At first, I thought the tenor guy was playing “out,” and I was like “yeah I like this. This is different”; then I realized he was a beginner haha. He sounds great, though!
Everyone has to start somewhere! Congrats to Correy for putting yourself out there with world class players and trying your best! Eric's playing is wonderful, as usual.
He wasn't terrible. Anybody would sound less than magnificent next to Eric and crew. I wish I had his guts to get up there. If he keeps that up he will progress and leave the naysayers in the dust.
In the world of "six degrees from......." I'm two degrees from the legendary Mr. Erskine as the saxophonist Richard Torres, who recorded an album with Peter and shared a stint in Stan Kenton's orchestra, was in a swing combo with me in 1998-9.
Yes, a rotten player. The name cats smugly look at him in a friendly way. They know better but are afraid to say or do anything. What kind of teachers could they be? The tune should have been stopped after a few of the horrible notes, and the poor player either ejected, or lectured to. I don't know what else to say. I am an alum of Berklee from late 70's/early 80's. This garbagey playing would not have been smiled at by teachers back then. Yelling at crappy players, kicking their ass, was part of the schooling back then.
Correy Harrisj with W/George Whitty-Piano, Eric Marienthal-Alto sax, John Patitucci-Bass, and Peter Erskine-Drms ? A unique chance , where, why , how ?
@@jaykerouac2 Eric, as world renowned expert and accomplished saxophonist, should have held back or even declined a solo improv, lest for fear the tenor beginner might be discouraged and perhaps gave up. Eric is as great an instructor as he is a sax expert; I have learnt so much from him, both as a person and saxophonist. Maybe, like a youthful Charles "Yardbird" Parker, Corey will return as the new John Coltrane or Michael Brecker, reincarnated (smile)
¡De nada! Pero la próxima vez, puends comprar el video, en lugar de beneficiarte de un video sin costo. Un video que, como tu describes, NO EXISTIRÍA si el joven no hubiera pagado por el plan de estudios que le permitió juntarse con los maestros que ves en el video.
Well look they probably invited him up there knowing how he plays. He’ll be a better musician for this. This video is free. It’s not like he’s ruining someone’s dinner or someone’s concert. So I say let him get some experience with the big cats in this better environment. Good on Eric for being a teacher.
Yes, painful. It's almost as though he were a student, who somehow purchased lessons online! Almost as if part of the curriculum of those lessons were to record a video performance with the masters that comprise the faculty of that school. After that, by virtue of some bizarre and unexplained constellation of phenomena, when asked to perform, that student "struggled" at his expected level of proficiency--far below what the masters can do!! We may never know. I mean, it's not as if the video were labeled with the name of the educational company that is so-structured. Very mysterious. But go on.
Ahhh there's nothing like elitist snobs to suck the joy out of music. They may be totally correct but a world made by perfect pitch and click tracks formulated and devoid of spontinaity will soon be upon us. AI robots can replace us mediocre struggling musicians who play with feeling out of love and the world will be a sterile unsurprising place. I'll be down by the railroad tracks blowing bad notes and the birds and frogs are going to back me up.
At first, I thought the tenor guy was playing “out,” and I was like “yeah I like this. This is different”; then I realized he was a beginner haha. He sounds great, though!
The tenor man is having a go and learning thats great power to him
Exactly. He's a student.
Everyone has to start somewhere! Congrats to Correy for putting yourself out there with world class players and trying your best! Eric's playing is wonderful, as usual.
Be Nice! We were all there at one time or another.....maybe we still are. 417 to 23 not bad odds. Carry On Mr. Correy!
Good work! Keep practicing! Congrats! Playing with Eric is just a dream for me...
He wasn't terrible. Anybody would sound less than magnificent next to Eric and crew. I wish I had his guts to get up there. If he keeps that up he will progress and leave the naysayers in the dust.
Exactly,
Give your man a break, we've all been there and I wasn't any better, I hope he's playing well and getting on with things 😊
Mr. Erick has to be the top 5 players in the world. Such a great tone and exciting lines.
Sometimes Ya gotta hit a few wrong notes first in your development before you can know the right notes! Great job tenor man!
You probably meant to say 'a few right notes.' lol
@@gmann7082 no, i meant to say wrong notes
@@brooklyntiger - Au contraire, mon frere. lol
jtaltorags3186
Sometimes you have to break a few eggs to make an omlette, but that dude playing tenor had the hens working overtime.😎
@@jaykerouac2 😂lololool
Great Everything!!!
2:49 the licc
troll
I need to transcribe the John bass solo! Always inspiring!
Master's lesson for a beginner! Good trial!
i would say I’m an intermediate and i would kill for lesson with Eric Marienthal
I love the alto sax 👏
NICE!!!!!!!!!!
Wow I don’t know what to say about the tenor sax playing. Eric Marienthal was amazing
Amazing
In the world of "six degrees from......." I'm two degrees from the legendary Mr. Erskine as the saxophonist Richard Torres, who recorded an album with Peter and shared a stint in Stan Kenton's orchestra, was in a swing combo with me in 1998-9.
U win the dream..just keep practising tenor guy👍
Nice job.
That look Patitucci gives that Tenor player @2:38 says it all 😂
Mestre Marienthal... Congratulations friends, the best sound...
What is this? A lesson for the tenor player? Very kind of these great musicians to share the stage with a beginner!
I believe that the company (artistworks) arranges for clients to play with their teachers if they are in the area.
Yes, a rotten player. The name cats smugly look at him in a friendly way. They know better but are afraid to say or do anything. What kind of teachers could they be? The tune should have been stopped after a few of the horrible notes, and the poor player either ejected, or lectured to. I don't know what else to say. I am an alum of Berklee from late 70's/early 80's. This garbagey playing would not have been smiled at by teachers back then. Yelling at crappy players, kicking their ass, was part of the schooling back then.
Which one is the tenor
Jazz snob
@@athanhwang8086 the man standing is playing the tenor
BRAVO
Yeah, great
Nice effort, keep playing man
What a great experience playing with these guys. Bit unkind putting it in the Comedy category.
Eric’s sound… that’s a sound that gets work
Eric just sounds like he is more experienced than the other saxophonist in my opinion.
He is, he’s an intermediate player getting a lesson with Eric
Primer ensayo parece
Correy Harrisj with W/George Whitty-Piano, Eric Marienthal-Alto sax, John Patitucci-Bass, and Peter Erskine-Drms ?
A unique chance , where, why , how ?
schwarzenegger did a good job on piano
Maybe the tenor sax is the producer. And he want to do jam with the masters
Maybe he _ate jam_ instead and it got stuck in the mouthpiece. That's why he sounded so bad. lol
@@faustus5481 DAMN BRO but so true tho
Клавишника браво.
coisa linda
Mestre Eric Marienthal
Listen to Michael Brecker on Blue bossa. Perhaps it gives some ideas. Good luck. 🎉🎉❤
Great Job!!!
Who's the guy who owns the tenor sax?😎
Faustus --- lol....that's the funniest putdown I've ever heard.
@justin vo
Yo, vo !!
@@jaykerouac2 Eric, as world renowned expert and accomplished saxophonist, should have held back or even declined a solo improv, lest for fear the tenor beginner might be discouraged and perhaps gave up.
Eric is as great an instructor as he is a sax expert; I have learnt so much from him, both as a person and saxophonist.
Maybe, like a youthful Charles "Yardbird" Parker, Corey will return as the new John Coltrane or Michael Brecker, reincarnated (smile)
アルトサックスの機種は何ですか？
What the tenor Man doing? Hehe
It's hard to play with Marienthal. Probably the tenor player was shy.
rcr7 saxofonista maybe he is just shit
Lars Bøe Music Ever consider he is probably a beginner? Dickhead...
El señor Erik se le queda observado al señor del tenor al final(momento incómodo y gracioso)
Roger Roger we lose in the deep universe gentleman whit tenor
Beautiful music, shame about a lot of the comments underneath it. Total morons, so rude and ignorant. I loved it. Keep playing.
6:01 gracias mi negro por arruinar un solo que jamás en mi vida podré escuchar, MUCHAS GRACIAS!
Jajajaja
¡De nada! Pero la próxima vez, puends comprar el video, en lugar de beneficiarte de un video sin costo. Un video que, como tu describes, NO EXISTIRÍA si el joven no hubiera pagado por el plan de estudios que le permitió juntarse con los maestros que ves en el video.
who is tenor sax player.may i know??please
I think Eric is the better player.
Я бы так пока не сыграла :)
Why?
THIS LICK 4:23 It‘s just perfect😩
The tenor man has no idea of the harmonic progression or improvisation of the musical piece.
I'm total agre.
Jajajaj
So embarrassing.....and in front of Eric Marienthal.
Well look they probably invited him up there knowing how he plays. He’ll be a better musician for this.
This video is free. It’s not like he’s ruining someone’s dinner or someone’s concert. So I say let him get some experience with the big cats in this better environment. Good on Eric for being a teacher.
Easy buddy , maybe he just start learning the music
ALTO PAS TELLEMENT MUSICAL
What brand is the tenor player playing?
What is this supposed to be a video for?
Does Eric play a Mark 6 alto?
Yes, for almost 50 years 🎷💪
They are playing the incorrect Real Book head. It is a short easy tune. Why not get it together?
Ajoute «Eric Marienthal» dans le titre de la vidéo et tu fait 2x plus de vues👌💪
Marienthal est vraiment un musicien exceptionnel
@@francoislernoux3611 mais totalement pourquoi il ne le serait pas?
Что это?
NI-YO-TOCO-ASI-DICE-MEDRANO
Nah… big up to the guy..
oye.afinen-ALSEÑOR_DEL_TNOR
A la firme ese tenor está hasta las huevasss
2:41
2:42
2:
2:
2:40
2:40
Very big and painfull struggle from tenor player, alto plays effortless like a bird
You got them mixed up
@@jawadmuh you are mixed in your head, read again you mixologic
Yes, painful. It's almost as though he were a student, who somehow purchased lessons online! Almost as if part of the curriculum of those lessons were to record a video performance with the masters that comprise the faculty of that school. After that, by virtue of some bizarre and unexplained constellation of phenomena, when asked to perform, that student "struggled" at his expected level of proficiency--far below what the masters can do!! We may never know. I mean, it's not as if the video were labeled with the name of the educational company that is so-structured. Very mysterious. But go on.
I think Eric is better at sax than the other player
Ahhh there's nothing like elitist snobs to suck the joy out of music.
They may be totally correct but a world made by perfect pitch and click tracks formulated and devoid of spontinaity will soon be upon us.
AI robots can replace us mediocre struggling musicians who play with feeling out of love and the world will be a sterile unsurprising place.
I'll be down by the railroad tracks blowing bad notes and the birds and frogs are going to back me up.
Eric jest bezkonkurencyjny!
Nn
the asphalted tenor sax. Not brave but conceited. sorry, nothing personal
Its really embarrasing listen the tenor player. Minimun a little bit of practice.
The tenor player needs more practice. Eric sounds more practiced and knows the song better.
Well he is Eric marienthal (I think that’s how you write it) so like it makes sense that he is very
Good
The tenor cannot play.
coño_dejen_tocar_al:_negro
even BILL CLINTON plays better the tenor sax then the guy on this video ...........))))))))))))))))))))))