Can Israel destroy Hamas? | Inside Story
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ย. 2024
- Israel’s war on Gaza has raged for nearly a year, with losses on both sides.
Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant says Hamas is effectively dismantled as a fighting force.
However, the group has refuted this, saying it has ample resources and new recruits.
After almost a year of war, is Hamas still capable of fighting the Israeli army?
And what does this mean for the dynamics on the ground in Gaza?
Presenter: Imran Khan
Guests:
Azzam Tamimi -- Political activist and author of the book, 'Hamas: Unwritten Chapters'
Mouin Rabbani -- Non-resident Fellow at the Center for Conflict and Humanitarian Studies
Paola Caridi -- Veteran Middle East journalist and author of 'Hamas: From Resistance to Regime'
Subscribe to our channel: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera....
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Israel #WarOnGaza #Hamas #BenjaminNetanyahu #YoavGallant #IsraeliHostages #IsraeliCaptives #FreeTheHostages #BringThemHome #BringThemHomeNow #Palestine #Gaza #GazaWar #IsraelGazaWar #IsraelHamasWar #IsraeliMilitary #IsraeliArmy #AlJazeeraEnglish
Both sides have a dream. One side's dream is based on the annihilation of the other while the other's dream is based on a peaceful rich country coexisting with their neighbors in a live and let live basis. Which of the dreams do you think deserves to come through.
Considering the facts, the undisputed fact that Israel wants to achieve the Greater Israel Project which would see all of Palestine, Jordan, a big part of Iraq, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, and Lebanon, annexed by the Israel Occupation.... I would say the Palestinians are right in wanting to live peacefully, get an education and live their lives peacefully with neighbouring countries. And then there is the FACT that Israel wants to take Lebanon. All of these statements are backed by statements from Israel Leading Politician's and the IDF. You can choose to live in your own bubble, I'll continue to listen to what the Israeli politicians say about what they want to do.
Israel wishes to coexist with everyone EXCEPT the Palestinians, that's the problem. On the Palestinians, 1/3rd wants Palestinians either ethnically cleansed or eliminated, 1/3rd wants peaceful coexistence and a state for Palestinians, and 1/3rd is confused about it and wants their lives to be stable and safe, by any means. That being said: if the majority of Palestinians still seek the destruction of Israel then the forces in Israel that want peace will never prevail. And that's what that old man sitting in Amman doesn't seem to understand. Either you share the land or you continue to lose it.
@@danielfrancis3736Are you ok??? You thinking is clearly extremely distorted.
I suggest you seek HELP but unfortunately there is no Cure for ZI 🐖 s brains
@@danielfrancis3736 Not true. Israel wouldn't fck with Palestinians if these beared ragge's up screamers wouldn't be filled with hate against them for being smarter and harder working.
If we look at history and compare the facts on the ground, there is only 1 identity that leads to the annihilation of a people and that is the identity that calls itself Zionism.
Look at the foundation of the current colonization that calls itself Israel.
the Irgun, the Lehi, the Haganah and the Palmach are the ones who started the annihilation of innocent Palestinian civilians.
Other than that, Jews have a positive experience of living under Islamic law, unlike Jews living in the West.
You have many Jewish rabbis who speak about this, past and present.
Algeria is the best model for the current anti-colonial struggle. It took over 100 years, but the colonizers eventually left.
I see no correlation. A colonizer has a home country to withdraw to and cut it’s losses. If there is no parent country, the motivation to protect your home becomes a do or die struggle. Do you only see motivation coming from one side? Because if that’s the case, you’re not accepting the reality of the situation.
@@Garmonbozia-nc7mm that's where the situation has changed. Jews came occupy New York or Florida. They already occupy US Congress. They have plenty of options such as the countries, Germany and UK, who love Israel more than they love their own citizens.
Israel is not colonizing any parts of anybody land. You have to understand that there were no countries before 1945 in that region the Jordan, Syria Iraq soudi Arabia etc.
@@tikasiwakoti9070 This person is correct. The mandate of Palestine refers to one part of Syria Palestina which makes up Syria,Jordan,Israel,Palestine and parts of Iraq. Nation states are a western thing. The Caliphate didn't have countries.
@@tikasiwakoti9070 NIgeria was not a country before 1960. does it make it right for England to take a part of the land and call it it their homeland?
They cannot.
Your Allah joined Mosad Today.
Alot of clueless people here if you know guerilla warfare or even warfare in general you'd know if they cannot defeat a guerilla movement that means it wins regardless of the losses, victory is measured by gains not losses and they've gained worldwide support and all they had to do is let Israel be itself, tactically they haven't won anything, strategically they've lost badly and they know it.
@@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi check your pager now
I’m American. I see Israel now as pure supernatural evil by their own action.
An ideology can only be destroyed when there is no more use for it. And resistance will always find an outlet.
You can always weaken it so much as to be nearly irrelevant and stop the conflict. Just look a Germany.
@@TmanRock9 Good luck weakening an ideology whose sole purpose is resistance when its people are still occupied and oppressed.
@@TmanRock9 the thing about Germany is, the German’s had sovereignty and were not living under occupation/blockade.
@@sharifahsspainbutthesissil9517 this is false, they lived under occupation for at least 5-10 years. They could not form any political party they wanted, they couldn’t make whatever they wanted and they couldn’t even vote until 5 years into the occupation.
@@sharifahsspainbutthesissil9517 this is false, they lived under occupation for at least 5-10 years.
this channel always has excellent stories
Absolute Gold standard reporting ❤ FREE PALESTINE❤🇵🇸
😂😂😂ok terrorist supporter rapist . Aj is a propaganda chanel. Get-out in the real world Palestinians are despised .
Free pagers for Palestine!
@@wiseget disgraceful 😢❤🇱🇧
Laughing no commonsense
My only hope is the chosen ppl stop begging US tax payers for everything. Fight you own wars
stop usa to create all wars and support of genocide
Dream on !
What are you talking about? Israel is the 51st State of America. Not DC or Puerto Rico, but Israel ! the sooner you realize that the sooner you will see the why's and the what's of current events
Looks like Al Jazeera starting to realise they were wrong and try to change the rhetoric 😅
Wrong about what? Izzy hasn't defeated Hamas at all.
Al Jazeera is one of the trustworthy channels
No, the Palestinians are not defeated because of Palestinian nationalism 🇵🇸
Impossible.. IDF already failed.
Yes it failed Gaza is occupied
@@molkakaminskiis it really
Open Ur eyes mate
@@muhammadesa2517the body count is showing, who takes it the deepest mate
@@molkakaminski keep the land, thats nothing, it make things more easy cus its know were they are, lol
@@xsunflxwerlol941 they knew where they were before and yet they are still dropping like flys.
Don't answer the pager.
Absolutely, any military unit can be destroyed. The ideology which drives them is a different story.
Destroyed…no. But historically, many ideologies have been reduced to docile levels through force that would seem like they were destroyed. Every government that lost in WW2 experienced this.
@Garmonbozia-nc7mm WW2 was not about freeing Germany or Japan it was the opposite. So no, that's not a good example. South Africa is a good and recent example. The African liberation movement in South Africa started circa 1908. Apartheid South Africa tried to Conquer Namibia and the surrounding countries just like Israel's map that you see Netanyahu projecting which stretches over all of Palestine, Lebanon and Jordan, parts of Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Iraq, Syria and Turkey.
In the same light, the racist apartheid system and government failed in South Africa. Nothing evil has ever lasted, and we have history as the source.
@@blendings2912The question was can an idea be defeated through force. You can change the rules if you want and move the goal posts but the answer remains the same. Ww2 is one example. History is replete with examples. Do you see any Aztecs or Mayans practicing human sacrifice since the Spanish invasion? How are the Carthaginians doing these days? Ideas die all the time or at least become docile.
Shall I bring up the Cherokee? The Iroquois? The Sioux?
How many religions died by force. Idolatry was rooted out and extinguished by so many “righteous “ warriors. Give me a break.
@@blendings2912screw Islam that’s the actual origin of the middle eastern conflict. Also ottomans fell and that land came under control of the victor. Kind of like how the ottomans gained that land through conquest and then allowed Arabs to migrate there. To the victor the spoils, doesn’t stop just because Islam loses. Fricking dork
There not believe what Israel say hamas fighter 17 thousand kill .. civilians people kill there say hamas fighter
New generation of fighter? So the children is a pawns and they are not innocent
So what do you expect, ask yourself
It doesn't literally mean a new generation you dolt.
I live in a world poisoned by the mystical mind
اللهم إن ذنوبي عظام وهي صغار في جنب عفوك يا كريم ، فاغفرها لي
Thank you for the report ; Feedom for Gaza .
Free pagers for Palestine!
Biased panel set-up.
Free free Palestine🇵🇸🕊
Free pager for you!
@@wiseget terrorist 👆🏼
They need to free themselves from Hamas.
@@AsenaT0105 From Hamas and religious tyranny.
The already have.
This discussion is not balance, because all the panelists are pro- Hamas.
To have a balance and serious discussion, Al Jazeera that is also the propaganda arm of Hamas should have brought in another disussent that is oppose to Hamas.
Israel sempre viveu de doaçao e como politico
Falastin 🇵🇸🙏🏻
May the creator stop this war.
The creator created all this mess
Take responsibility for your species and stop looking to imaginary friends.
@@Garmonbozia-nc7mm don't believe in god and despise those who fight in the name of their religions and gods - utterly stupid and shouldn't be left to their own will
@@Garmonbozia-nc7mm g0d is unfortunately real, but evil.
@@stopdeforestation Audubillah, don’t say that. Allah is the creator of all, the most just, and best planner of All.
The Palestinian cause is now on life support after the Al aqsa flood battered it terribly. This moderator made a critical statement that the invitees don't want to consider: only a negotiated solution (with Israel) will bring out the much desired 2-State solution. At some point Israel will have to be dialogued with and Hamas will not be in the position to be able to do so. That's what the problem really is for Hamas. They can never be allowed to be relevant anymore.
The answer is "BIG YES"
If yes why are still fighting
Your wish!
@@mohamedadem4731 Because they care for civilians. If they didn't the war would have been over long back.
@@mohamedadem4731 "Why"? Another smart one from the ME. SMH Sit down Mo. Let me guess you graduated from AJ University? Pathetic. Israel has spoken.
@@Hlth-cn4fh🤮🤮🤮
Sinwar has 72 hours.
You wish
Funny how this program is NOT one sided at all. What a load of propaganda.
Hamas is an Idiology not just a group of people... Millions of people around the world contain this Idiology.
Bad ideas are defeated every day, week, month, year, century, and millennia. This one will be too. Israel has spoken.
I think West Bank has no idiology, staying- stable as occupied then why are u burning them ?
terrorism?
@@BritanApril-g1j Yes n@zl0nlsm
Slaughtering people in concert ideology? I don't understand the point really.
So its true there are no innocent palestinian
To be sincere Hamas has fallen, but Aljazeera would like to portray Hamas as indefatigable, but this is far from the truth. You need to ask Hamas to care for the Palestinians and drop terrorism as violence doesn't work. The truth is that Hamas and its allies combined will never defeat Israel.
well said.
wish this was so but unfortunately they will never fall while Palestinians are being attacked - these resistance groups emanate from oppression and what is happening to the Palestinians is one of the worst humanitarian disasters - that has left thousands of people grieving and angry - whilst another Hamas may not rise - no-one can go through the pain and suffering that the Palestinians have gone through for decades without being able to express it somehow
we'll see.. I'm gonna come back here next year and tell you 'I told you so'
@@350kphu r an Israeli sympathizer 😢
@@megschwarz8876They asked for it by hating Jews for absolutely no valid reasons. Iran used Palestinians to fight their hate fueled war. All they have to do is develop their land like the Jews did and be ok. But they are too obsessed with religion and hate.
Hate breeds more hate
@@TerranRepublic0200 BS
"With losses on both sides". First time, Al Jazeera has conceded Hamas has lost combatants shying away from the common mantra "women and children".
When did they deny that? It’s war lol, ofc Hamas and Israel will lose men and equipment
So you imply womam and children are not combatants 😂😂😂😂😂 we no longer that naive
no put they can stop the weapons or slowing it down.
Bravo, ALL!
I found your program to be very informative, however, I am so disappointed that Ms Caridi and Mr. Tamimi were not allowed to finish their points of view. Thank you 🍁
How can hamas be dismantled when ever day the idf kills a woman or child they gain another member hamas never had army units that could fight conventionally they have always and will always use gurillla tactics and that won’t chang
Polio
Every thing is possible for Israel. Nothing possible for 56 countries , only can cry include AJ .
Joking,just ordinary hamas can't defeat since, you want 52 country for were you are joking
FR Palestin!
Look at the Reuters poll - huge shift in not supporting Hamas - after almost a year the Gazans are now thinking, Hmmm, maybe 10-7 was not such a great idea - certainly after their former heroes now resemble garden hedgehogs while they left their people to deal w IDF
Bro wut- just look at the polls.
Heard the same big talk from the USA about the Vietnamese resistance! 😂😂😂
@@angus7278 guessing w your millennial progressive laugh emojis you didn’t actually hear that 55 years ago
Guess Reuters was silly for publishing the Palestinian poll taken by Palestinians - yep, smiley, Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research (PCPSR)
@@DMAK99-h4fpro Palestinians generally like to deny the parts of reality that damage their position.
Strategic planning by wasting billions of US dollars
Paid a trillion just today…just for interest…🤦🏻♀ 🫏 🕳‘s
How can you destroy hamas wen their are hiding at the inocent children and woman.
I don’t think so AJ is Hamas too.😂
and you patronizes humus because you patronizes aj😀
☝️😎
You never know, until one tries.
Yes.
Next question.
No.
Next question.
And people ask why painter kill small hats. He know who's real enemy.
Al jazira is starting to get redundant wid their reports 😅
Seu tempo aqui na terra no máximo 100 anos só vai ficar suas fotos e o pó
Free palestine
❤️❤️❤️❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
🐕🦺💩🇵🇸💩
What happened in Lebanon is an example of the danger inherent in the Internet of Things
Pagers talk
I was Wondering , IF negotiations Should be taking seriouslly into account most from the Hostages perspectives than the Military ones thereof, plenty of WHATABOUTISM the War on Gaze's Strip, hardly Would be ending Whether Hamas going to be destroyed or not.
Freedom is an inherent Wish present screeming inward of the people.
Quem não trabalha tem muito tempo para desenvolver nunca trabalharam só mamando do eua
Hamas has lost Gaza after 7th October, Politically, Logically and Militarily.
quite the opposite. Individually, Hamas members were but they're now stronger than ever. All the kids orphaned and maimed are guaranteed to become the next generation of Hamas while Israel's image in the world stage is now tarnished. There are now nation wide protests across Israel due to how unpopular the war is and the only reason Bibi refuses to step is he'll be forced to step down or worse if he did.
I play the Uno reverse card
I think they are already are on a good way
could this lead to a nuclear holocaust
The people speaking in this interview are having an illussions.they still believe hamas is winning😂😂😂😂
Without the support of Muslim countries, it would be difficult for Palestine to establish a state, but Muslim countries have Western agents, such as Jordan.
Why am I being censored for saying that If they can’t stop polio, Israel will be fighting an opponent that is extremely proficient in inertia?
Oh the irony, Romans and Philistines butthurt about Jews 🤣
the jius have incredible losses at the ground offensive,
Yes it can
Bro 😎 Took 100 years to end British Rule in India Partition and Creation of Pakistan 🇵🇰.
Continue Your struggle against occupation in Legal System.🎪🇵🇸🍉☠️🕊️🤲🤞✌️
Who fights against the British aren't Pakistanis 😂😂😂
that's a strategy called divide et impere.
And what a peach of a nation emerged. Pakistan. Such a rich and wonderful peace loving country.
@@rabiasaeed2206 And yet, they followed the British form of government.
Lol, no.
Its not possible because Aljazeera is Hamas too
That makes zero sense, but gave me a laugh! 😂😂😂
☝️😎
Aren't you ? 😂😂😂
@@angus7278 "Al Jazeera is funded in whole or in part by the Qatari government."
@@jessemares6111 "Al Jazeera is funded in whole or in part by the Qatari government."
Stop bluffing
They’re only buying time.
Pretty sure they already did.
We Know within two years to come they will
Os pobres só tem tempo pra o trabalho pra sua sobrevivência mais no reino de Deus sua sabedoria vai ser julgada e os pobres que vão ser os ricos
Israel will never leave Hamas in gaza by any means,it will take time but the IDF will achieve their goals.
Not possible.
You fruit cakes are fighting 13 groups not just Hamas 🤣 your economy is being decimated
No matter how much it cost the USA. When will Israel stand on its own feet, or is that even possible?
Ideeef-are-cowards
Ideeef-r-rape-gangs
Too late as faild
Already gone
I wonder if this was all created on purpose by higher forces making the big three religions and seeing if we can reach a higher consciousness and kindness than we are going through right now on the planet or maybe we just got here ourselves because we could not read the instructions OR we got the wrong instructions I just am confused with it all
nope
Free plstn people
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
There Never was a Palestine and there Never will be one. God said so.
@@Truecolors326Israel is a pure invention! Palestine will be free! Like it or not! It's your problem!
Free pagers!
@@Truecolors326you learn from who . How do you know god say no a Palestine
@shasha14779 because unlike you I got a education in God's Word the KJV Bible.
can Israel destroy Hamas? that's the stupidest question I ever heard..and here's the answer.can Israel remove sadness and heartbreak that it caused to innocent people..Occupied Palestinian Territory - About 10% of the Gaza Strip's population has been killed, injured, or is missing due to the 293-day genocide carried out by Israel in the Strip, ongoing since 7 October 2023. Euro-Med Monitor's preliminary statistics indicate that about 50,000 Palestinians have been killed ..
4. Commitment to Democracy:
• It promises that the State of Israel will be founded on democratic principles, guaranteeing equality to all citizens, regardless of religion, race, or gender. It also calls for the protection of religious freedom, justice, and peace.
Hamas: Rejects any negotiated peace or peaceful resolution with Israel, emphasizing that jihad (holy war) is the only solution.
• Anti-Israel and Anti-Jewish Sentiment: The charter includes religiously motivated hostility toward Jews, often quoting Islamic texts to justify its stance.
Where is the common ground?
Why in the world Muslim is dead even 1people other country his dead the world was crying tell the answer
42
Perfect English mate!👍
Israeli war on Hamas. Support from regional allies?
As an Israeli, I am really sad that Hamas continues to be praised, this only causes the Palestinian people to suffer more and more because until Hamas is destroyed or surrenders unconditionally, the war will continue
As a human being myself I'm really sad that heartless b@st @rds like you still exist because you impose, support and justify occupation , oppression, apartheid and the suffering of a vulnerable people which you dehumanize. You Israelis are the reason why the Palestinians are suffering and why groups like Hamas exist.
They're just stupid
They don't even know what they're supporting
They just do it because others do it
Keep your so-called concern for the Zi 🐖 s, We Don't need it
Free Lebanon from Iran free Imran khan
Cachão não tem gaveta para vcs levar a seus bens
Mohammad Deif is still alive
What the difference
@@SureshGooheeram
It still matters because no one should say anything that is not true
Hamas is already destroyed!!
False
And yet the fighting continues, and will continue.
@@star80ist Of course. There will always be stupid people with weapons. But their entire organizational structure has been dismantled, not to mention thousands of "soldiers" have been lost🤷♂
@@star80ist these people are so arrogant that they actually believe the Palestinians are animals. As if Palestinians don’t love their families deeply- deep enough to feel rage when their loved ones are blown apart or burned alive in front of them. No matter what the name of armed resistance is- it will continue and grow in intensity because of the scale of the atrocities committed by Israel. Palestine now has 1,000 years worth of fighters. Good work.
☝️😎
Gaza is not destroyed?
9:44
What kind of question is this 😂?
I bet they throw away their mobile devices
They can destroy Hamas miltary capacity
Almost a year now
Hows that going
@@muhammadesa2517pretty good, humus has lost control over vast amount of the territory, the leaderships has been gutted, their numbers cut by over half, their ammunition stockpiles have skimmed down, their sponsors and allied nations leaders are falling left and right, humus fighters have resorted to stealing aid from their people causing a division and the major supporter of Humus has just been internationally embarrassed two separate times showing the world how outmatched they truly are.
At this rate it’s only a matter of time.
There a Africa saying to kill a crocodiles you destroy the eggs
😢💐
Short answer: yes
Short answer: no
PRAYING FOR ISRAEL 🇮🇱 🙏
Palestinian must understand that Jewish came to stay as a country
how about no
Makes no sense
Aslong as Israël keep their apartheid mindset going a new resistance will rise
Its not apartheid dont use the word if you dont know what it is i lived through apatheid
How much are they paying you
@@sherwiennascimento6310 20 million
Well good luck sell out
It is NOT apartheid it is common sense, to not want to be attacked by morons who believe in a cult that hates everything but their own nonsense.
The Holy Quran
😮 : Sad News to Tell you all the Quran has NO IDEA what Holiness is. The Claim that the Quran is Holy when it has no idea what the definition is is a DEAD GIVEAWAY Your Book isnt Holy which means if the COVER AINT TRUE , THE REST OF THEE BOOK AINT TRUE EITHER.
Matthew 5 Jesus defines what it means to be Holy showing his VAST WISDOM over the Quran.
😂😂😂
The bible can no longer be classed as the word of God
At least not fully
@muhammadesa2517 Yes it is. I never found a valid excuse to discredit it and neither can you
@@Truecolors326 there are 2 valid excuses
A) the bible was changed by religious leaders and christian rulers
Verses were taken out and verses were changed
How can U call something that was edited the word of God
B) the new testament was written by men yet it is a part of the Bible
How can the new testament be a part of the bible if it was written by men
These are the valid excuses and if U refuse to believe it then Ur an imbecile
Unlike the Bible and the Torah, the Qur'an has never been changed
No verse was taken out nor was any verse changed and it can't because if U change a single word in any verse of the Qur'an then it will change the meaning
Sometimes even if U change a harakah it can change the meaning
Allah sent down the Qur'an in Arabic for a reason
❤
❤❤