£1 Billion vs Perfect Facilities
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ย. 2024
- Welcome to TomFM! In today's Football Manager 2023 experiment video I give Barnet £1 Billion and Oldham Athletic the perfect facilities, to see which club performs better over 25 seasons.
🔔: MAKE SURE YOU SUBSCRIBE & TURN NOTIFICATIONS ON
💜: Twitch: / tomfm
🔵: Twitter: / tomfm_yt
🟠: Patreon: Patreon - / tomfm
🤖: Discord: / discord
⚫: TikTok: / therealtomfm
📸: Instagram: / tom_kelso
🛒: TomFM Store: teespring.com/...
🎥: My Set-Up: kit.co/TomFM/t...
About TomFM:
Welcome to TomFM, the home of Football Manager 2023 content. You can expect FM23 let's play videos as well as experiments and guides across the lifecycle of FM 2023. All videos uploaded at 5pm UK Time. Make sure you hit the subscribe button and turn the notification bells on for tutorials, wonderkids, tactics and lets plays!
#FM23 #FootballManager2023 #FootballManager
Barnet felt like those stories of lottery winners that splurge all their money on useless stuff and are broke within a year
A gambling addict could manage their finances better than barnet
I think the AI mismanages the finances while a human player could sculpt a strategy around meting out the 1 billion more responsibly
rick james said cocaine's a hell of a drug
Blew it all on a lifetime supply of wotsits
@@TomFM not a complete waste of money though! 😆
I think both Chesterfield and Wrexham have had a more interesting National league story of their own during this save, both going from the National league. Chesterfield getting up to the Championship (5:30) whereas Wrexham got to league one then dropped like a stone down back to the National league (7:17) I’m assuming Ryan dropped out.
That's what I love about these sorts of videos, the side narratives are so interesting! Rob and Ryan usually drop out pretty quickly in game, I suspect in FM24 they'll be programmed to stay a lot longer!
Maybe Ryan died. I mean it‘s 25 years in the future
Or he just dropped out as I don’t think people die in FM
@@wombatZlmao 🤣assuming the worst innit
@@adventureofalifetime1547 As Tom said. "side narratives" hahaha
I think on these sort of experiments it might be worth doing 2 clubs on either side. Feel like it's quite isolated especially if you pick the wrong clubs (looking at you Barnet)
It's a good idea, an insurance policy perhaps 😂 But I like how it shows some teams just can't manage finances as well as others.
@@TomFM I get that but I also think it'll emphasise just how badly that team managed their finances if you'd had another billion pound team going blow for blow with the youth product team in this scenario. Though whilst I have your attention I wonder what a 10th tier would do with all that money.... Say maybe someone like Huntingdon 👀
Considering how much more successful perfect facilities seem to be, instead of giving leagues/countries/clubs a £1bil cash or tv deal, you could try giving a leagues worth of clubs perfect facilities. Maybe a country like Portugal who have access to champs league and combined with a good youth rating might have interesting results.
Best comment
Netherlands could be interesting too
I like this, certainly worth testing!
I would have chosen perfect facilities from the start. The only risk there is the yearly cost of youth coaching and recruitment, but if the club goes up quickly enough as Oldham did, money isn't a problem anymore, especially as the youth make a big part of the team, several new ones arriving every year to make up for the ones who leave, for some big money, which isn't much needed to recruit other players. So the club can keep some money even without sponsors and still spend millions on better staff, bigger stadiums, or to maintain the facilities.
The main problem with billions is that recruited players are overpayed and hard to sell once they're not good enough anymore.
you shouldve flipped it at the end and given oldham 1B and Barnet the youth facilities to see if the outcome would be the same, would take ages though so maybe not
I’ll be honest. Taking over at Barnet at this point seems like it would be a lot of fun
Tom I think if the average human was given 1 billion than the ai they would spent it more wisely and not hand out over 67000 in league 2😂❤
Except the players will then just refuse to play for you. It's the way the game's coded.
I don't know, I'd hand out some pretty big contracts to players to get Lincoln City promoted 😂
Reputation means a lot in Football Manager, giving a club loads money with low rep means no players will want to go there. Whereas the great facilities means that Oldham got great players with no rep requirements. Also, once the real players start retiring, the game will replace them with regens of a similar skill level to their current level/rep so getting promoted quickly (like Oldham did) is a big advantange.
Good to see you finally use Oldham on these 💙
3:45 "soul-eh-man tahm-boo-rah"
This is the classic FM problem that the AI makes decisions based on team reputation, and not on anything else (albeit way worse than usual).
These "I've given them a lot of money" tests always fail because that reputation was unchanged, so they still act like the tiny club they are...
I think it depends. I've done similar videos in the past where I've given the entire National League £1bn and some will make it to the Premier League. But you are right, reputation is the single biggest deciding factor in the game.
The reputation in an experiment like this feels like it had a big impact.
I saw you put out a tweet asking for some new content ideas…
Taking inspiration from your around the block save, where you tried to sign players from only Eastern Europe, I’d love to see which region would come out on top.
A team in the premier league could be entirely made up from Scandinavian players for example. Another could be South Europe etc
Then you sim and see which region comes out on top. Or lock them players in/transfer embargo the clubs and see there journey through the English pyramid.
You could even restrict this further and make it under 21 players only and see which region’s wonderkids are the best.
I don't know why, but I want to see what would it need to happen for India to win world cup (I'm not Indian). Would it be just great youth facilities and coaching for all Indian clubs, bilion pounds for each club, or both.
I think it would be interesting for us, but probably time consuming for you, to see what would actually be needed for a not so football nation to win a world cup.
I think it would be interesting to do this again but give the team with unlimited budget the best scouts aswell
Perfect facilities is a much easier save than 1 billion pounds, of course you can manage those funds better if you take charge of the billionaire club but those youth facilities will start producing right away and carry you until you hit the premier league with a much lower wage bill and capable to make the jump
I would like to see this experiment again but combined. You give 1 Billion AND the Perfect Facilities to a single small club in the National League, like Dorking Wanderers, and see what happens.
This really speaks about how bad AI is in FM. 1 billion is strictly better than perfect facilities since it allows you to build the perfect facilities plus signing incredible players for the level. They should really work on this part of the game
Tom what would be awesome in these videos (especially clubs from countries who produce awesome youth players) check the highest current ability of the best players in the clubs. A bit like what you did at the start to show the best players out of the clubs to begin vs the rest of the world&EPL :)
This would be good to try with Barnet with a perfect scouting team and DoF and Oldham with perfect HoYD and youth coaching team.
Tom did a video on oldham! Oldham! My club! Cheers tom
the dramatic music in the buildup to season 3 is so stressful wth
Think you should do one with 3 teams - 1 with facilities, 1 with cash and 1 with half of each...
I love seeing Oldham winning up the latics
ini up the latics
You should have shown how Oldham transfer look like, how much they get from old the wonderkids.
Looks like TK is signing players again! Should of gave us the Perfect Facilities.
Try the same experiment with the same staff and same team. Something which was sone by other youtubers as well but with the facilities ir money spin
i'd have been interested to see how good oldham's facilities were by the end.
I would give my team 1 Billion pounds cause I could get those perfect facilities in the 1 billion aswell as build up a good squad for each season, also keep up the great work Tom you are one of my favourite TH-camrs to watch especially when times get tough your streams are great aswell
For a challenge, could you do a team with insane players but rubbish coaching and facilities and another the opposite. They could start in the vanarama national league.
6 millions per year on ground maintenance, seems the table of barnet's chairman is full of "sugar".
I hope Oldham do go back up to football league next season
Having played with facilities in a few saves I'd definitely pick that over the money.
Take a lower-division English league. Give a third of the clubs one billion dollars, give another third of the clubs perfect facilities, and give the rest of the clubs a 150,000-seat stadium. Run the experiment for twenty-five years and see what happens.
Brennan Johnson and Marcus Rashford ending up as the managers is not how I saw this video going.
My team i support irl has one of the best facilities in the world and the team is PAOK FC from Greece. So i would like the 1 billion for my team but even so they could not win the league lol....
I think i would've choose facilities because if i have better facilities i can make great youngsters and i can sell them for alot of money
But if i took the money i probably would spend it on mideocare player and i probaly wont get past the championship
Pre-watch comment: I always thought money>facilities because your facilities degrade fast and without money you stay stuck. If you have money you can upgrade those later.
how do you see the potential ability in game?
I wanna see the Rashford dynasty at Oldham
As a South Shields supporter, I'd be thoroughly disappointed if we're in League 2 come 2047 😂 our club is going places 🥹🥳🥳🥳
Need to do the same challenge with the same teams but give oldham the £1billion and Barnet the facilities
Do it as a save idea next year
Can u do a video on giving every club in the world 1/20 in all facilities & see what happens?
This is basically Brighton Vs chelsea this season
How do you add the filter that shows CA / PA in squad view?
You do it through the in game editor
You need the in game editor
Hi Tom, can you try and do an experiment to try and get Plymouth Argyle to win the Champions League?
Great video Tom 👍🏼
How are you seeing PA and CA in game?
Not sure it'll be a good video but could put one or two top European clubs in a crap league like Irish league and see if they can stay consistent in Europe in a lower rated league and poor TV revenue meaning they might need to cash in on players. Basically a race between growing league reputation vs top players leaving and finances collapsing
How do I see potential ability in numeric not stars? Please help me
Perfect facilities felt like such an obvious option for me. Think about producing the players ur r trying to sign. And having extras to sell and make profit.
Try with perfect staff all around
I'd bet the problem with Barnet was that even with all that money, their scouts were still only National League quality. So they probably overrated players due to bad/inaccurate scouts.
It's not the scouts, but the reputation. Their reputation says "invest only on National League-level things, don't bother with anything better", even though their money lets them do that.
@@llSuperSnivyll Yeah but they also were over-paying for players. Like I don't think you pay Jack Spong 30k/wk wages if they had a good read on his CA/PA. To me those wages say they thought he was better than he was.
@@cjjones633 I have tried checking that myself. I picked a Level 10 team (with the lower leagues database), and gave them maximum reputation.
I only did 6 seasons so far, but, despite the obviously worsening reputation, they do bring in players that are WAY above the league they're in (they have players with around 100 CA on a Level 7 league), but they are still overpaying them... one of them is earning 5 million pounds a year.
It's not as simple as it seems.
I have perfect everything and get below average intakes every year! so frustrating
What if you do the same but insteas of 1 billion a tv deal?
Experiment suggestion:
Can Will Still get Wrexham to the premier league?
Gotta do £1B perfect facilities and a perfect staff
Now this is an interesting experiment
1 billion, to invest in the best facilities this world can give you. You still have more money to revamp the management
i'd give my team a billion € because with that they can build the best facilities.
They need to improve the ai on how it spends money because everytime you give teams money they always just waste it on nothing
Only problem with this is its got very little to do with facilities but more to do with youth recruitment and junior coaching
£1000000000 vs Perfect Facilities vs Max Reputation next time.
I'd choose both and we'd win Jack all as a baggies fan
What game or program are you using to Sim this?
Im happy sheffield wednesday got to the prem in this save
please do the tv deal sim with India.
Hi Tom what facepack do you use?
Tom do you ever play fm touch?
Hi Tom. Can you give Turkish clubs 1 billion TV Deal?
What fm skin is Tom using?
Those tics 🟦⬜
How do you get the save game file? Want to manage Oldham
I'd rathee have facilities. On long term it will make me more than billion+players for my team
Na man in real life money all the way then spend that money on upgrading facilities
YAY BARNET IN A SIM
Ikr when he hit that image of the hive felt surreal
Люблю твой канал:)
Love your channel😊😊
Upgrade corporate facilities when you give 1 billion pounds so they spend smartly
Can u do more Oldham vids
Do EPL and national league swapping stadiums
Tom how do you sim seasons ahead without it taking hours and hours even when your manager is on vacation?
How do you know it doesn't take hours and hours? The only thing I could think of if it doesn't take hours for him is that he uses a smaller database or he has a beast of a PC.
Please give the Serie A tv deal same PL lets see if they will reach top league in the world 🙏🏻
How can you see the ability in numbers, do i need the editor?
You need the editor
please do the same thing but both clubs are in the prem
Before I watch this, Barnet will just end up signing the same players they would anyway but on silly wages. Oldham will do well short term, then plateau as the league they end up in be it championship or league one and slowly over time the facilities will degrade and anyone with talent will be signed by prem teams either as they're first team ready or just before. The games AI has no idea what to do when lower teams are given money
What skin do you use bro on fm
in the hands of a smart human being, having 1b is a lot better, a good FM player wouldn't be that stupid with their money. Heck, even a bad player wouldn't be that stupid, giving crazy high wages to less than good players. Barnet was really on a whole new level of incompetence here.
Oldham back in the prem 🤩
Do Philippines give too many football clubs in FM23!
Love it Tom
love barnet, my local club jus watched them get knocked out by their bitter rivals boreham wood in the playoffs
😪😪
In real life I would rather my club have one billion pounds, however, I think that the game will have the club with the facilities do better, and certainly have more sustained success.
chelsea would like a word
1 billion 😂
My Chelsea save in 2033 laughs
I made just under that In one season selling players I no longer wanted 😅
I made so much money I still had 500 million left after buying everyone I wanted 😮
in 25 seasons the perfect facilities could have made more than 1b. no transfers fee to pay cheaper loans on the players.
How good were the Barnet scouts? Seems like more of a failure to find the best players on their behalf than a failure to be able to pay the best players.
Classic Barnet, whenever they have had money they wasted it!
IRL, i would rather have my team get 1 billion. In fm, I would have 1 billion if I were the manager since AI dont know how to spend and improve. But AI should have facilities
Pick the billion then upgrade all facilities 🤷♂️