I agree but there should be a requirement to use the sample in creative ways so people don't just take music and lazily repurpose it. And if free sampling was a thing then it should be required for samplers to credit their samples. I respect hip hop artists who don't want to tell people what samples they use but I also think by doing so, those producers are being disrespectful to the artists they're sampling. Many artists who get sampled just want credit where it's due.
@@carstarsarstenstesenn first off, trying to legally define “transformative” or “creative” sampling is one of the reasons free sampling isn’t a thing yet, because big labels will always try and abuse that to discourage sampling more and more. All forms of sampling are valid, period. Calling some uses of sampling “creative” and others “lazy” misses the entire point of sampling in the first place. Secondly, I assure you most if not all sample based artists would be more than happy to give proper attribution to everything if free sampling was a thing. The entire reason people hide samples is because of copyright law, not to be greedy Patricia Taxxon has a great series on TH-cam called “the golden calf” which does a really good job of explaining how complete and utter copyright abolition is the only way for artists to have true creative freedom, I recommend you check it out (dw they’re only like 15 or 20 minutes total)
@@tescomealdeals I used to have the same perspective as you, but it's not that simple. You can definitely use a sample in a lazy way. A lot of less talented artists out there who take a sample and do nothing original with it. There would be people who would exploit it just to be lazy and make money from other people's work. And I assure you that there would be a significant amount of artists that would still not credit their samples even if required to. You seem to think all artists are nice people or something 😂 it's a lot of assholes out there, which is why artists feel the need to copyright their music. I'm usually on the side that sampling should be free game but we can't just let everyone sample whoever they want. It would be chaos
@@carstarsarstenstesenn whether or not you consider a use of sampling lazy is completely irrelevant, it’s still a valid form of musical expression. Think about it like this, there are arguably some very “lazy” ways to play guitar, for example you can just play nothing but a I-IV-V progression on a bunch of different songs. Is that lazy? Yeah, kinda. Can you criticise someone’s music for such a thing? Of course. Do you have the right to argue they shouldn’t be allowed to make said music? Absolutely not. Putting a stupid ass requirement of “creativity” on sampling is doing just that, restricting other people’s art because it doesn’t fit your subjective criteria of what defines originality. As Sean Booth of Autechre said, “this whole idea of judging music based off of how much effort it took is full of fail.” A good song being achieved “lazily” is made no worse by that fact. Second, you saying “there’s a lot of assholes” is just an awfully cynical take. Most people on this earth are nice and most artists who care at all about music will be more than happy to share samples if they were allowed to without legal repercussions. Just saying “but some people aren’t nice” is a lazy and reductive way of reasoning. But to be clear, I agree that attribution should be mandatory if free sampling became a thing, I’m just saying that the reason most people who hide samples right now choose to do so isn’t because they’re assholes who wanna keep samples to themselves it’s because they’d get demolished by copyright law if they did
@@tescomealdeals You don't think there's a larger catalogue of music on TH-cam? I find there's a lot of undergound electronic music from the early 90s to present that you just can't find on any other streaming platforms
It's a shame not just because this is a great song but it is a great opening track, and it transitions SOOO well into the next song "If loving you is wrong"... Can we fans do some crowdsourcing to get this track back on the album?
Never really listened to Beyoncé, but this song *almost* got me interested in doing so until I realized her people likely had this song pulled off Spotify.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor. I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
Huge shame they ruined the order of the album on Spotify and iTunes (due to copyright shit). The entire album is so brilliant in the original order, if anyone hasn’t heard the whole thing you def should!
How did beyonce drag it down? Do you think she burst in the studio and demanded her inclusion? No. If anyone "drags down" the track, it's Jaar himself.
Free sampling! Copyright laws need to change! They’re punishing creativity and hurting artists who are creating original pieces of music.
FREE SAMPLING!!!
I agree but there should be a requirement to use the sample in creative ways so people don't just take music and lazily repurpose it.
And if free sampling was a thing then it should be required for samplers to credit their samples. I respect hip hop artists who don't want to tell people what samples they use but I also think by doing so, those producers are being disrespectful to the artists they're sampling. Many artists who get sampled just want credit where it's due.
@@carstarsarstenstesenn first off, trying to legally define “transformative” or “creative” sampling is one of the reasons free sampling isn’t a thing yet, because big labels will always try and abuse that to discourage sampling more and more. All forms of sampling are valid, period. Calling some uses of sampling “creative” and others “lazy” misses the entire point of sampling in the first place.
Secondly, I assure you most if not all sample based artists would be more than happy to give proper attribution to everything if free sampling was a thing. The entire reason people hide samples is because of copyright law, not to be greedy
Patricia Taxxon has a great series on TH-cam called “the golden calf” which does a really good job of explaining how complete and utter copyright abolition is the only way for artists to have true creative freedom, I recommend you check it out (dw they’re only like 15 or 20 minutes total)
@@tescomealdeals I used to have the same perspective as you, but it's not that simple. You can definitely use a sample in a lazy way. A lot of less talented artists out there who take a sample and do nothing original with it. There would be people who would exploit it just to be lazy and make money from other people's work. And I assure you that there would be a significant amount of artists that would still not credit their samples even if required to. You seem to think all artists are nice people or something 😂 it's a lot of assholes out there, which is why artists feel the need to copyright their music. I'm usually on the side that sampling should be free game but we can't just let everyone sample whoever they want. It would be chaos
@@carstarsarstenstesenn whether or not you consider a use of sampling lazy is completely irrelevant, it’s still a valid form of musical expression. Think about it like this, there are arguably some very “lazy” ways to play guitar, for example you can just play nothing but a I-IV-V progression on a bunch of different songs. Is that lazy? Yeah, kinda. Can you criticise someone’s music for such a thing? Of course. Do you have the right to argue they shouldn’t be allowed to make said music? Absolutely not. Putting a stupid ass requirement of “creativity” on sampling is doing just that, restricting other people’s art because it doesn’t fit your subjective criteria of what defines originality. As Sean Booth of Autechre said, “this whole idea of judging music based off of how much effort it took is full of fail.” A good song being achieved “lazily” is made no worse by that fact.
Second, you saying “there’s a lot of assholes” is just an awfully cynical take. Most people on this earth are nice and most artists who care at all about music will be more than happy to share samples if they were allowed to without legal repercussions. Just saying “but some people aren’t nice” is a lazy and reductive way of reasoning. But to be clear, I agree that attribution should be mandatory if free sampling became a thing, I’m just saying that the reason most people who hide samples right now choose to do so isn’t because they’re assholes who wanna keep samples to themselves it’s because they’d get demolished by copyright law if they did
Hoping for this masterpiece to be back on spotify one day 💔
facts dude this is one of the best electronic tracks to come out in YEARS
@@tescomealdeals true
Just get TH-cam Music, pays artists better and you get access to a wider and deeper selection of tracks
@@lukealexander6233 pays artists better? Undeniably. “Gives you access to a wider and deeper selection of tracks”? Not at all lmao
@@tescomealdeals You don't think there's a larger catalogue of music on TH-cam? I find there's a lot of undergound electronic music from the early 90s to present that you just can't find on any other streaming platforms
Bruh this needs to be back on Apple Music, listening to 2017-2019 without this track is not the same
fr
Ill hook you up with it if you still need it
This song popped back in my mind after a few years and good god it's just as good if not better than I remembered
can’t believe they took this song off streaming platforms ughhh Beyoncé why ??? This is prob one of the best songs of all time
FOR REALL UGHHHH
wait why did they take this off is it because they sampled Beyonce??
that was one of my thoughts when I first heard this, it's a shame it got taken down :(
frrr im so mad
Money. Welcome to the real world.
Wanted to revisit this song on Spotify, and to my dismay it was removed. Masterful song in a masterful album. Such a shame.
It's a shame not just because this is a great song but it is a great opening track, and it transitions SOOO well into the next song "If loving you is wrong"... Can we fans do some crowdsourcing to get this track back on the album?
One of the best living artists, PERIOD.
Lmao.
Then you haven't listened to alot of music perhaps.
Dont get me wrong i like this too.
@@bruhology6437 please let me know if you have better ones
@@flabbymarshmellow01 Arca
he is one of those artists that isn't too appreciated in their 'prime' but will be studied in a decade or two, mark my words.
literally one of the best remixes ever lmfao holy shiiiiit
It’s not a remix
so fkn good cant believe its not on spotify
it used to be but it got taken down
Man, this dude and flume are living in the future. What a sound!
Rip to this on streaming platforms, this song is too good man.
god i'm in love with this song
damn that sound engineering top-notch !!
holy... new A.A.L , new Caribou, new Four Tet and new Pantha Du Prince. 2020 will be a great year!
Yeah there's some great records coming out. But about 2020 being a great year I come from the future and got some bad news...
This comment has not aged well
@@bruhology6437 was about to say the same thing
oh ye summer child
hahahha the best prediction ever
This is an entire experience, I love this so much
I didn’t expect this on David Dean Burkhart
same though lmao, i remember coming here for saint pepsi six years ago and now here i am again
this is stunning. i cant get over it
This album is insane
Do not listen with headphones whilst high you will transcend
That’s the point sis
I'm not even high and I'm trippin
i ascended and was greeted by jaar himself
"whilst" bruh
the classic "I listened to this while drugs :DDD" comment found in every. single. song on youtube
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
hm yes yes very smart that's an excellent take may i have your children good sireth
@@TheLinuskungyo shut up, that comment deserved no mockery
that sentence had me so confused because of that dash
forever missing this song on spotify
I need a Jaar x Forest Swords collab. Immediately.
Wow. This is just brilliant... Another great discovery thanks to KEXP radio who brought me there.
This song is perfect for calming down my OCD
LOL at the alamy stock photo watermarks in the cover
Just wait until alamy takes down the album cover as well...
Holy shit! This is good. Very good.
I'm scared
I fkn love Jaar, what a goddamn banger
happy to find this here, missed it
What an underrated masterpiece of an album
It was released today, how can it be underrated? Also it already has a positive review on Resident Advisor.
@@YesoMs I thought it was 2012-2017 :(
@@YesoMs Still Underrated lol
星野源の、ANNから～！！素敵すぎる！！！癖になります！
BEY! GET IT BACK ON ON SPOTIFY
Beyonce will literally have hundreds of songs sampled and artists will still get copyright strikes if they sample her. Funny how that works.
Beyoncé has to pay to sample songs - just like everyone else.
Never really listened to Beyoncé, but this song *almost* got me interested in doing so until I realized her people likely had this song pulled off Spotify.
masterpiece
is that a Beyonce sample?
andrewsully yes.
baby boy
and a sean paul sample at 0:43 and later
yes, indeed, that’s correct.
LOLLLLLL yesss
Udder udder udder
Why isn't this on spotify tf
probably didn't clear the beyonce sample lmao
It was for years it just got removed a couple of days ago :(
this is iconic why still off streaming wtf
Uses to listen to this all the time on the bus right before COVID hit
Clean boi
Great music
i will never forgive beyonce i'm sorry
tbf to beyonce it probably wasn't her decision lol it's usually the label that owns the rights
Beyoncé “Baby Boy (feat. Sean Paul)”
why'd this get taken off of Spotify? sample clearance?
OH MY GOD!
is this loss?
fabulous
why did this song get taken down??? cant find it on any of my music apps
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
I really like how 2017 - 2019 is more challenging and introspective than its predecessor.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
Me too.
This was removed from the bandcamp?
Nice Nicolas! ❤👏
This track is better than whole Beyonce discography combined. No wonder she mad lol
YES YES thanksss 💋
wth i just liked this song from my discover weekly
this shit is mindblowing
imma sample this
A wonderful song
music copyright laws are just getting petty at this point
Alguém sabe informar o porque essa música não estar mais disponível nas plataformas de stream? A Beyoncé mandou tirar?😂
pelo jeito sim. problemas de copyright.
(por sinal, curti sua foto. this is why é um discão.)
@@luizero99 Uma pena, acho a melhor do disco junto com Penny
Huge shame they ruined the order of the album on Spotify and iTunes (due to copyright shit). The entire album is so brilliant in the original order, if anyone hasn’t heard the whole thing you def should!
RIP streaming version. free sampling
Can’t believe they took this down because of a sample…. Can we change the laws please???
eu sabia que era a voz da beyoncé!
que fodaaa
Cette merveille a dégagé de Deezer pour une question de copyright. L'album n'est plus pareil sans...
Honestly I’m so mad at Beyonce I can’t believe she got this off Spotify
Nic didn’t have to go this hard
wig. gone.
flew
Snatched
oh man, free sampling.
They may have done tf sum. 🔥🔥🔥
在Spotify听完一整张发现歌少了，切换到大陆音乐app才知道是被下架了这一首最好的😂
dis was my strip song WHYYYY 😩😩😩
Night fright !!!!
I'm confused.
All seeing eye
Why did they have to take this off Spotify omg
wooo
taken off spotify, rip
So, I guess we're all here because Beyoncé wanted some more $$$?
!t's M4g1C!!!
Does anyone else feel the strong reminscence about Yes - Long Distance Runaround in the very beginning of the track?
no? the wii shop music reminds me of yes and stevie wonder tho
i'm scared xD
damn
AAL sounds like aphex twin
Melon head: "I give it a strong 8"
If this sounds like Aphex twin then im a fucking teacup
i guess it sounds like windowlicker but nothing else
this only sounds like aphex twin if Nicolas is literally the 2nd IDM artist you've ever listened to
Fantastic. A miracle! I just saw a guy in a wheelchair get up and walk to the radio to turn this shit off.
damn
I'm done with Spotify, kicked it off my phone.
Very good, I feel very inspired by aphex twin but that's cool
digital
Here cuz they remove it
RIP on Spotify… this got straight up removed and “Such a Bad Way” had the Kanye sample removed.
Thanks god i have both albums in vinyl
the remix is better than anything by beeoncey
Amazing tune gets taken siwn because of some tiny sample of a boring mainstream pop artist.
what the f was that
no me convence este tema
Neta mamasita
po ke
this is why streaming will never prosper. Soulseek forever.
beyonce drags down an otherwise killer track
nah these vocal samples are fresh as hell
How did beyonce drag it down? Do you think she burst in the studio and demanded her inclusion? No. If anyone "drags down" the track, it's Jaar himself.
@@talmagegarn3290 alright now you're just being headass
I hate that this is blocked on apple music 🙄