Her concerns were beyond valid. Not only was she bullied by the public as soon as she debuted just for debuting later, she was labelled the "talentless" member, and her being in the group was considered a punishment to the other members for not reaching a certain level of success. Remember, this is a girl who was hated on for crying at a friend's funeral. This treatment wasn't that long ago
😩 she's suffered so much, I'm so thankful for her to keep going strong, i'm always thankful that her family, other members and her close friend to fully support her. they always said to Yeri to just do whatever she wanna do, i love that
And then she had to perform a couple of days later. Black pink and RV members hugging her. Gosh it felt horrible to watch. How can people lack so much humanity?
@@Swish900you’re so weird lmfao you guys need to get off the internet sometimes and realise that if you said this to anyone irl they’d look at you like you’re insane FOR A REASON DO U HEAR URSELF😭
@@iinaego i think that's my own choice that i make . Also it's only comes out weird cause im not a native english speaker . And kpop is full of weird people
Yeri and Ningning not training together because in October 2015 Ningning still in Lets Sing Kids program so she probably joined SM in November. while Yeri debut with RV in March 2015, so their training periods didn't overlap. I think the group called White fox and the other member with Yeri was Koeun but i don't know for other girls name
@@stabil1ty That’s right! Sorry i actually meant that all they were introduced as part of the SM rookies project at some point. Some of them right after RV's debut, some others later, but this is how we called them for a long time as potential smngg members, the sm rookie girls, not in this exact combination tho. The best part is even if all the girls didn't debut together they remain friends and have a lot of cute interactions on IG (especially Yeri and Herin), along with former sm trainees as An Jong Min, Kepler's Chaehyun or actress Park Jung Yeon🥰 But as you said, we knew that Ning Ning was under SM until 2016 when she came out as part of SRG16☺️
Yup. That was Irene's way of getting the uncontrolled haters off of Yeri's back since SM was not doing ANYTHING about them. Irene is AWESOME for that! What a great Angry Mamma Bear to have! :D
Tbh I had no interest in RV during happiness and being natural. Like the whole concept back then seemed a bit basic and boring. But ice cream cake concept + yeri joining made me actually pay attention to them and like them.
@@dunkyourdonuts2282 You could not recognize their talents at all before Yeri joined? What exactly are you even listening to or looking at? They have material during their training that can still be found if you know where to look. All of it from before Happiness still WOWS people to this day. Where are you even from, that their abilities were just hum-drum for you? Damn. Put some respect on their name.
Tbh yeri joining redvelvet was the best idea like the girl used to single handedly carry them on variety shows like watch idol room knowing brothers etc she was the goat
she sings most of the backround vocals too and you can tell that she adds a different flavor to the "original" reve tone, just like giselle in aespa!!!!💘
People criticize her so much but this video shows that when Sm decided scrap the gg project, the first trainee they didn't want to loose was Yeri. Most of the girls Yeri likely trained with didn't even debut at another agency at the end. If Yeri wasn't valuable Sm would let her waste her youth like all the other girls
this has misinformation… yeri never dropped out of school, there’s pictures of her graduation during bad boy era! and Irene would pack her lunch for school, (it’s on a variety show if u don’t believe me, and they said it in an interview). also wasn’t there an interview done with red velvet where they said yeri didn’t join, bc of how young she was when ever debuted?
“ill do acting instead” as much as i love red velvet yeri, i also love actress yeri. i’ve watched bitch x rich and i love her acting. many people say most idols cant act, well she isnt one of them
So true. Yeri is really one of the few idol actors who can actually act very well. I've watched bitch × rich too and it was my fave drama last year. I'm waiting for it's season 2. BTW if you want, you should watch Yeri's previous drama "Blue birthday" which is her first acting project in a lead role. And it was very good too. Her acting is seriously no joke!
@@RiswjyV @cherriyeojin I got to see her one-episode drama Applause a while ago (about a girl who trains a dog to be an assistant animal, all while eventually realizing she has much to learn about the world that blind/disabled people are actually encountering) and I loved how she played off her own sweet personality while being able to show the character's flaws in a funny, natural sort of way. It's kinda gotten lost in the shuffle because of the scope of Blue Birthday and BitchXRich but I absolutely find it a worthwhile watch. For that matter, the fact Yeri chose to do Blue Birthday - given that show's themes - is really poignant and reflective of what she endured. I have so much respect for her for taking that project on.
That is what I heard. Maybe we have BAD information though because I am sitting over here in the middle of the United States... Who knows? I hope all the bad info gets corrected because this post surprised me.
@@dunkyourdonuts2282 It is really too bad and it makes no sense at all that 'haters gotta hate'. Imagine some people are SO MESSED UP in the head that they think they are SUPPOSED to hate other people 'just because'. Yeri was a TEENAGER and was getting full on BULLIED about every tiny little thing she did or said or looked like or made a decision about by Full-Grown 'ADULTS' who should know better. At some point, people should have out-grown being bullies. Their logic parts of the brain are supposed to kick in at some point, or otherwise how are these people supposed to be considered as adults? They are just giant toddlers. I thought I was messed up in the head! I know I am not perfect, I have problems. But I am REALLY GLAD that I can do logic, I can actually think for myself and figure things out on my own. One thing I figured out while I was still a kids is that the world needs Love. As grumpy as I get, I am always happy when I see and hear about kindness. When I see Human Beings acknowledging each other as Humans and not animals, not slaves, but as equals. Hate got us into the messes we are in all over the world. Nothing fixes those messes until there is understanding and a willingness to work together to fix them. Hate has no place in those conversations or workplaces. Hate just for the sake of Hate? That's the only thing these 'people' (trolls) are good at? Their parents should be ashamed of their kids and more importantly, ashamed of themselves.
@@Sweet_Like_A_Jack_Rose Well, not always. Taeil is the eldest in NCT but Taeyong was made the leader of both the 127 sub-unit and the overall group (though he is also one of the eldest in the group). But there's a good chance Yeri may have been made the leader as not only because of her age but also because she would've probably been the member with the most training experience.
aespa wasn't even a project back then. only ningning was in SME around that time?? others joined later so nope even if she didn't debut w rv, she wouldn't have been in aespa. the girls she trained with were different.
there's a video of Yeri and her friends performance in smtown concert back in 2014/2015 i forgot but you can search it. Btw Yeri already debut in RV even before Ningning joined SM
From what i heard from others, at SM theres 5% chance of debuting. So i feel like Yeri made the right choice. She did sacrifice a lot which i understand.
A bit misinformation here: •Yeri had connection either the red velvet pg members cause they lived and trained together, Irene and Seulgi especially dotes on her since trainee days along with the other rookie girls. • She was supposed to be the center of the new girl group along with the SR15Girls
Some people consider yeri "talentless" but truly she completes red velvet. Yeri's adlibs and verses breaks up red velvets killer vocals and also allows red velvet to have many different concepts. Yeri's parts in songs make red velvets songs more noticable, and give red velvet's songs the final touch or cherry on top. She doesn't just complete red velvet as a music group but red velvet socially. Imo yeri is the adlib queen in kpop, her sweet voice just immediately brightens up any song shes in and adds so much character to the song.
if anyone is still calling yeri talentless after a full decade post-debut, that’s simply because they dislike for whatever reasons they’ve come up with in their mind. she’s one of the best maknaes the industry has ever seen. gold standard. she comes with red velvet, whether others like that or not.
@@noahfan2719 I fully agree! red velvet wouldn't be the same without yeri! I've seen people try and make crazy rumors about her like she's "always super friendly with dudes" (meant in the inappropriate way), "has a bad attitude" and an "attention seeker" but even though fans may not know her personally just seeing all the people and the type of people yeri is friends with its clear that those rumors are just that, rumors. People will do anything these days to "justify" there hate/annoyance towards someone.
@@ujytb9761What songs would you recommend where Yeri has a decent number of lines to sing? She is not talentless but she does seem much less talented than the other 4 members.
@@RiswjyV @ujytb9761 Soshi's love and adoration of Yeri all the way to her "I'm unnie to aespa" era tell me that people of all generations absolutely adore Katie Kim.
Unfortunately, I still see many international fans hating or ignoring yeri and still wish she leave red velvet. But some fans love her and think she’s cute and funny.
I still feel sorry for the Mickey Mouse club Sm rookies girl trainees, none of whom have debuted. How painful it is to wait, waste time and effort for an opportunity that seems close but it’s just a daydream.
Maybe she took a pause? Or maybe it’s just to emphasize she didn’t go to school often. Many idols can graduate with going to only a few classes a year. Or like Jungkook who graduated at 19 bc he took a break year.
I love her. Having her is like a dream and I'm glad that she debuted in the end because I believe that Red Velvet was destined to be a five member group. I'm very fond of Yeri and meeting her and Red Velvet motivated me a lot. I could never understand how people hated on her for joining so late she was just a teen back then and she received so many backlash from those so called “fans” but Red Velvet only considers the Reveluv who stans the Five of them because RED VELVET IS FIVE AND WILL ALWAYS BE FIVE.
she made a good choice because it would take 6 years for sm to debut another gg WITH members that joined the company 2 years or more after her own debut
I loved Red Velvet’s debut with Happiness literally sooooo much at the time. I remember when Yeri was added I was nervous but then Ice Cream Cake was so amazing. Red Velvet is my ult group fr I love everything they’ve doneee
I Stan RV since debut but adding Yeri in the group is the best decision SM ever made because she's the lucky charm of Red Velvet. After adding her, the group get their first win and get recognize by public viewers.
😢😢 people are so mean. Be stronger, Yeri my girl ❤🤟🏽 you have great friendship in RV, and of course with Nayeon too. I love that ❤ Remember what Rihanna said, "Shine bright like a diamond, Sunlight Mama Lemon." ✨✨
I actually remember how she joined the group and after that, rv's popularity skyrocketed bcs of their amazing vocals and performances! She is a good choice for rv, and made the group brighter.
the problem is that she is the age of Aespa but in a 3rd generation group.... her career will end early bc he remembers are in their 30s while other idols her age are still promoting!
Kinda misinformations alot in this video. She did have connection with rv unnies during trainee days but shes close more with other trainees friends with the same ages as her. Shes also didnt dropped out of school? 😅 She did graduate from high school tho.
Yeri brings a bright cheerfulness to Red Velvet. She has a quick sense of humor and easily laughs at situations that she finds to be funny. She helps others not take themselves too seriously. She also makes funny boasts about things that she says she has done or knows how to do only to have it backfire on her when she attempts to do them.
i can’t imagine red velvet without yeri at this point!! they are so well rounded and compliment each other so nicely. and i love her dynamic with irene, mother and daughter :,)
I think overall from today's perspective it is better that she is part of Red Velvet than not. Her reasons for not wanting to join are valid though; also Yeri did receive hate after debuting with RV and throughout her time as a member. But in the end RV became one of the biggest groups in the industry that is still active today, while that other group never even made it to debut. Plus Yeri has her own unique personality in RV and helps balance it out. I hope she is more confident about her decision now 🙏
Tbh I think Yeri is RV lucky charm, the moment she joined RV the group became more successful and start getting recognition from both the public and Kpop fans in general back then.
ATTENTION KPOP STANS!! WE NEED YOUR HELP!! (Admin plz pin this) Nowadays as the popularity of Kpop is increasing, the amount of hate by so called sigma, chads, football fans blah blah blah is also increasing. And what makes this situation worse is the fans reaction. Nowadays, as you all know how these idols are treated by these toxic internet. They call them gay, call them weak, be racist towards. You all know what happened to stray Kids this time at the Met Gala and what usually happens to BTS on the internet and also BlackPink. I daily encounter approx 4-5 shorts/reels hating on BTS. Like comparing them with their football idols and lot more. And the comments are like, proud to be a bts hater, Kpop kpoop, etc. encounter approx 4-5 shorts/reels hating on BTS. So now please listen carefully, to stop this we have to first to fight among ourselves. Like between different Kpop stans. Like we need to stop hating different groups or stop fighting like, no BTS is the best or no BlackPink is. Stop it... We need to unite. Everyone we need to stop hating the fans or grps which are not your fav and stop fighting. EVERYONE HAS THEIR FAVOURITE GROUP. NEXT STEP IS VERY IMPORTANT We need toreacting to stop commenting on videos hating our fav grp or any Kpop grp. Or reply to any hateful comment or write any comment defending your grp in that video. For ex. You saw an edit a guy is comparing BTS with Ronaldo and he disrespected BTS in that just don't react just stop. You don't have to write any comment there neither positive or to write any comment there neither positive or negative. Or you have to react or reply to those shitcomments there neither positive or negative. Or you have you have to react or reply to those horrible comments there. Just leave, JUST REPORT THAT VIDEO/ SHORT/ REEL THAT'S IT. NO FURTHER REACTION. Please baby stans A I request you all to copy this by taking screen shot by Google lens, and paste this at every kpop video you see I saw this in a video and I'm posting it at every vid and I request you all do the same
it's not true she had no connection with the rest of RV members. Yeri joined SM very early, and was the one who brought Seulgi and Wendy on the infamous office tour which included the water dispenser. She was also very close to Irene, and they went on many trips together, and Seulgi always played with Yeri, because she didn't want Yeri to miss out on being a kid. That's why both of them claim they practically raised her. She's also a very funny partner in crime with Wendy, and Joy is always in competition with her in pranks and jokes.
because yeri already dropped out of school to training and performed at smtown concert with her friends, but then SM changed their mind to having Yeri alone join RV, of course she'd feel guilty to her friends and she said to not debut as idol and just be an actress. SM don't even debut her fellow friends and at the end everyone heartbroken and left the company
wdym she didn't have connection with the red velvet members? i remember seeing that irene used to pick her up from school before debuting and was like a big sister
yeah this channel obviously doesn't know about RV relationships. The members always said they trainings and living together and having really close bonds with each other, so it's crazy to make accusations of them not having connection. they've been together for 10 years, sharing sweat, blood and tears. If they all didn't have connection i don't think they be willing to comeback as a group for this long
I think what the channel meant was that Yeri didn't train with the red velvet members before they debut so she didn't have that bond with them. I could be wrong tho since i don't know whether they trained together or not
No yeri said it her self . In the interview. She never stated anything about irene treating her like her mother and taking care of her . She's just that condescending
@@Swish900also ur taking stuff out of context. Irene would pack her lunches when yeri was in red velvet not when yeri was a trainee! there’s a whole variety show that shows irene packing yeris lunches when she was in high school! not middle school.. during the time yeri was a trainee she was in middle school, she didn’t debut yet bc of how young she was. so please do ur research before making assumptions
Wait, didn’t Yeri also train with the rest of Red Velvet? If I’m mistaken please let me know but I’m pretty sure there are stories about their rookie days that involve Exo members, Red Velvet members and some Nct members.
Tbc as a bystander who occasionally listens to RV yeri definitely doesn't fit neither does she stand out as a part of the group. I don't mean this in a harsh way but the group was definitely complete without her. She would've shone better debuting in another group!
RIGHT! I mean lets be HONEST, yeri is the opposite of the other 4 members' strength like she wasnt as pretty as irene, wasnt tall and doesnt have good body like joy, wasnt a good dancer as seulgi and doesnt have good vocals as wendy. Yeri is your typical average idol tbh🤷🤷🤷 i dont see a star power in her she doesnt shine at all, no improvement. Maybe RV was too much for her, maybe she wouldve shone in another group...just maybe. Acting is the last resort i see for her at this stage of her career so she needs to ACE it or else she will become a memory.
@@aircole1000actually yeri has written songs for other people and also has stated that she has written and composed songs for red velvet so I can see even her even without acting still being active in the industry
@@hamster6827 what song to be specific? I mean i dont want to sound rude but lets be honest and lets face the reality here, RV is a 10yo group it means theyre on their way to the exit and will focus more on solo acts, in 10yrs i dont remember yeri shine in any of their comebacks, doesnt improved her singing/dancing, in general i dont see improvement and maybe thats the reason why her fanbase doesnt grow either, theres nothing to be excited about her🤷 Maybe her strengths are the offcam works like production, creative etc
@@aircole1000 she wrote for g-dragon, wrote and composed her own solo, wrote the English verses for red velevts feature with Elle Goulding, also wrote her and Irene's rap in red flavor, and she also said on a show either her's or on one she appeared in(i forgot😭😭)that she has written and composed unreleased songs that she wants her group to perform
@@aircole1000 also i wouldn't say she doesn't fit she is along with Wendy a major part of their vocal harmonies though for dancing she used to be really good now it seems like she doesn't really try as hard/isn't consistent and I think she was added to be apart of their dance line(has the most ceneter time in dumb dumb, opening dance break with irene and seulgi, gets duets dances with seulgi)
Seriously why is she so condesinding . Wasn't irene taking care of her when she was a trainee . At middle . School . She's just ungrateful for irene . She always had envy for her
Her concerns were beyond valid. Not only was she bullied by the public as soon as she debuted just for debuting later, she was labelled the "talentless" member, and her being in the group was considered a punishment to the other members for not reaching a certain level of success. Remember, this is a girl who was hated on for crying at a friend's funeral. This treatment wasn't that long ago
😩 she's suffered so much, I'm so thankful for her to keep going strong, i'm always thankful that her family, other members and her close friend to fully support her. they always said to Yeri to just do whatever she wanna do, i love that
And then she had to perform a couple of days later. Black pink and RV members hugging her. Gosh it felt horrible to watch. How can people lack so much humanity?
Bruh at the funeral . It was so obvious that she only ran to the front for attention . It's still obvious even when you see it now
@@Swish900you’re so weird lmfao you guys need to get off the internet sometimes and realise that if you said this to anyone irl they’d look at you like you’re insane FOR A REASON DO U HEAR URSELF😭
@@iinaego i think that's my own choice that i make . Also it's only comes out weird cause im not a native english speaker . And kpop is full of weird people
I remember Yeri, Koeun, Herin, Lami, Hina, Xu Yiyang and Ning Ning were the rookies girls back then❤
ahh that brought back memories!! i remember really wanting lami to debut
Yeri and Ningning not training together because in October 2015 Ningning still in Lets Sing Kids program so she probably joined SM in November. while Yeri debut with RV in March 2015, so their training periods didn't overlap.
I think the group called White fox and the other member with Yeri was Koeun but i don't know for other girls name
@@stabil1ty That’s right!
Sorry i actually meant that all they were introduced as part of the SM rookies project at some point. Some of them right after RV's debut, some others later, but this is how we called them for a long time as potential smngg members, the sm rookie girls, not in this exact combination tho.
The best part is even if all the girls didn't debut together they remain friends and have a lot of cute interactions on IG (especially Yeri and Herin), along with former sm trainees as An Jong Min, Kepler's Chaehyun or actress Park Jung Yeon🥰
But as you said, we knew that Ning Ning was under SM until 2016 when she came out as part of SRG16☺️
Jungyeon too
I love the recent Yeri/Ningning interactions in SMTOWN :D
omg 😭 fans hated her when she first joined rv and 😭
I love how they say their debut date is the day Yeri joined RV, instead of when they debuted with just 4 of them..
Yup. That was Irene's way of getting the uncontrolled haters off of Yeri's back since SM was not doing ANYTHING about them. Irene is AWESOME for that! What a great Angry Mamma Bear to have! :D
Tbh I had no interest in RV during happiness and being natural. Like the whole concept back then seemed a bit basic and boring. But ice cream cake concept + yeri joining made me actually pay attention to them and like them.
@@dunkyourdonuts2282 You could not recognize their talents at all before Yeri joined? What exactly are you even listening to or looking at? They have material during their training that can still be found if you know where to look. All of it from before Happiness still WOWS people to this day. Where are you even from, that their abilities were just hum-drum for you? Damn. Put some respect on their name.
@@jamescurfman3284 wtf they never said anything about the girls talents, they just said that for them the concept was boring
yeah,, she was originally part of gg white fox by sm with koeun
exactly i remember watching them performed in smtown concert
Tbh yeri joining redvelvet was the best idea like the girl used to single handedly carry them on variety shows like watch idol room knowing brothers etc she was the goat
she sings most of the backround vocals too and you can tell that she adds a different flavor to the "original" reve tone, just like giselle in aespa!!!!💘
Ive been following ReVe since Happiness and let me tell you, they feel complete as 5. I cant even imagine what they would be rn without Yeri
First, RV would not have been promoted half as well without Yeri... SM is SO STUPID for that...
Same!
Imagine yeri in aespa though 🥹
Edit: I SAID "IMAGINE" WTF 😒
I'm pretty sure it's another group project that was cancelled by sm. Don't think aespa as a concept was even thought back then during Yeri's training
No there were other trainees in sm rookies but sadly they left
yeri debuted before any members of aespa joined sm so it's not possible, it was probably a project that was later canceled by the company
@user-yv9gt7ym9s yeah, to your point the only Aespa member with possible overlap with her is Ningning.
@@Nicolesid1nope. even ningning joined sm after yeri become red velvet member. they don't training together
People criticize her so much but this video shows that when Sm decided scrap the gg project, the first trainee they didn't want to loose was Yeri. Most of the girls Yeri likely trained with didn't even debut at another agency at the end. If Yeri wasn't valuable Sm would let her waste her youth like all the other girls
It reminds me of Sheon (Kim Suyeon) joining Billlie after their debut. Something just clicked when the final member was added.
this has misinformation… yeri never dropped out of school, there’s pictures of her graduation during bad boy era! and Irene would pack her lunch for school, (it’s on a variety show if u don’t believe me, and they said it in an interview). also wasn’t there an interview done with red velvet where they said yeri didn’t join, bc of how young she was when ever debuted?
There is a whole video of her graduating high school with Twices maknae line
@@Hope-du4gw I know? I literally said she graduated high school? that happened during bad boy era..
@@MichelleCain-pq9bx I just gave a little more context while agreeing to your comment
@@Hope-du4gw okay!
I'm happy she joined...they are a perfect fit...I love all 5 members
“ill do acting instead” as much as i love red velvet yeri, i also love actress yeri. i’ve watched bitch x rich and i love her acting. many people say most idols cant act, well she isnt one of them
So true. Yeri is really one of the few idol actors who can actually act very well. I've watched bitch × rich too and it was my fave drama last year. I'm waiting for it's season 2. BTW if you want, you should watch Yeri's previous drama "Blue birthday" which is her first acting project in a lead role. And it was very good too. Her acting is seriously no joke!
@@RiswjyV agree! thank you for the recommendation, im gonna add that to my watch list!
@@cherriyeojin you're welcome. ☺️
@@RiswjyV @cherriyeojin I got to see her one-episode drama Applause a while ago (about a girl who trains a dog to be an assistant animal, all while eventually realizing she has much to learn about the world that blind/disabled people are actually encountering) and I loved how she played off her own sweet personality while being able to show the character's flaws in a funny, natural sort of way. It's kinda gotten lost in the shuffle because of the scope of Blue Birthday and BitchXRich but I absolutely find it a worthwhile watch.
For that matter, the fact Yeri chose to do Blue Birthday - given that show's themes - is really poignant and reflective of what she endured. I have so much respect for her for taking that project on.
Irene was literally a mother to yeri even before joining RV.
That is what I heard. Maybe we have BAD information though because I am sitting over here in the middle of the United States... Who knows? I hope all the bad info gets corrected because this post surprised me.
But even until now when yeri makes a joke with Irene who she's GROWN UP WITH, haters still call her disrespectful and tell her to quit the group
@@dunkyourdonuts2282 It is really too bad and it makes no sense at all that 'haters gotta hate'.
Imagine some people are SO MESSED UP in the head that they think they are SUPPOSED to hate other people 'just because'. Yeri was a TEENAGER and was getting full on BULLIED about every tiny little thing she did or said or looked like or made a decision about by Full-Grown 'ADULTS' who should know better. At some point, people should have out-grown being bullies. Their logic parts of the brain are supposed to kick in at some point, or otherwise how are these people supposed to be considered as adults? They are just giant toddlers.
I thought I was messed up in the head! I know I am not perfect, I have problems. But I am REALLY GLAD that I can do logic, I can actually think for myself and figure things out on my own. One thing I figured out while I was still a kids is that the world needs Love. As grumpy as I get, I am always happy when I see and hear about kindness. When I see Human Beings acknowledging each other as Humans and not animals, not slaves, but as equals.
Hate got us into the messes we are in all over the world. Nothing fixes those messes until there is understanding and a willingness to work together to fix them. Hate has no place in those conversations or workplaces.
Hate just for the sake of Hate? That's the only thing these 'people' (trolls) are good at? Their parents should be ashamed of their kids and more importantly, ashamed of themselves.
Maybe she would be part of aespa as the leader . Born 1999 older than Karina.
I'm not saying she wouldn't have been the leader, but being the oldest doesn't automatically make them one, look at Twice or IVE
@@Nicolesid1Different company different way. SM always make oldest member as leader.
@@Sweet_Like_A_Jack_Rose Well, not always. Taeil is the eldest in NCT but Taeyong was made the leader of both the 127 sub-unit and the overall group (though he is also one of the eldest in the group). But there's a good chance Yeri may have been made the leader as not only because of her age but also because she would've probably been the member with the most training experience.
aespa wasn't even a project back then. only ningning was in SME around that time?? others joined later so nope even if she didn't debut w rv, she wouldn't have been in aespa. the girls she trained with were different.
there's a video of Yeri and her friends performance in smtown concert back in 2014/2015 i forgot but you can search it. Btw Yeri already debut in RV even before Ningning joined SM
From what i heard from others, at SM theres 5% chance of debuting. So i feel like Yeri made the right choice. She did sacrifice a lot which i understand.
A bit misinformation here: •Yeri had connection either the red velvet pg members cause they lived and trained together, Irene and Seulgi especially dotes on her since trainee days along with the other rookie girls.
• She was supposed to be the center of the new girl group along with the SR15Girls
Some people consider yeri "talentless" but truly she completes red velvet. Yeri's adlibs and verses breaks up red velvets killer vocals and also allows red velvet to have many different concepts. Yeri's parts in songs make red velvets songs more noticable, and give red velvet's songs the final touch or cherry on top. She doesn't just complete red velvet as a music group but red velvet socially. Imo yeri is the adlib queen in kpop, her sweet voice just immediately brightens up any song shes in and adds so much character to the song.
if anyone is still calling yeri talentless after a full decade post-debut, that’s simply because they dislike for whatever reasons they’ve come up with in their mind. she’s one of the best maknaes the industry has ever seen. gold standard. she comes with red velvet, whether others like that or not.
@@noahfan2719 I fully agree! red velvet wouldn't be the same without yeri! I've seen people try and make crazy rumors about her like she's "always super friendly with dudes" (meant in the inappropriate way), "has a bad attitude" and an "attention seeker" but even though fans may not know her personally just seeing all the people and the type of people yeri is friends with its clear that those rumors are just that, rumors. People will do anything these days to "justify" there hate/annoyance towards someone.
This comment! 💯
Yerim best maknae😊
@@ujytb9761What songs would you recommend where Yeri has a decent number of lines to sing? She is not talentless but she does seem much less talented than the other 4 members.
@@RiswjyV @ujytb9761 Soshi's love and adoration of Yeri all the way to her "I'm unnie to aespa" era tell me that people of all generations absolutely adore Katie Kim.
i like to think of happiness and be natural as pre debut songs
I love yeri! And am so happy she is in the group : )
팬들도 합류 전에는 엄청 반대했었음 잘 되고 있는 중인데 왜그러냐면서.. 근데 아스케 티저 뜨자마자 여론 확 바뀜 해외는 모르겠는데 적어도 한국은 진짜 극적으로 바뀜 엄청 환대했던 기억이ㅎㅎ
Unfortunately, I still see many international fans hating or ignoring yeri and still wish she leave red velvet. But some fans love her and think she’s cute and funny.
I'm glad Yeri debuted in RV tho. ❤
I still feel sorry for the Mickey Mouse club Sm rookies girl trainees, none of whom have debuted. How painful it is to wait, waste time and effort for an opportunity that seems close but it’s just a daydream.
I can't imagine a world where Red Velvet remained OT4.
Yeri joining made the group feel complete.
Yeri didn't dropped out from School , She literally graduated from Hanlim in 2018 !!
Maybe she took a pause? Or maybe it’s just to emphasize she didn’t go to school often. Many idols can graduate with going to only a few classes a year. Or like Jungkook who graduated at 19 bc he took a break year.
First Yeri did not even wanted to join ( she even respected her peers sm )
And now, she's being sm hated for that.
Thank god she did❤❤❤
even if yeri didn't join red velvet i think she and red velvet would do just fine. i'm glad she did join red velvet though
love you yeri 💜
Having seen her acting, she indeed is an impressive actress
Yeri did have connection with the RV members. Irene and Seulgi even argued about who raised her more as a trainee.
My Yerikins!!!!
I love her. Having her is like a dream and I'm glad that she debuted in the end because I believe that Red Velvet was destined to be a five member group. I'm very fond of Yeri and meeting her and Red Velvet motivated me a lot. I could never understand how people hated on her for joining so late she was just a teen back then and she received so many backlash from those so called “fans” but Red Velvet only considers the Reveluv who stans the Five of them because RED VELVET IS FIVE AND WILL ALWAYS BE FIVE.
She brought down the average age.. 😂
she made a good choice because it would take 6 years for sm to debut another gg WITH members that joined the company 2 years or more after her own debut
I loved Red Velvet’s debut with Happiness literally sooooo much at the time. I remember when Yeri was added I was nervous but then Ice Cream Cake was so amazing. Red Velvet is my ult group fr I love everything they’ve doneee
I Stan RV since debut but adding Yeri in the group is the best decision SM ever made because she's the lucky charm of Red Velvet. After adding her, the group get their first win and get recognize by public viewers.
😢😢 people are so mean.
Be stronger, Yeri my girl ❤🤟🏽
you have great friendship in RV, and of course with Nayeon too. I love that ❤
Remember what Rihanna said,
"Shine bright like a diamond,
Sunlight Mama Lemon." ✨✨
LUMINAS KEEP STRE@MING!!! 1MILLION COMING SOON
❤
I actually remember how she joined the group and after that, rv's popularity skyrocketed bcs of their amazing vocals and performances! She is a good choice for rv, and made the group brighter.
She’s pretty
the problem is that she is the age of Aespa but in a 3rd generation group.... her career will end early bc he remembers are in their 30s while other idols her age are still promoting!
Kinda misinformations alot in this video. She did have connection with rv unnies during trainee days but shes close more with other trainees friends with the same ages as her. Shes also didnt dropped out of school? 😅 She did graduate from high school tho.
Yeri brings a bright cheerfulness to Red Velvet. She has a quick sense of humor and easily laughs at situations that she finds to be funny. She helps others not take themselves too seriously. She also makes funny boasts about things that she says she has done or knows how to do only to have it backfire on her when she attempts to do them.
The only sad thing there is here friends didn't debut
i can’t imagine red velvet without yeri at this point!! they are so well rounded and compliment each other so nicely. and i love her dynamic with irene, mother and daughter :,)
man from the thumbnail i thought yeri was going to teach us some chess opening/gambit. it would be great if it was real tho xD
i think yeri joining rv make the other members of smrookies left sm. because they hesitate whether they're going to debut or not
odd tho how she appeared in the happiness mv before her debut
Yeri is actually in the happiness M/V 🤓
I think overall from today's perspective it is better that she is part of Red Velvet than not. Her reasons for not wanting to join are valid though; also Yeri did receive hate after debuting with RV and throughout her time as a member. But in the end RV became one of the biggest groups in the industry that is still active today, while that other group never even made it to debut. Plus Yeri has her own unique personality in RV and helps balance it out. I hope she is more confident about her decision now 🙏
But she was in the start of the happiness MV
Yes. Same as the other younger SM Rookies Girls. She was supposed to be the center of the group project
Yes Good ONE
She was going to debut in aespa as the leader probably. That or twice
nope. She was supposed to be in another smgg not aespa
RED FLAVOR SHOULD BE HIGHER THE CONCEPT IS SO CUTE AND FUN
Omg without yeri , I can't imagine red velvet 😢😢😢
She had no connection but appears at the center of the screen in Happiness' intro... yeah...
Tbh I think Yeri is RV lucky charm, the moment she joined RV the group became more successful and start getting recognition from both the public and Kpop fans in general back then.
ATTENTION KPOP STANS!! WE NEED YOUR HELP!!
(Admin plz pin this)
Nowadays as the popularity of Kpop is increasing, the amount of hate by so called sigma, chads, football fans blah blah blah is also increasing. And what makes this situation worse is the fans reaction.
Nowadays, as you all know how these idols are treated by these toxic internet. They call them gay, call them weak, be racist towards. You all know what happened to stray Kids this time at the Met Gala and what usually happens to BTS on the internet and also BlackPink. I daily encounter approx 4-5 shorts/reels hating on BTS. Like comparing them with their football idols and lot more. And the comments are like, proud to be a bts hater, Kpop kpoop, etc. encounter approx 4-5 shorts/reels hating on BTS.
So now please listen carefully, to stop this we have to first to fight among ourselves. Like between different Kpop stans. Like we need to stop hating different groups or stop fighting like, no BTS is the best or no BlackPink is.
Stop it... We need to unite. Everyone we need to stop hating the fans or grps which are not your fav and stop fighting. EVERYONE HAS THEIR FAVOURITE GROUP.
NEXT STEP IS VERY IMPORTANT We need toreacting to stop commenting on videos hating our fav grp or any Kpop grp. Or reply to any hateful comment or write any comment defending your grp in that video.
For ex. You saw an edit a guy is comparing BTS with Ronaldo and he disrespected BTS in that just don't react just stop. You don't have to write any comment there neither positive or to write any comment there neither positive or negative. Or you have to react or reply to those shitcomments there neither positive or negative. Or you have you have to react or reply to those horrible comments there. Just leave, JUST REPORT THAT VIDEO/ SHORT/ REEL THAT'S IT. NO FURTHER REACTION.
Please baby stans A
I request you all to copy this by taking screen shot by Google lens, and paste this at every kpop video you see
I saw this in a video and I'm posting it at every vid and I request you all do the same
It must had been difficult for her to be the maknae in a group with Irene. Thankfully, the other girls seem like a good buffer
so miss-cast. carried by everyone else.
Mark has stuffed his pants with smth 😂
SM give pass card 😂
it's not true she had no connection with the rest of RV members. Yeri joined SM very early, and was the one who brought Seulgi and Wendy on the infamous office tour which included the water dispenser. She was also very close to Irene, and they went on many trips together, and Seulgi always played with Yeri, because she didn't want Yeri to miss out on being a kid. That's why both of them claim they practically raised her. She's also a very funny partner in crime with Wendy, and Joy is always in competition with her in pranks and jokes.
Imagine being offered a debut, turning it down and having to wait 5 more yrs
because yeri already dropped out of school to training and performed at smtown concert with her friends, but then SM changed their mind to having Yeri alone join RV, of course she'd feel guilty to her friends and she said to not debut as idol and just be an actress. SM don't even debut her fellow friends and at the end everyone heartbroken and left the company
@@stabil1ty I understand that, but if she didn't debut with RV and stayed egad.
@@stabil1tybut there’s pictures of her graduation during bad boy era? and irene would pack her lunch for school, yeri never dropped out of school
cosmic
So Sm entertainment screw Yeri up since she debuted later in Red Velvet. Everybody hated her and now we know she didn’t even wanted to debut with them
Oh. Great. I have been operating under false information ever since 2015. Got it. :P
Lol they bashed her badly when she joined redvelvet
Redo her performance because its just unfair
wdym she didn't have connection with the red velvet members? i remember seeing that irene used to pick her up from school before debuting and was like a big sister
yeah this channel obviously doesn't know about RV relationships. The members always said they trainings and living together and having really close bonds with each other, so it's crazy to make accusations of them not having connection. they've been together for 10 years, sharing sweat, blood and tears. If they all didn't have connection i don't think they be willing to comeback as a group for this long
I think what the channel meant was that Yeri didn't train with the red velvet members before they debut so she didn't have that bond with them. I could be wrong tho since i don't know whether they trained together or not
No yeri said it her self . In the interview. She never stated anything about irene treating her like her mother and taking care of her . She's just that condescending
She letteraly said . I have no such memories with the rv members back then . Meaning she never was or is gratful for irene's kindness at all
@@Swish900also ur taking stuff out of context. Irene would pack her lunches when yeri was in red velvet not when yeri was a trainee! there’s a whole variety show that shows irene packing yeris lunches when she was in high school! not middle school.. during the time yeri was a trainee she was in middle school, she didn’t debut yet bc of how young she was. so please do ur research before making assumptions
Hi
Should've stayed ot4
Wait, didn’t Yeri also train with the rest of Red Velvet? If I’m mistaken please let me know but I’m pretty sure there are stories about their rookie days that involve Exo members, Red Velvet members and some Nct members.
They most likely know each other but she might be closer with trainees of her age. Like Koeun and Hina.
I thought because she felt she'd be at the lowest visual level.
Alurnya kaya terlalu alus gasih?
Next girl group mean aespa
No it was a group project that got canceled
OT4
why?
Isn't she an actress or sth?
This channel seems to be good to practice listening skill. Is this ai voice by any chance?
Then why is she there what the hell?!
She would not have debuted then
red velvet FOURever 4.
Its been 10 years move on
why?
tbh she added nothing to the group other than bringing the average age down. lol
nah you tripping
As a non fans Yeri is like invincible in the group for me I always forgot she was even in red velvet considering how famous the other members are
It’s true, when Yeri joined red velvet, she truly brighten up red velvet and became a successful group
Tbc as a bystander who occasionally listens to RV yeri definitely doesn't fit neither does she stand out as a part of the group. I don't mean this in a harsh way but the group was definitely complete without her. She would've shone better debuting in another group!
RIGHT! I mean lets be HONEST, yeri is the opposite of the other 4 members' strength like she wasnt as pretty as irene, wasnt tall and doesnt have good body like joy, wasnt a good dancer as seulgi and doesnt have good vocals as wendy. Yeri is your typical average idol tbh🤷🤷🤷 i dont see a star power in her she doesnt shine at all, no improvement. Maybe RV was too much for her, maybe she wouldve shone in another group...just maybe.
Acting is the last resort i see for her at this stage of her career so she needs to ACE it or else she will become a memory.
@@aircole1000actually yeri has written songs for other people and also has stated that she has written and composed songs for red velvet so I can see even her even without acting still being active in the industry
@@hamster6827 what song to be specific? I mean i dont want to sound rude but lets be honest and lets face the reality here, RV is a 10yo group it means theyre on their way to the exit and will focus more on solo acts, in 10yrs i dont remember yeri shine in any of their comebacks, doesnt improved her singing/dancing, in general i dont see improvement and maybe thats the reason why her fanbase doesnt grow either, theres nothing to be excited about her🤷
Maybe her strengths are the offcam works like production, creative etc
@@aircole1000 she wrote for g-dragon, wrote and composed her own solo, wrote the English verses for red velevts feature with Elle Goulding, also wrote her and Irene's rap in red flavor, and she also said on a show either her's or on one she appeared in(i forgot😭😭)that she has written and composed unreleased songs that she wants her group to perform
@@aircole1000 also i wouldn't say she doesn't fit she is along with Wendy a major part of their vocal harmonies though for dancing she used to be really good now it seems like she doesn't really try as hard/isn't consistent and I think she was added to be apart of their dance line(has the most ceneter time in dumb dumb, opening dance break with irene and seulgi, gets duets dances with seulgi)
Seriously why is she so condesinding . Wasn't irene taking care of her when she was a trainee . At middle . School . She's just ungrateful for irene . She always had envy for her
girl what?
Bro what? What the hell do you mean? WTF?
Just shut up
She literally got hate for joining 😭
LUMINAS KEEP STRE@MING!!! 1MILLION COMING SOON