Wow what an incredible woman Celia Blay is. A pensioner, living in a small village in rural England, turned heroic detective and all round Good Samaritan. God bless her.
What upset me so much was him blaming his two daughters at first. They were so harmed by this. Once said it can not be removed from people's minds. Those poor girls really suffered. The city of Faribault is still affected by this. Him getting such a sentence really caused uproar here. This is why we need to make sure that the laws are on the books and that this crime will be there and have a life sentence with it. When you see him around town it is creepy.
The lady in the second story, Sylvia Blay, she kept reporting it until Dinkel was brought to justice, I think she saved lives, he would’ve kept going if he wasn’t caught, she’s a hero.
She's an inspiration. She needs to write a book honestly to show the dangers of these sick people out there and also here incredible to resiliant attitude to keep going until the PD and FBI have to listen.
I'm fucking pissed the lawyer used that as an excuse. Asperger's doesn't make someone use predatory tactics in order to obtain "consensual" sex. There's nothing consensual about that either. Psychotic is the right diagnosis.
That officer who found Catherine's purse took ALOT MORE INITIATIVE than my local PD. He made calls returned calls when there was no serious case as of yet.
merncat75 umm.... no it’s not? Idk her or where she lives, therefore I don’t know what police department she resides under. Soooo how is it pretty obvious?
Yep. I've dealt with depression since the third grade, and since the eleventh, suicidal...well, I really still don't know what to call it. Neither "thoughts" nor "tendencies" really seem to cover it. At any rate, the absolute last thing someone with these issues needs, _especially_ when the issue is unrequited love, is someone encouraging them to do it. Doubly so at a low point in life. It takes active, conscious, deliberate attempts at being optimistic and grateful to stay out of that pit, and too many days that's a taller order than we can manage, and people tending to not understand what depression is just makes things even more difficult. Just want to encourage you guys to stay on top of it and to view each day you get through as a victory in that war.
@@Goldnfoxx thanks man, she sends her best. She's going through a bad time right now and the support helps. Depression is so much worse than people make it out to be, I try my best to help her but some days I can only do so much.
@@Goldnfoxx I wish you a happy life full of love. We all have a purpose, I hope that you have found or will find yours. Take good care of yourself, you are important!!!
Toph Morris some days are tougher than others. My cat pulls me thru. If someone were to happen to me who would care for her. Would she grieve. I could never do that to her. And that and my family finding me stops me from doing anything.
@@turdferguson400 You know who's worse? You know who's a real son of a bitch? You know who's a real piece of work? That Hitler that's who. With a sociopath in the family I see why you developed a sense of humor and became a comedian. I love you Norm/Burt. Don't let the corona get on ya. You're a national treasure. Shame about Alex Trebeck. l'm gonna stop watching these depressing murder videos and watch one of yours!
patrick buster Hey man! What an awesome message. Thank you!! I hate to burst your bubble, but I’m actually just a 50-something chick from Australia. I love him, too! Xox
I'm kinda intrigued by William Melchert-Dinkel's wife standing by & supporting him in the photos. This guy spent years obsessively encouraging on-screen suicides- hundreds and hundreds of hours on the computer. Why would you want such a person anywhere near your & your family members' lives?
DeShawn 'Dawg' BNBG me too! My dad worked for a really prestigious law firm in Minneapolis, and he actually met William Melchert-Dinkel! His wife is apparently really really weird. William and his wife are STILL to this day trying to appeal his conviction, although the only kind of assisted suicide that is legal is the medically assisted suicide or the “Death with dignity” law. My dad was very rightfully uncomfortable around William and his wife.
@@natalieisanerd Very interesting to hear that. Looks like they had two grown daughters, wonder how they feel. I mean, imagine if they had a kid who was feeling a bit depressed because they're bullied at school or whatever; "It'll be fine honey, we'll sort it out. Just don't EVER mention it to your Grandfather, OK?"
Janice Sullivan this. I’ve pulled out of meetups and business transactions a couple of times because something didn’t feel right. You don’t have anything to lose by just saying know
i wrote the same thing... always go with your gut/instincts if something seems off don't go... first girl said it seemed strange. if she listened to her inner voice she'd still be here... my instincts have never failed me and i've had close calls before things u wouldn't believe
He lost his license to nurse earlier rumor has it he was "borrowing" meds. He worked at hospital and nursing homes. I have talked to people who worked with him. Some have said that things were happening on his shift that worried people.
I hear what you're saying only thing I think he waa not one of those" angels of death" who try to help people but he was getting off on it himself. For his benefit. Anyone who died when he was working should be looked into.
My running theory is that the expert witness: a) confused ASD (autism spectrum disorder, a social disorder where if anything people with it would be *less* likely to socially understand people enough to manipulate and catfish them, let alone think that's the best strategy) with ASPD (antisocial personality disorder, a disorder characterized by a consistent disregard for the law and other's rights, well-being, and/or feelings) and somehow missed the point where people with ASPD are capable of realizing what they are doing is wrong and are therefore still legally accountable for their actions or b) that that expert witness is in a competition with Sigmund Freud to see who can do more cocaine while practicing.
Aspergers/Autism does not cause someone to murder, but a sense of entitlement and viewing -women- other human beings as objects for your pleasure does. _Kindly keep your moronic bias to _*_yourself!_*_ It's quite a shame, considering you were off to such a good start._
I hate seeing/reading/becoming aware of the fact that people on the autism spectrum are - ignorantly - lumped into the same category as people that are either innately 'bad', or with people that cannot understand the difference between right and wrong. People with Asperger's are Not unintelligent; they're just...'"beyond". They're all (proven to be) willing/able to learn/accept levels of learning and comprehension that has yet to be fully explained. So, there we have it!...we Don't Know! If we're lucky af, we'll get closer to figuring it out within our lifetime.
I know the 2nd guy (Dinkle). I was friends with this daughter in high school. Used to go over to their house a lot. He always seemed a little creepy and off.
@@lefse2278 he didn't really talk to me at all. He just would look at us in a creepy way. I was cutting a lot and I think he liked that considering his suicide fetish.
My big brother committed suicide in 2006. 15 years later, I still miss him dearly. I think of him everyday. #2, Dinkle, should have gotten life!! He should NEVER be allowed on the internet again. He is a VERY dangerous human!! It is amazing how law enforcement ignored the ladies pleas. Humans like her deserve acknowledgement of just how heroic they are!!!! This case upset me terribly when it happened & still upsets me today!!
Condolences to your brother, but unfortunately aiding the suicide of another isn’t a capital offense. He physically didn’t murder those people he mentally killed them and that actually matters in a court of law. But I do agree that he should get a bigger sentence than that.
I hope you are well. I read somewhere "suicide doesn't end the pain-it just passes it on to others." I know it isn't super profound, but, it keeps me going. I kind of share it here and there. I guess you never know who it may also really strike a chord with, like it did with me. Encouraging people to carry it through just goes against every natural instinct we have. Wtf?
@@FlexedNoose Unfortunatelly. And it shouldn't be that way by law. Similar to psychological, emotional,mental abuse(which actually what he did is too). When only physical abuse counts in the eyes of law. Terrible😢
Most underrated comment on here yo, no offense to anyone but I went to the comments to see if someone said anything about him fixing it but i figured that was why he ReUp so quick but people making comments not mentioning the fix or thanking probably because they are too ignorant to realize it's s ReUp smfh
Someone remarked that you go to the " caption" option, and choose playback I used 1.25 the speech isnt so slow and more normal,to get here you touch the top right of the screen,three dots come up,tap them to get to the above items
Just the first case was senseless? With the main separating point being that she wasn't raped? So unless someone rapes a person before they kill them...the killing is senseless?
Exactly. Nothing about what she told him or where she met him was just the teeniest bit off to him? I know you can't jail people for being dumber than dirt, but, really...
its happened more than once.. look up craigslist ad for baby clothes michelle wilkins story... a woman named dynel lane posed as a pregnant woman wearing a fake belly...cut the baby out and rushed it to the hospital claiming it was hers but it died. the mother wilkins is still alive
1. I would NEVER meet up with ANYONE from Craigslist..even if it were about a job 2. If you happen to be a trusting enough person TO meet someone from Craigslist and they seem “strange” or give you the creeps....DO NOT, I REPEAT, DO NOT take your ass over there messing with them! They have a whooooole lot of “strange” shit in store for you.
@@xxxthebossxxx69 i know, and even after calling "Amy" before leaving... She still goes, despite that a guy must have answered... that should have turned that "not right" up to a "hell no!".
Omg the suicide one made me cry. I hope there IS a hell and that dinkle goes there. HOW evil and selfish to do that to vulnerable people whose lives could’ve been saved. Thank God for that lady. It just makes me SO ANGRY how so many people are so disconnected that they end up so sick.
Raymond Aranda 210sideshow He used people’s vulnerabilities to his advantage and caused them to harm themselves or at times, kill themselves, for his own pleasure. That’s how it’s selfish. Sorry if this seems rude in any way, thank you for reading it if you do.
phutura2049 The lady is life saver. Dinkel should have just went jogging had someone race him since he caused people to commit suicide just because he liked he liked a thrill of a chase, but of course early 2000s people experimenting with the internet and this man was evil and caused young adults or younger to kill themselves pretending to be someone on the internet he wasn’t. I’m mad at the sentences he got, one year in jail for assisting or aiding in suicides then three years but suspended then just one year but ended up serving 6 months.
I think Katherine was "coerced" into coming into that young monster's home by having a gun drawn on her. And the defense blamed it on Asperger's Syndrome!?!? That's outrageous! My son-in-law has AS! He and others who have this are NOT violent! This has nothing to do with this scumbag's actions in ending this young lady's life! NOTHING! As for the monster who egged people on to commit suicide, he deserves to spend his entire life in prison. He will only continue to do this. People like him don't change. He is a predator and will continue to be one. The monster who murdered that pregnant mother is a psychopath. Nothing that happened to her in her younger life caused her to do this.
In my experience if you push someone too much that has autism they can snap, l have experienced them having super human strength once they snap! Takes a lot to push them over the edge though!
my son-in law has ausbergers too.hes one of the gentlest peapol l know the last person whod commit such a crime. that guy killed katherine because 1 hes a loser and2 hes just plain wicked
@@kathleenmcconaha5608 yes l agree my son is autistic and my brother aspergs. l wish people were more like them. They don't make fun of others and are so nice and helpful, I'm sure that monster had something else wrong with him.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Willy Dinkle🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 If I ever met him I'd keep saying his name over & over again...just keep saying it!!🤣🤣🤣 He would probably try to kill me🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣willy dinkle willy dinkle Willy dinkle Willy dinkle Willy dinkle Haaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
It disgusts and disappoints me how many forms of law enforcement, including our own RCMP, dismissed the facts and pleas for help in the second story. That guy deserves to be crucified and slowly suffocated over those measly 360 days he got in jail!
I’m a depressed person who has suffered with it and suicidal thoughts for as long as I can remember. I’ve acted on such thoughts and am deeply sorry for doing as such. But, hearing that a woman named Ms. Blay is in this world and is fighting to help those of us who have found themselves for whatever reasons or causes facing such mental issues is uplifting in ways I cannot describe. I truly am ashamed of my actions (I will carry the scars of my ignorant actions for the rest of my life) and am also honestly thankful that this woman exists who endeavors to help those of us with such problems. I may not have a personal connection with her.....but I feel personally indebted to her. She has saved lives. I’m not religious whatsoever, and yet it feels so very right in saying, “Bless this beautiful woman. And, thank goodness that she was born and placed on this earth to help lost and confused souls.”
This channel never ceases to amaze me in how it can find three completely different types of utterly unthinkable horror at a time. "Well it can't get worse than... oh. Never mind then."
This is absolutely insane for me. When Kathrine popped up I knew I recognized her. I ask my older sister and she had babysat us once and we had never saw her again. I had absolutely no idea
I'm so proud of the woman in case #2. It's so hard to pursue justice, especially if you're talking about international stuff. And we STILL don't have that great laws with cyber stuff!!!!
*CATISHING* The cause of a strange but common syndrome which often effects the person in the home with a cat who finds it is their job to clean up after the cat. This shows when the human/cat-janitor of the home manifests the compulsion that forces them to continually clean their cats' litter boxes regardless of how overcome they feel by the grossness of this dirty and thankless job. And regardless of their aversion they will continue to do the job even when logic might dictate that a better way to deal with the situation could be to give the cat away... This is where catishing comes in, it is an evolutionary adaptation of the housecat that allows the cat to influence it's human janitor to continue this dirty task no matter what level of feeling the person has for the cat. It is similar to what horse trainers call horse whispering except in this case it is the strange and subtle way the cat is able to influence its human janitor to continue cleaning up after the cat regardless of how much or how little the janitor cares about the cat. Cat- ISHHHH- ing!! 😼💩🐈🤮🚿😽🤫😻
Regarding the second case: If anyone reading this NEEDS or wants someone to talk to when you are feeling like you want or need it... reach out here. I have Steam, Discord and if really really needed others I won't list here. 🥀Reach out... Don't suffer in silence and alone🌷🌷 If not here, online, then anywhere but just reach out. Don't be afraid🌱
Thanks for the reupload! You have a very sweet fanbase. I scrolled through quite a few comments on the last video and I never saw a negative thing about the sound cutting out. I only saw people excitedly waiting for you to reupload and politely letting you know what happened. That's really neat and hard to find with how much negativity constantly floods TH-cam.
Thanks for fixing the audio. Great video. That 1st guy is none too bright. That's the worst paper trail (or e-trail as it were) I've ever seen covered on this or any crime channel.
Kadie Ghannam Rateb if you haven’t checked them out yet, I found some at a dollar store. It is ridiculous the way people are acting. But remember we have an idiot for a president so no one knows what to do. I hope you & your household will be ok.
The first one, just imagine if that parks employee would’ve never called the police about the purse. It could have been wrapped in a bag or just ignored and that case would have never been solved. Yet in a matter of days (gotta be record time for most police depts lol) bc of that single act everything else unfolded so flawlessly
Lisa Montgomery, who carved a baby out of a pregnant woman's belly, had her death sentence carried out in late 2020. Lisa's sister had posted petitions for people to sign to have her sister's sentence commuted, saying that it was unfair for capital punishment to be carried out on someone who had been deemed insane. She didn't mention what her sister had done. However, most people remembered this horrendous case, and Lisa Montgomery was killed.
Out of all the videos of yours that I've seen and I've seen about 65 % of them .this one is probably the craziest of all . Keep up the work man . You are awesome !
i love cases like these. something about the late 00s-early 10s plus the internet is something that brings me amazing memories so these cases make me feel just that much unsettled because like, i wouldn’t think about that era in this way if that makes sense.
Dinkle reminds me of internet trolls, who say that "I can say what I want online, freedom of speech". What they don't understand that actions have consequences, despite whatever 'funny' intentions they have. It makes me sick.
Freedom of speech…. My freedom doesn’t end because you have mental problems. If you want to kill yourself based off of somebody’s WORDS, there’s bigger problems for you to worry about and you should be in therapy
I remember one of my middle school teachers reading the third story to me when it was in the newspaper. There are some crazy people out there. Stories like these three are a good example of what kind of people you'll find on the internet. Don't place your trust with people you met online. They could have other intentions.
Dinkles name fits him perfectly. He looks like a strange weird guy the whole I’m a nurse w a suicide fetish that’s one of the strangest things I’ve ever heard. If that’s a thing God help us.
Celia blay is a true hero if there were a thousand of her the world would be a better place she never gave up trying to be a good person no matter how many times the authorities told her to give up someone should get that lady a cape
It hurts my heart that to this day, people STILL use the internet to find jobs, a potential spouse, a good sale etc and think nothing of jetting off to someone's home to pick items up or meet someone. PLEASE, always, ALWAYS meet people in public and/or preferably bring someone along with you if you need to meet up with someone.
Celia is a real International Hero. She kept going, collecting her evidence even though the local police, Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the F.B.I. were not interested. Eventually, she got a Police group who specialised, and the nurse who was encoraging Suicides was eventually convicted.
The case of Michael Anderson... The only thing about the court proceedings that doesnt sit right with me is that the judge that diagnosed Michael wouldnt allow him to testify. Which lead's me to my next point. Why couldnt they have another doctor do the tests to confirm or disprove whether or not he had aspergers?
Wow what an incredible woman Celia Blay is. A pensioner, living in a small village in rural England, turned heroic detective and all round Good Samaritan. God bless her.
What upset me so much was him blaming his two daughters at first. They were so harmed by this. Once said it can not be removed from people's minds. Those poor girls really suffered. The city of Faribault is still affected by this. Him getting such a sentence really caused uproar here. This is why we need to make sure that the laws are on the books and that this crime will be there and have a life sentence with it. When you see him around town it is creepy.
aunt penny ugh I can just imagine.. I would say a couple rude words to him if I ever saw him walking around my town, that’s for sure!
@@peggysuewiskocil8183 To bad he hasn't been a victim of "suicide" yet.
The lady in the second story, Sylvia Blay, she kept reporting it until Dinkel was brought to justice, I think she saved lives, he would’ve kept going if he wasn’t caught, she’s a hero.
She's an inspiration. She needs to write a book honestly to show the dangers of these sick people out there and also here incredible to resiliant attitude to keep going until the PD and FBI have to listen.
i know... no one even cared accept her... she is truly a hero
She deserves to be knighted, in my opinion!
@@julz3tt3 I would 100% read that book
she restored my faith in humanity. I love her.
I have Asperger's and it hasn't prevented me from knowing right from wrong.
I'm fucking pissed the lawyer used that as an excuse. Asperger's doesn't make someone use predatory tactics in order to obtain "consensual" sex. There's nothing consensual about that either. Psychotic is the right diagnosis.
If anything it makes my son and I more of a “rule follower” than most. That’s how it goes when you know you suck at lying lol
Rules are literally my two sons favorite things lmao... Sociopath would be a better diagnosis...
Yeah I don't think "clumsy with your hands" is actually a symptom. I suspect the word "clumsy" is being misinterpreted.
OMG THANK YOU!!!
That officer who found Catherine's purse took ALOT MORE INITIATIVE than my local PD. He made calls returned calls when there was no serious case as of yet.
You're so right..
He went above and beyond compared to probably most local PD!
I was thinking the same thing, I hope that he was rewarded in some way.
What did your local PD do/not do?
@@pbjcullen7485
I think it's pretty obvious without getting into details on here
merncat75 umm.... no it’s not? Idk her or where she lives, therefore I don’t know what police department she resides under. Soooo how is it pretty obvious?
God bless Cilia Blay. We really need more people like her in this world.
Yesssssss
As long as people like Celia Blay exist I won't lose all hope in humanity.
Yes
She’s a hero and a legend.
The second one... My girlfriend is depressed and frequently has suicidal thoughts. Dinkle or whatever his name is should burn in hell.
Agreed .He should of got 10 years in prison.
Yep. I've dealt with depression since the third grade, and since the eleventh, suicidal...well, I really still don't know what to call it. Neither "thoughts" nor "tendencies" really seem to cover it. At any rate, the absolute last thing someone with these issues needs, _especially_ when the issue is unrequited love, is someone encouraging them to do it. Doubly so at a low point in life. It takes active, conscious, deliberate attempts at being optimistic and grateful to stay out of that pit, and too many days that's a taller order than we can manage, and people tending to not understand what depression is just makes things even more difficult. Just want to encourage you guys to stay on top of it and to view each day you get through as a victory in that war.
@@Goldnfoxx thanks man, she sends her best. She's going through a bad time right now and the support helps. Depression is so much worse than people make it out to be, I try my best to help her but some days I can only do so much.
@@Goldnfoxx
I wish you a happy life full of love.
We all have a purpose, I hope that you have found or will find yours.
Take good care of yourself, you are important!!!
Toph Morris some days are tougher than others. My cat pulls me thru. If someone were to happen to me who would care for her. Would she grieve. I could never do that to her. And that and my family finding me stops me from doing anything.
These 3 perps are some real "winners". No redeeming qualities whatsoever. Kudos to that woman that didn't give up on Case #2
Necron990 Totally agree. Bless her heart for everything she did. What a decent lady. 💜
@aaronsdavis no doubt, especially in Case #2. Suicide fetish?! Man to have been a cop that arrested him...
aaronsdavis not just psychopaths. Sociopaths can apply to these cases as well. I know, because I have one in my family. Zero empathy.
@@turdferguson400 You know who's worse? You know who's a real son of a bitch? You know who's a real piece of work? That Hitler that's who. With a sociopath in the family I see why you developed a sense of humor and became a comedian. I love you Norm/Burt. Don't let the corona get on ya. You're a national treasure. Shame about Alex Trebeck. l'm gonna stop watching these depressing murder videos and watch one of yours!
patrick buster Hey man! What an awesome message. Thank you!! I hate to burst your bubble, but I’m actually just a 50-something chick from Australia. I love him, too! Xox
I'm kinda intrigued by William Melchert-Dinkel's wife standing by & supporting him in the photos. This guy spent years obsessively encouraging on-screen suicides- hundreds and hundreds of hours on the computer. Why would you want such a person anywhere near your & your family members' lives?
DeShawn 'Dawg' BNBG me too! My dad worked for a really prestigious law firm in Minneapolis, and he actually met William Melchert-Dinkel! His wife is apparently really really weird. William and his wife are STILL to this day trying to appeal his conviction, although the only kind of assisted suicide that is legal is the medically assisted suicide or the “Death with dignity” law.
My dad was very rightfully uncomfortable around William and his wife.
@@natalieisanerd Very interesting to hear that. Looks like they had two grown daughters, wonder how they feel. I mean, imagine if they had a kid who was feeling a bit depressed because they're bullied at school or whatever; "It'll be fine honey, we'll sort it out. Just don't EVER mention it to your Grandfather, OK?"
I get the feeling his wife is just as strange as he is. . They're both nuts
@@RobinMarconeCassidyRN maybe his wife was into that sick thing too.
His wife used her religion to justify staying with him.
"He also said that he had a 'suicide fetish' "
Well, I've heard it all now 😩
AwkwardBlackGal not if you keep hanging out on the internet you haven’t!
If it exists people will cum too it
TayDeezy 408 child no.
😄😄😄
@Jennie Hughes you must be real fun at parties
If someone or something seems “not right,” listen to that internal voice!
Janice Sullivan this. I’ve pulled out of meetups and business transactions a couple of times because something didn’t feel right. You don’t have anything to lose by just saying know
I thought the same thing when I saw the spelling of the video title.
100%. If you ignore it you might very well regret it, with consequences of varying severity.
i wrote the same thing... always go with your gut/instincts if something seems off don't go... first girl said it seemed strange. if she listened to her inner voice she'd still be here... my instincts have never failed me and i've had close calls before things u wouldn't believe
My internal voice says "Smoke more pot." I'm a-gonna listen to it.
Did they look into Williams nursing career? Cause that sounds like one of those angel of death people.
He lost his license to nurse earlier rumor has it he was "borrowing" meds. He worked at hospital and nursing homes. I have talked to people who worked with him. Some have said that things were happening on his shift that worried people.
aunt penny him working at a nursing home makes me even more concerned
I hear what you're saying only thing I think he waa not one of those" angels of death" who try to help people but he was getting off on it himself. For his benefit.
Anyone who died when he was working should be looked into.
*was not
The older lady in the 2nd one is a damn saint. God bless her
Yes she is! She's a wonderful lady working so hard to save people ❤️ God bless her heart!
Aspergers/Autism does not cause someone to murder, but a sense of entitlement and viewing women as objects for your pleasure does.
Yes. Using that as an excuse is abhorrent.
My running theory is that the expert witness: a) confused ASD (autism spectrum disorder, a social disorder where if anything people with it would be *less* likely to socially understand people enough to manipulate and catfish them, let alone think that's the best strategy) with ASPD (antisocial personality disorder, a disorder characterized by a consistent disregard for the law and other's rights, well-being, and/or feelings) and somehow missed the point where people with ASPD are capable of realizing what they are doing is wrong and are therefore still legally accountable for their actions or b) that that expert witness is in a competition with Sigmund Freud to see who can do more cocaine while practicing.
Aspergers/Autism does not cause someone to murder, but a sense of entitlement and viewing -women- other human beings as objects for your pleasure does.
_Kindly keep your moronic bias to _*_yourself!_*_ It's quite a shame, considering you were off to such a good start._
I hate seeing/reading/becoming aware of the fact that people on the autism spectrum are - ignorantly - lumped into the same category as people that are either innately 'bad', or with people that cannot understand the difference between right and wrong. People with Asperger's are Not unintelligent; they're just...'"beyond". They're all (proven to be) willing/able to learn/accept levels of learning and comprehension that has yet to be fully explained. So, there we have it!...we Don't Know! If we're lucky af, we'll get closer to figuring it out within our lifetime.
@@annegrey3780 best comment.
He threw her purse away along with a bloody towel with his name marked on it.... ?
Evidently, this guy was a master of deception😁.
As they say, 'there are no perfect crimes.'
That was right up there with his defense stories. This is no master mind criminal.
Bob Jolly yep, even Sherlock would be stumped by this crime.
He thought it would be funny.
I know the 2nd guy (Dinkle). I was friends with this daughter in high school. Used to go over to their house a lot. He always seemed a little creepy and off.
Lo Johnson crazy. What were the interactions like?
@@lefse2278 he didn't really talk to me at all. He just would look at us in a creepy way. I was cutting a lot and I think he liked that considering his suicide fetish.
So you spent time with the Dinkle Family?
@@chocomanger6873 not a ton of time, but yes.
@@underestimated.dermestid Did you ever make fun of their last name?
Thank you Celia Blay for showing so much perseverance, determination, and not giving up. You ARE a hero 👍🏼😎🤘🏼
My big brother committed suicide in 2006. 15 years later, I still miss him dearly. I think of him everyday. #2, Dinkle, should have gotten life!! He should NEVER be allowed on the internet again. He is a VERY dangerous human!! It is amazing how law enforcement ignored the ladies pleas. Humans like her deserve acknowledgement of just how heroic they are!!!! This case upset me terribly when it happened & still upsets me today!!
Condolences to your brother, but unfortunately aiding the suicide of another isn’t a capital offense. He physically didn’t murder those people he mentally killed them and that actually matters in a court of law. But I do agree that he should get a bigger sentence than that.
I hope you are well. I read somewhere "suicide doesn't end the pain-it just passes it on to others." I know it isn't super profound, but, it keeps me going. I kind of share it here and there. I guess you never know who it may also really strike a chord with, like it did with me. Encouraging people to carry it through just goes against every natural instinct we have. Wtf?
@@FlexedNoose Unfortunatelly. And it shouldn't be that way by law. Similar to psychological, emotional,mental abuse(which actually what he did is too). When only physical abuse counts in the eyes of law. Terrible😢
I'm sorry for your loss. ❤
Hey bro I feel you're pain. Stand strong 💪
Dinkel should be banned for life from the internet.
Imagine if that was possible? I guess you could do it if you jailed someone for life.
And then castrated...if not executed.
u know that fkker is on the dark web somewhere
How could they enforce that?
@@Sciviias they enforce very limited internet access for sex offenders.
Metsher Dinkel needs a visit of Karma. So he got off with a 6 month sentence that does not sit well with me.
So sad.
*Melchert-Dinkle. Chills has bad diction. edit: but with my accent, i wouldn't be able to clearly say "Melchert" either.
Me either. Its a travesty
His name certainly fits him. Very much a dinkle.
That Dinkel man is one sick fuc** I just arghhh! Angry right now
THANK YOU FOR REUPLOADING WITH THE AUDIO PROBLEM AT THE LAST QUARTER FIXED.
Most underrated comment on here yo, no offense to anyone but I went to the comments to see if someone said anything about him fixing it but i figured that was why he ReUp so quick but people making comments not mentioning the fix or thanking probably because they are too ignorant to realize it's s ReUp smfh
Someone remarked that you go to the " caption" option, and choose playback I used 1.25 the speech isnt so slow and more normal,to get here you touch the top right of the screen,three dots come up,tap them to get to the above items
That poor woman, can't even imagine the pain and fear that she had to be filled with while being murdered and her unborn child ripped from her 😔
what a senseless killing that first case was.... ...
You got that right Bob it really got me pissed off.
I know!! That's what I kept saying, while listening. So pointless.
Just the first case was senseless? With the main separating point being that she wasn't raped? So unless someone rapes a person before they kill them...the killing is senseless?
In the last one, didn’t the husband notice that his wife wasn’t pregnant? Where did he think the baby came from???
Exactly. Nothing about what she told him or where she met him was just the teeniest bit off to him? I know you can't jail people for being dumber than dirt, but, really...
She'd been pretending for ages to be pregnant and needed to go get a baby.
@@angielou123 ~ yes but didn't he ever see her nude? or feel a growing tummy in bed etc. how can a husband not notice, he already has 2 kids!
@@NannupTiger she had multiple fake bumps for every month and wasnt ever seen nude
Under a cabbage in the garden ;)
Lisa obviously had issues, but I still don’t understand just how that drove her to commit such a heinous crime. Damn.
its happened more than once.. look up craigslist ad for baby clothes michelle wilkins story... a woman named dynel lane posed as a pregnant woman wearing a fake belly...cut the baby out and rushed it to the hospital claiming it was hers but it died. the mother wilkins is still alive
@@kimmyfreak200 Yes! Crazy, someone I think perhaps That Chapter, did a video about that story. Just awful :(
@@kimmyfreak200 Law & Order SVU based an episode on that story, if I'm not mistaken.
She's evil there's no excuse
Well she payed for it with her life en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Bobbie_Jo_Stinnett
"the police said if she didn't like what was online to just look the other way"
yeah cuz thats what most police do. nice work guys
I know, insanity
1. I would NEVER meet up with ANYONE from Craigslist..even if it were about a job
2. If you happen to be a trusting enough person TO meet someone from Craigslist and they seem “strange” or give you the creeps....DO NOT, I REPEAT, DO NOT take your ass over there messing with them! They have a whooooole lot of “strange” shit in store for you.
I can't believe she was that dumb to go even after she thought he was strange lol
@@xxxthebossxxx69 i know, and even after calling "Amy" before leaving...
She still goes, despite that a guy must have answered... that should have turned that "not right" up to a "hell no!".
I’ve met over 100 people off of Craigslist for multiple reasons. I’m still alive. I’ve never had an issue. Don’t be a fucking idiot and vet the person
Victim blaming. 🐸☕
Omg the suicide one made me cry. I hope there IS a hell and that dinkle goes there. HOW evil and selfish to do that to vulnerable people whose lives could’ve been saved. Thank God for that lady. It just makes me SO ANGRY how so many people are so disconnected that they end up so sick.
Raymond Aranda 210sideshow He used people’s vulnerabilities to his advantage and caused them to harm themselves or at times, kill themselves, for his own pleasure. That’s how it’s selfish. Sorry if this seems rude in any way, thank you for reading it if you do.
phutura2049 The lady is life saver. Dinkel should have just went jogging had someone race him since he caused people to commit suicide just because he liked he liked a thrill of a chase, but of course early 2000s people experimenting with the internet and this man was evil and caused young adults or younger to kill themselves pretending to be someone on the internet he wasn’t. I’m mad at the sentences he got, one year in jail for assisting or aiding in suicides then three years but suspended then just one year but ended up serving 6 months.
Yes it me sick to my stomach
Raymond Aranda 210sideshow r u joking with that question
That teacher reaching out to help others is an amazing woman!
This background music is perfect for these type of stories.
Thanks for the reupload! I was into the last story but couldn’t hear! Keep up the great work!
Yes!!
Raymond Aranda 210sideshow she did shut up
When he said, "St. Olaf Minnesota" I admittedly laughed. Rose Nyland anyone?
Me toooo🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I cracked the fuck up😂😂😂
Right?!😂🤣
Sure did.
"St. Olaf?"
"It's like I'm wearing a sign!"
🤣🤣🤣
I think Katherine was "coerced" into coming into that young monster's home by having a gun drawn on her. And the defense blamed it on Asperger's Syndrome!?!? That's outrageous! My son-in-law has AS! He and others who have this are NOT violent! This has nothing to do with this scumbag's actions in ending this young lady's life! NOTHING! As for the monster who egged people on to commit suicide, he deserves to spend his entire life in prison. He will only continue to do this. People like him don't change. He is a predator and will continue to be one. The monster who murdered that pregnant mother is a psychopath. Nothing that happened to her in her younger life caused her to do this.
In my experience if you push someone too much that has autism they can snap, l have experienced them having super human strength once they snap! Takes a lot to push them over the edge though!
my son-in law has ausbergers too.hes one of the gentlest peapol l know the last person whod commit such a crime. that guy killed katherine because 1 hes a loser and2 hes just plain wicked
@@kathleenmcconaha5608 yes l agree my son is autistic and my brother aspergs. l wish people were more like them. They don't make fun of others and are so nice and helpful, I'm sure that monster had something else wrong with him.
Aspies aren't known for wanton murder. Society is delusional.
Wait, St. Olaf is a real place? TIL. I thought it was fictional because of Rose from Golden Girls
Haha, man what a reference. I remember that haha!
Yes, it's a real place.
Back in St. Olaf, they called attempted murder “hürgenflürgen”
I thought it was a fake place too 😂
It’s not a town, but a university. One of the writers on the show went to the rival college.
Hahaha his name was Willy Dinkle. Of course he went nuts.
He actually used his wife's maiden name. People here in Faribault thinks he has trying to hide he's past.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Willy Dinkle🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 If I ever met him I'd keep saying his name over & over again...just keep saying it!!🤣🤣🤣 He would probably try to kill me🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣willy dinkle willy dinkle Willy dinkle Willy dinkle Willy dinkle Haaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
It disgusts and disappoints me how many forms of law enforcement, including our own RCMP, dismissed the facts and pleas for help in the second story. That guy deserves to be crucified and slowly suffocated over those measly 360 days he got in jail!
Kyote 10 ...yes , i'm with you ...i mean this guy is a middle aged family man , time to grow up dinkle . a true loser in every sense .
Canada seems pretty lax with sentencing...
Yes , laxed and ex-laxed ....
@Kyote I’ve been watching a lot of The Fifth Estate and I’ve noticed that, but the US Police Forces have their own problems (ex. Steven Avery Case).
I’m a depressed person who has suffered with it and suicidal thoughts for as long as I can remember. I’ve acted on such thoughts and am deeply sorry for doing as such.
But, hearing that a woman named Ms. Blay is in this world and is fighting to help those of us who have found themselves for whatever reasons or causes facing such mental issues is uplifting in ways I cannot describe.
I truly am ashamed of my actions (I will carry the scars of my ignorant actions for the rest of my life) and am also honestly thankful that this woman exists who endeavors to help those of us with such problems. I may not have a personal connection with her.....but I feel personally indebted to her.
She has saved lives. I’m not religious whatsoever, and yet it feels so very right in saying, “Bless this beautiful woman. And, thank goodness that she was born and placed on this earth to help lost and confused souls.”
🤍
In Michael's case, it was definitely premeditated murder. What a shame for Catherine's parents.
I watch this channel as like a bedtime story. Consequently, I had fallen asleep and didn’t even know there was a problem with the previous upload 😂
thanks for taking my mind off the Coronavirus!
You are going to be fine. The media and government is doing their best to scare Every one as much as possible.
Murder and suicide always does the trick. Lol
And thank you for reminding me again...
@@NASkeywest Same here in Canada. Low risk. High drama. Hysteria and violence in the toilet paper aisle. Gimme a freaking break.
@J D Of course...but no need to cause a stampede in the meantime. Take necessary precautions. Take care of your elderly neighbours. Be aware.
This channel never ceases to amaze me in how it can find three completely different types of utterly unthinkable horror at a time. "Well it can't get worse than... oh. Never mind then."
Craigslist is the website of death.
Plenty of Fish
It's lookin that way more and more
I’ve seen more death on watchpeopledie than on Craigslist tho
I'm guessing you haven't heard of the deep web, then...
YEP
This is absolutely insane for me. When Kathrine popped up I knew I recognized her. I ask my older sister and she had babysat us once and we had never saw her again. I had absolutely no idea
thank you for fixing the audio :D
The only channel I actually take the time to watch ads for. Thanks so much for the excellent content Criminally Listed.
In these shity and quite scary times, thanks for keeping us entertained.
Ireland loves ya
with shitty and quite scary stories but still somehow it helps
@@Safa-vy8xy sure dose
We live in the safest and most peaceful time in the history of humanity.
@@ButterBallTheOpossum 90 s were class
@@patrickkeane2067 *does
Yaaaaaay!! The sound is fixed! So glad I can finish this.
I'm so proud of the woman in case #2. It's so hard to pursue justice, especially if you're talking about international stuff. And we STILL don't have that great laws with cyber stuff!!!!
My god, man, your material is simply top notch!! Another great episode. Riveting and fascinating.
I love how the auto captions occasionally refer to Metsher Dinkel as 'Bowser Dickhole'
lol!
It seems to fit him better anyway.
lol i noticed that too.
It made me chuckle.
Imagine if people could petition to change his name to Bowser Dickhole...
*“catishing”*
XD he'll get it right one day lol
Haha. See I didn't even notice. I had to check after reading this. So I can't criticize.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
*CATISHING* The cause of a strange but common syndrome which often effects the person in the home with a cat who finds it is their job to clean up after the cat. This shows when the human/cat-janitor of the home manifests the compulsion that forces them to continually clean their cats' litter boxes regardless of how overcome they feel by the grossness of this dirty and thankless job. And regardless of their aversion they will continue to do the job even when logic might dictate that a better way to deal with the situation could be to give the cat away... This is where catishing comes in, it is an evolutionary adaptation of the housecat that allows the cat to influence it's human janitor to continue this dirty task no matter what level of feeling the person has for the cat. It is similar to what horse trainers call horse whispering except in this case it is the strange and subtle way the cat is able to influence its human janitor to continue cleaning up after the cat regardless of how much or how little the janitor cares about the cat.
Cat- ISHHHH- ing!!
😼💩🐈🤮🚿😽🤫😻
Regarding the second case:
If anyone reading this NEEDS or wants someone to talk to when you are feeling like you want or need it... reach out here. I have Steam, Discord and if really really needed others I won't list here.
🥀Reach out...
Don't suffer in silence and alone🌷🌷
If not here, online, then anywhere but just reach out. Don't be afraid🌱
Thank you god bless you!
Thank you this came right on time. It sucks having so many friends but yet no one to talk to.
Thanks for the reupload! You have a very sweet fanbase. I scrolled through quite a few comments on the last video and I never saw a negative thing about the sound cutting out. I only saw people excitedly waiting for you to reupload and politely letting you know what happened. That's really neat and hard to find with how much negativity constantly floods TH-cam.
I love how many of these sickos make the most simple mistakes that lead to their capture, unfortunately not all killers are this stupid.
There may be a typo but I know damn well my brain wasn't the only one that read it correctly...🤦♀️😂
Here to finish part 3 ☺️
Alexandra M isn’t everyone lol
You’ve put “catishing” instead of “catfishing” in the title bro.
Not hating or mocking, great video as always, just making you aware, all love.
I really just want you to keep saying Kajuji and Dinkle.
Right!!!?? Lol.. it was painful at first but then I started listening for it! 😂🤣
Pinky Blue lol me too!
Sounds like DINK HOLE hahaha
Hi, Bill! I'm surprised none of these craigslist stories are about you. 🙂
Love this channel so glad I stumbled across it a year ago❤️
Greatest discovery ever
Emily Lavelle same
Thanks for fixing the audio. Great video. That 1st guy is none too bright. That's the worst paper trail (or e-trail as it were) I've ever seen covered on this or any crime channel.
Thanks for the re-upload! I was eager to finish the last case
Thank you I was devastated last night 🖤
Hope you're doing better even though all this nonsense is still happening. Single motherhood is a challenge, but often creates great Moms. Stay well.
Third story is particularly cruel.
An she just got executed for it en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Bobbie_Jo_Stinnett
*3 Murders involving toilet paper theft* 😂
Oh jeez, wouldn't surprise me if that is to come... There have already been fist fights and arrests!
I had to get toilet paper because I was almost out at home and I was worried about walking to my car with it. Lol
Ridiculous isnt it!
Kadie Ghannam Rateb if you haven’t checked them out yet, I found some at a dollar store. It is ridiculous the way people are acting. But remember we have an idiot for a president so no one knows what to do. I hope you & your household will be ok.
Pamela Chambers the president has nothing to do with this situation lol you just wanted to bring that up huh
The first one, just imagine if that parks employee would’ve never called the police about the purse. It could have been wrapped in a bag or just ignored and that case would have never been solved. Yet in a matter of days (gotta be record time for most police depts lol) bc of that single act everything else unfolded so flawlessly
Always happy to see these videos drop. I constantly find myself going back and watching older CL videos when he used to talk faster. Different times.
The police in the Dinkel story should've at least referred Sylvia to a department that could help her.
Thank you SO much for fixing audio & for the reupload, you work so hard and are so kind
Like folgers" the best part of waking up is criminally Listed in my cup"
Mountain grown crystals.
Better than pee.
Wow! that is a amazing impression of Chills, my dude.
🤣🤣🤣
The narrator gets addicted to any game that sponsors the channel.
Ryan smart They always do....
I can’t stand the narrator
Lisa Montgomery, who carved a baby out of a pregnant woman's belly, had her death sentence carried out in late 2020. Lisa's sister had posted petitions for people to sign to have her sister's sentence commuted, saying that it was unfair for capital punishment to be carried out on someone who had been deemed insane. She didn't mention what her sister had done. However, most people remembered this horrendous case, and Lisa Montgomery was killed.
Thanks for fixing the audio issue. I've heard of cases like Lisa Montgomery having the same conclusion.
Out of all the videos of yours that I've seen and I've seen about 65 % of them .this one is probably the craziest of all . Keep up the work man . You are awesome !
i love cases like these. something about the late 00s-early 10s plus the internet is something that brings me amazing memories so these cases make me feel just that much unsettled because like, i wouldn’t think about that era in this way if that makes sense.
Good day to the CL family.
Good day to you too ✌️💙✨
Stay safe and healthy 💜
Thanks rose and Elena. Your response made my day a little better.
@@mysonismylife9280 glad to hear it! Sending all the good vibes ✌️💙✨
Hey brother 👋🏼 hope all is well! Good night from USA 🇺🇸!!!
Dinkle reminds me of internet trolls, who say that "I can say what I want online, freedom of speech". What they don't understand that actions have consequences, despite whatever 'funny' intentions they have. It makes me sick.
Freedom of speech…. My freedom doesn’t end because you have mental problems. If you want to kill yourself based off of somebody’s WORDS, there’s bigger problems for you to worry about and you should be in therapy
@@briannemarie9214 well, law disagrees and he got prison sentence - you'd know if you watched the whole video (29:12).
I remember one of my middle school teachers reading the third story to me when it was in the newspaper. There are some crazy people out there. Stories like these three are a good example of what kind of people you'll find on the internet. Don't place your trust with people you met online. They could have other intentions.
Thank you so much for posting these! You make my day by posting such interesting stories!
"Hey, I think that someone in this forum is encouraging people to kill themselves on webcam"
"Don't like, don't read"
Ikr?! That pissed me off
Thank you for fixing the sound. Much appreciated! Great video as always
Dinkles name fits him perfectly. He looks like a strange weird guy the whole I’m a nurse w a suicide fetish that’s one of the strangest things I’ve ever heard. If that’s a thing God help us.
Celia blay is a true hero if there were a thousand of her the world would be a better place she never gave up trying to be a good person no matter how many times the authorities told her to give up someone should get that lady a cape
Thank you for the re-upload! I was able to watch it without any problems.
Another great video 👍🏻 your voice is so relaxing tbh I fall asleep to your videos since your voice is so calming.
Thanks for the reupload.
New video 🥺 I have mental illnesses and I wouldn’t have the heart to catfish someone. Not when it happened to me for a brief time as a ‘joke’
It hurts my heart that to this day, people STILL use the internet to find jobs, a potential spouse, a good sale etc and think nothing of jetting off to someone's home to pick items up or meet someone. PLEASE, always, ALWAYS meet people in public and/or preferably bring someone along with you if you need to meet up with someone.
I don’t get how the first house looks “dilapidated”? It looks just fine to me...
Sweet!! Now to listen to the ending. Thank you CL!
Who gave this a thumbs down🤦😲😠? Maybe they are just having a bad day....
The spelling police gave it to him
I did I'm Lisa the one that cheated on her husband multiple times yes that's me I give this a thumbs
@Frank Pitts thank goodness we have the easy ability to fast forward on TH-cam 🤷♀️
@@maddisonbythesea3015 👍
Skidmore is the same town the Ken Rex McElroy killing happened.
I think that would be a good video idea: small towns with notable but unrelated crimes
No 1 Aussie Fan watching from NSW :D
Thank you CL for another quality upload.
Celia is a real International Hero. She kept going, collecting her evidence even though the local police, Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the F.B.I. were not interested. Eventually, she got a Police group who specialised, and the nurse who was encoraging Suicides was eventually convicted.
Celia Blay persistence saved lives. If there’s any hope in any of these stories, it’s that people like her exist.
The case of Michael Anderson... The only thing about the court proceedings that doesnt sit right with me is that the judge that diagnosed Michael wouldnt allow him to testify. Which lead's me to my next point. Why couldnt they have another doctor do the tests to confirm or disprove whether or not he had aspergers?
Asperger = evilberger
I’m so glad that man got his baby girl back
Thank you for uploading again so I could hear the end!
"Like an orchestra with a single out-of-tune instrument" 💔
Playing an instrument even out of tune, is still super impressive for someone who is dead.