Budget 2021: Clear shift of India's political economy to the Right & why it’s Modi’s 1st BJP budget
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- #CutTheClutter #Budget2021
Following the central government announcing the 2021 Budget Monday, Shekhar Gupta tells you about its features and benefits, its emphasis on growth, and how it harkens back to the 1991 reforms and the reformist face of the early 2000s Vajpayee government, in episode 673 of Cut The Clutter.
Brought to you by @tata.evofficial
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
High quality and fair journalism needs good people to pay just a little for it. Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
Kindly make an android and ios app. It will be much easier to monetize paid subscriptions. Majority use apps for news instead of visiting website.
Myanmar current situation CTC please
poda dei
Lol
This is not cut the clutter, this is adding to it...
What is new in this bill? what has changes to increase growth? what policy changes have occurred?
only piece of useful info was taxes haven't been changed...
The best quote on economics ever : 'Economists are not accountable the next day, but politicians are' !
But sg said economist should not be consulted that just sounds wrong. I myself have right wing and I don't want anyone wealth confiscated just like that. But I don't think ppl who have clear self interest in politics and no good knowledge and experience should be incharge of framing policies, they are simply incapable. This is clearly seen by the statements made the fm and how budget targets poll states
@@prakhargupta2081 they are mainly political party. They will try to hold power it is natural. They learnt from mistake of Vajpayee's second term.
Always trust Economists. Politicians are garbage
@@prakhargupta2081 He should say, Left of Centre Economists.
No good has come out of taxing the rich. They have enough resources to leave the country for good.
Ultimately the poor suffers.
@@prakhargupta2081 bro politicians only give opinions and directions all the data processing , work and calculations are done by beurocracy
I read an interview of Shekhar Gupta long bCk where he mentioned he is socially left and economically right. Well, I don't say I agree to everything he says, but I can see he is true to his words.
Agree with your view, but he is brilliant in moulding words w.r.t. platforms he's speaking at. He was a panelist in NDTV show of Roy pertaining economic survey, nice to listen his brilliance.
Libertarian Right.
Thats like every left wing bigot. They hail marxism and socialism and in the meanwhile buy billion dollar villas for their children from the.money sourced from people.
He is much more honest than others in left , that is why i listen to him
@@shivek1987 stop with your whining already. It's getting pointless now.
BJP finally doing what they were voted in to do. After 6 years .
@subhajit basak in economics!!
@subhajit basak On economic fronts bro 💁♂️
In Indian politics that is basically light speed
@subhajit basak
Ram Mandir is sentimental not economic. Triple talaq has some value definitely.
CAA was and still is an incomplete disaster. 370 was good politically, but GST was excellent and needed.
I wouldn’t say finally. GST was an important reform.. So was IBC and some other things which is why India went from 130 to 40 something in world banks ease of doing business in 5 years from 2014 to 2019
Gupta Ji saying BJP was doing wrong all these years and this year they shifted towards right side...
Yeah, he too believe that over socialism ruined the economy and India is a best example of failed industrialization.
He likes capitalism
@saitama takeowond Just for the objectivity please go and see the ranking of India in Ease of Doing business before 2015.
Indian Red Tape Bureaucracy and so many difficulties for a beginner, lack of Electricity, Lack of connectivity, No special freight carriers, over Urbanisation, no storage facilities, No Labour laws(either they form a union and don't work or they are exploited), State controlling most of the sectors, lack of industrial training in India, India always was on a conservative side of increasing FDI.
Narasimha Rao was a Socialist and MMS also was not a Capitalist but in 1991 there was no other option left other than LPG. It was not their vision instead, it was helplessness.
Like Venezuela is forced to allow private companies in Jan 2021, India was forced to adopt half-hearted LPG in 1991.
Take any country of SEA which got Independence after India, barring Pakistan all are on the right track of industrialisation.
"The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money." - Margaret Thatcher
The fact that we're favourably quoting Margaret Thatcher should be a red flag indicating that something is dreadfully wrong here.
socialism is the only economic syatem where we need evil rich people for it to work.
The Brits really don't consider Thatcher to be their best tbh...and that's not what Libertarian Socialism is about.
@@jasmeenmalhotra2225 yeah, there's something dreadfully wrong with your brain.
Socialist regimes have killed far more people than fascist regimes. Mao and Stalin ended up killing more people than Hitler yet some buffoons still think socialism works.
@@gabbar51ngh Thatcherism and the USSR are not the only two options available to us.
Also, I really wish there could be more civility and professionalism on these platforms. Personal attacks are unnecessary and counterproductive.
Yogendra Yadav is economists
""""""""""”""""""""""""" Is farmer
"""""""""”""""”""""""”"""" Is doctor
”""""""""""'""""""""""""""" Is teacher
""""”""""""""""""”"""""""""is politican
In short he is Johnny sins of india
I heard he will play role of protagonist in next nagin season of ekta Kapoor as icchadhari nag
Is it true????
😂😂😂
Thank god he not entered porn Industry. Otherwise, all Porn Stars will leave the industry after see his Thakela face 😂😂😂 then he will do dharna ..... Sab kaam Johny Sins karke jata hai, humko kuch nahi milta ..... Johny Sins a Bhakt 😂😂
Title also suits his agenda
Duggal sahab also
Yogendra yadav : food from multi star brand hotel ,
Cloths in friends party : costly branded dress but
In reality he will fight against capitalists
I don't know why some people criticize The Print.... !!
I'm so impressed with the way this man elaborated the budget....!! Thanks for information..👍👍🙏🙏
Shekhar sir is the only good thing in The Print ... other videos and articles are totally biased
Finally bjp is acting like a right wing party 👏👏
They are right wing party. Who has any doubt about this?
@@rahulmishra-yy2fv yrah ideologically but they never showed any signs of that economically
@@rahulmishra-yy2fv In india there is no right wing. BJP can more accurately be called Non-Left
@@aadarshrajsharma1856 Right wing is the biggest opposition for non left in the future
@@aadarshrajsharma1856 they are purely right wing party. But the fasict tag put on them by liberals and bastards are totally bullshit.
At last BJP realised that they are right wing party
@Sagar yeah you clearly defined it but economic liberalism (capitalism) is a trait of right wing that's why BJP is called right wing the rest of its policies are ideologies are like left and on the other hand our leftist parties are left on economic front but they act like right wing on ideological workout remember votebank.
@@itemgirlssexy6003 Yeah "ther hand our leftist parties are left on economic front but they act like right wing on ideological workout remember votebank." . This part is So true
@@ShivamAroraa Like it Depends. Not exactly... leaving aside Congress, it's true for others ,mostly Socialists, Leftists.
Congress has had a Big Coalition of Castes and Religion and then Some Economic Liberalism starting from Rajiv Era. Although he died, but even then he would have done same thing that PVNR did(Manmohan did what was instructed). Even Chidambaram did it. Only Pranab Mukherjee was quite left leaning.
@@KshitijBhambri1 the Nehrus are useless. They created and nurtured the Licence Raj, a ridiculous concept. PVN got rid of it.
@@rmrrao2675 That too in crisis.
PVNR himself was a socialist as Shekhar said.
Rajiv infact was much more Capitalist than PVNR or even MMS, he had brought Chidambaram from US back then, Indira was Authoritative Left, Nehru was Libertarian Left.
When Elon Musk will step on Mars to build a colony, he will find Yogendra Yadav there protesting against corny capitalist colonisation on behalf of Aliens who he believes are humans after watching that Ancient Aliens show on History TV.
That's OP bruhhh !!!! 🔥🔥
Haha!
😆😆
Where as Doungi will rename this is moon, yeah tou bholenaat ka sir ka clip.
Sick burn!
This is it. If Modi and BJP actively focus on economic growth for the next 10 years I'd be more than happy to ink my finger for them.
Imo This term was supposed to see big reforms but here a simple farm law has created so much chaos.
The demand of the time (next 5-10years) is reforms and proper regulation in almost every sector...But ye virodh aur andolan ka RNDI-RONA 😶😞
@@pushkarjha367 andolans will go after 2 months lmao
This comment section seems intellectual. Ndtv comment section mai ek hi Randi rona hai- "mudi ne desh bech diya🤡"
Agree bhai bs bhakt mudi gaumotura leke aa jate h Or sochte h bade cool h
@@observerdownunder3999 wahi na! Ek ko factually explain kar raha tha par usne mujhe bjp it cell member bol diya......
@@gjjjj1209 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@gjjjj1209 😂😂
Exactly. Bro after hearing it all from SG, I come here for gold level quotes and intelligent comments.
This is the party I voted for, not for the welfarism that was earlier adopted by Chicha
Chicha*
These day doesn't seem they will come in power in 24 keeping farm stir in head.
@@adityaratan8943 that's just drama.
What do you think how many people out there??
Don't you think people have work rather than protesting in THESE TIMES??
Go to World affairs and Study Iq fr better Analysis
@bhola shankar I don't have but jaats and Sikhs have Samajwadi party and AAP respectively 😭
BJP needs to communicate with the people why privatization is necessary and why government fails to do business. That erases it's hurdles in privatization.
People know but opposition and external support cause problems.
They r selling only those liabilities who r already sunken ! Air India n bail made already huge loses even before NDA government. They r very insufficient, even if see HAL who is making Tejas is also very slow and cost consuming, they took almost 8 yrs to complete 5 Tejas ! I feel that privatisation of Liabilities will give a push to these loss making Organisations. But i disagree with the privatisation of Education sector which is Venomous
@@rameshbhatia3913 investing people's money in non performing assets 😂😂😂
@@Akelehimarenge r u mad?? Where ur money got used ?? Let me know if it's true than I will also take part in the "Mudi should Rejine 🥴" movement
@@wisedesi442 people don't know. I mean the young generation is frustrated saying mudi is selling everything on Instagram.😂😂
You just go out there pissing people off left, right and centre.. you must be a true journalist 😂
You’ve hit it just right! The story of my life... tks for writing in... sg
So true. Last critical video of Modi was thoroughly disliked and they were abusive. Now they're elated.
I've my own personal biases. But rn..I trust only THE PRINT for this exact reason.
@@aadrath1236 only trust shekhar gupta not whole print idiot. The print is biased but not shekhar gupta.
@@ThePrintIndia 😂 I have faced abuse from all in Quora and I couldn't take it, I'm wondering how you take all the heat in really life !
To those saying Modi is selling the country, make sure you are using BSNL not Jio
😂😂😂
Reality of MUDI😡😡( watch all the videos & also support this channel who exposes everything)
th-cam.com/video/JKjkbsFaVJk/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/n5Nk_3zz8XY/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/jGtIdzV_m2c/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/d26WBqt7jhE/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/cKxvMaBGhwI/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/185LC9ljbgU/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/cIZK-RPFRmA/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/Q8VbOD4YK6k/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/x3MRh6tMHwQ/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/KFYfBnYj0Is/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/Ny8ADtBfkpU/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/56zXUL8WZgo/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/cAdAchOGRk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/RSOwFqaxw0o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/8XbJOCvrfTM/w-d-xo.html
Bahut b.... ki jalegi
True
Even I thought so, First Economic Right budget. Hope this continues into the future. Welfare requires Wealth, Wealth comes from Wealth Creators. Fed up with this demonizing of industrialists, corporates.
Wealth creators .....but but wealth for whom ....wealth for themselves ....that's the problem ...while treating workers as slaves ...work 9 to 6 with just 40 thousand ...you can't even survive on this much
@@naturelover8121 Start a business and pay your workers 1 lakh + ..
Trickle down doesn't work, never has, never will. I'm as liberal as they come (both social and economic), but you need checks and balances when there is humongous wealth disparity in the country. Entrepreneurship must be nurtured and given all incentives, and we must have investment friendly policies, but we need measures to make sure the benefits reach the labour class as well. The best way to do that is tax appropriately and invest in public infrastructure, not on stupid statues and places of worship.
@@siddharthmehta6220 If you restrict people from making money they will make money outside your country .. Supply side controls and overtaxation have never worked and never will ..Cost of statues and places of worship are miniscule compared to overall infra spends and these places are good for tourism..
@@naturelover8121 people say this ... But the fact is ....we live in a time of increased per capita income ... try a graph of per capita Income over the years like 200-300 years ...
The fact that SG can criticize a party on one day for doing bad stuff and then praise the same party on the very next day for doing good stuff, all this bamboozles me to say the least. But this is what I like about his journalism. Objective analysis like this is very hard to find nowadays due to all the polarization.
Keep up the good work, SG! 😎👍🏻
PS : Also, thanks to your team for bringing in all the necessary facts :)
Thanks for appreciating the team's hard work, Aman! Do keep writing in.
Chutiya hai saala
@@ThePrintIndia awesome journalism, Guptaji .
@@maheshbmmaheshbm1849 tere baap ki baat nahi kar rahe munna
It’s easy to make a rich guy poor than to make poor guy rich in India.
How many billionaires does a country of poor people need? Makes no sense for one person to hold that much money, it's the movement of money in the Economy that matters, In India money doesn't move, it just accumulates to the rich which use it to buy more of the public sector and govt. officials - a shocking amount of Indian billionaires absconded with money loaned from Indian banks to greener fields elsewhere - got to love crony capitalism.
@@sbains6096 I don't know about billioners but we definitely need to decrease the number of jealous people , who manufacturer and spread hate . Just because someone else was more capable and earned more than them .
@@sbains6096 billionaires become so by running succesful business and in the process giving millions of jobs. As it is said, "you become a billionaire by solving problems of a billion people"-
@@pratyushkishore9030 the issue is that the monopolised state of Indian economy will make sure there are less rich people .
If the govt ensures fair play( which they will not ) , people will not be able to leave the middle income trap.
20 years down the line, the middle income would be poverty synonymous as well, make no mistake.
It's the rich or the poor.
With the monopolies established, despise whatever debate you may have today with a random person, you'd fall in either spectrum in the coming 30 years.
Now choose what kind of reforms would have more rich people or more poor people.
It concerns you and me more than any other established monopolised rich person
Selfishness doesn't matter. The opportunity does. It is , till now , denied to access.
Cheers
@@sbains6096 its the poor who hold their money not the rich...they always invest
Modi’s always been on the right economically. That’s how he worked and developed Gujarat but at centre you have to be a little welfarist to win the poor votes
Yes I visited Gujrat..it’s more developed than Germany and England put together
@@psy_quest
Better than here and also from many states in India bro
Why was the wall required to hide the slums when Trump had come?
@@tumpasaha93 which cities don’t have slums ???
@@tumpasaha93 Slums develop when people from poor areas come to developed areas for jobs but can't afford housing. Mumbai has the biggest slum, that doesn't mean Mumbai is Poor
LIC IPO is huge... looking forward to it!!
Hopefully will get double digit lots of shares
I will definitely apply for it.
Thank god you guys have not said Desh Bech Dia
@@rahulmishra-yy2fv we are gupta ji's students 😂
@@sajaljain8843 People will especially open demat and trading accounts for this.
yes i am also waiting for our own aramco moment
The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings. The inherent virtue of Socialism is the equal sharing of miseries. - Winston Churchill ( i guess)
Quoting someone who caused millions of death in India is a great way to prove your point for the development of India. Bravo
@@krishnomanob lol
Although we hate the man who quoted this.. But is the perfect difference between socialism and capitalism. 🙂
That's socialism done bad... But capitalism like you explained is true everytime
@@krishnomanob Blaming Churchill for the Bengal famine is like Blaming Modi for the Kutch Earthquake. I have read enough on Bengal famine to come to the following conclusions that would explain what actually caused the death of three million Bengalis.
1: A large Section of Bengali Society for Centuries have been living on the edge of Starvation. The Region of Bengal was for a very long time, among the poorest in Subcontinent on per capita terms.
2: Every year it produced just about enough to feed its large population and in case of a short fall in any year, It would Import from the neighbouring Burma.
3: In the year 1943 the region of Bengal witnessed one of the worst cyclones of the century killing more than 14000 people and destroying the paddy crop. Simultaneously there was an outbreak of a fungal disease that took a heavy toll on the remaining paddy crop.
4. As a result, the local grain traders and merchants engaged in a massive hoarding which went unpunished because of connivance of the local administration. This caused an acute shortage of Bengal's staple food, Rice.
5. Remember it was a period when the World War 2 was in its full swing and the Japanese had already occupied Burma, shutting its trade with Bengal. As a Result, no Rice could be imported from Burma.
6. People had already started dying of Starvation when the London received the News of famine. Churchill at first was indifferent to it, being preoccupied with the war that was in a critical phase. His attitude of indifference also had something to do with his Racist and Xenophobic opinion of Bengalis who he believed bred like Rats causing the recurring scarcity of Grains. But in the end he got his head around the severity of the crisis and went out of his way to get Australia to send shipments of grain overlooking the margin of safety for their own wartime supplies and also sent Archibald Percival Wavell, a senior British Army officer as the new governor general of British India specifically with the brief of bringing the famine to an end. Wavell being a competent administrator began his rescue work by diverting troops and military vehicles from the British Indian Army at the height of World War 2 to fetch Rice from Surplus states like Andhra and Tamilnadu to Bengal and thus putting an end to the miseries of Bengalis.
Any unbiased student of History would not do the mistake of blaming Churchill for the Bengal famine but would in fact credit him for brining it to an end but Since majority of the Indians are ignorant and want to virtue signal on colonialism et al, would rather spew rank ignorance on the issue.
Really was waiting since 2014 for this sort or budget...hope to see more reforms..great to see the confidence that government has mustered to present it
Some Persons were going Gaga over Elon Musk becoming the richest person but at the same time they had pain their Arses when Mukesh Ambani became Billionaire. So the Moral is Not everyone deserves internet 🙄🙄🙄
That's because Elon Musk is true innovator, while Ambani thrives because of rent seeking and political connections
@@1591nithin but he is the one who gave cheap internet connectivity to the country. Who said Elon musk is true innovator he uses right people for right job and has sense of appreciation for out of the box ideas
@@1591nithin lol, Elon had made no profit and was burning investment money for his vision, in India your company goes to red, we make them into devil like Vijay Mallya. Mukesh Ambani is business man and he takes risk. The dude just changed his entire business portfolio from moving to IT and telecommunications from oil and gas. Its easy to say political contacts, but hard to earn only 1000 rupees by doing business in India.
@@1591nithin You should thank Ambani that you even got to know about Musk or else you would still be paying 250Rs for 1Gb internet
@@1591nithin Ambani gave you literal free internet. If that's not taking risk then I don't know what is
well done bjp, privatization is finally a stated policy, india needed a real right wing party and the prime minister did not disappoint. THANK YOU MODI !!!!!
I thought I will come here and see comments like" desh bech dia" , feku
@Abhishek Mishra 😂 rahul gandhi
@@ritikachaudhuri6151 i just added "THANK YOU MODI" in the end just to make sure i get to see the meltdown
@Abhishek Mishra I just came NDTV comment section and Reddit.
I bet your family has at least 50 government Sevant which unfortunately u don't deserve it
"The fact is nobody checks the facts!" ~ Guptaji
This applies to farmers protests and their anarchist supporters
@@gopaakrishnanmvenkataraman9129 Does it apply to Government?
@Arup Ratan Mitra I think u meant to say all of us ?
@Arup Ratan Mitra Amen to that
😂😂
Economist are not the one who are accountable the day after!!
So powerful.
Nirmala Sitaraman also should get some credit, I think more because for obvious reason she is FM.🙏
Everyone was criticizing her, but she just performed. I know there are many people behind her budget but still people should aplaus her.
True. I guess some of derision stemmed from non-acceptance of women in active power-position. Some previous FMs got away with far more incompetence.
Cometh the hour, cometh the woman (finally).
Agreed. It's funny how she was made the scapegoat for previous years without bringing in mention of the PM while this year every credit goes to PM and nothing to her.
Congress ++++ and Cow, that one was really funny :D
Even telangana cm blamed congress and bjp for doing same things differently & failing continuously.
@@vishwakchandra1881 Makes sense bro
@@Pulkit535 that is the truth, Congress +++ and cow. And it's not funny.
Coupta always starts with modi and ends with Cow, he has long been a fan of Steak
the word was count
After opposition starts quaking "suit boot ki sarkaar" they take a step back and withdraw the reforms like land acquisition, labour reforms, judiciary reforms, etc. Blunder by this government.
One of the best Cut the clutters I have watched.
Sg u haven't invite our one and only Yogendra yadav the economist, activist, farmer, revolutionary doctor etc in one word Jonny sins lite 🤮🤮
U forgot scientist..😂😂😂
Gajab bejati hai yogendra ki
Yogendra sinns bro.. What you mes up the surname
Wasn't he an astronaut also?
@@sachinkuchgave7365 bejati unki hoti hai, jinki koi izzat ho
Government's work is to regulate not to do business.
The the business part should be left with professionals so that they can work and earn and create jobs.
Lol
But losers keep shouting Ambani. Adani.
Yes. But jobs are often seen as a govt responsibility completely in India. Countries are usually proud of their highest job creators but the opposition uses Ambani Adani like a gaali. So fuvk them
But in a country like India where businessmen try to form a monopoly along with their political nexus, the government should regulate the market. The corruption of socialist approach would still be livable rather than the corruption of the capitalist one.
@@rishabhmishra9230 dude...where and when have there ever been any company or private firm that doesn't work towards being a monopoly or doesn't want to be one....Dont try to make it a case only for india man...govts around the world regulate them to some extent...and india does the same.... New companies or competition for already established firms will rise up only if the ease of business and startup culture is supported which is happening slowly.....not by stopping or hindering the growth of already established businesses and firms otherwise the other established businesses or firms around the world would not want to enter your market and your businesses won't be able to become big enough to compete for foreign exchange which means not enough jobs for anyone and much more... Don't justify socialism...it's a stupid idea that came from the noggins of stupid people to provide stupid dreams to other stupid people.
Work for your money and if you don't want to then atleast innovate for it... Don't drool over other people's money
At last, BJP has started to behave like a real conservative party
Yaa.. after shit showels to the face.
Same with Narsimha Rao too.
This country has the good old problem of having short lived victories like before. When calamity strikes.....consciousness suddenly rises otherwise it remains in,
" Na Khaunga Na Khaneh Dunga"
@@dbmdrums1105 Absolutely right, bro
More like fiscally conservativism
It's not conservative goon. It's a Liberatarian party
@@hybridwars3029 I think it's not libertarian party, they believe in absolute of the freedom of speech. They do restrict it.
Economics: Right
Cultural: Right
Social: Center
Governance: Center
This is the best approach for India. BJP needs to stop being overly Right on Social issues
Hotel Trivago?
Being economic *RIGHT* is *RIGHT* for India'
Now BJP becoming fully right wing party socially and ecommically I hope they continue reforms in remaining 3 year of this term of modi government India at least need 10% growth rate to compete with China which becoming new headache for India
And then in 2024 I will vote for BJP with a full heart and not half heartedly.
@@skntrn5195 do you see any intelligent opposition..lol so bjp in 2024 and 2029 and 2034
I will wait for 10 % gdp growth rate without manipulating data.
@@naveenkumarjha5428 if u cant trust indian estimates then u can trust IMF atleast... I hope we achieve more than 10% growth in coming years
@@naveenkumarjha5428 you have an option amongst the looney left opposition?
Why the disclaimer that this is an opinionated version of cut the clutter?
Aren't all your episodes opinionated?
Only that this time Shekar Gupta has stated it openly 😀
No. All others are decluttered news and insights.
Absolutely..in selection of topics..in their bias
.in their ha conveyed narratives ..articulate people can persuade you with their eloquence that is basically BS
Shekhar ji, I am a regular follower of your programs. This has been one of the best program of yours. You have shown that you not only understand politics, but economics also. You are right in saying that UPS 2, led by Sonia Gandhi (not Manmohan Singh), changed its route to absolute socialism. After all, Sonia Gandhi also seems to believe that India cannot grow by more than 3 1/2 percent per annum, and all her policies were aiming to bring down India's growth to that level. She also likes sycophants, which is the reason that many small leaders in the government dared to do whatever they wanted, and Prime Minister MMS was reduced to a meek spectator. You righty say that UPA 1 rided for some years on Vajpayee Govt's reforms. But no one gives credit to Vajpayee. Rather everyone talks about MMS for his successful tenure during UPA 1. AB Vajpayee was quite insightful in not just national/ international affairs, but also economic affairs. He had successfully controlled not just the inflation, but also the deep slowdown of 2001-02. India was among the first economies in the world to start showing signs of revival in 2003.
Shekhar sir is looking excited with prospectus of strategic disinvestment.... so am I
Ahem ahem. Did you mean Privatisation😂😂
Neither disinvestment nor privatization... Now it's called monetization
@@anmolkhosla2551 Privatization is a good word. Sell loss making and break even orcs to private players. They run it better and help the entire country to grow.
So am I as well. The government has no business to be in business. It must exit from even profit making PSUs.
Nobody is going to buy trash unless its recycled
"The democracy will cease to exist if you take away from those who are willing to work and give it to those who wouldn't."
India is a socialist State with mask of democracy. 75 years are best example.
It was never a true democracy. Won't be for next 15 years.
*communist anthem*
"willing to work"
Seems nice on the basis. However, the will to work comes from the nature of work and growth possibilities
In 30 years the divide of rich and poor will be worse than ever imagined.
Let's see what you'll be saying on the other side.
It's not capitalism, it's monopolised crony capitalism that is the issue
@@sorryminati4719 isn't it bound to increase. Billionaire like Tata, Ambani, Birla has either no child or maxm 2-3 children.
Whereas a rickshaw puller has 5-6 children. Who is responsible for their poverty?
@@sorryminati4719 and each and every business men in the world dream to create a monopoly. Some become successful, some don't. If a country of 1.4 billion can't produce enough talented entrepreneurs to prevent monopolies, then we should feel ashamed of ourselves
Felt blessed today to discover lots of economically right individuals in the comment section.
I love the way Shekher started, clearly stating that it'll be an opinion!
everything he says is an opinion, his sins of omission are what sets him apart as one of the greatest frauds of India.
Now we can actually call them right wing.
It was not just about right wing view but he was referring to the right way (he was appreciating it).
A classic example of Left embarrassing themselves
No , I don't even all BJP a ring wing.
Fact is nobody checks facts
- shekar Gupta 2021
bro take a look on sensex after Budget
"Economists are not accountable the next day, the politicians are!!" BRILLIANT !!!
I can see lot of enthusiasm and hope in the video as well as in comment , I hope for the best let's see if government can walk the talk ...... Major issue is all of this is not implemented to the core
Yogendra sins economists bhi hai😂😂😂
Yogendra Yadav _ Oh my God. Economist
Hey wanna join Harvard?
He is icchadhari can become anything😂
साबित का इच्छाधारी नाग वाला comment yaad aa gaya..😄😄😄
I thought that too...nowadays he is a farmer. 😁😁
Duggal Saab aaj economist hai🥴
I was listening professional investors, they were happy that this budget plan is made by "visionaries" & not by 'economists'.
The most difficult thing is to strike a balance between politics and economics.
Yogendra yadav economist !!!!!
संबित का इच्छाधारी नाग वाला comment yaad aa gaya..😄😄😄
Shekhar ji can you please cover the Myanmar coup and what it means for India. Keep up the great work! 🙏
Yes plz
Privatisation is the ultimate solution. No govt (Bjp/congress/aap)can provide govt job to 140 crore people.
7:27
'The fact is nobody checks the facts'
True
"Yogendra Sahab, aaj economist bane hain"
Don't forget Duggal sahab, the best you can get in every field
😂😂😂😂
इक्षाधारी योगेन्द्र यादव
Thank u for this brilliant video. I would request you to make video on Mayanmar crisis.
Myanmar k sath pakistan ho gaya 🤪 if you know 😂
@@harshalsingh2750 America 🤫
@@harshalsingh2750 lmao
@@prasadpapolu kutte kha liye kya bhai??
@@sunandabakshi2266 pakistan IT cell bhai
Gordon Gekko: "The point is, ladies and gentlemen, that greed, for lack of a better word, is good. Greed is right. Greed works. Greed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit."
SG sir's best line " Wo gareebi nahi hatha rahi thi wo ameeri hatha rahi thi" that was like awesome and to the point
love you sir
"Opinions are like Butts, everyone has them and it stinks"
😂
Damn that is a gold statment 😂😂😂
"Western ones will stink more than eastern"
You know what i mean 😂
@@anitag3500 Hahaha. That was clever... 😆
Haha, tell that to OPIndia
God yes , finally Economic conservatism comes home.
Love your comment. This is a good change.
Reform and conservatism are opposite words.
@@tamberlame27 so true
@@bhargavdesai7984 They are not. Conservatism is related to fiscal stance. Reform is neither conservative nor liberal. Both sides should carry out reforms, and have done so in the past.
@@tamberlame27 Fiscal Conservativism is very different.
This mind set should have been four years ago. Anyway good to see things in right direction. Gst collection record high, share mkt record, fdi flow excellent, reserves record level.
@Benny Ben i don't think so, maybe by 2030
Well the first budget was a very economic right but everyone bashed BJP.
Yogendra is Doctor, Lawyer, Economist........
.🐽
Also a farmer
Plumbers, astronaut, Police officer and fake Taxi driver also😂😂😂
Yogendra yadav is an asshole!
Someday we will see him in certain films and become a true Indian legend.
@@amantiwari4987 Agriculturalist 🤣
this farmer protest making me stressed angry frustrated...😭
When will Modi learn to tame the mad elephant?
They are anything but farmers. See the flag they are foisting.
Say what you want....this farmer protest will never go away 🤣😂 BJP will get frustrated to death 😜
@@maymena17 i think the farmers will get frustrated to death..not the government...watch out...
@@rakshithk711 Haha.... The Govt is already very frustrated and you can see the dirty tactics they are resorting to 👎 But farmers will never give up 🤞
Did anyone watched NDTV prime time on this budget. Their most hyped anchor is just short of getting a heart attack on Privatisation drive by this government.
Dear Professor, though I am a born cynic, your smile and your excitement compel me to trust this. I really really really hope you are totally absolutely right. A lot rides on it.
You can listen Shekhar Gupta for hours and it will still feel interesting.
Whoever followed Narsinha Rao + Man Mohan Singh in Economy lost the next elections- Remember Shekhar; simply because they moved from `Poverty as Problem' to `Poor as problem'
Hard disagree on the rampant hard-on for capitalism, specifically on insurance (profit by denying coverage), healthcare (price gouging desperate people) and banking (large too big to fail private banks making risky speculative investments).
sg saw the benefits of the 90's reform and understandably, loved it. But markets fail at certain edge cases, and we should be cognizant about that.
Keep up the good work!
If Modi can deliver on the economy then he can also deliver on the hindutva agenda otherwise prepare for a crash in the currency and the hindutva dream
The Hindutva still isn't defined properly.
By the words u go , its just the united Indian front.
But from liberal politics its a religious consolidation, which i don't ever think well be happening while Modi is heading the Govt.
May be Yogi might but I am 100% sure bjp won't bring him as a PM , if it does there ends the term for BJP .
@Krishnkant Singh Hindutva is nothing related to Religion. Infact Mr. Savarkar was an Atheist.
Hindutva talks about building a strong and powerful India based on Cultural and Regional Identity. Everyone in India is considered a Hindu.
@Krishnkant Singh Savarkar advocated abolishment of Caste system. He proposed that an oppressive societal divide led to weakening of Hindu Society. That made us susceptible to frequent foreign invasions.
I like the Idea of Hindutva where we flaunt our collective cultural identity unapologetically rather than emulating Western culture.
@@adityarane5735
The only thing the corrupt and fake media has succeeded is to defame the thoughts of Savarkar.
It hurts when these corrupt media defame him as a person begging for mercy.
@kok koku Didn't he said preserving cultural and regional identity? We have proudly embraced multiple religions over the time and we will continue to do it. The idea of Hindutva is not to oppose or oppress any religion or community, it is to safeguard the identity that we have been holding on for millenniums.
How we benifit from Shekhar's wisdom when he puts the national interest first.
No pun intended.
The most honest statement from Shekhar Gupta: 'The fact is no one checks the facts'.
Sir, stop calling Yogendra Yadav an economist and your friend. Nowadays he is a farmer and secondly, he doesn't deserve your friendship.
Modi promised this in 2014. It took a pandemic for him to finally deliver 6 years later.
Atal Bihari Vajpayee was one of the greatest PM of all time...
Modi 💓
@@amnrai12 Modi too.... Thts why I said "one of the"...
Modi Government going towards right direction with keeping in mind 2004 election result.They will go towards growth& reform with keeping together election winning tactics of RSS
Gupta ji is becoming the NEO sharma ji ka launda in News industry.🤓🤓
Liberals on Elon Musk:🥳🥳🥳🥳
Liberals on Ambani, Adani, Ramdev:🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
🤣🤣
I am honored to be a paid subscriber. I appreciate all your hard work in bringing in stellar expertise in all that you do.
Hi Rohit. Thank you for being a loyal subscriber of ThePrint.
Vintage SG! Finally Modi seems to have realized the "right" way forward! 👍
I Will Call It's Shekhar Sir's Hard Turn Right From His Last Video.
thank God for Shekhar Gupta !!! we definitely need more like him
We have lot of them
Every bhakt talks like him
SG plays with facts n data, observe carefully
Shekhar sir you have become the Desi 😂😂😂😂 Gordon Gekho " Greed is Good"
The FORCE recommendations being just left of center is a huge understatement
Modi is the Right man for India.
Very heartening developments today. Looks like Modi & Co are finally down to the 'vikas' plank for which most of India voted for.
SG sir, you will have the left brigade now calling you a pro Modi. I have followed you long enough to know you are the most objective senior journalist in the country. But must say, it was one of your more vocal criticisms of Sonia that I have heard.
SG supported Farm bills and it became a Panauti for goverment and now he is supporting this budget... Let's see what happens now.😅
Hahahha true😂😁😁
Lol true
Good presentation for a change. Thanks.
" The inherent virtue of Socialism is the equal sharing of miseries - Adam smith, Wealth of the nations"
There weren't any socialist examples when Adam Smith wrote his book so I'm assuming you found this quote on the internet without fact-checking.
Here's one from Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments (note the socialist quality implied in the words):
When the happiness or misery of others depends in any respect upon our conduct, we dare not, as self-love might suggest to us, prefer the interest of one to that of many. The man within immediately calls to us, that we value ourselves too much and other people too little, and that, by doing so, we render ourselves the proper object of the contempt and indignation of our brethren.
The world is much more complex that perceiving it through a black-white frame.
Maybe it was said by von mises or fa hayek probably
@@sbains6096 I have read Adam smith wealth of nations itself,.Liked it much, much more than Das kapital
@@SurajSharma-zi4sn nope written by Adam smith only in wealth of national. I have a pdf of same. You can also get it on internet.
Shekhar Gupta " everything happened in a democracy is politics and for votes"
meanwhile farm laws " are you comedy me "
Hi jorge.
Pepa 🐷👍👍👍😯🙂
Guptaji...pls dont mention clowns like Yogendra Yadav as your friends, or that you even know them. Your entire credibility will be at stake otherwise.
Our Beloved PM is the face of modern India and a trendsetter. Its a growth-oriented budget
Shekhar Gupta ji quoting Gordon Gekko made my day.
Punjiwaad amar rahe 🙌
This is an awesome budget... Finally the BJP is becoming a right wing growth centric party.
Be ready for massive social instability. Just mark my words and be happy.
@@yongzeal yeh dekh lenge
@@yongzeal : my ass...
@Benny Ben Right wing or right leaning governments are pro business governments.... They create policy changes that lead to increased privatization and decreased government interference in the market.
They tend to believe that it isn't a government's role to be in business.
The slogan of most right leaning governments is "less government, more governance."
@@yongzeal Based on what? All data points out to the fact, that for a low or middle income country to industrialize rapidly, they should follow Milton Friedman's monetarian policy of privatizing everything.
The biggest proponent of this theory, has been China... that has been able to transform its country from a poor agrarian economy to a global manufacturing powerhouse that has outcompeted all the industrialized countries of the world and is going to be a future superpower in the world.
If Shekhar Gupta is so excited with this budget then I am sure Modi govt must have done some tremendous work ;)
Shekhar bhaisab usually you speak against right wing.. in this episode you have given balanced and factual opinions. That is why I continued to watch this episode.
First of all kudos to the finance ministry for total degitalization of the budget process
And thanks for very objective analysis to Mr Shekhar Guptaji.