Salam Dr Hany. Surah Ibrahim (14): Verse 39 clearly contradicts what you are proposing. This is the verse where Prophet Ibrahim (a.s.) thanks Allah for granting him Prophet Ismail and Prophet Ishaq in his old age. Prophet Ismail is mentioned first - and as you say, there is a clear intention for every word in the Quran - this means that Prophet Ismail came before Prophet Ishaq and cannot therefore be Prophet Muhammad. This clear verse clearly contradicts your proposition that Prophet Ismail(as) was Prophet Muhammad (saw). In your comments below, you mentioned you have given your answer to this - where in the video have you done so? I watched the video and could not find it. Please provide the time so that I can review it. In as much as your approach to understanding the Quran is novel and refreshing, you should realise that it is not the only way to do so. Once there lived a man who had an insightful way of looking at the Quran - the number 19 - he was so convinced of his methodology that he published his own Quran and removed 2 verses from the Quran because they did not fit into his methodology. His name is Rashad Khalifa, whom I believe was very intelligent, just as you are. In his eagerness of his methodology towards the Quran, he lost his way and could not see the false state he was in. So you should be careful Dr Hany that you are not trapped in tunnel vision and believing that only your methodology is the only way. The Most Merciful is all Wise. His book cannot be constrained by just one methodology. His Book is a miracle. So take a step back and ask yourself what you are doing - let not your zeal and success in proposing a methodology to the Quran blind you in seeing the truth. One indicator of this is your claim that all others are wrong and you are right. Are you sure that you alone are right? You got to be careful here. May Allah guide us all closer to the truth.
@ Muhammad Qalam Salaamun Alaykum Thank you for taking the time to write. I thank you for your advice in the third paragraph. Nevertheless, you missive builds on several assumptions that are not true: 1. You provide Aya 14:39 as a basis for a rule you invented, that a list of names must necessarily mean temporal ordering. This rule is something YOU MADE UP and is clearly not supported in the Quran, as could be easily proven by Aya 4:163, where 3issa is listed before Haaroon, Sulayman and Daawood, etc, even though 3issa came after them. In other words, when we are providing a logical analysis, we need to validate our assumptions before going astray in critiquing and criticizing. DO NOT MAKE UP YOUR OWN RULES AND DO NOT CLAIM THAT THE QURAN MUST FOLLOW YOUR OWN IMAGINARY RULES. 2. You presented Aya 14:39 as a counter-example while failing to note that we have discussed that aya in detail in the video. Please watch the video before dismissing the evidence. IT IS YOUR JOB TO WATCH AND LEARN BEFORE YOU THROW ACCUSATIONS THAT ARE BASELESS. 3. You referred to the so-called methodology of Number 19. Again, this is a farse because the Quran itself, in Aya 74:31 (right after the verse of "19") tells us that that number was only given as a "fitnah" (test or trap) to those who are disbelievers... And therefore, whoever uses numerology based on "19" is clearly unaware of the danger of considering this number, and the warning against applying it "as a methodology"... And therefore, comparing me to Rashad Khalifa is an uninformed comparison, and perhaps even an under-handed attempt to dismiss the seriousness of the organic Quranic methodology I use exclusively on this channel... Furthermore, to even mention the misguided claims of Rashad Khalifa (taking out some verses of the Quran) is a clear attempt to imply that I WOULD EVEN CONSIDER playing loose with the integrity of the Quran... Anyone who has watched any video on this channel knows that I hold the integrity and the cohesiveness of the Quran above all else... 4. You claim that I am "trapped in tunnel vision and believing that only your methodology is the only way. The Most Merciful is all Wise. His book cannot be constrained by just one methodology."... First, I never claimed that it was "my methodology"! I keep stating that it is extracted from the Quran. There is a whole playlist about the methodology... Don't be lazy! Watch it and then you will be in a better position to criticize instead of throwing accusatory labels such as "tunnel vision", "zeal", and blinded"!!! Second: The Quran tells us clearly in Aya 1:6 that there is one Siraat, not many. Siraat is never provided in a plural form in the Quran... Furthermore, in Aya 6:153, Allahh warns us against following multiple ways, and insists that there is only one Siraat. That Siraat is the methodology, as we demonstrated in the segment on Surah Al-Fatiha (YT88) and other segments earlier. To elaborate further, I remind you that when Allahh tells us about the story of Zakariya and Yahya and Maryam and 3issa, as an example, there cannot be multiple ways to the facts in that story. All stories in the Quran follow a similar manner of unique facts that cannot be multiple. Those who claim that there are multiple WAYS TO INTERPRET THE QURAN ARE ONLY DESPERATE TO DISMISS THE IRREFUTABLE EVIDENCE OUR VIDEO SEGMENTS OFFER, AND ARE ONLY DESPERATE TO DEFEND THEIR ERRONEOUS WAYS AGAINST THE DEVASTATING EFFECT OUR VIDEOS ARE HAVING ON EXPOSING THEIR ERRONEOUS, BASELESS, AND SECTARIAN INTERPRETATIONS! If you had confidence in the book of Allahh, you would have confidence in the methodology he told us to follow! No apologies are needed in having full confidence and in defending the Siraat of our lord! Once again, I thank you for writing, and I value these exchanges, but you need to get out of your own tunnel vision, and allow yourself to embrace the truth the Quran and its irrefutable evidence! (I will keep a copy of this exchange in case it gets deleted by accident!) Regards
UNLESS YOU ARE Muhammad Qalam... PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! OTHERWISE, IT WILL BE DELETED.
Time Stamps 0:01 Introduction 4:01 In this segment 6:29 The traditional (erroneous) story of Ibrāhīm 10:53 Dissonance in traditional account about IssmāƐīl 25:04 Reminder about the concept of Markings 27:19 Reminder about the principle of intentionality 30:51 Reminder about the meaning of لا إلٰه إلا الله 36:05 Who is IssmāƐīl? 38:43 Primary Evidence (1) 4 exclusive, irrefutable markings 47:07 Primary Evidence (2) --- the messenger who is a prophet I:02:02 Primary Evidence (3) --- Supplication of Ibrāhīm 1:09:21 Primary Evidence (4) --- Separating two subjects of one verb 1:09:50 Secondary evidence (1) --- Present vs Past tense 1:13:37 Secondary evidence (2) --- Why was Muhammad not mentioned in the list of prophets 11:14:54 Verifying our conclusions (1) 1:20:47 Verifying our conclusions (2) 1:24:05 Verifying our conclusions (3) 1:30:29 Verifying our conclusions (4) 1:32:54 Verifying our conclusions (5) 1:34:52 Verifying our conclusions (6) 1:55:44 Debunking the traditional story of Hājar (or Hāgar) 2:05:28 What about As-Ṣafā and Al-Marwā in HAjj? 2:07:22 Is it true that IssmāƐīl is “ghulām Ḥalīm” whereas Iss-Ḥāq is “ghulām Ɛalīm”? 2:07:45 Summary so far 2:09:04 4 beautiful gifts 2:21:10 What are the implications of all of this? 2:27:19 A severe warning from Allahh to those who do not make amend 2:29:19 What to do with this information?
Keep it up Dr. Hani. It is an extremely important service you are rendering to the mankind not just Muslims. I salute you with the core of my heart and accept you the marvelous tutor of this century. May Almighty bless you and us the followers of your channel with great Hidaya. Lets be among the Mutaqeen, Alhaqa and Saliheen etc. Keep it up Dr. Hani i never want to stop listening your channel, I wish everyone on earth benefits from this great revelations of unravelling the scripture done so with delayed diligent understanding - Alakhira. The fresh spring water has now started flowing to our Kursi from Al-Arsh. Jazak Allah! I wish I was an Arabic native unfortunately I am not but I believe I am among the blessed ones that is why I am with you. Insha Allah Taallah!
Wow, it’s like learning how to walk all over again, but this time every step is pleasurable, all praises be to our Lord, the Almighty, the one who provides linguistic discernment
Alhumdulilla! I am feeling so blessed and thankful to Allahh swt for teaching us the correct knowledge of Quran. Thank so much! Dr. Hany, for your hard work and dedication
I have been super busy lately, now continuing back again from here. Watched the whole segment. Amazing, no more comments. If a genuinely say, learning Qur'an from your videos is the best part of my day well spent. Awesome!!!!
I did not understand when it is crystal clear. Ibrahim - Verse 39 ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَـٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَـٰقَ ۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ All praise is for Allah who has blessed me with Ishmael and Isaac in my old age. My Lord is indeed the Hearer of ˹all˺ prayers.
As of last week, I been practising the replacing of Allahuma with Rabbana or Rabbi. So have a few of my charges and apprentices after I told them the reasons why. I embraced Islam in early 1980, at age 18, travelled the world since deciding leaving school in search of Allah's path, has always been learning and enjoying the journey.
Dr Hanny, what about this verse? 14:39 ٱلۡحَمۡدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِي وَهَبَ لِي عَلَى ٱلۡكِبَرِ إِسۡمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسۡحَٰقَۚ إِنَّ رَبِّي لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ Praise be to God, who has granted me Ismail and Ishaq in my old age: my Lord hears all requests! -Surah Ibrahim, 39
I am tearing in joy. For so long time, for the past 6 years during my journey with the Quran, I came with the fact how could our people be easily misguided with so call our scholars? How could Muslims claim that the Quran is their primary source but in reality, they give more attention and preach extraneous sources? Despite their claims that the Quran is perfect and clear? And inventing extra Quranic teaching? So, since that, I disposed of all teaching that had never been approved by Quran, because it does not make any sense, and since that I found my life become more easily, happy and enjoying the freedom of not being in the shackle of religious authority. I rely on Allah only. I praise Allah that I finally found this channel that gives me more energy to follow “this forgotten path” and thanks to you, Dr. Hany and I am by your side, ready to become a witness
Gentleman, thank you..., We expect more from you, now that you began to lift this veil, stop not. Your language is clear and eloquent. We remain eager to hear more and more. Thank you, again. May Allah grant you more knowledge to explain it to those who are indeed in need for it.
Alhamdulilaah, I am a witness to this cause, and I am grateful to ALLAH for opening doors that we least expected as this knowledge has never been known to me nor to the ummah till to this day. This only goes to show how ALLAH is extremely merciful and yet some of us are refusing to accept .... oh people think twice and think again and ask questions that lead you to ALLAH only
Thanks a lot. I am behind you. Am learning afresh. I emptied my cup. It is a tough journey. At the time our Muslim Arab brethren is undergoing a tough transition, this is a good time to reflect and open our hearts and purify our Deen from such corruptionn
Salaamun Alaikum Al Hamdu Lillah After soaking everything in from this segment all I can say to all those who choose to refute; the description of Isma'eel(SAW) is given in Surah 19:54/5 now choose your rejection carefully, if as your flock choose to believe the corrupted sources and still claim Isma'eel(SAW) is the direct son or 1st son of Prophet Ebrahim(AS), Allah is giving his description in the above mentioned Surah as a Messenger and Prophet. With that in mind my question to the refutes and their flock is as a Messenger what was his message/scripture that he was tasked to deliver? May Allah guide everyone to better understanding. To Dr Hany and team keep up the great work you guys are doing. I thank Allah for revealing this knowledge to us through you guys. May Allah bless you guys and your families in this world and the next.
Please read surah 2:136,surah 3:84,surah 4:163.(there is also ishaq as brother whom allah sent his revealation) plz dont be in hurry.and i also know that allah mentioned ismael as a messenger and prophet but plz read surah 19:51 to 19:59. My question is to dr hany why allah swt separately mentioned that we revealed to you means muhammad saw and then ibrahim and ismael. And its 3 times. What about the reply of yaqub sons? i am not in hurry to accept these interpretation instantly so i will take my time and i request all of the viewers of dr hany plz dont put the eyes only on the crow but also on your ears.
It's funny how extraneous info coming from the Judeo-biblical sources there is always a sterile wife/ woman. This imported theme occurred multiple times in traditional books (taken from the corrupted Torah). Hamdulillah for this clarification.
Salaamun Alaykum, Dr. Hany, I have two points of confusion regarding this video. I may be mistaken, but I noticed that some of the concepts presented earlier were not consistent with the information provided in this video. For example, at TS 52:04, you mentioned two scriptures, the Torah and Injeel, which were not yet revealed at the time of Moses. However, I have learned from your other lectures that Injeel is not a scripture but refers to Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Additionally, at TS 1:14:18, Eisa was mentioned as one of the prophets who are "Saleheen," but I understand that Eisa was unable to complete his prophetic mission according to divine commands and thus returned as FQ. Could you please provide clarification on these points? Thank you for your time. Regards,
Good observation. In earlier segments we presented simplifications in order to avoid too many disclosures at once, to make it easier for people to understand. But later, we provided additional clarifications regarding the Injeel. Yes! The Injeel is NOT a scripture.
I am committed to standing up for Allah against those who corrupted our Deen (and continue to do so today). I will continue to toil on the Quran (alone) and qualify myself to be a firm defender of "The Truth". Praise to Allah who have guided us this and we were never to be guided if not for His direct Guidance............
Yes indeed, this two n half hour segment will keep us busy and demand our focus because we need to critically analyse the traditional translation/interpretation Vs versus what is exposed by dr. Hany...am glad this far that dr. Hany does not reject the hadiths completely but selectively accepted some of them valid as and when they are qualified by the quran... Also the literal meaning of some of the words in the quran as traditionally translated by the obvious practical usage like الارض to mean 'the scripture'(by dr. Hany) Vs 'the land'(as traditionally translated)... both meanings have their relevance depending whether they are to be taken as methaphor or as physical things in real life......
Salaamun Alaikum, I had difficulties with this segment ever since it was released months ago, but Alhamdulillah, starting from the understanding of the meaning of Al bait and Kaanu, it is clearer, mashaallah. Jazakallah u khairan kathiran
WOWWWW.... Alhamdolillah, Beautiful... an eye opener... May Allah lift more "clouds" form our vision/sight and take us closer to his path, as it is said "you take one step towards him he will come ten steps closer towards you" Thank you Dr Hany and keep up the great work you are doing to awaken the sleeping UMMAH... The people will say a lot many bad things about you but dont be disheartened... it was done before too... to those who struggeled in the way of Allah Oh Allah!! Our Lord, Our Sustainer.. Please guide us to the straight path which leads to you, and have mercy on us and join us with those who would be successful on the day of judgment... Aamin.
Assalamu'alaikum Dr Hany. Jazakallahu Khairan for your latest segment on Ishmael. Another surprised and revealing subject. Everything happens for a reason as to our own creation. The timing of it also matters & at Allahh's will. Everyone has his or her own timeline. As for me I don't really study the Qur'an in much detail until my later years for many reasons. Frankly, I do not regretted it because I found a channel that able to explain not only the contents but also provides the methodology in doing the tafsir. I thank Allah for in a way I am not corrupted or misguided by previous translations and interpretations but more importantly I'm able to learn and engage the Qur'an in a more guided way (due the methodology) together with you and the rest that watch this channel. This latest segment (video) reaffirmed that labels, terms or names are important in the process of trying to get to know something or someone. We just cannot know something in depth by just a single identifier or name. That's the reason Allah have many names or 'attributes'. It helps to condense or summarize a long explanation or description or wordy sentences so that we can easily remember. Carry on with the good & important work Dr Hany. May Allah continue to guide and protect you.
As salam alaikoum, What about the 39 ayat of surat Ibrahim? Because in this Ayat Ibrahim AS praise Allah for giving him at an old age Ismail and Ishaq... Very clear ???!!!!????
Allhumdulilah, I got the message Dr. Hany, the more I watch your lecturers the more I see you are logical with your evidence and some of the people that are committing are clearly as the Quran said in surah (34:43)
Ibrahim 14:39 ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَٰقَۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ Praise to Allah, who has granted to me in old age Ishmael and Isaac. Indeed, my Lord is the Hearer of supplication.
Issma3l is no other than our Beloved Muahmmed SAW. This segment brought joy to my heart. We stand with the evidence based knowledge in the Quran alone. AlhamduLillah!!!
I has been follow this channel for few month and keep revisit previous video while waiting for new one. No word to express joy except 'Alhamdullillah' . I will definitely follow Al Quran with promise evident rather follow them as 'mindunillah. Thank you Dr.Hany.
I'm really appreciate your education, i was always sceptical about the comparison off the corrupted Torah to the true Al'quraan . What always bothered me was the opening verses of surah Baqrah .." this is a book in which is NO doubt " . I thank almighty Allah for guiding me to you.
Brother this man is leading people astray, or Deen is protected our thiker* which is rememberance has been preserved. If you deny the authentic ahadeeth you deny your prayers your zakat your hajj and your umra, you deny every facit of your Deen. Anyone can think themselves above the Prophet peace be upon him but Allah choose him and preserved everything with a prestine miraculous science. We have a direct chain to the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him. Ask a scholar, do your own research Don't rely on this man's misguided babble.
Salamum alikum, I will be honest at first i was extremely shocked and in disbelief about the term Allahhummah, but after your second video about the common questions i have submitted to to the Quranic evidence. Thank you for opening my eyes
معاذ الله Did Prophet Miss This Point And Fail to teach His Sahaba?? Or This So Called Dr Atchan Is more Knowledgeable Out of Nowhere ?? May ALLAH Protect us From these kind of Dajjal Deceiver. قُلِ ٱللَّهُمَّ مَٰلِكَ ٱلْمُلْكِ تُؤْتِى ٱلْمُلْكَ مَن تَشَآءُ وَتَنزِعُ ٱلْمُلْكَ مِمَّن تَشَآءُ وَتُعِزُّ مَن تَشَآءُ وَتُذِلُّ مَن تَشَآءُ ۖ بِيَدِكَ ٱلْخَيْرُ ۖ إِنَّكَ عَلَىٰ كُلِّ شَىْءٍ قَدِيرٌ Invoke (O dear Prophet Mohammed - peace and blessings be upon him), “O Allah! Owner Of The Kingdom - You bestow the kingdom on whomever You will, and You take back the kingdom from whomever You will; and You give honour to whomever You will, and You humiliate whomever You will; only in Your hand lies all goodness; indeed, You are Able to do all things.” 3-Al Imran : 26 قَالَ عِيسَى ٱبْنُ مَرْيَمَ ٱللَّهُمَّ رَبَّنَآ أَنزِلْ عَلَيْنَا مَآئِدَةً مِّنَ ٱلسَّمَآءِ تَكُونُ لَنَا عِيدًا لِّأَوَّلِنَا وَءَاخِرِنَا وَءَايَةً مِّنكَ ۖ وَٱرْزُقْنَا وَأَنتَ خَيْرُ ٱلرَّٰزِقِينَ Eisa, the son of Maryam, said, “O Allah, O our Lord! Send down to us a table spread from heaven, so that it may become a day of celebration for us - for our former and latter people - and a sign from You; and give us sustenance - and You are the Best Provider Of Sustenance.” 5-Al-Ma'ida : 114 قُلِ ٱللَّهُمَّ فَاطِرَ ٱلسَّمَٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ عَٰلِمَ ٱلْغَيْبِ وَٱلشَّهَٰدَةِ أَنتَ تَحْكُمُ بَيْنَ عِبَادِكَ فِى مَا كَانُوا۟ فِيهِ يَخْتَلِفُونَ Invoke (O dear Prophet Mohammed - peace and blessings be upon him), “O Allah! The Creator of the heavens and the earth, the All Knowing of all the hidden and the open, You will judge between Your bondmen, regarding the matters in which they differed.” 39-Az-Zumar : 46 QUL ALLAHUMMA - Means ALLAH COMMAND TO SAY ALLAHUMMA.. Also ALLAH Coded Dua of Hazrat Esa With ALLAHUMMA.
@@muhammadqadri7631 Salam Brother Muhammad Qadri, I hope you and your family are in good health, and Allah provides you with tremendous blessings and peace. I pray that Allah grants you the highest levels of Jannah. Of course our beloved prophet Muhammad, and a lot of the Sahaba understood the truth, and knew the Quran because they were taught the divine lexicon. The prophet Muhammad knew exactly what the Quran was teaching. Dr Hany is not questioning that. The question is, did the information about the understanding and interpretation of the Quran (the Quranic lexicon) reach us through the Sahaba? The answer is no. You see the Hadith are constructed and collected by humans, there will be mistakes in it. In fact there are many contractions in bukari. You will never find that in the Quran. Thus, for our religion we can not rely 1000% on the hadith. We need to rely 1000% on the Quran. If the Quran claims one thing and the Hadith claims another, we take the Hadith and chuck it out. So why not use the Quran to discover the Quranic lexicon, just like they did with hieroglyphics. Now we must also understand the political climate at the time when these Hadith, Sira and Commentary of the Quran were written, Please listen to Dr Hany in this video with an open mind: th-cam.com/video/iJP1_vxBZh8/w-d-xo.html. Tell me this, what happens when a person in China speaks against China? or a person in North Korea speaks against the status Quo. Their head would be chopped off. If you challenge the state similar things happen to you if you lived in the umayyid or abbasi period. That is why there is a lot of corruption. The corruption was added in to our commentary, narrations and more. The Quran says it explains all thing (Verse (16:89)). So why not let the Quran explain the Quran. Why should we let the Bible explain the Quran? Or other corrupted stories. Regardless knowledge does not come from just reading the quran, or reading the translation, or listening to Dr Hany. Knowledge only comes when Allah Allows knowledge to be given. So we must pray to Allah, to allow us to understand his religion they way he intended. I would encourage you to watch this video, with the mind set of "I know nothing, let me have an empty cup of knowledge" th-cam.com/video/iJP1_vxBZh8/w-d-xo.html. After that if you have any questions, Dr hany is more than happy to answer. But please do yourself justice, and think with an open mind. Remember at the time of all Muhammad, please use to say the same thing "Why should i follow you when our forefathers have taught us this" If we had this mindset at the time of the prophet we might off been kufaars. Of course Dr Hany is not a prophet and can and will and has made mistakes, but the path to knowledge is to have an open cup and allow yourself to make mistakes. We are not saying Dr Hany is coming up with new knowledge, we are saying this is what the Quran is really saying, our beloved Muhammad understood it this way as well as well as the sahaba that Allah chose to teach, but then this knowledge was corrupted and did not reach us. Again I wish you the very best, I hope you and your family are safe, healthy and live a long and healthy life. Please make dua for me as well.
@@IaKhanic OH Here After 1400 Years ALLAH عزوجل gave Opportunity to Be on Truth And Led Ummah be Misguided for 1400 years As If there were No Awaliya Allah Or Mujaddid For 1400 years.. Every coming days Your Hany comes with new claim Now Prophet Ishmael is none other than Prophet MUHAMMAD صلى الله عليه و سلم Keep your Bloody Shit Upon You and your Dr Hany. I Know Your Framework Upon TH-cam With Paid Comments And Likers Of Your Dajjali Agenda..
@@muhammadqadri7631 Dear Brother please watch his video on Allahummah, he answers all your questions there. Quran 39 :46 has been answered here: th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html Quran 3 : 26 has been answered here: th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html Quran 5: 114 has been answered here : th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html Please do try and watch the entire video. Jazak Allah Khair
@@muhammadqadri7631 Brother I am a muslim and I promise that I am not a paid commenter. If im not mistaken the concept of a Muhaddid only comes from hadith, and not the Quran. Please correct me if i am mistaken. Also brother you and I both know that it is not wise to call names, please remember only Allah knows what the truth is. What IF Dr Hany is right? Now you will be accountable to Allah on the day of judgment. You can have a difference of opinion, and we can discuss it in a civil manner. Please practice kindness and patience as Allah has prescribed to us. Is this what you want to show the rest of the world? That muslims start in fighting when a researcher provides something that you personally do not believe in? Sir, if you don't wish to change your view point that is up to you. Fighting is beneath us. I invite you to be brothers with a difference in opinion, instead of two brother fighting.
Subhanallah Stunning details. The reason why no Muslim scholar objected these stories is they all are trained on following human sayings blindly without questioning. Infact in scientific terms these are stupid illiterates blind followers who don’t look for evidence . How can one expect they have any intellectual capabilities. It has taken me some time and visiting 3 times to understand parts of this segment. I have seen many of these scholars in my life who when questioned say to me I have become kafir and that is their intellectual level. When these people are given full authorities they issue fatwas on their own any their blind followers accept. Perfect example of mindoonillah
The Qur'an is not here to shackle our every thought, restrict our every movement and fill our lives with an inexhaustible list of do's and dont's. The Qur'an is here to elevate our existence, to illuminate our consciousness, to enlighten our awareness and to purify our cores If we only just LISTEN and submit ourself, submit our being, submit our very essence to Allah alone. Our Lord, allow us to HEAR and obey, our Lord, allow us to submit wholeheartedly to you alone. Our Lord, count us among the Dhurreeya of your blessed prophets and messengers.
Alhamdulillahi... The very evidence that gave me shivers was "iqtadih"... Allahu Akbar! It suffices alone, beyond all! Couldn't retain my tears, when I recalled the first teachings of tafseer al Quran I received back in early 2000... Allahu Akbar... I say Alhamdulillah again, for having allowed Dr. Hani discover this concept, and fed him the willing so that he can share with us! Alhamdulillahi. I believe this is not happening by accident, Allah SWT rather wanted us to be fortunate to live in this moment in time... So we can understand from Dr. Hani and we then share, in turn!
Sir in 6:89 when An Nubuwah is mentioned and you have translated it as ways of Prophethood? Can you plz put light if this is different than assigning the Prophethood?
I a m the first to support you in your explanation based on Quran evidence! Keep it up Allah bless you and those who appreciate your work including my self.
AssalamAlaikoum Dr i am not trying to challenge you,but i am so confuse,i need some clarification about thoses questions: If the word Allahuma is not correct or not good to say why it is mentioned in the coran example in sourat 3:26 If ismael=Muhammad what is about sourat 47 ?name sourat Muhammad not ismael? Sourat 47:2Muhammad is clear mentionned there why? not Ismael there so on. Please answer.
@@drikkona actually this segment starts with a question and end up with evidences from your lord, the author presented the quranic evidences in sequence and much more will be presented in next segment. Patience will always be rewarded.
Do we forget the greatest Hadeeth that we have? Where each word is beyond doubt and the veracity of each word beyond reproach. Where each word is authentic and each word is GUARANTEED to have been uttered by the tongue of our beloved Rasool (saw). Where each word was passed onto us verbatim in his role that was protected by Allah from any deviations or mistakes. Allah has caused US to inherit that Hadeeth just as he will cause others to inherit it after us. So, do we rely on the hadeeths of people or do we rely on the best of hadeeths...Al Qur'an? Our Lord guide us to your good pleasure, Our Lord guide us ever closer to you. Alhamdulillah
Alhamdhulillah for this segment Dr.Hany.... I'm pretty sure there's more to all what was taught to us . I'm glad to witness this truth. May Allah be with all of us at all times.
Salamun Alaikum Dr, I was trying to find this aya 14:39 as you have mentioned in the following "Pinned" comment but it is not there. I really request you to provide the translation of the aya 14:39 please. Jazak Allah Khairun
Alhamdulilahh. Allahh have shown His mercy and guidance by leading me to these information. Honestly I was not really shocked about these revelation because I already have a strong scepticism about the stories since my youth and subhan Allahh, this segment really relieve me from the unnecessary guilty concious. I receive your message Dr Hany and I am all in, Insya Allahh.
Brother this man is leading people astray, or Deen is protected our thiker* which is rememberance has been preserved. If you deny the authentic ahadeeth you deny your prayers your zakat your hajj and your umra, you deny every facit of your Deen. Anyone can think themselves above the Prophet peace be upon him but Allah choose him and preserved everything with a prestine miraculous science. We have a direct chain to the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him. Ask a scholar, do your own research Don't rely on this man's misguided babble.
The ayaat of surah Ibrahim 14:35 to 14:41, narrate Ibrahim (a.s) supplicating; 14:35 And when Ibrahim said: My Lord! make this city secure, and save me and my sons from worshipping idols: His supplication goes thru to ayaat 14:39 onwards to 14:41 14:39 الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ الَّذِي وَهَبَ لِي عَلَى الْكِبَرِ إِسْمَاعِيلَ وَإِسْحَاقَ إِنَّ رَبِّي لَسَمِيعُ الدُّعَاءِ Praise be to Allah, Who has given me in old age Ismail and Ishaq; most surely my Lord is the Hearer of prayer: In the above ayah 14:39, following through from ayaat 14:35 to 14:41, “me” would invariably refer to Ibrahim, that Allah gave (وَهَبَ) Isma’il and Ishaq to Ibrahim upon old age (عَلَى الْكِبَرِ). This ayah records a past event (“gave”) during the lifetime of Ibrahim (“in old age”) that connected him with Isma’il and Ishaq in the same time frame. As such, according to this ayah of the Quran (by my understanding), Isma’il had lived within the same general time period as Ibrahim and Ishaq. Then there is surah Aali Imran ayah 3:65; يَا أَهْلَ الْكِتَابِ لِمَ تُحَاجُّونَ فِي إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَمَا أُنزِلَتِ التَّوْرَاةُ وَالْإِنجِيلُ إِلَّا مِن بَعْدِهِ أَفَلَا تَعْقِلُونَ O followers of the Book! why do you dispute about Ibrahim, when the Taurat and the Injeel were not revealed till after him; do you not then understand? Ayah 3:65 states that the Taurat and Injil were revealed after him (بَعْدِهِ) namely, Ibrahim. We know that the Quran was revealed after the Taurat and Injil. Historically, the time difference between the Quran and the Injil is at least greater than 600 years and even greater when compared to the Taurat. That would put Ibrahim (as) and Muhammad (pbuh) very distant in time relative to each other. When ayah 14:39 is considered, it means that the situation between Isma’il (as) and Muhammad (pbuh) was also the same. How then does one reconcile your proposition with ayaat 14:39 and 3:65, which when read together, seem to be clearly pointing to Isma’il (as) and our Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) living in different times? Or is there another understanding to these ayaat?
Yes..I was angry along time..as early as 24 years old....just was uncomfortable with these stories reported well after the passing of nabi S.A.W. Shukran Dr Hani...As a woman I thought this was way uncomfortable...I am so happy that my thinking was correct...the Quraan does not relate such stories..it's too pure for that
curious to this syeikh on why he goes to the extent if the Quran already mention Ismael is the son of Ibrahim as it is clearly crystal clear. Ibrahim - Verse 39 ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَـٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَـٰقَ ۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ All praise is for Allah who has blessed me with Ishmael and Isaac in my old age. My Lord is indeed the Hearer of ˹all˺ prayers.
Dr Hany, I will stand up with you, on the side of Quranic teaching. I apologies deeply for all the hateful messages, but please know that you are not alone. We are with you and in support of your incredible research. This segment was mind blowing and I will have to re-watch it a few times to understand. May Allah guide me and other muslims that have been stuck in this lies for the past 1400 years
Salaamun Alaykum Dr, Hany. This is my second time watching this presentation. This is beautiful. I wish I could express my feelings and joy with proper words. This revelation is only going to elevate our status as Muslims. In my childhood, I heard a story about Muhammad sw that he was Allahh's (SWT) first creation. Allahh made him as a star. Now it makes much more sense. Allahh (SWT) informed the coming of Muhammad to every single prophet and messenger and in every scripture. From Ibrahim to Isa and in between, everyone knew about Muhammad with a different name (descriptive name of his characters). He was a shining star to all of them. They met him even before his actual physical creation. In one YT channel claim (with evidence) that the name of prophet Muhammad was also mentioned in Hindu scripture. Alhamdulillah!! No doubt that Ishmael was Muhammad.
Salaamun alaykum. Again, an amazing segment. I am unable to express multitude of feelings, that mixture of joy, shock, anger...especially towards end of the presentation where certain intentions have been exposed...many historical events now are being put into perspective...this is huge...
Thank you Dr Hany for another eye opening discourse, I thought a while back why Allah chose this time for bringing me to this Earth, and the connection with this channel gives me the answer, Allah chooses the best for each of his creations, and there could have been no better time to come to age than this time when the 'hoors' of the Quran are being unravelled. I love you Dr Hany!
I have heard this lecture from start to end twice and rewind in several parts numerous times to ensure that i understood what dr. Hany wants to convey about Ismael. I came to this channel only less than a month ago and i found that most of the expositions made by dr. Hany are fresh and mind provoking. I have long been the proponent and advocate that quran is the most superior above any scriptures, collection of stories, narratives about prophets of god or records of histories about famous peoples or events. Therefore i concur with dr. Hany that quran does not need other external sources to explain itself. In certain subjects the quran has straight forward message and simple statements to be followed whereas in some others the raw statements of the quran need to be studied, pondered, researched, explored and confirmed by knowledge and discoveries acquired and unvealed through various human methods, endeavours, observations, explorations and scrutinies. The expositions resulting from researches and analyses of the ayaats in the Quran maybe viewed as conclusive and satisfactory at certain times while other ayaats will remain as raw and prestine statements yet to be discovered but remain pure and preserved in its original and alive language. Quran is alive, therefore it will continue to guide those who sincerely strive to explore and seek the truth. As far as subject of Ismael is concerned, narratives about him, his parents and family lineage in other scriptures aside, about him as mentioned in the quran is to be taken as a prophet that existed between the time of prophethood of Ibrahim a.s. to the time of a final messenger Muhammad s.a.w. Whether or not he is the same person as prophet Muhammad s.a.w is not an issue or relevant anymore during our time because even if Ismael himself was a rasool and nabi, Muhammad s.a.w has clearly superceeded him as a final messenger of God. As we do not need to explore and follow the teachings of Musa a.s. in the Torah, we also need not explore, dig and follow the teachings of Ismael, even if he is not same as Muhammad because we have already guidance given by Allah through prophet Muhammad s.a.w. with us. To conclude i think we just let Ismael be Ismael and Muhammad be Muhammad. But we all agree that Muhammad s.a.w is the seal of the prophets, period! Lets move on.
@ Zahari Man IS THIS HOW YOU WANT PEOPLE SUFFERING FROM EXISTENTIAL CRISES (BECAUSE OF THE IRREFUTABILITY OF THE QURANIC EVIDENCE PRESENTED IN THIS VIDEO SEGMENT) TO DEAL WITH THIS DISCLOSURE? WE PRESENTED IRREFUTABLE EVIDENCE THAT IS WORLDVIEW-SHATTERING TO THEM, AND YOU ARE DISMISSING IT AS "not an issue or relevant anymore"? Regards
UNLESS you are Zahari Man PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT! UNLESS you are Zahari Man, your replies IT WILL BE DELETED.
@@mohammadsalman57 Bro Mohamad Salman.. سلام عليكم، What dr. Hany tries to point out is how erroneous are the interpretations of MOST of the religious scholars because they relied on corrupted sources outside the quran, i.e. the earlier scriptures and collection of canonised hadiths about prophet muhammad s.a.w. On this point we have to agree with him because all these sources, torah, injeel and hadiths were not written down until few hundred or perhaps thousand years after the main characters(moses, jesus and muhammad p.b.u.them all) passed away. The interpretations based on these sources could deviate from original message in the quran since human emotions and considerations(political or worldly interests) could creep in. But interpretations based on internal references of different verses in the quran could also resulted in different conclusions. The contemprary scholars who are spiritually inclined tend to treat the raw statements in the quran as parables or methaphores of highest degree whereas scholars who are logically and intelectually inclined would view the raw statements in the quran as a reflection of a supreme intelligent God. God's words to them are the advanced hints of reality, i.e. physical and metaphysics realm. To a spiritually inclined scholars the skies(السماوات) means layers or levels of devine knowledge and the means of acquiring this knowledge is through meditation and mental intuition. Whereas to the scientists, the skies(السماوات) mean the layers of electromagnetic energy or lightwaves of infinite ranges that occupy the entire spherical universe based on observable evidence through the use of sophisticated tools and equipments developed by God-given human intellect. Now back to the issue whether Ismael is Muhammad s.a.w? Based on evidence from the Quran, prophets Ibrahim, Ismael, Ishaq and Ya'qub and their followers belong to passed ummah; i want to term it as first ummah. This ummah ended with the passing of Ya'qub a.s. They were neither jews nor christians. I believe that Ismael lived in the first ummah era. The second ummah was those that came after Ya'qub; they were followers of Moses and Jesus: they were muslims then but now are reduced to al-yahud and an-nasara. Although they inherited corrupted teachings of Torah and Injeel, they exist until today. The third and final ummah is the followers of the final messenger and nabi, Muhammad s.a.w. Al-Baqarah 2:140 أَمْ تَقُولُونَ إِنَّ إِبْرَٰهِيم وَإِسْمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَٰقَ وَيَعْقُوبَ وَٱلْأَسْبَاطَ كَانُوا۟ هُودًا أَوْ نَصَٰرَىٰۗ قُلْ ءَأَنتُمْ أَعْلَمُ أَمِ ٱللَّهُۗ وَمَنْ أَظْلَمُ مِمَّن كَتَمَ شَهَٰدَةً عِندَهُۥ مِنَ ٱللَّهِۗ وَمَا ٱللَّهُ بغافل عما تعملون. Or are you saying that Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, and the descendants were Jews or Christians?’ Say, ‘Who knows better: you or God? Who could be more wicked than those who hide a testimony from God? God is not unaware of what you do.’ Al-Baqarah 2:141 تِلْكَ أُمَّةٌ قَدْ خَلَتْۖ لَهَا مَا كَسَبَتْ وَلَكُم مَّا كَسَبْتُمْۖ وَلَا تُسْـَٔلُونَ عَمَّا كَانُوا۟ يَعْمَلُونَ That is a nation which has passed. To it is what it strived, and to you will be what you strive. And you will not be asked about what they did.
Are you denying the revelations of ALLAH SWT AL-QURAN .if Dr Hany is right the whole ummah have been lied upon for 1400yrs and personally i believe Dr Hany is speaking the truth.
سلم عليكم ماشاءالله For lack of a better term, this segment made me feel like my whole 60 years life’s knowledge of Islam is now completely uprooted, while feeling goosebumps and shiver all over. This uprooting slowly happened since discovering this channel by chance 6 months ago. Tonight, this segment did it i.e. completely pulled the roots out of the ground. It has made me think that there’s been a coordinated effort, and not just lack of knowledge or wisdom of earlier scholars, to mislead the Muslim world since the death of our beloved ﷺ. Otherwise, there would have been reports in the tafseers, hadeeth and seerah that our beloved Muhammad ﷺ was Adam, Dhulkarnain, and Ishmael. Wouldn’t it? But this channel has brought good news to us. I like to think that Allahh is answering our prayers: ٱهْدِنَا ٱلصِّرَٰطَ ٱلْمُسْتَقِيمَ صِرَٰطَ ٱلَّذِينَ أَنْعَمْتَ عَلَيْهِمْ غَيْرِ ٱلْمَغْضُوبِ عَلَيْهِمْ وَلَا ٱلضَّآلِّينَ I look forward to more gifts from Dr. Hany Atchan.
That "fatilka ummukum bani maa' as-samaa' " statement really pissed me off. As someone who has watched your videos for sometime, I immediately recognized it as the statement of the ba3udah. The 'your .....' is really telling. Thanks Dr for opening our eyes.
Not only that but the audacity and arrogance. To fabricate a fake person, assign to it a relationship to a whole nation of people, then documenting it.
Alhamdulillah. Shukran for finally heeding to my patient and obvious and pressing question especially in light of your previous episode, asserting that our beloved Nabi Muhammad (saw), is from the lineage of Jacoob(as), Ishaaq(as) and Ebrahim(as). My "pen and paper" has been patiently waiting for the past two weeks. So Alhamdulillah, finally In the post. Very grateful for your patience, time, and unfailing spirit to deliver, Dr. Hany.
Assalamu aleikum Dr Hany, I always look forward to your videos. The joy I feel whenever I see the notification ,I can't express in words all I can say is Alhamdulilah for allowing me to be part of this enlightening journey. May Allah continue guide us and allow you to complete this mission. Now the stories are making sense, although I'm not a native Arabic speaker. Alhamdulilah and thank you Dr Hany. We are with you all the way , insha Allah.
Assalamulaikum.. Alhamdulillah... I would say that we are very lucky to have someone like you Dr. Hany speaking out the truth and not a carbon copy of the past. I respect you sir.. Wassalam
Salamun alaykum..How would Yaqub's sons know about Ismail if Abraham didn't have a son called Ismail and they didn't know there would be a future Ismail {named Muhammad}? Did they have knowledge of the future by mentioning him among the forefathers in their response to Yaqub? Similarly, how would Abraham know to mention Ismail as a future gift from Allah if he didn't have knowledge of the future (coming of Muhammad)? At least it doesn't seem that they had such knowledge of the unseen...
@ gerald etienne Ibrahim made a Duaa, and the angels gave him the glad tidings in Surah 15. This is how Ibrahim knew of Issmail, and Ibrahim taught his followers and children.
I can’t stop watching your videos. I want to learn everything about our Marvellous Quran. Everything you mentioned and showed to us the true meaning of stories which mislead millions of the truth seeking umma. I am so ecstatic and thankful to Allah answered my dua on learning reading understanding the true meaning in translation of the one and only Holy Quran. I have never looked up or read any Hadith at all as I was going to do that after I’ve learned to read the Quran. So now it seems that the Hadith I will be looking up in the near future will be in a different approach and thanks to Allah first of all and to you for bringing these to our attention and the future generation inshaAllah
Assalamuaikom dear brother, Doctor Hany. I took a huge cup of coffee and I've been listening to this video and I am amazed by your logic. This explains why we Muslims are far from being the leaders of this world, we don't even follow the Quran. Jasaka Allahu khairan
To think His Majesty gave Dr hany this knowledge, and not, say for example, Ibn Tamiya, just seems absurd. Islam civilised the world and to think all Muslims were misguided during all that time of scientific endeavour in the Islamic weekend is non sensical. Some of Dr hanys theories make sense but much of it also goes too far. If it truly is new knowledge I wonder why he doesn't go to Al Azhar and promote his queue there!!
Dr Hany this is the first comment I ever put on any youtube video since youtube's inception. This was amazingly deep. I totally agree on your points on what Quran is saying on similarity of Ismael(as) and prophet(saws). However, historically, do we have any indication if Ibrahim(as) has two sons or one? Because, authoritative history is also need to be considered in your scientific method.
This segment really lands a crushing blown on all the superstitious and mythological teachings that has traditionally been handed down to us. I am so grateful to Allah to have coming to contact with this channel your work is really very much appreciated May Allah continue to bless and protect you.
Alhamdoulillah. Wow Dr. Hany! Mashallah. May Allah protect you himself. I got lots of internal questions answered today. I cannot imagine someone with an atom of “fear of Allah” that would say anything negative to you. I’m grateful to Allah for this. Now life is starting to make sense for me. Thank you! I’m very happy today. الله أكبر
Salaamun Alaykum Dr. Hany. While rewatching this video I was revisiting again and again timestamp 19:20 where you clearly said that ayat 2:127 is not talking about Ibhahim AS 'raising the Kaaba'! I think this statement puts so many questions in front of us! My take is- Al-bayt' in the ayat is indicating the followers of Ibrahim AS in the first instance and the followers of our beloved Prophet SWAS in the later instance. Allahhu Alam.
I had always wondered why our beloved prophet was never mentioned by name when Allah mentioned all other prophets. Alhamdulillah this fits perfectly well. JazakAllah Khair!
Dr Hany, you are one of the true geniuses of our time. You are helping to clear many errors that have crept into our Deen and are made to look truthful. Your Kasorti, your Touch stone is the Quran. Ever since a child our late father has inculcated in us that the Quran is the only source of Guidance that we ought to be following. These words are not only from my father, but also stated very, very clearly in the Quran. Some Scholars of Quran like Allama Iqbal, Allama Ghulam Ahmed Pervez, Dr Abdul Wadud and others tried to bring us all back to the Quran. They at their time were called Kaafir! Very sad. Conspiracies Against The Quran is an excellent book by Dr Abdul Wadud. Many hadiths were fabricated by Jews, Persians, Christians and Idol Worshippers! The Quran also testifies to this: Woe to every fabricating imposter. Woe unto those who exchange false hadith for petty gains. There are those who say "we are Muslim " but in their hearts they are not. The above are just some of the verses in the Glorious Quran. Dr Hany, Our Deen has been hijacked for 1400yrs!! We have all been duped by a number 2 version of Islam. I really look forward to you talks and will especially look forward to the ones on SALAT AND ZAKAT. As you rightly say, the majority of so called Muslims are not ready to learn what is the true meaning of Salat and Zakat! " The birds with their wings outspread, know their Salat." A typical Muslim will say, yes, birds pray too!!! Oh my ghosh! What nonsense. Birds, however have been given Divine instinct. Dr Hany, may Allah swt reward you forever for the knowledge you are imparting to us. Please get in touch with Dr Shabir Ahmed USA, OURBEACON.COM who is also like minded. JZK
Alhamdulillah. Truly enlightening! I personally feel even more challenged to take the time to invest in studying and understanding the Quran. May Allah guide all of us.
Verses 6 ayah 46 ( *raw* ) : " Say, "Have you considered:1 if Allah should take away your hearing and your sight and set a seal upon your hearts, which deity other than Allah could bring them [back] to you?" *Look how We diversify2 the verses; then they [still] turn away.* "
Ah hah! I had this problem when ever I go across 19:54~55, "I was thinking about Ishmael(s), He was a Rasul & Nabi, and praises given to him these verses, the only story we here about him is this traditional story, which does not justify Quranic praise about him". I did not see this coming..........Wow........absolutely delighted.
AsSlaam o Alikum! always amazing reveals by you dear Dr. Hani, may Allah SWT rewards you for all the effort you go through, Ameen. My Q. is that what are the meanings of the names, Zul Qarneen and Ismael that these were used instead of the name of our Prophet(PBUH)? What was the relevance of using them in those particular verses?
Everything in the Quran is directed to those who reflect, not to those who rush. Did we think that we shall receive the guidance from Allahh without putting in the hard work that is commensurate with Allahh's reverence?
Al Hamdou Lillah and thanks for your patience and your zakat of received knowledge. i'm so happy to peel, with the help of Allah, the layers of darkness we've been imposed from centuries.
Dear Dr. Hani, Assalamu Alykum, I get your 4 makers but why did Allah SWT use the name Ismael at the beginning of ayat 19:54? Why didn't Allah SWT say Muhammed (saw), as Allah swt says Quran is made simple so you can be guided. I really need an answer to this question as in an another video you have stated Abu Lahab was Firaun. Again why didn't Allah swt state Firaun directly in Surah 111???
Salaamun ALAYKUM, I will join you to carry this message forward INSHA ALLAH. ALHAMDULILAAH, ALLAH is already removing the barrier (hijaab) when reciting / engaging AL QURAAN. and every time I revisit this channel I get new knowledge. I just want to Stay within the Womb not outside of it.
Salam Dr Hany. Surah Ibrahim (14): Verse 39 clearly contradicts what you are proposing. This is the verse where Prophet Ibrahim (a.s.) thanks Allah for granting him Prophet Ismail and Prophet Ishaq in his old age. Prophet Ismail is mentioned first - and as you say, there is a clear intention for every word in the Quran - this means that Prophet Ismail came before Prophet Ishaq and cannot therefore be Prophet Muhammad. This clear verse clearly contradicts your proposition that Prophet Ismail(as) was Prophet Muhammad (saw). In your comments below, you mentioned you have given your answer to this - where in the video have you done so? I watched the video and could not find it. Please provide the time so that I can review it.
In as much as your approach to understanding the Quran is novel and refreshing, you should realise that it is not the only way to do so. Once there lived a man who had an insightful way of looking at the Quran - the number 19 - he was so convinced of his methodology that he published his own Quran and removed 2 verses from the Quran because they did not fit into his methodology. His name is Rashad Khalifa, whom I believe was very intelligent, just as you are. In his eagerness of his methodology towards the Quran, he lost his way and could not see the false state he was in.
So you should be careful Dr Hany that you are not trapped in tunnel vision and believing that only your methodology is the only way. The Most Merciful is all Wise. His book cannot be constrained by just one methodology. His Book is a miracle. So take a step back and ask yourself what you are doing - let not your zeal and success in proposing a methodology to the Quran blind you in seeing the truth. One indicator of this is your claim that all others are wrong and you are right. Are you sure that you alone are right? You got to be careful here.
May Allah guide us all closer to the truth.
@ Muhammad Qalam
Salaamun Alaykum
Thank you for taking the time to write. I thank you for your advice in the third paragraph.
Nevertheless, you missive builds on several assumptions that are not true:
1. You provide Aya 14:39 as a basis for a rule you invented, that a list of names must necessarily mean temporal ordering. This rule is something YOU MADE UP and is clearly not supported in the Quran, as could be easily proven by Aya 4:163, where 3issa is listed before Haaroon, Sulayman and Daawood, etc, even though 3issa came after them. In other words, when we are providing a logical analysis, we need to validate our assumptions before going astray in critiquing and criticizing. DO NOT MAKE UP YOUR OWN RULES AND DO NOT CLAIM THAT THE QURAN MUST FOLLOW YOUR OWN IMAGINARY RULES.
2. You presented Aya 14:39 as a counter-example while failing to note that we have discussed that aya in detail in the video. Please watch the video before dismissing the evidence. IT IS YOUR JOB TO WATCH AND LEARN BEFORE YOU THROW ACCUSATIONS THAT ARE BASELESS.
3. You referred to the so-called methodology of Number 19. Again, this is a farse because the Quran itself, in Aya 74:31 (right after the verse of "19") tells us that that number was only given as a "fitnah" (test or trap) to those who are disbelievers... And therefore, whoever uses numerology based on "19" is clearly unaware of the danger of considering this number, and the warning against applying it "as a methodology"... And therefore, comparing me to Rashad Khalifa is an uninformed comparison, and perhaps even an under-handed attempt to dismiss the seriousness of the organic Quranic methodology I use exclusively on this channel... Furthermore, to even mention the misguided claims of Rashad Khalifa (taking out some verses of the Quran) is a clear attempt to imply that I WOULD EVEN CONSIDER playing loose with the integrity of the Quran... Anyone who has watched any video on this channel knows that I hold the integrity and the cohesiveness of the Quran above all else...
4. You claim that I am "trapped in tunnel vision and believing that only your methodology is the only way. The Most Merciful is all Wise. His book cannot be constrained by just one methodology."... First, I never claimed that it was "my methodology"! I keep stating that it is extracted from the Quran. There is a whole playlist about the methodology... Don't be lazy! Watch it and then you will be in a better position to criticize instead of throwing accusatory labels such as "tunnel vision", "zeal", and blinded"!!! Second: The Quran tells us clearly in Aya 1:6 that there is one Siraat, not many. Siraat is never provided in a plural form in the Quran... Furthermore, in Aya 6:153, Allahh warns us against following multiple ways, and insists that there is only one Siraat. That Siraat is the methodology, as we demonstrated in the segment on Surah Al-Fatiha (YT88) and other segments earlier. To elaborate further, I remind you that when Allahh tells us about the story of Zakariya and Yahya and Maryam and 3issa, as an example, there cannot be multiple ways to the facts in that story. All stories in the Quran follow a similar manner of unique facts that cannot be multiple.
Those who claim that there are multiple WAYS TO INTERPRET THE QURAN ARE ONLY DESPERATE TO DISMISS THE IRREFUTABLE EVIDENCE OUR VIDEO SEGMENTS OFFER, AND ARE ONLY DESPERATE TO DEFEND THEIR ERRONEOUS WAYS AGAINST THE DEVASTATING EFFECT OUR VIDEOS ARE HAVING ON EXPOSING THEIR ERRONEOUS, BASELESS, AND SECTARIAN INTERPRETATIONS!
If you had confidence in the book of Allahh, you would have confidence in the methodology he told us to follow! No apologies are needed in having full confidence and in defending the Siraat of our lord!
Once again, I thank you for writing, and I value these exchanges, but you need to get out of your own tunnel vision, and allow yourself to embrace the truth the Quran and its irrefutable evidence!
(I will keep a copy of this exchange in case it gets deleted by accident!)
Regards
UNLESS YOU ARE Muhammad Qalam...
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
OTHERWISE, IT WILL BE DELETED.
Time Stamps
0:01 Introduction
4:01 In this segment
6:29 The traditional (erroneous) story of Ibrāhīm
10:53 Dissonance in traditional account about IssmāƐīl
25:04 Reminder about the concept of Markings
27:19 Reminder about the principle of intentionality
30:51 Reminder about the meaning of لا إلٰه إلا الله
36:05 Who is IssmāƐīl?
38:43 Primary Evidence (1) 4 exclusive, irrefutable markings
47:07 Primary Evidence (2) --- the messenger who is a prophet
I:02:02 Primary Evidence (3) --- Supplication of Ibrāhīm
1:09:21 Primary Evidence (4) --- Separating two subjects of one verb
1:09:50 Secondary evidence (1) --- Present vs Past tense
1:13:37 Secondary evidence (2) --- Why was Muhammad not mentioned in the list of prophets
11:14:54 Verifying our conclusions (1)
1:20:47 Verifying our conclusions (2)
1:24:05 Verifying our conclusions (3)
1:30:29 Verifying our conclusions (4)
1:32:54 Verifying our conclusions (5)
1:34:52 Verifying our conclusions (6)
1:55:44 Debunking the traditional story of Hājar (or Hāgar)
2:05:28 What about As-Ṣafā and Al-Marwā in HAjj?
2:07:22 Is it true that IssmāƐīl is “ghulām Ḥalīm” whereas Iss-Ḥāq is “ghulām Ɛalīm”?
2:07:45 Summary so far
2:09:04 4 beautiful gifts
2:21:10 What are the implications of all of this?
2:27:19 A severe warning from Allahh to those who do not make amend
2:29:19 What to do with this information?
thank you brother may allah rewarded your contribution that benefit us with your effort
Nice!
Nice we really need a timestamps guy here please do this to future segments too
Dr Hany, can you please add this index to the video description, it will immensely help the listeners as they listen to this again and again.
Thank you very much. Uploaded.
Keep it up Dr. Hani. It is an extremely important service you are rendering to the mankind not just Muslims. I salute you with the core of my heart and accept you the marvelous tutor of this century. May Almighty bless you and us the followers of your channel with great Hidaya. Lets be among the Mutaqeen, Alhaqa and Saliheen etc. Keep it up Dr. Hani i never want to stop listening your channel, I wish everyone on earth benefits from this great revelations of unravelling the scripture done so with delayed diligent understanding - Alakhira. The fresh spring water has now started flowing to our Kursi from Al-Arsh. Jazak Allah! I wish I was an Arabic native unfortunately I am not but I believe I am among the blessed ones that is why I am with you. Insha Allah Taallah!
Wow, it’s like learning how to walk all over again, but this time every step is pleasurable, all praises be to our Lord, the Almighty, the one who provides linguistic discernment
Alhumdulilla! I am feeling so blessed and thankful to Allahh swt for teaching us the correct knowledge of Quran.
Thank so much! Dr. Hany, for your hard work and dedication
Alhamdulillah
I have been super busy lately, now continuing back again from here. Watched the whole segment. Amazing, no more comments.
If a genuinely say, learning Qur'an from your videos is the best part of my day well spent.
Awesome!!!!
I did not understand when it is crystal clear.
Ibrahim - Verse 39
ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَـٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَـٰقَ ۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ
All praise is for Allah who has blessed me with Ishmael and Isaac in my old age. My Lord is indeed the Hearer of ˹all˺ prayers.
As of last week, I been practising the replacing of Allahuma with Rabbana or Rabbi. So have a few of my charges and apprentices after I told them the reasons why.
I embraced Islam in early 1980, at age 18, travelled the world since deciding leaving school in search of Allah's path, has always been learning and enjoying the journey.
Alhamdullilah, Alhamdullilah irrabeel Alameen .. i stand with your teachings brother..I’m angry with the false narratives ..
Dr Hanny, what about this verse? 14:39
ٱلۡحَمۡدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِي وَهَبَ لِي عَلَى ٱلۡكِبَرِ إِسۡمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسۡحَٰقَۚ إِنَّ رَبِّي لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ
Praise be to God, who has granted me Ismail and Ishaq in my old age: my Lord hears all requests!
-Surah Ibrahim, 39
I am tearing in joy.
For so long time, for the past 6 years during my journey with the Quran, I came with the fact how could our people be easily misguided with so call our scholars?
How could Muslims claim that the Quran is their primary source but in reality, they give more attention and preach extraneous sources? Despite their claims that the Quran is perfect and clear?
And inventing extra Quranic teaching?
So, since that, I disposed of all teaching that had never been approved by Quran, because it does not make any sense, and since that I found my life become more easily, happy and enjoying the freedom of not being in the shackle of religious authority.
I rely on Allah only.
I praise Allah that I finally found this channel that gives me more energy to follow “this forgotten path” and thanks to you, Dr. Hany and I am by your side, ready to become a witness
Alhamdulillah
Gentleman, thank you..., We expect more from you, now that you began to lift this veil, stop not. Your language is clear and eloquent. We remain eager to hear more and more. Thank you, again. May Allah grant you more knowledge to explain it to those who are indeed in need for it.
Alhamdulilaah, I am a witness to this cause, and I am grateful to ALLAH for opening doors that we least expected as this knowledge has never been known to me nor to the ummah till to this day. This only goes to show how ALLAH is extremely merciful and yet some of us are refusing to accept .... oh people think twice and think again and ask questions that lead you to ALLAH only
Alhamdulillah
Thanks a lot. I am behind you. Am learning afresh. I emptied my cup. It is a tough journey. At the time our Muslim Arab brethren is undergoing a tough transition, this is a good time to reflect and open our hearts and purify our Deen from such corruptionn
“Noor” upon “Noor”.
May Allah bless you Dr Hany.
Salaamun Alaikum
Al Hamdu Lillah
After soaking everything in from this segment all I can say to all those who choose to refute; the description of Isma'eel(SAW) is given in Surah 19:54/5 now choose your rejection carefully, if as your flock choose to believe the corrupted sources and still claim Isma'eel(SAW) is the direct son or 1st son of Prophet Ebrahim(AS), Allah is giving his description in the above mentioned Surah as a Messenger and Prophet. With that in mind my question to the refutes and their flock is as a Messenger what was his message/scripture that he was tasked to deliver?
May Allah guide everyone to better understanding.
To Dr Hany and team keep up the great work you guys are doing. I thank Allah for revealing this knowledge to us through you guys. May Allah bless you guys and your families in this world and the next.
Alhamdulillah
Al Hamdulillah
Please read surah 2:136,surah 3:84,surah 4:163.(there is also ishaq as brother whom allah sent his revealation) plz dont be in hurry.and i also know that allah mentioned ismael as a messenger and prophet but plz read surah 19:51 to 19:59.
My question is to dr hany why allah swt separately mentioned that we revealed to you means muhammad saw and then ibrahim and ismael.
And its 3 times.
What about the reply of yaqub sons?
i am not in hurry to accept these interpretation instantly so i will take my time and i request all of the viewers of dr hany plz dont put the eyes only on the crow but also on your ears.
It's funny how extraneous info coming from the Judeo-biblical sources there is always a sterile wife/ woman. This imported theme occurred multiple times in traditional books (taken from the corrupted Torah).
Hamdulillah for this clarification.
Alhamdulillah, it open up alot of my confusions developed by the erroneous traditional stories.. thank you Dr
Salaamun Alaykum to all, Alhamdulillah
Salaamun Alaykum, Dr. Hany,
I have two points of confusion regarding this video. I may be mistaken, but I noticed that some of the concepts presented earlier were not consistent with the information provided in this video. For example, at TS 52:04, you mentioned two scriptures, the Torah and Injeel, which were not yet revealed at the time of Moses. However, I have learned from your other lectures that Injeel is not a scripture but refers to Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Additionally, at TS 1:14:18, Eisa was mentioned as one of the prophets who are "Saleheen," but I understand that Eisa was unable to complete his prophetic mission according to divine commands and thus returned as FQ. Could you please provide clarification on these points?
Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Good observation. In earlier segments we presented simplifications in order to avoid too many disclosures at once, to make it easier for people to understand. But later, we provided additional clarifications regarding the Injeel. Yes! The Injeel is NOT a scripture.
I am committed to standing up for Allah against those who corrupted our Deen (and continue to do so today). I will continue to toil on the Quran (alone) and qualify myself to be a firm defender of "The Truth". Praise to Allah who have guided us this and we were never to be guided if not for His direct Guidance............
Marvelous, Alhamdulillah. This 2.5hrs will keep us busy till the next one InsyaAllah. Thank you Dr Hany. Forever indebted.
Yes indeed, this two n half hour segment will keep us busy and demand our focus because we need to critically analyse the traditional translation/interpretation Vs versus what is exposed by dr. Hany...am glad this far that dr. Hany does not reject the hadiths completely but selectively accepted some of them valid as and when they are qualified by the quran...
Also the literal meaning of some of the words in the quran as traditionally translated by the obvious practical usage like الارض to mean 'the scripture'(by dr. Hany) Vs 'the land'(as traditionally translated)...
both meanings have their relevance depending whether they are to be taken as methaphor or as physical things in real life......
Salaamun Alaikum, I had difficulties with this segment ever since it was released months ago, but Alhamdulillah, starting from the understanding of the meaning of Al bait and Kaanu, it is clearer, mashaallah. Jazakallah u khairan kathiran
WOWWWW.... Alhamdolillah, Beautiful... an eye opener...
May Allah lift more "clouds" form our vision/sight and take us closer to his path, as it is said "you take one step towards him he will come ten steps closer towards you"
Thank you Dr Hany and keep up the great work you are doing to awaken the sleeping UMMAH...
The people will say a lot many bad things about you but dont be disheartened... it was done before too... to those who struggeled in the way of Allah
Oh Allah!! Our Lord, Our Sustainer.. Please guide us to the straight path which leads to you, and have mercy on us and join us with those who would be successful on the day of judgment... Aamin.
Assalamu'alaikum Dr Hany. Jazakallahu Khairan for your latest segment on Ishmael. Another surprised and revealing subject. Everything happens for a reason as to our own creation. The timing of it also matters & at Allahh's will. Everyone has his or her own timeline. As for me I don't really study the Qur'an in much detail until my later years for many reasons.
Frankly, I do not regretted it because I found a channel that able to explain not only the contents but also provides the methodology in doing the tafsir. I thank Allah for in a way I am not corrupted or misguided by previous translations and interpretations but more importantly I'm able to learn and engage the Qur'an in a more guided way (due the methodology) together with you and the rest that watch this channel.
This latest segment (video) reaffirmed that labels, terms or names are important in the process of trying to get to know something or someone. We just cannot know something in depth by just a single identifier or name. That's the reason Allah have many names or 'attributes'. It helps to condense or summarize a long explanation or description or wordy sentences so that we can easily remember.
Carry on with the good & important work Dr Hany.
May Allah continue to guide and protect you.
Alhamdulillah
As salam alaikoum,
What about the 39 ayat of surat Ibrahim?
Because in this Ayat Ibrahim AS praise Allah for giving him at an old age Ismail and Ishaq...
Very clear
???!!!!????
Allhumdulilah, I got the message Dr. Hany, the more I watch your lecturers the more I see you are logical with your evidence and some of the people that are committing are clearly as the Quran said in surah (34:43)
Ibrahim 14:39
ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَٰقَۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ
Praise to Allah, who has granted to me in old age Ishmael and Isaac. Indeed, my Lord is the Hearer of supplication.
Shukran for your sincere love
You are truly guided by the spirit
You are with Allah
Issma3l is no other than our Beloved Muahmmed SAW. This segment brought joy to my heart. We stand with the evidence based knowledge in the Quran alone. AlhamduLillah!!!
Isma3il is a descriptor for our beloved SAWS. There is no individual named Isma3il at the time to Ibrahim
I has been follow this channel for few month and keep revisit previous video while waiting for new one. No word to express joy except 'Alhamdullillah' . I will definitely follow Al Quran with promise evident rather follow them as 'mindunillah. Thank you Dr.Hany.
I'm really appreciate your education, i was always sceptical about the comparison off the corrupted Torah to the true Al'quraan . What always bothered me was the opening verses of surah Baqrah .." this is a book in which is NO doubt " . I thank almighty Allah for guiding me to you.
Alhamdulillah
In some Ayas the mention of prophets appears chronological, in other places not. Is there anything to this observation?
Brother this man is leading people astray, or Deen is protected our thiker* which is rememberance has been preserved. If you deny the authentic ahadeeth you deny your prayers your zakat your hajj and your umra, you deny every facit of your Deen.
Anyone can think themselves above the Prophet peace be upon him but Allah choose him and preserved everything with a prestine miraculous science. We have a direct chain to the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him.
Ask a scholar, do your own research Don't rely on this man's misguided babble.
Salamum alikum, I will be honest at first i was extremely shocked and in disbelief about the term Allahhummah, but after your second video about the common questions i have submitted to to the Quranic evidence. Thank you for opening my eyes
معاذ الله
Did Prophet Miss This Point And Fail to teach His Sahaba??
Or This So Called Dr Atchan Is more Knowledgeable Out of Nowhere ??
May ALLAH Protect us From these kind of Dajjal Deceiver.
قُلِ ٱللَّهُمَّ مَٰلِكَ ٱلْمُلْكِ تُؤْتِى ٱلْمُلْكَ مَن تَشَآءُ وَتَنزِعُ ٱلْمُلْكَ مِمَّن تَشَآءُ وَتُعِزُّ مَن تَشَآءُ وَتُذِلُّ مَن تَشَآءُ ۖ بِيَدِكَ ٱلْخَيْرُ ۖ إِنَّكَ عَلَىٰ كُلِّ شَىْءٍ قَدِيرٌ
Invoke (O dear Prophet Mohammed - peace and blessings be upon him), “O Allah! Owner Of The Kingdom - You bestow the kingdom on whomever You will, and You take back the kingdom from whomever You will; and You give honour to whomever You will, and You humiliate whomever You will; only in Your hand lies all goodness; indeed, You are Able to do all things.”
3-Al Imran : 26
قَالَ عِيسَى ٱبْنُ مَرْيَمَ ٱللَّهُمَّ رَبَّنَآ أَنزِلْ عَلَيْنَا مَآئِدَةً مِّنَ ٱلسَّمَآءِ تَكُونُ لَنَا عِيدًا لِّأَوَّلِنَا وَءَاخِرِنَا وَءَايَةً مِّنكَ ۖ وَٱرْزُقْنَا وَأَنتَ خَيْرُ ٱلرَّٰزِقِينَ
Eisa, the son of Maryam, said, “O Allah, O our Lord! Send down to us a table spread from heaven, so that it may become a day of celebration for us - for our former and latter people - and a sign from You; and give us sustenance - and You are the Best Provider Of Sustenance.”
5-Al-Ma'ida : 114
قُلِ ٱللَّهُمَّ فَاطِرَ ٱلسَّمَٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ عَٰلِمَ ٱلْغَيْبِ وَٱلشَّهَٰدَةِ أَنتَ تَحْكُمُ بَيْنَ عِبَادِكَ فِى مَا كَانُوا۟ فِيهِ يَخْتَلِفُونَ
Invoke (O dear Prophet Mohammed - peace and blessings be upon him), “O Allah! The Creator of the heavens and the earth, the All Knowing of all the hidden and the open, You will judge between Your bondmen, regarding the matters in which they differed.”
39-Az-Zumar : 46
QUL ALLAHUMMA - Means ALLAH COMMAND TO SAY ALLAHUMMA..
Also ALLAH Coded Dua of Hazrat Esa With ALLAHUMMA.
@@muhammadqadri7631 Salam Brother Muhammad Qadri, I hope you and your family are in good health, and Allah provides you with tremendous blessings and peace. I pray that Allah grants you the highest levels of Jannah.
Of course our beloved prophet Muhammad, and a lot of the Sahaba understood the truth, and knew the Quran because they were taught the divine lexicon. The prophet Muhammad knew exactly what the Quran was teaching. Dr Hany is not questioning that.
The question is, did the information about the understanding and interpretation of the Quran (the Quranic lexicon) reach us through the Sahaba? The answer is no. You see the Hadith are constructed and collected by humans, there will be mistakes in it. In fact there are many contractions in bukari. You will never find that in the Quran. Thus, for our religion we can not rely 1000% on the hadith. We need to rely 1000% on the Quran. If the Quran claims one thing and the Hadith claims another, we take the Hadith and chuck it out. So why not use the Quran to discover the Quranic lexicon, just like they did with hieroglyphics.
Now we must also understand the political climate at the time when these Hadith, Sira and Commentary of the Quran were written, Please listen to Dr Hany in this video with an open mind: th-cam.com/video/iJP1_vxBZh8/w-d-xo.html.
Tell me this, what happens when a person in China speaks against China? or a person in North Korea speaks against the status Quo. Their head would be chopped off. If you challenge the state similar things happen to you if you lived in the umayyid or abbasi period. That is why there is a lot of corruption. The corruption was added in to our commentary, narrations and more.
The Quran says it explains all thing (Verse (16:89)). So why not let the Quran explain the Quran. Why should we let the Bible explain the Quran? Or other corrupted stories.
Regardless knowledge does not come from just reading the quran, or reading the translation, or listening to Dr Hany. Knowledge only comes when Allah Allows knowledge to be given. So we must pray to Allah, to allow us to understand his religion they way he intended.
I would encourage you to watch this video, with the mind set of "I know nothing, let me have an empty cup of knowledge" th-cam.com/video/iJP1_vxBZh8/w-d-xo.html. After that if you have any questions, Dr hany is more than happy to answer. But please do yourself justice, and think with an open mind. Remember at the time of all Muhammad, please use to say the same thing "Why should i follow you when our forefathers have taught us this" If we had this mindset at the time of the prophet we might off been kufaars. Of course Dr Hany is not a prophet and can and will and has made mistakes, but the path to knowledge is to have an open cup and allow yourself to make mistakes.
We are not saying Dr Hany is coming up with new knowledge, we are saying this is what the Quran is really saying, our beloved Muhammad understood it this way as well as well as the sahaba that Allah chose to teach, but then this knowledge was corrupted and did not reach us.
Again I wish you the very best, I hope you and your family are safe, healthy and live a long and healthy life. Please make dua for me as well.
@@IaKhanic OH Here After 1400 Years ALLAH عزوجل gave Opportunity to Be on Truth And Led Ummah be Misguided for 1400 years As If there were No Awaliya Allah Or Mujaddid For 1400 years..
Every coming days Your Hany comes with new claim Now Prophet Ishmael is none other than Prophet MUHAMMAD
صلى الله عليه و سلم
Keep your Bloody Shit Upon You and your Dr Hany. I Know Your Framework Upon TH-cam With Paid Comments And Likers Of Your Dajjali Agenda..
@@muhammadqadri7631 Dear Brother please watch his video on Allahummah, he answers all your questions there.
Quran 39 :46 has been answered here: th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html
Quran 3 : 26 has been answered here: th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html
Quran 5: 114 has been answered here : th-cam.com/video/tyI1QKJgrSs/w-d-xo.html
Please do try and watch the entire video. Jazak Allah Khair
@@muhammadqadri7631 Brother I am a muslim and I promise that I am not a paid commenter. If im not mistaken the concept of a Muhaddid only comes from hadith, and not the Quran. Please correct me if i am mistaken.
Also brother you and I both know that it is not wise to call names, please remember only Allah knows what the truth is. What IF Dr Hany is right? Now you will be accountable to Allah on the day of judgment. You can have a difference of opinion, and we can discuss it in a civil manner. Please practice kindness and patience as Allah has prescribed to us.
Is this what you want to show the rest of the world? That muslims start in fighting when a researcher provides something that you personally do not believe in? Sir, if you don't wish to change your view point that is up to you. Fighting is beneath us. I invite you to be brothers with a difference in opinion, instead of two brother fighting.
AsSalamunAlaikum,
you didn't explain 14:39 clearly.
How come Ibraheem praise God for Ismael before even Ismael born [according to you].
What about surah [37]: 99-113 which narrated the dialogue between Ibrahim & Ismail about the qurban background?
Alhamdulillah Rabbila"laamin
yes Dr. Hany, we are standing with you ; we shall defend this book as much as we can.
My head and my heart stop paining since I started listening your teaching.ALHAMDULLILAH
Subhanallah
Stunning details.
The reason why no Muslim scholar objected these stories is they all are trained on following human sayings blindly without questioning.
Infact in scientific terms these are stupid illiterates blind followers who don’t look for evidence . How can one expect they have any intellectual capabilities. It has taken me some time and visiting 3 times to understand parts of this segment.
I have seen many of these scholars in my life who when questioned say to me I have become kafir and that is their intellectual level. When these people are given full authorities they issue fatwas on their own any their blind followers accept. Perfect example of mindoonillah
The Qur'an is not here to shackle our every thought, restrict our every movement and fill our lives with an inexhaustible list of do's and dont's.
The Qur'an is here to elevate our existence, to illuminate our consciousness, to enlighten our awareness and to purify our cores
If we only just LISTEN and submit ourself, submit our being, submit our very essence to Allah alone.
Our Lord, allow us to HEAR and obey, our Lord, allow us to submit wholeheartedly to you alone.
Our Lord, count us among the Dhurreeya of your blessed prophets and messengers.
Alhamdulillahi... The very evidence that gave me shivers was "iqtadih"... Allahu Akbar! It suffices alone, beyond all!
Couldn't retain my tears, when I recalled the first teachings of tafseer al Quran I received back in early 2000... Allahu Akbar...
I say Alhamdulillah again, for having allowed Dr. Hani discover this concept, and fed him the willing so that he can share with us! Alhamdulillahi.
I believe this is not happening by accident, Allah SWT rather wanted us to be fortunate to live in this moment in time... So we can understand from Dr. Hani and we then share, in turn!
Allahh is testing us. Alhamdulillah
Insha Allahh we will pass the test, and remain connected to Allahh alone, guided by his words alone.
I love when you get excited!
Gets me every time.
Incredible video so far as always!
Sir in 6:89 when An Nubuwah is mentioned and you have translated it as ways of Prophethood? Can you plz put light if this is different than assigning the Prophethood?
I a m the first to support you in your explanation based on Quran evidence!
Keep it up Allah bless you and those who appreciate your work including my self.
AssalamAlaikoum Dr i am not trying to challenge you,but i am so confuse,i need some clarification about thoses questions:
If the word Allahuma is not correct or not good to say why it is mentioned in the coran example in sourat 3:26
If ismael=Muhammad what is about sourat 47 ?name sourat Muhammad not ismael?
Sourat 47:2Muhammad is clear mentionned there why? not Ismael there so on.
Please answer.
Plz watch the full video before you ask questions.
I watch the full video before asking.plz just give me your opinion on my question
@@drikkona actually this segment starts with a question and end up with evidences from your lord, the author presented the quranic evidences in sequence and much more will be presented in next segment. Patience will always be rewarded.
we will clean up our deen and im with you fully
Do we forget the greatest Hadeeth that we have?
Where each word is beyond doubt and the veracity of each word beyond reproach. Where each word is authentic and each word is GUARANTEED to have been uttered by the tongue of our beloved Rasool (saw). Where each word was passed onto us verbatim in his role that was protected by Allah from any deviations or mistakes.
Allah has caused US to inherit that Hadeeth just as he will cause others to inherit it after us.
So, do we rely on the hadeeths of people or do we rely on the best of hadeeths...Al Qur'an?
Our Lord guide us to your good pleasure, Our Lord guide us ever closer to you.
Alhamdulillah
Alhamdhulillah for this segment Dr.Hany.... I'm pretty sure there's more to all what was taught to us . I'm glad to witness this truth. May Allah be with all of us at all times.
Salamun Alaikum Dr,
I was trying to find this aya 14:39 as you have mentioned in the following "Pinned" comment but it is not there. I really request you to provide the translation of the aya 14:39 please. Jazak Allah Khairun
Alhamdulilahh. Allahh have shown His mercy and guidance by leading me to these information. Honestly I was not really shocked about these revelation because I already have a strong scepticism about the stories since my youth and subhan Allahh, this segment really relieve me from the unnecessary guilty concious. I receive your message Dr Hany and I am all in, Insya Allahh.
Alhamdulillah
Brother this man is leading people astray, or Deen is protected our thiker* which is rememberance has been preserved. If you deny the authentic ahadeeth you deny your prayers your zakat your hajj and your umra, you deny every facit of your Deen.
Anyone can think themselves above the Prophet peace be upon him but Allah choose him and preserved everything with a prestine miraculous science. We have a direct chain to the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him.
Ask a scholar, do your own research Don't rely on this man's misguided babble.
@@GRayfoxasd dear brother, please watch prior segments (in correct sequence) before making any comment.
The ayaat of surah Ibrahim 14:35 to 14:41, narrate Ibrahim (a.s) supplicating;
14:35
And when Ibrahim said: My Lord! make this city secure, and save me and my sons from worshipping idols:
His supplication goes thru to ayaat 14:39 onwards to 14:41
14:39
الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ الَّذِي وَهَبَ لِي عَلَى الْكِبَرِ إِسْمَاعِيلَ وَإِسْحَاقَ إِنَّ رَبِّي لَسَمِيعُ الدُّعَاءِ
Praise be to Allah, Who has given me in old age Ismail and Ishaq; most surely my Lord is the Hearer of prayer:
In the above ayah 14:39, following through from ayaat 14:35 to 14:41, “me” would invariably refer to Ibrahim, that Allah gave (وَهَبَ) Isma’il and Ishaq to Ibrahim upon old age (عَلَى الْكِبَرِ). This ayah records a past event (“gave”) during the lifetime of Ibrahim (“in old age”) that connected him with Isma’il and Ishaq in the same time frame. As such, according to this ayah of the Quran (by my understanding), Isma’il had lived within the same general time period as Ibrahim and Ishaq.
Then there is surah Aali Imran ayah 3:65;
يَا أَهْلَ الْكِتَابِ لِمَ تُحَاجُّونَ فِي إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَمَا أُنزِلَتِ التَّوْرَاةُ وَالْإِنجِيلُ إِلَّا مِن بَعْدِهِ أَفَلَا تَعْقِلُونَ
O followers of the Book! why do you dispute about Ibrahim, when the Taurat and the Injeel were not revealed till after him; do you not then understand?
Ayah 3:65 states that the Taurat and Injil were revealed after him (بَعْدِهِ) namely, Ibrahim. We know that the Quran was revealed after the Taurat and Injil. Historically, the time difference between the Quran and the Injil is at least greater than 600 years and even greater when compared to the Taurat. That would put Ibrahim (as) and Muhammad (pbuh) very distant in time relative to each other. When ayah 14:39 is considered, it means that the situation between Isma’il (as) and Muhammad (pbuh) was also the same.
How then does one reconcile your proposition with ayaat 14:39 and 3:65, which when read together, seem to be clearly pointing to Isma’il (as) and our Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) living in different times?
Or is there another understanding to these ayaat?
We answered all these issues in the video.
Did you even watch the video?
Yes..I was angry along time..as early as 24 years old....just was uncomfortable with these stories reported well after the passing of nabi S.A.W. Shukran Dr Hani...As a woman I thought this was way uncomfortable...I am so happy that my thinking was correct...the Quraan does not relate such stories..it's too pure for that
Salaamun alykum Dr. Hany. From surrah abbasa and till now so many tears and joy ( Fruits within Qurran ). Jazakallah.
curious to this syeikh on why he goes to the extent if the Quran already mention Ismael is the son of Ibrahim as it is clearly crystal clear.
Ibrahim - Verse 39
ٱلْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ ٱلَّذِى وَهَبَ لِى عَلَى ٱلْكِبَرِ إِسْمَـٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَـٰقَ ۚ إِنَّ رَبِّى لَسَمِيعُ ٱلدُّعَآءِ
All praise is for Allah who has blessed me with Ishmael and Isaac in my old age. My Lord is indeed the Hearer of ˹all˺ prayers.
Watch the video. We already answered this question!
Why surah al baqarah verse no. 133 the ayat/ayah put 'and ismail and ishak' together. Also verse 136. TQ
Dr Hany, I will stand up with you, on the side of Quranic teaching. I apologies deeply for all the hateful messages, but please know that you are not alone. We are with you and in support of your incredible research. This segment was mind blowing and I will have to re-watch it a few times to understand. May Allah guide me and other muslims that have been stuck in this lies for the past 1400 years
I bear witness that i see the light. May Allah bless you always Dr Hany.
Salaamun Alaykum Dr, Hany. This is my second time watching this presentation. This is beautiful. I wish I could express my feelings and joy with proper words. This revelation is only going to elevate our status as Muslims. In my childhood, I heard a story about Muhammad sw that he was Allahh's (SWT) first creation. Allahh made him as a star. Now it makes much more sense. Allahh (SWT) informed the coming of Muhammad to every single prophet and messenger and in every scripture. From Ibrahim to Isa and in between, everyone knew about Muhammad with a different name (descriptive name of his characters). He was a shining star to all of them. They met him even before his actual physical creation. In one YT channel claim (with evidence) that the name of prophet Muhammad was also mentioned in Hindu scripture. Alhamdulillah!! No doubt that Ishmael was Muhammad.
Thank you so much for your dedication to discovering these truths and then sharing them.
Jazakallahu Khairan
Salaamun alaykum. Again, an amazing segment. I am unable to express multitude of feelings, that mixture of joy, shock, anger...especially towards end of the presentation where certain intentions have been exposed...many historical events now are being put into perspective...this is huge...
Thank you Dr Hany for another eye opening discourse, I thought a while back why Allah chose this time for bringing me to this Earth, and the connection with this channel gives me the answer, Allah chooses the best for each of his creations, and there could have been no better time to come to age than this time when the 'hoors' of the Quran are being unravelled.
I love you Dr Hany!
I have heard this lecture from start to end twice and rewind in several parts numerous times to ensure that i understood what dr. Hany wants to convey about Ismael.
I came to this channel only less than a month ago and i found that most of the expositions made by dr. Hany are fresh and mind provoking.
I have long been the proponent and advocate that quran is the most superior above any scriptures, collection of stories, narratives about prophets of god or records of histories about famous peoples or events.
Therefore i concur with dr. Hany that quran does not need other external sources to explain itself.
In certain subjects the quran has straight forward message and simple statements to be followed whereas in some others the raw statements of the quran need to be studied, pondered, researched, explored and confirmed by knowledge and discoveries acquired and unvealed through various human methods, endeavours, observations, explorations and scrutinies.
The expositions resulting from researches and analyses of the ayaats in the Quran maybe viewed as conclusive and satisfactory at certain times while other ayaats will remain as raw and prestine statements yet to be discovered but remain pure and preserved in its original and alive language.
Quran is alive, therefore it will continue to guide those who sincerely strive to explore and seek the truth.
As far as subject of Ismael is concerned, narratives about him, his parents and family lineage in other scriptures aside, about him as mentioned in the quran is to be taken as a prophet that existed between the time of prophethood of Ibrahim a.s. to the time of a final messenger Muhammad s.a.w.
Whether or not he is the same person as prophet Muhammad s.a.w is not an issue or relevant anymore during our time because even if Ismael himself was a rasool and nabi, Muhammad s.a.w has clearly superceeded him as a final messenger of God. As we do not need to explore and follow the teachings of Musa a.s. in the Torah, we also need not explore, dig and follow the teachings of Ismael, even if he is not same as Muhammad because we have already guidance given by Allah through prophet Muhammad s.a.w. with us.
To conclude i think we just let Ismael be Ismael and Muhammad be Muhammad.
But we all agree that Muhammad s.a.w is the seal of the prophets, period!
Lets move on.
@ Zahari Man
IS THIS HOW YOU WANT PEOPLE SUFFERING FROM EXISTENTIAL CRISES (BECAUSE OF THE IRREFUTABILITY OF THE QURANIC EVIDENCE PRESENTED IN THIS VIDEO SEGMENT) TO DEAL WITH THIS DISCLOSURE?
WE PRESENTED IRREFUTABLE EVIDENCE THAT IS WORLDVIEW-SHATTERING TO THEM, AND YOU ARE DISMISSING IT AS "not an issue or relevant anymore"?
Regards
UNLESS you are Zahari Man
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT!
UNLESS you are Zahari Man, your replies IT WILL BE DELETED.
This is such an underwhelming comment.
@@mohammadsalman57
Bro Mohamad Salman..
سلام عليكم،
What dr. Hany tries to point out is how erroneous are the interpretations of MOST of the religious scholars because they relied on corrupted sources outside the quran, i.e. the earlier scriptures and collection of canonised hadiths about prophet muhammad s.a.w.
On this point we have to agree with him because all these sources, torah, injeel and hadiths were not written down until few hundred or perhaps thousand years after the main characters(moses, jesus and muhammad p.b.u.them all) passed away.
The interpretations based on these sources could deviate from original message in the quran since human emotions and considerations(political or worldly interests) could creep in.
But interpretations based on internal references of different verses in the quran could also resulted in different conclusions.
The contemprary scholars who are spiritually inclined tend to treat the raw statements in the quran as parables or methaphores of highest degree whereas scholars who are logically and intelectually inclined would view the raw statements in the quran as a reflection of a supreme intelligent God. God's words to them are the advanced hints of reality, i.e. physical and metaphysics realm.
To a spiritually inclined scholars the skies(السماوات) means layers or levels of devine knowledge and the means of acquiring this knowledge is through meditation and mental intuition.
Whereas to the scientists, the skies(السماوات) mean the layers of electromagnetic energy or lightwaves of infinite ranges that occupy the entire spherical universe based on observable evidence through the use of sophisticated tools and equipments developed by
God-given human intellect.
Now back to the issue whether Ismael is Muhammad s.a.w?
Based on evidence from the Quran, prophets Ibrahim, Ismael, Ishaq and Ya'qub and their followers belong to passed ummah; i want to term it as first ummah. This ummah ended with the passing of Ya'qub a.s. They were neither jews nor christians. I believe that Ismael lived in the first ummah era.
The second ummah was those that came after Ya'qub; they were followers of Moses and Jesus: they were muslims then but now are reduced to al-yahud and an-nasara. Although they inherited corrupted teachings of Torah and Injeel, they exist until today.
The third and final ummah is the followers of the final messenger and nabi, Muhammad s.a.w.
Al-Baqarah 2:140
أَمْ تَقُولُونَ إِنَّ إِبْرَٰهِيم وَإِسْمَٰعِيلَ وَإِسْحَٰقَ وَيَعْقُوبَ وَٱلْأَسْبَاطَ كَانُوا۟ هُودًا أَوْ نَصَٰرَىٰۗ قُلْ ءَأَنتُمْ أَعْلَمُ أَمِ ٱللَّهُۗ وَمَنْ أَظْلَمُ مِمَّن كَتَمَ شَهَٰدَةً عِندَهُۥ مِنَ ٱللَّهِۗ وَمَا ٱللَّهُ بغافل عما تعملون.
Or are you saying that Abraham, Ishmael, Isaac, Jacob, and the descendants were Jews or Christians?’ Say, ‘Who knows better: you or God? Who could be more wicked than those who hide a testimony from God? God is not unaware of what you do.’
Al-Baqarah 2:141
تِلْكَ أُمَّةٌ قَدْ خَلَتْۖ لَهَا مَا كَسَبَتْ وَلَكُم مَّا كَسَبْتُمْۖ وَلَا تُسْـَٔلُونَ عَمَّا كَانُوا۟ يَعْمَلُونَ
That is a nation which has passed. To it is what it strived, and to you will be what you strive. And you will not be asked about what they did.
Are you denying the revelations of ALLAH SWT AL-QURAN .if Dr Hany is right the whole ummah have been lied upon for 1400yrs and personally i believe Dr Hany is speaking the truth.
Dr.Hany, we are ever ready. Keep teaching us, truth us come and falsehood has vanish.
Ameen!!!!
How when you are using Quran. May Allah Bless you and Continue to keep you in his Guidance
سلم عليكم
ماشاءالله
For lack of a better term, this segment made me feel like my whole 60 years life’s knowledge of Islam is now completely uprooted, while feeling goosebumps and shiver all over. This uprooting slowly happened since discovering this channel by chance 6 months ago. Tonight, this segment did it i.e. completely pulled the roots out of the ground.
It has made me think that there’s been a coordinated effort, and not just lack of knowledge or wisdom of earlier scholars, to mislead the Muslim world since the death of our beloved ﷺ.
Otherwise, there would have been reports in the tafseers, hadeeth and seerah that our beloved Muhammad ﷺ was Adam, Dhulkarnain, and Ishmael. Wouldn’t it?
But this channel has brought good news to us.
I like to think that Allahh is answering our prayers:
ٱهْدِنَا ٱلصِّرَٰطَ ٱلْمُسْتَقِيمَ
صِرَٰطَ ٱلَّذِينَ أَنْعَمْتَ عَلَيْهِمْ غَيْرِ ٱلْمَغْضُوبِ عَلَيْهِمْ وَلَا ٱلضَّآلِّينَ
I look forward to more gifts from Dr. Hany Atchan.
May Allahh recompense you with better roots, firmly grounded in his words and direct guidance
That "fatilka ummukum bani maa' as-samaa' " statement really pissed me off. As someone who has watched your videos for sometime, I immediately recognized it as the statement of the ba3udah. The 'your .....' is really telling. Thanks Dr for opening our eyes.
Not only that but the audacity and arrogance. To fabricate a fake person, assign to it a relationship to a whole nation of people, then documenting it.
Right on....same here....and the audacity part as well .....
Thank you brother, please keep moving forward with the Truth and the Language of Truth.
AL hamdu liL Llah. Another insightful lecture session. Thank you
Alhamdulillah. Shukran for finally heeding to my patient and obvious and pressing question especially in light of your previous episode, asserting that our beloved Nabi Muhammad (saw), is from the lineage of Jacoob(as), Ishaaq(as) and Ebrahim(as).
My "pen and paper" has been patiently waiting for the past two weeks. So Alhamdulillah, finally In the post. Very grateful for your patience, time, and unfailing spirit to deliver, Dr. Hany.
Assalamu aleikum Dr Hany, I always look forward to your videos. The joy I feel whenever I see the notification ,I can't express in words all I can say is Alhamdulilah for allowing me to be part of this enlightening journey. May Allah continue guide us and allow you to complete this mission. Now the stories are making sense, although I'm not a native Arabic speaker. Alhamdulilah and thank you Dr Hany. We are with you all the way , insha Allah.
Assalamulaikum..
Alhamdulillah... I would say that we are very lucky to have someone like you Dr. Hany speaking out the truth and not a carbon copy of the past.
I respect you sir..
Wassalam
Salamun alaykum..How would Yaqub's sons know about Ismail if Abraham didn't have a son called Ismail and they didn't know there would be a future Ismail {named Muhammad}? Did they have knowledge of the future by mentioning him among the forefathers in their response to Yaqub? Similarly, how would Abraham know to mention Ismail as a future gift from Allah if he didn't have knowledge of the future (coming of Muhammad)? At least it doesn't seem that they had such knowledge of the unseen...
@ gerald etienne
Ibrahim made a Duaa, and the angels gave him the glad tidings in Surah 15.
This is how Ibrahim knew of Issmail, and Ibrahim taught his followers and children.
@@MarvelousQuran Isn't Sura 15:53-55 about the promise of Ishaq? Aren't the glad tidings of a son referring to Ishaq?
@@geraldetienne1500 The Ghulam Alim is Issmail. The Ghulam Halim is Iss-haq
I can’t stop watching your videos. I want to learn everything about our Marvellous Quran. Everything you mentioned and showed to us the true meaning of stories which mislead millions of the truth seeking umma. I am so ecstatic and thankful to Allah answered my dua on learning reading understanding the true meaning in translation of the one and only Holy Quran. I have never looked up or read any Hadith at all as I was going to do that after I’ve learned to read the Quran. So now it seems that the Hadith I will be looking up in the near future will be in a different approach and thanks to Allah first of all and to you for bringing these to our attention and the future generation inshaAllah
Alhamdulillah
Assalamuaikom dear brother, Doctor Hany. I took a huge cup of coffee and I've been listening to this video and I am amazed by your logic. This explains why we Muslims are far from being the leaders of this world, we don't even follow the Quran. Jasaka Allahu khairan
Its a nice theory...but Ishmael was a different n separate person. Muhammed is not Adam, dhul quarnyn or Jesus which might be another theory
To think His Majesty gave Dr hany this knowledge, and not, say for example, Ibn Tamiya, just seems absurd. Islam civilised the world and to think all Muslims were misguided during all that time of scientific endeavour in the Islamic weekend is non sensical. Some of Dr hanys theories make sense but much of it also goes too far. If it truly is new knowledge I wonder why he doesn't go to Al Azhar and promote his queue there!!
Dr Hany this is the first comment I ever put on any youtube video since youtube's inception. This was amazingly deep. I totally agree on your points on what Quran is saying on similarity of Ismael(as) and prophet(saws). However, historically, do we have any indication if Ibrahim(as) has two sons or one? Because, authoritative history is also need to be considered in your scientific method.
As salamu alaykom ya dr. Hany how to make salah according to the qur'an
@Marvelous Quran why Rabbi sometimes it is written like that and some other times written like Rabby with ya?
Not sure what you are asking!
Generally, for Duaa, Rabbee is without a trailing Ya.
@@MarvelousQuran do they mean the same thing, with or without the trailing ya? And why are they written with and without ya?
Please refer to aya 2:133 ,where the name is mentioned after Ibrahim and before Eshaq.
Allhumdulilah, what an amazing segment!
Salamunalaikum,what is 'umrah' dr hanny
Dr. Hany, what aboute sura Nisa, ayet; 163... what is your view on it?
This segment really lands a crushing blown on all the superstitious and mythological teachings that has traditionally been handed down to us. I am so grateful to Allah to have coming to contact with this channel your work is really very much appreciated May Allah continue to bless and protect you.
(14:39) All praise be to Allah Who, despite my old age, has given me Ishmael and Isaac. Surely my Lord hears all prayers.
Alhamdoulillah. Wow Dr. Hany! Mashallah. May Allah protect you himself. I got lots of internal questions answered today. I cannot imagine someone with an atom of “fear of Allah” that would say anything negative to you. I’m grateful to Allah for this. Now life is starting to make sense for me. Thank you! I’m very happy today. الله أكبر
Salaamun Alaykum Dr. Hany. While rewatching this video I was revisiting again and again timestamp 19:20 where you clearly said that ayat 2:127 is not talking about Ibhahim AS 'raising the Kaaba'! I think this statement puts so many questions in front of us! My take is- Al-bayt' in the ayat is indicating the followers of Ibrahim AS in the first instance and the followers of our beloved Prophet SWAS in the later instance.
Allahhu Alam.
Subhan Allah Dr Hany , it’s simply opened up the eyes of Muslim ummah. Alhamdulillah. Please keep continuing…
Alhamdulillha i watched the video 3 times to understand, all that now is yusser Alhamdulillha ❤
I had always wondered why our beloved prophet was never mentioned by name when Allah mentioned all other prophets. Alhamdulillah this fits perfectly well. JazakAllah Khair!
Muhammed is mentioned 4 times in the Quran.
@@ajazio Also "Ahmad"
Read Q 48:29
Dr Hany, you are one of the true geniuses of our time. You are helping to clear many errors that have crept into our Deen and are made to look truthful.
Your Kasorti, your Touch stone is the Quran.
Ever since a child our late father has inculcated in us that the Quran is the only source of Guidance that we ought to be following. These words are not only from my father, but also stated very, very clearly in the Quran.
Some Scholars of Quran like Allama Iqbal, Allama Ghulam Ahmed Pervez, Dr Abdul Wadud and others tried to bring us all back to the Quran. They at their time were called Kaafir! Very sad.
Conspiracies Against The Quran is an excellent book by Dr Abdul Wadud.
Many hadiths were fabricated by Jews, Persians, Christians and Idol Worshippers! The Quran also testifies to this:
Woe to every fabricating imposter.
Woe unto those who exchange false hadith for petty gains.
There are those who say "we are Muslim " but in their hearts they are not.
The above are just some of the verses in the Glorious Quran.
Dr Hany, Our Deen has been hijacked for 1400yrs!! We have all been duped by a number 2 version of Islam.
I really look forward to you talks and will especially look forward to the ones on SALAT AND ZAKAT. As you rightly say, the majority of so called Muslims are not ready to learn what is the true meaning of Salat and Zakat!
" The birds with their wings outspread, know their Salat."
A typical Muslim will say, yes, birds pray too!!! Oh my ghosh! What nonsense. Birds, however have been given Divine instinct.
Dr Hany, may Allah swt reward you forever for the knowledge you are imparting to us.
Please get in touch with Dr Shabir Ahmed USA, OURBEACON.COM who is also like minded.
JZK
Alhamdulillah. Truly enlightening! I personally feel even more challenged to take the time to invest in studying and understanding the Quran. May Allah guide all of us.
Verses 6 ayah 46 ( *raw* ) : " Say, "Have you considered:1 if Allah should take away your hearing and your sight and set a seal upon your hearts, which deity other than Allah could bring them [back] to you?" *Look how We diversify2 the verses; then they [still] turn away.* "
Ah hah! I had this problem when ever I go across 19:54~55, "I was thinking about Ishmael(s), He was a Rasul & Nabi, and praises given to him these verses, the only story we here about him is this traditional story, which does not justify Quranic praise about him". I did not see this coming..........Wow........absolutely delighted.
Why was Hood, Saleh, Shuaib not mentioned in the list of surah anam that praises prophet and messengers?
Excellent question!!! This is how we engage the Quran.
AsSlaam o Alikum! always amazing reveals by you dear Dr. Hani, may Allah SWT rewards you for all the effort you go through, Ameen. My Q. is that what are the meanings of the names, Zul Qarneen and Ismael that these were used instead of the name of our Prophet(PBUH)? What was the relevance of using them in those particular verses?
Everything in the Quran is directed to those who reflect, not to those who rush.
Did we think that we shall receive the guidance from Allahh without putting in the hard work that is commensurate with Allahh's reverence?
Al Hamdou Lillah and thanks for your patience and your zakat of received knowledge. i'm so happy to peel, with the help of Allah, the layers of darkness we've been imposed from centuries.
Beautifully said. Alhamdulillah
Alhamdulillah
Dear Dr. Hani,
Assalamu Alykum,
I get your 4 makers but why did Allah SWT use the name Ismael at the beginning of ayat 19:54? Why didn't Allah SWT say Muhammed (saw), as Allah swt says Quran is made simple so you can be guided. I really need an answer to this question as in an another video you have stated Abu Lahab was Firaun. Again why didn't Allah swt state Firaun directly in Surah 111???
Did the prophet PBUH, ever do tafsirs on any surahs? If so which ones?
- لِلطَّآئِفِينَ وَٱلْعَٰكِفِينَ وَٱلرُّكَّعِ ٱلسُّجُودِ
🕵🏻♂️
Salaamun ALAYKUM,
I will join you to carry this message forward INSHA ALLAH.
ALHAMDULILAAH, ALLAH is already removing the barrier (hijaab) when reciting / engaging AL QURAAN. and every time I revisit this channel I get new knowledge. I just want to Stay within the Womb not outside of it.