Bill to Exclude CJI from Appointing CEC, ECs: Legislative Power Over Supreme Court: | UPSC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ธ.ค. 2024
- New StudyIQ Channel - / @upsccsestudyiq | Subscribe Now for Exclusive Videos and Amazing Content. Bill to Exclude CJI from Appointing CEC, ECs: Legislative Power Over Supreme Court: | UPSC
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August Batch : bit.ly/3OR0VCJ
Batch Starting on 11th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3OR0VCJ
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August Hindi Batch
बैच 11 अगस्त 2023 से शुरू हो रहा है | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3Qy5F1d
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August English Batch
Batch Starting on 11th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/446zwAW
UPSC IAS Long Term Prelims to Interview (P2I) LIVE 2025 August Batch
Batch Starting on 14th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/44YJuW9
UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 2
Batch Starting on 14th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/45fCpAg
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw
(PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature)
UPSC IAS (Mains) PSIR Optional Live 2024 (Comprehensive) Auguat Batch
Batch Starting on 16th August, 2023 | Class Timing -1:00 PM
To know more visit : bit.ly/3YHYjdL
UPSC IAS (Mains) Sociology Optional Live 2024 (Comprehensive) Auguat Batch
Batch Starting on 16th August, 2023 | Class Timing -1:00 PM
To know more visit : bit.ly/3DLi2PY
Uttar Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 3
Batch Starting on 18th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3qpxoq9
Bihar PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 3
Batch Starting on 18th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3QvoxOe
Gaurav Sir Current Affairs bit.ly/3jwDRsv
Complete Static GK by Dr. Gaurav Garg bit.ly/3O0FaxE
Banking Awareness (Static) by Dr Gaurav Garg bit.ly/36dElAI
Vipan Sir Courses - Courses to help you gain an edge with MCQs preparation
10000 MCQs of GA by Vipan Sir bit.ly/367qqMi
GS - Dr. Vipan Goyal bit.ly/3vbslbn
Download the App to Subscribe to the Course - bit.ly/StudyiqApp
For any doubt, Call 080-6897-3353 or Click here for Whatsapp Chat wa.me/917703861353
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August Batch : bit.ly/3OR0VCJ
Batch Starting on 11th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3OR0VCJ
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August Hindi Batch
बैच 11 अगस्त 2023 से शुरू हो रहा है | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/3Qy5F1d
UPSC IAS LIVE Prelims to Interview (P2I) 2024 August English Batch
Batch Starting on 11th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/446zwAW
UPSC IAS Long Term Prelims to Interview (P2I) LIVE 2025 August Batch
Batch Starting on 14th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/44YJuW9
UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 2
Batch Starting on 14th August 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM
Hurry Enrol Now : bit.ly/45fCpAg
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw
(PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature)
😢
😊
Option D
Under article 143
Eb
❤❤❤❤
Now, the quote is.... Absolute power corrupt absolutely...
People corrupt absolute power absolutely ....
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@nayanv-v7zunhe kya pata!! Wo to chauthi fail hai
Exactly
@@nayanv-v7z mere pg pe to nai laga hai
A bill should also be introduced on raising the educational standard as one of the eligibility criterion to contest various elections in India. The changing times need MPs MLAs having no less than a Masters degree in various fields & the Cabinet Portfolios should be assigned according to their specific traits. Sirf Pension, Salary or Perks or muft ka Ration khilaane ke liye MPs MLAs nahi banaye gaye hain apne Desh me
Aadmi vote na kare aise logon ko solution ho gya
And also before elections the party should state it clearly who will be head of different departments like Defence, Finance, etc and what are there qualification with proofs...
yes.. there also be criteria for voting right .. people should be atleast gratuate to vote other wise illetrate people will vote such petty thing
True
Best comment so far🎉
जो भी Power में होता है, उसे ऐसा लगता है, वो हमेशा रहेगा.
Supreme Court ⚖️ नहीं चाहता कोई उसके Judges 👨⚖️ के Appointment में दखल दें
जब केंद्र सरकार और जनता 👪 चाहती है कि Judges का Appointment निरपेक्षता से हो, जो पूरे राष्ट्र 🇮🇳 के लिए अच्छा है
लेकिन Supreme Court सबके काम में दखल देना चाहता है
जय हिंद जय भारत🇮🇳
this is applicable to even judiciary also bro
Aisi obvious se baaatei krke kya james bond wali feeling aati h kya😅
@@Priyaykanth2uska kaaran Fair Election hai..
Government kyun fair elections nahi chahti wo explain karo..itna bhi kya political Parties ki chaatna..
Haan, jesse apna CJI soch rha hai
As expected.... किसी भी सत्ता के पतन के कुछ सर्वमान्य कारण होते है। इतिहास में भी यही हुआ किंतु दुर्भाग्य है कि हम इतिहास से सीखने की बजाय, दोहराने में प्रबल विश्वास करते हैं 😊
Loll... Hindu to jagg raha h... Tu dadhi kata le pahle ...
@@swadeshdas2119 😊 मुखिया मुख सो चाहिए खान पान कहूं एक। पालत पोलत सकल अंग तुलसी सहित विवेक।।
@@swadeshdas2119😂😂😂 aaj kal to tere shiv ke bhi dadhi uug aai hai
@@mohammadnaushad9809 meaning?
@@swadeshdas2119kuch Hindu dusro ko jagate jagate khud ankhe band kar k ek party ki god mai so chuke h.
Selection Committee must be independent from politicians,
Politicians are always taking decision according to their interests 😢
Selection Committee must be independent from politicians
What about sc judges
Ambedkar ji keh gaye hai, ke acha samvidhan bhi galat admi ke hath me tabahi kar sakta hai.
अम्बेडकर जी ने कहा था कानून बनाओ पर 75 सालों मे नहीं बनाया गया था अब बन गया
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
Itna hi Acha samvidhan tha to abhi tak samvidhan me 100 se Jayada changes Q huye??
Reservation
@@nayanv-v7ztaaki govt ko tax mile
This shows that what Govt want.
2014 se pahile kaise krte the fir 😂😂
Chamche
@@Saa5962Sabconstitution k according. Tujhe pata nahi hoga shayad
@@sourav3199ghanta constitution k according 🤣🤣 acha se sunn rule he ab banaya gaya hai😂 lagta hai tuje aata nahi samaj mai 😂
Supreme court ka kaam hai law bana na naa ki politics mai Gus na Supreme court ke pass koi right he nahi ye sabh chiz ka appointment karne ka
The dictator is doing what he excels at, which is dictating.
What's the definition of a dictator?
Ur sentence is as oxymoron as your name . He gets elected by people every year. Let's have elections for judges also like in US then they can have a say in matters of democracy
@@biswasrout7759Modi
@@raghuveersinghrathore7395 he is elected. With absolute majority
@@pranavjetly7855hahaha true. Lekin fir ye chandrachud nepotism se kese andar aaega😂 power nhi chali jaegi iski😂
The order of supreme court is best in this matter.....in order to conduct fair and transparent elections in country the appointment of Chief Election commissioner is very crucial. So i think CJI should must be part of it to avoid any type of impartiality
then sc judges also hold very imp post let cec and ec be the part of collegium to select milords
@@AbhiSingh-qr1li PM is already party of it
Let the judiciary be transparent first
@@rajhandique4399 It is much morr transparent and unbiased than the current govt who is murdering democracy.
And who elects CJI? Is Is India a democracy or judicial?
this bill indicates how govt is openly fearing for 2024.
and how they r desperate to control every institution.
😂😂😂
True
70 saal se government matlab PM hi ek mantra insaan the jo EC aur CECs ko select karte the.
CJI should be included in selection committee for transparency of elections
CJI ko bhi bol na Justice ki appointment ma govt ko rights de
70000 cases us Supreme Court ma pending hai jahan CJI bathta hai
Khud inko 150 din Holliday chaye year ma but govt ke kamo m tang adane ki fursat gai
judges koi bhagwan nehi hota hai ke unke har bat sun na chaihe govt.ka bhi power hai...
True
@@DesertCult786 agar judge bi government lgayegi to bss hogya desh mai insaaf fir seeda hi North Korea ki tra ek raaja hi bnado
This is scary ..why nobody is talking about this 😢
Exactly. Each(Legislative & Executive) of them are powerful in their own sectors. Still Judiciary can interpret in law making process if The Constitution of India is being Voilated.
@@zaqs1970Exactly 💯
@@aerobgamer3475Exactly. This is the main problem. Each(Legislative & Executive) of them are powerful in their own sectors. Still Judiciary can interpret in law making process if The Constitution of India is being Voilated.
@@zaqs1970COMMON aadmi sirf court ja skta awaz uthane ke liye agar usko bhi government chunoti degi uski power kam krne lgi aise hi to court se bhi bharosa khtm ab hamara
@@zaqs1970vot to common admi karta hai commonsense less man😂
Election in democracy should be biased free, and fair.... Appointing CECs without leader of opposition and meddling with independent bodies of the country is undemocratic... Hence not less than anarchy....
Ryt
@@im_bharatiyaidiot constitution says that Election Commission should be independent. If selection committee having PM and Minister being part of 3 member committee cannot be independent hence its Constitutional. First read rules. Now don't say that Supreme Court order says that parliament has right to make laws. Yes they do have powe to make laws but parliament should also obey constitutional boundries set up by Constitution. Constitution says that Selection process should be independent. Parliament cannot ignore this condition.
@@avdhutpawar1545Did Constitution say CJI must be part of selection committee for EC ??😂...Saying Constitution for everything wont make anything constitutional.
First Judiciary must be reformed.Archaic Collegium system must be overhauled.
@@kirankoti6316 judgement just says that until parliament makes any law till then committee consist of PM, Leader Of Opposition and CJI will appoint EC just like CBI director. This will ensure that Government will not have full control of appoinnent hence independence of Election Commission will be maintained. If in future parliament makes any law then new commettie will take over the appoinment but parliament must make sure that committie must be neutral.
Well if it’s not a discussion of Liberandu as a free thinker I say Cab. Secretary should give name of 15 people who have capacity & capability to become EC out of which the committee member consisting of PM, Led. Of Opp ,Cab Minister & Opp Minister and they must elect 3 member and each must agree on selection of each member.
3 EC to keep a check on each other
Neither the last 65 years process was democratic nor this is.
This bill just kills the very spirit of our Indian Constitution.......
70 saal se EC aur CECs ko PM hi select karte the tab toh koi tanashahi nahi dikha kya??
@@swastikayanghosh160तुझे तानाशाही दिखी बता दे भाई
ये लोग कितना तानाशाही किए देख लो 9 साल में किसान बिल, डेमोनेटाइजेशन .....
Madam,Seperation of power nam ki bhi chij hoti hogi, law bnane ka right sirf parliament ko h 70 sal se same tha pr ab court ne khud ko ghusa liya ye appointment ka sc ka kbse ho gya, ना to es desh me 70 se tha और ना hi uk and usa के constitution me h
@@sandeepsinghshekhawat1629 bhai ye log alag hi nshe me hi 😂
@@swastikayanghosh160 lack of knowledge 😂
This is the blatant tussle of power between executive, legislative and judiciary 😢😢😢
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@nayanv-v7z Kyunki aaj se pehle sarkar ki nazar nahi padi thi students pe
@@DriveDawn aab bhai saadi krne pe v lagega GST😂😂
Sab par lagana chahiy gst
1% salaried tax payer hi kyu sambhale desh ko
Karodpati farmers bina tax diye ghum rhe scorpio thar fortuner me
@@jaimahakal4924 ha bhai sahi baat he aapki. Ab toh ham student logo ki bhi kamar tod di he. Wo makan malik gst badhne se rent badha raha he 😭😭
The way of development in democracy is quite interesting to learn law provisions with case study😊😊
Dictatorship coming soon
Democracy should be supreme
Democracy ab khatam ho gyi h
@@AshishGupta-of5px ha ha 😂😂🤣
@@AshishGupta-of5px kya hoti democracy...pata hai.. bas Chuslaman bala dialog de diya
Option D , when President asks for it , Advisory jurisdiction (Art. 143)
Ec must be independent and for this CJI must be in the selection committee..... Hope so.....
Kavi constitution pdha hai tumne jahil lagte ho apni bato se tum
30 likes ese hi nahi Mila use
Then to select judge sc must exclude from selection commision they only select those who work according to their idology. Gud job govt
@@akashdhawan6905 aap bata do
@@akashdhawan6905dhanyawad constitution likhne kelye😢
Now i am feeling our democracy in danger 😢😢😢😢😢😢
Cry hard
I thought it was from 2014, maybe that was just nonsense 🤔
Isse pahle only pm krte the selection tb nhi thi democracy khatre me ........ system same hi h phle hi jesa
Naah bro , punjab is in danger from khalistani goons
They should add pm of india in the selection process of CJI.
I think the order of supreme court should be followed. This will ensure the a minimal unbiased selection of the CEC and ECs. The main power of nominating 5 names for CEC still rests with the cabinet secretary so there is no point in involving a cabinet minister in the selection committee.
supreme Court नहीं चाहता कोई उसके Judges के Appointment में दखल दें
लेकिन वो सबके काम में दखल देना चाहता है
जय हिंद जय भारत
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
Absolute power corrupts absolutely
For those who are saying that they are doing wrond first of all from the past 75 years the election commissions are appointed by central govt just in recent times it was questioned and supreme court said till time there is no legislation this committee decision should follow...so there is nothing new this govt came up with its happening from the past...and in my opinion yes the third person should be neutral but it shouldn't b cji...now the selection should be on consensus not on majority
@@chetanbhalla565 In India which person is more neutral than CJI.
Ye dikhata hai ki is desh ke sansado ko desh ki kitni fikr hai same on government on this bill
Supreme court should also be open about how judges are appointed.
If u put a govt above court, it means u are putting a party above courts.
No party in this world can be non biased. Thats why having faith in courts is most important. Courts can't have personal gains, but when u elect a party to powder they have many things to gain.
@@ultimexg1419how is he putting party above court he is just saying appointment of cji should be open bcoz we are democratic country why the appointment should be done in shadows 🤔
@addyaddy3333 What about nepotism in select judges in courts? Is it democratic?
@@ultimexg1419What about nepotism in select judges in courts? Is it democratic?
@@addyaddy3333jb tumhari sarkar ayegi tb tum krlena😂😂
Supreme Court want time waste on sibbal cases on 370. But no time to correct pending cases
सही बात भाई,जो केसेज सालों से पेंडिंग है उसको खत्म नही किया जा रहा है,370 पर बहस हो रही है।
Aap Supreme court se jyada jante hain ? , You should respect your supreme court as an Indian , SC is the Protector of your fundamental rights.
At every step it is going Supreme court Vs Govt. , It means kahe n kahe toh problem hai , koe na koe toh desh ko colonized karna chahta hai.
Alert !!
अक्ल के अंधे हलुआ है न, एक मिनट में एक केस निपटा दें; आधे से ज्यादा सरकारी केस ही हैं
@@iamvinay2 Chapri ho kya , bolne se pehle socha toh karoo
Abhi SC me Gay ka mamla chal raha hai jo ki bahut important hai😂
Supreme court is right. Opposition should protest unless they are thinking about misusing it when they will be in power.
Bhaii leader of opposition already rhta hai us committee me. CJI ko hr hr jagah ugli krna hai to kya ho.
@@shailendrasinghbaghel9305
So, leader of opposition is just for name sake and show piece?
It needs only *2 yes* to appoint the CEC,EC.
Voiceless with 1 yes.
Selection process surely becomes unfair
I repeat
Selection process becomes unfair
LoO becomes a decoration to the panel?
Opposition was in power for 70 years. Why didn't they create the law? Why? Why? They knew they can play this move only once. Badhai ho aam choopiye. Aap fir se choopiye ban gaye.
@@shailendrasinghbaghel9305mughalpoot ho
@@GST_Wallahbangal me opposition nahi chahiye dogle, jaha panchayat chunav bhi hinsa hota hai
Its Very Dangerous For Democracy😢😢
😂😂😂😂
@@RKS442 brahmn andhbhgt come
@@pm6516 😚😚😚 I am proud of it.
@@RKS442well come with solid argument rather than faces
Wasn’t it dangerous when in last 65 years President selected EC on recommendation from PM. Oh sorry you’re another Liberandu
Maine POLITY KI NCERTs padhi hai wahan pe example Diye the ki Jab jab desh ke logon ne apne dear leader ko dictator banaya hai
Baad mein usi dictator ne unki pushte khatam kar di hain.....
So be careful dear citizens🙏
Then what about china 😂
Kon si ncrt me pda he
well said
the only comment ..that is making sense .😀
they have become expansionist powers whether through underhand tactics or legal power in their hands
They were selecting among themselves, constitutionally it's illegal. Even Ambedkar was against it.
Ambedkar what did
Ambedkar is the father of Indian constitution and he is the most scholar man in this world and no body can compete in terms of intellectual level and educational qualifications❤❤
He is only one person in this world, who acquired degree of Doctor of Science.
sad moment😂
Supporting u
EC and all the agencies like CBI, ED should be independent.
What do you mean when you say independent ?
They operate without accountability to anyone ?
@@Mithileshkumar-pb2kvhave you heard about supreme court comment??sc has called CBI parrot 🐦.thoda padho likho
@@SumitKumar-nv9bq bhai, what nonsense you are talking. If some institution is acting in influence that doesn't mean we should make it independent. Nothing is independent and nothing can be independent. Even the president can be held accountable. Even the supreme court judge can be removed.
@@Mithileshkumar-pb2kv you are not understanding what independent mean exactly?do you believe in the supreme court?
According to article 143 constitution of India when president ask to give advice on perticular matter then CJI will give his advice. But the point is that advice is not bound to follow by president
cji can deny giving advise too. this is madness
@@damon993yes, because there is already an attorney general available for legal advice for the president
@@Therealtruthexposure as much as I know attorney general give advices to cabinate minister whenever they ask. And his main duty to appear in courts on behalf of government
@@damon993 there are two categories of the matter on which opinion can be taken,
1. on any question of law of fact of public importance which has arisen, or which is likely to arise.
2. on any dispute arising out of any pre-constitunal treaty, agreement, covenant, engagement, Sanad or other similar instrument.
the Supreme Court may refuse on first one but in the second case, the supreme cout must tender its opinion.
opinion is advisory in nature in both the cases. not binding on Prez
इसीलिए देश का पीएम पढ़ा लिखा होना जरूरी हैं।
Toh bring change ess bar
Only Krezywala is to be made PM as being the only imandar aur bada padha hua neta hai
Chu ese bolte hei😂
@@perepaprabhakarasarma3150lund mera pada likha
Pehle tuu padhai karle fir baat karne aana
Please save Indian democracy ❤️❤️
Indian democracy is in Safe hands
It means weak opposition means democracy going toward Anarchy
opposition that sells freebies which destory the economy
Yes agr anarchy hogayi toh hamara desh China and Russia jaisa developed hojayega and we are very against it! Brother u raise your voice dnt worry we dnt want development as last 9 years , we want loot kasod like last 50 years!
Weak opposition or strong andhbhakts...
Dictatorship coming soon divide rule
@@sauravchauhan8909 what really anarchy se koi country developed hoota hai ,hmare freedom fighter waise hi sahid ho gye iss din kai liye ki koi Indian citizen yeh bolega wahh bhai , brother if you r preparing for civils than please chod do wo tyari your basic concepts are very very weak
The procedure of Supreme Court is the best.
विनाश काले विपरीत बुद्धि 🙏🙏🙏
Last 5 years SC is directly interfering in executive power by at any cost there should be some check and balances , although they want to in limelight, bypassing the power of Highcourt and lower courts also, they are deciding height of dahi handi, Jalikutti festival, who are hindus , rally,
Dictatorship coming soon
Jindgi bhar hindu this, hindu that hi kariyo😒
@@ashishsunny7963aur tum bas jindagi bhar hinduyo ko maaroge , hindu ladkiyo ka rape karoge to kya ham justice nahi maangenge
@@ashishsunny7963 kya mtlb ye zindagi bhr berozgaar rahega 💀
Trying to establish autocracy...
so before 2023 there was autocracy right ??
You need to understand that someday in future opposition will come to power and they wouldn't want this rule to exist so calm down😅
@@Diasaster andhabhagat
Exactly. Each(Legislative & Executive) of them are powerful in their own sectors. Still Judiciary can interpret in law making process if The Constitution of India is being Voilated.
Mai tho pehle se hi keh raha tha. Pr manta khon hai. Ab bhugte pura desh. Aur kya hoga yeahi hoga
I expect sc to abrogate this bill when passed.
SC can't... Because rule for nomination of EC is to be made by Legislative... And SC itself said in its order that our order is till the Legislature made Rule...
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@nayanv-v7zpaisa chahiye.... nxt yr election mein spend krna hai
@@pany167 to bhai ham student logo ne kya bigadaa he. 😓😓
I think u r a pappu fan.😅
Sir please make a video on latest CAG report on pm health insurance scam....
If you will pass through the area in which these MP lives around in South Delhi your heart will bleed to see the facilities most of these criminals getting.
Country: Ye ho kya Raha hai!
Govt: Hoga wahi Jo hum chahegey!
Opposition: kya karein!
Exactly. Each(Legislative & Executive) of them are powerful in their own sectors. Still Judiciary can interpret in law making process if The Constitution of India is being Voilated.
@@yashshivhare9623spam Krna bnd kr
country: tuu apna comment hata la😂
💯
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
SC should declare this decision as an unconstitutional thing
Who gives SC so much power to call the decision of parliament unconstitutional. SC only can interpret law not to make a law. If SC does so that SC judge can be dismissed by parliament.
Remove basic structure of constitution that is also unconstitutional
@@sumansarkar6984chomu basic structure
@@sumansarkar6984under judicial review the higher judiciary has the power to determine and invalidate any executive act or legislative act which is inconsistent with the constitution of India.
@@radheyadav6048 then there is no need of fundamental rights as well. Why SC would be bothered about this. Autocracy rule will be applied to our country.
SC is like an umpire (a neutral body) which is required.
Yeah, this umpire want to get involved in appointment of CEC and ECs but this umpire doesn't want any other to get involved in it's appointment of judges and CJI
@@ParikhTirthso you want the ruling party to get involved in appointment of judges??
No its a biased body
So, SC should never overpass Parliament !!!
@@destinations4u196opposition leader is also welcomed there but elected members of perliament not being there is not right.
In democracy If Ruling party (Govt) weakens judiciary means Current Govt want to stick to power by hook & crook & it's on their way to autocracy 😢
60-70 sal ek party ne raj kiya wha konsi democracy thi beta 😂😂
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@Saa5962Sabchutiye history pad le WhatsApp university ke
Ruling party janta se aati hai. Janta above any CJI or supreme court
@@Saa5962Sab tumhari to 10 saal m hi saans fool gyi🤣🤣
We should always respect our supreme Court judgments. This is totally unconstitutional the way the government pass this bill. The only conclusion that emerges from this bill is that the government is appointing its own puppet.
It means u are slave of SC.
If u can not question SC then u are not better than orthodox muslims !
@@FakeAccount-wp5wv I'm not a slave bro just think intellectually and then comment this bill make no sense if it's going to be appoint by 3-1 . If election's commission is independent then this bill make no sense
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@ROHIT22718Who was electric EC before... It was solely PM... Now this government has included opposition member... Atleast better than previous govt
1 October se kya hostel Or PG ke rent par 12 percent GST taxx lagega?? Yanki ki ab hostel ka rent mehnga hoga kya??
What would the government lose if CJI was in the appointment commission? Why does it want 2 nominees from its side in the committee? The answer is simple. If they are just, they need not do such acts. This is dangerous and they have crossed a big line.
Bro earlier there was only PM appointing, now there is involvement of opposition also...what else do you want
System wasn't just earlier and it's going to stay as it is
So if there is vote required to be taken on some decision then 2 votes will be majority and in favor of govt only so what's thr use of opposition in the list
@@ParikhTirthये सारे जज भी तो भाई भतीजावाद की उपज है । जनता ने इन्हें नही चुना, बल्कि ये ऊपर से हमारे ऊपर थोप दिए गए
Dictatorship coming soon
Ur comment is as logical as considering myself as dog because dog and me both have eyes
Attempt to bypass the SC to clear the path of arbitrariness...
It is the duty of govt & Parliament to upheld constitutional values discarded by Judiciary
@@naveenparashar4483judiciary and supreme court is the biggest and best interpretor of constitution, not the govt.
Thats why judiciary has the most powers including those to review any law which is enacted.
Test mae invigilator khud choose karoge toh pura world tumhe top marne pe doubt hi karega
@@ultimexg1419constitution says separation of power, so judiciary can't do whatever it likes , and govt still doing on basis of constitution
We should follow the same procedure in the recruitment of CJI also or atleast we can have a healthy discussion about that.
Right
Why
as a citizen of India, I agree with supreme court judgement . Election commission officer must be selected by The CJI,The PM , Leader of opposition. it is the best Combination of power for selecting independent Chief election commission officer. if not happen this government puppet will be election commission officer(no independent)
State election commissioner is chosen by state govt still like west Bengal govt chose for panchayat elections recently. Supreme court didn't interfere in that, it only targeted Central government in this rule. That shows open bias against ruling central govt in this order. So govt is right to bring this ordinance. Hypocrisy ki bhi koi seema hoti hai.. that's why you didn't talk about state govt still able to chose their own election commissioners.
@@punkedcrapThe power of the central gov is the same as the state gov??
Common man
Have you read the Judgement.
Judgement said that untill & unless law provided CEC shall be appointed by panel of CJI,PM & Leader of Largest opposition Party.
Election Commissioners act like Tribunal & hold constitutional office which ensure their independence.
Moreover any decision of Election Commission can be overturn by any High Court.Which ensure that accountability on CEC & EC can be enforced.
I agree
@@punkedcrapkarnataka ka bhi election comission bhi state government hi choose karta hai?
Supreme court should declared null or void for this bill
They Cant
@@hackeryt8292They Can. But we cannot say whether they will or they won't. 👍
Supreme Court doesn't want fare appointed procedure in Judiciary but wants power share in all executive bodies...hypocrisy ki bhi koi seema hoti h ...if election commission was kept free from Judiciary intervention by constitution makers there must be some good reasons...if governments are not doing good public can dethrone them but if Judges are doing bad no one can even talk about that u can face contempt of court...and they say we are savings democracy wah wah
LAW is not blind, it tends to make people under its rule blind, so that, people framing the law gets treated as GOD. Same laws made by Britishers are still running now, why ? they made laws to rule us, why are we still following it? need to diminish the powers given to judges of SC, cji, etc. and give some powers to public. Public should have some powers to.
Exactly first supreme court change collegium procedure then according to me it's right decision. 👌
@@sambitranjan9584
No, that's not how things work bro .
A SC can't interfere in executive bodies . SC themself is discarding the provisions of the constitution and then blaming others when others do it
@sambitranjan9584 before saying someone illiterate ...please check your education level and knowledge first...your language itself saying how shameless you are...For your kind information Judiciary is not guardian of democracy Judiciary is guardian of constitution...thoda padh likh le bhai aur samjh le in dono ke bich difference
Election commission should be a independent body to conduct election without fear and favour. #Its a undemocratic act #It will weaken democracy of India #It will weaken election commission of india #CJI should be in appointment committee. #Jai Hind
What transperency and constitution law follow by SC in appointment of judges
CJI also appoint CBI, chairman
@@BrijeshSingh-vz8zcसारे जज भी तो भाई भतीजावाद की उपज है । चाचा अपने भतीजे को कुर्सी सौप कर चला जाता है
Law should be also made on selection of judges
Ha yha bacha hua h ise bhe control kro
@@SanuSingh-to7ko obviously it should be controlled, 2 out of 3 judges in India are part of parivarwaad
Njac laye the supreme court ne unconstitutional Bata diya
Sabse corrupt h supreme court
Before commenting such brainless comment one should know that India is a very corrupt country.. so thoda bhot judiciary hai wo bhi barbad ho jaega
Part V
Article 143
POWER OF PRESIDENT TO CONSULT SUPREME COURT.
(a) law of Public importance - SC may tender or may refuse
(b) pre constitutional treaty - SC must tender
In both cases president is not bind to follow.
Totally right, CJI has no right to appoint election commissioner.
Pagal hai kya be
@@studytechchandan8692 Canada, Usa, uk, japan kahin bhi judiciary involve hota h CEC appointment me. Agar democratically elected government pe bharosa nhi h to vote mt de bhai.
@@ajaychowdhary7394 Tum logo ka comparison hi selective hai ....abhi koi negative cheez compare krdi na ....aa jao ge muh uthakr defend krne ....seriously tum logo se bda hypocrite koi bhi nii
@@versatilegang1747 Bhai sara court ka judgement aur constitution comparative study pe hi based h, isme itna trigger hone wali kya baat.
Now this move is concerning
Now the game will start on the doctrine of basic structure and i think results will be the same as NJAC.
Exactly bro
That time Legislature entered into Judiciary.
This time Judiciary has entered into legislature.
Judicial overreach.
If they scrap the law then it will be hypocritical to doctrine of separation of power cus this time Court will be violating the basic structure.
Only Third Member of panel pe amendment krne bol skta SC.
Njac ajata to fer sab gov ka control m
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@nayanv-v7zmodi need money for election compaign..thats why.
Now government can do anything whatever they want like this
Ambedkar kar nehi kar paye
I think this is good. Judiciary must not be integrated with politics. That's why three distinct department
@@techodisha4836 andhabhagat
@@techodisha4836 so you want that government or elected party in centre can use election commission and enforced directorate as their wish
@@techodisha4836EC isn't in politics
वहीं हो रहा है जो इजरायल में हों रहा है, जब चुनाव आयुक्त ही स्वतन्त्र नहीं होगा तो फिर चुनाव करवाने का क्या फायदा? किसी भी देश के लिए सुप्रीम कोर्ट और चुनाव आयुक्त का स्वतन्त्र होना बहुत जरूरी है लोकतंत्र के लिए। इनके बिना लोकतंत्र कि कल्पना करना व्यर्थ है 🙏🙏🙏
कोलेजियम सिस्टीम एक बार पड लीजिए समझने आयेगा अपना न्याय व्यवस्था कैसा है...
@@aryanb2770 तो आप ही बताइए क्या किया जाए , है कोई इससे बेहतर उपाय आप के पास ?🤔🤔
@@aryanb2770point par bat kar???
Aj kal free chunav nhi hote balki daru ki botal pe vote kharide jate hai local parties k dwara
A perfect neutral body consisting
1 PM
2 LoO
3 CJI
4 current cec
5 law minister
Wah bhai mast h
In Today either you support govt and make sure your retire plan or Govt remove you from your post by tactics.....RBi governor se lekar president Tak ainke hath me aur judge ko bhi retire plan de kar apni taraf krr rahe he
Bhai ab upar se student ke hostel par bhi 12 percent GST laga diya he 😩😩😩
@@nayanv-v7zkya baat kar rahe ho?
@@ris454 ha bhai. Recently GST council ki meeting hui he usme bola he. Aap bro गूगल kar sakte ho ya utub par searchh kar lo bro.
Complete judiciary is based on collegium, and they only talk about executive selection,i still remember when our previous law minister said in parliament to make a new way to appoint judiciary how they got annoyed, because of which law minister was replaced.
Yeah but there should be five member pm, opposition leader,cji, cabinet minister and a military leader
Atleast it will create a balance...the soldier knows better than this people.
Dictatorship coming soon
If there would be any committe which has power to appoint judge which has Executive or Legislature interference then there would be no seperate of Judiciary and independence of judiciary. Judiciary is itself seperate organ of govt. Though Collegium ia jot perfect but it is better than Njac
it is totally right judiciary should not interfare in politics
Election Commission neutrality is not politics, it is a must for democracy.
Do you know what is politics 😂😂 EC is independent body
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@princemyself1212💯
Selection of CEC & ECS should be unbiased in every manners.
It is 100 % correct not to involve Chief Jilustice or any justice in selectionnof of CEC OR EC. If Chief Justice is there in the selection panel, he may not be able to go justice if the selected CEC OR EC does any mischief on the ground that the Chief Justic ability will be doubtful for wrong selection or he has to bear in his mind while dealing such poeople cases.
Purely it is the ruling party selection nothing to do kwith the opposition and Chief justice.
Excellent work by Supreme Court
Supreme Court नहीं चाहता कोई उसके Judges के Appointment में दखल दें
जब केंद्र सरकार चाहती है कि Judges का Appointment निरपेक्षता से हो, जो पूरे राष्ट्र के लिए अच्छा है
Supreme Court नहीं चाहता उसके काम में कोई दखल दे
लेकिन वो सबके काम में दखल देना चाहता है
जय हिंद जय भारत🇮🇳
@@Priyaykanth2kit crll har jgha h tu
Good move by current govt. ✌✌
@@addyaddy3333be Logical
The Supreme Court verdict should be obeyed by the govt. if the same way the court's decision will continue to return then the courts should be closed.
Supreme Court नहीं चाहता कोई उसके Judges के Appointment में दखल दें
लेकिन वो सबके काम में दखल देना चाहता है
जय हिंद जय भारत
Phale Jaa kar SC ka verdict padho... SC itself said that their order is valid till Legislature made a rule... And as per Constitution Rule of Nomination of EC is to be made by Legislature
Kya koi bata sakta he sarkar ne student ke hostel Or PG par 12 percent GST taxx kyu lagaya????
@@love-yq6kb lol no. Everyone has different roles. The legislative, executive and judiciary. The courts play the role of protecting the rights of citizens if there is misuse by political leaders or anywhere and thus keep the ruling government and opposition both in check.
@@guptakjanardanyou are giving same reply in every comment are you try to divert people view on this case
According to Aristotle while criticising Plato said.power is like honey when it fall on tongue of someone's then it is impossible to pull in the tongue into the mouth
Last sentence of Ambedkar's speach in constitutional assembly.....😢😢😢
Dheere dheere democracy se door jata hua mera pyara bharat😢
Can you explain your claim with a reference to the indian constituition ?
Constitution hi democracy hai .
Opposite ka leader nahi hi kya , iss committee may
@@SONUKUMAR-hu9nrDimaag se paidal toh nahi ho... 3 logo ki Comittee me 2 log govt ke hi hongee toh 1 opposition ke hone ka fyadaa kyaa
Before 2014 supreme court never wanted to change appointment procedure of election commisioner... Now they are trying to do this..govt did right thing..
Colegium system should be abolished too
A judge who is confused about the concept of male & female shouldn't be allowed in SC
Bro nailed it 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
People who have zero knowledge of difference between gender and sex, should refrain from commenting over CJIs remarks.
@@ashishsunny7963 "gender, sex" Indeed i got no nowledge 🤡
😂😂😂
This raises the question on credibility of CEC
Thank you for your wonderful session 😊
i m bjp supporter but this scares me 😢plz save our democracy
For past 75 years there were no CJI in selection committee... Had democracy lost?
bhai itne saalo se yahi system tha lekin ye cji har chiz me apni power dikhana chahata hai
ye cji khud hi ek nepotism ka product hai
This is tanashahi
@@abhinaysingh8306 but bro then take action on cji why on cec... Its necessary for good election...
Iski jarurat bhi hai ab
Supreme court ko sb jagah interfare Krna h bt collegium system me koi dusra na aaye... Without any transparency, judge ka selection hota h... Good move by government...
Uska kaam h chomu
@@SanuSingh-to7ko ullu ke aulad... Har jagah interfare nhi Krna h... Government k 3 organs Legislative, executive, judiciary parallel h... Kisi k pass jada power nhi... Judiciary ka kaam decision ki constitutional validity ko check Krna h... Law bnane ka kaam parliament ka h...
Democracy ki अन्त अस्ति प्रारंभ 😢
Pakistan chala ja mast democracy milega 🤣🤣
@@Selmonbhoi... arey bhaiya bahot purana dialogue hogya
@@iannaadonis to Afghanistan chala ja;
ye naya hai or sahi bhi democracy ke mamale me
@@Selmonbhoi... na re bhaiya . Apne Manipur and bahot se states Mai gangrapes , sexual harrasment by political leaders of even underage kids, public naked parade of women ne toh Afghanistan ko bhi maat dedi. But good try. Just update is necessary of today's reality :)
Excellent decision taken...MY LORD IS EXCLUDED. WOW
People here are discussing about this without actually knowing what the supreme court judgement was.
The 5 judge constituional bench last year ordered that until parliament is making a law , the selection committee should include cji, pm and leader of opposition.
When the parliament makes a law regarding this vaccum, the order will automatically come to an end.
Although this bill is against the spirit of that judgement.
Justice katju has rightly said that 90% Indians are fool, and it is appearing to be true in this
comment section.
Whatever, contents of the bill are obvious & not okay for the independence of the election commission. The rest 10% of the population can very sharply see through this clever trick of the govt. Why not wish to strive to make the Election commission more independent .
Our ancestors will be crying on such current foolish generation.... autocracy is what government wants...and people are blind to see it
But it's not good for democracy
Supreme court' ka kaam judiciary h , legislative ya excutive nhi jo ab appointment karega...
Laxmikanth padh lo ek baar
Basic padh lo kiske pass kya power h
@@princemyself1212 Itna bara book parke tera dimag hang ho gaya 😂😂
Islye pahle Arihant ki polity parle ...😂
@@Political_Reactwhat's app University se graduate hue ho😅
@@princemyself1212
Esa to kuch nhi h laxmikant me ke SC ko intervene karna pade .
Infact dekha jae to basic structure naam ke bhi kuch nhi h constitution me ....bas SC ne apne Marzi ke add kar rakha h 🤷
This is insane move by Gov. Gov trying to take absolute control.
Polity padhke comment karo bhai
@@infinitylofinesssong Bina padhe mai kuch bolta hi nhi. Bas likh diye polity padh k comment kia karo.
Sometimes is not right with NDA government. They are disturbing the fundamental structure. 😢
Dictatorship coming soon
It's reality bro Hinduism in NDA is just politics
Fundamental structure also says judiciary and executive shouldn't interfere with each other so why judiciary is extending his power everywhere if judiciary wants to enters into executive decisions then allow executive to enter into collegium system.
@@kazuma2060 Power separation is important, government is making itself more powerful, which is not good. No one is talking about interfering . They can do so as government passed the law for Delhi .
Which was opposit of supreme courts decision.
@@Sanatan-pe8zy5fk9pat first read the SC verdict about the appointment process
Very well explained sir my all doubt clear 🙏🏻🙏🏻
CJI himself has said they will be involved in selection of election commission till government brings proper bill for that....
Once the proper bill is passed they will not be involved...
Commitiy will include member from opposition, person from ruling government recommended by PM.
Making a law is the job of parliament.
To make sure that all the lawas are being followed, implemented is the job of judiciary.
Last line is incorrect.
This bill should not be passed otherwise it will be not good for our democracy 😢
Abe sale anpadh 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@SagarKumar-lq4fc fir tum hi socho vai hum jaise unpadh logo v samajh gaye ki ye bill democracy k liye khatra hai par ap jaise educated log abhi tak nahi samajh paye 💀
@@sumitdhara2259 abe bevkoof dhyan se video ko fir se dekh lo, constitution bhi yahi kahta hai ki legislative dwara banaya gaya kanoon ke anusar hi CEC ka appointment hoga, supreme court ne isiliye aisa decision diya Kyoki abhi tak CEC ke appointment ko lekar legislative dwara koi law nhi bnaya gaya hai, lekin jab government ab law bana rahi hai to isase Democracy kaise khatre aa gyi, constitution me saaf likha hua hai ki CEC ka appointment legislative dwara bnaya gaya law ke according hoga, to supreme court bich apni taang kyu ghused rahi hai, supreme court ko apne kaam se matlab rakhni chahiye. Tum jaise logo ko Kuch pata hota nhi hai aur comment me akar emotional drama karta aur gyan deta hai, jakr pahle dhang se constitution padho, sarkar bilkul sahi kar rhi hai.
@@SagarKumar-lq4fc Legislative ne koi rule nahi banaya tha regarding to appointment of CEC, PM hi candidate recommend karta tha president ko aur isiliye SC ne ye committee banane ka decision liya tha ye simple chis saf saf bola hai video Mai 🤦 is committee se CEC ka appointment neutral hota, jo sarkar ko pasand nahi aya 😐 [PM, Cabinet minister, Leader of opposition] is committee ka kya hi fayda decision wahi PM ka hi matter karega LoO to just ek decoration ho gya 😂 Parliament k rule anusar hi CEC ka appointment hoga ye sabko pata hai aur problem v wahi pe a raha hai ki legislative jo committee bana raha hai wo bilkul v neutral nahi hai 🥲 ab tumhe sayed govt pe pura varosa se isiliye tumhe koi problem nahi dikh raha 😮💨
@@sumitdhara2259 उस hisab se to fir HC/SC ka judge appointment ko lekar sarkaar ne bhi ek committee bnayi thi NJAC jo collegium system se better tha isme bhi judge ka appointment neutral hota to SC ne ye kahte hue NJAC ko reject kar diya ki isme sarkar ka intefere ho jayega aur collegium system ko continue rakha, to CEC appointment ko lekar SC apni taang kyu ghused rahi hai yaha bhi to court ka interfere ho jayega, SC ko kisne adhikar diya dusre ke kaam me interefere karne ka, Mtlb SC yeh chahti hai ki wo sabhi ke kaam me interefere kare lekin uske kaam me koi interfere nhi kare waah re democracy, sarkaar bahut sahi kar rhi hai, SC ko apni aukaat yaad dilana bahut jaroori tha, judge log khud ko Lord maan liya hai khud ko law se bhi jyada supreme maan liya hai. Bahut jaroori hai Court ko apne ghutne par lana kyonki court aajkal jaroorat se jyada uchhal rahi hai.
Government can include the current chief election commissioner as the third person in selection panel to appoint CEC, ECs
आज से 70 साल तक ये ही व्यवस्था थी तब तक किसी को भी problem नहीं थी, बट अब हो रही हैं....70 सालों में इस व्यवस्था को q नहीं बदला! Hippocracy की भी हद होती हैं! अगर 70 साल से ये निष्पक्ष रूप से हो रहा था तो आगे भी ऐसा ही होगा okkkk
Exactly. Each(Legislative & Executive) of them are powerful in their own sectors. Still Judiciary can interpret in law making process if The Constitution of India is being Voilated.
Until government not introduce Bill in Parliament for selection committee of CEC(Chief Election Commissioner) CJI in process........ It clearly Say Until thats why govt introdused in Parliament..
SC के फ़ैसलो की अब कोई वैल्यू नहीं, सरकार जो चाहे वो कर सकती है 🙄🤒
Because wo overeach kar rahi hain
Jiska jo kaam hain wahi kare
Supreme court pe belive nahi hi govt ko
I didn't see HITLER but I'm seeing modern DICTETOR
Bill should be effective until & unless collegium exists
Wah great decision 🎉🎉❤
Excellent decision by the govt. SC had tried to enter into the vacant space of legislative and executive, which is now shut by the govt via parliament. SC Judge can not become a member to appoint executive posts in India.
Judges are part of deciding various Constitutional Posts. So nothing new.
Teesta Setalvad case is an example how CJI was running in a middle of function to grant her a bail at 10 PM , this shows how independent our judiciary is. If this the case of selection why judges are afraid to demolish Collegium System why cannot be Courts be held accountable of 5 crores pending cases . Hypocrites of judges speaks volume
Because if the collegium system is destroyed then govt. controlled the judiciary and the neutrality of judiciary get abolished
5 crore pending cases are there because there is shortage of courts in India
Tanashahi ki or kadam😮
Not a judiciary right
Is supreme court judge is elected or selected, government is elected by the people of India, they represent the will of the people
Govt. Right to vote not judiciary
Why always hate
@@lethaldose50 mtlb agr sarkar tanashah ho jaye to phir bachane wala koi ni.... 30% vote se sarkar bn jati h to 70% log sirf bhagwan k ashray hi rahenge... good analisis bro
@@whiteice2007 how ??
Option D
Advisory jurisdiction (Article 143)
Day will come when politicians say
Chit bhi meri patt bhi meri.