Thank you so kindly for your work!! Phillip Marsden is my grandfather , it's so lovely to see him!! He was so dapper! I'm so proud!! Thank You so much!
Don Ameche was one of the best panelists they had on the whole run of the show. He was articulate and made his points very clear. Another panelist I liked was Hy Gardner.
I'm with you Ed. He really is a master of the quick thinking, relevant questions. He doesn't waste everyone's time playing for the laugh, or playing to the crowd for attention. There's one game where 3 intelligent guys answer him with incredible speed, and accuracy. I'm looking for it as it's a treat to watch.
@@jodygoar7071 Thanks for your reply. On he other side of the fence, I don't see how Polly Bergen lasted as long as she did on this show. She had no business being on here in the first place because of the totally stupid stuff she said all the time.
That’s interesting because I thought that Don Ameche would question people like he was a prosecuting attorney and Hy Gardner was always insulting people.
@@leesher1845 I think that was part of Hy's semetic schtick, but his occasionally misplaced one liner ripostes (sometimes funny) were quick, and usually preceded by relevant questions often laying in the weeds with some good tricks. I thought he did a good job, and sort of accidentally insulted people as he trailed for the quick laugh. Of course Don Ameche's machine gun, rapid fire, relevant, poignant, piercing questions may have sounded harsh, but he played the game perfectly, and unlike many of the other people, realized it wasn't the Don Ameche comedy show. I'm with Eddie. I thought he was absolutely fantastic, and certainly quick-minded, and played the real game instead of trying to be cute or silly.
My grandfather was from the Philippines. I am only a quarter or eighth I believe, however I picked #1 immediately! Kitty for the win again! ❤️🤗 Seattle
'Ol Bud was on his game tonight. Didn't panic when the bird went rogue and covered for the kid to prevent an uncomfortable moment about the Pudge Willard answer.
Bud Collier was the consummate pro. I never saw him get frazzled and he always kept things moving on the show no matter what. The show was 1st class in those days. When it went to syndication with Garry Moore in the late 60s early 70s, it was not bad, but I feel that the CBS shows were the best. Sadly, if you have a game show today, sex, or off color stuff, or suggestive things, usually are standard fare. I am no prude, but these shows were squaky clean and look at the enjoyment people get watching them even today some 60+ years later!
@@forrestrivers1792 Especially when she keeps touching her clavicle in a "me, me, me" gesture in those games when she was the only one who was correct. Those times when she is the only one on the panel that I agreed with, I'd rather be wrong.
There are more than one type of parakeet. We have a few different ones in Australia. Maybe hes only talking about where he is. Budgies are in the parakeet family.
So, Polly Bergen had two kids then and one was age 13; and no liposuction back then! She was very pretty. But, unless she'd said it before, Bergen just publicly announced that she'd had her oldest child at age 16, which may have been accepted in her home state of TN back then.
Um, I saw Eisenhower's golf caddy on What's My Line just "last night." Don't ya think if they're gonna use the same people, they shouldn't use them in the same MONTH!
Bud in ski zooms in "like" super man and throws kisses to the pamel !!!! OMG , Don looks kinda out of it !!!! Kitty always wears that heart !!!! Polly is the best and smartest panelists of all !!!!
Reality check for the day: In 1959, the real caddy was I'd say probably 12 years old. In 2024, that would make him 77 years old. We are only here for a split second in time folks, enjoy every moment to its fullest.
Number 1 and 3 are in HIGH school and the only one that looks like he could be, 2, is in Junior High? These kids look way too long for high school and I'd think even in 1959, no one under 13 and a half made it there without being a grade skipping genius.
![What's My Line? - Arnold Palmer; Dina Merrill; Martin Gabel [panel] (Aug 7, 1960)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uyR0DFZ3Lx0/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you so kindly for your work!! Phillip Marsden is my grandfather , it's so lovely to see him!! He was so dapper! I'm so proud!! Thank You so much!
Impressive. Must be nice to see him. I was kind of worried about the bird flying around.
The #3 person pretending to be Phillip appeared to be suffering from stage fright. Bless his heart, but he was really nervous out there.
Don Ameche was one of the best panelists they had on the whole run of the show. He was articulate and made his points very clear. Another panelist I liked was Hy Gardner.
I'm with you Ed. He really is a master of the quick thinking, relevant questions. He doesn't waste everyone's time playing for the laugh, or playing to the crowd for attention. There's one game where 3 intelligent guys answer him with incredible speed, and accuracy. I'm looking for it as it's a treat to watch.
@@jodygoar7071 Thanks for your reply. On he other side of the fence, I don't see how Polly Bergen lasted as long as she did on this show. She had no business being
on here in the first place because of the totally stupid stuff she said all the time.
That’s interesting because I thought that Don Ameche would question people like he was a prosecuting attorney and Hy Gardner was always insulting people.
@@leesher1845 I think that was part of Hy's semetic schtick, but his occasionally misplaced one liner ripostes (sometimes funny) were quick, and usually preceded by relevant questions often laying in the weeds with some good tricks. I thought he did a good job, and sort of accidentally insulted people as he trailed for the quick laugh. Of course Don Ameche's machine gun, rapid fire, relevant, poignant, piercing questions may have sounded harsh, but he played the game perfectly, and unlike many of the other people, realized it wasn't the Don Ameche comedy show. I'm with Eddie. I thought he was absolutely fantastic, and certainly quick-minded, and played the real game instead of trying to be cute or silly.
Don "Let's take this whole thing too seriously" Ameche? Sorry, not my favorite.
All three of those women in the first segment were so lovely and charming with such beautiful smiles.
It's FORE not FOUR. It's what was yelled by the officers to tell the front line to kneel before the second line fired their volley.
Lady #1 in Game #1
Man #2 in Game #2
Boy #1 in Game #3
My grandfather was from the Philippines. I am only a quarter or eighth I believe, however I picked #1 immediately! Kitty for the win again! ❤️🤗 Seattle
'Ol Bud was on his game tonight. Didn't panic when the bird went rogue and covered for the kid to prevent an uncomfortable moment about the Pudge Willard answer.
Was cool seeing the behind the scenes action.
Bud Collier was the consummate pro. I never saw him get frazzled and he always kept things moving on the show no matter what. The show was 1st class in those days. When it went to syndication with Garry Moore in the late 60s early 70s, it was not bad, but I feel that the CBS shows were the best. Sadly, if you have a game show today, sex, or off color stuff, or suggestive things, usually are standard fare. I am no prude, but these shows were squaky clean and look at the enjoyment people get watching them even today some 60+ years later!
I agree.
I love the way Kitty gets so excited and giddy when she guesses the real one correctly.
Greg .Patrei : Yes, isn't it sweet how she jumps up and down in her seat? Of course, she was the only correct guesser in this instance. 😁
Hate when she does it. It is immature - childish.
@@forrestrivers1792 Especially when she keeps touching her clavicle in a "me, me, me" gesture in those games when she was the only one who was correct. Those times when she is the only one on the panel that I agreed with, I'd rather be wrong.
Looks like she's about to pee herself
It's all about her, in her mind.
Funny line by Polly about naming the 7000 islands
I love the little kid #3...who said he was a " male model"...!
Male model; that’s funny!
I'm betting the parakeet owner in game 2 was pretty nervous while his pet was flying around the cameras and crew, I know I would be.
that opening musical flourish is something I remember so well...I had to play it several times.
There are more than one type of parakeet. We have a few different ones in Australia. Maybe hes only talking about where he is. Budgies are in the parakeet family.
OK let's see here, Game 2 was strictly for the birds and Game 3 was about golfing birdies
Game 2 is evidence that sometimes a fail makes for better television.
Failure. "Fail" is a verb.
Celebrity Guests:
1. Polly Bergen
2. Don Ameche
3. Kitty Carlisle
4. Robert Q. Lewis
Host:
Bud Collyer
Panelists
So, Polly Bergen had two kids then and one was age 13; and no liposuction back then! She was very pretty. But, unless she'd said it before, Bergen just publicly announced that she'd had her oldest child at age 16, which may have been accepted in her home state of TN back then.
Two of the caddies have strong New York accents!
Um, I saw Eisenhower's golf caddy on What's My Line just "last night." Don't ya think if they're gonna use the same people, they shouldn't use them in the same MONTH!
Um, indeed.
Easy no.1 doesn’t have a New York accent!
Contestant #2 in game 1 had a nice face. Now you know why animals of any kind don't come on live shows too often. Too unpredictable.
Bud in ski zooms in "like" super man and throws kisses to the pamel !!!! OMG , Don looks kinda out of it !!!! Kitty always wears that heart !!!! Polly is the best and smartest panelists of all !!!!
No Kenneth. Just no.
Don, not Dom.
Pollyanna is an air head.
Hilarious with the parakeet!
Get to see the title art cards off stage
Reality check for the day: In 1959, the real caddy was I'd say probably 12 years old. In 2024, that would make him 77 years old. We are only here for a split second in time folks, enjoy every moment to its fullest.
Bud hold on to his feet
Number 1 and 3 are in HIGH school and the only one that looks like he could be, 2, is in Junior High? These kids look way too long for high school and I'd think even in 1959, no one under 13 and a half made it there without being a grade skipping genius.
The gifts they gave away were pathetic. Why would three young boys want Toni products?
For their moms ?
Gosh, these 50s Hairpieces look so PHONY!
I agree. Peggy Cass didn't join the panel until later in the show's run, but her wigs were always so fake looking.