I honestly don't understand how they're a Hip Hop group with two rappers. What in the world was Starship thinking, establishing a hiphop group with two rappers out of seven members literally makes no sense what so ever.
+Lisa Tang name a hip hope KPOP group with more than two rappers? Big Bang debuted as one and they have 2 rappers, same with iKON. Black Pink, SONAMOO debuted with the hip hop concept with 2 rappers. Starship did just fine.
I don't know IKON or SONAMOO well enough to say anything about them. I stated that Monsta X is a seven-member band with two rappers, Big Bang is FIVE-member band with two rappers, which balances out. If you do the whole maths and shit, you would clearly see that obviously YG did the whole hiphop concept better than Starship did. Same with BlackPink, they're only a four-member band, so clearly two rappers would make sense. Plus their line distribution is hella good, so again, YG did the whole concept better. And this is just at the top of my head, but I'm pretty sure Block B and BTS both have at least three rappers and is a seven-member band. I hope you understood what I'm trying to say here.
I know they are doing amazingly has a hiphop group, and I am extremely proud of Monsta X and what they have achieved. I just think that classifying them as a hiphop group with only 20% of members being rappers, while 80% of members are vocalist makes no sense, especially after recently watching No.Mercy. It's not that I don't love every member and/or wish to swap them out for anyone else, they all contribute something to the team. I think my comment comes from my bitterness of line distribution within Starship since they have this problem with Sistar, Boyfriend and Cosmic Girls (Although I can't say much for them just yet). Perhaps I was blinded by the unfairness of line distribution and I hope that I did not offend you or anyone else, but these are just my thoughts.
Lowkey annoyed with some of these comments. Yes Jooheon and kihyun got a lot of lines, it happens! As they have progressed as a group, the distribution changes. It all depends on the song who gets what lines and it changes! So yes they got a lot this time, but not always! Thank you for this video however
Well, i gotta say this is like one of the best line distribution of any of monsta x's songs. Im happy because Rush was the song that got me into monsta x :) Btw, the outro song, "That's Cheating" is my fav from The Clan Part 1 album. Thanks for making this video ^_^
Shownu is the only one has unafair lines. Hyungwon, Minhyuk, Wonho need to improve their vocals to have lines. It's not like they'll give lines to somwone who's not stable singing live and not as good as he really need to be. Their lines are distributed base on what their talents are. They record first the whole song, every member does that, and after that they'll give the lines to a specific member who fit the line the most. Sadly, only few lines fit with the visual line
i’m just here because i’ll make a tiktok content about monek line distributions jfjsjdd their distributions have come a long way really, sure they are promoting as 5 now but even their last ot7 release had fairer distributions! that’s what happens when the members have some involvement with the production process, members gets to showcase their strengths 🤩
+Bangtan is my jam xx but in this song the chorus is sang by all the members, so what difference is there in 1:39 compared to all the other chorus parts?
Hey, I have a question/request. My question is: is there a reason the songs are always slightly sped up? My request is that they be normal speed because then I could watch these videos for new songs I haven't heard yet and not listen to them distorted. Or even for songs I like/have heard before, it'd be nice to listen to them normally? Thanks!
+Eric B we do it for copyright reasons. for example, our Astro Cat's Eye video got muted because of copyright since we left it at its regular speed. :/ we had to speed it up and re-upload it because of it. some companies arent as strict but we pitch all of our videos just in case. sorry!! :c
thing is, i’m not mad about kihyun and jooheon having the most lines, my issue is that there could be some lines that could be given to hyungwon and minhyuk. kihyun and jooheon will naturally have the most lines, but i’m tired of starship giving hyungwon and minhyuk next to nothing. i’m not asking to see them be no 1 and 2, just to be able to hear their voices more frequently? idk
Shownu is the only one has unafair lines. Hyungwon, Minhyuk, Wonho need to improve their vocals to have lines. It's not like they'll give lines to somwone who's not stable singing live and not as good as he really need to be. Their lines are distributed base on what their talents are. They record first the whole song, every member does that, and after that they'll give the lines to a specific member who fit the line the most. Sadly, only few lines fit with the visual line
+Dat Panda we have 3 Astro line distributions already uploaded to our channel ^-^ Breathless (th-cam.com/video/SlWpv3bN5yk/w-d-xo.html) Hide & Seek (th-cam.com/video/FAFkjYMULi4/w-d-xo.html) Cat's Eye (th-cam.com/video/U-WyX-H4qQc/w-d-xo.html)
Does that mean the group can't survive without Jooheon and Kihyun......-_-........I really like Kihyun and Honey but they got way too much lines! Only the two sang like 70%of the whole song !
Jooheon has a really charismatic voice. I feel like that's why they always use him for the speaking parts.
People usually bash on Jooheon for having the most lines, but like, Monsta X is a hip hop group so of course the rapper will have the most
I honestly don't understand how they're a Hip Hop group with two rappers. What in the world was Starship thinking, establishing a hiphop group with two rappers out of seven members literally makes no sense what so ever.
+Lisa Tang name a hip hope KPOP group with more than two rappers? Big Bang debuted as one and they have 2 rappers, same with iKON. Black Pink, SONAMOO debuted with the hip hop concept with 2 rappers. Starship did just fine.
+Lisa Tang they're doing amazingly as a hip hop group so i dont understand your reasoning behind your comment?
I don't know IKON or SONAMOO well enough to say anything about them.
I stated that Monsta X is a seven-member band with two rappers, Big Bang is FIVE-member band with two rappers, which balances out. If you do the whole maths and shit, you would clearly see that obviously YG did the whole hiphop concept better than Starship did.
Same with BlackPink, they're only a four-member band, so clearly two rappers would make sense. Plus their line distribution is hella good, so again, YG did the whole concept better.
And this is just at the top of my head, but I'm pretty sure Block B and BTS both have at least three rappers and is a seven-member band.
I hope you understood what I'm trying to say here.
I know they are doing amazingly has a hiphop group, and I am extremely proud of Monsta X and what they have achieved. I just think that classifying them as a hiphop group with only 20% of members being rappers, while 80% of members are vocalist makes no sense, especially after recently watching No.Mercy. It's not that I don't love every member and/or wish to swap them out for anyone else, they all contribute something to the team.
I think my comment comes from my bitterness of line distribution within Starship since they have this problem with Sistar, Boyfriend and Cosmic Girls (Although I can't say much for them just yet). Perhaps I was blinded by the unfairness of line distribution and I hope that I did not offend you or anyone else, but these are just my thoughts.
Yassss they all filled up their names !
IKR THAT WHAT IM ALWAYS WORRIED ABT!!
hyungwon in the thumbnail always got me clickin
ME TOOO . OMGGGG YOUR PIC , I LOVE MUCHHHH . HYUNGWON MY WIFE ♡♡ SKFJKSJFDJJCKD
yas hyungwon my babe
+Mily Morais WIFE IM-
+smexy smexo HAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA
nayan * its kihyun
Lowkey annoyed with some of these comments. Yes Jooheon and kihyun got a lot of lines, it happens! As they have progressed as a group, the distribution changes. It all depends on the song who gets what lines and it changes! So yes they got a lot this time, but not always! Thank you for this video however
Traci Schaefer I agree!
Well, i gotta say this is like one of the best line distribution of any of monsta x's songs. Im happy because Rush was the song that got me into monsta x :) Btw, the outro song, "That's Cheating" is my fav from The Clan Part 1 album. Thanks for making this video ^_^
Jooheon, Kihyun & friends
😂→😞😞→😭😭😭
Hyungwon's aesthetic What song was that?
basically
Monsta 7 Well I.M got lines too, so basically Rap line, Kihyun and friends.
:3
Shownu is the only one has unafair lines. Hyungwon, Minhyuk, Wonho need to improve their vocals to have lines. It's not like they'll give lines to somwone who's not stable singing live and not as good as he really need to be. Their lines are distributed base on what their talents are. They record first the whole song, every member does that, and after that they'll give the lines to a specific member who fit the line the most. Sadly, only few lines fit with the visual line
Follow us on Twitter!
@ HEXA6ONKPOP
Updates, Requests, Future Video Polls, and More!
twiiter.com/hexa6onkpop
At this point I've accepted this might be the most Hyungwon will ever get. *sigh
theres nothing harder than being hyungwon biased ngl
+annyeong chanyeol agreed...being a hyungwon stan is hard
You forgot Interstellar :D
Kihyun in the thumbnail is my reaction to the line distribution
✌ thanks for monsta X 💕🔥 i love your videos
the thumbnail tho 😍
When you don't know where you should look, if it should be at the dance practice, the music video or at the line distribution.. xD
Morgan Morquez ME LMAO
Is Monsta X your jam now?? +Hexa6on
+MsRedambergreen tbh we're monsta x trash... lol. we just havent got around to do their older songs until now~
+MsRedambergreen tbh we're monsta x trash... lol. we just havent got around to do their older songs until now~
YAYYYY NEW VIDEO !!! I HOPE YOU CAN MAKE SPEED'S SONG
I support an unit with Kihyun and Jooheon ❤
Same, have you seen their cover of hold me tight? Or the jooheon a song grandmother bird.... So good
Ohhh that's true!!! I love him voices togheter ♥
they did a song together ''Attractive Woman-Kihyun & Jooheon''
+Lino - oh yesss that's one of my favorite songs.. how'd I forget to mention it lol
2chain❤️
Yeah more monsta x!
i’m just here because i’ll make a tiktok content about monek line distributions jfjsjdd their distributions have come a long way really, sure they are promoting as 5 now but even their last ot7 release had fairer distributions! that’s what happens when the members have some involvement with the production process, members gets to showcase their strengths 🤩
around 1:39 , its wonho's part, isn't it? you forgot it :'(
yes, you right
Isn't that just the chorus...?
+Emily Lee yeah but the chorus is still singing.
+Bangtan is my jam xx but in this song the chorus is sang by all the members, so what difference is there in 1:39 compared to all the other chorus parts?
actually the first chorus is sang by wonho and the second one by hyungwon, i think that only the last is sang by all members
Jooheon ft. Kihyun I.M and others (Not bashing Jooheon, I know they don't really have a say in the line distributions, but just saying)
Wonho is such a good singer! He deserves better my beautiful babe
wow thank you ❤❤
Yay!! Thank you!
woo!! thank you
jooheon, kihyun and I.M feat. some boys
I like this line distribution more than any other songs
can you please do Topp Dogg-The Beat? :)
YEEES
Yes please! Also 100% Want U Back
is it me or do they say "yeah, my shits so clean."
Hey, I have a question/request. My question is: is there a reason the songs are always slightly sped up? My request is that they be normal speed because then I could watch these videos for new songs I haven't heard yet and not listen to them distorted. Or even for songs I like/have heard before, it'd be nice to listen to them normally? Thanks!
to prevent copyright issues. copyright issues can cause the video to be banned on youtube and the account to get striked
+Eric B we do it for copyright reasons. for example, our Astro Cat's Eye video got muted because of copyright since we left it at its regular speed. :/ we had to speed it up and re-upload it because of it. some companies arent as strict but we pitch all of our videos just in case. sorry!! :c
i understand y u like it, but i actually enjoy the songs sped up.
thing is, i’m not mad about kihyun and jooheon having the most lines, my issue is that there could be some lines that could be given to hyungwon and minhyuk. kihyun and jooheon will naturally have the most lines, but i’m tired of starship giving hyungwon and minhyuk next to nothing. i’m not asking to see them be no 1 and 2, just to be able to hear their voices more frequently? idk
jooheon, kihyun ft the others
Stop saying that
Shownu is the only one has unafair lines. Hyungwon, Minhyuk, Wonho need to improve their vocals to have lines. It's not like they'll give lines to somwone who's not stable singing live and not as good as he really need to be. Their lines are distributed base on what their talents are. They record first the whole song, every member does that, and after that they'll give the lines to a specific member who fit the line the most. Sadly, only few lines fit with the visual line
Can you do monsta x white sugar or monsta x stuck???
JUSTICE FOR HYUNGWON,WHY? BECAUSE IN EACH SONGS HE BARELY GETS TO SING MORE THAN 10 SECONDS I'M LOWKEY MAD AT STARSHIP
can you do home run by got7 please?
I want Perfect Girl by Monsta X!!!
Jooheons part 😂😂😂😂 omg throwback to dance mom Shannon
thank youuuu
literally for more than half the video the only vocalist with more than 10 seconds was kihyun hmm.... sounds familiar. Oh yeah, EVERY SONG MUCH
Tysm
I just realized they have different colored shoes and it makes me really uncomfortable
Snuper - Platonic love please! :)
Or a different Snuper song. Any!
I've been wanting that too
Jooheon & Kihyun ft. Monsta X
YASSSS HONEY YASSSS
maybe i'm hella biased towards visual line but for real someone tell starship that they're are not background dancers..
justice for my babies!
DADDIES
good
Infinite back plss
YESSSS
Agree
Isaac Lim YES!!
How can the lead vocal get the last place?
Hello, JinJin! the same way the lead dancer (hyungwon) gets zero recognition for his dancing skills
Muzna I have to agree :')
Because the lines did'nt fit him. Understand?
okay so I'm not exactly in deep with MONSTA X but that song at the end caught my attention and I don't know it. Someone wanna fill me in?
Monsta X - Unfair Love (That's Cheating)
Oh thanks Imma go listen to it then
MONSTA X IS JUST KIHYUN&SHOWNU feat I.M (myyy)&JOOHEON :'(
MY MONSTA X ♡♡♡ JUSTICE FOR VISUALS
Starship vamos melhorar pq.assim não dá ....m
Jooheon's hair tho lol
do astro's hide and seek and breathless
+Dat Panda we have 3 Astro line distributions already uploaded to our channel ^-^
Breathless (th-cam.com/video/SlWpv3bN5yk/w-d-xo.html)
Hide & Seek (th-cam.com/video/FAFkjYMULi4/w-d-xo.html)
Cat's Eye (th-cam.com/video/U-WyX-H4qQc/w-d-xo.html)
+HEXA6ON okay thanks, keep up the good work
i just wanna knoww whos line is the vroom vroom' 😄
amran mohd nawawi wonho
wheres hyungwon I barely noticed him I think he should go solo...
What's the song at the end?
+emily Unfair Love - Monsta X
+HEXA6ON or that's cheating
+Angellife 133 or 빼치기야
Seventeen Chuck pleeease
4th
채물라분
....Wonho....😫😫
Me da depresion ver esta distribución :/
Does that mean the group can't survive without Jooheon and Kihyun......-_-........I really like Kihyun and Honey but they got way too much lines!
Only the two sang like 70%of the whole song !
the typical case of a group with an overrated vocal and and overrated rapper lol
can you do home run by got7 please?
YESS!! or trespass by monsta x