27:10 the narrator/commentator says he "doesn't consider his actions extreme" but he obviously does.. I'd really like to know both who he thought was molesting her, and most importantly, WHY he thought that.
I wonder if he's accusing his step-dad (her dad) of being the perpetrator, and did this to harm him, while using the story that his step-dad was abusing her as a way to both morally exonerate himself & harm the step-dad..
34:30 I was wrong - he says somewhere after 34:30 "then I'd be here about a 14-year-old, not a 4-year-old", thus likely referring to his youngest brother (he's 18, the brother at the house when the police came is 16, and he has 1 more brother - likely the 14-year-old he's mentioning. I wonder if that brother was his step-father's son from a previous relationship. The daughter seems to be his mother's + his step father's daughter.
I thought this was heartbreaking too. However, I wonder if the brother is the one he thought was abusing the sister because of that statement? (I'm only half way through)
@@xandercrews7314 no he was the abuser, he probably killed her because he was disgusted with what he had done and couldn’t face it anymore then snapped
Nah that’s creepy especially considering the fact that he’s accusing his brother of being an abuser. We will never know the truth, and I’m not going to sit here and accuse someone with no proof, my only point is that I don’t think it’s normal for an older brother to call his 4 year old sister “my baby”
This has to be one of the sickest, heartbreaking accounts of murder I’ve ever heard. The fact that he cut her neck once, and she screamed, and cried, then asked him, “Why are you killing me?”, is nauseatingly heinous. That poor, poor baby. She just wanted to paint with her big brother, whom she obviously trusted. OMG. I feel sick after watching this one. This made me very tearful. Murder is always horrific, but this account made me sick, sad, and livid all at once. 🤢😭😡
As an 18 year old guy with an 8 year old younger sister, this was extremely hard to watch. I’m basically a second parent to her, I could never in my life imaging purposefully hurting her in any way. I feel like it’s my job to protect her from any physical or emotional pain.
He would of probably killed his whole family. I wouldn't doubt for a second the kid murdered his sister because she resisted or threatened to "snitch" on his sexual abuse of her.
To be fair I’m only about 10 minutes in but he did just say he would have used the gun against the guy he believed to be assaulting her. He then killed her to protect her when he couldn’t get the gun
@@bigrichmccoy506 Yeah, he said he couldn't get the gun with which he seemed to be indicating that he was going to kill this supposed abuser of his sister with so he killed his sister.
I'm a grown man and I'm not ashamed to admit that the thought of that little girl lying on the floor, bleeding, asking her brother "why are you killing me?" made me cry
As a 18yr old girl with a four year old brother I cannot fathom ever doing anything even remotely close to this. That baby is my absolute world and genuinely my best-friend, alongside with the fact I am very maternal with him and love him just as much as I would love a child. The fact that somebody could kill a toddler like that is beyond me
Be Ever So GRATEFUL this Makes Zero Sense to you!! Its bc you know how to love and have compassion and empathy. May you have a long happy and joyous life! Peace ✌
yeah I really don't understand how these dudes can sleep being in a room with people like this all the time.... so scary to be face to face with an murder
@@smokinjodak9844 Just like people in the medical profession or in the military, they compartmentalize the aspects of their job from the rest of their life. You are trained to have a professional distance between you and your client or in this case, person in custody. There could be many different emotions going on and probably not fear at all. Frustration maybe and also maybe deep sadness at the type or mode of the crime. Empathy of course with the victim being a child when a lot of people in the caring/protecting professions are also parents with children. But you put on your nurse/doctor/military/police hat and do your job. You can't allow your job to affect you or you wouldn't be effective in that job.
I'm wondering did abuse happen? I just surprised the family didn't went to the hearing to see him condemned but I can understand why. Still psychotic to think that the only way to save his sister from "abuse" is in death. Not to mention from mom testimony that's the only relationship he maintained well with.
When she said she wanted to watch SpongeBob and paint that made me cry thinking of my niece. Can’t imagine anyone doing something that cruel to a innocent child
If you watch a lot of psychopath documentaries like I do then you would know that psychopaths are spiteful and tend to lash out when they don't get what they want.. The killing was more than likely to hurt his mom who would not let him purchase the firearm. Notice how he keeps bringing up the gun and how upset he was about it for no apparent reason. She may have stopped a mass shooting from taking place.
@@curtisvenom32 whether he is a Psychopath or not I don't buy his story. People who do heinous acts even when caught, love to tell half truths to make them look better.
100% Agree! He knew exactly what he was doing. Obviously, he had issues and should have gone to a psychiatrist, but for some reason, families don't like to seek help for their mentally unstable kids, they just ignore it until it's too late.🙄
I disagree. 40 years is too much. He was very cooperative. In the USA the sentences are more severe than in most countries, but it doesn't make the country safer.
Everyone is trying to find rational explanations, but I think the guy is honest and just has a twisted mind. He just really believed that was the solution.
Sometimes rationality just does not apply to some. Sometimes they are so convinced in the mission they are set in what they feel is justified. Does it justify the action? Most of the time no. No it does not. This is one case where it isn't. Guy was detached from reality and had a mission in mind and fully thought it out.
i think so too, maybe he was wrong about the family member abusing his sister but maybe he made himself believe it was true to justify his action, who knows
this is exactly what i think aswell, i started getting frustrated that the interrogators kept thinking he wasn’t truthful. i mean i get why they thought that but i really felt like he told them the whole truth and they just weren’t hearing him
@@wkwrd9667 I understand their rationale. But one thing I would imagine would be covered in training is always take into consideration someone may be genuinely crazy by the standards of the normal.
This was so... bizarre. It's weird to see someone so open about this. I believe that he truly thinks he was "protecting" her, and his parents supposedly laughing in his face for his concerns about Sabrina being abused is disturbing, but something is seriously wrong with him for going after her and not the alleged abuser.
@@HoneyPott11 He mentioned multiple times that it was his other 14 year old (step?) brother, but he didn't go after him because the brother was supposedly much bigger than him and he didn't get his gun. A *seriously cowardly excuse.
I'd bet all my money that there is no way anyone (except for himself maybe) ever abused his sister. If anyone did then why would he not just call the police?
Sitting there, covered in his little sister’s blood, describing how she asked why as he inflected a painful death upon her… this one hurts to listen to even as a random stranger. How his family must feel watching this and realising that their own son did something so horrible is impossible to understand. It must have felt like a surreal nightmare. How heartbreaking 😢
I couldn’t imagine having somebody you fully trust like a sibling doing something like that to you. Horrific and tragic even more so given her age, poor girl.
Its the most sad when it comes from your own family. I have reasons to believe that this is not normal, there are chemicals and other factors that are messing with people this day.
@@infinitesimotel you are absolutely correct about that please take some solace and do rest in the knowledge that what's done in the dark will be brought to the light
When Keith said that his brother said “What did you do to my baby” that was also rlly sad. Just by that line you can tell the 16yr old adored his baby sister and probably feels horrible for letting Keith watch her💔
@@drats1279 wow, that a pretty low blow. That's the type of choice words applied for your own pleasure; its just the thing someone with the mindset of "I'm superior because I have certain values would say" to a horribly depressed person leading them to their suicide, just to only try to justify it. Hitler had a superiority type of mindset, and he used it to justify the deaths of millions. Hitler didn't make a mistake, he murdered and tried to justify it. This person made a mistake, the consequences he was unaware of, and certainly didn't try to justify it, if anything someone else tried to explain it wasn't his fault. And then there are those that want the innocent to hurt, like Hitler
@@drats1279 I feel bad for you for that you get off on saying such stupid things. Normally when people get off on seeing complete strangers suffer, they themselves have some depressing shit going on in their lives. Hopefully it gets better but with that attitude, life’s only going to get worse 👎
These investigators do some serious work. How you talk to these people and see these crime scenes by day and go back to your family by night without losing your mind is incredible. They're such strong people.
They do lose their mind. Many develop sybstance abuse problems, depression, anger problems. I guarantee you if u talk to any investigator who regularly sees horrific stuff they will tell you it effects them immensely. Either that or they learn how to shut off their emotions, but that can result in built up hurt and huge outbursts. Not healthy
A distant relative of mine is a police officer and was tasked with investigating child p*rnography for 2.5 years. His task was to scan confiscated computers/servers and review online footage to find out whether there was indeed a case of CP. He had to look at that disturbing stuff all day! It was department policy that any one officer was limited to three years maximum doing this task, he stopped after 2.5 years. I was a preteen during that time, just like his daughter and experienced him as very closed off person who always seemed busy in his home office during our visits (as if he was hiding from/avoiding us) while we were with the rest of the family in another room. It was almost like he wasn't there, I could barely describe what he looked like during that time. After he got a different task, he became an open, social person and took part in family visits as normal. Even though we only saw him a few times a year, it was very obvious how much better he was doing without this depressing job.
That’s because a lot of people are ignorant and you don’t know the horrible things that happen every second of every day. Once you accept that things like that are always happening it’s easier to cope with
@@liliumpthpumpernickle8462 for me it's exactly the opposite, knowing that a lot worse things are happening every second everywhere around us, makes it much worse to cope with for me. Especially since having experienced bad things in my own childhood, and now being the mother of a 8yo daughter makes it really really really hard
It’s pretty obvious that he was the abuser. Why didn’t the detectives ask how Keith “knew” that “it was getting worse and worse by the day” - “it” being the abuse supposedly perpetrated by someone else?
My heart goes out to the other brother who really loved his little sister. The fact that somebody could do something so gruesome to their OWN SISTER is terrifying. I hope their brother is able to find peace and happiness even after the horror he has experienced.
Just like all psychopaths who are caught he'll try his best to deflect responsibility, to rationalize the act. There's no remorse here at all. He's just very upset he was caught. I can only hope he's put down in prison.
@@Bootmahoy88 monkeylover12 was referring to the innocent other brother, not the murderer himself. Could you imagine how their brother feels about what his brother did to their sister?! More than enough to totally fck someone up for life!
I dunno, he said multiple times that the other brother was molesting his sister. It could be a lie, but it happens to so many young girls that it's not unlikely. Little girl was probably surrounded by people she shouldn't have been around.
@@nich1238 there are two other brothers. one upstairs playing video games and another 14 yo who was out at a dance with the mom and step-dad. sounds like that's the one he's alleging harmed the sister but was too big for him to overpower
@@sallymaa1234 That's your issue. You are basing other peoples thoughts off of your own. This may come as a shock but EVERYONE is different. You are welcome to think whatever you like. Its a bit absurd though to go around telling people your own opinion as if its a fact.
@@sallymaa1234 IT took me 2 and a half hours to decipher your comment...but you are spot on...BTW until the age of 21 or 22 the brains of kids arent fully develop t and most importantly he could suffer from any kind of syndrom...very severe case he lost his sister to and will be aware from this fact...
EDIT: please stop replying. It's not worth your time. He seems to genuinely believe Sabrina was being abused. That coupled with the lack of proof, I wondered throughout this if he's experiencing a delusion. I don't really see signs of being a psychopath, I do however see potential signs of schizophrenia or a related disorder. Whatever the case, I hope he's helped while locked up. Rest in peace, Sabrina. Poor angel
Could also be the schizoid personality disorder - as him having "some" sort of PD was mentioned at 49:50. The guy is not delusional, this is just an example of how schizoids may reason, rationalize and justify.
@@para-mentischannelbypiggsy4240 his explanation regarding the abuser was mentioned. The logic might appear twisted, and it is. But it's true from his perspective, that's the whole point. What exactly is he lying about?
Yes this comes to the mind. He was frustrated because he could not buy a gun and so wanted to punish his mother. But maybe is he just plain nuts. Too much Metal music and an attraction for gore.
I hope his brother is okay. When he said “he was watching her, so I told him I would watch her” then his brother went to his room and he took his sister to the basement and murdered her. Then when the police came and he figured out what was happening he looked at his brother and said “what did you do to my baby” his heart probably shattered into a million pieces. I can only imagine the guilt he feels.. I couldn’t imagine being a parent and coming home to this.
@@InIt4TheMemez unfortunately it can be hard to prove, especially if 1- the victim is only 4 which presents a few problems and 2- that victim now can't confirm it (if she did have memory of it, that is). Many abused that young either don't remember or repress the memories. In his mind he 'threw away his life' and accepted all consequences for the greater good. If he was able to get a gun he stated he would have killed the abuser but he would win a knife fight so only thing left was to end her life. To him it was rational and 'out of love'. I don't agree with what he did but to him it was logical.
@@AlishaField1609 or the murderer was also the person that sexually assaulted her and killed her so she couldn’t tell anyone what he was doing. Asking her if she wanted to paint and then her laying down right after seems very odd and like they’d done it before 💔 it’s all so heartbreaking
He's a piece of shit I don't get emotional easy but fuck me this was pulling at my heart. The amount of pain I would put on this murderer. I hope the prisoners make his life true hell.
@@nvnax in the situation they were in, there's fear, adrenaline anxiety and they're being cuffed with him clueless. Maybe he meant to say "what did you do to my baby sister?!" But forgot sister?
@@topaz123212 I don’t mean that the guy who committed seems to have a genuine believe that whoever his brother is did do something to the young girl idk it’s weird to me
I've recently been watching a lot of your videos and have felt guilty over my morbid curiosity as it's been all too easy to forget that these are all real people that had their own fears, hopes & dreams and are now gone. This has hit me in an entirely different way however and despite the phrase being overused I can't think of a more fitting one; this is truly sickening. His demeanor, casual indifference, his detachment & his calm tone of voice. That poor, poor little kid. She must have been so fucking scared, so confused and in so much pain. I think I'll have to make this the last one of these I watch for quite some time. It's shown me a truly dark side of humanity that I frankly always knew was there but honestly wasn't expecting to affect me this much. People are capable of despicable acts.. the holocaust, the Cambodian killing fields, millions more over who's God is best ffs. So much death and suffering. R.I.P little lady, you deserved so, so much better from this world & I know I didn't know you but I'd give anything to have been able to be there somehow to keep you safe.
Same here, this one brought me to tears. I can't imagine how she felt, her fear and confusion having someone she trusted and loved doing that to her. This will be the last one for awhile.
The holocaust, Cambodian killing fields, Mao's Red Guard, Lenin's Russia... those are all **ATHIEST** PERPETRATORS. In fact, the vast majority of modern atrocities are committed by those who REJECT Christianity. Study history. Think logically.
That little girl, that little girl! This is literally heart breaking! the death of a child just hits different, it's just unbelievable. It could've been any of us. Life is unpredictable
Because when they do an interrogation they want it done right away after a crime. Well everything is fresh in somebody's mind and they can recount every detail. But yes it's quite disturbing
Yeah I'm surprised they didnt take the clothes for evidence right away as well. They usually do in these situations, where a suspect/victim is covered in fluids/evidence.
Part way through this, one things for certain, I have all the sympathy in the world for his brother. That guy has to be living with every ounce of undeserved guilt in the world.
that was the first thing i thought of when keith described taking his sister from his brother to the basement. as an older sibling myself, i hold so much guilt over things that happened with my siblings in the past even though i couldnt have changed it. at least my siblings are alive and happy now. his brother will never be able to see his sister again. what an absolute nightmare. i couldnt even imagine the devastation i would feel if i lost one of my siblings. i feel so sick to my stomach listening to this case. may they find peace in life.
I man he was supposed to be the one watching her. It was her responsibility and i still don’t understand how he supposedly didn’t hear any of the things going on...
@@datpsychobytch it looked like a three story house... he was upstairs and they were down a full floor in between, and he likely had at least the TV volume on if not a headset...
@@Punicia Guess that's very primitive emotion, makes me think of how all those chimps attacked that guy in California bcuz they were enraged with jealousy!
I actually believe he truly thought he was protecting her in his mind. The "4 minutes of pain" line really sealed that for me. Some people just don't see death as a bad thing and it seems he's one of those people. He thought he was freeing her from a lifetime of abuse with "4 minutes of pain." He could be in a state of paranoid psychosis. I have first hand experience with that and it will make you do/say some crazy shit that you somehow find a way to really believe with your whole soul.
Same. The cops where sort of annoying me trying to ask questions he answered the same and without hesitation. He clearly believed what he was doing was what he needed to do. He said it 100 times, he explained and was honest from the beginning. What sealed it for me was when he said “I’m not trying to hide anything, I called the police, I trust you, I didn’t change my clothes or anything”
@@SlayWithAnais While i do agree that ithink he belived he acually protected her: The real question is, was it the disorder that made him do it, or the music lyrics he was listening to or both. He was a loner & had a disorder, on top of that listen to stuff that subconsciosly most likely affected him. He also played video games. Personally iknow thers tons of horror and violent games out there. Hes reading Steven King books? Its not strange this affects someone with special types of disorders. This is coming from someone with Aspergers Syndrome himself (Autism).
I'm glad to see someone else felt this way. I assume it's like postpartum depression. Or my dad, who is schizophrenic, said to my mother "I love you Virginia, I'm sorry, but I have to kill you" he was trying to protect her from misery. Messed up. But yeah. I agree with you. To label these people as monsters, evil does us no good.
Very possible. I've seen other cases where killing someone is rationalized by "saving" them from a life of abuse, pain, etc. Often a parent being the murderer too. And due to how candid Keith was being, it's likely his thought process is true to him, regardless of how abnormal "society" may believe it to be. Why would you want to understand or rationalize like someone with a personality disorder anyway? It's a good thing to KNOW that you don't lack the moral compass, at least that's my thoughts.
As a younger sister to 2 older brothers, let me tell you that there is NOTHING wrong with older brothers calling their younger sisters their baby - they essentially help raise you and is a constant presence when both your folks are working or if one parent is doing the job for two. Something else is deffo wrong here and it's just a sad story all around.
I would assume calling a sibling "baby" is not appropriate in all household. In my family, it would be creepy if my brothers called me that. There are boundaries to be upheld in household, for example, calling your parents by their first names, in some household that is common, but it is rare. Just creepy.
@@JanSparkles1 While I understand what you are saying, you fail to understand my comment. Thinking about the usage of the word baby in all its connotations rather than its dictionary definition is what is creepy. And that is your problem. Edit: This response is in the context of my reply. Don't go assuming it's applicable to all households and families, like you have done.
@@JanSparkles1 but shes four ? i called my really young siblings or even my nieces my baby .. shes so young its not really weird . its not weird until they grow older and more mature and just like kids no longer call their parents mommy or daddy and parent stop kissing their younger children on the lips ...(which i wont lie sounds weird LOL) people stop calling their younger siblings baby . Although i had an older brother in law (over 25 years older than me) and he practically raised me (along with my sister) but he would call me baby girl or endearing terms ? i dont mind , but i understand how it can be seen as weird .
Bro i cant believe people think this is inappropriate. Literally she was so young and he was much much older compared to her, calling her baby would only mean he acted as a second parent to her. Whats with people's mind these days that it was so wrong for a big brother to call his 4 yo little sister a baby?
As someone with a little sister and a similar age gap, this hurts so much to watch. My world would end if something like that happened to her. My prayers go out to the family
For me same, also i just felt so horrible when he said the brother said "What did you do to my baby?" my heart sunk just putting myself in the brothers position i couldn't imagine hearing that about my little sister. My heart really does go out to the brother and Sabrina's family.
the same for me the part where he talks about what she said when he was stabing here was too much for me i started to fr cry i don't have that big of a age gap im 9 shes 12 years old i just fell like it's so sureal i can't really even think of something like this without sherading a tear
My sister once pulled a knife from our kitchen because she came home and heard me screaming upstairs and was willing to protect me with her life. Luckily I was having a panic attack and not being attacked. I feel horrible for her to have to mentally prepare for that and how scared she looked when she came up. the idea of a sibling wielding a knife to harm their sibling rather than protect them is horrible and unthinkable. Edit: People in the comments don't believe that this really happened, but just because there weren't signs of forced entry doesn't mean that this didn't happen. People you let into your house, friends or family or neighbors can attack you. She later said she thought it was my bf at the time hurting me. She was very relieved i was fine and she didn't tell me about grabbing the knife until the next day, she put it away once she saw i was okay so I wouldn't get scared. If you've had dissociation you would understand the screaming. I just posted what was on my mind, a memory about how love between siblings really looks and how amazing my sister is, and now I'm being accused of lying for attention. Fun!
I don’t even…know what to think of this. I want to say he’s “evil,” but he seems like he legitimately thought he was helping her. This strikes me as very, VERY severe and untreated mental illness. What an absolute tragedy all around.
You're right it is mental illness but this could easily all be a cover up as an excuse to just act on his impulses of wanting to murder someone and unfortunately the target for whatever true reason was the child. In his head I think he is in denial with a major guilty conscious of what he has just done and why, so he tries to believe this Narrative that he was "helping" her.
I don’t have kids of my own at 37, but my nieces are my life. And listening to what the 4 year’s old wanted to do, and what she got in return is truly heartbreaking. I keep questioning my brother & his wife if they kids been fed if I hear a little cry or agitation, and hear I’m listening to a 4 year olds last words to her brother is something I can’t take. And had to have a throw up break before continuing to listen further. And here he is sitting confessing to the murder! No matter how bad the situation, I can never imagine someone taking life of a child. 😢
@Ublimt Fip I agree wholely. I’m just saying that I believe that’s who it was. He also said something about the individual being bigger than him and taller than him and stronger than him. I believe that’s what he wanted the firearm for. Since that was removed from the equation, he knew he would never overpower his brother in a physical confrontation with a knife. He said if he had gotten the firearm, they would be there over a 14 year old, not a 4 year old. I’m in no way validating his thinking but that’s what he’s trying to get across. When he wasn’t allowed to babysit and the person he suspected was abusing her was, I think that set the trigger off that he had to get her away from him somehow. Why murder her and not try to run away with her to keep her away from the brother, I have no idea. That’s where his thinking is broken. I think the brother calling her “my baby” is extremely disconcerting. I don’t know any teenage boy that would say that about a sibling. It conjures up feelings of a special relationship he thought he had with her, that he felt she was his possession. He may have been right about the abuse in my opinion but, of the many ways he could’ve tried to stop it and help her, he chose the absolute worst option when there were so many other healthy avenues to take.
I also think he genuinely believes what he did was noble. And he thinks he did it to help her, but in reality, it’s like he wants to be a martyr. That’s why at the beginning he was talking about how he WAS going to graduate and he WAS going to have a good life. He’s not thinking about what’s best for Sabrina, he’s thinking that he made this sacrifice knowing he’d go to jail because he did something heroic in stopping the alleged abuse. It’s all a massive narcissist hero complex. He doesn’t really care that he sacrificed her life and her graduation and her future. That’s not important to him, his sacrifice of his own future to “save” her is his top priority.
Many here seems to believe he was the abuser, but him not understanding what the detectives were implying at first contradicts that. The way he acted through the whole thing makes me believe his version is 100% internally consistent to him. That makes him more dangerous if anything.
Ironically, sometimes this behavior evolves over time when there is severe abuse at a very young age. The reaction can often be very violent especially as the memories of previous abuse or trauma come to the surface. Justification for such events, when they come to the conscious mind, the forefront of memory, can be gruesome and without explanation. Even predators often don't understand when their victims become reactive. This is all so tragic and seemingly senseless. But it isn't.
@@aday1637 just what do you mean, it isn't tragic and senseless??? I read your comment and just because his actions may have manifest in his mind at some point, how can you say that this monsterous murder is not senseless and tragic?! WTF!!
I think it's more complicated than that. He came up with that story so that he wouldn't have to explain the real motive. He may have abused his sister, but I doubt it. This was a crime of passion, maybe he was jealous, got angry with her because she loved both her brothers, not just him.
@@tallcool1jeff If you actually read the comment, it said “This is so tragic and *seemingly* senseless. but IT ISNT.” Which means it’s tragic, and it SEEMS senseless, but it isnt senseless.
*His alter ego was the “assaulter/abuser”,* which he wasn’t able to process or rationalise the way a normal individual would’ve. In his mind, killing her was the only solution to this constant subconscious conflict between a loving/caring/moral brother and the assaulter/abuser brother. His statement to the effect of, “I hope I don’t have to repeat my statement in the court” and his mother’s statement that, “the only person he seems to be close to was his sister”, sums it up for me. He considered being known as the murderer (who sved his sister from this imaginary assaulter by killing her) is more moral than being known as a child abuser. Please Note: I’m NOT trying to justify his actions in any way, to the contrary for such crimes I take a much radical stand of NOT considering any psychological disorder/insanity even if it’s said to be present!
as someone with 2 brothers who always wanted a sister this just breaks my heart. you were the one person that was supposed to protect her no matter what...
C is a good grade. I got D for daydreaming, lol His speech may be disorganised because of the chaotic lifestyle. He is in a broken family and is sat with his sisters blood all over him. If he was more organised and not disorganised, the crime may never have happened or he might have gotten away with murder. I got the D for daydreaming in religious education lol I got an A in English.
Keith was the one abusing her so he felt he had to kill her before she told on him. It's so obvious. He said he kissed her neck after she died!? Is he expecting police to find his dna/saliva on her neck? That's suspect af esp given he stabbed her in the same area. People seem to be unaware of juvenilrle abusers/offenders. It's not uncommon but no one ever talks about it. I was a victim of two completely unrelated young men as a child and many inappropriate behaviours from brothers of school-friends. I can't be the only one.
@@ellaova It’s actually not so obvious. As explained in the video he really thought killing her would save her from pain. It’s referred to as mercy killing. In some instances when the dominant spouse in a relationship has been abusing their kids it’s rare but not completely unheard of for the other spouse to murder their kids to keep them from being abused anymore. In their mind it’s more humane than making them suffer through more attacks. Sure you’re not the only one. But that doesn’t mean you can just flat out say this guy was abusing his sister.
@Mortanius Langston such ignorant words. God created everything. An infinite universe full of infinite destruction. Since he created everything that means he created good… and evil. Because of the mistakes of 2 idiots who listened to a serpent innocent children suffer and die. You’re free to worship him just don’t pretend god didn’t know everything was gonna happen the way it did.
Even if his 4-year-old sister was being abused by another family member (it seems his then 14 and 16-year-old brothers were the only others left for his parents to “do nothing about”)- murdering her is one of the few things that is actually worse. His brain was broken. At 34:30 he says he suspected his 14-year-old brother.
Fr!! There were so many other things that would be SO much better than what he did. And while she was fucking AWAKE. It is so hard to understand how someone could do this
I have watched a lot of true crime over the years but this has to be one of the worst ones to listen to the recount of. It is hard to imagine a 4 year old girl having to go through what she did. Whether you believe he's telling the truth or lying it doesn't matter. This little girl did not deserve anything that happened to her.
Agreed, ive only ever seen one worse than this. Took place up in Canada. Man and women in their late 20's scouted a school, found a girl that was around 5 kidnapped her, raped her multiple times, then brutally murdered her with a hammer. The level of fear the girl must have gone through haunts me. The interviewer was excellent but the guy he was interviewing was silent as a mouse hardly said anything the entire time. A lawmen in the old west (I want to say Bill Hickok) claimed some men were like rabid animals and the only thing you can do with them is put them down. Of course I'm paraphrasing but unfortunately I think it's an accurate statement.
@@ledfloyd9035 Yea I have seen that one as well. If I remember right he was whining about wanting a blanket and attempting to elicit some type of sympathy when he himself showed none to the little girl he killed. I understand as that as animals we will never have a world with no more killing but of course that definitely does not excuse it. Though like you said some people just need to be culled from the herd and removed from society for their heinous actions against the most vulnerable of us.
@@curtisvenom32 Yea, I do believe he believes he is right based on his warped view of what may or may not even be happening. He clearly needs help and sadly he did not get it before he did what he did. I feel for the family because they lost 2 kids that day.
@@i2evielle Survival of the fittest, people... Its how we always lived... Who's to say killings wrong?? The courts?? Governments?? You?? I could attempt to kill you right now were you standing next to me alone in my house. If you succeed in killing me, well,I would have no hard feelings since I was the weaker one and natural selection chose you and you shouldn't have any hard feelings either if I were to succeed in killing you, nor should your parents or relatives or anyone... Sad everyone understands evolution but wont accept it.
I can’t even imagine trying to interrogate him knowing he killed his 4 year old little sister. He’s sitting there with her blood all over him she was a helpless baby and he seemingly did this because he’s mom told him he couldn’t buy a gun. None of this makes sense.
No, I'm pretty sure he wanted to buy the gun to kill his sister without any pain, and as he realised that he wouldn't be able to use a gun he used the next best thing that came to his mind: a knife. The plan to kill her to protect her (How weird that may sound) was already there way before his mother denied him the gun.
It doesn’t make sense to a lot of people , He wasn’t “Mad” at the fact that He didn’t get the Gun or Wasn’t allowed . He was Going to do that With the Gun or Without the Gun would’ve just made it Easier He had this feeling within himself that he was doing something Good something Right
He's a child who's never aged mentally but matured slightly academically, but with no sense of the very superficial, but still existent and usually self evident, post- adolescent wisdom gained after puberty tapers off. Sad for all involved. Sorry Sabrina, I hope you are at peace.
Obviously what he did was disgusting. But I do think that in his mind it made sense to him. From an outside perspective it seems inconceivable that anyone would believe that murdering his sister would help her. I think he felt he was backed into a corner with no other way to get her out of a situation where she's being molested on a regular basis, with whoever was assaulting her bigger and stronger than him. Nobody seemed to believe him when he tried to get her help in different ways. His original idea was to purchase a weapon so he could protect her from her abuser. When he wasn't able to do that he thought that killing her was the only way to free her from the torment. This flawed way of thinking unfortunately cost the life of a sweet little girl. He is the one responsible for her death, he knows this and I truly feel like he feels remorse and regret, but maybe if he were listened to and taken seriously when he brought forth the concern that she was being molested that he wouldn't have felt like this was necessary to take such drastic measures. He made the wrong choices and he and his family will have to live with that for the rest of their lives, may that little girl rest in peace. Sexual assault must be taken seriously. Mental illness must be taken seriously. This kind of thing doesn't happen out of the blue, there are always signs. We need to get better at recognizing those signs and getting these people help. These tragedies don't have to keep happening. I always hear "you'd never know this kid would be a murderer, he was always so nice!" People don't just become murderers and violent criminals. There are always red flags and warnings and they are just missed because nobody really knows what to look for. With better understanding of mental illness and better recourses to help the mentally ill I feel as though the number of these types of incidents would decrease.
At 34:30 onward we're given a clear hint at the alleged molester's age. Aside from that, I agree with what you're saying. He is definately not a person showing obvious signs of psychopathy. Quite the contrary. However there are some obvious flaws in his reasoning, that sadly ended in tragedy. It seems to me though, that from his point of view, he found himself in a situation where he had to choose between the lesser of two evils. Within his frame of reference, he only wanted to do good, however flawed it was.
@@epic5895 I don’t really know either but the important thing to note is he kept on saying he didn’t want to kill her and had no ill feelings towards her meaning that he could’ve felt that was the only way to help her but what he didn’t realize is that he would spend a lot of time repenting for his actions because he was nervous and he really had no other logical explanation as to why he killed her, personality disorder is strong in this one but he is not malicious
Exactly people like him are often misunderstood because they are disgusting by what he did but if they could have just been a bit more empathetic towards him they could’ve dealt with this situation quicker, he is clearly mentally ill with a few bad personality traits he didn’t do this because he wanted pleasure or control by intimidating his family, he did it because he was in pain seeing what that brute did to his sister and was probably too scared to tell the authorities about that person since he is reportedly a lot stronger than he is, it’s really tragic when you think about it enough
I have watched so many of these, I didn't think they could affect me. But when he described the moments when she was talking to him I had to gain a massive amount of respect for the ability of these officers to keep their composure and professionalism. Made me sick to my stomach.
@bigchimptactical it's hard to listen to it now. Knowing I have the option to click away. Unfortunately, these poor officers have to endure all of this. Makes me sick.
It scares me to think of all the things law enforcement and emergency service personnel have to go through and hear on a daily basis. They deserve so much respect for having enough composure to do what most of us couldn't. I wouldnt be able to do it. Took me multiple times to watch this the whole way through. Had to click off as it got to be too much for me. It's just horrific and heartbreaking
Maybe they did ask and you just cut it, but I was surprised not to hear the detectives inquire more about the sexual abuse claims. The detective on the right seemed incredibly uncomfortable and neither detective seemed to want to believe Keith because of how eerily calm and honest he was. Lidke you said, they seemed to want to find a motive that made more sense to them, but it wasn't a crime committed by a sane person. It doesn't have to make sense or be right to us, but it was what made sense to Keith.
they can't really use his statement as any kind of criminal report, he was obviously wrong in the head, you can't investigate if there is no probable cause
They possibly did but because they have no proof of the claims sometimes it better to just leave it out rather than include it and start theories or rumors when there's no proof of it being true/relevant. Just my thoughts on it anyway
@@MAGACUNTREEEEEEE I’m thinking the same thing. I think he abused her, being a half sister he sickly justified it, then realized she was old enough to tell her parents and he killed her to cover it up
Hearing his brother say "what did you do to my sister?" hit real deep for me. The pain and frustration his brother must have felt after would be painful for anyone to deal with. He must of felt guilt to not be able to protect his little sister as well as anger at his brother for what he did. Emotions most wont ever experience and for good reason.
Its also weird to phrase it like that since she is the sister to both of them. So he should have said What did you do to Sabrina. Phrasing it like that makes it seem like he didnt consider him a sibling to both of them.
@@teongreen5254it’s not weird. You fail to put yourself in the mindset of someone whose sister was just murdered. In that moment, nothing and no one else exists except you and her.
@@teongreen5254at the point where he realized his brother killed her he no longer considered him family. Hence saying “my sister” instead of our sister. Keith was dead to him at that point
Exactly. His brother was playing video games . He saves his life yet targets his little sister 😔 what could she possibly have done to him . Nothing . Both of their lives should’ve been spared .
I’m 18 and I’ve got a younger sister who is 7 and I’d die for her if I had to. She’s one of the few people in my life who genuinely seems to love me. I couldn’t imagine ever hurting her.
I can't imagine how mentally damaging it was for the police officers, brother & paramedics to see such a horrific crime scene. That poor innocent little girl. My heart breaks for all involved. This kid obviously had some kind of psychotic break to do what he did. It's sickening & disturbing what humans are capable of😢
They ARE mentally damaged. Look at the Abuse implications, Keth even didnt understand. I dont know what got him to do that, but in this interrogation hes way more symphathic than these psycho"cops", whos jobs is lieing and manipulate people. Even we EWU guys are mentally not very healthy to look this for entertainment.
It is sad but far from uncommon =( I dont even know what to say. I hope he was lying but he really seemed to believe his own story. Perhaps that little girl was suffering already. Dark family secrets are pretty common as well. But to use that as justification to kill the one who is suffering.... "He is much bigger and stronger than me" does not hold water when the weak party has the element of surprise and a weapon at hand... This case does not make any sense... Senseless violence wherever you look, so damn tiresome...
watching this, I realize that I couldn’t do this job. staying this calm, comforting him, asking the right questions … you really need nerves to be able to do that.
I think about that sometimes... How hard it must be to even be the arresting officer in cases like this or where they finally catch a sadistic serial killer or serial Г@pist... I'd have never been able to do that job
I used to work for the probation service. I know the feeling of having to distance yourself. You imagine that its like watching a film, not real life. Its the only way you can do it.
Compartmentalizing helps a lot, there was an incident where i tried convincing a belligerent drunk driver that i was not going to let him through to a overly populated area, i was waiting for the police to arrive to apprehend him, he began ramming the gate then proceeded to speed off, when i found him later on location his body had combined with the passenger side window as he wasn't wearing a seatbelt the vehicle had torn him in half and the top of his scalp, popped open and his cerebral fluid was leaking from his nose. I remember seeing his wallet, cellphone and keys laid perfectly in a row next to his corpse. And i remember going around his vehicle and just remembering his tires had real good tread. I turned in my report to my supervisor and the veteran on duty told me "next time let em out, wouldn't have to fill any paperwork out.." ... Years later and multiple engagements in South Dallas survived. I still remember the smell and think about the treads on the tire.
I don't understand how the parents were not more aware of his behaviour and personality. Him telling his parents that someone was trying to hurt his sister should have been a massive red flag and taken seriously. A good parent would question who, and they would have great concern if their child was making it up.
Plus, he told them he wanted a weapon to shoot the alleged abuser? What did the parents do about it? I think there's definitely something off about them
@@henrygallas8645 did he say he told them he wanted a gun to shoot the person he was accusing? I didn’t catch that. I thought he said he just wanted to by a firearm and his mother said no. I don’t know. My take away is there’s something off with him.
As the father of a 4 year old I cannot even imagine. I can't even describe what I feel when I hear this and it's not even my child. It hurts my soul and I don't even think we have a soul but it's still in pain
It took me about 5 minutes into the interrogation to realize that was blood. I couldn't believe they left the pants on him. With that much blood they would usually make him change before interviewing him. This whole thing is completely mind boggling and so sad 😔
I had a neighbor who thought a young relative was molesting her granddaughter. Every time she gave that little girl a bath she’d lay her on the floor and splay her open & ask people if it looked like the 2 yr-old had been violated. I wanted to tell her what she was doing was a violation to the little girl.
"You okay?" "Yeah" "How you doin?" "I'm fine" "You hangin in there?" "Yeah, I'm fine" I don't think any of us could imagine saying that after killing someone. Even after confessing to the crime and complying there's no way a sane and good person could be fine. Truly fascinating in the worst way possible.
I think this kid was the abuser. He seems like he was very excited about watching her. The mother didn’t want him to babysit her anymore. There’s a reason and he’s not saying that part. He was protecting her….from himself.
Tbh I don't see the smirk as strange. Some things are just so unbelievable someone could think / believe you did something you just smirk/laugh it off just because it's so stupid in your head you simply can't believe it no ? I mean I think so at least, i'd even say I act so too x/
“Why are you killing me?” I actually just all feeling in my body and my heart just dropped. To think of that poor little kid in such pain and confusion in that moment just genuinely broke me.
This may be the only case I have ever listened to that has genuinely made me nauseous, its such a conflicting stance to know that he may have actually thought he was helping her escape the abuse while also knowing that he inflicted something much worse onto her. There is definitely a mental issue at play here, and I only hope that the other brother finds some peace though all this because that is some devastating trama.
Too me it is important to know if that was truly the reason he did it, because if it's true what he says then the steps going forward should be more than just locking him away. It should be future prevention, making children aware that if someone is in a situation he claimed his sister was in that there's help, another way out.
@@jadegrenade8287 i agree 100% People don't understand psychology and most people will claim mental health this bad just deserves to be put out of its misery. Thats sad because people are not born evil. Something is always the cause that makes someone lose their ability to rationally look at a situation and know its wrong. In this case, he knew that through whatever television and movies teenaged kids usually watch that slitting the throat is "supposed" to be quick and painless. But he did not premeditate. He did not look up how to actually do this, and when he realized how difficult it was he did get scated. You could tell in his response he felt remorse and he openly admits what he did was wrong and even though he had good intentions he realized (sadly too late) that he did inflict much pain on his sister. One thing I noticed, the officers where trying to find a rational reason for what he did. Which makes about as much sense as him doing this in the first place. He was not rational. And they tried to say her shirt was pulled up to the neck, which may mean he had sexual desires. But anyone with a lick of common sense could tell he covered her neck because he was truly ashamed at what he had done. It was not quick and painless. She screamed and she cried. And at that point he lost all his senses and just tried to get it over with. He had no idea what he was doing. And you are right that since he got a regular prison sentence, he will not recieve any type of therapy. He may go on to injure someone else, or himself in prison. And even if he does not, he will be released in his 50s. Which means he is perfectly capable of doing this sort of thing again. Not all psychopaths are manipulative murderers. People live with this mental illness are live relatively normal lives with lots of therapy and occasionally medications (however, more often that not its the opposite,in which case the medications are only subduing their impulses and they are not learning how to deal with the real world such as they would be in actual therapy)
honestly its kinda driving me insane you even for a second believe his lie, if anyone was sexual abusing his sister it was likely him. He's saw her as an easy target for a first murderer and by the time it was done realized he was in over his head. There is a REASON his mom did not allow him to watch his sister.
@bonnyismydoggy6426 If you read some of the other comments, you may begin to see how a teen, who doesn't have a fully developed brain & lacks the ability to fully think thru a horrifying, emotionally complex situation, could make this bad choice when he felt backed into a corner. To some, sexual abuse & rape, especially of a child & particularly sexual abuse that is ongoing, and "torment" as he calls it, is WORSE than the decision to take the person's life.
@@FreedomAndJustice4All No, vast majority of people possess this thing called empathy all kids except antisocial kids possess it, what you are describing is a psychopathic behavior, and brain develops until the age of 25 - 30 should we permit crimes until the age of 30 on the account of underdeveloped brain? We should probably modify consent laws to the age of 30 as well after all pleasure centers of the brain don't develop until the age of 22.
@@FreedomAndJustice4All if that was the case you’d see more of these types of f’d up things between family members. 99.999% of teenagers know the difference between right and wrong
I can't imagine what her parents would think if they heard this. Your own son whom you love killing your daughter who you love. So tragic, so much emotional pain.
I'm sure the parents have seen/ heard this interrogation. His mother likely will be in his corner no matter what, regardless of what he did. She already lost her daughter, probably looks at it like she doesn't wanna lose a son as well (as messed up as that seems). The father, however probably hates him with a passion, seeing as though he killed his daughter. I'm referring to HER father btw, not his.
they love to slap random diagnoses onto every suspect without them actually fitting the diagnosis. they probably think it makes them sound more professional, but to anyone who knows about abnormal psychology knows they're just using pop psychology definitions that aren't based in fact but rather misinformation based in decades old ableism.
@malachiholder351 your comment is just proof that this channel is just based in 1950s pop psychology, ableism, and copaganda. That kind of opinion is the reason why institutionalization is going up every year. People with mental illnesses deserve rights and respect. Viewing a criminal case through the lens of "this is what mental illness looks like" is just inaccurate since the vast majority of people with mental illnesses don't commit crimes, It leads to mental illness being seen as so bad it needs to be locked away forever instead of treated with compassion, which in turn leads to people such as victims of abuse or people who live non-standard lifestyles to be institutionalized, and sometimes chemically labotomized like in the case of Amanda Bynes
I have a form of psychopathy/ASPD from a frontal lobe traumatic brain injury I sustained as a child. I have worked very hard in therapy for over 15 years now because my parents recognized there was something not right after my accident (cracked my skull open when I was 4 years old) through therapy I can intellectually understand empathy and have respect for right and wrong. It’s very hard for me to form deep connections with people and most of my emotions aren’t very deep or lasting in any way. I had issues with the law because I did have a drug issue for a number of years but I was just trying to feel something more than nothing all the time. If you know anyone you may think is having a hard time therapy can help(even in extreme situations like mine) I’m just glad my parents recognized the signs.
Yeah bro be careful. Your more likely to do something crazy... be careful. Study Jesus and his Gospel. Youll understand how demons whisper things in your ear.. keith listened to the voices... your not crazy brother. Fight the good fight
@@jonnhyappleseed7498 I’m not schizophrenic I’ve never heard voices. I would know any signs of a psychotic episode I’ve had one. And as far as religion goes I don’t believe in a god or demons. No worries I’m quite self aware.
Take care man. I was gonna suggest you to access your spiritual side or try to get in touch with Jesus. But since you mentioned in the previous comment that you're not spiritual, I will just say take care man. I'll pray for you. I'm in therapy for depression. I understand how hard these things can be. So hold on man, we're rooting for you. I'm sure you're meant for great things in life.
as a father of a 5 and 1 year old little girls hearing how she smiled at him so innocently and then he proceeded to killing her it damn near unbearable...
I've watched many interrogations but this one was probably the hardest one to watch. Little precious girl being murdered while trusting his brother and dying in shock asking why is he killing her. I shed a few tears there. That is just too much for me. My niece is 4yo and i just cannot imagine how on earth he could herm her. I would protect my niece with my own life if needed.
You cannot imagine it because your brain has a fundamental sense of reality, conscience, etc that 99.9999% of all humans have. But there is a tiny chance that something goes catastrophically wrong in the brain, through nature or nurture (or both) which makes some people see a completely different version of reality and commit unimaginable acts. Keith's brain seems to flip randomly between having a conscience, feeling guilt, feeling remorse, but still justifying murdering a 4 year old and describing it in gruesome detail (while still believing he loves her). Whatever mental condition this is, I highly doubt any amount of time in prison will fix it. It seems to be some kind of bizarre mix delusional disorder, paranoid schizophrenia, psychopathy, sociopathy, etc. A pure psychopath doesn't feel any remorse or guilt, but Keith clearly does feel these things to some degree. It is impossible for normal people to imagine doing such acts or even relate to them, because this isn't a normal functioning brain.
This one really hit home for me , and I’ve watched dozens of EWU videos .. given I have a 4 yr old daughter right now I can’t even begin to fathom someone hurting her. She’s the sweetest most innocent little soul u can imagine as are most 4 yr old little girls. I can’t understand how her own older brother could do this. The one person who is supposed to protect her no matter what.
Same here, I thought I could handle watching, but my stomach says otherwise. It's too painful to handle. He's pure evil and acting he cares and loves her. My baby boy is the same age 4yrs. I think watching this can traumatise us.
I have a beautiful smart as can be purest soul of a baby girl also 4 and my brain won't even let me think about her being hurt.. this fact alone should convince everyone in pure evil and should really motivate everyone to always be aware of your babies and protect them as much as humanly possible until they can protect themselves.. no little girl should have to endure something like this. I pray she found eternal peace and love quickly and has no memory of this disgusting fungus of a human
Two minutes into this and had the most awful chill throughout my body - 4 years old. Lying in a pool of blood , ‘multi coloured sweater and pink shoes and socks’ Honestly feel sick already. As a father to a little girl turning 3 tomorrow , this just breaks my heart. Good rest her soul 🙏
I had to skip through him explaining the details. I could never imagine my little girls hurting or suffering from anything, let alone something so sinister.
There are many cases where a child grows up with being abused, but instead of them realizing it’s abuse, they think it’s normal because it starts at such a young age. I believe he was abusing her, she was 4. She didn’t understand it was abuse. He made sure to tell them she was beautiful and he loved her. She was his best friend. They were very close. People are saying it’s about the gun but I don’t think you’re looking at the bigger picture. He was abusing her, and his parents didn’t listen. He couldn’t admit it out loud. I think he did want the gun, maybe to end himself instead. When he couldn’t get the gun, he decided to go with a knife and maybe couldn’t do it himself. So he decides to kill his victim to end his urges.
Yeah that’s exactly what I was thinking. It was also his half sister so it makes even more sense to me. I don’t think a person who finds out his little sister is getting abused , first instinct would be to go tell their parents but rather hurt whom they ever did it.
Yeah, but he wasn't worried that an autopsy might show something if she was being sexually abused (by him). He didn't seem like he was too worried about it. I totally get what you're saying though. I thought of that too. Very Very weird case, right? I don't know if I've ever seen a case like this, and I watch all kinds of Crime Drama shows. It just has a crazy vibe!! It's not just the case...it's HIM that is creepy because of his nonchalance attitude.
After watching this, and reading that the coroner found ZERO evidence of sexual abuse, I feel like he was suffering from delusions. Possibly on the spectrum of schizophrenia, but certainly a form of psychosis. And it may have very well been from his own interest in her that created this delusion. I think it was unimaginable to him to abuse her in that way and when he couldn’t stop thinking about her like that, and being confused by a delusion that some other person was doing those things, he felt like he needed to get rid of the possibility of harming her. In his mind, 4 minutes of suffering was more humane than being sexually abused by her brother. He seemed too eager to plead guilt to be a psychopath.
This one made me question myself on why I watch these interviews. I was absolutely devastated after listening to him recount what she said to him during the attack. That poor innocent happy child that doesn’t even know what evil is yet just wanted to paint with her big brother.
It's to understand the Human Condition, the narrator constantly throws out "disorders" which I've studied in 1st yr psych, but there is so much more nuisance than that. Don't worry, when you study psych, most text prompt you not to start diagnosis yourself or others. buy a textbook if your interested, they are usually better than any yt vid.
When he said that the knife wasn't a weapon or anything, I don't think he said it because he was trying to distance himself from the crime. He meant that the knife wasn't the kind of knife that was specifically designed to be a weapon, the kind of knife that you buy in a store that sells weapons. He was saying that he didn't specifically want to kill her with a knife, and the knife was just his closest option considering that he wanted to do it quickly to "protect her".
The thing that baffles me in terms of how the detectives were attempting to see if they could find a new motive for Kieth, is that they didn't attempt to question him about the prior abuse of his sister from another family member (Specifically how she was abused/what parts of her body/approximately how often/etc). It would have been much easier to catch him in a potential lie there, which would open up other possibilities for his motive. It's insane to me that they didn't dive into those details and specifics. Not to mention, I know they keep blurring the other family member's name, but it almost sounds like it's his own brother who he's talking about... Even though he's extremely adamant in saying his brother is innocent. Doesn't make sense. Also, I think the fact that police found those lyrics rewritten is a major major red flag. I think someone else in this family is guilty of something very sinister as well.
I thought the same thing. I will have to watch the video again but I believe they had said the 14 year was out with the parents. If that is correct then there are three boys and one girl.I also remember him saying that the one that was abusing her couldn't have any sugar because of the way he gets and that her abuse had been going on for two years. And that he had told his parents about it. How or Why did the investigators over look this ??
I was wondering too why they didn't dive into that more after he said it several times, the only logical reason, in my mind, for them to not ask more about the abuse(r) is that they didn't believe him in the first place and looked at it more as a distraction from what he did or to justify it in some weird kinda way, idk.
Im also wondering why they didnt dive deeper. The one thing that made me think it was a family member is he said multiple times he told his parents what was going on that they told him "don't be a snitch." He seemed pretty open the whole interrogation so i don't see why he would pick that to lie about. Even if its not his brother it must be someone close to the family for the parents to brush it off like that.
I think it's likely TWO other brothers - a family of three boys and one girl. An interrogator used the word "brothers" at one point in the video. The one present was not the one Keith thought abused Sabrina. I think the other one was implied to have been out with their parents that night. If I had to wager...older/eldest brother of the family, maybe with drug problems.
One time I was hanging out with my brother and his brand new friend. My brother leaves the room and we are not doing anything just sitting there watching tv, his friends face turns angry and he starts punching me as hard as he can in the arm then acts like nothing happened. I forced him out of the house, I knew he was dangerous. I didn't stop telling him to leave until he was out. A few years later, he wrapped his car around a pole. The security video showed he took the turn at 45 miles per hour without braking. He had no concept of the forces he was in control of and paid with his life. I truly believe I dodged a huge bullet by never letting him come over ever again.
I have a 6 year old daughter, and this is hitting way too close. I have been very desensitized to murder stories, but a couple of them involving children always get to me more than the rest. This one is going to be another that sticks with me.
@@enricozemmourez6153 desensitized doesn't mean I don't still feel bad for adult victims, or feel nothing for them. Its just a very different reaction. Being a parent, the child victims are just more relatable to me.
@Dethtones man thanks for you honesty in your comment I 100% feel the exact same way... Ps .. we also DO care if adults die it just doesn't effect us the same way.. CA'peesh 👍🏾
if I'm lying then you must know more about the area and kids on the bus right? What color was the half pipe in grasmere park? Who was the fat kid that sat behind Keith with his older crazy meth head girlfriend that followed the bus route in a beat up red jeep everyday?Name of the mom and son owned gyro spot in the strip mall off LaGrange and Willow? When did they put up those condos on Lancaster? Color of our bus drivers hair? And what was the rumor going around school that turned out to be false as to why he killed his sister? I could go on all day mijo @@bullfighterrecords
@@bullfighterrecords yes, he did. I have no reason to lie. I could drop old landmarks in the area and things only someone who grew up there would know but it would go right over your smooth brain.
God I'm usually never affected by stuff like this. All the shit I've been through in life made me so jaded. But him saying his sister was smiling at him and then asked "Why are you killing me?" I got heart palpitations. I just can't understand doing that... especially if she was hurting and abused. I mean, if his story is true he was the one person she could trust in the world and he let her die completely alone, betrayed, and terrified. Didn't even stick around, just ran off leaving her to her last moments alone and scared. No amount of explanation could clarify to me how he could kill a child, his own sister like that.
@@ianwalton284 🤣🤣🤣 You might be a wee bit. It was the older brother watching the little girl and then Keith took her to the basement. That's when the older brother went upstairs.
I believe this boy. This type of flat tone and anxiety relating to family shows just how dysfunctional it was. As someone who came from an abusive home for years I GENUINELY believed if my entire family died I wouldn’t care at all. Because when they don’t care for you correctly you start to isolate yourself and view them differently. It seems like a broken family and whatever happened to him made him think this was somehow the only option. Im not sure how he got there but this is exactly why we need to take better care of children and take them away from bad homes.
I don't. if anything I would say if an abuser existed I would suspect he was the abuser himself and the murder was to cover both, explaining why they might find signs of abuse and giving a reason for the murder other then "because I was afraid she would report me"
Yeah but there's no way to know, and If he is the psycho in the house then he could easily do and say all of this to try and get away with it. I mean he could do or say anything.
@alex4183 I understand you, and I also believe the suspect. I come from a very dysfunctional family and I deeply understand when you said that you wouldn't feel anything if all your family dies. And I figure you won't if it really happens! I didn't when I learnt my mother (the biggest abuser, mentally, psychologically, physical from a very young age) passed. I had no emotion whatsever, it felt like a faint relief, but it didn't heal my emotional wounds and consequences I deal with throughout my life. Demons are still there. I figure that also my grandma is dead by now (I had no contact with all of them since the late 80s/early 90s, God thanks!), but it doesn't affect me. She was the only one who was a little friendy with me, but she didn't stop the abuse, nor anybody else. Back to the case on hand, still I can't fanthom how the boy arrived at murder as the only option. Though it can be relatable to a certain point.
Same, and a great point. Thanks for speaking it out. I've actually wrote the same comment in one of the previous videos, but I got censored by youtube. The truth is, those sickening behaviors of a child are always a product of their parenting. If it's a healthy family, and there's no abuse happening in it, and you are giving enough care and attention to your child, then it would be impossible for something bad to come out of it. However, if there's abuse in the family, then it's a no brainer that his life will be f'd one way or the other. I got abused, and thrown away on the streets at the turn of 18 years. There's so many things I could have done. But lately can't find any motivation. I wish I just had a normal family. But at least I can warn other people online, that if they want a good child, it's not rocket science, just care about your child and don't abuse him/her. If you can't provide that, then don't have a child.
About 10 minutes in I started to get the feeling that he was being inappropriate with his sister and he killed her out of fear that she would tell somebody. So he figured it was better to kill his sister under the false justification that he was the hero for ending her suffering than exposed as an 18 year old sexually assaulting his own sister.
@@jaimevalencia6271 I watched the whole thing but I also understand that some information never comes to the surface... there are thousands of unsolved cases due to missing or unproven information
It takes a very special kind of person to be an interrogation officer. How to stay calm the way they do after hearing what this piece of rubbish did to his 4 year old sister, is beyond me.
Man I wouldn’t handle it (interrogator: being patient when u know what happened) especially when ur talking to the killer of a young child. I think I’ll lose my mind and do the same to him
You have to be in control of your emotions. And I don’t mean to be one of these officers. I’m talking in general. No one is truly in control of their emotions now days. Although I’m not either.
This is the sickest act I've seen. Brutally slaughtered his sister to save her. It was beyond comprehension when he was talking about what she said and did as he killed her. How can the mind of a young man be so sick to do this!
Ok, I THINK I am kinda starting to understand his train (wreck) of thought: Keith thought that his little sister was being abused. So, he asked his mom if he could get a gun. He wanted the gun to use on the abuser and to stop the abuse against his little sister. He needed the gun because the abuser was stronger than him and only a gun would stop the abuser. He acknowledges that he WOULD have gone to the police, but he didn't have any evidence of the abuse and knew the police wouldn't be able to do anything without the evidence. When he didn't get his mom's permission to get a gun, he reasoned that the only other way to stop the abuse was to end his little sister's life. He reasoned that 4 minutes of pain, ending in death, was better than daily abuse. So he killed his little sister with a knife, to end her suffering. His reasoning is... dementedly logical, but extremely limited! Why not focus on getting the evidence FOR the cops to help? Why not kidnap her and take her away from the abuser? Why not get a gun without permission? His logic is extremely narrow and can't seem to form complex conclusions. Plus, his morality is a unconventional. He has abuse worse than death. That isn't necessarily uncommon for victims of prolonged abuse, but him making that decision FOR a victim is extreme. Either he has extreme empathy (placing himself in her position), was being victimized himself (was projecting his pain and using her as a surrogate), or has a god complex (knows what's best for others).
@Will Dazey I don't agree with his story completely to be honest... Although it appears that he is telling the truth for the most part, the extended investigations by the police proved that she wasn't being abused, or at least there WASN'T any proof... I think it's something far more sinister... In other words, there was no "abuser", it was his delusion... Him convincing himself. He said that his sister was "laying" on the ground to paint... that could be some sort of grooming. Or at least his "thoughts". maybe he couldn't see himself doing it or ever hurting her in that way, so he chose to k*ll her instead... which is heartbreaking... I felt something break inside me when he said that she started screaming and crying and saying "why are you killing me"... How could anyone ever do such a thing... I believe he's telling the truth for the most part... But it could be something far more sinister and we will never know.
Yeah i always deduced psychopath is just another way to say stupid. And that "psychopaths dont have feelings" didnt make any sense to me. But i guess psychopath is more like stupidity or ignorance in the realm of taking into account somdbodys feelings.
@@lettiegrant9447 Not even once did I read in this comment that they agreed with him at all and how you could even jump to that collusion is completely bewildering, The comment was simply a logical breakdown/explanation as to what the boy had running through his mind. No agreements, just plain factual black and white thought process.
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
“Why are you killing me?” Is a haunting statement. Poor girl.
😢
27:10 the narrator/commentator says he "doesn't consider his actions extreme" but he obviously does..
I'd really like to know both who he thought was molesting her, and most importantly, WHY he thought that.
I wonder if he's accusing his step-dad (her dad) of being the perpetrator, and did this to harm him, while using the story that his step-dad was abusing her as a way to both morally exonerate himself & harm the step-dad..
34:30 I was wrong - he says somewhere after 34:30 "then I'd be here about a 14-year-old, not a 4-year-old", thus likely referring to his youngest brother (he's 18, the brother at the house when the police came is 16, and he has 1 more brother - likely the 14-year-old he's mentioning.
I wonder if that brother was his step-father's son from a previous relationship. The daughter seems to be his mother's + his step father's daughter.
That’s so incredibly sad poor girl.
this confession is so complete that investigators really don't even know what to ask.
Yep. They basically could just ask: Can you make it make sense? In about 20 different ways
@@scharf74He is almost like a robot that got caught in a logic paradox around Asimov three laws...
To me they got the confession but they never got the motive.... i think they knew what the motive was but couldn't get him to admit it.
@@adamimberti6948 u don't make sense at all !!???
@@adamimberti6948 he said he did it to save her from somebody
His brother saying “what did you do to my baby” is the most heartbreaking thing I’ve heard. I pray for him and his family
I thought this was heartbreaking too. However, I wonder if the brother is the one he thought was abusing the sister because of that statement? (I'm only half way through)
@@xandercrews7314 no he was the abuser, he probably killed her because he was disgusted with what he had done and couldn’t face it anymore then snapped
@@videoviewer8818 was his stepfather abuser then?
Nah that’s creepy especially considering the fact that he’s accusing his brother of being an abuser. We will never know the truth, and I’m not going to sit here and accuse someone with no proof, my only point is that I don’t think it’s normal for an older brother to call his 4 year old sister “my baby”
Pray*
This has to be one of the sickest, heartbreaking accounts of murder I’ve ever heard. The fact that he cut her neck once, and she screamed, and cried, then asked him, “Why are you killing me?”, is nauseatingly heinous. That poor, poor baby. She just wanted to paint with her big brother, whom she obviously trusted. OMG. I feel sick after watching this one. This made me very tearful. Murder is always horrific, but this account made me sick, sad, and livid all at once. 🤢😭😡
same!
As an 18 year old guy with an 8 year old younger sister, this was extremely hard to watch. I’m basically a second parent to her, I could never in my life imaging purposefully hurting her in any way. I feel like it’s my job to protect her from any physical or emotional pain.
you seem like a good older brother
Same with my baby sister 21 she 7
Yep no red flags for you Yet?
Awee I wish I had an older brother
You’re a good brother, you should be proud 💜 she is lucky to have you
The fact that this guy tried to buy a gun and was denied and this is how he reacted only makes me wonder what he would’ve actually done with a gun
Someone else posed an interesting theory, perhaps he kiIIed her out of revenge against his mother for not letting him get the gun.
Show his high school class mates how much he loves them
He would of probably killed his whole family. I wouldn't doubt for a second the kid murdered his sister because she resisted or threatened to "snitch" on his sexual abuse of her.
To be fair I’m only about 10 minutes in but he did just say he would have used the gun against the guy he believed to be assaulting her. He then killed her to protect her when he couldn’t get the gun
@@bigrichmccoy506 Yeah, he said he couldn't get the gun with which he seemed to be indicating that he was going to kill this supposed abuser of his sister with so he killed his sister.
I'm a grown man and I'm not ashamed to admit that the thought of that little girl lying on the floor, bleeding, asking her brother "why are you killing me?" made me cry
grown men cry, you arent a damn robot lol.
@@lynnsey9343 not funny
he said grown men do in fact cry and that it's perfectly normal cause "we arent a damn robots". i think you misunderstood what he meant
@@sourbongjuices9632 It should have been you
@@jaculaa01 he said lol
As a 18yr old girl with a four year old brother I cannot fathom ever doing anything even remotely close to this. That baby is my absolute world and genuinely my best-friend, alongside with the fact I am very maternal with him and love him just as much as I would love a child. The fact that somebody could kill a toddler like that is beyond me
Be Ever So GRATEFUL this Makes Zero Sense to you!!
Its bc you know how to love and have compassion and empathy. May you have a long happy and joyous life! Peace ✌
The level of calm displayed by these two as they interrogate this kid, still covered in his baby sister's blood, is astronomical.
yeah I really don't understand how these dudes can sleep being in a room with people like this all the time.... so scary to be face to face with an murder
Can't imagine the pain and memories they hold in their mind. Takes a strong person to be able to disassociate from that job enough to live normally.
@@smokinjodak9844 iam happy that iam not a policemen or someone from the army the shit that those people go through. i just cant.
When you want to put away evil, you do what you have to do.
@@smokinjodak9844 Just like people in the medical profession or in the military, they compartmentalize the aspects of their job from the rest of their life. You are trained to have a professional distance between you and your client or in this case, person in custody. There could be many different emotions going on and probably not fear at all. Frustration maybe and also maybe deep sadness at the type or mode of the crime. Empathy of course with the victim being a child when a lot of people in the caring/protecting professions are also parents with children. But you put on your nurse/doctor/military/police hat and do your job. You can't allow your job to affect you or you wouldn't be effective in that job.
The way she died, heart-breaking. Just totally trusting his brother and smiling, I can´t handle hearing his testimony.
I'm wondering did abuse happen? I just surprised the family didn't went to the hearing to see him condemned but I can understand why. Still psychotic to think that the only way to save his sister from "abuse" is in death. Not to mention from mom testimony that's the only relationship he maintained well with.
When she said she wanted to watch SpongeBob and paint that made me cry thinking of my niece. Can’t imagine anyone doing something that cruel to a innocent child
Hey most likely said and explained in a horrible way of death " die" . Just saying that from her brother die she's just repeating .
And he said all that with the blood from her on his pants. Dear jesus.
As a parent, how can you go on knowing one of your children killed the other.
If you watch a lot of psychopath documentaries like I do then you would know that psychopaths are spiteful and tend to lash out when they don't get what they want.. The killing was more than likely to hurt his mom who would not let him purchase the firearm. Notice how he keeps bringing up the gun and how upset he was about it for no apparent reason. She may have stopped a mass shooting from taking place.
Eerily similar to the Paris Bennett case!
@@cguibcx my thoughtz exactly.
Agreed.
@@curtisvenom32 whether he is a Psychopath or not I don't buy his story. People who do heinous acts even when caught, love to tell half truths to make them look better.
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
I don't care how young he is. But this kid should never ever be let out of prison. For the rest of his living years. Dang this is heartbreaking. Wow
100% Agree! He knew exactly what he was doing. Obviously, he had issues and should have gone to a psychiatrist, but for some reason, families don't like to seek help for their mentally unstable kids, they just ignore it until it's too late.🙄
When you Google his name now his pen pal profile comes up 🤮🤮
I disagree. 40 years is too much.
He was very cooperative.
In the USA the sentences are more severe than in most countries, but it doesn't make the country safer.
@@frednimzowi9852 he murdered his sister
@@prvt.harumi6821 I know, and I stick to my initial comment
Everyone is trying to find rational explanations, but I think the guy is honest and just has a twisted mind. He just really believed that was the solution.
Sometimes rationality just does not apply to some.
Sometimes they are so convinced in the mission they are set in what they feel is justified.
Does it justify the action? Most of the time no. No it does not. This is one case where it isn't. Guy was detached from reality and had a mission in mind and fully thought it out.
I mean it means his also a coward bc he rather kill his sister then kill the other guy that is bigger and stronger then him
i think so too, maybe he was wrong about the family member abusing his sister but maybe he made himself believe it was true to justify his action, who knows
this is exactly what i think aswell, i started getting frustrated that the interrogators kept thinking he wasn’t truthful. i mean i get why they thought that but i really felt like he told them the whole truth and they just weren’t hearing him
@@wkwrd9667 I understand their rationale. But one thing I would imagine would be covered in training is always take into consideration someone may be genuinely crazy by the standards of the normal.
Absolutely heartbreaking. She just wanted to paint and enjoy her precious young life. Rest in peace
Don't, you're gonna make me cry 😢 I kept thinking about my baby girl, she loves to paint and craft especially with her big brother
You ever have a kid lay down to paint? Painting was a code for something sinister.
So innocent, met with such unneccesary brutalness
@@JeffOnhill you maybe up to something ….
maybe he was the one abusing her and wanted to keep her quiet.
This was so... bizarre. It's weird to see someone so open about this. I believe that he truly thinks he was "protecting" her, and his parents supposedly laughing in his face for his concerns about Sabrina being abused is disturbing, but something is seriously wrong with him for going after her and not the alleged abuser.
Yes “something” was wrong alright. His mental state that’s what.
I think HE was the abuser
@@redeyedrednek that’s what I was thinking too because why wouldn’t he go after the abuser if he knew who they were?
@@HoneyPott11 He mentioned multiple times that it was his other 14 year old (step?) brother, but he didn't go after him because the brother was supposedly much bigger than him and he didn't get his gun. A *seriously cowardly excuse.
I'd bet all my money that there is no way anyone (except for himself maybe) ever abused his sister.
If anyone did then why would he not just call the police?
“Why are you killing me” makes me so unbelievably sad and angry
Sitting there, covered in his little sister’s blood, describing how she asked why as he inflected a painful death upon her… this one hurts to listen to even as a random stranger. How his family must feel watching this and realising that their own son did something so horrible is impossible to understand. It must have felt like a surreal nightmare. How heartbreaking 😢
❤😔❤
For real so sad
very sad
Would never talk to him again
@Max Shut up.
I couldn’t imagine having somebody you fully trust like a sibling doing something like that to you. Horrific and tragic even more so given her age, poor girl.
Its the most sad when it comes from your own family. I have reasons to believe that this is not normal, there are chemicals and other factors that are messing with people this day.
Liberals want to let him off with a stern warning
@@pepironi992 This is your take away? A political rant? Lol
@@infinitesimotel you are absolutely correct about that please take some solace and do rest in the knowledge that what's done in the dark will be brought to the light
@@RealMisawa yes
“She was completely innocent” “This was not temporary insanity” “This was premeditated”
Imagine being this guy’s lawyer.
Objection, hearsay.
What if any?
@@mcusson2
"Umm, sir, your client is admitting it right here in this courtroom..."
"Oh- is he?... Oh, well."
Easy money
For real he's crazy. He could have just called CPS to help his sister if any of that was even true
I will never understand how anyone can look at a child (let alone their own sibling) and even think about harming them. It’s just so unnatural
A person with empathy probably won’t ever understand it. Just like a psychopath probably can’t understand how people can feel genuine emotion.
People have all sorts of involuntary thoughts that they would rather not have but do anyway and never act on them
Just because your completly incompetent with actual life and nature in general dosnt mean everyone else is
Hearing how she died and talked to him so calmly and politely is just so heartbreaking. She deserved to see the world
Yes...poor little child 😥😥
I could say that about many
@@skyguy696 This is outrageous, it is unfair!
😢😭😂
@@_________5610 why are you using the laughing emoji? its not funny.
When Keith said that his brother said “What did you do to my baby” that was also rlly sad. Just by that line you can tell the 16yr old adored his baby sister and probably feels horrible for letting Keith watch her💔
Poor boy lost his sister and brother... 🥺
@@drats1279 wow, that a pretty low blow. That's the type of choice words applied for your own pleasure; its just the thing someone with the mindset of "I'm superior because I have certain values would say" to a horribly depressed person leading them to their suicide, just to only try to justify it. Hitler had a superiority type of mindset, and he used it to justify the deaths of millions. Hitler didn't make a mistake, he murdered and tried to justify it. This person made a mistake, the consequences he was unaware of, and certainly didn't try to justify it, if anything someone else tried to explain it wasn't his fault. And then there are those that want the innocent to hurt, like Hitler
@@drats1279 I feel bad for you for that you get off on saying such stupid things. Normally when people get off on seeing complete strangers suffer, they themselves have some depressing shit going on in their lives. Hopefully it gets better but with that attitude, life’s only going to get worse 👎
@@drats1279 bruh. The kid probably woulda killed the sister another night shut up.
It means brother knew his brother was a little wacko
These investigators do some serious work. How you talk to these people and see these crime scenes by day and go back to your family by night without losing your mind is incredible. They're such strong people.
They do lose their mind. Many develop sybstance abuse problems, depression, anger problems. I guarantee you if u talk to any investigator who regularly sees horrific stuff they will tell you it effects them immensely. Either that or they learn how to shut off their emotions, but that can result in built up hurt and huge outbursts. Not healthy
A distant relative of mine is a police officer and was tasked with investigating child p*rnography for 2.5 years. His task was to scan confiscated computers/servers and review online footage to find out whether there was indeed a case of CP. He had to look at that disturbing stuff all day!
It was department policy that any one officer was limited to three years maximum doing this task, he stopped after 2.5 years. I was a preteen during that time, just like his daughter and experienced him as very closed off person who always seemed busy in his home office during our visits (as if he was hiding from/avoiding us) while we were with the rest of the family in another room. It was almost like he wasn't there, I could barely describe what he looked like during that time.
After he got a different task, he became an open, social person and took part in family visits as normal.
Even though we only saw him a few times a year, it was very obvious how much better he was doing without this depressing job.
That’s because a lot of people are ignorant and you don’t know the horrible things that happen every second of every day. Once you accept that things like that are always happening it’s easier to cope with
@@liliumpthpumpernickle8462 for me it's exactly the opposite, knowing that a lot worse things are happening every second everywhere around us, makes it much worse to cope with for me. Especially since having experienced bad things in my own childhood, and now being the mother of a 8yo daughter makes it really really really hard
@@LRM12o8 that shit sounds unbearable. God bless him and good luck to him
It’s pretty obvious that he was the abuser. Why didn’t the detectives ask how Keith “knew” that “it was getting worse and worse by the day” - “it” being the abuse supposedly perpetrated by someone else?
That’s what I think
Actually insane that the cops didn't pursue this more. Its so obvious.
The autopsy showed no sign of abuse.
He was definitely covering up what he was doing
Why didn’t the detectives ask how Keith “knew” that “it was getting worse and worse by the day”...this is a very VITAL question
My heart goes out to the other brother who really loved his little sister. The fact that somebody could do something so gruesome to their OWN SISTER is terrifying. I hope their brother is able to find peace and happiness even after the horror he has experienced.
Just like all psychopaths who are caught he'll try his best to deflect responsibility, to rationalize the act. There's no remorse here at all. He's just very upset he was caught. I can only hope he's put down in prison.
@@Bootmahoy88 monkeylover12 was referring to the innocent other brother, not the murderer himself. Could you imagine how their brother feels about what his brother did to their sister?! More than enough to totally fck someone up for life!
Yeah the brother is always going to be mad at himself for turning his back.
I dunno, he said multiple times that the other brother was molesting his sister. It could be a lie, but it happens to so many young girls that it's not unlikely. Little girl was probably surrounded by people she shouldn't have been around.
@@nich1238 there are two other brothers. one upstairs playing video games and another 14 yo who was out at a dance with the mom and step-dad. sounds like that's the one he's alleging harmed the sister but was too big for him to overpower
The fact she was conscious during it all even talking to him and asking why he was killing her. The details of this make me feel physically sick.
The fact you are believing a murderer is what's really sick.
@@The_Cat_Authority I don’t see the need to lie about that. If anything it’s even more incriminating and would make his case less sympathetic.
@@sallymaa1234 That's your issue. You are basing other peoples thoughts off of your own. This may come as a shock but EVERYONE is different. You are welcome to think whatever you like. Its a bit absurd though to go around telling people your own opinion as if its a fact.
@@sallymaa1234 IT took me 2 and a half hours to decipher your comment...but you are spot on...BTW until the age of 21 or 22 the brains of kids arent fully develop t and most importantly he could suffer from any kind of syndrom...very severe case he lost his sister to and will be aware from this fact...
Ive never cried at one of these videos before this one. Tragic all around.
EDIT: please stop replying. It's not worth your time.
He seems to genuinely believe Sabrina was being abused. That coupled with the lack of proof, I wondered throughout this if he's experiencing a delusion. I don't really see signs of being a psychopath, I do however see potential signs of schizophrenia or a related disorder. Whatever the case, I hope he's helped while locked up.
Rest in peace, Sabrina. Poor angel
Could also be the schizoid personality disorder - as him having "some" sort of PD was mentioned at 49:50. The guy is not delusional, this is just an example of how schizoids may reason, rationalize and justify.
He's just lying, why not attack the abuser. He thrives on suffering.
@@para-mentischannelbypiggsy4240 his explanation regarding the abuser was mentioned. The logic might appear twisted, and it is. But it's true from his perspective, that's the whole point. What exactly is he lying about?
you a doctor? just wondering
Yes
The way he keeps referring to his mom denying his request to get a gun makes me think he was punishing his mom.
Yes this comes to the mind. He was frustrated because he could not buy a gun and so wanted to punish his mother.
But maybe is he just plain nuts. Too much Metal music and an attraction for gore.
@paulbizard3493 I listen to a lot of Metal. Not killed anyone....
@@jigglybits9624 not yet😅
@paulbizard3493 who knows what the future holds, if freedos keep going up in price, I cant be responsible for my actions
@@jigglybits9624 😅
I hope his brother is okay. When he said “he was watching her, so I told him I would watch her” then his brother went to his room and he took his sister to the basement and murdered her. Then when the police came and he figured out what was happening he looked at his brother and said “what did you do to my baby” his heart probably shattered into a million pieces. I can only imagine the guilt he feels.. I couldn’t imagine being a parent and coming home to this.
It was that brother abusing the little girl.....
@@AlishaField1609 says the psychopath baby killer
@@AlishaField1609 and it’s been confirmed that it was him?
@@InIt4TheMemez unfortunately it can be hard to prove, especially if 1- the victim is only 4 which presents a few problems and 2- that victim now can't confirm it (if she did have memory of it, that is).
Many abused that young either don't remember or repress the memories.
In his mind he 'threw away his life' and accepted all consequences for the greater good. If he was able to get a gun he stated he would have killed the abuser but he would win a knife fight so only thing left was to end her life. To him it was rational and 'out of love'.
I don't agree with what he did but to him it was logical.
@@AlishaField1609 or the murderer was also the person that sexually assaulted her and killed her so she couldn’t tell anyone what he was doing. Asking her if she wanted to paint and then her laying down right after seems very odd and like they’d done it before 💔 it’s all so heartbreaking
The fear that little girl must have felt in her final moments breaks my heart and makes me so angry
Did that to him, too
@Cuckoo_Lane don't worry, he'll get what he deserves in prison (I certainly hope so!)
@@Kathy_1991hopefully without vas
@@antonibertolacci7030 😆
😂
“What did you do to my baby” that poor brother, what a horrific thing to have to go through
For real...
He's a piece of shit I don't get emotional easy but fuck me this was pulling at my heart. The amount of pain I would put on this murderer. I hope the prisoners make his life true hell.
I find it strange how no one find the brother weird
@@nvnax in the situation they were in, there's fear, adrenaline anxiety and they're being cuffed with him clueless. Maybe he meant to say "what did you do to my baby sister?!" But forgot sister?
@@topaz123212 I don’t mean that the guy who committed seems to have a genuine believe that whoever his brother is did do something to the young girl idk it’s weird to me
I've recently been watching a lot of your videos and have felt guilty over my morbid curiosity as it's been all too easy to forget that these are all real people that had their own fears, hopes & dreams and are now gone. This has hit me in an entirely different way however and despite the phrase being overused I can't think of a more fitting one; this is truly sickening. His demeanor, casual indifference, his detachment & his calm tone of voice. That poor, poor little kid. She must have been so fucking scared, so confused and in so much pain. I think I'll have to make this the last one of these I watch for quite some time. It's shown me a truly dark side of humanity that I frankly always knew was there but honestly wasn't expecting to affect me this much. People are capable of despicable acts.. the holocaust, the Cambodian killing fields, millions more over who's God is best ffs. So much death and suffering. R.I.P little lady, you deserved so, so much better from this world & I know I didn't know you but I'd give anything to have been able to be there somehow to keep you safe.
Same my friend. Shalom
Such a cope
Same here, this one brought me to tears. I can't imagine how she felt, her fear and confusion having someone she trusted and loved doing that to her. This will be the last one for awhile.
Same here. I’m done with these for awhile. RIP Sabrina.
The holocaust, Cambodian killing fields, Mao's Red Guard, Lenin's Russia... those are all **ATHIEST** PERPETRATORS.
In fact, the vast majority of modern atrocities are committed by those who REJECT Christianity.
Study history. Think logically.
That little girl, that little girl! This is literally heart breaking! the death of a child just hits different, it's just unbelievable. It could've been any of us. Life is unpredictable
When did this happen
J03 b1den is a (p3)do
I hate when the victim is a child. I love investigations and interrogations, but it always find myself tearing up when a kid is involved. 😔
@@furyspec $$%$%
Oh hey, a fellow black cat right next door in the comment section. Mine is cooler than yours!
I can't believe this whole interrogation was done with him still in his clothes soaked in his sister's blood. That is so disturbing.
Ikr
:,(
Because when they do an interrogation they want it done right away after a crime. Well everything is fresh in somebody's mind and they can recount every detail. But yes it's quite disturbing
Yeah I'm surprised they didnt take the clothes for evidence right away as well. They usually do in these situations, where a suspect/victim is covered in fluids/evidence.
@Robert C. Christian I'm so sorry about your friend.
Part way through this, one things for certain, I have all the sympathy in the world for his brother. That guy has to be living with every ounce of undeserved guilt in the world.
that was the first thing i thought of when keith described taking his sister from his brother to the basement. as an older sibling myself, i hold so much guilt over things that happened with my siblings in the past even though i couldnt have changed it. at least my siblings are alive and happy now. his brother will never be able to see his sister again. what an absolute nightmare. i couldnt even imagine the devastation i would feel if i lost one of my siblings. i feel so sick to my stomach listening to this case. may they find peace in life.
I man he was supposed to be the one watching her. It was her responsibility and i still don’t understand how he supposedly didn’t hear any of the things going on...
@@datpsychobytch he was playing video games, he likely had headphones in.
Damn I didn’t think of that … this was a hard one
@@datpsychobytch it looked like a three story house... he was upstairs and they were down a full floor in between, and he likely had at least the TV volume on if not a headset...
He mentioned this conflict with his mother earlier and that part of his punishment was to NOT be allowed to babysit Sabrina.
This is no coincidence.
💯
right, something of a red flag here for sure
Yeah when you see the Obama posters in his room it ties it all together. He's a diddler.
He was likely jealous of his sister getting more attention from his mom. This made him fly into a narcissistic rage
@@Punicia Guess that's very primitive emotion, makes me think of how all those chimps attacked that guy in California bcuz they were enraged with jealousy!
I actually believe he truly thought he was protecting her in his mind. The "4 minutes of pain" line really sealed that for me. Some people just don't see death as a bad thing and it seems he's one of those people. He thought he was freeing her from a lifetime of abuse with "4 minutes of pain." He could be in a state of paranoid psychosis. I have first hand experience with that and it will make you do/say some crazy shit that you somehow find a way to really believe with your whole soul.
Same. The cops where sort of annoying me trying to ask questions he answered the same and without hesitation. He clearly believed what he was doing was what he needed to do. He said it 100 times, he explained and was honest from the beginning. What sealed it for me was when he said “I’m not trying to hide anything, I called the police, I trust you, I didn’t change my clothes or anything”
@@SlayWithAnais While i do agree that ithink he belived he acually protected her: The real question is, was it the disorder that made him do it, or the music lyrics he was listening to or both. He was a loner & had a disorder, on top of that listen to stuff that subconsciosly most likely affected him. He also played video games. Personally iknow thers tons of horror and violent games out there. Hes reading Steven King books? Its not strange this affects someone with special types of disorders. This is coming from someone with Aspergers Syndrome himself (Autism).
I'm glad to see someone else felt this way. I assume it's like postpartum depression. Or my dad, who is schizophrenic, said to my mother "I love you Virginia, I'm sorry, but I have to kill you" he was trying to protect her from misery. Messed up.
But yeah. I agree with you. To label these people as monsters, evil does us no good.
Honestly i would just kill myself
Very possible. I've seen other cases where killing someone is rationalized by "saving" them from a life of abuse, pain, etc. Often a parent being the murderer too. And due to how candid Keith was being, it's likely his thought process is true to him, regardless of how abnormal "society" may believe it to be. Why would you want to understand or rationalize like someone with a personality disorder anyway? It's a good thing to KNOW that you don't lack the moral compass, at least that's my thoughts.
had a psychopathic older brother. childhood was horrible. so sorry for this young girl who never got a chance.
Hope you have recovered well. You had? He's deceased?
@@redneckshaman3099 oh my god
@@jettsetgirl I got a sister and this vid hit me hard. EDIT: especially the other (normal) brother who lost a wee sister.
@@redneckshaman3099 You're parents must be so proud¿⊙?
@The magician BKNY put them to sleep for how long
As a younger sister to 2 older brothers, let me tell you that there is NOTHING wrong with older brothers calling their younger sisters their baby - they essentially help raise you and is a constant presence when both your folks are working or if one parent is doing the job for two. Something else is deffo wrong here and it's just a sad story all around.
I would assume calling a sibling "baby" is not appropriate in all household. In my family, it would be creepy if my brothers called me that. There are boundaries to be upheld in household, for example, calling your parents by their first names, in some household that is common, but it is rare. Just creepy.
@@JanSparkles1 True but the girl was really young so i feel like it makes sense
@@JanSparkles1 While I understand what you are saying, you fail to understand my comment. Thinking about the usage of the word baby in all its connotations rather than its dictionary definition is what is creepy. And that is your problem.
Edit: This response is in the context of my reply. Don't go assuming it's applicable to all households and families, like you have done.
@@JanSparkles1 but shes four ? i called my really young siblings or even my nieces my baby .. shes so young its not really weird . its not weird until they grow older and more mature and just like kids no longer call their parents mommy or daddy and parent stop kissing their younger children on the lips ...(which i wont lie sounds weird LOL) people stop calling their younger siblings baby . Although i had an older brother in law (over 25 years older than me) and he practically raised me (along with my sister) but he would call me baby girl or endearing terms ? i dont mind , but i understand how it can be seen as weird .
Bro i cant believe people think this is inappropriate. Literally she was so young and he was much much older compared to her, calling her baby would only mean he acted as a second parent to her. Whats with people's mind these days that it was so wrong for a big brother to call his 4 yo little sister a baby?
you can tell when the detective gets up and looks at the camera he is shook by having to talk to him for so long. what a tough job
As someone with a little sister and a similar age gap, this hurts so much to watch. My world would end if something like that happened to her. My prayers go out to the family
For me same, also i just felt so horrible when he said the brother said "What did you do to my baby?" my heart sunk just putting myself in the brothers position i couldn't imagine hearing that about my little sister. My heart really does go out to the brother and Sabrina's family.
Exactly how I feel. Kinda felt some anger towards him for doing what he did.
the same for me the part where he talks about what she said when he was stabing here was too much for me i started to fr cry i don't have that big of a age gap im 9 shes 12 years old i just fell like it's so sureal i can't really even think of something like this without sherading a tear
Prayers do nothing. 🙂
@@tupakkaonhyvaa must feel special don’t ya
My sister once pulled a knife from our kitchen because she came home and heard me screaming upstairs and was willing to protect me with her life. Luckily I was having a panic attack and not being attacked. I feel horrible for her to have to mentally prepare for that and how scared she looked when she came up. the idea of a sibling wielding a knife to harm their sibling rather than protect them is horrible and unthinkable.
Edit: People in the comments don't believe that this really happened, but just because there weren't signs of forced entry doesn't mean that this didn't happen. People you let into your house, friends or family or neighbors can attack you. She later said she thought it was my bf at the time hurting me. She was very relieved i was fine and she didn't tell me about grabbing the knife until the next day, she put it away once she saw i was okay so I wouldn't get scared. If you've had dissociation you would understand the screaming. I just posted what was on my mind, a memory about how love between siblings really looks and how amazing my sister is, and now I'm being accused of lying for attention. Fun!
Bless your heart, panic attacks are terrible but I’m glad you were safe. Hold onto her, y’all sound very close and loving.
God bless you and your family.
True, and she's got my respect 100%
@@jamesdaley1762 mine too, she certainly deserves it!
@@taraji_b I'm lucky to have a big sis like her! Thank you,I haven't had a panic attack in a few years thanks to therapy and medication!
I don’t even…know what to think of this. I want to say he’s “evil,” but he seems like he legitimately thought he was helping her. This strikes me as very, VERY severe and untreated mental illness. What an absolute tragedy all around.
You're right it is mental illness but this could easily all be a cover up as an excuse to just act on his impulses of wanting to murder someone and unfortunately the target for whatever true reason was the child. In his head I think he is in denial with a major guilty conscious of what he has just done and why, so he tries to believe this Narrative that he was "helping" her.
Manipulation is part and parcel of this level of evil.
Most disturbing part is we will never truly know , only him , and his conscious .
@@StriboggElite facts
@@StriboggElite facts. The way he said "she couldn't fight back" gave me chills. He knew she was helpless.
I don’t have kids of my own at 37, but my nieces are my life. And listening to what the 4 year’s old wanted to do, and what she got in return is truly heartbreaking. I keep questioning my brother & his wife if they kids been fed if I hear a little cry or agitation, and hear I’m listening to a 4 year olds last words to her brother is something I can’t take. And had to have a throw up break before continuing to listen further. And here he is sitting confessing to the murder!
No matter how bad the situation, I can never imagine someone taking life of a child. 😢
Same here and I wish nobody could harm another human or at the very least children.
When the brother asked "what did you do to my baby?"- he immediately knew. That is so heart-wrenching.
No, she deserved it, he’s a good kid!
I think the brother may have been the person he was accusing of allegedly abusing her. 😞
@Ublimt Fip I agree wholely. I’m just saying that I believe that’s who it was. He also said something about the individual being bigger than him and taller than him and stronger than him. I believe that’s what he wanted the firearm for. Since that was removed from the equation, he knew he would never overpower his brother in a physical confrontation with a knife. He said if he had gotten the firearm, they would be there over a 14 year old, not a 4 year old. I’m in no way validating his thinking but that’s what he’s trying to get across. When he wasn’t allowed to babysit and the person he suspected was abusing her was, I think that set the trigger off that he had to get her away from him somehow. Why murder her and not try to run away with her to keep her away from the brother, I have no idea. That’s where his thinking is broken.
I think the brother calling her “my baby” is extremely disconcerting. I don’t know any teenage boy that would say that about a sibling. It conjures up feelings of a special relationship he thought he had with her, that he felt she was his possession. He may have been right about the abuse in my opinion but, of the many ways he could’ve tried to stop it and help her, he chose the absolute worst option when there were so many other healthy avenues to take.
I also think he genuinely believes what he did was noble. And he thinks he did it to help her, but in reality, it’s like he wants to be a martyr. That’s why at the beginning he was talking about how he WAS going to graduate and he WAS going to have a good life. He’s not thinking about what’s best for Sabrina, he’s thinking that he made this sacrifice knowing he’d go to jail because he did something heroic in stopping the alleged abuse. It’s all a massive narcissist hero complex. He doesn’t really care that he sacrificed her life and her graduation and her future. That’s not important to him, his sacrifice of his own future to “save” her is his top priority.
@Ublimt Fip It was not the brother because he claimed the brother was older than him. And said that it was 14 year old person and he the killer is 18.
Many here seems to believe he was the abuser, but him not understanding what the detectives were implying at first contradicts that. The way he acted through the whole thing makes me believe his version is 100% internally consistent to him. That makes him more dangerous if anything.
Ironically, sometimes this behavior evolves over time when there is severe abuse at a very young age. The reaction can often be very violent especially as the memories of previous abuse or trauma come to the surface. Justification for such events, when they come to the conscious mind, the forefront of memory, can be gruesome and without explanation. Even predators often don't understand when their victims become reactive. This is all so tragic and seemingly senseless. But it isn't.
@@aday1637 just what do you mean, it isn't tragic and senseless???
I read your comment and just because his actions may have manifest in his mind at some point, how can you say that this monsterous murder is not senseless and tragic?! WTF!!
I think it's more complicated than that. He came up with that story so that he wouldn't have to explain the real motive. He may have abused his sister, but I doubt it. This was a crime of passion, maybe he was jealous, got angry with her because she loved both her brothers, not just him.
@@tallcool1jeff If you actually read the comment, it said “This is so tragic and *seemingly* senseless. but IT ISNT.”
Which means it’s tragic, and it SEEMS senseless, but it isnt senseless.
*His alter ego was the “assaulter/abuser”,* which he wasn’t able to process or rationalise the way a normal individual would’ve. In his mind, killing her was the only solution to this constant subconscious conflict between a loving/caring/moral brother and the assaulter/abuser brother. His statement to the effect of, “I hope I don’t have to repeat my statement in the court” and his mother’s statement that, “the only person he seems to be close to was his sister”, sums it up for me. He considered being known as the murderer (who sved his sister from this imaginary assaulter by killing her) is more moral than being known as a child abuser.
Please Note: I’m NOT trying to justify his actions in any way, to the contrary for such crimes I take a much radical stand of NOT considering any psychological disorder/insanity even if it’s said to be present!
as someone with 2 brothers who always wanted a sister this just breaks my heart. you were the one person that was supposed to protect her no matter what...
Even if she was a dumbitch?
Yeah, But he still thinks he protected her sister by killing her. That's just not right 😢
In his twisted mind he did
@@sumanan6661 or did he rationalize it to remove guilt from his mind? Ugh
I pray you have daughters. Girls need fathers like you.
" I would never have did it." He wasn't lying about that C in english.
😅
C is a good grade. I got D for daydreaming, lol
His speech may be disorganised because of the chaotic lifestyle. He is in a broken family and is sat with his sisters blood all over him. If he was more organised and not disorganised, the crime may never have happened or he might have gotten away with murder.
I got the D for daydreaming in religious education lol
I got an A in English.
@@cowoverthemootook me nearly half the video to realise he's got her blood all over his trousers
😂😂😂
@@kingwhisky7535 You wouldn't have noticed it at all if he'd gotten a B.
this hurts my heart. the fact that anyone could do this just to a little child is so scary
And it happens more and more .Bless her angel heart 😔🙏😪💔
Imagine what could have happened if his parents had allowed him to purchase a firearm.
Keith was the one abusing her so he felt he had to kill her before she told on him. It's so obvious. He said he kissed her neck after she died!? Is he expecting police to find his dna/saliva on her neck? That's suspect af esp given he stabbed her in the same area.
People seem to be unaware of juvenilrle abusers/offenders. It's not uncommon but no one ever talks about it. I was a victim of two completely unrelated young men as a child and many inappropriate behaviours from brothers of school-friends. I can't be the only one.
@@ellaova It’s actually not so obvious. As explained in the video he really thought killing her would save her from pain. It’s referred to as mercy killing. In some instances when the dominant spouse in a relationship has been abusing their kids it’s rare but not completely unheard of for the other spouse to murder their kids to keep them from being abused anymore. In their mind it’s more humane than making them suffer through more attacks. Sure you’re not the only one. But that doesn’t mean you can just flat out say this guy was abusing his sister.
@Mortanius Langston such ignorant words. God created everything. An infinite universe full of infinite destruction. Since he created everything that means he created good… and evil. Because of the mistakes of 2 idiots who listened to a serpent innocent children suffer and die. You’re free to worship him just don’t pretend god didn’t know everything was gonna happen the way it did.
Even if his 4-year-old sister was being abused by another family member (it seems his then 14 and 16-year-old brothers were the only others left for his parents to “do nothing about”)- murdering her is one of the few things that is actually worse. His brain was broken. At 34:30 he says he suspected his 14-year-old brother.
yo tay
Fr!! There were so many other things that would be SO much better than what he did. And while she was fucking AWAKE. It is so hard to understand how someone could do this
Wow
this man took reverse cycolgy to far
he was abused too
I have watched a lot of true crime over the years but this has to be one of the worst ones to listen to the recount of. It is hard to imagine a 4 year old girl having to go through what she did. Whether you believe he's telling the truth or lying it doesn't matter. This little girl did not deserve anything that happened to her.
Agreed, ive only ever seen one worse than this. Took place up in Canada. Man and women in their late 20's scouted a school, found a girl that was around 5 kidnapped her, raped her multiple times, then brutally murdered her with a hammer.
The level of fear the girl must have gone through haunts me. The interviewer was excellent but the guy he was interviewing was silent as a mouse hardly said anything the entire time.
A lawmen in the old west (I want to say Bill Hickok) claimed some men were like rabid animals and the only thing you can do with them is put them down. Of course I'm paraphrasing but unfortunately I think it's an accurate statement.
@@ledfloyd9035 Yea I have seen that one as well. If I remember right he was whining about wanting a blanket and attempting to elicit some type of sympathy when he himself showed none to the little girl he killed.
I understand as that as animals we will never have a world with no more killing but of course that definitely does not excuse it. Though like you said some people just need to be culled from the herd and removed from society for their heinous actions against the most vulnerable of us.
I think he raped her and then killed her, my opinion
@@curtisvenom32 Yea, I do believe he believes he is right based on his warped view of what may or may not even be happening. He clearly needs help and sadly he did not get it before he did what he did. I feel for the family because they lost 2 kids that day.
@@i2evielle Survival of the fittest, people... Its how we always lived... Who's to say killings wrong?? The courts?? Governments?? You?? I could attempt to kill you right now were you standing next to me alone in my house.
If you succeed in killing me, well,I would have no hard feelings since I was the weaker one and natural selection chose you and you shouldn't have any hard feelings either if I were to succeed in killing you, nor should your parents or relatives or anyone... Sad everyone understands evolution but wont accept it.
15 minutes in and this is too sickening to watch anymore.
I can’t even imagine trying to interrogate him knowing he killed his 4 year old little sister. He’s sitting there with her blood all over him she was a helpless baby and he seemingly did this because he’s mom told him he couldn’t buy a gun. None of this makes sense.
No, I'm pretty sure he wanted to buy the gun to kill his sister without any pain, and as he realised that he wouldn't be able to use a gun he used the next best thing that came to his mind: a knife. The plan to kill her to protect her (How weird that may sound) was already there way before his mother denied him the gun.
Probably had a mental illness from trauma or had it at a young age because of genetics so they never took it under control.
It doesn’t make sense to a lot of people , He wasn’t “Mad” at the fact that He didn’t get the Gun or Wasn’t allowed . He was Going to do that With the Gun or Without the Gun would’ve just made it Easier He had this feeling within himself that he was doing something Good something Right
Those poor parents😢. They just lost two kids…what a nightmare😢
He's a child who's never aged mentally but matured slightly academically, but with no sense of the very superficial, but still existent and usually self evident, post- adolescent wisdom gained after puberty tapers off. Sad for all involved. Sorry Sabrina, I hope you are at peace.
Obviously what he did was disgusting. But I do think that in his mind it made sense to him. From an outside perspective it seems inconceivable that anyone would believe that murdering his sister would help her. I think he felt he was backed into a corner with no other way to get her out of a situation where she's being molested on a regular basis, with whoever was assaulting her bigger and stronger than him. Nobody seemed to believe him when he tried to get her help in different ways. His original idea was to purchase a weapon so he could protect her from her abuser. When he wasn't able to do that he thought that killing her was the only way to free her from the torment. This flawed way of thinking unfortunately cost the life of a sweet little girl. He is the one responsible for her death, he knows this and I truly feel like he feels remorse and regret, but maybe if he were listened to and taken seriously when he brought forth the concern that she was being molested that he wouldn't have felt like this was necessary to take such drastic measures. He made the wrong choices and he and his family will have to live with that for the rest of their lives, may that little girl rest in peace. Sexual assault must be taken seriously. Mental illness must be taken seriously. This kind of thing doesn't happen out of the blue, there are always signs. We need to get better at recognizing those signs and getting these people help. These tragedies don't have to keep happening. I always hear "you'd never know this kid would be a murderer, he was always so nice!" People don't just become murderers and violent criminals. There are always red flags and warnings and they are just missed because nobody really knows what to look for. With better understanding of mental illness and better recourses to help the mentally ill I feel as though the number of these types of incidents would decrease.
I couldn't have said it better myself
At 34:30 onward we're given a clear hint at the alleged molester's age.
Aside from that, I agree with what you're saying. He is definately not a person showing obvious signs of psychopathy. Quite the contrary.
However there are some obvious flaws in his reasoning, that sadly ended in tragedy. It seems to me though, that from his point of view, he found himself in a situation where he had to choose between the lesser of two evils. Within his frame of reference, he only wanted to do good, however flawed it was.
Yeah, im so conflicted with this one. I don't know if it's okay to empathize with him or if I'm being tricked by a psychopath.
@@epic5895 I don’t really know either but the important thing to note is he kept on saying he didn’t want to kill her and had no ill feelings towards her meaning that he could’ve felt that was the only way to help her but what he didn’t realize is that he would spend a lot of time repenting for his actions because he was nervous and he really had no other logical explanation as to why he killed her, personality disorder is strong in this one but he is not malicious
Exactly people like him are often misunderstood because they are disgusting by what he did but if they could have just been a bit more empathetic towards him they could’ve dealt with this situation quicker, he is clearly mentally ill with a few bad personality traits he didn’t do this because he wanted pleasure or control by intimidating his family, he did it because he was in pain seeing what that brute did to his sister and was probably too scared to tell the authorities about that person since he is reportedly a lot stronger than he is, it’s really tragic when you think about it enough
I have watched so many of these, I didn't think they could affect me. But when he described the moments when she was talking to him I had to gain a massive amount of respect for the ability of these officers to keep their composure and professionalism. Made me sick to my stomach.
That is probably why they gave him the 50 min break. They themselves had to gather their emotions.
@@Sumthin420 that doesn't surprise me at all. It would be hard to sit there and listen to that.
@bigchimptactical it's hard to listen to it now. Knowing I have the option to click away. Unfortunately, these poor officers have to endure all of this. Makes me sick.
It scares me to think of all the things law enforcement and emergency service personnel have to go through and hear on a daily basis. They deserve so much respect for having enough composure to do what most of us couldn't. I wouldnt be able to do it. Took me multiple times to watch this the whole way through. Had to click off as it got to be too much for me. It's just horrific and heartbreaking
@@TheRealKjareFox agreed!
Maybe they did ask and you just cut it, but I was surprised not to hear the detectives inquire more about the sexual abuse claims. The detective on the right seemed incredibly uncomfortable and neither detective seemed to want to believe Keith because of how eerily calm and honest he was. Lidke you said, they seemed to want to find a motive that made more sense to them, but it wasn't a crime committed by a sane person. It doesn't have to make sense or be right to us, but it was what made sense to Keith.
I agree with you. Why would a mom not follow up on this or the detectives.
they can't really use his statement as any kind of criminal report, he was obviously wrong in the head, you can't investigate if there is no probable cause
They possibly did but because they have no proof of the claims sometimes it better to just leave it out rather than include it and start theories or rumors when there's no proof of it being true/relevant. Just my thoughts on it anyway
I'm thinking if there was abuse it was actually Keith. He named his brother but in some sick way he might have been saving her from himself.
@@MAGACUNTREEEEEEE I’m thinking the same thing. I think he abused her, being a half sister he sickly justified it, then realized she was old enough to tell her parents and he killed her to cover it up
Hearing his brother say "what did you do to my sister?" hit real deep for me. The pain and frustration his brother must have felt after would be painful for anyone to deal with. He must of felt guilt to not be able to protect his little sister as well as anger at his brother for what he did. Emotions most wont ever experience and for good reason.
Its also weird to phrase it like that since she is the sister to both of them. So he should have said What did you do to Sabrina. Phrasing it like that makes it seem like he didnt consider him a sibling to both of them.
@@teongreen5254i mean i wouldn’t call him my brother either if i found out he killed my little sister..
@@teongreen5254it’s not weird. You fail to put yourself in the mindset of someone whose sister was just murdered. In that moment, nothing and no one else exists except you and her.
@@teongreen5254at the point where he realized his brother killed her he no longer considered him family. Hence saying “my sister” instead of our sister. Keith was dead to him at that point
@@teongreen5254 weird under normal circumstances sure
How anyone could do this to a child let alone their own sister is horrifying to me
The more I learn about this guy, the less I like him
vvomen murder unborn children everyday without a second thought
Psychopath much???
Exactly. His brother was playing video games . He saves his life yet targets his little sister 😔 what could she possibly have done to him . Nothing . Both of their lives should’ve been spared .
@@MarmaladeSally such a common and Mundane response
I’m 18 and I’ve got a younger sister who is 7 and I’d die for her if I had to. She’s one of the few people in my life who genuinely seems to love me. I couldn’t imagine ever hurting her.
id die for my lil bro too.
I believe he was genuinely trying to end her suffering, but he should have reported the alleged abuse.
Like how you died for Anakin
@@skeeter1858 I love this
A child loves unconditionally.
Detective: Why didn't you just call DCFS?
Keith: I didn't have their number.
Right😂🤦🏻♀️! He is a psycho
I can't imagine how mentally damaging it was for the police officers, brother & paramedics to see such a horrific crime scene. That poor innocent little girl. My heart breaks for all involved. This kid obviously had some kind of psychotic break to do what he did. It's sickening & disturbing what humans are capable of😢
They ARE mentally damaged. Look at the Abuse implications, Keth even didnt understand. I dont know what got him to do that, but in this interrogation hes way more symphathic than these psycho"cops", whos jobs is lieing and manipulate people. Even we EWU guys are mentally not very healthy to look this for entertainment.
PTSD is coming for sure
Yeah especially those who saw it raw. So sad. May she RIP.
It is sad but far from uncommon =( I dont even know what to say. I hope he was lying but he really seemed to believe his own story. Perhaps that little girl was suffering already. Dark family secrets are pretty common as well. But to use that as justification to kill the one who is suffering....
"He is much bigger and stronger than me" does not hold water when the weak party has the element of surprise and a weapon at hand... This case does not make any sense... Senseless violence wherever you look, so damn tiresome...
@@NPC-jt3gp and when the guy youre accusing is 14 it doesnt make sense
watching this, I realize that I couldn’t do this job. staying this calm, comforting him, asking the right questions … you really need nerves to be able to do that.
I guess that's a call of the heart. I mean, people must be able to put those monster in the jail.
I think about that sometimes... How hard it must be to even be the arresting officer in cases like this or where they finally catch a sadistic serial killer or serial Г@pist... I'd have never been able to do that job
Lol yo forreal im sitting here wanting to beat the brakes off this kid
I used to work for the probation service. I know the feeling of having to distance yourself. You imagine that its like watching a film, not real life. Its the only way you can do it.
Compartmentalizing helps a lot, there was an incident where i tried convincing a belligerent drunk driver that i was not going to let him through to a overly populated area, i was waiting for the police to arrive to apprehend him, he began ramming the gate then proceeded to speed off, when i found him later on location his body had combined with the passenger side window as he wasn't wearing a seatbelt the vehicle had torn him in half and the top of his scalp, popped open and his cerebral fluid was leaking from his nose. I remember seeing his wallet, cellphone and keys laid perfectly in a row next to his corpse. And i remember going around his vehicle and just remembering his tires had real good tread. I turned in my report to my supervisor and the veteran on duty told me "next time let em out, wouldn't have to fill any paperwork out.."
... Years later and multiple engagements in South Dallas survived. I still remember the smell and think about the treads on the tire.
I don't understand how the parents were not more aware of his behaviour and personality. Him telling his parents that someone was trying to hurt his sister should have been a massive red flag and taken seriously. A good parent would question who, and they would have great concern if their child was making it up.
He never did.
Plus, he told them he wanted a weapon to shoot the alleged abuser? What did the parents do about it? I think there's definitely something off about them
It seems he was accusing his brother. He had a 14 yr old brother.
@@henrygallas8645 did he say he told them he wanted a gun to shoot the person he was accusing? I didn’t catch that. I thought he said he just wanted to by a firearm and his mother said no. I don’t know. My take away is there’s something off with him.
Like who is around their children that’s raising such concerns.
As the father of a 4 year old I cannot even imagine. I can't even describe what I feel when I hear this and it's not even my child. It hurts my soul and I don't even think we have a soul but it's still in pain
I know what you mean ! Totally heartbreaking !
Man this is really hard to watch ! 😩
For a dude with no soul you’re awfully emotional
“Why are you killing me?” Chilling and horrifying words to be uttered by an innocent 4 year old girl to her older brother
I agree,😭
Imagine the guilt his brother must feel for leaving his sister alone with that monster. It isn't his fault but I'd never be able to forgive myself
Appears like Keith is claiming his brother is the abuser
@@stwcrewldn exactly my point
@@MichaelErnest666 What point? Your comment makes no sense. You have to make a statement before you can say “exactly my point”.
@@SimRacingVeteran Oh No It's Okay 🤗
@@stwcrewldn it does sound like he’s saying “his br-“ when they trying to bleeped
Seeing that little Angel's blood on him throughout the whole interrogation broke my heart more 💔💔. RIP baby girl 👼👼
Kind if crazy they did that
In 2049, he will be your neighbor. 👍😬
Me too. BIG time.
It took me about 5 minutes into the interrogation to realize that was blood. I couldn't believe they left the pants on him. With that much blood they would usually make him change before interviewing him. This whole thing is completely mind boggling and so sad 😔
@@c.daniels3413 it took me longer and same thing with me. I couldn’t believe they left those pants on him. 😞
I had a neighbor who thought a young relative was molesting her granddaughter. Every time she gave that little girl a bath she’d lay her on the floor and splay her open & ask people if it looked like the 2 yr-old had been violated. I wanted to tell her what she was doing was a violation to the little girl.
Wow. My daughter's father SA'd her, so this sickens me.
That absolutely violated that little girl.
"You okay?"
"Yeah"
"How you doin?"
"I'm fine"
"You hangin in there?"
"Yeah, I'm fine"
I don't think any of us could imagine saying that after killing someone. Even after confessing to the crime and complying there's no way a sane and good person could be fine. Truly fascinating in the worst way possible.
S t a g e d ??
Maybe cause not even the victim realize wa gwarn , he just a answer accordingly.... smh.. he cah act...
They were most likely automatic responses, I highly doubt he meant them
@@syklystevens2581 uhh...what? what was staged? what did the victim realize? who's acting?
it’s how like if someone asks you how your doing the most common response is i’m fine or i’m good even if your not type thing
Shock has a role in the responses
I think this kid was the abuser. He seems like he was very excited about watching her. The mother didn’t want him to babysit her anymore. There’s a reason and he’s not saying that part. He was protecting her….from himself.
When asked if he had any inappropriate relationship with his sister he answers no but with a smirk that's very-very strange
Yup
I thought the same thing. He is the abuser. I hope he gets arse smashed in jail.
My thoughts exactly, he would've eliminated his whole family had he gotten that gun I bet.
Tbh I don't see the smirk as strange. Some things are just so unbelievable someone could think / believe you did something you just smirk/laugh it off just because it's so stupid in your head you simply can't believe it no ? I mean I think so at least, i'd even say I act so too x/
As the father of an 8 year old, this is extraordinarily difficult to watch without immediately crying.
Ditto. I couldn't begin to imagine and don't really want to. Not sure I'd ever be the same again.
wow, you can only feel anything about this if you relate it to yourself? sociopath alert
@@auto1nfanticid3 Don't be a moron.
Two daughters and two granddaughters here and this level of evil is beyond my ability to contain my rage and sadness
It’s truly horrifying. There’s no way to prevent something like this, that’s the scariest part
“Why are you killing me?” I actually just all feeling in my body and my heart just dropped. To think of that poor little kid in such pain and confusion in that moment just genuinely broke me.
This may be the only case I have ever listened to that has genuinely made me nauseous, its such a conflicting stance to know that he may have actually thought he was helping her escape the abuse while also knowing that he inflicted something much worse onto her. There is definitely a mental issue at play here, and I only hope that the other brother finds some peace though all this because that is some devastating trama.
Too me it is important to know if that was truly the reason he did it, because if it's true what he says then the steps going forward should be more than just locking him away. It should be future prevention, making children aware that if someone is in a situation he claimed his sister was in that there's help, another way out.
@@jadegrenade8287 facts
@@jadegrenade8287 i agree 100%
People don't understand psychology and most people will claim mental health this bad just deserves to be put out of its misery. Thats sad because people are not born evil. Something is always the cause that makes someone lose their ability to rationally look at a situation and know its wrong.
In this case, he knew that through whatever television and movies teenaged kids usually watch that slitting the throat is "supposed" to be quick and painless. But he did not premeditate. He did not look up how to actually do this, and when he realized how difficult it was he did get scated. You could tell in his response he felt remorse and he openly admits what he did was wrong and even though he had good intentions he realized (sadly too late) that he did inflict much pain on his sister.
One thing I noticed, the officers where trying to find a rational reason for what he did. Which makes about as much sense as him doing this in the first place. He was not rational. And they tried to say her shirt was pulled up to the neck, which may mean he had sexual desires. But anyone with a lick of common sense could tell he covered her neck because he was truly ashamed at what he had done. It was not quick and painless. She screamed and she cried. And at that point he lost all his senses and just tried to get it over with. He had no idea what he was doing. And you are right that since he got a regular prison sentence, he will not recieve any type of therapy. He may go on to injure someone else, or himself in prison. And even if he does not, he will be released in his 50s. Which means he is perfectly capable of doing this sort of thing again.
Not all psychopaths are manipulative murderers. People live with this mental illness are live relatively normal lives with lots of therapy and occasionally medications (however, more often that not its the opposite,in which case the medications are only subduing their impulses and they are not learning how to deal with the real world such as they would be in actual therapy)
honestly its kinda driving me insane you even for a second believe his lie, if anyone was sexual abusing his sister it was likely him. He's saw her as an easy target for a first murderer and by the time it was done realized he was in over his head. There is a REASON his mom did not allow him to watch his sister.
@@cherachapin3826 The path to Hell is paved with good intentions.
Those "four minutes of pain" must've felt like an eternity to that poor baby. How in the world can anyone do such a thing?
@bonnyismydoggy6426 If you read some of the other comments, you may begin to see how a teen, who doesn't have a fully developed brain & lacks the ability to fully think thru a horrifying, emotionally complex situation, could make this bad choice when he felt backed into a corner. To some, sexual abuse & rape, especially of a child & particularly sexual abuse that is ongoing, and "torment" as he calls it, is WORSE than the decision to take the person's life.
This is a mercy compared to other crimes commited on 4 year olds. But it still doesnt make it okay. She had gone through a lot. Rest in peace.
@@FreedomAndJustice4All No, vast majority of people possess this thing called empathy all kids except antisocial kids possess it, what you are describing is a psychopathic behavior, and brain develops until the age of 25 - 30 should we permit crimes until the age of 30 on the account of underdeveloped brain? We should probably modify consent laws to the age of 30 as well after all pleasure centers of the brain don't develop until the age of 22.
@@FreedomAndJustice4All if that was the case you’d see more of these types of f’d up things between family members. 99.999% of teenagers know the difference between right and wrong
I can't imagine what her parents would think if they heard this. Your own son whom you love killing your daughter who you love. So tragic, so much emotional pain.
Ion think they love ‘‘em anymore tbh
truly a spoiled kid. Probably neglected, too.
I would renounce my son and send him to hell.
@@mazraelventacus914 Same! Wicked ass son.
I'm sure the parents have seen/ heard this interrogation. His mother likely will be in his corner no matter what, regardless of what he did. She already lost her daughter, probably looks at it like she doesn't wanna lose a son as well (as messed up as that seems). The father, however probably hates him with a passion, seeing as though he killed his daughter. I'm referring to HER father btw, not his.
Why is this video titled "this is what a psychopath looks like" and then you say this is atypical behaviour from a psychopath.
proper ganja
they love to slap random diagnoses onto every suspect without them actually fitting the diagnosis. they probably think it makes them sound more professional, but to anyone who knows about abnormal psychology knows they're just using pop psychology definitions that aren't based in fact but rather misinformation based in decades old ableism.
Because he is still a psycho?
@malachiholder351 your comment is just proof that this channel is just based in 1950s pop psychology, ableism, and copaganda. That kind of opinion is the reason why institutionalization is going up every year. People with mental illnesses deserve rights and respect.
Viewing a criminal case through the lens of "this is what mental illness looks like" is just inaccurate since the vast majority of people with mental illnesses don't commit crimes, It leads to mental illness being seen as so bad it needs to be locked away forever instead of treated with compassion, which in turn leads to people such as victims of abuse or people who live non-standard lifestyles to be institutionalized, and sometimes chemically labotomized like in the case of Amanda Bynes
Totally agree
I have a form of psychopathy/ASPD from a frontal lobe traumatic brain injury I sustained as a child. I have worked very hard in therapy for over 15 years now because my parents recognized there was something not right after my accident (cracked my skull open when I was 4 years old) through therapy I can intellectually understand empathy and have respect for right and wrong. It’s very hard for me to form deep connections with people and most of my emotions aren’t very deep or lasting in any way. I had issues with the law because I did have a drug issue for a number of years but I was just trying to feel something more than nothing all the time. If you know anyone you may think is having a hard time therapy can help(even in extreme situations like mine) I’m just glad my parents recognized the signs.
Yeah bro be careful. Your more likely to do something crazy... be careful. Study Jesus and his Gospel. Youll understand how demons whisper things in your ear.. keith listened to the voices... your not crazy brother. Fight the good fight
@@jonnhyappleseed7498 I’m not schizophrenic I’ve never heard voices. I would know any signs of a psychotic episode I’ve had one. And as far as religion goes I don’t believe in a god or demons. No worries I’m quite self aware.
Take care man. I was gonna suggest you to access your spiritual side or try to get in touch with Jesus. But since you mentioned in the previous comment that you're not spiritual, I will just say take care man. I'll pray for you. I'm in therapy for depression. I understand how hard these things can be. So hold on man, we're rooting for you. I'm sure you're meant for great things in life.
@@jonnhyappleseed7498 nobody cares gtfoh
@@BloodSweatandFears why tf do people bring Jesus into this. I’m 100% sure people with no religion have better morals, something about their logic.
as a father of a 5 and 1 year old little girls hearing how she smiled at him so innocently and then he proceeded to killing her it damn near unbearable...
@GZues_Christ wth, how is that funny.
@GZues_Christ It's actually pretty nice outside, you don't have to be afraid of it.
@@Jesus__Christbut it is his business
@@Jesus__Christ ya never know it could be
@@Jesus__Christ well then let’s not assume
I've watched many interrogations but this one was probably the hardest one to watch. Little precious girl being murdered while trusting his brother and dying in shock asking why is he killing her. I shed a few tears there. That is just too much for me. My niece is 4yo and i just cannot imagine how on earth he could herm her. I would protect my niece with my own life if needed.
You cannot imagine it because your brain has a fundamental sense of reality, conscience, etc that 99.9999% of all humans have. But there is a tiny chance that something goes catastrophically wrong in the brain, through nature or nurture (or both) which makes some people see a completely different version of reality and commit unimaginable acts. Keith's brain seems to flip randomly between having a conscience, feeling guilt, feeling remorse, but still justifying murdering a 4 year old and describing it in gruesome detail (while still believing he loves her). Whatever mental condition this is, I highly doubt any amount of time in prison will fix it. It seems to be some kind of bizarre mix delusional disorder, paranoid schizophrenia, psychopathy, sociopathy, etc. A pure psychopath doesn't feel any remorse or guilt, but Keith clearly does feel these things to some degree. It is impossible for normal people to imagine doing such acts or even relate to them, because this isn't a normal functioning brain.
Obviously you are not a psychopath.
@@evaburnz She´s not a golfer either
aint no body care abt yo niece
No one asked
This one really hit home for me , and I’ve watched dozens of EWU videos .. given I have a 4 yr old daughter right now I can’t even begin to fathom someone hurting her. She’s the sweetest most innocent little soul u can imagine as are most 4 yr old little girls. I can’t understand how her own older brother could do this. The one person who is supposed to protect her no matter what.
Same, I couldn't finish watching this. And wondering whether I even should.
Same and I have a son almost his age. Something really wrong here, there is no way to square it.
Same here, I thought I could handle watching, but my stomach says otherwise. It's too painful to handle. He's pure evil and acting he cares and loves her. My baby boy is the same age 4yrs. I think watching this can traumatise us.
I have a beautiful smart as can be purest soul of a baby girl also 4 and my brain won't even let me think about her being hurt.. this fact alone should convince everyone in pure evil and should really motivate everyone to always be aware of your babies and protect them as much as humanly possible until they can protect themselves.. no little girl should have to endure something like this. I pray she found eternal peace and love quickly and has no memory of this disgusting fungus of a human
My gut feeling says HE was the abuser, and killed her to cover up his crimes.
Two minutes into this and had the most awful chill throughout my body - 4 years old. Lying in a pool of blood , ‘multi coloured sweater and pink shoes and socks’ Honestly feel sick already. As a father to a little girl turning 3 tomorrow , this just breaks my heart. Good rest her soul 🙏
I hope she lives a long happy peaceful life
I had to skip through him explaining the details. I could never imagine my little girls hurting or suffering from anything, let alone something so sinister.
@@yoyo-lf3ld shut up
God bless your little girl bro
This is nothing. Think of all the elites in the world spit roasting little kids and babies, and high fiving each other.
We cannot appreciate you guys at EWU crew enough. Every video is a masterpiece, better than the previous. THANK YOU.
Yes sir
I get paid to smoke weed & get high on my TH-cam channel lmao…
THANK YOU SO MUCH YOU GUYS!!!
@@SevenHunnid ok
The fake voice is overpowered though, so hard to keep track for me.
There are many cases where a child grows up with being abused, but instead of them realizing it’s abuse, they think it’s normal because it starts at such a young age. I believe he was abusing her, she was 4. She didn’t understand it was abuse. He made sure to tell them she was beautiful and he loved her. She was his best friend. They were very close. People are saying it’s about the gun but I don’t think you’re looking at the bigger picture. He was abusing her, and his parents didn’t listen. He couldn’t admit it out loud. I think he did want the gun, maybe to end himself instead. When he couldn’t get the gun, he decided to go with a knife and maybe couldn’t do it himself. So he decides to kill his victim to end his urges.
I think you are spot on
Yeah that’s exactly what I was thinking. It was also his half sister so it makes even more sense to me. I don’t think a person who finds out his little sister is getting abused , first instinct would be to go tell their parents but rather hurt whom they ever did it.
My thoughts exactly
What a sick son of a bitch... Hope he rots in hell. God bless that little girls soul ..
Yeah, but he wasn't worried that an autopsy might show something if she was being sexually abused (by him). He didn't seem like he was too worried about it. I totally get what you're saying though. I thought of that too. Very Very weird case, right? I don't know if I've ever seen a case like this, and I watch all kinds of Crime Drama shows. It just has a crazy vibe!! It's not just the case...it's HIM that is creepy because of his nonchalance attitude.
I am so sad and nauseated hearing this. That poor little girl, I have a 4 year old little girl who is the light of my life and can't imagine this.
After watching this, and reading that the coroner found ZERO evidence of sexual abuse, I feel like he was suffering from delusions. Possibly on the spectrum of schizophrenia, but certainly a form of psychosis. And it may have very well been from his own interest in her that created this delusion. I think it was unimaginable to him to abuse her in that way and when he couldn’t stop thinking about her like that, and being confused by a delusion that some other person was doing those things, he felt like he needed to get rid of the possibility of harming her. In his mind, 4 minutes of suffering was more humane than being sexually abused by her brother. He seemed too eager to plead guilt to be a psychopath.
yes i think he's delusional by murdering her it will make her, his forever
Yeah, I concur, he doesn't appear to be a psychopath.
That‘s exactly what a psychopath does lol
@@ratoecin7250 theres a difference between having psychosis and being a psychopath
I think youre absolutely spot on.
This one made me question myself on why I watch these interviews. I was absolutely devastated after listening to him recount what she said to him during the attack. That poor innocent happy child that doesn’t even know what evil is yet just wanted to paint with her big brother.
@@dbptwg Jeremiah 17:9
[9]The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?
I wonder why I watch them too. Studying evil, I suppose.
It's to understand the Human Condition, the narrator constantly throws out "disorders" which I've studied in 1st yr psych, but there is so much more nuisance than that. Don't worry, when you study psych, most text prompt you not to start diagnosis yourself or others. buy a textbook if your interested, they are usually better than any yt vid.
God is funny.
Me too
When he said that the knife wasn't a weapon or anything, I don't think he said it because he was trying to distance himself from the crime. He meant that the knife wasn't the kind of knife that was specifically designed to be a weapon, the kind of knife that you buy in a store that sells weapons. He was saying that he didn't specifically want to kill her with a knife, and the knife was just his closest option considering that he wanted to do it quickly to "protect her".
Thank you, I'm glad I'm not the only one that caught that
I was just coming here to comment this!!!
Yeah he was saying it as like a "it's not a combat knife"
@@qhoulss there always are
Yes.
WoW. Makes no sense... This boy is seriously sick. He should never be free.
Thank You & Best Regards
The thing that baffles me in terms of how the detectives were attempting to see if they could find a new motive for Kieth, is that they didn't attempt to question him about the prior abuse of his sister from another family member (Specifically how she was abused/what parts of her body/approximately how often/etc). It would have been much easier to catch him in a potential lie there, which would open up other possibilities for his motive. It's insane to me that they didn't dive into those details and specifics. Not to mention, I know they keep blurring the other family member's name, but it almost sounds like it's his own brother who he's talking about... Even though he's extremely adamant in saying his brother is innocent. Doesn't make sense. Also, I think the fact that police found those lyrics rewritten is a major major red flag. I think someone else in this family is guilty of something very sinister as well.
I thought the same thing. I will have to watch the video again but I believe they had said the 14 year was out with the parents. If that is correct then there are three boys and one girl.I also remember him saying that the one that was abusing her couldn't have any sugar because of the way he gets and that her abuse had been going on for two years. And that he had told his parents about it. How or Why did the investigators over look this ??
I was wondering too why they didn't dive into that more after he said it several times, the only logical reason, in my mind, for them to not ask more about the abuse(r) is that they didn't believe him in the first place and looked at it more as a distraction from what he did or to justify it in some weird kinda way, idk.
Im also wondering why they didnt dive deeper. The one thing that made me think it was a family member is he said multiple times he told his parents what was going on that they told him "don't be a snitch." He seemed pretty open the whole interrogation so i don't see why he would pick that to lie about. Even if its not his brother it must be someone close to the family for the parents to brush it off like that.
I think it's likely TWO other brothers - a family of three boys and one girl. An interrogator used the word "brothers" at one point in the video. The one present was not the one Keith thought abused Sabrina. I think the other one was implied to have been out with their parents that night. If I had to wager...older/eldest brother of the family, maybe with drug problems.
I agree. I was thinking why there were no questions about the abuse that was happening to her which brought on his decision
One time I was hanging out with my brother and his brand new friend. My brother leaves the room and we are not doing anything just sitting there watching tv, his friends face turns angry and he starts punching me as hard as he can in the arm then acts like nothing happened. I forced him out of the house, I knew he was dangerous. I didn't stop telling him to leave until he was out. A few years later, he wrapped his car around a pole. The security video showed he took the turn at 45 miles per hour without braking. He had no concept of the forces he was in control of and paid with his life. I truly believe I dodged a huge bullet by never letting him come over ever again.
Or maybe buddy was getting a sick drift in and the car got away from em
So quick to judge your fellow man
@@EVAASIVEOne and how would you describe the punching in the arm situation (if its true)? Just practicing MMA?
What a whacko
@@tiagomendes5505 Was he One Punch Man or something? lol
I cry eevry time!
I have a 6 year old daughter, and this is hitting way too close. I have been very desensitized to murder stories, but a couple of them involving children always get to me more than the rest. This one is going to be another that sticks with me.
Bro you need to stop watching this shit then.
Comments like this worry me. People only care if a child dies. When adults die people are just indifferent
@@enricozemmourez6153 desensitized doesn't mean I don't still feel bad for adult victims, or feel nothing for them. Its just a very different reaction. Being a parent, the child victims are just more relatable to me.
@@enricozemmourez6153 he probably needs attention
@Dethtones man thanks for you honesty in your comment I 100% feel the exact same way...
Ps .. we also DO care if adults die it just doesn't effect us the same way.. CA'peesh 👍🏾
He sat right behind the bus driver on our school bus and lived a block away from me. This is crazy watching this after all these years..
if I'm lying then you must know more about the area and kids on the bus right? What color was the half pipe in grasmere park? Who was the fat kid that sat behind Keith with his older crazy meth head girlfriend that followed the bus route in a beat up red jeep everyday?Name of the mom and son owned gyro spot in the strip mall off LaGrange and Willow? When did they put up those condos on Lancaster? Color of our bus drivers hair? And what was the rumor going around school that turned out to be false as to why he killed his sister? I could go on all day mijo @@bullfighterrecords
@@bullfighterrecords yes, he did. I have no reason to lie. I could drop old landmarks in the area and things only someone who grew up there would know but it would go right over your smooth brain.
Prove it
Was he autistic? My theory is his older brother forced him to take the blame. And autistic people are very easy to convince of doing that
@@PabloSanchezTHESecretWeapon ?
God I'm usually never affected by stuff like this. All the shit I've been through in life made me so jaded. But him saying his sister was smiling at him and then asked "Why are you killing me?" I got heart palpitations. I just can't understand doing that... especially if she was hurting and abused. I mean, if his story is true he was the one person she could trust in the world and he let her die completely alone, betrayed, and terrified. Didn't even stick around, just ran off leaving her to her last moments alone and scared. No amount of explanation could clarify to me how he could kill a child, his own sister like that.
Most offenders hide and lie. He just puts everything out there
Some people only learn by visuals or hands-on
Heartbreaking
I literally cried while watching it and knowing what that little girl went through at that age
B
Nm
Nn
The amount of regret this guys brother must have for letting his sister go with him.
i thought he said the uncle had the baby and then he took her down to the basement. I maybe stoned.
I was thinking the same, like damn man terrible
"What did you do to my baby?" That killed me.
@@ianwalton284 🤣🤣🤣 You might be a wee bit. It was the older brother watching the little girl and then Keith took her to the basement. That's when the older brother went upstairs.
I bet the mom is the one with regrets. Sounds like she was allowing some bad things to go on and leaving the kids to fend for themselves.
I believe this boy. This type of flat tone and anxiety relating to family shows just how dysfunctional it was. As someone who came from an abusive home for years I GENUINELY believed if my entire family died I wouldn’t care at all. Because when they don’t care for you correctly you start to isolate yourself and view them differently. It seems like a broken family and whatever happened to him made him think this was somehow the only option. Im not sure how he got there but this is exactly why we need to take better care of children and take them away from bad homes.
I don't. if anything I would say if an abuser existed I would suspect he was the abuser himself and the murder was to cover both, explaining why they might find signs of abuse and giving a reason for the murder other then "because I was afraid she would report me"
Yeah but there's no way to know, and If he is the psycho in the house then he could easily do and say all of this to try and get away with it. I mean he could do or say anything.
Bro, wtf is wrong with you? Do we need to throw your ass in prison also?
@alex4183 I understand you, and I also believe the suspect.
I come from a very dysfunctional family and I deeply understand when you said that you wouldn't feel anything if all your family dies. And I figure you won't if it really happens!
I didn't when I learnt my mother (the biggest abuser, mentally, psychologically, physical from a very young age) passed. I had no emotion whatsever, it felt like a faint relief, but it didn't heal my emotional wounds and consequences I deal with throughout my life. Demons are still there.
I figure that also my grandma is dead by now (I had no contact with all of them since the late 80s/early 90s, God thanks!), but it doesn't affect me. She was the only one who was a little friendy with me, but she didn't stop the abuse, nor anybody else.
Back to the case on hand, still I can't fanthom how the boy arrived at murder as the only option. Though it can be relatable to a certain point.
Same, and a great point. Thanks for speaking it out. I've actually wrote the same comment in one of the previous videos, but I got censored by youtube.
The truth is, those sickening behaviors of a child are always a product of their parenting. If it's a healthy family, and there's no abuse happening in it, and you are giving enough care and attention to your child, then it would be impossible for something bad to come out of it. However, if there's abuse in the family, then it's a no brainer that his life will be f'd one way or the other.
I got abused, and thrown away on the streets at the turn of 18 years. There's so many things I could have done. But lately can't find any motivation. I wish I just had a normal family. But at least I can warn other people online, that if they want a good child, it's not rocket science, just care about your child and don't abuse him/her. If you can't provide that, then don't have a child.
He was very consistent with his story, even when they asked in different ways.
About 10 minutes in I started to get the feeling that he was being inappropriate with his sister and he killed her out of fear that she would tell somebody. So he figured it was better to kill his sister under the false justification that he was the hero for ending her suffering than exposed as an 18 year old sexually assaulting his own sister.
Thats what i thought too but now it seems like he did it because of the firearm situation
I agree 100%
Yeah I thought this immediately .
Just watch the rest they talk about it
@@jaimevalencia6271 I watched the whole thing but I also understand that some information never comes to the surface... there are thousands of unsolved cases due to missing or unproven information
It takes a very special kind of person to be an interrogation officer. How to stay calm the way they do after hearing what this piece of rubbish did to his 4 year old sister, is beyond me.
Yeah. I wanna do something like that when I'm older but things like this make me want to vomit
Man I wouldn’t handle it (interrogator: being patient when u know what happened) especially when ur talking to the killer of a young child. I think I’ll lose my mind and do the same to him
You have to be in control of your emotions. And I don’t mean to be one of these officers. I’m talking in general. No one is truly in control of their emotions now days. Although I’m not either.
It doesn't take a special person lol
@@sarah0706 Did you notice his pant leg? I wouldn't be able to stop staring at what looks to me to be blood, that poor little baby's blood...
This is the sickest act I've seen. Brutally slaughtered his sister to save her. It was beyond comprehension when he was talking about what she said and did as he killed her. How can the mind of a young man be so sick to do this!
Ok, I THINK I am kinda starting to understand his train (wreck) of thought:
Keith thought that his little sister was being abused. So, he asked his mom if he could get a gun. He wanted the gun to use on the abuser and to stop the abuse against his little sister. He needed the gun because the abuser was stronger than him and only a gun would stop the abuser. He acknowledges that he WOULD have gone to the police, but he didn't have any evidence of the abuse and knew the police wouldn't be able to do anything without the evidence.
When he didn't get his mom's permission to get a gun, he reasoned that the only other way to stop the abuse was to end his little sister's life. He reasoned that 4 minutes of pain, ending in death, was better than daily abuse. So he killed his little sister with a knife, to end her suffering.
His reasoning is... dementedly logical, but extremely limited! Why not focus on getting the evidence FOR the cops to help? Why not kidnap her and take her away from the abuser? Why not get a gun without permission? His logic is extremely narrow and can't seem to form complex conclusions. Plus, his morality is a unconventional. He has abuse worse than death. That isn't necessarily uncommon for victims of prolonged abuse, but him making that decision FOR a victim is extreme. Either he has extreme empathy (placing himself in her position), was being victimized himself (was projecting his pain and using her as a surrogate), or has a god complex (knows what's best for others).
And you actually believe him? He was probably the abuser. He was jealous of her .
@Will Dazey I don't agree with his story completely to be honest... Although it appears that he is telling the truth for the most part, the extended investigations by the police proved that she wasn't being abused, or at least there WASN'T any proof... I think it's something far more sinister... In other words, there was no "abuser", it was his delusion... Him convincing himself. He said that his sister was "laying" on the ground to paint... that could be some sort of grooming. Or at least his "thoughts". maybe he couldn't see himself doing it or ever hurting her in that way, so he chose to k*ll her instead... which is heartbreaking... I felt something break inside me when he said that she started screaming and crying and saying "why are you killing me"... How could anyone ever do such a thing... I believe he's telling the truth for the most part... But it could be something far more sinister and we will never know.
Somewhere in the back of my mind, I can’t help but think that Keith was abuser himself.
Yeah i always deduced psychopath is just another way to say stupid. And that "psychopaths dont have feelings" didnt make any sense to me. But i guess psychopath is more like stupidity or ignorance in the realm of taking into account somdbodys feelings.
@@lettiegrant9447 Not even once did I read in this comment that they agreed with him at all and how you could even jump to that collusion is completely bewildering, The comment was simply a logical breakdown/explanation as to what the boy had running through his mind. No agreements, just plain factual black and white thought process.