I remember when I was younger I wasn't depressed.. but I would sit in my room and listen to music as if I was depressed.. fast forward to where I am today I'm so depressed and I'm not faking it
Silverstein's first album and A Static Lullaby's first album was my guilty pleasures back in the day. Now, just my personal pleasures everytime i play them CDs. That nostalgic rush, i'm an addict 😅
I can't say I envy your position, but in a curious way, I do. I envy your feelings whilst listening to this song, it reminds me of when my first-love gave up on me, suddenly, and without any valid explanation. Then just moved on another one. And I would listen to this... In a way, it was very comforting. I never understood that girl, she said liked me, she was also showing it. Now I just hear notes. Good luck on your recovery, time heals everything, you already know that.
I was on my 8th grade when I first heard this song from my classmate's MP3 player, that was 2007. Now I'm turning 30 and still listening to Silverstein. Damn I'm old
@bemy guest Evergreen are Post-Hardcore legends. But Silverstein is consistent in quality going on two decades. Imo Shane's word structure and vocals beat out Aaron's.
"Giving Up" I used to make the light shine for you, The sun has left my sky. Velvet walls surround my sorrows, I've sacrificed my pride. Giving up on me, You're giving up on me Giving up on me, You're giving up on me. I've laid myself to sleep tonight I know you've played out everything in your mind. And now you throw it all away, A shattered memory that you would stay. Through thick and thin with me, You're giving up on... Giving up on me, You're giving up on me Giving up on me, You're giving up on me. I've laid myself to sleep tonight I know you've played out everything in your mind, your mind And now you throw it all away A shattered memory that you would stay Through thick and thin with me. And when you feel the pain, I'm wishing I could stay. How can I say I love you back, You never made me happy. You've laid yourself to sleep! I never said this wouldn't hurt. You gave up everything! I never said I'd give it back. I know! (I know!) You'll never change! I won't be good enough for you. I know! (I know!) You'll make it through, I'll never be around to see. And now you throw it all away A shattered memory that you would stay Through thick and thin with me.
this. look at any rock band (of any subgenre) from the early to mid 2000s and look at how many views they get and compare it to modern trash. some of these soundcloud rappers have close to a billion views!
sigo escuchando estas canciones de cuando era adolescente y todavía me conmueve, de verdad muchas gracias por crear esto para gente como nosotros! ♥ ♥ ♥
Cualquiera escucharía está bella banda sus letras son tan duras yo tengo 37 años y siempre oi rock y metal pero esta banda en su época la dizfrute mucho es todo un clásico para la historia musical Larga vida para el rock ando roll saludos desde Perú 🤘 🇵🇪
2022, still coming back to Silverstein. They will forever be apart of my upbringing. My middle school years from 2008-2010 can never be forgotten with their music. Silverstein will always be a part of my music history.
This album is 20yrs old today and I’m still listening to it regularly. Can’t wait to see them at Riotfest and When We We’re Young festivals in Sept and Oct! 🤘
Seen em 6 ot 7 times when they were the best. It was my first concert before they even dropped an album. Along with hawthorn heights and Bayside. Been jamming these bands for 20+ years now. Please...go back and listen to these bands first couple albums.❤
first song from Silverstein I've listened to, just now in 2023 what can I say, fucking impressive, thanks for creating that, guys the video is 100% on point, straight up, no rubbish, early 00s are missed a lot, damn... we'll never be as young as we are at this moment
I feel like that when I listen to old Senses Fail compared to new Senses Fail. Buddy Neilsen was such a sad and angry teenager and now he's a super positive happy person
yo aquí en 2021 siendo seguidor y fan de estas grandes bandas y estas cosas, lo emo, lo punk rock, post hardcore etc. creo que cuando crezca recordare muy buena mi adolescencia y juventud :,))
I used to make the light shine for you. the sun has left my sky. velvet walls surround my sorrows. I've sacrificed my pride. you're giving up on me. I've laid myself to sleep tonight. I know you've played out everything in your mind. And now you throw it all away. A shattered memory that you would stay, through thick and thin with me. You're giving up on me. and when you feel the pain, I'm wishing I could stay. How can I say I love you back, you never made me happy. You've laid yourself to sleep, I never said this wouldn't hurt. You gave up everything; I never said I'd give it back. I know you'll never change; I won't be good enough for you. I know, you'll make it through, I'll never be around to see.
Cuando la perdi... dejo un vacío en mi corazón, se que esta en un lugar mejor, descansando en paz, en cambio yo viviendo un infierno... pero debo seguir adelante... y esta gran banda y su música me han ayudado mucho... siempre fan de Silverstein, he vivido lo peor y lo mejor, siempre recordare su musica
No one ever forgets their first true love which is what kills me to this day. Them 2000s era heartbreaks hit heavy. If you grew up in this era then you know.
In Chile a few people oly listen to this music, and i was talking before the "emo" culture dominates Chilean young. This was real music back in the time....2004 and 2005.
Alvaro Zambrano Si. Recuerdo que cuando comenzó esa ola de personas que usaban esa presunta estética sobre el "emo" muy pocas personas tenían idea de bandas como Silverstein y otras (para no comparar) desde antes. Creo que era una gran lucha hacer entender a esas personas que no era tan solo una cosa estética sino algo mucho más allá, como una salida a toda la mierda que rodeaba en esa época. asdjakldajls
This song made me take a huge interest in wanting to learn to play the drums when I was an 11 year old girl. I went on to play the drums for 8/9 years and even went to music college for music performance. All of my memories come flooding back when I hear this song.
I must say, I have been following this band since 05' and the way that this band jams in so right on point with solid punk rock music of the way it still should be today!! This band is serious talent and I recommend to the fullest!!!
Used to play the victory records sampler when I drove to school with my sister. This wasn’t never her type of music but she loved the songs on the sampler!
Shane Told is one of the greatest and most versatile performers to ever take the stage and he always has been. I appreciate that greatness is in the eye of the beholder but this is my take for those that are interested. I understand I will be talking to a lot of fans on here but just re-working my way through the back catologue and from where we start, at songs like this and "Smashed into pieces" through to "My Heroine" is big enough as it is. Worked my way through to "Bankrupt." (my latest gym smasher) and there is an immeasurable difference. I know this comment is focused around my opinion of Shane and his skills (and rightly so when most other bands of the era required TWO front men, let alone the same guy screaming then switching back and fourth between melody and brutality.) All credits to the other band members and their talents also. Shane is extremely unique and diverse a performer you will ever find to me though and I personally think it should be celebrated. I was at the very 1st Europe tour Silverstein ever performed at the Manchester, England, UK date and I will be at many more to come. Including the final as soon as they can afford to do the retirement tour rounds. Do we even need to discuss the epic Kanye cover of "Runaway?" This single alone still hits me as hard as my 1st listen.
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 1 // 100T vs FUT | FNC vs GEN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/erQ7pGChzxA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D1 | Summer | แข่งที่ไทย ต้องใส่ให้สุด](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jkuf7nCS7jI/mqdefault.jpg)
Anyone listening to this in 2024
I get emotional seeing people here bringing back their memories thanks to this song, it really captures a beautiful and innocent time in our lives.. 😢
cool comment.. Vibez.
yup, we're still here
Who else is here for Nostalgia?
We grew up listening to them. Especially in Jr High and High School
I remember when I was younger I wasn't depressed.. but I would sit in my room and listen to music as if I was depressed.. fast forward to where I am today I'm so depressed and I'm not faking it
Silverstein's first album and A Static Lullaby's first album was my guilty pleasures back in the day.
Now, just my personal pleasures everytime i play them CDs.
That nostalgic rush, i'm an addict 😅
I dont care if this early 2000s heartbreak. Its 2023 and my heart is broken and this was my go to song.
I had this song on repeat when I was heartbroken in 2007. It’s 2022 and I still love this song 💕
Same
Same😂
Who's still listening in 2023? I still can't live without Silverstein 😅
2024 here
@@musicilya6674 same
2020 still here not giving up
2021. This year this songs turns 18.
@@eliadigaetano3207 oh god we're old help
@@kyler3366 I'll turn 24 this month, that's not old! I 'only' discovered this song back in 2011 when I was 13.
My wife gave up on me
I can't say I envy your position, but in a curious way, I do.
I envy your feelings whilst listening to this song, it reminds me of when my first-love gave up on me, suddenly, and without any valid explanation. Then just moved on another one.
And I would listen to this... In a way, it was very comforting. I never understood that girl, she said liked me, she was also showing it.
Now I just hear notes. Good luck on your recovery, time heals everything, you already know that.
I was on my 8th grade when I first heard this song from my classmate's MP3 player, that was 2007. Now I'm turning 30 and still listening to Silverstein. Damn I'm old
Somehow one ends up here eventually
Same but im 23 lmao
Same but I’m 26 😢
I'm with you, bro.
Same boat and it honestly makes me smile
My life was awesome when this song came out. I had a lot of hope 20 years ago.
i am 24 and feel similar
@@xxfaze_brock_beast_lesnar_3891 24 as well and same
This is the kind of whiny vocals any emo band should model after, love this song, one of the greatest emo songs ive ever heard seriously
@bemy guest Evergreen are Post-Hardcore legends. But Silverstein is consistent in quality going on two decades.
Imo Shane's word structure and vocals beat out Aaron's.
based pinkerton pfp
not whiny, just them flooded emotions
they had the redux version, you should check it
Tom
Delonge?
What a banger. Great song from head to toe. Definition of an era.
Still blasting this in my car today and making other people uncomfortable. #2018
relatable
Was one of my fav song by silverstien
Niceeee.......
don't mind them they don't know what real music is,
Same in 2022
please someone bring me back to 2007
this is like 04 bro lol
i know but when i listend to it it was like 06-07 bro :D
Well, it won't be 2004-2007, but they do have a new album coming out this year. Their new single is pretty amazing sounding.
i just lold but yea this song is amazing
2dpp DAMN! I feel for you, thats 2 silversteinless years of life you had. lol
God, this song just opens the flood gates of an innocent time in my life where I thought my whole world was ending because of her.
"Giving Up"
I used to make the light shine for you,
The sun has left my sky.
Velvet walls surround my sorrows,
I've sacrificed my pride.
Giving up on me,
You're giving up on me
Giving up on me,
You're giving up on me.
I've laid myself to sleep tonight
I know you've played out everything in your mind.
And now you throw it all away,
A shattered memory that you would stay.
Through thick and thin with me,
You're giving up on...
Giving up on me,
You're giving up on me
Giving up on me,
You're giving up on me.
I've laid myself to sleep tonight
I know you've played out everything in your mind, your mind
And now you throw it all away
A shattered memory that you would stay
Through thick and thin with me.
And when you feel the pain,
I'm wishing I could stay.
How can I say I love you back,
You never made me happy.
You've laid yourself to sleep!
I never said this wouldn't hurt.
You gave up everything!
I never said I'd give it back.
I know! (I know!)
You'll never change!
I won't be good enough for you.
I know! (I know!)
You'll make it through,
I'll never be around to see.
And now you throw it all away
A shattered memory that you would stay
Through thick and thin with me.
❤
Ugh the memories 🖤
@@melodeeherrera5185 yep 👍🏾
Its really pathetic how these artists don't get the views and recognition that they deserve.
this. look at any rock band (of any subgenre) from the early to mid 2000s and look at how many views they get and compare it to modern trash. some of these soundcloud rappers have close to a billion views!
this video has almost a million view.
That's so true.
@@HisExcellencyx ikr
Well, this song came out before TH-cam even existed.
This whole song and the whole album is just depressing...
Most albums by Silverstein are sad/depressive/heartbreaking, if not all of them
Who's here in 2024?
🎉
sigo escuchando estas canciones de cuando era adolescente y todavía me conmueve, de verdad muchas gracias por crear esto para gente como nosotros! ♥ ♥ ♥
Cualquiera escucharía está bella banda sus letras son tan duras yo tengo 37 años y siempre oi rock y metal pero esta banda en su época la dizfrute mucho es todo un clásico para la historia musical
Larga vida para el rock ando roll saludos desde Perú 🤘 🇵🇪
Pura bellesa
Igual sigo escuchando esas canciones con un poco de phonk , saludos de Perú .
It’s 2024 and this shit is still a banger. ❤
Facts as a Scorpio homie too
5 years gone. Just like that. A shattered memory that you would stay through thick and thin with me. And now you've given up on me.
TwistinFool I just got divorced from the woman who I thought I would spend the rest of my life with, I know the hurt!
And that's why I don't trust women, Lol just got out of a relationship too
2 yrs gone* for me : /
How you doin today buddy? I see it's been 3 years. Hope things are lookin up now ❤
12 years gone here...
Imagine being 15 with a broken heart and hearing this for the first time when it got released. Oooooof.
2023-2024 im stil here not giving up
That intro ❤
Watching in 2015!
HOW DID YOU DO IT OMG
No, seriously, go fuck yourself
GodlikeCat lmfao cat loving nerd
GodlikeCat lmfao get fucking cancer bitch
watching in 2016. lol
watching in 2017. now wut
holy shit the nostalgia is real
Until now I'm so obsessed with this song. ❤️
Nice one ha
2023❤
2022, still coming back to Silverstein. They will forever be apart of my upbringing. My middle school years from 2008-2010 can never be forgotten with their music. Silverstein will always be a part of my music history.
This album is 20yrs old today and I’m still listening to it regularly. Can’t wait to see them at Riotfest and When We We’re Young festivals in Sept and Oct! 🤘
Seen em 6 ot 7 times when they were the best. It was my first concert before they even dropped an album. Along with hawthorn heights and Bayside. Been jamming these bands for 20+ years now. Please...go back and listen to these bands first couple albums.❤
I'm on a nostalgic binge right now
Sameeeee tears
Adrian M I am now too haha
Adrian M me 2
I listened to this close to 20 years ago. Still One of the best bands.
Holy shit the nostalgia
Old times, when my friends living in this World remember :(
This song never gets old.. still one of the best masterpiece I've ever heard
first song from Silverstein I've listened to, just now in 2023
what can I say, fucking impressive, thanks for creating that, guys
the video is 100% on point, straight up, no rubbish, early 00s are missed a lot, damn...
we'll never be as young as we are at this moment
My God, I never realized how much of a sad bastard Shane was.
But still, nostalgia won't let me forget this group/song.
I feel like that when I listen to old Senses Fail compared to new Senses Fail. Buddy Neilsen was such a sad and angry teenager and now he's a super positive happy person
Haha I know right? Same thing with old From First to Last.
Ryan N adderall does wonders
People change Bro!
And that's good!
Cause We're Humans & we need it to grow up!
@@rybread322 im 14 and i know silverstein and senses fail is that good? and im glad someone else knows senses fail😂
damn at 33 yrd old this makes me cry, i remeber being 16 17 playing this music video over and over again
I miss the days when me and the guy ive always loved used to sing these songs we were such big silverstein fans growing up
Absolutely love this album. Take me back to 05-07
i still have the album with the dvd. fucking bad ass
Trucker Bam I used to have it but that was long ago D;
I have to watch this video every night because I've lost just like this guy. I feel just like him
always and forever be here listening to this
Despues de mas de 10 años aun sigo escuchando silverstein, 2020 y seguimos contando
yo aquí en 2021 siendo seguidor y fan de estas grandes bandas y estas cosas, lo emo, lo punk rock, post hardcore etc. creo que cuando crezca recordare muy buena mi adolescencia y juventud :,))
Im still listen this songs 2023
I used to make the light shine for you. the sun has left my sky. velvet walls surround my sorrows. I've sacrificed my pride. you're giving up on me.
I've laid myself to sleep tonight. I know you've played out everything in your mind.
And now you throw it all away.
A shattered memory that you would stay, through thick and thin with me.
You're giving up on me. and when you feel the pain, I'm wishing I could stay.
How can I say I love you back, you never made me happy.
You've laid yourself to sleep, I never said this wouldn't hurt.
You gave up everything; I never said I'd give it back.
I know you'll never change; I won't be good enough for you.
I know, you'll make it through,
I'll never be around to see.
Awesome video from back in the day 📹
2022-2023 baby
Memories 😄😄😄
Underrated song. This has so much energy pain and love at the same time. One of my fav. Songs of Silverstein.
silverstein forever!!!
Redexs Francisco the newer album is so good
Cuando la perdi... dejo un vacío en mi corazón, se que esta en un lugar mejor, descansando en paz, en cambio yo viviendo un infierno... pero debo seguir adelante... y esta gran banda y su música me han ayudado mucho... siempre fan de Silverstein, he vivido lo peor y lo mejor, siempre recordare su musica
I love this band so much
"When Broken Is Easily Fixed" is my favorite album by Silverstein.
"Discovering the Waterfront" is my second favorite album by Silverstein.
No one ever forgets their first true love which is what kills me to this day. Them 2000s era heartbreaks hit heavy. If you grew up in this era then you know.
Más de una década y volver a escucharlos me trae nostalgia de mi adolescencia incomprendida. Me encantan por siempre ❤️
This is one of my favorite Silverstein songs. So good.
silverstein makes perfect music
now 2024 i'm f***in 29 Years old, this shit still make my hearts beat so fast
When we we're young
Yes sir 🤘🏼💯
I’ve loved this band for 20 years and it all started with this song!!!
In Chile a few people oly listen to this music, and i was talking before the "emo" culture dominates Chilean young. This was real music back in the time....2004 and 2005.
Alvaro Zambrano Si. Recuerdo que cuando comenzó esa ola de personas que usaban esa presunta estética sobre el "emo" muy pocas personas tenían idea de bandas como Silverstein y otras (para no comparar) desde antes. Creo que era una gran lucha hacer entender a esas personas que no era tan solo una cosa estética sino algo mucho más allá, como una salida a toda la mierda que rodeaba en esa época. asdjakldajls
+Alejandro De Arco Ahora se nota la gente que los escuchaba porque realmente les gustaba y no por una razón estética... Saludos :)
2018 aun en pie
2022 and I'm still here. 💔
I hope everybody here is doing okay in these trying times. Please stay safe.
❤❤❤
Nostalgia. Canada, thank you for Silverstein.
This song brings back so many memories during my teenage days 🥲
2021, Still here not given up
This song made me take a huge interest in wanting to learn to play the drums when I was an 11 year old girl. I went on to play the drums for 8/9 years and even went to music college for music performance.
All of my memories come flooding back when I hear this song.
This song was made 11 years ago. I was 3 wow this song is old but still an amazing song anyhow.❤️❤️
Reading your comment makes me feel old lol. I'm 29 and was in high school when this came out.
🤘 "I never said this wouldn't hurt"
Incredible lyric. Silverstein writes the best hooks!
I must say, I have been following this band since 05' and the way that this band jams in so right on point with solid punk rock music of the way it still should be today!! This band is serious talent and I recommend to the fullest!!!
This is true punk rock
If There's A Day We Can't Be Together, Keep Me In Your Heart, I'll Stay There Forever.
- Winnie The Pooh.
EVIL Co. wtf that's deep af
i still the feel the pain from the past
2021 i still listen
Used to play the victory records sampler when I drove to school with my sister. This wasn’t never her type of music but she loved the songs on the sampler!
Im 16 now and still a fucking emo, still listens to bands like Hawthorne heights, Armor for sleep, Saosin, etc.
Damn, we have plenty of things in common, that's also in my Playlist.
killanything inmyway666 wait till u turn 20, you'll hate yourself
The illuminati doesn't hate himself m8
are you still emo:)
I changed my name now
"I know you'll never change and I won't be good enough for you." This song is still one of my favourite by Silverstein ♥️
I wanna go back...
2017, 26 yrs old still here. thank you, and God bless.
i've laid myself to sleep tonight
the sound of my high school days....
good old days....
They just played in Burlington! ❤
Going on 33 years old n how I miss these times
Mi alma vuelve a rejuvenecer con este tema y mi corazón late con la misma intensidad de esa época tan hermosa de mi vida.
I'd be sad too if I broke up with a cute emo Winona Ryder look alike.
Same
gotta find me one of these girls
Ellescer ™ don't do it. it rarely ends well sincerely a "fixer upper" lmao
Nah. Legend has it, she got arrested for shoplifting.
Pump and dump bro pump and dump 😂
recuerdo cuando tenía 13 años
era el 2008
oooh
nostalgia....NA. Era el pasado nomás.
The quality of this video is terribly great. What a vibe
old time come back!!
2016 and still listening
Damn…… I miss her 😢
It really hurts when we stopped seeing this kind of music Nowadays
hey if you find any like this can u pmo i love this kinda music
Shane Told is one of the greatest and most versatile performers to ever take the stage and he always has been. I appreciate that greatness is in the eye of the beholder but this is my take for those that are interested. I understand I will be talking to a lot of fans on here but just re-working my way through the back catologue and from where we start, at songs like this and "Smashed into pieces" through to "My Heroine" is big enough as it is. Worked my way through to "Bankrupt." (my latest gym smasher) and there is an immeasurable difference. I know this comment is focused around my opinion of Shane and his skills (and rightly so when most other bands of the era required TWO front men, let alone the same guy screaming then switching back and fourth between melody and brutality.) All credits to the other band members and their talents also. Shane is extremely unique and diverse a performer you will ever find to me though and I personally think it should be celebrated. I was at the very 1st Europe tour Silverstein ever performed at the Manchester, England, UK date and I will be at many more to come. Including the final as soon as they can afford to do the retirement tour rounds. Do we even need to discuss the epic Kanye cover of "Runaway?" This single alone still hits me as hard as my 1st listen.
Las canciones de Silverstein
Me transportan al 2013/14
:')
Buenos tiempos
13/14?, esto me transporta al 2004-2007.
@@silvinocordovahuerta8387 cierto :v/
For About 4 minutes i turn back into a sad and chubby 15 year old. Good times.
You're giving up on meeeeeeeeh
Silverstein 💜🖤
what’s a chola like you listening to alternative 🤨
Depression was better back then