Hi i'm Roja Nur Azizah from class TBI - 20 A and I will answer Oktaviani'question based on what I understand. Another example based on tongue movement is according to the ye-he-ho theory in which they express something based on what comes out of their mouth naturally. Ancient people used to say "yo", "he", "ho" because of the sounds released from the words. the word is very easy to pronounce based on the shape of their mouth (the shape of their mouth is slightly tilted forward) and how they produce the sound. The language in the yo-he-ho theory is also usually used when they do something that must be in groups such as when cutting trees, catching fish in rivers, climbing and others.
Hi Rona My name is Muhammad Arkan Auzan from class TBI A20, i want to answer your question The main reason why there are so many languages has to do with distance and time. Groups of people are always on the move, seeking new opportunities. And languages change over time, too.
My name is Oktaviani. I want to answer your question. Here you are why there are so many different languages in the world. 1. Language Develops in More Than One Location Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It also makes language change over time. The dialects of the migratory groups of humans may develop in different directions, until they finally speak two separate but related languages. 2. War Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war. 3. Geographical Factors Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages. 4. Acoustic Adaptation As a result, it was found that languages originating from warm areas with dense tree cover tended to use less consonants, and conversely, cold regions with sparse trees tended to use higher vowel sounds. In total, it is estimated that acoustic adaptation may be responsible for about a quarter of the variation in the use of vowels and consonants between languages. 5. Rain The researchers found that in Australia, rainfall patterns influenced the number and distribution of Aboriginal languages in the country. In Australia, areas with higher rainfall will be populated by more people, which in turn affects the development of language there.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. Because human were all scatter in the world and have develop language differently to one another that resulted in the many language born differently due to difference in ways of development Thank you
Name: Siti Humairah Class: TBI 20-C According to the Bow-Wow theory our ancestors named things based on their sounds especially when they named animals, which I want to ask, what about the animal's name that is different from the sound it makes? and how do we name inanimate objects?
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I'll try my best to answer your question. There are many theories that are explained, in my opinion because of different theories that's why there are animals name that don't come from their sound. Language must have developed, so language may change. Then what about inanimate objects? In my opinion the answer is almost similar. There are so many theories about the origin of language, so i think people gave a name for inanimate objects just like the theories explain in this video. I'm sorry if there are some mistakes.
Name : Windha Lusiana Class : TBI 20-A Based on the theories that you explained, sir, the languages in this world are many and varied. According to you, apart from regional differences, is there a stronger factor, why does each region have a different language?
Such a nice question Siti Azizah Putri👍👍, but let me answer your question. I'll try my best. I think there is any language that even though it's just a language but has an implied meaning. I mean, like the local language, for example "bahasa banjar". There are many banjar language which is only a language but has an implied meaning, for example "baakal kakanak". "Baakal" is *berakal or pintar* in Bahasa Indonesia and "Kakanak" is *anak-anak* in bahasa Indonesia, which when we comined them, it mean that the children are smarter than us. I'm sorry if there are some mistakes. -from your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
Name : Muhammad Arkan Auzan Class : TBI A20 I still don't know what is it meaning from the start, language has no physical footprint or legacy, what does it mean?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A I'd like to answer your question. It means that there could be no physical legacy of language because at that time humans could not write.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. it means that language does not leave any physical traces of it's development during the age because it came in more naturally than and without any plan of development that can be track directly because you need to hear language not see it other than writing but even then you would not know how to read it without hearing it being said. Thank you
Name : Alfina Fuaidillah Class : TBI A-20 According to the theory that language got from Alien, Can aliens speak? If they could, what kind of language are they speak? Thank you 🙏
Hi Defi! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know. Yes, it is! We can know some theories and statements about where language comes from even though there is no single source that can be the main reference, but from there we can learn that the language we use today is a gift that we can enjoy and use for free. Especially if we as people who like to write and create stories will often find out some languages that we think are cool but other people just know about it. Thank you! Hope you can understand what I mean, cmiiw~
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A Beside of Linguistic learning, the theory of the origin of language is also important to historians and scientists. They need these theories in order to explain an event in the past to be more logical in accordance with science.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A I'd like to ask. 09:50 In Islam, God taught Adam the names of things in the universe when he was in heaven. So, what language did God teach to Adam while he was in heaven? Is it Arabic? Thank you.🙏
i'd like to answr your question ...i am risya aminah wisadia from TBI20A ... i think yes that God teach to Adam arabic language in heaven . because beside on hadist , Rasulullah SAW said : love arabic for three reasonn : i am an arabian, Quran was revealed in arabic and the lannguage of people of paradise is arabic ... so arabic is heaven official language and adam use arabic in heavenn until he down to earth thank you....sorry if there was a mistake
Name : Fatimatuzzahra Hidayah Class : TBI 20 A Yes, Prophet Adam when he came to earth spoke Arabic, because according to some scholars, Arabic is the language of heaven
Hai m noor my name is Nabila and i will try to answer your question. Based on some journal that i already read Nobody knows what language that people speak at jannah, nor the language used by Allah, because He never said anything about it, neither did His Prophet (Muhammad SAW). But there are some hadits that said if arabic language is jannah language (in other words arabic is language that Allah tought to adam)and this hadits has been narrated in any kitab such as al-Mujam al-Ausath created by at-Thabrani, al-Mujam al-Kabir created by at-Thabrani, al-Mustadrak created by al-Hakim, Syuab al-Iman created by al-Baihaqi, Ilal al-Hadits created by Ibnu Abi Hatim, and al-Maudhuat created by Ibnu al-Jauzi, but Imam al-Dzahabi asume if this hadits are maudhu (weak / fake) and Syekh Ibnu Taimiyyah also stated there is no desciption if arabic language is jannah language in Al-Qur'an. CMIIW and thank you!!
Name : Munaihah Sholihah Class : TBI 20 A Of course it will difficult if only use sign languange as a communication. World development will not like now, communication is an important subject for future progress
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A In my opinion, if this happens, then communication will be very difficult because a country may have more than 1 sign language. People from one country will be confused if they have to communicate with other countries because there is no universal language in sign language, unlike the language we usually use, we have English as a universal language.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. I think it would be very difficult because this means communication would very much rely on eyesight that has more limited to the place where our eyes can see. the effect of this would caused humans to never develop past the chimpanzee level of communication or maybe even worse since one of the advantages of communication through hearing is that hearing can be heard even without looking at the person. Thank you
Name : Al Zikri Nur Ramadani Class : TBI 20 A Unlike something that has a visual representation like painting portrait, building, property, or animals skeletons, ancient language doesn't have that. There are no writing because ancient language has existed before human can write and definitely there wasn't any sound recording back then.
Assalamua'alaikum wr.wb Name : Hanifah Amini Class : 20-A TBI In the bow-wow theory our ancestors named things based on their sound especially animals but how they named silent animals? or remain nameless?
Hi Hanifah! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know. So, The “bow wow” theory is the most popular but perhaps the most far-fetched theory of them all. Basically, it is the idea that human language and vocabulary originated as a form of imitation. It is said that language came from the imitation of animal sounds. The overall idea is that one’s language determines how one interprets a sound, and since we have may languages, one cannot prove that human vocabulary comes from them. Also, at that time they think more about how a sound or languages can come from the source so that most people at that time imitated sound untill they know the kind of languages rather than created it. Your question could be related to this. Thank you!~
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. one of the other noise the animal made is not just vocal but also by it's movement or any sound it can make. I'm sorry if there are anything wrong with my answer
Name : Al Zikri Nur Ramadani Class : TBI 20 A According to some of the scientific theory, the words are made by human when they hear something like wind sound or animals sound. So, how did human share these words to a large area, because the language not only spoken by one family or groups but it's spoken by so many people in particular area on earth.
Name : Zulfa Ikhlasiani Class : TBI 20 C what about body language? did ancient humans communicate with body language first before discovering language by speaking? So, is the body language in the past same as the body language used by deaf people now?
Hi zulfa, I want to discuss with you I think you are right, the body language used by deaf people now comes from the body language of ancient people, But, now it is being developed further so that it is becoming more popular and it is more commonly referred to as "sign language".
Hello Zulfa, let me answer it As you said, body language is still used today. Body language is no less important than speaking language. Languange body can help people who have disabilities such as deaf people. Body language can also help psychologists find answers to people's problems in terms of their body language. Body language can also be used as research by psychologists. Body language can be used by someone to find out what someone is feeling.
Name : Risya Aminah Wisadia NIM :200101030638 Class : TBI 20 A does the sign language that we use today for the deaf mute people come from ancient sign language ? .. and is every country sign language different?
Hai Risya, I wanna try to answer your question. Sign language was first taught by a doctor named Geronimo Cardano from Padua, Italy in the 16th century. In fact, no international sign language has yet been successfully implemented. Sign language is unique in its kind in each country. Sign language may differ in countries that speak the same language. For example, the United States and the United Kingdom, although they have the same written language, have completely different sign languages (American Sign Language and British Sign Language). The opposite is also true. There are countries that have different written languages (eg English and Spanish), but use the same sign language.
Nama : Norhasanah Class : TBI 20 A at 9:47 minutes explained In Islam, God taught adam things in the universe when he was in heaven. When Adam got to earth with eva they taught their children the language. Because Adam has many children. That is why Languages are different from each other. how do they get different languages? Does it come from a different way of pronouncing it so that other languages appear? didn't Adam teach them the same?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A In the beginning, humans only had a single language. But, there were a lot of Adam's children, so they migrated separately from each other, their languages will change too, develop to be more complex.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. Adam may teach the his children the same language but then his children would later on move to other places on the earth and the his children would have kids of their own and then teach them but there could possibly some cases in which the father died without teaching their own children everything and then this continued until a new language was born. Thank you
Name : Roja Nur Azizah (200101030758) Class : TBI 20 A The prophet Adam was the first person who was created by Allah SWT, is the language of the prophet Adam and his wife arguably the first language used by humans? Thank you
Oktaviani TBIA 20 However, our recent science and technology still cannot provide empiris data to prove the answers and we also don't have time machine to crosscheck the fact, so to this question I will answer based on my personal opinion. Yes, the language of the prophet Adam and his wife Hawa (Eve) is the first language used by humans, namely Arabic. why Arabic because before the prophet Adam and Eve was revealed on earth they used to live in heaven and in heaven using Arabic as a media of communication. Hope my answer can help you Oja! Thanks in advance
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A I'd like to answer your question. The answer is yes, because Adam was the first human, and Adam was taught a language while he was in heaven. so the first language used by humans is the language used by Adam.
Hi Fitna Aqila I will share you about my opinion I think Physical Adaptation Source and Genetic Source are related to each other. Because Language develops according to human capabilities. Humans who started out were apes who developed into smarter humans. Humans adapt to nature and other humans. Then the human begins to reproduce with a gene which is different in each human being. These genes can be intelligence and body shape. Thank you
Name : Winda Widiyanti Class :Tbi A 20 My question's, There is an evolutionary theory that says that brain development is influenced by the food consumed by humans. Adequate nutrition makes the brain develop optimally, so that language skills also become available. the fact is that animals also have speech anatomy like humans, but why did animals not evolve so that they have the ability to speak like humans?
Hello Winda Widiyanti, this is the answer in my opinion :) I will answer your question, we eat nutritious food such as protein, vitamins that will make the brain develop and so that language skills are available, yes I agree with that nutritious food is good for brain development, as well as Animals they also eat food that is almost the same as us but it doesn't have a language available like ours. In fact, it is certain that animal brains are also developed just like humans. Humans can be smart because they continue to supply knowledge. we can understand language and have good speech skills only in the human race not with animals. same with animals they also can only talk to other animals. and maybe that's the only revolution of every being (Maybe). Different creatures cannot speak the same language to each other. Except for humans who can learn foreign languages in the world, but humans also certainly don't understand animal languages :). then even if the animals whose intelligence exceeds their kind, for example chimpanzees they can not speak our language but they can speak sign language. Like a asking gesture, and the gesture is done because it is taught to them and taught repeatedly. And there are also Parrots who can follow human language. But not all languages can be followed, only words that are always repeated repeatedly and finally they memorize and continue to pronounce them. and many more intelligent animals beyond their kind. and their intelligence because they are taught by humans / their high IQ, like the dolphins for example, this animal is one of the smartest animals in the world.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. the reason why animals don't develop any ability to speak like humans are because most animals did not evolve to have the same organ as humans. The other reason is that possibly animals does not need to speak like humans since they have already perfected their own language. thank you
Hello.. I'm Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A I want to try to answer your question ^^ In the ding-dong theory, human named nature object based on their sounds. This is called the onomatopoeic (the formation of a word from a sound associated with what is named). Maybe, they named water as "srrrrr" , wind as "wuusshh" , and stone that falls as "krak krak". Thank you ^^
Name : Nabila Faizaturrahmah SRN : 200101030165 Class : TBI 20-A Nowadays we have a sign language, is it similiar with the body language that ancient humans use?
Helo Nabila, I want to answer your question Only similar does not mean the same, because the development of the age of sign language also develops for the better and also sign language is the same as body language because our bodies are the main role to express it.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. the reason why many linguist develop their based on the theory of evolution by darwin is because these theorese were develop in the west where the theory of evolution is the go to into explaining anything that had happen in the natural world, especially the ones that happen during the stone age due to how darwin's theory of evolution is the most plausible theory scientifically according to them. I'm sorry if there is anything wrong in my explanation.
Name : Lola Triandita (200101030399) TBI 20-B In the social interaction source theory they make a simple code or sign but Why they do it just when they want to do hunting or marriage?So for daily activities they keep silent without sounds for communication? Thank you🙏
Very different languages can share words (through borrowing) while different speakers of the “same” language may vary widely in their vocabulary due to factors of education or speaking style. Different languages may display the same sentence patterns, while a single language may display a great variety of patterns. :)
Hello, nice to meet you I'm M.Abdillah From TBI A 20, I'd like to answer your question Maybe, language have been developed in more than one place. Humans would speak thousand of different languages. That's because people move and languages change. Of course it is important because it to bind communities and cultures together. It preserve knowledge and connect people to their heritage. That's my answer and I'm sorry if there is a mistake. Thank you
Name: Tasyawwafal Ramadhan 200101030247 TBI B some people say that I'm crazy cuz I always think logically but I feel more relate to science theory than religious theory. Sorry, if this is a silly question but it was on my mind if Adam was the first human what language did he use? in Jews Adam uses divine language and in Islam Adam may use Arabic. I need more explanation about this. thank you, please don't judge me cuz I'm religious but i'll try my best
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I respect your thought or your opinion 👍. So, i want to answer your question with my opinion. I believe in religious theory more than science theory, but i didn't say that science theory is a wrong theory. So, i think that Adam use arabic. Why? Because there is a hadith which says that arabic is the language of the inhabitants of heaven, but this hadith is not shahih. If you can't accept this hadith, then look at prophet Nuh. Prophet Nuh is the closest descendant of the prophet Adam and Prophet Nuh use arabic for talking with people. Thank you and i'm sorry if you still can't understand, i think the best way is to learn with someone that is have knowledge about that👍
Hai tasyawwafal!! my name is Nabila and i will try to answer your question because your question is almost same as m noor's question. Based on some journal that i already read Nobody knows what language that people speak at jannah, nor the language used by Allah, because He never said anything about it, neither did His Prophet (Muhammad SAW). But there are some hadits that said if arabic language is jannah language (in other words arabic is language that Allah tought to adam)and this hadits has been narrated in any kitab such as al-Mujam al-Ausath created by at-Thabrani, al-Mujam al-Kabir created by at-Thabrani, al-Mustadrak created by al-Hakim, Syuab al-Iman created by al-Baihaqi, Ilal al-Hadits created by Ibnu Abi Hatim, and al-Maudhuat created by Ibnu al-Jauzi, but Imam al-Dzahabi asume if this hadits are maudhu (weak / fake) and Syekh Ibnu Taimiyyah also stated there is no desciption if arabic language is jannah language in Al-Qur'an. CMIIW and thank you!!
Hello, my name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. Such an incredible question 👍, i think this is a difficult question, but i'll try my best to answer it. In ancient time the belief system was very strong, so in my opinion our ancestors only followed the power of belief, so they are easy to be manipulated by something (including alien)
Name : Rona Nur Azzahra 200101030046 TBI 20 B "According to noam chomsky, human speech mau have appeared between 200,000 - 100, 000 years ago (before that we mau use sign language)" so, What if before the appeared sign language there was someone who didn't have both hands or was disabled at that time, could he communicate using the sign language? Thank You 🙏
Name: Tasyawwafal Ramadhan 200101030247 TBI B It's hard to answer your question but let me try answer it with my thoughts. maybe they have their own language which cannot be understood unless each other like a dog barking and fellow dogs might understand the meaning, or he/she could also do it with a facial expression. Thank you, I hope you get it what I meant
Name: Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi Class: TBI 20 A In the Bow-Wow theory, humans at that time named object around them especially animals based on the sounds that they (the object) produce. So what's the difference between the Bow-Wow and the Ding-Dong theory? Considering the Ding-Dong theory also states that humans named objects based on their sounds.
Hi, I'm Siti Azizah Puteri from Class A 2020 and I'll help Azmi to answer his question based on what I know. The difference between the Bow-Wow and the Ding-Dong theory are the Ding-Dong theory focused on origins of language based on what things sounded like, and the Bow-Wow theory focused on imitation. For example : In the Bow-Wow theory, Bow-Wow is the dog sound and Miaow is the cat's sound. Basically, it is the idea that human language and vocabulary originated as a form of imitation. It is said that language came from the imitation of animal sounds. In the Ding-Dong theory, bases the origins of language on onomatopoeia. This idea states that language began when humans started naming objects after a relevant sound that was already involved in their everyday life. Examples include words such as “boom,” “crash,” and “oink.”
Name : Alfaridzi Zulkarnain Class : TBI A 20 "For the Putting the Baby Down Theory, To stop stop their babies crying they created sounds. What kind of sounds that they make?"
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. I believe that is possible that they start making random noises until there is one that makes the baby calm down and keep using that. Thank you
Name : Sulthan Maysuja Setiawan Class: TBI 20 A SRN : 200101030185 about my question, is there any specific reason or history why Ding-dong theory is named, well, "ding-dong" theory ?
From what i know, why it called "ding-dong theory" because "ding-dong" it's a sound of bells ringing. Why is it from a bell? In my opinion it's because this theory explain that "humans named everything around them at that time based on sound that they got". So, i think that's why it called "Ding-dong" theory. Maybe the one that made this theory hear the sound of a bells ringing, when thinking about this theory. Thank you and i'm sorry if you still don't understand my explanation. -From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. the reason as to why it is called the ding dong theory is because this theory explains how inanimate object make a sound because of this it is compared to the bell that sometimes only called ding dong. Thank you
Name : arlina Fauziah class : TBI 20 B sorry for my delay in asking because yesterday i came home and did not get a good signal until this morning. permission to ask sir, in the hindi theory it is explained that language was made by sarasvati, what is the supporting theory that makes them believe this?
Hi let me let me give you an opinion... In my opinion, this theory is still unclear and there is no solid evidence that it is true. Because we all know that Sarasvati is one of the spiritual figures in Hinduism Who seems like a mythical character whose truth is not proven Imo, it's not about their beliefs about research scientists, it's more about their beliefs about their own religion. *Cmiiw
Actually, there is a study that conclude if people named object that they found based on name that they want, for the example rafflesia arnoldi that named by 2 person names (Dr. Joseph Arnold and sir Thomas Stamford Rafles).reffering to this question, in my opinion someone can named everything around them just based on sound that they got because the sound familiar and people easier to remember something that always they hear/ familiar with their ear such as “mengetok” that comes from sound of hitting our hand (tok tok) while hitting the door. CMIIW
I will try to answer it Before language was discovered, it was thought that humans communicated using sounds produced by their mouths and through body movements only. Then the human brain evolved and developed so that it could understand more difficult things. Humans then began to name objects, food, until a situation became a word that was easy to pronounce and was thought to mimic the sound source of the object. After that, slowly humans can speak by combining 2 different words, and then develop into language. Meanwhile, the diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors.
Name : Putri Maulida Rahmah Class : TBI 20-A As we know that every country has a different language and the theory that has been explained make me think that the languages spoken are different, but actually there are similar languages even though they are from different countries, for example Indonesia and Malaysia. So, why are there countries that have similar languages? Thank you.
Nama : Roja Nur Azizah (200101030758) Class : TBI - 20 A I want to answer Putri's question based on my understanding. Why are Indonesian and Malaysian languages almost the same? That's because Indonesian and Malaysian come from a language family (in Indonesian we say "rumpun bahasa" ) , namely Austronesian languages, The Austronesian language family (or sometimes called the "island language") is a language family that is very widespread in the world. From Taiwan and Hawaii in the far north to New Zealand (Aotearoa) in the far south and from Madagascar in the far west to Easter Island (Rapanui) in the far east. That is why Indonesian and Malaysian languages are almost similar.
Hai Putri! Allow me to answer your question :D Because it comes from the same language family, namely the Austronesian language. Then, why is the Malay language the foundation of Indonesian? In 1931, the Dutch conducted a language survey which resulted in the fact that Malay is only spoken by 500,000 people spread across the archipelago. Even though they are few, Malay speakers are spread all over Indonesia. For example, Loloan Malay in Bali, Amenan Malay in NTB, Larantuka Malay in NTT, Ambonese Malay in Maluku, Papuan Malay in Papua, Betawi Malay in Java, and various Malay languages on the islands of Sumatra and Kalimantan. In addition, the Malay language is also used in other nations such as Malaysia, Brunei Darussalam, and Singapore so as to facilitate bilateral relations between countries in Southeast Asia. Unlike the Javanese language whose speakers are only scattered on the island of Java.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20A I'd like to answer your question. In my opinion, some countries, some whose languages are similar, it is caused by: 1. These countries are geographically close together so that there will be acculturation of language and culture. 2. The occurrence of war, for example the Dutch who colonized Indonesia for centuries so that many words in Indonesia were absorbed from the Dutch language. 3. international trade, such as Arabs who trade in Indonesia, this causes many Arabic words to be absorbed into Indonesian.
Name : Maulida Hasanah SRN : 200101030492 Class : TBI 20 C I want to ask is there any evidence to support the theory of the assumption that language got from Aliens? Thank you🙏
Hello, I'm Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A If we look at it from an Islamic perspective, the first language in this world is Arabic. Because the language of heaven is Arabic and the prophet Adam was the first human being sent down from heaven, so he used Arabic. And also, because of that, so the mother of all languages is Arabic language. Thank you ^-^
Name : Muhammad Amienullah (200101030502) Class : 20C Tbi Putting the baby down theory About language!!! if the mother tongue soothes her crying child in her arms. Does that apply to all mothers in the world or only certain mothers?
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I'll try my best to answer your question and my answer is based on my perspective. For question number one, there are many theories that our lecturer explained, such as physical adaptation theory, genetic source theory, and natural sound source theory, etc. You can find more in this video. For question number two, in my opinion it's important to know where words come from, because if someone ask me or my students ask me (because maybe, i'll be a teacher in the future) and i don't know the answer, i'll be embarrassed definitely, especially i'm a college student and i'm studying it. But if i don't study about it and i'm not a college student, i think it's still important. I can increase my knowledge.
Name: Safa Class: Tbi c 20 I still can't understand about bow-wow and miaow, why are they make the bow-wow that called dog, and miaow called Cat? why don't they just tell it a bow-wow and a miaow??
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. Actually it's a little difficult to understand your question, but i'll try to answer from my understanding. My understanding is that you have more than one question and the answers will be different but still related to each other. For your question, why they called dog (bow-wow) and cat (miaow), because our ancestors at that time made language from the sounds of animals they heard. But if your question why people these days called a bow-wow is a dog and a miaow is a cat, it's because language has developed and languages in the world are different. I'm sorry if my understanding isn't right.
Name : Siti Marhamah Nim : 200101030816 Class : TBI 20 B ancestors create the language from their interaction with nature. How they named the nature that does not produce sounds such as mountains, caves, rocks and so forth ?🙏🏻
In my opinion it's a normal thing. You can understand that language but you don't or you can't speak it. Actually there are so many people i have met and they can understand some languages but they don't or can't speak in that language. If you ask why? Actually it's about their self confidence. Most of this problem is caused because of their lack self confidence. For example, i have one friend and he can understand really well when i speak in english, but he always gives me a response with indonesian language. So, i asked him why? And he said "I can't speak in english, but i can understand, i just feel embarrassed when i have to speak in english". I hope that you can understand my explanation, i'm sorry if you still can't understand. I try my best. Thank you. -From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
it is very possible, we can understand a language only by hearing the language continuously, like in the case of a baby who is about 8 months old. he understood but could not speak the language.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20A I'd like to answer your question We can understand a language without speaking. It calls receptive skills. Passive foreign language users are also referred to as receptive skills, someone who has receptive skills can respond and understand foreign languages passively as indicated by listening and reading skills that are more dominant than writing and speaking skills.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known. the way to understand a language without speaking it is to see their gesture, movement, and behavior to a certain extent. Thank you
Name : Nursyifa Ahyana SRN : 200101030415 Class : TBI 20 C Chomsky claims that human has Language Acquisition Device (LAD), so, my question is: does each human have a different LAD?
Hi Nursyifa! I think each human have a different LAD. The LAD concept is a purported instinctive mental capacity which enables an infant to acquire and produce language. It is a component of the nativist theory of language. This theory asserts that humans are born with the instinct or "innate facility" for acquiring language. The main argument given in favor of the LAD was the argument from the poverty of the stimulus, which argues that unless children have significant innate knowledge of grammar, they would not be able to learn language as quickly as they do, given that they never have access to negative evidence and rarely receive direct instruction in their first language. A summary explaining LAD by Chomsky states that languages are infinite pertaining to the sequence of word forms (strings) and grammar. These word forms organize grammatically correct sequences of words that can be pooled over a limited lexicon of each independent language. So, LAD is tasked to select from an infinite number of grammars the one which is correct for the language that is presented to an individual, for example, a child.
according to the information i have read. Every child has LAD since birth. This is evidenced by various discoveries such as those made by Howard Gardner. He said that since birth, children are equipped with various intelligences. One of the intelligences in question is language intelligence
Name: Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid Class: TBI 20 A Is there any trace or example of the daa daa and ding dong theory in today's language? because even if we look at the most primitive language that still existed now (at least that I know of) there are no such things.
Hi Harun! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know. Yes, there is! For example related to Ta-Ta theory, when we meet someone who is deaf, we usually often use body gestures to express something for them. Like, how we greet each other, we can use hand movement or body gesture even when we can't use international body language. And to the Ding-Dong theory, more often used by any mothers to teach their toddlers about the sounds or language of animals. So they can speak and know the language. Thank you!~
Name : Novi Wahyu Oktaviana (200101030045) Class : TBI 20-B What is the more specific understanding of "Putting the Baby Down Theory"? And what are its main characteristics?
There’s also a theory that language evolved when early humans lost the fur that let babies cling to their mothers - the ‘putting the baby down theory’ speculates that parent and infant would have more need to communicate when perpetual physical contact was abandoned.
Name : M.Abdillah Class : A 20 TBI Noam Chomsky claim that just human has Language Acquisition Device (LAD), but why in ancient time like what I saw on TV human just said, "gogo gaga", "Hoo haa hu" ? That's my question 🙏
Let me answer that, i think pre-historic human in TV are just some fiction writing, i mean like there's no proof that there's human speak like that, so they might just made those up for entertainment on TV.
Name : Rizqa Sahlaa Azqia SRN : 200101030807 Class : TBI 20 C how can humans recognize that it is the sound of an animal for example a cat with only a meow sound? can you explain more detail please?
Name : Fatimatuzzahra Hidayah Class : TBI 20 A I want to ask who created the theory for the first time there is a language created from aliens? can aliens speak?
Hello Fatimatuzzahra. I want to answer you second question "can aliens speak?". Until now, we still don't know if aliens really exist or not. Actually i don't know how our ancestors know about aliens, but if we think again, our ancestors had a strong belief system, where our ancestors would easily believe something. But it's different from our generation, we don't believe easily. So, if you ask if aliens can speak or not, i think there are two answers. First answer is aliens can speak if you want to believe it and second answer is aliens can't speak if you don't want to believe it. I think it's depend on you. I'm sorry if my explanation is wrong for you, but that's my opinion and my thought and i try my best. -From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
I will try to answer your question Who created the theory for the first time? In 1861, the historian of language Max Müller published a list of speculative theories of the origin of language. There are Bow-wow, Pooh-pooh, Ding-dong, and Yo-he-ho. Can Aliens speak? Astronomy experts from ITB judge L Malasan said there were several things that needed to be straightened out from extraterrestrial life. Scientists generally do not believe in aliens or UFOs because there is no scientific evidence of life in outer space so far, which is believed to be organisms, bacteria, single-celled animals, etc. But in my opinion, can aliens talk I would say "yes" because creatures must have the means of communication to do some work. I hope this help for you. Thanks
Hi Rahmawati, let me share a little opinion🙏 Alien languages, i.e. languages of extraterrestrial beings, are a hypothetical subject since none have been encountered so far. The research in these hypothetical languages is variously called exolinguistics, xenolinguistics or astrolinguistics. The question of what form alien languages might take and the possibility for humans to recognize and translate them has been part of the linguistics and language studies courses, e.g., at the Bowling Green State University (2001). Noam Chomsky (1983), basing on his theory of the existence of a genetically-predetermined universal grammar of human languages, holds that it would be impossible for a human to naturally learn an alien language because it would most probably violate the universal grammar inborn in humans. Humans would have to study an alien language by the slow way of discovery, the same way as scientists do research in, say, physics. Linguist Keren Rice posits that basic communication between humans and aliens should be possible, unless "the things that we think are common to languages-situating in time [and] space, talking about participants, etc.-are so radically different that the human language provides no starting point for it." Jessica Coon, a professor of linguistics at McGill University, was consulted for the linguistic aspect of the 2016 film Arrival. While acknowledging that the graphical language in the film was art without linguistic meaning, she stated that the film was a fairly accurate portrayal of the approach human linguists would use in trying to understand an alien language. actually, I don't really understand about this theory, but I just tried it. #cmiiw :)
Hi Rahmawati My answer is the same but i have shorter answer. Alien languages, i.e., languages of extraterrestrial beings, are a hypothetical subject since none have been encountered so far. The research in these hypothetical languages is variously called exolinguistics, xenolinguistics or astrolinguistics. The question of what form alien languages might take and the possibility for humans to recognize and translate them has been part of the linguistics and language studies courses, e.g., at the Bowling Green State University (2001). Noam Chomsky (1983), basing on his theory of the existence of a genetically-predetermined universal grammar of human languages, holds that it would be impossible for a human to naturally learn an alien language because it would most probably violate the universal grammar inborn in humans. Humans would have to study an alien language by the slow way of discovery, the same way as scientists do research in, say, physics.
Name : Alfiana Azizah SRN : 200101030648 Class: TBI 20C Hello, this is my question that seems difficult, from what I read in the world there are ± 7000 languages in the world. So how come there are so many different languages in the world? there are several languages with the same pronunciation or the same accent, and likely languages that are similar to that of a similar race / similar race. So how come there are so many languages in the world?
Hi Alfiana, let me introduce my self, My name is Nabila Putri Endah, According from article that i read there are many factor that made different language in this world one of them is based from geography factor for the example mountain, forest and river made Papua New Guinea become many small group (tribe), these groups have been around from long time ago and because of the split of Papua New Guinea group make they develope variety different language, next for similar language with the same pronounciation, it because there are some country that take other country languages from colonization, immigration and trade such as English langugae that consist of 30% original English and 35% Latin, Greek, and French language. CMIIW
Haiii azizah, let me give you an opinion on your question There are so many different languages in the world. These languages cannot be equated or be harmonized into one language only because there are many differences in culture and customs in each country. The background of language creation in each country also varies, depending on the characteristics of the country itself. And also depending on their daily habits. *cmiiw
Hi Alfiana. I will try answer it Before language was discovered, it was thought that humans communicated using sounds produced by their mouths and through body movements only. Then the human brain evolved and developed so that it could understand more difficult things. Humans then began to name objects, food, until a situation became a word that was easy to pronounce and was thought to mimic the sound source of the object. After that, slowly humans can speak by combining 2 different words, and then develop into language. Meanwhile, the diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors. At that time, our ancestors migrated to various countries in the world in search of food sources. Well, this cultural isolation has made the emergence of a different language in each country adapted to the natural conditions, food and other living things around it. This isolation causes the language in each country or region to be different. This also happens in Indonesia, lo, which is an archipelago, so that Indonesians are increasingly isolated in the areas where they live. This is why Indonesia has a language that is very diverse and also different in each region. Then when 2 groups came from 2 different places, the languages they had then mingled into one. This language blending then led to the creation of a new language, here, and it is called the super language or super language. Because of this the distance factor also influences the formation of language. For example, countries that are close together usually tend to have the same name for an object, such as between Indonesia and Malaysia.
Name: putri ayu andini Class: Tbi 20 b Answer: Could language be older than our species? Ancient DNA reveals us to be over 99% identical in the sequences of our protein coding genes to our sister species the Neanderthals (Homo neanderthalensis). The Neanderthals had large brains and were able to inhabit much of Eurasia from around 350,000 years ago. If the Neanderthals had language, that would place its origin at least as far back as the time of our common ancestor with them, currently thought to be around 550,000 to 750,000 years ago.
Name ; Norzaitun Nisa SRN : 200101030672 Class : TBI 20 C what about the sign language used by people with special needs, is there a history for this language? Thank u 💜🙏
Hello, I am Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A Actually, this is still a matter of debate among researchers. However, from several written records, some people think that Juan Pablo de Bonet was the person who invented sign language. In the year 1620, Bonet wrote a book that contained the first known manual alphabet system. The handshapes in this system represented different speech sounds. Need to be remember, Pablo was the first "recorded" person to discover sign language. Before that time, maybe there was many sign language that have invented, but it's just not recorded in history because of its development which is only around the society where humans at that time live. Thank you, I hope this can help you ^^
Name : Nur Hayati (200101030783) Class : TBI 20 C Question : What if a deaf baby was born?What kind of language that they use to communicate with? Because language is basically made by a sound/voice? Thx 😊
Name :Muhammad Al Habib NIM : 200101030398 Class : TBI_C hello friends here the creation of a language in ancient times using the sound of these objects ... here there is still something to make you confused whether the creation of a language in this world, was born because there are certain tribes? did the tribal leader create the language and teach it to others ?? so they can talk to each other ... thank you
My name is Novi Wahyu Oktaviana (200101030045). TBI 20-B. According to my understanding, humans speak or make language with emotionally, it is because if something happens in human life suddenly, it will spontaneously appear. In other words, the language with which emotions are spoken is an automatic or spontaneous response that cannot be controlled. Like fear, anger, pain and stuff. That's all I'm saying, please forgive me for any mistakes or flaws🙏
Hello fatimah My name is Norzaitun Nisa Class C I will answer ur question The diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors. At that time, our ancestors migrated to various countries in the world in search of food sources.
Languages can differ in many ways. They may use different sounds, they may make words in different ways, they may put words together to form a sentence in different ways, and that’s just for starters! When we talk about a ‘language’ we mean the act of speaking, writing or signing.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A I'd like to answer your question. There are 3 factors that might explain your question. 1. Language Develops in More Than One Location Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It makes language change over time. 2. War Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language become extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war. 3. Geographic factor . Language turns out to be unevenly distributed due to geographical factors of an area, you know Squad. For example, Europe has about 225 indigenous languages, while Papua New Guinea which is smaller than Europe has at least 820 languages! Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages.
Name : Muhammad Syahri SRN : 200101030299 Class : TBI 20-C In islam, don't we come from Adam's descendants who use one language, but now why do humans use many languages in this world?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A In the beginning, humans had a single language. Well, there were a lot of Adam's children, so they migrated separately from each other, their languages will change too, develop to be more complex. Thank you 🙏
Name: Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi Class: TBI 20 A Sorry if I couldn't answer this with Islamic source. But I found one information about why the languages in this world are different based on Christian view. In the Bible, Genesis 11: 6-9 6. The Lord said, “If as one people speaking the same language, they have begun to do this, then nothing they plan to do will be impossible for them. 7. Come, let us go down and confuse their language so they will not understand each other.” 8. So the Lord scattered them from there over all the earth, and they stopped building the city. 9. That is why it was called Babel because there the Lord confused the language of the whole world. This was a punishment from God because of the pride and arrogance of the Babylonians at that time who thought they could match God's power. Thank You 🙏😀
When Adam got to the earth with his wife Hawa (Eva) they taught their children their languange. Because of Adam's children are a lot. That's why make language are differences from One another
Hi syahri, i'm nabila and i want to try answering your question. There are many causes of many language in thos world, such as immigration, language develope in more than one location, geofrafic factor, and accoustic factor. CMIIW and thank youuu!!
Hi guys My Name is Nabila Putri Endah (170102031167) here i want to ask “ is it legal to make other country language become our language? Give me the reason” thank you guyss!!
Assalamualaikum wr.wb Name : Elma Azzahrah SRN : 200101030096 Class : TBI 20 C After seeing the many theories of the emergence of a language mentioned above, my question is whether to get a language today there have been many changes in vocabulary and word pronunciation that have occurred from ancient times to the present? Or just change it a little to improve the current vocabulary? Thank you🙏
Name : Annisa Alkautsar Class : TBI 20 A there are so many kinds of languages that exist in the world. Why can every country have a different language?
Name : Munaihah Sholihah Class : TBI 20 A in islam, god taught adam the names of things in the universe when he was in heaven. Then adam go to the earth with hawa. They taught children their languange. Because of Adam's children are lot that's why languange is difference from one and another. But it can be because many factor such as migration, geograpic, war, and social factors
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin Class: TBI 20 A The language in this world actually comes from one main language. The main language developed due to various factors so that eventually the language developed and the pronunciation in each world was different. Besides that, from one region to another there are different variations and different situations. As a result, region A or region B have differences in terms of pronunciation, environment or language in mentioning something.
My name is Oktaviani. I want to answer your question. Here you are why there are so many different languages in the world. 1. Language Develops in More Than One Location Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It also makes language change over time. The dialects of the migratory groups of humans may develop in different directions, until they finally speak two separate but related languages. 2. War Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war. 3. Geographical Factors Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages. 4. Acoustic Adaptation As a result, it was found that languages originating from warm areas with dense tree cover tended to use less consonants, and conversely, cold regions with sparse trees tended to use higher vowel sounds. In total, it is estimated that acoustic adaptation may be responsible for about a quarter of the variation in the use of vowels and consonants between languages. 5. Rain The researchers found that in Australia, rainfall patterns influenced the number and distribution of Aboriginal languages in the country. In Australia, areas with higher rainfall will be populated by more people, which in turn affects the development of language there.
Very helpful
Waduh om mantap
Makasih aa alip, mantap bisa ngerti aja kalo lah isi kontennya aa alip
Name: Oktaviani
Class: TBI A20
Is there an example of a language based on synchronization of body movement and tongue movement?
Hi i'm Roja Nur Azizah from class TBI - 20 A and I will answer Oktaviani'question based on what I understand.
Another example based on tongue movement is according to the ye-he-ho theory in which they express something based on what comes out of their mouth naturally. Ancient people used to say "yo", "he", "ho" because of the sounds released from the words. the word is very easy to pronounce based on the shape of their mouth (the shape of their mouth is slightly tilted forward) and how they produce the sound.
The language in the yo-he-ho theory is also usually used when they do something that must be in groups such as when cutting trees, catching fish in rivers, climbing and others.
What do you think is the importance of knowing linguistic theories in language teaching?
It's related to the content knowledge, pedagogy knowledge, pedagogy content knowledge and so on.
Name : Rona Salsabila
Class : TBI 20 A
How come there are so many different languages in the world?
Hi Rona
My name is Muhammad Arkan Auzan from class TBI A20, i want to answer your question
The main reason why there are so many languages has to do with distance and time. Groups of people are always on the move, seeking new opportunities. And languages change over time, too.
My name is Oktaviani. I want to answer your question. Here you are why there are so many different languages in the world.
1. Language Develops in More Than One Location
Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It also makes language change over time. The dialects of the migratory groups of humans may develop in different directions, until they finally speak two separate but related languages.
2. War
Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war.
3. Geographical Factors
Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages.
4. Acoustic Adaptation
As a result, it was found that languages originating from warm areas with dense tree cover tended to use less consonants, and conversely, cold regions with sparse trees tended to use higher vowel sounds. In total, it is estimated that acoustic adaptation may be responsible for about a quarter of the variation in the use of vowels and consonants between languages.
5. Rain
The researchers found that in Australia, rainfall patterns influenced the number and distribution of Aboriginal languages in the country. In Australia, areas with higher rainfall will be populated by more people, which in turn affects the development of language there.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
Because human were all scatter in the world and have develop language differently to one another that resulted in the many language born differently due to difference in ways of development
Thank you
Name: Siti Humairah
Class: TBI 20-C
According to the Bow-Wow theory our ancestors named things based on their sounds especially when they named animals, which I want to ask, what about the animal's name that is different from the sound it makes? and how do we name inanimate objects?
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I'll try my best to answer your question.
There are many theories that are explained, in my opinion because of different theories that's why there are animals name that don't come from their sound. Language must have developed, so language may change. Then what about inanimate objects? In my opinion the answer is almost similar. There are so many theories about the origin of language, so i think people gave a name for inanimate objects just like the theories explain in this video.
I'm sorry if there are some mistakes.
Name : Windha Lusiana
Class : TBI 20-A
Based on the theories that you explained, sir, the languages in this world are many and varied. According to you, apart from regional differences, is there a stronger factor, why does each region have a different language?
Name : Siti Azizah Puteri
Class : TBI A 20
Is there any language that maybe have an implied meaning even though it is only a language?
Such a nice question Siti Azizah Putri👍👍, but let me answer your question. I'll try my best.
I think there is any language that even though it's just a language but has an implied meaning. I mean, like the local language, for example "bahasa banjar". There are many banjar language which is only a language but has an implied meaning, for example "baakal kakanak". "Baakal" is *berakal or pintar* in Bahasa Indonesia and "Kakanak" is *anak-anak* in bahasa Indonesia, which when we comined them, it mean that the children are smarter than us.
I'm sorry if there are some mistakes. -from your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
Name : Muhammad Arkan Auzan
Class : TBI A20
I still don't know what is it meaning from the start, language has no physical footprint or legacy, what does it mean?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
I'd like to answer your question.
It means that there could be no physical legacy of language because at that time humans could not write.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
it means that language does not leave any physical traces of it's development during the age because it came in more naturally than and without any plan of development that can be track directly because you need to hear language not see it other than writing but even then you would not know how to read it without hearing it being said.
Thank you
Name : Alfina Fuaidillah
Class : TBI A-20
According to the theory that language got from Alien, Can aliens speak? If they could, what kind of language are they speak?
Thank you 🙏
Name : Al Zikri Nur Ramadani
Class : TBI 20 A
There's no real evidence of alien existence. So there's no way to find out what language they speak.
Name : Defi Nor Izati
Class : TBI A-20
Regarding the theory presented, is there any benefit in the present period outside of linguistic learning?
Hi Defi! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know.
Yes, it is! We can know some theories and statements about where language comes from even though there is no single source that can be the main reference, but from there we can learn that the language we use today is a gift that we can enjoy and use for free. Especially if we as people who like to write and create stories will often find out some languages that we think are cool but other people just know about it.
Thank you! Hope you can understand what I mean, cmiiw~
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
Beside of Linguistic learning, the theory of the origin of language is also important to historians and scientists. They need these theories in order to explain an event in the past to be more logical in accordance with science.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
I'd like to ask.
09:50 In Islam, God taught Adam the names of things in the universe when he was in heaven. So, what language did God teach to Adam while he was in heaven? Is it Arabic?
Thank you.🙏
i'd like to answr your question ...i am risya aminah wisadia from TBI20A ...
i think yes that God teach to Adam arabic language in heaven . because beside on hadist , Rasulullah SAW said : love arabic for three reasonn : i am an arabian, Quran was revealed in arabic and the lannguage of people of paradise is arabic ...
so arabic is heaven official language and adam use arabic in heavenn until he down to earth
thank you....sorry if there was a mistake
@@risyaaminahwisadia7119 thank you, it's clear. 👍
Name : Fatimatuzzahra Hidayah
Class : TBI 20 A
Yes, Prophet Adam when he came to earth spoke Arabic, because according to some scholars, Arabic is the language of heaven
Hai m noor my name is Nabila and i will try to answer your question. Based on some journal that i already read Nobody knows what language that people speak at jannah, nor the language used by Allah, because He never said anything about it, neither did His Prophet (Muhammad SAW). But there are some hadits that said if arabic language is jannah language (in other words arabic is language that Allah tought to adam)and this hadits has been narrated in any kitab such as al-Mujam al-Ausath created by at-Thabrani, al-Mujam al-Kabir created by at-Thabrani, al-Mustadrak created by al-Hakim, Syuab al-Iman created by al-Baihaqi, Ilal al-Hadits created by Ibnu Abi Hatim, and al-Maudhuat created by Ibnu al-Jauzi, but Imam al-Dzahabi asume if this hadits are maudhu (weak / fake) and Syekh Ibnu Taimiyyah also stated there is no desciption if arabic language is jannah language in Al-Qur'an. CMIIW and thank you!!
Name : M.Abdillah
Class : A 20 TBI
Is there the strongest theory that justifies how the origin of language was discovered?
Name: Oktaviani
Class: TBI A
What do you think if in this world only using sign language as communication?
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20 A
Of course it will difficult if only use sign languange as a communication. World development will not like now, communication is an important subject for future progress
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
In my opinion, if this happens, then communication will be very difficult because a country may have more than 1 sign language. People from one country will be confused if they have to communicate with other countries because there is no universal language in sign language, unlike the language we usually use, we have English as a universal language.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
I think it would be very difficult because this means communication would very much rely on eyesight that has more limited to the place where our eyes can see. the effect of this would caused humans to never develop past the chimpanzee level of communication or maybe even worse since one of the advantages of communication through hearing is that hearing can be heard even without looking at the person.
Thank you
Name : Ayunda Febriyani Trayumada
Class : TBI 20-B
why language has no physical footprint or legacy?
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20-A
Because languange it is not like something that can we hold or see
Thank you
Hi Ayunda, here I want to answer your question
I think maybe we don't have a time machine to find an explanation about it
Name : Al Zikri Nur Ramadani
Class : TBI 20 A
Unlike something that has a visual representation like painting portrait, building, property, or animals skeletons, ancient language doesn't have that. There are no writing because ancient language has existed before human can write and definitely there wasn't any sound recording back then.
Assalamua'alaikum wr.wb
Name : Hanifah Amini
Class : 20-A TBI
In the bow-wow theory our ancestors named things based on their sound especially animals but how they named silent animals? or remain nameless?
Hi Hanifah! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know.
So, The “bow wow” theory is the most popular but perhaps the most far-fetched theory of them all. Basically, it is the idea that human language and vocabulary originated as a form of imitation. It is said that language came from the imitation of animal sounds.
The overall idea is that one’s language determines how one interprets a sound, and since we have may languages, one cannot prove that human vocabulary comes from them. Also, at that time they think more about how a sound or languages can come from the source so that most people at that time imitated sound untill they know the kind of languages rather than created it.
Your question could be related to this. Thank you!~
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
one of the other noise the animal made is not just vocal but also by it's movement or any sound it can make.
I'm sorry if there are anything wrong with my answer
Name : Al Zikri Nur Ramadani
Class : TBI 20 A
According to some of the scientific theory, the words are made by human when they hear something like wind sound or animals sound. So, how did human share these words to a large area, because the language not only spoken by one family or groups but it's spoken by so many people in particular area on earth.
Name : Zulfa Ikhlasiani
Class : TBI 20 C
what about body language? did ancient humans communicate with body language first before discovering language by speaking?
So, is the body language in the past same as the body language used by deaf people now?
Hi zulfa, I want to discuss with you
I think you are right, the body language used by deaf people now comes from the body language of ancient people,
But, now it is being developed further so that it is becoming more popular and it is more commonly referred to as "sign language".
Hello Zulfa, let me answer it
As you said, body language is still used today. Body language is no less important than speaking language. Languange body can help people who have disabilities such as deaf people. Body language can also help psychologists find answers to people's problems in terms of their body language. Body language can also be used as research by psychologists. Body language can be used by someone to find out what someone is feeling.
Name : Risya Aminah Wisadia
NIM :200101030638
Class : TBI 20 A
does the sign language that we use today for the deaf mute people come from ancient sign language ? .. and is every country sign language different?
Hai Risya, I wanna try to answer your question.
Sign language was first taught by a doctor named Geronimo Cardano from Padua, Italy in the 16th century.
In fact, no international sign language has yet been successfully implemented. Sign language is unique in its kind in each country. Sign language may differ in countries that speak the same language. For example, the United States and the United Kingdom, although they have the same written language, have completely different sign languages (American Sign Language and British Sign Language). The opposite is also true. There are countries that have different written languages (eg English and Spanish), but use the same sign language.
Nama : Norhasanah
Class : TBI 20 A
at 9:47 minutes explained In Islam, God taught adam things in the universe when he was in heaven. When Adam got to earth with eva they taught their children the language. Because Adam has many children. That is why Languages are different from each other.
how do they get different languages? Does it come from a different way of pronouncing it so that other languages appear? didn't Adam teach them the same?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
In the beginning, humans only had a single language. But, there were a lot of Adam's children, so they migrated separately from each other, their languages will change too, develop to be more complex.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
Adam may teach the his children the same language but then his children would later on move to other places on the earth and the his children would have kids of their own and then teach them but there could possibly some cases in which the father died without teaching their own children everything and then this continued until a new language was born.
Thank you
Name : Roja Nur Azizah (200101030758)
Class : TBI 20 A
The prophet Adam was the first person who was created by Allah SWT, is the language of the prophet Adam and his wife arguably the first language used by humans?
Thank you
Oktaviani
TBIA 20
However, our recent science and technology still cannot provide empiris data to prove the answers and we also don't have time machine to crosscheck the fact, so to this question I will answer based on my personal opinion.
Yes, the language of the prophet Adam and his wife Hawa (Eve) is the first language used by humans, namely Arabic. why Arabic because before the prophet Adam and Eve was revealed on earth they used to live in heaven and in heaven using Arabic as a media of communication.
Hope my answer can help you Oja!
Thanks in advance
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
I'd like to answer your question.
The answer is yes, because Adam was the first human, and Adam was taught a language while he was in heaven. so the first language used by humans is the language used by Adam.
Fitna Aqila Salsabila (200101030162)
TBI 20-B
Are the two theories 'Physical Adaptation Source' and 'Genetic Source' related to each other?
Hi Fitna Aqila
I will share you about my opinion
I think Physical Adaptation Source and Genetic Source are related to each other. Because Language develops according to human capabilities. Humans who started out were apes who developed into smarter humans. Humans adapt to nature and other humans. Then the human begins to reproduce with a gene which is different in each human being. These genes can be intelligence and body shape.
Thank you
Name : Winda Widiyanti
Class :Tbi A 20
My question's, There is an evolutionary theory that says that brain development is influenced by the food consumed by humans. Adequate nutrition makes the brain develop optimally, so that language skills also become available. the fact is that animals also have speech anatomy like humans, but why did animals not evolve so that they have the ability to speak like humans?
Hello Winda Widiyanti, this is the answer in my opinion :)
I will answer your question, we eat nutritious food such as protein, vitamins that will make the brain develop and so that language skills are available, yes I agree with that nutritious food is good for brain development, as well as Animals they also eat food that is almost the same as us but it doesn't have a language available like ours.
In fact, it is certain that animal brains are also developed just like humans. Humans can be smart because they continue to supply knowledge. we can understand language and have good speech skills only in the human race not with animals. same with animals they also can only talk to other animals. and maybe that's the only revolution of every being (Maybe). Different creatures cannot speak the same language to each other. Except for humans who can learn foreign languages in the world, but humans also certainly don't understand animal languages :).
then even if the animals whose intelligence exceeds their kind, for example chimpanzees they can not speak our language but they can speak sign language. Like a asking gesture, and the gesture is done because it is taught to them and taught repeatedly.
And there are also Parrots who can follow human language. But not all languages can be followed, only words that are always repeated repeatedly and finally they memorize and continue to pronounce them. and many more intelligent animals beyond their kind. and their intelligence because they are taught by humans / their high IQ, like the dolphins for example, this animal is one of the smartest animals in the world.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
the reason why animals don't develop any ability to speak like humans are because most animals did not evolve to have the same organ as humans. The other reason is that possibly animals does not need to speak like humans since they have already perfected their own language.
thank you
Name: Safa
Class: Tbi C 20
so at the ding-dong theory is nature sound, how could they named sound of water, wind, stone falls down with those names?
Hello.. I'm Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A
I want to try to answer your question ^^
In the ding-dong theory, human named nature object based on their sounds. This is called the onomatopoeic (the formation of a word from a sound associated with what is named). Maybe, they named water as "srrrrr" , wind as "wuusshh" , and stone that falls as "krak krak".
Thank you ^^
Name : Nabila Faizaturrahmah
SRN : 200101030165
Class : TBI 20-A
Nowadays we have a sign language, is it similiar with the body language that ancient humans use?
Helo Nabila, I want to answer your question
Only similar does not mean the same, because the development of the age of sign language also develops for the better and also sign language is the same as body language because our bodies are the main role to express it.
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20 A
Why many linguist develop the theory of Evolution by Darwin?
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
the reason why many linguist develop their based on the theory of evolution by darwin is because these theorese were develop in the west where the theory of evolution is the go to into explaining anything that had happen in the natural world, especially the ones that happen during the stone age due to how darwin's theory of evolution is the most plausible theory scientifically according to them.
I'm sorry if there is anything wrong in my explanation.
Name : Lola Triandita (200101030399)
TBI 20-B
In the social interaction source theory they make a simple code or sign but
Why they do it just when they want to do hunting or marriage?So for daily activities they keep silent without sounds for communication?
Thank you🙏
Assalamualaikum wr.wb
Name: Zuraidah
Class: TBI 20 C
Is there any theory that justifies Noam Chomsky's theory?
Thank you,
Wassalamualaikum wr.wb
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20 A
I want to answer your question. Yes, there is another theory from Ferdinand De Saussure
Name : Adela Putri
Class : tbi c 20
what makes languages around the world different?
Very different languages can share words (through borrowing) while different speakers of the “same” language may vary widely in their vocabulary due to factors of education or speaking style. Different languages may display the same sentence patterns, while a single language may display a great variety of patterns. :)
Hello, nice to meet you
I'm M.Abdillah From TBI A 20, I'd like to answer your question
Maybe, language have been developed in more than one place. Humans would speak thousand of different languages. That's because people move and languages change. Of course it is important because it to bind communities and cultures together. It preserve knowledge and connect people to their heritage.
That's my answer and I'm sorry if there is a mistake. Thank you
Name: Tasyawwafal Ramadhan
200101030247
TBI B
some people say that I'm crazy cuz I always think logically but I feel more relate to science theory than religious theory. Sorry, if this is a silly question but it was on my mind if Adam was the first human what language did he use?
in Jews Adam uses divine language and in Islam Adam may use Arabic. I need more explanation about this. thank you, please don't judge me cuz I'm religious but i'll try my best
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I respect your thought or your opinion 👍. So, i want to answer your question with my opinion. I believe in religious theory more than science theory, but i didn't say that science theory is a wrong theory. So, i think that Adam use arabic. Why? Because there is a hadith which says that arabic is the language of the inhabitants of heaven, but this hadith is not shahih. If you can't accept this hadith, then look at prophet Nuh. Prophet Nuh is the closest descendant of the prophet Adam and Prophet Nuh use arabic for talking with people.
Thank you and i'm sorry if you still can't understand, i think the best way is to learn with someone that is have knowledge about that👍
Hai tasyawwafal!! my name is Nabila and i will try to answer your question because your question is almost same as m noor's question. Based on some journal that i already read Nobody knows what language that people speak at jannah, nor the language used by Allah, because He never said anything about it, neither did His Prophet (Muhammad SAW). But there are some hadits that said if arabic language is jannah language (in other words arabic is language that Allah tought to adam)and this hadits has been narrated in any kitab such as al-Mujam al-Ausath created by at-Thabrani, al-Mujam al-Kabir created by at-Thabrani, al-Mustadrak created by al-Hakim, Syuab al-Iman created by al-Baihaqi, Ilal al-Hadits created by Ibnu Abi Hatim, and al-Maudhuat created by Ibnu al-Jauzi, but Imam al-Dzahabi asume if this hadits are maudhu (weak / fake) and Syekh Ibnu Taimiyyah also stated there is no desciption if arabic language is jannah language in Al-Qur'an. CMIIW and thank you!!
Name : Ayunda Febriyani Trayumada
Class : TBI 20B
How is Alien can manipulated our anchestor so that we can bbe as smart as now?
Hello, my name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A.
Such an incredible question 👍, i think this is a difficult question, but i'll try my best to answer it. In ancient time the belief system was very strong, so in my opinion our ancestors only followed the power of belief, so they are easy to be manipulated by something (including alien)
Name : Rona Nur Azzahra
200101030046
TBI 20 B
"According to noam chomsky, human speech mau have appeared between 200,000 - 100, 000 years ago (before that we mau use sign language)" so, What if before the appeared sign language there was someone who didn't have both hands or was disabled at that time, could he communicate using the sign language?
Thank You 🙏
Name: Tasyawwafal Ramadhan
200101030247
TBI B
It's hard to answer your question but let me try answer it with my thoughts. maybe they have their own language which cannot be understood unless each other like a dog barking and fellow dogs might understand the meaning, or he/she could also do it with a facial expression. Thank you, I hope you get it what I meant
Name: Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi
Class: TBI 20 A
In the Bow-Wow theory, humans at that time named object around them especially animals based on the sounds that they (the object) produce.
So what's the difference between the Bow-Wow and the Ding-Dong theory? Considering the Ding-Dong theory also states that humans named objects based on their sounds.
Hi, I'm Siti Azizah Puteri from Class A 2020 and I'll help Azmi to answer his question based on what I know.
The difference between the Bow-Wow and the Ding-Dong theory are the Ding-Dong theory focused on origins of language based on what things sounded like, and the Bow-Wow theory focused on imitation.
For example :
In the Bow-Wow theory, Bow-Wow is the dog sound and Miaow is the cat's sound. Basically, it is the idea that human language and vocabulary originated as a form of imitation. It is said that language came from the imitation of animal sounds.
In the Ding-Dong theory, bases the origins of language on onomatopoeia. This idea states that language began when humans started naming objects after a relevant sound that was already involved in their everyday life. Examples include words such as “boom,” “crash,” and “oink.”
Thank you for the explanation, Ais ^^
@@NazamuddinAzmi762 With my pleasure ✨
Name : Alfaridzi Zulkarnain
Class : TBI A 20
"For the Putting the Baby Down Theory, To stop stop their babies crying they created sounds. What kind of sounds that they make?"
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20 A
In my opinion it would like sing a lullaby and gentle words to calm baby down
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
I believe that is possible that they start making random noises until there is one that makes the baby calm down and keep using that.
Thank you
Name : Sulthan Maysuja Setiawan
Class: TBI 20 A
SRN : 200101030185
about my question, is there any specific reason or history why Ding-dong theory is named, well, "ding-dong" theory ?
From what i know, why it called "ding-dong theory" because "ding-dong" it's a sound of bells ringing. Why is it from a bell? In my opinion it's because this theory explain that "humans named everything around them at that time based on sound that they got". So, i think that's why it called "Ding-dong" theory. Maybe the one that made this theory hear the sound of a bells ringing, when thinking about this theory.
Thank you and i'm sorry if you still don't understand my explanation.
-From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
the reason as to why it is called the ding dong theory is because this theory explains how inanimate object make a sound because of this it is compared to the bell that sometimes only called ding dong.
Thank you
Name : arlina Fauziah
class : TBI 20 B
sorry for my delay in asking because yesterday i came home and did not get a good signal until this morning. permission to ask sir, in the hindi theory it is explained that language was made by sarasvati, what is the supporting theory that makes them believe this?
Hi let me
let me give you an opinion...
In my opinion, this theory is still unclear and there is no solid evidence that it is true. Because we all know that Sarasvati is one of the spiritual figures in Hinduism Who seems like a mythical character whose truth is not proven
Imo, it's not about their beliefs about research scientists, it's more about their beliefs about their own religion.
*Cmiiw
Name : Siti Nur Syafa'ah
Class : TBI 20-B
How can humans named everything around them just based on sounds that they got?
Actually, there is a study that conclude if people named object that they found based on name that they want, for the example rafflesia arnoldi that named by 2 person names (Dr. Joseph Arnold and sir Thomas Stamford Rafles).reffering to this question, in my opinion someone can named everything around them just based on sound that they got because the sound familiar and people easier to remember something that always they hear/ familiar with their ear such as “mengetok” that comes from sound of hitting our hand (tok tok) while hitting the door. CMIIW
I’m sorry for my bad english hehe my Name is Nabila Putri Endah SRN 170102031167
@@nabilaputriendah3687 thnkyou💙
@@stnursyafaah5522 anytime 😉
I will try to answer it
Before language was discovered, it was thought that humans communicated using sounds produced by their mouths and through body movements only.
Then the human brain evolved and developed so that it could understand more difficult things.
Humans then began to name objects, food, until a situation became a word that was easy to pronounce and was thought to mimic the sound source of the object.
After that, slowly humans can speak by combining 2 different words, and then develop into language.
Meanwhile, the diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors.
Name : Putri Maulida Rahmah
Class : TBI 20-A
As we know that every country has a different language and the theory that has been explained make me think that the languages spoken are different, but actually there are similar languages even though they are from different countries, for example Indonesia and Malaysia. So, why are there countries that have similar languages?
Thank you.
Nama : Roja Nur Azizah (200101030758)
Class : TBI - 20 A
I want to answer Putri's question based on my understanding.
Why are Indonesian and Malaysian languages almost the same? That's because Indonesian and Malaysian come from a language family (in Indonesian we say "rumpun bahasa" ) , namely Austronesian languages,
The Austronesian language family (or sometimes called the "island language") is a language family that is very widespread in the world. From Taiwan and Hawaii in the far north to New Zealand (Aotearoa) in the far south and from Madagascar in the far west to Easter Island (Rapanui) in the far east.
That is why Indonesian and Malaysian languages are almost similar.
Hai Putri! Allow me to answer your question :D
Because it comes from the same language family, namely the Austronesian language.
Then, why is the Malay language the foundation of Indonesian? In 1931, the Dutch conducted a language survey which resulted in the fact that Malay is only spoken by 500,000 people spread across the archipelago. Even though they are few, Malay speakers are spread all over Indonesia. For example, Loloan Malay in Bali, Amenan Malay in NTB, Larantuka Malay in NTT, Ambonese Malay in Maluku, Papuan Malay in Papua, Betawi Malay in Java, and various Malay languages on the islands of Sumatra and Kalimantan. In addition, the Malay language is also used in other nations such as Malaysia, Brunei Darussalam, and Singapore so as to facilitate bilateral relations between countries in Southeast Asia. Unlike the Javanese language whose speakers are only scattered on the island of Java.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20A
I'd like to answer your question.
In my opinion, some countries, some whose languages are similar, it is caused by:
1. These countries are geographically close together so that there will be acculturation of language and culture.
2. The occurrence of war, for example the Dutch who colonized Indonesia for centuries so that many words in Indonesia were absorbed from the Dutch language.
3. international trade, such as Arabs who trade in Indonesia, this causes many Arabic words to be absorbed into Indonesian.
@@hope.of_bitnaa Thank you for your answer Roja😀
@@oktaviani5190 Thank you for your answer Okta😁
Name : Maulida Hasanah
SRN : 200101030492
Class : TBI 20 C
I want to ask
is there any evidence to support the theory of the assumption that language got from Aliens?
Thank you🙏
Name : Siti Nur Anisah (200101030243)
Class : TBI 20 C
Are paintings on walls and caves included in the theory of sources of social interaction ?
Name: Muhammad Nabiel El-Wafa
Class: TBI A-20
Question: What's the oldest language that have been discovered?
Nama : Nisa Auliana
Local : TBI 20 C
SRN : 200101030630
Which is the first language in the world?
Which is the mother of all languages?
Hello, I'm Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A
If we look at it from an Islamic perspective, the first language in this world is Arabic. Because the language of heaven is Arabic and the prophet Adam was the first human being sent down from heaven, so he used Arabic. And also, because of that, so the mother of all languages is Arabic language.
Thank you ^-^
Name : Muhammad Amienullah (200101030502)
Class : 20C Tbi
Putting the baby down theory
About language!!!
if the mother tongue soothes her crying child in her arms.
Does that apply to all mothers in the world or only certain mothers?
Name: Melati
Class: TbI A'17
I want to ask
What are the theories of origin of language? and Why is it important to understand where words come from ?
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. I'll try my best to answer your question and my answer is based on my perspective.
For question number one, there are many theories that our lecturer explained, such as physical adaptation theory, genetic source theory, and natural sound source theory, etc. You can find more in this video. For question number two, in my opinion it's important to know where words come from, because if someone ask me or my students ask me (because maybe, i'll be a teacher in the future) and i don't know the answer, i'll be embarrassed definitely, especially i'm a college student and i'm studying it. But if i don't study about it and i'm not a college student, i think it's still important. I can increase my knowledge.
@@putrimaulidarahmah8676 Thanks for your answer 🙏
@@melatichannel1840 You are always welcome 🙂
Name: Safa
Class: Tbi c 20
I still can't understand about bow-wow and miaow, why are they make the bow-wow that called dog, and miaow called Cat? why don't they just tell it a bow-wow and a miaow??
My name is Putri Maulida Rahmah and i'm from class 20 A. Actually it's a little difficult to understand your question, but i'll try to answer from my understanding. My understanding is that you have more than one question and the answers will be different but still related to each other.
For your question, why they called dog (bow-wow) and cat (miaow), because our ancestors at that time made language from the sounds of animals they heard. But if your question why people these days called a bow-wow is a dog and a miaow is a cat, it's because language has developed and languages in the world are different.
I'm sorry if my understanding isn't right.
Name : Siti Marhamah
Nim : 200101030816
Class : TBI 20 B
ancestors create the language from their interaction with nature.
How they named the nature that does not produce sounds such as mountains, caves, rocks and so forth ?🙏🏻
Name : Muhammad Noor Fadhillah
Class : 20 - A
how can you understand a language but not speak it?
In my opinion it's a normal thing. You can understand that language but you don't or you can't speak it. Actually there are so many people i have met and they can understand some languages but they don't or can't speak in that language. If you ask why? Actually it's about their self confidence. Most of this problem is caused because of their lack self confidence. For example, i have one friend and he can understand really well when i speak in english, but he always gives me a response with indonesian language. So, i asked him why? And he said "I can't speak in english, but i can understand, i just feel embarrassed when i have to speak in english".
I hope that you can understand my explanation, i'm sorry if you still can't understand. I try my best. Thank you.
-From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
it is very possible, we can understand a language only by hearing the language continuously, like in the case of a baby who is about 8 months old. he understood but could not speak the language.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20A
I'd like to answer your question
We can understand a language without speaking. It calls receptive skills. Passive foreign language users are also referred to as receptive skills, someone who has receptive skills can respond and understand foreign languages passively as indicated by listening and reading skills that are more dominant than writing and speaking skills.
Hello I'm Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid. Here is my answer to your question based on the information that I have already known.
the way to understand a language without speaking it is to see their gesture, movement, and behavior to a certain extent.
Thank you
Name : Nursyifa Ahyana
SRN : 200101030415
Class : TBI 20 C
Chomsky claims that human has Language Acquisition Device (LAD), so, my question is: does each human have a different LAD?
Hi Nursyifa!
I think each human have a different LAD.
The LAD concept is a purported instinctive mental capacity which enables an infant to acquire and produce language. It is a component of the nativist theory of language. This theory asserts that humans are born with the instinct or "innate facility" for acquiring language. The main argument given in favor of the LAD was the argument from the poverty of the stimulus, which argues that unless children have significant innate knowledge of grammar, they would not be able to learn language as quickly as they do, given that they never have access to negative evidence and rarely receive direct instruction in their first language.
A summary explaining LAD by Chomsky states that languages are infinite pertaining to the sequence of word forms (strings) and grammar. These word forms organize grammatically correct sequences of words that can be pooled over a limited lexicon of each independent language. So, LAD is tasked to select from an infinite number of grammars the one which is correct for the language that is presented to an individual, for example, a child.
according to the information i have read.
Every child has LAD since birth. This is evidenced by various discoveries such as those made by Howard Gardner. He said that since birth, children are equipped with various intelligences. One of the intelligences in question is language intelligence
Name : Diny Azizah (200102030039)
Class : TBI B 20
What is the meaning from "language has no physical footprint or legacy?
Name: Muhammad Harun Nur Rasyid
Class: TBI 20 A
Is there any trace or example of the daa daa and ding dong theory in today's language? because even if we look at the most primitive language that still existed now (at least that I know of) there are no such things.
Hi Harun! I am Siti Azizah Puteri from English Education Department Class A, and I'll help you based on what I know.
Yes, there is! For example related to Ta-Ta theory, when we meet someone who is deaf, we usually often use body gestures to express something for them. Like, how we greet each other, we can use hand movement or body gesture even when we can't use international body language.
And to the Ding-Dong theory, more often used by any mothers to teach their toddlers about the sounds or language of animals. So they can speak and know the language.
Thank you!~
Name : Novi Wahyu Oktaviana (200101030045)
Class : TBI 20-B
What is the more specific understanding of "Putting the Baby Down Theory"? And what are its main characteristics?
There’s also a theory that language evolved when early humans lost the fur that let babies cling to their mothers - the ‘putting the baby down theory’ speculates that parent and infant would have more need to communicate when perpetual physical contact was abandoned.
Name : M.Abdillah
Class : A 20 TBI
Noam Chomsky claim that just human has Language Acquisition Device (LAD), but why in ancient time like what I saw on TV human just said, "gogo gaga", "Hoo haa hu" ? That's my question 🙏
Let me answer that, i think pre-historic human in TV are just some fiction writing, i mean like there's no proof that there's human speak like that, so they might just made those up for entertainment on TV.
Name : Rizqa Sahlaa Azqia
SRN : 200101030807
Class : TBI 20 C
how can humans recognize that it is the sound of an animal for example a cat with only a meow sound? can you explain more detail please?
Name : Fatimatuzzahra Hidayah
Class : TBI 20 A
I want to ask
who created the theory for the first time there is a language created from aliens? can aliens speak?
Hello Fatimatuzzahra. I want to answer you second question "can aliens speak?". Until now, we still don't know if aliens really exist or not. Actually i don't know how our ancestors know about aliens, but if we think again, our ancestors had a strong belief system, where our ancestors would easily believe something. But it's different from our generation, we don't believe easily. So, if you ask if aliens can speak or not, i think there are two answers. First answer is aliens can speak if you want to believe it and second answer is aliens can't speak if you don't want to believe it. I think it's depend on you.
I'm sorry if my explanation is wrong for you, but that's my opinion and my thought and i try my best.
-From your classmate Putri Maulida Rahmah
I will try to answer your question
Who created the theory for the first time? In 1861, the historian of language Max Müller published a list of speculative theories of the origin of language. There are Bow-wow, Pooh-pooh, Ding-dong, and Yo-he-ho.
Can Aliens speak?
Astronomy experts from ITB judge L Malasan said there were several things that needed to be straightened out from extraterrestrial life.
Scientists generally do not believe in aliens or UFOs because there is no scientific evidence of life in outer space so far, which is believed to be organisms, bacteria, single-celled animals, etc.
But in my opinion, can aliens talk I would say "yes" because creatures must have the means of communication to do some work.
I hope this help for you. Thanks
nama : Rahmawati ( 200101030567 )
class : TBI 20 B
like what is a more detailed explanation of the assumption theory of language from aliens?
Hi Rahmawati,
let me share a little opinion🙏
Alien languages, i.e. languages of extraterrestrial beings, are a hypothetical subject since none have been encountered so far. The research in these hypothetical languages is variously called exolinguistics, xenolinguistics or astrolinguistics. The question of what form alien languages might take and the possibility for humans to recognize and translate them has been part of the linguistics and language studies courses, e.g., at the Bowling Green State University (2001).
Noam Chomsky (1983), basing on his theory of the existence of a genetically-predetermined universal grammar of human languages, holds that it would be impossible for a human to naturally learn an alien language because it would most probably violate the universal grammar inborn in humans. Humans would have to study an alien language by the slow way of discovery, the same way as scientists do research in, say, physics.
Linguist Keren Rice posits that basic communication between humans and aliens should be possible, unless "the things that we think are common to languages-situating in time [and] space, talking about participants, etc.-are so radically different that the human language provides no starting point for it."
Jessica Coon, a professor of linguistics at McGill University, was consulted for the linguistic aspect of the 2016 film Arrival. While acknowledging that the graphical language in the film was art without linguistic meaning, she stated that the film was a fairly accurate portrayal of the approach human linguists would use in trying to understand an alien language.
actually, I don't really understand about this theory, but I just tried it. #cmiiw :)
Hi Rahmawati
My answer is the same but i have shorter answer.
Alien languages, i.e., languages of extraterrestrial beings, are a hypothetical subject since none have been encountered so far. The research in these hypothetical languages is variously called exolinguistics, xenolinguistics or astrolinguistics. The question of what form alien languages might take and the possibility for humans to recognize and translate them has been part of the linguistics and language studies courses, e.g., at the Bowling Green State University (2001). Noam Chomsky (1983), basing on his theory of the existence of a genetically-predetermined universal grammar of human languages, holds that it would be impossible for a human to naturally learn an alien language because it would most probably violate the universal grammar inborn in humans. Humans would have to study an alien language by the slow way of discovery, the same way as scientists do research in, say, physics.
Name : Alfiana Azizah
SRN : 200101030648
Class: TBI 20C
Hello, this is my question that seems difficult, from what I read in the world there are ± 7000 languages in the world. So how come there are so many different languages in the world? there are several languages with the same pronunciation or the same accent, and likely languages that are similar to that of a similar race / similar race. So how come there are so many languages in the world?
Hi Alfiana, let me introduce my self, My name is Nabila Putri Endah, According from article that i read there are many factor that made different language in this world one of them is based from geography factor for the example mountain, forest and river made Papua New Guinea become many small group (tribe), these groups have been around from long time ago and because of the split of Papua New Guinea group make they develope variety different language, next for similar language with the same pronounciation, it because there are some country that take other country languages from colonization, immigration and trade such as English langugae that consist of 30% original English and 35% Latin, Greek, and French language. CMIIW
Haiii azizah, let me give you an opinion on your question
There are so many different languages in the world. These languages cannot be equated or be harmonized into one language only because there are many differences in culture and customs in each country.
The background of language creation in each country also varies, depending on the characteristics of the country itself. And also depending on their daily habits.
*cmiiw
Hi Alfiana. I will try answer it
Before language was discovered, it was thought that humans communicated using sounds produced by their mouths and through body movements only.
Then the human brain evolved and developed so that it could understand more difficult things.
Humans then began to name objects, food, until a situation became a word that was easy to pronounce and was thought to mimic the sound source of the object.
After that, slowly humans can speak by combining 2 different words, and then develop into language.
Meanwhile, the diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors.
At that time, our ancestors migrated to various countries in the world in search of food sources.
Well, this cultural isolation has made the emergence of a different language in each country adapted to the natural conditions, food and other living things around it.
This isolation causes the language in each country or region to be different.
This also happens in Indonesia, lo, which is an archipelago, so that Indonesians are increasingly isolated in the areas where they live.
This is why Indonesia has a language that is very diverse and also different in each region.
Then when 2 groups came from 2 different places, the languages they had then mingled into one.
This language blending then led to the creation of a new language, here, and it is called the super language or super language.
Because of this the distance factor also influences the formation of language.
For example, countries that are close together usually tend to have the same name for an object, such as between Indonesia and Malaysia.
Name: khairunnisa (200101030518)
Class: TBI 20 B
Could language be older then our species??
Thank you🙏
Name: putri ayu andini
Class: Tbi 20 b
Answer:
Could language be older than our species?
Ancient DNA reveals us to be over 99% identical in the sequences of our protein coding genes to our sister species the Neanderthals (Homo neanderthalensis). The Neanderthals had large brains and were able to inhabit much of Eurasia from around 350,000 years ago. If the Neanderthals had language, that would place its origin at least as far back as the time of our common ancestor with them, currently thought to be around 550,000 to 750,000 years ago.
Name ; Norzaitun Nisa
SRN : 200101030672
Class : TBI 20 C
what about the sign language used by people with special needs, is there a history for this language?
Thank u 💜🙏
Hello, I am Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi from TBI 20 A
Actually, this is still a matter of debate among researchers. However, from several written records, some people think that Juan Pablo de Bonet was the person who invented sign language. In the year 1620, Bonet wrote a book that contained the first known manual alphabet system. The handshapes in this system represented different speech sounds.
Need to be remember, Pablo was the first "recorded" person to discover sign language. Before that time, maybe there was many sign language that have invented, but it's just not recorded in history because of its development which is only around the society where humans at that time live.
Thank you, I hope this can help you ^^
Name : Nur Hayati (200101030783)
Class : TBI 20 C
Question : What if a deaf baby was born?What kind of language that they use to communicate with?
Because language is basically made by a sound/voice?
Thx 😊
Name :Muhammad Al Habib
NIM : 200101030398
Class : TBI_C
hello friends here the creation of a language in ancient times using the sound of these objects ...
here there is still something to make you confused
whether the creation of a language in this world, was born because there are certain tribes?
did the tribal leader create the language and teach it to others ??
so they can talk to each other ...
thank you
Name : Aslamiah (200101030728)
Class : TBI 20B
why do humans make language with emotions?
Thanks🙏🏻
My name is Novi Wahyu Oktaviana (200101030045). TBI 20-B.
According to my understanding, humans speak or make language with emotionally, it is because if something happens in human life suddenly, it will spontaneously appear. In other words, the language with which emotions are spoken is an automatic or spontaneous response that cannot be controlled. Like fear, anger, pain and stuff.
That's all I'm saying, please forgive me for any mistakes or flaws🙏
Name : Fatimah Az-zahro
NIM. : 200101030180
Class. : TBI 20 C
I want to ask how can there be differences in language in the world?
Hello fatimah My name is Norzaitun Nisa Class C
I will answer ur question
The diverse and different languages in each country are caused by the cultural isolation that occurred in the days of our human ancestors. At that time, our ancestors migrated to various countries in the world in search of food sources.
Languages can differ in many ways. They may use different sounds, they may make words in different ways, they may put words together to form a sentence in different ways, and that’s just for starters!
When we talk about a ‘language’ we mean the act of speaking, writing or signing.
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
I'd like to answer your question.
There are 3 factors that might explain your question.
1. Language Develops in More Than One Location
Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It makes language change over time.
2. War
Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language become extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war.
3. Geographic factor
. Language turns out to be unevenly distributed due to geographical factors of an area, you know Squad. For example, Europe has about 225 indigenous languages, while Papua New Guinea which is smaller than Europe has at least 820 languages!
Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages.
Name: Putri Ayu Andini
Srn: 200101030821
Class: TBI 20 B
Can genetic evidence help to decide when language evolved?
Thank you🙏🏻
Name : Muhammad Syahri
SRN : 200101030299
Class : TBI 20-C
In islam, don't we come from Adam's descendants who use one language, but now why do humans use many languages in this world?
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
In the beginning, humans had a single language. Well, there were a lot of Adam's children, so they migrated separately from each other, their languages will change too, develop to be more complex.
Thank you 🙏
@@m.nooramin-tbi20b80 It's clear explanation, thank you
Name: Muhammad Nazamuddin Azmi
Class: TBI 20 A
Sorry if I couldn't answer this with Islamic source. But I found one information about why the languages in this world are different based on Christian view.
In the Bible, Genesis 11: 6-9
6. The Lord said, “If as one people speaking the same language, they have begun to do this, then nothing they plan to do will be impossible for them.
7. Come, let us go down and confuse their language so they will not understand each other.”
8. So the Lord scattered them from there over all the earth, and they stopped building the city.
9. That is why it was called Babel because there the Lord confused the language of the whole world.
This was a punishment from God because of the pride and arrogance of the Babylonians at that time who thought they could match God's power.
Thank You 🙏😀
When Adam got to the earth with his wife Hawa (Eva) they taught their children their languange. Because of Adam's children are a lot. That's why make language are differences from One another
Hi syahri, i'm nabila and i want to try answering your question. There are many causes of many language in thos world, such as immigration, language develope in more than one location, geofrafic factor, and accoustic factor. CMIIW and thank youuu!!
Hi guys My Name is Nabila Putri Endah (170102031167)
here i want to ask “ is it legal to make other country language become our language? Give me the reason”
thank you guyss!!
Assalamualaikum wr.wb
Name : Elma Azzahrah
SRN : 200101030096
Class : TBI 20 C
After seeing the many theories of the emergence of a language mentioned above, my question is whether to get a language today there have been many changes in vocabulary and word pronunciation that have occurred from ancient times to the present? Or just change it a little to improve the current vocabulary?
Thank you🙏
Name : Annisa Alkautsar
Class : TBI 20 A
there are so many kinds of languages that exist in the world. Why can every country have a different language?
Name : Munaihah Sholihah
Class : TBI 20 A
in islam, god taught adam the names of things in the universe when he was in heaven. Then adam go to the earth with hawa. They taught children their languange. Because of Adam's children are lot that's why languange is difference from one and another. But it can be because many factor such as migration, geograpic, war, and social factors
Name: Muhammad Noor Amin
Class: TBI 20 A
The language in this world actually comes from one main language. The main language developed due to various factors so that eventually the language developed and the pronunciation in each world was different. Besides that, from one region to another there are different variations and different situations. As a result, region A or region B have differences in terms of pronunciation, environment or language in mentioning something.
My name is Oktaviani. I want to answer your question. Here you are why there are so many different languages in the world.
1. Language Develops in More Than One Location
Humans love to move, move from one place to another. It also makes language change over time. The dialects of the migratory groups of humans may develop in different directions, until they finally speak two separate but related languages.
2. War
Warfare can form a new language, or make an established language extinct. For example, societies that are defeated or conquered in war will usually be forced to speak the language of the victorious war.
3. Geographical Factors
Yes, geography plays a role here. Mountains, forests, rivers and swamps keep Papua New Guinea's population divided into many small tribes. These small groups have been isolated for so long that they have developed different languages of their own. Different tribes, different languages.
4. Acoustic Adaptation
As a result, it was found that languages originating from warm areas with dense tree cover tended to use less consonants, and conversely, cold regions with sparse trees tended to use higher vowel sounds. In total, it is estimated that acoustic adaptation may be responsible for about a quarter of the variation in the use of vowels and consonants between languages.
5. Rain
The researchers found that in Australia, rainfall patterns influenced the number and distribution of Aboriginal languages in the country. In Australia, areas with higher rainfall will be populated by more people, which in turn affects the development of language there.