এমন একটি মূল্যবান গুরুত্বপূর্ণ সংলাপের নথি , অনেক বিভ্রান্তি দূর করবে আধুনিক প্রজন্মের কাছে এবং সে সমস্ত শিক্ষক/ শিক্ষিকা সঠিক ভাবে রবীন্দ্রসংগীতের মূল্যায়ন না করে ,ভুল পথে চালিত করে শিষ্য/শিষ্যা কে, তাদের কাছে ।অনেক ধন্যবাদ আপলোডার কে এমন একটি শুভ প্রচেষ্টার জন্য
George da hit the nail on its head. Even in 2020 people love to hear the songs of George da and Hemanta da. Where are those great people who drafted the CIRCULAR about how to sing Rabindra Sangeet. Who remembers them but do remember and respect George da
- - - George Da is always immortal - - - those who don't know - - - ask any body who loves Rabindra Sangeet or for that matter any one who loves music and songs - - -
আমি এই ভদ্রলোক কে এক অসাধারণ শিল্পী বলেই জানতাম। কিন্তু রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুর কে এত সুন্দর বিশ্লেষণ করেছেন সেটা এই recording না শুনলে জানতে পারতাম না। এ হেন মহাপণ্ডিত কে যে ভাবে বিশ্বভারতী হেনস্থা করেছে তার জন্যে ওই সংস্থাকে ধিক্কার জানাই। প্রণাম জানাই রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুর কে, প্রণাম জানাই তাঁর অনুগত এই মহান শিল্পী Debabrata Biswas কে।
Ashadharon post. Kato ashonman pete hoeyeche shipike, kintu ajj amar mate srestho Rabindro Sangeet shilpi.pronam janai.ei mulyoban post ti share karar janyo anek dhanyobad.
Enriched with valuable information, lots of thanks to the person uploaded such facts. Openion of Debabrata Biswas vis a vis guidelines of biswabharati was very much controversial. Popularity of Debabrata Biswas is beyond question. His open heart interpretation of the music of Rabindrasangeet focussed on his depth of field... 🙏🙏🙏
Ami ekdom natun android phone byabohar korchi.Tai George dar group e join jlkorte deri holo.Ami nije Rabindra sangeet sikhechi ebong Rabindra anuragi.Tobu apnake asankho dhanyabad George dar sei 1974 er jantrana klisto ananukoronio kanthoswar upahar diye amader hriddho karar janya. Rintu Mukhopadhyay
In the Era of Rabindra Sangeet the eminent personality Jorge Biswas who was retrenchment by so called Rabidra premi who tried to stop his Khanta as long they couldn't get their target. Jorge Biswas is Debabrata Biswas. Thanks , lot who sent this message. With respected gratitude 🙏 my favourite singer's "Je rate mor doowarguli vhaglo jore "
Apnake dhanyabad. Apnader anthorik prochesta ar poribeson amader pray bishmitho itihash ar silpir asadharon mononsilota, ja thar ganer mothoi anonnyo o kalothirnyo tar sathe porichitho hote sahajya kore.
Respected Mr Basu. At the very outset I must convey my heartiest thanks for doing this historic job. I wish the video to be circulated to the maximum extent.I have written lots about the BMB episode but the same carry no value since I am a very very common person.Typogrorical errors are regretted.
more we understand lyric and tune, more it becomes easy for knowing what pace it requires. Use of instrument should be in need only as said clearly- to give minimum rest to singer or to fill any tune gap, else instrumental will become burden. I become disagree slightly from Debabratababu, as, then only certain rule becomes obvious when we fail to do certain things in a natural way. That circular was to protect rabindrasangeet from its misinterpretation, might be then it was looking too much,,,but now it looks truly relevant. Though I guess, by the sincere effort from afterwards singers, Rabindrasangeet is going to be destroyed very soon and it will not be different from either popular Bollywood item song or popular sad+ song. After Debabrata, Subinay, Chinmay, Hemanta, Sagar, Kanika..era, it has lost its easy and spontaneous appeal. Now it's digital,,,either too slow/no pace(0) or high speed(1)-nothing exists in between to match the song.
অসাধারণ এই পোস্ট
শুনে মন ভরে গেলো
কতো বড় শিল্পী ছিলেন তা আজকের প্রজন্ম চিন্তাভাবনার মধ্যে ও আনতে পারবে না *
সশ্রদ্ধ প্রণাম জানালাম *
Wow !!! English accent is so elegant !!
Kothay cockneyed Americanised accent aar kothay Queen's English - akaash - paatal !!
এমন একটি মূল্যবান গুরুত্বপূর্ণ সংলাপের নথি , অনেক বিভ্রান্তি দূর করবে আধুনিক প্রজন্মের কাছে এবং সে সমস্ত শিক্ষক/ শিক্ষিকা সঠিক ভাবে রবীন্দ্রসংগীতের মূল্যায়ন না করে ,ভুল পথে চালিত করে শিষ্য/শিষ্যা কে, তাদের কাছে ।অনেক ধন্যবাদ আপলোডার কে এমন একটি শুভ প্রচেষ্টার জন্য
George da hit the nail on its head. Even in 2020 people love to hear the songs of George da and Hemanta da. Where are those great people who drafted the CIRCULAR about how to sing Rabindra Sangeet. Who remembers them but do remember and respect George da
Durgadas Babu has gifted us with an unique gift and opportunity to know Late Debabrata Biswas intimately. Thanks, Sir
- - - George Da is always immortal - - - those who don't know - - - ask any body who loves Rabindra Sangeet or for that matter any one who loves music and songs - - -
Tremendous - Late Debabrata Biswas winning every hearts - enviable English pronunciation, and his captivating Bangla utcharan. Pranam
Shatabdi te noy sahasrabte ekjon emon manush jonman.
আমি এই ভদ্রলোক কে এক অসাধারণ শিল্পী বলেই জানতাম। কিন্তু রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুর কে এত সুন্দর বিশ্লেষণ করেছেন সেটা এই recording না শুনলে জানতে পারতাম না। এ হেন মহাপণ্ডিত কে যে ভাবে বিশ্বভারতী হেনস্থা করেছে তার জন্যে ওই সংস্থাকে ধিক্কার জানাই। প্রণাম জানাই রবীন্দ্রনাথ ঠাকুর কে, প্রণাম জানাই তাঁর অনুগত এই মহান শিল্পী Debabrata Biswas কে।
অপূর্ব জিনিস, এই ইউটুব কোম্পানিকে ধন্যবাদ !
Ashadharon post. Kato ashonman pete hoeyeche shipike, kintu ajj amar mate srestho Rabindro Sangeet shilpi.pronam janai.ei mulyoban post ti share karar janyo anek dhanyobad.
Enriched with valuable information, lots of thanks to the person uploaded such facts. Openion of Debabrata Biswas vis a vis guidelines of biswabharati was very much controversial. Popularity of Debabrata Biswas is beyond question. His open heart interpretation of the music of Rabindrasangeet focussed on his depth of field... 🙏🙏🙏
Amar praner jinish sakaler saathe bhag karar janya i eta upload korechhi. Apnader bhalo lagle ami dhanya.
Durgadas Basu asankhya dhonyobad
Wonderful..! The English pronunciation of Georgeda is EXCELLENT..!!
+Sonali Surjo Bengali as well!
ধন্যবাদ ! ধন্যবাদ !! ধন্যবাদ !!! আপনাকে ধন্যবাদ এই অসাধারন programme টা উপহার
দেবার জন্যে ।
Asadharon..!! Onek ajana tothyo jante parlam..! His English pronunciation is excellent.. couldn't compare with his normal conversation..
+Latifa Quadir Banglatao kharap na.
Amra Bhalo Bashi Debabrata Biswas er Gaan . Kichu Dhandabaj Bangali Budhijibi Eaisaab Dalbaji Koray Ganer Madhurjo Nasto Korechay. Bharatio ra Debabrata kay Darun Bhalo Bashay .
Unalloyed originality, so envied upon
Ami ekdom natun android phone byabohar korchi.Tai George dar group e join jlkorte deri holo.Ami nije Rabindra sangeet sikhechi ebong Rabindra anuragi.Tobu apnake asankho dhanyabad George dar sei 1974 er jantrana klisto ananukoronio kanthoswar upahar diye amader hriddho karar janya. Rintu Mukhopadhyay
+Rintu Mukhopadhyay apnader bhalo lagle amar khub bhalo lage!!!!
Marvelous collection....................
In the Era of Rabindra Sangeet the eminent personality Jorge Biswas who was retrenchment by so called Rabidra premi who tried to stop his Khanta as long they couldn't get their target. Jorge Biswas is Debabrata Biswas. Thanks , lot who sent this message. With respected gratitude 🙏 my favourite singer's "Je rate mor doowarguli vhaglo jore "
Getting goose bumps all over....
কি করে ধন্যবাদ জানাব জানি না এই অসাধারণ সংলাপ আমাদের কাছে উন্মুক্ত করার জন্য…..
এ জিনিস কখনো শুনতে পাবো ভাবতে পারিনি.......ধন্যবাদ দিয়ে ছোট করব না.....
হেমন্ত-র সংবর্ধনা 1985-র কোনো রেকর্ডিং থাকলে আপলোড করুন... Please
maharaj .... pronam.
Dababrata Biswas elevated the rendition of Rabindra to a level no one could ever reach.
🙏🙏🙏🙏
Apnake dhanyabad. Apnader anthorik prochesta ar poribeson amader pray bishmitho itihash ar silpir asadharon mononsilota, ja thar ganer mothoi anonnyo o kalothirnyo tar sathe porichitho hote sahajya kore.
Aamaar ei kshudra prachestaa je aapnaader bhaalo legechhe jene khub khushi holaam.Aapnaader asankhya dhanyabaad!
United
Aman. Drirabyktitwa. Aman. Satyer pujari. Nirlovi. Nirvejal sikhsito. O nirahankari. Manushke. Koti. Pranam. 😎🙏
wow!!! How did you get this recording... awesome - Thanks.
onek onek dhonyabad aapnake !!!!!
Great job done. Greatful to Durgadas Basu.
হাহাকারে হাহাকারে গভীর হলো সাগর
Respected Mr Basu. At the very outset I must convey my heartiest thanks for doing this historic job. I wish the video to be circulated to the maximum extent.I have written lots about the BMB episode but the same carry no value since I am a very very common person.Typogrorical errors are regretted.
Pronam janai Jorge da.
অপূর্ব ....।
Durgadas Babu apnake asankhyo dhannobad, apni j ki amullo sompod tule dilen
ONEK AJANA TATHYA JANLAM.... DHANYABAD SIR....
Unparallel utterance
Aha Aha ..
Ki bhasahay dhonyobad janabo?
আন্তরিক ধন্যবাদ🙏💕
onar engriji uchharon to oshadharon
montromukdher moto sunlam...Rabindra nath er gaan 'r er cheye sundoor bakkhya desh kaler simana chariye r keu dite parbe na. ...
camotkar o durlov
অনেকদিন আগে , সম্ভবত ১৯৫৮তে জর্জ বিশ্বাসের একক কণ্ঠে this weariness শুনেছিলাম। আবার শুনে সেইটৈ মনে পড়ল।
anobodhyo upload.....onar kotha toh kichu shona gelo.....
more we understand lyric and tune, more it becomes easy for knowing what pace it requires. Use of instrument should be in need only as said clearly- to give minimum rest to singer or to fill any tune gap, else instrumental will become burden. I become disagree slightly from Debabratababu, as, then only certain rule becomes obvious when we fail to do certain things in a natural way. That circular was to protect rabindrasangeet from its misinterpretation, might be then it was looking too much,,,but now it looks truly relevant. Though I guess, by the sincere effort from afterwards singers, Rabindrasangeet is going to be destroyed very soon and it will not be different from either popular Bollywood item song or popular sad+ song. After Debabrata, Subinay, Chinmay, Hemanta, Sagar, Kanika..era, it has lost its easy and spontaneous appeal. Now it's digital,,,either too slow/no pace(0) or high speed(1)-nothing exists in between to match the song.
Kishoregonjer Manush!!!
George dalogelive.
Peerless in every possible sense of term.....