More amazing than her singing the highest notes EVER! Is the fact she can change outfits between notes. Did anyone notice that her dresses change from RED TO BLUE? AMAZING...
You know what guys? both of them are good! they are both high notes `and I think all singer has different way how they sing, and also they are different vocal voice.
@@jerichovlogs7035 Dumbass is not about who sing higher! Mariah's version is untouchable. Mariah's in other song and live, has hit a Bb7. And what? Mariah's lower versión is more clean, stable and serena's version was uncontrolled, sometimes went off pitch and strained! Sorry 😂😂😂
Who wins higher note? That's clearly Serena. I love MC too. I knew MC before Serena. But it shouldn't be hard to admit someone else is rising up. No one will be on top forever. And of course we actually need it to be that way. Keeps us humble. Someone will surpass Serena in the same way or better, in the course of time. However, I do admit too that MC's was clearer. Don't know if that's just voice or music equipment.
Serena was literally terrible. Just cause somebody can scream a couple notes higher than somebody doesn’t mean that they are any better. Serena’s control and pitch were nonexistent. “Rising up”??? This video came out around 10 years ago (this is a reupload) and we haven’t heard anything else from her. She probably blew out her untalented voice.
Higher isn’t always better. Not only did Mariah sing it better, she can still go even higher and lower than that girl’s vocal range. This song was made a certain way to sound a certain way and Mariah knocked it out of the park and Serena just added like two or three higher notes. Let it be known that the quality of Serena’s notes and Mariah’s own are in entirely different leagues, but she added some notes so credit where credit is due. But if Mariah decided that adding those notes were necessary, best believe if would have wiped the floor with the extra notes Serena added. It’s not a mean or bad thing though. It’s literally Mariah Carey.
Mariah of course. You can't compare, and grown woman with a child, moreover Mariah has more lows, and Mariah can go higher than her, of course C7 note in Mariah's version wouldn't fit. It's about key, and I prefer the lowest version. Let's put this up side down, I wanna see Serena sing this in the original key, of course she can't.
A Serena está cantando com um som de estúdio enquanto a MC parece está fazendo no ao vivo. Acredito que para ser um vídeo de parâmetros deveria está ambas no mesmo estilo de gravação.
@@driveTOPlaya Not for all voices. Karen Clark sheard is one who’s voice stayed the same weight wise and timbre. Her voice didn’t get darker even past her 60’s.
No se trata solo de cantar las notas más agudas sino de transmitir emoción a través del canto, en este último aspecto Mariah se lleva de calle a la niña, se entiende que la experiencia hace la diferencia, por lo que la comparación es injusta.
MC napaka clear ng voice even in a high notes even in her whistling is also very clear napa kaganda ng boses niya di nkakasawang pakinggan..its clearly MC has won this battle😃
And then there is the beautiful version. Oh, Holy Night "SO HYANG" of Korea. Watch it and then tell me there is a better version!!! Don't get me wrong Iove the little Indonesian, Serena and Mariah, well I had a vision of love the first time I heard her!!! So Hyang's Oh, Holy Night and Bridge Over Troubled Water and Lean On Me with Michael Bolton watching her sing it!!
Serena went higher, therefore she won. Just because it's pre recorded people are bashing her? Uh okay. Mariah Carey pre recorded her version. This person just decided to use a live version to compare.
higher doesn't mean better. Mariah's version is musically good and pleasant to the ear while Serena's (no offense to her) version only cares about high notes (her high notes are all over the place) and dodge ALL the low notes on Mariah's version.
They're both good, but the mariah fans i think got a little bit mad of serena oasis cover because of the words saying like, 1/2 higher than Mariah Carey's cover.
Those who say Serena sang it better either has a childish taste, delusional, biased or ignorant about singing technicalities. Even a normal person would be able to tell something that is all over the place and irritating to the ear, y'all know who please.
Both are very good but I feel young lady was out of control hightly she's don't know how control her voice she's can sing but I can't compare Maria she's increable all over the world this song
Serena Onasis Did it So Much Better...what a Singer she is love her cover of "oh holy night" singing on a boat or dock...when she was 13....OMG she is great
Live vs recorded, really? Mariah's low versión is better, is deep and it is on pitch! Serena's version was uncontrolled and sometimes went off pitch! And I have to say serena's tone on her upper belt wasn't clear and sounds unpleasant and a little shouty! 😂😂😂 Who made this is a really stupid person!
Mariah. Serena is great too, but it seems like it’s pre recorded.
I think it is, you can see her dress change
It definetly is, but it doesn't sound like she faked her whistles
Yes its recorded aiii Mariah is live
All videos are pre-record and edit and refine and normally takes days to completely
I still go for Mori's live version!
Hi people with great music taste
Hello
Hahahahha
hii
Higher = Serena
Clean and sexy = MC
:D
sariaty rosanti AGREED
Serena is just better all around
@@haroldk724 there's no harmony in her high notes BEFORE
LoL
More amazing than her singing the highest notes EVER! Is the fact she can change outfits between notes. Did anyone notice that her dresses change from RED TO BLUE? AMAZING...
Lmaoo. I noticed that too. She did it in the studio and did a music video for it
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Because its recorded
While change the clothe,, she transformed to be a cat to hit that high note
The audio is only one but the videos are many. She is still playing fair.
You know what guys? both of them are good! they are both high notes `and I think all singer has different way how they sing, and also they are different vocal voice.
That’s all isn’t only about highest is vocal voices, both are in two different range of voices.
I'm in the Christmas spirit now
RexyTheDinosaur Films lol
Mariah😍 it does not matter how high the whistle is. it matters on how clean it is. no one can defeat Mariah. SING TO EXPRESS NOT TO IMPRESS😍
Serena is the higher version of mariah the whistle of mariah are C6 but serena are C7
But who's the cleaner?
Mariah!!! ❤️ Everything you said is true tho
Booo
@@jerichovlogs7035 Dumbass is not about who sing higher! Mariah's version is untouchable. Mariah's in other song and live, has hit a Bb7. And what? Mariah's lower versión is more clean, stable and serena's version was uncontrolled, sometimes went off pitch and strained! Sorry 😂😂😂
Serena may be higher but mariah carey voice is more beautiful she is very brave to compare her
Mariah because Serena had a lot of auto tune with the whistle notes and it was pre recorded
Who wins higher note? That's clearly Serena. I love MC too. I knew MC before Serena. But it shouldn't be hard to admit someone else is rising up. No one will be on top forever. And of course we actually need it to be that way. Keeps us humble. Someone will surpass Serena in the same way or better, in the course of time.
However, I do admit too that MC's was clearer. Don't know if that's just voice or music equipment.
Serena was literally terrible. Just cause somebody can scream a couple notes higher than somebody doesn’t mean that they are any better. Serena’s control and pitch were nonexistent. “Rising up”??? This video came out around 10 years ago (this is a reupload) and we haven’t heard anything else from her. She probably blew out her untalented voice.
MC is luv Serena is recorded
m.th-cam.com/video/M4qX3_8DLBc/w-d-xo.html, here's serena's live version.
Higher isn’t always better. Not only did Mariah sing it better, she can still go even higher and lower than that girl’s vocal range. This song was made a certain way to sound a certain way and Mariah knocked it out of the park and Serena just added like two or three higher notes. Let it be known that the quality of Serena’s notes and Mariah’s own are in entirely different leagues, but she added some notes so credit where credit is due. But if Mariah decided that adding those notes were necessary, best believe if would have wiped the floor with the extra notes Serena added. It’s not a mean or bad thing though. It’s literally Mariah Carey.
Serena is a child.Mariah already paved her way to legendaries.....Mariah cannot be compared.... Everyone is special in their own unique ways....
Mariah= solid high and low notes and perfect color, emotion and flavor
Serena onasis from INDONESIA..THANKS❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
They're both great in singing i don't believe in comparison...❤
You two are insanely good!
Being as young as she is, she can sing really high which could probably improve to be as great and clean as mariah’s 😊
It’s June and I’m listening to dis!? But it’s great 👍
Love u serena in Christ Name, only praise God! this is your talent came from Heaven Singing Palace.
That's why she can hit such a high note cuz of the wind......I guess
99% of the comments: she is so at singing. That 1% me: how she changing like dat!?
Increible voz celestial… definitivamente Los Ángeles prestan sus voces de vez en cuando, a seres mortales…
They’re both great in their own way
I'm really impressed...
wow this is hit..... what a voice
Sarena Onasis from Indonesia
Mariah of course. You can't compare, and grown woman with a child, moreover Mariah has more lows, and Mariah can go higher than her, of course C7 note in Mariah's version wouldn't fit. It's about key, and I prefer the lowest version. Let's put this up side down, I wanna see Serena sing this in the original key, of course she can't.
William Lucas, you are right! This is true!
@@dia9218 Yess and her upper belt was uncontrolled, strained and her tone in the high belt was unpleasant and sounds shouty, just not good!
Serena Onassis hun er bare total suveræn, langt bedre end resten, love her. Superp
Mariah sounds great
A Serena está cantando com um som de estúdio enquanto a MC parece está fazendo no ao vivo. Acredito que para ser um vídeo de parâmetros deveria está ambas no mesmo estilo de gravação.
RIP earphones user.
LOL...AMEN
Serena onasis
Higher doesn't mean Better
Booo
@@fcc2399 Why booo?
@Do Do so truueeeee
Serena wow
I think I'm impressed by mariah Carey's performance because she can sing it in her age of 40🌠🌠🌠🌠
Age has nothing to do with it. All ages of people have beautiful singing voices and talent.and btw 40 really isn't that old.
@@lashawnablanton4649 still mc
@@lashawnablanton4649 but when you rich 40 yrs old your voice would be more darker and matured
@@driveTOPlaya Not for all voices. Karen Clark sheard is one who’s voice stayed the same weight wise and timbre. Her voice didn’t get darker even past her 60’s.
Serena Onasis✨
Both are wow so amazing girls. Personally I love Serena Voice but we have to see Mariah I kinda older and voice change with. Btw i love the two voices
Can't stop praying this beautiful song much appreciation selena
No se trata solo de cantar las notas más agudas sino de transmitir emoción a través del canto, en este último aspecto Mariah se lleva de calle a la niña, se entiende que la experiencia hace la diferencia, por lo que la comparación es injusta.
Serena!!!!!!!? Onasis:)
MC napaka clear ng voice even in a high notes even in her whistling is also very clear napa kaganda ng boses niya di nkakasawang pakinggan..its clearly MC has won this battle😃
Both
Mariah cleaned my ears please don't compare the screaming with singing
RIP earphone's user
Mariah Carey é inigualável ❤❤❤
Serena
maria carey i love hehe
Mariah can still hit higher notes
nope still serena
No she can't lol her highest is B7.
@@sierra6293 mariah's o holy night highest note is not B7 but B6
Mariah Carey sing beautifully, she hit the low note so effortless and of course hit the high note with control.
Mariah Carey sounded more angelic
I like serena
And then there is the beautiful version. Oh, Holy Night "SO HYANG" of Korea. Watch it and then tell me there is a better version!!! Don't get me wrong Iove the little Indonesian, Serena and Mariah, well I had a vision of love the first time I heard her!!! So Hyang's Oh, Holy Night and Bridge Over Troubled Water and Lean On Me with Michael Bolton watching her sing it!!
Who si higher oh holy night Serena Onassis or Mariah Carey
Serena's voice is a lot more powerful and a lot more clear and hitting a D7 is very hard
Serena!
Pls... Mariah carey's no comparison. One and only. Shes the best😂😂😂
Mariah carey lah.. Quen Of Quen..
SARENA!!!!!
Sejak kapan Mad Dog bisa main keyboard?
Serena went higher, therefore she won. Just because it's pre recorded people are bashing her? Uh okay. Mariah Carey pre recorded her version. This person just decided to use a live version to compare.
higher doesn't mean better. Mariah's version is musically good and pleasant to the ear while Serena's (no offense to her) version only cares about high notes (her high notes are all over the place) and dodge ALL the low notes on Mariah's version.
Mariah Carey's Influence Y'all
Serena was great
Whistle Voice C7 ❤️
Serena Onasis boleh😊😊
Am I the only one that liked Sarina more!
Nope!
Serena!!
They're both good, but the mariah fans i think got a little bit mad of serena oasis cover because of the words saying like, 1/2 higher than Mariah Carey's cover.
In terms of Music Technicalities, MC wins
Serena is screaming
Ya jelas mariah carey dong... Semua orang tau siapa dia dong...🙏
Serena terbaik....goblok..dia orang indo❤❤❤❤❤
Serena= shouting
Mariah= Singing real Music
Those who say Serena sang it better either has a childish taste, delusional, biased or ignorant about singing technicalities. Even a normal person would be able to tell something that is all over the place and irritating to the ear, y'all know who please.
I'm a Mariah Carey fan but Serena sings it better.
Aint a fan of either but serena's was all over the place and very annoying to the ear. perfect example of "higher isn't always better".
Now your just lying she sounds like shit
Lol
Hahaha...dont compare selena to mariah carey! Obviously mariah carey can slay it!!! Damn 🤣
By far Serena is way better she was up higher with more vocals Mariah and she was singing to a camera, not even an audience.
Both are very good but I feel young lady was out of control hightly she's don't know how control her voice she's can sing but I can't compare Maria she's increable all over the world this song
She is indonesiann not filipino
Mariah is Mariah
Serena is Autotune
XD
Sooo true hahahah even her whitsle wass not really stable
Mariah coul hit higher notes that what Serena hit if would want to. Serena's chest voice sounds a bit screamy..
Tbh serena's take sounds edited in melodine
Mariah
Sorry young one but Mariah is in her own league.
Ojo dibanding bandingke
Serena Onasis Did it So Much Better...what a Singer she is love her cover of "oh holy night" singing on a boat or dock...when she was 13....OMG she is great
Mariah Carey is better
Just because it’s higher don’t mean it’s better because she sound a MESS SORRY😩😭😭
Kok gua lbh suka versi celine dion
Battle of the same aged not young, of course young other one, miss match for my observation,
Serena can't sing that whistle note in live it's pre-recorded but man Maria just wow ..
Yes she can look up her live videos
😂 you haven’t seen her live i’ve even seen
Why would Mariah be compared to a child.....Wate hel....Nee fok🙈🙈🙈🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦
lipsyn
🖕🖕
🤣🤣🤣
Mariah is lypsyncing..
Live vs recorded, really? Mariah's low versión is better, is deep and it is on pitch! Serena's version was uncontrolled and sometimes went off pitch! And I have to say serena's tone on her upper belt wasn't clear and sounds unpleasant and a little shouty! 😂😂😂 Who made this is a really stupid person!
Her whistles sound autotuned lol
They were all auto tuned
that was a fakest whistle i ever heard😏
Serena
Mariah
Serena!
Serena onasis
Mariah
Serena
Serena
Mariah