Mood... But at the same time: One day, it will work. The Zapatistas and Rojava still stand to this day, and anarchist thought is on the rise again. Mutual aid is becoming more and more commonplace, despite the damage neoliberalism and alienation have done. We have much ahead of us still - a lot of it awful, I will not lie. But we can't afford to give up hope. And in the worst case scenario? We shall rage against the dying of the light, and never go gentle into that good night. We're anarchists: Resistance is what we're best at. Makhno's legacy, that of both his successes and his failures, is ours to claim and draw lessons from.
@@kvanc1423 Rojava, or the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria is a Democratic Confederation in Northeast Syria. Its ideology, Democratic Confederalism, took heavy inspiration from and still draws upon Anarcho-Communism and libertarian socialism.
@@Theotok0s They effectively are, although they reject all labels other than neozapatist, their society is organized in line with anarchist ideology and neozapatismo takes heavy inspiration from libertarian socialism and anarchism
@@EugeneVDebs-bt5pd Thank you for taking the words out of my mouth lol. Yeah, this exactly. While not explicitly anarchist, I'd certainly classify them as left-libertarian and anarchist-adjacent at bare minimum.
This is not about the fact that Makhno let someone down, but about the fact that, due to the invasion of the Bolsheviks, it was not possible to build Anarchy.
@@somerandommen yea, but others except Makhno are cringe statists that disquised with communist title . We , the people saw how their "Proletarian Dictatorship" worked
Actually I amend my previous comment, I made it without thinking. Makno was a Communist. The Marxist-Leninists you mentioned were just State-Capitalist grifters who exploited the desperation of the workers for easy power.
@@somerandommen those words can mean a lot of different things depending on who you ask. Socialist can mean either any radical leftist, just marxists or just soc-dems Communist can be any one who strives for a communal society, although the term is usually just applied to marxist-leninists of the stalinist variety.
@@tabryis I tried that years ago and all it did was make me a victim, we ain't gotta massacre em just cripple their power so they can't betray us once we win
It wasn't really a backstab considering the Leninists and Makhnovites were never allied or even friendly towards each other in the first place. Yes, they cooperated on occasion but only because both of them considered the Whites to be the bigger threat. It was always clear that these two Ideologies were destined to clash with each other once the other Players in the Russian Civil War were eliminated.
@@tabryis Dude making light of my shit has been my coping mechanism since I was a teenager don't worry bout it Good news tho I got health insurance in febuary so I'm gonna get therapy Soon
For roman alphabet users here are the lyrics : Chorna vorozhka, Chorna vorozhka Krasno hadala. Bilo-chervonu, Bilo-chervonu Strichku splitala. Chorus: A u Hulyaypoli, A u Hulyaypoli, Svityatʹsya vyshni. Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Chomu tak vyyshlo?.. Nestor Ivanovych, Yak Vy poviryly V kazku pro shchastya, Yak Vam namiryaly, Yak Vam vidmiryaly Z chornoyi masti. Chorus Ponad zirnytsi, Ponad zirnytsi Koni halopom. Khloptsi bochantsi, Khloptsi vorpivtsi Pid perekopom. Chorus Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych Chom taka dolya, Shcho obnyala Vas Zemlya Paryzha - Ne Hulyaypolya. Chorus Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Chomu ne vyyshlo?
Чорна ворожка, Чорна ворожка Красно гадала. Біло-червону, Біло-червону Стрічку сплітала. Приспів: А у Гуляйполі, А у Гуляйполі, Світяться вишні. Нестор Іванович, Нестор Іванович, Чому так вийшло?.. Нестор Іванович, Як Ви повірили В казку про щастя, Як Вам наміряли, Як Вам відміряли З чорної масті. Приспів Понад зірниці, Понад зірниці Коні галопом. Хлопці бочанці, Хлопці ворпівці Під перекопом. Приспів Нестор Іванович, Нестор Іванович Чом така доля, Що обняла Вас Земля Парижа - Не Гуляйполя. Приспів Нестор Іванович, Нестор Іванович, Чому не вийшло?
Анархо-думер-вейв.
We will rise again!
I hope
neva eva dont change my nigı
remember karl marx maked bakunin speechleess
Душевно мужик поёт
Mood... But at the same time: One day, it will work. The Zapatistas and Rojava still stand to this day, and anarchist thought is on the rise again. Mutual aid is becoming more and more commonplace, despite the damage neoliberalism and alienation have done. We have much ahead of us still - a lot of it awful, I will not lie. But we can't afford to give up hope.
And in the worst case scenario? We shall rage against the dying of the light, and never go gentle into that good night. We're anarchists: Resistance is what we're best at. Makhno's legacy, that of both his successes and his failures, is ours to claim and draw lessons from.
rojava?
@@kvanc1423 Rojava, or the Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria is a Democratic Confederation in Northeast Syria. Its ideology, Democratic Confederalism, took heavy inspiration from and still draws upon Anarcho-Communism and libertarian socialism.
Zapatistas arent Anarchist
@@Theotok0s They effectively are, although they reject all labels other than neozapatist, their society is organized in line with anarchist ideology and neozapatismo takes heavy inspiration from libertarian socialism and anarchism
@@EugeneVDebs-bt5pd Thank you for taking the words out of my mouth lol. Yeah, this exactly. While not explicitly anarchist, I'd certainly classify them as left-libertarian and anarchist-adjacent at bare minimum.
Communist music: glorifying Che Guevara, Stalin and Mao
Anarchist music: *"why did you fail us, Makhno-senpai?"*
This is not about the fact that Makhno let someone down, but about the fact that, due to the invasion of the Bolsheviks, it was not possible to build Anarchy.
Both are Communist tho?
@@somerandommen yea, but others except Makhno are cringe statists that disquised with communist title . We , the people saw how their "Proletarian Dictatorship" worked
Actually I amend my previous comment, I made it without thinking. Makno was a Communist. The Marxist-Leninists you mentioned were just State-Capitalist grifters who exploited the desperation of the workers for easy power.
@@somerandommen those words can mean a lot of different things depending on who you ask.
Socialist can mean either any radical leftist, just marxists or just soc-dems
Communist can be any one who strives for a communal society, although the term is usually just applied to marxist-leninists of the stalinist variety.
Слава нестора махно!!!
>Махно
>Украинская Империя
>ладно...
>Махно
>империя
Что то не так?
@@user-kn6ed8zt4k махновщина - это анархо-коммунистическое движение, её невозможно связать с империей. Прочитай определение.
@@ancom9692 щас поменяю название украинская махновская республика
Уахахаха картинка в тему 🏴☠️🏴🖤
It did work across the Free Territories, then Makhno got backstabbed. In hindsight the red should never have been trusted.
Gotta do em the other way around once we get the fascists and libs outta the way
@@Mae_Dastardly that would make us the same as them. have some principles and dont become the monster they tried turning you into
@@tabryis I tried that years ago and all it did was make me a victim, we ain't gotta massacre em just cripple their power so they can't betray us once we win
It wasn't really a backstab considering the Leninists and Makhnovites were never allied or even friendly towards each other in the first place. Yes, they cooperated on occasion but only because both of them considered the Whites to be the bigger threat. It was always clear that these two Ideologies were destined to clash with each other once the other Players in the Russian Civil War were eliminated.
Id like to think that Ukrainians are listening to this right now.
friendly fire: on
Full solidarity to the Ukrainian peoples in this time of turmoil for them. Let's hope history won't repeat
🌻🇺🇦🌻🇺🇦🌻🇺🇦
to hell with the Kremlin
@@rebelgosha14Z8 ?
Mother anarchys love wasen't enough
Wow just like my real mother!
Oh wait she didn't have any
@@Mae_Dastardly yikes
@@aproppaknoife5078 c: I am a happy and well adjusted adult
@@Mae_Dastardly seek therapy and stop making light of your serious trauma.
@@tabryis Dude making light of my shit has been my coping mechanism since I was a teenager don't worry bout it
Good news tho I got health insurance in febuary so I'm gonna get therapy Soon
Nice.
Нестор Іванович чому не вийшло?
Cheka killed them nearly all...
For roman alphabet users here are the lyrics :
Chorna vorozhka,
Chorna vorozhka
Krasno hadala.
Bilo-chervonu,
Bilo-chervonu
Strichku splitala.
Chorus:
A u Hulyaypoli,
A u Hulyaypoli,
Svityatʹsya vyshni.
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych,
Chomu tak vyyshlo?..
Nestor Ivanovych,
Yak Vy poviryly
V kazku pro shchastya,
Yak Vam namiryaly,
Yak Vam vidmiryaly
Z chornoyi masti.
Chorus
Ponad zirnytsi,
Ponad zirnytsi
Koni halopom.
Khloptsi bochantsi,
Khloptsi vorpivtsi
Pid perekopom.
Chorus
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych
Chom taka dolya,
Shcho obnyala Vas
Zemlya Paryzha -
Ne Hulyaypolya.
Chorus
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych,
Chomu ne vyyshlo?
Чорна ворожка,
Чорна ворожка
Красно гадала.
Біло-червону,
Біло-червону
Стрічку сплітала.
Приспів:
А у Гуляйполі,
А у Гуляйполі,
Світяться вишні.
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович,
Чому так вийшло?..
Нестор Іванович,
Як Ви повірили
В казку про щастя,
Як Вам наміряли,
Як Вам відміряли
З чорної масті.
Приспів
Понад зірниці,
Понад зірниці
Коні галопом.
Хлопці бочанці,
Хлопці ворпівці
Під перекопом.
Приспів
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович
Чом така доля,
Що обняла Вас
Земля Парижа -
Не Гуляйполя.
Приспів
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович,
Чому не вийшло?
Y'all know Dielo Truda (Makhno's group) already answers this question? Read the "Platform"!
Tractors did the work for Ukraine
th-cam.com/video/yHBdojl9Ck4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=1O_GaCaMfEr_ql9C
Кiнськi Роздори
Кiнськi Роздори, Дiбрiвськi лiси,
Гайчурськi хлопцi чистоi роси
Свиснеш iз дуба - чуть на три вiки,
Скрiзь моi краяни, махновцi козаки.
Ех, розлита воля - гiрша iз отрут,
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Ех недарма хлопцi мед-горiлку п'ють
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Зна Марiуполь, Юзiвка i Дон
Рейди на Полтаву, Перекоп, Херсон.
Конi топтали зорi, мов квiтки,
Ми в степах розтали, ми - туман гiркий.
Ех, розлита воля - гiрша iз отрут,
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Ех недарма хлопцi мед-горiлку п'ють
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Досi ночами, лине грiм копит,
Ген за вiтрами, дикий степ кипить.
Кров'ю без тiла пiсня десь блука,
Сила незнищенна виходу шука.
Ех, розлита воля - гiрша iз отрут,
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Ех недарма хлопцi мед-горiлку п'ють
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Ех, розлита воля - гiрша iз отрут,
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Ех недарма хлопцi мед-горiлку п'ють
Соловей-Розбiйник народився тут.
Кiнськi Роздори. Сыспай сиэллэрдээх
Вольный перевод на ҺАҔ (Саха)
Перевёл Чаҕаан.𐰱𐰍𐰤
Сыспай сиэллэрдээх, Эҥэрдии тыалаах,
Ойуурдаах удьуор сиик уутун курдук.
Үһүрүөх кэрэх - үс үйэ кэмҥэ,
Үөдүтэн үксэтиэ Махно эрэттэрин!
Көҥүлү, күөмчүлүүр - күүһү утарбыт,
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Уохтаах утаҕынан айах-тутарбыт!
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Мореуполь эҥэр, Юзовка Дон
Полтаваҕа барыы, Переков, Херсон.
Үөр сылгы айаҥар, чэчик кэһиллэр,
Эҥсиэли тилэри, буор бурхаат көтөр.
Көҥүлү, күөмчүлүүр - күүһү утарбыт,
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Уохтаах утаҕынан айах-туттарбыт!
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Түүннэри арыт туйах ньиргийэр.
Тыалга ытыллан эҥсиэл оргуйар.
Хаан ыскай ырыа тыла буккуллан,
Бүппэт муҥур күүһэ манна өһүллэр!
Көҥүлү, күөмчүлүүр - күүһү утарбыт,
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Уоттаах утаҕынан айах-туттарбыт!
Түөкүн эрэт-бэрдэ манна үөскээбит!
Көҥүлү, күөмчүлүүр - күүһү утарбыт,
Түөкүттэр-бэртэрэ манна үөскээбит!
Уохтаах утаҕынан айах-туттарбыт!
Түөкүттэр-бэртэрэ манна үөскээбит!
Чаҕаан.𐰱𐰍𐰤
1-0 Lzzzzzz
Didn't ask Red Fascist
@@somerandommen lol. The Libertarian thinks I need their permission to speak 🤡
@@MotherRosie Doesn't even deny it lmaoooo... touch grass Nazi apologist.
@@somerandommen it's just pointless to call me a red fash when you literally know nothing about me 🙄
@@MotherRosie I know you're a Red Fascist
Я, конечно, одобряю предательство большевиков, но звучит отлично.
Bolsheviks go to hell for the betrayal!