Pesci *ahem* Kotkin is a true realist not a fatalist like Kissinger or Mearsheimer. The best thing about Stephen Kotkin is he can answer any question no matter how trivial or complex and the perspective from which he sees the world is always fresh and exciting, every answer has some golden nugget of knowledge that is an absolute pleasure to learn. I'd love to see him talking about Ukraine with Timothy Snyder, the brilliance and the IQ in that dialogue would be breathtaking...
He is a fan, advocate of military might as the exercised by the United States. He does not know who the Russians are....He says nothing of the Victoria Nuland power grab....He has never been to war...a historian full of hot air.
I taught German language for 47 years. I tried to weave into it history and culture. As time progressed, I became aware of how political the teaching of history had become. How does one teach history honestly in the current hyper political environment?
Each era had its political environment that discouraged any opposition. The change is, this seems to be a headless monster. The whole of society has a phobia about anyone saying anything 'negative' about them. And there is not one person you can pin on this "McCarthyism"
very late reply, but I think it's a mistake to expect history to be seperate from politics, because politics is part of history (integral part). The key is to have the bravery (or foolhardiness) to speak honestly regardless of the political landscape. To speak truth to power. And that also requires the bravery to both be wrong and accept being wrong.
I'm stunned! This is my first time listening to Kotkin, and what an amazingly insightful person he is. He doesn't come off as being left wing or right wing, just reality-based. I was fortunate enough to have had an amazing teacher who understood history and what its power really was, not memorizing dates, which installed a love of history that is still with me some 50 years later.
Excellent questioning. I like that quotations and asking a succinct question that requires a broad base. And then lets him talk. Peter Robinson is one of the best interviewers.
Okay, it took me 2 days to absorb this presentation. I have to say it's one of the best presentations I have ever seen on several subjects: Ukraine, Russia, China, Taiwan and a quick reference to the American system's self correcting abilities. Well done, gentlemen, and thank you so much!
It's absolutely amazing to hear these great minds. The sheer knowledge of Professor Kotkin and the astonishing interviewing skills of Peter Robinson are a great joy to listen to. As someone else mentioned before; setting up the table, a warm cup of tea and a blanket of wisdom. I have shared the link with many friends and peers already.
Peter Robinson's gift is he knows how to set a cozy table; how to make intricate topics go down smoothly with delicious confections and warm tea. Stephen Kotkins' talent is the knows how to work the announcer's box in a ballgame; how to read the man on the mound as outfield mills around, able to pick each one out and name what's distracting them. My complements to you both. A very satisfying visit. Please do it again, soon.
I love the fact that Stephen describes current situations in a basic descriptive way (no word olympics). The 10 bedroom house versus the 1000 bedroom house just makes sense. A lot of great questions as well.
The cost of the reconstruction of Ukraine may be also measured against the FUTURE size of Ukrainians economy. After all, not many expected post-WW2 Germany to end up as the economic powerhouse of Europe and many questioned the wisdom of the Marshall's Plan.
Several months ago, we heard Victoria Nuland, under oath, acknowledge that US has had Bioweapon research Labs in Ukraine, near the Russian border. Is that of concern to Russia ?
Kotkin toppled my concept of hitory. When a talented historian display his narrative of main current affair, Kotkin lifted the topics with your intelligence and with pop culture taste that benefit the most. [谷歌翻譯] Kotkin 推翻了我的歷史概念。當一位才華橫溢的歷史學家展示他對主要時事的敘述時，科特金用他的智慧和最受益的流行文化品味來提升話題。
I remember watching these interviews a year ago. They are what kicked off nearly an entire year of watching and reading literally everything i can on russia/ukraine and geopolitics. Thank you!
Thank you SO much for having THE BEST GUEST EVER on again. During the Ukraine war I really suggest you have him on every 1-2 months. His insight into everything Russia is peerless. He is a national treasure. Thank you, Dr. Kotkin for everything you do. We love you.
Aa a Central European I have much respect for this man...we need more man like him on both sides of the Atlantic to make Atlanticism work for future generations...
It is not true that Germany sends only a single digit number of tanks. They will send 14 Leopoard 2 A6 and 178 Leopard 1 A5 (together with Denmark and Netherlands). German contributions to the war effort are usually misrepresented and undervalued. This is mainly due to the German government being terrible at communication. If you look at the numbers, Germany is, in fact, second biggest supporter of Ukraine after the US (miliatry, financial and humanitarian aid).
When I went through Stanford, Western Civ was a required course lasting 9 months. It was largely intellectual history, readings of important writers. My idea today would be to require a year of SOME area’s history but allow choice among the Americas, Asia, Africa, or Europe. We need a wider view than just the US or Europe.
The outcome of the Russia-Ukraine war has serious consequences on the peaceful existence among all Asian nations, especially between Mainland China and Taiwan.
This man explained this war in almost 2 hours in detail and for a layman to understand. The media, newspapers and the US Government are still trying too explain it and make it make sense. This man is brilliant.
This show / interview series has both delighted me and infuriated me. That's just the way it should be! More Kotkin; I'm always interested in his perspective. Thanks!
Very profound discussion! Prof. Kotkin is a rare breed of scholar and intellectual. I am not sure that with education standards dwindling in USA and elsewhere in the West another Kennan or Kissinger or Kotkin will be produced anytime soon.
Wow! I just rewatched the two previous conversations with Stephen Kotkin yesterday, and now there's finally a new one after like 11 months! I must be pretty lucky.
Schools used to teach history and civics. Now they combine them and teach history through the lens of contemporary politics. No wonder kids aren't interested.
the problem is that the more you swipe and scroll through Social Media, the more you train your brain to FORGET instead of reading and imagining and training our brain to remember. The more people are hooked on Social Media the more they swallow whatever the screen feeds them not having the ability to remember the policies or world events of History.
OK first of all - if you don't invite this man back I'm full on rioting 😂. On a more serious note, I've been watching a lot of geopoliticians and historians lately but this conversation has reminded me why I need to go back to being a full on - book reading and consuming - student of history. It's not for everyone, God knows its not for everyone, but for those of us that have a love for it, we cannot lose that. In whatever capacity we can muster, we are going to have to be the stewards for future society to steer away from the mistakes of past millennia. Technology and industry has changed and evolved at break neck speeds, but the human condition has remained constant throughout a remarkable span of time. We have to remember that we can give humanity new toys to play with, but they will always remain human. That is our greatest strength and our greatest weakness, and those of us who can study the human condition across history, can shepherd us into a future worth protecting. God Bless these Titan's of intellectual thought sharing their wisdom with the masses. These episodes are criminally under watched for such a crucial moment in history, but the information is nevertheless a breath of fresh air in a chaotic world where history is afoot, and times are changing. Thank you for these questions, thank you for committing to more, please come back soon, we are patiently waiting for the next episode. Until next time.
Kotkin is one of the voices of reason that I pay attention to. I liked the way he knocked down the Putin argument concerning NATO by pointing out that many of its members are pacifist nations thus are not great threats to Russia.
I think maybe Americans don't realise the lack of homogeneity in Europe. This chat treats Europe as if it's all the same, but with different languages. In fact there are huge differences in both political spectrum and their policy focus e.g. the UK is staunchly pro-Ukraine and looks to former colonies, France is ambivalent on Ukraine considers North Africa as part of its sphere, but Hungary couldn't care less about places out of Europe and is fairly pro Putin. A joint army would be crippled by a lack of consensus on foreign policy.
Phenomenal interview. One constructive feedback - Peter, you have a very low octave voice (lovely as it is), and it is often hard to hear you in these interviews, while the guests are much easier to hear. I listen to these while working in the shop and find myself often having to scramble to wash my hands & turn the volume up to max to hear you (Peter). Could you possibly have your mic volume increased? Absolutely love Uncommon Knowledge. Thanks for the consideration, if you see this.
The problem professor Kotkin does not see is that his values are not representative of many of his fellow Americans. Yes, conservatives wish to see Western Civilization in our classrooms, but we see the European union as a repudiation of those values, not an extension of them. Mr. Robinson is absolutely correct. Europe has been infantilized. It has already descended into the cultural morass that conservatives in the U.S. are battling on all fronts. For those who, unlike professor Kotkin, understand that the rule of law is nothing when abstracted the kind of laws one enacts, his explanations really miss the mark, notwithstanding the great respect I have for the man.
Huge fan - I've learned so much from Prof. Kotkin over the last year, and even read both of his Stalin books after being exposed to his work through these videos. Thank you and glad to hear he is with Hoover now full time!!!
Cotkin’s remarks about the vaccine is a concern. I wonder is he aware of the high number of excess deaths around the world unrelated to Covid? What of the “died suddenly” phenomenon?
I wish you would have Stephen Kotkin on every week! The world needs him right now. 🌍
Pesci *ahem* Kotkin is a true realist not a fatalist like Kissinger or Mearsheimer. The best thing about Stephen Kotkin is he can answer any question no matter how trivial or complex and the perspective from which he sees the world is always fresh and exciting, every answer has some golden nugget of knowledge that is an absolute pleasure to learn. I'd love to see him talking about Ukraine with Timothy Snyder, the brilliance and the IQ in that dialogue would be breathtaking...
Pesci. Nice. Was thinking same.
This is one of my favorite interviews on this channel. Really like Stephen Kotkin.
He is a fan, advocate of military might as the exercised by the United States. He does not know who the Russians are....He says nothing of the Victoria Nuland power grab....He has never been to war...a historian full of hot air.
I taught German language for 47 years. I tried to weave into it history and culture. As time progressed, I became aware of how political the teaching of history had become. How does one teach history honestly in the current hyper political environment?
Each era had its political environment that discouraged any opposition. The change is, this seems to be a headless monster. The whole of society has a phobia about anyone saying anything 'negative' about them. And there is not one person you can pin on this "McCarthyism"
very late reply, but I think it's a mistake to expect history to be seperate from politics, because politics is part of history (integral part). The key is to have the bravery (or foolhardiness) to speak honestly regardless of the political landscape. To speak truth to power. And that also requires the bravery to both be wrong and accept being wrong.
I'm stunned! This is my first time listening to Kotkin, and what an amazingly insightful person he is. He doesn't come off as being left wing or right wing, just reality-based. I was fortunate enough to have had an amazing teacher who understood history and what its power really was, not memorizing dates, which installed a love of history that is still with me some 50 years later.
I could relate, I had a hs history teacher like that too.
Excellent questioning. I like that quotations and asking a succinct question that requires a broad base. And then lets him talk. Peter Robinson is one of the best interviewers.
And Kotkin is so clear in his explanations.
Okay, it took me 2 days to absorb this presentation. I have to say it's one of the best presentations I have ever seen on several subjects: Ukraine, Russia, China, Taiwan and a quick reference to the American system's self correcting abilities. Well done, gentlemen, and thank you so much!
Excellent survey of the Ukrainian situation. This Chanel is the jewel of TH-cam.
It's absolutely amazing to hear these great minds. The sheer knowledge of Professor Kotkin and the astonishing interviewing skills of Peter Robinson are a great joy to listen to. As someone else mentioned before; setting up the table, a warm cup of tea and a blanket of wisdom. I have shared the link with many friends and peers already.
Ik ook!
Talks with Stephen Kotkin, I always watch two to three times, savouring his understanding of the world. Absolute treat! Thanx for that.
Peter Robinson's gift is he knows how to set a cozy table; how to make intricate topics go down smoothly with delicious confections and warm tea.
Stephen Kotkins' talent is the knows how to work the announcer's box in a ballgame; how to read the man on the mound as outfield mills around, able to pick each one out and name what's distracting them.
My complements to you both.
A very satisfying visit. Please do it again, soon.
I love the fact that Stephen describes current situations in a basic descriptive way (no word olympics). The 10 bedroom house versus the 1000 bedroom house just makes sense.
A lot of great questions as well.
I always love and enjoy to listen to Stephen Kotkin
I am a Huge Stephen Kotkin fan. Please have him on more often. We need his Wisdom and Humor.
This really is a special show. Uncommon Knowledge is a treasure.
What a marvelous human being- learned, sensible, rational, decent, humility
Wow what a brilliant mind, this man needs to be an adviser to our political leaders.
I love this guy he explains complex ideas that can easily be digested
If you cannot explain a complex concept in plain terns you don't understand it
I'm fascinated by the topic of authoritarian governance. Steven gets to the heart of the matter.
This is one of the best political interviews I have ever seen. Thanks Prof. Kotkin.
This is the most enlightening interview I’ve seen in a very long while. Thank you to you both.
I'm a simple man, I see a Stephen kotkin video, I automatically like it!
Such an extraordinary, deep and substancial interview... really grateful indeed!
The cost of the reconstruction of Ukraine may be also measured against the FUTURE size of Ukrainians economy. After all, not many expected post-WW2 Germany to end up as the economic powerhouse of Europe and many questioned the wisdom of the Marshall's Plan.
Several months ago, we heard Victoria Nuland, under oath, acknowledge that US has had Bioweapon research Labs in Ukraine, near the Russian border. Is that of concern to Russia ?
Kotkin toppled my concept of hitory. When a talented historian display his narrative of main current affair, Kotkin lifted the topics with your intelligence and with pop culture taste that benefit the most.
[谷歌翻譯] Kotkin 推翻了我的歷史概念。當一位才華橫溢的歷史學家展示他對主要時事的敘述時，科特金用他的智慧和最受益的流行文化品味來提升話題。
I could listen to Stephen Kotkin speak for 10 hours straight. What a brilliant person he is.
Always epic to hear him speak. Hope he finishes the triology!
What I love about this guy is that he sounds exactly like Joe Pesci, it's like I'm getting a history lesson by the mob.
He looks like Pesci's twin and his credibility is in doubt with his interpretation of the war in Ukraine.
I remember watching these interviews a year ago. They are what kicked off nearly an entire year of watching and reading literally everything i can on russia/ukraine and geopolitics. Thank you!
Stephen kotlin is wonderful to listen to, His son is a fellow high school alum.
He really breaks it down in a clearer way than I think anyone else.
A fine display of balanced, rational intelligence. Thank you, gentlemen.
Stephen is a diamond.
Polished one at that.
Trully rare.
Thank you SO much for having THE BEST GUEST EVER on again. During the Ukraine war I really suggest you have him on every 1-2 months. His insight into everything Russia is peerless. He is a national treasure.
Thank you, Dr. Kotkin for everything you do. We love you.
Kotkin is so amazing, thank you!
Brilliant conversation gentlemen! Many thanks for sharing it with us!! ✨️
A truly fascinating discussion. I could have listened to several hours more of this. Thank you.
It is always a pleasure to listen to such a great intellectual and Peter Robinson is such a great host who never will interrupt his guest.
Another great interview with Kotkin. I didn't even notice that 1½ hours have passed so thumbs up to Peter and Stephen.
Aa a Central European I have much respect for this man...we need more man like him on both sides of the Atlantic to make Atlanticism work for future generations...
It is not true that Germany sends only a single digit number of tanks. They will send 14 Leopoard 2 A6 and 178 Leopard 1 A5 (together with Denmark and Netherlands). German contributions to the war effort are usually misrepresented and undervalued. This is mainly due to the German government being terrible at communication. If you look at the numbers, Germany is, in fact, second biggest supporter of Ukraine after the US (miliatry, financial and humanitarian aid).
I'm less worried about our world after watching this interview. Thank you.
Stephen Kotkin is an intellectual badass. Best wishes from Poland ;)
When I went through Stanford, Western Civ was a required course lasting 9 months. It was largely intellectual history, readings of important writers. My idea today would be to require a year of SOME area’s history but allow choice among the Americas, Asia, Africa, or Europe. We need a wider view than just the US or Europe.
Always great to see Kotkin. Stephen is a superb guest. He should get his own show.
Excellent! Bring him back for another enlightening round!
The outcome of the Russia-Ukraine war has serious consequences on the peaceful existence among all Asian nations, especially between Mainland China and Taiwan.
Excellent interview Mr Robinson; excellent answers Prof Kotkin. You both have such erudition and insight.
Great discussion. Intelligent. Insightful. Thought provoking. Thank you.
I wish he had a TH-cam channel... it's such a pleasure to hear this professor talking about any subjects✌️🇨🇱
Bravo to an expert educator. Thank you.
This man explained this war in almost 2 hours in detail and for a layman to understand. The media, newspapers and the US Government are still trying too explain it and make it make sense. This man is brilliant.
Couldn't click faster !
Can't get enough of Professor Kotkin, thank you
Amazing information about history and current events. Really enjoyed listening.
This show / interview series has both delighted me and infuriated me. That's just the way it should be! More Kotkin; I'm always interested in his perspective. Thanks!
Let's do an interview twice a week with Kotkin. He's so terrific!!!
Thank you so much for the excellent analysis on Ukraine!
More of Kotkin as often as possible pls. .. so so sane and thoughtful!!
Thank you. I find it hard to watch more than 15mins of anything on the internet and I watched all 1 hour 30 mins. Thank you both.
Steven Kotkin often leaves me gasping for breath.
Kotkin is a marvel.
Another great one Peter. Still up there with one of my favorite interview shows. Always fantastic guests with incredible insights.
You know ... I could sit here all day listening to Professor Kotkin. A big thanks to everyone who make clips like these possible
Thank You for this, the most sofisticated political discussion, that I almost ever have heard.
The best interview I ever see and hear in my life time. I am 75 this year. Thanks to both, as well as HT & CR.
This was a truly awesome interview. Thank you chaps.
Very profound discussion! Prof. Kotkin is a rare breed of scholar and intellectual. I am not sure that with education standards dwindling in USA and elsewhere in the West another Kennan or Kissinger or Kotkin will be produced anytime soon.
It's always a joy listening to this great man of history thankyou professor best regards from Samoa.
Absolutely amazing! Nothing short of phenomenal. Thank you.
Wow!
I just rewatched the two previous conversations with Stephen Kotkin yesterday, and now there's finally a new one after like 11 months!
I must be pretty lucky.
95 views
Thank you Professor Kotkin!
Schools used to teach history and civics. Now they combine them and teach history through the lens of contemporary politics. No wonder kids aren't interested.
Stephen Kotkin? Drop everything in my life and watch as soon as possible.
I liked this a lot. Definitely want to hear more from him!
the problem is that the more you swipe and scroll through Social Media, the more you train your brain to FORGET instead of reading and imagining and training our brain to remember. The more people are hooked on Social Media the more they swallow whatever the screen feeds them not having the ability to remember the policies or world events of History.
Kotkin has an astounding knowledge of history, and can weild it effectively!
Always one of my favourite guests
OK first of all - if you don't invite this man back I'm full on rioting 😂.
On a more serious note, I've been watching a lot of geopoliticians and historians lately but this conversation has reminded me why I need to go back to being a full on - book reading and consuming - student of history. It's not for everyone, God knows its not for everyone, but for those of us that have a love for it, we cannot lose that. In whatever capacity we can muster, we are going to have to be the stewards for future society to steer away from the mistakes of past millennia. Technology and industry has changed and evolved at break neck speeds, but the human condition has remained constant throughout a remarkable span of time.
We have to remember that we can give humanity new toys to play with, but they will always remain human. That is our greatest strength and our greatest weakness, and those of us who can study the human condition across history, can shepherd us into a future worth protecting. God Bless these Titan's of intellectual thought sharing their wisdom with the masses. These episodes are criminally under watched for such a crucial moment in history, but the information is nevertheless a breath of fresh air in a chaotic world where history is afoot, and times are changing.
Thank you for these questions, thank you for committing to more, please come back soon, we are patiently waiting for the next episode. Until next time.
What a fulfilling talk. Just brilliant!
I think that these type of shows should be broadcasted all over the world and in every language possible.
Kotkin is one of the voices of reason that I pay attention to.
I liked the way he knocked down the Putin argument concerning NATO by pointing out that many of its members are pacifist nations thus are not great threats to Russia.
I think maybe Americans don't realise the lack of homogeneity in Europe. This chat treats Europe as if it's all the same, but with different languages. In fact there are huge differences in both political spectrum and their policy focus e.g. the UK is staunchly pro-Ukraine and looks to former colonies, France is ambivalent on Ukraine considers North Africa as part of its sphere, but Hungary couldn't care less about places out of Europe and is fairly pro Putin. A joint army would be crippled by a lack of consensus on foreign policy.
Phenomenal interview. One constructive feedback - Peter, you have a very low octave voice (lovely as it is), and it is often hard to hear you in these interviews, while the guests are much easier to hear. I listen to these while working in the shop and find myself often having to scramble to wash my hands & turn the volume up to max to hear you (Peter). Could you possibly have your mic volume increased? Absolutely love Uncommon Knowledge. Thanks for the consideration, if you see this.
The problem professor Kotkin does not see is that his values are not representative of many of his fellow Americans. Yes, conservatives wish to see Western Civilization in our classrooms, but we see the European union as a repudiation of those values, not an extension of them. Mr. Robinson is absolutely correct. Europe has been infantilized. It has already descended into the cultural morass that conservatives in the U.S. are battling on all fronts. For those who, unlike professor Kotkin, understand that the rule of law is nothing when abstracted the kind of laws one enacts, his explanations really miss the mark, notwithstanding the great respect I have for the man.
He’s an intelligent man & aware of a lot that he cleverly avoids pointing out but overall, very difficult to disagree with
The rule of law that protects personal reciprocal freedoms of all, and enables our aspirations of an ever better, more productive lives.
Such a smooth watch and very insightful. Uncommon knowledge goes to those who wish to obtain it. Bravo
That was really good! Thank you!
Wonderful questioner amazing professor. So educational
One of your best shows.
Please invite Professor Kotkin soon,we need him badly at the moment !
Huge fan - I've learned so much from Prof. Kotkin over the last year, and even read both of his Stalin books after being exposed to his work through these videos. Thank you and glad to hear he is with Hoover now full time!!!
Cotkin’s remarks about the vaccine is a concern. I wonder is he aware of the high number of excess deaths around the world unrelated to Covid? What of the “died suddenly” phenomenon?
"If I can’t have this, no one can" - Paxton McCreary
If you take it you cant have it, but if you already dont have it and the other part has it, it looks like a win.
Stephen’s house analogy sounds like a landlord’s worst nightmare
Wonderful. Thanks for letting Stephen talk with not many interruptions.
This guy is nuts. Theres no point in fighting a war of attrition. then wow, now hes saying that he needs a world war. This is incredible.
Robinson sets up those questions so well!
This was refreshingly insightful and nuanced. Thank you.