Thanks for watching folks! Also see.. 5 Darkest Harry Potter Theories: th-cam.com/video/aHRyJxnNSbo/w-d-xo.html Top 10 Darkest Moments LEFT OUT of the Films (PART 1): th-cam.com/video/IA_W2k6NUF0/w-d-xo.html
I always felt sorry for Kreacher. After Harry, Ron and Hermione did not return to Grimmauld Place after escaping from the Ministry of Magic in DH., it is mentioned that Yaxley saw the entrance of Grimmauld Place and it was probably crawling with Death Eaters. Kreacher was finally happy. The trio left and Kreacher was happily cooking for their return. I can only imagine how heartbreaking it must have been for Kreacher to hear voices, thinking it was the trio, and being confronted with Death Eaters. You know they were not gentle with him and probably tortured him for information. He must have shown Harry real loyalty because he could have told the Death Eaters about the locket, but I suspect he didn't because, if he had, Voldemort would have known they were hunting horcruxes earlier than he did especially once Yaxley verified what they had taken from Umbridge. Anyway, I just think of that brief moment in time when Kreacher was happy and then it all going terribly wrong for him.
I too worried about Kreacher. But he led the house elves at the battle of Hogwarts, if memory serves me right. I don’t think it occurred to Harry that he could order him to him at their hidden sight, though he may not have for Kreacher’s safety-as they were eventually captured by death eaters. Kreacher probably had a hard time like all the protagonists, but I firmly believe he had a happy ending. Edit: P 734 in the hard back. Chapter 36
I mean...I'm unsure if he has shown loyalty to Harry or Regulus in this case. In the end, Kreacher knew that Regulus sacrificed his life for finding and destroying the locket. Kreacher couldn't destroy it but would definitely do anything to help with this task. He had to feel like a complete failure to not be able to fulfill his master's last wish. So even if Death Eaters tortured him, he would say nothing just for Regulus's memory. I'm not saying he didn't do it for Harry also, but Regulus motivated him more.
@@nelab.4614 Ultimately, I think he showed loyalty to both but I think he will always show more to R.A.B. simply because he knew Regulus since Regulus was a baby. Kreacher was 666 when he died and he served the Blacks his entire life so I think it is safe to say he knew Regulus for at least 20 years. He only really knew Harry for a few months. They were good months but I think Kreacher would have always been more loyal. So I agree with you that Regulus' memory would have been a big part of why he didn't tell the Death Eaters anything.
I too never understood why they didn't called kreacher later, after the events in the ministry. Yes Yaxley probably saw the entrance of Grimmauld Place. But he could never have told anyone about it because he was no secret keeper. So the Grimmauld Place never could have been entered with a croud of deatheaters. Yaxley of course maybe could have tortured Kreacher. But he is just one...
About Ariana's abuse : A lot of readers doubt that it was a few guys beating her into a pulp . Muggles persecuting wizards and witch-hunting was a very well known occurrence . It happened to quite a number of wizards ( including Harry) .. but the way Ariana became mentally unstable for the rest of her life , how her body from outside was quite normal, how Percival hunted down those boys with murderous intent, how none of the family could ever bear to mention it ... Probably those boys sexually assaulted Ariana in some way or other .
I believe so too. I'm not saying that physical assault is any less, but for the Dumbledore patriarch to hunt down those boys and murder them, consequences be damned, it was most likely that the attack was mostly sexual in nature.
Bill being so entirely grotesquely disfigured in the books, lends so much to how much she absolutely loves Bill, it's not because of his looks, it not only adds some dread to the story, but adds depth to Fleurs character. And I love it. The entire book she's phlegm, and none of the Weasley women like her, but her loyalty and love towards Bill makes them realise she's a good person. I liked this in the books.
I heard that the reason they left that out is because the actor who voiced him died. But I agree that it should have been included. They could have recast him for that 1 scene.
Skeeter was knowingly spreading lies about fourteen-year-olds' private lives and outed Hagrid as a half-giant, which caused him to have a sort of breakdown. Hermione received lots of abusive letters and even one which sprayed a dangerous substance all over her hands - both hands needed bandages, all because of Skeeter. The lies also temporarily made Mrs. Weasley, a kind person Hermione trusted, become antagonistic towards her, which can't've been easy for the girl. Yeah, trapping someone and blackmailing them into not doing mean things is mean, but honestly, one year of not being able to ruin lives seems like an appropriate punishment.
And who knows what else she did! Behaviors like that are ones that increase in frequency, becoming the go the go to for any problem it can solve...Often escalate into worse behavior and lower moral standards....and last she would do all the spying and still lie so her greed also made her a lil witch bitch! ... as the persons gets away with them!
Yes, I think the video underestestimates how powerfull the media of News Paper is espcially if said media is murdering the reputation of a 14 year old girl. Beside Rita Skeeter sets the fundament for a darker side of the media. In the 5th book the News Paper undermines Harry's and Dumbledor's certibility too. It keeps lying about Voldemord's return and puts live in danger by doing so. So what Hermione dose may not be right but it is not us dark as it it portraited here. The reason for Hermione's triumph is that she finally found a way to get at her, not because she enjoys to be mean to her. Honestly if I had been her I would not have released her in London as promissed I would have reported Rita enyway. -Besides Rita was not locked up in the jar for a year! She cought her after the turnament and she set her free in London.
Skeeter and her little helper, Draco Malfoy, also KNEW what they were doing by repeatedly outing Hermione as muggleborn to the readers of her articles. She plays towards a bigoted audience & Hermione promptly received dangerous hatemail in which people call her a "muggle"
She is like the worst form of paparazzi form, selfish and uncaring who she damages for the news scopes. So technically Hermione is not really dark to do this as I bet 90% of people might do this if they can.
Rita brought about her own imprisonment by picking the fight with Granger. And if you remember that Rita wrote that book on Dumbledore in DH. Her imprisonment wasn't long enough.
@@PhilBagels I was expecting the thumbnail about Hermione to be about Marietta and what Hermione did to her face. Edit: Although I think that's in the movie. If there is a mention in the books that it lasted for years, but not in the books, I don't know about it, although I've been told it's there.
Is it bad to feel slightly satisfied with Hermione's dark character traits? I find them rather amusing, tbf. Becase Hermione grew them out of her own nature and not influenced by any childhood trauma or cruel classmate. Her cunning traits started to develop when she made Madam Promfrey fix her bucked teeth. 👏 Well done Miss Granger!!
They aren’t even really dark character traits honestly. She’s, generally speaking an exceedingly kind character. What she did to Rita was honestly not that bad, and that was Hermione at her worst. She got kept in a jar for a a week and blackmailed into not writing for a year, in return for attempting to ruin several peoples lives by lying about them. For example in this case specifically the article she wrote about Hermione resulted in her receiving huge amounts of hate mail, one letter spraying a toxic substance over her hands physically injuring her, with some of the letters focusing on her being muggle-born, as well as Mrs Weasley temporarily being against her, an adult that she trusted, until firmly told by Harry that none of it was true, all of which must have been quite a stressful experience especially for a 14 year old girl. So honestly Rita skeeter deserved worse and it seems to me somewhat of an exaggeration to call events like these evidence of some dark side of the character, when they were while somewhat questionable mostly on the still overly kind side of the spectrum.
Perhaps you might include Harry's own descent into the Dark Arts - his uses of the Cruciatus and Imperius Curses, firing off Sectumsempra in battle, etc. It was as if, after Sirius' death, Harry's moral compass began to stray and "the ends justify the means" began to take hold...
Harry does get a little edgier toward the end, but if I remember correctly, he only ever used Sectumsempra against Draco when he didn't know what it did and Snape after Snape 1v1'd my boy Dumbledore. He used Expelliarmus as his standard combat spell otherwise, to the point that it tipped off Voldy who the real Harry was during the Polyjuice grand prix. He uh, did cruciate the hell out of a Carrow. Even then, it was after Bellatrix telling him that he had to really mean it. The uses of the Imperius curse were just... necessary. As you said, wartime Harry let the ends justify the means on occasion, but he generally had a good idea of where the line was and when to cross it.
@@DragonTigerBoss used the cruciotus curse against Bellatrix when she killed Sirius, he used the imperius curse on the goblin when trying to get into greengots. The only one he never used was the killing curse.
Although he wasn’t just using them on random people or students. He was right in suspecting Malfoy as a Death Eater & one of the Carrows spitting in Professor McGonagalls face was an affront, so he was showing loyalty to her by using the Cruciatus curse
Hermione's capture of Rita...the act alone IS distasteful, but as you mentioned, she had every intention of releasing her. This temporary confinement seems less a dark impulse on Hermione's part and more retribution for the slander and career-destroying damage that Rita did with her invasive reporting, stories that she spun deliberately to rouse readers and inflame tensions. She wasn't concerned with truth, scandal is the only thing that mattered to her.
Well, if Rita wouldn't have been easedropping on the window ledge in the hospital, she wouldn't have been caught. Also, she wouldn't have died... there were air holes in the jar. She only had to be in that jar for however long it takes for the train to get from Hogwarts to the station in London. What Hermione did wasn't really illegal. However Rita being an unregistered animagi, is illegal.
Not to mention Hermione was attacked and injured as a direct consequence of one of Rita's stories. I am not even sure what is the darker thing Hermione did: Capturing Rita or not reporting her, which would have resulted in Rita being captured for a longer time at a worse place.
Remmember that Hermione's acts towards Rita's is due to the girl almost dying a lot of times, with angry fans of Harry sending her letters with dangerous content made to hurt her. All because of Rita's article painting her as a horrioble woman who hurt Harry's heart. I love how flawed the characters are in HP, even the golden trio. xD
I think Montague getting trapped in limbo between the vanishing cabinets (and possibly a toilet) for weeks(?) is pretty dark…. Funny to us as the reader but I imagine it was like being buried alive in darkness….😢
@@The_unknown_legend1409 Yeah, I know what book it’s in thanks. I’m talking about it was in the first part of the two part video this channel has made on the subject.
I find Peeves missing a big thing in the movies, Rik Mayall would've made him likely a good fun addition, as I loved his roles in Bottom and Young ones. The Ariana's father going after the boys suggest it is far more then beating or pestering her, in my view and also something that easily fuelled Dymbledore's muggle dislike early on.
@@SKBottom maybe she was. I wish we got to hear more of Dumbledore's story. He seeked power, just like Voldemort, but stopped. Maybe Dumbledore had more humility than most people with power.
@@SKBottom Did we ever find out how old the boys were? I think I read somewhere they were older than Ariana, but not much (Like, maybe a year or two). Honestly, though? That'd do it. Though where did that idea come from?
they saw her performing magic and forced her to replicate it, and she was too young to know how to control it at the time so she couldn't - then I forgot what happened but they caused her to become a squib and she was insane after that
I don’t think Dumbledore was seeking power like Voldemort. He wanted a world where magical and non magical communities coexisted. He wanted the non magical people to not fear magical people and he wanted magical people to accept non magical people. He didn’t want what happened to his sister to happen to anyone else and he also didn’t want his sister to have to be kept hidden away. I think his intentions at first were good but Grindlewald’s influence over him was not so good.
Neh.. I can forgive Hermione for that. Rita was a menace! She needed to be put in check. Just because she was a writer, didn't give her the right to make up lies and slander people, let alone endlessly torment and harass them, when they were already under extreme stress. She had far worse coming! Hermione let her off easy.
I think you made a mistake when speaking about Bertha Jorkins. She may have told him about the Tri-wizard tournament, but the real piece of information she gave was about Barty Crouch, Jr's imprisonment by Crouch, Sr. Crouch, Sr. had modified her memory, which is why that information was difficult to obtain. Recall that later in the book, Sirius describes Bertha as being sharp as a whip and never forgetting anything. That was the true information that Voldemort found so useful from Bertha as he had no knowledge of Crouch, Jr. not being in Azakaban prior to this.
Hermione capturing and holding Rita Skeeter hostage wasn’t really dark, slightly unnerving yes, but not dark. While Hermione did enjoy the action, it was not out of malice, but out of both relief and accomplishment. She managed to catch a person who was illegally using magic because she was an unregistered Animagus, who was using said powers to rudely and nefariously spy on people and their private lives or duties. She was justified in her actions. If it was a person who uses their abilities in order to spread truth, Hermione would have turned a blind eye. However, Rita Skeeter is not said person.
I feel absolutely no guilt on Hermione’s behalf. Rita Skeeter had it coming for a long time. I don’t know who I hate more, Rita Skeeter or Dolores Umbridge. But I definitely hate both more than Voldemort.
Its also written what peeves once grew so angry at trying to be exorcised he took great glee at torturing staff and students alike and it took a bribe of prank products to break free plus winkys drunkenness where she was so upset she was released from crouch she was drinking herself to death
I thought Rita survived because she wrote a book about Dumbledore in the 7th book and that's why Harry found out more about Dumbledore and went to Godric's hollow
Rita Skeeter got off easy. Hermione was too kind hearted to give her what she truly deserved, and, sadly but predictably, she learned nothing from her experience.
They should have squashed Rita Skeeter or let her suffocate! There also should be a spell to permanently get rid of a poltergeist. I’m sure Dumbledore or Snape were smart enough to get rid of him!
@@SKBottomI think enslaving someone adds a level of insanity to the story. Because technically he “willingly” had she with her which just makes it all messed up. No wonder he didn’t marry or have other children. Can you imagine having memories of being in love with someone who you actually disliked…the trauma, and then what can you use as an excuse for your behavior, he probably just thought he was severely mentally ill.
Yeah, they just assumed it was broken... or it could of been going off because of Percy aswell. That snake better have been under the imperious curse, cause if not and he willingly acted that way too his family, he can go choke on one. With that said, if he was under the curse, he wouldn't of came back at all at the end unless the person who cast it was dead... if that even gets rid of it, I'm not really sure on that, I don't think it's ever been stated. So it makes me think he made all those choices with his own free will....Which why curse him when he's already willing to pimp himself out for the Ministry if Fudge asked him to
@@yamahakid450f percy didn't really become a problem til the 5th book, and at the end of the 7th he apologized to his family. Percy wanted to be high at the ministry, and due to the whole "Voldemort's back" thing, percy pretty much stopped accoiating with his family because they believed Harry. Honestly idk why Fudge didn't believe Dumbledore, Barty Crouch Jr. Was alive, and they'd used a truth potion on him, he told Dumbledore and several others what had happened. And (in the book) Fudge had the dementors kill performed on Crouch Jr . An old death eater that was believed to be dead, was posing as a teacher in Hogwarts. Honestly you'd think the ministry was a little more intelligent 🙄.
They gang raped her. It fits the mythology of centaurs. And if you read the passage about how Umbridge was acting in the hospital wing afterwards it's pretty clear. Makes it even darker when Ron trolls her with horse clopping noises
The momories about hepziba smith, the gaunts, Riddles job request, et cetera. And what about the battle of Hogwarts in Half Blood Prince. Bella smashing some glass and setting the hut on fire was all there was in the movie.
Hi HPT! Have you ever heard of the theory that Dumbledore used time turner to set everything so that Voldemort could be vanquished forever? The idea goes, that the famous infamous deus ex machina at the battle of Hogwarts, where Ron allegedly spoke parseltongue, having memorized it, would be due to Dumbledore actually time jumping from the past to the final battle with a time turner, retrieving the basilisk tooth himself from the chamber of secrets and giving them to Ron and Hermione and then altering their memory so that they thought that they would have actually entered the chamber of secrets by Ron speaking parseltongue he memorized from listening Harry speaking in his dreams. Dumbledore as the most powerful wizard who ever lived 100 % sure would have felt curiosity towards this extremely rare and dangerous magical artifact he possessed. He intensively studied the future and learned that the only timeline in which Voldemort would be defeated would be the one we read. Throughout the books Rowling made very clear that: a) Parseltongue can only be inherited, so Ron couldn't have possibly have learned it b) chamber of secrets required a opening command from a parseltongue, not just any random hissing noise memorized by a 17 year old wizard c) chamber of secret was sealed by the strongest professors of Hogwarts after the second book, so parseltongue alone couldn't have even opened it We know Dumbledore did plot Harry's life and he certainly did plot it in VERY strange way: 1) As he knew he was a horcrux, he never had to reason to expect anything from Harry and thus, caring whether he attends Hogwarts or where does he live his childhood wouldn't really matter, yet he especially insisted Harry would be left to the worst possible place a child could be left into, despite of knowing his life would have to end for Voldemort's demise. 2) Letting him face the most inhumane enemies every school year ever since he attended Hogwarts for no apparent reason. As the principal of Hogwarts and the most powerful wizard of his era he could have prevented almost every threat Harry ever ventured into, but instead he chose to let Harry to travel through five fantasy novels before personally involving him into the Horcrux hunt, which he had zero reasons to do. 3) actively helping Harry himself to mischief by literally gifting him one of the three deathly hallows he possessed, letting Sirius mail him Firebarnd etc... 4) Despite of his powers, he didn't even attempt to defend himself from death eaters when him and Harry landed at Hogwarts in the 6th book, letting the whole scenario to happen which led to Snape eventually killing him, which was exactly which needed to happen for the 7th book to happen. 5) We already learned at the 7th book that whole Harry's life was planned to his death with the resurrection stone and Snape's memories, so we know Dumbledore did plan his life from the beginning just to let Voldemort personally kill Harry for the exact reason to the Horcrux in him to be destroyed. Dumbledore was a benevolent spirit, so as the most powerful wizard in the history he would have desired to use his powers for good, meaning the destruction of the ultimate evil, which Voldemort represented. Rowling proved herself to be so flawlessly brilliant writer she simply couldn't have written this level of deus ex machina to the book. Either it was an inexplicable writer's error and laziness, or she wrote the deepest secret backstory to the book ever in the history of writing: the true mastermind of the book carefully studying the future and learning that the only theoretically possible way Voldemort could be eradicated would be if everything would be done in very precise certain way? What if Dumbledore studied the time turner just to learn that the only theoretical way in which Voldemort could be slain would be if EVERYTHING happened in this very, very bizarre way? And I mean, if you are anybody with a time turner you'd just chase your personal life goals like kiss your crush and get lots of money, but if you were the literal Dumbledore - the greatest wizard ever to have lived, you'd use it to study its greatest potential, which would be to study the future to eradicate the evil from the world. There's no reason why wouldn't he have used the artifact for exactly this purpose. What do you think?
@@bruhda7469 why should we assume that the most powerful wizard who ever lived was limited to the official safety cautions and limitations of time turners? and why should we assume dumbledore wouldn't couldn't open the door which he himself sealed in his own castle even without parseltongue, or even that he secretly couldn't have known it along with all his other secrets he for sure had? It's not a plot hole to assume that Dumbledore was even more powerful that he let others know, but it is terrible plot hole to assume that the written version of Ron Weasley speaking parseltongue would be the real truth.
I agree about 9 out of 10 moments should appear. Bertha Jorkins is just not important enough to be shown, it's enough to say what happened to her accurately by the characters who tell the story. And no need to feel sorry about Rita Skeeter because she deserved to suffer like that. One of the moments I loved Hermione the most.
No Voldemort asked to borrow a house elf from Regulus who volunteered Kreacher and he was forced to drink the potion as a result, it's part of how Regulus figures out about the horcrux.
Sometimes good people have to do bad things, because it’s the right thing to do. That’s chaotic-good. Being lawful-good is almost as bad as being any kind of evil. Most people are chaotic-good, because we know that right is better than good. Dumbledore is a perfect example of that, so I think we can forgive Hermione, or Fred & George, or Harry, or anyone else who may have done something objectionable for the right reasons.
Not that it's relevant but since they are rebooting Harry Potter (which I totally disagree with) why isn't anyone rebooting Narnia? It's been the same amount of time between the last HP and Narnia movies, which HP finished the franchise where as Narnia didn't. I would much rather a Narnia series reboot rather than Harry Potter.
I did a story treatment of Hermione being split personality due to her torturing at the hands of Bellatrix Lestrange. Where she kept her torturer's wand and had bouts of switching into a darker personality where she secretly hunted down Death Eaters and captured and tortured them. Sometimes going to Azkaban and torturing them in the prison. Hermione had a darker side as you pointed out. And no one comes away from that level of torture unscathed.
Hermione literally kidnapped Rita for weeks, stuffed her in a jar, would SHAKE THE JAR every once in awhile, blackmailed her into silence and then essentially ruined her career by silencing her from stirring up drama 😅😂😂 To give her credit, she did give her a breakout story with Harry. But book Hermione was a thug 😂
I don't blame Hermione at all. Rita Skita made Hermione look bad, and other girls were sending her insulting letters and even howlers, because Rita Skita claimed she was playing both Harry and Krum.
@@Larka661 true lol. It's just funny that Hermione of all people did this 🤣 gotta respect her for it tho. She had Rita dead to rights with the knowledge of her being an animagus.
@@that.canadian.vaper.guyTCVG well Hermione wanted to find out how she was getting private information without being caught. She found out Rita Skita was an unregistered animagus, which is illegal.
She didn't keep her in there for weeks! She cought her after the tornament in the hospitla and released her in London. -What Rita was doing with her kind of writing was worse! And she didn't ruin her carrier! Rita did well later as author of Dumbldores biography (which she only could write by oblivating an old woman).
RAB stole the Horcrux...but did he manage to destroy it before he died? I am curious about that one. If that is the case, then there was not 7 Horcruxes that happened.
Bertha, I think she found out about Barty Crouch Junior and Bartie Crouch Senior had put such a strong memory charm on her that breaking it messed her up. Like Big V bad but minister of magic jerk is bad too.
Peeves, I think he was loosening the screws on a chandelier when Professor McGonagal told him to untighten them in the opposite direction during Umbridge rule
I always though regulus knowing about the locket was a plothole. How would he learn about it? I doubt Voldemort was so stupid to tell hes death eaters about hes horcruxes and their whereabouts. We all know from the books that yes while he was pure evil he also was very smart. And think about it. If you had a horcrux what would be the best thing to keep it save. By not telling a soul about it would be the first step
That's a massive jump to assume that Hermione could have killed Rita. While she did blackmail Rita, you completely left out the part where she tells them that she put an unbreakable charm on the jar so that Rita couldn't transform back into being human, but it doesn't say ANYTHING about whether or not there are holes in the jar for air, and if the jar is unbreakable, Rita would be safer in it than out. Definitely wouldn't say that she did nothing wrong, but you're doing some Olympic level leaps to assume that Rita could have died in that jar.
Dumbledore‘s brother tell us a little bit when Harry into the town and is under the protection in his bar. His sister had killed their mother and needed to be handled because she was a malidictus. His father never explained why he attacked the Muggles that had abused the six year old that made her this way her magic into self. The reason being she would be sent to Saint Mungo for the rest of your life because of the statute of secrecy because she can’t control her magic. so wizards ruled then Dumbledore wouldn’t have to worry about that aspect of things. These boys who saw Ariana do magic and then burst through into their backyard and tried to force her to do it again had ruined the family. Really Dumbledore should’ve just let Aberforth leave school and take care of his sister and then Dumbledore go earn gold and make sure the two of them never had to fend for themselves that they had plenty of money. Of course Grindelwald use thecruciatus curse on Aberforth … but anyway
I really don't understand why didn't Hermione just hand Rita Skeeter to magical law enforcement authorities upon discovering she was an illegal Animagus and she was using this to do wrong. That would have been the right thing to do, and it would have solved the issue they had with the "journalist" very effectively.
Did RAB have a change of heart only because Big V asked for a house elf and Regulus gave him one and Big V planned on just leaving him to die, but because RAB had ordered Kreacher to come back was able to teleport away from the cavern And that caused Regulus to be incensed? Either way we saw how awesome Kreacher can be when he’s happy, because when the golden Trio we’re looking for Horcruxes and gave Kreacher the locket that RAB died for he was very caring and made sure that they were fed well and the place was clean.
Another great video by you - as always....but why this annoying nonsense with the contorted fake smiles in the thumbnails for this and other of your newest videos? 🙄
You're not allowed to use magic outside of school until 17. Harry was kind of an exception, first book he releases a boa constrictor from the zoo, and Dudly ends up in the snakes aquarium. That was unintentional. 2nd Dobby made a cake float over the visitors the Dursleys were trying to impress. So, not his fault. In the 5th book he uses the patronus charm to save him and Dudly, the ministry did a hearing on that, and since he was protecting himself and his cousin, he was cleared of charges. He blew his aunt up, unintentionally. His anger was getting the better of him, and sometimes a young wizard can't help what happens when your emotions take over.
@@Larka661 I think the magic law didn't eply in case of children to young for school because it seems to be in there nature that they are losing controle not just Harry.
Ha ha ha ha ha can’t stop laughing not at the video but the thumbnail ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha haHa ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
na she was unregistered and illegally stalking people in beetle form should have took a dump in the jar from the cat since most beetles eat crap and she is always full of it
3:00 Hermione can lose it, shortly after learning how to conjure Canaries she sent a whole bunch of them after Ron when he was snogging being with Lavender, when he comes back via the illuminator, she desperately wanted her want back because she was planning on messing Ron up and she physically hit him many times. I do believe in the book she just slapped Draco Malfoy, as opposed in the movies where she punched him, but her whatever you wanna call it has come up multiple times. But yes, imprisoning a human being, trapped as a for the majority of the year …
Please stop putting these ridiculous “joker” looking smiles on your thumbnails. It looks terrible. You’re free to do what you want of course but it just looks terrible and serves no purpose.
Thanks for watching folks! Also see..
5 Darkest Harry Potter Theories: th-cam.com/video/aHRyJxnNSbo/w-d-xo.html
Top 10 Darkest Moments LEFT OUT of the Films (PART 1): th-cam.com/video/IA_W2k6NUF0/w-d-xo.html
I always felt sorry for Kreacher. After Harry, Ron and Hermione did not return to Grimmauld Place after escaping from the Ministry of Magic in DH., it is mentioned that Yaxley saw the entrance of Grimmauld Place and it was probably crawling with Death Eaters. Kreacher was finally happy. The trio left and Kreacher was happily cooking for their return. I can only imagine how heartbreaking it must have been for Kreacher to hear voices, thinking it was the trio, and being confronted with Death Eaters. You know they were not gentle with him and probably tortured him for information. He must have shown Harry real loyalty because he could have told the Death Eaters about the locket, but I suspect he didn't because, if he had, Voldemort would have known they were hunting horcruxes earlier than he did especially once Yaxley verified what they had taken from Umbridge. Anyway, I just think of that brief moment in time when Kreacher was happy and then it all going terribly wrong for him.
I too worried about Kreacher. But he led the house elves at the battle of Hogwarts, if memory serves me right.
I don’t think it occurred to Harry that he could order him to him at their hidden sight, though he may not have for Kreacher’s safety-as they were eventually captured by death eaters.
Kreacher probably had a hard time like all the protagonists, but I firmly believe he had a happy ending.
Edit: P 734 in the hard back. Chapter 36
I mean...I'm unsure if he has shown loyalty to Harry or Regulus in this case. In the end, Kreacher knew that Regulus sacrificed his life for finding and destroying the locket. Kreacher couldn't destroy it but would definitely do anything to help with this task. He had to feel like a complete failure to not be able to fulfill his master's last wish. So even if Death Eaters tortured him, he would say nothing just for Regulus's memory. I'm not saying he didn't do it for Harry also, but Regulus motivated him more.
@@nelab.4614 Ultimately, I think he showed loyalty to both but I think he will always show more to R.A.B. simply because he knew Regulus since Regulus was a baby. Kreacher was 666 when he died and he served the Blacks his entire life so I think it is safe to say he knew Regulus for at least 20 years. He only really knew Harry for a few months. They were good months but I think Kreacher would have always been more loyal. So I agree with you that Regulus' memory would have been a big part of why he didn't tell the Death Eaters anything.
this! it always made me really sad
I too never understood why they didn't called kreacher later, after the events in the ministry.
Yes Yaxley probably saw the entrance of Grimmauld Place. But he could never have told anyone about it because he was no secret keeper.
So the Grimmauld Place never could have been entered with a croud of deatheaters. Yaxley of course maybe could have tortured Kreacher. But he is just one...
About Ariana's abuse : A lot of readers doubt that it was a few guys beating her into a pulp . Muggles persecuting wizards and witch-hunting was a very well known occurrence . It happened to quite a number of wizards ( including Harry) .. but the way Ariana became mentally unstable for the rest of her life , how her body from outside was quite normal, how Percival hunted down those boys with murderous intent, how none of the family could ever bear to mention it ... Probably those boys sexually assaulted Ariana in some way or other .
I always felt this was heavily implied
I believe so too. I'm not saying that physical assault is any less, but for the Dumbledore patriarch to hunt down those boys and murder them, consequences be damned, it was most likely that the attack was mostly sexual in nature.
Bill being so entirely grotesquely disfigured in the books, lends so much to how much she absolutely loves Bill, it's not because of his looks, it not only adds some dread to the story, but adds depth to Fleurs character. And I love it. The entire book she's phlegm, and none of the Weasley women like her, but her loyalty and love towards Bill makes them realise she's a good person. I liked this in the books.
Kreachers's redemption being left out is wrong.
Facts
I really hope its something they cover in the tv show
One of the many reasons I'm happy the TV series is coming
Still sad about them not being able to make it back for Kreacher’s meal after they broke into the ministry…
I heard that the reason they left that out is because the actor who voiced him died. But I agree that it should have been included. They could have recast him for that 1 scene.
Skeeter was knowingly spreading lies about fourteen-year-olds' private lives and outed Hagrid as a half-giant, which caused him to have a sort of breakdown. Hermione received lots of abusive letters and even one which sprayed a dangerous substance all over her hands - both hands needed bandages, all because of Skeeter. The lies also temporarily made Mrs. Weasley, a kind person Hermione trusted, become antagonistic towards her, which can't've been easy for the girl. Yeah, trapping someone and blackmailing them into not doing mean things is mean, but honestly, one year of not being able to ruin lives seems like an appropriate punishment.
And who knows what else she did! Behaviors like that are ones that increase in frequency, becoming the go the go to for any problem it can solve...Often escalate into worse behavior and lower moral standards....and last she would do all the spying and still lie so her greed also made her a lil witch bitch! ... as the persons gets away with them!
They could of used an unforgettable curse on her right infront of me, I would of giggled and forgot I saw anything. Same with Umbridge.
Yes, I think the video underestestimates how powerfull the media of News Paper is espcially if said media is murdering the reputation of a 14 year old girl. Beside Rita Skeeter sets the fundament for a darker side of the media. In the 5th book the News Paper undermines Harry's and Dumbledor's certibility too. It keeps lying about Voldemord's return and puts live in danger by doing so. So what Hermione dose may not be right but it is not us dark as it it portraited here. The reason for Hermione's triumph is that she finally found a way to get at her, not because she enjoys to be mean to her. Honestly if I had been her I would not have released her in London as promissed I would have reported Rita enyway. -Besides Rita was not locked up in the jar for a year! She cought her after the turnament and she set her free in London.
Yea but kidnapping is kind of illegal. Rita does awful things, but still.
Skeeter and her little helper, Draco Malfoy, also KNEW what they were doing by repeatedly outing Hermione as muggleborn to the readers of her articles. She plays towards a bigoted audience & Hermione promptly received dangerous hatemail in which people call her a "muggle"
"Rita could have died in there..."
And no one would have cared or missed her lol
She is like the worst form of paparazzi form, selfish and uncaring who she damages for the news scopes. So technically Hermione is not really dark to do this as I bet 90% of people might do this if they can.
Rita brought about her own imprisonment by picking the fight with Granger. And if you remember that Rita wrote that book on Dumbledore in DH. Her imprisonment wasn't long enough.
And imprisonment - even wrongful imprisonment - is not torture. Clickbait thumbnail!
@@PhilBagels I was expecting the thumbnail about Hermione to be about Marietta and what Hermione did to her face. Edit: Although I think that's in the movie. If there is a mention in the books that it lasted for years, but not in the books, I don't know about it, although I've been told it's there.
@@ceinwenchandler4716 It's in the book, but not in the movie. And even that, I wouldn't call torture. Acne isn't even painful.
Is it bad to feel slightly satisfied with Hermione's dark character traits?
I find them rather amusing, tbf. Becase Hermione grew them out of her own nature and not influenced by any childhood trauma or cruel classmate.
Her cunning traits started to develop when she made Madam Promfrey fix her bucked teeth. 👏 Well done Miss Granger!!
They aren’t even really dark character traits honestly. She’s, generally speaking an exceedingly kind character. What she did to Rita was honestly not that bad, and that was Hermione at her worst. She got kept in a jar for a a week and blackmailed into not writing for a year, in return for attempting to ruin several peoples lives by lying about them. For example in this case specifically the article she wrote about Hermione resulted in her receiving huge amounts of hate mail, one letter spraying a toxic substance over her hands physically injuring her, with some of the letters focusing on her being muggle-born, as well as Mrs Weasley temporarily being against her, an adult that she trusted, until firmly told by Harry that none of it was true, all of which must have been quite a stressful experience especially for a 14 year old girl. So honestly Rita skeeter deserved worse and it seems to me somewhat of an exaggeration to call events like these evidence of some dark side of the character, when they were while somewhat questionable mostly on the still overly kind side of the spectrum.
Rita had it coming for her, if you ask me.@@imperialinquisition6006
Perhaps you might include Harry's own descent into the Dark Arts - his uses of the Cruciatus and Imperius Curses, firing off Sectumsempra in battle, etc. It was as if, after Sirius' death, Harry's moral compass began to stray and "the ends justify the means" began to take hold...
Harry does get a little edgier toward the end, but if I remember correctly, he only ever used Sectumsempra against Draco when he didn't know what it did and Snape after Snape 1v1'd my boy Dumbledore. He used Expelliarmus as his standard combat spell otherwise, to the point that it tipped off Voldy who the real Harry was during the Polyjuice grand prix.
He uh, did cruciate the hell out of a Carrow. Even then, it was after Bellatrix telling him that he had to really mean it. The uses of the Imperius curse were just... necessary. As you said, wartime Harry let the ends justify the means on occasion, but he generally had a good idea of where the line was and when to cross it.
@@DragonTigerBoss used the cruciotus curse against Bellatrix when she killed Sirius, he used the imperius curse on the goblin when trying to get into greengots. The only one he never used was the killing curse.
If I’m not mistaken, these were mentioned in the Pt 1 video
Although he wasn’t just using them on random people or students. He was right in suspecting Malfoy as a Death Eater & one of the Carrows spitting in Professor McGonagalls face was an affront, so he was showing loyalty to her by using the Cruciatus curse
@@DragonTigerBoss "polyjuice grand prix" lmao 💀
Hermione's capture of Rita...the act alone IS distasteful, but as you mentioned, she had every intention of releasing her.
This temporary confinement seems less a dark impulse on Hermione's part and more retribution for the slander and career-destroying damage that Rita did with her invasive reporting, stories that she spun deliberately to rouse readers and inflame tensions. She wasn't concerned with truth, scandal is the only thing that mattered to her.
Well, if Rita wouldn't have been easedropping on the window ledge in the hospital, she wouldn't have been caught. Also, she wouldn't have died... there were air holes in the jar. She only had to be in that jar for however long it takes for the train to get from Hogwarts to the station in London. What Hermione did wasn't really illegal. However Rita being an unregistered animagi, is illegal.
Not to mention Hermione was attacked and injured as a direct consequence of one of Rita's stories. I am not even sure what is the darker thing Hermione did: Capturing Rita or not reporting her, which would have resulted in Rita being captured for a longer time at a worse place.
Remmember that Hermione's acts towards Rita's is due to the girl almost dying a lot of times, with angry fans of Harry sending her letters with dangerous content made to hurt her. All because of Rita's article painting her as a horrioble woman who hurt Harry's heart. I love how flawed the characters are in HP, even the golden trio. xD
Makes me love Hermione even more. If adults won't punish other adults for their bad behaviors, Hermione is the most powerful witch of her year!
I think Montague getting trapped in limbo between the vanishing cabinets (and possibly a toilet) for weeks(?) is pretty dark…. Funny to us as the reader but I imagine it was like being buried alive in darkness….😢
That was in the first one, wasn't it?
@@clfoster82 no i think that was in 5th book.( i think) . plus that is the cabinet from which death eaters would enter hogwarts on the 6th books
@@The_unknown_legend1409 yes but I think they meant that HP Theory already mentioned that plotline in the first video of this series :)
That was in Part 1.
@@The_unknown_legend1409 Yeah, I know what book it’s in thanks. I’m talking about it was in the first part of the two part video this channel has made on the subject.
Harry had a pretty rageful attitude in Order of the Phoenix that wasn’t shown in the movies.
Yes and at times he was arrogant when he lost his temper.
I find Peeves missing a big thing in the movies, Rik Mayall would've made him likely a good fun addition, as I loved his roles in Bottom and Young ones.
The Ariana's father going after the boys suggest it is far more then beating or pestering her, in my view and also something that easily fuelled Dymbledore's muggle dislike early on.
Most people assumed she was raped.
@@SKBottom maybe she was. I wish we got to hear more of Dumbledore's story. He seeked power, just like Voldemort, but stopped. Maybe Dumbledore had more humility than most people with power.
@@SKBottom Did we ever find out how old the boys were? I think I read somewhere they were older than Ariana, but not much (Like, maybe a year or two). Honestly, though? That'd do it. Though where did that idea come from?
they saw her performing magic and forced her to replicate it, and she was too young to know how to control it at the time so she couldn't - then I forgot what happened but they caused her to become a squib and she was insane after that
I don’t think Dumbledore was seeking power like Voldemort. He wanted a world where magical and non magical communities coexisted. He wanted the non magical people to not fear magical people and he wanted magical people to accept non magical people. He didn’t want what happened to his sister to happen to anyone else and he also didn’t want his sister to have to be kept hidden away. I think his intentions at first were good but Grindlewald’s influence over him was not so good.
Neh.. I can forgive Hermione for that.
Rita was a menace! She needed to be put in check. Just because she was a writer, didn't give her the right to make up lies and slander people, let alone endlessly torment and harass them, when they were already under extreme stress.
She had far worse coming! Hermione let her off easy.
I think you made a mistake when speaking about Bertha Jorkins. She may have told him about the Tri-wizard tournament, but the real piece of information she gave was about Barty Crouch, Jr's imprisonment by Crouch, Sr. Crouch, Sr. had modified her memory, which is why that information was difficult to obtain. Recall that later in the book, Sirius describes Bertha as being sharp as a whip and never forgetting anything. That was the true information that Voldemort found so useful from Bertha as he had no knowledge of Crouch, Jr. not being in Azakaban prior to this.
That thumbnail: why do I expect her to ask me, "You wanna know how I got these scars?"
My Father was a dentist…
Hermoinie should have put the unbreakae jar in a wet cement block
Neville and the burning sorting hat was the coolest fucking scene. I was so pissed they left it out of the movies.
The movies glossed over how physical Snape got with Harry after he looked at his memories.
Awesome thanks as always
Hermione capturing and holding Rita Skeeter hostage wasn’t really dark, slightly unnerving yes, but not dark. While Hermione did enjoy the action, it was not out of malice, but out of both relief and accomplishment. She managed to catch a person who was illegally using magic because she was an unregistered Animagus, who was using said powers to rudely and nefariously spy on people and their private lives or duties. She was justified in her actions. If it was a person who uses their abilities in order to spread truth, Hermione would have turned a blind eye. However, Rita Skeeter is not said person.
I feel absolutely no guilt on Hermione’s behalf.
Rita Skeeter had it coming for a long time.
I don’t know who I hate more, Rita Skeeter or Dolores Umbridge.
But I definitely hate both more than Voldemort.
Its also written what peeves once grew so angry at trying to be exorcised he took great glee at torturing staff and students alike and it took a bribe of prank products to break free plus winkys drunkenness where she was so upset she was released from crouch she was drinking herself to death
I thought Rita survived because she wrote a book about Dumbledore in the 7th book and that's why Harry found out more about Dumbledore and went to Godric's hollow
The exact moment that George died was pretty dark. The wall next to him exploded
Fred
@@lukenewt1683 oops
@@macwelch8599 But George lost ALL of his ear not just a part of it.
I loved when Hermione trapped Rita in the jar. Never thought of it as "dark" more as jsut.
Rita Skeeter got off easy. Hermione was too kind hearted to give her what she truly deserved, and, sadly but predictably, she learned nothing from her experience.
A very Good Video 👍🏻
They should have squashed Rita Skeeter or let her suffocate! There also should be a spell to permanently get rid of a poltergeist. I’m sure Dumbledore or Snape were smart enough to get rid of him!
Voldemort’s dad getting raped is pretty dark too.
I think it was more sexual enslavement
@@quedotelancine1685what's the difference? He was given a magical roofie.
@@SKBottomI guess you could look at it both ways. A love potion causes lust and obsession.
@@SKBottomI think enslaving someone adds a level of insanity to the story. Because technically he “willingly” had she with her which just makes it all messed up. No wonder he didn’t marry or have other children. Can you imagine having memories of being in love with someone who you actually disliked…the trauma, and then what can you use as an excuse for your behavior, he probably just thought he was severely mentally ill.
Voldemort's whole story is dark in retrospect. That's why he became what he was.
Rita deserved her confinement if you ask me.
Too bad they never added the Sneakoscope in the 3rd movie. It was always going off, because petegrew was there.
Yeah, they just assumed it was broken... or it could of been going off because of Percy aswell. That snake better have been under the imperious curse, cause if not and he willingly acted that way too his family, he can go choke on one.
With that said, if he was under the curse, he wouldn't of came back at all at the end unless the person who cast it was dead... if that even gets rid of it, I'm not really sure on that, I don't think it's ever been stated. So it makes me think he made all those choices with his own free will....Which why curse him when he's already willing to pimp himself out for the Ministry if Fudge asked him to
@@yamahakid450f percy didn't really become a problem til the 5th book, and at the end of the 7th he apologized to his family. Percy wanted to be high at the ministry, and due to the whole "Voldemort's back" thing, percy pretty much stopped accoiating with his family because they believed Harry. Honestly idk why Fudge didn't believe Dumbledore, Barty Crouch Jr. Was alive, and they'd used a truth potion on him, he told Dumbledore and several others what had happened. And (in the book) Fudge had the dementors kill performed on Crouch Jr . An old death eater that was believed to be dead, was posing as a teacher in Hogwarts. Honestly you'd think the ministry was a little more intelligent 🙄.
I still want to know what the centaurs did or were going to do to Umbridge.
They gang raped her. It fits the mythology of centaurs. And if you read the passage about how Umbridge was acting in the hospital wing afterwards it's pretty clear. Makes it even darker when Ron trolls her with horse clopping noises
6:20 I read the bookks to death and not once did I notice that Neville ended up on fire.... poor guy
In the movie of the Hogwarts fight, Neville’s head didn’t explode, I’m pretty sure.
Its annoying how they changed the plots for the movies. But a movie can only be so long. I hope they change that in the tv series.
Idk why but every time when you say "Hey everyone" my mind always complete the rest of it with "I'm the Canadian Lad" 😂
One of the strangest memes out in the world is making people look as if they had Tetanus to show that they are "evil".
The momories about hepziba smith, the gaunts, Riddles job request, et cetera. And what about the battle of Hogwarts in Half Blood Prince. Bella smashing some glass and setting the hut on fire was all there was in the movie.
Hi HPT! Have you ever heard of the theory that Dumbledore used time turner to set everything so that Voldemort could be vanquished forever?
The idea goes, that the famous infamous deus ex machina at the battle of Hogwarts, where Ron allegedly spoke parseltongue, having memorized it, would be due to Dumbledore actually time jumping from the past to the final battle with a time turner, retrieving the basilisk tooth himself from the chamber of secrets and giving them to Ron and Hermione and then altering their memory so that they thought that they would have actually entered the chamber of secrets by Ron speaking parseltongue he memorized from listening Harry speaking in his dreams. Dumbledore as the most powerful wizard who ever lived 100 % sure would have felt curiosity towards this extremely rare and dangerous magical artifact he possessed. He intensively studied the future and learned that the only timeline in which Voldemort would be defeated would be the one we read.
Throughout the books Rowling made very clear that:
a) Parseltongue can only be inherited, so Ron couldn't have possibly have learned it
b) chamber of secrets required a opening command from a parseltongue, not just any random hissing noise memorized by a 17 year old wizard
c) chamber of secret was sealed by the strongest professors of Hogwarts after the second book, so parseltongue alone couldn't have even opened it
We know Dumbledore did plot Harry's life and he certainly did plot it in VERY strange way:
1) As he knew he was a horcrux, he never had to reason to expect anything from Harry and thus, caring whether he attends Hogwarts or where does he live his childhood wouldn't really matter, yet he especially insisted Harry would be left to the worst possible place a child could be left into, despite of knowing his life would have to end for Voldemort's demise.
2) Letting him face the most inhumane enemies every school year ever since he attended Hogwarts for no apparent reason. As the principal of Hogwarts and the most powerful wizard of his era he could have prevented almost every threat Harry ever ventured into, but instead he chose to let Harry to travel through five fantasy novels before personally involving him into the Horcrux hunt, which he had zero reasons to do.
3) actively helping Harry himself to mischief by literally gifting him one of the three deathly hallows he possessed, letting Sirius mail him Firebarnd etc...
4) Despite of his powers, he didn't even attempt to defend himself from death eaters when him and Harry landed at Hogwarts in the 6th book, letting the whole scenario to happen which led to Snape eventually killing him, which was exactly which needed to happen for the 7th book to happen.
5) We already learned at the 7th book that whole Harry's life was planned to his death with the resurrection stone and Snape's memories, so we know Dumbledore did plan his life from the beginning just to let Voldemort personally kill Harry for the exact reason to the Horcrux in him to be destroyed.
Dumbledore was a benevolent spirit, so as the most powerful wizard in the history he would have desired to use his powers for good, meaning the destruction of the ultimate evil, which Voldemort represented.
Rowling proved herself to be so flawlessly brilliant writer she simply couldn't have written this level of deus ex machina to the book. Either it was an inexplicable writer's error and laziness, or she wrote the deepest secret backstory to the book ever in the history of writing: the true mastermind of the book carefully studying the future and learning that the only theoretically possible way Voldemort could be eradicated would be if everything would be done in very precise certain way? What if Dumbledore studied the time turner just to learn that the only theoretical way in which Voldemort could be slain would be if EVERYTHING happened in this very, very bizarre way? And I mean, if you are anybody with a time turner you'd just chase your personal life goals like kiss your crush and get lots of money, but if you were the literal Dumbledore - the greatest wizard ever to have lived, you'd use it to study its greatest potential, which would be to study the future to eradicate the evil from the world. There's no reason why wouldn't he have used the artifact for exactly this purpose.
What do you think?
This was an interesting read, I have never heard this theory!
@@NeverKissSomeFrog123 agreed
Ignores the 5 hour rule,and can time turners even go forward in time????
And dumbledore doesn't know parsletongue. Salazar probably wouldve installed alot of protective charms aswel
@@bruhda7469 why should we assume that the most powerful wizard who ever lived was limited to the official safety cautions and limitations of time turners? and why should we assume dumbledore wouldn't couldn't open the door which he himself sealed in his own castle even without parseltongue, or even that he secretly couldn't have known it along with all his other secrets he for sure had?
It's not a plot hole to assume that Dumbledore was even more powerful that he let others know, but it is terrible plot hole to assume that the written version of Ron Weasley speaking parseltongue would be the real truth.
Nice video bro
I agree about 9 out of 10 moments should appear. Bertha Jorkins is just not important enough to be shown, it's enough to say what happened to her accurately by the characters who tell the story. And no need to feel sorry about Rita Skeeter because she deserved to suffer like that. One of the moments I loved Hermione the most.
It has been said recently that Peeves was let off the movies on purpose, because he was making everyone laugh too much.
"You wanted to see magic. Why are you crying?" - Percival Dumbledore probably
I though regulus had Kreacher drink the potion. I'm gonna have to check that
No Voldemort asked to borrow a house elf from Regulus who volunteered Kreacher and he was forced to drink the potion as a result, it's part of how Regulus figures out about the horcrux.
In actuality it's actually fenrir greybacks face that's unrecognizable.
Let’s not forget that the Weasley twins petrified a garden gnome, painted it gold, put wings on it and placed it on top of the Christmas tree 😅
Sometimes good people have to do bad things, because it’s the right thing to do. That’s chaotic-good. Being lawful-good is almost as bad as being any kind of evil. Most people are chaotic-good, because we know that right is better than good. Dumbledore is a perfect example of that, so I think we can forgive Hermione, or Fred & George, or Harry, or anyone else who may have done something objectionable for the right reasons.
Her name was Bertha Jorkins at 6:20
Whenever I remember the movie series i imagine all the things they left out in my own little imaginary version of the whole series.
TBH, I connect with Hermione, would've done the same with Rita Skeeter
Not that it's relevant but since they are rebooting Harry Potter (which I totally disagree with) why isn't anyone rebooting Narnia? It's been the same amount of time between the last HP and Narnia movies, which HP finished the franchise where as Narnia didn't. I would much rather a Narnia series reboot rather than Harry Potter.
Yes, that would be a good thing!
I forgot how Neville being set on fire.
I did a story treatment of Hermione being split personality due to her torturing at the hands of Bellatrix Lestrange. Where she kept her torturer's wand and had bouts of switching into a darker personality where she secretly hunted down Death Eaters and captured and tortured them. Sometimes going to Azkaban and torturing them in the prison.
Hermione had a darker side as you pointed out. And no one comes away from that level of torture unscathed.
what's implied but not said is that Rita would DIE if she tried transform back into her human form.
Kreacher: "Tricksy Potterses!"
Hermione literally kidnapped Rita for weeks, stuffed her in a jar, would SHAKE THE JAR every once in awhile, blackmailed her into silence and then essentially ruined her career by silencing her from stirring up drama 😅😂😂
To give her credit, she did give her a breakout story with Harry. But book Hermione was a thug 😂
I don't blame Hermione at all. Rita Skita made Hermione look bad, and other girls were sending her insulting letters and even howlers, because Rita Skita claimed she was playing both Harry and Krum.
@@Larka661 true lol. It's just funny that Hermione of all people did this 🤣 gotta respect her for it tho. She had Rita dead to rights with the knowledge of her being an animagus.
@@that.canadian.vaper.guyTCVG well Hermione wanted to find out how she was getting private information without being caught. She found out Rita Skita was an unregistered animagus, which is illegal.
She didn't keep her in there for weeks! She cought her after the tornament in the hospitla and released her in London. -What Rita was doing with her kind of writing was worse! And she didn't ruin her carrier! Rita did well later as author of Dumbldores biography (which she only could write by oblivating an old woman).
People say Neville got hot in the later movies I guess they were right
RAB stole the Horcrux...but did he manage to destroy it before he died? I am curious about that one. If that is the case, then there was not 7 Horcruxes that happened.
Of course he didn‘t. That’s why it found it’s way into Umbridge‘s hands. You‘ve gotta reread deathly hallows ;-)
Makes me want to buy a new set of books.
Ariana was an obscurus. That rage killed her.
Bertha, I think she found out about Barty Crouch Junior and Bartie Crouch Senior had put such a strong memory charm on her that breaking it messed her up. Like Big V bad but minister of magic jerk is bad too.
Peeves, I think he was loosening the screws on a chandelier when Professor McGonagal told him to untighten them in the opposite direction during Umbridge rule
Just a question: I never caught Peeves dark past? Were is that written?
When Hermione put Skeeter in the jar, she forgot to use a lid without any air holes.... She's a waste of perfectly good oxygen.
I always though regulus knowing about the locket was a plothole. How would he learn about it? I doubt Voldemort was so stupid to tell hes death eaters about hes horcruxes and their whereabouts. We all know from the books that yes while he was pure evil he also was very smart. And think about it. If you had a horcrux what would be the best thing to keep it save. By not telling a soul about it would be the first step
Should Rita skeeter death affect anyone 🤔???.
Makerhe new show with everything from the books
That just Hermione is following the law by capturing her.
That's a massive jump to assume that Hermione could have killed Rita. While she did blackmail Rita, you completely left out the part where she tells them that she put an unbreakable charm on the jar so that Rita couldn't transform back into being human, but it doesn't say ANYTHING about whether or not there are holes in the jar for air, and if the jar is unbreakable, Rita would be safer in it than out.
Definitely wouldn't say that she did nothing wrong, but you're doing some Olympic level leaps to assume that Rita could have died in that jar.
Dumbledore‘s brother tell us a little bit when Harry into the town and is under the protection in his bar. His sister had killed their mother and needed to be handled because she was a malidictus. His father never explained why he attacked the Muggles that had abused the six year old that made her this way her magic into self. The reason being she would be sent to Saint Mungo for the rest of your life because of the statute of secrecy because she can’t control her magic. so wizards ruled then Dumbledore wouldn’t have to worry about that aspect of things. These boys who saw Ariana do magic and then burst through into their backyard and tried to force her to do it again had ruined the family. Really Dumbledore should’ve just let Aberforth leave school and take care of his sister and then Dumbledore go earn gold and make sure the two of them never had to fend for themselves that they had plenty of money. Of course Grindelwald use thecruciatus curse on Aberforth … but anyway
Unpopular opinion: Hermione Granger should have used the Cruciatus Curse on Rita Skeeter
It would’ve been less deadly than trapping her in a jar
I really don't understand why didn't Hermione just hand Rita Skeeter to magical law enforcement authorities upon discovering she was an illegal Animagus and she was using this to do wrong. That would have been the right thing to do, and it would have solved the issue they had with the "journalist" very effectively.
" Give her hell form us Peeves!!!!!!!"
Did RAB have a change of heart only because Big V asked for a house elf and Regulus gave him one and Big V planned on just leaving him to die, but because RAB had ordered Kreacher to come back was able to teleport away from the cavern And that caused Regulus to be incensed? Either way we saw how awesome Kreacher can be when he’s happy, because when the golden Trio we’re looking for Horcruxes and gave Kreacher the locket that RAB died for he was very caring and made sure that they were fed well and the place was clean.
rowena is the founder; helena is the daughter!
Wish they would’ve added peeves lol specially with unbridge
Forgotten Hermione disfiguring another student? Hermione Face-slasher Granger, that's her name.
They left the entirety of peeves!! 😭
If Hermione did capture Rita skeeter then Hermione still good cause Rita skeeter is evil 😈. 😈
Hermione should have dug a hole and tossed the jar into it. Or kept the beetle as a pet 🤣. Making it live on a beetles diet for the rest of its life.
Rita F’d with Hermione and found out.
Another great video by you - as always....but why this annoying nonsense with the contorted fake smiles in the thumbnails for this and other of your newest videos? 🙄
Skeeter was treated according to her actions.
What if Harry was exempt from using magic outside school
You're not allowed to use magic outside of school until 17. Harry was kind of an exception, first book he releases a boa constrictor from the zoo, and Dudly ends up in the snakes aquarium. That was unintentional. 2nd Dobby made a cake float over the visitors the Dursleys were trying to impress. So, not his fault. In the 5th book he uses the patronus charm to save him and Dudly, the ministry did a hearing on that, and since he was protecting himself and his cousin, he was cleared of charges. He blew his aunt up, unintentionally. His anger was getting the better of him, and sometimes a young wizard can't help what happens when your emotions take over.
@@Larka661 I think the magic law didn't eply in case of children to young for school because it seems to be in there nature that they are losing controle not just Harry.
That thumbnail is disturbing.
Book Hermione would have made a decent Slytherin.
She's muggle born, and Slytherin doesn't let muggle borns in it's house.
How dare you that doesn't happen to my precious Billy that's slander that you are saying. Bills fine.
No one ever talks about Tom Riddle Sr. getting raped.
Ha ha ha ha ha can’t stop laughing not at the video but the thumbnail ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha haHa ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
na she was unregistered and illegally stalking people in beetle form should have took a dump in the jar from the cat since most beetles eat crap and she is always full of it
Bill was never bitten, Fenrir clawed his face
What you saw of Hermione in the movie was only a small taste. Now she in 2023 spends her time torturing the world with her idiot ideas
these thumbnails are really goofy
Click bait
Nederlands
3:00 Hermione can lose it, shortly after learning how to conjure Canaries she sent a whole bunch of them after Ron when he was snogging being with Lavender, when he comes back via the illuminator, she desperately wanted her want back because she was planning on messing Ron up and she physically hit him many times. I do believe in the book she just slapped Draco Malfoy, as opposed in the movies where she punched him, but her whatever you wanna call it has come up multiple times. But yes, imprisoning a human being, trapped as a for the majority of the year …
Setting fire to Snape is no big deal apparently …
😊🏝🏜🗺
Please stop putting these ridiculous “joker” looking smiles on your thumbnails. It looks terrible. You’re free to do what you want of course but it just looks terrible and serves no purpose.