Christina is the soul singer while Perrie is the technical vocalist - even though both have soulful voices 🩵💯 Perrie reminds of Christina Aguilera in some aspects meshed with Beyonce, Celine & Whitney Houston 🩵💯✨ Lows - Christina Midbelts - Perrie (much better technique & resonance ) Upper Belts - Perrie Falsetto - Christina Head Voice - Perrie Perrie is the better vocalist
She tries to act like a Mezzo & idk why. She is clearly a very high set Soprano but she sacrifices ease for a chesty powerful tone when she could just blend it together 😩
This is my opinion: Low Notes - A3: Tie G#3: Tie G3: Tie (I would've given it to Perrie but hers was also near inaudible) F#3: Christina F3: Perrie E3: Tie Eb3: Christina D3: Tie C#3: Christina Belts - A4: Tie A4: Tie A4: Tie Bb4: Perrie Bb4: Perrie 100% B4: Perrie B4: Tie B4: Tie C5: Perrie (far healthier) C5: Tie C5: Perrie C#5: Perrie C#5: Perrie (one of her best C#5s) C#5: Perrie D5: Perrie (Christina's was...) D5: Perrie D5: Perrie D5: Tie Eb5: Tie Eb5: Tie Eb5: Perrie (even though she was lipsyncing) Eb5: Perrie E5: Tie E5: Perrie (this note was also lipped) E5: Perrie F5: Perrie (even Perrie sang Christina's song better than her lol) F5: Christina F5: Perrie F#5: Perrie F#5: Perrie F#5: Perrie (one of the most grounded and free F#5s she has EVER sung 😍😍😍) G5: Tie G5: Perrie G#5: Perrie Upper Register - C#5: Christina (LOVE the vibrato) D5: Perrie Eb5: Perrie (Christina's fell a bit flat) E5: Perrie F5: Perrie F#5: Perrie G5: Christina G#5: Tie A5: Christina (Perrie's was lipsynced) Bb5: Tie B5: Tie C6: Perrie C#6: Tie D6: Christina Eb6: Christina E6: Tie Lows - Christina (8) > Perrie (6) Belts - Perrie (33) > Christina (12) Upper Register - Perrie (11) > Christina (10) Christina has 30 points and Perrie has 50 points. Perrie wins by miles! Christina has such amazing control over her falsetto though! It's almost as rich as a proper head voice like Perrie's and her lows are no joke either but her belts need a LOT of work.
@@popvocalstv Perrie has been delivering some pretty good upper belts lately so it is very much possible that the whole performance was live. She has had almost 2 years of rest from live singing so I'm sure she has had lots of time to work on her weak areas. Plus, she has performed like 4 times in the past 2 years so her voice isn't getting worn out as easily as it usually would.
@@varunravi27 The high notes were pre recorded, as well as the E5 in Tears and some parts of iwdws, if you look at fancams you will notice the difference in volume + the fact that she moves her head exaggeratedly like she usually does when she's lip syncing, sadly the closest we have of live attempts of FAU's high notes is the acoustic version which is still not THAT live... 😕
@@dv4975 Anyone that knows even a bit about vocal technique would know that Christina’s technique is not sustainable. People defend her horrible technique with excuses such as soulfulness but there have been and still are many soulful singers and vocalists that ALSO maintain good vocal technique, including Perrie. Frankly speaking, other than her falsetto and vocal agility, none of Christina’s vocal registers are anything special compared to Perrie’s. Perrie is a classically trained vocalist with development in all of her registers (her vocal agility does need some work though so I’ll give that to Christina).
I prefer Perrie but I think they’re fairly equal in different ways. Christinas lows,agility,and head voice/falsetto seems to be superior to Perrie’s,but I think Perrie shines more in the belts and I think she just has a healthier way of approaching singing in general. Both are different but great singers. Maybe Perrie edges it out for me,but that doesn’t mean Christina isn’t really good. Just depends on if you like a more polished vocalist vs a more rough but equally compelling one
@moonlightespt1946 well, I'm not an expert, but I believe so actually. I'm talking about belting techniques specifically. You see, Christina is very well known for her raspy and growled vocals that she does all the time. That's very risky and can lead to vocal damage. She also tends to pull chest voice all the way up to those crazy high notes (E5/F5 and above). That's a bad technique, using mixed voice is the best choice. Also, most of the time, her belting is kinda forced/pushed. Sometimes, she sounds a bit throaty when belting because of the poor technique she's using, especially on higher notes. Perrie on the other hand does none of that. So, that's why I said Perrie uses proper techniques for singing, but Christina... Not so much. I respect your opinion too. After all, we can't deny that Christina is a vocal powerhouse and she's been a music icon for years. ❤️
@moonlightespt1946 you don't have to apologize at all. You're just trying to prove your point here by giving accurate and logical arguments, and I totally respect that. You're clearly very educated and experienced in this field and know a lot more than I do. So, it's literally not up to debate! 😂 You actually convinced me, well done! 👏 Have a great day/night! 💕
@moonlightespt1946 Well Perry has a better vibrato, consistency and her tehcnique as a whole is healthy in every aspect of her vocals. Xtina’s belting technique issue is a huge step back for her when it comes to VS battles.
I love Xtina's tone when she doesn't over do it. Lows: Perrie Mid Belts: Tie (I'm going with Xtina's more recent belts for that conclusion, Perrie has a slight edge though) Upper Belts: Perrie, she's more consistent imo. But Xtina's recent attempts are surprisingly good, less strained than a few years ago. Upper Register: tie, both are amazing. Perrie has, generally, a more classical sound and Christina is more contemporary, but the ease and healthy sound is there for both of them. Overall, Perrie wins for me, but not by that much. Lows were the deciding factor.
Really great video. As a fan of both, I think you made some really great choices to demonstrate their abilities whilst also demonstrating their styles. You chose interesting clips that I didn't expect to see, and although there were some clips that I thought would be good to include, I'm very satisfied with the clips you chose and really enjoyed the video. I'm always so impressed by the hard work you put into these, even when you dont know the artist that well. You try to show everyone in the best light, be fair, and most importantly, be fun. I think you have one of the best vocals accounts out rn. ❤ They're surprisingly close looking at their techniques. Christina was better in the lows, but Perrie did really well, too. I think overall, Perrie beat Christina in the belts because of the upper belts, but they were very close up till and including the eb5 (although I know theres gonna be people in the comments confusing distortion/drive with strain as there always is). It's surprised me, tbh and Christina, gave Perrie a good run for her money on the E5s and wasn't too far off her on the F5s and one or two f#5's either. Head voice/falsetto I have to give to Christina, overall she was more stable, had more freedom in the notes, a better tonal quality and more able to manouver around this register than Perrie although Perrie also did very well. I think even though I'm leaning slightly more towards Christina's technique overall, I do think they are very close, so I can see much of people's decisions in this being determined by who they prefer and then trying to justify by amplifying small differences or exaggerating flaws. In other words, it's a good way to see if you have more little mix fans or Xtina fans following your channel, lol.
Lows: Christina Mid belts: Tie Upper belts: Perrie Head voice: Perrie Overall they’re actually very close in terms of technique. Christina just supports a lot lower (down to E3) and Perrie has a more developed head voice, and is more free in upper belts. Also on the mid belts Perrie uses a more open “resonant” sound and Christina uses more (intentional) distortion but the support quality is actually about the same up to C#5/D5.
@@josivantorres2218 False information spread by Kpop fans. The same fans that said Ariana only supported up to B4 and Adele only supports up to A4 and is an “average” vocalist. KVA followers notoriously bring down western artists so that their faves are seen as more talented. Do your own research instead of blindly listening to biased “objective” analyses. Christina can not only support up to D5 but has produced resonance several times.
Christina showed she can still outsing almost everyone even today. How she maintained her voice is still a mystery lol. Perrie might be better in some areas, and she has a higher tessitura but her technique has been declining and so is her voice a little bit too unfortunately, she has to pass the test of the years for us to tell. So I think Christina for me💜
perrie for sure and tbh there could have been better examples for her in the lower and upper register but it would not have been too fair lol christina is an icon tho
@@popvocalstv there definitely coulda been better examples from G3 - F#3/F2 and definitely G#5 - C6. still, a fair video given that technique wise perrie is a good bit ahead imo even christina has shown proper technique before. great vid!
@@notyourdaddy2148 Well, I stand with the examples I used, tbh I wouldn't change anything I put in the video (and there isn't really a lot to work with in the low notes specially 😭), thanks for the support!
@@popvocalstv oh, as you should! the video was still great and like i said i don’t think it would be fair for christina anyway. is perrie’s B5 and C6 falsetto? it doesn’t sound like her usual head voice and im only used to her using her falsetto below F#5
IMO A3 equal G#3 Christina more clarity and depth G3 Perrie better tone and projection F#3 Equal F3 Equal E3 Perrie better tone and presence Eb3 Perrie better control and projection D3 pushed for both (neither ) C#3 neither A4 Perrie better control and tone and projection A4 Christina better power Bb4 Christina better power Bb4 Perrie better tone and technique B4 Perrie better openness B4 Christina better power C5 Perrie Christina’s was not as controlled C5 Perrie not strained or raspy C#5 Christina for power C#5 Perrie for tone C#5 Perrie for technique D5 neither both were tense D5 Perrie slightly better technique D5 Perrie better technique Eb5 neither but I guess Christina for technique Eb5 neither E5 Perrie healthier technique E5 Perrie not squeezed F5 neither but I guess Christina for technique and lack of tension F5 same as before F5 Perrie for connectedness F#5 Perrie for ease F#5 Christina for control G5 Perrie for control and power C#5 Perrie tone and lack of airiness D5 Perrie same reasons Eb5 Perrie for same reasons F5 Perrie for fullness and control G5 Christina for fullness and lack of airiness G#5 neither A5 Perrie for vibrato Bb5 Xtina Perrier sounded tense B5 Perrie for tone C6 neither both were pitchy C#6 Perrie for control and not sounding like a screech D6 Perrie same reasons Eb6 Perrie same reasons E6 Perrie for same reasons
I love both women, but it is not fair to compare the one to another, cause Christina is singing all of her songs by herself, where Perrie can take care, relax her vocals and come with the notes.
Low Notes: Xtina Belts : Tie (but Perrie’s technique is better) Mixed Notes: Perrie’s sound so much healthier Upper Register: Tie (Xtina’s is so gorgeous and pretty, while Perrie’s is so strong and operatic)
Perrie's voice has less tension, however, even though Xtina has some atrocious moments, atleast she can project hard. Perrie's tone isn't nearly as interesting as Xtina's.
xtina got the voice in every way....cos her voice have quality more than another singer....xtina have her own voice....i love perrie she include good singer n she has a voice too
Both have similar tones which is really pretty and thick. I think perries got lighter over the years compared to most of these old clips but still has some darkness imo. Now they both have annoying habits like over singing and just being over the top dragging out certain high notes and it just kinda ruins the song FOR ME and it’s like ok we get it you can hold your breath for a long time now relax 😅 they also put damage on their vocals doing all those unnecessary vocal holds and extensions but they are still really good vocalist. Now who is better I think Christina is. I’ve listened to here since the late 90’s early 2000’s and she just has not only a powerful voice but she can do more than just high notes. She can do many styles of singing and she is just iconic. I know many will come here and say perrie is better but I’m sorry she has to show me more in her solo career to surpass christina and what she did in little mix was great but the real showing will be by herself, people said she was held back in the group? Ok let’s see it.
@@dv4975 just admit you know nothing about Perries vocal capabilities because h the girl can literally do everything only thing she doesn’t do is that grunt sound Christina auguilera does and I say this as a fan of both, Perrie just approaches her singing in a healthier approach doesn’t dismiss xtina’s prowess
@@dv4975 if "tone" or "style" alone I would prefer Christina because she can do a lot of embellishments with her voice but Perrie's clearly the better vocalist here in technicality, note by note her delivery has more freedom and support from low to high.
Hope you liked It! 💙
Christina is the soul singer while Perrie is the technical vocalist - even though both have soulful voices 🩵💯
Perrie reminds of Christina Aguilera in some aspects meshed with Beyonce, Celine & Whitney Houston 🩵💯✨
Lows - Christina
Midbelts - Perrie (much better technique & resonance )
Upper Belts - Perrie
Falsetto - Christina
Head Voice - Perrie
Perrie is the better vocalist
I agree always with u ❤️
Yeah I agree!
Perrie is a queen of vocals. ❤
Fucking lies haha. Christina is better in every one
You can be a soul singer with proper technique. Pattie label, aretha Franklin, coko from swv just to name a few
Xtina would be the greatest vocalist OAT if she ditched that chest dominant mix
SO true 🎉🎉
She tries to act like a Mezzo & idk why. She is clearly a very high set Soprano but she sacrifices ease for a chesty powerful tone when she could just blend it together 😩
my thoughts exactly
This is my opinion:
Low Notes -
A3: Tie
G#3: Tie
G3: Tie (I would've given it to Perrie but hers was also near inaudible)
F#3: Christina
F3: Perrie
E3: Tie
Eb3: Christina
D3: Tie
C#3: Christina
Belts -
A4: Tie
A4: Tie
A4: Tie
Bb4: Perrie
Bb4: Perrie 100%
B4: Perrie
B4: Tie
B4: Tie
C5: Perrie (far healthier)
C5: Tie
C5: Perrie
C#5: Perrie
C#5: Perrie (one of her best C#5s)
C#5: Perrie
D5: Perrie (Christina's was...)
D5: Perrie
D5: Perrie
D5: Tie
Eb5: Tie
Eb5: Tie
Eb5: Perrie (even though she was lipsyncing)
Eb5: Perrie
E5: Tie
E5: Perrie (this note was also lipped)
E5: Perrie
F5: Perrie (even Perrie sang Christina's song better than her lol)
F5: Christina
F5: Perrie
F#5: Perrie
F#5: Perrie
F#5: Perrie (one of the most grounded and free F#5s she has EVER sung 😍😍😍)
G5: Tie
G5: Perrie
G#5: Perrie
Upper Register -
C#5: Christina (LOVE the vibrato)
D5: Perrie
Eb5: Perrie (Christina's fell a bit flat)
E5: Perrie
F5: Perrie
F#5: Perrie
G5: Christina
G#5: Tie
A5: Christina (Perrie's was lipsynced)
Bb5: Tie
B5: Tie
C6: Perrie
C#6: Tie
D6: Christina
Eb6: Christina
E6: Tie
Lows - Christina (8) > Perrie (6)
Belts - Perrie (33) > Christina (12)
Upper Register - Perrie (11) > Christina (10)
Christina has 30 points and Perrie has 50 points. Perrie wins by miles! Christina has such amazing control over her falsetto though! It's almost as rich as a proper head voice like Perrie's and her lows are no joke either but her belts need a LOT of work.
You pointing out some lipped notes but saying the Forget About Us F#5 is free and grounded when It's like clearly pre recorded It's sending me 🗣️
@@popvocalstv Perrie has been delivering some pretty good upper belts lately so it is very much possible that the whole performance was live. She has had almost 2 years of rest from live singing so I'm sure she has had lots of time to work on her weak areas. Plus, she has performed like 4 times in the past 2 years so her voice isn't getting worn out as easily as it usually would.
@@varunravi27 The high notes were pre recorded, as well as the E5 in Tears and some parts of iwdws, if you look at fancams you will notice the difference in volume + the fact that she moves her head exaggeratedly like she usually does when she's lip syncing, sadly the closest we have of live attempts of FAU's high notes is the acoustic version which is still not THAT live... 😕
You’re literally insane if you Think perri is better than Xtina
@@dv4975 Anyone that knows even a bit about vocal technique would know that Christina’s technique is not sustainable. People defend her horrible technique with excuses such as soulfulness but there have been and still are many soulful singers and vocalists that ALSO maintain good vocal technique, including Perrie. Frankly speaking, other than her falsetto and vocal agility, none of Christina’s vocal registers are anything special compared to Perrie’s. Perrie is a classically trained vocalist with development in all of her registers (her vocal agility does need some work though so I’ll give that to Christina).
Both sounds similar but Perrie has better technique, Xtina better tone & head voice!!
Great video
Yep I agree
Perrie is a queen of vocals. ❤
“Better technique” yet she can’t do 1 % of what Christina can
Perie has the better tone and hv.
Cuz that's not her style?
I prefer Perrie but I think they’re fairly equal in different ways. Christinas lows,agility,and head voice/falsetto seems to be superior to Perrie’s,but I think Perrie shines more in the belts and I think she just has a healthier way of approaching singing in general. Both are different but great singers. Maybe Perrie edges it out for me,but that doesn’t mean Christina isn’t really good. Just depends on if you like a more polished vocalist vs a more rough but equally compelling one
Christina is just a legend. Her voice can't be touched. But Perrie has a great technique
I completely agree
Perrie is a queen of vocals. ❤
Your opinion gave nothing.
I hope this new solo era sets Perrie as a well renowned vocalist like Christina already is since I think she’s amazing in her own right
Lower register: Christina.
Mid belts: tie.
Upper belts: Perrie.
Head voice: Perrie.
Falsetto: Christina.
So, it's a tie. Both are amazing! ❤️
@moonlightespt1946 you're right. Her agility is crazy, but Perrie has a better technique. So, it's pretty much a tie. ❤️
@moonlightespt1946 well, I'm not an expert, but I believe so actually. I'm talking about belting techniques specifically. You see, Christina is very well known for her raspy and growled vocals that she does all the time. That's very risky and can lead to vocal damage. She also tends to pull chest voice all the way up to those crazy high notes (E5/F5 and above). That's a bad technique, using mixed voice is the best choice. Also, most of the time, her belting is kinda forced/pushed. Sometimes, she sounds a bit throaty when belting because of the poor technique she's using, especially on higher notes. Perrie on the other hand does none of that. So, that's why I said Perrie uses proper techniques for singing, but Christina... Not so much. I respect your opinion too. After all, we can't deny that Christina is a vocal powerhouse and she's been a music icon for years. ❤️
@moonlightespt1946 you don't have to apologize at all. You're just trying to prove your point here by giving accurate and logical arguments, and I totally respect that. You're clearly very educated and experienced in this field and know a lot more than I do. So, it's literally not up to debate! 😂 You actually convinced me, well done! 👏 Have a great day/night! 💕
@moonlightespt1946 Well Perry has a better vibrato, consistency and her tehcnique as a whole is healthy in every aspect of her vocals. Xtina’s belting technique issue is a huge step back for her when it comes to VS battles.
Xtina can go both lower and higher than that, and her tone is incredible. But Perrie's belting range is just amazingg
Perrie❤
Perrie fucking Edwards 👑
Perrie for me, sound better. But the HV/Falsetto part, Xtina take that! Nice Collaboration and video!
❤❤❤
Perrie queen ❤🎉
I love Xtina's tone when she doesn't over do it.
Lows: Perrie
Mid Belts: Tie (I'm going with Xtina's more recent belts for that conclusion, Perrie has a slight edge though)
Upper Belts: Perrie, she's more consistent imo. But Xtina's recent attempts are surprisingly good, less strained than a few years ago.
Upper Register: tie, both are amazing. Perrie has, generally, a more classical sound and Christina is more contemporary, but the ease and healthy sound is there for both of them.
Overall, Perrie wins for me, but not by that much. Lows were the deciding factor.
Very good video. Perrie sounds much better
Really great video. As a fan of both, I think you made some really great choices to demonstrate their abilities whilst also demonstrating their styles. You chose interesting clips that I didn't expect to see, and although there were some clips that I thought would be good to include, I'm very satisfied with the clips you chose and really enjoyed the video.
I'm always so impressed by the hard work you put into these, even when you dont know the artist that well. You try to show everyone in the best light, be fair, and most importantly, be fun. I think you have one of the best vocals accounts out rn. ❤
They're surprisingly close looking at their techniques. Christina was better in the lows, but Perrie did really well, too. I think overall, Perrie beat Christina in the belts because of the upper belts, but they were very close up till and including the eb5 (although I know theres gonna be people in the comments confusing distortion/drive with strain as there always is). It's surprised me, tbh and Christina, gave Perrie a good run for her money on the E5s and wasn't too far off her on the F5s and one or two f#5's either. Head voice/falsetto I have to give to Christina, overall she was more stable, had more freedom in the notes, a better tonal quality and more able to manouver around this register than Perrie although Perrie also did very well. I think even though I'm leaning slightly more towards Christina's technique overall, I do think they are very close, so I can see much of people's decisions in this being determined by who they prefer and then trying to justify by amplifying small differences or exaggerating flaws. In other words, it's a good way to see if you have more little mix fans or Xtina fans following your channel, lol.
Thank you, that was cute 🥺
Lows: Christina
Mid belts: Tie
Upper belts: Perrie
Head voice: Perrie
Overall they’re actually very close in terms of technique. Christina just supports a lot lower (down to E3) and Perrie has a more developed head voice, and is more free in upper belts. Also on the mid belts Perrie uses a more open “resonant” sound and Christina uses more (intentional) distortion but the support quality is actually about the same up to C#5/D5.
Uuuhhh no for Christina’s support. The highest she’s ever supported was an A4 and consistently up to like an F4/G4
@@josivantorres2218 False information spread by Kpop fans. The same fans that said Ariana only supported up to B4 and Adele only supports up to A4 and is an “average” vocalist. KVA followers notoriously bring down western artists so that their faves are seen as more talented. Do your own research instead of blindly listening to biased “objective” analyses. Christina can not only support up to D5 but has produced resonance several times.
@@josivantorres22184:43 is blatantly supported
@@josivantorres22185:34 blatantly supported
Hv xtina definetly
Christina Aguilera
In belting its Perrie
And in low notes and falsetto/whistle register it’s definitely xtina
Christina showed she can still outsing almost everyone even today. How she maintained her voice is still a mystery lol. Perrie might be better in some areas, and she has a higher tessitura but her technique has been declining and so is her voice a little bit too unfortunately, she has to pass the test of the years for us to tell. So I think Christina for me💜
How?
Christina Ate
11:30 that was in my country 🥹💙
perrie for sure and tbh there could have been better examples for her in the lower and upper register but it would not have been too fair lol christina is an icon tho
For example?
@@popvocalstv there definitely coulda been better examples from G3 - F#3/F2 and definitely G#5 - C6. still, a fair video given that technique wise perrie is a good bit ahead imo even christina has shown proper technique before. great vid!
@@notyourdaddy2148 Well, I stand with the examples I used, tbh I wouldn't change anything I put in the video (and there isn't really a lot to work with in the low notes specially 😭), thanks for the support!
@@popvocalstv oh, as you should! the video was still great and like i said i don’t think it would be fair for christina anyway. is perrie’s B5 and C6 falsetto? it doesn’t sound like her usual head voice and im only used to her using her falsetto below F#5
For me its perrie, but at somethings chtistina is better
In My Opinion:
A3 - Xtina
G#3 - Xtina
G3 - Perrie
F#3 - Xtina
F3 - Perrie
E3 - Perrie
Eb3 - Xtina
D3 - Perrie
C#3 - Tie
A4 - Perrie
Bb4 - Tie
B4 - Perrie
C5 - Perrie
C#5 - Xtina
D5 - Perrie
Eb5 - Xtina
E5 - Tie
F5 - Xtina
F#5 - Perrie
G5 - Tie
G#5 - Tie
C#5 - Xtina
D5 - Xtina
Eb5 - Xtina
E5 - Xtina
F5 - Perrie
F#5 - Perrie
G5 - Xtina
G#5 - Xtina
A5 - Xtina
Bb5 - Tie
B5 - Xtina
C6 - Xtina
C#6 - Perrie
D6 - Perrie
Eb6 - Perrie
E6 - Xtina
Both are very similar and amazing vocalists , but i think perrie is technique better than Xtina .
Lows = xtina
High belt = perrie
Riffs and runs = xtina
Headvoice = both
Whistle = xtina
Christina: lows, mid belts, head voice, falseto, agility, runs and range;
Perrie: upper belts and support;
tie: vibrato
strain-na aguilera has a nice baritone voice
IMO
A3 equal
G#3 Christina more clarity and depth
G3 Perrie better tone and projection
F#3 Equal
F3 Equal
E3 Perrie better tone and presence
Eb3 Perrie better control and projection
D3 pushed for both (neither )
C#3 neither
A4 Perrie better control and tone and projection
A4 Christina better power
Bb4 Christina better power
Bb4 Perrie better tone and technique
B4 Perrie better openness
B4 Christina better power
C5 Perrie Christina’s was not as controlled
C5 Perrie not strained or raspy
C#5 Christina for power
C#5 Perrie for tone
C#5 Perrie for technique
D5 neither both were tense
D5 Perrie slightly better technique
D5 Perrie better technique
Eb5 neither but I guess Christina for technique
Eb5 neither
E5 Perrie healthier technique
E5 Perrie not squeezed
F5 neither but I guess Christina for technique and lack of tension
F5 same as before
F5 Perrie for connectedness
F#5 Perrie for ease
F#5 Christina for control
G5 Perrie for control and power
C#5 Perrie tone and lack of airiness
D5 Perrie same reasons
Eb5 Perrie for same reasons
F5 Perrie for fullness and control
G5 Christina for fullness and lack of airiness
G#5 neither
A5 Perrie for vibrato
Bb5 Xtina Perrier sounded tense
B5 Perrie for tone
C6 neither both were pitchy
C#6 Perrie for control and not sounding like a screech
D6 Perrie same reasons
Eb6 Perrie same reasons
E6 Perrie for same reasons
The reason I put some notes twice is because there were multiple clips for some notes
@@Oberatous-Udurabas you missed some clips tho 😭
@@popvocalstv wait really 😵💫
@@Oberatous-UdurabasMost of the notes had more then 2 examples and in most notes you only judged two 😭, also the G#5 Belt, E5 and F#5 hv
@@popvocalstv oh lol
Tone, HV, falsetto,lower I give to xtina,higher belts and technique I give to perry,total package as whole including versatility Christina Takes it..
Perrie has mor control in my opinion.
Vocal da Perrie é mais escuro q dá Christina,mas conseguem atingir as mesmas notas
I love both women, but it is not fair to compare the one to another, cause Christina is singing all of her songs by herself, where Perrie can take care, relax her vocals and come with the notes.
Οκ perrie hits the notes but she cant be compared to christinas tone, delivery and musicality
Christina aguilera canta demais
I love Perrie's F5. It's 😘
Christina's power is unmatched. She rocks. Her voice is like a storm
Low Notes: Xtina
Belts : Tie (but Perrie’s technique is better)
Mixed Notes: Perrie’s sound so much healthier
Upper Register: Tie (Xtina’s is so gorgeous and pretty, while Perrie’s is so strong and operatic)
Perrie is a better vocalist but both are really good
Perrie
Perrie for me, but the falsetto goes to Christina, and head voice for Perrie.
5:14 this transition is like butter ✨️✨️
Perrie's voice has less tension, however, even though Xtina has some atrocious moments, atleast she can project hard. Perrie's tone isn't nearly as interesting as Xtina's.
xtina got the voice in every way....cos her voice have quality more than another singer....xtina have her own voice....i love perrie she include good singer n she has a voice too
Christina is beyond Perri
not that far hun!!!
Yes beyond worse
@@sangtearalte5485 you are literally insane if you think perri is even close to Christina
@@dv4975 what???Perrie is an amazing singer too...just like christina...so what?!!
@@dv4975 you’re right. Perrie isn’t close to Christina cause Perrie is faaarrr better
Both have similar tones which is really pretty and thick. I think perries got lighter over the years compared to most of these old clips but still has some darkness imo. Now they both have annoying habits like over singing and just being over the top dragging out certain high notes and it just kinda ruins the song FOR ME and it’s like ok we get it you can hold your breath for a long time now relax 😅 they also put damage on their vocals doing all those unnecessary vocal holds and extensions but they are still really good vocalist. Now who is better I think Christina is. I’ve listened to here since the late 90’s early 2000’s and she just has not only a powerful voice but she can do more than just high notes. She can do many styles of singing and she is just iconic. I know many will come here and say perrie is better but I’m sorry she has to show me more in her solo career to surpass christina and what she did in little mix was great but the real showing will be by herself, people said she was held back in the group? Ok let’s see it.
both are still better than leighanne 🥰
@@wisqo2461 if you say so
@@AlwaysLM2011 just the truth
@@wisqo2461 if you say so
Both body leighannes weak bland vocals
The fact there are actual people who thinks Perrie is better than Christina is just insane 💀
cause technically she is better than Xtina, xtinas great Perries just a better vocalist
@@milkyteawithbiscuits3555 “technically” doesnt meant a thing in this debate. Christina can do a millions things perrie never could
@@dv4975 just admit you know nothing about Perries vocal capabilities because h the girl can literally do everything only thing she doesn’t do is that grunt sound Christina auguilera does and I say this as a fan of both, Perrie just approaches her singing in a healthier approach doesn’t dismiss xtina’s prowess
@@dv4975it's a vocal battle..so technicality played a huge role in this debate!!!!🙄
@@dv4975 if "tone" or "style" alone I would prefer Christina because she can do a lot of embellishments with her voice but Perrie's clearly the better vocalist here in technicality, note by note her delivery has more freedom and support from low to high.
Nothing compares to Xtina.
Btw I love them both so much