🆕🎦Join our WHATSAPP CHANNEL and watch our videos as soon as they are published. •••Note: We will not have access to your phone number••• ➡Click here: bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center⬅
According to the criteria we follow, he did not qualify for the main list. That does not mean he is not as good or better than anyone else on the list, I really like Carl Palmer! Thanks for commenting!
Emerson, Lake and P O W E L L, too 👌👌👌. The fabulous comeback after the Love Beach fiasco. All the people who saw them live during their (sadly) single tour, told me they were amazing. IMHO, that lineup should have lasted longer.
Neil Peart on top of his drumming, skills and ability. He wrote almost all Rush’s lyrics, and authored about nine books. He is my favourite human being. From🇨🇦
Cozy Powell just a honorable mention????!!!! Come on, the guy never took a drum lesson, he learned by himself, played with some of the greatest musicians ever, he was the guy everybody wanted in their bands... and just a honorable mention???!!!! He should be rated top 5, IMHO.
Underrated drummer, Jerry Mercer-April Wine. He plays very powerful, during lengthy drum solos. Other underrated drummers that I like are Bruce Crump-Molly Hatchet, Simon Kirke-Free, Bad Company, Roger Earl-Savoy Brown, Foghat, Artimus Pyle-Lynyrd Skynyrd.
Bill Ward is a rock icon, especially with Black Sabbath! He made it to the honorable mentions but could easily deserve a spot on the main list. What rank would you give him?
@@BackingTrackCenter I would have put him in the 5 slot ahead of Ringo in the 6 slot. Blacks Sabbath is my favorite band and think highly of him but even Bill put Ginger and Keith above him and he and Bonham were close friends.
As usual, a completely bogus list. Roger Taylor ??? Are you freakin' kidding me ? And Carl Palmer only gets an Honorable Mention ? WTF. Where's Clive Bunker ?
I also don't agree with several names that made it onto this list and their omissions, but I was faithful to the chosen methodology (See description) that resulted in this ranking. But from the perspective of the technique, who would be in your top 5? Thanks for commenting!
What s wrong with Roger Taylor being in this list? Do you actually play drums or you only like the sound of drums and drummers? The only wrong thing in this list Is Ringo Starr Who shouldnt even male It to the top 50
@@stefan8405 Ringo is an innovative drummer. Roger Taylor is "just a drummer", anyone could have filled his shoes. And yes, I am a drummer and a damn good one, too.
Roger Taylor maybe was not a fenomenal on skills but his sense of rithms, toms and tempos did an Epic and legend drums for one of the most sucessful career bands...Queen...IS not enought????
I agree! Carmine Appice is a legend with an amazing career. He almost made the list but ended up as an honorable mention. What position do you think he deserves?
Now I'm not quite the type to rate musicians, because I like variety and think most musicians contribute to this. The exception is Carmine Appice, who I would have rated first, as he has been a source of inspiration for many of those on your list, including John Bonham.
You mixed great drummers who played the perfect simple part for the song with the guys who can play four different time signatures while the band plays in yet a different one.
If you're talking about technical drumming Neil Peart is by far #1. I think that Neil could play anything that John Bonham did...But... I don't think Bonzo could handle some of Peart's more intricate stuff.
Ian Paice. When Peart arranged a Buddy Rich tribute which Paice attended there was a clear gap between who could handle Rich's style and who couldn't, Paice owned Peart but is too modest a guy to sing his own praises. The likes of myself are more than happy to on his behalf though.
Okay, Cozy Powell may not be in your top twenty, but is in my top ten especially in the classic lineup of Blackmore, Dio, Powell, Carey & Bain. Animal, number 1 in the puppet and animated genre has to be animal.
Cozy Powell is a big name, but he didn’t make it into the main list. He’s included as an honorable mention for being an incredible and influential drummer.
@@BackingTrackCenter I would put Cozy Powell way ahead of Roger Taylor for two reasons Powell has played in more successful bands and is a better drummer.
NOT as Famous.....?🫣 You mean like the other one from Toto....? before Simon jumped in.... 😇 Jeff Pocaro & Simon Phillips both should be in this Top 15.....!! 🛎⭐️
@RushfanUK i agree. I've liked Zep since I was young in the middle 70s. Overhearing my older brothers play their albums. I always like the drumming in Rock and Roll and Stairway to Heaven. Yet, I never knew or thought of Bonham as the greatest until I started watching these TH-cam top 10 videos about a decade ago. His drumming just doesn't generally catch my ear on most Zep songs. Keith Moon does, Ginger Baker, and Mitch Mitchell did when I discovered them later. Nobody, though, caught my ear instantly and on literally every track like Neil Peart did. Also watching him live is one of music's great treats. I don't personally think anyone can touch him, but that's just my opinion.
My Top Favorite 6 Drummers I have seen each group LIVE 4 times.... Phil Ehart - Kansas... Neil Peart - Rush... Frank Beard - ZZ Top... Bob Siebenberg - Supertramp... Nick Mason - Pink Floyd... Michael Shrieve - Santana many others in over 300 concerts since 1966.
Your list is fantastic. We will soon be making a list based on the opinions of our subscribers and will take your feedback into account. Thanks for commenting!
Although he is indeed one of the greatest drummers of all time, according to the methodology used he did not qualify for the main list, but was mentioned in the honorable mentions. Thanks for commenting!
I understand that the likes of Carl Palmer and Pierre Van Der Linden are for the older folks the omission of El Estepario Siberiano in a month old post is criminal!
I'm a John Bonham fan. We are living in a very competitive world, for this reason i don't like these classificatoons. We can enjoy with a lot of great drummers. Respect!!
Roger Taylor divide sempre le opinioni. Alcuni lo considerano tra i migliori per il suo stile unico, mentre altri preferirebbero vederlo più in basso. Grazie per aver commentato!
Good afternoon my friend I just made a list based on your Rolling Stone Magazine Ranking from 7 months ago, my Personal Ranking from 2 months ago as a reaction on Rolling Stone Magazine Ranking and this ranking. Best drummer got on each list 10 points, second drummer 9 points etc. By equal points I look on how many lists the drummer will appear and if possible with same points highest ranking on one list. (1,2, or 3) = number of how many lists the name is appearing. By equal point (H ) = Highest Ranking 6+2 , (L) = Lower Highest Ranking 5+3. (E)= Equal . Here we go: 01 John Bonham 26 02 Keith Moon 20 03 Ginger Baker 16 (3) 04 Neil Paert 16 (2) 05 Stewart Copeland 11 06 Mick Tucker 10 07 Loulou Tielman 9 08 Mitch Mitchell 8 (2) (H) 09 Ringo Starr 8 (2) (L) 10 Cesar Zuiderwijk 8 (1) 11 Dave Grohl 7 (2) 12 Sheila E 7 (1) 13 Alex van Halen 5 14/15 Danny Carey 4 (1) (E) 14/15 Charlie Watts 4 (1) (E)
Wow! How cool that you did your own analysis by cross-referencing rankings! The methodology seems pretty solid. Very well done! From your suggestions on the Rolling Stones list, I took into account names like Mick Tucker, Cesar Zuiderwijk and Loulou Tielman, they are in the honorable mentions and there are clips of them at the end of this video. Thanks for your collaboration!
@BackingTrackCenter Thanks for appreciation my friend. I could use my first list again but I wanted to see what would be the result with mixing 3 different sources. I saw from my list 9 out of 10 made it. Only Brad Wilk did not make it. He was in good company with Roger Taylor, Terrry Bozzio and Bill Bruford. Top 3 drummers were on 3 lists. John Bonham with 26 points out of max 30 is a solid number one. I will try to make a "Not Mariah Christmas And A Happy New Year List"
@@BackingTrackCenter Christmas is coming my friend and we will get plenty Mariah Carey and othher usual suspects to hear. Let us spread something completely different: The Not Marey Christmas Songs And Happy New Year List. This list is made to have more options those festive days. Just For Fun Or ..... Here we go: 01 Sparks - Christmas Without A Prayer 02 Gotcha - Da Ten Is Mightier Than Da Sword 03 Sabaton _ Christmas Truce 04 Fay Lovsky - Christmas Was A Friend Of Mine 05 Ramones - Merry Christmas (I Don't Want To Fight Tonight) 07 Tom Waits - Christmas Card From A H.........r In Minneapolis 08 The Pogues - Fairytale Of New York 09 Claw Boys Claw - Blue Bells 10 Run DMC - Christmas in Hollis 11 Lyric Noel - Carol Of The Bells 12 The Kinks - Father Christmas 13 Twisted Sister - Heavy Metal Christmas 14 Relient K - 12 Days Of Christmas 15 Dio - God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen Christmas Song No time for me to do a proper ranking so I will give you special attention for my Dutch input: numbers 2, 4, and 9. I hope you have time to make a vid so the audience can have a variety of Christmas songs you will not hear that often. With making this list biggest surprise was for me number 11. You are free to add or remove songs from this list. I hope you will enjoy this list.
Dennis Chambers, Dave Weckl, Pat Mastelotto, Gavin Harrison, Thomas Lang, Virgil Donati, Nicko McBrain, Dave Lombardo, Alex Van Halen y un gran etcétera
@@manuelgodinez7591 ....conoces a Daryl Anderson, Jhon Anastasio,Derrick Willams, Andy Gómez, Peter Taylor, Billy Swanson, Derek Norris, Brian CASSIDY, Lindsay ' FOX' Cetera, Wen Harrison, Mick O' List...etc??.
Great comments and drummers.shoulda made it 20- 25? Barrimore barlowe, palmer, bernard purdie, phil collins, ansley dunsbarr.couple of my personal faves are, weird reasons.spencer dreydon, sammy piazza
Christian Vander. Unique drummer, composer and vocalist. His style is a combination of jazz precise technique with rock energy. Tatsuya Yoshida, great drummer, composer and band leader. Many projects, solo works and various collaborations...
@Backing Track Center: I liked your list, other good drummers: Rob Reinner, Matt Sorum, Cozy Powell, Nick Mason, Nicko McBrain, John Densmore, Tommy Aldridge, Herman Rarebell, Clive Burr, james Cottak, and many more; Salutes.
I knew who was in first place before watching the video. Matter of fact I knew that John Bonham was the best after have listened to Moby Dick, Rip John.
Definitely, "Moby Dick" is one of the greatest showcases of Bonham's drumming skills. And the way he improvised live was out of this world. Thanks for commenting!
Don’t forget to like, leave a comment, and share. Subscribe to our channel and consider becoming a member to gain early access to our content for a small fee. Just click on th-cam.com/channels/dDrgupSK6NYXtj3CBcfw_w.htmljoin
หลายเดือนก่อน +2
Hard to argue with this list, and I appreciate that you shared your methodology. Some will argue for days and days about deserving drummers who didn't make this list, but it says a lot about classic rock (and classic rock fans, I guess) that the list is comprised solely of white men, who are either British or American. The sole "diverse" drummer that I can see here is Neil Peart, who was Canadian.
I agree, it's hard not to notice the lack of diversity. Do you have any suggestions for a list that features more diverse musicians? Thank you very much for your comment and welcome to the channel.
Next time a list could be made of Rock's most influential unknown players like Al Jackson, Benny Benjamin, Tony Thompson, Clyde Stubblefield and so many more who nobody knows their name......
I agree, Nick Menza and Steve Smith are amazing and made history. Have you heard Vital Tech Tones with Steve Smith, Scott Henderson and Victor Wooten? Thanks for commenting!
rick allen never gets any acknowledgement on these lists. he had to change everything to drum and he did it, like a beast. respect the gu who plays better than most, and one handed. ev xo
Are you kidding??? All due respect to the band for their loyalty. But... He wasn't that good with two arms. He had a specialized drum kit made to accommodate his handi-cap. He lost his arm because of irresponsible behavior..and was never anything special. But again all due respect to the bands loyalty. That's that.
@ScottD768 somewhat agree. Top 15? Definitely not. But other top 50 or 100 list? I feel he should be included. My opinion only. Thanks for replying. Ev xo
Ah, the great Levon Helm. (Just heard Garth passed away…now no one left living from The Band. 😭 Do yourselves a favor and watch “The Last Waltz” in tribute to The Band. We’re sadly losing the greats…the real musicians and bands from a bygone analog era.)
Ringo Starr com certeza está entre os maiores bateristas do rock, mas não pode estar entre os melhores. Não tem como. Importância é uma coisa, habilidade técnica e criatividade é outra
🆕🎦Join our WHATSAPP CHANNEL and watch our videos as soon as they are published.
•••Note: We will not have access to your phone number•••
➡Click here: bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center⬅
Cozy Powell.....😎
Yeah
Just a honorable mention.... one of the greatest drummers that walked this Earth!!!
Lars ulrich...
Great!
100%
The great CARL PALMER only got an honorable mention ?????? SMH !!!!!!!!
According to the criteria we follow, he did not qualify for the main list. That does not mean he is not as good or better than anyone else on the list, I really like Carl Palmer! Thanks for commenting!
What is the criteria
It's in the video description.
Yep
@@fingersfan1843 and David Grohl at #8?!?
Jeff Porcaro.
Paice, Palmer, Barlow, Cobham, Bonham, Copeland
In Order First John 'Octopus' Bonham
Emmerson,Lake and P A L M E R👍👍👍👍👍
Emerson, Lake and P O W E L L, too 👌👌👌. The fabulous comeback after the Love Beach fiasco. All the people who saw them live during their (sadly) single tour, told me they were amazing. IMHO, that lineup should have lasted longer.
Neil Peart on top of his drumming, skills and ability. He wrote almost all Rush’s lyrics, and authored about nine books. He is my favourite human being. From🇨🇦
I am all for it!! Neil was fantastic! Neil, and Cozy Powell are my all time favourite drummers.
@@GEDDY37 Absolutely agreed🇨🇦🤘
Neil!! AKA The Professor!!!!❤❤❤❤
Barrie Barlow , Jethro Tull .
Billy Cobham
Jon Hiseman
Both are outstanding musicians, pioneers of jazz rock and fusion...
Simon Phillips?
Cozy Powell just a honorable mention????!!!! Come on, the guy never took a drum lesson, he learned by himself, played with some of the greatest musicians ever, he was the guy everybody wanted in their bands... and just a honorable mention???!!!! He should be rated top 5, IMHO.
Great!
I'm on board with cozy. Inspiration.
@@Mark-lc3bh and I am all for it!!! Legend, icon
Carl Palmer, Barriemore Barlow...
Phil Ehart, Lee Kerslake, Robb Reiner and Barriemore Barlow!
Ehart and barriemore were always my favorites in the seventies
Yes! Phil. Glad to see other fans. Check out Propulsion One from their Absence of Presence album.
@@andreatittoni793 Your Right,Barlow in the Top 10 and Jethro Tull Outstanding Band also and the Bandamtes in Eye of Ian Anderson
Ian Paice should be at or near the top.. and I’m happy he was actually mentioned because he’s usually forgotten.
I completely agree!
@@ponytrekker8996 USUALLY, UNFORTUNATELY, UNFAIRLY AND UNDESERVEDLY
Underrated drummer, Jerry Mercer-April Wine. He plays very powerful, during lengthy drum solos. Other underrated drummers that I like are Bruce Crump-Molly Hatchet, Simon Kirke-Free, Bad Company, Roger Earl-Savoy Brown, Foghat, Artimus Pyle-Lynyrd Skynyrd.
Totally agree, Jerry Mercer is amazing and deserves more recognition, just like Bruce Crump and Simon Kirke. These drummers have incredible energy!
Mercer and kirke yes sir
Well all those
Лично для меня лучший это Джеймс Коттак. Вечная память ему😢
What about Bill Ward😊
Bill Ward is a rock icon, especially with Black Sabbath! He made it to the honorable mentions but could easily deserve a spot on the main list. What rank would you give him?
Yep
@@mikekeeler6362 Massive drop the Samsonite !!! 💥🌟🌟🌟
love so much
@@BackingTrackCenter I would have put him in the 5 slot ahead of Ringo in the 6 slot. Blacks Sabbath is my favorite band and think highly of him but even Bill put Ginger and Keith above him and he and Bonham were close friends.
Good list. Thanks
As usual, a completely bogus list. Roger Taylor ??? Are you freakin' kidding me ? And Carl Palmer only gets an Honorable Mention ? WTF. Where's Clive Bunker ?
I also don't agree with several names that made it onto this list and their omissions, but I was faithful to the chosen methodology (See description) that resulted in this ranking. But from the perspective of the technique, who would be in your top 5? Thanks for commenting!
What s wrong with Roger Taylor being in this list? Do you actually play drums or you only like the sound of drums and drummers? The only wrong thing in this list Is Ringo Starr Who shouldnt even male It to the top 50
@@stefan8405 Ringo is an innovative drummer. Roger Taylor is "just a drummer", anyone could have filled his shoes. And yes, I am a drummer and a damn good one, too.
Roger Taylor maybe was not a fenomenal on skills but his sense of rithms, toms and tempos did an Epic and legend drums for one of the most sucessful career bands...Queen...IS not enought????
@@U2WB yeah right keep telling yourself that.
Ha, Ha, Ha, Number1 is IAN PAICE!
@@DimTod-ps2wi only in your wet dreams. Bonzo is on top of the hill by far and you know it, despite you are a fan of Paice
Almost all British drummers. The talent pool of 60s-70s era British drummers was astounding!
True, the British scene of that era was a real cradle of talent!
@@BackingTrackCenter Mick Tucker-The Sweet!!!!!!!!
Carmine Appice should have been on this list.
I agree! Carmine Appice is a legend with an amazing career. He almost made the list but ended up as an honorable mention. What position do you think he deserves?
Now I'm not quite the type to rate musicians, because I like variety and think most musicians contribute to this. The exception is Carmine Appice, who I would have rated first, as he has been a source of inspiration for many of those on your list, including John Bonham.
Barrimore Barlow, Richard Bailey etc. However, it's great to see Ian Paice on the list.
You mixed great drummers who played the perfect simple part for the song with the guys who can play four different time signatures while the band plays in yet a different one.
Brian Downey of Thin Lizzy...
If you're talking about technical drumming Neil Peart is by far #1. I think that Neil could play anything that John Bonham did...But... I don't think Bonzo could handle some of Peart's more intricate stuff.
I agree, Neil Peart had an impressive technique and incredible range. He definitely brought a level of complexity that few could match.
Vinny Appice
@@cableken cuz he was always drunk!
Ian Paice. When Peart arranged a Buddy Rich tribute which Paice attended there was a clear gap between who could handle Rich's style and who couldn't, Paice owned Peart but is too modest a guy to sing his own praises. The likes of myself are more than happy to on his behalf though.
@@johnanthonyp Same goes for Dennis Chambers.
Okay, Cozy Powell may not be in your top twenty, but is in my top ten especially in the classic lineup of Blackmore, Dio, Powell, Carey & Bain.
Animal, number 1 in the puppet and animated genre has to be animal.
Cozy in my top 5!
Have we already mentioned Cozy Powell?
Cozy Powell is a big name, but he didn’t make it into the main list. He’s included as an honorable mention for being an incredible and influential drummer.
@@BackingTrackCenter I would put Cozy Powell way ahead of Roger Taylor for two reasons Powell has played in more successful bands and is a better drummer.
Carl palmer bonzo my 2 favs .barriemor barlow .3
Had to be Bonzo - my opinion only, of course!!
Phil Collins where is he?
Phil Ehart-Kansas. Phil also played on a Steve Hackett album
Good point! Phil Ehart is a great drummer and brought a unique sound to Kansas.
Bill Bruford number 14??? Bill Bruford is the best technician.
I agree. It's one of my favorites!
Brian Downey
@@powerage17 He's right up there!
ここで紹介されているロックドラマーベスト15は、みな人気バンドに所属する見た目のカッコ良さも持つ「有名人」という側面も強いスターばかり。そうしたタイプとは全く逆のドラマーで、最高だと思うのはジェフ・ベックやエルビス・コステロのドラマーを務めたサイモン・フィリップスです。決して派手ではないけれど、正確無比で切れ味鋭くて、グルーヴ感もたっぷり‼︎ 最高のドラマーなのです。
私も同意します、サイモン・フィリップスは、このリストに載っている他の人たちほど有名ではありませんが、偉大なドラマーです。彼の技術と正確さは印象的です。彼はもっと注目されるべきです！コメントありがとうございます！
@@BackingTrackCenter
お返事を頂き大変光栄です。
ありがとうございます！ 次なる動画も楽しみにしています！
NOT as Famous.....?🫣
You mean like the other one from Toto....?
before Simon jumped in.... 😇
Jeff Pocaro & Simon Phillips both should be in this Top 15.....!! 🛎⭐️
お気軽にご提案ください。チャンネルへようこそ！
Both received honorable mention at the end of the list, which doesn't mean they aren't fantastic drummers.
Bill Bruford is top 5 .....come on man !!!
For me he is also in the top 5.
Do people really think that John Bonham is the best drummer ever, that since he died 44 years ago not one drummer has surpassed him, I don't.
@RushfanUK i agree. I've liked Zep since I was young in the middle 70s. Overhearing my older brothers play their albums. I always like the drumming in Rock and Roll and Stairway to Heaven. Yet, I never knew or thought of Bonham as the greatest until I started watching these TH-cam top 10 videos about a decade ago. His drumming just doesn't generally catch my ear on most Zep songs. Keith Moon does, Ginger Baker, and Mitch Mitchell did when I discovered them later. Nobody, though, caught my ear instantly and on literally every track like Neil Peart did. Also watching him live is one of music's great treats. I don't personally think anyone can touch him, but that's just my opinion.
Animal's creation was inspired by young Paice in Blitzen jazz gig 1969
Steve Feronne, Jeff Porcaro, John Jr Robinson, Vinnie Colaita, Jim Gordon, Steve Gadd...
Corky Laing
Well these were definitely the most popular. Best Rock drummers?.... Nope.
What are the top 10 in your opinion?
Some of the best drummers in the world you’ll never know…..
Ringo Starr is right up there with Peter Criss and Charlie Watts!
@@basher5107 nonsens
@@jimimurti when you learn how to spell get back to me and I’ll take you to school on music!
@basher5107 ik zal je Nederlands leren dan!
My Top Favorite 6 Drummers I have seen each group LIVE 4 times.... Phil Ehart - Kansas... Neil Peart - Rush... Frank Beard - ZZ Top... Bob Siebenberg - Supertramp... Nick Mason - Pink Floyd... Michael Shrieve - Santana many others in over 300 concerts since 1966.
Your list is fantastic. We will soon be making a list based on the opinions of our subscribers and will take your feedback into account. Thanks for commenting!
@@BackingTrackCenter Watch Phil Ehart - Kansas do Magnum Opus Live. My favorite.
Phil Ehart pocket man fantastic drummer!
Rock is bonham.his drums is music.❤❤❤❤ . Love from sambtion band . Eilat israel.
I would add Jeff Porcaro, Simon Phillips, Thomas Lang and Phil Collins.
Where's Carl Palmer ?
Although he is indeed one of the greatest drummers of all time, according to the methodology used he did not qualify for the main list, but was mentioned in the honorable mentions. Thanks for commenting!
Barriemore Barlow. How do you not include Terry Bozzio
He received an honorable mention. If you can, check out the ranking details in the video description. Thanks for commenting!
Neil Peart and Lee Kerslake. Nicko McBrain of Iron Maiden.
I understand that the likes of Carl Palmer and Pierre Van Der Linden are for the older folks the omission of El Estepario Siberiano in a month old post is criminal!
👍
How could Carl Palmer not be on this list?
I'm a John Bonham fan. We are living in a very competitive world, for this reason i don't like these classificatoons. We can enjoy with a lot of great drummers. Respect!!
👍
My Fav- Phil Ehart - Kansas.... A Machine with sticks.
Roger Taylor dei Queen al decimo posto non merita questa posizione deve stare al 55esimo posto quello giusto per lui
Roger Taylor divide sempre le opinioni. Alcuni lo considerano tra i migliori per il suo stile unico, mentre altri preferirebbero vederlo più in basso. Grazie per aver commentato!
Good afternoon my friend I just made a list based on your Rolling Stone Magazine Ranking from 7 months ago, my Personal Ranking from 2 months ago as a reaction on Rolling Stone Magazine Ranking and this ranking. Best drummer got on each list 10 points, second drummer 9 points etc. By equal points I look on how many lists the drummer will appear and if possible with same points highest ranking on one list. (1,2, or 3) = number of how many lists the name is appearing. By equal point (H ) = Highest Ranking 6+2 , (L) = Lower Highest Ranking 5+3. (E)= Equal .
Here we go:
01 John Bonham 26
02 Keith Moon 20
03 Ginger Baker 16 (3)
04 Neil Paert 16 (2)
05 Stewart Copeland 11
06 Mick Tucker 10
07 Loulou Tielman 9
08 Mitch Mitchell 8 (2) (H)
09 Ringo Starr 8 (2) (L)
10 Cesar Zuiderwijk 8 (1)
11 Dave Grohl 7 (2)
12 Sheila E 7 (1)
13 Alex van Halen 5
14/15 Danny Carey 4 (1) (E)
14/15 Charlie Watts 4 (1) (E)
Wow! How cool that you did your own analysis by cross-referencing rankings! The methodology seems pretty solid. Very well done!
From your suggestions on the Rolling Stones list, I took into account names like Mick Tucker, Cesar Zuiderwijk and Loulou Tielman, they are in the honorable mentions and there are clips of them at the end of this video.
Thanks for your collaboration!
@BackingTrackCenter Thanks for appreciation my friend. I could use my first list again but I wanted to see what would be the result with mixing 3 different sources. I saw from my list 9 out of 10 made it. Only Brad Wilk did not make it. He was in good company with Roger Taylor, Terrry Bozzio and Bill Bruford. Top 3 drummers were on 3 lists. John Bonham with 26 points out of max 30 is a solid number one. I will try to make a "Not Mariah Christmas And A Happy New Year List"
@@BackingTrackCenter Christmas is coming my friend and we will get plenty Mariah Carey and othher usual suspects to hear. Let us spread something completely different: The Not Marey Christmas Songs And Happy New Year List. This list is made to have more options those festive days. Just For Fun Or ..... Here we go:
01 Sparks - Christmas Without A Prayer
02 Gotcha - Da Ten Is Mightier Than Da Sword
03 Sabaton _ Christmas Truce
04 Fay Lovsky - Christmas Was A Friend Of Mine
05 Ramones - Merry Christmas (I Don't Want To Fight Tonight)
07 Tom Waits - Christmas Card From A H.........r In Minneapolis
08 The Pogues - Fairytale Of New York
09 Claw Boys Claw - Blue Bells
10 Run DMC - Christmas in Hollis
11 Lyric Noel - Carol Of The Bells
12 The Kinks - Father Christmas
13 Twisted Sister - Heavy Metal Christmas
14 Relient K - 12 Days Of Christmas
15 Dio - God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen Christmas Song
No time for me to do a proper ranking so I will give you special attention for my Dutch input: numbers 2, 4, and 9. I hope you have time to make a vid so the audience can have a variety of Christmas songs you will not hear that often. With making this list biggest surprise was for me number 11. You are free to add or remove songs from this list. I hope you will enjoy this list.
#1. I saw Momma kiss Santa Claus.
John Mellancamp.
Danny Serafine of Chicago was one of the best drummers of all time.
Not a mention of Hal Blaine??...played on more hits than anyone on this list (and maybe everyone on this list put together!)
Mitch Mitchell, Clem Burke, Ian Paice, Will Calhoun, Marky Ramone.
Dennis Chambers, Dave Weckl, Pat Mastelotto, Gavin Harrison, Thomas Lang, Virgil Donati, Nicko McBrain, Dave Lombardo, Alex Van Halen y un gran etcétera
@@manuelgodinez7591 ....conoces a Daryl Anderson, Jhon Anastasio,Derrick Willams, Andy Gómez, Peter Taylor, Billy Swanson, Derek Norris, Brian CASSIDY, Lindsay ' FOX' Cetera, Wen Harrison, Mick O' List...etc??.
Chambers, Wecki are not rock drummers
@@manuelgodinez7591 ninguno d estos que nombras son baterías....solo Van Halen...
@@jorgevillanuevaarocena2697 tienes razón, son futbolistas
@@manuelgodinez7591 no los conozco...ni como futbolistas....? Tocan música Clásica, Hip- hop'....,?. Ni idea....
Earl Palmer, Hal Blaine, Jim Keltner, Jim Gordon
The usual list with the most famous not the best...at least there is Ian Paice on It...
Good selection I aspire to all these guys except Dave grohl
Jimmy Degrasso and Ted McKenna both surely deserves an honourable mention, if not a place in the top 15.
Great comments and drummers.shoulda made it 20- 25? Barrimore barlowe, palmer, bernard purdie, phil collins, ansley dunsbarr.couple of my personal faves are, weird reasons.spencer dreydon, sammy piazza
Yeah, maybe 15 was too few for so much talent! Thanks for commenting!
Listen to Terry Bozzio playing The Black Page then re-write the list!
👍
Christian Vander.
Unique drummer, composer and vocalist. His style is a combination of jazz precise technique with rock energy.
Tatsuya Yoshida, great drummer, composer and band leader. Many projects, solo works and various collaborations...
Vander and Yoshida are excellent choices, no doubt! We will consider them for a future list. Thanks for your comment!
@Backing Track Center: I liked your list, other good drummers: Rob Reinner, Matt Sorum, Cozy Powell, Nick Mason, Nicko McBrain, John Densmore, Tommy Aldridge, Herman Rarebell, Clive Burr, james Cottak, and many more; Salutes.
I'm glad you enjoyed the list. I've noted your suggestions for future videos. Thank you very much and welcome to the channel!
Ian Paice n.1💜💜💜
why not Carl Palmer...???!!!
Carmine Appice
I knew who was in first place before watching the video. Matter of fact I knew that John Bonham was the best after have listened to Moby Dick, Rip John.
Definitely, "Moby Dick" is one of the greatest showcases of Bonham's drumming skills. And the way he improvised live was out of this world. Thanks for commenting!
Charlie Watts never needed a watch to keep time. The watch needed Charlie Watts.
Perfect!
Don’t forget to like, leave a comment, and share. Subscribe to our channel and consider becoming a member to gain early access to our content for a small fee. Just click on th-cam.com/channels/dDrgupSK6NYXtj3CBcfw_w.htmljoin
Hard to argue with this list, and I appreciate that you shared your methodology. Some will argue for days and days about deserving drummers who didn't make this list, but it says a lot about classic rock (and classic rock fans, I guess) that the list is comprised solely of white men, who are either British or American. The sole "diverse" drummer that I can see here is Neil Peart, who was Canadian.
I agree, it's hard not to notice the lack of diversity. Do you have any suggestions for a list that features more diverse musicians? Thank you very much for your comment and welcome to the channel.
Easy to argue this list.
Next time a list could be made of Rock's most influential unknown players like Al Jackson, Benny Benjamin, Tony Thompson, Clyde Stubblefield and so many more who nobody knows their name......
Excellent suggestion. Thanks!
@ Tony Thompson isn’t known?
No. You just named the drummers of your favorite bands, nothing more.
The selection method was objective, you can check the step-by-step process in the video description.
John Hiseman!!!!!!!!
Bonham. Just Bonham!
This must have been hard to compile this list. So many great drummers to choose from and rank. I couldn't of done it
It really was tough! Do you think we got it right, or would you change something? Thanks for commenting!
I would put Aynsley dunbar, cozy powell, Tommy aldridge, Carmine appice style of drummer in there a bit more.
The police really you got a few wrong
Hi. I voted 4 more times. Hopefully that will help in getting a great repensentaion of players from across time, and styles.
John Bonham!!!
B.J. Wilson !!
Great list! I would add Nick Menza and Steve 'Machine Gun' Smith as well 👍
I agree, Nick Menza and Steve Smith are amazing and made history. Have you heard Vital Tech Tones with Steve Smith, Scott Henderson and Victor Wooten? Thanks for commenting!
@@BackingTrackCenter I have not, but I will be picking that up. I have all of Steve's Vital Information releases, which are all excellent.
Man, you're gonna love this sound. Look for volume 1.
rick allen never gets any acknowledgement on these lists. he had to change everything to drum and he did it, like a beast. respect the gu who plays better than most, and one handed. ev xo
I completely agree. Rick Allen is one of the greatest!
Are you kidding??? All due respect to the band for their loyalty. But... He wasn't that good with two arms. He had a specialized drum kit made to accommodate his handi-cap. He lost his arm because of irresponsible behavior..and was never anything special. But again all due respect to the bands loyalty. That's that.
@ScottD768 somewhat agree. Top 15? Definitely not. But other top 50 or 100 list? I feel he should be included. My opinion only. Thanks for replying. Ev xo
Gavin Harrison
Tony Williams is a great drummer!
My favorite drummer is Nick Menza, of Megadeth
Ah, the great Levon Helm. (Just heard Garth passed away…now no one left living from The Band. 😭 Do yourselves a favor and watch “The Last Waltz” in tribute to The Band. We’re sadly losing the greats…the real musicians and bands from a bygone analog era.)
Mike Mangini, the man is totally astonishing, truly ambidextrous.
Ginger Baker is a JAZZ drummer!
@@RSMGsndchannel Cream is a jazz band ?
Ian Paice, Cozy Powell, Barrymore Barlow
Где Кози? Где Уорд? Где Палмер?!!!
Полная безответственная чушь!
Прочтите описание, там есть полное объяснение этого рейтинга.
@@BackingTrackCenterИнтересное дело, можно общаться на разных языках. До чего дошел прогресс!
Из уважения к нашей аудитории мы стараемся расшифровывать наши ответы на том языке, на котором нас спросили, с помощью Google Translate.
Neil Peart is number 1
Agree but no disrespect to Bonham
You got Stewart Copeland & Mitch Mitchell in the wrong places. They should be 1st & 2nd.
I can't take that list serious without Phil Rudd on it.
👍👍
Ringo Starr com certeza está entre os maiores bateristas do rock, mas não pode estar entre os melhores. Não tem como. Importância é uma coisa, habilidade técnica e criatividade é outra
The order of this list is criminal
👍
Number one I agreed ! Bonham is the goat indeed ! Greatest ever my Bonzo ❤
Frank Beard from ZZ Top is underrated. He mixes it up on most of their songs (except the last album).
But you remember something this is all subjective it is not in stone
👍👍
Alex van Halen..
At least Cesar Zuiderwijk had been listed, still a powerhouse these days at a age of 76.
These types of lists and comparisons are by definition a fool's errand. Take it for entertainment value, only. You might enjoy it.
👍
Buddy Rich?
No rich? Or krupa?
Buddy Rich was a great drummer, but he's more associated with jazz than rock, which is why he didn't make the list. Thanks for commenting!
Eric Carr was always underrated. Never taken seriously because he was in Kiss.