@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN Heres a hindu patient who attacked doctor. And this is *ONLY 1 EXAMPLE* english.sakshi.com/telangana/2019/05/20/nims-doctor-attacked-by-patients-family-in-hyderabad
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN *BJP Relations with Doctors* List of *11 Prominent Attack on Doctors* . But Why there was no such hue and Cry, before you ask support BJP for standing with Doctor, Let see their history with Doctors *1)BJP leader throws shoes on Duty Doctor, Tripura April 2019.* medicaldialogues.in/bjp-leader-throws-shoes-on-duty-doctor-ima-gives-ultimatum-for-arrest/ … *2)BJP leader booked for ‘threatening’ doctor, Ludhiana, Nov 2017* indianexpress.com/article/cities/ludhiana/bjp-leader-booked-for-threatening-doctor-4916309/ … *3)BJP leader Jaspal Arora threatens to strip doctor in public,Sehore, MP, Jan 2017* indiatoday.in/india/story/bhopal-jaspal-arora-doctors-give-mass-resignations-bjp-district-hospital-sehore-956133-2017-01-20 … *4) BJP corporator booked for ‘assaulting’ doctor at Sassoon hospital Pune, March 2019* indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/pune-bjp-corporator-assaults-doctor-booked-5624294/ … *5) BJP MP Naran Kachhadiya sentenced to three years in doctor assault case, 2016* indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/naran-kachhadiya-bjp-mp-amreli-doctor-assault/ … *6) BJP leader beaten up a doctor in Mainpuri, June 2018* www.jagran.com/uttar-pradesh/agra-city-bjp-leader-beaten-at-doctor-in-mainpuri-18134089.html … *7) Female BJP leader beaten up doctor with slippers in Bareilly, June 2018* www.uttarpradesh.org/uttar-pradesh/female-bjp-leader-beaten-to-doctor-with-slippers-in-pratap-hospital-cctv-211011/ … *8) BJP Leader beaten up doctor with rifle, Mathura, June 2019* hindi.indiatvnews.com/india/uttar-pradesh-bjp-leader-beats-doctor-in-mathura-640364 … *9) BJP leader charged with assault on doctor couple, Hisar, Aug 2017.* navbharattimes.indiatimes.com/state/punjab-and-haryana/hisar/bjp-leader-charged-with-assault-on-doctor-couple/articleshow/59975108.cms … *10) BJP MP Ananth Kumar Hegde caught on camera beating up doctor at Karnataka hospital. Jan 2017* www.thenewsminute.com/article/bjp-mp-ananth-kumar-hegde-caught-camera-beating-doctor-karnataka-hospital-55168 … *11) BJP Leader's son beaten up doctor in Bhilai, Jun 2018* www.patrika.com/bhilai-news/bjp-leader-s-son-beaten-doctor-bhilai-2896905/ …
#Hope ... they hope things will be better after 3 years when they finish PG , so they suffer all physical mental torture and work like slaves for 3 years
Truly is just that Indian degrees are not valid outside and we have to give more exams to work abroad . If there wasn't this barrier half of Indian doctors will leave the country in just about an year.
And Then People are being surprised why doctors go to USA leaving India . It’s Ok to spend ₹500 for a Popcorn in Multiplex but it’s not ok to spend ₹400 on their health. Well if this types of Problems continue then Doctors should go to USA for a better Lifestyle and for Money also 👍🏻
@Sha : With no disrespect, those tests are not for money. They are for accurately diagnosing the condition that you have. Misdiagnosis leads to maltreatment which may harm the body, along with the worsening of the original condition that you had. Doctors are not magicians. They need tests and scans to know what's going on inside your body.
no one will even hit a mason ,plumber, carpenter , house maid or helper..even if they do something wrong...talking about police or mla is far off we doctors get less respect than not other profession but as humans... if you studied your ass of for continuous 8-10 years and get verbally abused or physically you would know...i dont get how few drunk or not drunk illiterate can do some thing like that people feel brave hitting people ..who they know will not fight back ...so brave
@ENTERTAINMENT UNLIMITED so y come to doctors then go to unani ayurveda if worried about side effect...and you are talking about negligence i will tell you what when there is emergency you have to treat the patient without knowing past history ...even if you dont want to...if there was a way i think doctor would tell refer everyone to the best doctor always in emergency...bro there is nothing called as perfection...its human body
aslo why always belame doctors...look for other reasons like infrstructure,supply,less doctors... you know doctors wont hit back .....i hope it happens with you at your workplace then you would know you spend 500 rs to watch movie at PVR...but 300 rs consultation fee at doctor feel ass burn....people ignore little early symptoms and go to doctor when emergency... and hope for best when we order test you feel like we are looting you...those test are for your only....look in other countries were there are insurance companies,better machines,protocols and all ...i think for a small thing people should be having test ...for fever also....so then they would c for them self and go to a better option if they dont like...actually the problm is people have half knowledge and talk shit....study medicine subject once then talk
I’m leaving india as soon as I get my mbbs degree cause there’s no hope of change here I’ll earn more in other countries too plus I’ll be treated with respect there
@@prithwisdas4654 but and this is a big BUT if you’re considering surgery stay in India or even cardiology after internal medicine or neurology cause it’ll be damn near impossible to get into surgery or competitive specialties like obgyn and urology as an international medical graduate
Bravo !! Thank U Quint for Showing reality of JR Doctors , It may sound hypothetical to common people and they think its a lie because its unbelievable for most people , First Year JR doctor in every medical college hospital in whole India is forced to do 24-36 hrs duty with 1-2 hrs sleep and a single meal in between , if they are lucky enough to get this one meal and 2 hr sleep .. after that duty he gets 5-6 hrs break for all his works including bath and eat n sleep , then again this cycle continues .... 🙂 Is this humane ? U tell ??
We do our jobs beyond what is expected of us but I wish Mainstream media in India were doing the minimum required of them. We need Good Journalism like you guys are doing. Very well done @TheQuint.
Even journalism won't change the way people think. Take cleanliness as an example. Even all the awareness couldn't keep the streets clean. The problem is we take things for granted. And we won't improve unless we suffer the consequences.
I am not afraid of safety of doctors alone, I am worried about their working conditions, hygiene and mental health also. If they are not getting rest, basic facilities of hygiene, facilities like emergency leaves, not getting time to spend with their families which are few basic fundamental needs of every human being, I don't know how can we expect best quality of output for a longer term. They are also humans and they also deserve to love and enjoy their life. Being a doctor doesn't mean ruining personal life.. in my opinion
Forget emergency leaves and family time , they are not getting 2 times meal and sleep more than 2-3 hours , only getting a bath in 6-7 days and this is not exaggeration its #truth , u can confirm any 1st year JR in any medical college in country ...
Maa baap kitni mehnat krte hai tab ek baccha doctor banta hai. Doctor banne kitna hard work krna padta hai baccho ko 18 se jiyada ghante bacche padai krtna padti hai. Respect doctor's plz🙏🙏
I am really proud of The Quint for doing this series about state of doctors.. A doctor myself ..I really want this issue to reach every citizen of this country..but no media captures this aspect... It's High time for the higher authorities to stand up and do something.. Kudos to this channel.. Plz share this to as many people you can
Not 200 hundred perpetrators but 2 trucks load of perpetrators .....200 in number is not possible or else medical College would had been risen to the ground ..... moreover why only her ? U should ask every other politicians what they are doing to ensure the safety of doctors bcoz this is not only happening in Bengal or Bangalore but every nook and corner of the world ,so plz don't try to turn this sensitive issue into a political one and simply accept that every other politician is at fault
Still we don't have enough Dr.. After reports like this we will will have fewer and fewer Drs.. So thank u quint. Like, if every junior dr. is living in this condition. 🙄
another problem for which there is no solution in our country, corruption is killing us inside out. This is the reason why most doctors in India move out abroad if they cannot eventually to a private hospital and or their own clinic. disheartening!
Doctors face a lot of issues and now a days it's very very critical for them to survive. Regarding to my all doctors Friends I would say try not to pursue MBBS seriously. Illiterate people tried to kill them, embarrass them so basically do graduate in any field weather it is commerce or arts or science or even engineering like I am a B/tech guy but talking about them they are brutally attacked by the people without knowing anything... I am standing and with u 🙏🏻. Jay Hind... thanks 'Quint' for this awareness video.👍🏼 "" Respect our doctors don't hurt them ""
@@shubhamsehgal2336 yes sir but what I am trying to say is doctors in our country are harassing, brutally attacking by the illiterate and dishonest people that's y I said not to pursue mbbs , most importantly this is not my statement, this is the statement from the doctors. All the best anyways..
When they say doctor here, they should mention government doctor because private hospital and private doctor has completely opposite situation, there patients are threaten, misbehaved, harassed, over charged, misdiagnosed.
It's so sad doctors who try so hard to save lives and save families from falling apart have no safety for their own lives . People give respect to those fake babas and politicians but doctor is treated like scrap .
Doctors themselves work hard day and night to see their patients recover! Their well being gives the doctors satisfaction and how ironical they only are beaten up due to the patient's not understanding of situations!
High time people become more aware and responsible,not just blaming doctors for every bad consequence. Commendable report,highlighting ground realities.
The beneficiaries are at fault as well. During my posting in the deaddiction units, patients readily spend thousands on alcohol but question us while advising multivitamins. I even witnessed an unusual event in the pediatric ward where the mother deliberately didn't give paracetamol to her child just because they decided not open the new bottle but use the older one instead which the father went back to home to bring it.
I've just watched a foreign hospital ICU scenario and came to this,I think here the problem is deep rooted and unimaginably complex.Here we cannot completely blame common ppl because they themselves are victims of beuracracy and not to forget doctors before or also part and victims of this system.And the majority of basic indian society think that doctors are in a very comfortable lifestyle and job earning vast amount of money and usually misinformed or ignorant of the stress they experience.No control of hospital and pharmaceutical charges is one of its main reasons.And also not forget that rapid and high increase in medical clg fee and tough exam pattern, marks oriented studies resulted in commercial minded medical students however we cannot blame all of them,though they really want to be selfless and service minded they are helpless becoz they have to compensate the amount they spend to acquire that position,that is the reason why majority of Indian parents want their children to be either doctor or engineer.we can only change this if we each of us will come out of our selfish ,care less zone,having said that, that continuous work hours is inhumane.
The more I want to love my nation, the more I develop hatred towards it. I wish to I could say that I love my country, and I would never ever leave this place but then, this place is turning into something I have never dreamed of. The world is changing into a not so good place but my nation is deteriorating.
As soon as patient is admitted in a hospital his relatives are given a long list of medicines and other medical items to be brought from outside . Relatives have to get it and handover to the duty nurse..out if that only a small portion of medical supplies are used where does the rest go?.. and moreover the hospital gets all medical supplies from the government whose pocket does it fill...the rot has spread throughout.
Facing humiliation & threats by local politicians and goons and pressurised by bossy higher authorities and beaten by patients & public... Missing own family life, Landing up in chronic illness... Thanks people for treating your healers with so many gifts.
I am a junior doctor and work for really long hours to keep caring for the patients! the government is not spending enough money on the health sector and all the blame is on us doctors..and nurses..the patient parties are sometimes violent and there is a sence of loss of empathy in them for us!
They should increase salaries of doctors irrespective of allopathy or indian medicine doctors or else doctors obviously will leave their homeland and work elsewhere, this country needs a lot of respect and salary hikes for professionals.
Plz ask the patients and their families about how badly these doctors and nurses treat a common person. They don't really save our lives they are just doing their jobs. And one lady in this video tells us that is difficult to treat a stranger, why the hell are u learning medical then??
to be honest , if someone visits poor states like odisha , Govt doctors dnt work properly , they simply treat better n pvt nursing homes by charging more . there 's a doctor named subhendu das very renowned well knowledgeable doctor , you will find him treating in pvt homes by charging 300 per person .the same doctor wont treat you better if you consult him in MKCG berhammpur (govt hospital) . how satire is that .
Please don't misbehave with the doctors, whichever part of India we are staying, there are always to help us, and the poor and needy don't understand this.. PLEASE DO SHARE THIS TO ALL🙏🙏
Log pdhe like log Jo unke liye kaam Krte h, unki izzat nhi krte. Junior doctors work most and this is not what they deserve. Almost every doctor tries their best when it comes to saving people but at times the best just isn't good enough. I can imagine people getting nasty for Co-operate behaviors in Hospitals, delays, irrational fees and policies but Junior doctors have nothing to do with it. Aisa hi chlta rha to more Doctors will rather work abroad than here. And then we would start complaining.. "India produces Engg and Doctors but they don't work for us".
Its quite common with the localities in karnataka. I have witnessed and threatened by bystanders when i was working in bangalore. Need better education instead of radical political teaching to common man. Such unorthodox practices by hospitals in karnataka has to be stopped by the authorities. Foreign countries have government hospitals with 5*facilities. The kind of money investment in india for medical facilities expansion is 30-40% lofted than developed countries. Simultaneously the people should come out of stupidity to understand the hospitals are not temples and medical professionals are not GOD.
I never support the manhandling of doctor. I just have few question for doctors Are Doctors being gentle in govt hospitals ? Doesnt govt doctors demand money with poor in district hospitals A govt office official doesnt even have some gentleness while saying patient is dead. This people can go on strike when KAR Govt wanted to introduce the price capping on services in pvt hospital. Y cant they fight against govt for better facility at hospital. Patients vist to hospital to get support. if any doctor is questioned about the problem in hospital the answer ... GO and ask GOVT. now for patients who is the govt rep. It is doctors. So before complaining so much, doctors do have loop holes please fill that gap. I do a regular visit to govt hospital. And writing this review. I strongly oppose the manhandling of doctors.
Quint is doing a great job covering this! People should blame the government for the lack of facilities and not the doctors who give their best everyday!
Doctors have to be careful about their work simple mistakes costs life once I was admitted to hospital one doctor made injection hurry it gave me heart attack
Every story has 2 side, you are showing one side only. There are very few cases where Dr. is ill-treated but there are 1000s of cases where Dr/hospital ate doing inhumane things.
The root cause of this issue is no adequate doctors as per patients ratio , employ more doctors , we know our is blessed with population and huge people live below poverty line , only govt hospital is their saviour, so recruitment of doctors and make them regular shift in any other govt jobs . If govt do this , it's good for doctors and patients.
true your not god. but patient treat their doctors as god. doctor is resemblance of god. government cannot provide security to each and every doctor. i have utmost respect for doctor. my family doctor Dr. Kosuri Jeevan is more than god to us. long live jeevan doctor and his family of doctors
When they said that their working hours begins at 9 and goes on till the next day, timing unknown and when the female doctor says “it takes a lot out of u” to treat a “stranger” at odd hours. Why then are they in that field?. Get out from there, and choose a cushy 9-6 job... don’t berate the profession for ur shortcomings and ur ineptness..
Stop your bullshit comments. Its very annoying to see a person comment this way without common sense. My own sister who is a doctor had a serious kidney problem after working day and night. Have some humanity while making such comments. Put yourself in their shoes before making such senseless statements. People like you are unfit to be called humans
Well that’s the humane side of doctors you are trying to show, ignoring their contempt and abhorrence to their patients and also rude behaviour to them is pervasive everywhere especially in government hospitals. That doctor is saying that ‘they are not god’’but they pretend like they are god and almighty and we are on their mercy.
Doctors at my place are business man! I don’t consider doctors to be anything more than a professional who does his job for monies!! He is just like any other professional in our country over appreciated job!
India most of people needs to be civilized to choose the right person for governing the state. Its high time now. Its just we are not the victim we just leave it careless.
I am a medical transcriptionist and I am aghast at the way our “doctors” complain of “little rest”, “inhumanly long hours” etc. simple. Then why did u enter the medical profession “knowing” all this?. Weren’t you guys made aware of all these in medical school?. Don’t u guys know actually that this is indeed the case?. Or were u all so immersed in social networking that u guys were totally unaware of even these basics?. This is how these youngsters should be treated and “Instagram generation” should be made aware in a language they understand that life is not a bed of roses and they’ve to respect patients and treat them like humans rather than just patients. Then see the respect. I have also come across doctors overworked and yawningly dictating operative reports etc, but yes that’s the way of life. That’s how it is. If u don’t like it, get out but don’t sully the medical profession in general. There’s some little respect I have towards doctors don’t make me erode that also...
Disappointed and disgusting. feels sad for all those doctors who are working so hard doing their duty looking after so many patients but are not appreciated and not been respected. people should understand that even doctors are humans not God's. please co-operate with the doctor and respect them.☺
Internship with no sleep and rude relatives of patient no security personnel is worst while on duty in night
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN THIS IS NOT ABOUT RELIGION OR CASTE. THIS IS ABOUT ILLITERACY
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN hindus do the same..
This is the problem.
U all are illusioned with a different story and
The real picture is kept away from u
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN how bigoted are you to even say this
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN
Heres a hindu patient who attacked doctor. And this is *ONLY 1 EXAMPLE*
english.sakshi.com/telangana/2019/05/20/nims-doctor-attacked-by-patients-family-in-hyderabad
@MATHA NOSHTO-MAN
*BJP Relations with Doctors*
List of *11 Prominent Attack on Doctors* . But Why there was no such hue and Cry, before you ask support BJP for standing with Doctor, Let see their history with Doctors
*1)BJP leader throws shoes on Duty Doctor, Tripura April 2019.*
medicaldialogues.in/bjp-leader-throws-shoes-on-duty-doctor-ima-gives-ultimatum-for-arrest/ …
*2)BJP leader booked for ‘threatening’ doctor, Ludhiana, Nov 2017* indianexpress.com/article/cities/ludhiana/bjp-leader-booked-for-threatening-doctor-4916309/ …
*3)BJP leader Jaspal Arora threatens to strip doctor in public,Sehore, MP, Jan 2017*
indiatoday.in/india/story/bhopal-jaspal-arora-doctors-give-mass-resignations-bjp-district-hospital-sehore-956133-2017-01-20 …
*4) BJP corporator booked for ‘assaulting’ doctor at Sassoon hospital Pune, March 2019* indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/pune-bjp-corporator-assaults-doctor-booked-5624294/ …
*5) BJP MP Naran Kachhadiya sentenced to three years in doctor assault case, 2016* indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/naran-kachhadiya-bjp-mp-amreli-doctor-assault/ …
*6) BJP leader beaten up a doctor in Mainpuri, June 2018*
www.jagran.com/uttar-pradesh/agra-city-bjp-leader-beaten-at-doctor-in-mainpuri-18134089.html …
*7) Female BJP leader beaten up doctor with slippers in Bareilly, June 2018* www.uttarpradesh.org/uttar-pradesh/female-bjp-leader-beaten-to-doctor-with-slippers-in-pratap-hospital-cctv-211011/ …
*8) BJP Leader beaten up doctor with rifle, Mathura, June 2019*
hindi.indiatvnews.com/india/uttar-pradesh-bjp-leader-beats-doctor-in-mathura-640364 …
*9) BJP leader charged with assault on doctor couple, Hisar, Aug 2017.* navbharattimes.indiatimes.com/state/punjab-and-haryana/hisar/bjp-leader-charged-with-assault-on-doctor-couple/articleshow/59975108.cms …
*10) BJP MP Ananth Kumar Hegde caught on camera beating up doctor at Karnataka hospital. Jan 2017* www.thenewsminute.com/article/bjp-mp-ananth-kumar-hegde-caught-camera-beating-doctor-karnataka-hospital-55168 …
*11) BJP Leader's son beaten up doctor in Bhilai, Jun 2018*
www.patrika.com/bhilai-news/bjp-leader-s-son-beaten-doctor-bhilai-2896905/ …
From doc A channel.
Thanks for being always standing for doctors.
Salute to this channel for reporting sad reality of India
From a jr. Doctor....Thank you quint for doing such unbiased and truthful reporting...will forever be indebted to you. ❤
Just watched your report on Junior Doctors of Bihar. ☠🤢🤮 i wonder why they haven't fled to some foreign country.
#Hope ... they hope things will be better after 3 years when they finish PG , so they suffer all physical mental torture and work like slaves for 3 years
Coz we still have hope..we still are fighting for change..
And we know..
Wat can happen wen we leave
Because they'd still have to sit for exams
Vai exam v dena padta he.. aise mooh uthake chale jayenge to kya karengw udhar
Truly is just that Indian degrees are not valid outside and we have to give more exams to work abroad . If there wasn't this barrier half of Indian doctors will leave the country in just about an year.
And Then People are being surprised why doctors go to USA leaving India .
It’s Ok to spend ₹500 for a Popcorn in Multiplex but it’s not ok to spend ₹400 on their health. Well if this types of Problems continue then Doctors should go to USA for a better Lifestyle and for Money also 👍🏻
Dont stereotype
Not everybody spends 500 on popcorn and don't get me started with the unnecessary tests and lakhs of rupees that you charge patients. 🖕
Ok not everybody spend 500 for popcorn..
@Sha : With no disrespect, those tests are not for money. They are for accurately diagnosing the condition that you have.
Misdiagnosis leads to maltreatment which may harm the body, along with the worsening of the original condition that you had.
Doctors are not magicians. They need tests and scans to know what's going on inside your body.
@@shaizahmed if u feel so...y dont u get a health insurance done..
U have so much of gyan..
Use it on correct place..
no one will even hit a mason ,plumber, carpenter , house maid or helper..even if they do something wrong...talking about police or mla is far off
we doctors get less respect than not other profession but as humans...
if you studied your ass of for continuous 8-10 years and get verbally abused or physically you would know...i dont get how few drunk or not drunk illiterate can do some thing like that
people feel brave hitting people ..who they know will not fight back ...so brave
@ENTERTAINMENT UNLIMITED so y come to doctors then go to unani ayurveda if worried about side effect...and you are talking about negligence i will tell you what when there is emergency you have to treat the patient without knowing past history ...even if you dont want to...if there was a way i think doctor would tell refer everyone to the best doctor always in emergency...bro there is nothing called as perfection...its human body
@ENTERTAINMENT UNLIMITED good thats why the best doctors of india are going to abroad ...no corruption there
ikram shareef I agree with u ..unlike USA doctors in India don't have medical history ,huge working hours load
aslo why always belame doctors...look for other reasons like infrstructure,supply,less doctors...
you know doctors wont hit back .....i hope it happens with you at your workplace then you would know
you spend 500 rs to watch movie at PVR...but 300 rs consultation fee at doctor feel ass burn....people ignore little early symptoms and go to doctor when emergency... and hope for best when we order test you feel like we are looting you...those test are for your only....look in other countries were there are insurance companies,better machines,protocols and all ...i think for a small thing people should be having test ...for fever also....so then they would c for them self and go to a better option if they dont like...actually the problm is people have half knowledge and talk shit....study medicine subject once then talk
@aakash shivam look bro if a person dies it jot just doctors fault ...its just that they are first to contact
I’m leaving india as soon as I get my mbbs degree cause there’s no hope of change here
I’ll earn more in other countries too plus I’ll be treated with respect there
Good
But bro 1year rural internship is compulsory
@@prithwisdas4654 i know that but after that for residency
@@avichal6630 yeah I am also considering that
@@prithwisdas4654 but and this is a big BUT if you’re considering surgery stay in India or even cardiology after internal medicine or neurology cause it’ll be damn near impossible to get into surgery or competitive specialties like obgyn and urology as an international medical graduate
Bravo !! Thank U Quint for Showing reality of JR Doctors ,
It may sound hypothetical to common people and they think its a lie because its unbelievable for most people ,
First Year JR doctor in every medical college hospital in whole India is forced to do 24-36 hrs duty with 1-2 hrs sleep and a single meal in between , if they are lucky enough to get this one meal and 2 hr sleep .. after that duty he gets 5-6 hrs break for all his works including bath and eat n sleep , then again this cycle continues .... 🙂
Is this humane ? U tell ??
Root of the problem is politician and not good governance...
In reality India need more doctors 😭😭
Yes I love medical I will be a doctor ☺
We do our jobs beyond what is expected of us but I wish Mainstream media in India were doing the minimum required of them. We need Good Journalism like you guys are doing. Very well done @TheQuint.
Even journalism won't change the way people think. Take cleanliness as an example. Even all the awareness couldn't keep the streets clean. The problem is we take things for granted. And we won't improve unless we suffer the consequences.
Sad but truth 🥺
Thank you doctor A for telling us about this ❤️ you
I am not afraid of safety of doctors alone, I am worried about their working conditions, hygiene and mental health also. If they are not getting rest, basic facilities of hygiene, facilities like emergency leaves, not getting time to spend with their families which are few basic fundamental needs of every human being, I don't know how can we expect best quality of output for a longer term. They are also humans and they also deserve to love and enjoy their life. Being a doctor doesn't mean ruining personal life.. in my opinion
Forget emergency leaves and family time , they are not getting 2 times meal and sleep more than 2-3 hours , only getting a bath in 6-7 days and this is not exaggeration its #truth , u can confirm any 1st year JR in any medical college in country ...
I got stage 1 hypertension at the age of 28... From my residency.. That's cost of my medical degree...
@@infinity-gn9xq no degree is worth your health and happiness. I'm a final year Medico, but I feel I India doesn't deserve doctors
Maa baap kitni mehnat krte hai tab ek baccha doctor banta hai. Doctor banne kitna hard work krna padta hai baccho ko 18 se jiyada ghante bacche padai krtna padti hai. Respect doctor's plz🙏🙏
@entertainment unlimite
So what you think an ideal doctor should be
I am really proud of The Quint for doing this series about state of doctors..
A doctor myself ..I really want this issue to reach every citizen of this country..but no media captures this aspect...
It's High time for the higher authorities to stand up and do something..
Kudos to this channel..
Plz share this to as many people you can
And then they ask why doctors leave india
Come to AP where govt doctors just give attendance & go to their clinics & come evening again give attendance & so on
Cuz of the reason mentioned above
Quint you should ask Ms Mamata Banerjee , where are the 200 perpetrator who beaten up doctors, why they are in bail .
There are many perpetrators roaming scot free. Many are even attached to a political party
Not 200 hundred perpetrators but 2 trucks load of perpetrators .....200 in number is not possible or else medical College would had been risen to the ground ..... moreover why only her ? U should ask every other politicians what they are doing to ensure the safety of doctors bcoz this is not only happening in Bengal or Bangalore but every nook and corner of the world ,so plz don't try to turn this sensitive issue into a political one and simply accept that every other politician is at fault
Hey Quint awesome job man in highlighting the Doctors issue.....
When we have uneducated politicians, there can be nothing more we can expect. I pray for all the doctors out there to stay safe.
Still we don't have enough Dr.. After reports like this we will will have fewer and fewer Drs..
So thank u quint. Like, if every junior dr. is living in this condition. 🙄
yes its a common scenario.....i think medical services in india were better during british era....
reason why Indian Doctors go to US/UK
Thank you quint..
another problem for which there is no solution in our country, corruption is killing us inside out. This is the reason why most doctors in India move out abroad if they cannot eventually to a private hospital and or their own clinic. disheartening!
Doctors face a lot of issues and now a days it's very very critical for them to survive. Regarding to my all doctors Friends I would say try not to pursue MBBS seriously. Illiterate people tried to kill them, embarrass them so basically do graduate in any field weather it is commerce or arts or science or even engineering like I am a B/tech guy but talking about them they are brutally attacked by the people without knowing anything... I am standing and with u 🙏🏻.
Jay Hind... thanks 'Quint' for this awareness video.👍🏼
"" Respect our doctors don't hurt them ""
It's better to be a doctor than any btech, commerce or arts course.
@@shubhamsehgal2336 yes sir but what I am trying to say is doctors in our country are harassing, brutally attacking by the illiterate and dishonest people that's y I said not to pursue mbbs , most importantly this is not my statement, this is the statement from the doctors.
All the best anyways..
Interns and pgs bear the brunt of the situation.
Not just interns pgs, also sr's & profs, I have seen them working inhuman hours for their age
When they say doctor here, they should mention government doctor because private hospital and private doctor has completely opposite situation, there patients are threaten, misbehaved, harassed, over charged, misdiagnosed.
It's so sad doctors who try so hard to save lives and save families from falling apart have no safety for their own lives . People give respect to those fake babas and politicians but doctor is treated like scrap .
Thank you so much Quint
Thanks for this video!
Doctors themselves work hard day and night to see their patients recover! Their well being gives the doctors satisfaction and how ironical they only are beaten up due to the patient's not understanding of situations!
0:11 Doctor A spotted…
High time people become more aware and responsible,not just blaming doctors for every bad consequence. Commendable report,highlighting ground realities.
The beneficiaries are at fault as well. During my posting in the deaddiction units, patients readily spend thousands on alcohol but question us while advising multivitamins.
I even witnessed an unusual event in the pediatric ward where the mother deliberately didn't give paracetamol to her child just because they decided not open the new bottle but use the older one instead which the father went back to home to bring it.
Please share dz vedios... In our social media... Thanks for making ds vedio🙏💕
I've just watched a foreign hospital ICU scenario and came to this,I think here the problem is deep rooted and unimaginably complex.Here we cannot completely blame common ppl because they themselves are victims of beuracracy and not to forget doctors before or also part and victims of this system.And the majority of basic indian society think that doctors are in a very comfortable lifestyle and job earning vast amount of money and usually misinformed or ignorant of the stress they experience.No control of hospital and pharmaceutical charges is one of its main reasons.And also not forget that rapid and high increase in medical clg fee and tough exam pattern, marks oriented studies resulted in commercial minded medical students however we cannot blame all of them,though they really want to be selfless and service minded they are helpless becoz they have to compensate the amount they spend to acquire that position,that is the reason why majority of Indian parents want their children to be either doctor or engineer.we can only change this if we each of us will come out of our selfish ,care less zone,having said that, that continuous work hours is inhumane.
The more I want to love my nation, the more I develop hatred towards it. I wish to I could say that I love my country, and I would never ever leave this place but then, this place is turning into something I have never dreamed of. The world is changing into a not so good place but my nation is deteriorating.
Like Gauraksha Dal , we need doctor Raksha dal
3:33 = Doctor A fans
it is bothway people and doctor are responsible for it in covid no doctor is coming to see the paitient it my personal experience
Jab doctor log
Give up kar denge
Tab pata chalega 😑😑😑😑😡😑
Where are nurse .. they also suffer ..
But doctors get more salary ..
Doctors also work harder then nurses. Don't u know the difference being a nurse and a DOCTOR
See that's the truth no one would blame MP who is irresponsible but the doctor's who are helping get targeted
As soon as patient is admitted in a hospital his relatives are given a long list of medicines and other medical items to be brought from outside . Relatives have to get it and handover to the duty nurse..out if that only a small portion of medical supplies are used where does the rest go?.. and moreover the hospital gets all medical supplies from the government whose pocket does it fill...the rot has spread throughout.
Go on, blame Mamata Banerjee CM of Bengal for it!
Arent the policticians responsible for this?
Facing humiliation & threats by local politicians and goons and pressurised by bossy higher authorities and beaten by patients & public... Missing own family life, Landing up in chronic illness... Thanks people for treating your healers with so many gifts.
What about the patients who die in hospital fire s ànd babies who get burnt in ICU s..... aren't doctor s responsible for it ...
#0.07 Doctor A now in UK
I am a junior doctor and work for really long hours to keep caring for the patients! the government is not spending enough money on the health sector and all the blame is on us doctors..and nurses..the patient parties are sometimes violent and there is a sence of loss of empathy in them for us!
Government may be spending but with lots of intermideate factors the money gets very less. Like mps, mlas, executives in hospitals, corruption.
Underpaid and long work hours .... lots of stress...
Great video quint. Subscribing ur channel because of this video
Hats off to doctors
Soooo true 😇
I feel bad for our doctors who trying there level best in such environment still not been respected for thier work
They should increase salaries of doctors irrespective of allopathy or indian medicine doctors or else doctors obviously will leave their homeland and work elsewhere, this country needs a lot of respect and salary hikes for professionals.
Nothing has changed.
pls i know u DR struggling a lot .... pls vote for AAP and see the change.... once change is change
A couple of my relatives died of doctors negligence...what do you say for that??!!
Doctors are also human. They are overworked so they may have forgotten about ur relative. They work continuously for so many hours at stretch.
India doesnt deserve trained medical professionals.....the work schedule is awesome in europe....everyone should migrate out of india.
Plz ask the patients and their families about how badly these doctors and nurses treat a common person. They don't really save our lives they are just doing their jobs. And one lady in this video tells us that is difficult to treat a stranger, why the hell are u learning medical then??
Me too think so...
Exactly...!
Every state in India same picture
Yes we should keep a gun with us!!
Quint is doing their duty ,but Andhbhakt don't like this
INDIA need a doc army...asap....otherwise country ll collapse soon
to be honest , if someone visits poor states like odisha , Govt doctors dnt work properly , they simply treat better n pvt nursing homes by charging more . there 's a doctor named subhendu das very renowned well knowledgeable doctor , you will find him treating in pvt homes by charging 300 per person .the same doctor wont treat you better if you consult him in MKCG berhammpur (govt hospital) . how satire is that .
If your working in government hospital have a respect for others ..you ppl treat patience like your like a god
Neet ki seats kyu nhi badhari govt.? Stress should be distributed. What a tragedy.!!!!
Thanks to let people know how difficult is to be a doctor.
Where is aamir khan now??
as if u voted for amir khan....
the problem in india is people in india are illiterate and dont question their elected leaders
Please don't misbehave with the doctors, whichever part of India we are staying, there are always to help us, and the poor and needy don't understand this.. PLEASE DO SHARE THIS TO ALL🙏🙏
Log pdhe like log Jo unke liye kaam Krte h, unki izzat nhi krte.
Junior doctors work most and this is not what they deserve. Almost every doctor tries their best when it comes to saving people but at times the best just isn't good enough.
I can imagine people getting nasty for Co-operate behaviors in Hospitals, delays, irrational fees and policies but Junior doctors have nothing to do with it.
Aisa hi chlta rha to more Doctors will rather work abroad than here. And then we would start complaining.. "India produces Engg and Doctors but they don't work for us".
Its quite common with the localities in karnataka. I have witnessed and threatened by bystanders when i was working in bangalore. Need better education instead of radical political teaching to common man.
Such unorthodox practices by hospitals in karnataka has to be stopped by the authorities. Foreign countries have government hospitals with 5*facilities. The kind of money investment in india for medical facilities expansion is 30-40% lofted than developed countries. Simultaneously the people should come out of stupidity to understand the hospitals are not temples and medical professionals are not GOD.
4:57🤣🤣 wtf!?
Pls do visit Engineering clgs too....show the condition of hostels...study pressure and suicides details, Jobs...pls do this
Noble profession eh?
Tumari wajah se Pakistan ko icj me kulbhusan jadhav ko dikkt aa rhi h
Doctors working in govt hospitals are only having this kind of suffering....
If you can't do the job, then why did u study 2 become a doctor?? Stop complaining. You're being paid. Just shut up & do your job!! Simple!
Straight from doctor A
I never support the manhandling of doctor.
I just have few question for doctors
Are Doctors being gentle in govt hospitals ?
Doesnt govt doctors demand money with poor in district hospitals
A govt office official doesnt even have some gentleness while saying patient is dead.
This people can go on strike when KAR Govt wanted to introduce the price capping on services in pvt hospital.
Y cant they fight against govt for better facility at hospital.
Patients vist to hospital to get support. if any doctor is questioned about the problem in hospital the answer ...
GO and ask GOVT. now for patients who is the govt rep. It is doctors.
So before complaining so much, doctors do have loop holes please fill that gap.
I do a regular visit to govt hospital. And writing this review.
I strongly oppose the manhandling of doctors.
Quint is doing a great job covering this! People should blame the government for the lack of facilities and not the doctors who give their best everyday!
Any doctor here
Doctors have to be careful about their work simple mistakes costs life once I was admitted to hospital one doctor made injection hurry it gave me heart attack
They r humans bruh
Yes doctor s are careless
Every story has 2 side, you are showing one side only. There are very few cases where Dr. is ill-treated but there are 1000s of cases where Dr/hospital ate doing inhumane things.
Exactly
Like organ transplant...
The root cause of this issue is no adequate doctors as per patients ratio , employ more doctors , we know our is blessed with population and huge people live below poverty line , only govt hospital is their saviour, so recruitment of doctors and make them regular shift in any other govt jobs . If govt do this , it's good for doctors and patients.
true your not god. but patient treat their doctors as god. doctor is resemblance of god. government cannot provide security to each and every doctor. i have utmost respect for doctor. my family doctor Dr. Kosuri Jeevan is more than god to us. long live jeevan doctor and his family of doctors
When they said that their working hours begins at 9 and goes on till the next day, timing unknown and when the female doctor says “it takes a lot out of u” to treat a “stranger” at odd hours. Why then are they in that field?. Get out from there, and choose a cushy 9-6 job... don’t berate the profession for ur shortcomings and ur ineptness..
Stop your bullshit comments. Its very annoying to see a person comment this way without common sense. My own sister who is a doctor had a serious kidney problem after working day and night. Have some humanity while making such comments. Put yourself in their shoes before making such senseless statements. People like you are unfit to be called humans
Right
What kind of attitudes....WTF
4:28 sir is right when ppl dont get a bed in ward or icu they say yaha ke dr. Shi se kaam nhi kar rahe hai wht they can do
Well that’s the humane side of doctors you are trying to show, ignoring their contempt and abhorrence to their patients and also rude behaviour to them is pervasive everywhere especially in government hospitals. That doctor is saying that ‘they are not god’’but they pretend like they are god and almighty and we are on their mercy.
Work 36 hrs straight without rest or food and in single shift u will become the so called rude person full of arrogance.
Please do cover the story of the anesthesiologist in jss hospital mysore who committed suicide
Treat a stranger, oh sorry madam so you studied medicine to treat your husband and parents?
Ha..ha..😂
4:56 hey ''Doc" A what were u abt to tell
Doctors at my place are business man! I don’t consider doctors to be anything more than a professional who does his job for monies!! He is just like any other professional in our country over appreciated job!
Don't stereotype. Go and visit a Govt hospital to get a reality check
Yes
All Hindi people who were in doctor. That's why kannada people slap you
India most of people needs to be civilized to choose the right person for governing the state. Its high time now. Its just we are not the victim we just leave it careless.
I am a medical transcriptionist and I am aghast at the way our “doctors” complain of “little rest”, “inhumanly long hours” etc. simple. Then why did u enter the medical profession “knowing” all this?. Weren’t you guys made aware of all these in medical school?. Don’t u guys know actually that this is indeed the case?. Or were u all so immersed in social networking that u guys were totally unaware of even these basics?. This is how these youngsters should be treated and “Instagram generation” should be made aware in a language they understand that life is not a bed of roses and they’ve to respect patients and treat them like humans rather than just patients. Then see the respect. I have also come across doctors overworked and yawningly dictating operative reports etc, but yes that’s the way of life. That’s how it is. If u don’t like it, get out but don’t sully the medical profession in general. There’s some little respect I have towards doctors don’t make me erode that also...
If they ger out, who will treat us? You! Chuthiya. All I can see here is your egoistic hatred, you cry like bitch. Take break. Lol
Disappointed and disgusting. feels sad for all those doctors who are working so hard doing their duty looking after so many patients but are not appreciated and not been respected. people should understand that even doctors are humans not God's. please co-operate with the doctor and respect them.☺
Can you do a video on Delhi govt. Hospital. Let's check the reality of govt. Claims
They made it already