It's a great deck and I'm also a believer in you can make any commander cedh but this deck is almost the exact same thing as my atraxa superfriends and I'd say it's like a higher power casual edh deck It's too slow I'n most cedh pods and you aren't on like a stacks strategy to like limit your opponents or anything .tbh if you want to make a cedh atraxa you'd probably just use her for colors and use other win cons like a hulk pile or something
Atraxa sees play from what I have gathered, otherwise this seems like add mana crypt, mox*, fetch lands and dual lands. No to mention that most cEDH decks would be dead in the water without the mana suite including the crypt and such
Ichormoon Gauntlet definitely has a home in this list for sure. And Tekuthal is good in certain situations but not all the time so I’d have to say maybe on that one for now. I don’t like the new Vraska cause it only targets one player with poison tokens.
@@battlegrizz3687 with Atraxa as the commander and playing Superfriends definitely gives Tekuthal more credit than he's being given I think. I think he's definitely a value add.
I still have all the cards for the deck, but it’s currently not put together. I have a very large collection of singles and I like to make a new deck at least every 2 weeks to try out.
@@SupremeCommanderMTG Appreciate the feedback. You could make Atraxa “work”, but her skills are better suited for edh. And planeswalkers are too slow. Cedh decks would’ve combo-ed off by then. And you don’t have enough interactions to prevent that. IMO, this is definitely “high powered” edh. You have lots of good high-powered cards, and a game-winning combo. You may be taxing opponents a little, but the overall cmc of your spells is too high. And thus a little slow. Doubling season would be quite a waste at that cmc since you could play other game-winning spells for that cost. It’s great in regular commander, but you’d want to play something that is close to winning the game by then. I faced a staxier Atraxa once, and even then, Atraxa was not a factor at all. She doesn’t provide much value coming off the command zone. She’s not a combo piece, and doesn’t provide much card advantage. And casting her at WUBG is a lot trickier than casting someone like Kenrith at 5cmc who needs just 4W and has access to all 5 colors. And you don’t get any Dockside help either. For her colors in cedh, you are better off with TnT. I can definitely see this lighting up a regular edh pod though. How did this deck fare against other cedh decks?
In order for this deck to see Cedh Play you will want to incorporate some more stax pieces to slow others down while being able to still go off with planeswalkers. Consider looking into Winter Orb, Stasis, Tangle Wire, Ensnaring Bridge, Dovin Hand of Control, and more low cost lock downs like mentioned
It's a great deck and I'm also a believer in you can make any commander cedh but this deck is almost the exact same thing as my atraxa superfriends and I'd say it's like a higher power casual edh deck It's too slow I'n most cedh pods and you aren't on like a stacks strategy to like limit your opponents or anything .tbh if you want to make a cedh atraxa you'd probably just use her for colors and use other win cons like a hulk pile or something
Do you have a list that may have a better list?
Atraxa sees play from what I have gathered, otherwise this seems like add mana crypt, mox*, fetch lands and dual lands. No to mention that most cEDH decks would be dead in the water without the mana suite including the crypt and such
So would Ichormoon Gauntlet, or Tekuthal, Inquiry Dominusmake your cut? I have a very similar list and don't know if I'd okay those or the new Vraska
Ichormoon Gauntlet definitely has a home in this list for sure. And Tekuthal is good in certain situations but not all the time so I’d have to say maybe on that one for now. I don’t like the new Vraska cause it only targets one player with poison tokens.
@@SupremeCommanderMTG thanks for the reply! I'll have to really look at ny list ti figure out what to cut for Ichormoon
@@battlegrizz3687 with Atraxa as the commander and playing Superfriends definitely gives Tekuthal more credit than he's being given I think. I think he's definitely a value add.
There's a way to infinite ult The new vraska, but really not needed in comp probably
It’s really hard to see the cards, I think you may need to move the camera closer
I love this deck, do you still have it?
I still have all the cards for the deck, but it’s currently not put together. I have a very large collection of singles and I like to make a new deck at least every 2 weeks to try out.
@@SupremeCommanderMTGdo you have a deck list at all? The link in the description doesn’t work.
@@matthewlongden8513 same question
Nice cards. But this ain’t cedh
What makes you say that? I think you can make any commander into a CEDH version, they just have different power levels.
@@SupremeCommanderMTG Appreciate the feedback.
You could make Atraxa “work”, but her skills are better suited for edh. And planeswalkers are too slow. Cedh decks would’ve combo-ed off by then. And you don’t have enough interactions to prevent that.
IMO, this is definitely “high powered” edh. You have lots of good high-powered cards, and a game-winning combo.
You may be taxing opponents a little, but the overall cmc of your spells is too high. And thus a little slow.
Doubling season would be quite a waste at that cmc since you could play other game-winning spells for that cost. It’s great in regular commander, but you’d want to play something that is close to winning the game by then.
I faced a staxier Atraxa once, and even then, Atraxa was not a factor at all. She doesn’t provide much value coming off the command zone. She’s not a combo piece, and doesn’t provide much card advantage.
And casting her at WUBG is a lot trickier than casting someone like Kenrith at 5cmc who needs just 4W and has access to all 5 colors. And you don’t get any Dockside help either. For her colors in cedh, you are better off with TnT.
I can definitely see this lighting up a regular edh pod though.
How did this deck fare against other cedh decks?
In order for this deck to see Cedh Play you will want to incorporate some more stax pieces to slow others down while being able to still go off with planeswalkers. Consider looking into Winter Orb, Stasis, Tangle Wire, Ensnaring Bridge, Dovin Hand of Control, and more low cost lock downs like mentioned