Why Roberto De Zerbi Should be Man Utd's Next Manager...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- JerseyFIFA Link in Instagram Bio: / atlantisfootball
(USE CODE: ATLANTIS)
SUB to the PATREON (7 day FREE TRIAL): patreon.com/AtlantisFootball572
Why Roberto De Zerbi Should be Man Utd's Next Manager...
Man Utd 4-3 Liverpool Extra Time Analysis (190k views): • How Ten Hag & Amad Won...
Recent Videos:
Kobbie Mainoo is a COMPLETE Midfielder: • Kobbie Mainoo is a COM...
Why Dalot is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED: • Why Dalot is CRIMINALL...
How Hojlund is Developing into the Complete Striker: • Hojlund is Evolving in...
How to Rebuild Man Utd's Midfield for £75M: • How to Rebuild Man Utd...
Email: atlantisfootball96@gmail.com
Instagram: @AtlantisFootball
Twitter: @atlantis861
I must state that in NO way, shape or form am I intending to infringe rights of the copyright holder. Content used is strictly for research/reviewing purposes and to help educate. All under the Fair Use law.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
If you ever wish for more information on visual or auditory terms, please click the link below:
is.gd/wvjoCp - กีฬา
JerseyFIFA Link in Instagram Bio: instagram.com/atlantisfootball/
(USE CODE: ATLANTIS)
SUB to the PATREON (7 day FREE TRIAL): patreon.com/AtlantisFootball572
Why Roberto De Zerbi Should be Man Utd's Next Manager...
Man Utd 4-3 Liverpool Extra Time Analysis (190k views): th-cam.com/video/u66-5Fc53L4/w-d-xo.html
The whole squad needs reshuffle; we have been changing coaches but not replacing the current players in the squad with better options
You have just blatantly lied on the internet we have literally reshuffled our quote on quote dead wood and brought in new players spending well over 400m pounds in two years and only a carabao cup to show for it, don’t you watch our games and see how poor we play it’s definitely on the system of how we play stop giving excuses to fuel your lies
@@Fanronginchina I'm sry I may be wrong but spending alot doesn't mean u spent something...as a Real Madrid fan I find utd buy $3 cheese for $10 bcuz they tend to wait last minute to buy the cheese, as much as u guys spent alot, u didn't change a thing all your so called "dead wood" is still there I often watch utd side and be like where are the elite players that deserve your badge...like if i were to pick someone from utd to replace anyone on my team thats aging wud only be Diogo Dalot for carvajal...u guys are very good but u can't keep blaming coaches or managers
@@pubgsniperlord7055who requests the players?
@@Fanronginchinaexactly. Ole got second place and was on top of the table at a point with Fred and McTom, an old Matic and a dramatic injury prone Pogba. We have Case , Mainoo, same McTom , same Bruno, and yet here we are… we have a better back four than Ole did. Just injury prone Bailly replaced by an injury prone butcher. Remember Ole got second place playing Daniel James! James >> Antony
@@pubgsniperlord7055 you would 100% blame the coach when it’s his fault and 100% blame the players when it’s their fault you said we overspend on players who’s fault is that definitely not the players fault the club is willing the pay exorbitant amount of money to get them another reason why it’s ten hags fault is when he was brought to Utd he was given veto power on any transfer that comes in he choose Antony,mount,casemiro,amrabat etc his talent ID is very poor and on players like garnacho and mainoo there’s this myth that he made them better that’s all lies they are naturally gifted players that are literally helping him keep his job
@AtlantisFootball I remember your poch vs eth video when you said that eth tactically is the best manager in the world (as all of us thought). What do you think went wrong? How does "the best manager in the world" suddenly become terrible tactician and should be sacked?
Because he’s not playing that style of football. He’s abandoned every philosophy he had at Ajax.
@@lmq9516he’s abandoned it because the players he inherited are incapable of playing his style of play
he doesnt, he is still a great manager, just 65 injuries this season alone and never more than 23 senior players available at once, compared to liverpool/city/villa/arsenals squads that had at least 28 senior players available every week. New board, new directors, new owners, anthonys case, 35 defensive lineups in 47 games, that alone would wreak havoc on any team. Remember he placed 3rd in his first season. Patience my friend.
@@rahbalder7581 bro have u seen an elite manager play as horrible with injuries as this man......in my opinion de zerbi has had injuries too and still played with the level of players he has had...eth makes us look like a poorly coached sunday league team playing pros ....how does bournemouth come to OT and out play us hooooowww
Do you think United should go for joao Felix this summer? He is similar to Kane in back to goal play and also could provide competition for Bruno in attacking midfield which might improve him and Hojlund in the process?
My bro,I agree with you in a lot of things,but I feel you're biased against Ten Hag,
Madness is doing the same thing expecting different results, changing the manager will not change anything in Man United. You sound like the Arsenal fans saying Arteta out back in 2021.There's nothing that Ten Hag or any other manager can do with these set of players,think about it. Just because you have a YT channel doesn't make you correct,I always read how passive and prejudiced you are when you reply to people who comment that we don't need a change in the football coach, laughing at their comments,its all just opinion,and as much as you feel entitled to yours,the same way I feel entitled to mine
Atleast bottom teams were not dominating arteta and its obvious he had style of football, for ten hag to say he can't play ajax style makes him clueless, first season at mancity, pep was ask will he abandon is style of because players are not really getting it , he replied no I will never do that even if it caused us we are still going to play that way.
@@saheedolawle so true, i'm so annoyed when he said that, he bought a lot of players these two seasons (n i believe most of them are his choices) n just because he didn't get de jong he said can't play that style. what a loser
@@hariantowijaya1937 exactly atleast we should be seeing positive vibes, we easily dominated by bottom teams really makes me lose up on the manager, brighton key players were sold last season even if they not performing well this season we can see how they dictate play and what they are trying to do even if they got beaten, who bought ball playing goal keeper still we can't play from the back.
@DuncanAu-fu4lg lol, he was beaten does mean he was dominated all through, hence he still played his style of football, tell me a single bottom team that manutd played this season that we dominated all through.
@@saheedolawle bro Arsenal came 8th twice, they had to sell almost everyone for anything to work in Arsenal. Ten Hag has being playing the football we have been playing for years not because he wants,because he has to, due to pressure that is on him to perform. Manchester United has the worst recruitment resources,not since Ten Hag came ,but for a long while before that,thats not Ten Hag's fault.Give him time under a better system above him, better players and I'm sure he will deliver
In my opinion, I think united should appoint julian nagelsmann as the new man united manager. I feel as though his style of play and tactics can develop and adapt to epl football. He's also a young manager so I feel as though he'll be good for us in the long term but I think it will maybe take 2 seasons of epl football for nagelsmann before he can win the league.
This is only if ten hag gets sacked because I think maybe ten hag needs one more season to prove himself.
Atlantis, I strongly feel de zerbi will still struggle with this current team if he’s to display his style here, if INEOS brings him in, they better start the rebuild from the midfield and central defense, these are two key areas were lacking right there. The personnels we have currently may likely suit more to a counter attacking system other than possession style.
And will we be patient enough when things aren’t going well, because I don’t think he will completely revamp the squad instantly, you know result matters a lot at a club like Manchester United.
I've been waiting for this video
How many Utd players can make it on the bench of the top 3?
Our squad is mediocre, how many players can play possession football? Bar Martinez who is can play excellence from the back? Which midfielder can dictate play? Maybe Kobbie but is he a Dm really?
Varane, Lindelof, Evans, AWB, Shaw, Maguire,Scott,Casemiro,DVB,Eriksem, Rashford, Pellistri, Martial, Antony and Sancho must be moved on or kept as rotation players. Greenwood is most likely getting sold, Amad should get more minutes to determine if he can play at a high level.
The squad is not mediocre at all. Far from it. It’s a top 4 squad. Garnacho, Hojlund, Bruno, Mainoo, Varane, Dalot, Shaw, Martinez, Onana are all good enough for a title challenging team.
Under a better manager they develop even further
@@AtlantisFootball how many games have Varane, Martinez and shaw played this season guven how Liverpool with less than half a season of Van dijk went from Champions league to Europa league
Even Casemiro one of our best last season has been injury prone and underwhelming this season
I think there's a flaw with De Zerbis Brighton that you didn't mention. Their system of baiting the opposition into a press in order to create an artificial counter attack is reliant on teams taking the bait. For example when Brighton played West Ham and the hammers stayed in their low block, Brighton were ineffective against west ham and failed to break them down.
At Man United with the team having quality players, opposition will be happy to sit deep and not take the bait under a de zerbi team. And because I don't think I've seen Brighton having an effective plan b for when teams don't take the bait, I wouldn't reckon he would be right for man united. I think we'd end up consistently getting top 4, but wouldn't be able to fight for league titles.
Ten hag is good enough, We just have had too many injuries this season since tge start of the season hence the under performance. If Licha wasnt injured at the start we would have easily been in top 4 rn.
He’s just not tho. Injuries aren’t an excuse for basic tactical errors. We wouldn’t be in the top 4 if Licha wasn’t injured at all.
Both Villa and tottenham have had injuries as well
Im not sure about de zerbi because he has no defensive structure which leads to him getting turned over by teams like Luton. Not to mention he got relegated with sassaulo
Mate what you on about? He didn’t get relegated with Sassuolo and he 100% has a defensive structure, better than Ten Hag. You literally can’t have watched Brighton at all
negative ball knowledge brighton can absolutely defend, did u not watch our game vs them? lmfao
@@AtlantisFootball I don't know because yes he plays attacking football but constantly losing 4-0 against other teams worries me because he alone with Ange and emery don't have any other tactic apart from attack attack attack and pray someone pops up with a goal. At least ten Hag knows when to sit back and let the opposition have the ball
Mate your understanding of the game is very limited if you define their tactics as “attack attack attack”. It’s just not. You need to watch videos on their tactical set up because you’re completely wrong here
@@comrademarii are you sure that was defending or our attack behaving like vanarama attackers
one think no one talks about is that Ten hag never got all the coaches he had at Ajax or he needs to get his style fully across.
Mate come on these excuses are getting ridiculous now 🤣
So you’re telling me Pep takes all his coaches from Barcelona to Bayern and then take them all to City as well? Or Klopp this the same😭
I feel bad for calling arsenal fans delusional under wenger
nah, this is not an excuse, but im sure that the coaches who were coaching under Ole are still there, and if im not mistaken, Ten Hag football at Ajax and Ole football are not even similar.
gee!
i didn't mean that, but at least they should get some new coaching staff who can help the manager put his ideas across in every little area.
If Leverkusan can do it with right manager, United definitely can do it with De Zerbi
Even Pep would be struggling with this team we have. We got ten hag into a team that has never played his type of football and with everything he had to deal he overachieved in his first season and not much changed in teh squad and we're expecting him to compete with teams that have had their managers for 3+ years? make it make sense.
Manchester united needs a coach like Max Allegri who is very pragmatic. Not a ideologue like de zerbi.
I do believe the current crop of players could excel better with a better tactical approach, which eth seems to be blind to. We all thought he would bring the tactical nous from his days at Ajax to Man utd, but instead, he seems more like in self-destruct mode than actually improving the team. Yes we need better players and we need to shift players not suited to the united level, but if De Zerbi can get his mid table team to perform above their level, I don't see why eth is struggling that much with current crop of players, unless there's something wrong going on behind the scenes that we don't know about. I don't think we can afford to give Ten Hag another season if that means losing out on a top manager when they have the luxury to choose from the upcoming vacancies that are very enticing to a lot of them. Even though the grass is always greener on the other side, but I think De Zerbi will be a great choice to kick start the ineos era going forward.
Can you make a video on players that will boost man utd but those players are not the ones we are being linked to like cheaper options
But the real problem with Man Utd isn't really the tactical side of things, it's the dressing room culture. No tactics are gonna work when players turn up for a match not wanting to break a sweat.
Yes it is the tactical side of things. Watch the games. The players are breaking a sweat, it’s the tactical set up which is the issue
@@AtlantisFootball It's true tactically we've been lacking and conceding double digit shots every game is a clear sign of a poor game plan. I guess what I'm on to is also the attitude of the players. I'm just afraid RDZ gets thrown under the bus just like his predecessors. He'll do well in his first season, like so many of the previous managers, and then players decide they don't feel up for it. I was Ole Out and when EtH came in, I thought we finally had a proper modern coach. That same feeling seems to repeat with every incumbent manager. Perhaps a change is inevitable given it's a result-based business but this dressing room definitely needs a good sorting out.
Look, if we take a comparison. If manager is a builder, then the tactics & philosophy & structure are the blueprint of construction, ie how the base and the building will look. The players are the raw materials. You can have the world's best builder and let's say we bring Pep in, who has the best tactics & philosphy (still has to deal with the horrendous structure), he has horrible raw material. You can't make a incredible building by hiring the best builder, but the raw material should also be good. If Man City/Pool/Arsenal players are cement and iron, most Man Utd players are sawdust. This might be a very illogical correlation but try and understand the point.
ETH, if sacked will be surely successful at another club. So, I feel for that and also, I feel bad for the incoming manager because he will have more or less the same fate
He won’t have more or less the same fate. You realise we’ve just been taken over by Ineos right?
Also the issues are tactical. A new manager immediately improves us
@@AtlantisFootball I absolutely agree with you that there are tactical problems but this is all about results and has been since we have had injuries to Martinez and Shaw especially. You say that the tactical patterns of play should be similar irrespective of injuries (like how Liverpool play the same way despite injuries). The problem is the profile of players we have is so varied. How can you except Maguire or Evans to do even half the things Licha does. Same with Lindelof, how can he do what Shaw does. If Pool have Matip and Konate out, they have Gomez and Quansah who aren't on the same level, but the profile is same. If Arsenal have Saliba out, Tomiyasu, Timber, Kiwior all aren't world class as him, but have a similar profile, same at Man City. I understand your frustrations abt tactical problems but this is by choice. You might disagree but you can't expect this players (who are available now) to control the game and score using that control. I would actually feel bad for De Zerbi, or Nagelsmann or any other coach who would come in because he would have the same fate. No manager can succeed if atleast 7-8 players are replaced with young hungry players. Apart from Bruno and Onana who played yesterday's game, you can't label our any other player as world class. Trust me, ETH is a world class manager, don't let the recent poor period blind you, he is a world class coach, at a level below Pep, Klopp, Mou, Ancelotti but a level above De Zerbi, Amorim etc. Sacking the manager isn't the solution.
Injuries are not an excuse stop using that. Every team has had injuries.
How does injuries make the defensive and possession systems completely full apart.
Mate just wouldn’t have the same fate at all. The squad is good enough to be in the top 4
ETH is not a world class manager mate. This next level delusion
Fully convinced with De zerbi
Absolutely agree
If Manchester united is looking for a new manager it should Simeon Inzaghi or Ruben Amorim De Zerbi is good but I don't think he's capable of handling a club with huge demands like united
I would like Ten hag to succeed but if they sack him then De zerbi , Naglsman would be the best option man ..as we would play possesion and v would had a better structure and a pattern of play which will also help the management to recruit players according to style of play ..hope of the best🤞
Bro De zerbi just left Brighton and ur dream might come true.
De zerbi at Utd 🔥😍 but knowing Utd They will be slow immediately going after him and other big clubs might snatch him 😢
i want ETH to suceed but if he was replaced i want it to be inzaghi of inter. i said a 352 would suit our team
There are a lot of Agreements & Disagreements in the comments section below. From Man Utd fans, to fans from other Clubs & other Leagues who are sincerely posting comments from their understandings & reasonings of Football.
But my opinion is Roberto DeZerbi is a Good Manager & even BETTER at Coaching. And thats what Man Utd needs after the priority which is the Right Boards around. Simply, he is BETTER than EtH¡!¡
Right now we've made the Biggest Boards Snatching in History, which is Omar Berrada. Ashworth, Wilcox so on could follow soon.
With Sir Jim, Omar, Ashworth behind DeZerbi we could be back to the Mighty Status we had. I'm sure of that. But we need a good Manager to back that up with.
The likes of Wan Bissaka could be the best when Coached by DeZerbi. There are lots of players who played with their talents but lots who have talents but lack the right people around to help them reach their potentials. Bissaka's biggest issue is crossing, could get to the 'best status' when DeZerbi comes in, cause DeZerbi is very good at Coaching.
DeGea could've benefited from DeZerbi too and lots of others.
We need to clear the unqualified players first.
EtH had a good season last season, even lot of the players who flopped this term. But he doesn't have a Pattern which is the problem. Another EtH's weakness is he doesn't change formation or tactics during an ongoing match like the one DeZerbi did when his team were being outplayed in the first 15mins. He made a tactical switch & he ruined EtH's side. I think EtH goes into a game with just a single plan, cause from kickoff to the end he kept only same idea. AGAIN the next match. If it doesn't work switch to another plan. Eth doesn't¡!¡
I was a big EtH defendant, even creating excuses to defend him. I started wanting him out during our depressing Champions League run.
I have been asking "why EtH don't use other ideas during an ongoing match‽‽‽" The only time I saw him do that was against Liverpool which helped but why don't he do it on a regular. EtH probably goes into a match with just a single plan, because he ALWAYS Play the same way each match. Then repeat it the next match.
Truly we have lot of weak players & lot of injuries but what is EtH's pattern‽‽‽
Sometimes we just run around the pitch. The players play to their limits. Have very low team work & no fights at all. Weak Cowards¡!¡
Why I prefer DeZerbi is because he is a Very Good Coach, VERY Good.
Ajax needs EtH.
Man Utd needs DeZerbi (1st Choice) or Emery.
Excellent video as per 👌🏾
Thanks man
@@ocelot9460 yes I absolutely can say De Zerbi is better than Ten Hag. You’re being delusional here
@@AtlantisFootball when ever nobody agrees with you, you just call them delusional.... get a grip pal, this TH-cam career wont last much longer if you act like your superior to everyone else just cause you know a bit about football.
You will need to change ALL coaches including the manager to make a difference
This is the man for the job
Forcing a professional player to become world class just because he has showed glimpses of it doesn't make sense. Ten hag must stay and some players must leave for the betterment of the team and their future.
I´d prefer Inzaghi, his work first at Lazio and now at Inter has been elite.
My hesitation with De Zerbi is his temperament. I think it was good that we didn’t go for Conte for similar reasons. Being a good coach is one thing but that’s not the only quality needed when coaching Manchester United.
I’m a huge fan of ten hag, but this video is spot on. The excuse of our players aren’t good enough to posses the ball is silly. People were saying the same about spurs for years
Thanks bro 🙏🏼 exactly my point. Postecoglou came in and improved so many of the tottenham players. Look at Bentancur and Porro for example
The same issue holding back Ten Hag from implementing a possession base system will be the same issue with De Zerbi. People are naive or kidding themselves if they think De Zerbi will magically change some of our players. Remember we use to say the same thing whn Ten Hag initially came in. Is a personal thing not manager issues
It’s not a personale issue. Ten Hag has Onana, Dalot, Kambwala, Maguire and Mainoo in the build up phase who are better technically than what De Zerbi has a Brighton.
De Zerbi 100% is able to do what he is doing at Brighton. It’s definitely a manager issue not a personnel issue.
I don’t know why people are making out as if United have a terrible squad. They don’t. They have the players to play out from the back, just not the system or strategy from the manager
Has he won anything that would be my first question?
That's not how you judge managers mate. That's literally how people who just started watching football last year would judge managers.
Did pep win anything before he took over at Barca, Arteta? Klopp before Dortmund?
better then ajax scam
@@AtlantisFootballbut that’s exactly how you judge managers. De Zerbi is a hipster’s choice and there are no guarantees he can deal with egos or big players.
@@adegokeademola7281 no it’s not. By that logic you wouldn’t have appointed Pep in 08, Arteta, klopp etc.
It’s just a lazy way of judging managers. Look at the clubs he has managers. You judge them based on their tactical intelligence and how they would improve the current team. Not just looking at what they have won.
Arsenal wouldn’t have appointed Arteta, Dortmund wouldn’t have appointed Klopp, Barca with Pep, Zidane and Real etc etc
@@adegokeademola7281 he’s not a hipsters choice at all.
In your next video, please talk about his pressing shape, love his football in general but not convinced by brighton's pressing game
whats your opinion on kieran mckenna?
I like De Zerbi but I personally prefer Motta as I really like his set up and how he's able to build out by using the GK in a back 3.
nah we aint sacking ten hag. changing manager will do nothing for us. maybe give us 6 months of good football then back to the same old shit. 65 different injuries this season alone. Never more than 23 senior players available at once, compared to liverpool/city/villa/arsenals squads that had at least 28 senior players available every week. New board, new directors, new owners, anthonys case. Give him more time with a solid board over him. 35 defensive lineups in 47 games, that alone would wreak havoc on any team. Remember he placed 3rd in his first season. Patience my friend.
@@rahbalder7581 Newcastle and Chelsea had the most injuries in the league and finished above us, we were in the relegation zone for a lot of defensive stats, we finished on negative GD, so I don’t care that he finished 3rd after nearly every club had an off year what’s he done this season to get my respect, are you forgetting he lost 7-0 in his precious 3rd place season and conceded the quickest goal in FA Cup final history
It’s funny to me that you made at least 1 video calling ETH one of the very best tacticians in the world when he had initially arrived and now are claiming that he’s completely clueless and plays a terrible system that wouldn’t get any better with better players. Him having the tactics at Ajax is no different than De Zerbi having the tactics at Brighton… neither are United. I’m sure you’d disagree, but it invalidates your point a little that De Zerbi is a better tactician than ETH lol.
Yes because football evolves mate. It doesn’t invalidate my point at all. Like Tuchel and Pochettino he was one of the best tacticians in the world but as the game has evolved he has fallen behind.
The same with Jose Mourinho.
It’s not the same as Ajax at all. De Zerbi has shown he is an innovator which gives confidence that he’ll adapt. Ten Hag wasn’t a innovator at Ajax. He followed the set tactical trend at the time.
I don’t see how this is a hard concept to grasp
Personally, I wouldn't want De Zerbi at United. Yes, we need a coach not a manager, RDZ is an excellent coach, and ticks a lot of boxes.But, I personally think possession based football isn't ingrained in our club at all.
We need a coach who focuses OOP and transitions than possession, merely keeping the ball and using magic to unblock final 3rd just doesn't work for us.
I am willing to keep ETH only on a condition that we purge the current squad and build on new young talents coming through youth system, Mainoo, Kambwala, Garnacho are examples how well you can tune young minds into a team.
If we need someone new then it has to Nagelsmann for me. Mckenna following him in 3-4 years time.
He's literally free now
My only worry is his rest defence issues if he fixes that I’ll be happy with him or Nagelsmann
Xabi Alonso please.. best of the lot. I know someone is gonna say with his Liverpool connections there’s no way he would go to Man Utd. But he played for Bayern too and now he is destroying Bayern for fun as well and denying them of a title with Leverkusen. So why not?
We can win the league with Eric ten hag..believe it. Give him the right players. Lets not be tempted by prolific coaches seeking fora job in exchange of a coach who has chosen to stand by his principles and cultural build up.
Mate I’d admire your optimism but we defo can’t win the league with ten Hag.
We’ve given him the players he wanted and we look worse now than under Ole
Ten Hag hasn’t stood by his principles at all. He’s literally completely changed his style of play
@@AtlantisFootball what people fault him for is that he went for a common sense approach...adaptability. He didnt have the right players so being pragmatic was the best option despite opposition. Win is the bottom line.
@@AtlantisFootball you know that Rome wasn't built in one day. You demanding such for the club sounds to be too unrealistic and unsustainable if quick fixes are to be made.
I agree ten hag needs to go but idk about De Zerbi. I havent really done much research on him
I’ll do a video on him but rewatch the arsenal and Liverpool games. Despite the results Brighton were excellent in both games in terms of playing out of the press and being narrow and compact in the defensive third. Add in higher level players and you can see how de Zerbi’s United could challenge the top 3
Mate, United first things first need to get rid of half the squad and that's not going to happen in any managers first season. We can't sack ten hag yet, we have to give him the structure and the right profiles of squad players. Only then we could judge him. Though i agree, some of the tactical mistakes are scary, but we can't keep doing the same thing over and over again
We have to sack ten Hag before rebuilding the squad. We rebuilt the squad with him and wasted £200m.
We don’t need to get rid of half the squad only about 7/8 players
Yes agreed we can’t keep doing the same thing over and over again. That thing is keeping a manager who is blatantly not good enough.
The most important thing is an elite level manager. Ten Hag just isn’t that
@@AtlantisFootball but if you think about it its a choice between selling rubbish players and sacking ten hag. I'd rather keep ten hag because i refuse to believe that he just forgot how to coach and how tactics work. He's playing like this on purpose because he knows that he can't do anything else with these players, neither can de zerbi, and he doesn't want to park the bus because that's completly not his style.
Unlike with ole and jose there's proof of ten hag playing offensive and tactically brilliant football, he just needs to get the players to do it. He even has done it to some extend at united whenever licha and shaw are both fit, so us not having a style of play is a myth
He can do something else with these players, de Zerbi is doing more with an inferior squad. You’re making out as if we have a relegation level squad. We are conceding 30 shots a match and you’re seriously telling he can’t do anything else? Come on man
I have heard similar songs countless times! Ten hag was arguably better at Ajax than De Cerbi at Brighton.. I would rather back our current manager!
We’re not gonna get de zerbi. Ten hag would need a 10M payout plus the 13 needed for de zerbi, plus we don’t have Dan ashworth in yet, which would be another payout rumored at 20M. Spending 43M on the leadership structure and staff is wishful thinking at best. That’s why were likely to end up with a potter or Southgate which is a massive downgrade on eth no matter what you think
Right but you don’t know that. We got berrada from city and ashworth from Newcastle. They’ll get the best manager available regardless of cost
De zerbi for me is the man
So we’re just going to ignore Brightons form this season? Might as well stick with ETH with a proper structure above him. 🤷
Mate have you watched Brighton? They’ve been very good this season, whilst also playing in Europe as well. Brighton have looked more impressive than United
Watch them vs arsenal and Liverpool they were excellent for most of the games
No tbh I don’t have much time to watch other games, only United. I just think EtH is getting a hard time atm and he’s been very unlucky. The players are more to blame than he is IMO and also feel the 2 pens against Chelsea were daylight robbery. I want us to give him another season and see after that - one thing I do appreciate about Brighton is their press resistance in playing out from the back but when we have a full defence to pick from plus reinforcements I feel we are capable of this. I don’t think people realise how much we miss Licha, he’s our most important player imo. I just want the players to have some accountability for a change. Good video, though! 👍
It is far more important that United overhaul this squad next summer apart from getting a new manager in.
It’s just not. We can’t rebuild with a manager who obviously isn’t good enough. The squad is decent, just needs to get rid of ageing players on big wages
@@AtlantisFootball I get your point. I also think Ten Hag's tenure has run it's course. I however, still believe that we need to prioritize quality players. Ten Hag may get another year from what I'm hearing. That means we throw everything we have at recruitment.
The way you are hyping de zerbi up one would think Brighton is challenging for the title come on man they are below us with a united squad so full of injuries
He’s at Brighton mate 💀 we are Man Utd, what are you on about 🤣
Every team has had injuries that’s no excuse.
Wow , the fact that you can't see the holes in your thinking is woeful
@@AtlantisFootball I know you dont like logic but why not recommend emery. At least hes a serious manager that has shown to improve a relegating team, unlike de zerbi who made a successful one worse
Mate I do like logic. You don’t apparently or just don’t watch Brighton. They are better under De Zerbi than Potter
@@AtlantisFootball They get destroyed with beautiful football every game. Their results are damning, only 3/17 good onces since 2024. DESTROYED by luton, fulham, roma, arsenal. Lost to tottenham, liverpool and wolves. Tied with wolves, west ham, everton and brentford. BUT HEY, they beat sheffield TWICE AND palace AND forest, all relegation teams. Oh and lets not forget mighty stoke city. And you didnt answer about emery cause you know hes 10x the manager de zerbi is. Berrada wont waste time with that loser
Good video, not sure why ppl who are ten hag in cant even begin to discuss that he has serious tactical issues atm, they often think you are saying Ten Hag is shit. He simply hasnt shown the tactical prowess neccesary, that may be "so far" but how long are we willing to wait? Have u done a video on Thiago Motta, i like the look of him personally. I rate De Zerbi highly tho.
It’s people who are casuals or just immature. They think the idea of supporting a club is just blindly supporting the manager. The would rather win arguments on Twitter than win trophies
@@AtlantisFootball it annoying, im aware we dont have the best squad in the league but its better than spurs imo and we definately have a good enough team to not conceed 58 shots in two games and allow brentford 85 touches in the box. No disrespect to ten hag but he hasnt fixed that issue all season. Its worrying.
@@AtlantisFootballcoming from someone who’s watched nearly every game for the past 2-3 years, it’s not immaturity or blind support it’s just fatigue. We’ve had it with the “the manager is the problem.” If you watch the games you see the lack of effort from a quite a few players. Other players just aren’t good enough. And some are good enough but just need to go at this point. I’m not saying ETH is a tactical savant bc he’s not but we’ve gone through 5 or 6 managers atp and kept a bulk of the same players through them all. Basic reason says that the players are a big part of the problem and more than likely the source.
Yeah take ETH out
Fergie Time - final few minutes, score goals and make a comeback
Ten Hag Time - final few minutes, concede
The content is baseless on any evidence. From the eye test point of view, de zerbi or any other coach cant depend on rashford and garnacho to press for its there weak part of their games. Its a personnel issue. Top coaches are where there are given then patience and time to build their vision.
Mate you’re just waffling. Garnacho is a fantastic presser what are you talking about
@@AtlantisFootball pressing coordination not only depends on a players intelligent movements, physique but also the ability to read the games to finds pressing triggers. He is too inexperienced and so direct for such approach. His pressings are as a results of instructions and not self initiative.
he doesn't have the players who can play out of the back and the ones who can have spent most of the season injured
Yes he does. De Zerbi does it with Dunk, Veltman etc. he does have the players. He just doesn’t have the system. Dalot, Onana, Mainoo, Maguire etc are all very good on the ball. Managers like Nagelsmann and De Zerbi would be able to do it.
Also the defensive shape is the biggest issue
@@AtlantisFootball a midfield of mainoo, Mount and casemiro could play it out but he hasn't had the players avalible who can do it. As he said he's playing the style he can with the players he has and its not the way his ajax played because he tried that fur8ng his first season and we got hammered. So they panicked and its messed this season up as well.
@@cellanjones28 invert Dalot infield with Mainoo. Then you have Onana, Maguire, Lindelof/Varane and a pivot of Dalot and Mainoo. He absolutely has the players to do it. Watch De Zerbi’s Brighton. He does it with players who are not at the level ten Hag has
@@AtlantisFootball Brighton have played that way since Potter was there, the only thing which changed was the structure, when we played it slow front the back we struggled to break teams down but with garnacho on the right it may work now BUT we gotta get our first team playing otherwise wan bisaka will be expected to play wing back lol.
You're on point bro. Big up from Uganda. But to be honest, ten hag has to be moved on given the current conditions and patterns of play. Mate, we're being exposed match in match out. And the bad thing is, the Coach blames the injuries which is partly responsible but we bought onana to improve our build up structure instead of playing longballs he's instructed to play.
Thanks bro 🙏🏼
Not holding my breath for SJR's leadership either cos with everything that has happened since they were confirmed part owners why Ten Hag still has a job...let him go asap cos every match now seems to be another level of low... can't wait for what they will serve up against Liverpool today...den again I have stopped watching the senior team for awhile now...the U18s have been killing it
What achievement has De Zerbi achieved in football
Mate I beg you watch football. He’s taken a Brighton side to the Europa league and has one of the best build up systems in world football with mid level players.
You don’t judge managers just by looking at their Wikipedia
In as much as you get it right most times this ain't it bro
At least not for now
It defo is right mate
Should have sacked Ten Hag in December like I said
@@AtlantisFootballI'm not so sure about de zerbi tho
I prefer Naglesmann
de zerbi will get a bounce for the 1st season, but we'll be back here again in 2 seasons. we don't want to wait for a rebuild.
No we won’t lmao. De Zerbi is a far better coach than ten Hag
@@AtlantisFootballif you think EtH is the problem, then we are going nowhere.
@AtlantisFootball if he comes I don't want us to give everyone a "free slate" again. If we do then he's doomed just like the others
He 100% is the problem. Either that or don’t understand the tactical side of the game. We are going absolutely nowhere with ten Hag
Right but no one said that
Fundamentally, you are ignoring the fact that you can have the best tactics but if the players don't want to or unable to implement it it won't work.
The issue is not whether ten hag is a good or bad manager, or whether someone else is better or worse.
Many players do not have the skillset demanded of elite football under modern tactics. You assert that its not because of players with no substantiation. Let me do the same. It demonstrably is because of the players. Every week we see the evidence.
De zerbi is a very risky decision if we don't clear out massively and recruit well. He is famed for and unrelenting in automation and precision, even more obsessive than pep (see relevant interviews). There is a big chance some of the personalities can't handle it and we will see them either crumbling, throwing de zerbi under the bus, or de zerbi melting down out of frustration.
Say what you will about ten hag, but he is stuck between a rock and hard place and is least not lashing out on players like Jose and Rangnick did. And a lot of what they said in the past is becoming blatantly clear to every united fan.
Mate that’s completely wrong. You don’t need elite level players to be able to set up a compact defensive shape do you.
Ten Hag is very clearly to blame. The issues are tactical
I didn't say elite. Brighton's players are _____, which some of man united's are not, they have proven it under various managers.
Again, as a content creater, you can't just assert something without proper substantiation. Allow me to do the same as you. "The players are clearly not up to it. The issue is purely personnel".
Should I start my own channel now?
The blank is for you to fill in, by the way. Btw, I'm not ten hag in or out. I think even if he is not the man gg forward, the issue are multi faceted.
@@johndorianturkelton there is proper substantiation. I literally made a video yesterday breaking down the tactical issues.
What has he won?
Not how you judge managers mate at the start of their career. What had Arteta, Pep, Klopp or Simeone won when they took over at Arsenal, Barca, Dortmund and Simeone.
He’s managed Brighton and Sassuolo amongst others, what do you expect him to win. He took Brighton to the Europa league
You need to watch Ruben Amorim and Simeon Inzaghi first before talking about De Zerbi
Yeah I have mate
Those who are questioning you're football knowledge should go back or watch Brighton play
Nah they don’t watch football mate 💀 just Twitter highlights
@@AtlantisFootballand I guess they won against Arsenal 😂😂😂.. football noobs😂😂😂
Anyone who is pro-Ten Hag has no reason to complain about the team's current struggles.
This is what you want.
You made your bed, now lay in it.
Will just use injuries as an excuse mate. I’ve realised most don’t understand the tactical side of the game which is why they can’t see the issues
Players like Maguire, Fran, Casemiro and Anthony cannot compete with coach De Zerbi, not even Ancelotti.
Fran? Maguire could
No Manchester fan should make excuses for players like rashford shaw and maguire anymore. Tired that mafia. They need to go
What you on about, Shaw hasn’t even been playing. No Manchester fan should be making excuses for ten Hag. He needs to go
De Zerbi would fail miserably at United
Who do i want to replace Zerbi in 18 months because the new lap dog keeps peeing. Or our fans should stop being entitled bitches because we aint IT no more and we need time.
His rest defence is bad that its compared to ours with a team bad defencivly i dont think its good idea
Mate what you on about? 🤣 Brightons rest defence is miles better than ours
Yeah sure,but Ten is legit....this is all a learning curve.....
He’s not legit. He’s well out of his depth. He’s not learning from it at all. The tactical issues have been there months
Thiago motta lol and nigelsman is overhyped, di zerbi first then Rodgers second option
This guy man 😂😂 comedy 😂😂
Its not tho is it. You just don’t know ball
@@AtlantisFootball what a mature comment. Here's your best comment trophy 🏆
I’ll saviour it as it’ll be more trophies than we win under ten Hag
I would rather have naglesmann or controversially McKenna but de zerbi would be my 3rd choice
would be sacked in 3 years
Would win the league in 3 years
Totally agree with everything in the video
That's why Brighton is below Man United and Man United has been crap this season does Liverpool does Barcelona want him does does Bayern Munich wanting it's not about knowledge it's about common sense
Mate do you even follow football? He’s at Brighton. We are Man Utd. And yes all of those clubs are interested in him. I begging you just keep up with the news or something
😂 31 out 46 different defensive partnership and u think de zerbi will do well with that 😂. Mate your analysis is poor and u just want to use any manager emerging to say united have to change a manager. Two years ago Eric Ten Hag Ajax could have come second or third in the primer league and also the 2018/2019 season proved woth the right player he can play better football. 😅😅😅 Sacking a manager who is in 6th with all this over achievement last season. I don't think any good analysis will say sack him and bring in de zerbi 😅
Yes he would. What on earth does that have to do with the midfield line and forward being too high and wide.
We’ve conceded 100 plus shots in 4 games. The only players we were missing vs Liverpool in that first half was Shaw and Martinez stop with these excuses.
We aren’t talking about 2019, we are talking about 2024
It’s bad analysis to blame injuries for the defensive system. None of the reasons you provided explain why our defensive shape is so poor. You can’t have watched de Zerbi’s sides much. He would 100% do better than ten Hag
Get Rio on the phone with Arteta
For what?
brighton are woefuly awful this season and its his second season. how can you want him at united? that will be another 2 years wasted.
Great Video. I must say De Zerbi is second on my list only behind Julian Naglesmann. I’d love to see a video on him as part of the INEOS rebuild to make comparisons.
Only issue with Nagelsmann is the euros. Would mean he only starts mid way through July which could be an issue for summer planning
@@AtlantisFootball Yeah true but with the strong links to Southgate, which I believe to be true, would it not be the same for him? I want Southgate nowhere near Utd but if the board are considering him as the favourite, surely it’s the same issues as Naglesmann regarding when they can take over. You could even argue Southgate could possibly be at the Euros longer given the bookies odds on them to win it but yet is somehow the favourite? Also, for De Zerbi, I wonder if there would be compensation to Brighton? Surely there must be? Would be nothing to pay compensation wise for Naglesmann which might be something else the board could be considering.
Nah I don’t believe the Southgate rumours. He may have been discussed but the reality is no one knows. Ineos aren’t going to be leaking their internal discussions so how do the press and media know?
The just connect dots by the fact that ashworth has been appointed and know that they can’t actually be held accountable for making stuff up because they’ll say, we only said they were considering him.
De Zerbi’s is £13m. Not sure about Nagelsmann but I think it’s worth paying for a manager
I say keep sack underperform manager until we have instant epl champion to get rival mouth shut. Chelsea hv balls to do it. Why united cant?😂
Why not Motta
Just think that De Zerbi is a bit more experienced and I have more to judge him on. Motta is a fantastic coach as well but I think he needs go somewhere like Brighton (around that level) before going to a super club
EtH 1 more season!
God no
Salom hamma menga koprog tomas tuhel yahshi chunki u angilyada ishlagan natijabor
Big fan of your vid's...but don't appreciate you discussing new managers for MUFC thank. TEN HAG IN for at least another season.
What are you on about 🤣🤣
@@AtlantisFootball Ten Hag is our manager and I've had enough of Journo's and others talking about replacing him. In my OPINION he doesn't need it nor deserve it..That''s all I'm saying. Go talk about Necastle's next manager or Chelsea's..no you won't..always Man Utd.
( I accept I'm being a git harsh on you as this is the content you do..but I'm sure you get the sentiment.)
Mate you need to grow up. We are absolutely shit. Of course we need to at least be discussing the possibility of new managers
Yes you are entitled to discuss new managers and no one I know will do it better than.you. I watch your videos and really like them but can't bring myself to watch this. That is ALL I'm trying say. Came across like having go at you and I apologise for that I care about what happens next. The managers aren't the problem in my view It's the squad. A new manager is fresh start (again) for these players. (PLEASE NO!! NOT AGAIN!) ETH is a good enough manager for the club as whole as well as the 1st team, despite his admittedly questionable tactics. Give him time this season is a write off.
As for growing up, I'm 66 and still working on it. Let me know when you get there! All the best too you and thanks for what you do.
@@despicable866 We’ve been horrific all season. The manager 100% is the problem.
Be honest do you actually understand the tactical side of the game? I don’t think you do which is why you can’t see the obvious issues. It’s not the players, it’s the tactical set up
I would love De Zerbi. We need our kids playing the same systems as well.
I think noo
Wrong I’m afraid
@@AtlantisFootball No because he hasn't done much at Brighton to warrant him a job at United, I would recommend Nagelsmann or even Ruben Amorin before I take Dizarbi, I'd rather keep 10hag.
De Zerbi is the outstanding no 1 option..
Agreed but expecting the "he hasn't won anything" comments
Outstanding my foot 😂😂 someone that can't do it in a club that doesn't seems to pressure him. You can't even compare United to Brighton dudes😂😂 Go back to School and start from Scratch
@@CtdGgames01 ball knowledge incredibly limited. Actually watch Brighton play because we both know you haven’t
@@CtdGgames01 de Zerbi is clearly the outstanding (or one of the) options. You need to be more mature. You’re meant to be a Man Utd supporter not a ten Hag supporter. Expect better from one of my viewers. Don’t worry keep watching my videos you’ll learn. I’ll try to make my content more beginner friendly 🙏🏼
@@AtlantisFootball dey play.. outstanding but can't do it with Brighton 😂😂😂
We have ETH. Stop pushing this shit
Yes and we are diabolical. Stop being deluded
You need to grow up. I’ll let you off because you’re young but you need realise you’re a Man Utd fan not a ten Hag Fan. You need to accept reality
You’re comparing De Zerbis Brighton that is well driven regardless of manager to Uniteds shitshow project that finally is about to take shape.
You CAN’T compare pre ineos players and matches to the new ones to come. There’s a massive difference. Ten Hag cannot play his preferred style of play because he simply does not have players to play a proper controlling playstyle.
That is why I’d say to give ETH until December atleast.
Hope you do realize that if we get rid of ETH it does not solve anything at this point and that he is the best possible manager for us right now.
F’ing Southgate is knocking at the door ffs. Be careful what you wish for..
@@wh0tLol ITS BRIGHTON WE ARE MAN UTD 😭 come on man.
Also Southgate can hardly make us worse. Also those are just rumours. You can’t just say keep Ten Hag coz there are rumours Southgate might take over.
De Zerbi’s Man Utd would be head and shoulders above Ten Hag’s no debate.
@@AtlantisFootball We’ll have to agree to disagree on this one.
Man United fans seems to have short term memory loss if they want to fire ETH already. Our squad is made up by 4+ managers and you expect our current manager to play his own style of fotball. C’mon That’s ridiculous.
As Ragnick said «we need a open heart surgery» and that has yet to happen. We haven’t got rid of our deadwood yet.
If or when that happens and the results are still shit; Then you could post a video about this to generated clicks.
This is nothing but dividing to our fan base and does not really help anything but your Wallet.
On the other hand, I do see some of your points. I’m just voicing my opinion.
great analysis, too many United fans complain about personnel, when the best managers adapt their systems to their players, eth would die for his philosophy than adapt to wat happens in game, and its the reason we concede so many shots and fail to retain possession, the 3 goals against Chelsea were reliant on the front 4’s decision making than any real tactical cohesion, leaving casemiro to defend the center backs when he clearly is outnumbered and old, and dalot constantly getting 2v1 all season long, it’s so clear to me that ETH refuses to adapt and must leave the club
Thanks man 🙏🏼
Gary oneil better than this guy 1000 times
No he’s not 🤣🤣🤣🤣 do you even watch football
De zerbi and bayern get smashed regularly. He's extreamly overrated.
No they don’t. He’s not overrated at all. Watch Brighton play, don’t just look at results.
What has he won what has he won🤮🤮🤮
Very limited football knowledge. You need to actually watch managers and their tactical set up. Not just judge them off trophies. By your logic you wouldn’t have appointed Pep, Arteta or klopp at the start of their careers. Look at the teams he has managed.
Come on man even you know this just lazy on your part
We might as well get Graham Potter he started at Brighton went to Chelsea how long did he last it's not about football knowledge lot more than that my friend
Mate your football knowledge is very limited. Potter and De Zerbi are completely different tactically.
This is just lazy analysis from you. Simply going “well he was Brighton manager and de Zerbi is Brighton manager so I’ll just assume they are exactly the same”
You need start watching managers and teams before having opinions on them. I don’t think you understand the difference in tactical set up between the two managers
De Zerbi will not work out for Man United. He needs a team of talented, well-balanced assistant coaches to implement his tactics, which Man United doesn't have. 🥹
Not the player, the head coach, but the assistant coach team needs to be replaced. Why is the frick no one talking about what Rangnick discovered.
Assisting coaches get positions because of their relationship, and the position was vacant. It doesn't matter if they fit for that position or not. It causes both redundant and shortcomings of talented assistant coach.
So many Man United head coaches can discover a talent and can't develop them but deteriorate them. If we replace Ten Hag, Garnacho, McTominey, and Wanbisaka will not develop anymore.
Without a good assistant coach team, a talented coach is only as good as a talented PlayStation coach. You don't understand how good Erik Ten Hag is.
Mate what you on about? His style of play needs less individual talent then ten hags. Also United have fantastic players, stop making out as if we have a relegation level squad.
Mate Ten Hag is good. It’s nothing to do with an assistant coach. You’re just making up random excuses. You have no idea how bad ten Hag has been tactically
How difficult is it to make a 20 minute video instead of a part 2
It’s literally double as long mate
I wonder how long apart you made these two videos? You showed so much faith in ETH in this video.
youtube.com/@atlantisfootball?si=c35thVHeGAdQmLWV
Link just goes to my channel
Forcing a professional player to become world class just because he has showed glimpses of it doesn't make sense. Ten hag must stay and some players must leave for the betterment of the team and their future.