Cows actually benefit the environment. Horses turn grasslands into deserts. Horses are an invasive species that harm the environment for native species. I can tell by the comments that 99% of you live in the city and have no real understanding of horses effects on the environment.
All I can say is no - this is so wrong in so many ways. Just so you all know where these horses are going after getting rounded up: slaughterhouses. It’s happened before - and it’ll keep happening. I love how they make this seem “okay”.
The western wild lands are in a severe drought. Horses are an introduced " invasive species" that destroy the environment for native species. Yes they need to be culled. Horses turn grasslands into deserts. That is just the hard truth. Environmental problems are not solved with drawing pictures of unicorns and rainbows
@@snakey973 It means ranchers make use of federal lands that are suitable for no other purpose and produce food for the country as a result. Feral horses just eat the grass, drink the water and produce zero benefits to anyone from it. They are parasites in that environment.
Another government lie, those horse do not look emaciated at all, proof there's plenty of resources for them!!! Show your proof that there's not enough resources!!
@@GardeninGrace If they removed 90% there would still be to many. Horses are an invasive species that harm the environment for native plants and animals. There is too many period.
Again, we’re talking about a non-native species that shouldn’t even exist here. When the government culls or controls the spread of feral pigs, asian carp, zebra mussels, and other non-native species, nobody says a thing, but because it’s a horse, suddenly it’s wrong. Interesting.
This breaks my heart. The majority of these beautiful free horses will be killed/sent to the horse meat factories. Their meat is a high commodity in parts of Europe. There is one such factory in rural south Missouri. Years ago I was able to rescue (for $) a horse and a donkey that were rounded up out west and at final auction before going to their death. This is just horrific:(
There are no plants processing horses in the US as the government has not allocated funds to pay government inspectors for such plants. Horses are shipped either to Canada or Mexico for processing.
If there are over 82,000 running wild that doesn't add up to them killing the "majority" of them for years. Overpopulation leads to starvation and sickness, that's bad for the horses just as it is for deer and rabbits.
@@karolanoble2858 From the USDA: ask.usda.gov/s/article/Is-Horse-meat-slaughtered-or-sold-in-the-US That plant in Missouri wanted a license to slaughter horses but it never went through.
This was probably filmed in the Twin Peaks HMA, an area set aside for wild horses and burros on the CA-NV border. Overpopulation means more horses than allowed by plan, not more horses than the land can support. The BLM assigns most of their food to privately owned livestock. When the horses consume more than their allocated share of the forage, usually around 20% of the total, helicopters restore the imbalance. The BLM rep is correct: Helicopters are the fastest and most efficient way of shifting resources back to the public-lands ranchers. They "manage" the horses to protect the ranchers, not the other way around.
They could control the breeding but they won't do it. These horses are not going to have a good end. They will not be pets, they are going to slaughter even if not directly. There are groups that bid on them at auction and sell them to Mexico for slaughter. We have to remember that there is also a drought and that creates problems for everyone. Also, sagebrush is disappearing and it's effecting the entire ecosystem. Fire has burned and burned so hot the roots were killed and cheat grass is taking over. That grass burns like crazy.
Always nice to have informed and reasonable comments on TH-cam. One way to help the "wild" horses is to stop eating beef. There has been some progress towards that for the sake of better human health (less meat, especially beef). The cattlemen's associations have been and are still very, very powerful politically; they are getting something for nothing and they want to keep it that way. To counter that all we can do is vote Democratic instead of Republican.
@@seanthe100 Exactly. A old cattle rancher we used to buy our hay from once told me that you can support 7 cows on the same size piece of land it takes to support 1 horse.
@@seanthe100 That’s between 177 HMAs,meaning an average of just 463 horses per.. & that’s on 26.9 million acres.That used to be 329 HMAs on 53.8 million acres,before the blm zeroed those out. The wild horses graze on just 17% of blm rangelands,where they are vastly outnumbered by livestock.They are being removed from the land that was designated for them by Congress,to make room for greedy welfare ranchers to graze sheep & cattle.Livestock graze 50-65% of the annual forage production,leaving less than half for the native species like elk,mule deer,sage grouse & the horses.
@@pedalingprospector2007 problem is,the land was designated for the horses,but they’re being removed to make room for cattle & sheep that shouldn’t be there.
@@seanthe100 not true, they evolved with native species in North America and are cospecies, good for other species, do not compete with other native specie. Even the retired blm director testified in court to that fact. 82k if that is how many out there (unverified) is one horse per hundreds of acres.
Cattle ranchers insist that the horses be removed so that the ranchers can use public lands for their private businesses (cattle ranching). Horses are removed and cattle are moved in.
Wild horses are not native to the Americas- they were introduced by Spanish colonizers in the 1500’s. Because of their importance to native tribes since then and their symbolic importance for the American west, congress passed a law protecting their existence as wild animals, but their populations must be managed to avoid overgrazing and degrading the natural environment.
@@HOHLfmly and human beings are also degrading the environment. That’s a separate issue. One of the ways we are degrading the landscape, however, is recklessly introducing nonnative species into various regions for our own convenience/amusement. This is no different than the issue of invasive feral cats in Hawaii or rabbits it Australia. Each species destroys the habitat for native species and must be kept in check.
They are not wild, they are feral animals just like feral cats and pigs and they destroy the true wildlife. They do not have natural predators or population control.
Animals need to be managed or they all die if they consume all there resources Shows how removed you are from reality. Why don't you do something productive and adopt one then? Nope, didn't think so.
They aren't wild animals. They are feral domestic horses. If they were dogs we'd call 'em strays. Most of them probably started out with owners or come down within a generation or two from owned horses. They are nothing special. If rather than having them bumming loose on federal land they were owned by some guy named Frank Johnson and allowed to roam loose on his fenced property the same way - stallions fighting over mares, mares having foals every year, no ready supply of food, drinking brackish water where they can find it, no shelter in bad weather, no worming or medical care, no farrier care, horses are ignored and you can't get near them if they are sick or injured - your sort would be the first to run to the authorities and complain about animal neglect and want ol' Frank arrested and fined. But having those same horses running loose on federal lands? Oh, wow! They suddenly turn into magnificent wild animals that need to be left alone, protected and admired as a symbol of our country's heritage, the soul of the Wild West! >:-(
@@DoubleDogDare54 - And yet, it's okay for human's cattle to go grazing on lands without issue. It's the same with Deer. We destroy the their forest habitat and we think, they will just move on to another forest. However, we are at the juncture where there isn't any where else for them to go. So they stay, which happens to be the lawn of the McMansion that was just plopped down on their former home and are labeled pests. The forest that is left is so overrun that they are starving to death. So hunts are planned to cull the herds. And damn if those sanctimonious people cry about the brutality of that. Hypocrites one and all, because the truth about why it is that Mustangs, deer and other wildlife don't have enough space to live is because the locust human beings that we are. We are killing ourselves in the process of doing it, as we need them ecologically.
I bet you would be the first to complain if herds got slimmed down by starvation or sickness. Or better yet get on and run on your own property. Land can only sustain so much , why do you think they controll the population of Bison in Yellowstone park. there is nothing worse then see any animal starv to death , or from diseases.
"You think you own whatever land you land on. The Earth is just a dead thing you can claim. But I know every rock and tree and creature Has a life, has a spirit, has a name. " Colors of the wind
You know they aren’t wild right? They are non native species that destroy environments of other native species ground nesting birds and native plants are the most visible but you can’t just add new creatures especially big creatures without dire consequences for the rest of the web
So, they run out of forage and their water supply dries up, you still want them left alone and you'll tell people to keep their hands off those horses and let nature take its course?
@@DoubleDogDare54 Animals have survived thousands of years just fine without help from us. They’ll figure it out. But humans…..we have to be in control of everything 🙄
@@Sarah-lb8cs A few years back I watched a video from Australia where large numbers of brumbies died around dried up water holes during a drought. That is what people will have to be okay with if you want nature to self regulate the population of feral horses out west.
I would definitely would not mind riding a horse to the grocery store . There’s so many Native American reservations in need of horses . Oh yeah I forgot the federal government can help with gathering the horses to relocating where they are needed .
Then how come reservations don't ask for them . They get the Buffalo that gets removed from the herds of Buffalo from Yellowstone park. And go ahead ride a horse to the grocery store, more power to you . I just hope if you own that horse, you take good care of it, that is including shots and deworming.
A number of Native Americans raise their own wild horses, and sadly some do not take good care of them and allow them to continue to breed indiscriminately in captivity. Nor do they get the vet care they need. I know of at least two outside families who buy horses from a reservation in Arizona and then rehab and train these horses before then finding them good homes. It's more of a rescue operation when they take in these horses off the reservations, and they always wish they could afford to save more of them.
They break up the families, injure the horses, corral them too closely & then they get sick & die. Like in CO, where over 100 horses died from equine flu.
Horses have been bred to be driven for thousands of years. It's not a bunch of Miles City, MT community college rodeo kids flying the helicopters, so relax.
They are kept in deplorable conditions and a significant amount have died from lack of vaccinations WHILE IN their facilities. If they are endangered, the management practices should NOT be a cause of death or injury, period.
What is needed is a hunting season for these horses. Have a hunting season instead of rounding them up and penning them on BLM facilities for the rest of their lives. Then no more roundups. The horses can live their wild, untamed lives until a hunter with a rifle and scope harvests those horses and fills his freezer with a half ton of organic caballo. The state issues the tags and gets money out of it instead of spending money on the roundups and feeding these bangtails after they are caught. Designate the month of October for horse hunting. The foals are done with the mares by then and hunters can harvest whatever they can get in the crosshairs.
@@DoubleDogDare54 Sadly at least 50 wild horses were shot to death, left to die or were injured in Arizona's Apache Sitgreaves National Forest in October. The killers didn't make sure they were dead, they didn't get a ticket from the state to approve of the killings or even take them out of the park. They left fractured horse familes and dead horses for any member of the public to find.
There is a proven birth control that the BLM basically refuses to use to a large degree. It's an injection that is shot into mares. It's much less cost than roundups and allows horses to stay on the range with their herds.
“Oh the poor wild horses, leave them alone.” What about the poor wildlife these FERAL animals are competing with? The waterways they’re destroying, the landscape they’re overgrazing? Don’t their lives and welfare matter? Feral horses are not wild horses, they are not native here. Equus ferus caballus is not native to North America and never was, it did not evolve here, it is an introduced invasive species. True native equines like equus lambei and equus simplicidens are long extinct and didn’t even resemble modern horses, their closest equivalent resemblance would be with tarpans, onagers and zebra, and they belonged to a much different environment. Arguing that feral horses are natural to the land and therefore belong here with their numbers unchecked would be the same as arguing for the introduction of elephants and African lions into North America. Mastodons and Columbia. mammoths once lived here did they not? One of the primary predators of the wild equines here was panthera leo atrox, therefore the only natural way to keep feral horse populations in check would be to introduce the closest equivalent predator that once roamed here, prides of lions. That would be insane, as insane as demanding that wild horse populations be left alone because they’re “wild and belong here.”
What's with wild horses. Who and what are they bothering? I hope these people who doing this are charged with cruelty to añimals . It's all about money to the government.
The herds increase at around 20% a year. If these bangtails eat down all the grass and their water sources dry up with the drought conditions in the West, will your sort be willing to let Nature take its course and have these horses die off due to starvation and lack of water? Can't have it both ways. If they need the help of humans to survive, they aren't wild animals and need to be removed from these areas . If they are wild animals, impose a hunting season on them and let starvation and lack of water take care of the rest of the problem, like with any other wild animal.
So when the government controls the spread of feral pigs (boar), is it still cruelty? Or is it because this non-native species is one people are fond of, that it then becomes a symbol of animal cruelty. Horses do not naturally occur in the American wilderness, they are merely domestic animals set loose who now cause imbalance on an ecosystem not designed for their presence.
@@Lakota828 Cattle and sheep pay their way. We eat them. Feral horses do not pay their way and are parasites on grazing land leased to ranchers that supply food to this country. Feral horses are not native wild animals like deer and elk. They are stray domestic livestock with no owners other than the BLM. As the BLM owns them, the BLM can do with them as they think best. And they think it is best to round them up, remove them from federal lands and sell them off to whoever wants them. So, this is not a matter of nature regulating itself as it is up to the BLM to call the shots. Deal with it.
They talked about using helicopters and motorized vehicles, the problem is according to Annie's law and the federal government THIS IS AGAINST THE LAW! #ANNIE'S LAW
This is disgusting and just so heart breaking - I hope people know and understand not only these horses are robbed of their home and their families get broken up - and being chased by helicopters is tramatic enough but most of them get treated terribly, and have to endure cruel humans - some that don't get sold or display potential to work for humans will get sold as 'meat' for human consumption and b/c US has banned horse meat - they get put on trains to endure horrible 2 to 3,000 mile journey to Mexico - many of them die from injuries and thirst (since they're bound for slaughter, they seldom get water or food - just the bare minimum) - I hope people understand we take their homes for animal agriculture - to make 'meat' for our food from animals (it's the same for chopping down rainforests) - if you love animals, if you have an ounce of compassion in your heatr - please stop being the cog in animal agriculture or testing or sporting (hunting), or skin-trade or illegal wild animal exports, anything that exploits and hurts animals - please be their protectors and champions
Spent almost half a billion dollars in 5 years...wtf??? To "manage" by human intervention what horses have been doing on their own for thousands of years...survive.
not if the international corporations country of registration is not in the US. eg: sp+ US made $5billion in revenue and only paid 14Million in fed. taxes for us based managers. than add all the tax payer subsidies those ranchers get, nope does not add up to the cost of removing wildlife.
We can identify and manage the heard growth with animals but why can’t we do this with humans….. there are far way to many people here on this earth…… I think we need to have a cap on how many kids we have……. We are like an infestation, we are so wasteful. Resources, metals, water, vegetation, food etc. horses don’t have that issues, but us humans do.
Just give it time most developed nations are not growing, even china is about to max out in a couple of years the human population is maxing out within the next century and decreasing.
That’s a horrible way to control resources. Killing 20k wild horses and burros are disgusting especially when this was their land. People need to stop using excess water like in swimming pools and having outrageous landscaping requiring lots of water. Everyone on the internet can look up ways to do their own part in preserving resources. Horses are majestic and they want and deserve their freedom. Surely, humans can understand that. The stress put on those horses being wrangled up and corralled is terrifying to them. Humans are going to cause every animal on Earth to be killed because they are greedy and selfish.
So basically the truth is that the horses are being rounded up to benefit the land for the beef cattle farmer. Nice. A balance cannot be found? Such as gelding male horses & then releasing them back?
The major issue which they just glanced over in this video is the reason why they’re rounding up the horses is because the government is leasing out the land that the horses were living on to cattle farmers. If the horses were still given the public land they always had we would not need to be rounding them up to keep them in holding for the rest of their lives, and the holding facilities are not pretty they’re thousands of horses in pens with little to know grass.
Lol, the federal government litterally killed off the few native horses that survived the ice age, so they could claim them all as invasive. Some tribes were very outspoken about this, and they are all gone now.
More humane method and environmentally friendly approach: Employ the cowboys! But the downside? It's bad for business, bad for the economy because you don't spend on gas fuels and don't sign up with helicopter contractors which means...no kickbacks for politicians...hehehe...just saying.
He's lying! The helicopter is terrorizing and they don't want to sit on a horse to round up those horses. They're so terrorized the horses and babies have heart attacks.
Unfortunately if you let them over populate they will destroy the range there on and then all those animal's will will starfe to death,and that's a horrible way to die. You need to remember there's no natural predators to keep the hearts down.
This is a very long standing problem between cattle ranchers and the wild horses. Do you eat steak, burgers? Any beef products? Cattle need large quantities of land to feed. Horses require just as much of not more. They are competing for limited resources, especially with the severe drought the West is experiencing.
@@kittyday1402 my point. They shouldn't be able to let their cattle graze on BLM land. So it is the cattle ranchers and the BLM allows them use the land set aside for wild animals. They started rounding up wild mustangs in Nevada in the 70s. It is wrong, just wrong.
I use to live in NV around a lot of those horses. You cant see them at night when driving on roads at high speed. But the horses feed the mountian lions. So that saves the cattle
I like the idea of cowboys preferably women. I do recall a movie of a young woman who did the corralling of the horses in the seventies or eighties. What percent for inoculations of strangles? And why did the shots get overlooked this spring? Why no shots?
Not sure why the stories of the horses starving and dying of thirst aren’t making the mainstream media? Every year horses starve and drought out due to miss management by Blm
The fact that people get upset about this is infuriating because you think they are cute well horses are non native and die terrible deaths on the range nobody cares when we do this with pigs but horses are sacred …no they are free meat
We originally had 86,000 free roaming wild horses and burros. 4,000 left? That is going to lead to immense inbreeding and low gene pools, and practically no symbol of freedom left. This drastic change summarizes how the government values the freedom of both animal and man. The Bureau of Land Management is going to take in far more horses than it knows what to do with and simultaneously violating the 1971 Wild Horses and Burros Act. Somehow we have children skipping meals and yet we have more than enough taxpayers dollars to export many of these horses to Mexico, where they will be turned into dog food. The hypocrisy is truly blood boiling.
What’s really blood boiling is the fact that you’re worried about a population of non-native animals that cause harm to an ecosystem instead of funneling your anger and passion towards native species who are truly threatened such as the bison or wolf. Maybe if people like you stopped worrying about protecting something that is harmful, then we could spend our time protecting species that actually need our help, instead of a freaking farm animal.
These are not a native species. We created this mess so we need to fix it. God has tasked us with being good stewards of his creation and letting invasive species we introduced destroy the native ecosystem is not that. This is similar to the wild rabbit infestations of Australia or the wild cat infestations of Hawaii. Fortunately, wild horses are much easier to manage.
I loved the idea of letting cowboys round them up. What’s the rush of rushing to round up these beautiful animals. If they allow people to live on the land to take care of the horses, then there would be no need for adoptions. With all of those millions of dollars they could pay cowboys well enough to save the horses and manage the land. I say there’s an underbelly to this and they want that land to build stuff we don’t need so they can make even more money than they do now. Greed always plays a part in an innocent scenario like this. We see you.
No its not a good idea most of the horses are going to the slaughter houses just like cows that is one of the things the government is trying to cover up
Wild Horses have far exceeded their numbers, we can legally hunt deers, bears, alligators and others but horses are off limit. Americas special interest is driving this country into the ground.
82000 horses is a lot of horses. I can see why culling may be best for them. In comparison, deer' life span are around 4.5yrs, while a wild horse's is 15yrs. That means they reproduce at rates that aren't balanced by natural deaths within the species. That eventually leads to interbreeding, disease and starvation, especially with the increase in climate change and wild fires. I think it's really the humane thing to do.
If there was 82k, is a drop in the bucket compared to the millions of deer. And the 20% they say is their high potential spreadsheet growth number and has never been proven. The Ac. of Sciences did a thorough research and found the average closer to 5% growth, because horses self regulate. There are a few herds that have proven self reg. meaning if there is few resources they have fewer foals, abundant resources than more. 82k is how many they already have taken through the years to hold in a holding pen.
This has nothing to do with humane treatment of horses. It's all for cattle ranchers who have practically free grazing rights on millions of acres of government land
Most of these go to slaughter. I have seen huge truck loads from lower 48 going thru port in anchorage alaska. Transported in open semi trucks with no food and water in all kinds of weather. Contact your reps and senators. Wildlife management the ultimate contradiction of terms
Wildlife management? I’m sorry but feral horses are not “wildlife”. They are non-native and should t exist in the wild at all, they are merely domestic animals set loose.
The horses are not slaughtered- it explains the adoption process in the video. It’s also worth noting that horses are not native to this particular part of God’s creation, but rather were introduced by the Spanish in the 1500’s. We manage their populations today to prevent overgrazing and soil degradation.
They are domestic horses. If you take these horses, break them to saddle, they are simply any other horse, just like all the other horses in Father God's creation. They are nothing special or out of the ordinary. Get over it.
Over grazing from wild burros and horses is a real problem. They are not native and they eat all the food that the native deer, elk, antelope, and bighorn sheep need. The burros actually try to scare away native species from watering holes. Managing herd size is essential, otherwise there is not enough food and animals starve…which is not exactly humane
China, Poland, Germany, Indonesia, Switzerland, Japan, Mexico along with other countries LOVE EATING horse meat. True! There have been stories in the past of so-called private individuals buying these beautiful, wild animals from the US Government, only to sell them, & have them end up, sadly, on some foreigner’s dinner table. Unacceptable! The US Government has a MORAL obligation to do a BETTER job of TRACKING these horses once they are SOLD! PERIOD!!!
And in South America Guinea Pigs aren't pets. They're a meat animal for locals like chickens. I get your emotional attachment to horses. But across the world people EAT MEAT. Different kinds of meat. Whatever easily available.
The fact that cattle are taking up the grazing land that used to be the Mustangs is the bottom line. Money. It’s always about money with people.
Cows actually benefit the environment. Horses turn grasslands into deserts. Horses are an invasive species that harm the environment for native species. I can tell by the comments that 99% of you live in the city and have no real understanding of horses effects on the environment.
THAT O MIGHTY DOLLAR
It's Not about the Horses, it's about Taking control of The Land to make a Financial Profit. Just a matter of time.
They aren’t native
@@sacramentofoodforest neither are you!!!!
All I can say is no - this is so wrong in so many ways.
Just so you all know where these horses are going after getting rounded up: slaughterhouses.
It’s happened before - and it’ll keep happening. I love how they make this seem “okay”.
It's so sad people doesn't see what's really happening right in front of them
The western wild lands are in a severe drought. Horses are an introduced " invasive species" that destroy the environment for native species. Yes they need to be culled. Horses turn grasslands into deserts. That is just the hard truth. Environmental problems are not solved with drawing pictures of unicorns and rainbows
That’s not true.
The cattle farmers think it’s ok
@@jacobbwalters8133 than tell us
No I am not buying it; not one of those horses look like they are starving.
This breaks my heart. Many horse families are broken up forever.
Life is tough all over. Deal with it.
Not to mention broken legs.
better than starvation.
If we weren't here to make sure there is enough public land for private cattle operations to graze...
Cattle serve a useful purpose. Feral horses do not.
Cattle are benificial, horses not so much. And ask the Navajo, fiftyK or so are denuding their sheep ranges and those horses arn't in the BLM number
@@DoubleDogDare54 you mean cattle make money for a private individual by grazing PUBLIC land? That's how they are beneficial? 😅
@@snakey973 It means ranchers make use of federal lands that are suitable for no other purpose and produce food for the country as a result. Feral horses just eat the grass, drink the water and produce zero benefits to anyone from it. They are parasites in that environment.
@@DoubleDogDare54 Many people eat horses.
Another government lie, those horse do not look emaciated at all, proof there's plenty of resources for them!!! Show your proof that there's not enough resources!!
Ikr
We saw a few horses...not most of them.
They make money off sending them to slaughterhouses to make meat and animal feed. Same with sending them to auction houses.
@@GardeninGrace If they removed 90% there would still be to many. Horses are an invasive species that harm the environment for native plants and animals. There is too many period.
Horse’s are Indians and Cattle are White Men still stealing land.
We adopted wild horses in 2000s…I hope more people can adopt!
The adoption program is a scam.
TH-cam hid the reply above mine, what does it say?
Even the animals ain’t free 😂😂😂🤦🏾♂️Government control wow
Again, we’re talking about a non-native species that shouldn’t even exist here. When the government culls or controls the spread of feral pigs, asian carp, zebra mussels, and other non-native species, nobody says a thing, but because it’s a horse, suddenly it’s wrong. Interesting.
The last part of the video showed a very young foal trying to keep up, sickening
This breaks my heart. The majority of these beautiful free horses will be killed/sent to the horse meat factories. Their meat is a high commodity in parts of Europe. There is one such factory in rural south Missouri. Years ago I was able to rescue (for $) a horse and a donkey that were rounded up out west and at final auction before going to their death. This is just horrific:(
There are no plants processing horses in the US as the government has not allocated funds to pay government inspectors for such plants. Horses are shipped either to Canada or Mexico for processing.
If there are over 82,000 running wild that doesn't add up to them killing the "majority" of them for years. Overpopulation leads to starvation and sickness, that's bad for the horses just as it is for deer and rabbits.
@@DoubleDogDare54 Desloge .Missouri
@@karolanoble2858
From the USDA:
ask.usda.gov/s/article/Is-Horse-meat-slaughtered-or-sold-in-the-US
That plant in Missouri wanted a license to slaughter horses but it never went through.
@@DoubleDogDare54 It did and still does. You truly don't believe everything the government tells you, right?
This was probably filmed in the Twin Peaks HMA, an area set aside for wild horses and burros on the CA-NV border. Overpopulation means more horses than allowed by plan, not more horses than the land can support. The BLM assigns most of their food to privately owned livestock. When the horses consume more than their allocated share of the forage, usually around 20% of the total, helicopters restore the imbalance. The BLM rep is correct: Helicopters are the fastest and most efficient way of shifting resources back to the public-lands ranchers. They "manage" the horses to protect the ranchers, not the other way around.
True
The BLM needs to be desolved right along with the BIA!
Thank you.
They could control the breeding but they won't do it. These horses are not going to have a good end. They will not be pets, they are going to slaughter even if not directly. There are groups that bid on them at auction and sell them to Mexico for slaughter.
We have to remember that there is also a drought and that creates problems for everyone. Also, sagebrush is disappearing and it's effecting the entire ecosystem. Fire has burned and burned so hot the roots were killed and cheat grass is taking over. That grass burns like crazy.
Always nice to have informed and reasonable comments on TH-cam. One way to help the "wild" horses is to stop eating beef. There has been some progress towards that for the sake of better human health (less meat, especially beef). The cattlemen's associations have been and are still very, very powerful politically; they are getting something for nothing and they want to keep it that way. To counter that all we can do is vote Democratic instead of Republican.
Why don't they just leave them alone?
82,000 is way too many for them to coexist with native species
@@seanthe100 Exactly. A old cattle rancher we used to buy our hay from once told me that you can support 7 cows on the same size piece of land it takes to support 1 horse.
@@seanthe100 That’s between 177 HMAs,meaning an average of just 463 horses per.. & that’s on 26.9 million acres.That used to be 329 HMAs on 53.8 million acres,before the blm zeroed those out. The wild horses graze on just 17% of blm rangelands,where they are vastly outnumbered by livestock.They are being removed from the land that was designated for them by Congress,to make room for greedy welfare ranchers to graze sheep & cattle.Livestock graze 50-65% of the annual forage production,leaving less than half for the native species like elk,mule deer,sage grouse & the horses.
@@pedalingprospector2007 problem is,the land was designated for the horses,but they’re being removed to make room for cattle & sheep that shouldn’t be there.
@@seanthe100 not true, they evolved with native species in North America and are cospecies, good for other species, do not compete with other native specie. Even the retired blm director testified in court to that fact. 82k if that is how many out there (unverified) is one horse per hundreds of acres.
why are you taking them away from these public lands!! why? I don't understand ,what are they using these lands for? it doesn't make sense to me.
Cattle ranchers insist that the horses be removed so that the ranchers can use public lands for their private businesses (cattle ranching). Horses are removed and cattle are moved in.
Wild horses are not native to the Americas- they were introduced by Spanish colonizers in the 1500’s. Because of their importance to native tribes since then and their symbolic importance for the American west, congress passed a law protecting their existence as wild animals, but their populations must be managed to avoid overgrazing and degrading the natural environment.
Cattle Ranching
@@jacobbwalters8133 your not native either.
@@HOHLfmly and human beings are also degrading the environment. That’s a separate issue. One of the ways we are degrading the landscape, however, is recklessly introducing nonnative species into various regions for our own convenience/amusement. This is no different than the issue of invasive feral cats in Hawaii or rabbits it Australia. Each species destroys the habitat for native species and must be kept in check.
Disgusting! Leave wild animals alone
They are not wild, they are feral animals just like feral cats and pigs and they destroy the true wildlife. They do not have natural predators or population control.
Animals need to be managed or they all die if they consume all there resources
Shows how removed you are from reality. Why don't you do something productive and adopt one then? Nope, didn't think so.
They aren't wild animals. They are feral domestic horses. If they were dogs we'd call 'em strays. Most of them probably started out with owners or come down within a generation or two from owned horses. They are nothing special. If rather than having them bumming loose on federal land they were owned by some guy named Frank Johnson and allowed to roam loose on his fenced property the same way - stallions fighting over mares, mares having foals every year, no ready supply of food, drinking brackish water where they can find it, no shelter in bad weather, no worming or medical care, no farrier care, horses are ignored and you can't get near them if they are sick or injured - your sort would be the first to run to the authorities and complain about animal neglect and want ol' Frank arrested and fined. But having those same horses running loose on federal lands? Oh, wow! They suddenly turn into magnificent wild animals that need to be left alone, protected and admired as a symbol of our country's heritage, the soul of the Wild West! >:-(
@@DoubleDogDare54 -
And yet, it's okay for human's cattle to go grazing on lands without issue.
It's the same with Deer. We destroy the their forest habitat and we think, they will just move on to another forest. However, we are at the juncture where there isn't any where else for them to go. So they stay, which happens to be the lawn of the McMansion that was just plopped down on their former home and are labeled pests. The forest that is left is so overrun that they are starving to death. So hunts are planned to cull the herds. And damn if those sanctimonious people cry about the brutality of that.
Hypocrites one and all, because the truth about why it is that Mustangs, deer and other wildlife don't have enough space to live is because the locust human beings that we are. We are killing ourselves in the process of doing it, as we need them ecologically.
I bet you would be the first to complain if herds got slimmed down by starvation or sickness. Or better yet get on and run on your own property. Land can only sustain so much , why do you think they controll the population of Bison in Yellowstone park. there is nothing worse then see any animal starv to death , or from diseases.
"You think you own whatever land you land on.
The Earth is just a dead thing you can claim.
But I know every rock and tree and creature
Has a life, has a spirit, has a name. "
Colors of the wind
Well said, Amen friend.
You know they aren’t wild right? They are non native species that destroy environments of other native species ground nesting birds and native plants are the most visible but you can’t just add new creatures especially big creatures without dire consequences for the rest of the web
These horses are actually invasive and disturbed the natural ecosystem the last few hundred years.
PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT BIRTH CONTROL FOR HORSES 🐴 THEN THEY CAN WORK ON BIRTH CONTROL FOR HUMANS, SO THEY CAN USE IT!! SAVE THE HORSES 🐴 💖
when they say birth control they are castrating the males in a process called gelding
Just leave those horses alone!!! Jesus…can’t we keep our hands off anything. 🤬
So, they run out of forage and their water supply dries up, you still want them left alone and you'll tell people to keep their hands off those horses and let nature take its course?
@@DoubleDogDare54 Animals have survived thousands of years just fine without help from us. They’ll figure it out. But humans…..we have to be in control of everything 🙄
@@Sarah-lb8cs A few years back I watched a video from Australia where large numbers of brumbies died around dried up water holes during a drought. That is what people will have to be okay with if you want nature to self regulate the population of feral horses out west.
I would definitely would not mind riding a horse to the grocery store .
There’s so many Native American reservations in need of horses . Oh yeah I forgot the federal government can help with gathering the horses to relocating where they are needed .
Then how come reservations don't ask for them . They get the Buffalo that gets removed from the herds of Buffalo from Yellowstone park. And go ahead ride a horse to the grocery store, more power to you . I just hope if you own that horse, you take good care of it, that is including shots and deworming.
@@anitakristensen4679 and quality shoeing! Concrete is tough on those hoofs!
A number of Native Americans raise their own wild horses, and sadly some do not take good care of them and allow them to continue to breed indiscriminately in captivity. Nor do they get the vet care they need. I know of at least two outside families who buy horses from a reservation in Arizona and then rehab and train these horses before then finding them good homes. It's more of a rescue operation when they take in these horses off the reservations, and they always wish they could afford to save more of them.
They break up the families, injure the horses, corral them too closely & then they get sick & die. Like in CO, where over 100 horses died from equine flu.
They round them up safely then keep them in captivity. I knew somebody that adopted 2 of these and they were horribly depressed.
We as humans need to stop thinking that we know best. Leave them alone. Let nature decide. Disgusted by this.
Was it nature that brought horses back to north America? After they naturally went extinct a few millenia ago
Why can't they just leave those wild horses alone to live in nature? They aren't hurting anyone or anything.😡
Because ranchers want to run cattle to make personal profit on public lands.
@@jodi9290 yes, you are right. So unfair and disgusting. Against nature.
Horses turn healthy grassland into desert.
Too many horses and you have no grass and no water.
Pay attention to the video.
The horses are competiting with cattle.
They also compete with wildlife.
No, people competing for money Lobbyist get it done!!!
How far are you running these horses for and in what heat. Running those little foals and the fear they must feel. There has to be a better way!
Horses have been bred to be driven for thousands of years. It's not a bunch of Miles City, MT community college rodeo kids flying the helicopters, so relax.
they dont consider fear, only consider the money they get out of this sham.
not to mention, twin peaks area is covered with volcanic boulders, many get foot injuries.
Yeah, shoot them.
these horses are going to slaughter so what difference does it make, they are going to die
Horses are not ingiginous to this land, originally ridden by Spanish Conquistadores, when allowed to roam free and breed became large herds.
THANK YOU CONGRESSWOMAN !!! ❤
Yes! Thank you!
They are kept in deplorable conditions and a significant amount have died from lack of vaccinations WHILE IN their facilities. If they are endangered, the management practices should NOT be a cause of death or injury, period.
“Save a horse, hire a cowboy”
As a full blooded Lakota, This can be stated we've seen this before. Trust no wasicu....... 😡😤 just sickening.
Why hasn't anyone come up with birth control kibble?
Horse, bear, Buffalo, deer.......
( put piles of it everywhere, for the specific animal)
What is needed is a hunting season for these horses. Have a hunting season instead of rounding them up and penning them on BLM facilities for the rest of their lives. Then no more roundups. The horses can live their wild, untamed lives until a hunter with a rifle and scope harvests those horses and fills his freezer with a half ton of organic caballo. The state issues the tags and gets money out of it instead of spending money on the roundups and feeding these bangtails after they are caught. Designate the month of October for horse hunting. The foals are done with the mares by then and hunters can harvest whatever they can get in the crosshairs.
@@DoubleDogDare54 look out you are going to get bomb barded with comments about your comment.
@@DoubleDogDare54 Sadly at least 50 wild horses were shot to death, left to die or were injured in Arizona's Apache Sitgreaves National Forest in October. The killers didn't make sure they were dead, they didn't get a ticket from the state to approve of the killings or even take them out of the park. They left fractured horse familes and dead horses for any member of the public to find.
There is a proven birth control that the BLM basically refuses to use to a large degree. It's an injection that is shot into mares. It's much less cost than roundups and allows horses to stay on the range with their herds.
Is anyone else sick and tired of the government!
No, Deanna. I like having medicare and and social security.
They make money off sending them to slaughterhouses to make meat and animal feed. Same with sending them to auction houses.
“Oh the poor wild horses, leave them alone.”
What about the poor wildlife these FERAL animals are competing with? The waterways they’re destroying, the landscape they’re overgrazing? Don’t their lives and welfare matter?
Feral horses are not wild horses, they are not native here. Equus ferus caballus is not native to North America and never was, it did not evolve here, it is an introduced invasive species. True native equines like equus lambei and equus simplicidens are long extinct and didn’t even resemble modern horses, their closest equivalent resemblance would be with tarpans, onagers and zebra, and they belonged to a much different environment.
Arguing that feral horses are natural to the land and therefore belong here with their numbers unchecked would be the same as arguing for the introduction of elephants and African lions into North America. Mastodons and Columbia. mammoths once lived here did they not? One of the primary predators of the wild equines here was panthera leo atrox, therefore the only natural way to keep feral horse populations in check would be to introduce the closest equivalent predator that once roamed here, prides of lions.
That would be insane, as insane as demanding that wild horse populations be left alone because they’re “wild and belong here.”
What's with wild horses. Who and what are they bothering? I hope these people who doing this are charged with cruelty to añimals . It's all about money to the government.
The herds increase at around 20% a year. If these bangtails eat down all the grass and their water sources dry up with the drought conditions in the West, will your sort be willing to let Nature take its course and have these horses die off due to starvation and lack of water? Can't have it both ways. If they need the help of humans to survive, they aren't wild animals and need to be removed from these areas . If they are wild animals, impose a hunting season on them and let starvation and lack of water take care of the rest of the problem, like with any other wild animal.
So when the government controls the spread of feral pigs (boar), is it still cruelty? Or is it because this non-native species is one people are fond of, that it then becomes a symbol of animal cruelty. Horses do not naturally occur in the American wilderness, they are merely domestic animals set loose who now cause imbalance on an ecosystem not designed for their presence.
@@DoubleDogDare54 No, it's just to make room for cows and sheep. Nature can regulate itself just fine without humans interacting.
@@Lakota828 Cattle and sheep pay their way. We eat them. Feral horses do not pay their way and are parasites on grazing land leased to ranchers that supply food to this country. Feral horses are not native wild animals like deer and elk. They are stray domestic livestock with no owners other than the BLM. As the BLM owns them, the BLM can do with them as they think best. And they think it is best to round them up, remove them from federal lands and sell them off to whoever wants them. So, this is not a matter of nature regulating itself as it is up to the BLM to call the shots. Deal with it.
They talked about using helicopters and motorized vehicles, the problem is according to Annie's law and the federal government THIS IS AGAINST THE LAW!
#ANNIE'S LAW
They are not game animals and as invasive species they aren’t subject to any protections
This is disgusting and just so heart breaking - I hope people know and understand not only these horses are robbed of their home and their families get broken up - and being chased by helicopters is tramatic enough but most of them get treated terribly, and have to endure cruel humans - some that don't get sold or display potential to work for humans will get sold as 'meat' for human consumption and b/c US has banned horse meat - they get put on trains to endure horrible 2 to 3,000 mile journey to Mexico - many of them die from injuries and thirst (since they're bound for slaughter, they seldom get water or food - just the bare minimum) - I hope people understand we take their homes for animal agriculture - to make 'meat' for our food from animals (it's the same for chopping down rainforests) - if you love animals, if you have an ounce of compassion in your heatr - please stop being the cog in animal agriculture or testing or sporting (hunting), or skin-trade or illegal wild animal exports, anything that exploits and hurts animals - please be their protectors and champions
Spent almost half a billion dollars in 5 years...wtf??? To "manage" by human intervention what horses have been doing on their own for thousands of years...survive.
Wild horses in the wild is a very majestic sight. Definitely a bucket list item.
It's Political at the end of the day, The protection of these Animals are not priority....this is an atrocity!!!🙏🐎
They are just feral domestic livestock. Why would they be protected by the government when they aren't supposed to be running loose to start with?
@Sky Mile Many wild animals are political: probably the most divisive are wolves.
The fact that people are complaining is mind blowing to me
It’s all about the water and grazing. The wild horses don’t pay taxes. Cattle ranches do.
not if the international corporations country of registration is not in the US. eg: sp+ US made $5billion in revenue and only paid 14Million in fed. taxes for us based managers. than add all the tax payer subsidies those ranchers get, nope does not add up to the cost of removing wildlife.
That lady has clearly never been by a wild horse talking about inhumane lol
I wish I could "unsee" what I just saw💔❤️🔥💔❤️🔥💔❤️🔥💔❤️🔥💔❤️🔥
We can identify and manage the heard growth with animals but why can’t we do this with humans….. there are far way to many people here on this earth…… I think we need to have a cap on how many kids we have……. We are like an infestation, we are so wasteful. Resources, metals, water, vegetation, food etc. horses don’t have that issues, but us humans do.
Well get your rope and find a tree and help us out here
Just give it time most developed nations are not growing, even china is about to max out in a couple of years the human population is maxing out within the next century and decreasing.
Spot on I have thought this way most of my life human population need to be controlled also
They don't need to round up so many horse!!! Just who's going to adopt these horses? Get the livestock off the land!
Leave the horses alone let them all run free they want to live to shame shame shame on our government
No, “shame shame shame” on you for not understanding the damaging ecological impact feral horses have on the landscape.
That’s a horrible way to control resources. Killing 20k wild horses and burros are disgusting especially when this was their land. People need to stop using excess water like in swimming pools and having outrageous landscaping requiring lots of water. Everyone on the internet can look up ways to do their own part in preserving resources. Horses are majestic and they want and deserve their freedom. Surely, humans can understand that. The stress put on those horses being wrangled up and corralled is terrifying to them. Humans are going to cause every animal on Earth to be killed because they are greedy and selfish.
those are good animals, bet the Native Americans will make the best of their animals, as always.
🙄
Who wants to tell this person about how domestic horses originated from Europe…. 😳
Wrong, wrong, wrong!!! 😡😡😡
Its so sick and sad. A free and wild animal being taken and treaded like property. They are not free if we are controlling them
So basically the truth is that the horses are being rounded up to benefit the land for the beef cattle farmer. Nice. A balance cannot be found? Such as gelding male horses & then releasing them back?
I wish I was around that area because I would release them. Sickening
Leave the animal's alone 😠
So you want to release them all to die of starvation and thirst on ranges that can't support their numbers? That's not very humane.
You want to release feral animals that will outcompete native species? You have truly contradicted your own beliefs
The major issue which they just glanced over in this video is the reason why they’re rounding up the horses is because the government is leasing out the land that the horses were living on to cattle farmers. If the horses were still given the public land they always had we would not need to be rounding them up to keep them in holding for the rest of their lives, and the holding facilities are not pretty they’re thousands of horses in pens with little to know grass.
Lol, the federal government litterally killed off the few native horses that survived the ice age, so they could claim them all as invasive. Some tribes were very outspoken about this, and they are all gone now.
More humane method and environmentally friendly approach: Employ the cowboys! But the downside? It's bad for business, bad for the economy because you don't spend on gas fuels and don't sign up with helicopter contractors which means...no kickbacks for politicians...hehehe...just saying.
If we hadn’t killed off all the wolves and predators we wouldn’t be having to intervene with nature.
He's lying! The helicopter is terrorizing and they don't want to sit on a horse to round up those horses. They're so terrorized the horses and babies have heart attacks.
LEAVE THEM ALONE!
Unfortunately if you let them over populate they will destroy the range there on and then all those animal's will will starfe to death,and that's a horrible way to die. You need to remember there's no natural predators to keep the hearts down.
Looks at wide open spaces with a couple of bushes and 6 blades of grass and can't understand why it's overpopulated cause there is so much room.
This is a very long standing problem between cattle ranchers and the wild horses.
Do you eat steak, burgers? Any beef products? Cattle need large quantities of land to feed. Horses require just as much of not more.
They are competing for limited resources, especially with the severe drought the West is experiencing.
These horses are on BLM land, not cattle ranchers land.
We should be like many Europeans and eat horse meat.
@@tdp73 Cattle ranchers are the reason this is happening.
@@kittyday1402 my point. They shouldn't be able to let their cattle graze on BLM land. So it is the cattle ranchers and the BLM allows them use the land set aside for wild animals. They started rounding up wild mustangs in Nevada in the 70s. It is wrong, just wrong.
@@tdp73 Yep! I think we should be able to shoot & eat the cattle on Federal land. Last time I checked, they paid $1/acre for grazing rights.
I use to live in NV around a lot of those horses. You cant see them at night when driving on roads at high speed. But the horses feed the mountian lions. So that saves the cattle
That sure doesn't seem to be working.
@@mikeprice4103 then why we do have more big cats and species of big cats in the us then we did 30 years ago?
@@skylercook1812 Cant hunt with dogs anymore so most of us gave up hunting cats.
Too many horses means no new trees. No more trees means no more people. "private" cattle grazing on public land needs to stop or I want my percentage.
I like the idea of cowboys preferably women. I do recall a movie of a young woman who did the corralling of the horses in the seventies or eighties. What percent for inoculations of strangles? And why did the shots get overlooked this spring? Why no shots?
Not sure why the stories of the horses starving and dying of thirst aren’t making the mainstream media? Every year horses starve and drought out due to miss management by Blm
82,000 x 1%=820 half of that equals 410 horses are killed in rounding up those horses if half of one percent a true percentage.
Just bring wolves back-they will reduce the herd. No need to do the roundups.
Leave the damn horses alone!! Whose next? The wild buffalos? 😠
The fact that people get upset about this is infuriating because you think they are cute well horses are non native and die terrible deaths on the range nobody cares when we do this with pigs but horses are sacred …no they are free meat
Greed is all it is. Leave the horses alone!!!!
Why are they using these terrible methods & not using birth control w/the horses?
To much money to be made by not doing this.
We originally had 86,000 free roaming wild horses and burros.
4,000 left? That is going to lead to immense inbreeding and low gene pools, and practically no symbol of freedom left. This drastic change summarizes how the government values the freedom of both animal and man.
The Bureau of Land Management is going to take in far more horses than it knows what to do with and simultaneously violating the 1971 Wild Horses and Burros Act.
Somehow we have children skipping meals and yet we have more than enough taxpayers dollars to export many of these horses to Mexico, where they will be turned into dog food. The hypocrisy is truly blood boiling.
What’s really blood boiling is the fact that you’re worried about a population of non-native animals that cause harm to an ecosystem instead of funneling your anger and passion towards native species who are truly threatened such as the bison or wolf. Maybe if people like you stopped worrying about protecting something that is harmful, then we could spend our time protecting species that actually need our help, instead of a freaking farm animal.
I am so tired of certain people playing GOD. Leave the Wild to be wild..
These are not a native species. We created this mess so we need to fix it. God has tasked us with being good stewards of his creation and letting invasive species we introduced destroy the native ecosystem is not that. This is similar to the wild rabbit infestations of Australia or the wild cat infestations of Hawaii. Fortunately, wild horses are much easier to manage.
They aren't native species.
These are feral animals with no natural predators for population control and are destroying natural resources.
News flash - Your budget is MY money. Stop abusing wild horses!
I loved the idea of letting cowboys round them up. What’s the rush of rushing to round up these beautiful animals. If they allow people to live on the land to take care of the horses, then there would be no need for adoptions. With all of those millions of dollars they could pay cowboys well enough to save the horses and manage the land. I say there’s an underbelly to this and they want that land to build stuff we don’t need so they can make even more money than they do now. Greed always plays a part in an innocent scenario like this. We see you.
No its not a good idea most of the horses are going to the slaughter houses just like cows that is one of the things the government is trying to cover up
Hey YELLOWSTONE need some horses?
Is there any petition to stop this?
Wild Horses have far exceeded their numbers, we can legally hunt deers, bears, alligators and others but horses are off limit. Americas special interest is driving this country into the ground.
This needs to be stopped ✋️ 😪 🤧
82000 horses is a lot of horses. I can see why culling may be best for them. In comparison, deer' life span are around 4.5yrs, while a wild horse's is 15yrs. That means they reproduce at rates that aren't balanced by natural deaths within the species. That eventually leads to interbreeding, disease and starvation, especially with the increase in climate change and wild fires. I think it's really the humane thing to do.
If there was 82k, is a drop in the bucket compared to the millions of deer. And the 20% they say is their high potential spreadsheet growth number and has never been proven. The Ac. of Sciences did a thorough research and found the average closer to 5% growth, because horses self regulate. There are a few herds that have proven self reg. meaning if there is few resources they have fewer foals, abundant resources than more. 82k is how many they already have taken through the years to hold in a holding pen.
@@marlyjung4102 Thanks for explaining 👍🏾
This has nothing to do with humane treatment of horses. It's all for cattle ranchers who have practically free grazing rights on millions of acres of government land
Our government is out of control.
Most of these go to slaughter.
I have seen huge truck loads from lower 48 going thru port in anchorage alaska. Transported in open semi trucks with no food and water in all kinds of weather.
Contact your reps and senators.
Wildlife management the ultimate contradiction of terms
Wildlife management? I’m sorry but feral horses are not “wildlife”. They are non-native and should t exist in the wild at all, they are merely domestic animals set loose.
Leave the horses alone
America! It can be inspiring and beautiful. It can also be dark and ugly. It’s soo many things, but it’s ours. It’s our America.
Leave the horses all alone
What are they really going to do to Father God's creation? I hope they do not slaughter them !
The horses are not slaughtered- it explains the adoption process in the video. It’s also worth noting that horses are not native to this particular part of God’s creation, but rather were introduced by the Spanish in the 1500’s. We manage their populations today to prevent overgrazing and soil degradation.
They are domestic horses. If you take these horses, break them to saddle, they are simply any other horse, just like all the other horses in Father God's creation. They are nothing special or out of the ordinary. Get over it.
Yep. Hire cowboys!
Let's be honest here...they are the definition of an invasive species. Like carp and kudzu and pythons.
I wonder how many horses are in Mongolia....
Approx 3 MILLION. They outnumber the humans. But are used for milk, transportation AND FOOD. Horses there are a MEAT animal like cattle is here.
Start canceling the cattle leases.
This country sucks!! These animals were born free and need to be left alone. Corral the government!!
I've been doing this research along with others for years!
Over grazing from wild burros and horses is a real problem. They are not native and they eat all the food that the native deer, elk, antelope, and bighorn sheep need. The burros actually try to scare away native species from watering holes. Managing herd size is essential, otherwise there is not enough food and animals starve…which is not exactly humane
Look at that video look how good that grass for land looks.
Now find video of where cattle have been grazing.
This is what the government said about the Indians to
They can choose healthy ,strong and beautiful ones to improve the genetics of domestic horses.
Not supposed to BE federal lands
This is ridiculous! The law says to leave them wild!😆
This is a case of as species being abused and killed so a few people or businesses benefit off PUBLIC PROPERTY, mine and yours
China, Poland, Germany, Indonesia, Switzerland, Japan, Mexico along with other countries LOVE EATING horse meat. True! There have been stories in the past of so-called private individuals buying these beautiful, wild animals from the US Government, only to sell them, & have them end up, sadly, on some foreigner’s dinner table. Unacceptable! The US Government has a MORAL obligation to do a BETTER job of TRACKING these horses once they are SOLD! PERIOD!!!
Great idea. Send them to Japan.
And in South America Guinea Pigs aren't pets. They're a meat animal for locals like chickens. I get your emotional attachment to horses. But across the world people EAT MEAT. Different kinds of meat. Whatever easily available.
Animal welfare has advanced very little in the last 150 years. So horrible for these horses.
Stop this!