The progress is good in the 1st evaluation..even they sound shaky..remember they sing it live..with the choreography within..still good ..SM training is magic..fighting D.A
yeah also their performance was pretty good Im ngl, they recieved a lot of criticism for it but I honestly loved it. Also they've just performed life is a movie on cbbc and I've been watching it on repeat as well!
@@Jazzyjihyo It was wonderful watching the whole docu-series and seeing them grow throughout. I think that criticism was a bit harsh but in the end it really pushed them to achieve their full potential. I'm quite excited for the debut!!!
@@fwabcaf yeah omg Im actually so excited, haters be haters but I have such good vibes about them! They have the passion and talent they could be the next big thing :)) and we will have supported them from the start
@@Jazzyjihyo I really go a lot off of vibes as well. They just feel like they genuinely care about each other and raising the others up. I'll be honest this isn't generally my type of music but it's easy to get swept up in it when you find something you like. Dear Alice has struck a chord lol.
Their voices may be a bit shaky, but they’re still good. With time, they’ll get better and better. Dear Alice, Alice will love it-the vibes, your vibes.
I'm hooked on this programme. I'm looking forward to the next episodes. I'm also hooked on this song. It's stuck in my head, especially in this basic form. Hope its a proper single. The music is giving me 80s boyband vibes .
This is actually impressive, we can hear their voices very clear here and idk how many kpop groups could sound like this. Voices are shaky but they all know how to sing. In kpop even when we hear idols sing live the backtrack is still loud so we don’t really know how stable they are. To me, especially for being one of the first if not the first time, this is great.
yeh felt like SM only has these high expectations for vocals to create drama for the show, theres def groups within the company that cant sing as stable as these guys and theyve debuted alr
@@Jazzyjihyo exactly, and there are definitely members in those groups that don’t know how to sing Iive at all. So it would be better if people held these guys at the same standard. If this was a popular kpop group everyone would be praising them
The vocal is there. It's apparent that they are not yet familiar with live singing while dancing but there is dynamic and power in their singing that I really like. SM did it again...when will I be free from this company 😂
THEY's soo luckyyy THAT SONG THEY GOT WAS SOOO GOOD!!! i meann very catchy not all debut groups have a great song coz they still be testing waters but this SOUNDSSSS AMAZING it'll be a HITT ITS SOO CATCHYYYY i just hope their body could catch up!!! they loosing breath with the heavy choreo parts!
Its not bad though since this is their first evaluation, while in most survival show the trainees went thru multiples monthly evaluations in their company before they joined the show.
@@emmatezuka7675 That's way too broad a generalization. It depends totally on the material and the performance. A lot of tracks by groups that involve dancing and singing will have the vocals pre-recorded as backup in live performances for the sound engineers who are monitoring if the group members are having problems with the vocals because they're tired from the dancing. If the sound engineers detect the singing failing, missing notes, going offkey, or insufficient volume, they'll bring in the recorded vocals to compensate. But they're are plenty of songs where that's not needed and in fact, in Japan, concerts are 100% live - the audiences demand it.
Reese and Dexter did the best vocal wise here. Olly didn't do bad but I think he might be nervous because of dancing. It's obvious James and Blaise won't be singers of the group but the best dancers, tho they can improve their singing if they want
The near bald one is the singer. It's not easy to sing and dance. Bg and gg aren't big in the West atm so they need a lot of luck to succeed and more to win over kpop fans who are now the natural audience for this music.
Honestly compared to some kpop groups they eating up these live vocals. Also it depends on the dance movement. Like the dance s pretty jumpy which makes it harder to stay stable. So yeah Reese is pretty amazing. I also think Olly did really well too.
I think they worried about dancing while singing too much, that their expressions didnt really fit the song vibe. I dont really mind about the shaky n unstable vocals since the choreo during chorus is quite tiring. Give them few weeks and im sure they will improve✨
This is so unfair to the guys that they should be filmed & judged so early in their training. I know Kpop trainees all have to audition individually but no Kpop group I know of gets exposed like this as a group so early in their progress. Of course the performance is rough; even the pro idol groups rehearse and rehearse and rehearse before letting anyone see it.
No sé les puede pedir mucho para una primera evaluación también. Cómo kpoper estoy acostumbrada a escuchar buenas voces estables, sobretodo de SM que tiene o ha tenido a vocales increíbles como Changmin , Onew , Taeyon , Baekhyun , Chen ,D.O , Jng , Boa , Winter ,Ning, Sohee . Yesung, Kyunhyun . Así que , estos muchachos tienen que dar mucho de ellos. Aún tiene un camino largo. Backstreet boys es un claro ejemplo también cuando se trata de bandas occidentales. Igualmente, la canción me encantó. Mucha suerte a estos chicos.
Me encantaria que a los grupos de kpop pongan las evaluacuones cantando y bailando al mismo tiempo, gente los ENCORE no cuentan Esto es oro para empezar y esta aprobado
at first i was like holy shit as expected this is cringe as heck but the longer i watch i'm like wait a minute i can actually see it they are on to something
Yes, we dont need to jump on the hate train like other people did. Dear Alice is a decent group with a very good debut song and people just want to hate them bcs theres no asian members😂 well they are not kpop boy group though, they are just kpop inspired british boyband.
I can really feel their struggle towards the end. But tbh, they are so good, at least to my standards. They just need to work on their dance bec it looks messy. It doesn't really feel like they're dancing as one. I can't wait to see their polished performance and see their improvements 🫶
exp edition was not bad at all, have you seen their live performances, there is a reason those men were older, they were already seasoned in musical theatre so they know their way around dancing with stable live vocals, please expose yourself to more music, respectfully
@@gierer797 Ik that I was just making a comment because of how people were making fun of EXP Edition back in the day not knowing we would get something worse lighten up lol
Estuvo muy bien considerando que toda la canción en vocal y no hay rap , aparte el baile es muy pesado y ellos lograron terminar sin ahogarse :) vamos !!
I believe there's even more better ones than those 5 boys... And i think one of the reasons why they're choosing is their background stories.. especially that tiktok boy 😅
The progress is good in the 1st evaluation..even they sound shaky..remember they sing it live..with the choreography within..still good ..SM training is magic..fighting D.A
After first week they're doing so well. More training they'll be so good.
꼭 그렇게 되길 바래요...
It’s literally their first evaluation I’m impressed, it’s not perfect but i see potential so much potential
None of them have it factor
@@mariasol1545 It's a group. You don't want to outshine other members
I've had this song stuck in my head for days. It's catchy.
yeah also their performance was pretty good Im ngl, they recieved a lot of criticism for it but I honestly loved it. Also they've just performed life is a movie on cbbc and I've been watching it on repeat as well!
@@Jazzyjihyo It was wonderful watching the whole docu-series and seeing them grow throughout. I think that criticism was a bit harsh but in the end it really pushed them to achieve their full potential. I'm quite excited for the debut!!!
@@fwabcaf yeah omg Im actually so excited, haters be haters but I have such good vibes about them! They have the passion and talent they could be the next big thing :)) and we will have supported them from the start
@@Jazzyjihyo I really go a lot off of vibes as well. They just feel like they genuinely care about each other and raising the others up. I'll be honest this isn't generally my type of music but it's easy to get swept up in it when you find something you like. Dear Alice has struck a chord lol.
They’re ok, but I can’t with the judges. They were like wtf is this 🤣🤣🤣
HAHAHAHAHAHA fr😂😂😂
Can't help, the standard is high
Rightfully so, lmao
😂😂😂
@vdy5791 Well I mean it does say their 1st week of evaluation, it's obviously gonna be pretty flawed during that point no matter what the standard is
Reese is really good!
Center material indeed. The only one who can pull off buzz cut
He has big charisma
Reese's vocals are crazy I could listen to his voice forever
for the level of 1st week training, they're so good, i think!
첫주니까....
U think? 😂
Their voices may be a bit shaky, but they’re still good. With time, they’ll get better and better. Dear Alice, Alice will love it-the vibes, your vibes.
a bit?😂
@@icyliciousblue I frankly seen much worst including some sm artist. The dancing is a mess tho.
well they are dancing
This is their first evaluation@@icyliciousblue
They seemed nervous here 😅
SM really knows where to find those vocalists with above average visuals, I can't.
Yeah but I don’t see this group being popular outside Korea… it’s giving EXP EDITION
I'm hooked on this programme. I'm looking forward to the next episodes. I'm also hooked on this song. It's stuck in my head, especially in this basic form. Hope its a proper single. The music is giving me 80s boyband vibes .
This is actually impressive, we can hear their voices very clear here and idk how many kpop groups could sound like this. Voices are shaky but they all know how to sing. In kpop even when we hear idols sing live the backtrack is still loud so we don’t really know how stable they are. To me, especially for being one of the first if not the first time, this is great.
yeh felt like SM only has these high expectations for vocals to create drama for the show, theres def groups within the company that cant sing as stable as these guys and theyve debuted alr
@@Jazzyjihyo exactly, and there are definitely members in those groups that don’t know how to sing Iive at all. So it would be better if people held these guys at the same standard. If this was a popular kpop group everyone would be praising them
shinee exist exo exist
Reese has it all; dance, phenomenal vocals, and looks
The judges faces omfg I’m screaming!!
I know right
definitely looking forward to their growth! Really like how raw it is.
Very good song. They are all lovely and performing well for the 1st training evaluation. Much expected for their final performance.
Reese is the main vocalist and center of the group❤
긴장풀고 연습더 해서 즐기면서 신나게 부르면 이 곡에 활기찬 느낌을 잘 살릴 수 있을듯
노래는 잘 뽑았네
노래는 몰겠고 리즈는 잘생김 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
The vocal is there. It's apparent that they are not yet familiar with live singing while dancing but there is dynamic and power in their singing that I really like. SM did it again...when will I be free from this company 😂
True
I'll second that😊.
Their songs are good!!!
and everyone thought reese was going to be the rapper.
Ikr😂 his voice is the best here
HAHAHAHA i think so
I thought he was a visual member but he was the main vocal LOL
THEY's soo luckyyy THAT SONG THEY GOT WAS SOOO GOOD!!! i meann very catchy not all debut groups have a great song coz they still be testing waters but this SOUNDSSSS AMAZING it'll be a HITT ITS SOO CATCHYYYY i just hope their body could catch up!!! they loosing breath with the heavy choreo parts!
It's literally a hit like What Makes You Beautiful level. I hope they debut it well.
Lets support these guys please😭🙏🏽 i feel like not many people are aware of Dear Alice and im quite worried about their debut😔
I need this somg to drop cause its a bopp
Woah the vocals eating now Im stanning
Its not bad though since this is their first evaluation, while in most survival show the trainees went thru multiples monthly evaluations in their company before they joined the show.
Their first ever training and evaluation? not that bad. They can go further. 🎉
The song is good! For only one week of training, this really isn't bad
I normally don't like shaved guy, but reese is so attractive
Cuz his face carried
❤❤❤Their back and shoulder move is so charming ❤❤❤
It's thier first week and this is hard. Y'ALL DID A GOOD JOB. Keep working hard it will come together!❤😂
Reese is phenomenal ❤❤❤
They sound amazing
I rather listen to this imperfect live singing than to a lot of "live" performances in kpop nowadays..
Everyone has their standards, I guess.
Me too ngl
Same here. Bcs live performances of K-pop groups nowadays are not actually LIVE. Its pre-recorded 😢
@@emmatezuka7675 That's way too broad a generalization. It depends totally on the material and the performance. A lot of tracks by groups that involve dancing and singing will have the vocals pre-recorded as backup in live performances for the sound engineers who are monitoring if the group members are having problems with the vocals because they're tired from the dancing. If the sound engineers detect the singing failing, missing notes, going offkey, or insufficient volume, they'll bring in the recorded vocals to compensate. But they're are plenty of songs where that's not needed and in fact, in Japan, concerts are 100% live - the audiences demand it.
First evaluation and this good is amazing, i mean in kpop some idols dont even know how to sing even after their debut
Very true some relying too much on lip sync and autotune
@@johnreton696 some do lip sync but atleast they know how to sing
Lip sync is better than not knowing singing
@GrizzElda22 most of hybe kpop group a tone deaf company
@@BigSM_hater_pinkblood BTS RM, Suga, Jin, Jimin
Oh please they actually sound better than alot of already-debuted idols especially nugu 4th gen bgs
Not bad! They did quite good imo.Their voice is a lil bit shaky and their dance is pretty good too.Anyway,not bad.
I CANT WAIT FOR THEIR DEBUT!!!!!
노래 좋고..친근한 비주얼 ㅎㅎ
너무 친근하다는게 함정ㅋㅋ
@@falLimlub-ce8is😂😂😂
Oh they have the potential... very good..
목소리는 확실히 팝의 본고장 본투비 팝.
ㅇㅈ ㅎㅎ같은생각이욤
Positive comments from koreans so far im so happy😭🙏🏽
That's cool. It's new for me.
노래 좋다 ❤
노랜 다 잘하네
빠져든다
노래도 좋고 목소리도 좋네요 격한 춤추면서 이정도 라이브면 잘 하는거같은데...
Positive comments from koreans so far im so happy😭🙏🏽
Reese and Dexter did the best vocal wise here. Olly didn't do bad but I think he might be nervous because of dancing. It's obvious James and Blaise won't be singers of the group but the best dancers, tho they can improve their singing if they want
Sooo excited for their evolution. They are good nglllll! Obsessed with this songggg. Here before 500 views😘Good luck boysssss!
The near bald one is the singer. It's not easy to sing and dance. Bg and gg aren't big in the West atm so they need a lot of luck to succeed and more to win over kpop fans who are now the natural audience for this music.
Reese is our bald king!
Its between Olly and Reese i think.
@@justmeajahpls not bald😂 but close
Honestly compared to some kpop groups they eating up these live vocals. Also it depends on the dance movement. Like the dance s pretty jumpy which makes it harder to stay stable. So yeah Reese is pretty amazing. I also think Olly did really well too.
Please they sing and dance at the same time guy
1st time performing? They did pretty good! I see mad potential in these boys. Dear Alice literally fighting! 💚💚💚
i love dear alice❤️
@@morgan-qc1wj I love BTS
열심히 하세용
트레이닝 받은기간에 비하면 상당히 잘하는거지
I think they worried about dancing while singing too much, that their expressions didnt really fit the song vibe. I dont really mind about the shaky n unstable vocals since the choreo during chorus is quite tiring. Give them few weeks and im sure they will improve✨
👍👍👍잘했어 이정도면
앞에서 저런표정으로 쳐다보면 진짜 긴장되겠다
Ayy a mi me gustó mucho ❤
Reese is rizzing with his vocals🥵
They are good
This is so unfair to the guys that they should be filmed & judged so early in their training. I know Kpop trainees all have to audition individually but no Kpop group I know of gets exposed like this as a group so early in their progress. Of course the performance is rough; even the pro idol groups rehearse and rehearse and rehearse before letting anyone see it.
They ain’t a kpop group and koreans dgaf about them so it doesn’t matter
No sé les puede pedir mucho para una primera evaluación también. Cómo kpoper estoy acostumbrada a escuchar buenas voces estables, sobretodo de SM que tiene o ha tenido a vocales increíbles como Changmin , Onew , Taeyon , Baekhyun , Chen ,D.O , Jng , Boa , Winter ,Ning, Sohee . Yesung, Kyunhyun .
Así que , estos muchachos tienen que dar mucho de ellos. Aún tiene un camino largo.
Backstreet boys es un claro ejemplo también cuando se trata de bandas occidentales.
Igualmente, la canción me encantó.
Mucha suerte a estos chicos.
남나라 언어로 노래까지 부른다는 것이 쉽지는 않겠지 ..서양과는 다를 힘든 단체 트레인닝 과정들을 어떻게 받아들일지..열정은 대단하다느낀다,,그럼에도 도전중이니까,
기존 원디랙션으로는 성공하기 힘드니 케이팝팬들을 끌어들이려고 하는게 보임...
그런데 케이팝팬들 수준이 너무 높아서 힘들거 같은데....
어떤기준으로 뽑았는지 이해할수가 없음...
외모되고, 보컬 좀 되고, 춤 좀되고 각각 뽑아놓니 팀이 산으로가네....
원디보다 비주얼이 딸림ㅠㅠ
아이돌 가수는 보여주는 음악이라 외모가 중요 + 한국팬들 기준 엄청 높은데 충족할진 모르겠음
노래는 좋네용
연습을 많이 하면 더 좋을거 같아요
Imagining One Direction dancing like this
They cant relate AT ALL... **flashbacks to one way or another mv lol**
Ok it's cute I'm watching a school performance.project.
노래 좋은듯~~~
와우❤❤❤❤❤
이 사람들 진짜 보이그룹으로 활동할건 아니고 그냥 영국 청년들의 한국 K팝체험 같은거겠죠? 그럼 뭐....한국에서의 좋은 추억 많이 가져가길...
sm에서 만든 영국팝그룹이라 kpop도 체험하게 하는듯 합니다.
Me encantaria que a los grupos de kpop pongan las evaluacuones cantando y bailando al mismo tiempo, gente los ENCORE no cuentan
Esto es oro para empezar y esta aprobado
They’re good they really are
i wanna see more evaluations cause even though they may sound not that good, they still sound very good and a bit stable
Patience, patience, and patience....
Need more training 2+ years
Lets go boys ❤
Olly's voice is so stable
Im sorry, do you mean Reese?
Both are great, but i prefer Olly's voice so
Both are the best singers in the group, reese is like zayn in 1D and olly is liam. Idk, its just my opinion
i don't wanna compare them with 1D but i agree with you both of them are really a great singer
@@ayla5661 i didnt though, dont get me wrong😭 even if i did, it's definitely not in a bad way cus i loooove both groups🫶🏽
at first i was like holy shit as expected this is cringe as heck but the longer i watch i'm like wait a minute i can actually see it they are on to something
Yes, we dont need to jump on the hate train like other people did. Dear Alice is a decent group with a very good debut song and people just want to hate them bcs theres no asian members😂 well they are not kpop boy group though, they are just kpop inspired british boyband.
@@han_js598and this is not their debut people will shocked them 👀
Where can I watch the show?
where can I find full video
Bilibili if u are outside of the uk
I can really feel their struggle towards the end. But tbh, they are so good, at least to my standards. They just need to work on their dance bec it looks messy. It doesn't really feel like they're dancing as one. I can't wait to see their polished performance and see their improvements 🫶
Need to be able to sing and dance at the same time.
They're not bad but The judges faces I can't they're like What im seeing
👁👄👁🤨
긍정적인 마음으로 응원하겠습니다.
물론 현재는 아마추어입니다. 많이 노력해서 꿈을 이루길 바랍니다.
노래는 좋은것 같습니다
Positive comments from koreans so far im so happy😭🙏🏽
When we thought EXP Edition was bad we got Dear Alice 😭
exp edition was not bad at all, have you seen their live performances, there is a reason those men were older, they were already seasoned in musical theatre so they know their way around dancing with stable live vocals, please expose yourself to more music, respectfully
@@gierer797 Ik that I was just making a comment because of how people were making fun of EXP Edition back in the day not knowing we would get something worse lighten up lol
I wonder if they could be the UK Eurovision entry?
This is not the kind of thing that does well at Eurovision, although it would give them some exposure
JAY of B.D.U. da vibras de este boygrup
I was thinking abt him too here 😂
Reese😍😍😍😍😍
노래는좋은디
OKAY, I WANNA KNOW THE UPDATE WITH THEM? I wanna know they made it!!
THEY MADE IT! They have a channel called ‘DearAliceOfficial’ (they’re band name is dear Alice) and they all made it together :)
@@Kpop-lover-2013 I am so stanning this unique group.
@@BiniNewJeans yup :3
They just dropped new vlog, pls give some love😔🙏🏽
Estuvo muy bien considerando que toda la canción en vocal y no hay rap , aparte el baile es muy pesado y ellos lograron terminar sin ahogarse :) vamos !!
Wow❤❤❤
They can improve 🎉
They got soul, it’s heart warming just not seeing them fit the business side of things…
난 괜찮은데? 라이브 춤추면서 저정도면. 다만..춤은 좀 다듬어야할듯 엣지 까리함이 없어.
Reese is amazing at singing
He should get the solo
But Ik he’s trying to be loyal but letting everyone try witch is actually kind
❤❤❤❤❤
A bit shaky, but tones super distict and beautiful ❤️
I believe there's even more better ones than those 5 boys... And i think one of the reasons why they're choosing is their background stories.. especially that tiktok boy 😅
Not bad but it's a very good song. They looked so quite nervous to doing a first evaluation performance so keep it up and on the next one.
실력들이 한국에서 아마추어같다. 트레이닝을 몇년 해야 할것같다
기본기가 탄탄한데? 케이팝스럽기만 한게 아니고 브릿팝느낌도 들고 나름 여유있어보여 딱딱하지가 않네! 갠적으로 너무 군무에 치중하지말고 보컬에 여유를 뒀으면 하네
Is this a leak? Where did u find this
@@hellobye7697 from their bbc documentary
its from the first ep of made in korea on bbc iplayer
1st ep is on bilibili, go watch it if u are outside of the UK
its criminal i have to be in the uk to watch this 😢