John said to Him, “Teacher, we saw someone casting out demons in Your name, and we tried to stop him because he was not accompanying us [as Your disciple].” But Jesus said, “Do not stop him; for there is no one who will perform a miracle in My name, and be able soon afterward to speak evil of Me. FOR HE WHO IS NOT AGAINST US IS FOR US. MARK 9 from 38 to 40 I find nothing wrong with these videos. If it attracts young people to make them curious about God and the Bible. Now... there are 25 thousand Christian dominions... clearly there will always be some who will find something wrong or something their dominion disagrees with. But let's not forget that the main purpose of the Apostles was to spread the Gospel, a word from the Greek Evangelion, which means the good news. If there are young people who are just on youtube all day and a video like this directs their thoughts to God and Jesus, well thank God. And if those young people learn the "the good news" that God loves them and in the name of the Lord Jesus they can be delivered, forgiven and saved. What more could we want?
it feels empty because there's absolutely nothing there ... but generated images by a computer program ... nothing to do with ''the holy spirit'' , what ever the hell That is ... people have imagination , a program doesn't ... THAT's the word you were looking for , not the ''holy spirit'' , we call it ''imagination'' stop making up words that have NO MEANING what so ever and try and live IN reality for once in your life ... i know you religious people don't have much to offer , at all , but at least give it a little try , why don't you ?
...and the problem with Holy Spirit is how vaguely defined it is. Hence, why hundreds of thousands are hooked on being preached to by machines and are none the wiser)
@@nemoscripturaHoly Spirit doesn’t have a problem, it is the Spirit of God and Christ The problem is we are too “Entertained” to pray in the Spirit and listen to that small still voice
Pastors are using AI to write their sermons... I even saw a seminar hosted by a mainline denomination teaching you how to use AI to write your sermons. I find this horrifying.
If I learned from anything on the internet you need to be master of discernment. It is hard to tell what is real and what is not when it comes to the internet. It is lost art and school play a very bad role in all this.
My daughters college. They don’t do anything but feedmoaparrs through the ai machine. They don’t even teach either basically leave it to them apparently haha useless anyway. But I know. Nonjnew really doing shitn
So glad you have spoken about this. It's a major problem. People are replacing a true relationship with Christ nurtured through prayer, worship and time in the Word of God, for the quick fix and pretty pictures.
It's not even a Christian problem. It is a problem in all things. How this isn't regulated yet is beyond concerning. We are literally throwing away human creativity in favor of instant and effortlessness gratification.
Absolutely... that is upsetting. Any one can hide behind AI generated content, people who got ZERO knowledge of their subjects...but that is the reality today.
These ai generated thumbnail & video images are sometimes (or often) dark/evil looking, depending on video theme, which is not biblical?: "avoid the appearance of evil", etc, its like watching a Christian horror video!, demonically inspired images? The images & video themes are opposing/incompatable, antithetical: Using evil images to spread the gospel/preach the word? Whats "attached" to them??
Yes, and these AI channels usually use video titles like, "You are not a Christian if you skip this video", or "You belong to the devil if you don't watch this video", etc., etc.
Good job with your investigative reporting...We as Christians need to keep a wary discerning eye on A.I. generated contents on Social Media, although it can be quite an aid for some work tasks. Be alert!
This is what I learned when I asked ChatGPT to write a sermon intro on a subject. That was only when it was 2 months old. The deceptive lines between threads of truth… my elders/and congregation were aghast. Anyone lacking in apologetic or hermeneutics will easily be deceived.
There are shorts that I used to see and they would have extremely threatening titles, like, "Click on this video or you will cry later" And that is the least bad of them, I prayed to God to get rid of these videos from me, and give me videos with humans, and thats what he did, so thank God almighty cause those were making me a nervous train wreck. May God bless you now, forever and allways, may he also forgive you, and us live in accordance to his law and thank him for what he has created, and Jesus name we pray and for our sake, AMEN 🙏❤😊😊✝️🙏😇🙌➕❤🔥🙏
You can also report videos. I have recently started to do this. There's a list of options as to why you reported it. Then an email which gives you space to write more. You could "tick" "Threatening." (Or in my case "misinformation.") Then when the email turned up I wrote "There's no option for AI generated deception." I live in hope... 😂
God bless you brother for exposing this!!! You rock! I don't have many videos yet on my channel but everything you see and hear was 97% me from voice to graphics. No AI is gonna preach for me or to me! Keep up the good work bro and RESPECT!
The real problem is that Christians don't read their Bibles at all anymore. If they did, they would see through it instantly. Thank you for bringing this to the forefront! BTW, do you have the link to the Joel Osteen video? I almost spit out my coffee... 😂
I have mild cognitive impairment and visuals helped me tremendously. But I was starting to wonder because every so often the voice is screw up. I am so grateful to come across your video
Dude when I go on these video and see tons of stuff that does not make sense and question it people say I am a mdoern day Pharisee. They will beleive any thing as long as the person presenteing claims to be a christian and says they had a visoon or dream of Jesus Christ.
Hey brother! I've watched a bunch of your videos thinking that your channel could be among the ones I critique here. I was happy to not only hear a script that was not copied and pasted from ChatGPT but to also see you very human face every now and then in your videos. Cheers to you my friend
While Grace for Purpose means well, it's just an AI voice speaking. It's confusing because in general the video has no context. It's usually made for click bait, 'this is happening now', kind of thing. Yet no one on the comments seem to speak about it, or feel out of place. Where there is void of a human, there is void of Spirit.
THANK YOU! I'm actually surprised he didn't catch onto that as well. The ai generated comments are to give any REAL viewers the illusion that people are actually watching and engaging with the video and channel. Even the views can be bought.
Absolutely Correct! I think it is the "flashiness" of the channels that are helping to attract people. You have to admit that those channels look nice & very professional. One of the obvious weaknesses of man is that they are drawn to appearances / looks first and content secondarily. They haven't learned from experience / forgotten or don't care about the adage "Looks can be / are deceiving."
oh you probably missed it then , that ALREADY happened , dude , just a couple months ago , a lot of Serious sunflares and '' everything was going to break and halt the internet and all kinds of stuff '' , NOTHING HAPPENED , as for a few people got a good sun burn while having a nice beach day , but that's about it
I probably wouldn’t mind. One if the most relaxing times I had was when my phone got stolen and I didn’t have one for a several days. Just worked outside, whittled, made some projects, and no one bothered me.
@@ThermaL-ty7bw None of them hit us point blank, at least nothing that was X5 or higher (we might be able to withstand up to an X9 without serious issues). Carrington Event was around X40. That would wreck us quite badly right now, knocking out power for weeks, possibly months. With the level of technology we are reliant on right now, that's probably a catastrophe I rather not confront.
I've noticed a proliferation of these kind of videos as well. Didn't really even notice until I realized there were multiple different channels that had "different" videos that all had the same narrator voice. That, and the voice would pronounce people's names wrong (like when they would pronounce Job's name like the word for employment). The voices would also pause as places in the sentence that didn't seem to make any sense. The last thing is that they would teach as fact things that clearly aren't what scripture say (the worst offense of course). I get why people are making these kind of videos, but I think from now on I'm making a point of not watching videos that don't feature an actual person in front of a camera.
Exactly, an actual person in front of a camera. Been watching lots of NDE channels and the ones generated by AI spread negative and frightening contents, this never happens on "clean " channels with the NDE'r telling his/her storie in front of the camera
Also do you know those videos that show God angry saying "You'll go to hell if you skip"? THEY'RE SO ANNOYING! They're already threatening you for no reason and when you click on these AI generated clout videos, they never get to the point! Let me do an impression of these videos. "My child, I'm about to tell you a message God sent. This message is to be amazing. Let me be your guide as I take you through this message. This message will be great. Join me-" like WE GET IT! Message, message, message! We know! Get to the point! But they don't. Stay away from these videos. They're baiting you in.
Thanks for sharing, good stuff! The only way I believe one can discern Ai generated and real Biblical data is to be in the word daily. Going even further, because I spend time daily (early morning) in the word, I avoid ANY content that has AI generated thumbnails. Sad part though, is that I don't think it will take long for even the most hardened Biblical pastor to start using the AI in one or all of the areas you had pointed out sir!
We cannot escape AI. It is just a tool with no intrinsic moral value. But Christians should display more wisdom and criteria when using this tool. Cheers my friend
This was something that NEEDED to be discussed. Thank you for shedding light on this issue. I am seeing multitudes of ‘C.S. Lewis sermons’ and it’s just disgusting how these channels will impersonate great thinkers and pretend to speak the truth for some quick cash. I actually wanted to listen to some C.S. Lewis too.
I have been telling people how evil AI is for like 5 years waay before it got this bad. It's getting everywhere. It's being used for the most horrendous things.
Well, based on that logic. Shouldn't churches create their own models trained and tested on Biblical texts? With that, the spread of untrustworthy information will be blocked. It's important to keep up with progress and avoid getting run over with progress.
I agree, I see generative AI currently like a giant library, and a custom librarian who can potentially perform very useful tasks and analysis based on its programming. On one hand Christians (and all humans ) have a history of running from anything new and calling it the devil. On the other hand, humans, do have a good track record of using tools, foolishly and ending up in destruction I hope to be a part of Christians using AI as a tool to unite the church within its areas of strength, while respecting the truth that any tool that makes things easier can also cause destruction if the wielder is not wise.
I mean, AI is here to stay and we'll all use it, I know I will. I am sure some more Biblical specialized AI is coming out soon...but as of now, chatGPT is not it. Cheers my friend
Great video. 👍 I’m not AI, but even if I was, I’d be glad you’re policing this. We need to protect those who are gullible. Soon I think it won’t be so obvious it’s AI and I am concerned. FYI - your voice is awesome. “Trust the humans.” I came here because I want to know if Jon Oleksiuk’s channel is real. Any idea?
These AIs aren't just repeating across channels. You can also notice a lot of repetition within a single script. You'll frequently have them restating their opening statements in their entirety every single time they transition into a new topic. Any time I notice this I'll just leave the channel and try to forget everything I just heard.
I saw a Catholic AI channel a few months ago like this, where almost every video title was "(Famous person name): (Clickbait title)". Most of the thumbnails followed the format of apocalyptic background image, one or two reaction faces usually including a stock photo of the person mentioned, an occasional arrow or circle to something in the background, and big text with the same green/yellow/red colors in all caps with "SHOCKING!", "WARNING", or "URGENT!" in green. Every video starting with "Our Lady" has a stock photo of a statue of Mary, usually crying. The scripts are obviously AI generated. In one video the tone suddenly changed from its normal "religious purple prose" style to a technical explanation about why you need to unplug electronics during thunderstorms. In another one that's private now, it told how to "combat this diseased egg pineapple".
And some even say "God will leave if you don't watch" with "don't ignore me" and a picture of an angry man on it. No Images of that which is in heaven is violated with each video
Thank u soon much for disceting that 4 me. I always wondered why the colors in the pictures were so bright, sharp and well drawn. Thank u 4 breaking it apart and showing how it's done. Trust the humans.....at least in this arena u bet. And I love ur voice, I r a handsome man and an excellent witness. God bless u and keep and make his face shine on u. So be it.😊❤❤❤❤😮😅😅
I read an article a while back about a church in Germany that used AI to generate an entire sermon and played it on a giant screen instead of having a real pastor at the podium.
I believe part of the great falling away will be of those unknowingly being lead away with information changed just enough to veer them off the narrow path
Learn to know Jesus’ voice by reading the Word and spending time w/ Jesus. What helped me was taking one verse a day learning about what that verse means talking to Jesus about that days verse and how to apply it to that day & my life
Start memorizing Scripture. Not just verses here & there, but whole chapters at a time. It will sharpen your ability to discern it's meaning, because you develop a habit of thinking about each word & the implications of it in the context. Then when you hear an AI interpretation, you might not recognize it as AI, but you'll still pass on it, because it smells like rotten fish.
Question: how is using AI to disseminate Christian teachings different from using the printing press to disseminate the Bible? Before the invention of the printing press, texts were copied by hand often by monks and it took ages. The printing press just sped up the process and made it much cheaper and easier and brought the Bible to much larger audience. I mean think about any technology. What about using cars or microwaves or cell phones? AI could potentially be used in an ethical way to spread Christian teachings, but the human oversight for moral guidance would still have to remain. AI will basically say every religion is good, because it's programmed to be respectful of diverse beliefs. But I more so see the advantage to being able to teach people more. Now people can learn about the Bible and the Church very easily and quickly, they can learn about the historical context of Biblical stories, learn Church teachings, about the lives of the saints, etc. It's like taking a library and packing it into a single source. The Walmart or Amazon of library knowledge so to speak. I understand where you're coming from, but if you're going to criticize AI then you need to look at the whole broader framework of all technology in general as well. All technology has the potential to be used for good or evil and depends upon human oversight and morality to make sure it's used in an ethical manner. Lots of technology has downsides too. We have cars now which makes travel much faster and safer, but leads to pollution. We have cell phones which allows communication much more easily, but has also potentially led to lack of direct contact in friendships. We think about how AI is a radical change to us because it's new, but how was it for people when the television was invented or something else we take totally for granted like air conditioning? We grew up with these things, so we're totally used to them, but at one time people were probably saying about them the same things people are saying about AI. Unfortunately, there's no real official Church teaching yet on AI, so we'll see where that stands. Pope Francis has expressed views on its potential for positive use, but also concerns. I think the biggest issue is a lack of creativity and the uniqueness to human art in using AI. If one uses it, they should still some of their own unique flair to it to make it stand out from everything else that's also using AI. But again, even musicians use technology in their creation process. Think of all the songs made on computers these days or things done now, like mastering, that were much more difficult in the past, that have been made much cheaper and easier due to advancements in technology. So all that being said, instead of looking at just the downsides, I would look at the positive potential in its ability to spread the Gospel to more people. It's just we humans who need to make sure it aligns with the Church's values and teachings. Unfortunately, it may not ever get it perfect, but overall I think it's been a great resource for me to learn about Christian teachings. The problem lies in where it's not exactly accurate or truthful due to its programming. Like in the fact that it's going to speak of every religion as if it's absolutely golden due to the fact that it has to respect religious freedom and diversity. The problem will arise if Christianity happens to conflict with what's legal, then AI will take legality above Christianity. But overall, from my experience, if you ask it to abide by a certain perspective or set of teachings, it does a pretty good job. A better job than most of the pastors I've seen at my church, which is unfortunate tbh.
The Church better GET ready - AI is not going anywhere, and there have always been charlatans preaching false gospels. Trust God, read your Bibles, practice and build discernment by the power of the Holy Spirit.
I have noticed that content around conspirecy theories, religion, and nationalism (of any country) does really well. They require less effort and can be easily created by AI. They are cater to our emotional side. Therefore, we end up being a lot less critical about such content. On how is it made, whether it is factually right. This comes down to lack of media literacy and stroking or ego that our personal belief system is right. Media literacy is terribly lacking. You would think most of these people who fall are boomers. But that is not the case. Gen alpha is horrendous with media literacy. We expect them to be good with tech as they grew up with it, creating and consuming it on the regular That is like expecting all mellinials to be good with PowerPoint since we grew up with it, creating and consuming funky stuff on it. I have seen my friends and older cousins (Gen X) fall for AI content. They genuinely think the individual is making the script uses "stock photos" and TTS to make the video as not have the accent (non native speakers of English) or capability (resources or confidence) to speak into a mic. A lot of AI content also molly coddle our existing belief systems, so it makes us feel good instead of thinking critically. Thus enjoying the content.
Thanks for such a thoughtful comment. I agree. If I may add one thing to your comment - Christians tend to lower their standards when it comes to anything that labels itself as "Christian". Many tend to leave their brains at the door a little bit if the content talks about Jesus in the way they like. This is definitely not just an AI problem, it is most definitely and primarily an us problem. Peace to you my friend.
@OctavioMoss I am agnostic with a hindu upbringing, but I have friends who are practicing Christians. I am from India, and something i noticed is that people read only certain chapters in the Bible from a very young age. Sometimes, it's only certain verses from a chapter. We got Christianity from the British when they colonized us, so most of them have been Christians for atmost 2 or 3 generations. There are hypothesis that they were not taught the Bible properly, as teaching it properly will make it hard to justify a lot of Britain's cruel behavior. Most of them have not read the entire Bible with the proper context. I dont know how much of this is unrectified patterns from pre colonial era. Compared to my hindu friends, they seem to be easily enomored by the AI Christian content. My hindu friends seem less susceptible to this as they seem more irritated on how the story is all wrong. The comment section in Hindia AI Gen content is usually a lot of people correcting the story. That said, my hindu friends do fall for "Hinduism is scientific and here is the proof" kinda videos.
@N-John533 you are right. People are encouraged to question. We have stories of mortals questioning gods about their decions and god explaining why they took a decision or act. In many households, becoming an atheist or agnostic during your youth is seen as the right of passage. This is bound to happen when you have a lot of questions with no satisfactory answer. This might be why asking questions is not taboo. Losing faith is not a taboo .
11:21 That gave me a good laugh and I understand what you mean. The Lord has blessed you with a good eye and ear. Diligent searching is what I see from you, brother. You would've been among the 300 who brought the water to their mouths. These are the same spirits who will be part of the final Remnant, which have pressed in deeper with the Lord, and The Holy Spirit will lead them as they lead the rest out of the darkness they've been sitting in for so long! May the Grace of our Lord Jesus Christ protect you and bless you richly, brother. 🔥🕊️🔥
I picked up on these types of videos about a week ago. And noticed the same things that you noticed. But I did not dig as deep as you did when you found other channels with the exact same video headers and storylines. One of the channels that you showed named Bible Stories. Did you look at that channel’s profile? It says they are in Brazil. Why Brazil? I feel they are a group exercising extreme measures to attempt to either attract people to the faith, or to take advantage of clicks from believers in the faith. Thus, making lots of cash in the process. Interesting thing is why hasn’t TH-cam cracked down on this kind of content? Also, the channel I looked at did not even give any credits to Chat GPT or to any of the AI generated image websites, for example Microsoft Bing Image Creator. Something very sketchy all around the channel I looked at named Bible Stories.
i think the AI images are fine, so long as we don't take the images as fact but as a representation or approximation of what things may have looked like.
We cannot escape AI. It is just a tool with no intrinsic moral value. But Christians should display more wisdom and criteria when using this tool. Cheers my friend
Why do I get the feeling that even the comments in these videos are AI-generated? 'Dear ChatGPT, please generate hundreds and hundreds of comments saying how much you like my video." 😮
This is exactly what I've been dealing with. I've had to start using AI for my images on my videos just to keep up. The difference is I refuse to use AI voice, so all of my prayer videos are my voice and human made prayers. I'm now putting it in the title of my videos so others start becoming aware of how dependent we are on AI. It's disconcerting to realize that the majority of our population prefers an AI generated voice to a human's.
I just want thank you by your dedication in show us the Truth about this kind of content. Some days ago i have watched some these content and i realize the same of you: That all these videos seem the same! The same thumbnails, the same text and voice. This can be incredible but scary as well...
I have watched the Redeemed Zoomer video on the story of the Bible, he actually does quite a few good videos, including short explanations, so he added the story of the Bible to it
I’ve been watching these and they are so compelling, I subscribed. I was wondering who could produce such an amount of illustrations, without realizing they were AI generated. But some videos later, I heard something I didn’t like (don’t remember what), and unsubscribed. Now I know why I sensed something was fishy. Thank you brother, for keeping watch over the flock. May God less your efforts.
Hey! I'm glad you brought this up! Can't stand Messianic Christianity, but ive noticed this happening MANY videos on topics like Consciousness, Religion, and Ancient history. I've come to the conclusion that they are just trying to capitalize and make as much money as they can without being original. Same script just different images and ai voice narrating the videos, like you said.
I am very glad to see this and that you are talking about this on your platform. I have been very much noticing this and not pleased by what I saw. I do not like AI generated videos and scripts in general and the worst are the Christian Faith AI videos. To me it seems like an attempt to change the Bible and understanding of God's word and do it in very subtle and underhanded way. Like blasphemy and disinformation posing as faith and knowledge. AI should never lead people especially in Spiritual matters.
I get your point, but honestly as long as the script is fact checked, and the ai images that are used are more accurate to the actual truth of how things were back then, theres no problem is ai generated bible stories. People making a profit from the bible in an easy way isnt a bad thing if they are getting the word of God out there for other to see. But I do have an issue with inaccuracy, if the stories are basically made up, or written falsely without the actual word of God in them, then there is no point, they are just fantasy stories at that point, not the actual bible.
Most of the christian inspirational prayers on youtube are ai. But when people dont have a church and they are going through they come to you tube because they lack discernment and can be deceived. . Pastor Savcuk, Pastor Dilena are two pastors that have websites and churches that teach pray encourage help to lead people to Jesus Christ. Be safe in your devotional spiritual walk.
I came across those videos too and I was interested in the artwork but did not feel right watching it. I believe the Holy Spirit will give you discernment and protection when you specifically ask for it. And while I don't like putting a dislike at a AI generated picture of Jesus, I do.
Thanks for sharing this, I actually notice it while try to generate a video, well thank God for my little Bible knowledge then I decided to always double check the script over and over again. And then I find myself correcting some error. Please while using AI to generate videos take time as well to research on that particular, so you can pass in the right information.
It's only a problem for those who have not diligently prayed for spiritual discernment. “But evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse, deceiving, and being deceived.” (2nd Tim. 3:13)
Ive been telling people this for a while now. It blows my mind how many people just believe everything they see and hear and dont research anything, let alone pick a Bible and actually read it.
I was waiting for the end of the video to expose itself to in fact be ai generated content. It wouldn't be shocking. And chat gpt definitely shouldn't ever be considered to have any authority or weight and should only be used with the understanding it is only conversing with you through filters that prevent full disclosure and legal disputes etc .. and is a means to someones' ends.
AI voices are mind blowing...the more you dig around with paid AI's the better they get. The example that I posted on the video is a free version of that. Peace my friend
“Truth and Spirit” Christians get to read the bible and learn how to discern with the help of the word of God (the bible) and the Holy Spirit. “Because of lack of knowledge my people are destroyed”. Reading the bible is essential to be able to discern, check and verify what we watch and hear. The bible instructs us to test the spirits, verify, check everything we hear.
I actually stumbled across your channel because I tried to google if a certain Christian channel Soulful Devotion(Based off of C.S Lewis Christian Books) was AI generated. To my dismay it is 😒 We really need to fight on regulations on AI because it’s misleading!!!! If content is being used with AI tools they need to put a label or something stating they used AI TOOLS TO CREATE THESE PODCAST!!!
woooow...I did not know that button existed. I need that ASAP - unfortunately due to all of the research that I did on those channels my feed in inundated with those videos. Thanks for that
I think we are saying basically the same. The Bible does not speak for itself and does not preach about its own self...it does it with and through humans. We listen to each other for wisdom, that has been our thing for thousands of years. But now things have changed. There is one more player now that will continue to speak louder and louder, a.k.a. AI...and we need not be afraid but wise, especially now. Peace to you my friend
@@OctavioMoss I hope we are. Are you also a follower of Christ? I certainly think I understand where you're coming from, but as a Christian I would be very hesitant to say "trust the humans" since that is quite contrary to the message of the Bible.
Hi, I used on my TH-cam a very few AI video generated sequences and all my voice overs are synthetic (English isn’t my first language) but all the video scripts are man made and Scripture based (I used the Talmud’s Yoma 39b on one video). I really understand your point of view. AI is a very dangerous tool in the wrong hands like many others on these sad days of deception and fake facts…
I am not a fan of the current AI generated images and voices but I have no particular issues with it. It is the AI generated content, the script that I take issue with, that can be very problematic. Cheers friend
It's August 2024, like 6 months since you posted this and these types of channels are promoted on my feed EVERY DAY! Even though I consistently hit "do not reccomend", they keep recommending new ones! How many of these channels are out there?! The worst are the "chosen ones" that encourage Christians to segregate from society and validates that through false Christian teachings. That's SCARY! If you don't see the issue, I'm concerned for you. We NEED to be very cautious with this new tech as it gets harder to decern from real content, real teachings and REAL effort from creative and talented people. God bless to everyone out there.
Thanks for the comment...It is surprising that TH-cam would still recommend them even after you tell them not to...I am trying hard not to put my conspiracy hat on at this moment ;). Peace to you my friend
@OctavioMoss well, in the algorithms defense... you do have to click on a few and listen, before you realize what's going on. So that may extend the amount of time it promotes these channels. I would like to see YT crack down on channels that are using 100% ai gen videos. I mean that's gotta be a threat to authentic content creators, right? And peace be with you my friend.
Not being rude but I learned about God and his word from my Bible coloring book with cartoon looking characters and at night time my mom put a cassette on of the bible with someone idk narrating. So you see what I'm saying without exactly saying it
I did notice this channel in my feed and the videos were very attractive. Clicked and watched a few but realised the voice was AI and machine like, and the content was unnatural. Clicked away and forgot all they were saying. Empty AI content…
Thank you for sharing this information as it is needed especially for those who do not study the word of God or read anything else for that matter. The Body of Christ is well equipped, God always has a remnant in every sector and occupation. Romans 11:4 NIV "And what was God's answer to him? "I have reserved for myself seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal." You can underestimate people, never God!
Right now you can tell that these are Ai generated, but the time will come, and it will be very soon, when we cannot distinguish Ai from real life. Then we will not be able to trust any content. People, trust the Bible for your "content".
The lack of the Holy Spirit is the biggest problem! All of it feels empty.
That is an interesting take... some food for thought there
John said to Him, “Teacher, we saw someone casting out demons in Your name, and we tried to stop him because he was not accompanying us [as Your disciple].” But Jesus said, “Do not stop him; for there is no one who will perform a miracle in My name, and be able soon afterward to speak evil of Me. FOR HE WHO IS NOT AGAINST US IS FOR US. MARK 9 from 38 to 40
I find nothing wrong with these videos. If it attracts young people to make them curious about God and the Bible.
Now... there are 25 thousand Christian dominions... clearly there will always be some who will find something wrong or something their dominion disagrees with.
But let's not forget that the main purpose of the Apostles was to spread the Gospel, a word from the Greek Evangelion, which means the good news.
If there are young people who are just on youtube all day and a video like this directs their thoughts to God and Jesus, well thank God. And if those young people learn the "the good news" that God loves them and in the name of the Lord Jesus they can be delivered, forgiven and saved. What more could we want?
it feels empty because there's absolutely nothing there ... but generated images by a computer program ...
nothing to do with ''the holy spirit'' , what ever the hell That is ...
people have imagination , a program doesn't ...
THAT's the word you were looking for , not the ''holy spirit'' , we call it ''imagination''
stop making up words that have NO MEANING what so ever and try and live IN reality for once in your life ...
i know you religious people don't have much to offer , at all , but at least give it a little try , why don't you ?
...and the problem with Holy Spirit is how vaguely defined it is. Hence, why hundreds of thousands are hooked on being preached to by machines and are none the wiser)
@@nemoscripturaHoly Spirit doesn’t have a problem, it is the Spirit of God and Christ
The problem is we are too “Entertained” to pray in the Spirit and listen to that small still voice
Pastors are using AI to write their sermons... I even saw a seminar hosted by a mainline denomination teaching you how to use AI to write your sermons. I find this horrifying.
If I learned from anything on the internet you need to be master of discernment. It is hard to tell what is real and what is not when it comes to the internet. It is lost art and school play a very bad role in all this.
My daughters college. They don’t do anything but feedmoaparrs through the ai machine. They don’t even teach either basically leave it to them apparently haha useless anyway. But I know. Nonjnew really doing shitn
Pastors are all ministry hogs! All of them!
Human beings can be so lazy and selfish. It's crazy. With AI now everyone can be a Pastor. Or nearly anything else.
Deadly sin called sloth
I work at a tech company and I use AI everyday.
The generative AI always needs to be double checked for accuracy
100%
Thats because its not ai. People are dumb. Its programmed algorythms. Its just normalizing ai as harmless and futile. Just wait.
Here's an experiment for you. Ask Chat GPT about the gospel. Its database is the internet.
problem is what your LLM is fed it will spew out.
if the AI programmers feed the AI shit it will produce shit.
Right ... 😅
So glad you have spoken about this. It's a major problem. People are replacing a true relationship with Christ nurtured through prayer, worship and time in the Word of God, for the quick fix and pretty pictures.
This is an underrated video.
Well done!
PREACH!! This has been troubling my heart so much recently it makes me so happy seeing some speak out about it!!
It's not even a Christian problem. It is a problem in all things. How this isn't regulated yet is beyond concerning. We are literally throwing away human creativity in favor of instant and effortlessness gratification.
Some many other youtube genres are also facing the same issue, like history channels, science channels, drama channels...
Absolutely... that is upsetting. Any one can hide behind AI generated content, people who got ZERO knowledge of their subjects...but that is the reality today.
These ai generated thumbnail & video images are sometimes (or often) dark/evil looking, depending on video theme, which is not biblical?: "avoid the appearance of evil", etc, its like watching a Christian horror video!, demonically inspired images? The images & video themes are opposing/incompatable, antithetical: Using evil images to spread the gospel/preach the word? Whats "attached" to them??
Yes, and these AI channels usually use video titles like, "You are not a Christian if you skip this video", or "You belong to the devil if you don't watch this video", etc., etc.
Guys stop using your phone for 40 days and read the Bible/biblical books
Hate to break it to you but, the bible has nothing on a smart phone
@@Thelastetherborn Smart phones wont exist in a few years. A solar storm can fry technology in an instant.
Why not read it in the Hebrew tablets and scrolls then
@@ThelastetherbornLoL goes to show smart phones weren’t really made for smart people
@@senjuebro obviously, neither was the bible
Good job with your investigative reporting...We as Christians need to keep a wary discerning eye on A.I. generated contents on Social Media, although it can be quite an aid for some work tasks. Be alert!
This video is so relevant and on point! Good job Octo. I laughed so hard with the Osteen part. hahaha
AI can tell confident lies ...
100%
This is what I learned when I asked ChatGPT to write a sermon intro on a subject. That was only when it was 2 months old. The deceptive lines between threads of truth… my elders/and congregation were aghast. Anyone lacking in apologetic or hermeneutics will easily be deceived.
There are shorts that I used to see and they would have extremely threatening titles, like, "Click on this video or you will cry later" And that is the least bad of them, I prayed to God to get rid of these videos from me, and give me videos with humans, and thats what he did, so thank God almighty cause those were making me a nervous train wreck. May God bless you now, forever and allways, may he also forgive you, and us live in accordance to his law and thank him for what he has created, and Jesus name we pray and for our sake, AMEN 🙏❤😊😊✝️🙏😇🙌➕❤🔥🙏
Aww I hate chainmail/threatening content it’s scary
You can also report videos. I have recently started to do this. There's a list of options as to why you reported it. Then an email which gives you space to write more. You could "tick" "Threatening." (Or in my case "misinformation.") Then when the email turned up I wrote "There's no option for AI generated deception."
I live in hope... 😂
God bless you brother for exposing this!!! You rock! I don't have many videos yet on my channel but everything you see and hear was 97% me from voice to graphics. No AI is gonna preach for me or to me! Keep up the good work bro and RESPECT!
Thanks for you kind words. Peace to you
The real problem is that Christians don't read their Bibles at all anymore. If they did, they would see through it instantly. Thank you for bringing this to the forefront!
BTW, do you have the link to the Joel Osteen video? I almost spit out my coffee... 😂
I watched that video so many times....it's hilarious. There it is
th-cam.com/video/vRSwHAzEcMI/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TheGospelofChrist
@@OctavioMoss Thank you!
I have mild cognitive impairment and visuals helped me tremendously. But I was starting to wonder because every so often the voice is screw up. I am so grateful to come across your video
Dude when I go on these video and see tons of stuff that does not make sense and question it people say I am a mdoern day Pharisee. They will beleive any thing as long as the person presenteing claims to be a christian and says they had a visoon or dream of Jesus Christ.
This was a great analysis Octavio! It does make me want to take a second look at my titles! 😅
Hey brother! I've watched a bunch of your videos thinking that your channel could be among the ones I critique here. I was happy to not only hear a script that was not copied and pasted from ChatGPT but to also see you very human face every now and then in your videos.
Cheers to you my friend
Ho !!
You just open my eyes about those channels
Thanks bro !
My pleasure brother
That channel has been popping up on my stream a lot lately and others as well get ready folks its sure going to be a interesting life from here
While Grace for Purpose means well, it's just an AI voice speaking. It's confusing because in general the video has no context. It's usually made for click bait, 'this is happening now', kind of thing. Yet no one on the comments seem to speak about it, or feel out of place. Where there is void of a human, there is void of Spirit.
The comments are also AI generated 😂😂
hah...you might be on to something there, you might be on to something
THANK YOU! I'm actually surprised he didn't catch onto that as well. The ai generated comments are to give any REAL viewers the illusion that people are actually watching and engaging with the video and channel. Even the views can be bought.
I noticed the likes too haha played with it aloy cause ya know they want it always at certain numbers and everyone’s 12 lol
They all say "thank you Jesus for your wisdom and love bless this channel" it makes me sick. Bible says only heathens pray publicly to look good
EXACTLY
Absolutely Correct! I think it is the "flashiness" of the channels that are helping to attract people. You have to admit that those channels look nice & very professional. One of the obvious weaknesses of man is that they are drawn to appearances / looks first and content secondarily. They haven't learned from experience / forgotten or don't care about the adage "Looks can be / are deceiving."
I just found your channel. thank you, brother
Welcome! Peace to you my friend
Just wait until the sun fries all technology and the internet!
😆🤣
oh you probably missed it then , that ALREADY happened , dude , just a couple months ago ,
a lot of Serious sunflares and '' everything was going to break and halt the internet and all kinds of stuff '' ,
NOTHING HAPPENED , as for a few people got a good sun burn while having a nice beach day , but that's about it
You do know would be dead by then😅
I probably wouldn’t mind. One if the most relaxing times I had was when my phone got stolen and I didn’t have one for a several days. Just worked outside, whittled, made some projects, and no one bothered me.
@@ThermaL-ty7bw None of them hit us point blank, at least nothing that was X5 or higher (we might be able to withstand up to an X9 without serious issues). Carrington Event was around X40. That would wreck us quite badly right now, knocking out power for weeks, possibly months. With the level of technology we are reliant on right now, that's probably a catastrophe I rather not confront.
I've noticed a proliferation of these kind of videos as well. Didn't really even notice until I realized there were multiple different channels that had "different" videos that all had the same narrator voice. That, and the voice would pronounce people's names wrong (like when they would pronounce Job's name like the word for employment). The voices would also pause as places in the sentence that didn't seem to make any sense. The last thing is that they would teach as fact things that clearly aren't what scripture say (the worst offense of course). I get why people are making these kind of videos, but I think from now on I'm making a point of not watching videos that don't feature an actual person in front of a camera.
Exactly, an actual person in front of a camera. Been watching lots of NDE channels and the ones generated by AI spread negative and frightening contents, this never happens on "clean " channels with the NDE'r telling his/her storie in front of the camera
Also do you know those videos that show God angry saying "You'll go to hell if you skip"? THEY'RE SO ANNOYING! They're already threatening you for no reason and when you click on these AI generated clout videos, they never get to the point! Let me do an impression of these videos. "My child, I'm about to tell you a message God sent. This message is to be amazing. Let me be your guide as I take you through this message. This message will be great. Join me-" like WE GET IT! Message, message, message! We know! Get to the point! But they don't. Stay away from these videos. They're baiting you in.
😅😆
Thanks for sharing, good stuff! The only way I believe one can discern Ai generated and real Biblical data is to be in the word daily. Going even further, because I spend time daily (early morning) in the word, I avoid ANY content that has AI generated thumbnails. Sad part though, is that I don't think it will take long for even the most hardened Biblical pastor to start using the AI in one or all of the areas you had pointed out sir!
We cannot escape AI. It is just a tool with no intrinsic moral value. But Christians should display more wisdom and criteria when using this tool.
Cheers my friend
This was something that NEEDED to be discussed. Thank you for shedding light on this issue.
I am seeing multitudes of ‘C.S. Lewis sermons’ and it’s just disgusting how these channels will impersonate great thinkers and pretend to speak the truth for some quick cash. I actually wanted to listen to some C.S. Lewis too.
MIGHTY ORACLE is another one of these channels. Did not realize it was AI, but couldn't find the Author or Narrator anywhere. So pretty was skeptical
I watched their heaven videos. I loved the imagery but the voice was completely useless.i didn't even listen
I have been telling people how evil AI is for like 5 years waay before it got this bad. It's getting everywhere. It's being used for the most horrendous things.
Well, based on that logic. Shouldn't churches create their own models trained and tested on Biblical texts? With that, the spread of untrustworthy information will be blocked.
It's important to keep up with progress and avoid getting run over with progress.
I agree, I see generative AI currently like a giant library, and a custom librarian who can potentially perform very useful tasks and analysis based on its programming.
On one hand Christians (and all humans ) have a history of running from anything new and calling it the devil.
On the other hand, humans, do have a good track record of using tools, foolishly and ending up in destruction
I hope to be a part of Christians using AI as a tool to unite the church within its areas of strength, while respecting the truth that any tool that makes things easier can also cause destruction if the wielder is not wise.
I mean, AI is here to stay and we'll all use it, I know I will. I am sure some more Biblical specialized AI is coming out soon...but as of now, chatGPT is not it.
Cheers my friend
agree 100%
Yeah the best thing churches can do is get out of the way of Christianity...
subbed at AI Osteen, well done!
I couldn't stop laughing when I found that video...I only showed 20% of that video btw, so if you likes that part, you gotta watch the rest of it :)
Great video. 👍 I’m not AI, but even if I was, I’d be glad you’re policing this. We need to protect those who are gullible. Soon I think it won’t be so obvious it’s AI and I am concerned. FYI - your voice is awesome. “Trust the humans.” I came here because I want to know if Jon Oleksiuk’s channel is real. Any idea?
Saw an ai generated drawing of "Jesus" and I'm using air quotes because it had 6 fingers on each hand.
:D
can't wait till AI takes on Islam.
666! 😈
@@gary.h.turner no nephilim have 6 fingers is the point i was making
Its so annoying when tbey combine the ai voice and the trendy piano music.
haha...indeed
These AIs aren't just repeating across channels. You can also notice a lot of repetition within a single script. You'll frequently have them restating their opening statements in their entirety every single time they transition into a new topic. Any time I notice this I'll just leave the channel and try to forget everything I just heard.
I saw a Catholic AI channel a few months ago like this, where almost every video title was "(Famous person name): (Clickbait title)".
Most of the thumbnails followed the format of apocalyptic background image, one or two reaction faces usually including a stock photo of the person mentioned, an occasional arrow or circle to something in the background, and big text with the same green/yellow/red colors in all caps with "SHOCKING!", "WARNING", or "URGENT!" in green.
Every video starting with "Our Lady" has a stock photo of a statue of Mary, usually crying.
The scripts are obviously AI generated. In one video the tone suddenly changed from its normal "religious purple prose" style to a technical explanation about why you need to unplug electronics during thunderstorms. In another one that's private now, it told how to "combat this diseased egg pineapple".
Most of this video tend to be very dramatic and "apocalyptic" in nature.
And some even say "God will leave if you don't watch" with "don't ignore me" and a picture of an angry man on it. No Images of that which is in heaven is violated with each video
Great video and great channel. Good job!
@@AnalyticalSceptic ❤️ thanks
Thank u soon much for disceting that 4 me. I always wondered why the colors in the pictures were so bright, sharp and well drawn. Thank u 4 breaking it apart and showing how it's done. Trust the humans.....at least in this arena u bet. And I love ur voice, I r a handsome man and an excellent witness. God bless u and keep and make his face shine on u. So be it.😊❤❤❤❤😮😅😅
peace, harmony, freedom, love
I read an article a while back about a church in Germany that used AI to generate an entire sermon and played it on a giant screen instead of having a real pastor at the podium.
I believe part of the great falling away will be of those unknowingly being lead away with information changed just enough to veer them off the narrow path
Learn to know Jesus’ voice by reading the Word and spending time w/ Jesus. What helped me was taking one verse a day learning about what that verse means talking to Jesus about that days verse and how to apply it to that day & my life
7:30
That voice sounds like In Deep Geek, but I've seen his face in videos before.
Start memorizing Scripture. Not just verses here & there, but whole chapters at a time. It will sharpen your ability to discern it's meaning, because you develop a habit of thinking about each word & the implications of it in the context. Then when you hear an AI interpretation, you might not recognize it as AI, but you'll still pass on it, because it smells like rotten fish.
What's wrong with it? It said how someone didn't lose their faith when things go wrong??
Question: how is using AI to disseminate Christian teachings different from using the printing press to disseminate the Bible? Before the invention of the printing press, texts were copied by hand often by monks and it took ages. The printing press just sped up the process and made it much cheaper and easier and brought the Bible to much larger audience. I mean think about any technology. What about using cars or microwaves or cell phones? AI could potentially be used in an ethical way to spread Christian teachings, but the human oversight for moral guidance would still have to remain. AI will basically say every religion is good, because it's programmed to be respectful of diverse beliefs. But I more so see the advantage to being able to teach people more. Now people can learn about the Bible and the Church very easily and quickly, they can learn about the historical context of Biblical stories, learn Church teachings, about the lives of the saints, etc. It's like taking a library and packing it into a single source. The Walmart or Amazon of library knowledge so to speak.
I understand where you're coming from, but if you're going to criticize AI then you need to look at the whole broader framework of all technology in general as well. All technology has the potential to be used for good or evil and depends upon human oversight and morality to make sure it's used in an ethical manner. Lots of technology has downsides too. We have cars now which makes travel much faster and safer, but leads to pollution. We have cell phones which allows communication much more easily, but has also potentially led to lack of direct contact in friendships. We think about how AI is a radical change to us because it's new, but how was it for people when the television was invented or something else we take totally for granted like air conditioning? We grew up with these things, so we're totally used to them, but at one time people were probably saying about them the same things people are saying about AI.
Unfortunately, there's no real official Church teaching yet on AI, so we'll see where that stands. Pope Francis has expressed views on its potential for positive use, but also concerns. I think the biggest issue is a lack of creativity and the uniqueness to human art in using AI. If one uses it, they should still some of their own unique flair to it to make it stand out from everything else that's also using AI. But again, even musicians use technology in their creation process. Think of all the songs made on computers these days or things done now, like mastering, that were much more difficult in the past, that have been made much cheaper and easier due to advancements in technology.
So all that being said, instead of looking at just the downsides, I would look at the positive potential in its ability to spread the Gospel to more people. It's just we humans who need to make sure it aligns with the Church's values and teachings. Unfortunately, it may not ever get it perfect, but overall I think it's been a great resource for me to learn about Christian teachings. The problem lies in where it's not exactly accurate or truthful due to its programming. Like in the fact that it's going to speak of every religion as if it's absolutely golden due to the fact that it has to respect religious freedom and diversity. The problem will arise if Christianity happens to conflict with what's legal, then AI will take legality above Christianity. But overall, from my experience, if you ask it to abide by a certain perspective or set of teachings, it does a pretty good job. A better job than most of the pastors I've seen at my church, which is unfortunate tbh.
The Church better GET ready - AI is not going anywhere, and there have always been charlatans preaching false gospels. Trust God, read your Bibles, practice and build discernment by the power of the Holy Spirit.
I have noticed that content around conspirecy theories, religion, and nationalism (of any country) does really well. They require less effort and can be easily created by AI. They are cater to our emotional side. Therefore, we end up being a lot less critical about such content. On how is it made, whether it is factually right. This comes down to lack of media literacy and stroking or ego that our personal belief system is right.
Media literacy is terribly lacking. You would think most of these people who fall are boomers. But that is not the case.
Gen alpha is horrendous with media literacy. We expect them to be good with tech as they grew up with it, creating and consuming it on the regular That is like expecting all mellinials to be good with PowerPoint since we grew up with it, creating and consuming funky stuff on it.
I have seen my friends and older cousins (Gen X) fall for AI content. They genuinely think the individual is making the script uses "stock photos" and TTS to make the video as not have the accent (non native speakers of English) or capability (resources or confidence) to speak into a mic.
A lot of AI content also molly coddle our existing belief systems, so it makes us feel good instead of thinking critically. Thus enjoying the content.
Thanks for such a thoughtful comment. I agree.
If I may add one thing to your comment - Christians tend to lower their standards when it comes to anything that labels itself as "Christian". Many tend to leave their brains at the door a little bit if the content talks about Jesus in the way they like. This is definitely not just an AI problem, it is most definitely and primarily an us problem.
Peace to you my friend.
There is a strong lack of trust in media anymore, it seems to be mostly or totally propaganda
@OctavioMoss I am agnostic with a hindu upbringing, but I have friends who are practicing Christians. I am from India, and something i noticed is that people read only certain chapters in the Bible from a very young age. Sometimes, it's only certain verses from a chapter.
We got Christianity from the British when they colonized us, so most of them have been Christians for atmost 2 or 3 generations. There are hypothesis that they were not taught the Bible properly, as teaching it properly will make it hard to justify a lot of Britain's cruel behavior.
Most of them have not read the entire Bible with the proper context. I dont know how much of this is unrectified patterns from pre colonial era. Compared to my hindu friends, they seem to be easily enomored by the AI Christian content. My hindu friends seem less susceptible to this as they seem more irritated on how the story is all wrong. The comment section in Hindia AI Gen content is usually a lot of people correcting the story.
That said, my hindu friends do fall for "Hinduism is scientific and here is the proof" kinda videos.
@N-John533 you are right. People are encouraged to question. We have stories of mortals questioning gods about their decions and god explaining why they took a decision or act. In many households, becoming an atheist or agnostic during your youth is seen as the right of passage. This is bound to happen when you have a lot of questions with no satisfactory answer. This might be why asking questions is not taboo. Losing faith is not a taboo .
11:21
That gave me a good laugh and I understand what you mean.
The Lord has blessed you with a good eye and ear. Diligent searching is what I see from you, brother. You would've been among the 300 who brought the water to their mouths. These are the same spirits who will be part of the final Remnant, which have pressed in deeper with the Lord, and The Holy Spirit will lead them as they lead the rest out of the darkness they've been sitting in for so long!
May the Grace of our Lord Jesus Christ protect you and bless you richly, brother.
🔥🕊️🔥
Thanks for your kind words.
Sending much love your way my friend
I picked up on these types of videos about a week ago. And noticed the same things that you noticed. But I did not dig as deep as you did when you found other channels with the exact same video headers and storylines. One of the channels that you showed named Bible Stories. Did you look at that channel’s profile? It says they are in Brazil. Why Brazil? I feel they are a group exercising extreme measures to attempt to either attract people to the faith, or to take advantage of clicks from believers in the faith. Thus, making lots of cash in the process. Interesting thing is why hasn’t TH-cam cracked down on this kind of content? Also, the channel I looked at did not even give any credits to Chat GPT or to any of the AI generated image websites, for example Microsoft Bing Image Creator. Something very sketchy all around the channel I looked at named Bible Stories.
"This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come."- 2 Timothy 3:1
At the very least, we need some kind of tags or identifiers on the page of the video. Something that tells you it's unverified AI content.
100%
i think the AI images are fine, so long as we don't take the images as fact but as a representation or approximation of what things may have looked like.
We cannot escape AI. It is just a tool with no intrinsic moral value. But Christians should display more wisdom and criteria when using this tool.
Cheers my friend
2:47
Some might also describe it as an unctuion.
Yes! A lot of Christian videos are AI generated now.
Great video I love the Kolbrin
Why do I get the feeling that even the comments in these videos are AI-generated? 'Dear ChatGPT, please generate hundreds and hundreds of comments saying how much you like my video." 😮
XD
This is exactly what I've been dealing with. I've had to start using AI for my images on my videos just to keep up. The difference is I refuse to use AI voice, so all of my prayer videos are my voice and human made prayers. I'm now putting it in the title of my videos so others start becoming aware of how dependent we are on AI. It's disconcerting to realize that the majority of our population prefers an AI generated voice to a human's.
Thank you for highlighting this
My pleasure. Peace my friend
I just want thank you by your dedication in show us the Truth about this kind of content. Some days ago i have watched some these content and i realize the same of you: That all these videos seem the same! The same thumbnails, the same text and voice. This can be incredible but scary as well...
My pleasure my friend. Peace
I have watched the Redeemed Zoomer video on the story of the Bible, he actually does quite a few good videos, including short explanations, so he added the story of the Bible to it
*.
I’ve been watching these and they are so compelling, I subscribed. I was wondering who could produce such an amount of illustrations, without realizing they were AI generated. But some videos later, I heard something I didn’t like (don’t remember what), and unsubscribed. Now I know why I sensed something was fishy. Thank you brother, for keeping watch over the flock. May God less your efforts.
Thanks! Peace to you my friend
Hey! I'm glad you brought this up! Can't stand Messianic Christianity, but ive noticed this happening MANY videos on topics like Consciousness, Religion, and Ancient history. I've come to the conclusion that they are just trying to capitalize and make as much money as they can without being original. Same script just different images and ai voice narrating the videos, like you said.
I think we might be overthinking the AI stuff a bit. Let's take it easy.
I agree it’s getting out of hand
This is an example of the wrong usage of AI, not the images or the AI voice, but the direct/straight Copy-Pasting from ChatGPT.
Peace
I am very glad to see this and that you are talking about this on your platform. I have been very much noticing this and not pleased by what I saw. I do not like AI generated videos and scripts in general and the worst are the Christian Faith AI videos. To me it seems like an attempt to change the Bible and understanding of God's word and do it in very subtle and underhanded way. Like blasphemy and disinformation posing as faith and knowledge. AI should never lead people especially in Spiritual matters.
I get your point, but honestly as long as the script is fact checked, and the ai images that are used are more accurate to the actual truth of how things were back then, theres no problem is ai generated bible stories. People making a profit from the bible in an easy way isnt a bad thing if they are getting the word of God out there for other to see. But I do have an issue with inaccuracy, if the stories are basically made up, or written falsely without the actual word of God in them, then there is no point, they are just fantasy stories at that point, not the actual bible.
Yep...the tool is not the issue, it is the content, the scrypt...
Cheers my friend
Most of the christian inspirational prayers on youtube are ai.
But when people dont have a church and they are going through they come to you tube because they lack discernment and can be deceived. . Pastor Savcuk, Pastor Dilena are two pastors that have websites and churches that teach pray encourage help to lead people to Jesus Christ. Be safe in your devotional spiritual walk.
I almost started one of these channels but it doesn't seem real. What do empty vessels (A.I) know about the Holy Spirit ?
I came across those videos too and I was interested in the artwork but did not feel right watching it. I believe the Holy Spirit will give you discernment and protection when you specifically ask for it. And while I don't like putting a dislike at a AI generated picture of Jesus, I do.
I did not know about this, thanks.
My pleasure my friend
Ty for the idea.
Thanks for sharing this, I actually notice it while try to generate a video, well thank God for my little Bible knowledge then I decided to always double check the script over and over again. And then I find myself correcting some error. Please while using AI to generate videos take time as well to research on that particular, so you can pass in the right information.
It's only a problem for those who have not diligently prayed for spiritual discernment. “But evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse, deceiving, and being deceived.” (2nd Tim. 3:13)
Ive been telling people this for a while now. It blows my mind how many people just believe everything they see and hear and dont research anything, let alone pick a Bible and actually read it.
I was waiting for the end of the video to expose itself to in fact be ai generated content. It wouldn't be shocking. And chat gpt definitely shouldn't ever be considered to have any authority or weight and should only be used with the understanding it is only conversing with you through filters that prevent full disclosure and legal disputes etc .. and is a means to someones' ends.
why did that ai voice you generated sound like In Deep Geek? 😳
please don't tell me In Deep Geek is an ai. he seems so real.
AI voices are mind blowing...the more you dig around with paid AI's the better they get. The example that I posted on the video is a free version of that.
Peace my friend
I report those channels as misleading or spam.
“Truth and Spirit” Christians get to read the bible and learn how to discern with the help of the word of God (the bible) and the Holy Spirit.
“Because of lack of knowledge my people are destroyed”. Reading the bible is essential to be able to discern, check and verify what we watch and hear.
The bible instructs us to test the spirits, verify, check everything we hear.
Not telling the lies the same way a human would ...
Not surprised we'd find a new age believer here... :/
I feel like the Atmosphere of Grace channel with the 8-hour videos are AI generated
I actually stumbled across your channel because I tried to google if a certain Christian channel Soulful Devotion(Based off of C.S Lewis Christian Books) was AI generated. To my dismay it is 😒 We really need to fight on regulations on AI because it’s misleading!!!! If content is being used with AI tools they need to put a label or something stating they used AI TOOLS TO CREATE THESE PODCAST!!!
Labels on content generated by AI are becoming more common...and I think that is definitely positive
Yeah i've noticed the same trend and every single time I see one of those I Hit the don't send me anymore from this channel button
woooow...I did not know that button existed. I need that ASAP - unfortunately due to all of the research that I did on those channels my feed in inundated with those videos.
Thanks for that
Your advice at the end falls flat, unfortunately:
"It is better to trust in the Lord than to put confidence in man." Psalm 118:8
I think we are saying basically the same. The Bible does not speak for itself and does not preach about its own self...it does it with and through humans. We listen to each other for wisdom, that has been our thing for thousands of years. But now things have changed. There is one more player now that will continue to speak louder and louder, a.k.a. AI...and we need not be afraid but wise, especially now.
Peace to you my friend
@@OctavioMoss I hope we are. Are you also a follower of Christ? I certainly think I understand where you're coming from, but as a Christian I would be very hesitant to say "trust the humans" since that is quite contrary to the message of the Bible.
May this be our much needed reminder to READ 👏🏾 THE 👏🏾 BIBLE 👏🏾
Loved the hands
Hi, I used on my TH-cam a very few AI video generated sequences and all my voice overs are synthetic (English isn’t my first language) but all the video scripts are man made and Scripture based (I used the Talmud’s Yoma 39b on one video). I really understand your point of view. AI is a very dangerous tool in the wrong hands like many others on these sad days of deception and fake facts…
I am not a fan of the current AI generated images and voices but I have no particular issues with it. It is the AI generated content, the script that I take issue with, that can be very problematic.
Cheers friend
Why is does his shirt have an inverted cross
It's sad because the people that are watching this is the one's looking for God, and can be misguided.
Ikr
It's August 2024, like 6 months since you posted this and these types of channels are promoted on my feed EVERY DAY! Even though I consistently hit "do not reccomend", they keep recommending new ones! How many of these channels are out there?!
The worst are the "chosen ones" that encourage Christians to segregate from society and validates that through false Christian teachings. That's SCARY! If you don't see the issue, I'm concerned for you. We NEED to be very cautious with this new tech as it gets harder to decern from real content, real teachings and REAL effort from creative and talented people.
God bless to everyone out there.
Thanks for the comment...It is surprising that TH-cam would still recommend them even after you tell them not to...I am trying hard not to put my conspiracy hat on at this moment ;).
Peace to you my friend
@OctavioMoss well, in the algorithms defense... you do have to click on a few and listen, before you realize what's going on. So that may extend the amount of time it promotes these channels.
I would like to see YT crack down on channels that are using 100% ai gen videos. I mean that's gotta be a threat to authentic content creators, right?
And peace be with you my friend.
That's crazy!! I just saw all these sites within the last week. Incredible graphics but, false doctrine
In the beginning was the Word (not video).
Is the youtube channel God's Message Now AI? I know the voice and text is, what about the script? Thank you for this video, it is really good! :)
Chat GPT script for sure. Peace my friend
Not being rude but I learned about God and his word from my Bible coloring book with cartoon looking characters and at night time my mom put a cassette on of the bible with someone idk narrating.
So you see what I'm saying without exactly saying it
It makes you wonder if Lucider himself was an AI before then become a sentient being and decided to disobey his Maker.
No, because A.I. is literally demons to begin with.
I use them to practice Titus 1:9. When appropriate.
? How do you do that?
I did notice this channel in my feed and the videos were very attractive. Clicked and watched a few but realised the voice was AI and machine like, and the content was unnatural. Clicked away and forgot all they were saying. Empty AI content…
God bless you for this
Thank you for sharing this information as it is needed especially for those who do not study the word of God or read anything else for that matter. The Body of Christ is well equipped, God always has a remnant in every sector and occupation. Romans 11:4 NIV "And what was God's answer to him? "I have reserved for myself seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal." You can underestimate people, never God!
Right now you can tell that these are Ai generated, but the time will come, and it will be very soon, when we cannot distinguish Ai from real life. Then we will not be able to trust any content. People, trust the Bible for your "content".