India and Hindus are proud on infinity foundation. Such a great and most assential required work. We are obliged and thankful for their hard work. I wish all the best for their success.
Thx for discussing Devdata’s work. I being in the west was initially fooled by his analysis but had some doubts. Now I know why he was treating everything as mythology by using western scholars. Good work. Thx and keep up good work. 🙏
monotheism is blamed as the instigator of ignorance, oppression, and violence. Monotheism has been a "totalizing discourse", often co-opting all aspects of a social belief system, resulting in the exclusion of "others". Monotheism is less pluralistic and thus less tolerant than polytheism, because monotheism stipulates that people pigeonhole their beliefs into one tenet. "Monotheism is irreconcilable with the existence in our nature of the instincts of benevolence" because it compels followers to devote themselves to a single Creator. The logic of monotheism ... yields little basis for tolerating other religions". Monotheism anesthetize the sense of wonder as if one were committed to a single line of thought by a cosmic legal contract".
Monotheism is the belief in The One True God , The Creator of ALL, Who created man and woman in His Image having great value. It’s the separation of man from God that brought in selfishness which results in greed and exploitation. And that’s why His constant drawing to Himself of His sons and daughters In fact monotheism will bring Righteousness peace and Joy
oh, the male egocentric guy sitting on high clouds ( btw being formless but a male and sitting on a formless bottom )has a MIND! And imagination!! And thoughts like ordinary mortals 😳 Ishwara/ Bhgvan is beyond mind body and senses!
Neither is monotheism the problem, nor is it the solution; it is just one among many beliefs. The belief that God does not exist, is also an intolerant bigotry. The real problem is being “Naastik” - the belief that there is no relationship between one living creature with another - that life is solely for the pleasure of my existence. Whether God exists or not in your belief system, you can be a better person if you find some way to believe in the rights and needs of others before you come to your own rights and needs. No religion is needed for this, and no religion which does not make you selfless has value to Mankind.
You should interview Shubhodeep - list down top 5 issues and ask him to address them - that would make it more interesting and reach more audience. Similar to the sanskrit nonstranslable series of videos - the best and most engrossing content on your channel.
Buddha had never accepted untouchability and caste system. Buddha said anyone can practise Buddha dharma and become Buddha. Buddha said that all sentient beings are Buddha by nature. 'Hinayana' is a name given by Mahayana to Shravakayana Buddhists on the basis of their view, path and fruit. Buddha was against the prevailing untouchability tradition. He denounced the untouchablilty tradition propagated by certain traditions.
Rajiv ji, stands - a Rishi, a modern Vyas - dealing in Hindu literature for our times at the same time defending and attacking, Kshatreeta Brahman. It is an act to emulate as much as one can by us all. raviji T&T.
I am worried about the future of Hinduism/ Sanatana Dharma because of people like Dev Dutt who’ll misguide the youth /future generations of secular Hindus.
*Devdutt Pattanaik* playing a good role to deviate the Hindu young generation and we can say that he born as Hindu but to work for the devaluing, defaming, degrading and demeaning of the original, philosophies, philosophical mythology of Sanatan Dharma and its structural integrity. *Devdutt Pattanaik* written so many books applying his *Intellect* and after little study, I found him a man of *"Tāmasik Intellect" !* *Intellect (Buddi):* *Classification of Human in terms of INTELLECT into 3 types: GITA, chapter 18:* 🔴Bhagavad Gita 14.1 The Divine Lord said: I shall once again explain to you the *supreme wisdom, the best of all knowledge;* by knowing which, all the great saints attained the highest perfection. *(To explain different types of Intellects possessed are called "Supreme wisdom".)* *Intellects of all human beings are classified into 3 main categories, namely, "Tāmasik Intellect", "Rajasic Intellect" and "Sattvic Intellect."* *Sattvic Intellect(Buddi):* Bhagavad Gita 18.30. The intellect is said to be in the nature of goodness, O Parth, *when it correctly understands* "difference between Dharma and Adharma", "path of activities and renunciation" and "what is proper action and what is improper action", "what is duty and what is non-duty", "what is to be feared and what is not to be feared", "what is binding force and what is liberating force" and "what is called bondage and what is called liberation" is called *Sattvic Intellect.* *🔴Rājasik Intellect (Buddi):* Bhagavad Gita 18.31. *The intellect* is considered in the mode of passion when it is confused between righteousness and unrighteousness, and cannot distinguish between right and wrong conduct. Humans under raja do not truly perceive "what is Dharma and what is Adharma," "what ought to be done and what should not," though they try to know and want to know all about the realities but can't. *🔴Tāmasik Intellect(Buddi):* *Bhagavad Gita 18.32. That intellect which is shrouded in darkness, imagining "irreligion to be religion", "good as bad and bad as good", "duties as non-duties and non-duties as duties", "adharma as dharma and dharma as adharma", and "perceiving untruth to be the truth" and all kinds of things contrarily, knows all knowable vice versa, sees all things upside down, is of the nature of "ignorance".*
I used to view devdut views on our culture. Now I understand he is not correct. Please keep up the good work exposing pseudo Hindus. I see Hindus started understanding the kaniving pseudo Hindus like devdut.
Also there is a guy Ranbeer who does podcasts.. he is not like devdutt but he is definitely confused and falls under spiritual but not religious bracket..
हिन्दुओ को खासकर युवाओ को कुछ भी पढ़ने से पहले सोचना समझना चाहिए। पहले अपने ग्रन्थो को पढ़े।जिससे सही गलत का बोध हो सके।हिन्दी या भारतीय भाषाओं के लेखको को अधिक पढ़े।
Devdutt's writings have always seemed ill-informed, non scholarly , driven by his own fancies. He never seemed to have any knowledge, in fact Prof Rajeev Malhotra has explained about his writings and few other people have also done so but the way u have busted his lies is commendable. Hope Neo sanatanis will benefit from this specially those who know less about sanatan and want to get some knowledge in capsules.
Which 'standard' dictionary says that the meaning of Aryamarg is Buddhist in origin? The concept of "Nation-State" indeed is a recent development. When travellers and invaders came to India, this country was divided into various provinces and the masses of these provinces never had a national consciousness, or the consciousness of being a part of an imagined community called "India". Devdutt is not the only one who blames Brahmanism for perpetuating caste. The chairman of the the Drafting Committee, Dr. B.R Ambedkar, also had the same views regarding the Brahmins. Please read "The Annihilation of Caste" if you doubt me. I am not in favour of ridiculing any man for his caste though for a man is far more than his caste. Good Luck with whatever you wish to prove.
No, no. There are various Christian myths. They are myths because they may not be historically accurate, but rather intended to convey moral or spiritual lessons. Mythological themes and elements occur throughout Christian literature. The creation story in Genesis, which includes the account of Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden; the story of Noah and the Great Flood; the story of Jonah and the whale; the story of the Tower of Babel; the story of the birth of Jesus Christ… these are just a few. With Islam, they share these myths.
Myths? Books in the Bible are not myths but anything, man made is a myth. That’s why Jesus told us to follow Him and not man. As our heart is deceitful
@@Anti-NWO Oh yes. Like the Christian White supremicists in the US and Hungary. Let us go a little further: fundamentalist Jews in Israel, and fundamentalists in Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism. Bigotry is the favourite breakfast for the right wing.
Then why r u watching ? If u r. A fan of Devdutt stay away ...it's clear frm the title wht the video was going to be about ....if facts bother u so much then u hv a lopsided view ...u hv no right to stop someone frm criticizing a shallow work ...u however can choose wht to consume ..if u dnt like dnt watch ..dnt preach n call ppl jokers ..itni mirchi lagi hai aapko toh mat dekho ...he isn't saying anything wrong ...
This Nityananda Swami & the casteist Infinity Foundation has significant problems with a non-Brahmin commenting on Indian religion. They have no issues when brahmins like Amish Tripathi rewrite puranic texts. Rajiv Malmutra & his southern black Brahmin companion is making all Nityanandas go crazy. We Indians have the right to opine on our understanding of Indian religion, and we don't need the permission of Brahmins to do so. If you don't like it, then don't read it.
Have u heard of purvapaksha ??? If alll Indians can interpret text why not Rajiv and his southern black brahmin companion????😂😂😂😂 You kinda gave a self defeating argument there😂 N the hate u emit is the same or greater than what you accuse others of..
They are not interpreting texts but slandering & maligning Devdutt P. They can criticize his texts but comparing him to one head of Ravana is beyond defamation which is a result of a sustained effort from their lobby to defame him.
Shallow or not, he played an important role. This is Monday morning football. Criticism nearly a decade later. Things discussed out of time and context. This is a needlessly hurtful take down of an individual by all the authors of this book. This is bullying. Shame on you
There are so many not-so-hindu. Hindus who are trying to dismantle Hinduism. Why are they doing this is it money the cause Is it notoriety I can understand people from other religions doing this but someone being Hindu and trying to degrade Hinduism befuddling.😢
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
Such a scholarly work by Subhodeep ji and then the intellectual comments from Shri Nityanand ji is so nice to watch.
Wonderful. Waiting for kindle edition. Thanks Infinity Foundation. Immense work!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤
It makes me happy to think this content is available online. Grateful for your contributions...
India and Hindus are proud on infinity foundation. Such a great and most assential required work. We are obliged and thankful for their hard work. I wish all the best for their success.
Devdutt started his career as a writer on Hinduism to promote it. But down the line, he became a Macaulay putra.
WEST MONEY
Thank you Nityanand Sir, and thank you, Rajiv Sir, for everything.
Thx for discussing Devdata’s work. I being in the west was initially fooled by his analysis but had some doubts. Now I know why he was treating everything as mythology by using western scholars. Good work. Thx and keep up good work. 🙏
monotheism is blamed as the instigator of ignorance, oppression, and violence. Monotheism has been a "totalizing discourse", often co-opting all aspects of a social belief system, resulting in the exclusion of "others". Monotheism is less pluralistic and thus less tolerant than polytheism, because monotheism stipulates that people pigeonhole their beliefs into one tenet. "Monotheism is irreconcilable with the existence in our nature of the instincts of benevolence" because it compels followers to devote themselves to a single Creator. The logic of monotheism ... yields little basis for tolerating other religions". Monotheism anesthetize the sense of wonder as if one were committed to a single line of thought by a cosmic legal contract".
Monotheism is the belief in The One True God , The Creator of ALL, Who created man and woman in His Image having great value. It’s the separation of man from God that brought in selfishness which results in greed and exploitation. And that’s why His constant drawing to Himself of His sons and daughters
In fact monotheism will bring Righteousness peace and Joy
How come monotheism being less pluralistic becomes less tolerant?
oh, the male egocentric guy sitting on high clouds ( btw being formless but a male and sitting on a formless bottom )has a MIND! And imagination!! And thoughts like ordinary mortals 😳
Ishwara/ Bhgvan is beyond mind body and senses!
@@binaysingh4883 my or the highway is the answer.
Neither is monotheism the problem, nor is it the solution; it is just one among many beliefs. The belief that God does not exist, is also an intolerant bigotry. The real problem is being “Naastik” - the belief that there is no relationship between one living creature with another - that life is solely for the pleasure of my existence. Whether God exists or not in your belief system, you can be a better person if you find some way to believe in the rights and needs of others before you come to your own rights and needs. No religion is needed for this, and no religion which does not make you selfless has value to Mankind.
You should interview Shubhodeep - list down top 5 issues and ask him to address them - that would make it more interesting and reach more audience. Similar to the sanskrit nonstranslable series of videos - the best and most engrossing content on your channel.
Thank you both!
Great service to Indians by exposing shallowdutt patanaik
You guys are killing it! Keep up the good work!
Great analysis by Subhodeep ji. "Masala Author" 😆😆😆
জয় শ্রী গনেশ। জয় সীতা রাম। জয় বজরং বলি হনুমান কি জয়। জয় রাধে কৃষ্ণ। হর হর মহাদেব। সত্য সনাতন ধৰ্ম কি জয়।
জয় শ্রীরাম।❤❤🤝🤝
Buddha had never accepted untouchability and caste system. Buddha said anyone can practise Buddha dharma and become Buddha. Buddha said that all sentient beings are Buddha by nature. 'Hinayana' is a name given by Mahayana to Shravakayana Buddhists on the basis of their view, path and fruit. Buddha was against the prevailing untouchability tradition. He denounced the untouchablilty tradition propagated by certain traditions.
Rajiv ji, stands - a Rishi, a modern Vyas - dealing in Hindu literature for our times at the same time defending and attacking, Kshatreeta Brahman. It is an act to emulate as much as one can by us all. raviji T&T.
New title - Devdutt Pattnaik's masala world!!
हिन्दू सबसे evolved है और रहेगा सदा ही😊👌💐👍😊
Nityananda ji 🙏 for a very Rational Analysis .
So agree with you...his interpretation is so misleading ... Nothing like what advaita Vedanta Talks about
I am worried about the future of Hinduism/ Sanatana Dharma because of people like Dev Dutt who’ll misguide the youth /future generations of secular Hindus.
यस🎉प्रणाम
If Devdutt Pattanaik is an expert on Hinduism , then I am Marilyn Monroe
Ravana had 10 heads in real. Old painting, craving before 18th century show it.
Jaigurudev
Next round for PRASHANTOLOGY please.
*Devdutt Pattanaik* playing a good role to deviate the Hindu young generation and we can say that he born as Hindu but to work for the devaluing, defaming, degrading and demeaning of the original, philosophies, philosophical mythology of Sanatan Dharma and its structural integrity.
*Devdutt Pattanaik* written so many books applying his *Intellect* and after little study, I found him a man of *"Tāmasik Intellect" !*
*Intellect (Buddi):*
*Classification of Human in terms of INTELLECT into 3 types: GITA, chapter 18:*
🔴Bhagavad Gita 14.1
The Divine Lord said: I shall once again explain to you the *supreme wisdom, the best of all knowledge;* by knowing which, all the great saints attained the highest perfection. *(To explain different types of Intellects possessed are called "Supreme wisdom".)*
*Intellects of all human beings are classified into 3 main categories, namely, "Tāmasik Intellect", "Rajasic Intellect" and "Sattvic Intellect."*
*Sattvic Intellect(Buddi):*
Bhagavad Gita 18.30. The intellect is said to be in the nature of goodness, O Parth, *when it correctly understands* "difference between Dharma and Adharma", "path of activities and renunciation" and "what is proper action and what is improper action", "what is duty and what is non-duty", "what is to be feared and what is not to be feared", "what is binding force and what is liberating force" and "what is called bondage and what is called liberation" is called *Sattvic Intellect.*
*🔴Rājasik Intellect (Buddi):*
Bhagavad Gita 18.31. *The intellect* is considered in the mode of passion when it is confused between righteousness and unrighteousness, and cannot distinguish between right and wrong conduct. Humans under raja do not truly perceive "what is Dharma and what is Adharma," "what ought to be done and what should not," though they try to know and want to know all about the realities but can't.
*🔴Tāmasik Intellect(Buddi):*
*Bhagavad Gita 18.32. That intellect which is shrouded in darkness, imagining "irreligion to be religion", "good as bad and bad as good", "duties as non-duties and non-duties as duties", "adharma as dharma and dharma as adharma", and "perceiving untruth to be the truth" and all kinds of things contrarily, knows all knowable vice versa, sees all things upside down, is of the nature of "ignorance".*
Excellent analysis!
I used to view devdut views on our culture. Now I understand he is not correct. Please keep up the good work exposing pseudo Hindus. I see Hindus started understanding the kaniving pseudo Hindus like devdut.
Also there is a guy Ranbeer who does podcasts.. he is not like devdutt but he is definitely confused and falls under spiritual but not religious bracket..
Yes he needs to be educated about the true nature of Hinduism
He's here for merely money making. Nothing about spiritualism or religion.
@@Anti-NWO if so that is dangerous..
I also would like to know Rajiv ji's current opinion on Nithyanand of Kailasa
हिन्दुओ को खासकर युवाओ को कुछ भी पढ़ने से पहले सोचना समझना चाहिए। पहले अपने ग्रन्थो को पढ़े।जिससे सही गलत का बोध हो सके।हिन्दी या भारतीय भाषाओं के लेखको को अधिक पढ़े।
Misra ji why discuss about such headless... people
धार्यते इति धर्म:
🙏🙏
Devdutt's writings have always seemed ill-informed, non scholarly , driven by his own fancies. He never seemed to have any knowledge, in fact Prof Rajeev Malhotra has explained about his writings and few other people have also done so but the way u have busted his lies is commendable. Hope Neo sanatanis will benefit from this specially those who know less about sanatan and want to get some knowledge in capsules.
Excellent analysis! Glad that another scholar has deconstructed this fraud Devdutt Patnaik
Devdutt Pattnaik is a tasteless masala box, trying to cook masala dosa in a pizz hut
Which 'standard' dictionary says that the meaning of Aryamarg is Buddhist in origin? The concept of "Nation-State" indeed is a recent development. When travellers and invaders came to India, this country was divided into various provinces and the masses of these provinces never had a national consciousness, or the consciousness of being a part of an imagined community called "India".
Devdutt is not the only one who blames Brahmanism for perpetuating caste. The chairman of the the Drafting Committee, Dr. B.R Ambedkar, also had the same views regarding the Brahmins. Please read "The Annihilation of Caste" if you doubt me. I am not in favour of ridiculing any man for his caste though for a man is far more than his caste.
Good Luck with whatever you wish to prove.
No, no. There are various Christian myths. They are myths because they may not be historically accurate, but rather intended to convey moral or spiritual lessons. Mythological themes and elements occur throughout Christian literature. The creation story in Genesis, which includes the account of Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden; the story of Noah and the Great Flood; the story of Jonah and the whale; the story of the Tower of Babel; the story of the birth of Jesus Christ… these are just a few. With Islam, they share these myths.
Myths? Books in the Bible are not myths but anything, man made is a myth. That’s why Jesus told us to follow Him and not man. As our heart is deceitful
Take away the “ mythical original sin” and Christianity collapses like a weakling. The very foundation is based on myth.
@@vish2553 yes. You may be right. But then all religions have a heavy dose of mythology. Without that, they can't survive
@@lalluchettan yes but Christianity has bigotry.
@@Anti-NWO Oh yes. Like the Christian White supremicists in the US and Hungary. Let us go a little further: fundamentalist Jews in Israel, and fundamentalists in Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism. Bigotry is the favourite breakfast for the right wing.
Devdutt is at best a 3rd rate mmbs doctor.
Buddha cousin
Sasta writer hai ye devdutt. Isko to mai amazon pe search bhi na karu !!
I don’t know how I feel about episode. These jokers are even tackling this only because Devdutt was successful
Then why r u watching ? If u r. A fan of Devdutt stay away ...it's clear frm the title wht the video was going to be about ....if facts bother u so much then u hv a lopsided view ...u hv no right to stop someone frm criticizing a shallow work ...u however can choose wht to consume ..if u dnt like dnt watch ..dnt preach n call ppl jokers ..itni mirchi lagi hai aapko toh mat dekho ...he isn't saying anything wrong ...
so successful he keeps his comment section off, so nobody can expose him.
He has 0 knowledge of any scriptures.
So Devdutt "was" successful????? is he dead now??? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Devdutt is a fame chaser and has a cowardice disposition
This Nityananda Swami & the casteist Infinity Foundation has significant problems with a non-Brahmin commenting on Indian religion. They have no issues when brahmins like Amish Tripathi rewrite puranic texts. Rajiv Malmutra & his southern black Brahmin companion is making all Nityanandas go crazy. We Indians have the right to opine on our understanding of Indian religion, and we don't need the permission of Brahmins to do so. If you don't like it, then don't read it.
Have u heard of purvapaksha ???
If alll Indians can interpret text why not Rajiv and his southern black brahmin companion????😂😂😂😂
You kinda gave a self defeating argument there😂
N the hate u emit is the same or greater than what you accuse others of..
N to quote you
IF U DONT LIKE IT DONT READ IT !!!!
😂😂
They are not interpreting texts but slandering & maligning Devdutt P. They can criticize his texts but comparing him to one head of Ravana is beyond defamation which is a result of a sustained effort from their lobby to defame him.
@@varunahmitrah He must sue them for defamation asap.. !!!
@@offencebestdefence500 Yes he should 😡.
DEVDUTTOLOGY.
WHAT RIDICULOUS NONSENSE WORD.
SHAVAN-MUTROLOGY WOULD BE BETTER.
Shallow or not, he played an important role. This is Monday morning football. Criticism nearly a decade later. Things discussed out of time and context. This is a needlessly hurtful take down of an individual by all the authors of this book. This is bullying. Shame on you
Why is critical evaluation of Devdutt's work shameful? If the critique is factually incorrect, then you respond with facts..
Bullying 😂😂😂
He presented purva paksha. You come up with uttar paksha.
Is he a crybaby 😂😂😂
Venkat ji,
But you have not made any clarification on any of the comments made about Shri Deva Datt ji. raviji
There are so many not-so-hindu. Hindus who are trying to dismantle Hinduism. Why are they doing this is it money the cause
Is it notoriety I can understand people from other religions doing this but someone being Hindu and trying to degrade Hinduism befuddling.😢
🙏🙏🙏