Our poor Prophet (saw)😢.. it's very saddening to know what kind of so called companions he had to deal with. Oh Allah send blessings to muhammad and his family.
@@badvibes2568you call that a refutation? What a bunch of weak ass argument by farid, sounded more like he responded by crying at sayed ammar’s lecture
@@cano8448true. Absolutely weak and justifying Omar’s actions. Wallahi I said I need to watch it with an open mind and i got nothing useful from it. Look at the S.A.N dissect their own books and the response is a weak video making excuses and adding context to the Hadith like they were there.
with this series out now, no sunni on the day of judgement can use the excuse that they didnt know. its right here. online. forever. if your ignorance is stopping you from searching for the truth, dont be surprised when it takes you directly to the gates of hell. Alhamdulillah for Sayed Ammar.
They are arrogant because they have understood their beliefs is built from a pack of cards so they’re doing anything to protect it as any small vibrations will make it collapse. I understand their dilemma as to accept means to understand everything they ever were taught and knew/know is not real and they must let it go. But what they don’t understand is Allahs swt’s mercy that they will be so lucky to receive for coming to salvation!
This is just the type of conversation that Banu Israil used to have with Nabi Musa a.s. Always a subliminal disrespect and questioning of the holy messenger
@@sullyqureshi676 I don’t know him well enough but I always thought he was like some comedian who pretend to be a religious leader. Have seen some funny videos of him
You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided. Surah al qasas, verse 56. What Dr. Ammar did was to inform you then indeed it’s Allah who guides. May Allah soften your heart sister
@@sullyqureshi676r u guys still waffling on about thumbnails. Have you seen the thumbnails and titles of their videos? 😂😂😂😂 The videos of these is “debating” with a person who says he is a Shia but is clearly not right in the head and they use this guys poor state of mind as step stone to “fame” by mocking him n the Shia beliefs through him! Definitely Umer moves
@@sullyqureshi676astagfar may Allah help you by the acts of Umer and the words of the holy prophet saw Umer is his dushman (enemy) so guess who ur cursing….. but I am not 1 bit surprised after seeing what I have seen over the last few nights. Might as well befriend the fire whist ur in this earth buddy! 😂
Thank you for another magnificent presentation, Sayyed. Truly another lankmark in the history of the Shia-Sunni debate, probably the best presentation of the Shia position ever. It is an honor and privelege to be one of the first people to watch this historic broadcast. May all of our Sunni brothers see the light and return to the real Islam.
HAPPY RAMADAN! ❤❤❤ Subhanallah Sayed. Once again, a SLAM DUNK! Sayed has done lots of research and taken his time, we really appreciate it 🤲 We should do the same! INSHALLAH 👍❤️
As a Shia, some of the narrations from the Sunni sources mentioned in this video were previously unknown to myself and absolutely shocked me. Whilst I've always been certain that Shi'ism is the correct path, I still had a few lingering uncertainties/doubts about a few issues, especially regarding the alleged demonisation of certain 'companions' by the Shias but Wallahi I have never been more certain than when Sayyed Ammar got to the point where Umar ibn Khattab told RasulAllah (saw) 'do not do that'. The audacity??? I am honestly horrified at the fact that his numerous acts of disrespect are so blatantly overlooked or excused by our Sunni brothers and sisters, as well as the Muslims of the time. Truly shocking. Thank you Sayyed for such an informative series that sheds light on the true characters of some of these historical personalities from the 'Sahih' sources of other schools of thought that cannot be denied or rejected by them. May Allah bless you and reward you in this life and the next for the service and much needed education you provide to the Ummah, Ameen.
Mzahra --i can understand your point, but some wahabis love umar is at level if you even say things , due to they believe he is jannah, " 10 sahabs who guranteeed jannah" -fake, their wahabi scholar would call u kafir straighwaay. sad truth.... they dont want to do any critical analysis. But what is tryly shocking is how bog alaims like bukhari. atbari and others overlook this shady and eveil personality ...
Sayed if you can please post the description of where you find these and the Hadith number and such I would like to read them and better equip myself when debating please and thank you
Mashallah.sayd Duas for you.May Allah grant you good health & save you from those who want to stab you & slander you. Allah will always be with you Love every lecture of yours 🙏😊
I grew up listening to nothing but liws from sunni Imams nothing but fake blunder stories and they suger coated it all but when Syed opens their books it breaks my heart to hear the stuff the prophet had to bare by these so called kalifas. Syed Ammar is a sword that splits sunni lies in peices
As an ex sunni my heart aches for every sunni how they are still being misled by what they were told and sadness of all sadness is they aren’t even willing to listen 😢 please pray for my family
And you still have our brothers in Islam saying why is Ammar discussing such contentious topics in this Month of peach and piety. Honestly it’s sad but then again Allah (swt) did say “He guides whom He pleases” - To my Sunni brothers and sisters - the hardest thing in life is to unlearn what you have learnt.
Wslm Warahmatullahi Wabaraakatuh, Thank you very much Sir for sharing the knowledge. look what I found on reply from other side. I respect and follow authentic studies after research. I don't believe in sects. I'm a Muslim JAZAAKALLAH
Masha Allah, what is interesting and infuriating at the same time, is the fact that many Sunnis have heard about these things, even researched it themselves but somehow they still persist in following the doctrine of heresy that Umar and Abu Bakr created, they brought about this division among Muslims. However, this does not take away your personal responsibility and conscious choices, as a human being you have intellect (aql) and intelligence. One can easily realize that everything went wrong with Islamic leadership after the Prophet (saw) despite his definitive appointment of Imam Ali (as) on many occasions, most notably at the event of Ghadir al-Khum. So why still cling onto the three illegitimate Caliphs (Khulafa) when you know that the right path to Islam and the Prophet (saw) is tied only to Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) and his holy progeny of 11 Imams (as)?! Ultimately, no one can force people to heaven or to hell, it is their choice, they shall earn it.
Aslm oumar bad character shows many time he always get angry easily on many things .he was short temper he can't control his anger . look at maula Ali as how patience and humble to Allah. Even his two beloved sons was chosen by Allah to be a matry. He accepted it and obeyed Allah whatever the consequences and even accept defeat in his life just for love and obedient to Allah his lord .he respected the prophet and followed his path. All praise to Allah.
muhammad, salla Allahu 'alaihi wa alihi wa sahbihi wasallam, had to tell 'umar ibn al-khattab so many times to refrain from causing severe fitan according to so many sunni ah-hadeeth. everything from differing with the qadr of muhammad to willing to unalive several, several unwarranted people
umar knocks out abu hurrairah. umar KO abu hurrairah in around 628 AD, there was no refree to stopped the fight. But according to history, it was shocking to disocver he fled the in the battle of uhud, and according to narration "umar was fleeing like a goat very fast" 🙆♂🙆♂ i am confused to say if he was a chamion or a coward
O you who believe! Stand devoutly for Allah as witnesses of justice, and do not let your “ANIMOSITY” for some people prevent you from being fair. Be fair, as it is closer to piety, and observe your duty to Allah.5:8….. which is exactly what Sayed & the lovers of Ahlul Bayt (as) have done. No disrespect to the sisters but the brothers must start acting like Men. Ya need to put the emotions aside. Bottom line our religion is based upon LOVE and our hate for the oppressors of ahlul bayt has not impaired our judgment, our reasoning, our ilm as it has done to the ahlul sunnah.
Yh Farid and Sunnah Discourse got so desperate they had to make a response video for the sake of it. I watched all of them, they don’t actually give a substantial counter-argument. They either mock Ammar or try to pick out little parts of Ammar‘s words and twist it.
@@A.A471that’s what they do best. Run away like their hero umar (L) They mock us for exposing them from their own books. It’s embarrassing. let them continue folding their arms like the Jews.
The issue of not listening to the order of the Prophet peace be upon him is not understood in an absolutist way that is presented or misrepresented. For example, Ali openly refused to remove the Prophet's name from the peace treaty at hudaybiyya (mustadrak wasail al-shia) even though the Prophet's order was explicit "umhu ya Ali". Based on Nakshawani's approach why did Ali do ijtihad here and not act upon the Prophet's explicit command? Who is the Prophet? Disobeying the Prophet's order is not allowed ever, it counts as kufr?
so let me understand what you are saying, ALi didn't want to delete the part which mentions the prophethood of Muhammad(saw) while her did upon the second order of the prophet with the prophet not being angry with Ali but also saying that it is okay, you can delete it while umar refutes the prophet on many things and still didn't do it even after many requests and orders. that is not the same level. one is deleting the prophethood of Muhammad(saw) while the other is the complying with the order of Prophet which in no way it goes against ALLAH(SWT). no wonder you can't understand this, your heart is closed and eyes are blind and only allah can guide you
@@_7-8-6_ Because it needs a heart to believe in a religion and believe in a prophet that ALLAH has sent and then when requested to delete that part which says the that person is not the prophet. When asked that to delete Muhammad the prophet of Allah from the treaty, what was the response from the prophet Muhammad (PBUH)? he said, indeed i am the prophet of Allah. and then asked Ali (as) to delete that part in which Ali hesitated and then if the prophet was angry with the hesitation, he would have been angry but instead in comforted him and said: A sunnah for a sunnah meaning that how they delete Muhammad Messenger of Allah today and tomorrow they will delete the part of your title too which hint to leader of the believers being deleted when he signed a treaty and only then Ali started to re-edit the writing. this is the difference of speech in Prophet Muhammad talking with Ali then Ummar while with one he was comforting and while with the other he was angry.
Yes Prophet's order: "umhu ya Ali" was not followed by Ali "ma amhu ismak" for good reason which Ali understood based on various factors. This is the whole point alhamdulillah.
Sprinting into History: Breaking Records in the 100-Meter Dash 🏃🏃🏃🏃🏃Umar🦌🦌umar said "i was running like a mountain goat during uhud battle" reference . Jami al-Bayan an Tawil al-Quran,Tafsir al-Tabari,➡➡ He sprints... its in sunni books
Answer to the guy who is saying that imam Ali married his daughter to umer in Al-Kafi, know that the author of Al-kafi is Kulayni and he already said that to take what goes according to Quran and reject what don't go according to Quran. The author didn't take narrations only from Shias but also from sunnis because sunnis were also students and admirers of our imams. For example founders of sunni MALIKI and HANAFI schools were also students of Imam jaffer al sadiq as. So Al kafi is not infallible only Quran is infallible. Of course there are shia and sufi followers of our imams too. So he took chain of narrations from different places. But not everything is correct. If anything goes against Quran we don't have to accept it. Everyone is welcome who wanted to learn from our imams. They only wanted to help people. And AL-KAFI volume 4 says in "H, Ch. 114, h 3" how daughter of prophet saw Fatima was abused after his death and her rights and inheritance were taken from her. And how she was buried secretly by imam Ali as. Till this day Muslim ummah don't know for certain where is her grave exactly. Such a prominent female figure of Islam buried in unmarked grave. Yet know one finds this suspicious? She was part of her father's heart. Prophet saw loved her dearly. He even called her part of his own body. Yet she's buried in an unmarked grave and Sunni khalifas did not attended her funeral. Obviously sunnis will remain sunnis and shias will remain shias. But this whole fadak situation is very suspicious. Only Allah is the true judge so let's find out when we all go to him. Before that let's be good slave of Allah and ask his forgiveness.
To this day we don't know for sure where is the grave of Fatima daughter of prophet saw is. H, Ch. 114, h 3 Ahmad ibn Mihran, may Allah grant him blessing, has narrated from narrated in a in a marfu manner and Ahmad ibn Idris has narrated from Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Jabbar al-Shaybani has said that narrated to me al-Qasim ibn Muhammad al-Razi who has said that narrated to him Ali ibn Muhammad al-Hurmuzi from abu 'Abdallah al-Husayn ibn Ali (a.s.) who has said the following. "When Fatima (a.s.) passed away Amir al-Mu'minin Ali (a.s.) buried her secretly, camouflaged her grave site he then stood up facing the grave of the Messenger of Allah said, "O the Messenger of Allah may He grant you blessings on behalf of me the on behalf of your daughter who is visiting you and will pass this night in the soil in your location whom Allah chose to make join you the fastest. O the Messenger of Allah of my patience has reached to the brims and I miss so much your chosen one (daughter) and my self-control is banished for the departure of the leader of the ladies of the worlds. The only solace for me is to follow your tradition and be mournful for your own departure from us. A little while ago I placed you in your grave and your spirit left your body between my own throat and chest. Yes, in the book of Allah (for me) there is the best form to express acceptance of Allah's decision ""We are the servants of God and to Him we shall all return." (2:156) The trust is returned and the commit is recalled amd al-Zahra' is taken away from us. How sad, O the Messenger of Allah, the green skies and the dusty earth seem to us. My sadness has become perpetual and my night have become sleepless. There is an anxiety that will not relieve my heart until Allah will chose for me the dwelling like that where you are. I have a heart bleeding sorrow and a restless anxiety. How quickly the separation took place? To Allah I raise my complains and your own daughter will explain to you how your 'Umma (followers) succeeded in committing injustice against her. You may ask her questions and find information about the case from her. How great was the sorrow that she will find a place and an ear to express to. She would say Allah will judge because he is the best judge. I offer my prayer to Allah to grant you blessings as a note of farewell but not because of disappointment and despaired. If I return it is not that I have become tired and if I will stand up it will not be because of pessimism in the promise of Allah to those who exercise patience. Indeed to exercise patience is more safe and fruitful. Had not been for the mischief of the enemies I would have turned the place a place of worship andd would have kept my worship continuous and would cried like the mothers for the death of their son for the great loss. In the sight of Allah your daughter is buried secretly, her rights are taken away unjustly, her inheritance is withheld for no valid reason. It all has happen just after you left and your memories are still fresh. To Allah O the Messenger of Allah we complain and from you Ohh the Messenger of Allah we seek condolences. May Allah grant blessings to you and to her. May the peace and happiness of Allah be with you."
Taken together these sunnas show us that Ummar R was a flawed human being going through his journey of Muslimhood, just like anyone of us. Together with the fact that the prophet was so kind and approachable he may have forgotten at times the high status of the prophet of Allah and behaved as he is narrated to have done. It would be interesting if someone compiled all the narrations related to Ummar R in chronological order to see if he changed in general for good over time. Ramadan Kareem iA.
Bro he was a deserter, usurped. Persecuted early muslims. Even with a strong Muslim army he returned back. The army reminded him of the oath not to turn back. He ran from the battle and left prophet in the midst of battle. When everyone believed in 2012 the world will end. But we muslims remembered that imam Mahdi is to come, so the world can't end. His faith was shakeable, he believed prophet died and ran.
He called prophet delirious when he prophet ordered him to join the army and leave Medina during his sick time. When the hudaybiyya peace treaty was signed, he said he doubted prophet's prophethood
Even Sunni believes Umar threaten to burn the door of prophets daughter. And Umar and others met at Saqifa to choose who would rule next. While prophet was close to his last moments.
Sayed, I being a shia am sorry to say you are wrong at 1 place. Umar doesn't think of something, and Allah reveals a verse. But umar knows better than Allah. Allah had missed 3 things that umar thought of, and Allah said, "Oh right, I missed that, Thank you for reminding me and agreeing with umar revealed 3 verses." I urge you to correct yourself, Sayed. Don't disrespect umar's highness.
So I don’t see what exactly the purpose is exactly or what was proved from this video. Sure Umar ibn khattab had some questionable behavior but he was never condemned by the prophet. Even in that hadith where he struck abu hurreira at the end the prophet still agreed with Umar’s opinion so we may see it as impolite but if the prophet was okay with it at that moment who are we to say anything. Lastly it seems like any human companion he would offer his opinion or advice because he understood the prophet was also human but wouldn’t question or interject if the prophet informed him what he was saying was divine knowledge. All the companions are human and they can make mistakes I don’t see it as black or white either they’re perfect or no good at all, they may have had some shortcomings but we’re overall good enough for the prophet to keep as close companions. Maybe I’m missing the point so open to feedback and more knowledge inshallah.
Please share other companions sharing their opinions. Isnt there a hadith that says you cant even utter the sound uff to your parents - what does that mean in relation to the father of the religion? The point of the video is to shed light on not painting all the companions with the same brush and encourage discourse. Once an individual can accept not all companions were the same you can start to piece together where the straight path is, as thats what we're all after, right?
@@sraza94 yes I agree everything is case by case and all the companions are their own individuals and I also have questions as to why Umar ibn kittab cleared the room when the prophet was in his last moments as well as him becoming the caliph over Ali. However I feel like the in the video he’s being completely dismissed or portrayed as a pretty bad guy. I’m just confused that if he was a bad guy or untrustworthy or unreliable, why did the prophet keep him as a companion? I do understand that not all companions may be equal and none are perfect because they are humans so we do have to look at everything case by case.
Shia hates abubakr umar usman aisha, ebadis in Oman thinks usman and ali were the failed government un successful polititions . created all the fitnah , cudnt controll. And sunnies loves all of them
Haha this was the best comment I’ve ever read 😂😂 if that is the case then that is your and your Muftis problem, you are friends with shaytan we couldn’t expect less from you O indeed “ You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided.” Al qasas verse 56
Subhannallah as a sunni i always tried to be positive about Shia. But your hate for Umar is clearly shown. As a sunni alhamdoullilah we have no hate for none of the companions and respect Ahle Bait. On the day of judgment i prefer that position. We would not even talk negative about our dead family members. Why should i be negative about a companion of the prophet on the basis of literature.
The Prophet (PBUH) stayed with Umar (ra) so Who am i to distance myself. Hate is never a good advisor. Keep your hate al the way to the day of judgement. The black that you are wearing is starting to remind me more of darkness than good. Please show me a statement from the prophet (pbuh) where he tells me to hate a companion? Your intellect is being ruined by your hate unfortunately.
Listen pal. Your entire Religion and Faith is based upon" literature”. You certainly ain’t receiving wahy from from Allah Pal much less do you ponder over his verses . The Rasul saww has more right over the sahaba and over your dead family members who you would never talk negative about them yet somehow your heart is indifferent towards any negativity towards the Rasul saww which only indicates there is no Eeman inside of it . At the very least , the very least your heart should hate it . Hipocrite
So you want to give utmost respect of the companion on the basis of literature but you will not critisize his disobidience and disrespect of prophet according to same literature? 🤔🤔🤔
[4:135] O you who believe! be maintainers of justice, bearers of witness of Allah's sake, though it may be against your own selves or (your) parents or near relatives; if he be rich or poor, Allah is nearer to them both in compassion; therefore do not follow (your) low desires, lest you deviate; and if you swerve or turn aside, then surely Allah is aware of what you do. tl;dr: You have to maintain justice even though they are own blood or father no less than a companion.
Guys chill it’s not that serious if they have issue with it they can answer back please don’t make it seem like he is the first to do this this is very common on TH-cam
Absolutely load of nonsense you are saying he is showing these scholars faces in his thumbnails because they are the ones he is answering too. Have some audacity to prove his analysis wrong instead of going out of context.
Umar also married umm kulthum the daughter of Ali alayhi al-salaam, so this seems to undermine such criticisms or they were not a problem for Amir al-mu'mineen
Umar never married any daughter of Ali ibn Abi Talib. But this lecture isnt about Umar‘s relationship with Ali ibn Abi Talib, so it doesn’t undermine anything. You’ve diverted into a different topic. The Hadiths are clear brother, so please don’t neglect these narrations, not in Shia books, but in Sunni books. It may be hard to see this side of Umar, when you may have been growing up that Umar was this very good man. But the Shia don’t revere Umar just for the sake of it, there is clear and justified reasoning as to why the Shia dislike Umar.
Hey Mr Ganesh horse worshipper .. stop. Focusing on side points let's get to the crux of the matter .. prove me your beliefs and I'll become a majoosi like U ..wallahi - prove that zuljana is the reincarnation of Allah SWT .. - prove the birth of your Mahdi - prove to me your 12 imamah by name in the Qur'an and authentic sunnah - prove your taqqqi and naqqi is infallible
who ever has said Zuljana is the reincarnation of Allah SWT... you have the internet, maybe make sure the claims you are making have some ground LOLLLLL
Okay, first give me source if abu bakr and umar name in Holy Quran as caliphs… 😂😂😂 And for all your questions, ask you muftis and do some research brother, read read atleast something instead wasting time on taraweeh… 💤💤🔥
Our poor Prophet (saw)😢.. it's very saddening to know what kind of so called companions he had to deal with. Oh Allah send blessings to muhammad and his family.
The fact that all this information comes from their own books yet they still call Shias kafir for hating the Sahabas and wives. Astaghfirullah
Refutation: th-cam.com/video/GBO5TafF4LE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=-m0vTbYxOGI9X9wK
May Allah guide us all
@@badvibes2568you call that a refutation? What a bunch of weak ass argument by farid, sounded more like he responded by crying at sayed ammar’s lecture
@@badvibes2568just look at the second comment in that video please
@@badvibes2568 lol. He's just preaching. Hasn't proved anything and just giving a point of view. Use books to prove someone incorrect.
@@cano8448true. Absolutely weak and justifying Omar’s actions. Wallahi I said I need to watch it with an open mind and i got nothing useful from it. Look at the S.A.N dissect their own books and the response is a weak video making excuses and adding context to the Hadith like they were there.
with this series out now, no sunni on the day of judgement can use the excuse that they didnt know. its right here. online. forever. if your ignorance is stopping you from searching for the truth, dont be surprised when it takes you directly to the gates of hell. Alhamdulillah for Sayed Ammar.
Ahsent well said brother. It’s all right in front of their eyes. In their own books. And yet they’re still arrogant.
They are arrogant because they have understood their beliefs is built from a pack of cards so they’re doing anything to protect it as any small vibrations will make it collapse. I understand their dilemma as to accept means to understand everything they ever were taught and knew/know is not real and they must let it go. But what they don’t understand is Allahs swt’s mercy that they will be so lucky to receive for coming to salvation!
God bless you Dr Sayed Ammar for exposing the truth from their own books.
This is just the type of conversation that Banu Israil used to have with Nabi Musa a.s. Always a subliminal disrespect and questioning of the holy messenger
saudi rulers are originally jewish anyway
Good insight, brother.
Why do that when Guidance and the stairs of paradise are right in front you, auzobillah😢
Wow subhanAllah. What a lecture. Im left stunned. OMG this video no words to describe. May Allah lengethen your life sayed
Sayyed Ammar you are the best of best, I’m SO PROUD to be a follower of the right path
What do you think of Ustadh Asim Khan?
@@sullyqureshi676 I don’t know him well enough but I always thought he was like some comedian who pretend to be a religious leader. Have seen some funny videos of him
@@feraidonferaidon748 Ustadh Asim Khan not Asim Hussain. Also,wouldnt be surprised if Ali Dawah or Asrar Rashid's face are on thumbnail anytime soon
You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided. Surah al qasas, verse 56. What Dr. Ammar did was to inform you then indeed it’s Allah who guides. May Allah soften your heart sister
@@sullyqureshi676r u guys still waffling on about thumbnails. Have you seen the thumbnails and titles of their videos? 😂😂😂😂
The videos of these is “debating” with a person who says he is a Shia but is clearly not right in the head and they use this guys poor state of mind as step stone to “fame” by mocking him n the Shia beliefs through him! Definitely Umer moves
"Do not do that"
Prophet Umar
Shameless umar lanat on him and his supporters
SALAAMULLAH ALA UMAR WA LANATULLAH ALA DUSHMANE UMAR
@@sullyqureshi676astagfar may Allah help you by the acts of Umer and the words of the holy prophet saw Umer is his dushman (enemy) so guess who ur cursing….. but I am not 1 bit surprised after seeing what I have seen over the last few nights. Might as well befriend the fire whist ur in this earth buddy! 😂
Lanatullah on your taqi and naqqi ..majoosi maddad
Thank you for another magnificent presentation, Sayyed. Truly another lankmark in the history of the Shia-Sunni debate, probably the best presentation of the Shia position ever. It is an honor and privelege to be one of the first people to watch this historic broadcast. May all of our Sunni brothers see the light and return to the real Islam.
We are blessed to have Sayed Ammar as our speaker. May Allah protect Sayed Ammar Nakshwani
Thank you Sayed !
Sayyed cookin Sunnis for Iftar 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣😆😆
HAPPY RAMADAN! ❤❤❤
Subhanallah Sayed. Once again, a SLAM DUNK! Sayed has done lots of research and taken his time, we really appreciate it 🤲 We should do the same! INSHALLAH 👍❤️
Wow. Just Wow
Do not do that.. 🤣🤣
@@romeohuss7434 😂
As a Shia, some of the narrations from the Sunni sources mentioned in this video were previously unknown to myself and absolutely shocked me. Whilst I've always been certain that Shi'ism is the correct path, I still had a few lingering uncertainties/doubts about a few issues, especially regarding the alleged demonisation of certain 'companions' by the Shias but Wallahi I have never been more certain than when Sayyed Ammar got to the point where Umar ibn Khattab told RasulAllah (saw) 'do not do that'. The audacity??? I am honestly horrified at the fact that his numerous acts of disrespect are so blatantly overlooked or excused by our Sunni brothers and sisters, as well as the Muslims of the time. Truly shocking.
Thank you Sayyed for such an informative series that sheds light on the true characters of some of these historical personalities from the 'Sahih' sources of other schools of thought that cannot be denied or rejected by them. May Allah bless you and reward you in this life and the next for the service and much needed education you provide to the Ummah, Ameen.
Mzahra --i can understand your point, but some wahabis love umar is at level if you even say things , due to they believe he is jannah, " 10 sahabs who guranteeed jannah" -fake, their wahabi scholar would call u kafir straighwaay. sad truth.... they dont want to do any critical analysis. But what is tryly shocking is how bog alaims like bukhari. atbari and others overlook this shady and eveil personality ...
یا علی (ع)❤
Mashaallah Syed Thanks to Allah we have been Shia and love only to our Ahlulbait in our heart.
786
Bravo! Bravissimo, Sayed!
May Allah protect you from those who will want to harm you after hearing all these unpleasant truths, Sayed! Aameen!
Some of these sunnis, do they love the sahaba more than Rasullullah?
Exactly 👍
Yup. I work with sum and they always put the Sahabah over the Ahlul Bayt a.s. Smh.
Just imagine a guy who doesn’t know tayaammum became Caliph of Islam !
Sayed if you can please post the description of where you find these and the Hadith number and such I would like to read them and better equip myself when debating please and thank you
Just take notes while listening to the lecture.
786
You can watch again and pause the recording to write down the info.
Mashallah
Alhamdullilah i am Shia! Ya Allah THANK YOU. You guide whoever you want to guid and you miss guide anyone you want to miss guide.
Wallahi this was great and loved your response Ya Sheikh😅❤
Mashallah.sayd
Duas for you.May Allah grant you good health & save you from those who want to stab you & slander you.
Allah will always be with you
Love every lecture of yours
🙏😊
Aameen to these dua!
Amazing
I grew up listening to nothing but liws from sunni Imams nothing but fake blunder stories and they suger coated it all but when Syed opens their books it breaks my heart to hear the stuff the prophet had to bare by these so called kalifas. Syed Ammar is a sword that splits sunni lies in peices
Mashallah Sayed ❤️
After this please can we take a min to recite Fatiha for Sunni theology
game set and match for umar, salafi theology and mufti menk, mufti menk is a super wahabi 🤭🤭
As an ex sunni my heart aches for every sunni how they are still being misled by what they were told and sadness of all sadness is they aren’t even willing to listen 😢 please pray for my family
RIP SUNNI SECT😂
Awesome comment!
😅hahahahaahah prove me from the Qur'an that your 12 imams are masoom hahahahahaah
We can't even ask the commander regarding the order given but umar had guts to ask the commander of the world
May Allah bless you 🤲
Uffff Lanat on Umar ibn khattab
And you still have our brothers in Islam saying why is Ammar discussing such contentious topics in this Month of peach and piety. Honestly it’s sad but then again Allah (swt) did say “He guides whom He pleases” - To my Sunni brothers and sisters - the hardest thing in life is to unlearn what you have learnt.
Wslm Warahmatullahi Wabaraakatuh,
Thank you very much Sir for sharing the knowledge.
look what I found on reply from other side.
I respect and follow authentic studies after research. I don't believe in sects. I'm a Muslim
JAZAAKALLAH
Subhanallah
Alhamdulillah for the love of Ahlulbait AS
This video has completely dismantled the Book Sahih Bukhari..The amount of illogical and stupid stuff written in it and People call it Sahih?.
Wow syed bless you. Proper eye opener. The sadness is After all this they still won't accept the facts..
ماشآءالله 😮😮😮😮
Umar also beat up a woman and his sister as well
He beat hz Fatima to death and mole e kainat was bagging to Umar to her life....he also beat him too
God bless you syed as no one has ever discussed these so called sensitive topics😂😂😂
Subhanallah I’m Shia
Masha Allah, what is interesting and infuriating at the same time, is the fact that many Sunnis have heard about these things, even researched it themselves but somehow they still persist in following the doctrine of heresy that Umar and Abu Bakr created, they brought about this division among Muslims. However, this does not take away your personal responsibility and conscious choices, as a human being you have intellect (aql) and intelligence. One can easily realize that everything went wrong with Islamic leadership after the Prophet (saw) despite his definitive appointment of Imam Ali (as) on many occasions, most notably at the event of Ghadir al-Khum. So why still cling onto the three illegitimate Caliphs (Khulafa) when you know that the right path to Islam and the Prophet (saw) is tied only to Ali ibn Abi Talib (as) and his holy progeny of 11 Imams (as)?! Ultimately, no one can force people to heaven or to hell, it is their choice, they shall earn it.
Aslm oumar bad character shows many time he always get angry easily on many things .he was short temper he can't control his anger . look at maula Ali as how patience and humble to Allah. Even his two beloved sons was chosen by Allah to be a matry. He accepted it and obeyed Allah whatever the consequences and even accept defeat in his life just for love and obedient to Allah his lord .he respected the prophet and followed his path. All praise to Allah.
Memes for days with this series 💀 “do not do that x1000”
Omar is out of the circle of islam
Sayed is Standing on business this Ramadan
muhammad, salla Allahu 'alaihi wa alihi wa sahbihi wasallam, had to tell 'umar ibn al-khattab so many times to refrain from causing severe fitan according to so many sunni ah-hadeeth. everything from differing with the qadr of muhammad to willing to unalive several, several unwarranted people
God bless this man ❤always showing the truth from there own books ❤❤ i need a husband like him❤ insha'Allah
❤❤❤
"DO NOT DO THAT" ALLAH O AKBAR ASTAGFRIULLAH -147
May Allah not support umar and his gang of followers of today
When Hassan Allahyari calls you all jama'at-e-Umariya.... Don't get rude, accept it he's right!!
Starts 7:10
Champion!
do not. do that. 💀
😂 wallahi and still they will deny
Wow
It is very disheartening to see taking price of priceless things
Hopefully everyone understands...
umar knocks out abu hurrairah.
umar KO abu hurrairah in around 628 AD, there was no refree to stopped the fight. But according to history, it was shocking to disocver he fled the in the battle of uhud, and according to narration "umar was fleeing like a goat very fast" 🙆♂🙆♂ i am confused to say if he was a chamion or a coward
اللهم العن العمر
Umar was the mastermind of everything happened after prophet
Umar was the mastermind, indeed but after the 3rd caliph usman, Mu'awiya (may 1 trillion lanat on him) was the mastermind of everything @@evervid9251
true:biggest hyppcrite close to muwayia how wahabi love umar and muwaia is mind boggling for me, @@evervid9251
O you who believe! Stand devoutly for Allah as witnesses of justice, and do not let your “ANIMOSITY” for some people prevent you from being fair. Be fair, as it is closer to piety, and observe your duty to Allah.5:8….. which is exactly what Sayed & the lovers of Ahlul Bayt (as) have done. No disrespect to the sisters but the brothers must start acting like Men. Ya need to put the emotions aside. Bottom line our religion is based upon LOVE and our hate for the oppressors of ahlul bayt has not impaired our judgment, our reasoning, our ilm as it has done to the ahlul sunnah.
YA Ali madad ❤🙌
Can someone explain the ending ? So after Umar said something a verse of the Quran was revealed ?
That’s what umar is claiming. He’s implying that he has a direct connection to god as if he is a prophet istaghfrilah
If these actions are not open kufr (denial) of the Sunnah , then what is O Umar.😅
'Najaf? No, Karbala? No, Samarrah? Maybe." 😂
Only then he was happy 😅
Sayyid Ammar tbarik Allah 3layk you got Fareed Paranoid and sweating over there
Lanatullah Alayhi
Yh Farid and Sunnah Discourse got so desperate they had to make a response video for the sake of it. I watched all of them, they don’t actually give a substantial counter-argument. They either mock Ammar or try to pick out little parts of Ammar‘s words and twist it.
@@A.A471 They were using emotional arguments not facts
@@biggms13g Yh
@@A.A471that’s what they do best. Run away like their hero umar (L)
They mock us for exposing them from their own books. It’s embarrassing. let them continue folding their arms like the Jews.
How to donate?
46:45 😂 Wallah true.
52:30
Lmao,
The issue of not listening to the order of the Prophet peace be upon him is not understood in an absolutist way that is presented or misrepresented. For example, Ali openly refused to remove the Prophet's name from the peace treaty at hudaybiyya (mustadrak wasail al-shia) even though the Prophet's order was explicit "umhu ya Ali". Based on Nakshawani's approach why did Ali do ijtihad here and not act upon the Prophet's explicit command? Who is the Prophet? Disobeying the Prophet's order is not allowed ever, it counts as kufr?
so let me understand what you are saying, ALi didn't want to delete the part which mentions the prophethood of Muhammad(saw) while her did upon the second order of the prophet with the prophet not being angry with Ali but also saying that it is okay, you can delete it while umar refutes the prophet on many things and still didn't do it even after many requests and orders. that is not the same level. one is deleting the prophethood of Muhammad(saw) while the other is the complying with the order of Prophet which in no way it goes against ALLAH(SWT). no wonder you can't understand this, your heart is closed and eyes are blind and only allah can guide you
Please clarify why Ali not following the Prophet's command is the same as following his command?
@@_7-8-6_ Because it needs a heart to believe in a religion and believe in a prophet that ALLAH has sent and then when requested to delete that part which says the that person is not the prophet. When asked that to delete Muhammad the prophet of Allah from the treaty, what was the response from the prophet Muhammad (PBUH)? he said, indeed i am the prophet of Allah. and then asked Ali (as) to delete that part in which Ali hesitated and then if the prophet was angry with the hesitation, he would have been angry but instead in comforted him and said: A sunnah for a sunnah meaning that how they delete Muhammad Messenger of Allah today and tomorrow they will delete the part of your title too which hint to leader of the believers being deleted when he signed a treaty and only then Ali started to re-edit the writing. this is the difference of speech in Prophet Muhammad talking with Ali then Ummar while with one he was comforting and while with the other he was angry.
Yes Prophet's order: "umhu ya Ali" was not followed by Ali "ma amhu ismak" for good reason which Ali understood based on various factors. This is the whole point alhamdulillah.
What do you think of Ustadh Asim Khan?
Sprinting into History: Breaking Records in the 100-Meter Dash 🏃🏃🏃🏃🏃Umar🦌🦌umar said "i was running like a mountain goat during uhud battle" reference . Jami al-Bayan an Tawil al-Quran,Tafsir al-Tabari,➡➡ He sprints... its in sunni books
Mashallah
BULB
Answer to the guy who is saying that imam Ali married his daughter to umer in Al-Kafi, know that the author of Al-kafi is Kulayni and he already said that to take what goes according to Quran and reject what don't go according to Quran. The author didn't take narrations only from Shias but also from sunnis because sunnis were also students and admirers of our imams. For example founders of sunni MALIKI and HANAFI schools were also students of Imam jaffer al sadiq as. So Al kafi is not infallible only Quran is infallible. Of course there are shia and sufi followers of our imams too. So he took chain of narrations from different places. But not everything is correct. If anything goes against Quran we don't have to accept it. Everyone is welcome who wanted to learn from our imams. They only wanted to help people. And AL-KAFI volume 4 says in "H, Ch. 114, h 3" how daughter of prophet saw Fatima was abused after his death and her rights and inheritance were taken from her. And how she was buried secretly by imam Ali as. Till this day Muslim ummah don't know for certain where is her grave exactly. Such a prominent female figure of Islam buried in unmarked grave. Yet know one finds this suspicious? She was part of her father's heart. Prophet saw loved her dearly. He even called her part of his own body. Yet she's buried in an unmarked grave and Sunni khalifas did not attended her funeral. Obviously sunnis will remain sunnis and shias will remain shias. But this whole fadak situation is very suspicious. Only Allah is the true judge so let's find out when we all go to him. Before that let's be good slave of Allah and ask his forgiveness.
To this day we don't know for sure where is the grave of Fatima daughter of prophet saw is.
H, Ch. 114, h 3
Ahmad ibn Mihran, may Allah grant him blessing, has narrated from narrated in a in a marfu manner and Ahmad ibn Idris has narrated from Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Jabbar al-Shaybani has said that narrated to me al-Qasim ibn Muhammad al-Razi who has said that narrated to him Ali ibn Muhammad al-Hurmuzi from abu 'Abdallah al-Husayn ibn Ali (a.s.) who has said the following. "When Fatima (a.s.) passed away Amir al-Mu'minin Ali (a.s.) buried her secretly, camouflaged her grave site he then stood up facing the grave of the Messenger of Allah said, "O the Messenger of Allah may He grant you blessings on behalf of me the on behalf of your daughter who is visiting you and will pass this night in the soil in your location whom Allah chose to make join you the fastest. O the Messenger of Allah of my patience has reached to the brims and I miss so much your chosen one (daughter) and my self-control is banished for the departure of the leader of the ladies of the worlds. The only solace for me is to follow your tradition and be mournful for your own departure from us. A little while ago I placed you in your grave and your spirit left your body between my own throat and chest. Yes, in the book of Allah (for me) there is the best form to express acceptance of Allah's decision ""We are the servants of God and to Him we shall all return." (2:156) The trust is returned and the commit is recalled amd al-Zahra' is taken away from us. How sad, O the Messenger of Allah, the green skies and the dusty earth seem to us. My sadness has become perpetual and my night have become sleepless. There is an anxiety that will not relieve my heart until Allah will chose for me the dwelling like that where you are. I have a heart bleeding sorrow and a restless anxiety. How quickly the separation took place? To Allah I raise my complains and your own daughter will explain to you how your 'Umma (followers) succeeded in committing injustice against her. You may ask her questions and find information about the case from her. How great was the sorrow that she will find a place and an ear to express to. She would say Allah will judge because he is the best judge. I offer my prayer to Allah to grant you blessings as a note of farewell but not because of disappointment and despaired. If I return it is not that I have become tired and if I will stand up it will not be because of pessimism in the promise of Allah to those who exercise patience. Indeed to exercise patience is more safe and fruitful. Had not been for the mischief of the enemies I would have turned the place a place of worship andd would have kept my worship continuous and would cried like the mothers for the death of their son for the great loss. In the sight of Allah your daughter is buried secretly, her rights are taken away unjustly, her inheritance is withheld for no valid reason. It all has happen just after you left and your memories are still fresh. To Allah O the Messenger of Allah we complain and from you Ohh the Messenger of Allah we seek condolences. May Allah grant blessings to you and to her. May the peace and happiness of Allah be with you."
The whole fadak situation will also be covered as Syed Ammar said. Buckle up it’s gonna be a hell of a ride!
😂do not do that 3ajiiib!!!
Taken together these sunnas show us that Ummar R was a flawed human being going through his journey of Muslimhood, just like anyone of us. Together with the fact that the prophet was so kind and approachable he may have forgotten at times the high status of the prophet of Allah and behaved as he is narrated to have done. It would be interesting if someone compiled all the narrations related to Ummar R in chronological order to see if he changed in general for good over time. Ramadan Kareem iA.
Bro he was a deserter, usurped. Persecuted early muslims. Even with a strong Muslim army he returned back. The army reminded him of the oath not to turn back. He ran from the battle and left prophet in the midst of battle. When everyone believed in 2012 the world will end. But we muslims remembered that imam Mahdi is to come, so the world can't end. His faith was shakeable, he believed prophet died and ran.
He called prophet delirious when he prophet ordered him to join the army and leave Medina during his sick time. When the hudaybiyya peace treaty was signed, he said he doubted prophet's prophethood
Umar was anti-sunnah. He said if a person doesn't have water, they shouldnt pray then. But Quran says you should do tayammum.
Even Sunni believes Umar threaten to burn the door of prophets daughter. And Umar and others met at Saqifa to choose who would rule next. While prophet was close to his last moments.
Which copy of the Quran are you using? Please add a link?
Sayed, I being a shia am sorry to say you are wrong at 1 place.
Umar doesn't think of something, and Allah reveals a verse.
But umar knows better than Allah. Allah had missed 3 things that umar thought of, and Allah said, "Oh right, I missed that, Thank you for reminding me and agreeing with umar revealed 3 verses."
I urge you to correct yourself, Sayed. Don't disrespect umar's highness.
Something wrong with your religion brother.
My guy has lost it
Why don't people understand sarcasm these days 🙄
@@liahnatashahalihassan8033
SARCASM ?????
@@RudeIsRude I think you took it a bit too far with that. You’ve basically mocked Allah SWT in the process of your sarcasm
Nice thumbnail
So I don’t see what exactly the purpose is exactly or what was proved from this video. Sure Umar ibn khattab had some questionable behavior but he was never condemned by the prophet. Even in that hadith where he struck abu hurreira at the end the prophet still agreed with Umar’s opinion so we may see it as impolite but if the prophet was okay with it at that moment who are we to say anything. Lastly it seems like any human companion he would offer his opinion or advice because he understood the prophet was also human but wouldn’t question or interject if the prophet informed him what he was saying was divine knowledge. All the companions are human and they can make mistakes I don’t see it as black or white either they’re perfect or no good at all, they may have had some shortcomings but we’re overall good enough for the prophet to keep as close companions. Maybe I’m missing the point so open to feedback and more knowledge inshallah.
Please share other companions sharing their opinions.
Isnt there a hadith that says you cant even utter the sound uff to your parents - what does that mean in relation to the father of the religion?
The point of the video is to shed light on not painting all the companions with the same brush and encourage discourse. Once an individual can accept not all companions were the same you can start to piece together where the straight path is, as thats what we're all after, right?
@@sraza94 yes I agree everything is case by case and all the companions are their own individuals and I also have questions as to why Umar ibn kittab cleared the room when the prophet was in his last moments as well as him becoming the caliph over Ali. However I feel like the in the video he’s being completely dismissed or portrayed as a pretty bad guy. I’m just confused that if he was a bad guy or untrustworthy or unreliable, why did the prophet keep him as a companion? I do understand that not all companions may be equal and none are perfect because they are humans so we do have to look at everything case by case.
you are not worthy of washing Omars r.a. feet
Shia hates abubakr umar usman aisha, ebadis in Oman thinks usman and ali were the failed government un successful polititions . created all the fitnah , cudnt controll. And sunnies loves all of them
Sunni loves everyone including shaitan cauz he was once angel I heard mufti say this
Haha this was the best comment I’ve ever read 😂😂 if that is the case then that is your and your Muftis problem, you are friends with shaytan we couldn’t expect less from you O indeed “ You surely cannot guide whoever you like ˹O Prophet˺, but it is Allah Who guides whoever He wills, and He knows best who are ˹fit to be˺ guided.” Al qasas verse 56
Its like loving hiтler and jews at the same time or supporting palestine and israel at the same time
I'm sure if I disrespect the prophet sunnies would love me too
Criteria for munafiqun. Congrats sunnie
Subhannallah as a sunni i always tried to be positive about Shia. But your hate for Umar is clearly shown. As a sunni alhamdoullilah we have no hate for none of the companions and respect Ahle Bait. On the day of judgment i prefer that position. We would not even talk negative about our dead family members. Why should i be negative about a companion of the prophet on the basis of literature.
Haven't you watched the video? It shows everything your beloved Khalif did. It's your Sahih books or are you simply mentally handicapped
The Prophet (PBUH) stayed with Umar (ra) so Who am i to distance myself. Hate is never a good advisor. Keep your hate al the way to the day of judgement. The black that you are wearing is starting to remind me more of darkness than good. Please show me a statement from the prophet (pbuh) where he tells me to hate a companion? Your intellect is being ruined by your hate unfortunately.
Listen pal. Your entire Religion and Faith is based upon" literature”. You certainly ain’t receiving wahy from from Allah Pal much less do you ponder over his verses . The Rasul saww has more right over the sahaba and over your dead family members who you would never talk negative about them yet somehow your heart is indifferent towards any negativity towards the Rasul saww which only indicates there is no Eeman inside of it . At the very least , the very least your heart should hate it . Hipocrite
So you want to give utmost respect of the companion on the basis of literature but you will not critisize his disobidience and disrespect of prophet according to same literature? 🤔🤔🤔
[4:135] O you who believe! be maintainers of justice, bearers of witness of Allah's sake, though it may be against your own selves or (your) parents or near relatives; if he be rich or poor, Allah is nearer to them both in compassion; therefore do not follow (your) low desires, lest you deviate; and if you swerve or turn aside, then surely Allah is aware of what you do.
tl;dr: You have to maintain justice even though they are own blood or father no less than a companion.
What a grifter, adding popular Muslims in his thumbnails to gain views. So pathetic.
its actually so shameless
Hijab did that to him though
Guys chill it’s not that serious if they have issue with it they can answer back please don’t make it seem like he is the first to do this this is very common on TH-cam
Absolutely load of nonsense you are saying he is showing these scholars faces in his thumbnails because they are the ones he is answering too. Have some audacity to prove his analysis wrong instead of going out of context.
When the topic killed you off and your only answer was to bark on a picture. That is shameless
Umar also married umm kulthum the daughter of Ali alayhi al-salaam, so this seems to undermine such criticisms or they were not a problem for Amir al-mu'mineen
786
Wait till you hear everything about that sordid matter…
Umar never married any daughter of Ali ibn Abi Talib. But this lecture isnt about Umar‘s relationship with Ali ibn Abi Talib, so it doesn’t undermine anything. You’ve diverted into a different topic. The Hadiths are clear brother, so please don’t neglect these narrations, not in Shia books, but in Sunni books. It may be hard to see this side of Umar, when you may have been growing up that Umar was this very good man. But the Shia don’t revere Umar just for the sake of it, there is clear and justified reasoning as to why the Shia dislike Umar.
True@@A.A471
Are you completely serious? So say that umar really married um kumthum. You accept umars disrespect to the prophet or how should we understand this?
This that married this really sets the level of intelligence amongst ahlul sunnah
Hey Mr Ganesh horse worshipper .. stop. Focusing on side points let's get to the crux of the matter .. prove me your beliefs and I'll become a majoosi like U ..wallahi
- prove that zuljana is the reincarnation of Allah SWT ..
- prove the birth of your Mahdi
- prove to me your 12 imamah by name in the Qur'an and authentic sunnah
- prove your taqqqi and naqqi is infallible
who ever has said Zuljana is the reincarnation of Allah SWT... you have the internet, maybe make sure the claims you are making have some ground LOLLLLL
Umar, the second rightly guided Caliph and leader of the whole Muslim ummah is a side point for you??????????
You okay bro?
Okay, first give me source if abu bakr and umar name in Holy Quran as caliphs… 😂😂😂
And for all your questions, ask you muftis and do some research brother, read read atleast something instead wasting time on taraweeh… 💤💤🔥
No doubt the way you started your comment shows you are characterless as umar ibn unknown (la)
@@wh8370 hahaha it doesn't affect our religion..where is imamat is the pillar of your majoosi religion..get my point akhee
Mashallah