Jackson was working with a smaller supply of material, and lighter material at that. A child's novel was not going to match an adult's trilogy in emotional impact.
@@LordBaronsworth I feel sorry for those who hate The Hobbit. They only have 3 movies set in Middle-Earth that they get to enjoy. We on the other hand get 6!
The story of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit mean more to me than anyone could know. Middle Earth is like a rope that ever connects me to my childhood and has always been there ever since I was born, the music, the characters, the journey, it all calls to me. I grew up knowing it, my parents introduced it to us before I could even speak, and it calls me to the mountains where I would listen to The Hobbit audio book camping while I was young, it feels like it is connected to my soul. It is a symbol of my home, my Dad, and the longing for group of companions just like that, as you said. It connects me to the feeling of looking at vast mountain ranges, untouched, that feel like they belong to you because it's where you grew up. When I watched the movies for the first time in highschool, it became one of my all time favorite movie trilogy's. Then after, I re-read The Hobbit and finally read all The Lord of the Rings in about a month. I hope one day, I can give my children the same experience I had with the stories, and that when they read it, hear it, or see it, they learn love, companionship, and commitment to something bigger than yourself, that no matter how small they are or who they are, they can make a change. I hope when they look out into the forest, and up at the mountains, that is what they think of, and that it'll remind them of me the same way I am reminded of my Dad. To that I just say, Thank You J.R.R Tolkien.
Random Girl I know exactly how you feel. Every time I think of something wise Gandalf said, every time I hike the mossy, dirty, and green mountains of my home state, and more than anything, when I hear the song of the shire in my head, I feel that no matter where I am and no matter how dark the times may be that I am somehow home. Not a place in the waking world, nor in my dreams, but a beautiful little hobbit hole in the center of heart that opens it’s door only to the very old friends who take me back to middle earth, to my home.
You are not alone , there literally millions of people feeling the same . Its lotr we are talking about. It's the best cinema experience for a reason
In the book, Gimli said "Faithless is he who says farewell when the road darkens". After Boromir's death the fellowship could have easily been broken, yet each character/group continued on to the goal of destroying the one ring. That is loyalty to the beliefs and commitment the fellowship made to themselves and each other. They all continued to have faith in each other. As Arwen and Aragorn each said, "There is always hope". Hanon le, melon nin (thank you my friend), i am now a subscriber!!😚👌☺
Jennifer Baldini Thank you for sharing! This is such a good reference from the source material to back up the thesis of this video. It’s amazing how such incredible qualities from the original works are captured well by the filmmakers for the film adaptation; we can see the main themes from the film reflected in the book, and vice versa. Good to have you as a subscriber, Jennifer!
@pyropulseThey all did their best concerning the circumstances. Aragorn understood Frodo has to go on "alone". So the next best thing is to save M&P.
I'm a simple guy, I see LOTR video I smash like button.
one does not simply hit the like button
I’m also a simple guy, I see a good LOTR comment, I smash the comment like button ;)
I'm not a simple guy, i seem to point out unoriginal comments
I was 18 when I watched the LotR trilogy for the first time. I was impressed but not invested at all.
I had heard so many stories over the years of this epic, revolutionary piece of cinema and naturally, my mind created its own interpretation of what I had heard. So, of course, when I watched it, it wasn’t like my mind made it out to be.
Fast forward two years (into the present), three watch-throughs later, having watched countless video essays and love letters to these films (and also having watched the Hobbit trilogy (oof… >_>)) and with each viewing, it got more and more amazing. These characters grew so much on me, although they are really just names and words in a script but brought to life by amazing performances!
The music is beyond words. Just hearing the Shire theme is enough to make me tear up and send a chill down my spine. From intimate moments to epic, large-scale battles, the soundtrack is just so incredibly perfect and wonderful, I really can’t express it.
This is a great video essay and you really captured a lot of what makes us love The Lord of the Rings so much. The ending though, so touching… Can't wait for your next part on this masterpiece!
Very similar to me. I was around 15 and watched the movies and understood they were great movies and enjoyed them but felt no investment in them. A year or 3 later it was as if something just clicked and I was watching the movies multiple times a year and learning everything I possibly could about them and the books and laughing and tearing up at scenes every time. I still watch them around once a year and return to Middle-earth in all its glory
I don't think it can be overstated how important the technical aspects of these movies are in supporting/enhancing the emotion conveyed in the story and characters. The music, the cinematography, the sound design and the editing in these movies is so good at communicating the emotional beats of what's going on. You almost don't even have to pay attention to what's being said in order to just "feel" the impact of what's happening. The filmmaking itself has such emotional weight to it. Howard Shore's amazing score combined with these amazingly beautiful and epic shots (beautiful and epic even when it's just a shot of an actor's face... even when what's going on in frame is disgusting like an Uruk-Hai being birthed, the shot still looks amazing) with perfectly timed editing and powerful sounds for everything... I don't think any movie combines these factors more perfectly than Fellowship of the Ring does. You can get lost in a world of feeling just purely from looking at and listening to these movies. As I have done... many times...
It's the greatest fantasy movie I've ever seen in my life. I can't describe my feelings about this movie. I just can feel it. 😢😢😢
Thanks a lot for making such a GOOD VIDEO.🙏🙏🙏
Really enjoyed your piece here - made me remember why this film resonated with me so much.
You know you love a story, and you know a story has done such a beautiful job when you watch a 2 second clip with two words, "For Frodo.", and it immediately sends shivers down your spine.
the quality of this channel is just insane..
My dad introudced me to the world of Tolkien at a very young age. He read The Hobbit to me and we watched the LOTR 2d animated movie. I read The Hobbit myself a few years later at the age of 11 ish and tried reading the LOTR books but I wasn't ready yet. A year after the first movie came out my mom finally allowed me to watch it on VHS with my dad and I fell in love with it. I bought all the LOTR games for the PS2 and some for PC and have both the extended and theatrical version on DVD and I still play many of the games and read the books from time to time but I watch the extended edt of the movies every year. LOTR are one of the very few products of art and entertainment that make me cry:')
your childhood was awesome
I grew up with LOTR. First my sister read me the Hobbit and then we watched the 1976 animated version. My sister had the boardgame. I often fell asleep while the animated version was playing and it seeped into my very blood. When the movies came out it was an extremely emotional thing for me because it felt like coming home. I watch the movies and read the books all throughout the year because LOTR is.. Home.
@@YTistooannoying Hear hear!
Did the same. Read all the books, saw that animated version. When I heard they were making a proper version and doing all 3 books. I couldn't wait for release date. The stunning cinema photography is what grabbed me and how faithful to the books they were. It wasn't cheesy or cutified like other movies of my childhood books
same ! my dad took me to the theater a the age of nine years old to see Lord of the Rings ... It has completely changed my life since then, I am now a huge fantasy fan and proud:) Thanks to my dad and Tolkien!
These films are the literal definition of cinematic masterpiece. I fisrt watched them when i was 14/15 just before the Hobbit films came out. I fell in love with them immediately. I watched the extended versions (which are the only versions I will accept) at least once a month (lol back when i still had free time) and read every Tolkien book I could get my hands on. These films affected me in a way i can only describe as life-changing. They are my favourite films of all time and cannot be replicated (I'm looking at you Amazon).
As a kid, I really disliked all the Arwen stuff in the middle of nowhere, but on my most recent watch, I really appreciated it, and totally bought her and Aragorn’s relationship in a way I never had before
This whole Arwen storyline gives Aragorn an actual arc, which he misses in the books or which is really underdeveloped in the books.
I don't like Arwen as a character, but she gives Aragorn so much more depth to his character.
Splendid video and such creative ideas. As a fan of the series, I can say that I agree with most of your points except the part where you said the fellowship lacked the historical relationship. Most of the characters actually had a very close relationship with each other. Legolas and Aragorn for example, Aragorn was raised by the elves in Rivendell and Legolas was an acquaintance of Aragorn. And we can see how Legolas defends Aragorn verbally in the Council of Elrond. Also the four of the hobbits had known each other for a long time. Although some of them had known each other, I believe what you were trying to say was that the fellowship had some antagonising characters (Boromir-Aragorn, Gimli-Legolas). And actually this is what makes the fellowship so emotionally effective. As the audience, we witness how their relationship become so intimate with time and how they even feel willing to risk their lives for each other (Boromir's death for example). Finally, I would like to say that Gimli-Legolas friendship was so emotional for me. Especially this dialogue between Legolas and Gimli brought tears to my eyes: "Never thought I'd die fighting side by side with an Elf - What about side by side with a friend?"
Thank you for your comment and kindness!
... Yes, there are *certain* histories, but the Fellowship *as a whole* is a collection of strangers. I’m making that point collectively, not individually.
In the film, we don’t see much evidence for Aragorn’s and Legolas’ prior relationship; this is briefly alluded to but not expounded upon.
Therefore, it remains true that, at least to audience, the fellowship is a group of strangers (as I said in the video, also, the Hobbits and Gandalf don’t really fit the mold of being strangers to one another. I excluded them).
Thanks again!!
"Aye, I could do that"
Great video. I truly love the trilogy and its incredible storytelling.
Mr. Krepshus Thank you so much! I love your work as well. Cheers, friend!
@@meaningofthings Thank you so much, I didn't know your watched my videos :) I can't wait for the next two parts.
Lord of the rings is my favorite fantasy and film trilogy of all time. I watched them as a kid around 2007 with my dad. They were game changing. The battle of helms deep and Minas tirith were mind blowing. Watching the extended versions in 2012 were yet again, mind blowing. Now in 2018 about 10 years later, I have read all of The books, played the games, and know all the lore. I have experienced this wonderful universe. As a kid I loved the action but now I appreciate the writing and story and THEMES. This story is the first and greatest fantasy and work of all time. Tolkien truly put important life lessons in his work and Jackson adapted it beautifully. Also the music is the best soundtrack ever.
I wasn't old enough to watch LotR in the theaters unfortunately. But i was old enough to see the Marvel Cinematic Universe unfold. The MCU is good but it does not come anywhere close to LotR. LotR is literally as close to perfection that you could get
Josh Walker MCU is trash
@@James-yy4vl That was the exact thing I wanted to comment lol
I've come to despise the whole idea of cinematic 'Universe'. Hey lets make it clear that the Hobbit inhabits the same 'Universe' as Lo.t.R. Bahh!
I don't understand how this channel isn't bigger. Amazing quality. Easily one of my favorites
Draiden Thank you so much!
& hey, it takes a village to make something a household name. :) If you want, share this video and spread the word on it!
Well it wasn't really the writers of the films that made us believe in their emotional impact, it was THE writer *J.R.R.* *Tolkien* The story and characters were already written.
Well not many read the books. So the writers of the film do count!
I am lucky enough to say that i saw ALL 3 films at the cinemas when they came out. It was basically a family tradition at x mas. I was about 7 when the i saw the 1st one and even back then at that age i knew the movie was amazing and that the journey had only just begun. In my opinion lord of the rings is to movies what avatar is to television. Both masterpieces and actually share a lot of similarities.
But thank you for this. Your videos make me love my favorite things even more than i thought possible :)
I envy every single one of you 😭😭 I will pay 4 times the price to watch it in theatres today.
This theme of loyalty, of fellowship, resonates so much with me. It's an ideal, that to this day, is so essential to me. Loyalty to your friends is one of the highest virtues in my opinion. I guess that is why LotR is so very important and so emotional for me. It really does hold a special part in my heart.
Well said. As we keep putting principles and morals in jeopardy, making it a characteristic of modern day society, the movie holds more and more to me.
It should be noted that Aragorn and Legolas also have a relationship, as they have known each other for many years in the books, but it's not talked about at all in the movies. They have traveled together and I think they even hunted Golum together on orders from Gandalf.
And Aragorn and Gandalf have a relationship. And all 4 Hobbits have relationships with each other (Merry, Pippin, and Frodo are literally related to each other). And all 4 Hobbits have relationships with Gandalf, though Frodo has the best relationship with him. And given Faramir's knowledge of and experience with Gandalf, Boromir is probably familiar with him, as I'm sure each member of the Fellowship actually is.
@@Richard_Nickerson Gandalf is the cog of the fellowship. He knows the fellowship better than most.
this shit is what i subbed for, i love it so much!
Me too, bruh. Me too.
*makes a serious face and places fist above the heart*
Truth
I love your analysis of these films! I was thinking of the scene in Return of the King where Frodo wakes up and sees everyone in his room - and the audience is made to remember that Frodo, unlike us, hasn't known of any of their outcomes the entire time. It seems like the final reinforcement of fellowship you were talking about - after all that time, they were all still fighting for him (even Gandalf, who he thought was dead). Its such a beautiful scene.
I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on Sam and Frodo's friendship. It seems as if the series begins with them and ends with them. We watch as they endure so much together, making their final goodbye so heartbreaking!
First Avatar now this? Killing it dude! Can't wait for the full series!
is it confirmed that there will be a series ?
@@AbdelilahMhimdi yup, he says it's the first of 3
thanks
@@AbdelilahMhimdi no prob!
Beautiful, poignant and in depth analysis of the greatest films ever made and indeed greatest source material. You had me in tears at the use of the soundtrack and the visuals and reinforced why these movies mean so much to people. You have deservedly earned yourself another sub. Can’t wait for the next two parts!
I know alot of the credit goes to Howard Shore's amazing music, Peter Jackson's directing and cinematography, and of course the actors and countless others who produced the original films you borrowed content from, but some of the credit also belongs to you, for making literally the first TH-cam video ever to bring me to tears of joy as you described all the ways in which the fellowship reaffirmed their commitments at the end. Brought back all the feels, and reminded me why The Lord of the Rings is my favorite film trilogy of all time.
Yeah, and no credit to Tolkien himself...
@@Richard_Nickerson That's unnecessary.
@@khodexus4963 Is it? The video gives all the writing credit to the movie makers, and you're trying to give credit to this guy who had absolutely nothing to do with either the books or the movies.
Give credit where it's due, don't kiss ass.
@@Richard_Nickerson I quite explicitly did just that. You seem to merely be trolling.
@@khodexus4963 Oh yeah? Let's see... you edited your comment, and you still make no mention of Tolkien and still give credit to this guy who had absolutely nothing to do with any of the books or movies. Yes, that is doing just that, you're absolutely right.
It's such a pure and heavy story. I don't remember a time that I didn't know what Lord of the Rings was, but I always wanted to hear or see it told again and again. As I grew up, I knew why. It's exactly what Sam's speech says.."those are the stories that stuck with you, even if you were too small to understand why".
It shows what honor truly is, it shows us that even the heros had short comings, but they all chose to overcome them in the end. They all became servants to eachother & carried brotherly-love for one another..something we should all have and do.
It will always be deeper and more important to so many people than most understand or believe.
At 10:00 is when the tears started coming out.
Great essay. I'm sitting here going "Wow, yeah, he's right, that's exactly how it feels..."
I kind of took it for granted at first, but the fact that this fellowship is so strong that it connects story threads that don't meet again for SO long... is kind of incredible. I remember reading the books for the first time and being super excited for the characters to meet again, I was looking forward to it so much that it filled me with excitement and joy for basically two entire books. And when they succeed in the end and everything is over, even though the evil is defeated, it it so gut wrenching to witness the end of the fellowship. All of them going their separate ways, some most likely to never meet again. Man, if I think about it too hard, I'm gonna cry again, and I already did that for a looong time after finishing the books... :'D
Awesome made video!! The edit is just crazy good. LOTR means a lot to me, watched it for the first time when I was 8 years old. I've been a big fan through out the years and I have so many memories related to these films. The movies takes every emotional cell you have in your body and makes it into music, life, storytelling... and the actors are just ON POINT in the best combination ever possible.
Every word in this video was 100 % correct.
I was wating to this video SO MUCH!
Me too....
The LOTR films came out when I was in high school---one of the lowest points in my life. They were one of the only sources of joy and beauty I can remember from that time; they helped me through so much. I am really happy you are making this series.
There are so many videos of people talking about why the Lord of the Rings is the best work of all time. I love it.
There’s a reason they won so many academy awards
Im so grateful of how i was raised. Raised in the enviroment of fantasy stories like LOTR, Harry Potter, Star Wars, Narnia, etc. From age 6 i believe. I am a huge nerd on fantasy stories, and love to write my own stories. Good music, and amazing stories gives you a wonderful childhood. Furthermore, i came to love history too, and have since watched amazing historical movies. I am very grateful, that i wasn’t raised as my friends, who barely knows what a movie is, and thinks that every fantasy movie is shit, without ever having seen it.
As a 12 year old watching these movies I was blown away by the scale of the spectacle, the enormous battles and giant armies of evil, epic speaches and the heroism on display, all grounded in the attention to detail during the production, making middle earth feel like a place that actually existed. I always liked the third movie the most.
Now I can appreciate the quite moments as well and understand how they are an integral part to the beauty of these movies and this story in general. Howard Shore's score is perfect too, without him these movies wouldn't be what they are. 15 years later these movies are still my favorite pieces of cinema but for different reasons. Today The Fellowship of the Ring is my favorite movie between the three.
We're so lucky to have these movies, it's a true miracle that they were made the way they are.
My heart is broken because there's only one part right now. I needs the other 2! I agree wholeheartedly. This series is and will probably forever be my favorite. As a writer I strive for my books to be a fraction as good as this series and if someone ever compares my books to these I could die happy
Really great job! Not enough videos on the Lord of the Rings. Can’t wait for the rest! 👊🏻
When I was younger I just thought Lord of the Rings was cool, but a couple months ago I marathoned them over a weekend and I actually got choked up at the end, for the first time after like 12 watches. I was amazed at how deep it actually is if you really invest in it
I just wanted to say... thank you.
I was in need for smart and deep analysis of movies. This channel is amazing!
And about this particular video...well I'm just going to admit that you made my share a tear or two. I love LOTR for years, i watched movies countless times.
You captured and put into the words what I felt, what many of us felt on scene between Sam and Frodo. I cry on that scene every single time and the reason why i exactly as you said it..because we are longing for a commitment like that, for someone who will keep our back no matter what. This is so true...
Thank you so much for this video.
Wish you all the best.
The LOTR has been my favorite movie experience for many many years. I watch the entire series (directors extended cut) twice a year. I've seen all the special features and watched the films with commentary by both directors and actors. I LOVE LOTR! You have perfectly captures what was only a "thought and a shadow" in my own mind. Excellent video, I am now a subscriber and look forward to the rest of the series!
This is your best edit yet. Amazing work.
Based on one of the most read and loved books of all time. Which touches on a vast amount of important ageless topics relevant to individuals and humanity at large. And a generally well done adaptation of the books by the movie. Combined with one of the most fantastic and moving musical scores of all time by Howard Shore. And there you have it, you have a winning formula.
Rare to have a character driven plot, with an emphasis on character development and relationships these days to be honest.
It just struck me that at the end of Fellowship Frodo pulls Sam up from the water and saves him, through his love and commitment for him, and in Return of the King at the end of all things Sam pulls Frodo up as he hangs above Mount Doom. Through water, through fire. Beautiful parallels.
This isn't the only fellowship analysis video on TH-cam worth watching, but it's probably my favorite. Thank you.
This video is truly exceptional. The LOTR trilogy is so emotionally intense, and I could never put my thumb on why. Thank you :)
Beautiful Video. Love it. Really made my day. Acctualy the LOtR is the reason why I started studying Film
These films were so impactful for my childhood. What a brilliant, touching tribute to that. Thank you.
I got introduced to this series as a child with the Lego LOTR, then I watched the trilogy, and after that I started getting more and more involved to the LOTR. Then I became a great fan. Time has passed but I'm still, and i will always be a fan of this series (including the Hobbit).
I just came from your atla videos and between them and this I’m legit crying too this is so beautiful and good
Your assessment is nothing short of brilliant, and I can truly relate to your feelings as well. The emotional heft of this movie and the Trilogy as a whole is palpable, and has no peer in cinematic history for bringing out the full gamut of emotions in me. Joy, laughter, dread, sadness, and ultimately exultation (among many other feeligs!) are present and on full display when I watch these three films! No other movie has managed to move me so completely and thoroughly as this Trilogy. I also have the added bonus of sharing these feelings about the film with my Daughter who loves and appreciates them as much I as do, so sharing that Love of the Trilogy enhances the bond that she and I already share.
I look forward to (hopefully!) more of your assessments covering The Two Towers and The Return of the King as well. Great job!
This is the best LOTR analysis I've ever seen. And it is just a third of the whole analysis. Congratulations!
So glad you brought these videos back! Thank you!
Almost cried watching this. No trilogy has ever impacted my life the way lord of the rings has and does. Not a day goes by where I am not thinking of the movie or books in some way.
As someone who's been reading Tolkien avidly since 1974, I find it quite fascinating how invested in the story people are who first saw the films without prior reading of the books. If you haven't read all the Tales from Arda yet, you've an entire universe into which to fall!
Man I know what you are talking about. I have seen the movies like a billion times. Whenever I finish them I always feel a hole in my heart. Thanks for telling me why.
Truly still one of my favourite pieces of work on YT
I got chills at 13:00....how did you know? D': You're absolutely right.
I wasn't expecting you to hit the nail on the head so accurately for that rhetorical question. Dude.
I was sobbing by the end of this video. It was beautiful, my guy.
As a life-long Tolkien fan I truly enjoyed your analysis, and you have a new supporter now! Keep up the great work!
The ending of this video is just heartbreaking beautiful!!! This video explains perfectly why I love LOTR so freaking much.
Establishment and commitment, audience trust.
Challenges along the way.
Splitting of the group, is all in vain?
Reinforcement of commitment.
Even when the road ahead looks terrifying, we need someone who won't abandon us. That's essential.
Makes sense.
Love the video.
At 9:35, you can't help but tear up as the video goes on. This guy put it into words what we actually feel at that moment
2:23 got me. not the words but the music. this theme is so awesome so emotional so memoriable i think that the music in lotr is the reason for the emotions you feel during the movies.
3:33 to 3:41 Just, wow. The building of their relationship is done so well throughout the story that until you see the stark contrast between the two moments you don't realize just how much has changed.
Real fellowship is defined by the decision to stay in the face of hardship and waning emotion. No relationship of any sort will have power to lift you up and make you better unless both parties are committed to each other on a level above emotion. Real love is a decision.
Great video.
Scott Darrington Great words!
we need more channels and videos on youtube with this level of quality thank you so much! :D
Man I just binged watched your avatar vids and now this. The audo is clear, the edditing is spot on and the topics taken up are expanded upon with razor focus. I cannot comprehend why this channel does not have more subs. But any ways you have one more. Great work
OMG! Such a good video!
I just realized something, the genius behind Tolkiens story:
By gathering a group of strangers to commit to a cause bigger than them, but at the same time have the item they all are committing to be the one thing that is constantly trying to tear them apart you have a constant narrative and emotional conflict in the story at any time, no matter what happens.
It's the "I am not going to give up"-feeling both the book and the movies gives the audience that makes you emotionally invested in the movie.
Your video is so on point, and somehow I never realized it is that one simple thing that makes the lord of the ring so good.
Like two parents getting an unwanted child, but they decide to fully commit to raising it despite not loving each other, nor the child, but still takes all their energy and effort to commit towards this cause. That's what's noble, loveable and heartfelt.
That is also what's wrong with so many blockbusters today, they're missing the one simple commitment and promise the main characters should make in the start of the story.
Not a single Lord of the rings character has an important plot or emotional relevant dramatic backstory, they just all happen to be in this situation and now have to fully commit to the cause, or they'll die. And we get to know these characters through their actions, and actions of loyalty. Not through their tragic origins, but through their relationship with each other.
You don't really need to explain anything, all u need is characters who commit to the cause.
Another great thing about LotR that struck me is the amount of characters you spent relatively little time with, but you actually feel close to
Thank you Mr. Narrator; You did an insightful and touching job with the narrative. Well done.
So good. Thanks for making this.
Ready for the next 2 parts I've never watched a TH-cam video back to back like this one.. You earned this mans subscribe.. Well done well done
The Lord of the Rings movies are my favorite movies of all time, and I am often wary of watching analysis videos about them. You did them justice. Thank you.
My Girlfriend doesn`t get it ... sad
my bf doesn`t get it too
@@SS-si6lz i feel with you. at least we can enjoy it ourselfs
Simply epic.
the only movie trilogy that touches me for it's characters not it's special effects or sheer beauty. I believe in this commitment, weight of cinema for these movies.
I've just been getting into this trilogy seriously for the first time in years. Such a coincidence that all these quality LotR videos are coming out.
Good reminder that a modern blockbuster can still have quality writing. So many people dont understand why I hated Starwars Episode 8, lots of people dont see the laziness in writing plaguing Hollywood.
I'm so glad you do these... Thank you!
Loved this a lot. I think you captured in words what I felt when i watched this, roughly at the same time and age that you did. Nice production value too.
Thank You so much for revealing why I cried at that part when Sam went into the water for staying with Frodo. I have never realised that I wanted to have a friend like him. This is a very important thing in life and so few could tell they have just one.
Great analisys!
This is a series that will speak to generations to come. It is as timeless and legendary as the original Star Wars trilogy.
elrond- "no oath, nor bond is laid to go further than you will"
that line further states that any one of these people really don't have to stick around and just goes to show how much their connection grows from being total strangers(well at least some of them) to willingly laying down their lives for the others for the greater good despite not being bound by anything but their own choices to stay.
Really beautiful video, thank you. I didn’t think a video essay could make me start to tear up
A Precious video (My precious). Good luck with your fracture.
Vicente Ortega Rubilar Thanks! Except... that injury was years ago. All healed up now! Cheers to you.
One of the most beautiful ways to describe the the movie I have ever seen :)
Thank you so much for your hard work presenting this!
The best tale in the history of tales
being raised on lord of the rings, i have never found films that have made me feel so much nuance every time. i have an overwhelmingly strong feeling of nostalgia every time someone even brings it up
That was a beautiful conclusion, well said.
Wow I loved this. So spot on. I love this series, but never quite dug in like have fleshing out just what exactly it is these movie do. Great video. Looking forward to parts 2 and 3.
In this video, you have beautifully expressed my own collected thoughts!
I watched this with tear building up :'( I have watched the trilogy at least 10 times but i still watch it time to time. Masterpiece !! Im going to watch it to my kids in the future.
This was really fantastic, and got me a little weepy! I think it's time to watch these movies again :) Thanks for making this.
I just watched the first movie yesterday...this video came right in time!
MountainPepsi For the first time?!
How do you not have more subscribers ?! Also These movies are my favourite. The extended editions are the only way to watch them.
Thank you for putting into words the feelings LOTR gives. Its the fellowship between characters. The commitments they make and the fact they stick to them in spite of what lay ahead. I think that near universally appeals to people. Everyone wants that sort of connection whether it's someone who would go to the ends of the earth for you or someone you care so deeply for that you would go to the ends of the earth for them.