Looks good. I will email Prossh deck list to commander cast or just give a list to William the next time I see him. Let me know what you think of it after you see the list. Thank you. I going to add food chain and shared animosity to my deck those are both great ideas.
The problem with 3-color decks in commander is that they start to get too close to be 3-color goodstuff. Granted, I think some of the goodstuff like Purphoros is very appropriate for this deck, but most of the cards in this deck could reasonably be in any jund commander deck without breaking a sweat. Not sure how I feel about that. Good list, I believe in your winning rate, I think I would like to test more out-of-the-box cards though. And a small suggestion: I would easily swap that thoughtseize of yours for a rakdos's return. They serve different purposes, since seize is for early game usually, but just an annoyance in multiplayer commander, while rakdos's return is a huge spell in the game.
I love Prossh, it's my favorite deck. However yours seems much more beat down where mine is more combo with. Cards like Ashnod and Phyrexian alter to help me go infinite. Your missing coat of arms though It's won me lots of games for just being able to kill opponents out of no where. I also opted to have Greater good in my deck because it churns through the cards in the deck really quickly to find what I need. Why no Craterhoof Behemoth? He kills people on the spot if you cast him the turn after Prossh or Tooth and Nail entwine for him and Avenger of Zendikar. I also run all the double token effects because they help me go infinite with Phyrexian alter and Prossh and I love threaten effects in the deck because you commander is a sac engine. Some card choices I think you might want to consider, Gaea's Cradle is perfect for the deck so is Xengos the Reveler for mana generation, Sarkan Vol for his threaten and haste. It is so much fun stealing an Eldrazi before your opponent can swing with it then sacing it. Stealing a Planeswalker with zealous conscripts so you can steal the ultimate comes up from time to time. Last week I lent the deck out and lost to zealous conscripts which stole my Ral Zarek at 7 loyalty. Overall love the general he gives you so many avenues to explore in deck construction and having fun, thats what Commander is all about
I'm surprised to not see Nath of the Gilt-leaf in here considering you play Sadistic Hypnotist. And I concur that Craterhoof should be an auto include with a token deck, also why no Diabolic Intent, Skeletal Scrying, or Blasphemous Act?
That would be like saying you should cut all win conditions from your deck as they'll all just get countered by a player playing blue. Might as well not play Tooth and Nail and other such cards that can be game winning, right? Plus a general like this is going to generally lose to a control heavy blue deck 1v1 anyways. Most blue decks for 1v1 commander play white which give them access to things like Meddling Mage and Nevermore as to prevent someone from casting their general, follow all that up with a ton of counter magic and removal. This deck however seems much more multiplayer focused but either way 1v1 or not you don't cut win conditions because you fear counterspells.
***** I'm sorry but cutting Craterhoof out of a deck that generates as many tokens as this deck does seems outright silly. Your argument before was playing against a blue player as the reason for not running Craterhoof but now you're arguing to not run it because it does nothing on it's own while Tooth and Nail is better. I agree 100% that Tooth and Nail is by far a better card but the fact still remains that Craterhoof is a win condition and it should be in a token deck like this that generates a large number of tokens. In regards to this comment: "And the Behemoth, although good cant win on its own." You can't evaluate a card with the question "Does this card win on it's own?" because if you did then you wouldn't be able to play anything really. Lets face it Tooth and Nail doesn't win on it's own either because there are up to two other cards you get with it that can win you the game or get you out of a particular situation. You evaluate cards based on how well it works with the theme of the deck and since this deck has a theme of generating a lot of tokens Craterhoof is an auto include.
singleT314 I agree with singleT314, not a voltron list. Running things like Beastmaster Ascension, Shared Animosity, Ogre Battledriver and Purphoros, God of the Forge all lean toward a token theme. He isn't playing any auras and aside from greaves and clamp(obviously a draw engine for tokens) he doesn't have any equipment for the general.
This is the most Jund good stuff deck I've ever seen. It's literally just full of expensive cards that have no synergy with each other aside from the combo pieces. It's one of the laziest built decks I've ever seen.
I've got an oldborder only jund deck. The only tutor is gamble. That's quite fun. This is just filled with tutors and inf combos. I find it boring, others may not.
Yeah, same here. I had an Azami deck and a Mimeoplasm deck, azami was all combos, mimeoplasm was all aggro, all the tutors, and after a while it got reaaaaally boring. So i've powerdowned all of my decks, and it's much more fun.
![Graham's Zur the Enchanter CMDR Deck [EDH / Commander / Magic the Gathering]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/itXhrSl1qdc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Graham's Zur the Enchanter CMDR Deck [EDH / Commander / Magic the Gathering]](/img/tr.png)
![Shaun's Sydri, Galvanic Genius CMDR Deck [EDH / Commander / Magic the Gathering]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6F61eO3f274/mqdefault.jpg)
![Brian's Daretti, Scrap Savant CMDR Deck [EDH / Commander / Magic the Gathering]](/img/n.gif)
Sweet deck Eric! I was expecting more token generating cards, but the way you've got it set up sounds like it works out just dandy.
Mana crypt I need that.... For my casual deck to make it competitive!!!!
Ethan Ford Ford well you probably have one now xd
Any Prossh deck is incomplete without Mycoloth.
Come on now.
Looks good. I will email Prossh deck list to commander cast or just give a list to William the next time I see him. Let me know what you think of it after you see the list. Thank you. I going to add food chain and shared animosity to my deck those are both great ideas.
The problem with 3-color decks in commander is that they start to get too close to be 3-color goodstuff. Granted, I think some of the goodstuff like Purphoros is very appropriate for this deck, but most of the cards in this deck could reasonably be in any jund commander deck without breaking a sweat. Not sure how I feel about that. Good list, I believe in your winning rate, I think I would like to test more out-of-the-box cards though.
And a small suggestion: I would easily swap that thoughtseize of yours for a rakdos's return. They serve different purposes, since seize is for early game usually, but just an annoyance in multiplayer commander, while rakdos's return is a huge spell in the game.
If you can get a mana crypt for the deck you should get a Gaea's Cradle.
He doesn't look like he needs nor want that card
Orcish Lumberjack is a fun and interesting card. The other 98 though? Not so much.
I love Prossh, it's my favorite deck. However yours seems much more beat down where mine is more combo with. Cards like Ashnod and Phyrexian alter to help me go infinite. Your missing coat of arms though It's won me lots of games for just being able to kill opponents out of no where. I also opted to have Greater good in my deck because it churns through the cards in the deck really quickly to find what I need. Why no Craterhoof Behemoth? He kills people on the spot if you cast him the turn after Prossh or Tooth and Nail entwine for him and Avenger of Zendikar. I also run all the double token effects because they help me go infinite with Phyrexian alter and Prossh and I love threaten effects in the deck because you commander is a sac engine. Some card choices I think you might want to consider, Gaea's Cradle is perfect for the deck so is Xengos the Reveler for mana generation, Sarkan Vol for his threaten and haste. It is so much fun stealing an Eldrazi before your opponent can swing with it then sacing it. Stealing a Planeswalker with zealous conscripts so you can steal the ultimate comes up from time to time. Last week I lent the deck out and lost to zealous conscripts which stole my Ral Zarek at 7 loyalty. Overall love the general he gives you so many avenues to explore in deck construction and having fun, thats what Commander is all about
I'm surprised to not see Nath of the Gilt-leaf in here considering you play Sadistic Hypnotist. And I concur that Craterhoof should be an auto include with a token deck, also why no Diabolic Intent, Skeletal Scrying, or Blasphemous Act?
That would be like saying you should cut all win conditions from your deck as they'll all just get countered by a player playing blue. Might as well not play Tooth and Nail and other such cards that can be game winning, right? Plus a general like this is going to generally lose to a control heavy blue deck 1v1 anyways. Most blue decks for 1v1 commander play white which give them access to things like Meddling Mage and Nevermore as to prevent someone from casting their general, follow all that up with a ton of counter magic and removal. This deck however seems much more multiplayer focused but either way 1v1 or not you don't cut win conditions because you fear counterspells.
***** I'm sorry but cutting Craterhoof out of a deck that generates as many tokens as this deck does seems outright silly. Your argument before was playing against a blue player as the reason for not running Craterhoof but now you're arguing to not run it because it does nothing on it's own while Tooth and Nail is better. I agree 100% that Tooth and Nail is by far a better card but the fact still remains that Craterhoof is a win condition and it should be in a token deck like this that generates a large number of tokens.
In regards to this comment:
"And the Behemoth, although good cant win on its own."
You can't evaluate a card with the question "Does this card win on it's own?" because if you did then you wouldn't be able to play anything really. Lets face it Tooth and Nail doesn't win on it's own either because there are up to two other cards you get with it that can win you the game or get you out of a particular situation. You evaluate cards based on how well it works with the theme of the deck and since this deck has a theme of generating a lot of tokens Craterhoof is an auto include.
Food Chain, big surprise hahaha
my buddy runs prossh this deck list should help give him some ideas minus more than a few cards haha
I´d suggest Hornet Queen for this deck. 5 supreb blockers (and fodder) for 6 mana!
marf loog 7*
did you home brew this one?
why arent you running mycoloth?
Tundra is the worst fetch land lol
Why aren't you running kher keep in the spot of a basic
Cool list but I run my pros has voltron
this feels more like a token list though
singleT314 I agree with singleT314, not a voltron list. Running things like Beastmaster Ascension, Shared Animosity, Ogre Battledriver and Purphoros, God of the Forge all lean toward a token theme. He isn't playing any auras and aside from greaves and clamp(obviously a draw engine for tokens) he doesn't have any equipment for the general.
i am assuming this is built for 1v1
You arent playing hypergenisis, golgari grave-troll or glimpse of nature ;)
MYCOLOTH?!
earth craft + squirrel's nest = infinite tokens
two enchantments out of 99 cards.not worth tutoring
Its a two card combo that creates 2 new win conditions to a deck, yeah worth putting in
Add purphoros and it becomes instant damage to the whole table...
nice video, but get a better mic Dx
duuuude too much life losss
This is the most Jund good stuff deck I've ever seen. It's literally just full of expensive cards that have no synergy with each other aside from the combo pieces. It's one of the laziest built decks I've ever seen.
yawn
one of the most boring decks i've seen. expensive tho.
what kind of deck would you consider "exciting"?
I've got an oldborder only jund deck. The only tutor is gamble. That's quite fun. This is just filled with tutors and inf combos. I find it boring, others may not.
I dig. I had an Azami deck which was absolutely ridiculous with combos. I sold it.
Yeah, same here. I had an Azami deck and a Mimeoplasm deck, azami was all combos, mimeoplasm was all aggro, all the tutors, and after a while it got reaaaaally boring. So i've powerdowned all of my decks, and it's much more fun.