Aladdin 2019 - Nostalgia Critic
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Only a few dozen tickets left for the October 2nd showing of the It Part 2 review at Hollywood Blvd. Get your tickets here - theawesomestor...
A giant parrot, hallucinating Jasmine, and Casper the Friendly Genie? It's another Disney remake alright, and despite this one being a crowd pleaser, the Nostalgia Critic is anything but amused as he reviews 2019's Aladdin remake.
Support this week's charity here - cachouston.org/
Aladdin is a 2019 American musical fantasy film produced by Walt Disney Pictures. Directed by Guy Ritchie, who co-wrote the screenplay with John August, it is a live-action adaptation of Disney's 1992 animated film of the same name, which is based on the eponymous tale from One Thousand and One Nights. The film stars Will Smith, Mena Massoud, Naomi Scott, Marwan Kenzari, Navid Negahban, Nasim Pedrad, Billy Magnussen, and Numan Acar, as well as the voices of Alan Tudyk and Frank Welker.
Go to our Store for Awesome Stuff - theawesomestor...
Get some Nostalgia Critic T-Shirts here - shrsl.com/?~96c0
See more at our Site: channelawesome.com
Facebook: / channelawesome
Twitter: / channelawesome
Instagram: / channelawesome
Like Doug on Facebook: / 127127037353766
The ONLY Official TH-cam channel for the Nostalgia Critic and Channel Awesome.
New Nostalgia Critic episodes every Wednesday at 5PM CST.
#Aladdin #Aladdin19 #Disney
NostalgiaWeen starts next week!!!!
Only a few dozen tickets left for the October 2nd showing of the It Part 2 review at Hollywood Blvd. Get your tickets here theawesomestore.com/index.php?dispatch=products.view&product_id=30002
Love your videos! Can’t wait for the review! 😁
I enjoyed it!
Review South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut.
Pretty sure that the giant parrot Jafar turned into was supposed to be a Roc, the legendary bird from Arabian mythology that was so big it could carry elephants away in its talons, but ok.
Review smokey and the bandit part 3
"The film has the *disadvantage* of not being animated."
PLEASE SAY THAT LOUDER FOR THE DISNEY EMPLOYEES IN THE BACK!
I always thought this should be a common sense, that's why remake takes time and hard work for.......however they seem to misunderstood animation and story details, just like change the scene for "Can you feel the love TONIGHT" from night to afternoon
Can I get a freaking "amen" to this proof of wisdom ?
*AMEN !*
you mean louder for the people who keep paying for the tickets
*Executives
Say louder
the reason why they didn't make the whole movie bollywood is simple.
It was too big a risk. and disney doesn't make remakes to experiment or explore new possibilities.
That might have had a significant impact and broke a new record. That would have been frigging awesome!
Edited by Sans Handlebars.
They could have had some awesome dance sequences and actually done something interesting and new with this if they took a page out of Bollywood instead of trying to copy animation into live action as usual.
Well that and the fact that bollywood is Hindi film, not middle eastern.
What would Disney have to lose, anyway? They have more money than Eugene Krabs!
You know, it's not even a risk! This movie was gonna make money no matter what! Why not have fun with it? Why make it so bland?
"The disadvantage of not being animated." Thank you! It's frustrating how many people equate live action as superior to animation in every way when it's not. They're different and some movies are better suited to one or the other.
Yeah.
Like, imagine if some of the Pixar films were live action?
Like Up, CoCo, the Incredibles. We wouldn't be able to get the movement, speed, goofy proportions that animation can give us.
Like with the live action Cat in the Hat
@@nylalady3509 We do not mention that film.
@@SukoYote LOL Forgive me!
People seem to think that the original was animated because of primitive technology. Hand-drawn animation wasn't anywhere near an undeveloped medium at the conception of Aladdin!
People can't fathom that if they originally had the choice between live-action and animated, they would have a strong case for animation for artistic possibilities alone.
I actually think Will Smith did fine as the genie when he’s allow to be Will Smith, not Will Smith pretending to be Robin Williams. Friend Like Me is a great example. The genie is a character that needs to be a big personality and both Robin Williams and Will Smith are big personalities in very different ways.
"Which leads to...
...Me getting booze, I'm sorry, I'm too sober for this!"
He's still got it.
Vintage Nostalgic Critic.... *"I may have lost a step or two but I still Do know how to dance - Rowdy Rowdy Piper"*
yea i feel that Channel Awesome has really hit its stride these past 2 years (his earlier stuff was great but ive been liking these with more consistency, and the jokes land more often and dont always require prior knowledge [big lipped aligator moment anyone?])
@@abucket14 I felt he slightly went downhill right before Cancel Culture hit him with ChangeTheChannel, but afterwards him and the others on Channel Awesome have had such a boost in energy and creativity.
That whole Jasmine was the Genie twist. I'm going to say right now, that could have worked. Maybe genies originated in Sherabot, and Jasmine's mother was a genie, maybe her mothers bracelet was the manacle from when she was a Genie and Jafar killed her when he learned she was free and couldn't grant his wishes. That's why he's so focused on Sherabot, if the mother came from there, then there must be other magical artifacts or knowledge. And all the years of repression stopped Jasmine from tapping into her powers, but when Jafar takes over and she sees the Genie, she realizes her mother was a genie and Jasmine, by that lineage gives her the ability to become a Genie, so Jafar uses his sorcery to try and force her to give up her humanity and become his wife, giving up not only her freedom as a woman, but as a human.
It acts as a way to show how the repression from things like stereotypes or gender roles can harm a person and puts Jasmine's desire for freedom in a much more literal battle, not to mention it provides an interesting story about how Genies come to be. But more importantly it provides an interesting moral that I don't know how to quantify, so I'll explain. Jasmine wants to be treated equally to a man (in that she wants the right to rule). In becoming a Genie, she would have to power to change things, but she would be at the mercy of anybody's whim. She could have ultimate power and in doing so the right to rule, but she chooses not to because if she can't rule on her own terms, she won't do it. Even as I type this I can't fully explain my thought process, so I'll just leave it here.
It would be an actually strong and interesting female character with nuance. And an interesting story with nuance (throwing a woman in power is not a magical key to heaven, just like overpowering a female character doesn't magically make her a good female character, etc.) It could actually take gender issues head on instead of...this half ass attempt Hollywood has been pulling for marketing.
It would build on the universe too. I totally get it!
I read and understood all of it. I wholeheartedly agree with this idea
Cool idea
Interesting, I agree
Very nice!
is Aladdin Indian, Egyptian, or middle eastern?
disney: "yes"
In the original story, he's Chinese.
Arabian I think. Today's Philistines
@Aly elDin story takes place in modern china
The original tale takes place in what is now called Xinjiang, now part of China. Aladdin N Jasmine are turkic speaking chinese. Muslim but not arab.
@@VanaeCavae okay that clarifies some things. It is important to note very important to note that despite it often be called the Thousand and One Arabian Nights Arabia was far from the only setting. Those Thousand and One stories took place all over the Persian Empire Arabia Baghdad China Egypt parts of Greece all of the Middle East and Far East Orient you know
"How did you get through the guards?"
"I snuck past."
"All 48 of them? Even the ones that eat fire?"
Okay, I can't be the only one who wants to see the guards that eat fire
Not gonna lie: I wanted to see that too. Now THAT would’ve been interesting!
Agrabah has some really talented guards! Did someone tell the Ringling Bros about these guys?
Am I the only one who remembers characters doing that in the original?
@@captainvader921 I remember a guy swallowing a sword and nearly dying when Abu yanked it out of his throat, but I can't remember any firebreathers in the original Aladdin
Also, don’t forget: in the opening credits of Aladdin ( 1992 ) there was a guy who blew fire out of his mouth.
Honestly Jasmine's song had me SO DAMN CONFUSED in the theater.
"Wh- What, is SHE magic now? Thanosing everybody away? What the heck??"
SansMotivation
RIGHT it came out of nowhere like bruh this is the climax and you’re singing about girl power, I WANNA SEE THE STORY
I think we all had issues with the random girl power bits that broke the momentum in a movie that's was fun, but that's all.
Its in her head. This is how internal dialogue is often handled in stage productions, where they can't cut away to a different scene the same way you can in a movie.
she doesn't even have the gauntlet and stones
It was her imagination
Should renamed this movie "How I met your Mother in Agrabah"
Shinaba
Could have worked but how would we know if it would bring in 1.049 billion $$$ ?
You win comment of the month award
Just a mild note on one thing he didn't touch on--
We first meet Jasmine unintentionally stealing from a merchant to feed a kid. In the animated it's believable because she's sheltered and it's obviously her first time out. But in this one... this Jasmine wants to be FUCKING SULTAN. Her straight-up taking it from the table and then being surprised when the merchant gets angry that she has no money makes no sense. This Jasmine is well-read and can read maps and should know all about money and rules of society. Why would she casually take a product and think it'd be okay???
I get they'd want to keep the intro of both Jasmines the same, but they're different characters, and it just seemed so incredibly off for this one.
I also thought that she'd mention improving the state of the poor once she's in charge, since Aladdin and poor kids and shit. But it wasn't focused on.
Imagine if Aladdin took Jasmine to her mother's country Shirabad on the magic carpet ride. It'd be romantic, a meaningful gesture, and we would actually see this country that's apparently so important. And maybe we'd actually learned how she was killed.
And why would she leave home without any money? Surely she gets an allowance or something?
Yeah must admit. I think it would have worked better if she knocked apples onto the ground for the kids and got caught doing it or something. This scene undercut her character from the start in the remake. It's like she's smart and savvy and can run a nation, but doesn't seem to understand the concept of money and payments.
I think it would make more sense for her to simply pay for the apple and Aladdin somewhat seeing through her disguise. Then Aladdin would try to maybe swindle some money from her only to fall for her and resume the original story.
God bless. Thank you. My thoughts exactly))
Critic: “Save me, gin!!”
Me: “Heh. I see what you did there. Djinn🧞♂️ → gin. I’m onto you.”
AGREED ON THE WORD PLAY FOR ONE JUMP!
“He’s got a sword!”
“You idiots! We’ve all got swords!!”
😂😂😂😂
"Eeee-EEE-eeeh." *drops sword and skedaddles*
Sean Connery "he's got an S-word
@@colorcola1464 The OP was referencing the original animated film, as was mine.
"He's got a Keyblade!"
“You idiots! We’ve all got Keyblades!!”
YES XD
“WHO DISTURBS MY SLUMBER-Eh we don’t have time”
**parrot noise** “HoW iS tHiS MoViE lOngEr?!”
“I’m jafar...”
This part made me laugh
Good question Hei Hei.
@@nathanharris6450 I'm buster!
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Move over Raiders of the Lost Arc, Most epic movie intro evec unlocked
I can't wait for the live action remake of Aladdin 4: Jafar May Need Glasses. That is going to be epic.
Stewie had a point...
Can I see it again?
@@wizzlewazzle9202 uhhhh... About the same number one may have been better.
Number 3... Number 4
Not as riveting as filing taxes though xD
21:05 "How come he don't want me man" you thought you could sneak that in and we wouldn't notice??? You monster!
I laughed a lot harder than I should have lol.
@@Phinal_Flash Me too.
The problem is with Jasmine’s song is that the movie shoved it in with no real reason. It feels forced
Forced girl power in a Disney property? Unheard of!
@@andresacosta7885 random thanos snap unheard of
Still an epic song though
Not only that, but they did it with the ONE Disney princess that talks shit to everyone. I could see this song working for Cinderella or something like that, but Jasmine would literally be my last option for the song.
Juan Inchauspe yeah. It’s a great song and the actor sings it beautiful but it just doesn’t fit with the established character.
Ah yes. Jasmine, the Disney princess who in the animated version had absolutely no trouble constantly saying exactly what she thought about people and her general situation; who would tell off her father, her father's right-hand man and (as far as she was concerned) a total stranger for objectifying her *multiple times* ; who thought absolutely nothing of going after whatever she wanted regardless of what anyone said or told her what she should be doing... Yes, she *really* needed "fixing" and given a song about not being silenced. God knows she was just *so* passive before...
🙄
I thought she was more of a strong character in the animated version too IMO, But what really bugs me is that in the original is that she doesn't want to be forced into marriage but wants to find love however in the remake she's willing to accept Jafar's forced proposal when he threatens her father, it's like they didn't re-watch the original before making this movie.
@@forestmckenzie7921 consdering how many things are botched in those remakes i seriously doubts they even watched a first time
you know he kinda sounds like iago when he's mad and yelling
I was thinking the same!!!
The Gilbert Gottfried one or the King Candy one?
"I can show you the world!" Except for your mother's home country. We don't have the creativ- I mean, time for that.
Cold blooded lol
Bro they didn’t even go to Greece and China like the original
Queen Of Hidden Snow yeah your right
Jam! 😆
Guess which one of these had too much of?
Starkid’s “Twisted” is a much better “Aladdin” remake than the “Aladdin” remake.
Amen, please?
Id rather watch the Thief of Bagdad 1940
Even the 1990 Disney version is much better
HE FUCKED A TIGER
This is all your fault jafar
Twisted is legit my favorite theatre production of all time. It's absolutely brilliant.
"What remains of a man when that man is dead and gone? Only memories and stories of his deeds will linger on. But what if a man's accomplishments aren't in the tale they tell? Are the deeds that go unheralded his legacy as well? If a war breaks out tomorrow, we'll all have hell to pay. Why protect my reputation? I'm a dead man either way. How will they tell my story? How will they tell my tale? Will anybody even care? The question, then, is whether tis nobler in the mind to be well-liked but ineffectual, or moral but maligned. I'll never be a hero all the citizens adore, but if I hide to save my life, what has my life been for? What has my life been for? The road AHEAD MAY TWIST. But I WILL NEVER SWERVE! I'll GIVE THEM ALL THE UNSUNG ANTIHERO THEY DESERVE! I've NOTHING left to lose, so the only path to choose is TWISTED! Let them twist my words, let the people scorn me. Who cares if no-one will ever mourn me? Let them BURY THE SIDE OF THE STORY they'll NEVER LEARN! LET THE TRUTH BE TWISTED! LET MY LIFE BE TWISTED! I'LL BE TWISTED, IT'S MY TURN!"
Aladdin 1992 : scimitar fighting with a giant snake
Aladdin 2019 : running away from giant parrot... and we have jam...
weak, isn't it?
I think Guy Ritchie did not want to use giant snake again, because he just did it in his previous movie about King Arthur.
@@ПавелПовх-з3у that's your explanation?
yeah, the new version is so much better in that regard. People already hate snakes more than enough.
@@TabalugaDragon Can't tell if you're serious.
We don't hate on a 2000 foot long giant magic cobra because it's a cobra. We hate the guy he is under the scales.
Disney should’ve hired the cloak from Dr. Strange to play the rug
Isn't it theirs to begin with? Dr. Strange would have been one of the first Marvel Movies to come out under Disney's aegide, wouldn't it?
Aladdin 2019 being part of the MCU is now my new head canon
HECK YES
@@sanchobanana3507 The genie would make one Hell of an Avenger.
INGENIOUS
We’ve had the Disney Renaissance, now with the live action remakes I say, “Welcome to the Disney Dark Ages.”
Disney Zombie Apocalypse
@@FF-tp7qs
That's an accurate title.
The Disney Dark Ages was more like the 80s, at least for their box offices.
@@welcometothemetaverse2523 all the movies coming back as shambling husks of their former selves hungering for the cash of the living
As far as live action goes, maybe. As for animation, not at all
@@welcometothemetaverse2523 Sooo... the Disney Industrial Revolution where they automate movies?
Missed Opportunities! A Disney Tradition!
Found it!
I now just watched the reaction video. Only took a few seconds to find this.
Or "Overkill" a Disney tradition 🤣🤣🤣
found it !!
Lion king Broadway music: I wanted to be translated into the remake but Jon favreau said no!
“What’s NC going to review for his 1st nostalgiaween video?”
“It.”
“What movie?”
“It.”
“No, what’s the name of the movie?”
“It is the name of the movie!”
“So It is it?”
“Yes.”
“And is he going to show it to us?”
“No, Us is another movie altogether!”
“Get out.”
“Leave Jordan Peele out of this.”
“Well what is it?”
“It is this.”
“So, this is it?”
“No that’s Michael Jackson!”
“Are you some kind of joker or something?”
“No, Joker is a completely different clown! Pennywise is the clown!”
“What’s Pennywise?”
“It is Pennywise!”
“So the movie is Pennywise?”
“No the movie is It!”
“But isn’t Pennywise it?”
“It is Pennywise!”
“So the movie is Pennywise?”
“No, the movie is it!”
“This is confusing!”
“Because you’re not getting it!”
“We’re not getting a review?”
“No we are getting a review!”
“Why you little-“
“What is it?”
“THATS WHAT I’M TRYING TO FIGURE OUT!!!!”
How long did you sit on this masterpiece?
Who's on First?: Murder Clown Edition.
The classic wordplay never dies.
OMFG IM FREAKING DYING! That sounded a lot like a white valley girl diva. Whatever. It’s because I am.
THIRD BASE!
Its sad how much she out-sings him in A Whole New World.
To be fair, she out-sings everyone in this movie.
Well she is one of the best actors in the movie and of course her singing voice is great.
They honestly should have retitled the movie JASMINE: An Aladdin Story and called it a day. Because this was HER movie. Am I wrong or am I right?
@@chasehedges6775 You are correct.
Similar Can You Feel the Love Tonight in 2019Lion King
I appreciate how Will Smith really tries to make his genie his own, but this movie panders way too much to our nostalgia.
3:20 Little boy: "Maybe if you rap."
Little girl: "It's better when you rap."
Oh, no, nope, NO!...
Shame.
Genie: Now, this is a story all about how
My life got flipped into Agrabah.....
Tim curry would have been great as a live action jafar
Oh please Tim Curry is in everything good. The more challenging quest and a possible critic video would be to find something where he isn´t good.
Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha Wa-Ha
*Y E S*
to bad he's in a wheelchair now
or al pacino
"what the hell what we smoking when we made this?"
This is exactly what Disney said whenever they made a live action reboot
Nah, they probably think it's fine
Crazy Crew these remakes are just dumb as they live and I’ll never watch these remakes ever
Lol funny thing is I have not seen the new Aladdin....I had to see how the Critic destroys it. Did it with beauty and the beast, and who knows what else
They where thinking 💰💴💵💶💷💸💳💱💲
Crazy Crew that’s what Doug asked after they made their “review” of The Wall and got a 2.3 on IMDb
"What, does becoming the Sultan just get you a new hat?"
Yeah, it kind of does. Like, the Sultan isn't shown to be a dictator running on fear and oppression. His guards aren't automatons, forced to obey his orders, they can choose not to obey.
It's actually a very nice example of how Jafar's short-sighted lust for power betrays him: he wastes a wish claiming a title he didn't need. Once he's the most powerful sorcerer in the world, he could just MAKE the Sultan abdicate to him. But no, he demands someone bestow the title on him...without earning it, so it doesn't get him anything: "Cool, you're the Sultan, me and the rest of the guards are going to rebel."
Pretty much the same thing from the original there, too. Sultan was a wasted wish..
"If you will not bow to your sultan, then you will cower before a sorcerer!"
George Carlin pointed out that in every different religion or culture there's always a different kind of hat.
The Hindus have the turban
The muslims have the keffiyeh
The Jews have the yarmulke
The Pope has a pointy hat on one day a flat hat the next
Everyone's got a fuckin hat
@@jakeitnbakeit Rule Nr. 1: As a ruler, you need a fancy hat.
@@jakeitnbakeit It's called the Papal Tiara.
well to be fair the first of the 3 rules says he can't use genie's power TO KILL PEOPLE so he can't do that to take over
At least when digimon had a giant parrot, they had it fighting a fire breathing dinosaur.
😂
that fight was badass though
I haven't seen Digimon, but reading that sentence has me immediately sold.
@@alexolson1716 watch it it's awesome there's plenty of awesome fights like that
Pitching Jafar in the 90s: Oh he's a diabolical, evil mastermind. He's ugly, dark and so snakelike that he actually turns into a giant snake at the end!
Pitching Jafar in the 10s: Well he's... there.
When I first watched this remake on TV, I was half expecting Phelous to chime in and refer to him as “Jafart”, like he does to the sorcerer villains in all the animated Aladdin mockbusters made to capitalize off the original Disney film.
Well, he is there and he is good at enlarging parrots.
The original Jafar would eat his 2019 counterpart in his snake form.
Am I the only one who had a problem with how Jasmine lied to Aladdin saying she was someone else when they met and then being mad at him for lying about his identity?
Yes it bothers me in both Aladdin films that Jasmine lies to Aladdin but then get mad at him when he lies about his identity.
Hypocrisy at its finest
Missed opportunity on the ending: "This was an Arabian Nightmare."
Yeah, but at the same time kind of expected. Granted kind of felt like would have been a better ending.
It wasn't
ArrrRRRABIAN NIIIIIIIIGHTMAAARES
yeah!
Well, he DID use "arabian nightmare" in his top 11 Disney villains.
*Coming in 2030 Disney live action remake of Frozen*
The ''old'' never bothered me
@@cheek077
🎶 The old never bothered me anyway.
Shhhhhhhhh! Don't give them ideas!
Well that TV show sorta did
I need you to think of Patrick right now. Does he even exist?
"Oh my God she was the genie all along, now that's a twist this movies needs!"
if you mean the story teller fun fact THAT WAS CANON IN THE ORIGINAL they just dropped it from the movies it's been confirmed by the writers that the lamp seller at the start of the original disney's aladdin is in fact you guessed it genie
@Zak Strayder i think that was the idea
My problem with this new Aladdin that the Critic should've criticized was that this Aladdin was not only selfish of not wanting to free the Genie, he was clumsy and scared.
The original one was more caring and brave, he was tough himself to find a way to win Jasmine's heart, he fought Jafar as a giant snake and when he was helpless and powerless he still wasn't afraid and came up with another way to defeat Jafar.
😧 Especially when Aladdin was ambushed, kidnapped by the gaurds, and tossed into the ocean. Aladdin still fought and didn't give up trying to get to the lamp. He doesn't quit fighting even when the odds are against him.
“Save me, gin!”
Don’t you mean djinn?
😂😂😂
No, I'd rather have Gin.
And tonic
I was gonna say Jinn and do another prequel joke but Djinn’s funnier.....well it makes more sense at least.....
Imagine jin kazama been called as djinn kazama?
Will Smith’s genie taking over for Robin Williams is like a good stepfather taking over for a greater father. Can’t exactly replace what ya had but he does his best and you can appreciate it
He does his best....but the problem is he is doing his best to try and out-RobinWilliams Robin Williams.
The genie should have been rewritten for Will Smith to be Will Smith.
And that means also rewriting the songs, most of which were too slow and lacked energy.
Good analogy
Edward Lafferty No, no he wasn’t. Will Smith has ALWAYS been able to play the energetic, over-enthusiastic character. Have you ever seen Fresh Prince? As for the songs; even NC acknowledged the songs were done really well and had some good changes that made them more suitable for Will. I can respect people bringing up the flaws of these movies, but don’t nitpick things like this for dumb reasons.
@@edwardlafferty8796 Robin Williams is like a True Genie he was other the top funny outstanding nobody could ever top a Genie like him
Will tried his best at The Genie but honestly in my opinion this wasn't the right role for him
If i were to suggest people who would play The Genie give it to either Jim Carrey or even heck Jamie Costa he sure does one hell of a Robin Williams impression
He was horrible
Heres the wishes Alladin should of made.
1 The ability to sing
2 The ability to emote
3 Wish the Genie free
The same could have said for Jafar
😁
@NoEnya
Considering that “Prince Ali Reprise” was completely left out of the remake, Jafar need to make a wish just for the chance to sing at all.
@markcobuzzi826 can that guy even sing? I mean, I know animated Jafar can but this guy? I think Disney dodged a bullet on that one😐
The Aladdin remake done in a Bollywood style would have been amazing!
16:48 all these jams but where's the Space Jam?
"SAVE ME, GIN!"
Save me, Djinn?
Coincidence, or clever word play?
He should totally review Wishmaster this Nostalgiaween
I noticed that too! XD
“Is it too much to ask for both?”
Wielding Eminator Huh...I didn’t catch that. Nifty.
Nah bro. He means you need a hangover to watch this stuff.
The one thing that had everyone worried, Will Smith Genie, soon became one of the better parts of the movie.
But of course, we all still miss Robin Williams
My sister's high school's play of Aladdin was a better live-action version.
Same as the Twisted play by Starkid production. The story was told by Jafar point of view, an excellent humor and fun songs. Also, every character was well developped and likable; even Prince Akhmed was funny X) This play is way better than the remake Disney did, it's more creative and interresting too.
@@ladypool1404 Ah, another Starkid fan, I've never met one of us in the wild before!
Jasmine had the infinity gauntlet the whole time. She snapped the guards out of existence
"Tell me more tell me more. Was his voice autotune?" hahaha
"The Aladdin Remake movie. Do you know what is in the Aladdin Remake movie?"
"Delicious Jams and Jellies?"
I understood that reference.
National Treasure!
And spoons
How about my foot?
and sheep cheese
This was tolerable but inoffensive. The Lion King is insufferable
Agreed.
The Lion King 2019 is a photo realistic replica of original 1994 version which is disgrace to me and the Lion king fandom
This movie clearly put in an Actual effort into being entertaining in its own right and not just a carbon copy of the original, did it succeed? Ehhh mixed bag there
But there was a clear And honest Try.
Same can't be said for the lion king
Axaul Honestly I kinda feel the opposite, but that's probably because Aladdin is my favorite Disney film. Lion King (2019) just bored the shit out of me. Aladdin (2019) actually pissed me off.
I never saw the 2019 version of "The Lion King". So, I wouldn't have an opinion on that one.
Why did a thoroughly Arab story suddenly get injected with all this Bollywood stuff?
Did Disney seriously just go "Ahh its all foreign, who cares"
It's all brown, who cares.
People don't exactly have positivity to the Middle East, but they are okay with India especially as they are increasing as a burgeoning economy. Much like how Hollywood panders to China, it's good business.
That said, the fictional region of Agribah could easily of been a mix, so it's not ridiculously far off. I would of preferred if it actually just went with Bollywood. It was an amusing movie, good for one watch, but I wish it had just gone fully bollywood.
To be technical, the original story of Aladdin likely took place in East Turkestan (or Xinjiang in modern China), so it's closer to India than the Middle East. But yeah, it's still weird.
Hey boys and girls, I'll do you one better: The original version of the Aladdin story had a CHINESE setting. So it was never supposed to be 100% Arabian anyway. Oh well.
The 1001 nights were a mix of Arab, Indian, Chinese, African European etc. tales. Comes from the middle east being the cross road of many cultures during that time.
Tekno Pathetic pretty much
This is the first time when the ending credits are ACTUALLY the best part of the movie!
I had no interest or desire to see this or the Lion King remake. I knew they were both pointless bullshit. As much as I love Will Smith, even he didn’t make me wanna see it. He hasn’t done a good movie in years, the last semi decent movie he did was Men in Black 3 in 2012.
I’m so sick of remakes, reboots and sequels
During Jasmine’s song I figured she was Thanosing everyone away. Shows how Aladdin is connected to the MCU.
The same thing came to my mind. I could only think of Thanos
I wasn't sure I saw it right at first
I'm impressed with this mortal Jasmine.
"The remake is taking advantage of the original's focus so they don't have to try as hard." The MO of ever Disney remake past and future.
Fun Fact: The only reason Donkey Kong Country exists is because Nintendo wanted to compete with the Aladdin video game. No joke!!!!!
Idk why the quiet “I’m Jafar!” Made me laugh so hard...
🤣 Same!
yep
Ray-Ray Rambles same
12:02 Doctor Strange’s cloak has more personality than the live action carpet
Burn.
I was very disappointed how they handled my scene in the remake. Still, I think he's RATHER TASTY!
I can’t believe you exist
@@AndreNitroX could've made the account for this joke, not gonna r/beetlejuicing this
Mehrunisa lmfao
Ooh sorry they cut you out in the remake
"She's a princess."
"Aren't they all?"
👏👏👏
That was a pretty charming line cause you should treat girls like that
@@arcspark4937 heck yeah my guy
@@arcspark4937 then how should you treat a guy?
@@heder232 oh dont be like that. cant I applaud chivalry without being criticized?
@@arcspark4937 we are not in the middle ages tho
I see a pattern in the Disney remakes. All of them lack build up and character development.
I like to call this movie "Fresh Prince Ali".
That actually sounds like a better movie
I'd watch that movie.
That’s a good one!
Fabulous he
Ali ababwa
6:20
That was the major disadvantage the "live-action" Lion King had. It wasn't animated. The animals looked TOO real, and they couldn't have the expression you get in animation. They also cut out any "cartoony" bits to maintain the illusion that it was a National Geographic documentary. There was no Timon in a hula skirt. There was no Rafiki doing karate. The "Can't Wait to be King" song was neutered by not having the goofy cartoony parts. Even a giant lion's head in the clouds wasn't realistic enough for it.
RedHeadKevin Still don’t get why they didn’t do what the Jungle Book did.
@@bbolin5626 It didn't work in the Jungle Book either.
Because Disney doesn't understand the saying "if it's not broken, don't fix it"neither one of these live action remakes seems to have been made simply to fix the broken original. So lets make Timon look like a real Meerkat lets make Scar look like a real lion instead of the lion version of Jafar, lets remove the Remember who you're with a lion in the clouds.
Well Shere Khan actually looked a little bit better in the live action version.
@@sandernielsen8018 They aren't trying to fix anything, they just make easy money.
Imagine if some TH-camrs got together, and made their own version of the live action remakes, but with passion instead of greed as their main motivation, to show how Disney SHOULD have done it
I'd pay to watch that!
Does this mean we're gonna get a Lion King 2019 review? I'd love to see that.
Oh Yeah! That movie needs a good roasting! 😜
I would like to see his reaction on that, but it wasn't really that good. You couldn't really get good acting from CGI animal mouths so most of the speaking and emotion fell a bit flat. It was literally a carbon copy of the original, in National Geographic form.
He reviewed it as Doug.
@@authorrobjohnson3178 He also reviewed this Aladdin movie as Doug. Nostalgia Critic is different.
And Laura, I know the movie's bad. I haven't seen it, but I've heard plenty of things. I just wanna see Nostalgia Critic jokes and reactions.
technically we’ve already got one
Nostalgia Critic: *sees a djinn*
“Save me Gin!!!”
Ironically in a blue bottle too
I don't think that Supernatural entity in Middle Eastern culture referred to jinn has a silent D in it
@@ahreneverist143 screw that- call Sam and Dean.
@@gamerthoughtscommentaryand6186 Jinn (Arabic: الجن, al-jinn), also Romanized as djinn or Anglicized as genies (wikipadia)
I miss Gilbert Gottfried doing his role in the original movie
I just read this in Gilbert Gottfrieds voice
It’s the only non-annoying role he’s ever done 😆
Like. WHY ALAN TYDUK
I mean.....
Don't we all
Me too
Love the girl power song that immediately ends with her begging a man to solve the problem...
I love how while pointing out the negatives he still gives credit where credit is due
Trying to have Will Smith do Robin Williams things, is like trying to have John Wayne do Jim Carrey things!
Lol
Aaalllllllrighty then pilgrim!
@@TheAphexTim lol
And in fact Will Smith tried to be a bit different from Robin Williams.
John Wayne in the Conqueror. ~grin~
Now imagine John Wayne in 'The Mask'.
When I was little I barely understood half the things said to me. I have an auditory processing disorder, and most things people said sounded garbled. When Jafar in the animated version pulled out the knife, I had no idea what he said, but I saw his the lighting in the scene, how Jafar suddenly looked really menacing (well...even more menacing), and of course the knife. That helped me still understand what was going on. The live action, I’d just have seen a really bored dude standing there.
Bummer.
HOpE/pRay THaT OnE RECOvERS SOOn In a GOOD HOLy DIvInE way SUCCESSFULLy may THE HOLy DIvInE GOD THE FaTHER OF JESUS CHRIST DO IF FIT.
Honestly, this may be the most enjoyable remake out of all of them
Will Smith was pretty funny and yea Jafar is terrible in this but after that
There are differences unlike the lion king remake and so enjoyable things in it
P.S don’t yell at me for sharing my opinion you can hate it but I sorta enjoyed it
considering you set the bar so low by calling it the most enjoyable REMAKE.... why argue?
most of us that despise the remakes have little desire to compare them.
Jafar is so badly miscast what a shame. And I know nothing can beat the original, but it seems like Disney was deliberately trying to mimic the original, so you might as well go all the way. The sets and costumes are gorgeous for the most part though, I'll give them that
I have to agree apart from the Live-action The Jungle Book. This is one of the better Live-action Disney remakes.
"Well, uh, the djinn... It attacked me!"
"The...the gin attacked you? You're...drinking gin?"
"No, ass-hat, the djinn!"
- _Sam and Dean Winchester, Supernatural_
Ha, ha~! XD
So, the denim fabric attacked you?
Cool
So Nadakhan?
23:54- a gigantic CGI snake with the motion capture likeness of the new Jafar’s actor would be terrifying.
@@Dinossword Or just make it a fucking Roc. Larger Iago is dumb, an actual Roc would have been an actual threat.
@@Dinossword that fact isn't very fun when they made hardly any effort at all in that regard. A more accurate sentence would be "Sad fact, the giant parrot was supposed to be a Roc but that would have been far too original for a remake so they didn't give enough shits to try very hard."
@@Dinossword Had they made the effort to make it look like a terrifying bird of prey and not a giant parrot, I think a lot of us would've made the effort to look it up.
i think the giant parrot is kinda referencing the great roc from the original tale
I mean, the parrot is kinda scary while that big, but, you know, it just can't replace the snake...
6:13
"You know the man who sleeps on a bed of needles?"
"Yes?"
"A fat guard fell on him. Now he's dead."
Joe Wilenzik Two others choked on shit... a lot of good people are dead.
"Yeah well unlike Aladdin, Abdul probably had a family that loved him!"
It's all your fault Jafar
Sheesh, you guys have a Twisted sense of humor!
donutmaster437 thanks
Honestly, Naomi Scott was the real star of this remake.
20:26
NC: Pfft, no arguments here.
"Aw , That's Hot , That's Hot "
Will Smith
No
"That's hot"
-Paris Hilton
@@GaryTurbo I'd like to tell a story all about how my life got bottled upside down
It will only take a minute so don't go far, I'll tell you how I became the prince of Agrabah
It's a hot mess is what it is!
Nathaniel Foga Nice Shark Tale reference.
Ironically the genie being the story tellers actually a theory people have with the original.
Chris Dugan That was the original intent, which is why Robin Williams voiced him, but that was changed later in development.
@@lpatterson787 I think it was changed due to time
There's a deleted ending where The Merchant appears and says "Ahh Happy end to the tale! Are you sure you don't wanna buy this lamp? Like I said things aren't always what they seem." Then he turns back into the Genie and says"Are they?" Then just like in final film, the last line is the Genie saying "Made ya look."
@@Laki2006 no it was cus the original ending got corrupted
Yeah I heard people say that the Peddler was Genie all along.
This is like if Bollywood failed to Bollywood itself.
Aladdin: “We have Jams!”
Genie: “Move away from the Jams!!!!”
Pumpkin: "Give me the Jam!"
Same, Will.
I was really disappointed to not see the “evil” version of Jasmine
yeah but it's a remake and it's better than the lion king one,you have to admit that at least.
SupportGaming 2019 However this movie doesn’t make up for how boring they made Iago, so both movies suck
Edmonton Boy Yes, I found what they did with Iago super-boring. The original was one of the first movies I remember seeing in theaters, and he’s always been my favorite character in it. Maybe he would have been a bit distracting if he could really talk like in the original... but from what? This lame version of his master? An Aladdin who doesn’t seem to give a shit half the time? They didn’t fill the void with anything interesting. I actually kind of liked the giant version of him, but it was no replacement for the snake.
@@edmontonboy99 true i did hate what they did to iago,but we should know by now that remakes won't always follow things accurately
@@TBustah Can't have Iago without Gilbert Gottfried!
I ain't gonna lie: in my opinion, I think Will Smith did a great job with the opening song.
2:54
Well, most of mediterranean pirates were actually arabs from North-African shore. This particular scene may be unintetionally pretty accurate.
Well Algeria is on the Medetrainian sea
@@nifralo2752 I can confirm it I am in Algeria and couple feet away from the Medetrainian Sea
"...pretty accurate" = A galleon at a time before firearms?
I was literally imagining Aladdin saying "I hate sand" when Doug brought up Star Wars.
I hate dust
Lol we're never going to let that one go, are we?
Sorry, the jasmine song was “let it go” 3.0 Moana did it too
This song was a version of "Let It Go" that I could actually stand.
Can I just point out that with the Cave of Wonders, no one ever says “Don’t touch anything but the lamp”, instead, Jafar asks Aladdin _only bring him the lamp_ which is very different from being asked to avoid touching anything but the lamp.
Ya didn't mention 2 of my biggest complaints.
1. Near the end, Jasmine just blurts out a super in depth back story for one of the guards out of nowhere, trying to get us to feel for him, but I was just confused as to how this is the first time any of this was mentioned.
2. During the song, One Jump Ahead, it's a song about him being a hungry thief, and in the original, showcased how he was a hungry thief. In this version, he sang it while helping Jasmine so what he was doing didn't fit with the lyrics or the meaning of the song.
Watching this one compared to the original just made me miss the original voice actors more. And it kills me that Robin Williams isn’t around anymore and I miss him like hell.
I remember Jafar's quote: -You can read books but you cannot read expirience.
Doug: Will Smith looks scary!
Cypher Raige: DENIED! SIT DOWN!
I've said it before and I'll say is again. I recommend watching Starkid's "Twisted" on TH-cam. It's a fan-made comedy musical where Jafar is the hero. Note, it's not kid friendly.
agreed!! twisted is SOO good
Ok glad I wasn’t the only one who thought she was putting more into acting than him
𝕍𝕆𝕃𝔸𝕀ℝ𝔼 feel like i legit see you everywhere on these comment pages
@@ActivistVictor I'd like to tell a story all about how my life got bottled upside down
It will only take a minute so don't go far, I'll tell you how I became the prince of Agrabah
Ya but i thoight hr was suppose to. Cause hes like a chill cool dude or whatever
@@AlexxxPerales
Being chill doesn't mean being emotionless.
@@AlexxxPerales Uh...no...
The bad thing about the live action film: they had a live action version of Aladdin..... THE BROADWAY PRODUCTION AND TOUR!!!!!!
That's what the Nostalgic Critic fails to see, and fails to mention throughout the entire video. It's more loosely based on the Broadway musical, duh!
You could make the same argument for live-action versions of Beauty and the Beast and The Lion King. They also had Broadway shows. Well, sadly for Beauty and the Beast’s case, the Broadway production’s not around anymore. But you could still watch some professional and high school productions of the musical though, so you’d still get a live-action Beauty and the Beast experience.
That “Tell Me More” Grease reference got me 😂 thanks so much for making these man consider yourself subbed
Every time Jaffar appears, I can hear the Critic saying "I'M JAFFAR!", as in the actor tries to convince people that he is actually playing the character. XD
Now I am wondering. Who do you think would be more “intimidating” if they crossed paths with one another, Jafar in the 2019 Aladdin remake or Fire Lord Ozai in M Night Shyamalan’s The Last Airbender adaptation? Or would it just devolve into a silly slap fight between those two live-action character portrayals?
We could kick both their asses 😒
@@markcobuzzi826 Mark Hamill would've been a far better live-action Fire Lord Ozai; at least we know he'd get the voice right.
...Now that I think about it, could you imagine Mark Hamill as live-action Iroh? It would be both surprisingly fitting and extremely ironic.
Will did a good job, but Robin Williams is certainly a hard act to follow!
i didnt see the remake but i thank doug for telling me why i should not see it
people forget that the first is animated. ANIMATED. A lot of the mannerisms from genie in the animated movie is why Robin is loved.
as for the voice, Will is Will and Robin is Robin. But Robin's Genie would be too cartoony for a LIVE ACTION movie.
The movie had to blend the fun with some realism.
While genie is animated an magical..WHY would he be just as equally animated as the animated movie?
We should know by now that the mannerisms in animated shows are meant for us..not the people in that universe.
A dropped jaw that hits the ground and makes a ring like an Anvil hitting..in animated movies is equivalent to nothing more than raised eyebrows in the real world. Cartoons MUST be exaggerated for fun. You just can't have it that way in the real world without it being too damn corny.
So basically, the movie, if you just understand how it HAS to be different, will be AS enjoyable as the animated movie.
it shouldn't be seen as compared. It should be seen as capable of being paired. And they pair nicely.
You can ask your kids, or yourself which you'd rather watch, the animated or live animateion adn still get the same feelings of the story and some enjoyment.
@@agonleed3841 I understand what you are getting at, but have you seen Robin live? The man is a cartoon. The animators got a lot of inspiration from watching him do the lines, and only enhanced what they were already seeing. Will Smith is good when it's him, but the animation for him didn't do him any favors. It was very clunky. If they styled it more like classic movie musicals and really tried a fresh take, rather than some mix that fell flat, then it would have been great. No one is mad that it's different, they are mad it's not different _enough_ .
I also disagree that the animated mannerisms in cartoons are for the audience, as quite often, characters will interact with those mannerisms. Like Aladdin and Jafar to Genie and so forth.
@@bandotaku starting from the end...yes they interact..buyt it's "normal" in their world. That's why I used the term "equivalent" or thought I did.
Real live people..that would be too cartoony. The movie didn't want to be too damn cartoony.
I watch a lot of asian movies as well. Fantasy movies. In a lot of those, they will have a little magical pet. Something like a Stitch from Lilo and Stitch. It can be anything. Some octopus looking thing..whatever.
A lot of manga/anime have those also. In the anime they are very animated. Very exagerrated with the movements and features. But in live action, that magical fantasy thinig has to be toned down.
There are some that go the exaggerated route..but even then you can tell the difference in QUALITY.
The ones that are more animated are considered "cheap" in a way. Too cartoony. Childish. Something anyone over the age of 15 would maybe have apprehensions to watch.
Whereas the ones that tone it down is enjoyed by all ages more often.
And I grew up on the old aladdin and robin williams. He's one of my favorite comedians for his antics. But I've seen his serious tones as well. And if they had him in this live action, they'd try to tone him down. He'd be a mix...as Will is. In an effort for him to be fun..but not OVER THE TOP.
Honestly, I think the tune people would be on then would be, "oh my god, they wasted Robin Williams. He did so great in the animated movie, but they didn't let him do that in this live action."
The movie is live action and they wanted it to have a base in the real life.
Again..in this world that doesn't believe it's a cartoon..doesn't really have the ideas of the exaggerations of such...WHY would Genie drop his jaw ALL the way to the ground with an anvil sound?
It's great that WE get the references of some impressions..but what would this REAL LIFE person in THIS specific world..what would his reactions be?
He can't continue the conversation when this magical thing is making impressions that he doesn't have a clue about. He's going to call it out. And it will be constantly him asking, "ok, so who's that one" And the genie saying, "yuou know what, never mind..not your time" which would be a lame running joke after the 3rd impression.
And there's no reason to do impressions of many people within agrabah because WE don't know many people of Agrabah. We only know a few. So Aladdin would get the impressions, but not us. Then..who cares?
So..if Robin was doing it..the same rules would apply. And his voices are impressions also..voices Aladdin wouldn't know.
In animation, cartoons..we just accept it because..they're cartoons. They can do anything. It's a cartoon. They can know anything across time and space. You don't even expect it to be real. You can visually see that there are no rules besides whatever they illustrator wants.
So..take away a lot of the visual and audio impressions and what do you have? Exactly the performance that Will gave
The animated series was a hard act to follow.
Loki: I have an army.
Tony Stark: We have a Hulk.
Aladdin: 16:49
Lol!!
What the hell is he honking? Chimps? Chips? Champs?
Edit: ...was that jams? Oh god, why is it pronounced so oddly?!
The crossover that we didn't need but we secretly want.
I’ve got a jar of dirt!
I'd imagine Robin Williams is rolling in his grave he is the Best Genie from the original Aladdin Will Smith's Genie in the 2019 Aladdin remake is Okay But NOT That Great
"What the hell were we smoking when we made this?" That's the question the director probably should've asked himself when he finished this movie.
Thank god Guy Ritchie had The Gentlemen up his sleeve the same year this putrid mess came out. Except that wasn’t REMOTELY appropriate for little kids, lmfao
you see, they are setting up a sequel, Aladdin 2: Shirabath, Revenge of Jafar