Wildfire is a wonderful boss theme, and it makes one feel absolutely badass during it. However, Genshin's boss themes are sort of an opposite. They make the boss feel badass. During the Cocolia fight I felt "Oh damn this is a very big moment for me and my character" while Genshin makes me feel "Holy shit this boss is going to clap me".
@@fatui-ginger i mean to be fair, most bosses in genshin aren't challenging if you're good enough to avoid them Like with star rail its a RPG where it is inevitable you will take damage, but genshin can be overcome with pure skill alone.
@@timothyaintit5989especially when you play it in coop and your party members don't understand that they need the 4 construct in the corner to survive and just destroy them immediately when they spawn
@@saimyintmyat9373 totally, it's not like over half of the tracks are literally lessons in trap music. Most vocal songs are pop but a majority of the actual ost are peak edm.
Wildfire is really epic and it left an impact on me, i feel like a hero who's gonna save the day when i fight cocolia and wildfire is playing on the background.
I think both styles have their merits. Genshin’s going for that classic epic feel with the choir, orchestra, and ethnic flare based on the region. Star rail goes for a Devil may cry vibe with hard rock and tons of energy to punctuate certain moments.
Honkai Impact: Wave goodbye to the past when hope and faith have grown so strong and sound Genshin Impact: *DO MI NA TUS! DOMINATUS! DOMINATUS!* Honkai Star Rail: *WE’VE MADE A CHOICE GO FIGHT AGAINST YOUR FAAAAAATE!*
Me who remembered Honkai Impact: "No No No No No No ........... NOOOO PLEASE NOOO!!!!!" "Insert any song you remember from Honkai (Mine is basically Lying, Moon Halo, tRue, Oracle and Reoracle or Da Capo😢😢😢😢)" Me who remembers Genshin: "This is so peaceful and very much helps me concentrate" Me Who Remembers Star Rail: "Calm, jazz beat and Burn my blood for the Emperor or Empress with emotions to burn your body as bright as a Phoenix!!!!"
Traveler: “Let me just absorb the element from this statue.” Trailblazer: “God has stopped time, given me this chance to pull this Lance from the heart of this planet, and seize the moment to pierce this everlasting blizzard.”
Tbh all the songs are epic. It just happens that Genshin feels like art that you go along with, while Star Rail feels like a journey you are making yourself.
Fun fact about the scara boss fight, there is a lyrics that goes "why did you throw me on the fifth night" referencing to Japanese culture giving their children names on 7th night, so scara doesnt even have a name and ei just left him. Genshin's boss theme always reflects on the boss history
@Youji 私 Tbh Wildfire is more about Belobog as a whole changing instead of just the MC. That's my why fire MC's ult art includes a lot of Belobog characters.
The soundtracks that went with the Raiden Shogun boss fights were incredible. In the first fight with her, there's this heartbeat-like sound that plays so ominously, it even made my heart beat faster and I'm thinking: "Oh yeah, I definitely die here..." such a dreadful feeling, in a good way. That just means the music is doing its job.
honestly, this makes me really amazed on how much effort hoyo is doing in making varied soundtrack, from classical opera, pop-stylized, dubstep, and now rock. from hi3rd, genshin, and star rail. you could feel the different use of context, like how in scara's theme it symbolizes how the fight is not really in your favor, and you need your wits to be able to win, whilst wildfire really shows how even the aeons are going "beat his ass cuh, we gotchu", symbolizing the will of the aeon to defeat the seemingly impossible stellaron-infused cocolia... though i guess the community won't ever tolerate each other due to the difference in tastes (personally, due to my taste, hi3rd still is one of the top in my opinion)
i personally enjoy all three of them but put genshin on the lowest, not because of gacha, combat, exploration or events. but due me missing somethings and needing to go online to finish that thing(its just annoy me)
I really liked how they timed star rail’s boss music according to certain events within the battle, while on the other hand i like how the genshin boss themes loop pretty seamlessly
During that whole fight I slowly realized I was very unprepared for that boss battle, but by the power of the music I refused surrender and I won, sadly only March was the survivor.
@@jace1332Same lol In the phase 2 of the boss my healer lynx died and the only one along with tingyun the only ones left are March 7th and Trailblazer in my final turn both the Boss and my characters are last hit luckily march 7 was alive to grant shield to the trailblazer and then finish it with ultimate If it takes long I would have lost tho
Hot take, Both are good, both give different vibes that heavily fit their fight and the themes around them. Hoyo community needs to stop taking shots at eachother, and start praying together for pity on banners.
Remember these OSTs were made by music artists, not the dev teams from both game, there is no point of trashing these OSTs cuz that means we are literally trashing on the poor artists who put all their effort into making these.
Fr...most of the comments be saying "HSR's musics are better" or "Genshin's ones are better" and acting like they're speaking facts when it's literally their opinion and there's not even a point of clashing abt it when their themes and vibes and stories are simply just different. I mean just imagine that HSR's music being used in Scara boss fight...it wouldn't even go with the fight...it would just make it appear weird unlike how cool it is in HSR😭. The different music just suits the different stories ppl can't be overlooking all this💀
Both of them slap. One slaps you with an unimaginable amount of epicness while the other slaps you with a tonal whiplash. Both are an absolute win and both make you feel like a badass hero. I'm not going to elaborate which theme slaps you with what.
The context is very different though, for genshin the bosses are all beyond mortal beings with unknown streght to us, we are fighting for our life against these legendary menaces. In HSR, from narrative viewpoint we already won the battle with the powerup/getting the blessing of the aeon
Yeah, both songs have different context and meaning. Tried to put Wildfire in Scaramouche boss battle, it doesn't strike as much as Polumnia. Same goes to Polumnia to Cocolia boss fight.
@@stressedhaish69420 from what've seen for now in HSR, it is not. it's more campy and has a more light hearted story telling tone like P5. Genshin's lore is one of the more f0ckedup lores I've read in games, the problem is the game doesn't throw it your face, you have to pursue it.
@@rootedpen2 Nah in the future updates hsr will surely become darker than genshin. I mean in the first ever major quest a relevant character already died. In the first ever update. And since its an honkai game we can expect it to be darker than genshin with the way its going. And theres already rumours that one of the characters on the express will die in the 1.2 update. Saying this as a ar 55 player btw.
@@dahandsomeguywithcoolglass8949 umm isn't the age rating already 12 only? At 14 they can show minor wounds, at 17 is when they can show metal gear rising level of gore
@@dahandsomeguywithcoolglass8949he game doesn't have to have gore for its music to be doom-inspired tho, op just wanted something more akin to djent and extra crunchy low strings
tbh i love how hyv makes music to fit each game and represent not only what the player is fighting but the emotion the main character should feel through the music too, like how in scaras theme its dread and fear but also courage on traveller's end and the desperate attempt scara makes to keep the gnosis, while in cocolias theme its the blinding power she feels through the stellarons influence and the trailblazer's determination to win.
the virgin traveler: simply gets elemental powers but still needs to be bailed out be every archon the chad trailblazer: impresses literal cosmic gods to the point that they give you a powerup to fight against a planetary cancer
Is it just me or Trailblazer are too overpowered already. Like they are already at level of a god. Unlike genshin's MC who has lost most of their original strength and weapon. (They're still pretty op to go against an archon) I've seen the power level difference between honkai and genshin is a lot.
Not to be that guy, but for the confused lads, scara's theme in that moment says "novis natus" (newly born, born anew, born again, translations may differ) not "dominatus". Still the point gets through
scaramouche boss theme is a masterpiece cause it tells a story of scaramouche and the way yu peng chen delivered it was a chef's kiss wildfire is a song that's making us hype and give goosebumps as we fight cocolia and defeat her and giving hope to bronya and the others both are great but these two are made by two different composers in a game that has different genre and its own set of music and it depends on one's own opinion whether they prefer scaramouche's boss theme or wildfire tho in my own opinion, i love genshin's music since it makes me imagine a fight between me and those bosses as wel as making my gaming experience in genshin more immersive while star rail is pretty new and listen to many of its ost and songs, I still prefer genshin's overall, maybe I would be more a fan of star rail's music as time passes but it can't top any of my favorites as of yet.
Lets be clear, both are absolute master pieces, just one is focus on the player about to wreck the boss, a song of hope and determination which we resonante easier, while the other shows the characters mind, on despair and divinity, how behind everything he is saying, is a vulnerable and hurt person, and i think both are beautiful in different aspects.
@@saimyintmyat9373 makes 0 sense and edgey crap writen for the incels that can only play Honkai Impact if t hey put in a male character to self insert to lol
Wildfire reminds me of like when an anime protag is about to beat up the final boss full of heroism and justice, while Scarmouche's theme, reminds me of like some sad betrayal
I believe it's a matter of taste but, DAMN man, the boss theme scaramouche is so fire, pardon me honkai veterans, but nothing buys me more than an opera in Latin, the master piece.
Thanks for saying that the Honkai was good but Genshin is better. Instead of the comments in which I see where people are saying Honkai is trash in which it isn't.
@@thatguythere6161same though lol. I've heard like a hundred different rock songs with similar vibe as wildfire so it's like,damn this is pretty cool. But for genshin boss themes which are all very unique and doesn't feel repetitive overall composition wise,it's like,Wow WTF piece am I listening to?!?! So many instruments and so many things going on. Amazing.
I bet Wildfire is the national anthem for the Abyss Order (but in Khaenri'an Latin presumably) Especially because of we've made a choice go fight against your fate
Wildfire is great, but I often return to Genshin's music in general. Honkai music is dynamic, heroic and hype, but Genshin's music makes me feel soothing. I can feel a soul in Genshin's music.
Personally I find star rail to have a lot of good "chill and vibe" tracks. Belobog admin district, boulder town, the express, and the master control zone being some of the best IMO
I tend to remember genshins more cause honkais just doesn't stand out to me as much like in the cocallia fight I wasn't really understanding or finding her character interesting so I was hoping maybe they have a honkai rock theme about her character similar to genshin but it was more bout the MC which I don't mind but I still wish it did something similar. And the area and combat music are just average to me like each nation/area has unique combat music that fits in around is aesthetic star rail I just don't get that feeling
This channel never fair to Genshin, i mean this channel is just Genshin roast at best, hell even he show full screen scene for HSR but just small screen for Genshin
My favorite in Genshin still is "Bane of Ambitions". It feels like you are actually fighting against this being that is much more powerful than you are.
This is just typical Honkai fanboy channel, especially this guy, most of his Video are comparing Genshin to something and roast it or straight up Genshin roast intensify
@@Zkr7 The comments from those Honkai stans aren't any better, just look how much they are d*ckriding that ooohhh soooo almighty "pLaNeT dEsTrOyInG dRaGoN". Said "dragon" couldn't even destroy a measly space station, lmao. 💀 If THAT'S the "planet destroying" power, than both the Emanators and Aeons are a friggin joke.
@@ht-kruku Glad you said that HT. I have been waiting for this. What you are describing is the genre. The context is everything that led up to this moment. So for Genshin, The orchestra is to be reminiscent of grand and epic ascension. It is meant to praise the birth of the new God. No matter how misguided, he is still a New Born God. Novi Natus. The chant you hear is the praise of a new born God. So it is meant to be majestic. That's why the lyrics are in Latin. You're fighting against a God. At that moment the world isn't focused on you. It's on Scaramouche. We are opposing Scaramouche. That's the context. In contrast. Beating Cocolia is a matter of survival for Belobog. And you are fighting to protect the world. And you're not just fighting for the world, you're opposing ideals. At that moment, Cocolia is not the focus of the story. You are. Cocolia is the one that's opposing you. That's the context. Genshin is meant to evoke the feeling of misguided glory and power of a God. HSR evokes the feeling of being triumphed. It sings about your will to fight against fate. There a shit more nuances in the Orchestra. Wildfire is pretty basic in terms of the whole package. Wildfire is literally a theme song about your fight against Cocolia. Genshins song conveys a whole lot by simple chants. I don't expect you to understand considering your fuck all knowledge about the difference between context and genre.
Sigh, another misunderstanding. Cocolia was not one of those maniacs who commit genocide just for the sake of it. She lose hope and preferred to obey the Stellaron hoping that it can fix everything. Even Himeko and the collective minds of previous guardians state that they won't judge Cocolia for abandoning all hope.
Isnt this the bird meme, where the point of the meme is even though both of the music is good, the one sung by the crow (trailblazer) is louder....so why is the comment section arguing over comparisons, both are good and both fit their respective scenario's
Although the latter was nice genshin Music Was really the one that usually hit me up,its not about my heroism,its about telling story about certain place or Character that can make you wondering "What happened?" "How." And why"
More than that. Context. In the context Scara theme is fine tuned to his character. It tells his story. The theme in HSR is about humanity saying fuck you to stellaron.
The examples chosen here are both fantastic pieces of music, and while I do think that Wildfire has a more immediate hype factor, I can get a lot more out of Scaramouches Boss theme by actively listening to it and appreciating the many layers of musical depth. It's a Beethoven level masterpiece.
@@Phantom_Zone same, i lost my motivation lately after playing nearly 5 year, just because the fandom become worse and worse everyday because of superiority complex and exageration
![James Fridman Photoshop Trolls [2020]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5CKFV0vU2WY/mqdefault.jpg)
(Part 2) Genshin VS Honkai Star Rail "BOSS Theme"
th-cam.com/video/psfFLAIBTlo/w-d-xo.html
Genshin theme is about the boss, Star Rail theme is about us railing the boss.
Edit: 11 months later, we literally rail a boss
💀💀
I mean Cocolia kinda fine tho ngl
Star Railing the boss
@@randomgoodcommentor2072 i agree
@@randomgoodcommentor2072 from behind lets gooooo
@@randomgoodcommentor2072 it's hard fighting her with one hand
Genshin: The boss is a badass
Star rail: *We* are a badass
MGRR Sam Theme:Memory broken
yes, yes we are😂
@@Glitch_Tron.DMC Vergil: I AM THE STORM THAT IS APPROACHING
@@dante_loves_plzza Musson:ok Let's fight
PGR: NARWHAL
Cocolia:WHY WONT YOU DIE
Trailbalzer:Preservation son
"It shields in response to physical trauma"
And yes, I decided to do this 7 months late
@@jamespage5239 bro I stopped playing hsr already but anyway glad your are here
@@anarchistlilia lol you are gonna get comments months later
Now's a good time to continue playing@@anarchistlilia
@@DDrag0n_ nah I got bored
Wildfire is a wonderful boss theme, and it makes one feel absolutely badass during it. However, Genshin's boss themes are sort of an opposite. They make the boss feel badass. During the Cocolia fight I felt "Oh damn this is a very big moment for me and my character" while Genshin makes me feel "Holy shit this boss is going to clap me".
I was actually scared on my first fight with scara cause the music was so intense.
But the boss fight was easy even with my trash artifacts 😔💔
@@fatui-ginger i mean to be fair, most bosses in genshin aren't challenging if you're good enough to avoid them
Like with star rail its a RPG where it is inevitable you will take damage, but genshin can be overcome with pure skill alone.
The song is very filled with the idea of Preservation, the perfect theme for the Belebog quest.
Signora still sets that hardest for me tbh
@@timothyaintit5989especially when you play it in coop and your party members don't understand that they need the 4 construct in the corner to survive and just destroy them immediately when they spawn
Honkai: pop
Genshin: Modern classical music
Star rail: rock
HI3d is dubstep & neurofunk.
@@Siritkam he probably meant songs from Hi3. They are pop songs.
@@saimyintmyat9373 totally, it's not like over half of the tracks are literally lessons in trap music. Most vocal songs are pop but a majority of the actual ost are peak edm.
@@Izbiski_ Characters PVs are peak ost for hi3.
@@Siritkam and a mountain of abused Violins...
Wildfire is really epic and it left an impact on me, i feel like a hero who's gonna save the day when i fight cocolia and wildfire is playing on the background.
Can't wait for xianzhou final 's song too.
@@saimyintmyat9373 Same!
Why are u everywhere
@@imhavingdiarrhea6926 Becuz ur having a diarrhea ;)
You could say it made quite an honkai impact
Genshin one: mother bullying her son
Hsr one: we're bullying Bronya's mom.
True😂
If you have bronya on the team it's practically the same, but in reverse
@@trextrexoba8202ngl having bronya call her mother evil and proceeding to shoot her felt like a huge character arc
I think both styles have their merits. Genshin’s going for that classic epic feel with the choir, orchestra, and ethnic flare based on the region.
Star rail goes for a Devil may cry vibe with hard rock and tons of energy to punctuate certain moments.
God damn it now I can't stop imagining Seele's ult becoming judgement cut end
Oh wait, it already exists
Honkai Impact: Wave goodbye to the past when hope and faith have grown so strong and sound
Genshin Impact: *DO MI NA TUS! DOMINATUS! DOMINATUS!*
Honkai Star Rail: *WE’VE MADE A CHOICE GO FIGHT AGAINST YOUR FAAAAAATE!*
Me who remembered Honkai Impact: "No No No No No No ........... NOOOO PLEASE NOOO!!!!!" "Insert any song you remember from Honkai (Mine is basically Lying, Moon Halo, tRue, Oracle and Reoracle or Da Capo😢😢😢😢)"
Me who remembers Genshin: "This is so peaceful and very much helps me concentrate"
Me Who Remembers Star Rail: "Calm, jazz beat and Burn my blood for the Emperor or Empress with emotions to burn your body as bright as a Phoenix!!!!"
@@sherman790 what
@@sherman790 hey do u remember "nightglow" and its specific animatic vid called "final lesson"
@@fellboat I do and I didn't want to bring the pain of losing her once again thats why cause its PTSD
@@sherman790 ah pain such common thing maybe your ganna get mor ptsd in a specific game
Not many boss battles make you feel like the boss. Wildfire and Persona 5’s Rivers in the Desert are legit YOUR boss music
Don't forget DOOM. The player makes the demons hear the boss music.
If you like this type of thing, I recommend Final Fantasy 14. Your character actually has a theme song in certain fights which is amazing :)
I don't really like that tbh.
@@aviliamidorin Wasn't replying to you but thanks for the input :)
@@Uncle-JJJJ wasn't replying to you either
Are you going to simply travel? Or are you gonna fucking trailblaze?
Being a nameless is so fun
@@gavinbailey36 Beating trash cans to go through the trash is fun
@@Miss_Unagi Nah. What's better is gaining Mr. Trashcan's respect without violence.
enemy felled
HSR>>>>>
Traveler: “Let me just absorb the element from this statue.”
Trailblazer: “God has stopped time, given me this chance to pull this Lance from the heart of this planet, and seize the moment to pierce this everlasting blizzard.”
Whatever you say
it was cool watching it but it felt like the biggest plot armour to exist lol
@@oh-noeSomeone didn't pay attention to the story
@@ochur116why? traveler has no mc moment?
Tbh all the songs are epic. It just happens that Genshin feels like art that you go along with, while Star Rail feels like a journey you are making yourself.
And that's exactly the thing that not everyone can understand or appreciate art
@@spymadmax584 you make it sound like genshin is for a niche audiance, which isn't exactly the case
Thats why we are called the Trailblazers
@@shiinondogewalker2809 a lot of people in the comments don't understand that Latin lyrics is lyrics too
@@shiinondogewalker2809 it isn't for niche audience but only small subset of its fanbase can truly appreciate genshin's music
Fun fact about the scara boss fight, there is a lyrics that goes "why did you throw me on the fifth night" referencing to Japanese culture giving their children names on 7th night, so scara doesnt even have a name and ei just left him. Genshin's boss theme always reflects on the boss history
you worded it so damn right also as someone who prefers classical over rock I will always still prefer genshin’s take on their OST’s & BGM
Exactly, that's why I love Genshin's songs
Damn, those are full with meanings and not just a random word.
That's why gi osts are superior
@Youji 私 Tbh Wildfire is more about Belobog as a whole changing instead of just the MC. That's my why fire MC's ult art includes a lot of Belobog characters.
Ah yes, the best genre.
Music that makes Y O U the boss.
When the music started i was like who is the boss now huh?😎✨️
Legit I shivered with the biggest grin, every time I play that echo of war I gamer lean and whisper “you’re stuck in here with me now”
I really love both but there is something about the classical aspect in Genshin music that no other game was able to make feel
You clearly haven't played a single Final Fantasy game, like, ever then.
@@TheRogueX Okay? Cool ig lol
@@TheRogueX you must be great at parties. Genshin themes are awesome.
@@TheRogueX and you clearly haven't ever listened to good composition ever since you think final fantasy is somehow a benchmark.
The soundtracks that went with the Raiden Shogun boss fights were incredible. In the first fight with her, there's this heartbeat-like sound that plays so ominously, it even made my heart beat faster and I'm thinking: "Oh yeah, I definitely die here..." such a dreadful feeling, in a good way. That just means the music is doing its job.
honestly, this makes me really amazed on how much effort hoyo is doing in making varied soundtrack, from classical opera, pop-stylized, dubstep, and now rock. from hi3rd, genshin, and star rail.
you could feel the different use of context, like how in scara's theme it symbolizes how the fight is not really in your favor, and you need your wits to be able to win, whilst wildfire really shows how even the aeons are going "beat his ass cuh, we gotchu", symbolizing the will of the aeon to defeat the seemingly impossible stellaron-infused cocolia...
though i guess the community won't ever tolerate each other due to the difference in tastes (personally, due to my taste, hi3rd still is one of the top in my opinion)
Nah don't worry people just get bored and want drama but at the end of the day they play BOTH games lol
Yes i think it's high time to create a community that appreciates all the differences. Variety, people
i personally enjoy all three of them but put genshin on the lowest, not because of gacha, combat, exploration or events. but due me missing somethings and needing to go online to finish that thing(its just annoy me)
Too bad so many honkai players just have a hate boner for genshin for no reasons
@@vnminecraft9656 the music community of hoyoverse is my safe place
I really liked how they timed star rail’s boss music according to certain events within the battle, while on the other hand i like how the genshin boss themes loop pretty seamlessly
The "WE MADE A CHOICE GO FIGHT AGAINST YOUR FATE" part lined with Serval's burst while I was playing it was PERFECT
During that whole fight I slowly realized I was very unprepared for that boss battle, but by the power of the music I refused surrender and I won, sadly only March was the survivor.
Considering you have no time to switch out lightcones, no one was ready for that battle. Ironically, trailblazer was my only survivor.
@@jace1332Same lol In the phase 2 of the boss my healer lynx died and the only one along with tingyun the only ones left are March 7th and Trailblazer in my final turn both the Boss and my characters are last hit luckily march 7 was alive to grant shield to the trailblazer and then finish it with ultimate If it takes long I would have lost tho
For me, only Dr. ratio and Natasha survived, and Natasha was nowhere near dying lmao
Only Natasha with me
Hot take, Both are good, both give different vibes that heavily fit their fight and the themes around them.
Hoyo community needs to stop taking shots at eachother, and start praying together for pity on banners.
Hot take.
YOU ARE PERFECTLY CORRECT.
I keep seeing people who are saying "Genshin is better than Star rail" and so on and I am like "WHO ASKED"
@@jaredjosephsongheng372 yeah and vice versa and I'm like they are both fun!
Remember these OSTs were made by music artists, not the dev teams from both game, there is no point of trashing these OSTs cuz that means we are literally trashing on the poor artists who put all their effort into making these.
Fr...most of the comments be saying "HSR's musics are better" or "Genshin's ones are better" and acting like they're speaking facts when it's literally their opinion and there's not even a point of clashing abt it when their themes and vibes and stories are simply just different. I mean just imagine that HSR's music being used in Scara boss fight...it wouldn't even go with the fight...it would just make it appear weird unlike how cool it is in HSR😭. The different music just suits the different stories ppl can't be overlooking all this💀
wildfire literally gives me so much motivation tbh
Not enough to make me the storm that is approaching tho
@@JeSt4mwildfire + bury the light?! WHOAAAAAAAAAAA🤯😳🤩🥵😱
@@JeSt4m nor enough to make me Undefeatable, Find my flame and Break through it all from Sonic-Chan himself.
Ok, now I want a Berried Delight
@@chuchelohuyuchelo wildfire+find your flame🔥🔥
Both of them slap. One slaps you with an unimaginable amount of epicness while the other slaps you with a tonal whiplash. Both are an absolute win and both make you feel like a badass hero. I'm not going to elaborate which theme slaps you with what.
I need new version of this meme with recent final Penacony boss
Genshin vibing...
DMC music outta nowhere: 💥 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I don’t know why, but Honkai boss theme reminds me so well of MGRR and DMC
@@FumoSakuya exactly, when i heard the theme when fighting cocolia i was like, damn, thats pure motivation
The context is very different though, for genshin the bosses are all beyond mortal beings with unknown streght to us, we are fighting for our life against these legendary menaces. In HSR, from narrative viewpoint we already won the battle with the powerup/getting the blessing of the aeon
That's why wildfire is heroic and epic but polumnia omnia feels ominous and scary
Yeah, both songs have different context and meaning. Tried to put Wildfire in Scaramouche boss battle, it doesn't strike as much as Polumnia. Same goes to Polumnia to Cocolia boss fight.
Comparing HSR music to Genshin music is like comparing P5 to Dark Souls. Two games with COMPLETELY different vibes
HSR is more dark i guess because its Honkai
@@stressedhaish69420 from what've seen for now in HSR, it is not. it's more campy and has a more light hearted story telling tone like P5.
Genshin's lore is one of the more f0ckedup lores I've read in games, the problem is the game doesn't throw it your face, you have to pursue it.
@@rootedpen2 yess!!
@@stressedhaish69420 HSR may/may not become depressing, mihoyo is unpredictable.
@@rootedpen2 Nah in the future updates hsr will surely become darker than genshin. I mean in the first ever major quest a relevant character already died. In the first ever update. And since its an honkai game we can expect it to be darker than genshin with the way its going. And theres already rumours that one of the characters on the express will die in the 1.2 update. Saying this as a ar 55 player btw.
I like both games. Genshin's almost every music is calm and heart melting. On the other hand, star rails music is just badass.
if the next boss theme is doom inspired, hsr is instantly my favourite game
Yeah, but the parent community said no for gore
@@dahandsomeguywithcoolglass8949 then that proves those parents aren't family christian enough.
@@dahandsomeguywithcoolglass8949 umm isn't the age rating already 12 only? At 14 they can show minor wounds, at 17 is when they can show metal gear rising level of gore
@@dahandsomeguywithcoolglass8949he game doesn't have to have gore for its music to be doom-inspired tho, op just wanted something more akin to djent and extra crunchy low strings
tbh i love how hyv makes music to fit each game and represent not only what the player is fighting but the emotion the main character should feel through the music too, like how in scaras theme its dread and fear but also courage on traveller's end and the desperate attempt scara makes to keep the gnosis, while in cocolias theme its the blinding power she feels through the stellarons influence and the trailblazer's determination to win.
This one video is probably why I started HSR. And I love every second of it.
Also me listening to nightglow...
Thank you, sensei😢
"Draw the gaze of The Preservation, Qlipoth."
gave me goosebumps ngl
nah i remember first time getting to the cocolia boss fight hypest shit that happened
Latin into a Japanese flute drop: I’m in trouble
Guitar solo into rock vocals: you’re in trouble
the virgin traveler: simply gets elemental powers but still needs to be bailed out be every archon
the chad trailblazer: impresses literal cosmic gods to the point that they give you a powerup to fight against a planetary cancer
Traveller: Gains a lesser ability of the archon
Trailblazer: BLESSINGS COME FORTH FROM THE AEONS; CARRY OUT MY PATH, TRAILBLAZER!
And the omnipresent Captain???
Is it just me or Trailblazer are too overpowered already. Like they are already at level of a god. Unlike genshin's MC who has lost most of their original strength and weapon. (They're still pretty op to go against an archon)
I've seen the power level difference between honkai and genshin is a lot.
@@glistica if you consider Herrschers being equivalent of Emanators then yea it's only going up from here
@@dynomite463 Plot twist: Traveller is Akivili xD
Wildfire is that Hero Music when entering Boss Battle. It's not even Cocolia's XD
As it should xD
I've figured the song isn't about the Trailblazer
Genshin with the Interdimensional Space Whale smuggling Dubstep within its stomach... 🎶🎶🎶
Not to be that guy, but for the confused lads, scara's theme in that moment says "novis natus" (newly born, born anew, born again, translations may differ) not "dominatus". Still the point gets through
Honestly no matter what, I will always love Azhdaha's battle music. Something about it just makes it so catchy to me.
Well thats Typical Genshin music masterpiece, while all HSR music is give west vibe thats i most hate
@@Zkr7 Being Honest Wildfire,and most of ost at Hertha Space staion are good.
The rest,especially Space china are pretty boring to hear
@@sayki3002 Right
@youji5015always catchy my ass
Most boss songs were mid at best
Azdaha and andrius are the only ones worth mentioning
@@Mehieddin7 which one is better wildfire or dvalin's ost?
Wildfire is what the boss hears when we enter it's domain.
Bosses when you have two hunt units and are having almost all of the blessings of the hunt:
@@adriantepes4355
Player: Pulls seele and bronya
Literally every mob in the game:
@@Aan-kun lol sadge for the mobs
scaramouche boss theme is a masterpiece cause it tells a story of scaramouche and the way yu peng chen delivered it was a chef's kiss
wildfire is a song that's making us hype and give goosebumps as we fight cocolia and defeat her and giving hope to bronya and the others
both are great but these two are made by two different composers in a game that has different genre and its own set of music and it depends on one's own opinion whether they prefer scaramouche's boss theme or wildfire
tho in my own opinion, i love genshin's music since it makes me imagine a fight between me and those bosses as wel as making my gaming experience in genshin more immersive while star rail is pretty new and listen to many of its ost and songs, I still prefer genshin's overall, maybe I would be more a fan of star rail's music as time passes but it can't top any of my favorites as of yet.
Lets be clear, both are absolute master pieces, just one is focus on the player about to wreck the boss, a song of hope and determination which we resonante easier, while the other shows the characters mind, on despair and divinity, how behind everything he is saying, is a vulnerable and hurt person, and i think both are beautiful in different aspects.
Genshin knows how to flesh out a boss' themes through music
HSR knows how to sell you on a scene
Honkai Apho 2:
*SO ONE . IS ALLOWED . TO BE BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRRNNNN*
Badass.
then slay that freaking *high note*
*WE'VE KNOWN WHAT TO BELIVE WITHOUT ANY DOUBT*
What does that even fuckin mean lol
@@saimyintmyat9373 makes 0 sense and edgey crap writen for the incels that can only play Honkai Impact if t hey put in a male character to self insert to lol
:000-:0:13 : sephiroth, sephiroth. 0:14 : oh no, not him again
That Cocolia boss theme REALLY gives me MGR vibes
Wildfire reminds me of like when an anime protag is about to beat up the final boss full of heroism and justice, while Scarmouche's theme, reminds me of like some sad betrayal
I believe it's a matter of taste but, DAMN man, the boss theme scaramouche is so fire, pardon me honkai veterans, but nothing buys me more than an opera in Latin, the master piece.
That's because Yu-Peng Chen made it. Man is the Archon of Music.
Yeah, the star rail one is good, but I feel like I’ve heard 20 different songs like it before, while the Genshin one is much more unique.
Thanks for saying that the Honkai was good but Genshin is better.
Instead of the comments in which I see where people are saying Honkai is trash in which it isn't.
@@thatguythere6161same though lol. I've heard like a hundred different rock songs with similar vibe as wildfire so it's like,damn this is pretty cool. But for genshin boss themes which are all very unique and doesn't feel repetitive overall composition wise,it's like,Wow WTF piece am I listening to?!?! So many instruments and so many things going on. Amazing.
I think we can conclude one thing from the music of Genshin and Honkai Star Rail/Impact, Mihoyo makes some goddamn banger ass music
Star Rail: You are kicking the boss's ass and it is epic
Genshin: The boss is kicking your ass, and it is epic.
I bet Wildfire is the national anthem for the Abyss Order (but in Khaenri'an Latin presumably)
Especially because of we've made a choice go fight against your fate
PAIN WILL COME WITH THE BLADE!
If you don't mind, I might need some explanation for this
@@rin0847 PAIN WILL WAKE UP THE DESPONDENT CROWD IN THIS DORMANT WORLD SOOOOME HOOOOWWWWW
@@rin0847 PAIN WILL WAKE UP THE DESPONDENT CROWD IN THIS DORMANT WORLD SOOOOME HOOOOWWWWW
@@kuildoor UNSHEATH A SWORD NOT TO KILL!! UNSHEATH A SWORD TO REND THOSE.. CLOUDS ABOVE THE GROUND.. WAKE UP, TO HEAR THE CHEERING SOUND!!!!
But i'd more prefer to Scaramouche boss theme
Same 🎉
I enjoy both 😐
Polumnia Omnia is a pure masterpiece. I thank lord yu peng chen for his existence
Agreed
Star Rail has that Metal Gear/DMC vibe with its music and I dig it
FINNALY SOMEONE NOTICE !!!
As someone who is never a fan of English songs, I prefer Genshin boss themes.
Wildfire is great, but I often return to Genshin's music in general. Honkai music is dynamic, heroic and hype, but Genshin's music makes me feel soothing. I can feel a soul in Genshin's music.
Personally I find star rail to have a lot of good "chill and vibe" tracks. Belobog admin district, boulder town, the express, and the master control zone being some of the best IMO
Wildfire is great but scaramouche boss theme is just way more better
@@Arestwo515 azhdaha 2nd phase theme is superior to both in my opinion
I tend to remember genshins more cause honkais just doesn't stand out to me as much like in the cocallia fight I wasn't really understanding or finding her character interesting so I was hoping maybe they have a honkai rock theme about her character similar to genshin but it was more bout the MC which I don't mind but I still wish it did something similar. And the area and combat music are just average to me like each nation/area has unique combat music that fits in around is aesthetic star rail I just don't get that feeling
@@teddyisaliar271 if you mean starrail then fair but the game only in its first version so....
I love how Stelle is really getting into the song, while Lumine is giving the same look March does lol
Bro out here committing war crimes by not letting the scara boss beat drop not finish
Wildfire drop prefectly at when the Meteor fall is pure epic
Genshin boss make me feel the grand- ness of bosses, Starrail make me feel like the protagonist fighting against fate and destiny
The Star rail music is just absolutely mind blowing.
i like the addition of latin in genshin. honestly, latin is such an underrated language though. i love it.
Chad scaramouche boss theme vs virgin cocolia boss theme/wildfire
Chad Scaramouch lol
Mommy issues bad written character. His OST is fire tho. But I mean... Wildfire is LITERALLY FIRE
@@silhouette9699 still better than honkshit dogshit wildfailure tho. Polumnia omnia>wildfailure
@@silhouette9699 still better writen than wildfire and cocolia tho. Polumnia omnia just slap harder than wildfire.
Also Scaramouche is so well-written 😭
@@silhouette9699 bad written huh, easily one of best written char and out of nowhere you say the otherwise? oh okay LMAO
nothing can top scara’s battle theme. i literally CAME to that shit… iykyk 😶
i’m so sorry why did i type this
Average scara fan:
@@whyyoumadbro2370 😭😭
Testify by void mournfinale: i exist
Genshin gives me chills, Honkai gets me hyped. Love it
Both themes are fire, I loooove Scaramouche’s battle OST BUT COCOLIA’S IS SOOOO GOOD TOO
I still prefer a complex, more classical song over your stereotypical rock, pop or whatever with vocals - it feels less cheap
Not fair when its not even the best part of scaramouche theme, lol
This channel never fair to Genshin, i mean this channel is just Genshin roast at best, hell even he show full screen scene for HSR but just small screen for Genshin
The channel always been like this
the lyrics only come out when cocolia does the zongli meteor attack tho
genshin rarely or never got music with lyric. the only one i remember is la vaguelette. i dont count people say random thing in orcestra as lyric.
Props to designer, cocolia fight was badass
"You're tough, but it's never been about you!"
Oh, Arknights are on a different level xD
My favorite in Genshin still is "Bane of Ambitions". It feels like you are actually fighting against this being that is much more powerful than you are.
Bane of Ambitions is one of my favs as well! Such an underrated OST, it really feels like the theme of eternity.
I can’t believe starrail released 7 months ago…
It feels like so much longer.
The guy for Genshin : show a tiny image
The guy for Star Rail : SHOW THE IMAGE FULL SCREEN
Seems fair lol
It's the bird meme
This is just typical Honkai fanboy channel, especially this guy, most of his Video are comparing Genshin to something and roast it or straight up Genshin roast intensify
3/4 the video is wildfire lol . Very fair
@Leozeo™ honk
@@Zkr7 The comments from those Honkai stans aren't any better, just look how much they are d*ckriding that ooohhh soooo almighty "pLaNeT dEsTrOyInG dRaGoN".
Said "dragon" couldn't even destroy a measly space station, lmao. 💀
If THAT'S the "planet destroying" power, than both the Emanators and Aeons are a friggin joke.
Im HSR player but bro you are comparing Opera with Rock? You high enough bro
Both are boss themes
@@ht-kruku
Used in a different context and in different genres.
@@Phantom_Zone the context is similar and one is an hack and slash the other is a jrpg, and the metal is a descendent from classic music so
@@ht-kruku
Glad you said that HT. I have been waiting for this.
What you are describing is the genre. The context is everything that led up to this moment.
So for Genshin, The orchestra is to be reminiscent of grand and epic ascension. It is meant to praise the birth of the new God. No matter how misguided, he is still a New Born God. Novi Natus. The chant you hear is the praise of a new born God.
So it is meant to be majestic. That's why the lyrics are in Latin. You're fighting against a God. At that moment the world isn't focused on you. It's on Scaramouche. We are opposing Scaramouche.
That's the context.
In contrast. Beating Cocolia is a matter of survival for Belobog. And you are fighting to protect the world. And you're not just fighting for the world, you're opposing ideals. At that moment, Cocolia is not the focus of the story. You are. Cocolia is the one that's opposing you.
That's the context.
Genshin is meant to evoke the feeling of misguided glory and power of a God.
HSR evokes the feeling of being triumphed. It sings about your will to fight against fate.
There a shit more nuances in the Orchestra. Wildfire is pretty basic in terms of the whole package. Wildfire is literally a theme song about your fight against Cocolia.
Genshins song conveys a whole lot by simple chants. I don't expect you to understand considering your fuck all knowledge about the difference between context and genre.
Thanks for reminding me of that fire of a battle
that was an unintended pun
when I fought cocolia I was screaming from excitement it hits hard
In Genshin you're fighting a broken person.
In HSR you're fighting a genocidal maniac.
That genocidal maniac is also broken. Cuz got controlled or some shit.
@@hdWWtchR Cocolia wasn't really evil, she just made some huge sacrifices to protect Belobog. She tried to follow both destruction and preservation.
@@desi-420 I didn't say she's evil, if anything she's just subconsciously controlled
Sigh, another misunderstanding. Cocolia was not one of those maniacs who commit genocide just for the sake of it. She lose hope and preferred to obey the Stellaron hoping that it can fix everything. Even Himeko and the collective minds of previous guardians state that they won't judge Cocolia for abandoning all hope.
The best song they made is still Fischl's battle theme Die Mittsommernacht-Fantasie
The true correct opinion
fr i miss that theme so bad
What I can see is while stelle fighting the boss,caelus on background support her with singing _wildfire_
I thought I clicked a wrong video and that I'm listening to comparison of Genshin OST and Metal Gear Rising OST
Man, genshin impact really did an amazing job with its music
Whatever ppl say, I still prefer genshin over hsr anytime. I play both the games btw
@@spymadmax584 spiral abyss 12-1 💀 i feel its even harder than bosses, monsters can 1 shot you in one combo if you dont have enough regens
@@lamhoang8986 guess what people wanted came true. Spiral abyss becoming much more difficult
@@whyyoumadbro2370yet still mostly a joke with proper team comps and somewhat decent artifacts
@@Mehieddin7 true, though I see alot of people right now struggling to 36 star this current abyss. Consecrated beasts are annoying cunts to fight.
Isnt this the bird meme, where the point of the meme is even though both of the music is good, the one sung by the crow (trailblazer) is louder....so why is the comment section arguing over comparisons, both are good and both fit their respective scenario's
"It's a turn based fighting game don't go too crazy"
Jonathan Steingard:
Although the latter was nice genshin Music Was really the one that usually hit me up,its not about my heroism,its about telling story about certain place or Character that can make you wondering
"What happened?" "How." And why"
Love how they ignored signora boss fight theme which has one of the most badass guitar themed soundtrack
Wildfire give me dmc5 vibe damn
it's the storm that is approaching🌪🌩
Search apho, a mihoyo masterpiece
,, Wake the fuck up samurai. We have a boss to burn "
Felt like I could conquer the world while fighting Cocolia
Honkai just went Metal gear? HELL YAH
Yeah. Try putting that theme in genshin. It wouldn't fit right? That's why it's called theme. It should fit what genre or what it is.
More than that. Context.
In the context Scara theme is fine tuned to his character. It tells his story.
The theme in HSR is about humanity saying fuck you to stellaron.
My first week of playing star rail, that cutscene gave meeee chilllsss! it was so good lol
The Cocolia fight was pure kino. Really hope we get another cool moment like that at some point.
I absolutely love wildfire but scara theme will always be my favorite boss theme
The examples chosen here are both fantastic pieces of music, and while I do think that Wildfire has a more immediate hype factor, I can get a lot more out of Scaramouches Boss theme by actively listening to it and appreciating the many layers of musical depth. It's a Beethoven level masterpiece.
Reminds me about the Fire Emblem: Three house ost being a little chill, meanwhile God Shattering star
HSR: Yes, we love MGRR
So here we go again with the honkai fans showing their elitism again, especially this certain creator with obvious bias
You think this is bad. Try going to their subreddit.
@@Phantom_Zone i did😔
@@ocean7790 I visited HI3. Safe to say I lost all my motivation to try the game.
@@Phantom_Zone same, i lost my motivation lately after playing nearly 5 year, just because the fandom become worse and worse everyday because of superiority complex and exageration
This is a hi3 channel. Ofc that's what you expect is happening