So interesting as I watched this video it occurred to me that for at least a year I no longer feel a need to go to the movies or even watch TV, streaming nor do I feel a need to listen to the radio station or music I used to listen to. Things that were so "important" to me have simply fallen away since I had returned to the faith in 2023 and immersed myself in reading Catholic books, reading the Bible, going to mass, and a prayer life that includes daily rosaries and other devotions. It really does change your whole being and mind in the most gentlest way - so gentle you don't even notice the transformation.
And yet... Good movies can help people to understand others and also to understand what can be wrong in our own behavior... Especially Kdramas, such as The king eternal monark, It's ok not to be ok, Are you human....
These books speak for themselves if You can find them and read them yourself. There were 5 volumes written as well as some smaller booklets given to Maria Valtorta by Heaven. They are written in such a way as to make you feel like you are watching the events many of which are described in the Bible(but in a more short-handed; just to make a point manner) not alive as in these beautiful writings!
I see St Charbel, behind you there.. just to let you and your viewers know that his relic will be in the Dominicans, The Black Friars church in Kilkenny next weekend. Sun from 4 pm to 6 ☺️🕊️🙏🏽
I was blessed when I read the ten volumes. I was unaware of the criticisms so I read it without scrutiny or bias. Someone I respect mentioned to read the book regarding Mary from the works of Maria Valtorta and in looking for it I came across the volumes and began reading. I’m so very thankful! It was like cold water for a thirsty soul. The details endeared me to Jesus, it reminds me of where it says in scripture “He went about doing good” pages and pages of Jesus doing good! With so much love that when the transition comes to nearer His passion, death I could feel the heaviness in the change. How Maria V must have suffered seeing these visions so clearly!
My lovely mummy has been reading this since 1989 without stopping she’s always torturing us to read it and I don’t enjoy reading. The words seem to go together on me. I prefer to listen to stuff which is why I’m listening to your podcast. I’m going to have to make the effort. It was written by a woman who was bed bound, she was ill. She was in her bed in Italy towards the end of the second world War. It has to be revelation and Pope John Paul II loved it and Padre Pio loved it.
Father roshini has enlightened me on Maria valtorta and I don’t find it offensive like Luisa piccaretta it draws me closer to God and our blessed mother
@@thecatholicman There are some lovely holy things said by Luisa but like the apparitions in Lourdes there were many other apparitions and all looked very holy and many fell for them but on closer inspection turned out to be demonic in nature I remember a lecture by father John hardon who investigated apparitions and mystics etc and showing some he investigated to a Protestant friend he couldn’t believe his eyes and was convinced of there authenticity and he looked at him and laughed and said I’m condemning them all the Catholic Church is very strict when it comes to the matter of apparitions etc
I think it’s a blessing if people get the grace to get time to read ,but even though I be busy at work , sometimes we don’t realise how many times we read or listen to the word of God each day , in daily readings or when we go to mass, there was something you said there Robert maria book which I agree , it opened up the scriptures. I only as I say read one book ,maybe in the future I will get the grace to read them all , as I said before in the last comment, it’s the attention to detail especially,I really felt the Holy Spirit open up my heart to specific background information on the scriptures and felt I was there myself witnessing this. True like all books translated into English you will get errors but these are minimal , but no human being could write this ,it would be impossible to make up volumes and volumes . God bless ,to mass now the struggle goes on in my life just like everyone else 🙏
Reading the Poem of the Man-God brought about the conversion of my son and his return to the Church. As for me, it has deepened my faith and relationship with our Lord. So, therefore, the "fruits" of reading it has been very good in our lives. Haven't you ever wondered why, after three years of His public ministry, there wasn't more in the Gospels? The poem also brings the personalities of the apostles and holy women, to life. After reading the Poem, all five volumes, I think the title should have been, "The Gospel According to Jesus." That's because, by western thought, it is not a poem.
We're capable of learning many things and are blessed to have someone such as yourself willing to teach us. Thankyou & God bless! *Jesus was a storyteller*🙏🕊📿☘️
Thank you , we must all learn to discern, I will try get this book what's to loose, I've been reading many books so why not this. My main reading though is the bible and for any advice I go to the catachism.🙏🙏🙏
One of the very important signs that we should listen to is the Church when it rules on any visionary, to ignore that is to call out the Church as being wrong. Maria Valtorta's book has been condemned by the Church on a number of occasions and yet this is ignored. Cardinal Ratzinger said of the writings: The 'Visions' and 'dictations' referred to in the work, The Poem of the Man-God are simply literary forms used by the author to narrate in her own way the life of Jesus. The cannot be considered supernatural in origin. The Apostolic nuncio Archbishop Agostino Cacciavillan, pointed out that, although the index was abolished in 1965, it still retains its moral force and faithful Catholics should heed the reservations and cautions expressed in it. Are we that desperate for to be close to Christ we need to turn to books written by someone whose writings have been decided are NOT be of supernatural origin. No wonder there is such a split in the Church when the congregation are seeking anything to know Christ. As you said: the Four Gospels are enough.
Article III of the Apostles Creed reads: "Who was Conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary " The Catechism of the Council of Trent was promulgated by a great Dominican Pope, St. Pius V. Where this Catechism discusses the third article of the Apostles Creed, it does so using one of tbe most beautiful and sublime pieces of prose I have ever read. It lifts us up and completely engages the mind, heart and soul in union with the most Holy Trinity. So do many other non controversial books on the basics of the Faith. Can anyone who has ever read 'The Incredible Catholic Mass ' by Fr. Martin von Cochem, not put it down, feeling more united with Christ than ever? Robert recommends using Lectio Divina to read sacred Scripture. As do I. It fosters a deeper union with the most Holy Trinity. Robert refers to the poem of the man-God as Supernatural. I was just wondering when did the Holy Office say this officially? Robert refers to this book as being a sign of Divine Origin and gives the impression it is necessary for our Salvation. It would be great if Robert could confirm this; or say that the book isn't necessary for Salvation. On Pentecost Sunday the Holy Ghost revealed the complete Deposit of Faith to the Apostles. It would be cruel to think, the Holy Ghost didn't reveal that Valtorta is necessary for Salvation, if this be truly so. Valtorta isn't in the Deposit of Faith. So Roman Catholics are free to decide whether to read her or not. My view is that Valtorta isn't necessary for Salvation as she wasn't in the Fidei Depositum at Pentecost. So long as we believe in, and base our lives on the perennial binding public revelation of the Church, the Holy Ghost will lead us to Heaven.
This isn’t a question over salvation. Nobody who reads Valtorta is saying it’s necessary to for salvation. It is efficacious for growth in sanctity though. It’s a catapult into the spiritual life.
@amberdv8796 I asked Robert To clarify whether he was saying Valtorta was a sine qua non for Salvation. As usual he never answers my questions head on and directly. You have now clarified this issue.
As Christ pointed out is why would the demons do good things in the name of God? Evangelicals claim Marian apparitions are demonic because they don't promote Jesus. Well, the "O my Jesus, forgive us our sins. Save us from the fires of Hell, especially those mist in need of your mercy." prayer spoken by the Blessed Mother to the three shepherd childen refutes that. Orémus Y'all.
That is true and it has fostered thousands of Saints. But in the modern age the word of God has been so terribly destroys be so many bishops and priests, and forgotten by laity. God sends a sign when it’s needed.
@@dankmatter3068 Of course we are still Protestant, because the Bible reveals the errors of the Catholic Church, and Martin Luther and others protested about the errors, and the errors still remain. So why shouldn't we still be Protestants?
Robert, I am so surprised and disappointed in those who have such a negative view of Medjugorie and of you. I've been to Medjugorie in 2013, and it has never stopped affecting my life, making me even more aware of our journey here and staying on track toward heaven our home. My heart is stronger toward the holy trinity! I Love God our Father Jesus our Savior and the Holy Spirit our Advocate! Mary leads us to her to the Trinity!
Salvation is possible without the Medjugorje HOAX. If you want to make a pilgrimage to a REAL apparition site I recommend based on experience: Guadeloupe, Lourdes and Fatima. Medjugorje has not been approved by the Holy Office. I disapprove of Medjugorje. I DO NOT have a negative attitude towards Robert. I am sure he would be disappointed if everyone agreed with him all the time.
@dermotquigley356 Well, of course, salvation is possible without Medjugorie, no one has said otherwise! If you were aware of the many fruits from Medjugorie, you might at least Not use the word hoax in sharing your opinion! No one is encouraged to believe in any apparitions.
@@lindakelly49I am entitled to call a dodgy set of unapproved (they will never be approved) apparitions a HOAX. Private revelation is NOT BINDING. THE FIDEI DEPOSITUM IS BINDING.
Don’t worry about those who have a negative view on Medjugorje. There is always going to be a debate about it, and it’s actually healthy. Pray, fast, go to mass, and help those around you. Have faith and be at peace
@@dermotquigley356 If it's a hoax why are these the fruits? satan would be committing suicide. The fruits of Medjugorje 1. Long Lineups for confession 2. Hundreds to thousands for adoration and mass 3. Stations of the Cross 4. Conversions to the Catholic Faith 5. Renewal of Catholic living
Have you read Maria Valtorta’s volumes volumes called The Notebooks (I have 2of them) and also her book called The End Times? These are a very interesting read. These are also dictations from Christ.
Folks. Cardinal Ratzinger has stated that there is no supernatural origin in the poem of the Man God. John Paul 11 confirmed this view as well. End of story. Robert is not the repository of knowledge of whose writings are supernatural or not. You only have to Google for all the information you need .
Thank you Sharon for clarifying this. In my comment I asked Robert when did the Holy Office declare Valtorta poem Supernatural. Thanks to your research we now know the Holy Office never said anything of the sort.
@dankmatter3068 Where have I said I don't like Robert? I respect him but don't agree with him on everything. So can you point to a specific comment I have made where I say I don't like Robert ? Robert, could you confirm please, that you only want people who are pro Maria Valtorta to follow your channel? If that is so, I shall unsubscribe. Do you want people who accept the perennial binding public revelation of the Church but not Medjugorje to steer clear of your channel? Do you want people who disagree with you on anything, to steer clear of your channel? You REALLY need to Clarify this.
I was seriously going to go and read it until I read the comments, and there was an association with Medjugorge, and as hard as I’ve tried, I am unable to believe anything about Medjugorge is from Heaven.
"You will know them by their fruits." The fruits of Medjugorje 1. Long Lineups for confession 2. Hundreds to thousands for adoration and mass 3. Stations of the Cross 4. Conversions to the Catholic Faith 5. Renewal of Catholic living The fruits of Maria Valtorta's writings 1. Deepening in love for Jesus and Mary 2. More detailed explanation of the gospel 3. Peace, love and joy
The problemn is nowdays people can be very easily missled because they know nothing about God, the Gospel, the church... So all these private revelations and the apocryphal gospels it's a big mess... easy to feal lost...easy to have a wrong understanding of the "divine will" and even Louisa Picaretta puts thing so weardly as if she was talking about her lover 😵💫 the safest thing to do is to cling to the four Gospel... For the rest, don't get lost....
On Mary tv on internet on Saturday 7 September UK starting I think 4pm time Ivan Visionary from Medjugorje has invited all to pray 2 Rosaries and be with Ivan Live in his Chapel to receive Our Beautiful Blessed Mother 🌹 in Ivans Apparition,this is A Beautiful Grace dont miss it, rita England 🙏🌍🙏🌹🕊️This happened yesterday and you can see recording on Marytv🌹Thanks be to God🌹 and Our Beautiful Blessed Mother 🌹🙏🌍🙏🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️
Robert darling. You are becoming more and more fanatical in every post. You behave as if your posts are beyond criticism. They are not. Dont let your posts become your addiction.
Robert , It is settled!!! Stop preaching. Our Lady said to read it when sh was asked by the visionaries in Medjugorje. Father Leon Pereira highly recommends it due to this. It’s legit!!! Our Lady approves it and recommends it!!
I know I keep saying this, but I believe Medjugorje is a hoax. I would just ask anyone to be careful when your ego comes into play. And I was there, in the very early days.
@@VictorMaxol You are free not to believe, for God lets us to choose Life or Death on our own free will. I was an atheist before and, through Medjugorje, I became a Catholic. You do not know, nor understand. May God have mercy and grant understanding. Amen!
@@dermotquigley356 You're asking someone else to explain your belief? It's a nonsensical request. There are many things that aren't strictly necessary for salvation or explicitly part of the deposit of faith, but that doesn't make them invalid. For example, devotions such as the Rosary or Carmelite Scapular aren't necessary for salvation as such. But we'd be ill advised to ignore them. Apparitions such as Knock or Kibeho aren't part of the deposit of faith, but they give us an important message that is relevant to our salvation. You are free to believe or not believe in any apparition, but that, or reading a private revelation, has nothing to do with acknowledging the deposit of faith. Very separate things.
When I was young (the 80's) Valtortas books inflamed faith in my family. Our beautifully illustrated family bible was only opened to be admired not studied.
So interesting as I watched this video it occurred to me that for at least a year I no longer feel a need to go to the movies or even watch TV, streaming nor do I feel a need to listen to the radio station or music I used to listen to. Things that were so "important" to me have simply fallen away since I had returned to the faith in 2023 and immersed myself in reading Catholic books, reading the Bible, going to mass, and a prayer life that includes daily rosaries and other devotions. It really does change your whole being and mind in the most gentlest way - so gentle you don't even notice the transformation.
So gorgeous
❤❤
And yet... Good movies can help people to understand others and also to understand what can be wrong in our own behavior... Especially Kdramas, such as The king eternal monark, It's ok not to be ok, Are you human....
Another great video from you. Thank you for all you do Robert.
These books speak for themselves if You can find them and read them yourself. There were 5 volumes written as well as some smaller booklets given to Maria Valtorta by Heaven. They are written in such a way as to make you feel like you are watching the events many of which are described in the Bible(but in a more short-handed; just to make a point manner) not alive as in these beautiful writings!
I see St Charbel, behind you there.. just to let you and your viewers know that his relic will be in the Dominicans, The Black Friars church in Kilkenny next weekend. Sun from 4 pm to 6 ☺️🕊️🙏🏽
I was blessed when I read the ten volumes. I was unaware of the criticisms so I read it without scrutiny or bias. Someone I respect mentioned to read the book regarding Mary from the works of Maria Valtorta and in looking for it I came across the volumes and began reading. I’m so very thankful! It was like cold water for a thirsty soul. The details endeared me to Jesus, it reminds me of where it says in scripture “He went about doing good” pages and pages of Jesus doing good! With so much love that when the transition comes to nearer His passion, death I could feel the heaviness in the change. How Maria V must have suffered seeing these visions so clearly!
My lovely mummy has been reading this since 1989 without stopping she’s always torturing us to read it and I don’t enjoy reading. The words seem to go together on me. I prefer to listen to stuff which is why I’m listening to your podcast. I’m going to have to make the effort. It was written by a woman who was bed bound, she was ill. She was in her bed in Italy towards the end of the second world War. It has to be revelation and Pope John Paul II loved it and Padre Pio loved it.
Father roshini has enlightened me on Maria valtorta and I don’t find it offensive like Luisa piccaretta it draws me closer to God and our blessed mother
Luisa writes a completely different genre
@@thecatholicman
The book Lady chatterleys lover is timid compared 🫢
@@martinmartin1363 I don’t understand the divine will spirituality at all. Maybe when I become holier it will click.
@@thecatholicman
There are some lovely holy things said by Luisa but like the apparitions in Lourdes there were many other apparitions and all looked very holy and many fell for them but on closer inspection turned out to be demonic in nature
I remember a lecture by father John hardon who investigated apparitions and mystics etc and showing some he investigated to a Protestant friend he couldn’t believe his eyes and was convinced of there authenticity and he looked at him and laughed and said I’m condemning them all the Catholic Church is very strict when it comes to the matter of apparitions etc
Thank you Robert. Lord bless you and yours.
I think it’s a blessing if people get the grace to get time to read ,but even though I be busy at work , sometimes we don’t realise how many times we read or listen to the word of God each day , in daily readings or when we go to mass, there was something you said there Robert maria book which I agree , it opened up the scriptures. I only as I say read one book ,maybe in the future I will get the grace to read them all , as I said before in the last comment, it’s the attention to detail especially,I really felt the Holy Spirit open up my heart to specific background information on the scriptures and felt I was there myself witnessing this.
True like all books translated into English you will get errors but these are minimal , but no human being could write this ,it would be impossible to make up volumes and volumes .
God bless ,to mass now the struggle goes on in my life just like everyone else 🙏
Reading the Poem of the Man-God brought about the conversion of my son and his return to the Church. As for me, it has deepened my faith and relationship with our Lord. So, therefore, the "fruits" of reading it has been very good in our lives. Haven't you ever wondered why, after three years of His public ministry, there wasn't more in the Gospels? The poem also brings the personalities of the apostles and holy women, to life.
After reading the Poem, all five volumes, I think the title should have been, "The Gospel According to Jesus." That's because, by western thought, it is not a poem.
We're capable of learning many things and are blessed to have someone such as yourself willing to teach us. Thankyou & God bless! *Jesus was a storyteller*🙏🕊📿☘️
Thank you very much Robert 🙏❤️
Isn’t this like the Mystical City of God and the revelations from Bl. Anne Catherine Emmerich? I’m intrigued.
The mystical body of God was destroyed and rewritten years later. Emmerich’s works are heavily edited by brentano
Thank you , we must all learn to discern, I will try get this book what's to loose, I've been reading many books so why not this. My main reading though is the bible and for any advice I go to the catachism.🙏🙏🙏
Please do!
One of the very important signs that we should listen to is the Church when it rules on any visionary, to ignore that is to call out the Church as being wrong.
Maria Valtorta's book has been condemned by the Church on a number of occasions and yet this is ignored.
Cardinal Ratzinger said of the writings: The 'Visions' and 'dictations' referred to in the work, The Poem of the Man-God are simply literary forms used by the author to narrate in her own way the life of Jesus. The cannot be considered supernatural in origin.
The Apostolic nuncio Archbishop Agostino Cacciavillan, pointed out that, although the index was abolished in 1965, it still retains its moral force and faithful Catholics should heed the reservations and cautions expressed in it. Are we that desperate for to be close to Christ we need to turn to books written by someone whose writings have been decided are NOT be of supernatural origin. No wonder there is such a split in the Church when the congregation are seeking anything to know Christ. As you said: the Four Gospels are enough.
Article III of the Apostles Creed reads: "Who was Conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary "
The Catechism of the Council of Trent was promulgated by a great Dominican Pope, St. Pius V.
Where this Catechism discusses the third article of the Apostles Creed, it does so using one of tbe most beautiful and sublime pieces of prose I have ever read. It lifts us up and completely engages the mind, heart and soul in union with the most Holy Trinity.
So do many other non controversial books on the basics of the Faith. Can anyone who has ever read 'The Incredible Catholic Mass ' by Fr. Martin von Cochem, not put it down, feeling more united with Christ than ever?
Robert recommends using Lectio Divina to read sacred Scripture. As do I. It fosters a deeper union with the most Holy Trinity.
Robert refers to the poem of the man-God as Supernatural. I was just wondering when did the Holy Office say this officially?
Robert refers to this book as being a sign of Divine Origin and gives the impression it is necessary for our Salvation. It would be great if Robert could confirm this; or say that the book isn't necessary for Salvation.
On Pentecost Sunday the Holy Ghost revealed the complete Deposit of Faith to the Apostles. It would be cruel to think, the Holy Ghost didn't reveal that Valtorta is necessary for Salvation, if this be truly so.
Valtorta isn't in the Deposit of Faith. So Roman Catholics are free to decide whether to read her or not. My view is that Valtorta isn't necessary for Salvation as she wasn't in the Fidei Depositum at Pentecost.
So long as we believe in, and base our lives on the perennial binding public revelation of the Church, the Holy Ghost will lead us to Heaven.
This isn’t a question over salvation. Nobody who reads Valtorta is saying it’s necessary to for salvation. It is efficacious for growth in sanctity though. It’s a catapult into the spiritual life.
@amberdv8796 I asked Robert
To clarify whether he was saying Valtorta was a sine qua non for Salvation.
As usual he never answers my questions head on and directly.
You have now clarified this issue.
As Christ pointed out is why would the demons do good things in the name of God? Evangelicals claim Marian apparitions are demonic because they don't promote Jesus. Well, the "O my Jesus, forgive us our sins. Save us from the fires of Hell, especially those mist in need of your mercy." prayer spoken by the Blessed Mother to the three shepherd childen refutes that.
Orémus Y'all.
To be honest I don't know how anyone can live without our lovely Blessed Mother.
You only need the word of God, the Bible, nothing else.
That is true and it has fostered thousands of Saints. But in the modern age the word of God has been so terribly destroys be so many bishops and priests, and forgotten by laity. God sends a sign when it’s needed.
Protestants have the word of God and they are still protestant, you need more than that nowadays.
@@dankmatter3068 Of course we are still Protestant, because the Bible reveals the errors of the Catholic Church, and Martin Luther and others protested about the errors, and the errors still remain. So why shouldn't we still be Protestants?
Robert, I am so surprised and disappointed in those who have such a negative view of Medjugorie and of you. I've been to Medjugorie in 2013, and it has never stopped affecting my life, making me even more aware of our journey here and staying on track toward heaven our home. My heart is stronger toward the holy trinity! I Love God our Father Jesus our Savior and the Holy Spirit our Advocate! Mary leads us to her to the Trinity!
Salvation is possible without the Medjugorje HOAX.
If you want to make a pilgrimage to a REAL apparition site I recommend based on experience: Guadeloupe, Lourdes and Fatima.
Medjugorje has not been approved by the Holy Office.
I disapprove of Medjugorje. I DO NOT have a negative attitude towards Robert. I am sure he would be disappointed if everyone agreed with him all the time.
@dermotquigley356 Well, of course, salvation is possible without Medjugorie, no one has said otherwise! If you were aware of the many fruits from Medjugorie, you might at least Not use the word hoax in sharing your opinion! No one is encouraged to believe in any apparitions.
@@lindakelly49I am entitled to call a dodgy set of unapproved (they will never be approved) apparitions a HOAX. Private revelation is NOT BINDING. THE FIDEI DEPOSITUM IS BINDING.
Don’t worry about those who have a negative view on Medjugorje. There is always going to be a debate about it, and it’s actually healthy. Pray, fast, go to mass, and help those around you. Have faith and be at peace
@@dermotquigley356 If it's a hoax why are these the fruits? satan would be committing suicide.
The fruits of Medjugorje
1. Long Lineups for confession
2. Hundreds to thousands for adoration and mass
3. Stations of the Cross
4. Conversions to the Catholic Faith
5. Renewal of Catholic living
Where is the video on Maria? I can't find it. I missed that video. I never heard of her.
Have you read Maria Valtorta’s volumes volumes called The Notebooks (I have 2of them) and also her book called The End Times? These are a very interesting read. These are also dictations from Christ.
Unfortunately these books are so expensive that I will never be able to afford them.
They are all free on the web in digital form or you can listen for free the audio book on Zacchie Sea channel
@@thecatholicmanThank you. I found the audio books on TH-cam and started listening today.
I found the audio books
@@thecatholicman God bless you. From Sydney Australia 🇦🇺
Folks. Cardinal Ratzinger has stated that there is no supernatural origin in the poem of the Man God. John Paul 11 confirmed this view as well. End of story. Robert is not the repository of knowledge of whose writings are supernatural or not. You only have to Google for all the information you need .
Thank you Sharon for clarifying this. In my comment I asked Robert when did the Holy Office declare Valtorta poem Supernatural. Thanks to your research we now know the Holy Office never said anything of the sort.
Cardinal Ratzinger never read the work or the investigations. www.valtorta.org.au/The-Valtorta-Enigma.pdf
If you don't like Robert or Maria Valtorta then you don't have to be here.
@dankmatter3068 Where have I said I don't like Robert? I respect him but don't agree with him on everything.
So can you point to a specific comment I have made where I say I don't like Robert ?
Robert, could you confirm please, that you only want people who are pro Maria Valtorta to follow your channel? If that is so, I shall unsubscribe.
Do you want people who accept the perennial binding public revelation of the Church but not Medjugorje to steer clear of your channel?
Do you want people who disagree with you on anything, to steer clear of your channel?
You REALLY need to Clarify this.
@@dankmatter3068. Darling. I love Robert. I’m trying to help him
Apparently the cinema and Hollywood, was originally Jesuit theatre, a good reason to boycott it.
Apparently, the cinema and Hoolywood was originally Jesuit Theatre, so that is a goog enough reason to boycott it.
I was seriously going to go and read it until I read the comments, and there was an association with Medjugorge, and as hard as I’ve tried, I am unable to believe anything about Medjugorge is from Heaven.
🤦🏻
Entirely Correct. The late Fr. Malachi Martin and even my own regular confessor said it was a HOAX.
It remains UNAPPROVED by the Holy Office.
"You will know them by their fruits."
The fruits of Medjugorje
1. Long Lineups for confession
2. Hundreds to thousands for adoration and mass
3. Stations of the Cross
4. Conversions to the Catholic Faith
5. Renewal of Catholic living
The fruits of Maria Valtorta's writings
1. Deepening in love for Jesus and Mary
2. More detailed explanation of the gospel
3. Peace, love and joy
@@dankmatter3068I don't believe in Medjugorje. I go to confession regularly. I pray the Rosary and stations of the Cross. Imagine that!
The problemn is nowdays people can be very easily missled because they know nothing about God, the Gospel, the church... So all these private revelations and the apocryphal gospels it's a big mess... easy to feal lost...easy to have a wrong understanding of the "divine will" and even Louisa Picaretta puts thing so weardly as if she was talking about her lover 😵💫 the safest thing to do is to cling to the four Gospel... For the rest, don't get lost....
I think the Poem of the Man-God is a very simple reading, Our Lord didn't complicate his message.
On Mary tv on internet on Saturday 7 September UK starting I think 4pm time Ivan Visionary from Medjugorje has invited all to pray 2 Rosaries and be with Ivan Live in his Chapel to receive Our Beautiful Blessed Mother 🌹 in Ivans Apparition,this is A Beautiful Grace dont miss it, rita England 🙏🌍🙏🌹🕊️This happened yesterday and you can see recording on Marytv🌹Thanks be to God🌹 and Our Beautiful Blessed Mother 🌹🙏🌍🙏🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️
Jesus Jesus Jesus 🙏❤️
Robert darling. You are becoming more and more fanatical in every post. You behave as if your posts are beyond criticism. They are not. Dont let your posts become your addiction.
Why are you so disrespectful? If you don't get his point I don't know what to tell you???
Robert , It is settled!!! Stop preaching. Our Lady said to read it when sh was asked by the visionaries in Medjugorje. Father Leon Pereira highly recommends it due to this. It’s legit!!! Our Lady approves it and recommends it!!
Go to Medjugorje.
I know I keep saying this, but I believe Medjugorje is a hoax. I would just ask anyone to be careful when your ego comes into play.
And I was there, in the very early days.
@@VictorMaxol You are free not to believe, for God lets us to choose Life or Death on our own free will. I was an atheist before and, through Medjugorje, I became a Catholic. You do not know, nor understand. May God have mercy and grant understanding. Amen!
@@VictorMaxol A hoax In what way? Increasing and strengthening the Catholic faith? That’s a very crafty work of the Devil.
@@dermotquigley356 You're asking someone else to explain your belief? It's a nonsensical request. There are many things that aren't strictly necessary for salvation or explicitly part of the deposit of faith, but that doesn't make them invalid. For example, devotions such as the Rosary or Carmelite Scapular aren't necessary for salvation as such. But we'd be ill advised to ignore them. Apparitions such as Knock or Kibeho aren't part of the deposit of faith, but they give us an important message that is relevant to our salvation. You are free to believe or not believe in any apparition, but that, or reading a private revelation, has nothing to do with acknowledging the deposit of faith. Very separate things.
When I was young (the 80's) Valtortas books inflamed faith in my family. Our beautifully illustrated family bible was only opened to be admired not studied.