Fun episode, but I think Jack should've picked them rather than the blind format this time. It's such a personal preference thing, and he was definitely way more into some of the honorable mentions.
i was thinking the same thing! unlike usual YIAYs / jackasks / etc, this is completely different every time, and must be quite fun to look through, so i’m surprised he didn’t want to find them himself. however, i’m glad the honourable mentions section was so large as it allowed him to swap some out that he preferred.
Here's the thing: usually the ones Jack picks tend to be a combination of clever jokes and well made spooky submissions, while his honorable mentions are usually references he didn't get, really good drawing/Photoshop that he wanted to recognize, and the very scariest submissions. I feel like the council swapped it.
I agree with everyone saying that Jack should pick these himself, but I do like seeing him blind react to his favorite ones. Maybe a livestream of the selection process with an edited vod showing Jack’s best reactions, immediately followed by the usual calendar list and honorable mentions.
Seeing Jack be so proud of his Morshu impression, to the point where he does it in multiple videos, is probably one of the funniest things ever. (Not a diss, tho, that’s a good impression.)
Y’all, no disrespect to the council, but they dropped the ball on this one. The honorable mentions are all so much better than the chosen ones. This YIAY definitely doesn’t work with the blind format
The ALF lore ended with Alf getting abducted by the government while trying to escape earth. I’m not kidding, that’s how the show ended. So, yeah, it is entirely possible that Alf is dead and our taxes paid for his death.
I'm glad I'm not the only one that thought Jack should've made the picks. I feel so many of the picks were just picked for being generally good drawn fan art but a lot didn't have much for inside jokes or utilize the source image. The trashy memey photoshops are always my favorite.
@@justinfabela4899 I know it's a good movie, it's just that there's no context for the reference. Unless that line is a meme now or something, I don't know. In which case I guess you can just use it in any context because that's how memes work.
yeah the ones that were built off jack making decisions and doing something with them don't really translate well. luckily it seems he can veto them lol
I wish he wouldn't have done this one blind. Some of the challenge stuff is nice blind, but others I really miss him choosing which he loves. It's fun hearing why some get him so excited whether it's bc it's hilarious, smart, or just really impressive art to him.
I think a good way to do this yearly Yiays, and still have a bit of the blind format, is to have Jack choose the images used for the 31 days, and the Mods choose the Honorable Mentions
@@hellterminator what? thats the point, its better if he picks them all, but he wouldnt see the honorable mentions. therefore keeping some of the blind format. reread what they said.
@@apexkonchu2234 ? No he wouldn’t? Because he wouldn’t pick them, unless you’re implying he might have potentially previewed them while trying to find his favorite submissions
@@marcodiaz7199 That's exactly what I'm saying. He wouldn't know which ones the council picked, but he'd still have seen them all. Thus defeating the entire point of the blind format, since he wouldn't be seeing them for the first time in the video.
honestly, even though I prefer the blind yiays over the normal ones, I feel like the special yearly tradition ones should be left for jack to choose, some of the choices for this year's halloween just didn't seem that good imo, and a lot of the honorable mentions were better than the chosen submissions
@@glowstoneunknown Yep, kinda. I still think it should have been like that for all of them and not even present them as one for each day. But yeah, he must have done it to save time, more than to do the blind format.
On ALF lore, he didn't *officially* die at the end of the series, but the fact him getting murdered by the US government is the preferred ending to the series by fans then the actual ending should tell you everything you need to know about the ALF movie.
oh my god the way he perfectly replicated his own inflection from 2015 in that “hey guys, very excited about today’s video!” gave me CHILLS. he still remembers…
@@TheAlexSchmidt Actually, it's not creepy at all. You'd think it but it's not. And it's actually not pedophilia. It paints a very realistic, relatable portrayal of puberty and mental health and overall it's just a smart, witty show. Season 5 comes out on November 5th and I'm looking forward to seeing what the main characters get up to after Season 4.
@@hazardousfromage ...Do you even know what the show's based on and why they're making the themes about puberty and mental health? It's not just trying to be like South Park and that's it. If it did that alone then I too would brush it off as a generic adult cartoon, but it's not.
@@meetaverma8372 the problem is that this are the things the council likes and not jack, so the ones that are supposed to be a reference will loose all the meaning since jack mostly won't recognize them
@@bornofpixels i mean, they aren’t exactly wrong. in america at least, the right has completely politicized this disease, and because of that we are still one of countries hit the hardest by it to this day.
I don't envy the council but I think Jack knows what he likes and knows what his audience likes, as made evident during the honourable mentions section
Yeap. They should have made a 40-50 pre-selection and maybe a suggestion on some specific ones for specific dates but the final decision should be Jack's.
I think the council took "spook me up" literally, most of the picks are scary but i was only focus on the memes or some other funny/clever trending stuff
For the tour, since it’s close to the holidays, who would be down to sing the royalty free Christmas songs before the show and during the intermission?
Honestly, I feel like YIAY episodes like this one could be better if it wasn't blind. I know it's a ton of work picking out the submissions, and it's OK if this is still blind next year, but I feel the past years' spook me up episodes went with Jack's own narrative that he wanted, not the Creative Council's, and I feel the difference is visible. Still a great video, but that's just my two cents on it.
i think this is so one thing that shouldnt be done blind, i think the choices are better when jack chooses for this one... idk but i mean if mr john film is having fun then who cares
'I don't remember my own jokes...' But we do and your comedy is hard to come by and that's what keeps us watching ALL of your videos. You and Erin are treasures.
"I bet it's really well written" Yeah, he *definitely* hasn't seen Big Mouth. There are plenty of ways to describe it, "well written" isn't one of them.
Here's all the halloween Twitter profile pictures from the Honorable Mentions that Jack used to switch out from the selected 31 pics (in case you don't see them on Twitter): October 4th (Bojack Horseman): 14:13 October 10th (Morshu) : 18:08 October 11th (Glitch): 15:27 October 14th (Malignant): 17:03 October 21st (Berries and Cream): 13:55 October 23rd (THICC): 14:31 October 24th (Robot Chicken): 17:45 October 26th (Steve from Blue's Clues): 18:47
I like the funny/meme submissions much more than the actual "scary" ones. Like, visually they're impressive but they're just boring when there's a bunch of them.
i was a boy. they were 138 girls. can i make it any more obvious? thats right, i had a crazy dream last night. HAHAHAHAHA!!! im the funniest youtube star ever. youre welcome for laughing dear ben
There’s a very clear difference between jacks reactions to the honorable mentions and the actual 31. Guess this yiay isn’t really fit for the blind format
2:24 I don't think I've ever agreed with you more Jack, art styles for adult shows are so ugly "it's a shame" is really the kindest way to describe them
literally just switch the honorable mentions with the actual picks. i think the council prioritized generic (although well-made) fanart over the pop culture references and parodies this tradition is known for
Meh… The council tried to hard to pick “Cool” ones this year. THATS NEVER BEEN THE POINT OF THIS! The point has always been to choose the ones that are so bad they are good.
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞 (◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over TH-cam: This is fine Someone: Says "heck" TH-cam: Be gone #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞 (◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over TH-cam: This is fine Someone: Says "heck" TH-cam: Be gone #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
You know, I don't really like this blind format for the creation-based yiays. I want to see brilliant creations presented well by Jack, not Jack reacting to them
The council didn't really do a great job this time. Honorable mentions are way better than the actual 31 picked, since it's just pure memes. The art is good but picking half of it isn't really the spirit of YIAY. Lmao, I'm looking at this way too much.
@@kaitlinrenee7572 in the last year, Jack started doing most of his videos in a blind format. Before, he would select all the submissions. Now he has a council that compiles it all for him that allows him to see all the responses for the first time on camera. It makes less work for him and he has to come up with jokes and reactions on the spot. He has said in other videos that his creative energy was running out but once he adopted this blind format, he is more enjoying making videos again.
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞 (◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over TH-cam: This is fine Someone: Says "heck" TH-cam: Be gone #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
"I've never seen the show, I'll bet the show is extremely well-written" Yeah... you're not missing much. It's dogshit. Nothing but the same joke over and over again.
Im glad jack switched some around, there were a bit too many drawn ones, and of course they're incredibly well done, but the whole fun of it is to make jack look like a goofball trying to cosplay something terribly, not incredibly well drawn fanart
the amount of movies and shows that jack has never seen genuinely infuriates me, i hope whenever he says “idk i’ve never seen it” that he’s joking but i genuinely can’t tell
As much as I agree that a lot of the honorable mentions deserve to be in the 31 over others, it would feel shitty to see on a special annual video that you made the cut and then get taken off :/ really hope they get some of those mentions in their regardless
Ive been watching jack for years but always take like 6-8 month breaks and then catch up and doing this made me realize these have been getting less funny and more artsy and 'scary' each year
@Dylan Rodrigues yeah, its cause he just doesnt laugh at stuff anymore cause its not funny. I remember him genuinely laughing a lot during yiay episodes but this video felt like someone tried to lighten up the mood during a funeral
9:31 Yeah, I kinda had a little moment of disassociation a few weeks ago from the realization that it's been about a year since Among Us became popular. Like damn.
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞 (◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over TH-cam: This is fine Someone: Says "heck" TH-cam: Be gone #однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
Get your dang TOUR TIX so I can humiliate you onstage!! jacksfilmslive.com/
The big mouth one was something I never knew I needed
Thank u
A
Jack, I hope one day you can YIAY the UK.
#YIAYternational
forehead man
"Yes daddy." 💋
~ Dilldo Faggins
DAMN IT!!! I told you, on 2020, that I will make a BIG CHUNGUS... AND YOU PEEKED DAMN IT!!!
Lol
No wonder it was so cursed
E
eyyyy it scream man
YO ITS PELO! (Spooky dance) ITS SPOOKY MONTH!a
I respect the fact that Jack admitted he already saw Pelo’s submission.
Yay two spam bots in a row. My favorite.
@@Darvoth Your comment has been permanently tainted by the spam bots, you have been exiled to live in shame
E
@Laffy Taffy big Chungus
@@Darvoth this only happens to very early comments. pro tip: delete your comment after all the bots invaded, and then comment it again
I recognise that the Jacksfilms Council has made a decision. But given that it’s a stupid-ass decision, I’ve elected to ignore it.
@Boost_Java where's Jesse!
Boost_Java I WANNA SEEEEE ITTT what’s the link
@Boost_Java I thought you meant the dog for a second
Mass Effect be like
I understood that reference
Fun episode, but I think Jack should've picked them rather than the blind format this time. It's such a personal preference thing, and he was definitely way more into some of the honorable mentions.
Yeah, I think this shouldn't be treated as a regular YIAY. The point should be Jack choosing the choices, not his reaction.
Maybe a combination then? The council can sort through the fodder and make a shortlist and Jack can finalize it later.
Yeah sorry council you guys dropped the ball on this one
@@HamsterMaster8 The council did well, but as Maddi said, it's a personal preference thing.
i was thinking the same thing! unlike usual YIAYs / jackasks / etc, this is completely different every time, and must be quite fun to look through, so i’m surprised he didn’t want to find them himself. however, i’m glad the honourable mentions section was so large as it allowed him to swap some out that he preferred.
Here's the thing: usually the ones Jack picks tend to be a combination of clever jokes and well made spooky submissions, while his honorable mentions are usually references he didn't get, really good drawing/Photoshop that he wanted to recognize, and the very scariest submissions. I feel like the council swapped it.
I don’t know why but I read this in Ben Shapiro’s voice
@@blomp5374 I wish that wasn't the first time that the way I talk had been compared to Ben Shapiro's tone... I guess I got to work on my pretension
@@TheGreenhat2000 I think it's sometimes fine to come off as pretentious when you're saying something that's objectively right haha
@@bozuteru2160 a thing Ben Shapiro never is; right
@@bozuteru2160 Lmao sure, "right"
I agree with everyone saying that Jack should pick these himself, but I do like seeing him blind react to his favorite ones. Maybe a livestream of the selection process with an edited vod showing Jack’s best reactions, immediately followed by the usual calendar list and honorable mentions.
thats the perfect idea
That’s a great idea
Yeah
We need a clock behind Jack so we know how long he takes to come up with terrible jokes
this is the most underrated comment in youtube history 😂
Someone edit that into the picture.
Also how long he takes to get a joke
now I wanna see an full and non-edited episode of Yiay
th-cam.com/channels/r0vU3lx-9jyitxE9jVjpKQ.html
Seeing Jack be so proud of his Morshu impression, to the point where he does it in multiple videos, is probably one of the funniest things ever. (Not a diss, tho, that’s a good impression.)
Jack should be more proud of his work in general. Just don't tell him as he must stay firmly on (or rather below) the ground.
It feels like it’s his drunk party trick and I’m obsessed
lol
Y’all, no disrespect to the council, but they dropped the ball on this one. The honorable mentions are all so much better than the chosen ones. This YIAY definitely doesn’t work with the blind format
They picked that weird DeviantArt style for some reason
It's good tho
8 years of telling Jack his normal face is spooky enough
8 YEARS????
Joined 3 years ago
but you joined TH-cam in 2017
@@therandomidiotontheinternet yeah lol and he only has 5 comments on this channel
@@cinenaz I'm so glad I'm not the first person to check
The ALF lore ended with Alf getting abducted by the government while trying to escape earth. I’m not kidding, that’s how the show ended. So, yeah, it is entirely possible that Alf is dead and our taxes paid for his death.
E
And I turned him to Alf.
Worth it
Even worse is that it was supposed to be a two-parter but the network wouldn't even produce the actual intended ending.
That's not ENTIRELY true.
The real finale was actually the TV movie Project: Alf, which continued the story from the last episode.
Jack at most of the ones the council chose: “I’ve never seen this”
Jack during honourable mentions: I LOVE THIS
Jack talking about Big Mouth: I'm sure it's a great Show.
Narrator: It isn't
jack: im sure it was well written
narrator: *hysterical laughter*
I thought the main kid looked like JacksFilms when I watched it.
It pisses me off that the Wikipedia channel for it mentions NOTHING negative about it, especially the art style.
@@EojinsReviews I mean the company who made the show writes the wikipedia, of course the company who made it would write good stuff about it
Anytime I read a narrator comment, I always read it in Morgan freeman voice
The more you know, he actually does say "Think Mark, think" in the comics.
E
@@EEEEEEEE True.
"You thought this was a misquote, but you didn't check the comics! Think, Mark, think!"
I'm glad I'm not the only one that thought Jack should've made the picks. I feel so many of the picks were just picked for being generally good drawn fan art but a lot didn't have much for inside jokes or utilize the source image. The trashy memey photoshops are always my favorite.
It has got to feel amazing to be in honourable mentions and hear Jack essentially say, "come, this is no place to die."
Infinity War reference why?
@@calebmurphy9406 cause its a good movie. i didnt even recognize the reference till i saw your comment lol. thanks habibi
@@justinfabela4899 I know it's a good movie, it's just that there's no context for the reference. Unless that line is a meme now or something, I don't know. In which case I guess you can just use it in any context because that's how memes work.
@@calebmurphy9406 Yeah i get you. Im just being dumb
@@calebmurphy9406 it's been a meme for a couple years, it's got experience.
I gotta be honest, this is a rare yiay that suffered from being in the blind format
yeah the ones that were built off jack making decisions and doing something with them don't really translate well. luckily it seems he can veto them lol
Agreed
Yea I felt like a lot of these werent nearly as good as last year
I wish he wouldn't have done this one blind. Some of the challenge stuff is nice blind, but others I really miss him choosing which he loves. It's fun hearing why some get him so excited whether it's bc it's hilarious, smart, or just really impressive art to him.
I think a good way to do this yearly Yiays, and still have a bit of the blind format, is to have Jack choose the images used for the 31 days, and the Mods choose the Honorable Mentions
But then he would have seen them, he just wouldn't know which ones they picked.
@@hellterminator what? thats the point, its better if he picks them all, but he wouldnt see the honorable mentions. therefore keeping some of the blind format. reread what they said.
@@iimdone He would still have seen the honourable mentions, because he'd have looked through them all while picking the top 31.
@@apexkonchu2234 ? No he wouldn’t? Because he wouldn’t pick them, unless you’re implying he might have potentially previewed them while trying to find his favorite submissions
@@marcodiaz7199 That's exactly what I'm saying. He wouldn't know which ones the council picked, but he'd still have seen them all. Thus defeating the entire point of the blind format, since he wouldn't be seeing them for the first time in the video.
Jack “I don’t drink red wine”
Jack’s podcast art: am I a joke to you?
Noticed that too
It's blood
I was looking for this comment
the fact that jack has NEVER seen the 21 vine before is both absolutely incredible and sad
honestly, even though I prefer the blind yiays over the normal ones, I feel like the special yearly tradition ones should be left for jack to choose, some of the choices for this year's halloween just didn't seem that good imo, and a lot of the honorable mentions were better than the chosen submissions
Especially since Jack still seemed to really enjoy making the tradition ones, as appose to standard yiays.
Absolutely Agree, he didnt even get quite a few of the top 31 because theyre not really HIS kind of humor
I feel like in the future jack should pick the pictures himself, mainly because it makes it feel more like a competition of sorts.
he did that in the past tho, for like 5 years, it's nice to see his genuine first reactions to them
He's too lazy to go back.
@@glowstoneunknown He can still do first reactions to a 40-50 pre-selection but decide which ones get featured himself
@@92brunod well he kinda did that anyway regardless, he swapped a couple of the honourable mentions out to actually use them
@@glowstoneunknown Yep, kinda. I still think it should have been like that for all of them and not even present them as one for each day. But yeah, he must have done it to save time, more than to do the blind format.
On ALF lore, he didn't *officially* die at the end of the series, but the fact him getting murdered by the US government is the preferred ending to the series by fans then the actual ending should tell you everything you need to know about the ALF movie.
Ah what? I was born in 1999 and ever Alf thing scared me... a what!?
What in the fresh hell is this???
what
oh my god the way he perfectly replicated his own inflection from 2015 in that “hey guys, very excited about today’s video!” gave me CHILLS. he still remembers…
E
How could he ever forget?
Man, you got foot lettuce too?
Jacksfilms does a great impression of Jacksfilms.
Which one was that specifically?
Jack also not liking the terrible art style for adult cartoons, brings me more joy then I can express.
I think Big Mouth at least is supposed to be ugly since otherwise it'd be pretty creepy (so I've heard, I haven't really watched it)
@@TheAlexSchmidt Actually, it's not creepy at all. You'd think it but it's not. And it's actually not pedophilia. It paints a very realistic, relatable portrayal of puberty and mental health and overall it's just a smart, witty show. Season 5 comes out on November 5th and I'm looking forward to seeing what the main characters get up to after Season 4.
@@monkshoodpsychosis it’s the worst show I’ve ever watched. They want to be like South Park but the writing staff are far inferior
Must be pretty funny knowing you got a dislike on a TH-cam comment from a fan who will defend Big Mouth til the day she dies
@@hazardousfromage ...Do you even know what the show's based on and why they're making the themes about puberty and mental health? It's not just trying to be like South Park and that's it. If it did that alone then I too would brush it off as a generic adult cartoon, but it's not.
Yeah, never let the council pick the Halloween submissions again 😬😬
These are actually scary though
@@meetaverma8372 the problem is that this are the things the council likes and not jack, so the ones that are supposed to be a reference will loose all the meaning since jack mostly won't recognize them
Whenever jack gets an answer from pelo he's like a little kid on Christmas.
@let's watch ! oh fuggin knob off will ya?
@@themr.foster6118 bri ish
@@themr.foster6118 amazing insult
E
F
replacing the big mouth one with the bojack horseman one is definitely the way to go
I sense anxiety in everyone from the main 31, knowing that one of them is getting replaced
A few actually from the sound of it 😅
jack's prediction about among us only lasting a month is strangely similar to everyone's predictions of the pandemic
And everyone's prediction about among us.
i mean if it wasn't sensationalized by political media...
@@bawbehh Congrats, you ruined the entire comment
@@bornofpixels i mean, they aren’t exactly wrong. in america at least, the right has completely politicized this disease, and because of that we are still one of countries hit the hardest by it to this day.
There is no such thing as a coincidence
I don't envy the council but I think Jack knows what he likes and knows what his audience likes, as made evident during the honourable mentions section
Yeah, the council has been great, but for this particular video it's not the same.
Yeap. They should have made a 40-50 pre-selection and maybe a suggestion on some specific ones for specific dates but the final decision should be Jack's.
I think the council took "spook me up" literally, most of the picks are scary but i was only focus on the memes or some other funny/clever trending stuff
For the tour, since it’s close to the holidays, who would be down to sing the royalty free Christmas songs before the show and during the intermission?
Love this idea
E
@@EEEEEEEEE
@@jacksfilms jacksfilm we love you come to brazil
Hell yeah, jingle my bells baby
Jack: (Laughs at every Big Chungus joke)
Also Jack: "This is the only good Big Chungus joke."
it's meant to be "in just 4 words"
Council, I just wanted to say that picking Big Mouth Jack over BoJacksfilms is the worst decision you've ever made.
YA
Honestly, I feel like YIAY episodes like this one could be better if it wasn't blind. I know it's a ton of work picking out the submissions, and it's OK if this is still blind next year, but I feel the past years' spook me up episodes went with Jack's own narrative that he wanted, not the Creative Council's, and I feel the difference is visible. Still a great video, but that's just my two cents on it.
Yup, i feel the same, this one shouldn't have been blind, he ended up liking 2 of them in the honorable mentions
I wholeheartedly agree, I kinda miss the scripted format sometimes
I fully agree
someone tell the council not to approve literally every drawing submitted
I think it should have been blind but jack gets to decide which one goes with which day
If only the “I Thlammed my Penith in the car door” meme hadn’t died out as quickly as it did.
I’m totally bribing the council next time.
Wait that meme died already? I'm still watching tons of vids of it lmao
@@RatOfTheWoods It kinda morphed into the Batman + Parappa meme, but I don't know if it's "dead" necessarily.
Correction Jack: He does say “Think, Mark, Think” in the comics it’s the the show that misquoted him
Counterpoint: people are quoting the show which is where the screenshot was from
i think this is so one thing that shouldnt be done blind, i think the choices are better when jack chooses for this one... idk but i mean if mr john film is having fun then who cares
Holy crap lois it's Roy Koopa from Super Mario Bros 3
The council put in too many gore photos where jack just likes the memes
Yep. Exactly.
And still chose the Big Mouth one
This is the only thing of the regular series that should 100% not be blind
The honourable mentions were so much better than the actual picks
ouch XD
@@cintaloren7472 bruh go away
Yep. Death to the council.
They always are💀 it's been like that for for a few years now
I have to agree
'I don't remember my own jokes...'
But we do and your comedy is hard to come by and that's what keeps us watching ALL of your videos. You and Erin are treasures.
E
Well Erin is anyway.
“I am a sucker and a simp, and a cuck, for the warioware games” never something thought i’d hear, i love it thanks :)
Jack just Vetoing the councils choices is way too funny to me
"I bet it's really well written" Yeah, he *definitely* hasn't seen Big Mouth. There are plenty of ways to describe it, "well written" isn't one of them.
Here's all the halloween Twitter profile pictures from the Honorable Mentions that Jack used to switch out from the selected 31 pics (in case you don't see them on Twitter):
October 4th (Bojack Horseman): 14:13
October 10th (Morshu) : 18:08
October 11th (Glitch): 15:27
October 14th (Malignant): 17:03
October 21st (Berries and Cream): 13:55
October 23rd (THICC): 14:31
October 24th (Robot Chicken): 17:45
October 26th (Steve from Blue's Clues): 18:47
The Morshu impression was unironically great
E
@@cintaloren7472 WHY NO PLEASE
Next time the council should choose a top 50 and jack chooses the top 31 at the end
E
Or maybe the honourable mentions somehow
18:20 that's actually an amazing impression
I like the funny/meme submissions much more than the actual "scary" ones. Like, visually they're impressive but they're just boring when there's a bunch of them.
Yeah absolutely
Yeah it feels more like it should be a bunch of references than not-really-scary stuff
Yeah usually jack judt has the last 3 or 4 be creepy
This has the same energy as opening tens of Christmas presents that you don't want.
Have these editors not seen the past videos in the series? Literally so many of the honorable mentions should’ve just been top picks
Can't believe we missed "Squid Game" Jack by just a tiny bit
i was a boy. they were 138 girls. can i make it any more obvious? thats right, i had a crazy dream last night. HAHAHAHAHA!!! im the funniest youtube star ever. youre welcome for laughing dear ben
E
@@EEEEEEEE Can’t believe someone would say something so controversial yet so true, hats off to you brave soldier!
@@EEEEEEEE someone needs to make a bot that just replies this under every comment..would be better than the..other ones anyway
@@cintaloren7472 oh no the bots are becoming self aware..... whatever its a good point i cant be mad
There’s a very clear difference between jacks reactions to the honorable mentions and the actual 31. Guess this yiay isn’t really fit for the blind format
2:24 I don't think I've ever agreed with you more Jack, art styles for adult shows are so ugly "it's a shame" is really the kindest way to describe them
That Morshu impression was too good for us.
We don't deserve this Jack, you're wasting your talents on the little people.
literally just switch the honorable mentions with the actual picks. i think the council prioritized generic (although well-made) fanart over the pop culture references and parodies this tradition is known for
all the submissions are great. i wish i could create art that good, but i hate when the tradition’s broken, damnit! lol
While I think YIAY in general is great blind, I think this in particular worked better when you pick the answers yourself
Imagine getting in the 31 slots and jacks just like, i like this one better
This is the second time Jack has done the ENTIRE Morshu bit on a YIAY
Whens the first time?
Yeah whens the first time
Meh…
The council tried to hard to pick “Cool” ones this year.
THATS NEVER BEEN THE POINT OF THIS!
The point has always been to choose the ones that are so bad they are good.
The joy I get every year from seeing spook me up in my notifications is priceless.
E
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞
(◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over
TH-cam: This is fine
Someone: Says "heck"
TH-cam: Be gone
#однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞
(◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over
TH-cam: This is fine
Someone: Says "heck"
TH-cam: Be gone
#однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
You know, I don't really like this blind format for the creation-based yiays. I want to see brilliant creations presented well by Jack, not Jack reacting to them
This!
I feel like there should be a mix of council and Jack. like Jack chooses 40+ and the council chooses the top 31 *_IN_* those 40.
I don't think the surprise format was the right call for this tbh
Ok, but that Morshu one totally deserved a spot on the 31.
I always love watching to see which one falls on my birthday. Truly the best part of having an October birthday
I’m surprised at the lack of Squid Game submissions
The council didn't really do a great job this time. Honorable mentions are way better than the actual 31 picked, since it's just pure memes. The art is good but picking half of it isn't really the spirit of YIAY. Lmao, I'm looking at this way too much.
What is the council? I’ve not watched jack in a while but this video is a yearly tradition for me and I’m very confused lol
@@kaitlinrenee7572 in the last year, Jack started doing most of his videos in a blind format. Before, he would select all the submissions. Now he has a council that compiles it all for him that allows him to see all the responses for the first time on camera. It makes less work for him and he has to come up with jokes and reactions on the spot. He has said in other videos that his creative energy was running out but once he adopted this blind format, he is more enjoying making videos again.
@@kaitlinrenee7572 also the council is a group of discord mods iirc
@@paigebrown438 okay thanks!
@@slaphand9578 ah okay thanks’
Jack said he got rid of his wife and chip, however the indicator showed they were just injured. THEY GOT AWAY ALIVE. Thank the heavens.
the "we have a tradition" line at the beginning makes me extremely happy
I think the problem is that the council chose way too much of the actuall creepy ones, instead of mixing more of the ironic/funny ones
Exactly this!
Honestly i dont think spook me up fits the blind format. jack picking the answers seems more important when everything is so referential.
the blind YIAYs are cool, but I don't think they work well for the more artsy ones like this one
Jack getting hyped for Pelo's answer warms my cold, dead heart.
A true Jacksfilms fan would know that you should censor the knees, not the foot
only us biches are burdened with this knowledge 😔😔😔
good thing they didnt censor the earlobes 😩😩😩
the "become as dogs" one is genius, and the council is cultureless for not recognizing that lmao
E
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞
(◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over
TH-cam: This is fine
Someone: Says "heck"
TH-cam: Be gone
#однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
Lmao thanks
@@cintaloren7472 Silence, bot
*"Hey guys really excited about me in this corner"* KILLED me
A lot of the honorable mentiond are better than the ones picked
I definitely agree. I dont feel the council really understood what made the past years' picks so great.
YOOO WE GOT THE SAME PFP
@@CharzBoi nice
"I've never seen the show, I'll bet the show is extremely well-written"
Yeah... you're not missing much. It's dogshit. Nothing but the same joke over and over again.
How does that show get a certified 100% every season and end up with a billion seasons is beyond me.
17:34 ngl this do be givin me DHMIS vibes haha 😂👀😳💀
I have an idea, the creative council picks a bunch of profiles, and Jack picks his favorites during the video.
I had the same thought, i think that's the best way
3:00 how ironic, he actually says "Think mark, think" in the comics
Im glad jack switched some around, there were a bit too many drawn ones, and of course they're incredibly well done, but the whole fun of it is to make jack look like a goofball trying to cosplay something terribly, not incredibly well drawn fanart
you have destroyed my heart and soul in three seconds at 18:44, well done sir
the amount of movies and shows that jack has never seen genuinely infuriates me, i hope whenever he says “idk i’ve never seen it” that he’s joking but i genuinely can’t tell
Yeah he's really missing out on Big Head
I get so excited to do this every year and then always forget and miss the deadline
"Bringing YIAY to you".
Literally none of the cities are near me.
👍
It's not even in a country near me.
@@satisacro
Sucks for you.
@@satisacro Not even a continent near me
He wasn’t talking about the tour. He’s right behind you. Run.
I think maybe next year have the council pick out like 40 or 50 pictures and then jack chooses what ones he will use
It's so great to see jack excited for a submission made by pelo, pelo is a great guy and deserves the excitement and hype he got
As much as I agree that a lot of the honorable mentions deserve to be in the 31 over others, it would feel shitty to see on a special annual video that you made the cut and then get taken off :/ really hope they get some of those mentions in their regardless
Ive been watching jack for years but always take like 6-8 month breaks and then catch up and doing this made me realize these have been getting less funny and more artsy and 'scary' each year
@Dylan Rodrigues yeah, its cause he just doesnt laugh at stuff anymore cause its not funny. I remember him genuinely laughing a lot during yiay episodes but this video felt like someone tried to lighten up the mood during a funeral
The hello Peter one was perfect omg
9:31 Yeah, I kinda had a little moment of disassociation a few weeks ago from the realization that it's been about a year since Among Us became popular. Like damn.
6:37 "decide"
Sure Jack, sure
Jack has confirmed he’ll shave his head at some point
E
AISURU.TOKYO/piit?[Have-Sex]💞
(◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*18 years and over
TH-cam: This is fine
Someone: Says "heck"
TH-cam: Be gone
#однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
Jack's Morshu was the most beautiful thing I've ever heard.