What Payman Quitting Labor Says About Australia’s Political System | 10 News First
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ก.ค. 2024
- The biggest political issue right now - a Labor Senator ditching the party over Palestine - can seem a bit disconnected from your daily life.
But it matters, it goes to the heart of some big issues in this country - how we respond to diversity, to differing opinions, and whether all Australians can be heard in our political system.
Watch 10’s Late News weeknights at 10pm AEST.
Subscribe to 10 News First to get the latest updates and breaking news: bit.ly/37DDbL1
Join the conversation and follow us on:
Twitter: / 10newsfirst
Facebook: / 10newsfirst
Instagram: / 10newsfirst
TikTok: / 10newsfirst
10 News First airs at 5 pm, seven nights a week in your local market on Network 10.
Missed the bulletin? Catch up at 10play.com.au/news
10 News First is based in Australia and is a division of Paramount.
A law must be made immediately, while it is possible, that faith based parties is not allowed. Change the constitution quickly.
No one should be allowed to swear allegiance to our parliament or nation on a koran, no-one.
She cares more about Palestine than Australia. Let's give her a free ticket there.
No religion in politics , otherwise we wouldn’t have issues like now!!
@@maryioannucci9874
That's a concern for other countries that are involved in the bronze aged mentality of Waring your neighbours ...it'll never end in the middle east ...it's not an Australian governmental concern
It is totally about religion and therefore not something anyone can solve ...becoming a part of it is simply throwing fuel on a fire
@@maryioannucci9874 .... Jews are also Palestinian people , difference is they are not Arabs ..... They have every right to form safe communities , towns and a country ‼️
Is lamb very much political,pork not so much.
@@maryioannucci9874nope
@@harleydavidsonstreet5560 Someone deleted my comment.. why ‼️❓I was neither rude nor obnoxious 🤷🏻♂️‼️❓❓
She should never have been allowed to enter an roll in parliament, As she as dual citizenship,
The host and the guest appears to know zero about Islamaphobia. They use the term without understanding its origins and the connotations of it. Educate yourself.
Dutton did not single out those candidates! He listed them amongst several other groups that could form part of a minority government with Labor.
Dutton''s head is , infested with Islamophobia, an incurable disease. What Dutton has to realize is that Christianity was not of their decent/origin, though it was IMPOSED on Europeans despite apparent incompatibility with their pop culture. All major religions originated in Middle East not in Europe, and they all co-existed long before Europeans( the culprit of ALL chaos we see today around us) messed it all up and created chaos. That is the fact Dutton is ignorant of. They took over the Christianity, distorted and made it appear as something of their own by putting cosmetics and decorations on it. Prove me wrong !
Get her out of government
The Senator was elected to represent the interests of Western Australia and west Australian's as a member of the Senate not her own personal issues.
Australian politicians need to start worrying about Australia not other countries
How about supporting genocide ? is that ok ??
@@gauthapandith
How about two tribes still fighting over a desert a couple of millennia later
Quite tragic really
@@gauthapandithDon't want anything to do with it, get it?
@@gauthapandithand how about go and fighting for the country you live, which clearly isn't this one
@@gauthapandith You miss the point completely m8, we need to worry about ourselves more & not other countries like Israel, Palestine, Ukraine, & in the past; Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, Korea etc.
As long as we have Australian kids that are waking up on an empty stomach then going to school without eating, wearing worn out shoes that never fit in the first place & a shopping bag for a school backpack, we need to worry less about other countries & more about our own. As long as we have people that are homeless, struggling to afford a house & food, we need to worry less about other countries problems. As long as we have indigenous & outback communities that need help with the basics for life, we need to worry less about other countries issues. As long as we have emergency room wait times in multiple hours & people waiting months & months to get surgeries done, guess what? yeah we need to worry less about other countries & more about our own. As long as we have tragically broken men killing themselves due to the last wars we sent them to, then maybe we should hold off on actions that could lead us to sending more of those young men to be maimed, killed or come back with broken souls.
When we have basically fixed or severely reduced things like, poverty, homelessness, veteran issues, when we have the healthcare system running the best it possibly can & all the other problems we have in this country sorted out, then yeah sure, we can send more non lethal aid & civilian support to countries that are our neighbours like PNG, Solomon Islands, East Timor & all our other Island nation neighbours we have that can benefit from out help.
Finally once we have got our own nation & it's people sorted out & we have done the same for our neighbour nations then yeah we can start sending the same non lethal aid & civilian support for other countries outside of our nations sphere of influence. I think it only fair that Australia's politicians prioritise looking after Australians first.
Labour is shocking. We need to vote for independents
Absolutely agree 👍
One Nation
Independents can't change anything. A wasted vote. How about ready parties policies and then chosing. Then you get change.
@@cactuscake1323 Nope. But you must have figured that out by now.
Radical Islam is the snake hiding in the grass,
Moderate Islam is the grass hiding the snake.
Radical Judaism is the snake hiding in the grass
Radical Christianity is the grass hiding the snake
White supremacy is the snake hiding in the grass boyo.
@@K.T.Nasiri And yet, Christ said, "whoever is free of sin can throw the first stone". Whats-his-name said, "stone her". > 'Without lies, islam dies'.
All religion is holding back humanity…… humanity only advanced dramatically once science overruled religion…
@@K.T.Nasiri taqiyya?
A dual citizenship person doesn't have the right to be in our government
Or to fight in a foreign war and then return to this country.
Thanks to Labor
The tribe wanted it as they have double agents spanning the Globe.
Funny how this was not a problem 5 minutes ago and conveniently raised by her own party who want her out.
So true.
She's a dual citizen and therefore should not be a Federal Government office holder in this country. It's a criminal offence and she should be thrown out of office and prosecuted. All monies she has received need to be repaid and she should be stripped of all entitlements.
Funny how this was not a problem 5 minutes ago and conveniently raised by her own party who want her out.
@@johncrow5552Yes, she was fine while they thought they could control her. Those in the party that knew she was a dual citizen should be gone also, they're all as bad as each other.
@@larstorders9695 After this happened a few years ago, how can it still be an issue? The excuse is she couldn't revoke it due to the Taliban. So? She is still a dual citizen! You cannot make use that as the excuse to let her run....and then turn around and call her a dual citizen when you want her gone. Politicians really have no morals.
Wait til you find out how many dual citizenship politicians we have
Would not be allowed to.. Under Labour's party rules. Never go against the party. If you don't want faith-based policies. I need to stop inviting heavily religious people into the country.
Been concerned that the minority may become too influencing on the majority.
First of all, the labour party needs to be none religious supporters by not supporting a state that wants to create a religion called Judaism. That also supports those who occupy others' land and filling with European DNA and simply colonisation by killing innocents. Even in israel, DNA tests are not allowed to make sure not to expose these European invation. While supporting Zionist child killer her dual citizenship was OK, but now it's an issue. If Australians are true to their apology toward aboriginal people, then first avoid supporting extremist colonial Zionist, then treat all Australians equal by giving freedom of speech. She is leaving labour as labour fails to support humanity and not because she wants to create a religious party. Clean the dirts in your body that you say others have. In fact, while supporting religious fanatics, Australian party leaders are becoming jokers.
If you get elected by people who supported you for being Labor and then resign. Then resign from parliament until you can stand as an independant and test the electorate.
She should not keep her position in the senate. The labor party won the seat not her
She was voted in to represent WA,not Hamas.
She is confused about why she was elected. Its about the running of this country not another country, its not about disrupting our Government.
🤨 but the weak government allow us to!
Lol,what government. Australia is a joke
Religion and politics should not be mixed. She also has dual citizenship - that's against the rules. She should never had been allowed into Australian politics for that reason alone, in the first place. I remember years ago when different politicians lost their place or had to give up their dual citizenship.
Funny how this was not a problem 5 minutes ago and conveniently raised by her own party who want her out.
@@johncrow5552 Everything that Party does, makes me trust them even less.
It's not damaging our system no elected personal should stand up in our Parliament house for another country. This is Australia this is our parliament not for radial & religious purposes.
Why would Labor not support its own policy platform?
It is sad for Australia that political division in country is caused by some overseas problem which has nothing with Australia. If that is working principle and because Australian society is so diverse it is very much possible that any overseas issue and they are many btw would shake Australia profoundly ! Should we really allow such things to happen importing overseas problems?
Actually.. if Australia is sending Israel weapons and aid through elbit systems military contracts. Pretty sure “that has something to do with Australia” that’s my taxes.
The vast majority who belong to diverse culture should listen to Ben Habib. From a diverse culture, his view on diversity is most realistic when moving to the new country that one must embrace and not use for various reasons, not betray but to value peace.
Im so not interested in this, i decided to watch the u k elections...too much time has been devoted to her
Free speech is not Islamophobia 🤦♂️
Free speech on Palestine is a democratic move guaranteed by the constitution
Al-Takiya is a very effective way to deal with those who oppose extremist ideology. Playing Victimcard is a hallmark in Al-Takiya and once in the majority your enemy is either crushed, converted or forced to live as second class citizen. Australia is only a handful of Countries which has survived thus far either because of tough immigration laws and its Geological location. Look at Europe and UK. They have gone past beyond repair. Hold these politicians accountable else we are toast
Diversity is a con, we need a less diverse and more united country.
Do you want to bring back the white Australia policy?
Nothing to do with race all about being Aussie first @@beesplaining1882
Diversity is not the problem here it is politics.
what scares you so much about diversity given humanities eternal migration and sharing of genes? What is it about a world no longer solely represented by isolated tribal values but digitially driven global ones that you find it so hard to accept? Get a grip of yourself . History moves forever onwards.
@@matersingh4403 Are you friends with everyone? No! You are friends with peeps who share your values and interests. Thats how "tribes" form. From tribes you get countries.
usman is hardly popular with anyone other than woke fascists, like C10's employees
Woke fascists? Isn't that a contradiction?
@@freeman10000 nope, fascism is national socialism, the woke are not internationalists, so they are fascist
Does diversity include people who aren't supposed to be there in the first place.
@@djlow2398 diversity… “only if you parrot our point of view”
Love to get Payman's take on the LGBT situation.
What this nation needs is a leader who puts the nation first and not his party...We have a leader who puts his party first and not the nation..All the signs of a one term goverment.
She has duel citizenship, she must be kicked out of parliament if she doesn't cancel one of them just like others have had to do to be in parliament, no exceptions.
Labor (and the coalition) want the same thing she does, a 2 state solution. They just have more diplomatic ways of achieving that goal. She is not from Palestine which means she is crossing the floor for religious reasons. Religion should stay out of politics. Religion has no business in politics, and it is because of religions we have killing and hatred like whats happening in Israel.
The statement that religion causes wars is an old party favorite but that is an infantile argument. Wars are always about resources, religion or ideology is just the sales pitch.
@@-rx3wy sure, by the leaders that's true. But for the rest it's the true meaning and excuse for atrocities.
Any news about the Liberal Party’s diversity issue? Or One Nation’s?
It's not about politics it's about money.
She aint gonna give up all that money...
Who really cares. ! Seriously
@charl, Australians, obviously. No need to ask if Australia is where the true loyalty is....Question say a lot don't they....?
Centrelink do they have this "We care" motto
I never vote in labour party any more more than of labour support in my 40 years
What it tells you is that when you elect someone to represent Western Australians they expect you to represent Western Australians not the people of Palestine.
So true. As an representative of your Australia community, your loyalty is to Australia, not any foreign entity
Proof that youtube comment sections are full if idiotic dribble.
@@jjing6548Your literally saying this as both labour and liberal party leaders openly confirm to have received funds from “Israeli lobbyists”. Our politicians are being purchased and your here calling a bench crosser a foreign agent 😂😂
@2gunzupPAC She's a literal foreign agent though.
What's the problem?
@@matlenaghan7488 that would make the whole greens party who raised the motion to recognise a Palestinian state foreign agents.. a recognition mind you that has already been undertaken by 146 countries around the world.
Separation of Parliament from Religion and Faith is important for a Westminster type Democracy we have in this country. Afghanistan is not a fine example of Democracy and Hamas leadership needs to explain what they did with the billions of dollars they received through UNRWA except building tunnels under Gaza and bombing Israel while living in five star luxury in Doha, Qatar .
The only Diversity we need is the one without those who not embrace Australian values and system.
Go Go Senator Paycheque.
What's the point of dual citizenship?
Have allegiance to the country you represent
Sen payman does not address all australias on the issue of the holy lands Israel!
If she disagrees with the Australian government's policies, she has the option to leave the country.
The Australian government are in the minority when it comes to recognising the Palestinian people.
What ?
@@Wefdog85 so what
@@Martinoconnor-du6lc so why would someone leave a country where the majority of the population agrees with their views?
I disagree with the government on a lot of things but should I leave the country? I am an Australian, where do you suggest I go?
Well done Labor for kicking fati out ❤❤❤-vote 1 oz
We need to vote for a labour party out. We are not buying Islamophobia anymore or any wokenes😡
Please lets keep church and state separate lest we end up like the US.
Its simply ...go against your party
-lose your job
Its that simple ...its not some indication of a larger problem
Its called having a lack of loyalty for your team ...and its a fitting punishment for being ludicrous and thinking you are more special thay your team
@@oftin_wong spoken like a true man that would go down with a sinking ship.
@@2gunzupPAC
I wouldn't be a politician
I'm too creative ...but like any team
If someone goes against the tribe
They get voted out ...simple
Lets make the this molehill a mountain cause ratings
We were told diversity is our strength....
Barbaric bronze aged mentality surrounding religions are never going to make a strong society
Only weaken them and make room for a lack of smarts
I don't agree for what you say but I defend your right to say it
Bullying
Faith-based politics? Your policies allowed it into the country. Now, get used to it and other surprises that come with it.
Is lamb the problem?
Anthony Dorknese......one gene away from being Mr Garrison.
why would the muslims ever vote Labor when they are all actually very conservative?
a: because it's about power.
LEFTIES
She is beyond selfish.
Genocide is OK by you then?
@@maryioannucci9874Go over there and support their cause if you are truly concerned, it is not an issue for Australian Politics or taxpayers support.
@@evil17 your ignorance of our complicity is irrelevant.
@evil17 it I'd an issue for decent human beings. Genocide should not be condoned.
@@evil17 go over there? Actually our tax dollars and weapons are going over there to commit this genocide. Is that an issue regarding “our tax payers and politics”??
Sectarian vote now.
We never voting for labour.
Nobody cares.
Hello nobody.
@ana. WRONG. True Australians care, Only True Australians Care.
She did the right thing. Australia's position on Gaza is nothing short of disgraceful. unity should not be more important than morality.
Absolutely ❤❤
If over 150 countries can recognise Palestine inc the most recent ones (Ireland, Spain and Norway) and the Australian Labor party can't than it shows who is pulling the strings
❤
Exactly, and the imbeciles I see posting comments like "She was elected to represent Australians, not Palestinians" shows how imbecilic the general population is. Because the policies that Australia follows matter on the international stage.
If these idiots were thinking about Australia's interests as an ethical national actor, they wouldn't be blindly chastising a woman for crossing the floor for common human decency.
@paul, what complete and utter garbage! Sharia Law out!
For God's sake. This is not about religion. it's about basic humanity. At least Payman has the courage of her conviction and that qualifies her above and beyond and the forelock tuggers in the corrupt two-party system.
You know when an issue is of genuine concern, not only to the country but the whole world. That is where both parties form a consensus to silence any dissent.
Albanese is pandering to the Jewish Lobby.
I disagree. They are pandering to whichever side of the electorate can benefit them, in whatever region, to whatever belief system. That is why they have opened the borders so much to these people, for their vote.
We proud of Fatima payman .
Haaaa ! By "we" you obviously are not referring to infidels. We can clearly see through her purpose for being in parliament, and it's not for the benefit of "ALL" in her electorate.
“Faith Based” political parties, Chloe? You meant “Religious Faith Based”! Words Chloe! Senator Payman’s position is not based on religion rather it is based on “humanity”.
Surely you jest ! She is too transparent. Her mission here is palpable, and destined to fail.
She is very brave woman.
She is just doing as she is instructed from the imam/mosque, and the koran.
Honourable Senator Fatima Payman displayed to the world the very best of Australia.
LOL, they don't have a diversity issue.
Albaness .
We wait now to rhe people's we are waiting for owers response about owers visa.
Already, you take a new notice with teapect the visas.
crazy from member moss comments
labor is bad policies