Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza discussing the Blasphemy Law in Pakistan
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- Watch the full podcast with Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza:
• Full UNCENSORED Podcas...
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Well Needed CLIP ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !
First time i have seen some sensible Maulana. India k bhi mualana ko esa hona chahiye
Thanks sir ❤
AMEEN
🖤
سورتہ فاتحہ اور ختم نبوت کی نفی
قرآن کا یہ اصول ہے کہ قرآن مجید میں کوئی بھی دعا ایسی نہیں پائی جاتی جو نا ممکن چیز کے لئے کی گئی ہو۔ مثلآ اللہ مجھے قیامت تک حیات بخش یا سورج کی سیر کروا وغیرہ وغیرہ ۔ ہر دعا ممکنات میں سے ہے۔ مثلاً میرے گناہ بخش دے نقصان اٹھانے والوں میں سے نہ بنانا صحت عطا فرما آنکھوں کی ٹھنڈک عطا فرما دشمن پر فتح نصیب فرما وغیرہ وغیرہ ۔ اب سوال یہ ہے کہ اگر امت مسلمہ یہود اور عیسائیوں کی طرح اپنے اعمال اور عقائد کے لحاظ سے بن نہیں سکتی تو سورتہ فاتحہ کے آخری حصہ میں یہ دعا کیوں سکھائی گئی ہے کہ ہمیں ان کی طرح نا بنانا جن پر تیرا غضب نازل ہو مطلب یہود اور ان کی طرح نہ بنانا جو گمراہ ہوئے یعنی مسیحی۔ اب سوال یہ ہے کہ اگر مسلمان یہود کی طرح ہو جائیں تو اس کا اعلاج کیا ہے؟ یہود اگر بگڑیں تو ان کے لئے پے در پے انبیاء مطلب آسمان سے تازہ روحانی خوراک اور مسلمان اگربگڑ جائیں تو ان کے لئے وہی مزہبی رہنما اور وہی خوراک جس نے انہیں بیمار کیا؟ یہ سورتہ فاتحہ کے آخری حصہ میں یہود اور مسیحیوں سے جو مماثلت کی گئی ہے بہت دلچسپ ہے اور اسی میں امت کا حل بھی بتایا گیا ہے۔ جو سمجھے سو سمجھے
Chicco gcgg Vichy gcgg Vichy
Religion is the opium of the masses. Pakistan must focus on developing scientific tempartment
Bcz of this opinion TLP attack on him 4 time.
They themselves are the product of Establishment.
Their stance is just invalid as they also defend Chisti Rasool Allah.
Freedom of Expression should be given to all. Abolish Blasphemy Law. There should be no Blasphemy law in any Islamic country.
ISLAM survives only because of BLASPHEMY & APOSTASY Laws.
Islam dies without lies. The predicament of "Moderate muslim" is understandable though
Islam doesn't allow blasphemy at all there should be laws on it but those laws should be properly regulated so no one can use them for there banifits
@@Islamic_Essence Blasphemy is nothing but criticism. Why it should not be allowed ? No religion is a holy cow. Freedom of expression is must for modern age. One can not depend on age old things. Individual faith is altogether a private matter and hence can not be discussed. Let's criticize every religion. This will improve every religion and finally humanity religion will win.
@@bogusrevealer9890 Logical questioning is allowed in Islam you can disagree and not belive. We can only answer and give you the message. But mocking or burning books that are holy to me that's what blasphemy is. You are free to question our religion Logically but can't disrespect that disrespect and disagreement is different. where will you draw the line?
@@Islamic_Essence
Right to Self Expression is right of everyone. You cannot snatch that right in the 21st century. But yes right to expression does not mean right to say abusive words or saying violent acts against someone which will try to spread malice and mischief. But overall Criticism of Islam and all other religions should be allowed in an intellectual manner.There should be no concept of Blasphemy in any Muslim or any Christian country.
Pakistan has persecuted Muslims too in the false case of Blasphemy.
Not a fan of offending people on purpose but even with proof killing someone for blasphemy is still barbarianism
That's why they should be given a chance to repent
If this comment offends people then let them be offended. U are absolutely right
Dear Pakistani Hindus, Christians, Sikhs, Parsis and Qadianis you being born and raised in this country Pakistan, may seems like the worst thing that has happened to you. As a Muslim, I realize your pain. In a country where even Muslims are usually labeled as blasphemers and brutally lynched, it's understandable if you question your safety here. Therefore, I urge you to consider finding a way out of this land 🇵🇰 before it's too late. Fundamentalists may be coming for u next, chanting ‘Allahu Akbar’ & ‘Labbaik Ya Rasoolullah’.
Thanks bro ❤ aap jaise log bhi meri tarah Rational Muslim bangaye hain.
Secularism is part and parcel of Islam but Mullahs hijacked true Islam from us.
and please dont do dawah where you go to. otherwise very soon you will have to find a new place to go to
Now ur comment justifies the URDU word "انسانیت"
It is happening from the 18% Hindu population to the 1%. It is understandable that, those 17% were stuck by religious zombies and lost their identity.
Its only a matter of time.... There won't be any Blasphemy law. Freedom of expression is universal truth.
No Blasphemy law=> Islam finished.
@@jasha9sandhu So what. Modern time, modern religion.
Yes bro I support you and that too I am a Muslim.
@@bogusrevealer9890Modern time modern religion? So you're gonna change the laws of the Quran and Ahadith?
@@zawarshah8335 Yes, they need to change, they're way outdated and factually incorrect and incosistent.
The way our Christian brothers are persecuted there makes me sick.
I remember the case of Asia Bibi and Rimsha Masih.
And why did u forget the poor Buddhist Sri Lankan who was beaten and brunt! Coz he was not from Christianity!
Oppression and injustice mei bhi pehle Christian and fir koi aur! 😂
@@devshreebhardwaj3096 Persecution of Christians happened today in Jaranwala, that's why he is saying that.
@@devshreebhardwaj3096
Shut up you andbakht kahi ka. India mai bhi Christian Bhai behn mehfooz nahi hai. Mai khud Indian Muslim hu. Aur Christains par India mai bhi bohat zulm hota hai tum Hindu ki wajah se. So kindly shut up you bigot.
Jab oppressed ka saath dena ho toh waha uska dharam nahi dekha jaata balki insaniyat dekhi jaati hai aur ALLAH ka Islam teaches humanity to all.
You know Quran told us to respect people of the book(Includes Jews,Muslims and Christians).
@@jahidhosssin54456 i know, but that's never followed, the whole Islamic World is a witness to this expect for Jordan because, most Christians there have tribal connections to Muslims, so its the tribe connection saving them.
A very sensible fellow, sadly too few people like him.
Yar this man is love. I love his podcast
❤
Why does the Pakistani judiciary not take such maulana to jail ? But then no expectations to act like an educated human from Pakistan.
A PODCAST With Javed Ahmed Ghamidi and his student Hasan Ilyas should be recorded too.
Mixing religion in everything costs Pak it's destiny....constitution and not religion which is personal should be the guiding force
Please make a video on incident which involve burning of whole villages of minorities. Just to spread awareness that what Pakistanis are doing to its minorities on the name of religion. Thank you
Blasphemy law is " Iss aag me sab jalenge"😅🤣 in another words.
Manipur😂😂
@@ifham12 shardha yaad hai momin. Tumlog ka kaam sirf matam manana rah gaya hai bas mauka mile or rona chalu
🤣😂. Manipur me hua so galat huwa par manipur manipur karte raho . Tumlog kisi had tak gir sakte ho desh ko bhi badnam kar sakte ho apne ego ke liye. Dhatt teri ki Gattarcchapo.😂
@@ifham12 Tumlogo kuch din pahle Hinduo ke temple tode ab 8 church tod diye pakistan ke Faislabad me. Ye lo hai shanti ke masiha shantidoot the so called peaceful religion . Boom💥💨
@@ifham12 Tumlog ek no ke lalchi hooro ke liye kahi bhi phat jate hai or dusra kaam allha se darte raho jindagi bhar jaise ki wo koi jallad ho. Hum hindu kabhi bhagwan se nahi darte balki pyar karte hai, aur hame hame hoor foor me intrest bhi nahi lete. Sab jooth ka kahani banaya hai lalach do eslam me samil karo aur dara ke rakho allha se baccho ki tarah ki sare baate mane or eslam bhi na chhode dar se. Tumlogo se sari duniye me sirf asanti failya hai bas majhab ke naam pe shanti se insano ki tarah rehna nahi aata. Engineer sahab ko ek ne maulana ne fatwa jari kar diya hai marne kitne shandoot ho tum log🤣😅
All these yt influencers from pakistan will never highlight the plight of Hindus in pakistan, yet they want friendship with India. Never trust them
ہمیں چاہیے بھی نہیں۔
@@talaltariqq_Well, ur PM definitely needs to...hence, ur ministers crying for friendship with us in ur Parliament. Lol
@@kishandubey7882Who are you even suggesting bruh. These are the same guys who didn't accept dead bodies of Thier own soldiers in Kargil. Pakistan in itself is a baigarat kaum not only it's leaders. Otherwise they would hav fought back to Thier leaders to get bodies back. That's why entire nation is a circus 😂
This is the reality of these converted Punjabi uslims of KANGALADESH ( PAK ) " 👩 MAA WEE ANEE 💃 DHEE WEE ANEE 👦 PUTTAR WEE ANAA JAWAI ( Son in-law ) WEE ANAA RAB NAI RANG LAYA TAYE NUU ( daughter in-law ) WEE ANEE AAI KOI KEE KARAY JITHAY SARA TABAAR ( PAK ) HEE ANAA HOWAY " under the influence of 8th century feudal brutal barbarian blood thirsty political ideology called .... ...lam
6:32 Brother love your work but please kindly do something about the audio and sound settings of your videos. Horrible distortion
I'm a Hindu, I don't believe in burning of holy books as freedom of expression.
We don't want any books burned. We know the horrors of Nalanda at the hand of Bakhtiar Khilji.
A bakhtiar khilji ne galat kiya ye same usi trha hai jese baghdad me HALAKU KHAN ne kiya tah...lekin baat ye hai k in bndo ka gunnah or galat kaam ki saza aj k muslims ko ne deni chaye jinho ne galat ne kiya
Lekin baat ye hai ki bakhtiar khilji ne jo kiya usne Islam ki roshni mein hi to Kiya, kafiron ki muqaddas kitab , imarat todna jalana nhi sikhaya?
Kya kafiron ko lootna ho nhi sikhaya?
Endia ke masalmam kya fakkr nhi karte apne baap dadao kke kaam ke uppar?
Karte hai fakr
Burning is not good and is bad. But yes positive criticism should be tolerated.
Nalanda was burned bcz Qur'an mentions and allows to destroy all the things related to kafirs....
@@HAVOC_PUBGfir aaj k Muslims ko bolna chaiye... Khilji harami tha. Bolenge?😂 Nahi.. man he man baap maantr Hain use.
Love this podcast (2)
❤
My favourite podcast from your playlist.
I hope you do another one.
🙌
You guys are wasting time talking inhumane law a islamic or non-islamic. Pehla Insaan bhano..
because of such thinking in every pakistanis, the country still live in a stone age.
M A Mirza may need to _tone_ it down a bit. I intend this respectfully. I can see how his enthusiasm and passion clouds his ability to express his points more sensibly. He definitely made a few good points, there's no difficulty in recognizing this, but I agree with the lady from the Ministry on recognizing that a gustakhi can extend to propriety of expression, adab in address, and preventing oneself from inserting our own common speech and superimposing our understanding on historical encounters. Overconfidence (where I have witnessed such occurences) can lead one to do so, without batting an eyelid. It's a very "bedouin-like" attitude to Islam. (I say "bedouin-like" with all its positive and negative connotations.)
A crash course on adab and people's general ignorance of religion can remedy this somewhat. (If there's a will somewhere.)
Anyhow, it's great to see the discussion brought up, even if it could do with some tidying of thoughts along the way. It's unfortunate that religiously-affiliated people often have to pick up the pieces socially, after some public outrage occurs (with not the slightest link to the religion). I guess it comes with territory nowadays.
Lots of questions covered, thanks ❤
❤
Great podcast Shahzad , can you kindly invite Waqar Zaka as a guest .
😅😅
Duniya Chand pe chali Gaye ..aur musalman aaj v 6th century me
Aur sita Randi Kahan pr?
I hope molvis mein bhe kch sense aye asi.
Emotional ker k mulk k bera gark ker dya hu
MASHA-ALLAH.... ALLAH PAK ISS ENGINEER KI HIFAZAT FARMAY.. BAAT LOGICALLY KARTA HE... WELL DONE THE BRAVE REPORTER
In a democratic country there should not be any place for Blasphemy law..This is 2024. No matter how much disliking is between different religions I would never want anyone to be killed in the name of religion. Why can't we be tolerant ? I would not like anyone disrespecting ny God, but I would also not want anyone to be killed for the same. Human life is not so cheap. When God has given life then it should be God's decision to take away a life. Why are we trying to be God ?
I love Ustad G engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza 🌷❤️
If only we had a few more like you Sir
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience
Freedom of Expression should be given to all. Abolish Blasphemy Law. There should be no Blasphemy law in any Islamic country.
@ 29 September 2023
@ 12 Rabi Ul Awwal in India ❤
Ali bhae is a great great great great great great legend
سورتہ فاتحہ اور ختم نبوت کی نفی
قرآن کا یہ اصول ہے کہ قرآن مجید میں کوئی بھی دعا ایسی نہیں پائی جاتی جو نا ممکن چیز کے لئے کی گئی ہو۔ مثلآ اللہ مجھے قیامت تک حیات بخش یا سورج کی سیر کروا وغیرہ وغیرہ ۔ ہر دعا ممکنات میں سے ہے۔ مثلاً میرے گناہ بخش دے نقصان اٹھانے والوں میں سے نہ بنانا صحت عطا فرما آنکھوں کی ٹھنڈک عطا فرما دشمن پر فتح نصیب فرما وغیرہ وغیرہ ۔ اب سوال یہ ہے کہ اگر امت مسلمہ یہود اور عیسائیوں کی طرح اپنے اعمال اور عقائد کے لحاظ سے بن نہیں سکتی تو سورتہ فاتحہ کے آخری حصہ میں یہ دعا کیوں سکھائی گئی ہے کہ ہمیں ان کی طرح نا بنانا جن پر تیرا غضب نازل ہو مطلب یہود اور ان کی طرح نہ بنانا جو گمراہ ہوئے یعنی مسیحی۔ اب سوال یہ ہے کہ اگر مسلمان یہود کی طرح ہو جائیں تو اس کا اعلاج کیا ہے؟ یہود اگر بگڑیں تو ان کے لئے پے در پے انبیاء مطلب آسمان سے تازہ روحانی خوراک اور مسلمان اگربگڑ جائیں تو ان کے لئے وہی مزہبی رہنما اور وہی خوراک جس نے انہیں بیمار کیا؟ یہ سورتہ فاتحہ کے آخری حصہ میں یہود اور مسیحیوں سے جو مماثلت کی گئی ہے بہت دلچسپ ہے اور اسی میں امت کا حل بھی بتایا گیا ہے۔ جو سمجھے سو سمجھے
Dick Claudi hxfuuu dass gffgh
Blasphemy hatao humanity bachao 🕋💣💣💣🕋🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
@goddessdevi2869bro calm down
@goddessdevi2869aby ya Lndians hn inka brain🧠 chota hota hai, science bhi yshi kehty hai
جو حدیث امام علی ع کے بارے میں پیش کی ہے اس میں امام علی ع نے کہا کہ آپ نے ہمارے ساتھ زیادتی کی یے ہم رسول اللہ ع کی قرابت کی وجہ سے اپنا حق سمجھتے تھے ۔ اس میں کہیں مشورہ نہ لینے کا ذکر ہی نہیں ہے یہ حدیث 4240 بخاری سے ہے۔ انجینیر صاحب حدیث میں اپنے جملے ٹھوک رہے ہیں۔ علمی کتابی صاحب ذرا حدیث کو دوبارہ پڑھیں
Imran khan and my sweeper is same for blasphemy law
Engineer ke examples bhe........Allah hidayat dy
شغل لگا رہے گا اور دنیا کو اصل اسلام دیکھائی دیتا رہے گا ۔
Ye to puch ki Islam mayn bjay,sood pe paise Lena haraam hye to pakisthan kaise loan le raha hye byaj pe tab to ye mulla pakad ke sab pakisthani haraam hogaye🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
So antisemitic laws are pushed down our throats but blasphemy law should be abolished!
Lkin huzzor saw ki azwaaj ka nikah slamat rehta hai
Brave
توہین کے قوانین نے اب عوامی ردِعمل اس حد تک واہیات کر دیا ہے کہ بات اس گفتگو سے بھی آگے جا پہنچی ہے، جج کوئی توہین کے کیس میں پبلک رائے کے خلاف فیصلہ کر کے تو دکھائے
mashAllah
🙌
Did Mohammad get anyone killed for blasphemy? How did blasphemy laws enter Islam?
th-cam.com/video/msRmoRak8LA/w-d-xo.html
If you are muslims then I feel sorry for your limited knowledge about islam. If you are non muslim then let me inform you that Mohammed killed many just because they criticized him. Let me give you one example of that-
A woman used to write satire about mohammad. Then Mohammad said his companions "who can kill her for me". A sahabi stood and said he will do it. Later in a night the sahabi went to the woman's home and killed her. At that time she was sleeping with her breast-feeding children. More interestingly Mohammad guaranteed the killer that he will be in jannat after death. 😂 What a joke about 72 hoorwala jannat
Please explain Sura Nisha ayat 24, how can Allah allows killing of people and then have sex with their wifes and daughters. How can it be message from a creator?
I read the ayah after seeing your comment and what I got was that you haven't even read the ayah yourself 🤣 it is clearly written that you have to ask their consent and marry them legally in Nikah after they are captured nowhere its said that you can force them it also says that you have to make them equal to other woman when deciding mahr and dowry, So please go back and learn more
@@wasaymoria9061 How logical answer, how can you expect a women to have Nikka after killing their family members. If it happens with you and your family you would still have the same opinion?
The religion gives them liberty to do everything wrong
That’s what saint MIYAMITTU IS DOING CONVERTING FORCEFULLY.MARRYING THEM TO OLD MULLAHS
@@Ddgstationearth do You have any idea what usually happen with women after a war, compared to that this is a 100 times better treatment and yes I would be happy if there is a war and my family is captured like this I would pray that the people capturing are Muslims cause they will receive a lot better treatment than if it was a non Muslim they might be raped and murdered
NOW THE CHURCH IS BURNT AFTER SOME TIME SOME PROPERTY DEVELOPER WILL BUILD BUILDING MALL END OF THE STORY
Timely upload when the church has been burnt down.
This clip is uploaded specially on burning of churches
La ilah il Allah mohammad Rasulallah
There are certain limits to everything, why everyone is running to Engr instead of the Ulama who have put there whole life into Deen. This liberism is making us worst like the West. Or wahi sa jo parh k ata hai unhe k yahe haal hotta hai k wo tolerance tolerance karte hai yaha take k sub normal hojaye.
Ha ye waqiah waqqi mai buhat he dard naak hai aise nahe karna chaheya tha laikn tum sub kaha thay, jab sweden ma Quran Jalaya gaya kisi na pocha k hamain kya karna chaheya?
West k ye haal thab howa jab unho na sub kuch bardasht karna shoro krdeya tu ab dhaik LGBTQ wala scene ye aise he chalta hai bhai
Or Engr saahb deen ma addition ko he biddat kehtay hai or ap sahaba k baaton ko ya ahadith ko aise apne extra alfaaz ma nahe keh skte ye koi ap ke ya meri likhi howe nazam nahe hai, jis na sahih bukhaari or sahih muslim likhi hai us na ye sub references wagera issi liye likhe hai k is ma koi addition na ho, warna tu koi b kisi k baat sun k agay keh daita k us na aise keh deya itni mehnat k kya zarorat.
This man has some social issues awareness??
Aur ye bhi puchna ki agar umra ki hisab se jannat mayn hooren milengi to jo 74saal main Ayub Khan margaya,75,80saal main jinna mar gaya hye to unko kya 74,80saal ki hooren milengi?
Tab hooren Milne ka kya phayda🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
74 whores for every whoreson that become prettier, fairer and more virginal after every deflowering 😂
Khud hi ek rule bna k khud hi hans raha. Ye knowledge apnay pass rakh.😂😂
@@talashegumshuda5791what knowledge? This is the junk you believe in. Dissecting the fantasies of a seventh century epilectic patient.
Yar I love this podcast
❤
Musalmano me Aisa kyu hai ki tum mujhe bataoge ki mujhe kya krna hoga aree Bhai jisko jis tarah se bhi apne ishwar ko manna hai Mane ye batane Wale kon hote h
Yrr Islam ko hijack krDiya hai kuxh element's ny.
Ye blasphemy rule hi bakwas hai.
This is not eruope where you do such things and Muslim stood and just of watch.
Toh tera matlab ???
Sar tan se juda ?
@@comparativereligiondailynews oh you pathetic vegetarian mind your own business
omg.....whole pakistan discussion is religions.... what is wrong and what is right... and till now all have different opinions 😂😂😂😂😂
another world reaching Moon and Mars.... discussing on AI and quantum computers.... 😂😂😂
احمدی مسلمانوں کے با رے میں یہ موصوف انجینیر صاحب خود فیصلہ صا در فرما تے ہیں۔ احمدی مسلمانوں پہ یہ نظر کرم کیوں؟پگڑی بچا نا یا اسلام سے محبت؟
Ye 3 number log kon?
Iska start hi Sahaba RAA ko frame karne sy hota hai
lol, why he adds engineer to his name? he knows engineers dont have title but i guess he just wants everyone to know he is somewhat educated.
He explains the reason. Go figure it out.
C grade engineer used to mental gymnastics and no innovation
@@TiamatJkeyboard warriors barking.
Why do doctors add Dr before their names?
Why do lawyers add Adv before their names?
Why do professors add Prof before their names?
@@IdreesGhazi786 smooth brained child.
P.Eng is a title that goes after your name. Without the professional designation, being an engineer is quite ordinary.
This guy is an engineer? If you are quoting scriptures all the time, you are an imam not an engineer 😅😅.
@UraidTariq LOL...in India he wouldn't qualify as a mechanic😅
پاکستان سے زندہ بھاگ
نہیں، پاکِستان میں واپس آؤ۔
Mirza Saab! Phr judge ko kon bachye ga?
Islam ki bongiya
Read Ibn e Sayyad derails when he disrespect Rasool Allah S.A.W. what hapoehed and reaction of Rasool Allah S.A.W.
Multiple churches vandalised, bibles burnt in Faisalabad on allegation of blasphemy... but these beggars are worried about rising Hindutva, Manipur, kashmir etc.
No wonder the whole country lives on alms and beg to make a living. 😂😂😂
gat hind, monkey hanuman ky chaat ja kr . nikaly saly hindu kutay
Hypocrisy=Pakistan
This space was reserved for discussion, but somehow you managed to make it about hate. Reflects your social conditions _and_ your conditioning. 🙌
@@ThePakChinaYou can use this language in India also. I guarantee Indian will not kill you. But Pakistan is a national security state with mob mentality.
Ok bro, everything happening in the world is due to Pakistan. As always you should blame us and you're right always 😂😂