The Younger-Dryas was not a single event, but rather 2 separate events of extraterrestrial impacts that happened approx 1,500 years apart at the end of the last ice age. Randall Carlson covers this in great depth and detail.
@@willymakeit5172 - Actually everything I said can be easily searched and located. The only thing I could possibly do for you would be to post direct links, which FascistTube adamantly refuses to allow.
@@dreamingmusic3299Links to Randall Carlson I'm sure. I can debunk Carlson with 1 Google Search for you. Pangborn Bar Clovis site. What is it? It's a Clovis tool site that sits on top of a Scablands Mega-flood Bar near Wenatchee. The ONLY way this is possible is if the floods were pre-Covis occupation just as all dating work in the Scablands tells us.
Tina, thank you very much for your excellent presentation! I'm convinced your explanation of what happened in our not so distant past is very accurate. Keep up the spectacular work as it's so refreshing and much appreciated!
Lady Tina ,your research is impeccable and the depth of work demands serious respect. Your total body of work will provoke a strong response and force the truth to come forth!I'm working my way thru you series and I'm dieing to see your conclusions when you present them on who these ancient civilizations are.Most conclusions in this area inevitable lead to something not of this planet, so you intense pursuit of this truth is greatly appreciated! The truth will set you free!
Thank you Fred! I'm really grateful for your support! I'm still searching...there are so many mysteries. Hope one day we will get to the truth together 🙂
So glad I was recommended your video on the osiris shaft today. I went on a marathon. I'm so glad you point out the tooling marks and how they are similar to sites around the world. I've left comments on channels wishing people would notice how important it is.
You deliver! One thing you might consider is that all of these population charts depend on one thing. Land based finds. Nobody has ever really bothered looking offshore. As most modern day Human populations are coastally based, we can assume the same for the past. Sea levels are now 400 or so feet higher, currently obscuring any remains. That said, I am uncertain if that was taken into consideration when these charts were created. It might well have been.
Thank you for your insight. You brought up an interesting point. From the papers I read, some of the population studies are based on the radiocarbon record of sites on land; some used whole genome sequence data from individuals to study the genomic evidence; and some researched the changes in genetic variation, DNA mutation rate, etc. to reconstruct effective population sizes. Granted that the ancient DNA evidence is all collected on land, they might present only a portion of the true ancient population. Were the people who lived on the now-submerged coastal cities genetically different from the ones whose DNA we have? I don't know but it'll be exciting to find out.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Tina, just saying... And I don''t have a public TH-cam channel, but how about jazzing up the background a bit? A few warm colors, maybe a book or two... that kind of thing...
Its amazing how much knowledge you have. I am also very impressed how you back-up all your thoughts/ideas with charts and evidence or published articles. Keep doing what you are doing, you are very good at it. Thank you!
It's funny I only just found this video, after leaving a rant on the Younger Dryas in a previous video comment. I believe you are on the right course with your theories.🐌
Thanks Jack! I made a followup video on this subject discussing the period of the severe population bottleneck. Would like to hear your feedback on it :-) When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Great to see more people are seriously studying the possibility that humans were highly advanced prior to Younger Dryas. I first stumbled across Graham Hancock's TED talk "Is the house of history built on foundations of sand?" which has the disclaimer: "NOTE from TED: Please be aware that this talk contains outdated and counterfactual assertions, and should not be understood as a representation of modern scholarship on ancient civilizations." I believe, like many others, that grant money and careers will be lost if their collective reconstruction of human history is wrong. These academic scholars are desperate to discount any challenge to their theories. The truth will eventually overcome these roadblocks and become scientifically accepted. Thank you for your work on these presentations. Our understanding of human history today is about to be flipped on it's head!
Thank you Bob. I watched that Graham Hancock's TED talk as well and it was an eye opener. I agree that most if not all mainstream scholars are avoiding to discuss the possibility of one or more highly-advanced civilizations existed in ancient time. Thank you for your support and I appreciate it.
Thanks Tina. Prof. Barry Cunliffe is worth getting to know, as is his book on the migrations across Eurasia: By Steppe, Desert and Ocean. The map at the 39:30 min mark shows how there was a corridor stretching from China to central Europe and back across which people even during the Ice Age I presume could travel and wander. There is another variable I'd like you to consider when thinking about the aftermath of one of periodic Comet strikes (and I think the flood mentioned in the Timaeus, ca 9600, a Meltwater Pulse, came back in 6200, Doggerland gets flooded and Meltwater Pulse II, then again in 2800, the rise of Sumer and again in 536 AD, the Ravenna Comet Mosaic [see Ruth Dwyer's youtube video on this] which I believe were set on a 3400 year elliptical path after the first strike which led to the 1200 year cooling. The comet didn't just evaporate entirely even after impact. That variable is whether the declination of the earth changes, as the Egyptians told us per Timaeus (the story of Phaethon). Thus, not only did the North Pole move but there could have been a new axis of rotation. Giza, Cuzco, Rapa Nui and Angkor Wat, among other notable sites, are all on a great circle. I think that great circle was once the equator, which is how you could have easily found Rapa Nui. (Pretty hard otherwise, and why bother?) I think the declination changed by roughly 30 degrees. I think the story of Demeter (Ceres in Rome, as in Cereal) looking for her daughter Persephone who was kidnapped by Hades and taken to the Underworld is the story of the first appearance of winter and seasons. Persephone got to come back up to be with her grain growing mother but had to return down under for a season each year. Think about it and thanks again. Always a pleasure. HH [Barry Cunliffe -- th-cam.com/video/oOj_MV6o0Vk/w-d-xo.html]
I have had the opportunity to be close to a great Sage for years and many times he has spoken of a previous society with technology that is beyond ours. Your are doing an amazing job in bringing this information to the people. Please continue.
Where are the artifacts of the lost civilizations. Yes there are megalithic structures but where are the traces of machines/tools that built them. No archeologists have found any evidence of advanced technology.
@@brucesoehngen852 , I ponder on this question and wonder if we suddenly abandoned machinery/tools in a quarry or construction site due to a cataclysmic event, would there be anything left of them after 13,000 or more years?
Hi Tina! I have watched many channels talking about this fascinating topic but the vast majority of them leave us with even more doubts. I don't know why it took me so long to find your channel here and your explanations are so simple and important, didactic too, in fact super didactic. A real pearl in this sea of disagreements that is the net. Thank you very much and congratulations.
So glad to hear that you find my video helpful! Thank you very much for the support :-) Btw I made a follow-up video discussing what might have happened during the human population bottleneck over 15,000 years ago. Hope you will enjoy it too. Here is the link: When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Hi Tina, I just found your channel, WOW!!! Your scientific approach is a breath of fresh air, your analysis is poignant, and well researched. Keep doing what you do!
Thank you for another excellent video, Tina. Your range of skills, from technological mastery and eloquent communication skills to critical analyis and reflection are exceptional. How did you get here? 🙂
Thank you Toni! You are too kind. I'm just curious and would like to do research on things... other than that, I think my architectural background definitely helps me better formulate my ideas :-)
i really like your documentary. i also want to mentioned the care you take to answer the comments that peoples give to you ..this is well appreciated and show that you respect us .so have a good day and thank Tina .thanks really.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina You are so knowledgeable I had no idea of these caves in China. Gobekli Tepe was the first mindblowing site I was aware of. Now, it seems primitive! Looking forward to your next reveals
Thanks for such an informative and engaging presentation👍！The resilience of our ancestors was truly impressive to me. What a thought-provoking video to watch during the pandemic！
I wonder if there is a technology similar to LiDAR that can digitally removed sand/soil and water... we probably will find ancient ruins beneath the now-unpopulated landscapes.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina GPR has been widely used and works pretty well . Sarah Parcek is leading space archeologist and started a crowd search .. I think Oil ,mining , and military have huge jump on the rest of us , having developed all these methods for us. I heard there a city under Gobi sands
@@CuriousBeingbyTina they do this other thing with a network of probes and electricity .. even deep blast surveys that read like sonograms. With all the new 3d modeling ... secrets will be revealed
@@shermanatorosborn9688 How exciting! Thanks for the information. I think there must have many ancient ruins submerged under the ocean and/or buried in sand. Can't wait to see these new discoveries
The past is more complicated than we’re taught. Cosmic impacts definitely appear to be implicated however, I’ve personally seen evidence of granite surface vitrification on human worked stone. A temperature in excess of 2200 Celsius is required to accomplish this. Maybe the reason we don’t find the remains of the builders aside from those already dead and buried prior is because they were vaporised
@@markvianen2282 Interesting that you caught the incorrect translation in the Bible. The word for "salt" was used when it should have read "vapor" or "smoke"
I just found You! Very well done video. Your presentation is very concise and makes a person think. Please do more about the younger dryas impact theories, I am fascinated by Your video presence.
Welcome and thank you for the support, Tanya! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-) I made a followup video on the human population bottle happened before Younger Dryas - 20,000-15,000 Years Ago When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html Hope you will find it interesting.
Tina, as usual you have done very nice work here. You are following where the data leads. While there were several areas around the globe where advanced civilizations existed (the gods had divided up the world among themselves) before the younger dryas and its triggering event (a comet impact-see the Carolina Bays), the most famous of these was the kingdom of Atlantis (Aztlan) and its beautiful main island. Traders and statesmen from around the globe travelled to this amazing place to obtain precious materials and knowledge. All that remains is for you or Graham Hancock to find it. You might begin by looking where the ancient Egyptians and Aztecs said it was located.
@@bennichols561 uh huh… and your background is? I find graham to be quite intelligent and willing to question the obvious bullshit mainstream narrative on history.
Quite interesting read in German online portal Scinexx today: Researchers from Brown university discovered and examined strange dark rocks that cover a vast area in the Atacama desert, spread across 75km. They concluded that they are condensed matter from enormous low-altitude airbursts of large comet fragments. The analysis of microscopic zirkon and other crystals and the isotope ratios led to an initial age estimation of around 12.000 years plus/minus 500 yrs. Pretty close or spot on to the Younger Dryas Event at the same time windown. Seems like there must have been a global rain of large comet fragments all over the world that certainly totally ruined the day for the people at that time.
That's very interesting indeed. Thank you for sharing with me! I agree with you - there appears to have been a global comet fragments rain during YD. It must have been a disastrous time for the people and societies.
Another superb video Tina I do believe there was a cataclysmic event that wiped out or at least contributed to wiping out an advanced civilisation that existed before our own. Not neccesarily more advanced than us but advanced in a different way (perhaps a way more suited to a harmonious planet though!). Loving your work thanks again for the fantastic information!!
New subscriber here :) Great video, but one distinction I see. There is a difference between surviving a glacial maximum and surviving a rapid cooling event. The glacial maximum (supposedly) came on slowly over the course of thousands of years. Glaciers retreating less in the summer than they grow in the winter. People can slowly migrate south over many generations. A rapid cooling event like what would occur from a comet filling the sky with debris (blocking out the sun) would be devastating. No sun = no plants = no animals. When that happens the only food you are going to have for several years is what you already have stored and preserved. Probably would not have been much for Clovis type hunter gatherers. I like the way you think outside the box. Keep up the great work!
Thank you Michael! I has similar thoughts with you regarding the comet impact. However I changed my mind after finding some data points. The YD comet was much smaller than the one that ended the Dinosaurs' time (therefore less negative affect on lives on earth) and there appears to be no obvious human population decline during or after the rapid cooling event. I made a follow-up video explaining my thoughts on the time period when the human population declined for a few thousand years: When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html Hope you will find it interesting :-)
Pre-Younger-Dryas sites that correlate with megalithic sites lead many of us to believe those peoples were highly advanced. Their rock construction with Ashlar facings of gigantic rock is curious but there doesn't appear to be any other advanced artifacts from that time...no arches, no bridges, no written languages, no advanced artistry or grand earth projects like regional irrigation or river damming. The tantalizing notion of advanced civilizations from examples of megalithic structures is just that, an enticing curiosity that needs more research. I do not believe there is a hidden cabal with secret knowledge of those long ago places. I do wish we knew how massive stones were cut and moved. My hunch is that it was vibratory sound technology.
The areas that would have suffered most from comet impact on the ice sheets would be coastal and riverine areas where flooding and tsunamis would cause major destruction. It doesn't take a lot of deaths to collapse a civilization, just destruction of its infrastructure. How quickly would modern people lose their technological knowledge if our major cities were suddenly submerged below the sea?
Another great and informative presentation. I find great pleasure and mental stimulation from your presentations, an astute and curious mind. Around the dryas timed data have you considered a Solar Nova as a causal factor. Many, if not all the the discovered global effects could also be attributed to a mini or full Nova and other events that may surround this phenomenon. As in tectites, conflagrations, possible polar shifts and the like. Human migration would be a necessity after such an event for survivors and the reestablishment of society. The 11 to 12 thousand year cyclical time stamp also rings bells for me. Thank you for your perspective.
I watched a science program (probably Nova on PBS) that said polar shifting occurs on average every 12,000 years or so and that they can be tracked deep underwater using some type of magnetics (magnetic poles shift with the polar shift). I am horrible at science, but this is a theory worth covering. I also wonder if a space rock that hits one the poles couldn't have slightly knocked the planet off of its usual rotation arouond the sun. I wonder how even knocking Earth a 1/2 a degree off could influence the seasons and weather - and polar shifts.
Hi another great video.I found the population comparison very interesting as Im unaware of any event that matches with a population decline 15000 years ago. I would like to add that there were 3 cataclysmic events starting with the Bolling Alerod temperature spike around 14000 BCE then the temperature drop around 12800 BCE and lastly the second temperature spike around 11600, this would have a devestating effect on any civilization during this period. I'm looking forward to your future ideas and videos.Cheers
Thank you for your comment, Andrew. It is interesting to see the population bottleneck happened around 20,000 to 15,000 years ago. I haven't found a catastrophic event that might be related to this time period. The Last Glacial Maximum ended at 19-20,000 years ago ans was followed by the melting of the glaciers and the rising of sea level. This deglaciation took thousands of years which means humans should have had time to relocate to higher grounds. I agree that the temperature spikes you mentioned (the Bolling Alerod and the one around 11,600 BC) were more extreme with more abrupt sea level rises and would have caused severe damage to civilizations. A lot to be studied... thanks again for the support.
the vocal accent on your english language is wonderfull one question from me; is 'stoneage' during the building of megalythic stone structure? seems to me that after stone construction should be called 'post-stone' age
A thing most people overlook, the Giraffe is the tallest Modern Land Animal. It can't be taller because of the size of it's Heart pumping the blood. So the Gravity of Earth had to have been different for the massive Land Dinosaurs.
Completely agree, Tina. Advanced peoples lived in defined locations around the world with lesser peoples in the wild lands not unlike today with sophisticated city dwellers separated from the rude country folk. The advanced ones may not have been exactly the same species either. It could be, as is sometimes said, “complicated”
Watched this excellent video again. Listened more closely, had to rewind a few spots, etc. Read part of the referenced article from Nature. Assuming the comet caused a great flood and nuclear winter which wiped out most of humanity seemed correct until now. This video is ahead of it's time. Keep up the good work.
Fantastic work very very good work ... I'd love you to work with our team and reserch with is one day maybe do a video ... you know all of them well ziggy and shermie you have met our excellent at what you do it's an honour to watch your work Phil aav
@@CuriousBeingbyTina the honour is ours keep up the good work... you know where we are ... of you come to Twitter you can reserch with is anytime il add you to my team 😊
IOt was not a 'cosmic impact,' that caused the sudden decline of the megalithic sites and people. You must also account for the physical destructives effects of such an impact. The impact, generated global earthquakes, and shattered the crust deep beneath the surface. This caused water to be expelled from beneath the Earth's surface, as well as causing periods of steady rain. It's the "Great Flood!" Huge cataclysmic waves, washed over large portions of the Earth. There is evidence of this, as there is evidence of the longer term effects, like climate change and an ice age, that you speak of. The Younger-Dryas event, did cause changes in climate, but the impact also caused huge amounts of damage, death and destruction, on a global scale.
Just want to add the following meteors of the Younger Dryas impacts: Willamette Meteor (aka Tomonous), Cape York Meteor (all 3 chunks) and Corossol Meteor.
Your thesis is thought provoking as was your thesis on the Osiris Shaft.and worthy of a Like and Subscription to your channel & work Tina. I look forward to hear your thoughts regarding vitrification of the stone structures & statues of antiquity.
Very interesting and goodbye to the Comet Disaster theory of people being wiped out en masse. Well Done! :-) Thinking about it, the polygonal walls were global so the knowledge of how to build them was 'common knowledge'. It is possible that the social structures that enabled such commonality were destroyed by the Comet's effects. I think that you are right about multiple civilisations and I think their interconnections were rather damaged by a multitude of impacts. Perhaps the wall builder's travelled across the seas building for the 'Rich' and then moving on. As for the absence of megalithic sites in Northern America, well it was largely under ice at the time and hence no building. Also no evidence of impact because the ice absorbed the energy released. Antonio Zamora has identified such an incident however by deduction based on the geomorphology of The Carolina Bays. I am thinking that there was a massive interruption to the flow of knowledge rather than extinction of various peoples.
I have seen maps similar to the one you show at 1:50 that show multiple strikes from the asteroid/comet impacting the Ice sheets and Northern Ocean regions as well as a few erratics that struck other portions of the globe. Such multiple impacts and air bursts would have unleashed massive flooding and tsunamis. And since 95% or so of humans tend to live along the coast or river valleys, these floods would not have left much that had not been washed away. The raising sea levels would have subsequently swallowed up what ever was left and after a few thousand years under the sea, only glass, gold and stone would not deteriorate. But if you want to look, try 300-500 feet below the ocean
¡Gracias! Hice un video de seguimiento sobre el cuello de botella de la población que ocurrió hace entre 20,000 y 15,000 años: cuando los humanos enfrentaron la extinción: ¿el final de una civilización avanzada anterior? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html Y un video sobre el Gran Diluvio: th-cam.com/video/3auX61KzZIc/w-d-xo.html También uno relacionado con Gobekli Tepe: th-cam.com/video/aYoWFMJ17Ds/w-d-xo.html Espero que los encuentre interesantes.
You are the most convincing advocate for this compelling idea. Not least because scepticism and a certain admiring coolness about early modern (western) "scientific truth" ideology informs your thinking. In my humble opinion.
Thankyou Tina for your very good 👍 work. It gave me more insight in the cataclysm and the bottleneck. The stone work look alike but yet not so it must have a common source , at least the toolmarks often look the same. (So i heard that the king of atlantis had 10 children who might devaided the world 🌎 and each may have done their own style on the stone work with the same technology.?) water springs 💧 seems to be importent to them all ? Was some egyptian statues and buildings and the glassdesert burnt 🥵 by this comet ☄️ ?
Thank you for the continuous support! :-) I really appreciate it. I did read that some Egyptian statues show extreme heat damages. Maybe the heat burn were caused by this fragmented comet...
From others who study space weather and the electromagnetic environment of the earth they propose that the 13,000 year event has phased subharmonic echos including one at 6,500 years ago as well as lesser ones including at 3,200 years ago
Great video!! I've been catching up on all the videos you've posted on this Channel. You have GREAT content/presentations!! My only other comment is showing pics of ancient Native Americans on horseback, I believe there were no horses in the Americas since the YD Impact and were only recently reintroduced by the Spanish in the 1500's.
Thank you very much for the support, David. I truly appreciate it! You are right - I realized that the illustrations of Native Americans on horses was an oversight since horses were reintroduced to the Americas during the Middle ages.
Transportation of goods is a very important part of any advanced civilization. Even today if shipping were to breakdown our civilization would breakdown as a result fuel electricity and food are carried far and wide the breakdown of shipping would devastate the entire world
I was recently watching a series from a YT channel called OzGeographics on the impact of the Burckle object (comet, asteroid, whatever). The main chunk (of what's thought to be 3) landed in the southern Indian Ocean, roughly between Madagascar and Australia. What's particularly interesting is the date given: 5000 BC. Evidence suggests that the tsunami caused by this ocean impact reshaped shorelines as far away as South America. It likely affected well-known population centers of the era, like Egypt and Mesopotamia, with shores surrounding the Indian Ocean getting scoured by a wave estimated to reach about 500' high. A period of essentially worldwide torrential rain followed the impact. This seems likely to be a cause for worldwide flood myths, in that c. 3000 BC is recent enough for a lot of different peoples to remember such an event. Also reported on this same site is recently begun research relating to an impact and tsunami in the Mediterranean, near Greece, which could potentially play a role in the Atlantis myth.
Dear Tina, I like your analytic sharpness. You have an important point made here. The previous civilizations did in fact not die out because of the Younger Dryas impact. Ancient peoples made the same mistake however, as they had built their centers at the sea shore as we do today. Underwater archaeology will give you answers to your questions. best Dieter
Tina check out the Vela supernova happening same time as younger-dryas. the Carolina Bays and the Andes uprising and Indian land submerged. Also the planet wide tsunamis created could have easily wiped out civilizations. Hard to believe population stats in light of the geographical devastation. And the tsunamis would have left the land wet for thousands of years. Cereals were hybridized on the side of mountains could it be the land was too wet to farm so farms had to be up the mountains.
Anther great video done! I have been wondering if fossile remains of the human of a lost civilization were found like those of dinosaurs or cave men, we would have direct evidenc. But direct answer is no fun. Watching your video teachs me a lot of new knowlege about the earth. Thank you :-)
Interesting problems to navigate. Animals couldn't change their routine, but people could. That could explain the mega fauna extinction. And maybe our genetic pool didn't go down significantly because we performed some instant adaptation and kept track of our relatives while we were huddled together under shelter. I would still expect a significant drop in food stores. That would really teach a species agriculture, and maybe that is what inspired our change from hunter/gatherers.
Wherever these civilisations were in the ice age and younger dryas for sure they would have been centered near the coastline, a coastline in places now upto 500ft underwater( Pacific Northwest ). That sort of sea rise would certainly contribute to their destruction. We need to search the continental shelves for signs of them.
Very well put together and backed up with documentation. Great job! There had to be advanced civilazations in the past. If fact I think there were many over many millions of years. Egyptians in loin clothes did not build the pyramids as mainstream archeologists would have us believe.
Thank you Mike! I appreciate your comment and I agree that there could be more advanced civilizations in the past. I also agree with your that the ancient Egyptians didn't build the great pyramids. I made a few videos on the underground shafts and pyramids on the Giza Plateau, hope you can check them out! Here is one: The Osiris Shaft: Part of a Prehistory Mine from a Lost Civilization? th-cam.com/video/JuGt7JEWT6E/w-d-xo.html
Good logical analysis. What about sea level increases due to ice cap melting. Many of your pictures show humans in or at the waters edge. These areas would surely be effected? Also, I’m sure the earths weather system we see today would be different back then.
Thank you. Yes, since the ancient times, many cities were established by the water/ coastlines. The ice cap melting definitely would have made an impact on these coastal cities, though based on the sea level studies, the ice melting induced sea level rise was incremental like less than a feet a year. The comet impact could have led to tsunamis in some regions which could be more detrimental to people who lived that.
It seems likely that the Younger Dryas was caused by an asteroid or comet impact, even a series of them. One mystery here in the Philippines is the presence of tektites which are part of the Australasian strewn field. Studied by anthropologist Otley Beyer, their origin or impact site is unknown, thus there is no exact date associated with them, as they are not found in a sratigraphic layer, but are above ground, suggesting a pleistocene event. There are impact sites associated with them, the most recent if which is the one in Cambodia, said to be an impact crater, but now a lake called Tonle Sap.
Glad I watched this again. I think whenever we look at human population data going back to the younger dryas time frame and beyond the evidence presented needs a disclaimer that the finding for said models are base on evidence only found at the current sea level and above (ACSLA) if you will. The population dynamics map segment demonstrates that humans primary settlement choice by far was along the coast lines as I am sure it has been ever since the first groups of early homo's discovered them. I am just pointing out that it is impossible for us to actually know what the exact populations or the extent of our accomplishments really were. We know all the most densely populated and prime real estate that we once inhabited, built cities on, raised our families, lived and died on, etc. is now 400 plus feet under water and washed away by time. It would be illogical to think that our true beginnings didn't start somewhere down in those once abundant lands where the land met the sea many many thousands of years before recorded history. Some of our most ancient civilizations claim they came from lands swallowed by the sea and geology proves that to be true. I also believe the evidence for several if not more advanced civilizations that once lived around the globe is glaringly obvious. The evidence left to us is as overwhelming as it is impossible to explain and to the ones simply pointing to the earliest know peoples there and "saying they did it", your arguments or evidence is weak at best and in most cases make zero sense when scrutinized with logic. Thank you for your valuable contribution in this field Tina you have a knack for presenting a very well thought out analysis based on your advanced knowledge and logic to explain the subjects you cover.
Thank you for sharing your insight with me. I really appreciate it. I agree that sea level change has reformed the human habitation regions and I discussed this change in a few earlier videos (such as this one: Ancient Chinese Quarry: Proof of Prehistory Advanced Technology?! th-cam.com/video/FCPhQWjCtus/w-d-xo.html ) There could be many submerged cities to be discovered. Thank you again for the support!
Comet and all space bodies are sphere holding a negative electrostatic charge of various degrees among each body. (Just like in a heated house in winter our body pick up electrostatic in space in house after moving from living room to the bedroom). As comet distance getting closer and closer that trigger a discharge between earth and comet which equalizes the two where repulsion began have avoided the collisions. However prior to electric charge difference equalization there was a mass material delivery delivering gas vapor fluid solid living organisms mammals and anything that was loose on the surface, from one body to the next. So the great flood is not the only event took place at the time that included mud fall. Debris burying Gobekli Tape and mist other parts on earth.
This is a very interesting study. Based on my research into the megalithic structures so far I do not believe we are dealing with multiple megalithic builder civilizations. There are several overt and subtle key points of compatibility between structures throughout the Mediterranean region, Iran and Peru and as far from them as Sri Lanka. Indicating at least some level of contact. Not the least of which are the mysterious "knobs" protruding from stone blocks and from bedrock. To the casual observer they appear different but the key is in the subtleties. Some would say similarities would merely indicate transmission of knowledge over time but we have zero evidence of this and the majority of the structures I have looked over so far share signature subtleties that indicate close contact. Particularly when they appear thousands of kilometers away from the Mediterranean region, down in Peru. I talked to someone who works with the A.R.E. in Virginia Beach and he believes the Megalithic structures came after the destruction of the comet impact, after descendents of the survivors were able to develop more advanced technologies thousands of years later and that the cultural similarities seen between Mediterranean, Central and South American regions in the more relatively recent past are transmissions from those survivors.
Interesting, thank you for sharing your insight. I appreciate it. I am very curious about the technique these ancient people utilized to built these amazing sites. Could be something very different from ours.
![[UNCUT] “บอสณวัฒน์” ลากไส้!! ใครหนุนหลัง "แม่ตั๊ก ป๋าเบียร์" I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 30 ก.ย. 67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QlD7mU2KKRk/mqdefault.jpg)
i doubt many humans would survive a comet impact nowadays after seeing panic buying of toilet rolls were far too removed from nature nowadays
The Younger-Dryas was not a single event, but rather 2 separate events of extraterrestrial impacts that happened approx 1,500 years apart at the end of the last ice age. Randall Carlson covers this in great depth and detail.
Reference please.
@@willymakeit5172 - Actually everything I said can be easily searched and located.
The only thing I could possibly do for you would be to post direct links, which FascistTube adamantly refuses to allow.
@@dreamingmusic3299 I wonder if Tina would also be willing to upload these to Odysee or allow someone else to.
@@dreamingmusic3299Links to Randall Carlson I'm sure.
I can debunk Carlson with 1 Google Search for you. Pangborn Bar Clovis site. What is it? It's a Clovis tool site that sits on top of a Scablands Mega-flood Bar near Wenatchee.
The ONLY way this is possible is if the floods were pre-Covis occupation just as all dating work in the Scablands tells us.
Tina, thank you very much for your excellent presentation! I'm convinced your explanation of what happened in our not so distant past is very accurate. Keep up the spectacular work as it's so refreshing and much appreciated!
Glad it was helpful! Thank you for the compliment. I appreciate you.
Lady Tina ,your research is impeccable and the depth of work demands serious respect. Your total body of work will provoke a strong response and force the truth to come forth!I'm working my way thru you series and I'm dieing to see your conclusions when you present them on who these ancient civilizations are.Most conclusions in this area inevitable lead to something not of this planet, so you intense pursuit of this truth is greatly appreciated! The truth will set you free!
Thank you Fred! I'm really grateful for your support! I'm still searching...there are so many mysteries. Hope one day we will get to the truth together 🙂
So glad I was recommended your video on the osiris shaft today. I went on a marathon. I'm so glad you point out the tooling marks and how they are similar to sites around the world. I've left comments on channels wishing people would notice how important it is.
You deliver! One thing you might consider is that all of these population charts depend on one thing. Land based finds. Nobody has ever really bothered looking offshore. As most modern day Human populations are coastally based, we can assume the same for the past. Sea levels are now 400 or so feet higher, currently obscuring any remains. That said, I am uncertain if that was taken into consideration when these charts were created. It might well have been.
Thank you for your insight. You brought up an interesting point. From the papers I read, some of the population studies are based on the radiocarbon record of sites on land; some used whole genome sequence data from individuals to study the genomic evidence; and some researched the changes in genetic variation, DNA mutation rate, etc. to reconstruct effective population sizes. Granted that the ancient DNA evidence is all collected on land, they might present only a portion of the true ancient population. Were the people who lived on the now-submerged coastal cities genetically different from the ones whose DNA we have? I don't know but it'll be exciting to find out.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Always my pleasure Tina! Don't judge a name by it's nomenclature! xxx
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Tina, just saying... And I don''t have a public TH-cam channel, but how about jazzing up the background a bit? A few warm colors, maybe a book or two... that kind of thing...
@@ancientbuilds3764 Maybe I will consider that... :-)
yes! it seems that some highly advanced populations lived in coastal areas. there is one underwater in India that I'd like to know more about.
Its amazing how much knowledge you have. I am also very impressed how you back-up all your thoughts/ideas with charts and evidence or published articles. Keep doing what you are doing, you are very good at it. Thank you!
I appreciate that! Thank you for your support :-)
It's funny I only just found this video, after leaving a rant on the Younger Dryas in a previous video comment. I believe you are on the right course with your theories.🐌
Thanks Jack! I made a followup video on this subject discussing the period of the severe population bottleneck. Would like to hear your feedback on it :-)
When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Great to see more people are seriously studying the possibility that humans were highly advanced prior to Younger Dryas. I first stumbled across Graham Hancock's TED talk "Is the house of history built on foundations of sand?" which has the disclaimer: "NOTE from TED: Please be aware that this talk contains outdated and counterfactual assertions, and should not be understood as a representation of modern scholarship on ancient civilizations." I believe, like many others, that grant money and careers will be lost if their collective reconstruction of human history is wrong. These academic scholars are desperate to discount any challenge to their theories.
The truth will eventually overcome these roadblocks and become scientifically accepted. Thank you for your work on these presentations. Our understanding of human history today is about to be flipped on it's head!
Thank you Bob. I watched that Graham Hancock's TED talk as well and it was an eye opener. I agree that most if not all mainstream scholars are avoiding to discuss the possibility of one or more highly-advanced civilizations existed in ancient time. Thank you for your support and I appreciate it.
Thanks Tina. Prof. Barry Cunliffe is worth getting to know, as is his book on the migrations across Eurasia: By Steppe, Desert and Ocean. The map at the 39:30 min mark shows how there was a corridor stretching from China to central Europe and back across which people even during the Ice Age I presume could travel and wander. There is another variable I'd like you to consider when thinking about the aftermath of one of periodic Comet strikes (and I think the flood mentioned in the Timaeus, ca 9600, a Meltwater Pulse, came back in 6200, Doggerland gets flooded and Meltwater Pulse II, then again in 2800, the rise of Sumer and again in 536 AD, the Ravenna Comet Mosaic [see Ruth Dwyer's youtube video on this] which I believe were set on a 3400 year elliptical path after the first strike which led to the 1200 year cooling. The comet didn't just evaporate entirely even after impact. That variable is whether the declination of the earth changes, as the Egyptians told us per Timaeus (the story of Phaethon). Thus, not only did the North Pole move but there could have been a new axis of rotation. Giza, Cuzco, Rapa Nui and Angkor Wat, among other notable sites, are all on a great circle. I think that great circle was once the equator, which is how you could have easily found Rapa Nui. (Pretty hard otherwise, and why bother?) I think the declination changed by roughly 30 degrees. I think the story of Demeter (Ceres in Rome, as in Cereal) looking for her daughter Persephone who was kidnapped by Hades and taken to the Underworld is the story of the first appearance of winter and seasons. Persephone got to come back up to be with her grain growing mother but had to return down under for a season each year. Think about it and thanks again. Always a pleasure. HH [Barry Cunliffe -- th-cam.com/video/oOj_MV6o0Vk/w-d-xo.html]
This production with 10+k subs is so much better than some of the channels I watch with millions. Great work! Officially subbed. 😀
Thank you very much for the support :-) Welcome!
I have had the opportunity to be close to a great Sage for years and many times he has spoken of a previous society with technology that is beyond ours. Your are doing an amazing job in bringing this information to the people. Please continue.
Thank you Jaime! So glad to hear that ♥ really appreciate it!
Where are the artifacts of the lost civilizations. Yes there are megalithic structures but where are the traces of machines/tools that built them. No archeologists have found any evidence of advanced technology.
@@brucesoehngen852 , I ponder on this question and wonder if we suddenly abandoned machinery/tools in a quarry or construction site due to a cataclysmic event, would there be anything left of them after 13,000 or more years?
There should be quite a bit left of how it was done. Unless they took all the equipment back in their flying saucers 😀
Hi Tina! I have watched many channels talking about this fascinating topic but the vast majority of them leave us with even more doubts. I don't know why it took me so long to find your channel here and your explanations are so simple and important, didactic too, in fact super didactic. A real pearl in this sea of disagreements that is the net. Thank you very much and congratulations.
So glad to hear that you find my video helpful! Thank you very much for the support :-) Btw I made a follow-up video discussing what might have happened during the human population bottleneck over 15,000 years ago. Hope you will enjoy it too. Here is the link: When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Great video...quality information! Thank you 😊
Thank you!
Hi Tina, I just found your channel, WOW!!! Your scientific approach is a breath of fresh air, your analysis is poignant, and well researched. Keep doing what you do!
Welcome aboard! Thank you for the support :-)
Great work and wonderful information here. Keep digging, no pun intended.
Thank you!
Thank you for another excellent video, Tina. Your range of skills, from technological mastery and eloquent communication skills to critical analyis and reflection are exceptional. How did you get here? 🙂
Thank you Toni! You are too kind. I'm just curious and would like to do research on things... other than that, I think my architectural background definitely helps me better formulate my ideas :-)
Great work please keep it up you are changing the world
Thank you Nicco!
i really like your documentary. i also want to mentioned the care you take to answer the comments that peoples give to you ..this is well appreciated and show that you respect us .so have a good day and thank Tina .thanks really.
Thank you Denis. I appreciate your support. Have a nice day :-)
Your videos are interesting, your English is impeccable, and your beauty is flawless!❤️
@@CuriousBeingbyTina you are welcome sweetheart. 👍
Great to see all the views. Awesome channel and well researched and theorized. Megalithic dudes around the world appreciate.
Thank you for the support! I appreciate it :-)
I feel I've signed for an advanced university course. Thanks a bunch! Very intriguing stuff
Glad that you enjoyed my videos! Welcome aboard :-)
@@CuriousBeingbyTina You are so knowledgeable I had no idea of these caves in China. Gobekli Tepe was the first mindblowing site I was aware of. Now, it seems primitive! Looking forward to your next reveals
Thanks for such an informative and engaging presentation👍！The resilience of our ancestors was truly impressive to me. What a thought-provoking video to watch during the pandemic！
Glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for your support!
lidar showed unknown civilizations in the Amazon and Guatemala shows 60x times bigger .So populations were never calculated correctly to begin with
never trust an archeologist
I wonder if there is a technology similar to LiDAR that can digitally removed sand/soil and water... we probably will find ancient ruins beneath the now-unpopulated landscapes.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina GPR has been widely used and works pretty well . Sarah Parcek is leading space archeologist and started a crowd search .. I think
Oil ,mining , and military have huge jump on the rest of us , having developed all these methods for us. I heard there a city under Gobi sands
@@CuriousBeingbyTina they do this other thing with a network of probes and electricity .. even deep blast surveys that read like sonograms. With all the new 3d modeling ... secrets will be revealed
@@shermanatorosborn9688 How exciting! Thanks for the information. I think there must have many ancient ruins submerged under the ocean and/or buried in sand. Can't wait to see these new discoveries
Your level of research is by far the best out there. It is away a pleasure to see your latest post.
Thank you very much Derek! I always appreciate your support :-)
The past is more complicated than we’re taught. Cosmic impacts definitely appear to be implicated however, I’ve personally seen evidence of granite surface vitrification on human worked stone. A temperature in excess of 2200 Celsius is required to accomplish this. Maybe the reason we don’t find the remains of the builders aside from those already dead and buried prior is because they were vaporised
Sodom and Gomorra got the full force of the device that left those marks.
Lot's wife turned around and was vaporised, with them.
@@markvianen2282 Interesting that you caught the incorrect translation in the Bible. The word for "salt" was used when it should have read "vapor" or "smoke"
@@megret1808 Interesting that you know that the wrong translation was used, who do you work for?
@@markvianen2282 just an interested armature
well done Tina, thank for the intelligent sharing, really evry educational indeed
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it :-)
I just found You! Very well done video. Your presentation is very concise and makes a person think.
Please do more about the younger dryas impact theories, I am fascinated by Your video presence.
Welcome and thank you for the support, Tanya! Hope you will enjoy my other videos too :-) I made a followup video on the human population bottle happened before Younger Dryas - 20,000-15,000 Years Ago When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Hope you will find it interesting.
Tina, as usual you have done very nice work here. You are following where the data leads. While there were several areas around the globe where advanced civilizations existed (the gods had divided up the world among themselves) before the younger dryas and its triggering event (a comet impact-see the Carolina Bays), the most famous of these was the kingdom of Atlantis (Aztlan) and its beautiful main island. Traders and statesmen from around the globe travelled to this amazing place to obtain precious materials and knowledge. All that remains is for you or Graham Hancock to find it. You might begin by looking where the ancient Egyptians and Aztecs said it was located.
For anyone that wishes to look further into the younger dryas event have a look into professor Randall Carlson and graham Hancock.
Thanks again Tina!
Lol forget Hancock. For him any possibility is a certainty. Hes as scientific as a witch doctor.
@@bennichols561 uh huh… and your background is?
I find graham to be quite intelligent and willing to question the obvious bullshit mainstream narrative on history.
@@mikeprandota3120 good for you.
Quite interesting read in German online portal Scinexx today: Researchers from Brown university discovered and examined strange dark rocks that cover a vast area in the Atacama desert, spread across 75km. They concluded that they are condensed matter from enormous low-altitude airbursts of large comet fragments. The analysis of microscopic zirkon and other crystals and the isotope ratios led to an initial age estimation of around 12.000 years plus/minus 500 yrs. Pretty close or spot on to the Younger Dryas Event at the same time windown. Seems like there must have been a global rain of large comet fragments all over the world that certainly totally ruined the day for the people at that time.
That's very interesting indeed. Thank you for sharing with me! I agree with you - there appears to have been a global comet fragments rain during YD. It must have been a disastrous time for the people and societies.
Love all your videos. Keep up the great work
Thank you! I appreciate the support :-)
Another superb video Tina I do believe there was a cataclysmic event that wiped out or at least contributed to wiping out an advanced civilisation that existed before our own. Not neccesarily more advanced than us but advanced in a different way (perhaps a way more suited to a harmonious planet though!). Loving your work thanks again for the fantastic information!!
Thank you Jimmy! Yes this civilization could have had very different technologies. I appreciate your support!
It's happened more than once, we been here since the start
New subscriber here :) Great video, but one distinction I see. There is a difference between surviving a glacial maximum and surviving a rapid cooling event. The glacial maximum (supposedly) came on slowly over the course of thousands of years. Glaciers retreating less in the summer than they grow in the winter. People can slowly migrate south over many generations. A rapid cooling event like what would occur from a comet filling the sky with debris (blocking out the sun) would be devastating. No sun = no plants = no animals. When that happens the only food you are going to have for several years is what you already have stored and preserved. Probably would not have been much for Clovis type hunter gatherers. I like the way you think outside the box. Keep up the great work!
Thank you Michael! I has similar thoughts with you regarding the comet impact. However I changed my mind after finding some data points. The YD comet was much smaller than the one that ended the Dinosaurs' time (therefore less negative affect on lives on earth) and there appears to be no obvious human population decline during or after the rapid cooling event. I made a follow-up video explaining my thoughts on the time period when the human population declined for a few thousand years: When Humans Faced Extinction - the Ending of a Previous Advanced Civilization? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Hope you will find it interesting :-)
Pre-Younger-Dryas sites that correlate with megalithic sites lead many of us to believe those peoples were highly advanced. Their rock construction with Ashlar facings of gigantic rock is curious but there doesn't appear to be any other advanced artifacts from that time...no arches, no bridges, no written languages, no advanced artistry or grand earth projects like regional irrigation or river damming. The tantalizing notion of advanced civilizations from examples of megalithic structures is just that, an enticing curiosity that needs more research. I do not believe there is a hidden cabal with secret knowledge of those long ago places.
I do wish we knew how massive stones were cut and moved. My hunch is that it was vibratory sound technology.
Thank you for your insight, William. I appreciate it.
I love your shows! Thanks SOO MUCH for ALL you do! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Glad you like them! Thank you for the support! ❤
The areas that would have suffered most from comet impact on the ice sheets would be coastal and riverine areas where flooding and tsunamis would cause major destruction. It doesn't take a lot of deaths to collapse a civilization, just destruction of its infrastructure. How quickly would modern people lose their technological knowledge if our major cities were suddenly submerged below the sea?
This is by far the best video on this topic I have seen.. Thank you for your deep research and clear presentation.. Very exciting!
So glad to hear that - thank you for the support!
Reminds me of the Olmecs in Graham Hancocks work. Awesome.
Thanks!
This is the most informative and most engaging presentation about the Younger Dryas that I have found. Thanks!
Wow, thank you! Glad to hear that. Hope you will like my other videos too :-)
Another great and informative presentation. I find great pleasure and mental stimulation from your presentations, an astute and curious mind. Around the dryas timed data have you considered a Solar Nova as a causal factor. Many, if not all the the discovered global effects could also be attributed to a mini or full Nova and other events that may surround this phenomenon. As in tectites, conflagrations, possible polar shifts and the like. Human migration would be a necessity after such an event for survivors and the reestablishment of society. The 11 to 12 thousand year cyclical time stamp also rings bells for me. Thank you for your perspective.
Thank you for the support. I appreciate you sharing your insight, Gary. I need to look into the solar nova - that could be a connection. Thank you!
I watched a science program (probably Nova on PBS) that said polar shifting occurs on average every 12,000 years or so and that they can be tracked deep underwater using some type of magnetics (magnetic poles shift with the polar shift). I am horrible at science, but this is a theory worth covering. I also wonder if a space rock that hits one the poles couldn't have slightly knocked the planet off of its usual rotation arouond the sun. I wonder how even knocking Earth a 1/2 a degree off could influence the seasons and weather - and polar shifts.
I absolutely love this channel and host.
Thank you! It's my personal channel :-)
Hi another great video.I found the population comparison very interesting as Im unaware of any event that matches with a population decline 15000 years ago. I would like to add that there were 3 cataclysmic events starting with the Bolling Alerod temperature spike around 14000 BCE then the temperature drop around 12800 BCE and lastly the second temperature spike around 11600, this would have a devestating effect on any civilization during this period. I'm looking forward to your future ideas and videos.Cheers
Thank you for your comment, Andrew. It is interesting to see the population bottleneck happened around 20,000 to 15,000 years ago. I haven't found a catastrophic event that might be related to this time period. The Last Glacial Maximum ended at 19-20,000 years ago ans was followed by the melting of the glaciers and the rising of sea level. This deglaciation took thousands of years which means humans should have had time to relocate to higher grounds. I agree that the temperature spikes you mentioned (the Bolling Alerod and the one around 11,600 BC) were more extreme with more abrupt sea level rises and would have caused severe damage to civilizations. A lot to be studied... thanks again for the support.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina thanks. It's a facinating subject to think about.
the vocal accent on your english language is wonderfull
one question from me; is 'stoneage' during the building of megalythic stone structure?
seems to me that after stone construction should be called 'post-stone' age
Thank you! The current term of Stone Age seems be not related to the megalithic sites but more to the usage of stone tools.
A thing most people overlook, the Giraffe is the tallest Modern Land Animal. It can't be taller because of the size of it's Heart pumping the blood. So the Gravity of Earth had to have been different for the massive Land Dinosaurs.
Awesome video!
Thank you!
Beautiful, excellent have no words, Thank You for your work.
Thank you for the support! I really appreciate it :-)
Very informative.thank you .great presentation 😊
Thank you for the support! 😊
Excellent presentation, great content
Much appreciated!
Brilliant video Tina ❤️🇬🇧
Glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for the support :-)
Thank you Tina for your video! Informative and logically presented as usual. Just wondering if your undergrad studies are in science or enginnering
Thanks Edwin! I majored in architecture for my undergrad.
@@CuriousBeingbyTina , wow.. no wonder the level of research demonstrated in your video is so systematic and scientific!
@@yiwenedwinang5696 Thanks Edwin. You are too kind.
Completely agree, Tina. Advanced peoples lived in defined locations around the world with lesser peoples in the wild lands not unlike today with sophisticated city dwellers separated from the rude country folk. The advanced ones may not have been exactly the same species either. It could be, as is sometimes said, “complicated”
Just found your channel! I am in love!!!
Welcome!! Hope you can check out my other videos too!
So glad to bump into your channel, thanks for the information and excellent presentation
I'm trying to catch up your good work, keep safe...
Thank you Carlos! Welcome :-)
I appreciate your thought provoking presentations. They are sensible and more importantly don't promote 'ancient aliens' nonsense.
Thank you for the support, Frank. I want my studies to fact-based and objective :-)
Watched this excellent video again. Listened more closely, had to rewind a few spots, etc. Read part of the referenced article from Nature. Assuming the comet caused a great flood and nuclear winter which wiped out most of humanity seemed correct until now. This video is ahead of it's time. Keep up the good work.
Thank you very much for the support, Jerry. I really appreciate it!
Thank you very important information and you present it so clearly. !
Glad it was helpful! Hope you will like my other videos too :-)
I like your open mind thinking. Nobody really knows. But thinking is important
Thank you!
Fantastic work very very good work ... I'd love you to work with our team and reserch with is one day maybe do a video ... you know all of them well ziggy and shermie you have met our excellent at what you do it's an honour to watch your work Phil aav
Thank you for all your support! :-) Glad to find fellow independent researchers ♥
@@CuriousBeingbyTina the honour is ours keep up the good work... you know where we are ... of you come to Twitter you can reserch with is anytime il add you to my team 😊
@@ancientalternativeview9011 Thank you! I might join Twitter someday and reach out to you 😊
@@CuriousBeingbyTina would be an honour you already know the 10 or so in my team so feel free anytime all the very best 😉😊
IOt was not a 'cosmic impact,' that caused the sudden decline of the megalithic sites and people.
You must also account for the physical destructives effects of such an impact.
The impact, generated global earthquakes, and shattered the crust deep beneath the surface.
This caused water to be expelled from beneath the Earth's surface, as well as causing periods of steady rain.
It's the "Great Flood!"
Huge cataclysmic waves, washed over large portions of the Earth. There is evidence of this, as there is evidence of the longer term effects, like climate change and an ice age, that you speak of.
The Younger-Dryas event, did cause changes in climate, but the impact also caused huge amounts of damage, death and destruction, on a global scale.
Great vid! Thanks!
Glad you liked it! Hope you will check out my other videos too.
Your a smart lady and a curious being. Lots of class
Thank you for the support :-)
Just want to add the following meteors of the Younger Dryas impacts: Willamette Meteor (aka Tomonous), Cape York Meteor (all 3 chunks) and Corossol Meteor.
Thank you for sharing your insight with me! Much appreciated :-)
Your thesis is thought provoking as was your thesis on the Osiris Shaft.and worthy of a Like and Subscription to your channel & work Tina.
I look forward to hear your thoughts regarding vitrification of the stone structures & statues of antiquity.
Very interesting and goodbye to the Comet Disaster theory of people being wiped out en masse. Well Done! :-) Thinking about it, the polygonal walls were global so the knowledge of how to build them was 'common knowledge'. It is possible that the social structures that enabled such commonality were destroyed by the Comet's effects. I think that you are right about multiple civilisations and I think their interconnections were rather damaged by a multitude of impacts. Perhaps the wall builder's travelled across the seas building for the 'Rich' and then moving on. As for the absence of megalithic sites in Northern America, well it was largely under ice at the time and hence no building. Also no evidence of impact because the ice absorbed the energy released. Antonio Zamora has identified such an incident however by deduction based on the geomorphology of The Carolina Bays. I am thinking that there was a massive interruption to the flow of knowledge rather than extinction of various peoples.
I have seen maps similar to the one you show at 1:50 that show multiple strikes from the asteroid/comet impacting the Ice sheets and Northern Ocean regions as well as a few erratics that struck other portions of the globe. Such multiple impacts and air bursts would have unleashed massive flooding and tsunamis. And since 95% or so of humans tend to live along the coast or river valleys, these floods would not have left much that had not been washed away. The raising sea levels would have subsequently swallowed up what ever was left and after a few thousand years under the sea, only glass, gold and stone would not deteriorate. But if you want to look, try 300-500 feet below the ocean
Thank you Tina
Thank you for watching!
I wonder if the ancients built megastructures for protection from the looming comet.
That's a possibility.
Your gonna hit one million subs in a short time watch
I hope so :-) Thank you for the support!
Thank you
Agreed shermie this is excellent!!
Thanks for the support!
Interesante... Deberías hacer un video como se conecta este evento con gobleki tepes y la historia del diluvio universal...
¡Gracias! Hice un video de seguimiento sobre el cuello de botella de la población que ocurrió hace entre 20,000 y 15,000 años: cuando los humanos enfrentaron la extinción: ¿el final de una civilización avanzada anterior? th-cam.com/video/Zs4zLKbp4Ic/w-d-xo.html
Y un video sobre el Gran Diluvio: th-cam.com/video/3auX61KzZIc/w-d-xo.html
También uno relacionado con Gobekli Tepe: th-cam.com/video/aYoWFMJ17Ds/w-d-xo.html
Espero que los encuentre interesantes.
You are the most convincing advocate for this compelling idea. Not least because scepticism and a certain admiring coolness about early modern (western) "scientific truth" ideology informs your thinking. In my humble opinion.
Thank you very much for the compliment. I appreciate your support.
You have a great narrating voice. Thanks for the video 😬
Thank you kindly! ☺
Thankyou Tina for your very good 👍 work. It gave me more insight in the cataclysm and the bottleneck. The stone work look alike but yet not so it must have a common source , at least the toolmarks often look the same. (So i heard that the king of atlantis had 10 children who might devaided the world 🌎 and each may have done their own style on the stone work with the same technology.?) water springs 💧 seems to be importent to them all ?
Was some egyptian statues and buildings and the glassdesert burnt 🥵 by this comet ☄️ ?
Thank you for the continuous support! :-) I really appreciate it. I did read that some Egyptian statues show extreme heat damages. Maybe the heat burn were caused by this fragmented comet...
Always love your tube
Thank you for supporting my YT channel
well done..very interesting
Thanks Steve!
From others who study space weather and the electromagnetic environment of the earth they propose that the 13,000 year event has phased subharmonic echos including one at 6,500 years ago as well as lesser ones including at 3,200 years ago
thank u for ur teachings
I'm learning as well :-) Thank you for the support!
Great video!! I've been catching up on all the videos you've posted on this Channel. You have GREAT content/presentations!! My only other comment is showing pics of ancient Native Americans on horseback, I believe there were no horses in the Americas since the YD Impact and were only recently reintroduced by the Spanish in the 1500's.
Thank you very much for the support, David. I truly appreciate it! You are right - I realized that the illustrations of Native Americans on horses was an oversight since horses were reintroduced to the Americas during the Middle ages.
Asteroids and Comets are very different from each other. Whomever your translator is fire that person.
I love you videos
Transportation of goods is a very important part of any advanced civilization. Even today if shipping were to breakdown our civilization would breakdown as a result fuel electricity and food are carried far and wide the breakdown of shipping would devastate the entire world
I was recently watching a series from a YT channel called OzGeographics on the impact of the Burckle object (comet, asteroid, whatever). The main chunk (of what's thought to be 3) landed in the southern Indian Ocean, roughly between Madagascar and Australia. What's particularly interesting is the date given: 5000 BC. Evidence suggests that the tsunami caused by this ocean impact reshaped shorelines as far away as South America. It likely affected well-known population centers of the era, like Egypt and Mesopotamia, with shores surrounding the Indian Ocean getting scoured by a wave estimated to reach about 500' high. A period of essentially worldwide torrential rain followed the impact. This seems likely to be a cause for worldwide flood myths, in that c. 3000 BC is recent enough for a lot of different peoples to remember such an event.
Also reported on this same site is recently begun research relating to an impact and tsunami in the Mediterranean, near Greece, which could potentially play a role in the Atlantis myth.
Aren't the Clovis people known to have had a very varied diat?
At 3:38 In Montana USA there are megaliths too.
Dear Tina, I like your analytic sharpness. You have an important point made here. The previous civilizations did in fact not die out because of the Younger Dryas impact. Ancient peoples made the same mistake however, as they had built their centers at the sea shore as we do today. Underwater archaeology will give you answers to your questions. best Dieter
Thank you Dieter. Yes I think there are many underwater sites to be discovered!
Tina check out the Vela supernova happening same time as younger-dryas. the Carolina Bays and the Andes uprising and Indian land submerged. Also the planet wide tsunamis created could have easily wiped out civilizations. Hard to believe population stats in light of the geographical devastation. And the tsunamis would have left the land wet for thousands of years. Cereals were hybridized on the side of mountains could it be the land was too wet to farm so farms had to be up the mountains.
Anther great video done! I have been wondering if fossile remains of the human of a lost civilization were found like those of dinosaurs or cave men, we would have direct evidenc. But direct answer is no fun. Watching your video teachs me a lot of new knowlege about the earth. Thank you :-)
Thank you for the continuous support! I really appreciate it :-)
Interesting problems to navigate. Animals couldn't change their routine, but people could. That could explain the mega fauna extinction. And maybe our genetic pool didn't go down significantly because we performed some instant adaptation and kept track of our relatives while we were huddled together under shelter. I would still expect a significant drop in food stores. That would really teach a species agriculture, and maybe that is what inspired our change from hunter/gatherers.
Wherever these civilisations were in the ice age and younger dryas for sure they would have been centered near the coastline, a coastline in places now upto 500ft underwater( Pacific Northwest ). That sort of sea rise would certainly contribute to their destruction. We need to search the continental shelves for signs of them.
I agree.
Very well put together and backed up with documentation. Great job!
There had to be advanced civilazations in the past. If fact I think there were many over many millions of years. Egyptians in loin clothes did not build the pyramids as mainstream archeologists would have us believe.
Thank you Mike! I appreciate your comment and I agree that there could be more advanced civilizations in the past. I also agree with your that the ancient Egyptians didn't build the great pyramids. I made a few videos on the underground shafts and pyramids on the Giza Plateau, hope you can check them out!
Here is one: The Osiris Shaft: Part of a Prehistory Mine from a Lost Civilization? th-cam.com/video/JuGt7JEWT6E/w-d-xo.html
@@CuriousBeingbyTina I will check it out. You do great work
@@mikejh4353 Thank you!
ЛАЙК!!! Цікаве відео. ДЯКУЮ. УСПІХІВ та ЗДОРОВ`Я.
Сподіваюся, ви також зможете переглянути мої інші відео :-)
@@CuriousBeingbyTina Якщо буде можливість.
Good logical analysis. What about sea level increases due to ice cap melting. Many of your pictures show humans in or at the waters edge. These areas would surely be effected? Also, I’m sure the earths weather system we see today would be different back then.
Thank you. Yes, since the ancient times, many cities were established by the water/ coastlines. The ice cap melting definitely would have made an impact on these coastal cities, though based on the sea level studies, the ice melting induced sea level rise was incremental like less than a feet a year. The comet impact could have led to tsunamis in some regions which could be more detrimental to people who lived that.
Thanks!
Thanks a lot for the support! Much appreciated :-)
It seems likely that the Younger Dryas was caused by an asteroid or comet impact, even a series of them. One mystery here in the Philippines is the presence of tektites which are part of the Australasian strewn field. Studied by anthropologist Otley Beyer, their origin or impact site is unknown, thus there is no exact date associated with them, as they are not found in a sratigraphic layer, but are above ground, suggesting a pleistocene event. There are impact sites associated with them, the most recent if which is the one in Cambodia, said to be an impact crater, but now a lake called Tonle Sap.
Good to see you! :)
Thanks for the support :)
Glad I watched this again. I think whenever we look at human population data going back to the younger dryas time frame and beyond the evidence presented needs a disclaimer that the finding for said models are base on evidence only found at the current sea level and above (ACSLA) if you will. The population dynamics map segment demonstrates that humans primary settlement choice by far was along the coast lines as I am sure it has been ever since the first groups of early homo's discovered them. I am just pointing out that it is impossible for us to actually know what the exact populations or the extent of our accomplishments really were. We know all the most densely populated and prime real estate that we once inhabited, built cities on, raised our families, lived and died on, etc. is now 400 plus feet under water and washed away by time. It would be illogical to think that our true beginnings didn't start somewhere down in those once abundant lands where the land met the sea many many thousands of years before recorded history. Some of our most ancient civilizations claim they came from lands swallowed by the sea and geology proves that to be true. I also believe the evidence for several if not more advanced civilizations that once lived around the globe is glaringly obvious. The evidence left to us is as overwhelming as it is impossible to explain and to the ones simply pointing to the earliest know peoples there and "saying they did it", your arguments or evidence is weak at best and in most cases make zero sense when scrutinized with logic. Thank you for your valuable contribution in this field Tina you have a knack for presenting a very well thought out analysis based on your advanced knowledge and logic to explain the subjects you cover.
Thank you for sharing your insight with me. I really appreciate it. I agree that sea level change has reformed the human habitation regions and I discussed this change in a few earlier videos (such as this one: Ancient Chinese Quarry: Proof of Prehistory Advanced Technology?! th-cam.com/video/FCPhQWjCtus/w-d-xo.html )
There could be many submerged cities to be discovered. Thank you again for the support!
@@CuriousBeingbyTina It's my pleasure Tina thank you..
Comet and all space bodies are sphere holding a negative electrostatic charge of various degrees among each body. (Just like in a heated house in winter our body pick up electrostatic in space in house after moving from living room to the bedroom). As comet distance getting closer and closer that trigger a discharge between earth and comet which equalizes the two where repulsion began have avoided the collisions. However prior to electric charge difference equalization there was a mass material delivery delivering gas vapor fluid solid living organisms mammals and anything that was loose on the surface, from one body to the next. So the great flood is not the only event took place at the time that included mud fall. Debris burying Gobekli Tape and mist other parts on earth.
This is a very interesting study.
Based on my research into the megalithic structures so far I do not believe we are dealing with multiple megalithic builder civilizations. There are several overt and subtle key points of compatibility between structures throughout the Mediterranean region, Iran and Peru and as far from them as Sri Lanka. Indicating at least some level of contact. Not the least of which are the mysterious "knobs" protruding from stone blocks and from bedrock. To the casual observer they appear different but the key is in the subtleties. Some would say similarities would merely indicate transmission of knowledge over time but we have zero evidence of this and the majority of the structures I have looked over so far share signature subtleties that indicate close contact. Particularly when they appear thousands of kilometers away from the Mediterranean region, down in Peru.
I talked to someone who works with the A.R.E. in Virginia Beach and he believes the Megalithic structures came after the destruction of the comet impact, after descendents of the survivors were able to develop more advanced technologies thousands of years later and that the cultural similarities seen between Mediterranean, Central and South American regions in the more relatively recent past are transmissions from those survivors.
Interesting, thank you for sharing your insight. I appreciate it. I am very curious about the technique these ancient people utilized to built these amazing sites. Could be something very different from ours.