Анна Нетребко несомненно - Бриллиант! У меня нет возможности посещать концерт с её участием....очень её обожаю....умница...дай Бог ей Счастья,Любви и Здоровья!
As a singer, I can tell you that's about as much fun as you can have with your clothes on. It becomes competitive, and the quality (and often volume) just soars.
Me sorprendió que los tres intérpretes estuvieran tan risueños durante la ejecución de un aria dramática. Luego pensé que los que les motivaba la risa era algo relacionado con la carpeta de la partitura. Tenían una sola para los tres y se la veía muy usada y con papeles pegados para marcar las hojas.Parecía la carpeta de un ensayo más que la de una presentación ¿Habrían olvidado o perdido sus carpetas para el concierto?. Tal vez el buen humor fue una manera de superar el inconveniente. Lo importante es que los tres se lucieron en la parte vocal y que su actitud no desentonó dado el clima relajado del concierto. No puedo opinar de la pronunciación del francés por parte de la soprano ni del barítono, pero Kauffman ha sido elogiado en varias ocasiones por franco parlantes por su pronunciación y conocimiento del francés.
Lamentable la voz dura de la soprano, de principio al final. Empujada con mucha PRESION del aire. Escasa ARMONIA entre las 3 voces.... Me dá mucha pena.
Could they not afford to have three books so that each could have one? This is hysterical to watch, but really it's not that bad. The French needs a lot of work, but other than that, I loved it. You could tell that at the end they were so happy to have this over and done with. LOL
I have the impression that at 1:24, Schrott is not looking at his then life partner with appreciation, but rather in amazement at how she pronounces the French ‘sein’, namely like the French ‘ses’: ironically, playfully, in love. Wonderful! (And in the repetition at 1:57: a facial expression that says: Okay, that's just how she's doing it here). It seems to give the lie to her statement that he was only good in bed. But what do we know. All in all, it seems to have been sung sight-read without any rehearsal, what a great performance. Well, you can expect that from those absolutely top singers!
C'est certes pas mal, mais tout de même, cela fait un peu "brut de décoffrage", style "je donne des décibels et des aigus, et appréciez ! Gounod est quand même plus subtil. Certes, le finale de Faust est forte et puissant, mais tout de même, il demande une diction impeccable (ce qui n'est pas le cas ici) et exige de ne pas hurler les notes. Faust, c'est un opéra puissant et haut sur le plan technique, cela ne signifie nullement qu'il requiert des braillards.
Save yourself time. Don't watch these clowns. Find the 1986 rendition with Carol Vaness, Jerry Hadley and James Morris, and watch the respect this piece deserves.
Thanks God Jonas Kaufman is a bit saving this awesome piece of art from a total disaster … What a shame : come on… they need a book to sing the most famous final of one of the most legendary Opera ? They actually don’t sing : they shout ! Just seems they want to expediate this part as fast as they can. No nuance, no interpretation… this is bad. Very bad
Omg....some pf the highest paid opera singers in the world and nobody thought of bringing three scores if they already need them... 🙉🙉🙉 pronounciation and interpretation very weak ... I feel second hand shame for them, sorry :(((
Die drei Herrschaften samt Orchester bemühten sich redlich, leider ganz ohne Erfolg, denn dieses Finale ist für alle hier Beteiligten wohl eine Nummer zu groß. Die Aufnahme mit Sutherland, Corelli & Ghiaurov liegt qualitativ Lichtjahre entfernt vor der hier vorgetragenen Darbietung.
I was at this concert!! Such a fantastic night
Magnifique,Anna Netbretko a une voix extraordinaire, quelle puissance, avec Jonas Kaufmann en plus 👏👏👏 une merveille ❤
Анна Нетребко несомненно - Бриллиант! У меня нет возможности посещать концерт с её участием....очень её обожаю....умница...дай Бог ей Счастья,Любви и Здоровья!
As a singer, I can tell you that's about as much fun as you can have with your clothes on. It becomes competitive, and the quality (and often volume) just soars.
This looked like an experiment that worked. Bravo!!
Thanks for posting.
The silliness is mitigated by the soaring voices.
Quelle belle complicité ça devrait toujours être ainsi l'opéra quelque chose de vivant non ennuyeux !
Fantastic. as was the concert. Thank you.
No me deja compartir este video. Una pena, realmente. Es maravilloso.
Me sorprendió que los tres intérpretes estuvieran tan risueños durante la ejecución de un aria dramática. Luego pensé que los que les motivaba la risa era algo relacionado con la carpeta de la partitura. Tenían una sola para los tres y se la veía muy usada y con papeles pegados para marcar las hojas.Parecía la carpeta de un ensayo más que la de una presentación ¿Habrían olvidado o perdido sus carpetas para el concierto?. Tal vez el buen humor fue una manera de superar el inconveniente.
Lo importante es que los tres se lucieron en la parte vocal y que su actitud no desentonó dado el clima relajado del concierto.
No puedo opinar de la pronunciación del francés por parte de la soprano ni del barítono, pero Kauffman ha sido elogiado en varias ocasiones por franco parlantes por su pronunciación y conocimiento del francés.
Lamentable la voz dura de la soprano, de principio al final. Empujada con mucha PRESION del aire. Escasa ARMONIA entre las 3 voces.... Me dá mucha pena.
sin duda es un area dramatica, creo que su buen humor se debiaa lo bien que estaban cantando algo que -al parecer- no estaba muy ensayado
Fue un pequeño lapsus de la Netrebko al inicio de su intervención
😂👍
Speaking as one who cannot carry a tune in a paper bag, I am SO ENVIOUS, ❤
Toujours la même beauté vocale et physique, la même complicité heureuse et joyeuse , un premier violon et un chef éblouissants
😅
Could they not afford to have three books so that each could have one? This is hysterical to watch, but really it's not that bad. The French needs a lot of work, but other than that, I loved it. You could tell that at the end they were so happy to have this over and done with. LOL
+jc2971 Books? They couldn't memorize it? LOL! You're right, hilarious to watch, but not that bad. Just gotta listen and not watch. :)
No. One book for the three is more informal. More in line with the happy mood of the evening
Did they not know they were going to perform this???
Exactly! Completely amateurish to have the libretto in front of you.
Видно, что спето с листа) Но как спето!Браво!👏
Magnifico!
Um, why wasn't it memorized? Or at least have three separate stands each with their own music...
Great version!
I have the impression that at 1:24, Schrott is not looking at his then life partner with appreciation, but rather in amazement at how she pronounces the French ‘sein’, namely like the French ‘ses’: ironically, playfully, in love. Wonderful! (And in the repetition at 1:57: a facial expression that says: Okay, that's just how she's doing it here). It seems to give the lie to her statement that he was only good in bed. But what do we know.
All in all, it seems to have been sung sight-read without any rehearsal, what a great performance. Well, you can expect that from those absolutely top singers!
Хороший концерт
Bravo!!! 🌟 Bravo!!!🌟 Magnifica Anna Netrebko!!! ♥🌟♥🌟♥🌟
Heard it Live with Ramos Vargas instead of Jonas Kaufmann because he was ill! It was a pity but Vargas was far more than a Backup! Just awesome!
Merveilleux...
Laughing! Gounod and Goethe deserve better!
Faust as opera comique. Next they will do the death scene from Romeo and Juliet.
Sublime !
This was rather strange! But still well done😂
C'est certes pas mal, mais tout de même, cela fait un peu "brut de décoffrage", style "je donne des décibels et des aigus, et appréciez ! Gounod est quand même plus subtil. Certes, le finale de Faust est forte et puissant, mais tout de même, il demande une diction impeccable (ce qui n'est pas le cas ici) et exige de ne pas hurler les notes. Faust, c'est un opéra puissant et haut sur le plan technique, cela ne signifie nullement qu'il requiert des braillards.
A fine performance of a classic ensemble number, although the basso sounds baritonal.
Que coisa mais linda!
Bravo bravo bravo
Yes Charles, Erwin's French is terrible indeed, but his voice is terrific !!!
ощущение, будто они все пытались переорать друг друга🤔
Espetacular.
G BOPERAC LINDISIMOS VIDEOS Y MUY BUEN SONIDO .......
👍💖💐🌹
A surprise - I had never heard Anna as Marguerite or Erwin as the devil
ø
A coté de la plaque, les pauvres... et çà les fait rire !
Талантливо
Прелестно!!!!
Is it that difficult to commit to memory? It's a serious part, not comedic.
Injustamente a los divos se les perdona todo.
Save yourself time. Don't watch these clowns. Find the 1986 rendition with Carol Vaness, Jerry Hadley and James Morris, and watch the respect this piece deserves.
Thanks God Jonas Kaufman is a bit saving this awesome piece of art from a total disaster … What a shame : come on… they need a book to sing the most famous final of one of the most legendary Opera ?
They actually don’t sing : they shout ! Just seems they want to expediate this part as fast as they can. No nuance, no interpretation… this is bad. Very bad
Exactly. Using the music in front of them was like a college concert.
Anna Netrebko turned into Castafiore :/
Шротт прикольный))
Omg....some pf the highest paid opera singers in the world and nobody thought of bringing three scores if they already need them... 🙉🙉🙉 pronounciation and interpretation very weak ... I feel second hand shame for them, sorry :(((
지겨워 성악계에는 그얼굴이 그얼굴이네 우리나라 만해도 소프라노들중에 세계적인 역량을 가진가수들 꽤 있던데 제발좀 적극적인 사고를 가지고 유럽무대에 적극 진출했으면 함
now that was horrible!!! my favourite opera manhandled by three mismatched voices!!! be honest people
Hey I'm new in opera, can you explain why? I still can't identify between what's good and bad here haha
@@Mariana16562 ...first and foremost, this an opera you have memorized. Singing from the score is extremely amateur.
French vocal coaches could improve this a lot. The Russian is by default the best.
Une partition imprimée pour trois hahahaha. Y a plus de pognon.
Erwin's French is atrocious.
who cares - l am listening to the voice (and never to the way it is pronounced) which is important in MY opinion
Eccellente !
Schrott is a caricature of Mefisto. Ana's ending totally too low.
Sie ist sehr bemüht, ihre 2 berühmten Tenöre zu überschreien,
unangenehm
Terrible.
Michiel de Beer, si, terribile. Una fiera di paese.
Netrebko on aime ou on n aime pas. Moi je n aime pas.
A circus and clowns.
Die drei Herrschaften samt Orchester bemühten sich redlich, leider ganz ohne Erfolg, denn dieses Finale ist für alle hier Beteiligten wohl eine Nummer zu groß. Die Aufnahme mit Sutherland, Corelli & Ghiaurov liegt qualitativ Lichtjahre entfernt vor der hier vorgetragenen Darbietung.
Жз
Fat show?
Hubbidub