People are saying Dog is better, but I'd like to put this in perspective. Let's say Dog makes it into the soundtrack but Cat doesn't. Everyone would be bored and used to Dog, so once they find Cat they'll like it more. And maybe for the same reasons to dislike it. I could imagine people saying stuff like "It's more chill than Dog. I like it more." But people are saying now "I like Dog more. It's less boring." I dunno. Just thought I'd point that out. Despite that people still might like Dog more, I just thought I'd put that out there.
This is bizarrely wonderful. When Dog comes in, I have this distant, fuzzy memory of it. I’ve heard it before, back when I was just a kid, playing Minecraft with my brothers on PS3. We used to play Music Discs while we built in creative mode, and Cat was my brother’s favorite. He would play it over and over, and in the meantime we would build and casually listen, just having fun. We never noticed that Dog was an extra track, it just sort of played in the background and subtly engraved itself in our minds. Hearing it is cathartic. Cat has always seemed too short to me, and now I know why. It really sucks that Mojang won’t be working with C418 anymore and is slowly removing his music in favor of Microsoft copyrighted content. This disc will never officially be whole again… and neither will my childhood.
I prefer cat because it's chilling but relaxing at the same time. Dog definitely sounds just as good. It's like scents, Strawberries smell sweet and so do lemons but yet they smell completely different. I wonder if that made sense.
Remember when the catdog song said "Alone in the world was a little catdog"? Maybe they made this song to reference the fact that steve is alone in the world
I recently got some studio headphones, and I was scrolling through songs to listen to like stuff by pink floyd and the doors , I am or would I say not a very emotional man but when I heard the beautiful synth buzz of cat I felt so idk how to put it into words magnified of attention and emotion when I heard this track the build up just had me imagining the memories of my life and space and just traveling through time and imagery of other lives and how they lived theirs from all the photographs, videos,experiences one human can even make up on their own. I felt waves and waves of comfort like if it was a drug an artifical substance of synthesized comfort but I take a good feeling knowing that human brain is capable of feeling how I felt we as humans should reflect that it is amazing to simply be alive. I have said what I wanted to say.
Nah tbh they should just add back the Easter egg of if you play the entire cat disc dog starts playing that too on ever platform not just console edition legacy
I remember when minecraft looked colorful and bright, then once it got to beta 1.8 it got a lot darker (which i liked) and then after that, the game just became....................yeah.
Onigiri-Sempai Minecraft today is still very fun to play, but (in my opinion) older versions are a lot funner and better. Especially the strange glitches. I don’t know why older versions seem more fun too me but it could be because they are simpler.
wow if you put it together (remix) it will seems to be more beautiful because those 2 disc is very simular to each other so what I think is remix is the best!! :)
hour ly On the console edition it's put in one music disk called "Cat". It sounds great together, and I don't know why they're even considered two separate songs. Honestly, C418 could've made the songs together and no one would be the wiser.
Nolan it’s a shitty and useless comment which is never funny and half the time doesn’t even make sense since they only comment about their experience, ignoring that some videos ACTUALLY WERE RELEVANT IN THE PAST
damn, that's 13 years ago, i thought it's just about 6 or 7 years ago, though i dont play the game at 2011 but i felt like i was, i felt nostalgic when i hear the ost music
I’ve grown to enjoy the fact that Minecraft grass no longer crunches aggressively when you walk on it, kinda like Steve got anger management and stopped stomping around as much.
For the longest time, I had no idea Dog even existed. I discovered it one day when I played Cat on a jukebox on the ps3 edition. Just as I was about to pop it out and play another, Dog started playing. Me and my friends just stood there dumbfounded, we had no idea that could happen.
My first time playing minecraft was at 5 years but then very quickly the pc/or minecraft got damaged by the pixelmon mod so i could play there, so i spend all my life in PS3 edition , man this hits me so hard
Jonathan Delgado this is the song cat, and unused song dog, which is cat with different instruments, combined. Cat is the song at the beginning, with dog being at the half way point.
cat - more calm and quiet, like cats usually are
dog - more playful and energetic, like dogs usually are
my cat crazy and my dog calm i think they are cag and dot
hey just like blue and pinke-
iqbaltrojan usually. key words
The opposite of my cats and dog.
@@iqbaltrojan D O T
In my opinion, both of the songs sound kinda incomplete without each other.
Thats why theyre in the same disc
@@goora1866 they're not on pc sadly i don't even know why, i mean the first version of Minecraft was on pc, i don't understand
@@91yugo77 actually the first Minecraft version was Xbox 360
@@AxeGuy2005 hmmm no. Minecraft was called cave game on pc in 2009 and the Xbox 360 version in 2012 so
so its not just me
This Is a perfect song for a Minecraft Movie ending song
yeah it is
Thank you for the idea. Might consider that.
You might get what you want!
welll.... not everything is lost. mojang will release a minecraft movie! lets just wait for mojang to give us what we've been asking
Alpha is a much better fit for that, give it a listen when you have a chance
Both are complement eachother, I always suspected that cat isn't "complete". And now, after 9 years, I've found dog :D
Legacy Version is the Best version ever
on console edition, you used to be able to play cat and also get dog on the same disc.
Yup
Amazing
Sigh I remember that
That’s actually still how it is on the Wii U edition
Yup, miss those days haha
People are saying Dog is better, but I'd like to put this in perspective. Let's say Dog makes it into the soundtrack but Cat doesn't. Everyone would be bored and used to Dog, so once they find Cat they'll like it more. And maybe for the same reasons to dislike it. I could imagine people saying stuff like "It's more chill than Dog. I like it more." But people are saying now "I like Dog more. It's less boring." I dunno. Just thought I'd point that out. Despite that people still might like Dog more, I just thought I'd put that out there.
Thank you for sharing.
I personally like how Cat is used in the beginning half of this mix as a calmer buildup for Dog, the more exciting second half.
True
I listened more to dog than i ever listened to cat and i honestly still think cat sucks compared to dog.
Dog is better
This is bizarrely wonderful. When Dog comes in, I have this distant, fuzzy memory of it. I’ve heard it before, back when I was just a kid, playing Minecraft with my brothers on PS3. We used to play Music Discs while we built in creative mode, and Cat was my brother’s favorite. He would play it over and over, and in the meantime we would build and casually listen, just having fun. We never noticed that Dog was an extra track, it just sort of played in the background and subtly engraved itself in our minds.
Hearing it is cathartic. Cat has always seemed too short to me, and now I know why.
It really sucks that Mojang won’t be working with C418 anymore and is slowly removing his music in favor of Microsoft copyrighted content.
This disc will never officially be whole again… and neither will my childhood.
[0:00 - (19) Cat / C418 Volume Alpha]
[3:06 - (20) Dog / C418 Volume Alpha]
I prefer cat because it's chilling but relaxing at the same time. Dog definitely sounds just as good. It's like scents, Strawberries smell sweet and so do lemons but yet they smell completely different. I wonder if that made sense.
Bonus: both the tracks and the fruits go well together
Amy cat preferers want plant extinction
This was how it was on the old console versions, and this is how it should be on Java & Bedrock
There is actually an Easter Egg where if you play the entire CAT disc, DOG starts playing.
I agree
there *is* that Easter Egg, but only in the console edition of Minecraft sadly QnQ
@@peanut1162 I WANT TO TRY IT OUT!
@@RockinRay-dp6zx oh I have a PS4 with legacy I did a long time ago
Only in legacy console
Just like I remember it. You can't have one without the other. Cat without Dog is like a tree without it's leaves. They need eachother.
Deciduous trees: ._.
winter: heh
Shame that they didn't keep the dog song with the cat song together, you would understand the song a bit more...
That's only on console btw.
If you are on xbox minecraft, they kept Dog on it. You just have to wait after cat. Dog isn't on any other version
@@amno1568 lie
Your name tells alot.
Bruh be like Bruh 😂
Remember when the catdog song said "Alone in the world was a little catdog"? Maybe they made this song to reference the fact that steve is alone in the world
Until Alex came along, which made them both buddies ^^^^^
it reminds me of smthing wonderful in my life. like a really sunny and cheerful day. the middle part and ending of dog is awesome and beautiful
I love this song, it takes me back to my multiplayer world on splitscreen ps3 with my brother and sisters.
I recently got some studio headphones, and I was scrolling through songs to listen to like stuff by pink floyd and the doors , I am or would I say not a very emotional man but when I heard the beautiful synth buzz of cat I felt so idk how to put it into words magnified of attention and emotion when I heard this track the build up just had me imagining the memories of my life and space and just traveling through time and imagery of other lives and how they lived theirs from all the photographs, videos,experiences one human can even make up on their own. I felt waves and waves of comfort like if it was a drug an artifical substance of synthesized comfort but I take a good feeling knowing that human brain is capable of feeling how I felt we as humans should reflect that it is amazing to simply be alive. I have said what I wanted to say.
yeah, something like that too!
petition to release dog as a separate music disc in all versions
it needs to be re-added to cat
@@Smubear yeah, Dog feels much better as an extension to cat. Dog is basically the beatdrop. I don’t know why they removed it
@@NeonBlueLight they complement each other too well
Sadly this will never happen.
send a message to mojang
bro mojang, just imagine, next 1.17 snapshot, "Added C418 - Dog as a music disc"
Nah tbh they should just add back the Easter egg of if you play the entire cat disc dog starts playing that too on ever platform not just console edition legacy
and we didnt
@@sarccacious and we probably never will
I like cats and dogs THESE ARE THE BEST MUSIC EVER AND THESE ARE ALWAYS STUCK IN MY HEAD
Agreed
walter
I like foxes cuz they're cats+dogs
i used to play a fair amount of console back in the day and never questioned why cat was missing an entire chunk after going back to pc
yeah its missing a entire area that 16 blocks on the x axis 256 blocks on the y axis and 16 blocks on the z axis
Wow! This background photo is very very Nostalgic!
Hello person guy
@@CrispyBlazin hello person guy
I remember when minecraft looked colorful and bright, then once it got to beta 1.8 it got a lot darker (which i liked) and then after that, the game just became....................yeah.
Why am i hearing pictures
Onigiri-Sempai Minecraft today is still very fun to play, but (in my opinion) older versions are a lot funner and better. Especially the strange glitches. I don’t know why older versions seem more fun too me but it could be because they are simpler.
this was the biggest hit of nostalgia I've had in 2020.
Ahh.. the old terrain, textures, and the music takes me back to simpler times
9 rabbits disliked
Don't forget 3 Chickens and 2 Sheep as well.
lol
3 squids want to dislike but don't have the rights to
And guardians, and I think fish? Idk any more updates after 1.8
*24
The cat is sleeping while the dog is running around the house chasing its tail.
Meow
-
Minecraft
-
Best game, ever.
-
5 years ago.... minecraft was amazing but today.....man wish Minecraft wasn't filled with kids...
A wise TH-cam commenter once said: You shouldn't let other people ruin your experience.
@@Squaredy now 7 years... Damn that's a lot of time... :(
@@habitualcrush Spanish its even WORSE
"TROLLING PEOPLE REEEE"
@Steven Lenz im leaving fornite and moving to Minecraft, wish me luck
Bro this vid is 11 year old and youtube just suddenly recommended it to me lol.
dog starts at 3:06
BluMango thanks
The Amazing World Of Jack I thought it was both
thank you
I listen to this every night before I sleep to cheer myself up about school
Wow this used to be my jam back when I played a lot of minecraft... that nostalgia from five or six years ago woah
The cat is peaceful and calm
The dog is energetic and motivational
Makes sense
wow if you put it together (remix) it will seems to be more beautiful because those 2 disc is very simular to each other so what I think is remix is the best!! :)
hour ly i aggree they make sences when there together 🙂
hour ly On the console edition it's put in one music disk called "Cat". It sounds great together, and I don't know why they're even considered two separate songs. Honestly, C418 could've made the songs together and no one would be the wiser.
th-cam.com/video/vd-WRT2v-Sc/w-d-xo.html
Cat: Has music more quiet, calm, and etc, like cats
Dog: More loud, energized, and etc, like Dogs
4:05 - the rest of the song fills me with a lot of nostalgia.
this music reminds me of 2010 really nostalgic when we were happy and we didn't know it
😭😭😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺
5:05 that part always remember me that in every note there's a clip of an amazing building
The memories
That picture fits perfectly with the music, for some reason.
The Og Minecraft Player Award goes to you on this community!!!
You is first
@@valdirvieira4660 Minecraft used to be a niche thing back in the day haha
@@TheDolphinTuna u r still active :O
@@randomlightstand Yup. Still addicted to TH-cam after all these years!
2011: No
2012: No
2013: No
2014: No
2016: Uh... No
2017: Yeah, but actually no.
2018: Nope
2019: Sure, why not?
U talking bout mine craft or... the song...?
@@starman41829 He's talking about youtube recommendations
Markquaad E ooh right
Shane Manzano we get it kid you’ve seen it too many times
Nolan it’s a shitty and useless comment which is never funny and half the time doesn’t even make sense since they only comment about their experience, ignoring that some videos ACTUALLY WERE RELEVANT IN THE PAST
That background is really nostalgic, reminds me of old minecraft wallpapers
damn, that's 13 years ago, i thought it's just about 6 or 7 years ago, though i dont play the game at 2011 but i felt like i was, i felt nostalgic when i hear the ost music
I always played Minecraft on my Wii U, and this is the version of cat that we listened to. I never knew it was a special remix.
0:00-3:05music cat
3:05-5:38music dog
4:48 why this part always gets me
I started with minecraft beta 1.7.3
Im missing old minecraft so much :(
Im missing the old sounds
now you can switch to old minecraft just search
I’ve grown to enjoy the fact that Minecraft grass no longer crunches aggressively when you walk on it, kinda like Steve got anger management and stopped stomping around as much.
@@RickyRiceB grrr dont step on me
-grass
Haha grass go *CLOMP CLUMPCHP CHUOMP*
dog. remix of cat
cat. standard
hmm i think that right
They both fit together perfectly
This is the way this song is meant to be listened. They should have kept Cat with Dog. Legacy Console Edition forever.
For the longest time, I had no idea Dog even existed. I discovered it one day when I played Cat on a jukebox on the ps3 edition. Just as I was about to pop it out and play another, Dog started playing. Me and my friends just stood there dumbfounded, we had no idea that could happen.
proably my number one favorite song of all time!
Those three notes that start the song back up at 3:55 is like a drop in dubstep.
Without one,the song would be more regular.
I love playing on my 360, and one of my favorite things is playing cat and hearing another song that I only hear on that version.
aahhh yes, the yin and yang of minecraft music discs.
That picture, was the first thing I saw of minecraft.
Hello my fellow minecraft veteran
Honestly, splitting these was as sick and cruel of a move as going to an orphanage and adopting 1 sibling but not the other
*so beautiful* 😭
SaturnThePlanet1248 ツ no you’re beautiful
You are the larger hula hooper ever
These two are some of Daniel’s best.
memories back in the xbox 360
This is suprisingly good
I usually played this disc on the tutorial world of Minecraft XBOX 360
I remember after school going to my friend's house to play Minecraft, we put this song and... bruh I'm 14 and I feel so old with this song
@Mr Brest at 8
Ahh... The old times i play Minecraft on My Xbox 360 and hear that song all the day ..
oh hey this the exact video i listened to 11 years ago
Seed?
Lemme guess, "Darude Sandstorm". -_-
Nooooo The world looked cool!
i remember most world looked like this in alpha
Yep. Good times. :)
it actually is Darude-Sandstorm
Omg, you are a legend.
Without perfect time, it sounds a bit different, but also it sounds good like Toby did with megalomania, Mojang u little _________
BUDDY
little buddy
even after 11 years, i still like this
ight, ima play it on replay while playing minecraft.
if you play it on replay, it infinitely loops for being reversed 0-0
Cat dog!!!!!!!
These discs along with 11 and 13 are my faves
i teared up when i heard the drop for cat, cat is just so much more nostalgic for me
>Implying that green text is not usable in a no green text place.
I remember dog in MCPE trailers and let's plays
Good ol' times
This is what I needed
The songs connect properly ingame
Theres something kinda sad about this. Bittersweet kinda sad like from mario galaxy
IT'S BACK
[MEOW-BARK]
Me-arf!
I KNEW I wasn't going crazy!
The disc WAS longer before!
Play this at my funeral. I don't care who or when, just do it. My dying wish.
This video was released 20 days before wolves came in the game, and 10 months before ocelots did so.
Holy shit
If dog and cat was diferent disc and not just the same disc whit a diferent version, it would be beatifull
this better be included in Steve's fighter pass
Cries in dungeon music
My first time playing minecraft was at 5 years but then very quickly the pc/or minecraft got damaged by the pixelmon mod so i could play there, so i spend all my life in PS3 edition , man this hits me so hard
I remember when I was like 7, I would be playing on creative mode in my world on Xbox 360 and I would keep replaying the cat song while building
Dog gave me a sense of nostalgia.
MY HEAAAAAAAART
I LOVED HERRRRRRRRR
2:04 dog melody can be heard
i love this music is very.....nostalgic sad and calm yeah is the best music of minecraft
Great Music
heavenly!
i like dog more it sounds cool
yeah both are goooood the cat has peaceful song and the dog has higher pitch
super zombie play lists same
super zombie play lists true
Ikiuia hello again
what does this have to do with CatDog?
Ba-Dum Tsss
Randomly Ryan And Excited Ethan it's used on console
CatDog is on console editions.
Jonathan Delgado this is the song cat, and unused song dog, which is cat with different instruments, combined. Cat is the song at the beginning, with dog being at the half way point.
Ba Dum Tssssh!
thank you
I like dog better because I barely knew it existed and it’s like a breath of fresh air
Cat... mesmerizing and relaxing, Dog... Enjoyable and energetic
i think dog is better beacuse completes cat and its more energic
Ah, gives me memories of when I didn't own an Xbox 360 yet and could only play Minecraft Lite when that was still around.
I used to play mc when i was 6 years old . I loved to play in my fathers ps4 and i always played this song when i was in creative mode
Oh Yeah Yeah lets bring those Nostalgic classic memorys before memes are famous i am right fellas ?
Yes
Maniffer this ain’t no meme. This is art
Why am I watching this 10 YEARS AFTER IT WAS UPLOADED
the nostaliga from playing music disk Cat on minecraft Wii U edition....