Keen to own a luxurious 1-bedroom apartment at Fourth Avenue Residences in Singapore's prestigious Bukit Timah District? With direct access to Sixth Avenue MRT and within 1km of Raffles Girls' Primary School, this is an opportunity not to be missed. Contact owner at morriestory@gmail.com today. Can Malaysia turn Forest City into the next Southeast Asia financial hub? Let us know in the comments below! If you enjoyed this video, do like, subscribe and buy us a coffee: bmc.link/worldknowmore Check out this video on Malaysia's epic loss of talent to Singapore: th-cam.com/video/m-NiSCWd65g/w-d-xo.htmlsi=X2DwlPOHQ9SXaUCA
Connect singapore and forest city with a bridge and borderless passage and see the region thrive. Immigration controls are destroying the economy and causing massive pollution due to congestion.
Impossible to turn new Project as similar to Spore.Spore is City state built by Stanford Raffles since 1819.as proverd as said Rome is not built in a day Seemly Msia looking inferior But actually Malaysian Sarawak Iban in interior is Richest.waiting the next 20year 200 3:42 20
A competent, clean government will take no part in a private company project or foreigner owned developed property, unfortunately , it is not this case here due to vast Royalty interests involved.Secondly, we still don't have a clean competent government even after 2018 historic unseat of BN government.
Without govt help , the forest city will be a real failure and sour point forever. There is merit to do this as it actually can make the area into a vibrant productive areas being close to Singapore and to the coming major Port in Malacca developed by China . This would bring jobs to the area. There will be lots of Chinese and Singapore companies will be investing etc.
Not really true. The project was already existed even before the Madani govt. So Madani govt has no part in it. Yes, by revitalising it , is just like rescuing those many abandoned project. It is a good project . Only thing is it needs certain advantages and that advantages are what the Madani provided to revive the project. It is better to make it profitable, collect taxes and complements the Malacca big port project and provide JB more residential and commercial units now idle to accommodate the influx of many Singaporeans and Malaysians with the opening of the RTS link between Singapor/Malaysia. Know the economics. The govt is doing the right thing Your narrative is wrong and
HK was the financial hub and it still is. It takes decades for SG to come to par with HK. Talk is cheap until you start to understand the difficulties involved in getting there.
Because tuanku doesn't want to kacau Tanah Melayu in mainland Malaysia. That is why building an artificial island for foreign mass investment hopefully it could drive economic growth for Malaysia as well.
When it does succeed..Greedy selfish politicians will crash in and mess it up..Only wise rakyat/citizens must vote in an uncorrupted PM can we continue to progress otherwise will regress a deep fall..Pray for a harmonious & progressive Malaysia🙏❤🙏
'High risk', 'Bold' multi Billion Plan built on the shoulder of ordinary people purse string or our nation's vast resources is always part of Malaysia Government Policy since Independence.If it is successful, Malay Monarch and Chinese corporation reap the gains, if not, Malaysians pay the losses.
The only thing successful about investing in Forrest City is that you’d get to see success across the border in Singapore from the comfort of your balcony, and that’s the only success you’ll see. But, at least you get to breathe in the vapours of success coming originating from Singapore.
pls learn basic demand and supply first before you mass produce so many units. Rome isn't build on one day. No city was built from 'mega-project' and then expect all humans to live in it. obviously built by those who overly day-dream.
Sigh... The problem with Forest City, or any other mega-projects, failed because of the inability of the government to realize that their people are nit able to afford to buy or spend in these places. A nation must have the critical consumer population to even go ahead with projects like these. Don't put the cart in front of the horse.
@@mayfoo02 Even so, such a big project will fail because there are not enough consumers to buy such high price properties. If they have started small and expand later when the properties are majority occupied, then, build on another stage, it may succeed.
It would become a joint JB-Singapore Special Economic Zone. The HSR from Kunming connects Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, Malaysia, and Singapore will be built after the former PM of Malaysia canceled it. Furthermore, the Singapore to JB MRT will enhance transportation from the Rain Forest location. Except for one of the 8 apartments completed recently, the rest were occupied.
that is why government housing policy should lead to the houses needed by the rakyat not foreigners. we should go back to 40% low cost 40% mid cost and 20% luxury homes.
@@mishahul Totally agree 💯. Singapore will be part of that Private Entity trying to make it happen. A Financial Hub which will rival Singapore Financial Status??? Lets see if it works. They need Land...They are Out of It after A Ban on Sand to Singapore was in place recently...allegedly for Reclaimation Projects which changes the sea current leading up to disastrous consequences after the recent oil spill. Losing Their Curve is detrimental to the Marine Ecosystem n clean up effort or the natural occurrence into the deep sea away from human habitats. Turning it into A Casino was Singapore first initiative yet it will be in direct competition to MBS n Sentosa. JB has never seen itself as Malaysia. Always trying TO BE SINGAPORE. Maybe Singapore will take over that Ghost City for good n The JB Palace could recoup their 100billion losses. If only the Developer n Investors had the foresight to use the area n build An Intergrated Playground combining... Public Housing Landed...Condos...Retirement Oasis n A Waterfront Luxury Living for Foreigners 2nd Home. Alas Creativity n Long Term Planning not A Thing with Greedy Investors. It will give Malaysians working in Singapore...A Home or even Rental Units for singles. Lost Opportunity. WASTAGE with Mega Projects is A Huge Issue in Malaysia.
Not surprising a Singaporean media outlet critizing Malaysias development project and at same time, advertise their tiny 1 bed room apartment at a triple price than in Malaysia 😂😂😂😂
Very poor location. It’s just beside Singapore’s port and heavy industries. Imagine the environment the supposed target group, the wealthy people, have to put up with. And staying among labourers and workers.
Only those with good hard cold cash and young with open mindset will fall for it. The name clearly stated Forest City. It is two different entity and human will be like a sandwich living there.
Sinkiepore actually hates it when Malaysia do well economically. They really do not like that Malaysia is becoming a powerhouse for Semicon and data centers. If the government play their cards right and build infrastructure projects like HSR and LRT to stop at Forest City, it will become a success because of its strategic location.
Yes. I agree with u. As u said "if" malaysia do this and "if" malaysia do that. "If" only I strike lottery; "if" only I look like Tom Cruise. In the meantime, u continue to dream the "if", OK?
Malaysia does not have a population big enough for this kind of mega projects. Also it is not cheap. How many consumers can afford that? The project must start small first and build on that.
@@thinkie12 Infrastructure projects does not only benefit the locals. FYI, Changi-KLIA is the world's busiest international route with 4.9 million seats in 2023. A high-speed rail that can take passengers from Singapore to KL in 90 mins will be in demand compared to flight because a train is still needed to reach KL from KLIA. Considering that over 300,000 Johoreans work in Singapore and commute via motorbikes on a daily basis, LRT will be in demand once RTS is operational as commuters can take the LRT to RTS link and then the MRT in Singapore. It is not a stretch to say it's possible to commute from Johor to Singapore daily for work within 1 hour of travelling time. Hence, why properties near RTS are selling like hot cakes now.
Everytime Malaysia announced some major project, they always say it will compete with Singapore. When they first build KLIA they say they will compete with Changi. When they build the seaport at Port Klang, they can compete with singapore port. Let's see how this financial hub turns out
Singapore soon gonna be dead city... global warming...shortage of clean water, food supply and other resources, the fact is Malaysia & Indonesia will no longer supply. While singapore gonna be land less too many stress citizen, bunch of old folks... Singapore have to create under sea city....but have to overcome tsunami n etc....
Planning a high end residential and commercial area right beside Singapore’s port and heavy industries doesn’t sound well. If I’m rich and wealthy I wouldn’t pick to stay beside heavy industries and with loads of foreign labourers and workers staying close by.
kami rakyat 🇲🇾 cukup bertuah mempunyai salah 1 perdana menteri all the best sepanjang kemerdekaan kami..jika kamu menyatakan kehilangan kami projek2 mega berbillion dollar atau apa sekalipun jika ia tidak menguntungkannya kepada masyarakat bawahan terutama sekali kepada warga & rakyatnya???itu lebih baik kami kehilangannya..kerana hari ini saya cukup berkeyakinan kepada pemimpin kami yang lebih mementingkan dahulu keselesaan rakyat serta kehidupan asasi rakyatnya yang diutamakan..jika projek2 mega ini yang kebiasaannya lebih menguntungkan kepada org2 luar daripada penghuni warga negaranya..ofcorse lebih baik ia tidak berjaya seperti apa yang diharapkan..apa yang penting sesuai dengan keperluan warganya diutamakan itu yang dipandang oleh kepimpinan kami pada hari ini..ianya cukup membahagiakan bagi kami sebagai warga negaranya..biarlah kami maju sealiran hasrat rakyatnya yang tidak banyak yang ketertinggalan..bukan untuk mengisi kantong2 orang luar dipikirkan tetapi rakyatnya diutamakan..welldone my presiden DATUK SERI PADUKA DI-RAJA DATUK ANWAR IBRAHIM..1990an saya menikmati pembelajaran kami ketika itu dia sebagai menjawat jawatan menteri pendidikan yang terbaik di negara kami malah diasia tenggara..& hari ini sesuailah beliau menjadi prime minester kami semoga kesejahteraan negara kami semakin baik bukanlah untuk didunia bukanlah untuk kami bermegah megah seperti negara2 lain tetapi apa yang penting sekali adalah kami rakyatnya yang ekonominya lebih baik dari sebelumnya..itu yang lebih penting bagi kami bukan untuk siapa2 bagi pihak asing..sejahtera negara berdaulat kami itu yang sentiasa kami doakan selalu..semoga orang luar dapat lebih memahaminya..lawan tetap lawan..
Build some kind of border crossing to Singapore, and buyers will flood in. Rail, ferry, or pedestrian will work as long as there is a connection to the MRT in Singapore
And connected to the Singapore’s port and heavy industries area, which is situated right beside. Together with hordes of labourers and workers staying close together. Don’t think this environment would be attractive to the supposed target group, ‘the rich and wealthy’.
I stayed in one of the houses. A RM2 mollion home. It's haunted. I lost 4 solitaire diamond rings. I told the hostess about it, she too is a foreigner. She ribbish it off. All that was left in my bag was a watch & 2 imitation rings & a cheap gold plated ring. I mix the rings all in a bag when l left my house to stay with her. When l wrnt back home l wanted to put them back for safe keeping. To my horror, all 4 solitaires disappeared. I wore those rings regularly but hospital procedure requested l remove it that Thursday. Friday, l was in my friend's place. I kept them in my bag mixed with others. Saturday l wrnt home. That night l found them all missing. I suspected her or the toyol. She's jobless, husband works overseas. Period.
Project yg tidak berfaedah tidak di uruskan ngan baik. Rakyat Malaysia kebanyakkan tidak mampu nk beli pun. Jual ke orang luar menambahkan lagi orang asing berkuasa Yg hilang 1 juta Chiness dlm negara masih belum ada titik noktah. Apa tah lagi isu lambakan warga asing illegal yg buat negara ni macam negara mereka.Membaiki bandar yg sedia ada lagi bagus dr buat Pulau Buatan. Hurm dh kira untung tapi rentong. Jual murah aja kat rakyat baru la Raja berjiwa rakyat.
The Mr 10 percent was not given a share that's why he protest, remember the high speed train he stop the project renegotiate went to China with LGE came back and lie to the public that he already cuts down on the price instead they cut corners to bring the price down nothing change now we have to pay more for the original price
Singapore'a financial hub was built through years/decades of hard works. Malaysia with their political instability and tidak apa attitude coupled with brain drain trend, can dream on.
the reason it flopped is multifactorial.. but mainly due to the unstable political background in Malaysia for the last decade, COVID and also background intererence by YouKnowWho... it has potential, but need strong leaders to step up and take responsibility, a good public transport system(because its far from the general population) and backing by the government, who knows it might turn out to be good.. but having live in JB, knowing what's going on behind the scene, things are much more complicated than that..
Malaysia is always dreaming..ask them about their Wawasan 2020 plan.. it's 2024 already.. Whene KLIA opened years ago, they claim it will rival Changi Airport.. I wonder 🤔
TUN M wawasan 2020 planning to be fail from beginning, The Policies does support to encourage to fail due to untouched and illogical businesses activities which not meritocracy in planning human capital. Corruption is planning ahead than meritocracy systems.
So many hate comments from probably Singaporeans. Just sit and relax. Time will tell if the govts plans would work. This project is fully funded by private sector. Govt of the day is only pushed to make it a success because..you know why..but if it fails it really doesnt hurt the Malaysian govt a bit..but if it turns out to be a success..it will really benefits Malaysia..this project is even raised on a manmade island. 😘
@@detox78 Singapore will be part of that Private Entity trying to make it happen. So don't even go there. A Financial Hub which will rival Singapore Financial Status??? Lets see if it works. They need Land...They are Out of It after A Ban on Sand to Singapore was in place recently...allegedly for Reclaimation Projects which changes the sea current leading up to disastrous consequences after the recent oil spill. Losing Their Curve is detrimental to the Marine Ecosystem n clean up effort or the natural occurrence into the deep sea away from human habitats. Turning it into A Casino was Singapore first initiative yet it will be in direct competition to MBS n Sentosa. JB has never seen itself as Malaysia. Always trying TO BE SINGAPORE. Maybe Singapore will take over that Ghost City for good n The JB Palace could recoup their 100billion losses. If only the Developer n Investors had the foresight to use the area n build An Intergrated Playground combining... Public Housing Landed...Condos...Retirement Oasis n A Waterfront Luxury Living for Foreigners 2nd Home. Alas Creativity n Long Term Planning not A Thing with Greedy Investors. It will give Malaysians working in Singapore...A Home or even Rental Units for singles. Lost Opportunity. WASTAGE with Mega Projects is A Huge Issue in Malaysia.
Mahathir pour Billion into Langkawi and yet it fail And more than 90 % of his project fail When Najib sell 49% of Proton it suddenly earning Money Moreover Mahathir cannot accept it than he want to start another car project Luckily nobody invest cos it's bound to fail He alone wasted Billion and Billion of Malaysia Hard earn money where it can be use to help the Malay community Comparatively he is nothing to DSAI Yang terbaik PMX
it's obviously a failure without Chinese buyers who can't get their money out of China now. And they didn't feel welcome in Malaysia with MM2H being changed for the worse every few months
The problem with the current government are corruption and nepotism, incompetent ministers and poor planning and uncontrolled developement leads to environment disaster.
Actually it’s because the Chinese government put a limit to funds being transferred overseas. So a lot of Chinese cannot buy, thus, d project went south.
@@haon2205 It's called multilateral cooperative partnerships for the mutual benefit of all concerned parties, a.k.a. what grownups do. But you lot can't even spell it, much less comprehend its meaning.
They design is yucky in the first place and disaster in pricing the units. Turn the whole thing into a most integrated multi purpose Sea Port site, this will make Singapore going crazy and give Port of Singapore's a run for their money in Jurong. I love a good comeback move for a mean neighbor who wish an ill will and did not morally support for this project
the 3 bedder condo are going at rental of RM1000 per month with almost no taken, maybe 2-3 takers a month, not sure if that's even enough to cover the maintenance fees let alone the mortgage.
How does a failed mega project started by the Johor Sultan, whose job is to further the interests of his State, protect the Malayan race? A few 1000 Chinese from China can take over Malaysia?
Agreed 100%. Another YouTubber who use deceiving title to capture viewership and clickrate. I have already unsubscribed many and will add this one to my list to skip.
😅you don't need forest city to do drug, just turn old changi prison into one, but careful, old Hotel California Song say "you can go in anytime, but you can never leave"😅😅
*Too expensive for local residents. ..Malaysia will soon buy this whole project for a song at China investors expense. See who can withstand the financial burden in a long run.*
The title should change to A dream turns into a nightmare. Now they hope Singapore can invest in it. What a joke. Johore in reality has much potential and thrives more only on its own not as a state part of Malaysia. Many Johoreans work in Singapore. Earn strong sing dollars is better than weak ringgits. They became wealthy Johoreans possibly owning many more properties in Johore and other states in Malaysia.
Visited this place before, the sale-person snobbishly told "only applicable to China citizen, not for Malaysian. You can see but don't ask at all". Lack of cultural and art elements. It is waiting to be a failure project.
Malaysians developers love to talk big, talk bigger , and talk the biggest for all the world to know that we have bigger mouths that sound the goodest . !!!!!!
I see no problem with the project including marketing it. The only big issue is when the leaders inside the country were not united at all. That surely becomes a main ingredients for failure and sounding an alarm bell to the tourists and foreign investors. I have high respect for Mahathir, but what he did had just brought more bad image to Malaysia rather than uplift its already struggling economy. The project was already ongoing, and the only thing the Gov't of Malaysia could've done to address those issues of foreign influx and securities of its local citizens is to pass newer legislations and policies to ensure the safeguards and benefits that are more advantageous to the improvement of the economy and its local citizens while promoting and making the project attractive to foreign clients.
Keen to own a luxurious 1-bedroom apartment at Fourth Avenue Residences in Singapore's prestigious Bukit Timah District? With direct access to Sixth Avenue MRT and within 1km of Raffles Girls' Primary School, this is an opportunity not to be missed. Contact owner at morriestory@gmail.com today.
Can Malaysia turn Forest City into the next Southeast Asia financial hub? Let us know in the comments below!
If you enjoyed this video, do like, subscribe and buy us a coffee: bmc.link/worldknowmore
Check out this video on Malaysia's epic loss of talent to Singapore: th-cam.com/video/m-NiSCWd65g/w-d-xo.htmlsi=X2DwlPOHQ9SXaUCA
Connect singapore and forest city with a bridge and borderless passage and see the region thrive. Immigration controls are destroying the economy and causing massive pollution due to congestion.
It's the same case wth other countries inc US
Impossible to turn new Project as similar to Spore.Spore is City state built by Stanford Raffles since 1819.as proverd as said Rome is not built in a day Seemly Msia looking inferior But actually Malaysian Sarawak Iban in interior is Richest.waiting the next 20year 200 3:42
20
On next 20years
Corruption and nepotism is Malaysia’s biggest enemy
Doomed.
@@Regional123 racism too
what about racism intimidation bullying unjustified discrimination plus plus????🐥🐥🐥🐸🐸🐸🐸
@@lordguan88you meant reverse racisme?
More like it is Malaysia common practices and long political tradition.
A competent, clean government will take no part in a private company project or foreigner owned developed property, unfortunately , it is not this case here due to vast Royalty interests involved.Secondly, we still don't have a clean competent government even after 2018 historic unseat of BN government.
Without govt help , the forest city will be a real failure and sour point forever.
There is merit to do this as it actually can make the area into a vibrant productive areas being close to Singapore and to the coming major Port in Malacca developed by China .
This would bring jobs to the area.
There will be lots of Chinese and Singapore companies will be investing etc.
Then Singapore would be the worst country?.
Cos the government investment arm hv its hand practically everywhere..😂
Because BN is still in the government. The voters have been duped by the politicians.
Governments through out the world work hand in hand with private developers.
Not really true.
The project was already existed even before the Madani govt. So Madani govt has no part in it.
Yes, by revitalising it , is just like rescuing those many abandoned project.
It is a good project . Only thing is it needs certain advantages and that advantages are what the Madani provided to revive the project.
It is better to make it profitable, collect taxes and complements the Malacca big port project and provide JB more residential and commercial units now idle to accommodate the influx of many Singaporeans and Malaysians with the opening of the RTS link between Singapor/Malaysia.
Know the economics.
The govt is doing the right thing
Your narrative is wrong and
Financial hub is not supposed to be in form of buildings
HK was the financial hub and it still is. It takes decades for SG to come to par with HK. Talk is cheap until you start to understand the difficulties involved in getting there.
Hahahs😂
This topic is laughing stock for sleepy johor
Malaysia has so much land she doesn't need to have 4 man-made islands. Are mega projects like this about money laundering or plain old kickback?
50% forest policy.
Only man made island can kill-off nature provide swampy marine life nursery and fill up royalty coffer effectively in Johore State😤
Because tuanku doesn't want to kacau Tanah Melayu in mainland Malaysia. That is why building an artificial island for foreign mass investment hopefully it could drive economic growth for Malaysia as well.
Land is a state affair not federal
Trying to be smart yet stupid
It is clear that this project really aim is to make the rich richer. *cough (sultan johor)
The title of this video should be "Could this $1b ghost city beats SG to be the next Financial Hub ?".
The same opportunity of making langkawi free port but slowly silent suffering from death island.
SMiLE 😀
When it does succeed..Greedy selfish politicians will crash in and mess it up..Only wise rakyat/citizens must vote in an uncorrupted PM can we continue to progress otherwise will regress a deep fall..Pray for a harmonious & progressive Malaysia🙏❤🙏
So true. Mega projects provide politicians with opportunities to pocket kick backs. Material used are substandard.
Malaysia is never short of bold plans. Making these bold plans reality is in short supply.
'High risk', 'Bold' multi Billion Plan built on the shoulder of ordinary people purse string or our nation's vast resources is always part of Malaysia Government Policy since Independence.If it is successful, Malay Monarch and Chinese corporation reap the gains, if not, Malaysians pay the losses.
What abt the perpetual corruption
Well, after change of government, Putrajaya decided to keep it .
Introduce duty-free, ferry terminal to Singapore, a helicopter landing pad, a horse racing track, and a casino on this Financial Island.
No Go Singapore . if you want Malaysians to support own country : we are the tax-payers. Singapore is a foreign country.
🤨 what you want is a gambler paradise! … to rob legally
@@PP-vf1kx if none of the above means it's doomed paradise.
The only thing successful about investing in Forrest City is that you’d get to see success across the border in Singapore from the comfort of your balcony, and that’s the only success you’ll see. But, at least you get to breathe in the vapours of success coming originating from Singapore.
Forest City was not built to compete with Singapore but rather to capture any spillover from the world's most expensive city.
Honestly, will you stay in FC ?
pls learn basic demand and supply first before you mass produce so many units. Rome isn't build on one day. No city was built from 'mega-project' and then expect all humans to live in it. obviously built by those who overly day-dream.
@@douglasstanley5209 He already said. Expensive City. Only those who are temporary love fashion as a form of life will learn to stay there to feel it.
Sigh... The problem with Forest City, or any other mega-projects, failed because of the inability of the government to realize that their people are nit able to afford to buy or spend in these places. A nation must have the critical consumer population to even go ahead with projects like these. Don't put the cart in front of the horse.
This has got othing to do with the govt. Its aprivate project whose major shareholder is the Johor sultan. Get your facts right
It was the accessibility to the Rain Forest not available due to the cancellation of the HSR project.
@@mayfoo02 Even so, such a big project will fail because there are not enough consumers to buy such high price properties. If they have started small and expand later when the properties are majority occupied, then, build on another stage, it may succeed.
@@thinkie12 well, tell that to country garden
How is it has failed? It only uses 10% of the total envisioned , and more 65% of the housing has been sold...
It would become a joint JB-Singapore Special Economic Zone. The HSR from Kunming connects Laos, Cambodia, Thailand, Malaysia, and Singapore will be built after the former PM of Malaysia canceled it. Furthermore, the Singapore to JB MRT will enhance transportation from the Rain Forest location. Except for one of the 8 apartments completed recently, the rest were occupied.
that is why government housing policy should lead to the houses needed by the rakyat not foreigners. we should go back to 40% low cost 40% mid cost and 20% luxury homes.
@@mishahul
Totally agree 💯.
Singapore will be part of that Private Entity trying to make it happen.
A Financial Hub which will rival Singapore Financial Status???
Lets see if it works.
They need Land...They are Out of It after A Ban on Sand to Singapore was in place recently...allegedly for Reclaimation Projects which changes the sea current leading up to disastrous consequences after the recent oil spill.
Losing Their Curve is detrimental to the Marine Ecosystem n clean up effort or the natural occurrence into the deep sea away from human habitats.
Turning it into A Casino was Singapore first initiative yet it will be in direct competition to MBS n Sentosa.
JB has never seen itself as Malaysia.
Always trying TO BE SINGAPORE.
Maybe Singapore will take over that Ghost City for good n The JB Palace could recoup their 100billion losses.
If only the Developer n Investors had the foresight to use the area n build An Intergrated Playground combining...
Public Housing
Landed...Condos...Retirement Oasis n A Waterfront Luxury Living for Foreigners 2nd Home.
Alas Creativity n Long Term Planning not A Thing with Greedy Investors.
It will give Malaysians working in Singapore...A Home or even Rental Units for singles.
Lost Opportunity.
WASTAGE with Mega Projects is A Huge Issue in Malaysia.
😂😂😂 I needed A Good Laugh.
Thank you ❤
Mahathir caused the fall of this mega project. Mahathir is very racist.
thats why we Couldn't agree and not Listening to communist mentality
It is really a forest city now ha ha ha
Not surprising a Singaporean media outlet critizing Malaysias development project and at same time, advertise their tiny 1 bed room apartment at a triple price than in Malaysia 😂😂😂😂
Connect Forest City directly to Singapore would boost the incentive for people to live there,
Very poor location. It’s just beside Singapore’s port and heavy industries. Imagine the environment the supposed target group, the wealthy people, have to put up with. And staying among labourers and workers.
Only those with good hard cold cash and young with open mindset will fall for it.
The name clearly stated Forest City. It is two different entity and human will be like a sandwich living there.
I have a piece of good news for you. Hallucination is not illegal.
Delusion is not haram. 😂
It's harmless and it's free.
It's stupid to compare Ghost city/Johor with down south. Usually, you compare capital cities.
It is - if drugs are involved
@@eriklee9462🤔 what you’re describing is mental illness! .. it’s worse
this project has destroyed the livelihood of the fishermen..no wonder it is doomed.
The problem, forest city may be sinking with china way of building 😂. It is just my opinion
You maybe right because the Chinese employed Indian workers for the projects. 😂 😂 😂
Sinkiepore talking about sinking, now that's funny😂
You can't govern properly when there there is corruption and international financial services need strong and effective governance.
Sinkiepore actually hates it when Malaysia do well economically. They really do not like that Malaysia is becoming a powerhouse for Semicon and data centers. If the government play their cards right and build infrastructure projects like HSR and LRT to stop at Forest City, it will become a success because of its strategic location.
Yes. I agree with u. As u said "if" malaysia do this and "if" malaysia do that. "If" only I strike lottery; "if" only I look like Tom Cruise. In the meantime, u continue to dream the "if", OK?
Malaysia does not have a population big enough for this kind of mega projects. Also it is not cheap. How many consumers can afford that? The project must start small first and build on that.
@@oldtabrough1026 😂😂😂😂😂
@@thinkie12 Infrastructure projects does not only benefit the locals. FYI, Changi-KLIA is the world's busiest international route with 4.9 million seats in 2023. A high-speed rail that can take passengers from Singapore to KL in 90 mins will be in demand compared to flight because a train is still needed to reach KL from KLIA.
Considering that over 300,000 Johoreans work in Singapore and commute via motorbikes on a daily basis, LRT will be in demand once RTS is operational as commuters can take the LRT to RTS link and then the MRT in Singapore. It is not a stretch to say it's possible to commute from Johor to Singapore daily for work within 1 hour of travelling time. Hence, why properties near RTS are selling like hot cakes now.
National Interest vs Foreign Entities Greed.
You really will not be The Making of A Leader.
Don’t buy. Already so old and outdated. The investment is damn suai. You buy, you lose money.
Everytime Malaysia announced some major project, they always say it will compete with Singapore. When they first build KLIA they say they will compete with Changi. When they build the seaport at Port Klang, they can compete with singapore port. Let's see how this financial hub turns out
It's all failed terribly😅
Maybe Singapore should just annex Malaysia lol
And one minister even shamelessly said that if malaysia rule Singapore it will definitely be better develop 😅 just imagine this joker is from JB
True enough... its like Msian are forever chasing after the shadow of Spore. Sad 😢
Singapore soon gonna be dead city... global warming...shortage of clean water, food supply and other resources, the fact is Malaysia & Indonesia will no longer supply. While singapore gonna be land less too many stress citizen, bunch of old folks... Singapore have to create under sea city....but have to overcome tsunami n etc....
I think it wasn't a Malaysia plan to have a financial center there. It was a China plan assisted by one of the leaders in the particular state.
We love to be the ones who are envious for once
Most Singaporeans have no interest in this dwelling. Project designed based on incompetencies.
Sale to Singapore: Convert to high raise building fish farm or pig farm also a possible revenue generating proposal.. 😊
NONSENSE : BS . . the project is completed NOT Failed yet... the Condo prices are upheld, not reduced . Property never expired too soon .
The high-rise farming was a flop. The owner recently closed the farm and sold the building.
@@ssrae-2229 Agreed! That's why it is called Ghost Town.🤣
I prefer fish farm....at least when it sink, the fish can survive, not the pig.🤫
Planning a high end residential and commercial area right beside Singapore’s port and heavy industries doesn’t sound well. If I’m rich and wealthy I wouldn’t pick to stay beside heavy industries and with loads of foreign labourers and workers staying close by.
too little too late....
Forest City Solution: Lease the land to Singapore for 99 years!
😂😂😂 Imho, better make it perpetuity with a nominal payment of RM 1,000 like penang instead.
Yes you can. Depends on who will handles it.
Sea water lever is arising
Plan for boats soonest
Do not allow Singapore to take advantage to earn money from other buyers. Nobody want to invest in Singapore.
HSR from China direct to Forest City, now declared as Duty-Free Island to promote tourism.
No, corruption is not the problem.
It's unbridled greed.
Greed will destroy Johore and Malaysia.
May Allah forgives us and protect us all.
kami rakyat 🇲🇾 cukup bertuah mempunyai salah 1 perdana menteri all the best sepanjang kemerdekaan kami..jika kamu menyatakan kehilangan kami projek2 mega berbillion dollar atau apa sekalipun jika ia tidak menguntungkannya kepada masyarakat bawahan terutama sekali kepada warga & rakyatnya???itu lebih baik kami kehilangannya..kerana hari ini saya cukup berkeyakinan kepada pemimpin kami yang lebih mementingkan dahulu keselesaan rakyat serta kehidupan asasi rakyatnya yang diutamakan..jika projek2 mega ini yang kebiasaannya lebih menguntungkan kepada org2 luar daripada penghuni warga negaranya..ofcorse lebih baik ia tidak berjaya seperti apa yang diharapkan..apa yang penting sesuai dengan keperluan warganya diutamakan itu yang dipandang oleh kepimpinan kami pada hari ini..ianya cukup membahagiakan bagi kami sebagai warga negaranya..biarlah kami maju sealiran hasrat rakyatnya yang tidak banyak yang ketertinggalan..bukan untuk mengisi kantong2 orang luar dipikirkan tetapi rakyatnya diutamakan..welldone my presiden DATUK SERI PADUKA DI-RAJA DATUK ANWAR IBRAHIM..1990an saya menikmati pembelajaran kami ketika itu dia sebagai menjawat jawatan menteri pendidikan yang terbaik di negara kami malah diasia tenggara..& hari ini sesuailah beliau menjadi prime minester kami semoga kesejahteraan negara kami semakin baik bukanlah untuk didunia bukanlah untuk kami bermegah megah seperti negara2 lain tetapi apa yang penting sekali adalah kami rakyatnya yang ekonominya lebih baik dari sebelumnya..itu yang lebih penting bagi kami bukan untuk siapa2 bagi pihak asing..sejahtera negara berdaulat kami itu yang sentiasa kami doakan selalu..semoga orang luar dapat lebih memahaminya..lawan tetap lawan..
Build some kind of border crossing to Singapore, and buyers will flood in. Rail, ferry, or pedestrian will work as long as there is a connection to the MRT in Singapore
Agree. Need a bridge from Singapore, provided Singapore government om consented to it.
And connected to the Singapore’s port and heavy industries area, which is situated right beside. Together with hordes of labourers and workers staying close together. Don’t think this environment would be attractive to the supposed target group, ‘the rich and wealthy’.
I stayed in one of the houses. A RM2 mollion home. It's haunted. I lost 4 solitaire diamond rings. I told the hostess about it, she too is a foreigner. She ribbish it off. All that was left in my bag was a watch & 2 imitation rings & a cheap gold plated ring. I mix the rings all in a bag when l left my house to stay with her. When l wrnt back home l wanted to put them back for safe keeping. To my horror, all 4 solitaires disappeared. I wore those rings regularly but hospital procedure requested l remove it that Thursday. Friday, l was in my friend's place. I kept them in my bag mixed with others. Saturday l wrnt home. That night l found them all missing. I suspected her or the toyol. She's jobless, husband works overseas. Period.
Must be an educated TOYOL to know the genuine gems!!
This is why we should never listen to mahathir
this is not Mahathir's project. He was against it
This ghost city got nothing to do with Tun Dr Mahathir! Where u come from any way??😂😂😂
Project yg tidak berfaedah tidak di uruskan ngan baik. Rakyat Malaysia kebanyakkan tidak mampu nk beli pun. Jual ke orang luar menambahkan lagi orang asing berkuasa Yg hilang 1 juta Chiness dlm negara masih belum ada titik noktah. Apa tah lagi isu lambakan warga asing illegal yg buat negara ni macam negara mereka.Membaiki bandar yg sedia ada lagi bagus dr buat Pulau Buatan. Hurm dh kira untung tapi rentong. Jual murah aja kat rakyat baru la Raja berjiwa rakyat.
thats why we Couldn't agree and not Listening to communist mentality
The Mr 10 percent was not given a share that's why he protest, remember the high speed train he stop the project renegotiate went to China with LGE came back and lie to the public that he already cuts down on the price instead they cut corners to bring the price down nothing change now we have to pay more for the original price
yes , add more money , Malaysia can do it
A new brilliant steps by PMX, no more ghost town because THE RTS link will complete soon
Singapore'a financial hub was built through years/decades of hard works. Malaysia with their political instability and tidak apa attitude coupled with brain drain trend, can dream on.
the reason it flopped is multifactorial.. but mainly due to the unstable political background in Malaysia for the last decade, COVID and also background intererence by YouKnowWho... it has potential, but need strong leaders to step up and take responsibility, a good public transport system(because its far from the general population) and backing by the government, who knows it might turn out to be good.. but having live in JB, knowing what's going on behind the scene, things are much more complicated than that..
Malaysia is always dreaming..ask them about their Wawasan 2020 plan.. it's 2024 already..
Whene KLIA opened years ago, they claim it will rival Changi Airport.. I wonder 🤔
Mahathir dreams a lot but most of his dreams don't work out. It vanished in thin air, poof!
TUN M wawasan 2020 planning to be fail from beginning, The Policies does support to encourage to fail due to untouched and illogical businesses activities which not meritocracy in planning human capital. Corruption is planning ahead than meritocracy systems.
Funny that SG raising environmental concerns, which we all know they bought sand (gali) currently from Indonesia, previously thailand. Weird la
Reason is because Drm Racist Policy Now with Support from Sultan of Johor, no racism. Foreign investors might come back.
Wait and see Forest city will flourish and grow into World class financial center
What is your optimism based on? It's a flop with no Chinese buyers now or in the future, so who is going to buy there? Not Malaysians either.
So many hate comments from probably Singaporeans. Just sit and relax. Time will tell if the govts plans would work. This project is fully funded by private sector. Govt of the day is only pushed to make it a success because..you know why..but if it fails it really doesnt hurt the Malaysian govt a bit..but if it turns out to be a success..it will really benefits Malaysia..this project is even raised on a manmade island. 😘
@@detox78
Singapore will be part of that Private Entity trying to make it happen.
So don't even go there.
A Financial Hub which will rival Singapore Financial Status???
Lets see if it works.
They need Land...They are Out of It after A Ban on Sand to Singapore was in place recently...allegedly for Reclaimation Projects which changes the sea current leading up to disastrous consequences after the recent oil spill.
Losing Their Curve is detrimental to the Marine Ecosystem n clean up effort or the natural occurrence into the deep sea away from human habitats.
Turning it into A Casino was Singapore first initiative yet it will be in direct competition to MBS n Sentosa.
JB has never seen itself as Malaysia.
Always trying TO BE SINGAPORE.
Maybe Singapore will take over that Ghost City for good n The JB Palace could recoup their 100billion losses.
If only the Developer n Investors had the foresight to use the area n build An Intergrated Playground combining...
Public Housing
Landed...Condos...Retirement Oasis n A Waterfront Luxury Living for Foreigners 2nd Home.
Alas Creativity n Long Term Planning not A Thing with Greedy Investors.
It will give Malaysians working in Singapore...A Home or even Rental Units for singles.
Lost Opportunity.
WASTAGE with Mega Projects is A Huge Issue in Malaysia.
my day does not go by without watching your video and Emile Cosman
Mahathir pour Billion into Langkawi and yet it fail And more than 90 % of his project fail When Najib sell 49% of Proton it suddenly earning Money Moreover Mahathir cannot accept it than he want to start another car project Luckily nobody invest cos it's bound to fail He alone wasted Billion and Billion of Malaysia Hard earn money where it can be use to help the Malay community Comparatively he is nothing to DSAI Yang terbaik PMX
dsai will be puppet communist
**Correction Chinese buyers offer special visa..NOT Citizenship..& Sad & True Dr M remarks scarce off Chinese buyers.
it's obviously a failure without Chinese buyers who can't get their money out of China now. And they didn't feel welcome in Malaysia with MM2H being changed for the worse every few months
Sell it cheap to SG and turn the place as the main producer of agriculture and livestocks needed by Singapore to boost its self-sustainability.
The problem with the current government are corruption and nepotism, incompetent
ministers and poor planning and uncontrolled developement leads to environment disaster.
Plaza Rakyat over 25 years . I am not holding my breath.
The name itself already is two element in it.
Forest vs. City.
Bye Bye. Better Sell to Singapore
SG not Dumb … Project Built on Reclaimed Land too hastily 😊
One of the most expensive projects in the world that failed, hope the Malaysian government can overcome it
Only in Fairy Tales!
Tak ada orang visionary to put up idea's to generate the project
Dr M was the one who screwed up Forest city... it was actually doing ok...
He screwed up a lot of things.
Do some research. Forest city is built by Country Garden, and they are in a financial crisis in China because of the housing bubble
Actually it’s because the Chinese government put a limit to funds being transferred overseas. So a lot of Chinese cannot buy, thus, d project went south.
Hello! This project got nothing to do with Tun Dr Mahathir! The main share partner of this project was the Johor Sultan, now the Agong.
You're spot on
Anything that come from Malaysia 🇲🇾 better to stay out cos too risky and not worth it 😮
This is not a Malaysian project for Gods sake.
@mayfoo02 Correct .The project is from China but is controlled by the Malaysia government and the one who is suffering now mostly from china 😂🤣🤣
i dont understand this - why call yourself forest city NEXT TO garden city. Isn't better to be in the latter???
This is where questionable money can go to roost
Who stops this mega project ?
Political leaders or China ?
Who loses ?
Now they want Singapore to invest into this project and shoot its own feet? Not so dumb leh. Unless the returns favor S'pore greatly. If not, no deal.
Malaysia will watch what Singapore do and try to copy.
@@teckkeeang4363 Like pleasing the western master?
No deal for Singapore.. they target China n other btw they just sold out they commercial site without depend on Singapore.. u don't watch news 😂
@@haon2205 It's called multilateral cooperative partnerships for the mutual benefit of all concerned parties, a.k.a. what grownups do. But you lot can't even spell it, much less comprehend its meaning.
Says who they want Singapore to invest in the project? The project primarily failed because Country Garden went bust
It's a wet dreams and will remain a wet dreams.
The King of M'sia is also the Sultan of Johor. Bad timing becos China stopped money flow overseas & killed the demand.
They design is yucky in the first place and disaster in pricing the units. Turn the whole thing into a most integrated multi purpose Sea Port site, this will make Singapore going crazy and give Port of Singapore's a run for their money in Jurong. I love a good comeback move for a mean neighbor who wish an ill will and did not morally support for this project
learn the basic demand and supply first before simply build thousands of units
DON'T WATSE OUR MONEY. TURN IT BACK INTO NATURE AND PARKS.
the 3 bedder condo are going at rental of RM1000 per month with almost no taken, maybe 2-3 takers a month, not sure if that's even enough to cover the maintenance fees let alone the mortgage.
Forest City is doomed to fail, because it is in Malaysia.
To make Forest City thrive, sell it to Singapore.
Do it as a special category sector of the economy with many special prevelages
Next Financial Powerhouse of Asia????..in Msia Bolih?
what are you smoking
So many negative undertones in this clip. Wonder who commissioned this video.... The road and belt project cancelled? Get your facts right!
*Forest City it's to become a completely Malaysia Financially Hub Centre, have Offshore financial centre at Labuan 🇲🇾*
Ah...singapore channel centric despite its world-ly title...no wonder its all doom and gloom when it comes to Malaysia
Mahatir probably sensed that the Chinese will just take over,Mahatir was and always is a protector of the Malayan race
How does a failed mega project started by the Johor Sultan, whose job is to further the interests of his State, protect the Malayan race? A few 1000 Chinese from China can take over Malaysia?
Not for me. Ghost place. To much money... gone with the wind. For nothing. NADA.
100 more years will still the same 😂😂😂😂😂 regardless of what..
I think this entire video is AI generated. No real insight or understanding. Waste of time viewing.
Agreed 100%. Another YouTubber who use deceiving title to capture viewership and clickrate. I have already unsubscribed many and will add this one to my list to skip.
$10 Billion Malaka Gateway, remember that?
The developer is Hatten from Singapore
What a pro Singapore content ! Threaten already?
You Sld love the neighbor bro
HELLO IF CASINO CAN’T REVIVE FOREST CITY MAYBE TRY TO REZONE FOREST CITY AS SPECIAL ZONE THAT TAKING DRUG IS LEGAL. 👍👍👍
😅you don't need forest city to do drug, just turn old changi prison into one, but careful, old Hotel California Song say "you can go in anytime, but you can never leave"😅😅
*Too expensive for local residents. ..Malaysia will soon buy this whole project for a song at China investors expense. See who can withstand the financial burden in a long run.*
The title should change to A dream turns into a nightmare. Now they hope Singapore can invest in it. What a joke. Johore in reality has much potential and thrives more only on its own not as a state part of Malaysia. Many Johoreans work in Singapore. Earn strong sing dollars is better than weak ringgits. They became wealthy Johoreans possibly owning many more properties in Johore and other states in Malaysia.
Ya, everything also rival Singapore. These days any project big and small in Asia all rivaling Singapore.. 😅
MAKE MONEY IN SINGAPORE
SPEND MONEY IN JOHORE
Visited this place before, the sale-person snobbishly told "only applicable to China citizen, not for Malaysian. You can see but don't ask at all". Lack of cultural and art elements. It is waiting to be a failure project.
Malaysians developers love to talk big, talk bigger , and talk the biggest for all the world to know that we have bigger mouths that sound the goodest . !!!!!!
I see no problem with the project including marketing it. The only big issue is when the leaders inside the country were not united at all. That surely becomes a main ingredients for failure and sounding an alarm bell to the tourists and foreign investors. I have high respect for Mahathir, but what he did had just brought more bad image to Malaysia rather than uplift its already struggling economy. The project was already ongoing, and the only thing the Gov't of Malaysia could've done to address those issues of foreign influx and securities of its local citizens is to pass newer legislations and policies to ensure the safeguards and benefits that are more advantageous to the improvement of the economy and its local citizens while promoting and making the project attractive to foreign clients.
If you ask me, I will choose JB city center where the RTS is located, not some forest far far away from JB city center
wow sure... 50 years to reach here, not 50 months
Malaysia Go 🎉
The sultan of Johor is the current King of Malaysia...hahahahaha. He has more authority to do what he wants....😅
this is a joke , right. you set up a few buildings and suddenly you think you can become a global financial centre.