If something made god, then the maker would be greater, and "god" would not be god, or this "god" is an idol. God exists for his own sake; an eternal being.
Actually, this question is a dog chasing it's tail: If something made God, and the Pre-something made the something, and the Pre-Pre-something made the...... It never ends.
Yeah, you're right. They like to call it an infinite regression. This of course is non sensible and illogical. We know the universe had a beginning. We know that nothing comes from nothing. It is 100% logical to believe that if EVER there was truly nothing then there couldn't ever be anything. No brainer really. God bless you.
Jupiter rotate every 10.5 hours. Hopefully everybody’s still understood what you were trying to say and I appreciate what you guys are doing! Keep it up until the devil fallen down!!!
@@PJRayment So couldn't the universe itself have existed in some form or another without having any beginning? Who's to say that the singularity didn't always exist? When people claim that "god" must exist after asking "what came before the singularity?", isn't that assuming that the singularity couldn't have just existed without needing a creator? Why assume that a sentient, supernatural deity HAD to have created the universe? The universe just as easily could have always existed without needing a beginning.
@@vanation321 "So couldn't the universe itself have existed in some form or another without having any beginning?" Many scientists used to believe in the 'Steady State' model of the universe, which held that the universe had been around forever. However, that was replaced with the Big Bang model because the Steady State model didn't actually fit the observations. The laws of thermodynamics are against an eternal universe. The 2nd law, in particular, says that the universe is running down, using up its energy. Given that there is still available energy, the universe has not fully run down. Therefore it has not been around forever. It has a beginning. "Why assume that a sentient, supernatural deity HAD to have created the universe?" Because nothing can create itself, and the physical universe had a beginning. So the cause of the physical universe-i.e. everything physical-had to be something non-physical, or supernatural.
@@PJRayment Do you think that "God" is a sentient, self-aware, all knowing and all loving, conscious being who willfully created the universe? Also, is there a scenario in which the laws of physics and thermodynamics as we know it weren't necessarily around during the singularity? Do you also think that every living thing is a part of this god, or that a part of God exists within every living thing? I'm just interested, not necessarily bashing your opinions, I just think that it's impossible for us humans with our tiny brains to even begin comprehending the origin of existence in general, let alone whether or not a sentient/self-aware being is behind it all, or if existence itself has always existed.
@@vanation321 1. Yes, but without the unwarranted scare quotes. 2. Anyone can invent any scenario they want. 3a. No. 3b. No, although it depends on what you mean by that. God is not made of parts. "I just think that it's impossible for us humans with our tiny brains to even begin comprehending the origin of existence in general, let alone whether or not a sentient/self-aware being is behind it all, or if existence itself has always existed." Why do you think that it's impossible? I'm not suggesting that we can completely comprehend it, but I don't know why you're sceptical that we "even begin" to comprehend it. And in fact simply by thinking about the question, you have _begun_ to comprehend it. And why do you consider our brains to be "tiny"? They are among the largest brains known to exist, and have been described as the most complex pound of matter in the universe. Further, many people _have_ thought a lot about this, and have be able to deduce various things about it.
@@dopeydonaldtrump3744, the there's Dopey the driveby word farter. Hey, on the topic of the video, which you're too stupid to elaborate on: So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
@@2fast2block Hahaha Brilliant. Let's continue this conversation because it gave me a good laugh when I read your reply. So, I agree with you ! A supernatural creator is not necessarily bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Great, we agree ! Ok, moving on. Show me any evidence, any evidence at all, for anything supernatural. I'm not asking for evidence of your creator, just one tiny piece of verifiable evidence of anything supernatural. I'll accept any evidence for anything...fairies, hobglobins, gods, ghosts, santa claus....anything, just to make it easy for you.
Evidence is merely your way of testing god. If you believed in god, like many people do. You would have read thou shalt not test the lord. Instead you should ask the right questions when approaching god. After all. If we are to come to him as lower beings we should humble ourselves to his soveirgn nature. What I mean by that is we are inferior to him. Less smart. Weaker. And totally bound by his rules and creation. So just ask him to show you. And he will. I'm not gonna give you evidence because I've already proven his existence to myself through the way I just described so my advice, just ask him the right questions and humble (put yourself below him) yourself.
@@Snowcone-lg3oj It would have been easier just to admit that you have no evidence. I am not going to ask your imaginary friend for evidence that it exists, that would make me as crazy as you.
It can't. Even though it is basic common sense and basic science, they still favor their god did it, the god of nothing, that has nothing as evidence. Then, if that was not bad enough, they call us creatards as if they actually have a grasp of knowledge how the universe was created. Reading the bible, it's interesting how many times Satan's side is proven wrong, but Satan does NOT care about that; he just cares about deceiving.
Scribes were/are paid big money to write about messages that the gods were giving to them, so of course, for each individual scribe to keep writing, was the greatest of temptations. Those many conflicting stories, is why, rather than uniting devotees, the stories divide devotees into right-fighting groups.
@@lewiscarey6984 According to a "Centrist" both left and right are radical. Pertaining to politics, rather than Extreme Left, or Extreme Right ... the word Centrist implies middle of the road ... moderate ... as in "not going to extremes either way." In a country where people vote, the object is, the voters are either for or against certain issues, and for that reason, will vote for either one party, or the other. For instance ... those who believe that abortion offends the will of a god, will be voting for the party that promises to make abortion illegal. While those who want to give women the power to make their own decisions, will vote for the party that promises to keep abortion legal. When it pertains to the subject of abortion, there isn't any middle of the road. Gun control, or the lack thereof is another touchy subject, where voters either vote for one side, or the other side on that issue. I suggest that politicians in the Centrist party, by trying to follow the middle of the road, will ultimately leave the middle of the road; veer off either to the extreme left, or to the extreme right ... which has occurred to every group of politicians that tried to improve the old system for something new, and hopefully more agreeable to everyone.
If you think about this it’s endless like who made god and who made who made god see it goes on forever just like what was here before the Big Bang and what was before that you can say this unlimited times and you would never know the answer or what happens when we die where do we go and when does that end
No,use your logic here if the person or God who made the 2nd God is responsible then who created the first God then Because God has his purpose or in other words God created him self or,the universe created God man+soul+abilities granted to him there may be other possible reasons for the creation of the Omni creator
I did not enjoy the episode of origins tv entitled "who made God " at all. because the episode has nothing to do with answering this question. This question is impossible to answer so why try. The only thing the episode did was say that' it's the wrong question to ask' and say that God is so beyond our understanding that he doesn't need to have been created. Essentially, you're saying or implying that God created himself. but you never come close to answering the question about how that could be possible. All you say is God is super natural so he's not limited to the natural laws of physics we know of-the ones which he himself created. This ,however true it may be, still does not answer the question of "who made God",. You will never probably come close to being able to answer this question. even if God himself explained it all to you , you still probably could never grasp the meaning of it all. where God came from Is impossible for someone with a meager human brain to ever understand . Humans know nothing about supernatural physics . The analogy the speaker used saying that "it's like asking who did the bachelor marry" is irrelevant and completely absurd. The speaker used too many atheistic "scientific materialism " terms like space-time and event horizon. Both of these terms are man-made junk terms based on fake and false theories that are not remotely true. there is no such thing as space time and there is no such thing as an event horizon nor is there such a thing as a black holes which the term event horizon is related to. (It's impossible for black holes to exists, it's just another scientific scam ) there is no space -time . Time and space are unrelated . Time is an independent force upon which everything else is dependent upon . Even though there is some good information within this episode , the average adult would already have known this information. It doesn't address the subtitle of the show at all. It's insulting to ask the question and then say, well we have no answers so let's not even ask that question afterall . and this show is certainly not enough to ever convert an atheist into a believer. This episode should never have had this outrageous subtitle. because the question of who made God is answerable by humans. and nobody else but God will ever possibly understand it . Stop trying to answer things nobody can possibly know other than God himself. My own personal theories are far superior to anything that was presented in this episode . Stop pretending to have the answers for things you couldn't possibly know . You spent way too much time trying to use bible passages to prove your point. God speaks with actions not words, so stop proclaiming the Bible as being the word of god . If some people are too blind to see that gods signature is clearly written within every thing he ever created ,then they deserve the darkness . .
Great response to the question in the title. So disappointing to hear the blatant errors of biblical interpretation that they throw about at the end, claiming that creator is Jesus. No. Jesus was clear. He is a man. He is the Son of God, God’s anointed one. His FATHER is the Creator, the God of the Jews. Yes, the council of Nicea was a huge unscriptural mistake!
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
God is different of the universe. God is eternal, our universe is temporary. God is not material, our universe it is. A universe had yo be created. God didn't.
Another one that can't listen. God was and needed no creation. So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
Yes Brent, why don't you listen. God was and needed no creation ! The same as the flying spaghetti monster. He has always been here. You must be stupid if you don't know that.
@@seminiigreene5792, gee, so you want me to lie. Not just that, it's too bad you were not there to correct God in His MANY verses that He explains what fools do. God should have been more kind and lied too, according to you. I'll go by what God says and speak the truth. You can go on with your stupidity.
It helps to pay attention and not sleep through it. Granted, I don't agree with all they say, either. But it was made clear God needs no origin. God does not need to be made. It's actually a very stupid question. So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
@@dopeydonaldtrump3744, ok, you did one of your famous word farts, "The irony of your comment is obviously completely lost on you." God is supernatural and you're way of thinking is ONLY in the natural. Yet we know creation can't happen naturally. We only have two options and naturally lost 100%, but to you, natural still wins. Now, try to muster up enough gas to make another word fart as if you know what "irony" is.
@@2fast2block 1. god is supernatural ? Prove it please. 2. Which god are we discussing here ? 3. "Your way of thinking is only in the natural" Extremely poor English but I think I understood you and also corrected some of your grammar. And yes, of course I think "in the natural". What else is there ? 4 "We know creation can't happen naturally". Really ? Who is "we" ? You and your mate down the pub ? 5. "We only have two options etc". Options for what ? Options for who made god ? Your poor English makes it very difficult to understand what you are trying to say.
I agree with most of this, but the speaker lowers his credibility by making multiple false statements about science. (1) The speaker said that atheists depend on the big bang. But for thousands of years, atheists insisted on an eternal universe. They accepted a beginning to the universe only when the evidence for this beginning became overwhelming in the mid 20th century. This is one of the cases where the Bible got it right first--the speaker's mistake gives atheists too much credit. Many atheists still desire to remove this beginning to the universe. (2) The speaker says that Jupiter is so big that its day is long. However, Jupiter rotates in less than 10 hours. (3) The speaker says that the moon moves away from the earth "a couple of inches per year." It actually moves at 1.5 inches (3.8 centimeters) per year. These are fairly minor mistakes, but the speaker should be more careful in his words.
THE CLERGY CREATED GOD IN THEIR OWN IMAGE, LITERALLY. ONLY THE CLERGY can officially speak, write, and approve/disapprove of 'God's' words or writings based on heterodoxy (i.e., deviation from accepted or orthodox standards or beliefs), which the clergy also created and is the closely guarded and sole responsibility of the clergy. "God" is their creation and is wholly fictive in character. That alone is sufficient to explain why God, A so-called "all-powerful, all-knowing being, can't speak, write or appear. That's why the clergy's God failed to respond to the fervent prayers of the condemned Jews lined up for the "showers" in the Nazi death camps. Praying to your God will ALWAYS have the same results despite the occasional coincidence or the believer's game of counting the hits and ignoring the misses. The Bible says, “Knock, and the door WILL be opened” (tell that to my dead sister who believed the Bible when it said, "If you ask it in his name, it's yours"). No qualifiers are mentioned other than belief. My firmly believing Christian sister, who died in 2013, was a gifted musician who devoted her life to religious music because she believed. Oh, the irony! Per Occam's razor, which of the two scenarios requires the fewest assumptions? That God is real and there is another totally separate "spiritual world" that controls the physical Universe and is populated by other invisible, "spiritual" beings who are unable to speak, write, or appear, or is it the uncomplicated alternative explanation that the clergy lied and continued to lie about their non-existent, “non-contingent” invention. This is supported by the explicit and ubiquitous lying by the clergy and their apologists that can be seen here on TH-cam in the MAJORITY of the videos with a religious topic. The very people who prohibit the bearing of false witness have adopted lying AS A STRATEGY. People lie to lead people AWAY FROM THE TRUTH. WHY WOULD TRUTH TELLERS TELL LIES? The "spiritual world" cannot be confirmed as genuine, and the power of the clergy's God hypothesis is that it cannot be falsified. The absence of God necessitates the basis of belief as "faith" due to the most critical lack of evidence of all: a God that actual human perceptions and experience can verify firsthand. THIS MEANS GOD IS A CONCEPT THAT IS TOTALLY LACKING IN POWER AT ANY LEVEL OF AGENCY. When pressed, the clergy will even define God out of existence by claiming he is beyond time and space (HOW could they possibly know THAT) before they lose an argument or admit the truth. The Christian habit of claiming knowledge they don't have begins with the clergy. Clearly, the choice is between 1) the clergy lied about God because it gave them power over others and provided a privileged position in society with monetary rewards (a prevalent human motivation), or 2) is it that we must account for an ENTIRE OTHER WORLD that claims that God is in control (but the clergy is incapable of showing genuine evidence to back up their claims even though their God claims involve Biblical assertions about the physical world which can be scientifically tested). Obviously, it is the former. This is the SAME and ONLY plausible explanation for the impersonation of "god(s), by non-Christian clergy responsible for “Sacred Texts” in the worship of the many other gods of which YOU, the reader, are an atheist. It’s the same trick and the same process in Christian and pagan situations. In both instances, the other religions' gods and spiritual beings also cannot speak, write, or appear. WHAT AN AMAZING COINCIDENCE. ALL SPIRITUAL BEINGS, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, WHATEVER THEIR CLAIMS OF DIVINE POWER, CANNOT WRITE, SPEAK, OR APPEAR, AND THE COMMON DENOMINATOR AMONG ALL SPIRITUAL BEINGS IS THE CLERGY, WHO PUBLICALLY PRETEND TO WRITE AND SPEAK FOR THEIR GOD(S). Part of the fraud is the clergy’s claim of “Divine revelation.” BUT THE CLERGY’S GOD DOESN’T KNOW MORE THAN THE CLERGY, WHICH SHOWS THE CLERGY’S GOD TO BE FALSE, AND THAT IS LIVING PROOF OF THE FRAUD THAT THE CLERGY PERPETRATED ON THE WORLD WHEN THEY FIRST IMPERSONATED A SUPREME BEING. THAT THE WORLD’S CLERGY IS THE UNIVERSAL CREATOR AND IMPERSONATOR OF ALL GODS AND SPIRITUAL BEINGS IS AN INTELLECTUAL SLAM DUNK! Claiming that God wrote the corrupt, mistake, and forgery-filled Bible does extreme violence to the concepts of all-powerful, all-knowing and totally invalidates the faith-based postulation of a "Supreme Being." God, it turns out is no mystery AT ALL. OCCAM'S RAZOR RULES. Nothing can be more contrary to religion and the clergy than reason and common sense. - Voltaire All religions are founded on the fear of the many and the cleverness of the few. - Stendhal
My name is Jared William Landry. I am 41 years old. My former occupation: Private Investigator, Bodyguard, Bail Enforcement Agent, Executive Protection Officer, Security Officer, Recovery Agent, Head of your Private SWAT Team as well as a doing drug interdiction as a CI for the better part of 16 years. Education a quick note I only finished 5th grade at 12 years of age attained a job installing hardwood floors, by the age of 13 I graduated Ground School Aviation. At the age of sixteen I had a company vehicle with Seiler Plumbing and Heating and Cooling Westby Wisconsin. I build my own home in that time when I turn Twenty-One I decide to attend college at WWTC in Fennimore Wisconsin. I obtained 68 college in Criminal Justice and attended Police Academy. Of which I was the top student. I finished my schooling at WWTC in 2008. And 2013 I applied to Viterbo University. Having told them what I have done they would offer me a scholarship if I were to go get my GED. In 2018 I obtained 68 college credits in criminal justice and attended police academy. In 2013 I obtained GED and attended Viterbo University. Education: Arson Investigator, Hazmat/Weapons of Mass Destruction Anti-Terrorism, Firearm Proficiency Training Basics, Security Training, Executive Protection Training, Bail Enforcement Training, NARK II DRUG Identification, Private Investigator Basic, First Responder Wisconsin Standards plus CPR, Community Policing, Impaired-Driving, eEmotional Survival for Law Enforcement, DWI Detection, Language Lab, Policing in America, Legal Context, Tactical Skills, Relational Skill, Patrol Procedures, Investigation Police Academy, Interview of Witness, Constitutional Law Juvenile Law, Pyychology, Ground School Aviation . Family: Most of my family has taken an active role in today's society / politics. From my uncle being mayor of a major city, to my father being a people's Advocate. My family has always had an interest in helping others. My father has always served his community as well as his country. At the age of 17 my father would leave for Vietnam as a boy but returning man. He has spent 10 years on a major fire department Lafayette Louisiana. Where he he made captain in six short years. My grandfather and my uncle served on the same department for many years. My father showed me that if I work hard anything was possible. I want you to know I'm here to work hard for you as a man of the people for the people. I believe dearly in my country please help me to CHANGE THE WORLD. VOTE JARED WILLIAM LANDRY AS A WRIGHT IN CANDIDATE FOR PRESIDENT 2020. ITS TIME TO LIBERATE OUR WORLD. VOTE JARED WILLIAM LANDRY FOR PRESIDENT AND CHANGE THE WORLD DOING IT. I PROMISE I WILL PUT LAW ENFORCEMENT IN IT'S PLACE. I WILL HAVE TRUMP TRIED FOR MANSLAUGHTER. I WILL STOP ALL OF IT.
God can't do (a) logically impossible things, like make a square circle, a married batchelor, or a rock too big for him to lift, nor things that are opposed to his nature, so He can't lie. God can do anything that can be done, regardless of how much power, intellect, or etc. is required.
Yet all other gods of mythologies have died out. If man made God in his own image to suit his own needs then there would be no sin and no need for a savior. Man would have made himself perfect, since God is perfect, no?
You're correct that there is no science here. But this is not a scientific topic. That doesn't make it nonsense. I notice you didn't actually point out any error in it.
This was going so well until Jesus was equated as God. Jesus is not the creator, and he admits this. Collossians 1-15 is quite clear when it states he was the BEGINNING of creation. And - Who was he praying to? And why is does he say he is the son, in a father and son relationship? And please, no nonsense Trinitarian answers.
@Robert Davies, Gospel of John 1st chapter. Jesus never denied He is the Creator. He made himself equal to God the Father (philippians 2:6 and on...). Several occasions in the gospels demonstrate Jesus commanded the attributes of God (forgiveness, all-knowing, healing, etc...) To assert that Jesus himself admits his non-deity is a bad guess and demonstrates poor study . . .
@@gospelmuanza4814 I am saying that the lifespan of this universe is 1.28 trillion years old after which another universe will be reborn in a continuing cycle.
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
![“อ.เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม” มาตามคำเรียกร้อง แหกศาสตร์ฮวงจุ้ย เตือนสติอย่างมงาย | แฉ 7 พ.ย. 67 [1/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5fc4S3xBNfc/mqdefault.jpg)
If something made god, then the maker would be greater, and "god" would not be god, or this "god" is an idol. God exists for his own sake; an eternal being.
whosays true
Actually, this question is a dog chasing it's tail: If something made God, and the Pre-something made the something, and the Pre-Pre-something made the......
It never ends.
At some point there had to be an eternal supernatural being that was always there to bring us out of the state of nothingness.
Yeah, you're right. They like to call it an infinite regression. This of course is non sensible and illogical. We know the universe had a beginning. We know that nothing comes from nothing. It is 100% logical to believe that if EVER there was truly nothing then there couldn't ever be anything. No brainer really. God bless you.
Iam glad God is not available for mankind to see him in his office 😂
Iam glad my father in heaven is not available for mankind to visit him in his office somewhere on planet earth 🌎 lol 😂
Jupiter rotate every 10.5 hours. Hopefully everybody’s still understood what you were trying to say and I appreciate what you guys are doing! Keep it up until the devil fallen down!!!
Thank you so much for making these videos. They really help me to interpret the Scriptures and to strengthen my relationship with Jesus ❤️
No one created God he has no begining or end he is eternal
How is that possible
God told us that He IS the beginning and the end (Rev 1:8, Rev 21:6, Rev 22:13), the Bible does not say that God had no beginning.
God made Himself, thats why we worship Him. He is the self-existing one, the created uncreated.
How can anything create itself? God has no beginning; He simply exists outside time.
@@PJRayment So couldn't the universe itself have existed in some form or another without having any beginning? Who's to say that the singularity didn't always exist? When people claim that "god" must exist after asking "what came before the singularity?", isn't that assuming that the singularity couldn't have just existed without needing a creator? Why assume that a sentient, supernatural deity HAD to have created the universe? The universe just as easily could have always existed without needing a beginning.
@@vanation321
"So couldn't the universe itself have existed in some form or another without having any beginning?"
Many scientists used to believe in the 'Steady State' model of the universe, which held that the universe had been around forever. However, that was replaced with the Big Bang model because the Steady State model didn't actually fit the observations.
The laws of thermodynamics are against an eternal universe. The 2nd law, in particular, says that the universe is running down, using up its energy. Given that there is still available energy, the universe has not fully run down. Therefore it has not been around forever. It has a beginning.
"Why assume that a sentient, supernatural deity HAD to have created the universe?"
Because nothing can create itself, and the physical universe had a beginning. So the cause of the physical universe-i.e. everything physical-had to be something non-physical, or supernatural.
@@PJRayment Do you think that "God" is a sentient, self-aware, all knowing and all loving, conscious being who willfully created the universe? Also, is there a scenario in which the laws of physics and thermodynamics as we know it weren't necessarily around during the singularity? Do you also think that every living thing is a part of this god, or that a part of God exists within every living thing? I'm just interested, not necessarily bashing your opinions, I just think that it's impossible for us humans with our tiny brains to even begin comprehending the origin of existence in general, let alone whether or not a sentient/self-aware being is behind it all, or if existence itself has always existed.
@@vanation321
1. Yes, but without the unwarranted scare quotes.
2. Anyone can invent any scenario they want.
3a. No.
3b. No, although it depends on what you mean by that. God is not made of parts.
"I just think that it's impossible for us humans with our tiny brains to even begin comprehending the origin of existence in general, let alone whether or not a sentient/self-aware being is behind it all, or if existence itself has always existed."
Why do you think that it's impossible? I'm not suggesting that we can completely comprehend it, but I don't know why you're sceptical that we "even begin" to comprehend it. And in fact simply by thinking about the question, you have _begun_ to comprehend it.
And why do you consider our brains to be "tiny"? They are among the largest brains known to exist, and have been described as the most complex pound of matter in the universe.
Further, many people _have_ thought a lot about this, and have be able to deduce various things about it.
...like he said a kid said that god made himself I trust that kid
The big bang happend God spoke it and bang it happened!
But who created god??
@@chadrasmussen6127 Didn't you watch the video?
It appears that just isn’t true. There was no big bang.
The answer is beyond human being reason
that's pretty convenient
@@dopeydonaldtrump3744, the there's Dopey the driveby word farter. Hey, on the topic of the video, which you're too stupid to elaborate on:
So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
@@2fast2block Hahaha Brilliant. Let's continue this conversation because it gave me a good laugh when I read your reply.
So, I agree with you ! A supernatural creator is not necessarily bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Great, we agree !
Ok, moving on. Show me any evidence, any evidence at all, for anything supernatural. I'm not asking for evidence of your creator, just one tiny piece of verifiable evidence of anything supernatural. I'll accept any evidence for anything...fairies, hobglobins, gods, ghosts, santa claus....anything, just to make it easy for you.
Evidence is merely your way of testing god. If you believed in god, like many people do. You would have read thou shalt not test the lord. Instead you should ask the right questions when approaching god. After all. If we are to come to him as lower beings we should humble ourselves to his soveirgn nature. What I mean by that is we are inferior to him. Less smart. Weaker. And totally bound by his rules and creation. So just ask him to show you. And he will. I'm not gonna give you evidence because I've already proven his existence to myself through the way I just described so my advice, just ask him the right questions and humble (put yourself below him) yourself.
@@Snowcone-lg3oj It would have been easier just to admit that you have no evidence. I am not going to ask your imaginary friend for evidence that it exists, that would make me as crazy as you.
Who made matter? God.
The answer depends on who or what we decide to call God.
For you.
I’m trying to think about it
In this discussion...What do you call 'God' ??Do you think of a physical entity OR what ??
We exist in four dimensions not three. Height, Length, Width, and Time. Five, if you add the spiritual dimension.
How can nothing exploded to everything??
It can't. Even though it is basic common sense and basic science, they still favor their god did it, the god of nothing, that has nothing as evidence. Then, if that was not bad enough, they call us creatards as if they actually have a grasp of knowledge how the universe was created.
Reading the bible, it's interesting how many times Satan's side is proven wrong, but Satan does NOT care about that; he just cares about deceiving.
Good video
Totally
Scribes were/are paid big money to write about messages that the gods were giving to them, so of course, for each individual scribe to keep writing, was the greatest of temptations. Those many conflicting stories, is why, rather than uniting devotees, the stories divide devotees into right-fighting groups.
What many conflicting stories?
HOW DID YOU Arrive AT the conclusion about right wing as opposed to radical left??????????????? 👎
@@lewiscarey6984 According to a "Centrist" both left and right are radical.
Pertaining to politics, rather than Extreme Left, or Extreme Right ... the word Centrist implies middle of the road ... moderate ... as in "not going to extremes either way."
In a country where people vote, the object is, the voters are either for or against certain issues, and for that reason, will vote for either one party, or the other.
For instance ... those who believe that abortion offends the will of a god, will be voting for the party that promises to make abortion illegal. While those who want to give women the power to make their own decisions, will vote for the party that promises to keep abortion legal. When it pertains to the subject of abortion, there isn't any middle of the road.
Gun control, or the lack thereof is another touchy subject, where voters either vote for one side, or the other side on that issue.
I suggest that politicians in the Centrist party, by trying to follow the middle of the road, will ultimately leave the middle of the road; veer off either to the extreme left, or to the extreme right ... which has occurred to every group of politicians that tried to improve the old system for something new, and hopefully more agreeable to everyone.
If the Big bang was the cause of us who made the Big Bang.GET IT
What is "Inner Voices"? (2.22.82)
If God was made, He is not God. Only a self-exist God can be the ultimate creator. You will have the unfettered answer, when you see God in His realm.
And I’m 8 it took two hours but I think god made himself
How does anyone or anything make him/itself?
If you think about this it’s endless like who made god and who made who made god see it goes on forever just like what was here before the Big Bang and what was before that you can say this unlimited times and you would never know the answer or what happens when we die where do we go and when does that end
No,use your logic here if the person or God who made the 2nd God is responsible then who created the first God then Because God has his purpose or in other words God created him self or,the universe created God man+soul+abilities granted to him there may be other possible reasons for the creation of the Omni creator
I did not enjoy the episode of origins tv entitled "who made God " at all. because the episode has nothing to do with answering this question. This question is impossible to answer so why try. The only thing the episode did was say that' it's the wrong question to ask' and say that God is so beyond our understanding that he doesn't need to have been created. Essentially, you're saying or implying that God created himself. but you never come close to answering the question about how that could be possible. All you say is God is super natural so he's not limited to the natural laws of physics we know of-the ones which he himself created. This ,however true it may be, still does not answer the question of "who made God",. You will never probably come close to being able to answer this question. even if God himself explained it all to you , you still probably could never grasp the meaning of it all. where God came from Is impossible for someone with a meager human brain to ever understand . Humans know nothing about supernatural physics . The analogy the speaker used saying that "it's like asking who did the bachelor marry" is irrelevant and completely absurd. The speaker used too many atheistic "scientific materialism " terms like space-time and event horizon. Both of these terms are man-made junk terms based on fake and false theories that are not remotely true. there is no such thing as space time and there is no such thing as an event horizon nor is there such a thing as a black holes which the term event horizon is related to. (It's impossible for black holes to exists, it's just another scientific scam ) there is no space -time . Time and space are unrelated . Time is an independent force upon which everything else is dependent upon . Even though there is some good information within this episode , the average adult would already have known this information. It doesn't address the subtitle of the show at all. It's insulting to ask the question and then say, well we have no answers so let's not even ask that question afterall . and this show is certainly not enough to ever convert an atheist into a believer. This episode should never have had this outrageous subtitle. because the question of who made God is answerable by humans. and nobody else but God will ever possibly understand it . Stop trying to answer things nobody can possibly know other than God himself. My own personal theories are far superior to anything that was presented in this episode .
Stop pretending to have the answers for things you couldn't possibly know .
You spent way too much time trying to use bible passages to prove your point.
God speaks with actions not words, so stop proclaiming the Bible as being the word of god . If some people are too blind to see that gods signature is clearly written within every thing he ever created ,then they deserve the darkness . .
HIS MOM AND DAD 😊🪄✨🧬
True
Great response to the question in the title. So disappointing to hear the blatant errors of biblical interpretation that they throw about at the end, claiming that creator is Jesus. No. Jesus was clear. He is a man. He is the Son of God, God’s anointed one. His FATHER is the Creator, the God of the Jews.
Yes, the council of Nicea was a huge unscriptural mistake!
King
How about just saying that the universe has been here forever
Don't go that route. It's a simple question. Who made God!
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there
must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed
and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
God is different of the universe. God is eternal, our universe is temporary. God is not material, our universe it is. A universe had yo be created. God didn't.
I agree with most everything here except that the Earth is flat and the Bible says so. The original word for circle in Hebrew does not mean sphere.
Didn't answer the question...
Another one that can't listen. God was and needed no creation.
So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
Yes Brent, why don't you listen. God was and needed no creation ! The same as the flying spaghetti monster. He has always been here. You must be stupid if you don't know that.
Your being very rude, don't call him stupid! >:(
@@seminiigreene5792, gee, so you want me to lie. Not just that, it's too bad you were not there to correct God in His MANY verses that He explains what fools do. God should have been more kind and lied too, according to you.
I'll go by what God says and speak the truth. You can go on with your stupidity.
So emmmmmm, who made god ????? 26 minutes of video with this title and you didn't tell us !
It helps to pay attention and not sleep through it. Granted, I don't agree with all they say, either. But it was made clear God needs no origin. God does not need to be made. It's actually a very stupid question.
So in your way of thinking, if a supernatural creator created the natural realm, then that supernatural creator who created the natural realm with its natural laws has then become also bound by those natural laws the supernatural creator created. So explain why a supernatural creator is also bound by the laws the supernatural creator created. Or, show how smart you are and just give your science for creation happening naturally and don't forget to give your science how the natural laws were created, too. If you want to act smart, it may be a good idea to actually show you are.
He always was. Numbnuts.
@@Snowcone-lg3oj Hahaha...brilliant. The irony of your comment is obviously completely lost on you.
@@dopeydonaldtrump3744, ok, you did one of your famous word farts, "The irony of your comment is obviously completely lost on you."
God is supernatural and you're way of thinking is ONLY in the natural. Yet we know creation can't happen naturally. We only have two options and naturally lost 100%, but to you, natural still wins. Now, try to muster up enough gas to make another word fart as if you know what "irony" is.
@@2fast2block 1. god is supernatural ? Prove it please.
2. Which god are we discussing here ?
3. "Your way of thinking is only in the natural" Extremely poor English but I think I understood you and also corrected some of your grammar. And yes, of course I think "in the natural". What else is there ?
4 "We know creation can't happen naturally". Really ? Who is "we" ? You and your mate down the pub ?
5. "We only have two options etc". Options for what ? Options for who made god ? Your poor English makes it very difficult to understand what you are trying to say.
I agree with most of this, but the speaker lowers his credibility by making multiple false statements about science. (1) The speaker said that atheists depend on the big bang. But for thousands of years, atheists insisted on an eternal universe. They accepted a beginning to the universe only when the evidence for this beginning became overwhelming in the mid 20th century. This is one of the cases where the Bible got it right first--the speaker's mistake gives atheists too much credit. Many atheists still desire to remove this beginning to the universe. (2) The speaker says that Jupiter is so big that its day is long. However, Jupiter rotates in less than 10 hours. (3) The speaker says that the moon moves away from the earth "a couple of inches per year." It actually moves at 1.5 inches (3.8 centimeters) per year. These are fairly minor mistakes, but the speaker should be more careful in his words.
No beginning God always was not like mere man.
This does not answer the question in the title of the video, "Who Made God?"
You're right. But you're also wrong.
THE CLERGY CREATED GOD IN THEIR OWN IMAGE, LITERALLY. ONLY THE CLERGY can officially speak, write, and approve/disapprove of 'God's' words or writings based on heterodoxy (i.e., deviation from accepted or orthodox standards or beliefs), which the clergy also created and is the closely guarded and sole responsibility of the clergy. "God" is their creation and is wholly fictive in character. That alone is sufficient to explain why God, A so-called "all-powerful, all-knowing being, can't speak, write or appear.
That's why the clergy's God failed to respond to the fervent prayers of the condemned Jews lined up for the "showers" in the Nazi death camps. Praying to your God will ALWAYS have the same results despite the occasional coincidence or the believer's game of counting the hits and ignoring the misses. The Bible says, “Knock, and the door WILL be opened” (tell that to my dead sister who believed the Bible when it said, "If you ask it in his name, it's yours"). No qualifiers are mentioned other than belief. My firmly believing Christian sister, who died in 2013, was a gifted musician who devoted her life to religious music because she believed. Oh, the irony!
Per Occam's razor, which of the two scenarios requires the fewest assumptions? That God is real and there is another totally separate "spiritual world" that controls the physical Universe and is populated by other invisible, "spiritual" beings who are unable to speak, write, or appear, or is it the uncomplicated alternative explanation that the clergy lied and continued to lie about their non-existent, “non-contingent” invention. This is supported by the explicit and ubiquitous lying by the clergy and their apologists that can be seen here on TH-cam in the MAJORITY of the videos with a religious topic. The very people who prohibit the bearing of false witness have adopted lying AS A STRATEGY. People lie to lead people AWAY FROM THE TRUTH. WHY WOULD TRUTH TELLERS TELL LIES?
The "spiritual world" cannot be confirmed as genuine, and the power of the clergy's God hypothesis is that it cannot be falsified. The absence of God necessitates the basis of belief as "faith" due to the most critical lack of evidence of all: a God that actual human perceptions and experience can verify firsthand. THIS MEANS GOD IS A CONCEPT THAT IS TOTALLY LACKING IN POWER AT ANY LEVEL OF AGENCY. When pressed, the clergy will even define God out of existence by claiming he is beyond time and space (HOW could they possibly know THAT) before they lose an argument or admit the truth. The Christian habit of claiming knowledge they don't have begins with the clergy.
Clearly, the choice is between 1) the clergy lied about God because it gave them power over others and provided a privileged position in society with monetary rewards (a prevalent human motivation), or 2) is it that we must account for an ENTIRE OTHER WORLD that claims that God is in control (but the clergy is incapable of showing genuine evidence to back up their claims even though their God claims involve Biblical assertions about the physical world which can be scientifically tested).
Obviously, it is the former. This is the SAME and ONLY plausible explanation for the impersonation of "god(s), by non-Christian clergy responsible for “Sacred Texts” in the worship of the many other gods of which YOU, the reader, are an atheist. It’s the same trick and the same process in Christian and pagan situations. In both instances, the other religions' gods and spiritual beings also cannot speak, write, or appear.
WHAT AN AMAZING COINCIDENCE. ALL SPIRITUAL BEINGS, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, WHATEVER THEIR CLAIMS OF DIVINE POWER, CANNOT WRITE, SPEAK, OR APPEAR, AND THE COMMON DENOMINATOR AMONG ALL SPIRITUAL BEINGS IS THE CLERGY, WHO PUBLICALLY PRETEND TO WRITE AND SPEAK FOR THEIR GOD(S).
Part of the fraud is the clergy’s claim of “Divine revelation.” BUT THE CLERGY’S GOD DOESN’T KNOW MORE THAN THE CLERGY, WHICH SHOWS THE CLERGY’S GOD TO BE FALSE, AND THAT IS LIVING PROOF OF THE FRAUD THAT THE CLERGY PERPETRATED ON THE WORLD WHEN THEY FIRST IMPERSONATED A SUPREME BEING. THAT THE WORLD’S CLERGY IS THE UNIVERSAL CREATOR AND IMPERSONATOR OF ALL GODS AND SPIRITUAL BEINGS IS AN INTELLECTUAL SLAM DUNK!
Claiming that God wrote the corrupt, mistake, and forgery-filled Bible does extreme violence to the concepts of all-powerful, all-knowing and totally invalidates the faith-based postulation of a "Supreme Being." God, it turns out is no mystery AT ALL. OCCAM'S RAZOR RULES.
Nothing can be more contrary to religion and the clergy than reason and common sense. - Voltaire
All religions are founded on the fear of the many and the cleverness of the few. - Stendhal
what god??? where??
The God. Everywhere.
My name is Jared William Landry. I am 41 years old. My former occupation: Private Investigator, Bodyguard, Bail Enforcement Agent, Executive Protection Officer, Security Officer, Recovery Agent, Head of your Private SWAT Team as well as a doing drug interdiction as a CI for the better part of 16 years. Education a quick note I only finished 5th grade at 12 years of age attained a job installing hardwood floors, by the age of 13 I graduated Ground School Aviation. At the age of sixteen I had a company vehicle with Seiler Plumbing and Heating and Cooling Westby Wisconsin. I build my own home in that time when I turn Twenty-One I decide to attend college at WWTC in Fennimore Wisconsin. I obtained 68 college in Criminal Justice and attended Police Academy. Of which I was the top student. I finished my schooling at WWTC in 2008. And 2013 I applied to Viterbo University. Having told them what I have done they would offer me a scholarship if I were to go get my GED. In 2018 I obtained 68 college credits in criminal justice and attended police academy. In 2013 I obtained GED and attended Viterbo University.
Education: Arson Investigator, Hazmat/Weapons of Mass Destruction Anti-Terrorism, Firearm Proficiency Training Basics, Security Training, Executive Protection Training, Bail Enforcement Training, NARK II DRUG Identification, Private Investigator Basic, First Responder Wisconsin Standards plus CPR, Community Policing, Impaired-Driving, eEmotional Survival for Law Enforcement, DWI Detection, Language Lab, Policing in America, Legal Context, Tactical Skills, Relational Skill, Patrol Procedures, Investigation Police Academy, Interview of Witness, Constitutional Law Juvenile Law, Pyychology, Ground School Aviation . Family: Most of my family has taken an active role in today's society / politics. From my uncle being mayor of a major city, to my father being a people's Advocate. My family has always had an interest in helping others. My father has always served his community as well as his country. At the age of 17 my father would leave for Vietnam as a boy but returning man. He has spent 10 years on a major fire department Lafayette Louisiana. Where he he made captain in six short years. My grandfather and my uncle served on the same department for many years. My father showed me that if I work hard anything was possible.
I want you to know I'm here to work hard for you as a man of the people for the people. I believe dearly in my country please help me to CHANGE THE WORLD. VOTE JARED WILLIAM LANDRY AS A WRIGHT IN CANDIDATE FOR PRESIDENT 2020. ITS TIME TO LIBERATE OUR WORLD. VOTE JARED WILLIAM LANDRY FOR PRESIDENT AND CHANGE THE WORLD DOING IT. I PROMISE I WILL PUT LAW ENFORCEMENT IN IT'S PLACE. I WILL HAVE TRUMP TRIED FOR MANSLAUGHTER. I WILL STOP ALL OF IT.
Is it the Truth Tho?
Um he made himself duh
He can't make himself otherwise that implies he isn't eternal
I never believed in big bang.. But God if he exist, is somewhat partial.. not good enough as we humans perceived
I think the universe made itself and then It made God as the guardian.... IDK
How does something make itself?
:0
IF GOD CAN DO ANYTHING T H E N CAN HE BUILD A ROCK SOOO B I G THAT HE HIMSELF C A N ' T L I F T ??? !!! Hmmmm ????? Dec 16, 2020
God can't do (a) logically impossible things, like make a square circle, a married batchelor, or a rock too big for him to lift, nor things that are opposed to his nature, so He can't lie. God can do anything that can be done, regardless of how much power, intellect, or etc. is required.
In the beginning, mankind created God, in his own image, to suit his own needs. Let's not confuse this with cosmology!
What's your evidence for that?
Yet all other gods of mythologies have died out. If man made God in his own image to suit his own needs then there would be no sin and no need for a savior. Man would have made himself perfect, since God is perfect, no?
Um, DNA actually verifies evolution...
These are loads of bullshits. Absolute nonsense. No science here.
You're correct that there is no science here. But this is not a scientific topic. That doesn't make it nonsense. I notice you didn't actually point out any error in it.
This was going so well until Jesus was equated as God. Jesus is not the creator, and he admits this. Collossians 1-15 is quite clear when it states he was the BEGINNING of creation. And - Who was he praying to? And why is does he say he is the son, in a father and son relationship? And please, no nonsense Trinitarian answers.
@Robert Davies, Gospel of John 1st chapter. Jesus never denied He is the Creator. He made himself equal to God the Father (philippians 2:6 and on...). Several occasions in the gospels demonstrate Jesus commanded the attributes of God (forgiveness, all-knowing, healing, etc...) To assert that Jesus himself admits his non-deity is a bad guess and demonstrates poor study . . .
The universe didn't come from nothing. It came from the death of the previous universe. Birth comes from death, and death comes from birth.
so when did that start?
@@gospelmuanza4814a great kalpa ago which is 1.28 trillion years ago
@@ianl3527 you saying that the universe is eternal ? Or it started 1.28 trillion years ago?
@@gospelmuanza4814 I am saying that the lifespan of this universe is 1.28 trillion years old after which another universe will be reborn in a continuing cycle.
@@ianl3527 And what's your evidence for that?
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there
must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed
and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
Why
It's not rocket science: Nothing could have come from nothing so there
must have been something, nay someone - an eternal being who designed
and created the universe (design can only come from a mind).
design, creating, mind, all this things you say are not bound by God…. what makes you think God has a mind?