You've probably gotten this request before but I would love to see you questioning the duel logs in this season. He's really smart and I think he would do well
Hello again ladies and gentleman, another day, another request for Hardleg Joe to grace the ruling quiz putting his knowledge of Crystron to the test! I do love this series though, keep it up!
SolemnVanguard (also SolemnYugioh) would be an interesting one to me as I see him do more investing for YGO than playing but he is a world-class Vanguard player. I'd be intrigued to see how much of that skill transfers to other card games.
Small clarification: at 8:19, cat Shark does not freeze the original attack of Gigantic Spright to 6400, it sets the current attack to 6400. This is an important distinction to understand the difference between atk/def modifiers and how to correctly apply them
An interesting thing on question #7 is that something similar happened to me in Master Duel, i had sunny and my opponents uses triple tacticts to steal, i chain sunny to summon both twins, on resolution they steal blue and i can only activate blue effect to destory and not red to draw.
@@xatuyou8045 he could choose different HEROes I think joseph only got E heroes. It is definitely an archtype where a lot of questions could be made and mbt has much more experience with weird rulings then ruggles which I feel should play a role
I would have gone 7 out of 8. Funnily enough I also would have used the lifeline to ask coder about how evenly matched would resolve against towers and I also would have given the same answer in question 8 as the contestant did. Looking back at it actually not a hard question but I still do feel a lot better about my rulings understanding
1st one had a scenario come up like this, it doesn't target, but since it's an "and" conjuction you need both to happen, so nothing happens here and smashers resolves without effect. It's also due to cards face downs have no stats. 2nd one I will say 3200 since the modifier of the cat shark would make it 6400 if you detach the material being a fusion-link it will be 3200 base since it no longer can apply it's own modification. I could be wrong though. Spright says the original attack becomes this, So he's 3200 base when cat shark resolves making him 6400 base.
Loved the video shout out to crush cards and our main man distant coder. Plus thank you for the ruling help on dp sword soul seem to hate my muskets 🤷🏻.
That Trouble Sunny effect is just like Endymion’s scale effect. That Mystic Mine ruling with Carrot is just like Magician’s Combination. I don’t even know these rulings. I just know how other cards work with the exact same wording.
@distantcoder on Question #8 Evil twin ki-sikil & lil-la specifies location where a the cards the opponent must send to the GY. So in that case a token gets removed and robina gets banish when it leaves the field via its own effect. How can your opponent send to the “GY” all of the cards if some can’t because of location rulings?
My brains just rattled up on the last question with them believing for sure that token can't be send to GY since what I know token can be send to the graveyard unless for cost but can't be banished that's my understanding and they made me second guessing it daym nice question
@@CrushCards nah, it's not the point, it was just because you wasn't agreeing with each other, so I thought you might struggle to get a single point haha
@@samuelcastillo5246 LMAO honestly that was my biggest fear going into it 🤣🤣🤣 it’s hard enough making a decision on your own, but we have to get to the same line and then AGREE haha 🤣🤣🤣 I hope we at least made it entertaining!
when you came to the carrot effect i immediately thought of what I had in a recent tournament. They summoned gigantic spright and i activated fogblade on it. then they chained carot on it but still it's only that effect the card will stay and reaply so gigantic was negated and he basically did -1. fun.
I had this interaction with a judge on a ycs. It was a skill drain thingy and before commiting a play I asked him "If Skill drain is active, I activate a monster effect and then the monster leaves the field as CL2, does the effect resolve?" And after seing my hand (which contained ogre) the judge told me that answering this question would be coaching. To this day I don't get this whole coaching thingy.
@@skuamato7886 Basically, judges can't answer theoretical questions that would impact your decision making. Or answer any questions that involve private knowledge. You can ask things like "Is a Pendulum zone that has a pendulum monster scaled also still considered a Spell/Trap zone?" or you can ask how a particular chain of effects that were already activated will resolve. But you can't ask something like "If I play this set of moves, what will happen?".
I got tripped up by cat shark and the last question, as well as the detaching for gigantic lol if I was being generous I’d give myself a half point for the gigantic/book of moon question but I got 5 totally correct
Loving the series reboot but I feel like these life lines need a redo, especially the judge one. Asking a judge in this almost never comes up because a lot of times you can't answer a question without giving the entire answer away. I think "asking the judge" should just be inherent to the game where they can ask you anything similar at any time and the actual lifeline should be calling a friend or something else.
Great video, and I actually learned some stuff I'd never even thought about (XYZ monsters retain their materials when flipped face-down??), but I've got a question related to one of the ruling quizzes. In this Mystic Mine/Carrot negation question, if you tribute a Rank/Link 2 Monster with Carrot, can you destroy the Mine? Since Carrot is a negate that effect, then if blah blah destroy it, does negating the on-activation 'effect' of Mystic Mine count as successfully resolving the first part of Carrot's effect?
from this video i learned that one of duel logs's scripted videos is wrong in rescue rabbit vs dark world, reign-beaux activates the cheerful coffin, rabbit chains macro cosmos, then reign-beaux chooses to discard 0 this is a chet cause he has to discard at least one
so i have an idea maybe for season 3 start having followers try their luck at rulings and the reward for like all 8 questions right be like a 3month sub to the twitch or something?
I don't think I've ever summoned Evil Twins Lil-la and Ki-Sikil when my opponent had more than 0 cards, just doesn't happen, that effect just don't happen.
Coder, i have 1 question where 50% of my friends have a different ruling opinion then the other 50%. Question: If beetrooper stinglancer target "bean soldier" in your gy and "basic insect" in my gy, c2 you dd crow my"basic insect" on resolve i know stinglancer stil get to summen but does de "bean soldier" stil gets placed on the bottem of the deck or not, because 1 of the 2 targets was lost?
So I'd really like Coder doing a video on this whole coaching thing because I always feel like I can basically never ask a judge anything in a tournament aside from "So I/my opponent did x, was that legal?" E.G. a few questions I would have maybe asked here: Does the Twin work just like evenly does in terms of how it's affecting the player vs. how it's affecting cards? Can I send a token to the Graveyard for cost to, let's say, pay cost for an effect? Can I attempt to send Robina to the GY? I'm btw 99% sure the answer to all these questions is yes, I'm just curious wether a judge could answer them in this specific situation EDIT: Watched the final part where coder answered the qquestion and I have to confess, I wasn't aware that you can't send a token to the grave as cost. I guess the reason is that no card on earth sends as cost, they all tribute for cost. And that works.
You cannot send a face up Floowandereeze & Robina to the graveyard as a cost since it cannot be sent to the graveyard. You can send it as part of an effect, it will simply get banished instead.
To sum it up, the difference between cost and effect is the cost must be paid in full whereas the effect is just the resolution of the card. So if you can't pay the cost for a card (i.e. Send 1 card you control to the GY), then you can't use the token or Robina as the card for the cost because neither of them can be sent to the GY as cost. However, because the effect is resolving, then the token and Robina will be affected by the effect, but they'll just go to their respective places (banish for Robina and poof out of existence for the token)
Wait so, with the last question with towers/token/Robina and Ki-silkil&li-la Whats the difference here vs Gozen Match? I believe with gozen match you are forced to only keep the token (and im un sure about Robina)
8:36 I still don't get why it's 6400. In previous rulings when a value friezes, it cannot be modifed, so why can it here? if it says double on both effects, shoudl the second double not remove the first double, and be at 3200?
In terms of last question. If they choose to send Towers would it actually send? Cause I’ve had situations on Master Duel when I’ve summoned Metaphys Horus using the effect of making my opponent choose a monsters they control and give it to me they selected said Towers (and Ulti Falcon) and it did not switch to my control
To answer your question, yes the Towers will be sent to the GY, because the Live Twins has an effect that makes the player perform a certain game action, and does not interact directly with said Towers. Do you follow me so far? As for your Metaphys Horus example, this interaction is a lot like Creature Swap. Creature Swap, despite its wording, does not make the player perform a game action, but rather affects the monsters themselves. Thus, when resolving the effect of Creature Swap and cards like it (such as your Metaphys Horus, for example) if the opponent were to choose a monster that is unaffected by said Creature Swap effect, the monster swap does not take place, and the card resolves without effect.
How is "banished face-down" different from "sending to the gy" in the context of getting rid of tokens? you can send a token for Ki-Sikil & Lil-La but not banish for Evenly? how does that makes sense? I get that it cant be face-down but, like, a token cant be in gy as well. "They just go *poof*"
Question: say opponent activates Mine, I respond with Carrot quick eff as CL2 tributing a lv2, when resolving backwards, am I not allowed to simply pop Mine before its effect begins applying? Similar as if my opponent flips IO and I respond with Cyclone as CL2, poping IO before it begins applying its effect
I think more PhoenixFlareX when it comes to the Dragunity archetype, but I know he's currently doing his own thing with his own life. Still would like to see Cyberknight do one of these quizzes, but idk if he's really "well known" for Dragunity. He seems like he just builds whatever he's super interested in. Although...maybe he could do a quiz on the Number monsters. He does collect all of them, in every rarity possible (he's got a binder dedicated to just the Numbers), so maybe a "Does Cyberknight Know "Number" Rulings" video would be very interesting to see.
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.83[1/2] เปิดแคมป์หลอนต้อนรับ 2 ตัวพ่อแห่งวงการผี!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2uPuHYHgwiI/mqdefault.jpg)
You need to get The Cali Effect on this!
earth machine rulings 🤣
With a spooky dogwood question
I would love that
SalamanGREAAAAAAAAT Rulings
Cali effect for sure
Debating what is considered "reasonable" in a question that involves Mystic Mine is asinine 🤣🤣
This episode was great 👍 love it.
You've probably gotten this request before but I would love to see you questioning the duel logs in this season. He's really smart and I think he would do well
On which deck ?
@@Elou-hq3cq E V E R Y
@@Elou-hq3cq YES!
Yes put the duel logs, specifically on crazy box or blue eyes
Just finding coder and I have to say, I need this man to colab with the whole yugiverse. These rulings vids are the sauce
Hello again ladies and gentleman, another day, another request for Hardleg Joe to grace the ruling quiz putting his knowledge of Crystron to the test!
I do love this series though, keep it up!
Time for the Cali effect or
Cap G to be on the show this was one of my top 3 of all the quizzes done
You should bring Dire on for Generaider rulings :)
SolemnVanguard (also SolemnYugioh) would be an interesting one to me as I see him do more investing for YGO than playing but he is a world-class Vanguard player. I'd be intrigued to see how much of that skill transfers to other card games.
I love these rulings quiz Coder! Carry on with these man!!
Smashing it
Aw man! @Crush Cards need to feature on What's In The Box!!
Coder being one of the best friends reassuring crush card is lovely at the end there
This video will always be sentimental because it was uploaded when my first child was born
Would love to see Zara/5thrate on with Megalith Drytron! I'm sure there's tons of material there for some interesting questions
Yooo I agree
Loved this collab! It’s always a great time when you, Bryan and Logan are together!
This episode was great! Can't wait for o37wolf on synchron rulings
Should call Paulo PRRJ for one of those. He just said in his last video that he doesn't think he knows rulings, just memorizes them
Hey Coder, noticed a typo in your description
"Head over and check out Farfa's TH-cam & Twitch"
Should be Crush Cards. Love your content mans, cheers
fixed! ty for spotting that!
Small clarification: at 8:19, cat Shark does not freeze the original attack of Gigantic Spright to 6400, it sets the current attack to 6400. This is an important distinction to understand the difference between atk/def modifiers and how to correctly apply them
An interesting thing on question #7 is that something similar happened to me in Master Duel, i had sunny and my opponents uses triple tacticts to steal, i chain sunny to summon both twins, on resolution they steal blue and i can only activate blue effect to destory and not red to draw.
You have to make one on Hero with Ruggles!✨
I think he’s trying avoid the same decks as last season and mbt already did hero.
@@xatuyou8045 he could choose different HEROes I think joseph only got E heroes. It is definitely an archtype where a lot of questions could be made and mbt has much more experience with weird rulings then ruggles which I feel should play a role
@@U1TR4F0RCE ruggles would likely get gladbeasts if anything
CAME AT THE SPEED OF (Quick Effect): You can Tribute this card; Special Summon up to 1 "Ki-sikil" monster and up to 1 "Lil-la" monster from your GY.
I would have gone 7 out of 8. Funnily enough I also would have used the lifeline to ask coder about how evenly matched would resolve against towers and I also would have given the same answer in question 8 as the contestant did. Looking back at it actually not a hard question but I still do feel a lot better about my rulings understanding
1st one had a scenario come up like this, it doesn't target, but since it's an "and" conjuction you need both to happen, so nothing happens here and smashers resolves without effect. It's also due to cards face downs have no stats.
2nd one I will say 3200 since the modifier of the cat shark would make it 6400 if you detach the material being a fusion-link it will be 3200 base since it no longer can apply it's own modification. I could be wrong though. Spright says the original attack becomes this, So he's 3200 base when cat shark resolves making him 6400 base.
This episode was way funnier than it should have been.
Crush Cards they made it fun man
We had a lot of fun with it 🤣💖
@@CrushCards I loved the subathon, you guys were great
Look at crush cards out here knowing things! Love to see it
I love these Ruling Quizzes man! But dang, they totally misunderstood that last question lol
Ooh! Any chance you could get Dark Armed Duelist on here with Blackwings or Tele-DAD type stuff?
I watched this live (haha funny pun). This video was pure chaos. I love it!
Loved the video shout out to crush cards and our main man distant coder. Plus thank you for the ruling help on dp sword soul seem to hate my muskets 🤷🏻.
Kinda wild but the cat shark ruling question actually came up for me in locals yesterday. This video definitely came in clutch lol
Crush cards pog! Their channel/community got me back into yugioh!
🥹💖 that’s so sweet I love that for you!
@@CrushCards I greatly appreciate the videos y'all have posted 🙏It helped a lot with getting through covid, haha
That Trouble Sunny effect is just like Endymion’s scale effect.
That Mystic Mine ruling with Carrot is just like Magician’s Combination.
I don’t even know these rulings. I just know how other cards work with the exact same wording.
"Im sorry, is that Towers?" logan is fucking hilarious with her unfiltered comments
Surely do Penguinz0 with Gren Maju/Banish rulings
Cardmarket - Yu-Gi-Oh! should be featured here. They are very friendly/knowledge and should be considered if possible.
Yo eventually it would be cool if ya did a “Does Coder know Code Talker rulings”
@distantcoder on Question #8 Evil twin ki-sikil & lil-la specifies location where a the cards the opponent must send to the GY. So in that case a token gets removed and robina gets banish when it leaves the field via its own effect. How can your opponent send to the “GY” all of the cards if some can’t because of location rulings?
My brains just rattled up on the last question with them believing for sure that token can't be send to GY since what I know token can be send to the graveyard unless for cost but can't be banished that's my understanding and they made me second guessing it daym nice question
You guys did the paca pals proud!
So yeah, I was expecting a perfect 0 out of 8
I'm not the only one who was expecting that! XD
I’m so sorry I disappointed y’all I really tried to speed run the 0-8 🤣🤣
@@CrushCards nah, it's not the point, it was just because you wasn't agreeing with each other, so I thought you might struggle to get a single point haha
@@samuelcastillo5246 LMAO honestly that was my biggest fear going into it 🤣🤣🤣 it’s hard enough making a decision on your own, but we have to get to the same line and then AGREE haha 🤣🤣🤣 I hope we at least made it entertaining!
@@CrushCards haha totally
the live twin questions were so easy and she kept 2nd guessing them.
Would love to see the Duel Logs do one of theses on Springans
Insane format pls more of That
@crushcards are just nice people.
GET HEAD TO HEAD BATTLES ON THIS
when you came to the carrot effect i immediately thought of what I had in a recent tournament. They summoned gigantic spright and i activated fogblade on it. then they chained carot on it but still it's only that effect the card will stay and reaply so gigantic was negated and he basically did -1. fun.
@@dhanyl2725 diameter negates activation, carrot negates effect
Gonna vouche for Yishan or head2head battles for Gren Maju again.
Get some duel logs on, it seems like he has a breadth of card knowledge, I’d love to see that put to the test
It'd be cool to see E3 yugioh on this, with either Edison rulings or Dragonlink ones.
I would love to see Oblivious Obviously take on this challenge with fluffals
Honestly i heard a judge calling something "coaching" for absolutely every question imaginable.
I had this interaction with a judge on a ycs. It was a skill drain thingy and before commiting a play I asked him "If Skill drain is active, I activate a monster effect and then the monster leaves the field as CL2, does the effect resolve?" And after seing my hand (which contained ogre) the judge told me that answering this question would be coaching. To this day I don't get this whole coaching thingy.
@@skuamato7886 Basically, judges can't answer theoretical questions that would impact your decision making. Or answer any questions that involve private knowledge. You can ask things like "Is a Pendulum zone that has a pendulum monster scaled also still considered a Spell/Trap zone?" or you can ask how a particular chain of effects that were already activated will resolve. But you can't ask something like "If I play this set of moves, what will happen?".
I got tripped up by cat shark and the last question, as well as the detaching for gigantic lol if I was being generous I’d give myself a half point for the gigantic/book of moon question but I got 5 totally correct
Lets gooooooo big dawg, Cali effect on the show with Earth machine rulings
Loving the series reboot but I feel like these life lines need a redo, especially the judge one.
Asking a judge in this almost never comes up because a lot of times you can't answer a question without giving the entire answer away. I think "asking the judge" should just be inherent to the game where they can ask you anything similar at any time and the actual lifeline should be calling a friend or something else.
I love this
I still can’t get over that view
This series is incredibly entertaining
Gotta get Skyhawk on to answer the most obscure fluffal ruling sometime
When coder brought out the MM i knew it was gonna be a problem, but I didn't know that MM was that big of a problem tbh
Cali Effect ruling quiz on Tri-Brigade/Scareclaw/Earth Machine when? :)
You'd think it would be Virus card rulings given their channel name.
I thought we get Bryan with Zombies
Great video, and I actually learned some stuff I'd never even thought about (XYZ monsters retain their materials when flipped face-down??), but I've got a question related to one of the ruling quizzes.
In this Mystic Mine/Carrot negation question, if you tribute a Rank/Link 2 Monster with Carrot, can you destroy the Mine? Since Carrot is a negate that effect, then if blah blah destroy it, does negating the on-activation 'effect' of Mystic Mine count as successfully resolving the first part of Carrot's effect?
Yes, you can destroy Mystic Mine if you Tributed a Link/Rank 2 monster to activate Carrot's effect.
from this video i learned that one of duel logs's scripted videos is wrong
in rescue rabbit vs dark world, reign-beaux activates the cheerful coffin, rabbit chains macro cosmos, then reign-beaux chooses to discard 0
this is a chet cause he has to discard at least one
We need Cali effect on here, and get team samurai for six samurais
if the target of book of moon is redoer? does redoer goes back at the field FACEDOWN? because the detach is also part of the effect
You got me on the last one Coder hahaha
You HAVE to get the Cali effect on here, it would be epic 😳😳😳.
so i have an idea maybe for season 3 start having followers try their luck at rulings and the reward for like all 8 questions right be like a 3month sub to the twitch or something?
I don't think I've ever summoned Evil Twins Lil-la and Ki-Sikil when my opponent had more than 0 cards, just doesn't happen, that effect just don't happen.
If only there as a one word phrase for “resolve without effect”
Hands down my favorite coder content 👍
Ohhh I get it. Twins. Level 2’s. Crush cards. Classy.
Be cool to see if Jesse Kotton can get them all right and cool to see Milano on the show
Coder, i have 1 question where 50% of my friends have a different ruling opinion then the other 50%.
Question:
If beetrooper stinglancer target "bean soldier" in your gy and "basic insect" in my gy, c2 you dd crow my"basic insect" on resolve i know stinglancer stil get to summen but does de "bean soldier" stil gets placed on the bottem of the deck or not, because 1 of the 2 targets was lost?
So coder will use poof (which is definitely slang), but fizzle which many people intuitively understand what it means from other media doesn’t work?
logan for a second sounded a bit like hulk hogan @13:05 ngl
So I'd really like Coder doing a video on this whole coaching thing because I always feel like I can basically never ask a judge anything in a tournament aside from "So I/my opponent did x, was that legal?" E.G. a few questions I would have maybe asked here:
Does the Twin work just like evenly does in terms of how it's affecting the player vs. how it's affecting cards?
Can I send a token to the Graveyard for cost to, let's say, pay cost for an effect?
Can I attempt to send Robina to the GY?
I'm btw 99% sure the answer to all these questions is yes, I'm just curious wether a judge could answer them in this specific situation
EDIT: Watched the final part where coder answered the qquestion and I have to confess, I wasn't aware that you can't send a token to the grave as cost. I guess the reason is that no card on earth sends as cost, they all tribute for cost. And that works.
You cannot send a face up Floowandereeze & Robina to the graveyard as a cost since it cannot be sent to the graveyard. You can send it as part of an effect, it will simply get banished instead.
To sum it up, the difference between cost and effect is the cost must be paid in full whereas the effect is just the resolution of the card. So if you can't pay the cost for a card (i.e. Send 1 card you control to the GY), then you can't use the token or Robina as the card for the cost because neither of them can be sent to the GY as cost. However, because the effect is resolving, then the token and Robina will be affected by the effect, but they'll just go to their respective places (banish for Robina and poof out of existence for the token)
Costs can check your face down cards.
Effects cannot check face down cards.
Wait so, with the last question with towers/token/Robina and Ki-silkil&li-la
Whats the difference here vs Gozen Match? I believe with gozen match you are forced to only keep the token (and im un sure about Robina)
i dont recall and am to lazy to check but have we did Ruggles into this series?
8:36 I still don't get why it's 6400. In previous rulings when a value friezes, it cannot be modifed, so why can it here? if it says double on both effects, shoudl the second double not remove the first double, and be at 3200?
My suggestions are as follows. Rata aka rank10ygo, duel logs, or tgs anime.
Theses are tough rulings.
wait, does the carrot ruling works the same against continous traps, like gozen match or rivalry?
please, PLEASE have cimo and gage together for an episode
head to head battles either gren maju or tearlamnets
Coder with sunlight in the background
In terms of last question. If they choose to send Towers would it actually send?
Cause I’ve had situations on Master Duel when I’ve summoned Metaphys Horus using the effect of making my opponent choose a monsters they control and give it to me they selected said Towers (and Ulti Falcon) and it did not switch to my control
To answer your question, yes the Towers will be sent to the GY, because the Live Twins has an effect that makes the player perform a certain game action, and does not interact directly with said Towers. Do you follow me so far?
As for your Metaphys Horus example, this interaction is a lot like Creature Swap. Creature Swap, despite its wording, does not make the player perform a game action, but rather affects the monsters themselves. Thus, when resolving the effect of Creature Swap and cards like it (such as your Metaphys Horus, for example) if the opponent were to choose a monster that is unaffected by said Creature Swap effect, the monster swap does not take place, and the card resolves without effect.
Thank you for this
I have no idea what deck he plays but can you get Tyler Telford of Dead Soldier Inc on the show?
We need seereax dotodoya or rhymestyle on this show!
They are one of the best editors in the yugitubing space fr
🥹🥹💖💖💖 omg stahp you’re so sweet
How is "banished face-down" different from "sending to the gy" in the context of getting rid of tokens? you can send a token for Ki-Sikil & Lil-La but not banish for Evenly? how does that makes sense? I get that it cant be face-down but, like, a token cant be in gy as well.
"They just go *poof*"
What if you do this quiz with The Duel Logs DuelLogs, but for BANNED cards specfically?
ohhhhhhhhh that hardleg tease is sooooo gooood!!!!!!!!
Question: say opponent activates Mine, I respond with Carrot quick eff as CL2 tributing a lv2, when resolving backwards, am I not allowed to simply pop Mine before its effect begins applying?
Similar as if my opponent flips IO and I respond with Cyclone as CL2, poping IO before it begins applying its effect
Yeah you can, but like, why would you? If you can pop the mine, why are you also activating Carrot effect?
Direygo with generaider
Calieffect with salamngreat or earthmachine/machina
When will we see Ruggles on the show? Maybe Glad Beast rulings?
Tou should do "does ACP aka GoatDuels know goat format rullings?"
Cyberknight with Dragunity rulings wil be interesting
I think more PhoenixFlareX when it comes to the Dragunity archetype, but I know he's currently doing his own thing with his own life.
Still would like to see Cyberknight do one of these quizzes, but idk if he's really "well known" for Dragunity. He seems like he just builds whatever he's super interested in. Although...maybe he could do a quiz on the Number monsters. He does collect all of them, in every rarity possible (he's got a binder dedicated to just the Numbers), so maybe a "Does Cyberknight Know "Number" Rulings" video would be very interesting to see.