This reminds me of my grandfather. He was my hero. I dont have a very tight family, at least they never seemed to want to be, but he was my family. He taught me to work hard and be honest, to be a kind man. He died and I watched him go. This reminds me of my grandfather at the end.
This album is obscenely beautiful. Reminds me of the atmospheric washes of Fragile's (my favorite HALO) instrumentals. No attempt is made to try and create 'classics' or world changing material. It's all based in the moment; on subtlety and minimalism. Stunning.
Time is our only true enemy brother. It's the great divider; therefore, we must cherish every moment before it also consumes us. I like this N.I.N album , quite different
@@echoradiata "Ein Fehler in der Matrix. Oder eine Botschaft aus dem Jenseits." Sorry, idk how to translate since it's a quote from the series' early eps.
really remarkable how he can make the banjo sound so sad... and even that guitar in the end that sounds like one of those James Bond Themes to me totally fits in here love that piece of pure art so much thank you trent:)
I heard it last in 2015 and I’ve been looking for it since 2017. It was on a random playlist that doesn’t exist anymore so I had no idea where to look and I’ve been going through every other album possible until today when I found this playlist with all the ghost albums I’m so happy right now! Sorry 😂 I didn’t even remember what the song sounded like whatsoever! I just knew i would eventually find it if it wasn’t a fan made song that got taken down or something.
I find it interesting how Trent Reznor used a banjo and used it to give the song a goth goth sound. Usually a banjo is only ever used in country music. Trent Reznor is so creative.
I like to listen to this while walking through my neighborhood, pretending all the houses have been empty for years and I'm the last one left. Me and the stray cats. I like listening to this while petting cats too. :3
I see many interoperate this song differently. I’ll tell you my experience. You see I discovered NIN fairly recently. This year. There were many things that happened and I’ve gotten very bored. I would essentially binge NIN albums to get as much I could of the songs into my heart (I am still going). Some I liked more than others. That’s okay. Things like entertainment and music are subjective. I like the ghosts tracks. The new one and this one. Of all the songs 28 Ghosts IV is my personal favorite. And that’s comparing it to all the other top songs Trent made. At least to me. I would put it somewhere high in a list. Maybe with Reptile? Somewhat Damaged? 28 just has a calm tone throughout. It also feels more sorrowful as it goes along. But even by the end to me it feels like hope or salvation is there. Like as grey as things get, color is still there. And it always will be. Shifting along time.
Actually ...I cnt hear these types of music when m down..fact is these all music seems like having some surreal and melancholic vibes at the same time..very powerful
This reminds me of the beginning of thunderstorm when clouds are ready to burst... Dunno why I like to listen to Ghosts especially in spring. And of my beloved who texted me cuz I have Reznor in insta nickname. He was born on the 28th, and I'm on the 29th of September
To be honest, I've never completely listened to the Ghosts album in its entirety. There's a video on here with a compilation of Trent's best ambient music and heard this track on there. I knew it was from one of the Ghost's albums and I tracked this song down. Really good song. I really love it
This song reminds me of after you pass away and you're reviewing your life. Its innocent and light at first, but progresses into something increasingly dark and hopeless, until there is nothing.
Its the end of the world. I looked in the distance to see a man play his banjo. A man filled with sorrow but hope. I moved on, let him be, as I listened to the last sound I'd ever hear.
Art is what you make it, wether its a painting, just a scenery, sounds crunched together to make music, or even just a piece af trash lying around. art is different to everyone and beautiful to some, trent reznor certainly has a way to make these sounds come together into an symphony of noise. and in no way am i referring to the site. these volumes are definately an aquired taste and the taste is awesome!!!
Yes! Exactly! While I respect the 'classic' NIN rock music, it isn't really my scene. But I am in love with all of their instrumental work! The Ghosts albums, The Fragile: Deviations and all their movie soundtracks of course! It's so unique. It's all I listen to nowadays...I would kill to see a show like that XD
I see it as a calm before the storm type... i mean this sounds like a climax right before a "final battle".. its just my take on the song, anyway i love it
Reminds me of someone I know. A short journey from innocence, tainted early by obscene family, to a pubescence corrupted immediately by alcohol and drugs, then by meaningless sex forced upon her through intoxication by an older monster who didn't care. All of it culminated into a person who sees the corrupted nightmare that is her life as safe and normal. And I love her.
wow, it's like they've brought together The Boards of Canada and a bunch of classical instruments and made an amazing musical experience out of raw emotion. I love this.
its awesome when instruments that have been stereotyped as being married to a certain genre are used in places most wouldn;t think to look.would like to learn how to play banjo, but don't care for bluegrass...i live in NC usa so thats what everyone who knows how to play, plays. awesome track, one of my favs from ghosts i-iv
@champloo12345 Art is an expression. It can't be right or wrong. It's all how a person interprets it. I can draw a bad picture and it's art because someone may grab some emotion from it, even if the artist is the only one the art evoked emotion from. This all stems from, what is art? There are many different answers, but that was mine. It is an expression and if the person draws the crappiest picture I've ever saw, I guess they are an artist; they brought an expression on my face afterall.
In my drama class we're doing a project using this ghost. The story is a wife kills her drunken husband, except we present it backwards starting with the funeral, and it;s four seperate scenes ending with the actual murder.
This song makes me think that I'm being hunted in a bayou forest area by mad cultists with shotguns and pitchforks ! and I'm franticly running and vaulting over dead tree's ,rocks and stuff.
Used by Eddie Peugeot & Family (Eddie e Seus Peugeots) TV at post-match after tragical "Minerazzo" ten years ago after Germany scored 7-1 on Brazil at World Cup.
NiN has been a part of my whole life until this day, born in 83,I didn't know what I was to grow into, years down the line, I woke up one day thinking and knowing, I was an outcast. My best friend introduced me to this band when it was on an actual cassette tape, mind you.i first heard, the tape album, The Downward Spiral. Then I started to, I guess move into a different shell, and nin inspired me to yell at the "posers " ! Also to lead an artist like myself to greatness. I thank you for all the music and inspiration my friends.
@champloo12345 You dont need to force your own emotion on others. Thats not art imho. Art is showing people a different way to look at the world and letting them create their own emotions from it. I can see paint thrown against a canvas and realize its supposed to be the "artist" in anger but why should i care? Everyone gets angry. I have no connection to your anger. Show me a different way to look at the world or some beauty in everyday life and it sparks my mind and emotions.
Rez is brilliant I’m glad people stopped paying attention…more nails for the people who need them…it’s over the younger peoples heads anyway…you would have dad to have been there since pretty had machine my little darlings lol
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
This reminds me of my grandfather. He was my hero. I dont have a very tight family, at least they never seemed to want to be, but he was my family. He taught me to work hard and be honest, to be a kind man. He died and I watched him go. This reminds me of my grandfather at the end.
😭🙏🏻
Was only 3 when I seen my grandfather off I was the last person to see him
Thank you
Beautiful.
This reminds me of driving through the snow-covered woods at night with my uncle. I played this for him and he dug it instantly. Good times :-)
This album is obscenely beautiful. Reminds me of the atmospheric washes of Fragile's (my favorite HALO) instrumentals.
No attempt is made to try and create 'classics' or world changing material. It's all based in the moment; on subtlety and minimalism.
Stunning.
Your description was delightful brother.
Love
The end sequence makes me think of how time destroys everything, and eventually everything around you will have been consumed by it
This came out like years ago never heard it now I have gotta say it gives you some much emotion but that's just me
Time is our only true enemy brother. It's the great divider; therefore, we must cherish every moment before it also consumes us. I like this N.I.N album , quite different
funny to read this as the 2nd comment from top,just came here after watching season 2 finale of Dark
@@TOKRocK84 I just started watching! Crazy coincidences huh
@@echoradiata "Ein Fehler in der Matrix.
Oder eine Botschaft aus dem Jenseits."
Sorry, idk how to translate since it's a quote from the series' early eps.
really remarkable how he can make the banjo sound so sad...
and even that guitar in the end that sounds like one of those James Bond Themes to me totally fits in here
love that piece of pure art so much
thank you trent:)
Has always been one of my favourite pieces of music. Very hard to find something that matches the beauty of this.
That interesting because I get the opposite feeling, like someones reassuring me that it'll be alright when I know it's all over.
Just when I thought I’ve heard everything by NIN, I find this absolutely beautiful song I’ve never heard of.
I heard it last in 2015 and I’ve been looking for it since 2017. It was on a random playlist that doesn’t exist anymore so I had no idea where to look and I’ve been going through every other album possible until today when I found this playlist with all the ghost albums I’m so happy right now! Sorry 😂 I didn’t even remember what the song sounded like whatsoever! I just knew i would eventually find it if it wasn’t a fan made song that got taken down or something.
Same!!!!!
I find it interesting how Trent Reznor used a banjo and used it to give the song a goth goth sound. Usually a banjo is only ever used in country music. Trent Reznor is so creative.
I like to listen to this while walking through my neighborhood, pretending all the houses have been empty for years and I'm the last one left. Me and the stray cats.
I like listening to this while petting cats too. :3
Right now it would be a real possibility. 😮
Go to keys oklahoma then it'll be true
I love this comment
Damn 9 years ago this shit old
@@loungegod 10 years ago now damn
Atticus Ross is absolute genius 😭
This is my fave theme from the Ghost album it´s just...... pure art
I like the mood change throughout the song from the sadness to the melancholy to the hope and all the way back to the longing.
this song gave me shivers down my spine when I first heard it
:) love NIN
I see many interoperate this song differently. I’ll tell you my experience. You see I discovered NIN fairly recently. This year. There were many things that happened and I’ve gotten very bored. I would essentially binge NIN albums to get as much I could of the songs into my heart (I am still going). Some I liked more than others. That’s okay. Things like entertainment and music are subjective. I like the ghosts tracks. The new one and this one. Of all the songs 28 Ghosts IV is my personal favorite. And that’s comparing it to all the other top songs Trent made. At least to me. I would put it somewhere high in a list. Maybe with Reptile? Somewhat Damaged? 28 just has a calm tone throughout. It also feels more sorrowful as it goes along. But even by the end to me it feels like hope or salvation is there. Like as grey as things get, color is still there. And it always will be. Shifting along time.
Something same happening to me.i m binge listening to all the nin albums..it's either addictive or very subjectivity beautiful
Actually ...I cnt hear these types of music when m down..fact is these all music seems like having some surreal and melancholic vibes at the same time..very powerful
This reminds me of the beginning of thunderstorm when clouds are ready to burst... Dunno why I like to listen to Ghosts especially in spring.
And of my beloved who texted me cuz I have Reznor in insta nickname. He was born on the 28th, and I'm on the 29th of September
To be honest, I've never completely listened to the Ghosts album in its entirety. There's a video on here with a compilation of Trent's best ambient music and heard this track on there. I knew it was from one of the Ghost's albums and I tracked this song down. Really good song. I really love it
This song reminds me of after you pass away and you're reviewing your life. Its innocent and light at first, but progresses into something increasingly dark and hopeless, until there is nothing.
Damn. The buildup in the middle and then it drops back off... death
yeah i strongly remember the last time i passed away too
It's good to know that intuitive minds still exist in the internet space.
Its the end of the world. I looked in the distance to see a man play his banjo. A man filled with sorrow but hope. I moved on, let him be, as I listened to the last sound I'd ever hear.
Art is what you make it, wether its a painting, just a scenery, sounds crunched together to make music, or even just a piece af trash lying around.
art is different to everyone and beautiful to some, trent reznor certainly has a way to make these sounds come together into an symphony of noise. and in no way am i referring to the site.
these volumes are definately an aquired taste
and the taste is awesome!!!
Can we get a live show of the ghost albums? I don't need lyrics, just instrumentals, this would be amazing.
I’ve been hoping for ambient shows one day, soundtrack work included. I’d love that.
Yes! Exactly! While I respect the 'classic' NIN rock music, it isn't really my scene. But I am in love with all of their instrumental work! The Ghosts albums, The Fragile: Deviations and all their movie soundtracks of course! It's so unique. It's all I listen to nowadays...I would kill to see a show like that XD
Omg yes!!
I love this one. Amazing.
very beautiful and depressing song . Love it .
this is the song that help fills me depression... wait most of his music does... and the damn insomnia
The increasing tempo behind the guiter is just gives a feel that something is up but u cnt really decide
I see it as a calm before the storm type... i mean this sounds like a climax right before a "final battle".. its just my take on the song, anyway i love it
In my opinion, the most morose ghost without being directly creepy.
Fantastic in every way. One of the best off of Ghosts.
Reminds me of someone I know.
A short journey from innocence, tainted early by obscene family, to a pubescence corrupted immediately by alcohol and drugs, then by meaningless sex forced upon her through intoxication by an older monster who didn't care. All of it culminated into a person who sees the corrupted nightmare that is her life as safe and normal.
And I love her.
WinstRising Goddamn...
Oh...
The world can be so cruel at times.
You should be a writer.
This is such amazing music, I am a Baroque nut but damn this is the best of the modern era.
Love the drums
Such a beautiful and deep song. I absolutely love it.
A sad, foreboding, and creepy track
wow, it's like they've brought together The Boards of Canada and a bunch of classical instruments and made an amazing musical experience out of raw emotion. I love this.
Did Kanye sample this? I can’t shake the feeling he has
'Life is a joke'
I come to this specific video once a day, hear the song, read the words. I remember it, and then I go and meddle in.
Thank you for posting this
It makes me feel so hopefull. IDK way
yeah , i thought that was kinda silly also...i can definitely see the comparison between this & "hurt"
GOT TO BE MY FAVORITE.
its awesome when instruments that have been stereotyped as being married to a certain genre are used in places most wouldn;t think to look.would like to learn how to play banjo, but don't care for bluegrass...i live in NC usa so thats what everyone who knows how to play, plays. awesome track, one of my favs from ghosts i-iv
AkaruAbsolution your post made me laugh so hard. Thank you.
@champloo12345
Art is an expression. It can't be right or wrong. It's all how a person interprets it. I can draw a bad picture and it's art because someone may grab some emotion from it, even if the artist is the only one the art evoked emotion from. This all stems from, what is art? There are many different answers, but that was mine. It is an expression and if the person draws the crappiest picture I've ever saw, I guess they are an artist; they brought an expression on my face afterall.
In my drama class we're doing a project using this ghost. The story is a wife kills her drunken husband, except we present it backwards starting with the funeral, and it;s four seperate scenes ending with the actual murder.
Gives me a mix of Rimworld's OST and Halo's with NIN touch of course.
This song makes me think that I'm being hunted in a bayou forest area by mad cultists with shotguns and pitchforks ! and I'm franticly running and vaulting over dead tree's ,rocks and stuff.
Used by Eddie Peugeot & Family (Eddie e Seus Peugeots) TV at post-match after tragical "Minerazzo" ten years ago after Germany scored 7-1 on Brazil at World Cup.
one plus one equals three
Only way to prove that is to kill everyone who says it's two.
@@piercelyq sure I guess. *injects lethal dose of morphine to self
NiN has been a part of my whole life until this day, born in 83,I didn't know what I was to grow into, years down the line, I woke up one day thinking and knowing, I was an outcast. My best friend introduced me to this band when it was on an actual cassette tape, mind you.i first heard, the tape album, The Downward Spiral. Then I started to, I guess move into a different shell, and nin inspired me to yell at the "posers " ! Also to lead an artist like myself to greatness. I thank you for all the music and inspiration my friends.
@champloo12345 or the being that they are, and not what they became of the mind. That too my friend is art.
@champloo12345 How can a man make a beautiful picture, and, yet, not make art? Beauty isn't bland
Hillcrest. (somebody will notice)
Hillcrest.
1:22 to 1:55
Shiny.
yea well your one of the only people that do that (besides myself) most people want to compare it to downward spiral
yea.....on us
Sad piece here (maybe a good bye ending)
@champloo12345 You dont need to force your own emotion on others. Thats not art imho. Art is showing people a different way to look at the world and letting them create their own emotions from it. I can see paint thrown against a canvas and realize its supposed to be the "artist" in anger but why should i care? Everyone gets angry. I have no connection to your anger. Show me a different way to look at the world or some beauty in everyday life and it sparks my mind and emotions.
is that a banjo or ukelele? Ive never really recognized it before but thats a pretty familiar NIN sound.
You sir should write what you just said in poem form and submit it....
I'd like to see that, lol
@xBryanTechx whatever
Rez is brilliant I’m glad people stopped paying attention…more nails for the people who need them…it’s over the younger peoples heads anyway…you would have dad to have been there since pretty had machine my little darlings lol
Outer wilds anyone?
@vicquits So laugh.
The world is fucked
Is that a banjo?
Yea
I put words to this I call it alone. No one cares tho.
This reminds me of old town Road
Paul Kwame check out ghosts 34 lol
Old town road was remixed from sections of 28 34 and others...... the underpinnings of old town road IS ghosts
Thanks for the upload, but this is a really poor sound quality version
What is wrong with your videos? There is a sound glitch on the background..
I feel like Lil Nas X could make another big hit out of this one. I know they say lightning never strikes twice but why not?