Do-Si-Dos used to be my favorite, but they're not the same. Trefoils used to taste like Lorna Doone's back in the day. I think they changed the recipe for a lot of their cookies.
I feel the peanut butter (that they use now) is what has changed the taste of Do-si-dos. It is like it's a cheaper peanut butter...like a filler ingredient mixed in with less real peanut butter.
Well, it depends on where you live and, which manufacturer makes them, if they don’t come through the ABC cookie company! The other manufacturer makes them the same but, you can tell they aren’t exactly made the same and, nor do they taste the same, the quality just doesn’t measure up to the same! Let me tell, I have had them once and, I ‘m telling you that’s exactly the issue. The ABC Cookie Company for the Do Si Dos they make a crispy oatmeal cookie,the other company makes a similar cookie but, it isn’t a oatmeal cookie, it’s just a cookie! Yeah, I rarely have ever lived where it wasn’t ABC, I seen a taste test also to where they also compared the difference with both the manufacturers! Because, Do Si Dos have been my favorite forever, and, I pay attention because, they will help each other out when, they have a issue with shortages! And,since the pandemic, it has been no secret they to have had shortages in the past few yrs to for that reason. And, I am guessing what that was cause, the ABC Company is the best! I have not tried the newest ones, it’s harder now for me to get them more and more cause, I don’t drive but, I like them all but, I just like that crispy oatmeal with peanut butter the best!
@@yeahokay8229Well, it isn’t like they pronounced, it actually pronounce tree foils but, with one e! Those to are good to if you freeze them and, they end up a tad soft and, you can actually taste the butter in them more!
My #1 favorite is the Lemonades (put them in the freezer or fridge they’re delicious 😋🤤🤤 I promise). I just looked up the nearest place to buy them near me, I’m most definitely going to buy my seasons worth 😂
Should review some popular Trader Joe's items if you have one nearby. Their frozen foods are great and the snacks are great. Their cookies are basically better copies of the best girl scout cookies.
I'm 44, haven't had girl scout cookies in years, but based on what I know and my taste buds, #1 mint, #2 samoas, #3, tagalongs, and #4 the toffee cookies in that order would be my favs... love your show, keep 'em comin'! ( :
Mint chocolate is bomb! They're so good out of the freezer! Since I was kid they're my favorite, #1. #2 the oatmeal peanut butter. #3 the coconut one. #4 lemon. I haven't tried the other ones.
My favorite girl scout cookiees are 3) lemon -ups, 2 )thin mints, and 1) samosas 🔥🔥🔥🔥 I've been eating both thin mints and samosas, since my childhood as a brownie and girl scout, but now I'm an adult, and my flavor profile for girl scout cookiees hasn't changed 💜💙💜💙
Y’all hurt my feelings with the Trefoils, they’re my fave! I would love to see y’all rank ice creams like Ben & Jerry’s, Haagen-Dazs, Breyers, Van Leeuwen, Blue Bell, Mayfield, Turkey Hill, Blue Bunny, etc. You could rank which brand has the best vanilla ice cream, for example.
Too funny 😂. My favorites are the ones you don’t like…trefoils and thin mints. I remember selling these cookies for 50 cents a box. And, yes, I’m over 65 😮
I just went through such hassle to get US Girl Scout cookies and now you’re saying I didn’t get some of the best ones 😢. As a Canadian it’s HARD to get them because they don’t ship to Canada and the website doesn’t take Canadian credit cards. The email for the state GS council also bounced back emails from outside of country. Next year I will have to try and add lemonups and smores if I can source them again
Depending on where in canada you are, can you travel across country lines to come to MN, WI, or some other border states? Several Walmarts & grocery stores (like Cub Foods in MN) usually has a troop outside the stores on Saturdays. Call that state's local Girl Scouts to ask what stores allow troops to sell there.
Selena, If you're going to go through trouble to get them, try the Lemonades rather than the LemonUps. They're so much better; they are baked by ABC Bakers (LemonUps are Little Brownie Bakers). For that matter, the Thin Mints by ABC are also much better than those from Little Brownie Bakers..
I haven't had Girl Scout cookies in years but the samoas were always my favorite. And the Thin Mints are very good when there's nothing else around and you're poor
Hey guys, I don't know if they changed the names this year. Our cookies have different names.(NJ) The tagalongs are called peanut butter patties. The only name that is the same is the thin mints. Rhino I'm with you. They are nasty. My favorite is the peanut butter patties.😂😂
Samoas are my favorite.. Keebler makes a similar cookie. I also like dos e dos( spelling). Just saying guy in the orange hat is off by cutting off the coconut
Samoas is the best cookie and then Thin Mint use to be the next best, but I see they have changed from back in da day. Matthew play nice with your friends 😅😅
Thin Mints are #1. Now, back in the da,y it was the peanut butter sandwich cookies…..when they were the ORIGINAL recipe and called “Savannahs”, The new ones are NOWHERE near as good.
i wish nesquik would bring back the samoa's and thin mint's choco milk... shit was fire! used to get high n slam those milky way slammers also while watching mxc on spike... i can smash a half of a sleeve of thin mints in a sitting n im 38
Best cookies hands down are the Samoas. They are definitely the ones you risk your diet for.
Agreed
It’s not a risk. You know what you’re giving up when them samoas in arms reach. lol
@@tribethedemon1756 😂 Facts
Thin mints are #1. Put them in the freezer. I just ate a whole roll. Everyone i know loves them and I am not in my 60's..lol
Right!🔥😂
Never understood why so many ppl hate on em …🤦♂️
I'll do some strange things for a pack of THIN MINTS 🌿
Yes!!!! I thought I was the only one that put them in the freezer!!! Thin Mints hands down!!
I got some in my refrigerator right now, they're not my favs tho.
1. Samoas
2. Thin Mints
3. Tagalongs
Never tried the s’mores but will check them out!
Samoas are and will always be my best. Followed by the do-si-dos and maybe the thin mints
How DARE you disrespect the thin mints!!😂😂😂 I have loved those since I was a Girl Scout and I'm 52 now. My 2nd choice would be the smores!
I love this show. So different. So many different opinions!!
Thin Mints are Superior!!!!!!! And I’m only 40!!!!! I think it’s funny how yall went from eating half the cookie to the FULL cookie by the end!!!! 😂😂😂
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PURCHASING FROM MY DAUGHTERS! I love this so so much. Thanks again!
I try to avoid girlscout cookies every year but I can’t… they’re just so good. My favorites are adventurfuls, Tagalongs, thin mints, and do si dos.
My favorite are the lemonade 🍋 cookies. 😋
Samoas are my forever favorite but I'm a coconut girl 🥥 However, I do love some thin mints 😊
Do-Si-Dos used to be my favorite, but they're not the same. Trefoils used to taste like Lorna Doone's back in the day. I think they changed the recipe for a lot of their cookies.
I feel the peanut butter (that they use now) is what has changed the taste of Do-si-dos. It is like it's a cheaper peanut butter...like a filler ingredient mixed in with less real peanut butter.
Yes they definitely changed the Trefoils I used to enjoy them with a glass of milk
Well, it depends on where you live and, which manufacturer makes them, if they don’t come through the ABC cookie company! The other manufacturer makes them the same but, you can tell they aren’t exactly made the same and, nor do they taste the same, the quality just doesn’t measure up to the same! Let me tell, I have had them once and, I ‘m telling you that’s exactly the issue. The ABC Cookie Company for the Do Si Dos they make a crispy oatmeal cookie,the other company makes a similar cookie but, it isn’t a oatmeal cookie, it’s just a cookie! Yeah, I rarely have ever lived where it wasn’t ABC, I seen a taste test also to where they also compared the difference with both the manufacturers! Because, Do Si Dos have been my favorite forever, and, I pay attention because, they will help each other out when, they have a issue with shortages! And,since the pandemic, it has been no secret they to have had shortages in the past few yrs to for that reason. And, I am guessing what that was cause, the ABC Company is the best! I have not tried the newest ones, it’s harder now for me to get them more and more cause, I don’t drive but, I like them all but, I just like that crispy oatmeal with peanut butter the best!
@@yeahokay8229Well, it isn’t like they pronounced, it actually pronounce tree foils but, with one e! Those to are good to if you freeze them and, they end up a tad soft and, you can actually taste the butter in them more!
Rank the best french fries next 🤩
My #1 favorite is the Lemonades (put them in the freezer or fridge they’re delicious 😋🤤🤤 I promise). I just looked up the nearest place to buy them near me, I’m most definitely going to buy my seasons worth 😂
You have to put the Thin Mints in the freezer before you eat them. They are 🔥. I’m 27 😂😂
Not everyone's preference. Freezing them mutes the flavors.
Tagalong and thin mints but need to have thin mints cold for me. You guys should do fast food cheesburger ranking
Thin mints nuff said
Lemonades go crazy
Should review some popular Trader Joe's items if you have one nearby. Their frozen foods are great and the snacks are great. Their cookies are basically better copies of the best girl scout cookies.
Samoas are my absolute favorite. Thin mints are my 2nd favorite.
I'm 44, haven't had girl scout cookies in years, but based on what I know and my taste buds, #1 mint, #2 samoas, #3, tagalongs, and #4 the toffee cookies in that order would be my favs... love your show, keep 'em comin'! ( :
Thin Mints!!! 🎉Oh, and I’m not 60!😂
Thin mints all day!
Mint chocolate is bomb! They're so good out of the freezer! Since I was kid they're my favorite, #1. #2 the oatmeal peanut butter. #3 the coconut one. #4 lemon. I haven't tried the other ones.
My #1 are the Thanks-A-Lots. I haven't purchased a girl scout cookie since they discontinued them 😢
Those and samoas are my fav. I was so sad when the thanks a lot were discontinued too.
Adventurfuls are the absolute best! And I love thin mints too!
Anything with peanut butter 🥜 and chocolate 🍫 I'm a big fan of indeed.
Do-Si-Dos are the best and an uncrustable in the air fryer with cinnamon sprinkled on top is so good
You guys should try all the fish sandwiches out right now cause it's alot of them out right now
Which ones
@@MakeItHappen-Media McDonald's Wendy's Burger King Popeye's Culver's
Arby's like I said there's alot of them out there right now for fish sandwiches
I’m 40 and a Thin Mints fan. I only got Thin Mints and Samoas this year. The person that said put the thin mints in the freezer I agree.
My favorite girl scout cookiees are 3) lemon -ups, 2 )thin mints, and 1) samosas 🔥🔥🔥🔥 I've been eating both thin mints and samosas, since my childhood as a brownie and girl scout, but now I'm an adult, and my flavor profile for girl scout cookiees hasn't changed 💜💙💜💙
Samoas. No "s" in there. 😀
I'm late watching this but Thin Mints has always been my favorite.
I ate a whole box of cold samoas by myself the other day. 😔 I have no regrets but I'm back to low carb today!
me too lol
Thin Mints are top tier! Been my favorite since a child. I'm also a chocolate lover, a mint lover, and a mint chocolate chip ice cream lover...lol
Ate a whole sleave of Do si do's...gained 3 pounds. Worth it😅
😂😂😂😂
I’m 44 and I loveeeee thin mints 🤦🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️
For me, my 1,2,3= 1: Samoas. 2: Thin Mint (frozen). 3: Tag-A-Long. Make an icecream sandwich with those!
Y’all hurt my feelings with the Trefoils, they’re my fave!
I would love to see y’all rank ice creams like Ben & Jerry’s, Haagen-Dazs, Breyers, Van Leeuwen, Blue Bell, Mayfield, Turkey Hill, Blue Bunny, etc. You could rank which brand has the best vanilla ice cream, for example.
My absolute favorite are the Thin Mints! I like them out of the refrigerator. 😂 I’m not 60.. I just turned 56!! 🤣🤣
I’m into the Samoas myself. But, the other one’s I can’t lie just may pick up.
Tagalongs are my favorite!
Yall was tripping about those Adventurefuls. I buy a whole case of them. Yall should review Burgers next or Breakfast sandwiches
Have many times eaten an entire box of Do-si-dos in one sitting and lived with the
roof of my mouth shredded for days. Worth it.
Despise Samoas.
Trefoils was my first go to until they came out with the s'mores lol. I think i choose them first and then trefoils and also the peanut butter ones
Too funny 😂. My favorites are the ones you don’t like…trefoils and thin mints. I remember selling these cookies for 50 cents a box. And, yes, I’m over 65 😮
Thin mints are top tier! Especially when put in the freezer!! I've been eating them since I was in my 20s 😂
Matt,make these cookies on your show. Each in a short.
Tagalongs #1 for me but thin mints are next. For sure they don't make them like they use to
Tagalongs, Lemonups, Samoas❤❤❤
Samoas used to be Carmel Delights and they were banging. Thin mints get second place then the lemon ones.
They still are Caramel Delights (delites?) in some areas; ABC bakes them.
I just went through such hassle to get US Girl Scout cookies and now you’re saying I didn’t get some of the best ones 😢. As a Canadian it’s HARD to get them because they don’t ship to Canada and the website doesn’t take Canadian credit cards. The email for the state GS council also bounced back emails from outside of country.
Next year I will have to try and add lemonups and smores if I can source them again
Depending on where in canada you are, can you travel across country lines to come to MN, WI, or some other border states? Several Walmarts & grocery stores (like Cub Foods in MN) usually has a troop outside the stores on Saturdays.
Call that state's local Girl Scouts to ask what stores allow troops to sell there.
Selena, If you're going to go through trouble to get them, try the Lemonades rather than the LemonUps. They're so much better; they are baked by ABC Bakers (LemonUps are Little Brownie Bakers). For that matter, the Thin Mints by ABC are also much better than those from Little Brownie Bakers..
Thin mints are the best hands down and I stand by what I said especially if you put them in the freezer
I was just getting ready to subscribe but then y'all disrespected them lemon joints. That's a no-no. It's on sight, fa real!!! 😁😋
Samoas is my all time favorite!!!
"you can eat the thin mints at my funeral richie" - Howie Benchwarmers 😂😂
lol me! I’m in my 40’s and thin mints are 😋
Thin mints
samoas is my fave and i do like the mint ones cold and yall could try tacos or burritos lol
Tacos sound good lol
I haven't had Girl Scout cookies in years but the samoas were always my favorite. And the Thin Mints are very good when there's nothing else around and you're poor
I meant the peanut butter cookie
That peanut BUTTER 😂
Hey guys,
I don't know if they changed the names this year. Our cookies have different names.(NJ)
The tagalongs are called peanut butter patties. The only name that is the same is the thin mints. Rhino I'm with you. They are nasty. My favorite is the peanut butter patties.😂😂
My favorite is tagalongs.
so do they give them away or throw them in the garbage?
Thin mints #1
Samoas are the 🐐! I love me a good trefoil tho crumbled on ice cream 🍨.
I choose violence today, shortbread are my favorite ❤️
Samoas - been my favorite girlscout cookies forever and i nevere remember the name of them. Just them girlscout cookies.
Samoas are my favorite.. Keebler makes a similar cookie. I also like dos e dos( spelling). Just saying guy in the orange hat is off by cutting off the coconut
The lemon cookies are the best
I just finished a box of Tagalongs yesterday but my number ones are thin mints then trefoils
Thin mints!? Lol
THIN MINTS ❤
Rank Nothing Bundt Cake flavors next
SAMOAS is my favorite!
I love lemon so I vote for the lemon cookies even though I am in the minority ❤
Samoas and Thin Mints. I’m on that zero sugar life right now so… didn’t give into temptation this year and buy any.
The Girl Scout S’mores are the best
Samoas is the best cookie and then Thin Mint use to be the next best, but I see they have changed from back in da day.
Matthew play nice with your friends 😅😅
1. Samoas
2. Thin Mints
❤ samoas are my fav
cant believe no1 said anything about the `glaze situation on the backside` XD
Do a crown royal flavor challenge and a cereal or ruffles chips challenge
Thin Mints are #1.
Now, back in the da,y it was the peanut butter sandwich cookies…..when they were the ORIGINAL recipe and called “Savannahs”, The new ones are NOWHERE near as good.
Samos and Thin Mints are THE BEST! LOL
You lost me with the thin mints lol
body armor taste test perhaps yay or nay?
Lemon 🍋
3.5
I also love a great Homemade fresh Oatmeal Cookie 👍
Everyone hit the like button now now tbh all of em or nasty they need 2 make new ones
Samoas is definitely the best one. I never tried anything else
i wish nesquik would bring back the samoa's and thin mint's choco milk... shit was fire! used to get high n slam those milky way slammers also while watching mxc on spike...
i can smash a half of a sleeve of thin mints in a sitting n im 38
Y'all didn't try the toast yay. Those are my favorite
Do-si-dos #1
Samoas are my jam
The thin mints are better frozen. The Samoas and s’mores are best in the microwave a few seconds.
#1 top row and #2 & #4 bottom row. I really have a hard time putting down #4
🔥🔥
Y'all did chicken sandwiches its only right to do fast food fish sandwiches. See who has the best fish sandwich
Dosidos are the best ones.
Don’t come for the mint now 😂
I fucks with the Peanut Butter
Samoas!!!!
Do a donut review.