If you look closely: Rufus Scrimgeour's body language shows that he was paying attention to Harry's snitch since he knew snitches have flesh memories and it contains something
@James Stockdale it's a good theory. The only thing that is proven is: Voldemort tortured Rufus for info and Voldemort's death eaters would show up when anyone said Voldemort's name. But touching harry? Not sure. Maybe he handed harry the snitch with the cloth for formality purposes and to protect the snitch. He handed Ron the deluminator with a cloth wrapped around it.
Good point, although I find the cloth a weird addition, considering it is unnecessary once the snitch had been touched/caught the first time. But I never noticed the details of this scene until after I read the books. Scrimgeour is very suspicious of the items in Dumbeldore's Will.
Dumbledore actually gave the cloak to Harry his first year and He also didn't come upon the resurrection stone until later in the books and he was always in possession of the elder wand
Isn't he in possession of those three at the same time? The cloak is in his possession all this time and at the time when he's ready facing death he has the resurrection stone, and that's after he disarmed Draco Malfoy. Am I wrong?
I didn’t like Rufus Scrimgeour, but I was very sad when I read that he was captured and horrifically tortured by Voldemort for information, yet he refused to give up Harry. What’s that saying, in their last moments people show you who they really are.
I mean what was his option?? He would die anyway - Voldemort would’ve not kept him alive and he wanted Voldemort dead and believed Harry could might be the only chance to achieve that so he didn’t give off information not bc he cared for Harry but bc he cared for all the innocent people that had to die on Voldemorts hands!
*Ron knew a book* that Hermione didn't! Funny, because Ron isn't a reader! 📚 *Hermione knew about flesh memories* though she lacked much knowledge about Quidditch! 🏰🧹 2:32 You can see Hermione is edgy about Harry taking the Snitch afraid it might reveal its secret in front of the Prime Minister. 💼
@@shangrencao1211 Hermione doesn’t know about the resurrection stone is inside the golden snitch. The only history I would at least Hermione know about would be the history of the golden snitch. Quidditch through the ages was not a story in the tale of beedle the bard. Quidditch through the ages is a separate book telling the story of the golden snitch and what it is. The resurrection stone was a secret that was not mentioned in the book. Just take it from me who has read all 7 books and the 3 library books (the tales of beedle the bard, quidditch through the ages, and Fantastic beasts and where to find them).
Hermione (and Harry) grew up in muggle families and her mother didn't read wizard tales to her. By the time she started reading wizard books, she was past the age of fairy tales. Ron grew up in a wizard family.
To Ron , it was a book his mom would read to the Weasley siblings. It should be a core memory of his childhood... whereas the ones brought up in the muggle families heard about the stories of knights and princes and mermaids etc . Hermione, of course knew about flesh memories, because her two friends were always talking about quidditch near her and she is intuitive, so thought that something should happen here ..
Well, Keep in mind that the snitch had the resurrection stone inside but since nobody knew that, So, At that moment, yes, Ron got the coolest thing. Good for him
Scrimgeour was brash on his approach, but he always meant well. And it's not that the trio didn't trust him, but knew it was wise to not be apart of the ministry since Voldemort would be looking for Harry, and any connection to the Ministry would be very easy to track.
Scrimgeour is very underrated in the films. Sure he never was the biggest character but defenetly one of the good guys. Even when getting tortured to death he never gave up on Harry's location and died to protect them
I mean, he's kind of right that Harry definitely doesn't have any claim to it, and neither does Dumbledore really. It presents itself to whomever it deems worthy.
@@lukesmith720 Yes. In the books he was tortured for Harry's whereabouts and even though Scrimgeour knew Harry was at the Weasleys he never said anything which saved the Weasleys from being tortured as well and bought Harry more time. It has a bigger impact in the book since Harry and Scrimgeour have a huge fight for their final conformation at the end of this scene. It makes him sacrifice more meaningful. I don't ever think it's mentioned in the movies.
My favorite part has always been the pronunciation of Ron’s full name - “Ronald Billius Weasley” !! Also of course, “Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore” !!! :D
let's appreciate for a moment how Emma Watson acts out something Hermione will state later in the film: she thought the snitch would open at Harry's touch. Before Harry takes the snitch, she's actually JUST about to say it when she finally decides not to.
@@yagirlzyier3142 Yeah you can also tell the minister (not trying to spell his name) was hoping it would open same as in the books. If you never read the books you wouldnt have known why the minister was acting like that toward the snitch
@@vikingthedude so first of all you need to know that the creator of snitch wears gloves while making the snitch. Once the snitch has been caught by the seeker it is preserved. The snitch won't open unless it receives the touch of the seeker who had caught it. Here the minister was expecting that once harry touches the snitch it would unveil the secret that Dumbledore probably would have tried to give through the snitch. But as you can see in the scene it doesn't open itself, if you remember how he caught his first snitch then you will know that it was in his mouth so the snitch would reveal the message once he keeps it in his mouth. That's why they are all so desperate here. P.s. I highly recommend you to read the books! They are so wholesome!
Scrimgeour is such an underrated character. He was one of the greatest aurors in history, was taken by surprise by Voldemort and had to fight him by himself and gave him a good fight before being killed, and would no doubt have been a great Minister for a long time had the former event not taken place. Possibly better than Shacklebolt became, although Kingsley was also a great auror and underrated in his own right.
@@John-yo4sz Then why did he try to follow through on Fudge's plan to get Harry to support the Ministry? Or covering up a mass breakout from Azkaban, or not reporting on Mad-Eye Moody's death whatsoever?
@@John-yo4sz Not to mention irascible. When Harry called out Scrimgeour for being incompetent and corrupt, Scrimgeour poked him with his wand. Burned a hole in Harry's shirt.
Caden Rolland What? That didn't seem like junk at all. Holy shit, if a device of which none other exists made by Dumbledore himself, a book from Dumbledore's personal collection, and the Golden Snitch from Harry's first ever Quidditch game seem like junk, I'd hate to be your parents at Christmas. Fuck me...
@@Ranger1812 Your arguments can easily be defeated. At the first glance, a device that can turn on and turn off lights would be fun to use but it wouldn't be that useful (remember i'm talking about at first glance, yes it will all be useful later), then we have a collection of children's fairytales, yeah it would be a read but not very helpful. And then we have a sports item that Harry caught on his first Quidditch game, like cmon, this would be the equivalant of giving me a sandwich i dropped at the park years ago (aside from placing a stone that can resurrect people in it).
@@Ranger1812 And yet he's still right. OK here, this is better. A magical light switch. Really? That's about as useful as a book of matches. And they all have wands so the light switch isn't looking useful at all. A fairy tale book? That is totally useless! If you get one for your birthday you're not going to be happy about it. The Golden Snitch. This is equivalent to getting the first baseball or Cricket ball you used to win your first game. That's got sentimental value, but you'd be expecting a lot more from the most powerful wizard of all time who was also your best friend. They were all expecting exciting and powerful magical items, not the equivalent of a book of matches.
Imagine being visited by literally the minister of wizarding world in britain just to tell you that the most powerful wizard even in death, still has favourites.
Emma was showing her talents in this scene. She barely speaks, but you can see the gears turning in Granger's head as she's trying to figure out the deeper meaning among the items.
Wow in the book Scrimgeour was full-on interrogating them about why Dumbledore left them these items. I really liked and trusted Scrimgeour when I first watched the movies (partly because I love Bill Nighy), but after reading the books I realize how untrustworthy he was.
He definitely seemed untrustworthy and not likeable too in the book version during this scene where he interrogates them about the items Dumbledore left them. However, after the wedding scene when Kingsley sends the Patronus to let them know the ministry has fallen it's later revealed that Voldermort tortured Scrimgeour to get the whereabouts of Harry which he didn't reveal, so Scrimgeour's last act before his death was to protect Harry.
It's not that he's untrustworthy; he's worry about millions of innocent lives, but because of Fudge's mistakes, he's not even given a fair chance to work with the people who might have the info needed to take Voldemort down.
His heart was in the right place but yeah, book Scrimgeour was a bit arse and honestly not that much better than fudge in certain aspects and just overall gave Harry a reason to be annoyed and not trust him. Movie Scrimgeour played by the brilliant Bill Nighy at least gives you the impression that he actually knows what he’s doing and takes the impending threat seriously while also having a calm yet stern demeanour similar to dumbledore
@@TheDeathmail honestly that’s what I’m saying he became the way he is due to all of the piled up mess and shit that was left behind from the past six movies/books so he really had no choice it’s like presidents whatever unwise or incompetent choices they make their predecessors always pay the price of their past mistakes
They imply it when Harry touches the snitch and nothing happens. He was expecting the skin contact to reveal something, but it didn't in this moment. Scrimgeour does this body jerk thing which makes it seem he was expecting something to happen.
@@tailsfan11westandwithukraine I just assumed it was to darken the street so he and those with him wouldn't be noticed. That's my best theory thought I'm doubting it myself since many other lights were still lit in the street and I'm quite surprised no one notice or at least heard the sound of the motorbike Hagrid arrived on. I haven't read the books so there's probably a reason behind it that I don't know. Or maybe the movie just wanted to show off their visual effects.
😌I know real Harry Potter fans felt the nostalgia when Ron received the deluminator . That was literally the first magic used in the opening scene of “The Philosophers stone”, when Dumbledore and Ms Mcgonagoll drop Harry off at Privet Drive as a baby.
Yesss definitely 1st nd 2nd part of deathly hallows brings all childhood memories back Like deluminator, gryffindor sword , golden ball , dobby's comeback 🥺❤
And it was also used by madeye in book 5. I remembered Sirius black, the deluminator and the gleam of triumph when the time came in books 3, 5 & 7 respectively
I much prefer the movies line of what Dumbeldore wrote in his will than that of the books. Movie: To Ronald Bilius Weasley, I leave my Deluminator. A device of my own making, in the hopes that when things seem most dark, it will show him the light. Book: To Ronald Bilius Weasley, I leave my Deluminator, in the hope that he will remember me when he uses it. The movie version sounds much more like something Dumbledore would say. And its great foreshadowing as to how he will use it.
Zealous It’s not just foreshadowing, it’s the truth. All of the messages Dumbledore left with his bequests were instructions disguised as personal messages. “in the hope that when things seem most dark, it will show him the light.” He disguised as hoping he uses the Deluminator well with its basic ability his hope that, if Ron walks out (because of the effect of the locket, lest we forget), the Deluminator will show him the ball of light from Hermione saying his name. “in the hope that she find it entertaining and instructive.” He disguises as the book being one of fun stories with morals the hope that she realises one of the stories (entertaining) will reveal information they need along with the sign the Deathly Hallows (instructive). “as a reminder of the rewards of perseverance and skill.” He disguises as a normal life lesson the wisdom and encouragement that they’re going to go through immense turmoil and tribulations, but they can do this immense task, as well as of course giving him a clue as to the mindset he’ll need to have, and hiding what Harry will need to help and comfort him as he walks to his supposed death.
He didn’t only know he wanted it - he told Harry he can’t do it alone, that he needs his friends (Dumbledore said that to him in the books) and he was right - Harry would’ve already died in book 1 without his friends and he always did everything with them yet they never get enough credit only the famous Harry Potter. He wasn’t any more special than they were he had just became a Horcrux bc the death spell went against Voldemort and by killing you split your soul (and one part of his soul held on to Harry) so Harry couldn’t die bc of the love due the sacrifice of his mother (Voldemort could not love) - that’s it Without Hermione they would’ve died in deathly hollows already in the beginning since she healed Ron from splintering preventing him to blead out (Harry had no idea) .. having made all the preparations in the bag - the books, the tent etc .. she saved him from Voldemort disappeared etc
To Ron the disluminator- Because Dumbledore knew we was hardheaded, hot tempered and would cause problems so he gave Ron a tool to guide him. To Hermione he left the storybook- He knew that the story of the three brothers, owners of the deathly Hollows, was there and she would figure it out. Harry the snitch- it’s obvious he knew the stone was there, since he had the cloak and knew was he was dead Voldy would go after the wand. He knew Harry would continue the journey and find a way to destroy Voldy. Plus, his portrait instructed Snape to give the sword to him so he could destroy the horucrux.
Harry does have a problem with care for others. But Ron talks some sense into him: “do you think that George took that curse for you?” I think Rufus is telling Harry something similar and recommending that he rely on others just as much as himself. And I agree with those points.
They should have had Scrimgeour mention that the Sword (and by extension the sorting hat) was the only relic left belonging to the founders of Hogwarts, as the Cup, Diadem and Locket had been missing for centuries. This would make Harry realize that perhaps (part of) the reason Dumbledore left him the sword was to prevent Voldemort from turning it into a Horcrux and that he must have stolen the other relics and wanted the sword to complete his collection.
Kind of the opposite. He withheld the items for a month, which is the legal limit the ministry is allowed to. They checked for everything and tried to find clues and meaning of why the three got those items.
Read the damn books!🤦♀️ it was the total opposite👌 That wasn’t Dumbledores will at all - he held the items away from them (which held them back) instead of doing his duty as a prime minister (which he absolutely sucked as) while hundreds of people out there died.. like Harry said „oh so that’s what you’ve been doing while people out there get slaughtered every day (…)“ Y‘all make everyone into a hero & throw the wildest most dum assumptions and other idiots believe it bc nobody bothered to read the originals
Dumbledore leaving ron this great diluminator then he leaves hermoine a book and she like um ok and then harry being is that it cause all he got was a snitch he is like but I'm the chosen one😂
Dumbledore was a beast it took what 7 wizards and him being hexed by a curse and not to mention he designed his own death now that speaks to his abilities no wonder Voldemort was afraid of him
there are so many as solutions that could've easily led to Harry finding the horcruxes and defeating them, but then it wouldn't have been as exciting and interesting.
It’s funny how watching back this, his reaction to giving Harry the snitch in hopes that it would open and reveal what’s inside but didn’t happen then, as it was later revealed since he caught the snitch with his mouth, he had to kiss it to open it 🤣
I never like they ditched hagrids character in every movie after first 2 movies. He has more screen time in first two and Harry Hagrid chemistry was so strong.
I think Dumbledore probably knew that the sword wasn't his to give and just snuck a mention of it into the will so that the gang would know it was important (which it was in destroying horcruxes).
Albus made this before he died, he wanted the Ministry of Magic to give it to the trio, but they had to inspect it first before they can present it. When they found that no dark magic was included, the minister got the go ahead. The minister for Magic visited the trio in the Burrow (the Weasleys house) and presented them items Dumbledore left for them to continue his hunt for Voldemort’s Horcruxs, Harry Potter was given the first snitch he has ever caught as a Quidditch seeker, Ron Weasley was given Albus’s Deluminator, Hermione Granger was given a book called the tales of Beedle the bard. Dumbledore also wanted to give the sword of Gryffindor to Harry, but the minister cannot since it did not technically belonged to Dumbledore.
The burrow looks so depressing in the later films. It was so lovely landing their in chamber of secrets. And in the books it doesn't change. Why do they suddenly live in the middle of a drab corn/wheat field/marsh. There's nothing whimsical about the structure, everyone is dressed in dark tones, everything looks dead and drab and dark. They're getting married in August ffs, it's still a joyous occasion. God I hate the Yates films.
Kinda says a lot about how Scrimgeours personality because he could've easily sent a low level staffer to do this or Mr Weasley himself but instead he personally goes to their house for this
Hard to find any scene after the first movie where Ron isn't made out to be a bumbling fool, and this is no different. In the BOOK Hermione doesn't even know what Beetle and the Bard is, since a nursery rhyme book/fairy tale book was irrelevant to her as an 11 year old newly learning that she's a witch. It astounds Harry that Ron knows of a book that Hermione does not. Here they just look at him like he's an idiot. More pathetic characterization and character assassination of Ron.
Scrimgour was expecting the snitch to open when Harry touched it, as was Hermione. His reaction is something only readers of the book would catch on to and understand why.
Funny how Ron and Harry gets cool things 1. Curious why he left them the items but 2. Hermione just gets a book like thinking uh ok? I will take that don’t think that I’d be interested in reading it though lol
If you look closely: Rufus Scrimgeour's body language shows that he was paying attention to Harry's snitch since he knew snitches have flesh memories and it contains something
Shang Ren Cao You don’t need to look closely.
Hermione did too.
James Stockdale ... no... why would that happen?
@James Stockdale it's a good theory. The only thing that is proven is: Voldemort tortured Rufus for info and Voldemort's death eaters would show up when anyone said Voldemort's name. But touching harry? Not sure. Maybe he handed harry the snitch with the cloth for formality purposes and to protect the snitch. He handed Ron the deluminator with a cloth wrapped around it.
Yeah I noticed it too! He was expecting for something to happen when Harry touched it, but got disappointed when nothing happened.
Good point, although I find the cloth a weird addition, considering it is unnecessary once the snitch had been touched/caught the first time. But I never noticed the details of this scene until after I read the books. Scrimgeour is very suspicious of the items in Dumbeldore's Will.
The fact that Dumbledore possessed the stone of resurrection, elder wand and cloak of invisibility is amazing to me
Ddlala63 ikr
making dumbledore the master of death
Dumbledore actually gave the cloak to Harry his first year and He also didn't come upon the resurrection stone until later in the books and he was always in possession of the elder wand
Isn't he in possession of those three at the same time? The cloak is in his possession all this time and at the time when he's ready facing death he has the resurrection stone, and that's after he disarmed Draco Malfoy. Am I wrong?
@@buck_williams8841 thanks dude
I didn’t like Rufus Scrimgeour, but I was very sad when I read that he was captured and horrifically tortured by Voldemort for information, yet he refused to give up Harry. What’s that saying, in their last moments people show you who they really are.
I mean what was his option??
He would die anyway - Voldemort would’ve not kept him alive and he wanted Voldemort dead and believed Harry could might be the only chance to achieve that so he didn’t give off information not bc he cared for Harry but bc he cared for all the innocent people that had to die on Voldemorts hands!
*Ron knew a book* that Hermione didn't! Funny, because Ron isn't a reader! 📚
*Hermione knew about flesh memories* though she lacked much knowledge about Quidditch! 🏰🧹 2:32 You can see Hermione is edgy about Harry taking the Snitch afraid it might reveal its secret in front of the Prime Minister. 💼
but if you look Scrimgeour's body language, he wanted to know what's inside of the snitch
@@shangrencao1211 Hermione doesn’t know about the resurrection stone is inside the golden snitch. The only history I would at least Hermione know about would be the history of the golden snitch. Quidditch through the ages was not a story in the tale of beedle the bard. Quidditch through the ages is a separate book telling the story of the golden snitch and what it is. The resurrection stone was a secret that was not mentioned in the book. Just take it from me who has read all 7 books and the 3 library books (the tales of beedle the bard, quidditch through the ages, and Fantastic beasts and where to find them).
Hermione (and Harry) grew up in muggle families and her mother didn't read wizard tales to her. By the time she started reading wizard books, she was past the age of fairy tales. Ron grew up in a wizard family.
She is rapemeat😊
To Ron , it was a book his mom would read to the Weasley siblings. It should be a core memory of his childhood... whereas the ones brought up in the muggle families heard about the stories of knights and princes and mermaids etc .
Hermione, of course knew about flesh memories, because her two friends were always talking about quidditch near her and she is intuitive, so thought that something should happen here ..
About time that Ron gets the coolest thing
Well, Keep in mind that the snitch had the resurrection stone inside but since nobody knew that, So, At that moment, yes, Ron got the coolest thing. Good for him
Not the snitch had the stone that it wayyyyy more powerful but they don’t know that yet
I like how Harry smiles a bit when reminiscing his first Quidditch match
Scrimgeour was brash on his approach, but he always meant well. And it's not that the trio didn't trust him, but knew it was wise to not be apart of the ministry since Voldemort would be looking for Harry, and any connection to the Ministry would be very easy to track.
Bill Nighly was excellent here!
Scrimgeour is very underrated in the films. Sure he never was the biggest character but defenetly one of the good guys. Even when getting tortured to death he never gave up on Harry's location and died to protect them
The amazing thing is, this was all part of Dumbledore's plan to take down Voldemort.
"Bloody hell... what's the ministry of magic doing here?"
Minister looking like he gonna tell the gang not to do drugs and to become a popstar instead because they give them to you for free
Only gigachads and gigachadesses get the reference
The second object Dumbledore left to Harry was the Sword of Gryffindor, but Scrimgeour refused to give it to him.
They didn’t have it anyway. Snape had it and secretly gave Harry
I mean, he's kind of right that Harry definitely doesn't have any claim to it, and neither does Dumbledore really. It presents itself to whomever it deems worthy.
Too bad Bill Nighy only had a short stint as Minister of Magic. The way the man delivers his lines is genius
He died a hero
Rufus Scrimgeour?
@@lukesmith720 Yes. In the books he was tortured for Harry's whereabouts and even though Scrimgeour knew Harry was at the Weasleys he never said anything which saved the Weasleys from being tortured as well and bought Harry more time. It has a bigger impact in the book since Harry and Scrimgeour have a huge fight for their final conformation at the end of this scene. It makes him sacrifice more meaningful. I don't ever think it's mentioned in the movies.
His voice reminds me so much of Jim Dale's who did the audiobooks of Harry Potter. Makes me feel nostalgic.
I think we both know the answer to that question Mr. Potter.
Clearly, we don't. Doesn't make any sense why he said it.
i feel like the direction and the editing are out of sync. bill nighy is being very large but the scene is very small.
also, the line "he's too strong," is rather meaningless as presented. strong in what sense? what's the actual danger scrimgeour is trying to convey?
I love how he says LAST will and TEStament
And the shocked face of Harry and Ron when Rufus mentioned Prof. Albus name
Like "what? He really knew he would be dead and made his last will on us?"
And the shocked face of Harry and Ron when Rufus mentioned Prof. Albus name
Like "what? He really knew he would be dead and made his last will on us?"
Ron & Hermione get 1 item each.
Harry gets 2 items to himself.
Ron & Hermione together: That’s not fair!!!!!!
From the the back view I thought the minister looked like snape. When I first watched it I thought wtf
Tbh I see what you mean by how he walks too
I love this scene in that the character of Rufus Scrimgeour speaks extremely clearly.
Ad của dây dừa này chưa bao giờ ngán giọng hát. Từ 2015 đến bây giờ.
its amazing to see davy Jones traded his claws and tentacles in for a wand and look at him now minister of magic
After he presented the items, he would be killed by Voldemort, causing the Ministry to fall.
My favorite part has always been the pronunciation of Ron’s full name - “Ronald Billius Weasley” !!
Also of course, “Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore” !!! :D
Hermione: It belongs to Harry!
Me: Hermione shut up!
Aint that the same actor that played Davy Jones?
Yes, Bill Nighy.
Straight up thought Ron as about to ask "What is it?", press a button, and it would turn on - just a regular battery flashlight.
The Lines About what dumbledore left Ron are better on screen than on page
Also, do you fear deaTH?
*grindelwald pointing the elder wand at the minister*
Do you?!
@@onelesslooseend1273 yer a cruel man, gallert grindelwald!
The full names were crazy 😂
Bill nighy😊
Bill Nighy the final bequest guy.
I wish Sirius black will in harry potter movie I wanna know what he does with 12 Grimald place and creture the house elf
That guy played davy Jones in pirates of the carribean
The minister pronounces “potter” weird xd
This scene reminds me of Transformers
Mr. Potter, do you fear death?
Ronald BBBBBBBBilius Weasley.
I suppose the idea was borrowed from Tolkien's 'The Lord of the Rings'
I never realized bill nighy is in this movie
Davy Jones 🤣
Yet and then they ask may he have been a relative,possibly an affair with Mrs Wesley......
george in the beginning-🦋🦋
Ikkk
yea
Yup
I don't know why? But I just love the way he said POOTER
Sameee
3:33
He said pooter 😅😅😏😏 er poo
xx DEMON xx No he clearly didn’t.
I think he said more of Harry James poeter
"...to Ronald *BILIUS* Weasley..."
Ikr if I was Harry or Hermione i would of cracked up.
@RANIA MALIK they were named phebion and Gideon
@@shiningpharaoh uhhh who
@@MyBitch925 he's talking about the Prewetts I guess. Fabian and Gideon prewett
@RANIA MALIK no his uncle
let's appreciate for a moment how Emma Watson acts out something Hermione will state later in the film: she thought the snitch would open at Harry's touch. Before Harry takes the snitch, she's actually JUST about to say it when she finally decides not to.
TheAnonymusVlog She's not about to say it, she's just looking in anticipation. Same with Scrimgeour.
Ben Tarr no she was about to say it cuz she said it in the books
@@yagirlzyier3142 Yeah you can also tell the minister (not trying to spell his name) was hoping it would open same as in the books. If you never read the books you wouldnt have known why the minister was acting like that toward the snitch
@@dylanrich69 why did he act like that? I didn't read the books
@@vikingthedude so first of all you need to know that the creator of snitch wears gloves while making the snitch. Once the snitch has been caught by the seeker it is preserved. The snitch won't open unless it receives the touch of the seeker who had caught it. Here the minister was expecting that once harry touches the snitch it would unveil the secret that Dumbledore probably would have tried to give through the snitch. But as you can see in the scene it doesn't open itself, if you remember how he caught his first snitch then you will know that it was in his mouth so the snitch would reveal the message once he keeps it in his mouth. That's why they are all so desperate here.
P.s. I highly recommend you to read the books! They are so wholesome!
Scrimgeour is such an underrated character. He was one of the greatest aurors in history, was taken by surprise by Voldemort and had to fight him by himself and gave him a good fight before being killed, and would no doubt have been a great Minister for a long time had the former event not taken place. Possibly better than Shacklebolt became, although Kingsley was also a great auror and underrated in his own right.
If you read the book, you'll see how corrupt Scrimgeour really was.
@@yosefdemby8792 I wouldn't say corrupt, more like really misguided.
@@John-yo4sz Then why did he try to follow through on Fudge's plan to get Harry to support the Ministry? Or covering up a mass breakout from Azkaban, or not reporting on Mad-Eye Moody's death whatsoever?
@@yosefdemby8792 I also see that as Scrimgeuor being misguided (and incompetent)
@@John-yo4sz Not to mention irascible. When Harry called out Scrimgeour for being incompetent and corrupt, Scrimgeour poked him with his wand. Burned a hole in Harry's shirt.
i love how when hes like babbity rabitty and her cackling stump,hermione and harry just look at him like he's crazy😂😂
🤣
Well they both grew up in Muggle households so I guess those tales are more common place in the Wizarding world
It all seemed like a bunch of junk but he knew that they'd figure it out. All those things were just what they needed.
Caden Rolland What? That didn't seem like junk at all. Holy shit, if a device of which none other exists made by Dumbledore himself, a book from Dumbledore's personal collection, and the Golden Snitch from Harry's first ever Quidditch game seem like junk, I'd hate to be your parents at Christmas. Fuck me...
@@Ranger1812 Your arguments can easily be defeated. At the first glance, a device that can turn on and turn off lights would be fun to use but it wouldn't be that useful (remember i'm talking about at first glance, yes it will all be useful later), then we have a collection of children's fairytales, yeah it would be a read but not very helpful. And then we have a sports item that Harry caught on his first Quidditch game, like cmon, this would be the equivalant of giving me a sandwich i dropped at the park years ago (aside from placing a stone that can resurrect people in it).
Ben Tarr Anger management classes for you sir.
@@Ranger1812 And yet he's still right.
OK here, this is better.
A magical light switch. Really? That's about as useful as a book of matches. And they all have wands so the light switch isn't looking useful at all.
A fairy tale book? That is totally useless! If you get one for your birthday you're not going to be happy about it.
The Golden Snitch. This is equivalent to getting the first baseball or Cricket ball you used to win your first game. That's got sentimental value, but you'd be expecting a lot more from the most powerful wizard of all time who was also your best friend. They were all expecting exciting and powerful magical items, not the equivalent of a book of matches.
Boxer Robert That was the appropriate response. I’m sick of idiocy not being ridiculed.
Imagine being visited by literally the minister of wizarding world in britain just to tell you that the most powerful wizard even in death, still has favourites.
Voldemort is the most powerful by far just not as smart
@@PDaddy0120 Dumbledore is more powerful than Tom. Voldemort was a close 2nd to Albus, but as Dumbledore said, Tom rarely learns from his mistakes.
Why wouldn't he...
@@elitegamer9310Exactly, even Voldemort knew that’s why all of his plans to attack Harry were with them being away from Dumbledore
Dumbledore wasn't biased he died for Draco not Harry
His voice is soo calming.
Right? He’d be great at ASMR
Not so much when he's the captain of the Flying dutchman 😎
@@longlivethevillain6945 exactly i kept thinking that, since he makes the same face expressions as he did as davy jones. But his normal voice is calm
@@longlivethevillain6945 at least he has a heart this time.
Emma was showing her talents in this scene. She barely speaks, but you can see the gears turning in Granger's head as she's trying to figure out the deeper meaning among the items.
...it's called acting. It's her job.
@@TaxingIsThieving and it’s worth highlighting when she does her job especially well, such as in this scene.
Wow in the book Scrimgeour was full-on interrogating them about why Dumbledore left them these items. I really liked and trusted Scrimgeour when I first watched the movies (partly because I love Bill Nighy), but after reading the books I realize how untrustworthy he was.
He definitely seemed untrustworthy and not likeable too in the book version during this scene where he interrogates them about the items Dumbledore left them. However, after the wedding scene when Kingsley sends the Patronus to let them know the ministry has fallen it's later revealed that Voldermort tortured Scrimgeour to get the whereabouts of Harry which he didn't reveal, so Scrimgeour's last act before his death was to protect Harry.
It's not that he's untrustworthy; he's worry about millions of innocent lives, but because of Fudge's mistakes, he's not even given a fair chance to work with the people who might have the info needed to take Voldemort down.
His heart was in the right place but yeah, book Scrimgeour was a bit arse and honestly not that much better than fudge in certain aspects and just overall gave Harry a reason to be annoyed and not trust him.
Movie Scrimgeour played by the brilliant Bill Nighy at least gives you the impression that he actually knows what he’s doing and takes the impending threat seriously while also having a calm yet stern demeanour similar to dumbledore
@@TheDeathmail honestly that’s what I’m saying he became the way he is due to all of the piled up mess and shit that was left behind from the past six movies/books so he really had no choice it’s like presidents whatever unwise or incompetent choices they make their predecessors always pay the price of their past mistakes
They imply it when Harry touches the snitch and nothing happens. He was expecting the skin contact to reveal something, but it didn't in this moment. Scrimgeour does this body jerk thing which makes it seem he was expecting something to happen.
Ron’s gift - albus used it beginning of first movie
We know
Before I watched the Deathly Hallows, I never thought I’d see it again. Why did Albus use it on those streetlights, anyway?
@@tailsfan11westandwithukraine I just assumed it was to darken the street so he and those with him wouldn't be noticed. That's my best theory thought I'm doubting it myself since many other lights were still lit in the street and I'm quite surprised no one notice or at least heard the sound of the motorbike Hagrid arrived on. I haven't read the books so there's probably a reason behind it that I don't know. Or maybe the movie just wanted to show off their visual effects.
@@LMC97 good guesses, all of them
Was also borrowed by moody in book 5, which was cut from the film
😌I know real Harry Potter fans felt the nostalgia when Ron received the deluminator . That was literally the first magic used in the opening scene of “The Philosophers stone”, when Dumbledore and Ms Mcgonagoll drop Harry off at Privet Drive as a baby.
this whole two part movie was filled with nostalgia from the first movie
Yesss definitely 1st nd 2nd part of deathly hallows brings all childhood memories back Like deluminator, gryffindor sword , golden ball , dobby's comeback 🥺❤
And back then it was still just called the Put-Outer. 😂😂😂
And it was also used by madeye in book 5. I remembered Sirius black, the deluminator and the gleam of triumph when the time came in books 3, 5 & 7 respectively
Fun fact: This is the same actor that played Davy Jones in pirates of the caribbean
He's also Quentin from The Boat that Rocked.
Bill Nighy?
That's, why im here
Same. Just found out and wanted to see again Lol I can still hear Davy Jones a little in his voice.
@@DragonGod24 yeah me too, such a underrated villian
I much prefer the movies line of what Dumbeldore wrote in his will than that of the books.
Movie: To Ronald Bilius Weasley, I leave my Deluminator. A device of my own making, in the hopes that when things seem most dark, it will show him the light.
Book: To Ronald Bilius Weasley, I leave my Deluminator, in the hope that he will remember me when he uses it.
The movie version sounds much more like something Dumbledore would say. And its great foreshadowing as to how he will use it.
Zealous It’s not just foreshadowing, it’s the truth.
All of the messages Dumbledore left with his bequests were instructions disguised as personal messages.
“in the hope that when things seem most dark, it will show him the light.”
He disguised as hoping he uses the Deluminator well with its basic ability his hope that, if Ron walks out (because of the effect of the locket, lest we forget), the Deluminator will show him the ball of light from Hermione saying his name.
“in the hope that she find it entertaining and instructive.”
He disguises as the book being one of fun stories with morals the hope that she realises one of the stories (entertaining) will reveal information they need along with the sign the Deathly Hallows (instructive).
“as a reminder of the rewards of perseverance and skill.”
He disguises as a normal life lesson the wisdom and encouragement that they’re going to go through immense turmoil and tribulations, but they can do this immense task, as well as of course giving him a clue as to the mindset he’ll need to have, and hiding what Harry will need to help and comfort him as he walks to his supposed death.
@@Ranger1812 I didn't remember the purpose of the book. Thanks
That's not quite right. Dumbledore is a lot more humorous in the books so adding this joke actually fits perfectly well.
But the movie doesn’t include Hermoine’s bit about the properties of the snitch and the creator who wears gloves…
happiness can be found in the darkest of times when one remembers to turn on the light
Dumbledore knew Harry's friends would help him destroy the Horcruxes and defeat Voldemort. He left them tools, not gifts.
He didn’t only know he wanted it - he told Harry he can’t do it alone, that he needs his friends (Dumbledore said that to him in the books) and he was right - Harry would’ve already died in book 1 without his friends and he always did everything with them yet they never get enough credit only the famous Harry Potter. He wasn’t any more special than they were he had just became a Horcrux bc the death spell went against Voldemort and by killing you split your soul (and one part of his soul held on to Harry) so Harry couldn’t die bc of the love due the sacrifice of his mother (Voldemort could not love)
- that’s it
Without Hermione they would’ve died in deathly hollows already in the beginning since she healed Ron from splintering preventing him to blead out (Harry had no idea) .. having made all the preparations in the bag - the books, the tent etc .. she saved him from Voldemort disappeared etc
To Ron the disluminator- Because Dumbledore knew we was hardheaded, hot tempered and would cause problems so he gave Ron a tool to guide him.
To Hermione he left the storybook- He knew that the story of the three brothers, owners of the deathly Hollows, was there and she would figure it out.
Harry the snitch- it’s obvious he knew the stone was there, since he had the cloak and knew was he was dead Voldy would go after the wand. He knew Harry would continue the journey and find a way to destroy Voldy. Plus, his portrait instructed Snape to give the sword to him so he could destroy the horucrux.
"You cant fight this war on your own" badass line
I always thought he said "you c3nt, fight this war on your own" because Harry Potter has bad relationship with Ministry of Magic.
@@alexbork4250😂😂😂
Harry does have a problem with care for others. But Ron talks some sense into him: “do you think that George took that curse for you?” I think Rufus is telling Harry something similar and recommending that he rely on others just as much as himself. And I agree with those points.
Bill Nighy absolutely killing It. As usual
LET NO JOYFUL VOICE BE HEARD - LET NO MAN LOOK UP AT THE SKY WITH HOPE - and let this say be cursed by we who ready to wake….THE KRAKEN
They should have had Scrimgeour mention that the Sword (and by extension the sorting hat) was the only relic left belonging to the founders of Hogwarts, as the Cup, Diadem and Locket had been missing for centuries. This would make Harry realize that perhaps (part of) the reason Dumbledore left him the sword was to prevent Voldemort from turning it into a Horcrux and that he must have stolen the other relics and wanted the sword to complete his collection.
I doubt the sword could be turned into a Horcrux after it absorbed basilisk poison.
I love how Schrimgeor knows that he doesnt have much time as Minister before Voldemort kills him so he decided to follow up on Dumbledore's last will
Kind of the opposite. He withheld the items for a month, which is the legal limit the ministry is allowed to. They checked for everything and tried to find clues and meaning of why the three got those items.
@@LuffyTwoYearsHow do you know this? Was it in the book?📕
@@yassinkoumaneh8288 Yes
@@yassinkoumaneh8288yess
Read the damn books!🤦♀️ it was the total opposite👌
That wasn’t Dumbledores will at all - he held the items away from them (which held them back) instead of doing his duty as a prime minister (which he absolutely sucked as) while hundreds of people out there died.. like Harry said „oh so that’s what you’ve been doing while people out there get slaughtered every day (…)“
Y‘all make everyone into a hero & throw the wildest most dum assumptions and other idiots believe it bc nobody bothered to read the originals
he looks like someone who Grindelwald owes a debt
Wow this comment jumps throught a lot of movies 😂
I see what you did there
lmao, nice take on that one
"Oh come on, Bappity rabbity! No?"
Ron so disappointed Hermoine and Harry dont know the wizard fairy tales 😂
The fact Harry doesn't get the sword here is the very reason they beat Voldemort
This man may be a right Bastard but a Bastard with honor. He chose death rather than betray a young man he barely knew by anything but reputation.
I really wish we had more scenes with Bill Nighy.
He was he was cast in Half Blood Prince.
@@AlinktoPersonabut the character wasn’t in the script
There's something amazing about the way he said "Bilius." That little headjerk he does right before he says it. Can't quite explain it.
Davy Jones meets Harry Potter
I never realized the actor played both roles!
And its funny cause the year after this movie came out a potc movie came out
pretty sure he has a rivalry against Gellert Grindelwald
Dumbledore leaving ron this great diluminator then he leaves hermoine a book and she like um ok and then harry being is that it cause all he got was a snitch he is like but I'm the chosen one😂
Dumbledore was a beast it took what 7 wizards and him being hexed by a curse and not to mention he designed his own death now that speaks to his abilities no wonder Voldemort was afraid of him
Am I the only one who finds this scene oddly soothing and slightly similar to an ASMR video?
what if Dumbledore left a portrait of himself to Harry, he could ask all the questions he had about everything =D
Maybe portraits of old Hogwarts headmasters are required to stay in the office
@@joewhitehead3 can there be two ?
there are so many as solutions that could've easily led to Harry finding the horcruxes and defeating them, but then it wouldn't have been as exciting and interesting.
@@harveyspecter1855
Yes, there can be two. And the Portrait occupants can move between the two. Like Phineas Black from the books.
@@harveyspecter1855 yeah. And they can move I think
It’s funny how watching back this, his reaction to giving Harry the snitch in hopes that it would open and reveal what’s inside but didn’t happen then, as it was later revealed since he caught the snitch with his mouth, he had to kiss it to open it 🤣
Actually in the book, Harry had to say to the snitch: I’m about to die
I found it weird that Hermione who actually knows so much thought just because the sword came to Harry's help, it becomes his.
She knows they gonna need the sword. Thats why she claims it.
The sword is inside the sorting hat the Fake sword is in bellatrix vualt in gringots.
Ron gets a deluminator Hermione gets a book Harry gets a fu##ing sword lol
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I never like they ditched hagrids character in every movie after first 2 movies. He has more screen time in first two and Harry Hagrid chemistry was so strong.
Well the movie’s technically rebooted after chamber of secrets
0:54 *B I L I U S*
PPPPP- O T T A H
Damn Davy Jones is going places, first a pirate and now minister for magic. Way to go man
This is my favorite scene from the later films, if not the entire series. It’s so tactile.
"I think we both know the answer to that, Mr. Potter"
Not really. There's about a dozen reasons you could conceivably want to speak to him, my dude...
I don't know why but i love Rufus 😳
I think Dumbledore probably knew that the sword wasn't his to give and just snuck a mention of it into the will so that the gang would know it was important (which it was in destroying horcruxes).
Fun fact Bill Nighy who played Scrimgeour did worked with David Yates on a telefilm
He's also the same guy who played Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean.
@@jaredruff9823 i know
Albus made this before he died, he wanted the Ministry of Magic to give it to the trio, but they had to inspect it first before they can present it. When they found that no dark magic was included, the minister got the go ahead. The minister for Magic visited the trio in the Burrow (the Weasleys house) and presented them items Dumbledore left for them to continue his hunt for Voldemort’s Horcruxs, Harry Potter was given the first snitch he has ever caught as a Quidditch seeker, Ron Weasley was given Albus’s Deluminator, Hermione Granger was given a book called the tales of Beedle the bard. Dumbledore also wanted to give the sword of Gryffindor to Harry, but the minister cannot since it did not technically belonged to Dumbledore.
I think Dumbledore knew that he couldn’t give Harry the sword. He was giving him a clue.
The burrow looks so depressing in the later films. It was so lovely landing their in chamber of secrets. And in the books it doesn't change. Why do they suddenly live in the middle of a drab corn/wheat field/marsh. There's nothing whimsical about the structure, everyone is dressed in dark tones, everything looks dead and drab and dark. They're getting married in August ffs, it's still a joyous occasion. God I hate the Yates films.
Kinda says a lot about how Scrimgeours personality because he could've easily sent a low level staffer to do this or Mr Weasley himself but instead he personally goes to their house for this
Hard to find any scene after the first movie where Ron isn't made out to be a bumbling fool, and this is no different. In the BOOK Hermione doesn't even know what Beetle and the Bard is, since a nursery rhyme book/fairy tale book was irrelevant to her as an 11 year old newly learning that she's a witch. It astounds Harry that Ron knows of a book that Hermione does not. Here they just look at him like he's an idiot. More pathetic characterization and character assassination of Ron.
3:16 Correcting Hermione?................SO YOU HAVE CHOSEN DEATH!
The sword may present itself to a worthy gryffindor, dat does not make it that wizards property
Isn't Davey Jones from Pitates the Minister??
Yep
“To HERMYYONEE JEAN GRANGER.”
I’m sorry but could you have said her first name any worse 😂😂
The way he says perseverance omg
Where's the flying dutchman?
Scrimgour was expecting the snitch to open when Harry touched it, as was Hermione. His reaction is something only readers of the book would catch on to and understand why.
That's because Harry caught the snitch in his mouth not by hand that's why when he put his lips on it the snitch opened up
Funny how Ron and Harry gets cool things 1. Curious why he left them the items but 2. Hermione just gets a book like thinking uh ok? I will take that don’t think that I’d be interested in reading it though lol
Is it just me, or is Scrimgeours Apparating sound louder than everyone else's?
Dumbledore and Snape apprition is silent apprition,a special ability.