Should we analyze only the main/strongest vocalists next? How about boy group version too? Boy Group Version: th-cam.com/video/s9XtA38E_o8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=rnMPPYzQJBhqMVQC Exciting News! This video is proudly sponsored by the premier destination for KPOP fashion! Dive into the world of K-fashion with us: 🛒 Explore our collections here: www.fashionchingu.com/?TH-cam&Social&EKCristobal& 🌎 Global Shipping available! (With a few exceptions) 📦 Enjoy Free Delivery on orders exceeding 60 USD! Get ready to elevate your style game!
Didnt this channel used to do boygroups before but then deleted it? Its a shame really.. You guys had some great videos for bg before. Hopefully its not gonna be the same thing just with different editing
Yep! They had been going viral so many times for their dancing skills and not just their live vocals. It's the way Julie hits the beats perfectly and cleanly, while Natty known for the way she has 'groove' and makes people want to watch her dance. Even famous professional dancers in Korea compliments the two. As for Belle, her vocal range is huge and Haneul is getting known for being stable on stage when she sings. KIOF is so talented.
@@Abbieh07CB okay that some type of lie! Idk what ur blabbering about! Ruka is better then Kiss of life and the whole of babymonster is better then kiof
Top 3 things I agree with the analysis: 1. BABYMONSTER is the 5th gen best female group in terms of vocals. 2. Belle and Dahyun are indeed the top girl group members in terms of vocals in the 5th gen. 3. Gehlee needs more lines to sing!
I think babymonster is the best 5th gen female group in terms of both vocals and rap Because asa and ruka are such excellent Rappers and Ahyeon and Chiquita are good too
Vocal and rap as a group, yes! Baemon is the front runner (within this list only, I would have to delve more into other groups). As for the dance department, they could also be, as a group (considering all the skills of the members, not just the top dancers). Their well-balanced dance skills extend to their dance with no bad dancers at all, so this would elevate them collectively. But I’ll be talking with my dancer friend first before arriving at a conclusion.
Kiof, Baby monster, and Unis gave me hope in 5th gen. Listen y’all Unis is full of minors yeah but they are talented. Hybe keeps giving us uncooked ggs and it doesn’t taste good. And k-netizens say Itzy had bad vocals 😅
The fact that Unis immediately debuted with just 2 months of preparation but is not afraid of singing live, they really need more recognition alongside with kiof! They're both underrated:((
@@whoopthy Hybe is probably seeing all of the comments about their vocal training and hopefully they will try to improve them 🤷♀🤷♀ Its okay to criticize things when they're true
@@thekpopcroww Hybe is an entertainment company which wants to make money and seemingly the best way is to have a lot of gp support and fans. Both fans and the gp are going to care more about what music they like than the most holy talented vocal group in a generation. Seeing their idols at the top gives them the idea they are going the right way with no need to change it. The hate train towards illit and lsf will just make them take proper legal action to protect their artists, which means there is very little chance they’ll see the actually valid constructive criticism, but even then there is very little of that
It is funny to me how many people do not yet know that both Ruka & Asa are skilled vocalists with beautiful vocal tone, color, and texture and can hit some amazing notes.
Unis members are still young, for sure many of them will debut as a 6th Gen group. Since we all knew that Unis ain't a permanent group, they are project group bound for disbandment.
@@seunkwoo that's your opinion, we are all entitled to our own opinions. If that's what you want to believe let it be, I dont want to argue with you, I think you're old enough to watch and hear to music shows and performaces
@JisooLisaRosemyqueen Unfortunately views mean nothing these days. 72 million of the views on Stuck in the middle are ad views meaning it would only have around 40 million views without ads. On the other hand, magnetic has 88 million views with only 11 million ad views which gives them around 77 million views without ads.
The fact Unis has different vocal ranges and colors the potential they have in the future if fully nourished was incredible knowing how good they are at such a young age.
I still don’t get it when bmon use a lot of deep tones but they do good and go viral. I just think that the company or the producers doesn’t know how to utilize her tone because from what i’ve seen, they are going for high pitch songs which to me is not what the audience are looking for in this era of music.
The one I love the most in every UNIS member are their visuals and vocal stability, even when singing live while dancing. As a rookie, they can really improve a lot and learn more as they move forward. UNIS Fighting! ❤
Exactly, they have a long way to go! Considering how their training ground was only the survival show with 2months prior preparing for their debut shows that they really need to be recognized more with their talent as they have.
they are still young for sure many of them will debut as a 6th Gen group. Since we all knew that Unis ain't a permanent group. A project group bound for disbandment.
The best thing about it all is that you can see that these girls are learning and actively improving and hellllll I can't wait to see what absolute units some of them grow into in the future
elisia's voice is a gift that cannot be obtained through training, The high voice you get in practice many times when singing high songs, but the beautiful voice is a gift that few have received
So true...effortless while others when they are singing like they are thinking what to do next yet the sound coming out is ordinary and weak. Elisia's voice is a gift, the tone coming out is nowhere like anyother makes you calm and happy and light is a gift..natural vibrato and resonance is mesmerizing and strong. Even when she dances, that throat is still giving out a voice that that's a gift...she's still young and in my opinion, she is the strongest vocalist of them all being the most stable with dancing, therefore she is the real monster.
The analysis is so true Honestly UNIS now are nothing compared to them in Universe Ticket, they havent show their full potential yet, hopefully next comeback they give fair lines to the members and some cool concept like in the Universe Ticket, they're very talented despite being so young, im wishing f&f give them a song where the 2 main vocalist have highnotes or sing the highnote together like in their performance "Beautiful" by Wannaone in Universe Ticket, i wanna hear Elisia's falsetto and doing vibrato again. F&F is spoiling everafters since they said that they will release 3 mini album this year❤
YG deserves criticism for mismanaging their groups, but when they debut a girl group they are ready for primetime performances, and better prepared to perform at Coachella than a group like Le Sserafim.
UNIS members are still young and their vocals are still developing. These are their raw talents being showcased to the world compared with the others who had years of training before debuting as a group.
I totally agree with your technical evaluation and analysis. Also agree with the current level with UNIS. All UNIS's vocals except heonju are on the process of maturing as they are too young and growing, with the help of continuous vocal training, base on their current exposure (vocally) UNIS will possibly become a vocal powerhouse after two years as the earliest base on my opinion. Gehlee is the most underrated and underused vocally, she provides alot of depth and color for overall group vocal quality and harmonization. A natural talented Alto tone is widely recognized, honed and maximized by solo or group artists in the Philippines, North America and Latin Countries. Overall what we love about UNIS is their remarkable growth and big potential to become one of the powerhouse of 5th gen within nearing their end of contract.
from what i’ve heard, gehlee requested little lines bc she’s not very confident with her korean speaking (if you notice she’s taken a lot of english lines) and she wanted to focus on her dancing as well. but i don’t think there’s any excuses for giving elisia little to no lines as the main vocalist
@@astervotyI think this was the part gehlee requested of few lines during what is love performance based from what gehlee's mother told us. What concerns me is all songs from UNIS, Gehlee is one of the or the least lines wherein her vocal texture is rare and vocal quality is average yet she was underutilized. Anyways I am very hopeful that their next album would be different.
@@peterpaulvillapez4750 Rather than more lines, people should push for songs that would better maximize their unique tones. Like both Yoona (main rapper) and Gehlee (probably sub vocal and sub rapper) were severely underutilized in their debut album and have the least lines because the songs there were not rap heavy. I think more lines would be given to them if some of the songs chosen for their CB would be heavier on rock/rap.
@@astervoty Eli has the third most lines in their debut album though, so she actually had quite a lot of lines. As for being main vocalist, she is one, but I think she's not holding that role for their debut album. As what we've seen in Universe Ticket, there could only be one MV in a song. Also, following the pattern in groups with more than 1 main vocal, there may be a shifting of roles - Seowon and Eli would probably switch, with Eli taking the MV role for the comeback and Seowon taking a step back. This would also allow Seowon to rest her voice as she's been straining it hard for more than 2 months.
UNIS are full of raw talents and unique visuals. They did not have the years of professional training that other groups have before their debut because they debuted immediately after winning the UT global audition. I follow them because I want to see their journey from an unknown group from a new company, and see how they develop and excel as a global k-pop girl group. I also followed BTS from being an unknown group in 2016 under an unknown company to where they are today.
Belle & Dahyun are the best individually, BabyMonster is the best all-around, & UNIS has the best potential because their vocalists have good foundations & are all still very young. overall, the 5th gen kpop are in very good hands.
Gehlee and Nana as well as Kotoko have quite unique voices- the thing is, F&F entertainment doesn’t know how to use those tones in Unis’s songs. Unis is one of those 5th gen groups who can sing live. The good thing with Unis is that the company doesn’t force the members out of their comfort zone (singing wise) like Be Lift did with Moka, yet Unis still provides a reasonably good performance considering they just debuted and to a lot of the members it’s new to be perform front of so many people. I think one of the main reasons Unis isn’t popular even though they have the skills is because they are under a new and quite unknown company. I hope in the future more people will stan them and they will get more noticed. Imo I think a lot of people don’t know that Unis debuted from the same survival show that the Vanesya meme came from. And to all those people who will refuse to listen to Unis’s music because of their age: It's unfortunate to see people criticizing Unis and other young K-pop groups solely based on their age. While it's understandable to have concerns about the pressure and expectations placed on young artists, it's important to recognize that many successful K-pop groups have debuted at a similar age, (e.g Newjeans, Lesserafim- I said *similar* not *the same* ) Instead of focusing on age, we should be evaluating these groups based on their music, performances, and potential. Unis has already shown impressive talent and dedication to their craft, and I believe they have the potential to become one of the leading groups in the industry. Instead of tearing them down, we should be supporting and encouraging them to continue improving and growing as artists. After all, age is just a number, and true talent is timeless. The lineup has already been decided and there’s nothing we can do about it. The only thing we can do is support the girls and protect them from all these haters hating on them for their age. Don’t bash me y’all 😭
@@eggiemybaby Yes, but she doesn't get too many lines, imo Gehlee's voice suits Unis's concept very well, but in the end, nobody can control F&F- my intention isn't saying "the company needs to give her more lines", it's more like "I hope F&F realizes that fans love Gehlee's voice and that she has good vocal control."
It's ironic how Runext fans actually considered Moka as a potential main vocal of the debut line up, but now she's considered the worst vocalist of the group😔
@@cannycounter Yeah voice editing make fans sometimes totally frog in the well. I coincidentally found discussion on reddit before Illit debut where people seriously though that Illit have better singers than BM.
most of Unis members are between the age of 14-16 years old vocal wise its not yet matured but they are already killin it live. their potential is on top.
I love this review I am only a UNIS Stan but I watch the whole video and nodded like it's cool to know other 5th gen GG's I hope for all of them to be successful and Improve in the future
@@EKCristobala year later tag this video and make another one that will compare and contrast their skills as of now to their next year's skills. Would really appreciate it❤
Every time YG make a new Boy group or Girl group. they are not disappoint the Audience because they know how to sing live and technique. That's the reason why YG different and unique to the other Agency in the Korea Entertainment.
Babymonster my fav id this gen 🔥 They was not loved at beginning for their song , but soon they started to get in hearts od people through their RAW TALENTS
@Nakarinification actually, if they win roty this year, f&f stated that they will extend the girls’ contract for 2 more years. so everafters are working extra hard to stream and vote these days
@@bhst7487 even if the account is actually made by a filipino, what’s wrong with it? made by one or not, you can’t deny the fact that they ACTUALLY have potential to rival the famous groups. they’re young, and there’s more to them that hasn’t been showcased yet. these girls are talented. more talented than you’d ever be..🗿
@Nakarinification roty IS the rookie award, roty literally just means rookie of the year... also it’s still possible if the fandom is putting the work. that mindset is what’s keeping underrated groups from rising bcs of ppl that has no belief in them bcs you guys are always ‘hybe this’ ‘yg that’ ‘jyp this’ ‘sm that’ ‘illit this’ ‘bm that’ and more bs💀
@Nakarinification you made the roty a big part of this convo when i literally just replied sumn to you about their contract extension. roty is literally out of the conversation but you lengthened it out🗿 i said they have the potential... idek why you bought up other groups in this convo
@@pieistasty just stating what the judges/unicorns and the people who have watched it and have agreed upon that those were the most genuine reactions/comments of praise towards a trainee in all of the history of any Group survival show in SKorea. So?
Thank you for doing this video! I know some people in the comments are upset and think you should have waited since 5th gen is still new but I think it's a good idea to have something that can show the growth of these groups since you'll most likely do more videos on all of them in the future👍 I really hope you can do an analysis or ranking of KIOF in all categories(vocal, dance, and rap) since they're about to hit their one-year mark; they've all shown amazing growth just in this one year so I'd love to see a breakdown of that as well as have something to compare to after more time passes. Since Julie, Natty, and Belle are considered some of the top idols in their main positions and Haneul is proving to be not far behind her unnies in any category I think it'd be a great video to demonstrate excellence in all of these categories with the KIOF girls as the example❤
@@taylorswift664 Belle actually worked under sm as a composer/songwriter she got close to ningning so she might have picked up some of sm vocal techniques
Elisia has the best vocal technique despite her young age. Her tone is pleasing unlike others who sound like they're screaming. She has great control and dynamics. And she doesn't just sing, she tells a story
I love kiss of life they are full of all rounders. Their concepts are unique as well, and I love how each of their songs are just bold and full of life. I guess they really up to their girl group name. #KissOfLife
How literally perfect was this analysis. You did an incredible job, and I'm impressed how accurately you called out TripleS and Kiss of Life's strengths and weaknesses. Your ranking was exactly what i was thinking following the analysis. Very fair and unbiased. I'm a big TripleS stan (Go Dahyun!!) but given your criteria it totally makes sense the group would land at middle of the pack. You even highlighted Shion's one performance of Girls Never Die when she took lead on Dahyun's notes! Like you literally missed Nothing. So impressed and will follow 👏🏼
In summary, ILLIT has the least vocal talent in this review and i hope Hybe will do something about it rather than just making their money pay for trophies or music chart ranking. Music lovers are not deaf so everyone will question why the girl group with no talent always win. And it will boomerang back to Hybe in a very negative way.
You made slandering. Although Illit's vocal technique is not good but they are already have fans before debut. Because they came from survival show. People vote them. Vocal technique can be learn.
cuz the "group with no talent" puts out the best songs, magnetic is like a 1000 times better song than sheesh, if yg stops producing shit songs with awful lyrics babymonster will get music show wins all of the time
You need to understand that most of the awards that can be earned in the K-pop industry rely heavily on the music and its performance (charts, streams, etc.). It doesn't matter whether the artist who releases the music is a good vocalist, dancer, rapper, or anything else. "Magnetic" is a viral hit, similar to "Cupid" by FIFTY FIFTY (though "Cupid" is much more popular). Even my family, friends, and classmates, who don't even listen to K-pop, know and dance to "Magnetic." Moreover, before it was even released, a little snippet from the highlight medley, which was released 10 days before their debut, had already gone viral. It gained around 10k-20k+ uses on TikTok and CapCut alone. That was before it was even released on all streaming platforms; it was just a little snippet. Literally, almost every community-whether K-pop, editing, gaming, anime, or just any videos-is using the "Magnetic" audio; it's really just that popular right now. In summary, if you want to win those awards, just release good music that will attract a lot of people.
@@bok402bok “Best songs” are subjective. Magnetic is catchy and in the dream-dance pop genre which is trendy amongst the generation nowadays. Although it DOES NOT show the members talents nor does it prove anything worth of a “debut” from a survival show. Sheesh is very objective. It’s a hip hop track with strong pre choruses and bridge. And it’s a pretty good damn debut for OT7 Baby Monster. So maybe the problem is that HYBE should really train their artists and also put the ones deserving to debut!.
I would like to point out that the one example they gave of UNIS Seowon straining her voice was when she was sick, before she debuted, and when she wasn't even performing. All that to say, I think she's amazing, and it says a lot about her that that's how far one has to dig to find an example of subpar vocals.
As a TripleS fan, I have to say I’m always impressed by DaHyun’s vocals… She doesn’t seem to have a limit. I’m so interested in keep discovering what the other members can bring to the table as members like Mayu,HyeRin, ShiOn and HaYeon seem to have pretty decent voices but we still haven’t heard them enough to have an opinion about their technique. I’m just willing to discover more about their capabilities and keep listening to DaHyun’s amazing voice
yeah, I think the whole analysis is fair but maybe the editor is not super knowledgeable about tripleS and the newer members because Sohyun is not even top 10 best vocalist in the group... there is Mayu, Nakyoung, Yubin, Hayeon, Seoah, Joobin, Kaede, Yooyeon, Chaeyeon, Seoyeon... tripleS is actually pretty stacked vocally. Even if most of these girls are not known for their high notes they sing so well and have beautiful voices! People should keep an eye on Seoah and Joobin, the maknaes. They will have more opportunities to showcase their talent later but I really love their vocal color.
@@GK-dl8bi I also agree with SoHyun. She has a deep voice and her voice is nice but she strains sometimes as she has more of a deep tone. I think especially Naky, Mayu, HaYeon (in Just Do It she carries the vocals with ShiOn) and JooBin. It’s true that we haven’t seen a lot of the maknae line but JooBin and SeoAh definitely have potential as they’re stated as Vocals in the group. Also I pretty have a lot of expectations about HaYeon’s vocals. Also I have to remember that HyeRin had really good vocals in the AAA and the LOVElution activities, is like she is not Main Vocal material but she has a lot of potential and she sounds actually pretty good live. We also don’t have to forget how much of an improvement Kaede and SoYeon have made in their vocals. Also I forgot about ChaeYeon, for me she seems quite strong live as well!!
@@GK-dl8bi Idk from a technical standpoint, it doesn’t seem like you’re that knowledgeable about tripleS. Sohyun has the second widest support range and has decent qualities when she sings in her comfortable register. Therefor, she is interchangeable with Jiwoo when it comes to vocals as they’re both 2/3rd place while Dahyun is 1st. ShiOn, Nakyoung, and Kotone are the only other members who’ve shown support thus far, hence why the editor said those things in the video
Unis is scary group it they try to cover every song. They can own them with their own version. Gehlee, Bang Yunha, Yoona are so underrated if you follow them during universe Ticket they are so good...
Most of the groups here are still young. So we can still have a lot of time for improvement. Especially Seowon of UNIS. Miss Girl legit is a 12 year old. Her voice is still going to mature.
Mayu, Kaede, Hayeon, nakyoung also have good imapact on the vocal line of TripleS. As you can check Kaede's note in call me baby cover and Door by Aria. 19:58 mayu's adlibs in Girls never stage, Hayeon whistle note in Just do it. Also other member still got a lot to show🫶🏻
tripleS has some great vocal talent. There are some members that simply didn't have the opportunity to show it yet but they will on smaller subunits in the near future!
Elisia isnt the most powerful vocalist but for me she has the most refined technique, she has complete control on her voice and can really be the best inside her vocal ranges❤
Our Elisia Seowon yunha and gehlee will be sure all rounder singer Unis was the most top 1 in terms of vocals skills there stable live performance while dancing was so impressive
Omg! Exactly, in reality only Nana and Kotoko that are weak in vocal, infact they are good but just strains a lot in live singing, others are so good! And like what you said, Yoona is an amazing vocalist with wide range, my favourite performance of her in UT era is DKWTD and SuperStar (?) I forgot the name, in two of those songs her positions are very different, one a vocalist and one a rapper, but both of those she devoured..! And not putting Hyenjou in the vocal line is kindda offensive! She's one of the best vocalist in every group she joins, her voice is soothing, smooth, and uniqe!
@@mukhlisnurdin2361 i 100% agree, Nana puts a lot of energy into her dance and i think thats why she has to strain her voice- people misunderstand her (not u), shes not a bad singer, she just has a different unique tone that the company doesnt quite know how to use. At least her and kotoko and the rest of unis r actually stable while singing live... im having flashbacks from moka... *im not hating on moka its hybes problem*
@@sttraw_beryy Yess..Nana is energetic in her dances, that's why her voice strains, I could understand it for Kotoko too, why? Cause her choreos are mostly bumpy and jumpy and it makes her voice doesn't sound clear, ngl producers always give Kotoko jumpy choreos so Kotoko shine more and be cute in every type of song when in reality gurl doesn't need those she's already cute in her own way..(-flashback of PD picking her for the "Special Performance" at a music show (SBS?) just because of that "kawaii" mini jump)
There are like 6/8 decent vocalist to the group, Hyeonju herself is a main Vocalist on her previous group and Yoona's stability is an advantage to be recognized as a good vocalist even tho her level isn't that high to Elisia and Seowon. The only 2 members of UNIS needs more improvement for their vocals, nonetheless they all deserve the recognition!^^
tripleS, the idol of all possibilities. A perfect tag for a group that has a growing potential in different aspects. 25% for a vocal line might be small for other people but other members can cover the other roles of an idol perfectly. Some members excells in dancing, some in rapping, some noticeable all rounders, and some just starting to show potential. They are a group that shows stable and non scaling growth. Waiting for your other videos with them and thank you for noticing their talents especially Dahyun in this area of skill ❤
I wonder if op took bsides into consideration for this: - Chaeyeon is one of tripleS’ better vocalists and she especially shines in bsides - Kaede is really good as well and her vocal color literally goes with any sound - Kotone is also someone with the potential to get better vocally as she is already pretty versatile in her voice - Mayu is extremely UNAPPRECIATED for her vocals even though she was one of the main vocals in the Evolution bsides, either singing lines Jiwoo got as well or having adlibs like in Heavy Metal Wings - Hayeon is pretty versatile in her voice and we know she can do whistle notes, we just need to hear her more - Joobin has a pretty mature voice considering she is an 09 liner so imagine how much better she will be when her voice matures more (Chiyu is literally her song) - Chaewon seems pretty good and versatile in what we heard of her in the bsides, she has potential to be the main vocal of Glow - Seoah is in the same case as Joobin of having an amazing voice despite being a 2010 girlie, she shines in the bsides and I think she will probably be Glow’s main vocal. TripleS has a crap load of members, so not everyone can showcase their talents in the title tracks, but looking into their bsides you can find so much potential in them.
@@QueenQueen0824I agree with all of this, while seeing who sang which part in the ot24 album I was especially surprised with Seoah and Joobin, they did some challenging vocal parts, I can't wait to see how they'll develop. About Kae and Mayu they're very underrated for a while already, I'm especially excited about Kaede development because she only trained as a dancer before entering Modhaus and she already improved so much, so it shows that Modhaus is training the girls properly, another proof of that is Jiwoo, although she was already decent during MTG, she improved A LOT in the past 2 years, she got soooo much better
Simultaneous singing and dancing, no one beats Elisia. She is on top, the most stable and most versatile and relaxed, effortless "Performer" amongst all these individuals and she is still young. As a group UNIS should ranked higher than 4...maybe 2nd. They only only have a two-week preparation prior to debut.
Based on my rank of those main vocalist here the list: 1) Dahyun Triple S (technique and vocal versality but need show her vocal color) 1) Rami (Strong vocal color and need to show more her techique) 2) Belle (Our ariana always slayed! But sometimes I found her vocal almost shaky) 3) Seowon and Elisia ( I love both, i believe their vocal skills will go further as their room to grow is so big!) Honorable: Minju.. I love her vocal color but she lacks of vocal range and technique, I believe if she trained so well then she can shows her true ability. Currently her vocal still same as the lead vocal position from a small company
If we're talking about vocals. Elisia is the one to look out for. She's still yound adn yet she's that good. Imagine what she can do with her voice in the future. Nott o mention she's filipina. If you know what i mean. 🙂
Kiss of life is SUPREMACY 🔥👑 And Natty and Julie are the hottest female idols , they drive you crazy with their movements, sensuality, their beauty and their stage presence 🤯🤯🔥🔥
Well I wouldn’t say very stable ( coming from an Asa bias) other then ahyeon, the rappers aren’t the best vocalist. Although Asa is decent, we haven’t seen enough of ruka yet
UNIS members during Universe Ticket is a different story. If you watch it you’ll know what kind of monsters Elisia, Seowon, Hyeonju, Bang Yunha and Gehlee are when it comes time to vocals and stage presence.
And then people be saying "Unis is so overrated" like where? They're so underrated where their MV didn't even reached 30M in just 1 month bro, they can call Unis "overrated" if they just debuted then like Their MV reached 30M or more in just 4days or 5days👁️👄👁️
All the vocalist on those groups are superb. Specially those whos already 20 as their vocal is already mold. I'm interested with those young ones from unis. They're really young yet they have so much potential. I'm excited to see them grow through the years. 😊
ELISIA eat your baby monster filo good in English can speak fluently unlike K-pop you insert filo in K-pop will be big problem in Korean 5th gen hahahha
ELISIA eat your baby monster filo good in English can speak fluently unlike K-pop you insert filo in K-pop will be big problem in Korean 5th gen hahahha
I'm a bbmonster fan and you're totally right: Rami and Rora have great technics Pharita can hit easily high notes because of her natural tone Ahyeon can hit easily belt notes because of her confidence and natural tone Chiquita has soft tone, but still getting better day by day
While I kind of agree with your analysis. You missed to mention that UNIS also sings live. Also, I think you missed heyunju and Yoona. They are very underrated but have very stable singing voices. However, I do agree Seowoon is still maturing and Nana Nd Kotoko just need to train about but right now they are decent still. If you would rank 5th gen by vocals I would put top 3 Baby Monster, KOL then UNIS
I can’t wait to see baby monster, kiss of life and UNIS TO GROW BECAUSE NO HAS SEE WHAT I HAVE SEEN!! These groups are more than people think they are❤so proud of them!!!
this was a good video, you where blunt and not sugar coating, i hope you continue to make videos like this so we(viewers) can see the progress of each GG.
Can you make an analysis of tripleS members only? I know there are a lot of members but I would love to see an analysis of them only (or maybe their possible vocal line?) because it's hard to find people talking about their vocals
Unis is a great group, very diverse vocal range and visuals and charm. F&F just needs to stop playing it safe and give them an all out song, otherwise they'd stay in mediocre rank and won't stand out.
This is a great analysis. I can say that it was objective and i love it, every take was supported. I totally agree with the rankings as well while i do wanna see UNIS rank higher(subjective), i can't help but agree with your takes. At the end of the day, its already good to see UNIS be on par of the top 5th gen girl groups knowing that most of them are still underdeveloped vocally due to less to training background. I wish nothing but success on all the girl groups and looking forward to see more group strive to be better and be on par with these 5 groups. cos right now, they are currently the standard of 5th gen KPOP.
I just want to say thank you so much for noticing Rora vocal abilities. I keep saying this that technically she’s at bar next to rami, she’s just overshadowed by ahyeon strong vocals and rami unique vocals and of course the other members’ popularity on top of that yg keep giving her small Lines on the side never giving her the chorus which is really sad. Pls support Rora as she is very underrated
she didn't say hyeonju can't . I have to agree on the analysis, the girls that were mentioned here were really greater vocalist than of Hyeonju, sad to say. She is my bias btw. Hyeonju!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Should we analyze only the main/strongest vocalists next? How about boy group version too?
Boy Group Version: th-cam.com/video/s9XtA38E_o8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=rnMPPYzQJBhqMVQC
Exciting News!
This video is proudly sponsored by the premier destination for KPOP fashion! Dive into the world of K-fashion with us:
🛒 Explore our collections here:
www.fashionchingu.com/?TH-cam&Social&EKCristobal&
🌎 Global Shipping available! (With a few exceptions)
📦 Enjoy Free Delivery on orders exceeding 60 USD!
Get ready to elevate your style game!
Yes sure
@@omartoothyes
@@Spacerecord-yv5ozlet’s go!
@@EKCristobal yah 🎉
Didnt this channel used to do boygroups before but then deleted it? Its a shame really.. You guys had some great videos for bg before. Hopefully its not gonna be the same thing just with different editing
The fact that Minju still singing using her former agency vocal technique speaks how her current agency trained their idols 😅
Is she the one from YG?
Yes@@Multifandomgirl1499
@@Multifandomgirl1499yes she was a yg trainee for many years (trained together with ruka)
it’s actually hard to change vocal habits but i still agree with your point
@@swxtner2076 Thank you so much. That's what I thought too after seeing their analysis that she's like a vocalist from YG.
the fun fact is KIOF is not just live vocal group. they are also outstanding dancers too. I believe Natty and Julie are top tier dancer
Yep! They had been going viral so many times for their dancing skills and not just their live vocals. It's the way Julie hits the beats perfectly and cleanly, while Natty known for the way she has 'groove' and makes people want to watch her dance. Even famous professional dancers in Korea compliments the two. As for Belle, her vocal range is huge and Haneul is getting known for being stable on stage when she sings. KIOF is so talented.
But so is Ruka,Asa,Rami,Chiquita and Ahyeon!
@@Kpop_BM07
We said top tier not average!
Ruka is the closest to Julie while others are average,Natty is the best!
@@Abbieh07CB okay that some type of lie!
Idk what ur blabbering about!
Ruka is better then Kiss of life and the whole of babymonster is better then kiof
@@Kpop_BM07 don't drag kiof just to praise your fave. they're both good, okay?
Top 3 things I agree with the analysis:
1. BABYMONSTER is the 5th gen best female group in terms of vocals.
2. Belle and Dahyun are indeed the top girl group members in terms of vocals in the 5th gen.
3. Gehlee needs more lines to sing!
I think babymonster is the best 5th gen female group in terms of both vocals and rap
Because asa and ruka are such excellent Rappers and Ahyeon and Chiquita are good too
Vocal and rap as a group, yes! Baemon is the front runner (within this list only, I would have to delve more into other groups). As for the dance department, they could also be, as a group (considering all the skills of the members, not just the top dancers). Their well-balanced dance skills extend to their dance with no bad dancers at all, so this would elevate them collectively. But I’ll be talking with my dancer friend first before arriving at a conclusion.
Gehlee asked for less lines lol
Well competition is coming with bad villain and they sang live
@@ilovekpop12345how did you know? You asked her?
Kiof, Baby monster, and Unis gave me hope in 5th gen. Listen y’all Unis is full of minors yeah but they are talented. Hybe keeps giving us uncooked ggs and it doesn’t taste good. And k-netizens say Itzy had bad vocals 😅
The fact that Unis immediately debuted with just 2 months of preparation but is not afraid of singing live, they really need more recognition alongside with kiof! They're both underrated:((
I don’t understand why y’all just don’t ignore hybe groups if you don’t like them?
@@whoopthy Hybe is probably seeing all of the comments about their vocal training and hopefully they will try to improve them 🤷♀🤷♀ Its okay to criticize things when they're true
@@thekpopcroww Hybe is an entertainment company which wants to make money and seemingly the best way is to have a lot of gp support and fans. Both fans and the gp are going to care more about what music they like than the most holy talented vocal group in a generation. Seeing their idols at the top gives them the idea they are going the right way with no need to change it. The hate train towards illit and lsf will just make them take proper legal action to protect their artists, which means there is very little chance they’ll see the actually valid constructive criticism, but even then there is very little of that
hybe bgs don't have that much technical skill in vocals too.
It is funny to me how many people do not yet know that both Ruka & Asa are skilled vocalists with beautiful vocal tone, color, and texture and can hit some amazing notes.
i would say talented more… the skilled vocalists are the strongest ones in baemon
Yes...they must be not the STRONG VOCALISTS but they are amazing singers... especially Asa...was blown away by her Me myself and I cover
Yea but they are underdeveloped vocally. Asa has potential.
It's a testament to how good their vocalists are.
they can't even produce light support sadly
it's okay, UNIS are still babies and have a lot more to learn, but watch out they are fast learners and full of potentials ❤
i believe they are the youngest by average here
@@EKCristobal their average is 16yr olds the youngest being 13 and only 1 adult being 23
Unis members are still young, for sure many of them will debut as a 6th Gen group. Since we all knew that Unis ain't a permanent group, they are project group bound for disbandment.
if they are babies and have alot to learn they shouldnt debut
@@seunkwoo that's your opinion, we are all entitled to our own opinions. If that's what you want to believe let it be, I dont want to argue with you, I think you're old enough to watch and hear to music shows and performaces
i hope babymonster gets some non ballad title tracks that really show off their vocals soon. i’m so desperate for a singing chorus
i wonder what their single will be next month. also i think a winter/Christmas ballad will be great too…
@@EKCristobalWe all had stuck in the middle and it flopped sadly
@@JB-45flopped? it’s a good song song with hella views and has hella streams lol
I agree, we had such a beautiful song and even that flopped 😢@@JB-45
@JisooLisaRosemyqueen Unfortunately views mean nothing these days. 72 million of the views on Stuck in the middle are ad views meaning it would only have around 40 million views without ads. On the other hand, magnetic has 88 million views with only 11 million ad views which gives them around 77 million views without ads.
I'm excited to see where you placed Belle, Seowon and Elisia!
it’s a group content hehe
illit being last is so ironic considering runext literally had vocalists like jiwoo, chanelle, and jeongeun.........
and the members sounded good DURING runext then drank hybe water
if Jiwoo, Chanelle, and Jungeun debuted with ILLIT, they could be 3rd in this analysis as a group…
@@ksoobynit was the editing.All of the perfomances were retouched
If RUNEXT wasn’t rigged illit would be a lot higher in this ranking
thats right, belift should've debuted the "bad boy unit"
The fact Unis has different vocal ranges and colors the potential they have in the future if fully nourished was incredible knowing how good they are at such a young age.
@Nakarinificationthey might consider making the contract longer !
@Nakarinification kep1er renewed and they're not necessarily big.
@Nakarinification 2 years and 6 months will be enough, considering them as they r from a new company.
@Nakarinificationi genuinely think they will renew their contract
@@Cl0ver_le4fythey will papa choi spoiling the girls because of rapid growth wait for it 🥰🫰
Gehlee’s voice is whole and deeper, which lends well for western music but kpop prefers the airy high pitch sounds
yes this is a factor
Agree! Her voice quality is perfect for western music
I still don’t get it when bmon use a lot of deep tones but they do good and go viral. I just think that the company or the producers doesn’t know how to utilize her tone because from what i’ve seen, they are going for high pitch songs which to me is not what the audience are looking for in this era of music.
Oh like chipmunks?
The one I love the most in every UNIS member are their visuals and vocal stability, even when singing live while dancing. As a rookie, they can really improve a lot and learn more as they move forward. UNIS Fighting! ❤
Exactly, they have a long way to go! Considering how their training ground was only the survival show with 2months prior preparing for their debut shows that they really need to be recognized more with their talent as they have.
and they are really young so there's a lot of room for improvement.
fighting 💪
they are still young for sure many of them will debut as a 6th Gen group. Since we all knew that Unis ain't a permanent group. A project group bound for disbandment.
The best thing about it all is that you can see that these girls are learning and actively improving and hellllll I can't wait to see what absolute units some of them grow into in the future
elisia's voice is a gift that cannot be obtained through training, The high voice you get in practice many times when singing high songs, but the beautiful voice is a gift that few have received
So true...effortless while others when they are singing like they are thinking what to do next yet the sound coming out is ordinary and weak. Elisia's voice is a gift, the tone coming out is nowhere like anyother makes you calm and happy and light is a gift..natural vibrato and resonance is mesmerizing and strong. Even when she dances, that throat is still giving out a voice that that's a gift...she's still young and in my opinion, she is the strongest vocalist of them all being the most stable with dancing, therefore she is the real monster.
Exactly even when she's jumping while singing, her voice stability is really amazing @@mikepadz1976
@@mikepadz1976that's a Filipino throat chakra 🧐 it could be more higher if she will
The analysis is so true
Honestly UNIS now are nothing compared to them in Universe Ticket, they havent show their full potential yet, hopefully next comeback they give fair lines to the members and some cool concept like in the Universe Ticket, they're very talented despite being so young, im wishing f&f give them a song where the 2 main vocalist have highnotes or sing the highnote together like in their performance "Beautiful" by Wannaone in Universe Ticket, i wanna hear Elisia's falsetto and doing vibrato again. F&F is spoiling everafters since they said that they will release 3 mini album this year❤
Wow I will buy that 🥰
Yes
YG deserves criticism for mismanaging their groups, but when they debut a girl group they are ready for primetime performances, and better prepared to perform at Coachella than a group like Le Sserafim.
Why did Le Sserafim have to be brought up when they aren’t even in the video?
@@jazzyedwards3871 cry about it
@@jazzyedwards3871 Why aren't they in the video? Don't they have vocalists good enough to be ranked?
@@iagreewithyou3478
Are they 5th gen?
@@unclejuan8301 With the rookie-like quality of their singing, they might as well be 5th gen.
UNIS members are still young and their vocals are still developing. These are their raw talents being showcased to the world compared with the others who had years of training before debuting as a group.
I just knew belle and dayhun would be the top individual vocalist on this list !
Dahyun from which group?
@@alvi_omiTripleS
naah its rami
Dreaming @@skydendy97
@@nurruddinaniqz.r.a597 nahhh, im not dreaming, the age gap is so seen. and the ability gap is so small
I totally agree with your technical evaluation and analysis. Also agree with the current level with UNIS. All UNIS's vocals except heonju are on the process of maturing as they are too young and growing, with the help of continuous vocal training, base on their current exposure (vocally) UNIS will possibly become a vocal powerhouse after two years as the earliest base on my opinion. Gehlee is the most underrated and underused vocally, she provides alot of depth and color for overall group vocal quality and harmonization. A natural talented Alto tone is widely recognized, honed and maximized by solo or group artists in the Philippines, North America and Latin Countries. Overall what we love about UNIS is their remarkable growth and big potential to become one of the powerhouse of 5th gen within nearing their end of contract.
Hopefully they'll renew. 🙏 It would be a shame not to see more of the group together in their vocal and talent peak in two years!
from what i’ve heard, gehlee requested little lines bc she’s not very confident with her korean speaking (if you notice she’s taken a lot of english lines) and she wanted to focus on her dancing as well. but i don’t think there’s any excuses for giving elisia little to no lines as the main vocalist
@@astervotyI think this was the part gehlee requested of few lines during what is love performance based from what gehlee's mother told us. What concerns me is all songs from UNIS, Gehlee is one of the or the least lines wherein her vocal texture is rare and vocal quality is average yet she was underutilized. Anyways I am very hopeful that their next album would be different.
@@peterpaulvillapez4750 Rather than more lines, people should push for songs that would better maximize their unique tones. Like both Yoona (main rapper) and Gehlee (probably sub vocal and sub rapper) were severely underutilized in their debut album and have the least lines because the songs there were not rap heavy. I think more lines would be given to them if some of the songs chosen for their CB would be heavier on rock/rap.
@@astervoty Eli has the third most lines in their debut album though, so she actually had quite a lot of lines. As for being main vocalist, she is one, but I think she's not holding that role for their debut album. As what we've seen in Universe Ticket, there could only be one MV in a song. Also, following the pattern in groups with more than 1 main vocal, there may be a shifting of roles - Seowon and Eli would probably switch, with Eli taking the MV role for the comeback and Seowon taking a step back. This would also allow Seowon to rest her voice as she's been straining it hard for more than 2 months.
UNIS are full of raw talents and unique visuals. They did not have the years of professional training that other groups have before their debut because they debuted immediately after winning the UT global audition. I follow them because I want to see their journey from an unknown group from a new company, and see how they develop and excel as a global k-pop girl group. I also followed BTS from being an unknown group in 2016 under an unknown company to where they are today.
Belle & Dahyun are the best individually, BabyMonster is the best all-around, & UNIS has the best potential because their vocalists have good foundations & are all still very young. overall, the 5th gen kpop are in very good hands.
Very direct to the point summary of their skills! Good job 👏
@EKCristobal do you think that if haneul improved kiof can be 1st
Gehlee and Nana as well as Kotoko have quite unique voices- the thing is, F&F entertainment doesn’t know how to use those tones in Unis’s songs. Unis is one of those 5th gen groups who can sing live. The good thing with Unis is that the company doesn’t force the members out of their comfort zone (singing wise) like Be Lift did with Moka, yet Unis still provides a reasonably good performance considering they just debuted and to a lot of the members it’s new to be perform front of so many people. I think one of the main reasons Unis isn’t popular even though they have the skills is because they are under a new and quite unknown company. I hope in the future more people will stan them and they will get more noticed. Imo I think a lot of people don’t know that Unis debuted from the same survival show that the Vanesya meme came from.
And to all those people who will refuse to listen to Unis’s music because of their age:
It's unfortunate to see people criticizing Unis and other young K-pop groups solely based on their age. While it's understandable to have concerns about the pressure and expectations placed on young artists, it's important to recognize that many successful K-pop groups have debuted at a similar age, (e.g Newjeans, Lesserafim- I said *similar* not *the same* ) Instead of focusing on age, we should be evaluating these groups based on their music, performances, and potential.
Unis has already shown impressive talent and dedication to their craft, and I believe they have the potential to become one of the leading groups in the industry. Instead of tearing them down, we should be supporting and encouraging them to continue improving and growing as artists. After all, age is just a number, and true talent is timeless. The lineup has already been decided and there’s nothing we can do about it. The only thing we can do is support the girls and protect them from all these haters hating on them for their age.
Don’t bash me y’all 😭
Well say👏👏👏👏👍❤
@@marygracemaarat9768 Tysm ! ^^
The producers of Nan know how to use Gehlee's voice they highlighted her voice during the performance
@@eggiemybaby true i really like nan to.. hope they can collab again😊 😋
@@eggiemybaby Yes, but she doesn't get too many lines, imo Gehlee's voice suits Unis's concept very well, but in the end, nobody can control F&F- my intention isn't saying "the company needs to give her more lines", it's more like "I hope F&F realizes that fans love Gehlee's voice and that she has good vocal control."
It's 6 out of 7 vocalist for babymonster. Asa can sing and hit high notes too. She sings in stuck in the middle bridge part and like that
And in her pre-debut song too. She will probably be a sub vocalist and in another group I think she could have been lead vocalist.
I would like you to do this again after a year, and see what improve and what have not. 👌
for sure!
let’s include i-land 2 gg & smngg next time
I'll wait for this, so I'm leaving a comment for alert haha
UNIS are still young yet their vocals already sounds like veterans .. ❤😊
definitely all of them doesn't sound like veterans, they're just like good enough to sing
because that is what we call a talent or a gift. the veterans don't even sound like what a veteran should have sounded to be.
Curious them!!!!! they are very good❤🔥
It's ironic how Runext fans actually considered Moka as a potential main vocal of the debut line up, but now she's considered the worst vocalist of the group😔
Because in Runext they added pitch correction that's why a lot of fans are saying that they become weak in vocals after debut
Lots of liv auto tune and pitch correction
That show is rigged as hell
Since when?
@@cannycounter Yeah voice editing make fans sometimes totally frog in the well. I coincidentally found discussion on reddit before Illit debut where people seriously though that Illit have better singers than BM.
I’m so happy you included the weak cover by Unis Elisia :))
there are no other materials :( we need eli to be given more singing opportunities but it’ll be hard i bet, given she’s a foreigner
I like KIOF vocal versatility because each member have a distinct vocal color and i love that!!
most of Unis members are between the age of 14-16 years old vocal wise its not yet matured but they are already killin it live. their potential is on top.
Elisia seowon Seo dahyun belle rami jiwoo rora ahyeon haneul shion these girls have great vocal strength
I love this review I am only a UNIS Stan but I watch the whole video and nodded like it's cool to know other 5th gen GG's I hope for all of them to be successful and Improve in the future
thank you for being open minded. fighting for UNIS!
@@EKCristobala year later tag this video and make another one that will compare and contrast their skills as of now to their next year's skills. Would really appreciate it❤
@@Jonaz3rdVer.sure thing
Same here
Ditto
Every time YG make a new Boy group or Girl group. they are not disappoint the Audience because they know how to sing live and technique. That's the reason why YG different and unique to the other Agency in the Korea Entertainment.
Babymonster my fav id this gen 🔥
They was not loved at beginning for their song , but soon they started to get in hearts od people through their RAW TALENTS
unis def gonna be one of the powerhouses in the near future, all the members are young and have such a long time and chance for improvement
@Nakarinification actually, if they win roty this year, f&f stated that they will extend the girls’ contract for 2 more years. so everafters are working extra hard to stream and vote these days
@@bhst7487 no? they actually have the talent to do so... you’re too set on the big 4 LMAO
@@bhst7487 even if the account is actually made by a filipino, what’s wrong with it? made by one or not, you can’t deny the fact that they ACTUALLY have potential to rival the famous groups. they’re young, and there’s more to them that hasn’t been showcased yet. these girls are talented. more talented than you’d ever be..🗿
@Nakarinification roty IS the rookie award, roty literally just means rookie of the year... also it’s still possible if the fandom is putting the work. that mindset is what’s keeping underrated groups from rising bcs of ppl that has no belief in them bcs you guys are always ‘hybe this’ ‘yg that’ ‘jyp this’ ‘sm that’ ‘illit this’ ‘bm that’ and more bs💀
@Nakarinification you made the roty a big part of this convo when i literally just replied sumn to you about their contract extension. roty is literally out of the conversation but you lengthened it out🗿 i said they have the potential... idek why you bought up other groups in this convo
I have high hopes with UNIS. The girls are packed with talents!
Sadly, it's a temporary group
@@viorangealgobro can't even read articles 🤡
ELISIA IS THE BEST VOCAL.... I WATCH UNIVERSE TICKET AND THE COACH SAID ELISIA HAS A POWERFUL VOICE AND CONFIDENT
So?
@@pieistasty She/he is just simply stating. And you? What's your problem?
🥱🤡
@@pieistastyobese😂
@@pieistasty just stating what the judges/unicorns and the people who have watched it and have agreed upon that those were the most genuine reactions/comments of praise towards a trainee in all of the history of any Group survival show in SKorea. So?
Jealous@@pieistasty
I love how you only spoke facts and really seem to know what you are doing ❤
thank you so much. we are still growing day by day…
This is the most in-depth and well-founded opinion I’ve seen about fifth-generation vocalists among girl groups. I totally agree with your opinion❤
thank you so much
Unis is young but full
package of talents!!! 🥰
Thank you for doing this video! I know some people in the comments are upset and think you should have waited since 5th gen is still new but I think it's a good idea to have something that can show the growth of these groups since you'll most likely do more videos on all of them in the future👍
I really hope you can do an analysis or ranking of KIOF in all categories(vocal, dance, and rap) since they're about to hit their one-year mark; they've all shown amazing growth just in this one year so I'd love to see a breakdown of that as well as have something to compare to after more time passes.
Since Julie, Natty, and Belle are considered some of the top idols in their main positions and Haneul is proving to be not far behind her unnies in any category I think it'd be a great video to demonstrate excellence in all of these categories with the KIOF girls as the example❤
Thank you. Let’s see in the future~
UNIS will be BIG.
let’s see
@Nakarinification F& F maybe called small company but in terms of wealth they are in the top.
UNIS is a temporary group sooo
@@viorangealgo what's the big deal? U can't sing that's why you jealous hahahs
Kiss of Life can pass off being in YG. Their vocal styles are so YG-style.
well Julie was a trainee at TheBlackLabel before so yup, i agree with you
For me they feel like SM style..... Ningning and Winter
@@taylorswift664 Belle actually worked under sm as a composer/songwriter she got close to ningning so she might have picked up some of sm vocal techniques
i get the following vibes:
Julie and Natty - YG
Belle - SM
Haneul - idk JYP?
@@naornever Hanuel is probs JYP she has that bubbly aura and matches their vocal wants
Elisia has the best vocal technique despite her young age. Her tone is pleasing unlike others who sound like they're screaming. She has great control and dynamics. And she doesn't just sing, she tells a story
@Nakarinification I disagree but respect your opinion.
"she doesn't sing, she tells a story" ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!🥰
i agree 100% ❤
I love kiss of life they are full of all rounders. Their concepts are unique as well, and I love how each of their songs are just bold and full of life. I guess they really up to their girl group name.
#KissOfLife
How literally perfect was this analysis. You did an incredible job, and I'm impressed how accurately you called out TripleS and Kiss of Life's strengths and weaknesses. Your ranking was exactly what i was thinking following the analysis. Very fair and unbiased.
I'm a big TripleS stan (Go Dahyun!!) but given your criteria it totally makes sense the group would land at middle of the pack.
You even highlighted Shion's one performance of Girls Never Die when she took lead on Dahyun's notes! Like you literally missed Nothing. So impressed and will follow 👏🏼
aww appreciate this so much. thank you!
In summary, ILLIT has the least vocal talent in this review and i hope Hybe will do something about it rather than just making their money pay for trophies or music chart ranking. Music lovers are not deaf so everyone will question why the girl group with no talent always win. And it will boomerang back to Hybe in a very negative way.
You made slandering. Although Illit's vocal technique is not good but they are already have fans before debut. Because they came from survival show. People vote them. Vocal technique can be learn.
@@anistardi well 8% votes againts 92%votes for Babymonster in Mushow real time vote really showed it, and it happens 2 times 😂😂😂
cuz the "group with no talent" puts out the best songs, magnetic is like a 1000 times better song than sheesh, if yg stops producing shit songs with awful lyrics babymonster will get music show wins all of the time
You need to understand that most of the awards that can be earned in the K-pop industry rely heavily on the music and its performance (charts, streams, etc.). It doesn't matter whether the artist who releases the music is a good vocalist, dancer, rapper, or anything else.
"Magnetic" is a viral hit, similar to "Cupid" by FIFTY FIFTY (though "Cupid" is much more popular). Even my family, friends, and classmates, who don't even listen to K-pop, know and dance to "Magnetic." Moreover, before it was even released, a little snippet from the highlight medley, which was released 10 days before their debut, had already gone viral. It gained around 10k-20k+ uses on TikTok and CapCut alone. That was before it was even released on all streaming platforms; it was just a little snippet. Literally, almost every community-whether K-pop, editing, gaming, anime, or just any videos-is using the "Magnetic" audio; it's really just that popular right now.
In summary, if you want to win those awards, just release good music that will attract a lot of people.
@@bok402bok “Best songs” are subjective. Magnetic is catchy and in the dream-dance pop genre which is trendy amongst the generation nowadays. Although it DOES NOT show the members talents nor does it prove anything worth of a “debut” from a survival show.
Sheesh is very objective. It’s a hip hop track with strong pre choruses and bridge. And it’s a pretty good damn debut for OT7 Baby Monster. So maybe the problem is that HYBE should really train their artists and also put the ones deserving to debut!.
I would like to point out that the one example they gave of UNIS Seowon straining her voice was when she was sick, before she debuted, and when she wasn't even performing. All that to say, I think she's amazing, and it says a lot about her that that's how far one has to dig to find an example of subpar vocals.
Yes! Please more lines for Gehlee, like it’s so obvious that she’s way better than most maybe not better than Elisia and the other main but still.
like why F&F????
Illit is only on the list because of Minju an ex-trainee of YG😅
People who force others to believe ILLIT have good vocals are just a bunch of kids and still immature.
@@iamuugawei but minju does have good vocals no one can deny it
@@meryemtachi2174 average vocal
Finally someone well said about UNIS
thanks!
As a TripleS fan, I have to say I’m always impressed by DaHyun’s vocals… She doesn’t seem to have a limit. I’m so interested in keep discovering what the other members can bring to the table as members like Mayu,HyeRin, ShiOn and HaYeon seem to have pretty decent voices but we still haven’t heard them enough to have an opinion about their technique. I’m just willing to discover more about their capabilities and keep listening to DaHyun’s amazing voice
yeah, I think the whole analysis is fair but maybe the editor is not super knowledgeable about tripleS and the newer members because Sohyun is not even top 10 best vocalist in the group... there is Mayu, Nakyoung, Yubin, Hayeon, Seoah, Joobin, Kaede, Yooyeon, Chaeyeon, Seoyeon... tripleS is actually pretty stacked vocally. Even if most of these girls are not known for their high notes they sing so well and have beautiful voices! People should keep an eye on Seoah and Joobin, the maknaes. They will have more opportunities to showcase their talent later but I really love their vocal color.
@@GK-dl8bi I also agree with SoHyun. She has a deep voice and her voice is nice but she strains sometimes as she has more of a deep tone. I think especially Naky, Mayu, HaYeon (in Just Do It she carries the vocals with ShiOn) and JooBin. It’s true that we haven’t seen a lot of the maknae line but JooBin and SeoAh definitely have potential as they’re stated as Vocals in the group. Also I pretty have a lot of expectations about HaYeon’s vocals. Also I have to remember that HyeRin had really good vocals in the AAA and the LOVElution activities, is like she is not Main Vocal material but she has a lot of potential and she sounds actually pretty good live. We also don’t have to forget how much of an improvement Kaede and SoYeon have made in their vocals. Also I forgot about ChaeYeon, for me she seems quite strong live as well!!
@@GK-dl8bi Idk from a technical standpoint, it doesn’t seem like you’re that knowledgeable about tripleS. Sohyun has the second widest support range and has decent qualities when she sings in her comfortable register. Therefor, she is interchangeable with Jiwoo when it comes to vocals as they’re both 2/3rd place while Dahyun is 1st. ShiOn, Nakyoung, and Kotone are the only other members who’ve shown support thus far, hence why the editor said those things in the video
Unis is scary group it they try to cover every song. They can own them with their own version. Gehlee, Bang Yunha, Yoona are so underrated if you follow them during universe Ticket they are so good...
Best vocalists of the groups:
Kiof - belle
Illit - minju
Unis - elisia
Babymonster - rami
(Idk abt tripleS)
Most of the groups here are still young. So we can still have a lot of time for improvement. Especially Seowon of UNIS.
Miss Girl legit is a 12 year old. Her voice is still going to mature.
the youngest main vocal
Mayu, Kaede, Hayeon, nakyoung also have good imapact on the vocal line of TripleS. As you can check Kaede's note in call me baby cover and Door by Aria. 19:58 mayu's adlibs in Girls never stage, Hayeon whistle note in Just do it. Also other member still got a lot to show🫶🏻
tripleS has some great vocal talent. There are some members that simply didn't have the opportunity to show it yet but they will on smaller subunits in the near future!
Unis and babymon FTW❤
Elisia isnt the most powerful vocalist but for me she has the most refined technique, she has complete control on her voice and can really be the best inside her vocal ranges❤
Our Elisia Seowon yunha and gehlee will be sure all rounder singer Unis was the most top 1 in terms of vocals skills there stable live performance while dancing was so impressive
Ahyeonnieee high note, rami technique, rora siren voice, angeletic voice of chiquita, pharita's bright note
i swaer gehlee's lower regiser is something even foreign like her voice
her lows are her best!
Kiof are really THAT GROUP
well-rounded
While u don't care about OH Yoona from Unis, she's a very capable singer and rapper employing wide range of vocal techniques.
Fr !! I hope Unis gets more recognition- for they can actually sing live
Omg! Exactly, in reality only Nana and Kotoko that are weak in vocal, infact they are good but just strains a lot in live singing, others are so good!
And like what you said, Yoona is an amazing vocalist with wide range, my favourite performance of her in UT era is DKWTD and SuperStar (?) I forgot the name, in two of those songs her positions are very different, one a vocalist and one a rapper, but both of those she devoured..!
And not putting Hyenjou in the vocal line is kindda offensive! She's one of the best vocalist in every group she joins, her voice is soothing, smooth, and uniqe!
@@mukhlisnurdin2361 i 100% agree, Nana puts a lot of energy into her dance and i think thats why she has to strain her voice- people misunderstand her (not u), shes not a bad singer, she just has a different unique tone that the company doesnt quite know how to use. At least her and kotoko and the rest of unis r actually stable while singing live... im having flashbacks from moka...
*im not hating on moka its hybes problem*
@@sttraw_beryy Yess..Nana is energetic in her dances, that's why her voice strains, I could understand it for Kotoko too, why? Cause her choreos are mostly bumpy and jumpy and it makes her voice doesn't sound clear, ngl producers always give Kotoko jumpy choreos so Kotoko shine more and be cute in every type of song when in reality gurl doesn't need those she's already cute in her own way..(-flashback of PD picking her for the "Special Performance" at a music show (SBS?) just because of that "kawaii" mini jump)
There are like 6/8 decent vocalist to the group, Hyeonju herself is a main Vocalist on her previous group and Yoona's stability is an advantage to be recognized as a good vocalist even tho her level isn't that high to Elisia and Seowon. The only 2 members of UNIS needs more improvement for their vocals, nonetheless they all deserve the recognition!^^
Every live performance of BABYMONS7ER is the best advertising. Like a very good commercial.
BABYMONSTER SLAYEDD
tripleS, the idol of all possibilities. A perfect tag for a group that has a growing potential in different aspects. 25% for a vocal line might be small for other people but other members can cover the other roles of an idol perfectly. Some members excells in dancing, some in rapping, some noticeable all rounders, and some just starting to show potential. They are a group that shows stable and non scaling growth.
Waiting for your other videos with them and thank you for noticing their talents especially Dahyun in this area of skill ❤
Welcome. Pretty sure the management and the girls appreciate Dahyun so much - she’s the vocal core of tripleS.
If you have 30 members it's very possible 😂
I wonder if op took bsides into consideration for this:
- Chaeyeon is one of tripleS’ better vocalists and she especially shines in bsides
- Kaede is really good as well and her vocal color literally goes with any sound
- Kotone is also someone with the potential to get better vocally as she is already pretty versatile in her voice
- Mayu is extremely UNAPPRECIATED for her vocals even though she was one of the main vocals in the Evolution bsides, either singing lines Jiwoo got as well or having adlibs like in Heavy Metal Wings
- Hayeon is pretty versatile in her voice and we know she can do whistle notes, we just need to hear her more
- Joobin has a pretty mature voice considering she is an 09 liner so imagine how much better she will be when her voice matures more (Chiyu is literally her song)
- Chaewon seems pretty good and versatile in what we heard of her in the bsides, she has potential to be the main vocal of Glow
- Seoah is in the same case as Joobin of having an amazing voice despite being a 2010 girlie, she shines in the bsides and I think she will probably be Glow’s main vocal.
TripleS has a crap load of members, so not everyone can showcase their talents in the title tracks, but looking into their bsides you can find so much potential in them.
@@QueenQueen0824 completely agree. TripleS girlies got sooo much to show
@@QueenQueen0824I agree with all of this, while seeing who sang which part in the ot24 album I was especially surprised with Seoah and Joobin, they did some challenging vocal parts, I can't wait to see how they'll develop. About Kae and Mayu they're very underrated for a while already, I'm especially excited about Kaede development because she only trained as a dancer before entering Modhaus and she already improved so much, so it shows that Modhaus is training the girls properly, another proof of that is Jiwoo, although she was already decent during MTG, she improved A LOT in the past 2 years, she got soooo much better
Simultaneous singing and dancing, no one beats Elisia. She is on top, the most stable and most versatile and relaxed, effortless "Performer" amongst all these individuals and she is still young. As a group UNIS should ranked higher than 4...maybe 2nd. They only only have a two-week preparation prior to debut.
Based on my rank of those main vocalist here the list:
1) Dahyun Triple S (technique and vocal versality but need show her vocal color)
1) Rami (Strong vocal color and need to show more her techique)
2) Belle (Our ariana always slayed! But sometimes I found her vocal almost shaky)
3) Seowon and Elisia ( I love both, i believe their vocal skills will go further as their room to grow is so big!)
Honorable: Minju.. I love her vocal color but she lacks of vocal range and technique, I believe if she trained so well then she can shows her true ability. Currently her vocal still same as the lead vocal position from a small company
@@namihirosi lol, my bad! But at least I'm a non-fan that want her to have more improvement
@@namihirosiwell tbf, there are no other main vocalists in the list in the video
I agree with everything except belle being lower then rami,I think she's better,but I respect yoir opinion
@@pieistasty thank youu, I love Bellle's voice, her voice is unique
where Rora?
If we're talking about vocals. Elisia is the one to look out for. She's still yound adn yet she's that good. Imagine what she can do with her voice in the future. Nott o mention she's filipina. If you know what i mean. 🙂
Babymonster and Kiss of Life 👏🏻👏🏻
Kiss of life is SUPREMACY 🔥👑
And Natty and Julie are the hottest female idols , they drive you crazy with their movements, sensuality, their beauty and their stage presence 🤯🤯🔥🔥
Thanm you for including UNIS ❤❤❤
You’re welcome
BABYMONSTER'S VOCALS DO NOT PLAY, EVEN THEIR RAPPERS ARE VERY STABLE VOCALISTS😭❤️
It should be coz they' train for many yrs even chiquita train for almost 2 yrs.
@@onsight9234chiquita is the epitome of having natural skills, hence, even at only almost 3 years of training, there’s so many developments already
Yeah. That's why their amazing coz honing talents for yrs give them the edge compared to the other group.
Well I wouldn’t say very stable ( coming from an Asa bias) other then ahyeon, the rappers aren’t the best vocalist. Although Asa is decent, we haven’t seen enough of ruka yet
unis is still young but has huge potential lets wait they're still young I hope the company will take care of this group
UNIS members during Universe Ticket is a different story. If you watch it you’ll know what kind of monsters Elisia, Seowon, Hyeonju, Bang Yunha and Gehlee are when it comes time to vocals and stage presence.
Yesss!!!
Glad you notice about Gehlee! Her voice is amazing! And hoping theyll give her more lines next comeback
Unis for me is underrated
And then people be saying "Unis is so overrated" like where? They're so underrated where their MV didn't even reached 30M in just 1 month bro, they can call Unis "overrated" if they just debuted then like Their MV reached 30M or more in just 4days or 5days👁️👄👁️
@@gehleeeysbro didn't know the word "UNIS is from new small company" 🤡🤡
Ok anyone who stans both babymonster and kiof are the ones who stan actual talent and music 👏🏻
All the vocalist on those groups are superb. Specially those whos already 20 as their vocal is already mold. I'm interested with those young ones from unis. They're really young yet they have so much potential. I'm excited to see them grow through the years. 😊
People need to start accepting, Babymonster is the best 5th gen vocal group
@@maybelyncabanog6484 I am talking about vocals and 5th gen.
As a UNIS fan, I already accepted this. Not really concerned about the competition here, I just want my girls to succeed in their career! ❤
ELISIA eat your baby monster filo good in English can speak fluently unlike K-pop you insert filo in K-pop will be big problem in Korean 5th gen hahahha
ELISIA eat your baby monster filo good in English can speak fluently unlike K-pop you insert filo in K-pop will be big problem in Korean 5th gen hahahha
@@johneisleytiu5110that's really so sweet of you and love how you are so non toxic and not tryna start a war 😂❤
YG should put Rora to those highnotes Ahyeon is good but I think Rora's vocal range is more suitable...for high registers...
Rara's voice isn't comfortable in high ranges, that's why she's always covered low songs for their evaluations
I'm a bbmonster fan and you're totally right:
Rami and Rora have great technics
Pharita can hit easily high notes because of her natural tone
Ahyeon can hit easily belt notes because of her confidence and natural tone
Chiquita has soft tone, but still getting better day by day
In my opinion in Unis Hyeonju is one of the member that supports the overall vocal of the group. Does everyone agree???
Yes! Her live vocals are so stable, I was shocked she wasn't included in the video
Unis holds potential
You should know that one of the vocalists from the girl group VVUP is called "Kim" she has a very unique voice and technique.
While I kind of agree with your analysis. You missed to mention that UNIS also sings live. Also, I think you missed heyunju and Yoona. They are very underrated but have very stable singing voices. However, I do agree Seowoon is still maturing and Nana Nd Kotoko just need to train about but right now they are decent still. If you would rank 5th gen by vocals I would put top 3 Baby Monster, KOL then UNIS
I love Unis...they are multi talented...❤
Can u do an updated list cause there’s a lot of tripleS members that showed potential last year especially kaede, hayeon and Seoah
Unis is so much younger than the other groups ...
correct
I can’t wait to see baby monster, kiss of life and UNIS TO GROW BECAUSE NO HAS SEE WHAT I HAVE SEEN!! These groups are more than people think they are❤so proud of them!!!
Regarding UNIS Yoona is a decent rapper, Hyeonju is vocally great too, Yunha is also a very capable vocalist
this was a good video, you where blunt and not sugar coating, i hope you continue to make videos like this so we(viewers) can see the progress of each GG.
Thank you! Will do!
Can you make an analysis of tripleS members only? I know there are a lot of members but I would love to see an analysis of them only (or maybe their possible vocal line?) because it's hard to find people talking about their vocals
Unis is a great group, very diverse vocal range and visuals and charm. F&F just needs to stop playing it safe and give them an all out song, otherwise they'd stay in mediocre rank and won't stand out.
Unis is the best! It's just that right now it seems like their showcasing their cuteness more than their vocals. But they're all amazing singers.
This is a great analysis. I can say that it was objective and i love it, every take was supported. I totally agree with the rankings as well while i do wanna see UNIS rank higher(subjective), i can't help but agree with your takes. At the end of the day, its already good to see UNIS be on par of the top 5th gen girl groups knowing that most of them are still underdeveloped vocally due to less to training background. I wish nothing but success on all the girl groups and looking forward to see more group strive to be better and be on par with these 5 groups. cos right now, they are currently the standard of 5th gen KPOP.
thank you sm
great analysis
thank you!
I just want to say thank you so much for noticing Rora vocal abilities. I keep saying this that technically she’s at bar next to rami, she’s just overshadowed by ahyeon strong vocals and rami unique vocals and of course the other members’ popularity on top of that yg keep giving her small Lines on the side never giving her the chorus which is really sad. Pls support Rora as she is very underrated
hyeonju was literally cignature's main vocalist, my girlie can sing!
she didn't say hyeonju can't . I have to agree on the analysis, the girls that were mentioned here were really greater vocalist than of Hyeonju, sad to say. She is my bias btw. Hyeonju!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I AM BEYOND OF BEING PROUD OF BABYMONSTER. I'M PROUD OF CALL MYSELF THEIR FAN.
UNIS... Everyone can sing and has the potential to even improve further. Each has a different tone and quality. ❤