The new year brings a new and different energy; may it be filled with Rachamim and great Simcha for Eretz Israel, the Chosen People, and all who stand with Israel. Baruch Hashem from NC, USA.
P.S.& N.B. Not only those who have certain titles of authority and knowledge can impart a higher form of insight and raise you up as a result, but also YOU can do the same with what the Creator gave and made at your birth. IOW, we can ALL learn from each other!
Are you refering to Devarim 4:2,when explaining do not add or subtract with combination with Devarim 16:18-21 I'm trying to understand the Sages descerniment. Shalom!!
Great Shiur. Thanks to Rav Breitowitz. A question. Are there sources in Tanakh or Talmudic literature that provide reasons why the malkhut (monarchy) became hereditary, meaning passing by progeny from father to son. It seems odd. David hamelech was anointed by the great priest prophet Samuel. Wouldn't it be normal to have kings anointed (appointed, using current political jargon) by an assembly of priests or khakham gdolim, as long as they belong to Judah tribe. It could be anyone. It doesn't have to be descendant from the previous monarch. I have come to believe that Hereditary monarchy is contrary to normal functioning political system, if not to say contrary to judaim statem of government. Any idea? Thanks much.
@DiegoGarcia-nk8cj Sorry, I am not versed in Kabalah. Your comment or answer is tautological. It does't answer why the judaism monarchy became hereditary. That was my question. Please excuse my ignorance of Kabalah, I am not yet worthy to attempt to study it, for I know it is not something easy to comprehend. If you are well versed in it, please enlighten me as to the hereditary Malkhut that Judaism upholded, or else tell me what the Arizal said about the material malkhut (meaning the human sphere malkhut) and not the spiritual keter of Hashem. Thank you.
I'm not sure that a comparison can be made from the days of David Hamelech and the prophet Samuel A"h...in their days the anointing was made through prophecy. The midrash explains that when Samuel arrived to the home of Yishai, he wanted to anointed the brother of King David. THEN, through prophecy he was told not to annoint this brother rather David, This seems to be the nowadays reason we lament the loss of the Beit Hamikdash ...as well as the loss of prophecy because we can not foresee the future, whereas the prophet receives his or her prophecy from the all knowing I hope that I understood your question As far hereditary the tehilim states that the monarchy will never pass from the lineage of David ...the tribe of Judah was mentioned in the blessings of Yakov avinu.Lo yasur. The lineage was later narrowed to the seed of David.
@ronheeer Thanks very much for your insight and information on Malkhut. The hereditary monarchy in the life long duration of united monarchy than the divided one was marked by teŕrible kings and vassals, with few good ones in between, according to the Tanach. Another point that can be argued against hereditary monarchy, is the example that Moshe rabbenu provided by Not pushing his son Gershon to lead the Jewish nation. Instead, opting for Joshua to lead the nation to the promised land. Thanks again for responding. All the best tou you and Sabbath Shalom.
It sounds like we can be unburdened by what has been I was wondering why Kamala kept repeating that. Turns up that is a message from Hashem that we can be renewed and become new people. For Jewish people that Marxist statement has a completely different meaning Teshuva is a wonderful gift!
OBEDIENCE, so to speak, should be put in the following context: While G-D wants you to VOLUNTARILY and even JOYFULLY comply with his will expressed through the various sages rabbis and the Grand S, upreme court, this does NOT imply or mean any kind of SLAVERY or even SERVITUDE to your fellow Jew or human being - REGARDLESS of his qualifications ( Rabbi, Rebbe, Rav, Gaon, Tzaddik, PhD or MD!) It is an invitation to those who know to impart this knowledge so that everyone can reach and identify with The Creator in him and in others through - MUTUAL RESPECT! We must not forget that we were slaves and servants in ancient Egypt and STAY AWAY FROM doing what was done to us - to others! ☺️
The new year brings a new and different energy; may it be filled with Rachamim and great Simcha for Eretz Israel, the Chosen People, and all who stand with Israel. Baruch Hashem from NC, USA.
😊❤
😢😢😢
😢😢
Baruch Hashem , such excellent Rabbi .
Thank you Rabbi
LOVE HARAV Yitchak Breitowitz!!!!
I am so grateful to you Rabbi for your teaching, for your universal Chesed. It nourishes my soul
Zekher tzadik livrakha.
This Rov is amazing! 🥳🩵
Thank you lovely lecture ❤🕎
Thank you Rabbi ❤
Thank you for your deep wisdom, rabbi Breitwitz ❤
Baruch Hashem!
Am Israel chai ❤
Can the Rov please explain the Talmud which states that anyone who states Dovid sinned is mistaken?
Thank you in advance
P.S.& N.B.
Not only those who have certain titles of authority and knowledge can impart a higher form of insight and raise you up as a result, but also YOU can do the same with what the Creator gave and made at your birth.
IOW, we can ALL learn from each other!
Are you refering to Devarim 4:2,when explaining do not add or subtract with combination with Devarim 16:18-21 I'm trying to understand the Sages descerniment. Shalom!!
Also,Are the Sages refering to Shemos 21:22,22:8? In order to come to this conclusion?
Great Shiur. Thanks to Rav Breitowitz. A question. Are there sources in Tanakh or Talmudic literature that provide reasons why the malkhut (monarchy) became hereditary, meaning passing by progeny from father to son. It seems odd. David hamelech was anointed by the great priest prophet Samuel. Wouldn't it be normal to have kings anointed (appointed, using current political jargon) by an assembly of priests or khakham gdolim, as long as they belong to Judah tribe. It could be anyone. It doesn't have to be descendant from the previous monarch. I have come to believe that Hereditary monarchy is contrary to normal functioning political system, if not to say contrary to judaim statem of government. Any idea? Thanks much.
@DiegoGarcia-nk8cj Sorry, I am not versed in Kabalah. Your comment or answer is tautological. It does't answer why the judaism monarchy became hereditary. That was my question. Please excuse my ignorance of Kabalah, I am not yet worthy to attempt to study it, for I know it is not something easy to comprehend. If you are well versed in it, please enlighten me as to the hereditary Malkhut that Judaism upholded, or else tell me what the Arizal said about the material malkhut (meaning the human sphere malkhut) and not the spiritual keter of Hashem. Thank you.
I'm not sure that a comparison can be made from the days of David Hamelech and the prophet Samuel A"h...in their days the anointing was made through prophecy.
The midrash explains that when Samuel arrived to the home of Yishai, he wanted to anointed the brother of King David. THEN, through prophecy he was told not to annoint this brother rather David,
This seems to be the nowadays reason we lament the loss of the Beit Hamikdash ...as well as the loss of prophecy because we can not foresee the future, whereas the prophet receives his or her prophecy from the all knowing
I hope that I understood your question
As far hereditary the tehilim states that the monarchy will never pass from the lineage of David ...the tribe of Judah was mentioned in the blessings of Yakov avinu.Lo yasur.
The lineage was later narrowed to the seed of David.
@ronheeer Thanks very much for your insight and information on Malkhut. The hereditary monarchy in the life long duration of united monarchy than the divided one was marked by teŕrible kings and vassals, with few good ones in between, according to the Tanach. Another point that can be argued against hereditary monarchy, is the example that Moshe rabbenu provided by Not pushing his son Gershon to lead the Jewish nation. Instead, opting for Joshua to lead the nation to the promised land. Thanks again for responding. All the best tou you and Sabbath Shalom.
It sounds like we can be unburdened by what has been
I was wondering why Kamala kept repeating that. Turns up that is a message from Hashem that we can be renewed and become new people.
For Jewish people that Marxist statement has a completely different meaning
Teshuva is a wonderful gift!
OBEDIENCE, so to speak, should be put in the following context:
While G-D wants you to VOLUNTARILY and even JOYFULLY comply with his will expressed through the various sages rabbis and the Grand S, upreme court, this does NOT imply or mean any kind of SLAVERY or even SERVITUDE to your fellow Jew or human being - REGARDLESS of his qualifications ( Rabbi, Rebbe, Rav, Gaon, Tzaddik, PhD or MD!)
It is an invitation to those who know to impart this knowledge so that everyone can reach and identify with The Creator in him and in others through - MUTUAL RESPECT!
We must not forget that we were slaves and servants in ancient Egypt and STAY AWAY FROM doing what was done to us - to others! ☺️
Wasn't the Rav for MRNA jabs?
@@leszekwolkowski9856 Which Rav, and what are you getting at?
@@jakobw135 that the Rav was mistaken and it's a good think if you were not obedient.
B''H
Thank you rabbi