Hey, thanks for the tutorial. Unfortunately, you skipped a step, which means it no longer works for me. You skip the part where you connect Voronoi B(5:51). You can't see or understand what you've connected it to. Unfortunately, I get the message for Solid Intersection: "Boolean Intersection set is empty"
I know it is already too late, but the voronoi is connected to a relay that is connected to the scale node. I ran into the same problem, you can spot where he connect it to later on in the video. it's very easy to miss, took me an hour to figure it out.
First of all great Tutorials - keep it up! Secondly I'm stuck at 5:26 because I dont know which bounding box/brep I need to insert in the *Voronoi 3D* component
I searched and looked and it is the last thing of the very first group, the scale note. It goes into a relay node and then into B from the Voronoi note. Sadly it still doesn't work
Hello, do you know why the connection between the voronoi 3D with the solid intersection doesn't work?? the error message is " the booleen intersection set is empty"
hello...firstly love your videos...thank you much...they are so very helpful. I was actually doing a project using this tutorial of yours, but I am getting "Boolean Intersection set is empty" error and the solid intersection is failing. Can you please help me with that.? Again thank you for all your videos❤❤
I also got the same problem. I put connection from Brep to Breps B and connection from Voronoi 3D to Brep A in Solid Intersection and error disappeared.
I'm having an issue with my model. Not sure if it's because I started with a brep instead of a subd. Everything works up until the multipipe command converting to a mesh body. The multipipe populates but the mesh does not. Any advice?
I am stuck at 3:09 solid intersection. It says Boolean intersection set is empty. Also when I click on SubD it doesn’t show the outline of the helmet, just shows the box. Please help
Is it possible to create the this Voronoi structure inside a sharp edge box? I've been trying to create it, from Box -> Mesh - > Subd from Mesh -> Subd .... and all the process you've showed. However, I just can't create it inside a sharp edge box
hello sir, thanks for your great tutorial I wanna ask you how to keep some edges that comes form a brep object, then I can create and conbine edges at whever I want. Hope your response thanks
I am enjoying the lecture. I did the same thing as before with the basic subd box object of Rhino, but there is an error in solid intersection. I don't know why, could you please tell me?
Glad you enjoyed it, if you get intersection results while getting an Orange Warning, leave it and proceed to the next process. It will be fixed after the Point filter process. But if you don't get any intersection, possibly, you could try out flipping the brep (in case the face flipped).
Fantastic tutorial. I see in your final render there are some deformations. Also can the mesh be closed for 3D printing? Did you 3D print the red one at the start of the video? Thanks again.
can someone please help me at 10:46 , where "smooth, interior" is typed? when i do that and plug it into Member Index, I get an error saying that the 'M; value is empty
Hi all, I need some help: I followed the tutorial, but I found that there are unjoined parts of the voronoi. This causes an open mesh. How can be done to eliminate the tubes that do not join?
I think i know what your talking about, is it the part where he skips a step, so you end up not knowing where the Voronoi bottom part is connected to. It's connected to the relay that is connected to the scale node. (you can spot it at 10:17, where he zooms in you can see where that connection is connected to). Took me an hour to figure out what I was missing. (total 3 hours)
I have a problem with the gh-parallel script: (5:35) I have set input_b of the script to "access list" because "object of type GUID has no len() [16:1]" But then I get this error: "1. Error running script: System.Guid value cannot be converted to System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep] in method Rhino.Geometry.Brep[] CreateBooleanIntersection(System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep], System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep], Double) [16:1]" I double and triple checked, the script is identical to the one shown in the video. Everything else works perfectly.
The error you're seeing typically occurs when the script is expecting a Brep but is receiving something else, Make sure you set the Hint for both inputs to Brep (Right-click on each input, select Hint, and choose Brep)
i have a qustion "why the Voronoi 3D and Multipipe" is red in grasshopper? Voronoi 3D says 1. At least a single valid point must be supplied Multipipe says 1. Solution exception:points must contain at least 1 point
Basic question - I have a stitched bumper in step format in Rhino and it is shown as ' 1 open poly surface's in rhino command window. Not able to 'set as one sub D' . Am I missing any conversion for subD input before starting?
@@3DBeast Thaks! Also in minute 4:49 how can I test if each point is inside? And in minute 5:24 Voronoi 3D got more connections but theres no explanation about what happened, so maybe you can help me
Hi, I know this video is a lil old and I'm just trying to make something like this to make a 3D print but I'm trying to use something that I've designed in solidworks ¿How should do I import the archive?
This is an interesting way to make carbon fibre structures. Say making bicycle parts. First 3d print the swiss cheese structure, then poke in long straw in either the x-axis, y-axis etc. or even in rings like a coil. Then put in the carbon fiber in the straw. Next pull out the straw but leave the carbon fiber remain in the cheese. Repeat the process to insert more fiber until the structure is full. The final process is to impregnate the cheese with resin. Such structure should be stronger than other methods.
So I don’t know if it is a hardware or software issue but once I get to the voronoi 3D part it just lags like crazy, takes a solid 5 minutes of loading once I’m at the merge component and I put it in the voronoi 3D. I have a Ryzen 7 4000 series with an rtx 3050, maybe it’s not optimised enough for grasshopper although I usually have no problems using other softwares like blender, clo or even rhino in general. By the way great video, the explanations are really well done.
I've had the same problem! did you found a soultion without using dendro??? I played with all the parameters but the problem is still there. It come out from the "remove unecessary edges" step.
Is there a way that I can organize that lattice without using voronoi cells. Of course the answer i the classical lunch box tools or reparametrization for even surface subdivisions. Are there any other strategy for the same voronoi cells but organized? I'll work with the classical gradient triangulations. :P Besides this is example opens the pandora box to more complex structural systems that are organized and those that are randomized. Optimization may come later. As usual, 3D beast being 3D beast. :P
Yes, indeed! You can experiment with the point placements. The randomness comes from the randomly generated points. You can try out an organized point grid for a more structured result.
Finally, figure it out, the "Merge" component's output must switch to the "Flatten" mode to exactly merge two bunch of points together, which allows the "Voronoi 3D" to generate the correct cells.
For all stuck at ,,BOOLEAN INTERSECTION'' error quote ,,Boolean intersection set is empty''. U need to put G output of the ,,SCALE'' component of the Bounding box set to B input in BOOLEAN INTERSECTION''. That should solve the problem.
agree, I added "Python 3 Script" and copied the text, renamed the connections to a/b/c, and it shows the script-running error "name 'b' is not defined". When I connect Brep and Voroni to Python, I get "1. Error running script: object of type 'Guid' has no len() [15:1]"
good, but very complicated to use Grassopper... it's a task for a visual programmer, not for the average Rhino user. (it's similar in BLENDER). Playing with Grassopper is not for everyone.
This would be good except that it goes so fast I have to watch the same section 10 times to try and capture everything that's said in a 10 second clip.
Hey, thanks for the tutorial. Unfortunately, you skipped a step, which means it no longer works for me. You skip the part where you connect Voronoi B(5:51). You can't see or understand what you've connected it to. Unfortunately, I get the message for Solid Intersection: "Boolean Intersection set is empty"
i have the same issue
Same here
I know it is already too late, but the voronoi is connected to a relay that is connected to the scale node. I ran into the same problem, you can spot where he connect it to later on in the video. it's very easy to miss, took me an hour to figure it out.
I feel this is one of the first and only good grasshopper beginner tutorials.
First of all great Tutorials - keep it up!
Secondly I'm stuck at 5:26 because I dont know which bounding box/brep I need to insert in the *Voronoi 3D* component
I searched and looked and it is the last thing of the very first group, the scale note. It goes into a relay node and then into B from the Voronoi note. Sadly it still doesn't work
I selected everything and then pressed on the mouse wheel and then on the play button that says "recompute" suddenly everything worked.
@@jukama7671 Thank You, I don´t know how You fidure that out but yes thanks!
Good timing, I love your videos bro. Keep up the great work 😁
Thanks! More to come :)
Hello, do you know why the connection between the voronoi 3D with the solid intersection doesn't work?? the error message is " the booleen intersection set is empty"
Apparently, there are several of us at this dead end. A hint from the author would be most welcome!
@@fluxcapacitor try increasing the distance of the points group command to 1.5, worked for me
@@harrywall3045did it really work? I can’t get mine to work either 😊
i selected everything and then pressed on the mouse wheel and then on the play button that says "recompute" suddenly everything worked.
5:25 what did u put in box input in voronoi 3d?
Did you find out?
Per object - box
it is the great video!!
but I'm stuck at 10:48 because I cannot understand the smooth,interior means
hello...firstly love your videos...thank you much...they are so very helpful.
I was actually doing a project using this tutorial of yours, but I am getting "Boolean Intersection set is empty" error and the solid intersection is failing.
Can you please help me with that.?
Again thank you for all your videos❤❤
same problem
I am also facing the same problem
So am I. It’s not working
Did you manage to do it?
I also got the same problem. I put connection from Brep to Breps B and connection from Voronoi 3D to Brep A in Solid Intersection and error disappeared.
I'm having an issue with my model. Not sure if it's because I started with a brep instead of a subd. Everything works up until the multipipe command converting to a mesh body. The multipipe populates but the mesh does not. Any advice?
I am stuck at 3:09 solid intersection. It says Boolean intersection set is empty. Also when I click on SubD it doesn’t show the outline of the helmet, just shows the box. Please help
I solved that problem simply changing the imput order of the wires haha
@@danielmonforte9669 can you please elaborate im stuck at the same spot :((((
Is it possible to create the this Voronoi structure inside a sharp edge box? I've been trying to create it, from Box -> Mesh - > Subd from Mesh -> Subd .... and all the process you've showed. However, I just can't create it inside a sharp edge box
super detailed tutorial,love it
wondering if i can recreate the same pattern with nurbs?
hello sir, thanks for your great tutorial
I wanna ask you how to keep some edges that comes form a brep object, then I can create and conbine edges at whever I want. Hope your response thanks
superb explanation, keep up the good work
Thanks, More to come
I am enjoying the lecture.
I did the same thing as before with the basic subd box object of Rhino, but there is an error in solid intersection. I don't know why, could you please tell me?
Glad you enjoyed it, if you get intersection results while getting an Orange Warning, leave it and proceed to the next process. It will be fixed after the Point filter process. But if you don't get any intersection, possibly, you could try out flipping the brep (in case the face flipped).
@@3DBeast thank u🫡
@@이승민-b5q8hdid it work?
Fantastic tutorial. I see in your final render there are some deformations. Also can the mesh be closed for 3D printing? Did you 3D print the red one at the start of the video? Thanks again.
I have this a s a hobby, so well explained!!! Better then the most others.
Huge Respect!
Best Tutorial on youtube!!!!!!!!
whoa!!! this was the best tutorial ever!!
Hey! I am stuck at "3:09" solid intersection gives a message "boolien intersection set is empty" how to proceed?
Same
Same
3:03 im stuck at this part. It doesn't show the pattern on my project just the box
preview off the box
can someone please help me at 10:46 , where "smooth, interior" is typed? when i do that and plug it into Member Index, I get an error saying that the 'M; value is empty
//smooth, interior
type it exactly like this
why change the volume to area? i dont get the point there. I see that when use volume component the solid intersection cant functional.
Hi all, I need some help: I followed the tutorial, but I found that there are unjoined parts of the voronoi. This causes an open mesh. How can be done to eliminate the tubes that do not join?
I think i know what your talking about, is it the part where he skips a step, so you end up not knowing where the Voronoi bottom part is connected to. It's connected to the relay that is connected to the scale node. (you can spot it at 10:17, where he zooms in you can see where that connection is connected to). Took me an hour to figure out what I was missing. (total 3 hours)
@@mrmb380thank you for your comment. It works
Thank you for sharing this amazing video
You’re very welcome! 😊
@@3DBeast thank you
this is the best way to model caves for lvl design in games
I'm stuck in minute 5:00, don't know how you got the box with the true list
you don't need it
how you fix it? im stuck there
Is there any way to get the mesh in a way, so one can further work with it? Like cutting it with a nurbs volume? Thx
This is so amazing!
Thank You!
I have a problem with the gh-parallel script: (5:35)
I have set input_b of the script to "access list" because "object of type GUID has no len() [16:1]"
But then I get this error:
"1. Error running script: System.Guid value cannot be converted to System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep] in method Rhino.Geometry.Brep[] CreateBooleanIntersection(System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep], System.Collections.Generic.IEnumerable`1[Rhino.Geometry.Brep], Double) [16:1]"
I double and triple checked, the script is identical to the one shown in the video.
Everything else works perfectly.
The error you're seeing typically occurs when the script is expecting a Brep but is receiving something else, Make sure you set the Hint for both inputs to Brep (Right-click on each input, select Hint, and choose Brep)
@@3DBeast that solved it.
Thank's a lot!
i have a qustion "why the Voronoi 3D and Multipipe" is red in grasshopper?
Voronoi 3D says 1. At least a single valid point must be supplied
Multipipe says 1. Solution exception:points must contain at least 1 point
i stuck in the second quest too, did you solve it?
@@yulin2520 and u ?
What voiceover software did you use in this video? It sounds way better than some of your older ones.
this is so nice , thanks for your detailed tutorial , love it , followed.
👍
Basic question - I have a stitched bumper in step format in Rhino and it is shown as ' 1 open poly surface's in rhino command window. Not able to 'set as one sub D' . Am I missing any conversion for subD input before starting?
select the surface in rhino and type tosubd, that should make a copy of the surface and convert it as a subd
I love the video! Could you please mention the file format you have used for the helmet ? i bring a step file inside and not able to 'set to 1 subd'
Hey, stuck at 1:08, how do you put the counter?
Just double-click the canvas and enter the value for the counter-aka, the number slider.
@@3DBeast Thaks! Also in minute 4:49 how can I test if each point is inside? And in minute 5:24 Voronoi 3D got more connections but theres no explanation about what happened, so maybe you can help me
@5:18 to what did u connect the voronoi 3d box to ?
Hi, I know this video is a lil old and I'm just trying to make something like this to make a 3D print but I'm trying to use something that I've designed in solidworks ¿How should do I import the archive?
Welcome back
Thanks for the warm welcome! More exciting projects coming soon
goodlooking interface of rhino
u r amazing bro, this is the best video
No me funciona, dice “boolean intersección set is empty”
Porfavor si alguien puede ayudenmeeee 😫🙏🏻
Nice, I like using Dendro over multipipe to mesh curves.
Thanks. voxel based is another alternative. but don't give good mesh topology.
Please, share the grasshopper's file 🙏🙏🙏
This is an interesting way to make carbon fibre structures.
Say making bicycle parts.
First 3d print the swiss cheese structure, then poke in long straw in either the x-axis, y-axis etc. or even in rings like a coil.
Then put in the carbon fiber in the straw. Next pull out the straw but leave the carbon fiber remain in the cheese.
Repeat the process to insert more fiber until the structure is full.
The final process is to impregnate the cheese with resin.
Such structure should be stronger than other methods.
So I don’t know if it is a hardware or software issue but once I get to the voronoi 3D part it just lags like crazy, takes a solid 5 minutes of loading once I’m at the merge component and I put it in the voronoi 3D. I have a Ryzen 7 4000 series with an rtx 3050, maybe it’s not optimised enough for grasshopper although I usually have no problems using other softwares like blender, clo or even rhino in general.
By the way great video, the explanations are really well done.
Super helpful, thank you!
Good job！！！, can you share the resources that support downloading SubD models?"
yes , in the description
Thank you
You're very welcome
Can it work on nurbs poly surface ?
very cool! i noticed the resulting mesh is an open mesh. Is there a way to ensure the resulting mesh is closed?
Run it through dendro!
I've had the same problem! did you found a soultion without using dendro??? I played with all the parameters but the problem is still there. It come out from the "remove unecessary edges" step.
solved it!!!!!!!!! the secret is in the power of breps!!!the differences between subd edges and breps edges is real
Is there a way that I can organize that lattice without using voronoi cells. Of course the answer i the classical lunch box tools or reparametrization for even surface subdivisions. Are there any other strategy for the same voronoi cells but organized? I'll work with the classical gradient triangulations. :P
Besides this is example opens the pandora box to more complex structural systems that are organized and those that are randomized. Optimization may come later. As usual, 3D beast being 3D beast. :P
Yes, indeed! You can experiment with the point placements. The randomness comes from the randomly generated points. You can try out an organized point grid for a more structured result.
Can i replace voronoi cells with other determined lattice structures？And make some interference effects？Looking forward to a reply，thx
thanks a lot! for some reason in my file the stracture is a lot more dense unlike what seems to be 2 layers in the video, care to shed some light?
How to make point of brep true??
I keep having merged line after merge, what to do?
fixed
Is this method suitable for the sphere shape subD? There are always some weird sharp burrs outside the sphere lattices, I just can't figure it out.
Finally, figure it out, the "Merge" component's output must switch to the "Flatten" mode to exactly merge two bunch of points together, which allows the "Voronoi 3D" to generate the correct cells.
Stuck at multipipe, object reference not set to instance of an object.
Hi I have a moroccan dome to be modelled in grasshopper can u plz help me?
This is awesome!
For all stuck at ,,BOOLEAN INTERSECTION'' error quote ,,Boolean intersection set is empty''. U need to put G output of the ,,SCALE'' component of the Bounding box set to B input in BOOLEAN INTERSECTION''. That should solve the problem.
bravo Ognjene !
I still can’t get it do work there
Is there a way to make it into a closed solid?
wait what? Blender and Grasshopper is possible?
grasshopper works fine with Mac? every plug in works ok?
i did everything right, step for step. but it doesnt work, pls help
HEY, Do you provide the script from this video ?
wow , thank you very much
...I don't know if someone is still stuck on "Boolean Intersection set is empty"...I've join Voronoi 3d into Brep A and Brep into Brep B and it works!
It works. Thanks
No me funciona:(
I did that, but it did the inverse. Did this happen to you as well?
THANK YOU!
Do you feel that the computer is caton when you use grashopper?
Does it have to be a subd, or can i use any solid?
you can use brep. He even converts his subd to brep in the video.
brilliant !
superb... 👍
🙌
hi, how to use gh python paralels?
agree, I added "Python 3 Script" and copied the text, renamed the connections to a/b/c, and it shows the script-running error "name 'b' is not defined". When I connect Brep and Voroni to Python, I get "1. Error running script: object of type 'Guid' has no len() [15:1]"
Great.
thx for tutorial . can make tutorial for lattice insole
Can this hat be manufactured?
The real question
I did a pavillion for a project in spain, wish I had this video 2 months ago lol
Lovely ❤
I don't have factor as a command in grasshopper
you r greatfull
good, but very complicated to use Grassopper... it's a task for a visual programmer, not for the average Rhino user. (it's similar in BLENDER). Playing with Grassopper is not for everyone.
did anyone got a good result out of this video?
thats cool
I followed everything exactly but there is no result as it was in the box.
Try not graphing the solid intersection parameter
@@Ssimone202how do I do that?
@@benjamincffoster4574 Just leave it as it is
This would be good except that it goes so fast I have to watch the same section 10 times to try and capture everything that's said in a 10 second clip.
Mariotte siphon
Thank you